Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
2000-10-03 IEEE 80216-0020r1
1
Project IEEE 80216 Broadband Wireless Access Working Grouplt httpieee802org16 gt
Title Minutes of 80216 Session 9
Date Submitted 2000-10-02
Source(s) Scott Marin
80216 Secretary
Voice 972-424-2386Fax 972-516-2202E-mail smarinixnetcomcom
Re 80216 Session 9 (Denver Colorado USA 11-15 September 2000)
Abstract This document records the minutes of 80216 meetings held at 80216 Session 9
Purpose To record progress and decisions of the Working Group
Notice This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussionand is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s) The material in thisdocument is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s)reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw material contained herein
Release The contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in thiscontribution and any modifications thereof in the creation of an IEEE Standards publication tocopyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may includeportions of this contribution and at the IEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce inwhole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor also acknowledgesand accepts that this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
Patent Policyand Procedures The contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10)
lt httpieee802org16iprpatentspolicyhtml gt including the statement ldquoIEEE standards mayinclude the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justificationin the opinion of the standards-developing committee and provided the IEEE receives assurancefrom the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for thepurpose of implementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to thestandard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in the development process and increasethe likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chairlt mailtorbmarksieeeorg gt as early as possible in written or electronic form of any patents(granted or under application) that may cover technology that is under consideration by or hasbeen approved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216web site lt httpieee802org16iprpatentsnotices gt
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
2
Minutes of 80216 Session 9A Interim Session of the IEEE 80216
Working Group on Broadband Wireless AccessDenver Marriott Southeast Denver Colorado USA
11 to 15 September 2000
1 Monday Sept 11 2000 Opening PlenaryAt 1400 Roger Marks 80216 Chairman called Session 9 to order (See Appendix A forOpening Plenary presentation slides)
Marks presented the Opening Plenary agenda The Opening Plenary agenda was approved withoutobjection
Marks presented the schedule for the week and noted the times in which 80216 attendees areinvited to events of the co-located 2000 IEEE Radio and Wireless Conference (RAWCON2000)Marks noted several parallel 80216 sessions and asked for comments on the agenda The schedulefor the week was approved without objection
Marks reviewed the 80216 process including the rights of all attendees and rights of members
Marks commented on the IEEE SA sponsor ballot pool and noted that the web site contains a formthat must be submitted to register for the pool Participants need to join IEEE-SA or pay aballoting fee to join the balloting group You must take action to register because registration is notautomatic
Marks continued with additional details on the rights of members and observers
Scott Marin 80216 Secretary noted that the session is being taped for accuracy that Session 9will use four attendance books (one for each task and study group) and that badges with votingtokens have been preprinted
Marks explained that 80216 registration of $140 is to be paid at the front desk of the hotel
Marks explained that document distribution would be from a DHCP server via 10BaseT100BaseT or 80211b connections Marks asked if document distribution by server was acceptableTwo people objected and asked for distribution by the flash card Marks said we would work out amethod of updating and distributing documents via his flash card
Marks summarized the RAWCON meeting schedule
Marks read the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy
Marks introduced the minutes from Session 8 Scott Marin reminded Marks of his request toinclude the revised 80216 membership list that resulted from attendance at Session 8 Marksasked for approval of the Session 8 minutes amended to include the 80216 membership list thatresulted from Session 8 The minutes as amended were approved without objection
Marks as chair of TG1 reported that the plan is to resolve all comments and by the end of theweek to approve a motion to send a draft to working group letter ballot Jim Mollenauer co-
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
3
editor explained the editing process as an outgrowth of the prior process used on the functionalrequirements document
Marks was asked if a document with the incorporated comments would be available for reviewMarks noted that a new document was posted last night with the consolidated MAC comments
As chair of the TG1 MAC Carl Eklund explained that a two-pass process is planned to resolvecomments the first pass for editorial and the second pass for technical Brian Petry asked that thegroup consider accepting editorial comments as a group
Jeff Foerster agreed to put a document containing consolidated PHY comments on the server forJim Mollenauer to consolidate with the MAC
As chairman of TG1 PHY Jay Klein reported that 58 comments and several contributions hadbeen received and would be dealt with during the week
As co-chair of TG2 Andy McGregor summarized the TG2 plans (See Appendix A)
In a slight deviation from the approved agenda Marks introduced Jim Carlo Chairman of 802 andVice-chair of the IEEE-SA Standards Board Carlo commented that he came to Session 9 toobserve and help the process He would attend until Wednesday and encouraged people to askquestions of him
As Chairman of TG3 Brian Kiernan reported that 13 contributions and 130 comments regardingthe functional requirements had been received About half of the comments were editorial Kiernancommented that the objectives for the week are to 1) finish the requirements document 2) establishan evaluation criteria and 3) deal with the issue of having a TG3 MAC common or different fromthe TG1 MAC
Marks reminded attendees that all voting members can vote in TG1 TG2 and TG3
As chairman of the WirelessHUMANtrade Study Group Durga Satapathy reported that the primarytask for the week to was to complete a draft PAR A key issue is to define the scope Sixcontributions have been received and several issues require resolution Drayt Avera will be actingsecretary for WirelessHUMANtrade at Session 9
Marks as 80216 Chairman charged task groups to among other things stick to the schedules andto turn on all documents before leaving Denver
Marks asked for new business and none was offered
Without objection the Opening Plenary was adjourned
2 Wednesday 13 September 2000 Midweek PlenaryAt 1702 Roger Marks Chairman of 80216 called the Midweek Plenary to order
Marks presented the agenda Marks accepted additions from Jay Klein to report on ETSI BRANHIPERACCESS and from Scott Marin to make a motion on the editorial process The modifiedagenda (Appendix B) was adopted without objection
Marks reviewed the agenda for ndashthe week and changes to the associated meeting rooms Using the80216 server connection Marks updated the agenda file on the server (Appendix B)
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
4
Concerning conference fees Marks asked that everyone pay the $140 by close of business todayso that he can check registration status tomorrow
Marks presented an update on the 80216 server and explained the process to upload files
Scott Marin as 80216 secretary commended Task Group chairs and attendance book people forthe good job of keeping the attendance books up to date In an informal pole attendees showedstrong support for the new multiple book approach
Regarding the TG1 MAC group Carl Eklund reported good progress in resolving comments AWednesday evening session is planned to continue comment resolution Eklund reported that theTG1 MAC group has decided to use a 48-bit MAC address instead of a 64-bit address Eklundexpressed some concern with the completeness of the document citing that no comments had beenreceived on the last 100 pages Eklund stated that the document is in much better shape than onMonday and expected to have an even better document by Friday Marks asked if changes ofinterest to TG3 had been made Eklund responded that TG3 requirements had been considered andcited as examples the additions of options for ARQ and shorter frames
Regarding the TG1 PHY Jay Klein stated that the 58 comments had been resolved and that thegroup was now resolving TBDs Klein stated that the plan is to continue with TBDs after a jointmeeting with the TG1 MAC group Klein was hopeful that a new version would be ready byFriday for release as a letter ballot
Regarding TG2 Andy McGregor explained that a decision had been reached that coexistenceanalysis can be based on individual transmitter emissions and TG2 decided that it was unnecessaryto aggregate emitters Coordination triggers had been agreed The grouprsquos goal is to handle all editsby Thursday The TG2 task group has requested a joint meeting with TG1 PHY at 800amThursday this was agreed to an arranged Andy McGregor reported that Marianna Goldhammerhad presented an update from ETSI TM4 and noted that TG2 expected to prepare a liaison reply
Regarding TG3 Brain Kiernan explained that TG3 had been working through comments receivedon the functional requirements and that work would continue at a Wednesday evening meeting from1930-2200 Kiernan further noted that TG3 plans to complete the characteristics and evaluationcriteria by the end of week Kiernan also noted that TG3 plans to develop a call for contributionson models (channel and traffic) and a call for preliminary abstracts on PHY proposals TG3 hadreceived a liaison letter from ETSI BRAN and Kiernan noted that TG3 needed to appoint a liaisonperson from TG3 to ETSI BRAN Kiernan announced a joint TG1TG3 meeting tomorrow nightand a joint TG3WirelessHUMANtrade meeting at 800-900 tomorrow
Regarding WirelessHUMANtrade Durga Sataphy reported completing review of the sevencontributions and that consensus had been reached to use 80211a and ETSI HIPERLAN2 as abasis for a PHY Satapathy further explained that the draft PAR states that the MAC would drawfrom the 80216 MAC Satapathy noted that WirelessHUMANtrade is developing the Five Criteriadocument Marks asked if the PAR required use of the stated standards Satapathy said no
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
5
In a charge to Task Groups Marks asked groups to submit meeting minutes by the end of theweek and to propose motions at future 80216 plenary meetings using only documents from theserver
Regarding ITU-R Joint Rapporteurs Group (JRG) 8A-9B Joseacute Costa reviewed document IEEE80216l-0016 Marks highlighted the importance of liaison with the ITU-R
Jay Klein reported on ETSI BRAN HIPERACCESS Liaison
Marks explained that ETSI BRAN 80211 and 80215 now share password protected documentsMarks also stated that 80216 must decide whether to share password protected documents withETSI BRAN By IEEE procedure working group letter ballot documents are considered draftstandards and must therefore be copyrighted and protected
Marks reported that a letter (document IEEE 80216l-0025) had been received from Andrew Kreigpresident of the Wireless Communications Association The letter announced the appointment ofDemos Kostas as liaison from WCA to 80216
Under new business Scott Marin expressed concern and the potential to abuse the editorialprocess to influence documents
Motion1 Scott Marin 2nd Brian Petry That the 80216 Chairman establishes written guidelines(boundaries) for editors that among other things explains what editors can and cannot do
Motion1 passes without objection Marks took an action to present draft editorial rules forapproval at the closing plenary
Marks adjourned the midweek plenary at 1810
3 Friday 15 September 2000 Closing PlenaryAt 1005 Roger Marks called the meeting to order
Marks presented a draft agenda The agenda (See Appendix C) was approved without objection
Marks reported a few bugs with the registration fees that may need to be fixed and asked people tocheck their hotel statements carefully
Marks displayed the server page and explained the organization and ways to uses the server
Marks announced that 80216 Vice Chair Lou Olsen had resigned and that a new vice chair wouldbe elected at 80216 Session 10 Marks appointed Brian Petry as Acting Vice Chair until theelection Brian Petry accepted the appointment (and said hersquod continue to push for cookies atbreaks)
Marks displayed logo_bpng which had been introduced in a previous message to the 80216 e-mail reflector
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
6
The above logo was approved without objection
Regarding WirelessHUMANtrade Durga Satapathy reported a decision to use the 80216 MAC anda PHY based on ETSI BRAN HIPERLAN2 and 80211a (See presentation in Appendix C)Satapathy also reported completion of a draft project authorization request (PAR) and presentedthe draft
Motion2 Durga Satpathy 2nd Drayt Avera to accept the 91500 version of theWirelessHUMANtrade PAR (serverspublicWirelessHUMAN PAR 2000-09-15doc) with somelatitude to adjust text before submission to the 802 Executive Committee
The proposed WirelessHUMANtrade PAR be forwarded to the IEEE 802 SEC at least 30 days priorto the start of the following IEEE 802 Plenary session subject to a comments from IEEE 80211and 80215 and a comment revision process on the 80216 email reflector
Marks asked that the PAR be changed from a ldquoNew Standardrdquo to a ldquoSupplementrdquo The change wasaccepted without objection
Motion2amended Durga Satpathy 2nd Drayt Avera to accept the 91500 version of theWirelessHUMANtrade PAR (serverspublicWirelessHUMAN PAR 2000-09-15doc) with somelatitude to adjust text before submission to executive committee and that the type of document be asupplement rather than a new standard
The proposed WirelessHUMANtrade PAR be forwarded to the IEEE 802 SEC at least 30 days priorto the start of the following IEEE 802 Plenary session subject to a comments from IEEE 80211and 80215 and a comment revision process on the 80216 email reflector
Motion3 to amend Motion2 Tom Kolze 2nd Chet Sharali to amend Motion2 by addingDOCSIS 11 to the PAR Where it says ldquoMAC 80216rdquo to add ldquoDOCSIS 11rdquo
By token vote 3 for 15 against Motion3 fails
By token vote 23 for 1 against 4 abstain Motion2 as amended passes The approveddocument is IEEE 80216h-0013r0
Marks congratulated the WirelessHUMANtrade study group for reaching this stage in their work
Regarding TG1 MAC Carl Eklund reported that TG1 received several hundred comments on thedraft specification and used most of the meeting time to resolve the comments A major emphasis
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
7
was placed on removing the PHY dependencies from the MAC Eklund noted that a joint meetingwas held with TG3 in which many misunderstandings were discussed
Regarding the TG1 PHY John Liebetreu presented a summary (See Appendix C)
Motion4 John Liebetreu 2nd not needed to initiate a Working Group Review of the IEEE802161 working document number 802161-0001r4 (to be constructed by incorporating theresolved comments listed in document number 802161-0009 into 802161-0001r3) Thereview is set to begin September 29 and to end October 30 2000 See call for comments 802161-0005
By voice vote all for Motion4 passes
Marks reviewed the additional call for contributions on 802161rsquos open technical issues noting adue date of 30 October 2000 and that convergence layer text for IP Ethernet and ATM will besubmitted by Carl Eklund Glen Sater and Ken Stanwood respectively
Regarding TG2 Andy McCregor presented the meeting minutes (IEEE 802162c-0022) and notedfour recommendations from the meeting 1) to use a more formal call for comments 2) to invitecomments from other organizations such as WCA NSMA RABC and ARIB 3) to formally askfor comments from the Broadband Wireless Association of the UK and 4) to put the next draft ofthe coexistence practice on the public side of the IEEE 80216 web site
Marks asked TG2 to remove the copyright notice from their working document and not call thedocument a draft until a later stage in the process
Regarding TG3 Brian Kiernan reported (see Appendix C) adoption of the TG3 functionalrequirements document development of evaluation criteria and development of a call forcontributions In addition TG3 adopted the TG1 MAC and formed the TG3 MAC Ad Hoccommittee to review the TG1 MAC
Motion5 Brian Kiernan 2nd not needed Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bull Establish a common 80216 MAC based on 802161-0001r4
bull Require each 80216 task group to define its mandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMAC
bull Shall ensure backward compatibility and maintenance of the common MAC and
bull Shall strive to ensure forward compatibility of the common MAC
By token vote 24 for 0 against 1 abstain Motion5 passes See Appendix E
Marks acknowledged several organizational issues that must be worked Marks will try to resolveas many issues as possible by the November meeting
Regarding upcoming meetings Marks noted that the next meeting (Session 10) will be in TampaFlorida and that the opportunity exists to extend the Task Group meetings to Friday morning orMonday morning Marks also noted the possibility of joint meetings with other 802 workinggroups
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
8
Marks noted that Session 11 is scheduled for 22 to 26 January 2001 in Tel Aviv Israel hosted byBreezeCOM
Marks noted that Session 13 (May 7-11 2000) will be a joint meeting with 80211 and 80215 andpossibly ETSI BRAN Marks noted his desire to hold interim meetings together with other 802groups
Marks asked for a straw pole as to those in favor of meeting Sundays none for and about 20against
Regarding Liaison Marks noted that ETSI BRAN recommended that Demos Kostas act as contactin both directions Marks plans to reply using Demos Kostas in both directions
Marks noted that as of this week 80216 members and observers now have access to a mirror ofall ETSI BRAN documents Marks will send out information to members and observers on how toaccess the documents
Regarding liaison with ETSI BRAN Marks showed a draft liaison letter (80216l-00_28doc)
Motion6 Marks 2nd Brian Petry to approve draft letter presented by Marks (document IEEE80216l-0028)
Motion7 Brian Petry Brian Kiernan to amend motion6 by replacing we appoint Dr Kostas asour informal contact person for the information exchange with for a contact person wethereby appointing no contact person
Motion7 by voice vote all for Motion7 passes
Motion6 by voice vote several for one opposed Motion6 passes
Scott Marin 80216 secretary had to leave the meeting and George Fishel took over as secretary
Andy McGregor presented a draft liaison letter by TG2 David Trinkwon proposed an amendmentto letter The letter as amended was approved by voice vote
Gene Robinson from the regulatory affairs committee presented three draft letters to regulatorybodies of the US Canada and the UK The letters were edited by Marks The letters wereapproved by unanimous voice vote
Brian Petry indicated that a document containing a draft editorial policy and procedures is on theserver Brian Petry said that anyone wishing to be an editor should read the document Thechairman requested that members give information to Brian on the editorial process
At 1228 Marks adjourned Session9
4 AcknowledgementsThe 80216 secretary would like to thank the sub-group chairs (Carl Eklund Jay Klein AndyMcGregor Brian Kiernan and Durga Satapathy) and the people who took care of the attendancebooks for each group (Juan Zuniga Carl Bushue and Drayt Avera) The multiple attendance bookapproach seemed to work well due mainly to the help of the above people
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
9
Respectfully
Scott Marin
80216 Secretary
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
10
Appendix A Opening Plenary Presentations
Opening Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Opening Plenary Meeting AgendaMonday 11 September 2000 1400-1515
See Opening Plenary presentation slidesOpening of Session 9 and of Opening Plenary Meeting 1400Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Opening Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule of meetings for the week Marks V
Membership and Voting 1410Rights of members observers and others Marks IAttendance list procedure Marin IVoting token procedure Marin I
Announcements 1415Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks ILogistics rooms breaks etc Marks IIndividual and Anti-Trust Marks IIEEE 80216 Patent Policies and Procedures Marks I
Approvals 1425Minutes of Session 8 (IEEE 80216-0017) Marks V
802161 1430Report Marks IEditing Mollenauer Petry 802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1440Report McGregor I
802163 1450Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1500Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1510Voting in Task Groups and Study Groups Marks I
New Business 1513
Closing 1515Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
11
Agenda for the Week
80216 Session 9 AgendaSchedule (tentative)
Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMo
n
RAWCONKeynote Address
Ballroom A-D120-150 pm
(80216 RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster
Session530-700 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCON Lunch1230-130 pm
(80216 RegistrantsInvited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster
Session530-700 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon 5
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG3Salon GH8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
12
Chairmans Opening Plenary Presentation
IEEE 80216 Session 9 Opening Plenary Meeting
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
NoneDate Submitted
2000-09-11Source
Roger Marks Voice +1-303-497-3037NIST Fax +1-303-497-7828325 Broadway MC 81300 E-mail marksnistgovBoulder CO 80303
VenueSession 9 Opening Plenary
Base DocumentNone
PurposeThis presentation is to be inserted in the Session 9 minutes
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) ororganization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to addamend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creationof an IEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contributionand at the IEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor alsoacknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16 iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including thestatement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms andconditions for the purpose of implementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chairltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt as early as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentsnoticesgt
IEEE 80216Working Group on
Broadband Wireless Access(BWA)
Session 9Opening Plenary
11 September 2000
200-315 pm
Session Opening
bull Call to Order
bull Welcome
80216 Officers
bull Chair Roger Marks
bull Vice Chair Lou Olsen
bull Secretary Scott Marin
Agenda
bull Presentation of 80216 OpeningPlenary Agendandash Chair asks for unanimous consent to
approve
bull Schedule of meetings for the weekndash Chair asks for unanimous consent to
approve
Rights of Allbull To subscribe to the 80216 Email Reflector
(stds-802-16) and thereby be notified ofdocument publication meetings minutes
bull To post to stds-802-16 in accordance with thereflector rules
bull To examine documents unless copyrightconcerns prohibit it
bull To contribute documents in response to aCall for Contributions
bull To attend and participate in 80216 meetingsif registered
bull To join the Sponsor Balloting Pool
IEEE and IEEE SA Membership
bull Members are encouraged to join IEEEIEEE Standards Association and IEEEComputer Society
bull Such membership is not required forWorking Group Membership ObserverStatus or Sponsor Ballot PoolGroup
Sponsor Ballot PoolGroup
bull Balloting Pool is being constructed
bull Future 80216 draft standards will beballoted by a Balloting Group drawn frommembers of the 80216 Balloting Pool
bull To join the 80216 Balloting Pool use theform on the web
bull Members of IEEE Standards Association[IEEE or CS + $10] can participate in BallotGroup without paying special fee
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
13
Rights of Members amp Observers
bull To examine draft standardsbull To participate in Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To examine the votes of Working
Group membersbull To examine the Member and Observer
contact databases
Exclusive Rights of Membershipbull To make or second a motion at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote if and only if present at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote in 80216 Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To vote by email on any issue involving
80216 or its subsidiariesbull To lodge complaints about Working Group
operation with the 802 Executive Committeebull To petition the 802 Executive Committee in
writing
Attendance Listbull Recorded at each ldquomeeting intervalrdquo
ndashAfternoon MonTueWedThundashMorning TueWedThuFri
ndashEvening Thu
ndashSelf-declared ldquosubstantially allrdquo of meetingndashSession ldquoParticipationrdquo 75 of meeting intervals
bull =will round down to 6
bull Attendance recorded in parallel meetingsndashvoting credit for presence at either
bull Attendance is public recordndashattendance will be reported on webndashcontact info will not be posted (just company)
Secretaryrsquos Announcementsbull Scott Marin
ndash Attendance books (four of them)
bull Write your namebull If new and unregistered insert business
card in pocketbull Initial and keep the book movingbull Remember your book and page number
ndash Voting tokensbull Printed on badge for Membersbull Raise to vote
Registration
bull $140
bull Registration fee form at front deskndashHotel guest charge to roomndashOthers credit card
bull Receive copy of form as receipt
Document Distributionbull Server http10001bull Run DHCPbull Use 10BaseT or 100BaseTXbull Use 80211b or 80211 DSSS Wireless
bull Upload files using anonymous ftp
bull Flash Card may be available
Logistics
bull Meeting Roomsndash Vary throughout the week
bull Breaksndash Always in large room (E or D)
bull RAWCON events
Individuality
bull In IEEE standards meetingsparticipation is by individualndash you do not represent a company or
organization
bull Membership belongs to the individualnot an organization and may not betransferred
Legal and Anti-Trust
bull Any discussions that relate to thevalidity or cost of patent use shall beavoided
bull Any discussions or any materialrelating to an ongoing litigation shallbe avoided
bull Any discussions of pricing or issuesthat would violate US antitrust lawsshall be avoided
IEEE 80216 Patent Policybull IEEE 80216 operates under the Patent Policy of
the IEEE Standards Association as set forth inClause 6 of the IEEE-SA Standards BoardBylaws This policy includes the statement
bull IEEE standards may include the known use ofpatent(s) including patent applications if there istechnical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and providedthe IEEE receives assurance from the patentholder that it will license applicants underreasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standard
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
14
IEEE 80216 Patent Policy (cont)bull IEEE 80216 interprets in the opinion of the standards-
developing committee as in the opinion of the members of theWorking Group Early disclosure to the Working Groupparticipants of patent information that might be relevant to thestandard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and to increase the likelihood that the draftpublication will be approved for publication IEEE 80216 strivesto make such information available as soon as possible forconsideration by individual members in their voting decisionsHowever in its meetings and electronic forums IEEE 80216does not permit discussions concerning the validity orapplicability of intellectual property claims The only role a patentclaim plays in Working Group discussions concerns ensuringcompliance to the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures
bull Justification for the inclusion of technology is limited to thetechnical merits of the technology
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresAnyone whether participating in IEEE 80216 or notshould notify the Chair of any patents (granted orunder application and regardless of the assignee orthe patent nationality) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved byIEEE 80216 Such notification should be in written orelectronic form (email is preferred) and need notmake any statement concerning enforcement orlicensing The Chair will presume that suchnotification is intended for public release and will assoon as practical post it to the web along with otherPatent Notices On File with IEEE 80216 The Chairand the Working Group will take no positionregarding the validity or applicability of any patents
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresWritten contributions to IEEE 80216 standards development willnot be accepted without an acknowledgement of familiarity with theIEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures Thisacknowledgement will be part of the mandatory contribution coversheet and will read
ldquoThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policyand Procedures (Version )
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information thatmight be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce thepossibility for delays in the development process andincrease the likelihood that the draft publication will beapproved for publication Please notify the Chair as early aspossible in written or electronic form of any patents (grantedor under application) that may cover technology that is underconsideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 TheChair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 websiterdquo
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresThe Chair once formally notified and once apotentially relevant draft standard exists shallwrite to the identified party and request that aLetter of Assurance be filed with the Chair forforwarding to the IEEE-SA Patent Committee inaccordance with the instructions in the IEEE-SAStandards Board Operations Manual A samplerequest letter and response letter are availableWhen the Patent Committee has accepted theletter as a Letter of Assurance informationregarding the letter will be indexed in the Recordsof IEEE Standards-Related Patents
Approval of Minutes
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to
ndash approve Document IEEE 80216-0017(Minutes of Session 8)
TG1 (802161)bull Air Interface for Fixed Broadband
Wireless Access Systemsbull 10-66 GHz
bull Chair Roger Marksbull Editor Jim MollenauerBrian Petrybull MAC Chair Carl Eklundbull PHY Chair Jay Klein
TG1 Goals for Week
ndashStay on Development PlanbullInitiative Working Group Letter BallotbullSeek approval at Closing Plenary
ndashMACbullComment resolutionbullMeet with TG3
ndashPHYbullComment resolutionbullOther contributionsbullMeet with TG2
TG2 (802162)ndashCoexistence of Broadband Wireless
Access Systems
ndashCo-Chair Andy McGregorndashCo-Chair Leland LangstonndashVice Chair Reacutemi Chayer
ndashEditor Vito Scaringindash Secretary Reza Arefi
TG3 (802163)bull Broadband Wireless Access Systems
in Licensed Bands from 2 to 11 GHzbull Chair Brian Kiernanbull Vice Chair Carl Bushuebull Secretary Dean Changbull Functional Requirements
ndashBrian PetryndashGeorge Fishel
WirelessHUMANTM Study Group
bull Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed MetropolitanArea Networks
bull Chair Durga Satapathybull Secretary Sanjay Moghe
bull Chartered at Session 6bull Renewed at Session 8bull Writing a PAR
bull To coordinate with 80211 and 80215
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
15
Charge to Task Groupsbull Complete the task on your agenda
ndashUpdate agenda on bulletin board
bull Prepare for next meetingndashCall for Contributions etc
bull Prepare for Closing Plenary
ndashAll motions to be in writingbull Document everything
ndash submit documents before you leavendash provide document index on bulletin board
bull Presentations to server 2 hours in advance
Voting in Task Groups
bull Only 80216 Voting Members may vote in taskGroup meetingsndashShow Voting Token
bull All present are eligible to vote at Study Groupmeetings
New Business
bull Request for New Business items
Adjournment
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to adjournthis meeting of Working Group 80216until the Midweek Plenaryndash(5-6 pm on Wednesday 13 September)
TG2 Status Report
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 1
IEEE 802162 Activities
Recommended Practice forCoexistence of BroadbandWireless Access Systems
Co-chairs Leland Langston Andy McGregor
Vice Chair Remi ChayerEditor Vito Scaringi
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 2
Activities since San DiegoMeeting
bull R7 of draft Practice issued late July
bull Several input docs and comments receivedbull Teleconference held Sept 7th ndash 8 participants
ndashSignificant discussion on content
bull R8 of draft Practice available Sept 11th
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 3
Plans for Denver
bull Close issue of single vs multiple interferers
bull Review doc for consistency amp completenessbull Present summary to joint TG1TG2bull Post R9 in week of Sept 18th
bull Seeking comments from any 80216 participant
bull TARGET TG ballot following Tampa meeting
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
16
Appendix B Midweek Plenary Presentations
Midweek Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Midweek Plenary Meeting AgendaWednesday 13 September 2000 1700-1800
Opening of Midweek Plenary Meeting 1700Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Midweek Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule Update Marks V
Announcements 1705
Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IAttendance books badges etc Marin I
802161 1710
Report Marks I802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1720Report McGregor I
802163 1730
Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1740
Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1745
Liaison 1750
ITU Costa ETSI BRAN Klein
Closing 1755
New Business (Marin Editorial Process) Marks VAdjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
17
Agenda for the Week as revised at the Midweek Plenary
80216 Session 9 Agenda Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMon
RAWCONKeynoteAddress
Ballroom A-D
120-150 pm(80216
RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCONLunch
1230-130pm
(80216Registrants
Invited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon G
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon H
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG16-730 pmSalon E
TG3Salon E
8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
TG3730-10 pm
Salon E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
18
Appendix C Closing Plenary Presentations
Closing Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Closing Plenary Meeting AgendaFriday 15 September 2000 10 am -1200 noon
Opening 1000Call to Order Marks IAgenda Marks V
Announcements 1003Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IVice Chair Marks I80216 Logo Marks D
WirelessHUMAN 1010Report Satapathy IPAR Approval Satapathy V
802161 1025Report Marks I802161 Working Group Review Marks V
802162 1050Report McGregor IFinal Task Group Review McGregor IMotions McGregor V
802163 1110Report Kiernan IMotions Kiernan V
Future Meetings 1130
Session 10 6-10 November 2000 Hyatt Regency Tampa Tampa Florida USA Marks ISunday Monday Friday at Session 10 Marks DSession 11 22-26 January 2001 Tel Aviv Israel Marks ISession 12 12-15 March 2001 Hyatt Regency Hilton Head South Carolina USA Marks ISession 13 7-11 May 2001 Orlando Florida USA along with IEEE 80211 and 80215 Marks I
Liaison 1135
ETSI BRANnotification of 802161 status and offer of password Marks V
Regulatory Agency notifications Robinson V
New Business 114080216 Editorial Policy MarinPetry V
Closing 1200
Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
19
WirelessHUMANtrade Closing Presentation[Insert Document Title Here]
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
[The appropriate coordinator normally the Task Group Chair will fill in this number after obtaining it from the 80216 Chair The
document number will match that of the base contribution with ldquoprdquo replacing ldquocrdquo For example 802161p-00nn]Date Submitted
[2000-07-13]Source
[Durga Satapathy] [Voice(913) 534-6338] [Sprint] [Fax (913) 534-6522] [7101 College Blvd Suite 1436 B] mailto[durgasatapathymailsprintcom [Overland Park KS 66210]
Venue
[IEEE 80216 Session 8]Base Document
[If this presentation illustrates an 80216 document cite the document number and URL lthttpieee802org16hellipgt]Purpose
[WirelessHUMAN Study Group report at closing plenary]Notice
This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s)The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw materialcontained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creation of anIEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution and at theIEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor also acknowledges and acceptsthat this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including the statementldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developingcommittee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purpose ofimplementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chair ltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt asearly as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology that is under consideration by or has beenapproved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentslettersgt
IEEE 80216 Plenary Report
Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed Metropolitan Area Network
(WirelessHUMANTM) Study Group
Durga P Satapathy
WirelessHUMANTM Update
bull Reviewed 8 contributions
bull Achieved consensus on selecting standardsto utilizemodifyndashMAC 80216ndashPHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
bull Drafted PAR and 5 criteria
WirelessHUMANTM PAR Scope This standard specifies the physical layer and media access control
layer of the air interface of interoperable fixed broadband wirelessmetropolitan area network systems including point-to-multipoint Thestandard enables access to data video and voice services with qualityof service in unlicensed bands designated for public network access Itwill focus on the 5-6 GHz range and may be applied to unlicensedbands between 2 and 11 GHz The WirelessHUMAN standard willutilize or modify applicable elements from the following
MAC 80216
PHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
The development of the WirelessHUMAN standard will follow thetimeline as shown in Appendix A
WirelessHUMANTM Timeline
bull Call For Proposals for WirelessHUMAN PHYMAC Nov 2000)ndash PHY Modifications of 80211a HIPERLAN2ndash MAC Modifications of 80216
bull Review proposals Jan 2001
bull Select candidate proposals at Interim meeting Feb 2001bull Decision on specific modifications March 2001
bull First Draft Standard May 2001
bull Comment Resolutions July 2001
bull Second Draft Standard Sep 2001bull Finalize WirelessHUMAN Standard Nov 2001
Purpose of Proposed Project
To enable rapid worldwide deployment of innovative cost-effectiveand interoperable multi-vendor broadband wireless metropolitan areanetwork products operating in the unlicensed bands To facilitatecompetition in broadband access by providing fixed wirelessalternatives to wireline broadband access Identify techniques totolerate interference in the unlicensed bands facilitate strategies forcoexistence with other unlicensed band systems such as 80211a andmaximize the carrying capacity of the unlicensed bands Encourageconsistent worldwide allocation and accelerate the commercializationof unlicensed broadband wireless access spectrum Utilization ofunlicensed frequencies will address a market that includes residencesSmall Office-Home Office (SOHO) telecommuters and Small andMedium Enterprises (SME)
WirelessHUMAN Study Group Participants
Sprint RF Solutions Agilent Technologies
Intel Breezecom Adaptive BroadbandNokia Transcomm Inc Cabletron
Ericsson BNA Systems WirelessHomeLucent Escape Carleton UniversityIntracom Malibu Networks Carnegie Mellon UniversityProxim Ultracom Georgia Institute of TechnologyWaveIP Harris Corporation HRL Laboratories LLCN Band Com Wireless Inc Western MultiplexCoreon Inc Cabletron systems Communications Research Center
Runcom Magnolia Broadband Yokogawa Electric CoInnowave ECI
Motion
The proposed WirelessHUMANTM PARbe accepted
TG1 MAC ClosingPresentation
(TG1 MAC reportppt)
1 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
TG1 MAC group
bull Resolved comments received during Final TaskGroup review
bull Major effort to remove any particular PHYdependence from the MAC
bull Process of adding features useful for TG3requirments started
bull Meeting with TG3
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
20
2 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
Important MAC decisions
bull Adoption of EUI-48 addresses (previouslyEUI-64)
bull Addition of error control to MAC layer(previously defined in TC layer of PHY B)
bull Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes into asingle mode
bull Redesigned DL MAP message for higherspectral efficiency
TG1 PHY ClosingPresentation
Document Number80216pp-
TitlePHY TG1 Report at Session 9
Date Submitted
91500Source
Jay KleinVenue
Denver September 2000Base Document
None
PurposeReport
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist the IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the
contributing individual(s) or organization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after furtherstudy The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by 80216
IEEE Patent Policy
The contributor is familiar with the IEEE Patent Policy which is set forth in the IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylawslthttpstandards ieeeorgguidesbylawsgt and includes the statement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s)
including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developing committee and provided theIEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standardrdquo
PHY TG1 Report Session 9
Jay KleinEnsemble Communications
Documents Submitted
bull 802161pc-0044 (2000-09-07) Recommendation onLMDS Radio Propagation Channel Models
bull 802161c-0007 (2000-09-10)FEC Parameterization for Data Transport (Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0006 (2000-09-08)FEC Parameterization for Control Channel Information(Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0004 (2000-09-01)Frequency Synthesizer Model Parameters (Lars Lindh andHans Somerma)
Documents Submitted ndash cont
bull 802161c-0003 (2000-09-01)Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes in802161 (Ken Stanwood)
bull 802161c-0001 (2000-08-08)Summary of Open PHY Issues in IEEE 802161-0001 (Jeff Foerster)
Work done
bull All editorial comments resolved
bull All technical comments reviewed andresolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull TBDs resolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull Met with MAC group for ldquosynchronizingrdquo
TG3 Closing Presentation
802163 Task Group Reportbull Finished and Adopted Functional
Requirements Document except for editorialsndashOutput Comment database on server
bull Developed an initial List of EvaluationCriteria for PHY proposal evaluations FullCriteria to be developed at next meeting
bull Issuing two calls for contributionsndashPreliminary PHY proposalsndashDeployment Traffic and Propagation
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS
bull Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull Session 10 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband WirelessAccess will be held on 6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA In orderto assist in the evaluation of air interface proposals the 802163 Task Groupinvites contributions addressing the following issues
lang Traffic and deployment models based on single and multi-cellsystems
lang Channel propagation model
bull Contributions must be submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt Submissions will beconsidered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible followingreceipt for public access on the 80216 Web Site Email your contribution tothe 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernanltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 Chair Roger Marksltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS - Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull The Task Group 3 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access is preparing to define the PHY protocols for abroadband wireless access air interface specification for frequencies from 2 through 11 GHz The specification will be based on submittedcontributions with increasing detail required as the process progresses Mergers and improvements will be encouraged with final selectionscheduled for June 2001
bull The TG3 Task Group invites the submission of initial contributions representing proposed PHY solutions Contributors will be grantedagenda time during 80216 Working Group Session 10 (6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA) to present and discuss the merits oftheir proposals Only submissions to session 10 will be eligible for invitation to submit more detailed proposals to session 11 Eachproposal will be allocated equal agenda time on Tuesday November 7 If time permits the allocations will be 15 minutes of presentationfollowed by 15 minutes of discussion Submissions must follow the guidelines below
lang Include a descriptive titlelang Include an overview and a reference model that describes functions including interfaces to other layerslang Describe the benefits of the proposed PHY including any unique featureslang Describe any drawbacks of the proposed PHY
bull Explain how the submitted PHY relates to existing standards such as ITU-R JRG 8A-9B IEEE 80211 DOCSIS 11 ETSI HiperLAN orothers If it is based on an existing standard what differences occur due to BWA characteristics
lang Emphasize the scalability of the proposed PHY to deal efficiently with various data types as described in the 802163Functional Requirements Document
lang Include a statement on intellectual property rights and how 80216 may utilize the proposed PHY in a standard
bull The proposals will be evaluated based on criteria in the Evaluation Table below However at this initial stage contributions are not expectedto address in detail the discussion items in that table instead aiming for the more general description as outlined above Each of the VotingMembers of 80216 are eligible to participate in the evaluation if present Submitters receiving a combined score of 6 or better (out of 10) inany criterion in the Evaluation Table will be invited to submit more a detailed contribution for Session 11 (January 22-26 2001 in Tel AvivIsrael) Note that submissions need not represent a complete PHY but may focus on specific components
bull Contributions will be considered only if submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216 Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt The template requires a cover page and a narrative
bull Submissions will be considered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible following receipt for public access on the 80216Web Site lthttpieee802org16gt
bull Email your contribution to the 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernan ltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 ChairRoger Marks ltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
802163 Task Group Report
bull Officially Adopted TG1 MAC as TG3 DraftMAC
bull Create TG3 MAC Ad Hoc to review TG1MAC and provide TG3 Comments
bull Two Motions for the Working GroupndashLiaison to ETSI BRAN sub11 GHz WGndashEstablishment of 80216 Common MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
21
Motion 1
That the 80216 Working Group appoint ChetShirali as a liaison to the ETSI BRAN sub11GHz Working Group
Motion 2
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MACbullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
22
Appendix D Attendance at Session9Session9 was an interim session The 75 interval attendance criteria for Session 9 was 6 ormore intervals Please contact the 80216 Secretary (smarinixnetcomcom) if you feel yourattendance has been recorded incorrectly
The following 126 peopleregistered attendance at 6or more intervals and metthe attendance criteria
Aboukarr BakriAn SongArefi RezaArunachalam ArunAvera DraytAvivi EliAyyagari DeepakBaragar IanBaseghi BehshadBaugh CR (Rick)Belfiore CarlosBenyamin-Seeyar AnaderBushue CarlBuskila BaruchChan RebeccaChang DeanChayer ReacutemiCondie MaryCornelius JamesCosta JoseacuteCrilly Jr William JDoherty EdwardEdmonston BrainEidson BrianEklund CarlEl-Damhougy HeshamFishel GeorgeFoerster JeffreyGarrison G JackGesbert DavidGoldhammer MariannaGuillemette PhilGupta RakeshHadad ZionHall EricHamilton MichaelHammons RogerHatim BayaHebron YoanHilberman DanHosur SrinathHsuan YiHudson ThomasHum ColemanHunter WayneJacobsen EricJamali Hamadi
Jorgensen JacobKang InchulKasslin MikaKiernan BrianKim JohnKitroser ItzikKlein JayKolze ThomasKostas DemosKwak Byung-JaeKwak JoeLangley John BLangston J LelandLeiba YigalLewis BarryLicardie SergioLiebetreu JohnLindh LarsLo TitusMarin ScottMarks RogerMcCallister RonMcGregor AndyMcMullin RoderickMeyer RonaldMiddleton AndrewMizoguchi MasatoMody ApurvaMollenauer JamesPadan UziPetry BrianPleasant WayneRalston WilliamRan MosheResheff GuyRhodes ValentineRobinson GeneRoehr WaltRzeszewski TedSantacesaria ClaudioSatapathy DurgaSater GlenScaringi VitoScarpa CarlSchwartz RandallSegal YossiSellars MalcolmShan Tie-JunShimada ShusakuShirali ChetSkaar HelgeSmith SteveStamatelos George
Stambaugh KarlStanwood KenStewart MichaelStruhsaker PaulSydor JohnTappenden ChrisTateishi KimiyaTavormina JoeThomas RaymondThompson PaulTrinkwon DavidVan Waes NicoVarma SubirWachira MuyaWang ArthurWang Chao-ChunWang LeiWang XiaofengWard BobWhitehead PhilipWhiting RobertWilliams David GWise CurtWiss JohnYanover VladimirZuniga Juan Carlos
The following 18 peopleregistered attendance atless than 6 intervals anddid not meet theattendance criteria
Alspaugh MatthewCarlo JimFalconer DavidFoley MarkFoster RobertGupta AlokHancock DaleHarel HaimKhanna AmarpalKreig AndrewMonk AntonNadeau JamesOng Ling ChuenRafie ManouchehrRibner David BWheatley Chuck FYang S MichaelYurtkuran Erol
Motion 5
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MAC based on802161-0001r4bullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
Appendix E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
2
Minutes of 80216 Session 9A Interim Session of the IEEE 80216
Working Group on Broadband Wireless AccessDenver Marriott Southeast Denver Colorado USA
11 to 15 September 2000
1 Monday Sept 11 2000 Opening PlenaryAt 1400 Roger Marks 80216 Chairman called Session 9 to order (See Appendix A forOpening Plenary presentation slides)
Marks presented the Opening Plenary agenda The Opening Plenary agenda was approved withoutobjection
Marks presented the schedule for the week and noted the times in which 80216 attendees areinvited to events of the co-located 2000 IEEE Radio and Wireless Conference (RAWCON2000)Marks noted several parallel 80216 sessions and asked for comments on the agenda The schedulefor the week was approved without objection
Marks reviewed the 80216 process including the rights of all attendees and rights of members
Marks commented on the IEEE SA sponsor ballot pool and noted that the web site contains a formthat must be submitted to register for the pool Participants need to join IEEE-SA or pay aballoting fee to join the balloting group You must take action to register because registration is notautomatic
Marks continued with additional details on the rights of members and observers
Scott Marin 80216 Secretary noted that the session is being taped for accuracy that Session 9will use four attendance books (one for each task and study group) and that badges with votingtokens have been preprinted
Marks explained that 80216 registration of $140 is to be paid at the front desk of the hotel
Marks explained that document distribution would be from a DHCP server via 10BaseT100BaseT or 80211b connections Marks asked if document distribution by server was acceptableTwo people objected and asked for distribution by the flash card Marks said we would work out amethod of updating and distributing documents via his flash card
Marks summarized the RAWCON meeting schedule
Marks read the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy
Marks introduced the minutes from Session 8 Scott Marin reminded Marks of his request toinclude the revised 80216 membership list that resulted from attendance at Session 8 Marksasked for approval of the Session 8 minutes amended to include the 80216 membership list thatresulted from Session 8 The minutes as amended were approved without objection
Marks as chair of TG1 reported that the plan is to resolve all comments and by the end of theweek to approve a motion to send a draft to working group letter ballot Jim Mollenauer co-
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
3
editor explained the editing process as an outgrowth of the prior process used on the functionalrequirements document
Marks was asked if a document with the incorporated comments would be available for reviewMarks noted that a new document was posted last night with the consolidated MAC comments
As chair of the TG1 MAC Carl Eklund explained that a two-pass process is planned to resolvecomments the first pass for editorial and the second pass for technical Brian Petry asked that thegroup consider accepting editorial comments as a group
Jeff Foerster agreed to put a document containing consolidated PHY comments on the server forJim Mollenauer to consolidate with the MAC
As chairman of TG1 PHY Jay Klein reported that 58 comments and several contributions hadbeen received and would be dealt with during the week
As co-chair of TG2 Andy McGregor summarized the TG2 plans (See Appendix A)
In a slight deviation from the approved agenda Marks introduced Jim Carlo Chairman of 802 andVice-chair of the IEEE-SA Standards Board Carlo commented that he came to Session 9 toobserve and help the process He would attend until Wednesday and encouraged people to askquestions of him
As Chairman of TG3 Brian Kiernan reported that 13 contributions and 130 comments regardingthe functional requirements had been received About half of the comments were editorial Kiernancommented that the objectives for the week are to 1) finish the requirements document 2) establishan evaluation criteria and 3) deal with the issue of having a TG3 MAC common or different fromthe TG1 MAC
Marks reminded attendees that all voting members can vote in TG1 TG2 and TG3
As chairman of the WirelessHUMANtrade Study Group Durga Satapathy reported that the primarytask for the week to was to complete a draft PAR A key issue is to define the scope Sixcontributions have been received and several issues require resolution Drayt Avera will be actingsecretary for WirelessHUMANtrade at Session 9
Marks as 80216 Chairman charged task groups to among other things stick to the schedules andto turn on all documents before leaving Denver
Marks asked for new business and none was offered
Without objection the Opening Plenary was adjourned
2 Wednesday 13 September 2000 Midweek PlenaryAt 1702 Roger Marks Chairman of 80216 called the Midweek Plenary to order
Marks presented the agenda Marks accepted additions from Jay Klein to report on ETSI BRANHIPERACCESS and from Scott Marin to make a motion on the editorial process The modifiedagenda (Appendix B) was adopted without objection
Marks reviewed the agenda for ndashthe week and changes to the associated meeting rooms Using the80216 server connection Marks updated the agenda file on the server (Appendix B)
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
4
Concerning conference fees Marks asked that everyone pay the $140 by close of business todayso that he can check registration status tomorrow
Marks presented an update on the 80216 server and explained the process to upload files
Scott Marin as 80216 secretary commended Task Group chairs and attendance book people forthe good job of keeping the attendance books up to date In an informal pole attendees showedstrong support for the new multiple book approach
Regarding the TG1 MAC group Carl Eklund reported good progress in resolving comments AWednesday evening session is planned to continue comment resolution Eklund reported that theTG1 MAC group has decided to use a 48-bit MAC address instead of a 64-bit address Eklundexpressed some concern with the completeness of the document citing that no comments had beenreceived on the last 100 pages Eklund stated that the document is in much better shape than onMonday and expected to have an even better document by Friday Marks asked if changes ofinterest to TG3 had been made Eklund responded that TG3 requirements had been considered andcited as examples the additions of options for ARQ and shorter frames
Regarding the TG1 PHY Jay Klein stated that the 58 comments had been resolved and that thegroup was now resolving TBDs Klein stated that the plan is to continue with TBDs after a jointmeeting with the TG1 MAC group Klein was hopeful that a new version would be ready byFriday for release as a letter ballot
Regarding TG2 Andy McGregor explained that a decision had been reached that coexistenceanalysis can be based on individual transmitter emissions and TG2 decided that it was unnecessaryto aggregate emitters Coordination triggers had been agreed The grouprsquos goal is to handle all editsby Thursday The TG2 task group has requested a joint meeting with TG1 PHY at 800amThursday this was agreed to an arranged Andy McGregor reported that Marianna Goldhammerhad presented an update from ETSI TM4 and noted that TG2 expected to prepare a liaison reply
Regarding TG3 Brain Kiernan explained that TG3 had been working through comments receivedon the functional requirements and that work would continue at a Wednesday evening meeting from1930-2200 Kiernan further noted that TG3 plans to complete the characteristics and evaluationcriteria by the end of week Kiernan also noted that TG3 plans to develop a call for contributionson models (channel and traffic) and a call for preliminary abstracts on PHY proposals TG3 hadreceived a liaison letter from ETSI BRAN and Kiernan noted that TG3 needed to appoint a liaisonperson from TG3 to ETSI BRAN Kiernan announced a joint TG1TG3 meeting tomorrow nightand a joint TG3WirelessHUMANtrade meeting at 800-900 tomorrow
Regarding WirelessHUMANtrade Durga Sataphy reported completing review of the sevencontributions and that consensus had been reached to use 80211a and ETSI HIPERLAN2 as abasis for a PHY Satapathy further explained that the draft PAR states that the MAC would drawfrom the 80216 MAC Satapathy noted that WirelessHUMANtrade is developing the Five Criteriadocument Marks asked if the PAR required use of the stated standards Satapathy said no
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
5
In a charge to Task Groups Marks asked groups to submit meeting minutes by the end of theweek and to propose motions at future 80216 plenary meetings using only documents from theserver
Regarding ITU-R Joint Rapporteurs Group (JRG) 8A-9B Joseacute Costa reviewed document IEEE80216l-0016 Marks highlighted the importance of liaison with the ITU-R
Jay Klein reported on ETSI BRAN HIPERACCESS Liaison
Marks explained that ETSI BRAN 80211 and 80215 now share password protected documentsMarks also stated that 80216 must decide whether to share password protected documents withETSI BRAN By IEEE procedure working group letter ballot documents are considered draftstandards and must therefore be copyrighted and protected
Marks reported that a letter (document IEEE 80216l-0025) had been received from Andrew Kreigpresident of the Wireless Communications Association The letter announced the appointment ofDemos Kostas as liaison from WCA to 80216
Under new business Scott Marin expressed concern and the potential to abuse the editorialprocess to influence documents
Motion1 Scott Marin 2nd Brian Petry That the 80216 Chairman establishes written guidelines(boundaries) for editors that among other things explains what editors can and cannot do
Motion1 passes without objection Marks took an action to present draft editorial rules forapproval at the closing plenary
Marks adjourned the midweek plenary at 1810
3 Friday 15 September 2000 Closing PlenaryAt 1005 Roger Marks called the meeting to order
Marks presented a draft agenda The agenda (See Appendix C) was approved without objection
Marks reported a few bugs with the registration fees that may need to be fixed and asked people tocheck their hotel statements carefully
Marks displayed the server page and explained the organization and ways to uses the server
Marks announced that 80216 Vice Chair Lou Olsen had resigned and that a new vice chair wouldbe elected at 80216 Session 10 Marks appointed Brian Petry as Acting Vice Chair until theelection Brian Petry accepted the appointment (and said hersquod continue to push for cookies atbreaks)
Marks displayed logo_bpng which had been introduced in a previous message to the 80216 e-mail reflector
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
6
The above logo was approved without objection
Regarding WirelessHUMANtrade Durga Satapathy reported a decision to use the 80216 MAC anda PHY based on ETSI BRAN HIPERLAN2 and 80211a (See presentation in Appendix C)Satapathy also reported completion of a draft project authorization request (PAR) and presentedthe draft
Motion2 Durga Satpathy 2nd Drayt Avera to accept the 91500 version of theWirelessHUMANtrade PAR (serverspublicWirelessHUMAN PAR 2000-09-15doc) with somelatitude to adjust text before submission to the 802 Executive Committee
The proposed WirelessHUMANtrade PAR be forwarded to the IEEE 802 SEC at least 30 days priorto the start of the following IEEE 802 Plenary session subject to a comments from IEEE 80211and 80215 and a comment revision process on the 80216 email reflector
Marks asked that the PAR be changed from a ldquoNew Standardrdquo to a ldquoSupplementrdquo The change wasaccepted without objection
Motion2amended Durga Satpathy 2nd Drayt Avera to accept the 91500 version of theWirelessHUMANtrade PAR (serverspublicWirelessHUMAN PAR 2000-09-15doc) with somelatitude to adjust text before submission to executive committee and that the type of document be asupplement rather than a new standard
The proposed WirelessHUMANtrade PAR be forwarded to the IEEE 802 SEC at least 30 days priorto the start of the following IEEE 802 Plenary session subject to a comments from IEEE 80211and 80215 and a comment revision process on the 80216 email reflector
Motion3 to amend Motion2 Tom Kolze 2nd Chet Sharali to amend Motion2 by addingDOCSIS 11 to the PAR Where it says ldquoMAC 80216rdquo to add ldquoDOCSIS 11rdquo
By token vote 3 for 15 against Motion3 fails
By token vote 23 for 1 against 4 abstain Motion2 as amended passes The approveddocument is IEEE 80216h-0013r0
Marks congratulated the WirelessHUMANtrade study group for reaching this stage in their work
Regarding TG1 MAC Carl Eklund reported that TG1 received several hundred comments on thedraft specification and used most of the meeting time to resolve the comments A major emphasis
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
7
was placed on removing the PHY dependencies from the MAC Eklund noted that a joint meetingwas held with TG3 in which many misunderstandings were discussed
Regarding the TG1 PHY John Liebetreu presented a summary (See Appendix C)
Motion4 John Liebetreu 2nd not needed to initiate a Working Group Review of the IEEE802161 working document number 802161-0001r4 (to be constructed by incorporating theresolved comments listed in document number 802161-0009 into 802161-0001r3) Thereview is set to begin September 29 and to end October 30 2000 See call for comments 802161-0005
By voice vote all for Motion4 passes
Marks reviewed the additional call for contributions on 802161rsquos open technical issues noting adue date of 30 October 2000 and that convergence layer text for IP Ethernet and ATM will besubmitted by Carl Eklund Glen Sater and Ken Stanwood respectively
Regarding TG2 Andy McCregor presented the meeting minutes (IEEE 802162c-0022) and notedfour recommendations from the meeting 1) to use a more formal call for comments 2) to invitecomments from other organizations such as WCA NSMA RABC and ARIB 3) to formally askfor comments from the Broadband Wireless Association of the UK and 4) to put the next draft ofthe coexistence practice on the public side of the IEEE 80216 web site
Marks asked TG2 to remove the copyright notice from their working document and not call thedocument a draft until a later stage in the process
Regarding TG3 Brian Kiernan reported (see Appendix C) adoption of the TG3 functionalrequirements document development of evaluation criteria and development of a call forcontributions In addition TG3 adopted the TG1 MAC and formed the TG3 MAC Ad Hoccommittee to review the TG1 MAC
Motion5 Brian Kiernan 2nd not needed Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bull Establish a common 80216 MAC based on 802161-0001r4
bull Require each 80216 task group to define its mandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMAC
bull Shall ensure backward compatibility and maintenance of the common MAC and
bull Shall strive to ensure forward compatibility of the common MAC
By token vote 24 for 0 against 1 abstain Motion5 passes See Appendix E
Marks acknowledged several organizational issues that must be worked Marks will try to resolveas many issues as possible by the November meeting
Regarding upcoming meetings Marks noted that the next meeting (Session 10) will be in TampaFlorida and that the opportunity exists to extend the Task Group meetings to Friday morning orMonday morning Marks also noted the possibility of joint meetings with other 802 workinggroups
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
8
Marks noted that Session 11 is scheduled for 22 to 26 January 2001 in Tel Aviv Israel hosted byBreezeCOM
Marks noted that Session 13 (May 7-11 2000) will be a joint meeting with 80211 and 80215 andpossibly ETSI BRAN Marks noted his desire to hold interim meetings together with other 802groups
Marks asked for a straw pole as to those in favor of meeting Sundays none for and about 20against
Regarding Liaison Marks noted that ETSI BRAN recommended that Demos Kostas act as contactin both directions Marks plans to reply using Demos Kostas in both directions
Marks noted that as of this week 80216 members and observers now have access to a mirror ofall ETSI BRAN documents Marks will send out information to members and observers on how toaccess the documents
Regarding liaison with ETSI BRAN Marks showed a draft liaison letter (80216l-00_28doc)
Motion6 Marks 2nd Brian Petry to approve draft letter presented by Marks (document IEEE80216l-0028)
Motion7 Brian Petry Brian Kiernan to amend motion6 by replacing we appoint Dr Kostas asour informal contact person for the information exchange with for a contact person wethereby appointing no contact person
Motion7 by voice vote all for Motion7 passes
Motion6 by voice vote several for one opposed Motion6 passes
Scott Marin 80216 secretary had to leave the meeting and George Fishel took over as secretary
Andy McGregor presented a draft liaison letter by TG2 David Trinkwon proposed an amendmentto letter The letter as amended was approved by voice vote
Gene Robinson from the regulatory affairs committee presented three draft letters to regulatorybodies of the US Canada and the UK The letters were edited by Marks The letters wereapproved by unanimous voice vote
Brian Petry indicated that a document containing a draft editorial policy and procedures is on theserver Brian Petry said that anyone wishing to be an editor should read the document Thechairman requested that members give information to Brian on the editorial process
At 1228 Marks adjourned Session9
4 AcknowledgementsThe 80216 secretary would like to thank the sub-group chairs (Carl Eklund Jay Klein AndyMcGregor Brian Kiernan and Durga Satapathy) and the people who took care of the attendancebooks for each group (Juan Zuniga Carl Bushue and Drayt Avera) The multiple attendance bookapproach seemed to work well due mainly to the help of the above people
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
9
Respectfully
Scott Marin
80216 Secretary
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
10
Appendix A Opening Plenary Presentations
Opening Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Opening Plenary Meeting AgendaMonday 11 September 2000 1400-1515
See Opening Plenary presentation slidesOpening of Session 9 and of Opening Plenary Meeting 1400Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Opening Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule of meetings for the week Marks V
Membership and Voting 1410Rights of members observers and others Marks IAttendance list procedure Marin IVoting token procedure Marin I
Announcements 1415Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks ILogistics rooms breaks etc Marks IIndividual and Anti-Trust Marks IIEEE 80216 Patent Policies and Procedures Marks I
Approvals 1425Minutes of Session 8 (IEEE 80216-0017) Marks V
802161 1430Report Marks IEditing Mollenauer Petry 802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1440Report McGregor I
802163 1450Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1500Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1510Voting in Task Groups and Study Groups Marks I
New Business 1513
Closing 1515Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
11
Agenda for the Week
80216 Session 9 AgendaSchedule (tentative)
Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMo
n
RAWCONKeynote Address
Ballroom A-D120-150 pm
(80216 RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster
Session530-700 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCON Lunch1230-130 pm
(80216 RegistrantsInvited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster
Session530-700 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon 5
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG3Salon GH8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
12
Chairmans Opening Plenary Presentation
IEEE 80216 Session 9 Opening Plenary Meeting
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
NoneDate Submitted
2000-09-11Source
Roger Marks Voice +1-303-497-3037NIST Fax +1-303-497-7828325 Broadway MC 81300 E-mail marksnistgovBoulder CO 80303
VenueSession 9 Opening Plenary
Base DocumentNone
PurposeThis presentation is to be inserted in the Session 9 minutes
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) ororganization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to addamend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creationof an IEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contributionand at the IEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor alsoacknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16 iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including thestatement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms andconditions for the purpose of implementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chairltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt as early as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentsnoticesgt
IEEE 80216Working Group on
Broadband Wireless Access(BWA)
Session 9Opening Plenary
11 September 2000
200-315 pm
Session Opening
bull Call to Order
bull Welcome
80216 Officers
bull Chair Roger Marks
bull Vice Chair Lou Olsen
bull Secretary Scott Marin
Agenda
bull Presentation of 80216 OpeningPlenary Agendandash Chair asks for unanimous consent to
approve
bull Schedule of meetings for the weekndash Chair asks for unanimous consent to
approve
Rights of Allbull To subscribe to the 80216 Email Reflector
(stds-802-16) and thereby be notified ofdocument publication meetings minutes
bull To post to stds-802-16 in accordance with thereflector rules
bull To examine documents unless copyrightconcerns prohibit it
bull To contribute documents in response to aCall for Contributions
bull To attend and participate in 80216 meetingsif registered
bull To join the Sponsor Balloting Pool
IEEE and IEEE SA Membership
bull Members are encouraged to join IEEEIEEE Standards Association and IEEEComputer Society
bull Such membership is not required forWorking Group Membership ObserverStatus or Sponsor Ballot PoolGroup
Sponsor Ballot PoolGroup
bull Balloting Pool is being constructed
bull Future 80216 draft standards will beballoted by a Balloting Group drawn frommembers of the 80216 Balloting Pool
bull To join the 80216 Balloting Pool use theform on the web
bull Members of IEEE Standards Association[IEEE or CS + $10] can participate in BallotGroup without paying special fee
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
13
Rights of Members amp Observers
bull To examine draft standardsbull To participate in Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To examine the votes of Working
Group membersbull To examine the Member and Observer
contact databases
Exclusive Rights of Membershipbull To make or second a motion at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote if and only if present at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote in 80216 Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To vote by email on any issue involving
80216 or its subsidiariesbull To lodge complaints about Working Group
operation with the 802 Executive Committeebull To petition the 802 Executive Committee in
writing
Attendance Listbull Recorded at each ldquomeeting intervalrdquo
ndashAfternoon MonTueWedThundashMorning TueWedThuFri
ndashEvening Thu
ndashSelf-declared ldquosubstantially allrdquo of meetingndashSession ldquoParticipationrdquo 75 of meeting intervals
bull =will round down to 6
bull Attendance recorded in parallel meetingsndashvoting credit for presence at either
bull Attendance is public recordndashattendance will be reported on webndashcontact info will not be posted (just company)
Secretaryrsquos Announcementsbull Scott Marin
ndash Attendance books (four of them)
bull Write your namebull If new and unregistered insert business
card in pocketbull Initial and keep the book movingbull Remember your book and page number
ndash Voting tokensbull Printed on badge for Membersbull Raise to vote
Registration
bull $140
bull Registration fee form at front deskndashHotel guest charge to roomndashOthers credit card
bull Receive copy of form as receipt
Document Distributionbull Server http10001bull Run DHCPbull Use 10BaseT or 100BaseTXbull Use 80211b or 80211 DSSS Wireless
bull Upload files using anonymous ftp
bull Flash Card may be available
Logistics
bull Meeting Roomsndash Vary throughout the week
bull Breaksndash Always in large room (E or D)
bull RAWCON events
Individuality
bull In IEEE standards meetingsparticipation is by individualndash you do not represent a company or
organization
bull Membership belongs to the individualnot an organization and may not betransferred
Legal and Anti-Trust
bull Any discussions that relate to thevalidity or cost of patent use shall beavoided
bull Any discussions or any materialrelating to an ongoing litigation shallbe avoided
bull Any discussions of pricing or issuesthat would violate US antitrust lawsshall be avoided
IEEE 80216 Patent Policybull IEEE 80216 operates under the Patent Policy of
the IEEE Standards Association as set forth inClause 6 of the IEEE-SA Standards BoardBylaws This policy includes the statement
bull IEEE standards may include the known use ofpatent(s) including patent applications if there istechnical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and providedthe IEEE receives assurance from the patentholder that it will license applicants underreasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standard
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
14
IEEE 80216 Patent Policy (cont)bull IEEE 80216 interprets in the opinion of the standards-
developing committee as in the opinion of the members of theWorking Group Early disclosure to the Working Groupparticipants of patent information that might be relevant to thestandard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and to increase the likelihood that the draftpublication will be approved for publication IEEE 80216 strivesto make such information available as soon as possible forconsideration by individual members in their voting decisionsHowever in its meetings and electronic forums IEEE 80216does not permit discussions concerning the validity orapplicability of intellectual property claims The only role a patentclaim plays in Working Group discussions concerns ensuringcompliance to the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures
bull Justification for the inclusion of technology is limited to thetechnical merits of the technology
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresAnyone whether participating in IEEE 80216 or notshould notify the Chair of any patents (granted orunder application and regardless of the assignee orthe patent nationality) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved byIEEE 80216 Such notification should be in written orelectronic form (email is preferred) and need notmake any statement concerning enforcement orlicensing The Chair will presume that suchnotification is intended for public release and will assoon as practical post it to the web along with otherPatent Notices On File with IEEE 80216 The Chairand the Working Group will take no positionregarding the validity or applicability of any patents
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresWritten contributions to IEEE 80216 standards development willnot be accepted without an acknowledgement of familiarity with theIEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures Thisacknowledgement will be part of the mandatory contribution coversheet and will read
ldquoThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policyand Procedures (Version )
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information thatmight be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce thepossibility for delays in the development process andincrease the likelihood that the draft publication will beapproved for publication Please notify the Chair as early aspossible in written or electronic form of any patents (grantedor under application) that may cover technology that is underconsideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 TheChair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 websiterdquo
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresThe Chair once formally notified and once apotentially relevant draft standard exists shallwrite to the identified party and request that aLetter of Assurance be filed with the Chair forforwarding to the IEEE-SA Patent Committee inaccordance with the instructions in the IEEE-SAStandards Board Operations Manual A samplerequest letter and response letter are availableWhen the Patent Committee has accepted theletter as a Letter of Assurance informationregarding the letter will be indexed in the Recordsof IEEE Standards-Related Patents
Approval of Minutes
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to
ndash approve Document IEEE 80216-0017(Minutes of Session 8)
TG1 (802161)bull Air Interface for Fixed Broadband
Wireless Access Systemsbull 10-66 GHz
bull Chair Roger Marksbull Editor Jim MollenauerBrian Petrybull MAC Chair Carl Eklundbull PHY Chair Jay Klein
TG1 Goals for Week
ndashStay on Development PlanbullInitiative Working Group Letter BallotbullSeek approval at Closing Plenary
ndashMACbullComment resolutionbullMeet with TG3
ndashPHYbullComment resolutionbullOther contributionsbullMeet with TG2
TG2 (802162)ndashCoexistence of Broadband Wireless
Access Systems
ndashCo-Chair Andy McGregorndashCo-Chair Leland LangstonndashVice Chair Reacutemi Chayer
ndashEditor Vito Scaringindash Secretary Reza Arefi
TG3 (802163)bull Broadband Wireless Access Systems
in Licensed Bands from 2 to 11 GHzbull Chair Brian Kiernanbull Vice Chair Carl Bushuebull Secretary Dean Changbull Functional Requirements
ndashBrian PetryndashGeorge Fishel
WirelessHUMANTM Study Group
bull Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed MetropolitanArea Networks
bull Chair Durga Satapathybull Secretary Sanjay Moghe
bull Chartered at Session 6bull Renewed at Session 8bull Writing a PAR
bull To coordinate with 80211 and 80215
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
15
Charge to Task Groupsbull Complete the task on your agenda
ndashUpdate agenda on bulletin board
bull Prepare for next meetingndashCall for Contributions etc
bull Prepare for Closing Plenary
ndashAll motions to be in writingbull Document everything
ndash submit documents before you leavendash provide document index on bulletin board
bull Presentations to server 2 hours in advance
Voting in Task Groups
bull Only 80216 Voting Members may vote in taskGroup meetingsndashShow Voting Token
bull All present are eligible to vote at Study Groupmeetings
New Business
bull Request for New Business items
Adjournment
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to adjournthis meeting of Working Group 80216until the Midweek Plenaryndash(5-6 pm on Wednesday 13 September)
TG2 Status Report
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 1
IEEE 802162 Activities
Recommended Practice forCoexistence of BroadbandWireless Access Systems
Co-chairs Leland Langston Andy McGregor
Vice Chair Remi ChayerEditor Vito Scaringi
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 2
Activities since San DiegoMeeting
bull R7 of draft Practice issued late July
bull Several input docs and comments receivedbull Teleconference held Sept 7th ndash 8 participants
ndashSignificant discussion on content
bull R8 of draft Practice available Sept 11th
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 3
Plans for Denver
bull Close issue of single vs multiple interferers
bull Review doc for consistency amp completenessbull Present summary to joint TG1TG2bull Post R9 in week of Sept 18th
bull Seeking comments from any 80216 participant
bull TARGET TG ballot following Tampa meeting
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
16
Appendix B Midweek Plenary Presentations
Midweek Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Midweek Plenary Meeting AgendaWednesday 13 September 2000 1700-1800
Opening of Midweek Plenary Meeting 1700Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Midweek Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule Update Marks V
Announcements 1705
Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IAttendance books badges etc Marin I
802161 1710
Report Marks I802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1720Report McGregor I
802163 1730
Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1740
Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1745
Liaison 1750
ITU Costa ETSI BRAN Klein
Closing 1755
New Business (Marin Editorial Process) Marks VAdjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
17
Agenda for the Week as revised at the Midweek Plenary
80216 Session 9 Agenda Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMon
RAWCONKeynoteAddress
Ballroom A-D
120-150 pm(80216
RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCONLunch
1230-130pm
(80216Registrants
Invited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon G
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon H
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG16-730 pmSalon E
TG3Salon E
8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
TG3730-10 pm
Salon E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
18
Appendix C Closing Plenary Presentations
Closing Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Closing Plenary Meeting AgendaFriday 15 September 2000 10 am -1200 noon
Opening 1000Call to Order Marks IAgenda Marks V
Announcements 1003Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IVice Chair Marks I80216 Logo Marks D
WirelessHUMAN 1010Report Satapathy IPAR Approval Satapathy V
802161 1025Report Marks I802161 Working Group Review Marks V
802162 1050Report McGregor IFinal Task Group Review McGregor IMotions McGregor V
802163 1110Report Kiernan IMotions Kiernan V
Future Meetings 1130
Session 10 6-10 November 2000 Hyatt Regency Tampa Tampa Florida USA Marks ISunday Monday Friday at Session 10 Marks DSession 11 22-26 January 2001 Tel Aviv Israel Marks ISession 12 12-15 March 2001 Hyatt Regency Hilton Head South Carolina USA Marks ISession 13 7-11 May 2001 Orlando Florida USA along with IEEE 80211 and 80215 Marks I
Liaison 1135
ETSI BRANnotification of 802161 status and offer of password Marks V
Regulatory Agency notifications Robinson V
New Business 114080216 Editorial Policy MarinPetry V
Closing 1200
Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
19
WirelessHUMANtrade Closing Presentation[Insert Document Title Here]
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
[The appropriate coordinator normally the Task Group Chair will fill in this number after obtaining it from the 80216 Chair The
document number will match that of the base contribution with ldquoprdquo replacing ldquocrdquo For example 802161p-00nn]Date Submitted
[2000-07-13]Source
[Durga Satapathy] [Voice(913) 534-6338] [Sprint] [Fax (913) 534-6522] [7101 College Blvd Suite 1436 B] mailto[durgasatapathymailsprintcom [Overland Park KS 66210]
Venue
[IEEE 80216 Session 8]Base Document
[If this presentation illustrates an 80216 document cite the document number and URL lthttpieee802org16hellipgt]Purpose
[WirelessHUMAN Study Group report at closing plenary]Notice
This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s)The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw materialcontained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creation of anIEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution and at theIEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor also acknowledges and acceptsthat this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including the statementldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developingcommittee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purpose ofimplementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chair ltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt asearly as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology that is under consideration by or has beenapproved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentslettersgt
IEEE 80216 Plenary Report
Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed Metropolitan Area Network
(WirelessHUMANTM) Study Group
Durga P Satapathy
WirelessHUMANTM Update
bull Reviewed 8 contributions
bull Achieved consensus on selecting standardsto utilizemodifyndashMAC 80216ndashPHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
bull Drafted PAR and 5 criteria
WirelessHUMANTM PAR Scope This standard specifies the physical layer and media access control
layer of the air interface of interoperable fixed broadband wirelessmetropolitan area network systems including point-to-multipoint Thestandard enables access to data video and voice services with qualityof service in unlicensed bands designated for public network access Itwill focus on the 5-6 GHz range and may be applied to unlicensedbands between 2 and 11 GHz The WirelessHUMAN standard willutilize or modify applicable elements from the following
MAC 80216
PHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
The development of the WirelessHUMAN standard will follow thetimeline as shown in Appendix A
WirelessHUMANTM Timeline
bull Call For Proposals for WirelessHUMAN PHYMAC Nov 2000)ndash PHY Modifications of 80211a HIPERLAN2ndash MAC Modifications of 80216
bull Review proposals Jan 2001
bull Select candidate proposals at Interim meeting Feb 2001bull Decision on specific modifications March 2001
bull First Draft Standard May 2001
bull Comment Resolutions July 2001
bull Second Draft Standard Sep 2001bull Finalize WirelessHUMAN Standard Nov 2001
Purpose of Proposed Project
To enable rapid worldwide deployment of innovative cost-effectiveand interoperable multi-vendor broadband wireless metropolitan areanetwork products operating in the unlicensed bands To facilitatecompetition in broadband access by providing fixed wirelessalternatives to wireline broadband access Identify techniques totolerate interference in the unlicensed bands facilitate strategies forcoexistence with other unlicensed band systems such as 80211a andmaximize the carrying capacity of the unlicensed bands Encourageconsistent worldwide allocation and accelerate the commercializationof unlicensed broadband wireless access spectrum Utilization ofunlicensed frequencies will address a market that includes residencesSmall Office-Home Office (SOHO) telecommuters and Small andMedium Enterprises (SME)
WirelessHUMAN Study Group Participants
Sprint RF Solutions Agilent Technologies
Intel Breezecom Adaptive BroadbandNokia Transcomm Inc Cabletron
Ericsson BNA Systems WirelessHomeLucent Escape Carleton UniversityIntracom Malibu Networks Carnegie Mellon UniversityProxim Ultracom Georgia Institute of TechnologyWaveIP Harris Corporation HRL Laboratories LLCN Band Com Wireless Inc Western MultiplexCoreon Inc Cabletron systems Communications Research Center
Runcom Magnolia Broadband Yokogawa Electric CoInnowave ECI
Motion
The proposed WirelessHUMANTM PARbe accepted
TG1 MAC ClosingPresentation
(TG1 MAC reportppt)
1 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
TG1 MAC group
bull Resolved comments received during Final TaskGroup review
bull Major effort to remove any particular PHYdependence from the MAC
bull Process of adding features useful for TG3requirments started
bull Meeting with TG3
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
20
2 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
Important MAC decisions
bull Adoption of EUI-48 addresses (previouslyEUI-64)
bull Addition of error control to MAC layer(previously defined in TC layer of PHY B)
bull Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes into asingle mode
bull Redesigned DL MAP message for higherspectral efficiency
TG1 PHY ClosingPresentation
Document Number80216pp-
TitlePHY TG1 Report at Session 9
Date Submitted
91500Source
Jay KleinVenue
Denver September 2000Base Document
None
PurposeReport
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist the IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the
contributing individual(s) or organization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after furtherstudy The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by 80216
IEEE Patent Policy
The contributor is familiar with the IEEE Patent Policy which is set forth in the IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylawslthttpstandards ieeeorgguidesbylawsgt and includes the statement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s)
including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developing committee and provided theIEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standardrdquo
PHY TG1 Report Session 9
Jay KleinEnsemble Communications
Documents Submitted
bull 802161pc-0044 (2000-09-07) Recommendation onLMDS Radio Propagation Channel Models
bull 802161c-0007 (2000-09-10)FEC Parameterization for Data Transport (Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0006 (2000-09-08)FEC Parameterization for Control Channel Information(Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0004 (2000-09-01)Frequency Synthesizer Model Parameters (Lars Lindh andHans Somerma)
Documents Submitted ndash cont
bull 802161c-0003 (2000-09-01)Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes in802161 (Ken Stanwood)
bull 802161c-0001 (2000-08-08)Summary of Open PHY Issues in IEEE 802161-0001 (Jeff Foerster)
Work done
bull All editorial comments resolved
bull All technical comments reviewed andresolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull TBDs resolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull Met with MAC group for ldquosynchronizingrdquo
TG3 Closing Presentation
802163 Task Group Reportbull Finished and Adopted Functional
Requirements Document except for editorialsndashOutput Comment database on server
bull Developed an initial List of EvaluationCriteria for PHY proposal evaluations FullCriteria to be developed at next meeting
bull Issuing two calls for contributionsndashPreliminary PHY proposalsndashDeployment Traffic and Propagation
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS
bull Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull Session 10 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband WirelessAccess will be held on 6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA In orderto assist in the evaluation of air interface proposals the 802163 Task Groupinvites contributions addressing the following issues
lang Traffic and deployment models based on single and multi-cellsystems
lang Channel propagation model
bull Contributions must be submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt Submissions will beconsidered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible followingreceipt for public access on the 80216 Web Site Email your contribution tothe 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernanltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 Chair Roger Marksltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS - Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull The Task Group 3 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access is preparing to define the PHY protocols for abroadband wireless access air interface specification for frequencies from 2 through 11 GHz The specification will be based on submittedcontributions with increasing detail required as the process progresses Mergers and improvements will be encouraged with final selectionscheduled for June 2001
bull The TG3 Task Group invites the submission of initial contributions representing proposed PHY solutions Contributors will be grantedagenda time during 80216 Working Group Session 10 (6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA) to present and discuss the merits oftheir proposals Only submissions to session 10 will be eligible for invitation to submit more detailed proposals to session 11 Eachproposal will be allocated equal agenda time on Tuesday November 7 If time permits the allocations will be 15 minutes of presentationfollowed by 15 minutes of discussion Submissions must follow the guidelines below
lang Include a descriptive titlelang Include an overview and a reference model that describes functions including interfaces to other layerslang Describe the benefits of the proposed PHY including any unique featureslang Describe any drawbacks of the proposed PHY
bull Explain how the submitted PHY relates to existing standards such as ITU-R JRG 8A-9B IEEE 80211 DOCSIS 11 ETSI HiperLAN orothers If it is based on an existing standard what differences occur due to BWA characteristics
lang Emphasize the scalability of the proposed PHY to deal efficiently with various data types as described in the 802163Functional Requirements Document
lang Include a statement on intellectual property rights and how 80216 may utilize the proposed PHY in a standard
bull The proposals will be evaluated based on criteria in the Evaluation Table below However at this initial stage contributions are not expectedto address in detail the discussion items in that table instead aiming for the more general description as outlined above Each of the VotingMembers of 80216 are eligible to participate in the evaluation if present Submitters receiving a combined score of 6 or better (out of 10) inany criterion in the Evaluation Table will be invited to submit more a detailed contribution for Session 11 (January 22-26 2001 in Tel AvivIsrael) Note that submissions need not represent a complete PHY but may focus on specific components
bull Contributions will be considered only if submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216 Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt The template requires a cover page and a narrative
bull Submissions will be considered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible following receipt for public access on the 80216Web Site lthttpieee802org16gt
bull Email your contribution to the 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernan ltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 ChairRoger Marks ltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
802163 Task Group Report
bull Officially Adopted TG1 MAC as TG3 DraftMAC
bull Create TG3 MAC Ad Hoc to review TG1MAC and provide TG3 Comments
bull Two Motions for the Working GroupndashLiaison to ETSI BRAN sub11 GHz WGndashEstablishment of 80216 Common MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
21
Motion 1
That the 80216 Working Group appoint ChetShirali as a liaison to the ETSI BRAN sub11GHz Working Group
Motion 2
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MACbullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
22
Appendix D Attendance at Session9Session9 was an interim session The 75 interval attendance criteria for Session 9 was 6 ormore intervals Please contact the 80216 Secretary (smarinixnetcomcom) if you feel yourattendance has been recorded incorrectly
The following 126 peopleregistered attendance at 6or more intervals and metthe attendance criteria
Aboukarr BakriAn SongArefi RezaArunachalam ArunAvera DraytAvivi EliAyyagari DeepakBaragar IanBaseghi BehshadBaugh CR (Rick)Belfiore CarlosBenyamin-Seeyar AnaderBushue CarlBuskila BaruchChan RebeccaChang DeanChayer ReacutemiCondie MaryCornelius JamesCosta JoseacuteCrilly Jr William JDoherty EdwardEdmonston BrainEidson BrianEklund CarlEl-Damhougy HeshamFishel GeorgeFoerster JeffreyGarrison G JackGesbert DavidGoldhammer MariannaGuillemette PhilGupta RakeshHadad ZionHall EricHamilton MichaelHammons RogerHatim BayaHebron YoanHilberman DanHosur SrinathHsuan YiHudson ThomasHum ColemanHunter WayneJacobsen EricJamali Hamadi
Jorgensen JacobKang InchulKasslin MikaKiernan BrianKim JohnKitroser ItzikKlein JayKolze ThomasKostas DemosKwak Byung-JaeKwak JoeLangley John BLangston J LelandLeiba YigalLewis BarryLicardie SergioLiebetreu JohnLindh LarsLo TitusMarin ScottMarks RogerMcCallister RonMcGregor AndyMcMullin RoderickMeyer RonaldMiddleton AndrewMizoguchi MasatoMody ApurvaMollenauer JamesPadan UziPetry BrianPleasant WayneRalston WilliamRan MosheResheff GuyRhodes ValentineRobinson GeneRoehr WaltRzeszewski TedSantacesaria ClaudioSatapathy DurgaSater GlenScaringi VitoScarpa CarlSchwartz RandallSegal YossiSellars MalcolmShan Tie-JunShimada ShusakuShirali ChetSkaar HelgeSmith SteveStamatelos George
Stambaugh KarlStanwood KenStewart MichaelStruhsaker PaulSydor JohnTappenden ChrisTateishi KimiyaTavormina JoeThomas RaymondThompson PaulTrinkwon DavidVan Waes NicoVarma SubirWachira MuyaWang ArthurWang Chao-ChunWang LeiWang XiaofengWard BobWhitehead PhilipWhiting RobertWilliams David GWise CurtWiss JohnYanover VladimirZuniga Juan Carlos
The following 18 peopleregistered attendance atless than 6 intervals anddid not meet theattendance criteria
Alspaugh MatthewCarlo JimFalconer DavidFoley MarkFoster RobertGupta AlokHancock DaleHarel HaimKhanna AmarpalKreig AndrewMonk AntonNadeau JamesOng Ling ChuenRafie ManouchehrRibner David BWheatley Chuck FYang S MichaelYurtkuran Erol
Motion 5
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MAC based on802161-0001r4bullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
Appendix E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
3
editor explained the editing process as an outgrowth of the prior process used on the functionalrequirements document
Marks was asked if a document with the incorporated comments would be available for reviewMarks noted that a new document was posted last night with the consolidated MAC comments
As chair of the TG1 MAC Carl Eklund explained that a two-pass process is planned to resolvecomments the first pass for editorial and the second pass for technical Brian Petry asked that thegroup consider accepting editorial comments as a group
Jeff Foerster agreed to put a document containing consolidated PHY comments on the server forJim Mollenauer to consolidate with the MAC
As chairman of TG1 PHY Jay Klein reported that 58 comments and several contributions hadbeen received and would be dealt with during the week
As co-chair of TG2 Andy McGregor summarized the TG2 plans (See Appendix A)
In a slight deviation from the approved agenda Marks introduced Jim Carlo Chairman of 802 andVice-chair of the IEEE-SA Standards Board Carlo commented that he came to Session 9 toobserve and help the process He would attend until Wednesday and encouraged people to askquestions of him
As Chairman of TG3 Brian Kiernan reported that 13 contributions and 130 comments regardingthe functional requirements had been received About half of the comments were editorial Kiernancommented that the objectives for the week are to 1) finish the requirements document 2) establishan evaluation criteria and 3) deal with the issue of having a TG3 MAC common or different fromthe TG1 MAC
Marks reminded attendees that all voting members can vote in TG1 TG2 and TG3
As chairman of the WirelessHUMANtrade Study Group Durga Satapathy reported that the primarytask for the week to was to complete a draft PAR A key issue is to define the scope Sixcontributions have been received and several issues require resolution Drayt Avera will be actingsecretary for WirelessHUMANtrade at Session 9
Marks as 80216 Chairman charged task groups to among other things stick to the schedules andto turn on all documents before leaving Denver
Marks asked for new business and none was offered
Without objection the Opening Plenary was adjourned
2 Wednesday 13 September 2000 Midweek PlenaryAt 1702 Roger Marks Chairman of 80216 called the Midweek Plenary to order
Marks presented the agenda Marks accepted additions from Jay Klein to report on ETSI BRANHIPERACCESS and from Scott Marin to make a motion on the editorial process The modifiedagenda (Appendix B) was adopted without objection
Marks reviewed the agenda for ndashthe week and changes to the associated meeting rooms Using the80216 server connection Marks updated the agenda file on the server (Appendix B)
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
4
Concerning conference fees Marks asked that everyone pay the $140 by close of business todayso that he can check registration status tomorrow
Marks presented an update on the 80216 server and explained the process to upload files
Scott Marin as 80216 secretary commended Task Group chairs and attendance book people forthe good job of keeping the attendance books up to date In an informal pole attendees showedstrong support for the new multiple book approach
Regarding the TG1 MAC group Carl Eklund reported good progress in resolving comments AWednesday evening session is planned to continue comment resolution Eklund reported that theTG1 MAC group has decided to use a 48-bit MAC address instead of a 64-bit address Eklundexpressed some concern with the completeness of the document citing that no comments had beenreceived on the last 100 pages Eklund stated that the document is in much better shape than onMonday and expected to have an even better document by Friday Marks asked if changes ofinterest to TG3 had been made Eklund responded that TG3 requirements had been considered andcited as examples the additions of options for ARQ and shorter frames
Regarding the TG1 PHY Jay Klein stated that the 58 comments had been resolved and that thegroup was now resolving TBDs Klein stated that the plan is to continue with TBDs after a jointmeeting with the TG1 MAC group Klein was hopeful that a new version would be ready byFriday for release as a letter ballot
Regarding TG2 Andy McGregor explained that a decision had been reached that coexistenceanalysis can be based on individual transmitter emissions and TG2 decided that it was unnecessaryto aggregate emitters Coordination triggers had been agreed The grouprsquos goal is to handle all editsby Thursday The TG2 task group has requested a joint meeting with TG1 PHY at 800amThursday this was agreed to an arranged Andy McGregor reported that Marianna Goldhammerhad presented an update from ETSI TM4 and noted that TG2 expected to prepare a liaison reply
Regarding TG3 Brain Kiernan explained that TG3 had been working through comments receivedon the functional requirements and that work would continue at a Wednesday evening meeting from1930-2200 Kiernan further noted that TG3 plans to complete the characteristics and evaluationcriteria by the end of week Kiernan also noted that TG3 plans to develop a call for contributionson models (channel and traffic) and a call for preliminary abstracts on PHY proposals TG3 hadreceived a liaison letter from ETSI BRAN and Kiernan noted that TG3 needed to appoint a liaisonperson from TG3 to ETSI BRAN Kiernan announced a joint TG1TG3 meeting tomorrow nightand a joint TG3WirelessHUMANtrade meeting at 800-900 tomorrow
Regarding WirelessHUMANtrade Durga Sataphy reported completing review of the sevencontributions and that consensus had been reached to use 80211a and ETSI HIPERLAN2 as abasis for a PHY Satapathy further explained that the draft PAR states that the MAC would drawfrom the 80216 MAC Satapathy noted that WirelessHUMANtrade is developing the Five Criteriadocument Marks asked if the PAR required use of the stated standards Satapathy said no
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
5
In a charge to Task Groups Marks asked groups to submit meeting minutes by the end of theweek and to propose motions at future 80216 plenary meetings using only documents from theserver
Regarding ITU-R Joint Rapporteurs Group (JRG) 8A-9B Joseacute Costa reviewed document IEEE80216l-0016 Marks highlighted the importance of liaison with the ITU-R
Jay Klein reported on ETSI BRAN HIPERACCESS Liaison
Marks explained that ETSI BRAN 80211 and 80215 now share password protected documentsMarks also stated that 80216 must decide whether to share password protected documents withETSI BRAN By IEEE procedure working group letter ballot documents are considered draftstandards and must therefore be copyrighted and protected
Marks reported that a letter (document IEEE 80216l-0025) had been received from Andrew Kreigpresident of the Wireless Communications Association The letter announced the appointment ofDemos Kostas as liaison from WCA to 80216
Under new business Scott Marin expressed concern and the potential to abuse the editorialprocess to influence documents
Motion1 Scott Marin 2nd Brian Petry That the 80216 Chairman establishes written guidelines(boundaries) for editors that among other things explains what editors can and cannot do
Motion1 passes without objection Marks took an action to present draft editorial rules forapproval at the closing plenary
Marks adjourned the midweek plenary at 1810
3 Friday 15 September 2000 Closing PlenaryAt 1005 Roger Marks called the meeting to order
Marks presented a draft agenda The agenda (See Appendix C) was approved without objection
Marks reported a few bugs with the registration fees that may need to be fixed and asked people tocheck their hotel statements carefully
Marks displayed the server page and explained the organization and ways to uses the server
Marks announced that 80216 Vice Chair Lou Olsen had resigned and that a new vice chair wouldbe elected at 80216 Session 10 Marks appointed Brian Petry as Acting Vice Chair until theelection Brian Petry accepted the appointment (and said hersquod continue to push for cookies atbreaks)
Marks displayed logo_bpng which had been introduced in a previous message to the 80216 e-mail reflector
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
6
The above logo was approved without objection
Regarding WirelessHUMANtrade Durga Satapathy reported a decision to use the 80216 MAC anda PHY based on ETSI BRAN HIPERLAN2 and 80211a (See presentation in Appendix C)Satapathy also reported completion of a draft project authorization request (PAR) and presentedthe draft
Motion2 Durga Satpathy 2nd Drayt Avera to accept the 91500 version of theWirelessHUMANtrade PAR (serverspublicWirelessHUMAN PAR 2000-09-15doc) with somelatitude to adjust text before submission to the 802 Executive Committee
The proposed WirelessHUMANtrade PAR be forwarded to the IEEE 802 SEC at least 30 days priorto the start of the following IEEE 802 Plenary session subject to a comments from IEEE 80211and 80215 and a comment revision process on the 80216 email reflector
Marks asked that the PAR be changed from a ldquoNew Standardrdquo to a ldquoSupplementrdquo The change wasaccepted without objection
Motion2amended Durga Satpathy 2nd Drayt Avera to accept the 91500 version of theWirelessHUMANtrade PAR (serverspublicWirelessHUMAN PAR 2000-09-15doc) with somelatitude to adjust text before submission to executive committee and that the type of document be asupplement rather than a new standard
The proposed WirelessHUMANtrade PAR be forwarded to the IEEE 802 SEC at least 30 days priorto the start of the following IEEE 802 Plenary session subject to a comments from IEEE 80211and 80215 and a comment revision process on the 80216 email reflector
Motion3 to amend Motion2 Tom Kolze 2nd Chet Sharali to amend Motion2 by addingDOCSIS 11 to the PAR Where it says ldquoMAC 80216rdquo to add ldquoDOCSIS 11rdquo
By token vote 3 for 15 against Motion3 fails
By token vote 23 for 1 against 4 abstain Motion2 as amended passes The approveddocument is IEEE 80216h-0013r0
Marks congratulated the WirelessHUMANtrade study group for reaching this stage in their work
Regarding TG1 MAC Carl Eklund reported that TG1 received several hundred comments on thedraft specification and used most of the meeting time to resolve the comments A major emphasis
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
7
was placed on removing the PHY dependencies from the MAC Eklund noted that a joint meetingwas held with TG3 in which many misunderstandings were discussed
Regarding the TG1 PHY John Liebetreu presented a summary (See Appendix C)
Motion4 John Liebetreu 2nd not needed to initiate a Working Group Review of the IEEE802161 working document number 802161-0001r4 (to be constructed by incorporating theresolved comments listed in document number 802161-0009 into 802161-0001r3) Thereview is set to begin September 29 and to end October 30 2000 See call for comments 802161-0005
By voice vote all for Motion4 passes
Marks reviewed the additional call for contributions on 802161rsquos open technical issues noting adue date of 30 October 2000 and that convergence layer text for IP Ethernet and ATM will besubmitted by Carl Eklund Glen Sater and Ken Stanwood respectively
Regarding TG2 Andy McCregor presented the meeting minutes (IEEE 802162c-0022) and notedfour recommendations from the meeting 1) to use a more formal call for comments 2) to invitecomments from other organizations such as WCA NSMA RABC and ARIB 3) to formally askfor comments from the Broadband Wireless Association of the UK and 4) to put the next draft ofthe coexistence practice on the public side of the IEEE 80216 web site
Marks asked TG2 to remove the copyright notice from their working document and not call thedocument a draft until a later stage in the process
Regarding TG3 Brian Kiernan reported (see Appendix C) adoption of the TG3 functionalrequirements document development of evaluation criteria and development of a call forcontributions In addition TG3 adopted the TG1 MAC and formed the TG3 MAC Ad Hoccommittee to review the TG1 MAC
Motion5 Brian Kiernan 2nd not needed Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bull Establish a common 80216 MAC based on 802161-0001r4
bull Require each 80216 task group to define its mandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMAC
bull Shall ensure backward compatibility and maintenance of the common MAC and
bull Shall strive to ensure forward compatibility of the common MAC
By token vote 24 for 0 against 1 abstain Motion5 passes See Appendix E
Marks acknowledged several organizational issues that must be worked Marks will try to resolveas many issues as possible by the November meeting
Regarding upcoming meetings Marks noted that the next meeting (Session 10) will be in TampaFlorida and that the opportunity exists to extend the Task Group meetings to Friday morning orMonday morning Marks also noted the possibility of joint meetings with other 802 workinggroups
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
8
Marks noted that Session 11 is scheduled for 22 to 26 January 2001 in Tel Aviv Israel hosted byBreezeCOM
Marks noted that Session 13 (May 7-11 2000) will be a joint meeting with 80211 and 80215 andpossibly ETSI BRAN Marks noted his desire to hold interim meetings together with other 802groups
Marks asked for a straw pole as to those in favor of meeting Sundays none for and about 20against
Regarding Liaison Marks noted that ETSI BRAN recommended that Demos Kostas act as contactin both directions Marks plans to reply using Demos Kostas in both directions
Marks noted that as of this week 80216 members and observers now have access to a mirror ofall ETSI BRAN documents Marks will send out information to members and observers on how toaccess the documents
Regarding liaison with ETSI BRAN Marks showed a draft liaison letter (80216l-00_28doc)
Motion6 Marks 2nd Brian Petry to approve draft letter presented by Marks (document IEEE80216l-0028)
Motion7 Brian Petry Brian Kiernan to amend motion6 by replacing we appoint Dr Kostas asour informal contact person for the information exchange with for a contact person wethereby appointing no contact person
Motion7 by voice vote all for Motion7 passes
Motion6 by voice vote several for one opposed Motion6 passes
Scott Marin 80216 secretary had to leave the meeting and George Fishel took over as secretary
Andy McGregor presented a draft liaison letter by TG2 David Trinkwon proposed an amendmentto letter The letter as amended was approved by voice vote
Gene Robinson from the regulatory affairs committee presented three draft letters to regulatorybodies of the US Canada and the UK The letters were edited by Marks The letters wereapproved by unanimous voice vote
Brian Petry indicated that a document containing a draft editorial policy and procedures is on theserver Brian Petry said that anyone wishing to be an editor should read the document Thechairman requested that members give information to Brian on the editorial process
At 1228 Marks adjourned Session9
4 AcknowledgementsThe 80216 secretary would like to thank the sub-group chairs (Carl Eklund Jay Klein AndyMcGregor Brian Kiernan and Durga Satapathy) and the people who took care of the attendancebooks for each group (Juan Zuniga Carl Bushue and Drayt Avera) The multiple attendance bookapproach seemed to work well due mainly to the help of the above people
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
9
Respectfully
Scott Marin
80216 Secretary
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
10
Appendix A Opening Plenary Presentations
Opening Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Opening Plenary Meeting AgendaMonday 11 September 2000 1400-1515
See Opening Plenary presentation slidesOpening of Session 9 and of Opening Plenary Meeting 1400Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Opening Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule of meetings for the week Marks V
Membership and Voting 1410Rights of members observers and others Marks IAttendance list procedure Marin IVoting token procedure Marin I
Announcements 1415Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks ILogistics rooms breaks etc Marks IIndividual and Anti-Trust Marks IIEEE 80216 Patent Policies and Procedures Marks I
Approvals 1425Minutes of Session 8 (IEEE 80216-0017) Marks V
802161 1430Report Marks IEditing Mollenauer Petry 802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1440Report McGregor I
802163 1450Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1500Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1510Voting in Task Groups and Study Groups Marks I
New Business 1513
Closing 1515Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
11
Agenda for the Week
80216 Session 9 AgendaSchedule (tentative)
Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMo
n
RAWCONKeynote Address
Ballroom A-D120-150 pm
(80216 RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster
Session530-700 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCON Lunch1230-130 pm
(80216 RegistrantsInvited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster
Session530-700 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon 5
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG3Salon GH8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
12
Chairmans Opening Plenary Presentation
IEEE 80216 Session 9 Opening Plenary Meeting
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
NoneDate Submitted
2000-09-11Source
Roger Marks Voice +1-303-497-3037NIST Fax +1-303-497-7828325 Broadway MC 81300 E-mail marksnistgovBoulder CO 80303
VenueSession 9 Opening Plenary
Base DocumentNone
PurposeThis presentation is to be inserted in the Session 9 minutes
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) ororganization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to addamend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creationof an IEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contributionand at the IEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor alsoacknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16 iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including thestatement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms andconditions for the purpose of implementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chairltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt as early as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentsnoticesgt
IEEE 80216Working Group on
Broadband Wireless Access(BWA)
Session 9Opening Plenary
11 September 2000
200-315 pm
Session Opening
bull Call to Order
bull Welcome
80216 Officers
bull Chair Roger Marks
bull Vice Chair Lou Olsen
bull Secretary Scott Marin
Agenda
bull Presentation of 80216 OpeningPlenary Agendandash Chair asks for unanimous consent to
approve
bull Schedule of meetings for the weekndash Chair asks for unanimous consent to
approve
Rights of Allbull To subscribe to the 80216 Email Reflector
(stds-802-16) and thereby be notified ofdocument publication meetings minutes
bull To post to stds-802-16 in accordance with thereflector rules
bull To examine documents unless copyrightconcerns prohibit it
bull To contribute documents in response to aCall for Contributions
bull To attend and participate in 80216 meetingsif registered
bull To join the Sponsor Balloting Pool
IEEE and IEEE SA Membership
bull Members are encouraged to join IEEEIEEE Standards Association and IEEEComputer Society
bull Such membership is not required forWorking Group Membership ObserverStatus or Sponsor Ballot PoolGroup
Sponsor Ballot PoolGroup
bull Balloting Pool is being constructed
bull Future 80216 draft standards will beballoted by a Balloting Group drawn frommembers of the 80216 Balloting Pool
bull To join the 80216 Balloting Pool use theform on the web
bull Members of IEEE Standards Association[IEEE or CS + $10] can participate in BallotGroup without paying special fee
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
13
Rights of Members amp Observers
bull To examine draft standardsbull To participate in Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To examine the votes of Working
Group membersbull To examine the Member and Observer
contact databases
Exclusive Rights of Membershipbull To make or second a motion at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote if and only if present at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote in 80216 Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To vote by email on any issue involving
80216 or its subsidiariesbull To lodge complaints about Working Group
operation with the 802 Executive Committeebull To petition the 802 Executive Committee in
writing
Attendance Listbull Recorded at each ldquomeeting intervalrdquo
ndashAfternoon MonTueWedThundashMorning TueWedThuFri
ndashEvening Thu
ndashSelf-declared ldquosubstantially allrdquo of meetingndashSession ldquoParticipationrdquo 75 of meeting intervals
bull =will round down to 6
bull Attendance recorded in parallel meetingsndashvoting credit for presence at either
bull Attendance is public recordndashattendance will be reported on webndashcontact info will not be posted (just company)
Secretaryrsquos Announcementsbull Scott Marin
ndash Attendance books (four of them)
bull Write your namebull If new and unregistered insert business
card in pocketbull Initial and keep the book movingbull Remember your book and page number
ndash Voting tokensbull Printed on badge for Membersbull Raise to vote
Registration
bull $140
bull Registration fee form at front deskndashHotel guest charge to roomndashOthers credit card
bull Receive copy of form as receipt
Document Distributionbull Server http10001bull Run DHCPbull Use 10BaseT or 100BaseTXbull Use 80211b or 80211 DSSS Wireless
bull Upload files using anonymous ftp
bull Flash Card may be available
Logistics
bull Meeting Roomsndash Vary throughout the week
bull Breaksndash Always in large room (E or D)
bull RAWCON events
Individuality
bull In IEEE standards meetingsparticipation is by individualndash you do not represent a company or
organization
bull Membership belongs to the individualnot an organization and may not betransferred
Legal and Anti-Trust
bull Any discussions that relate to thevalidity or cost of patent use shall beavoided
bull Any discussions or any materialrelating to an ongoing litigation shallbe avoided
bull Any discussions of pricing or issuesthat would violate US antitrust lawsshall be avoided
IEEE 80216 Patent Policybull IEEE 80216 operates under the Patent Policy of
the IEEE Standards Association as set forth inClause 6 of the IEEE-SA Standards BoardBylaws This policy includes the statement
bull IEEE standards may include the known use ofpatent(s) including patent applications if there istechnical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and providedthe IEEE receives assurance from the patentholder that it will license applicants underreasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standard
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
14
IEEE 80216 Patent Policy (cont)bull IEEE 80216 interprets in the opinion of the standards-
developing committee as in the opinion of the members of theWorking Group Early disclosure to the Working Groupparticipants of patent information that might be relevant to thestandard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and to increase the likelihood that the draftpublication will be approved for publication IEEE 80216 strivesto make such information available as soon as possible forconsideration by individual members in their voting decisionsHowever in its meetings and electronic forums IEEE 80216does not permit discussions concerning the validity orapplicability of intellectual property claims The only role a patentclaim plays in Working Group discussions concerns ensuringcompliance to the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures
bull Justification for the inclusion of technology is limited to thetechnical merits of the technology
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresAnyone whether participating in IEEE 80216 or notshould notify the Chair of any patents (granted orunder application and regardless of the assignee orthe patent nationality) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved byIEEE 80216 Such notification should be in written orelectronic form (email is preferred) and need notmake any statement concerning enforcement orlicensing The Chair will presume that suchnotification is intended for public release and will assoon as practical post it to the web along with otherPatent Notices On File with IEEE 80216 The Chairand the Working Group will take no positionregarding the validity or applicability of any patents
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresWritten contributions to IEEE 80216 standards development willnot be accepted without an acknowledgement of familiarity with theIEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures Thisacknowledgement will be part of the mandatory contribution coversheet and will read
ldquoThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policyand Procedures (Version )
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information thatmight be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce thepossibility for delays in the development process andincrease the likelihood that the draft publication will beapproved for publication Please notify the Chair as early aspossible in written or electronic form of any patents (grantedor under application) that may cover technology that is underconsideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 TheChair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 websiterdquo
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresThe Chair once formally notified and once apotentially relevant draft standard exists shallwrite to the identified party and request that aLetter of Assurance be filed with the Chair forforwarding to the IEEE-SA Patent Committee inaccordance with the instructions in the IEEE-SAStandards Board Operations Manual A samplerequest letter and response letter are availableWhen the Patent Committee has accepted theletter as a Letter of Assurance informationregarding the letter will be indexed in the Recordsof IEEE Standards-Related Patents
Approval of Minutes
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to
ndash approve Document IEEE 80216-0017(Minutes of Session 8)
TG1 (802161)bull Air Interface for Fixed Broadband
Wireless Access Systemsbull 10-66 GHz
bull Chair Roger Marksbull Editor Jim MollenauerBrian Petrybull MAC Chair Carl Eklundbull PHY Chair Jay Klein
TG1 Goals for Week
ndashStay on Development PlanbullInitiative Working Group Letter BallotbullSeek approval at Closing Plenary
ndashMACbullComment resolutionbullMeet with TG3
ndashPHYbullComment resolutionbullOther contributionsbullMeet with TG2
TG2 (802162)ndashCoexistence of Broadband Wireless
Access Systems
ndashCo-Chair Andy McGregorndashCo-Chair Leland LangstonndashVice Chair Reacutemi Chayer
ndashEditor Vito Scaringindash Secretary Reza Arefi
TG3 (802163)bull Broadband Wireless Access Systems
in Licensed Bands from 2 to 11 GHzbull Chair Brian Kiernanbull Vice Chair Carl Bushuebull Secretary Dean Changbull Functional Requirements
ndashBrian PetryndashGeorge Fishel
WirelessHUMANTM Study Group
bull Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed MetropolitanArea Networks
bull Chair Durga Satapathybull Secretary Sanjay Moghe
bull Chartered at Session 6bull Renewed at Session 8bull Writing a PAR
bull To coordinate with 80211 and 80215
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
15
Charge to Task Groupsbull Complete the task on your agenda
ndashUpdate agenda on bulletin board
bull Prepare for next meetingndashCall for Contributions etc
bull Prepare for Closing Plenary
ndashAll motions to be in writingbull Document everything
ndash submit documents before you leavendash provide document index on bulletin board
bull Presentations to server 2 hours in advance
Voting in Task Groups
bull Only 80216 Voting Members may vote in taskGroup meetingsndashShow Voting Token
bull All present are eligible to vote at Study Groupmeetings
New Business
bull Request for New Business items
Adjournment
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to adjournthis meeting of Working Group 80216until the Midweek Plenaryndash(5-6 pm on Wednesday 13 September)
TG2 Status Report
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 1
IEEE 802162 Activities
Recommended Practice forCoexistence of BroadbandWireless Access Systems
Co-chairs Leland Langston Andy McGregor
Vice Chair Remi ChayerEditor Vito Scaringi
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 2
Activities since San DiegoMeeting
bull R7 of draft Practice issued late July
bull Several input docs and comments receivedbull Teleconference held Sept 7th ndash 8 participants
ndashSignificant discussion on content
bull R8 of draft Practice available Sept 11th
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 3
Plans for Denver
bull Close issue of single vs multiple interferers
bull Review doc for consistency amp completenessbull Present summary to joint TG1TG2bull Post R9 in week of Sept 18th
bull Seeking comments from any 80216 participant
bull TARGET TG ballot following Tampa meeting
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
16
Appendix B Midweek Plenary Presentations
Midweek Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Midweek Plenary Meeting AgendaWednesday 13 September 2000 1700-1800
Opening of Midweek Plenary Meeting 1700Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Midweek Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule Update Marks V
Announcements 1705
Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IAttendance books badges etc Marin I
802161 1710
Report Marks I802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1720Report McGregor I
802163 1730
Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1740
Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1745
Liaison 1750
ITU Costa ETSI BRAN Klein
Closing 1755
New Business (Marin Editorial Process) Marks VAdjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
17
Agenda for the Week as revised at the Midweek Plenary
80216 Session 9 Agenda Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMon
RAWCONKeynoteAddress
Ballroom A-D
120-150 pm(80216
RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCONLunch
1230-130pm
(80216Registrants
Invited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon G
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon H
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG16-730 pmSalon E
TG3Salon E
8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
TG3730-10 pm
Salon E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
18
Appendix C Closing Plenary Presentations
Closing Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Closing Plenary Meeting AgendaFriday 15 September 2000 10 am -1200 noon
Opening 1000Call to Order Marks IAgenda Marks V
Announcements 1003Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IVice Chair Marks I80216 Logo Marks D
WirelessHUMAN 1010Report Satapathy IPAR Approval Satapathy V
802161 1025Report Marks I802161 Working Group Review Marks V
802162 1050Report McGregor IFinal Task Group Review McGregor IMotions McGregor V
802163 1110Report Kiernan IMotions Kiernan V
Future Meetings 1130
Session 10 6-10 November 2000 Hyatt Regency Tampa Tampa Florida USA Marks ISunday Monday Friday at Session 10 Marks DSession 11 22-26 January 2001 Tel Aviv Israel Marks ISession 12 12-15 March 2001 Hyatt Regency Hilton Head South Carolina USA Marks ISession 13 7-11 May 2001 Orlando Florida USA along with IEEE 80211 and 80215 Marks I
Liaison 1135
ETSI BRANnotification of 802161 status and offer of password Marks V
Regulatory Agency notifications Robinson V
New Business 114080216 Editorial Policy MarinPetry V
Closing 1200
Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
19
WirelessHUMANtrade Closing Presentation[Insert Document Title Here]
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
[The appropriate coordinator normally the Task Group Chair will fill in this number after obtaining it from the 80216 Chair The
document number will match that of the base contribution with ldquoprdquo replacing ldquocrdquo For example 802161p-00nn]Date Submitted
[2000-07-13]Source
[Durga Satapathy] [Voice(913) 534-6338] [Sprint] [Fax (913) 534-6522] [7101 College Blvd Suite 1436 B] mailto[durgasatapathymailsprintcom [Overland Park KS 66210]
Venue
[IEEE 80216 Session 8]Base Document
[If this presentation illustrates an 80216 document cite the document number and URL lthttpieee802org16hellipgt]Purpose
[WirelessHUMAN Study Group report at closing plenary]Notice
This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s)The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw materialcontained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creation of anIEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution and at theIEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor also acknowledges and acceptsthat this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including the statementldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developingcommittee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purpose ofimplementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chair ltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt asearly as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology that is under consideration by or has beenapproved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentslettersgt
IEEE 80216 Plenary Report
Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed Metropolitan Area Network
(WirelessHUMANTM) Study Group
Durga P Satapathy
WirelessHUMANTM Update
bull Reviewed 8 contributions
bull Achieved consensus on selecting standardsto utilizemodifyndashMAC 80216ndashPHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
bull Drafted PAR and 5 criteria
WirelessHUMANTM PAR Scope This standard specifies the physical layer and media access control
layer of the air interface of interoperable fixed broadband wirelessmetropolitan area network systems including point-to-multipoint Thestandard enables access to data video and voice services with qualityof service in unlicensed bands designated for public network access Itwill focus on the 5-6 GHz range and may be applied to unlicensedbands between 2 and 11 GHz The WirelessHUMAN standard willutilize or modify applicable elements from the following
MAC 80216
PHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
The development of the WirelessHUMAN standard will follow thetimeline as shown in Appendix A
WirelessHUMANTM Timeline
bull Call For Proposals for WirelessHUMAN PHYMAC Nov 2000)ndash PHY Modifications of 80211a HIPERLAN2ndash MAC Modifications of 80216
bull Review proposals Jan 2001
bull Select candidate proposals at Interim meeting Feb 2001bull Decision on specific modifications March 2001
bull First Draft Standard May 2001
bull Comment Resolutions July 2001
bull Second Draft Standard Sep 2001bull Finalize WirelessHUMAN Standard Nov 2001
Purpose of Proposed Project
To enable rapid worldwide deployment of innovative cost-effectiveand interoperable multi-vendor broadband wireless metropolitan areanetwork products operating in the unlicensed bands To facilitatecompetition in broadband access by providing fixed wirelessalternatives to wireline broadband access Identify techniques totolerate interference in the unlicensed bands facilitate strategies forcoexistence with other unlicensed band systems such as 80211a andmaximize the carrying capacity of the unlicensed bands Encourageconsistent worldwide allocation and accelerate the commercializationof unlicensed broadband wireless access spectrum Utilization ofunlicensed frequencies will address a market that includes residencesSmall Office-Home Office (SOHO) telecommuters and Small andMedium Enterprises (SME)
WirelessHUMAN Study Group Participants
Sprint RF Solutions Agilent Technologies
Intel Breezecom Adaptive BroadbandNokia Transcomm Inc Cabletron
Ericsson BNA Systems WirelessHomeLucent Escape Carleton UniversityIntracom Malibu Networks Carnegie Mellon UniversityProxim Ultracom Georgia Institute of TechnologyWaveIP Harris Corporation HRL Laboratories LLCN Band Com Wireless Inc Western MultiplexCoreon Inc Cabletron systems Communications Research Center
Runcom Magnolia Broadband Yokogawa Electric CoInnowave ECI
Motion
The proposed WirelessHUMANTM PARbe accepted
TG1 MAC ClosingPresentation
(TG1 MAC reportppt)
1 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
TG1 MAC group
bull Resolved comments received during Final TaskGroup review
bull Major effort to remove any particular PHYdependence from the MAC
bull Process of adding features useful for TG3requirments started
bull Meeting with TG3
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
20
2 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
Important MAC decisions
bull Adoption of EUI-48 addresses (previouslyEUI-64)
bull Addition of error control to MAC layer(previously defined in TC layer of PHY B)
bull Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes into asingle mode
bull Redesigned DL MAP message for higherspectral efficiency
TG1 PHY ClosingPresentation
Document Number80216pp-
TitlePHY TG1 Report at Session 9
Date Submitted
91500Source
Jay KleinVenue
Denver September 2000Base Document
None
PurposeReport
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist the IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the
contributing individual(s) or organization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after furtherstudy The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by 80216
IEEE Patent Policy
The contributor is familiar with the IEEE Patent Policy which is set forth in the IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylawslthttpstandards ieeeorgguidesbylawsgt and includes the statement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s)
including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developing committee and provided theIEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standardrdquo
PHY TG1 Report Session 9
Jay KleinEnsemble Communications
Documents Submitted
bull 802161pc-0044 (2000-09-07) Recommendation onLMDS Radio Propagation Channel Models
bull 802161c-0007 (2000-09-10)FEC Parameterization for Data Transport (Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0006 (2000-09-08)FEC Parameterization for Control Channel Information(Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0004 (2000-09-01)Frequency Synthesizer Model Parameters (Lars Lindh andHans Somerma)
Documents Submitted ndash cont
bull 802161c-0003 (2000-09-01)Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes in802161 (Ken Stanwood)
bull 802161c-0001 (2000-08-08)Summary of Open PHY Issues in IEEE 802161-0001 (Jeff Foerster)
Work done
bull All editorial comments resolved
bull All technical comments reviewed andresolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull TBDs resolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull Met with MAC group for ldquosynchronizingrdquo
TG3 Closing Presentation
802163 Task Group Reportbull Finished and Adopted Functional
Requirements Document except for editorialsndashOutput Comment database on server
bull Developed an initial List of EvaluationCriteria for PHY proposal evaluations FullCriteria to be developed at next meeting
bull Issuing two calls for contributionsndashPreliminary PHY proposalsndashDeployment Traffic and Propagation
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS
bull Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull Session 10 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband WirelessAccess will be held on 6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA In orderto assist in the evaluation of air interface proposals the 802163 Task Groupinvites contributions addressing the following issues
lang Traffic and deployment models based on single and multi-cellsystems
lang Channel propagation model
bull Contributions must be submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt Submissions will beconsidered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible followingreceipt for public access on the 80216 Web Site Email your contribution tothe 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernanltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 Chair Roger Marksltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS - Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull The Task Group 3 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access is preparing to define the PHY protocols for abroadband wireless access air interface specification for frequencies from 2 through 11 GHz The specification will be based on submittedcontributions with increasing detail required as the process progresses Mergers and improvements will be encouraged with final selectionscheduled for June 2001
bull The TG3 Task Group invites the submission of initial contributions representing proposed PHY solutions Contributors will be grantedagenda time during 80216 Working Group Session 10 (6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA) to present and discuss the merits oftheir proposals Only submissions to session 10 will be eligible for invitation to submit more detailed proposals to session 11 Eachproposal will be allocated equal agenda time on Tuesday November 7 If time permits the allocations will be 15 minutes of presentationfollowed by 15 minutes of discussion Submissions must follow the guidelines below
lang Include a descriptive titlelang Include an overview and a reference model that describes functions including interfaces to other layerslang Describe the benefits of the proposed PHY including any unique featureslang Describe any drawbacks of the proposed PHY
bull Explain how the submitted PHY relates to existing standards such as ITU-R JRG 8A-9B IEEE 80211 DOCSIS 11 ETSI HiperLAN orothers If it is based on an existing standard what differences occur due to BWA characteristics
lang Emphasize the scalability of the proposed PHY to deal efficiently with various data types as described in the 802163Functional Requirements Document
lang Include a statement on intellectual property rights and how 80216 may utilize the proposed PHY in a standard
bull The proposals will be evaluated based on criteria in the Evaluation Table below However at this initial stage contributions are not expectedto address in detail the discussion items in that table instead aiming for the more general description as outlined above Each of the VotingMembers of 80216 are eligible to participate in the evaluation if present Submitters receiving a combined score of 6 or better (out of 10) inany criterion in the Evaluation Table will be invited to submit more a detailed contribution for Session 11 (January 22-26 2001 in Tel AvivIsrael) Note that submissions need not represent a complete PHY but may focus on specific components
bull Contributions will be considered only if submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216 Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt The template requires a cover page and a narrative
bull Submissions will be considered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible following receipt for public access on the 80216Web Site lthttpieee802org16gt
bull Email your contribution to the 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernan ltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 ChairRoger Marks ltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
802163 Task Group Report
bull Officially Adopted TG1 MAC as TG3 DraftMAC
bull Create TG3 MAC Ad Hoc to review TG1MAC and provide TG3 Comments
bull Two Motions for the Working GroupndashLiaison to ETSI BRAN sub11 GHz WGndashEstablishment of 80216 Common MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
21
Motion 1
That the 80216 Working Group appoint ChetShirali as a liaison to the ETSI BRAN sub11GHz Working Group
Motion 2
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MACbullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
22
Appendix D Attendance at Session9Session9 was an interim session The 75 interval attendance criteria for Session 9 was 6 ormore intervals Please contact the 80216 Secretary (smarinixnetcomcom) if you feel yourattendance has been recorded incorrectly
The following 126 peopleregistered attendance at 6or more intervals and metthe attendance criteria
Aboukarr BakriAn SongArefi RezaArunachalam ArunAvera DraytAvivi EliAyyagari DeepakBaragar IanBaseghi BehshadBaugh CR (Rick)Belfiore CarlosBenyamin-Seeyar AnaderBushue CarlBuskila BaruchChan RebeccaChang DeanChayer ReacutemiCondie MaryCornelius JamesCosta JoseacuteCrilly Jr William JDoherty EdwardEdmonston BrainEidson BrianEklund CarlEl-Damhougy HeshamFishel GeorgeFoerster JeffreyGarrison G JackGesbert DavidGoldhammer MariannaGuillemette PhilGupta RakeshHadad ZionHall EricHamilton MichaelHammons RogerHatim BayaHebron YoanHilberman DanHosur SrinathHsuan YiHudson ThomasHum ColemanHunter WayneJacobsen EricJamali Hamadi
Jorgensen JacobKang InchulKasslin MikaKiernan BrianKim JohnKitroser ItzikKlein JayKolze ThomasKostas DemosKwak Byung-JaeKwak JoeLangley John BLangston J LelandLeiba YigalLewis BarryLicardie SergioLiebetreu JohnLindh LarsLo TitusMarin ScottMarks RogerMcCallister RonMcGregor AndyMcMullin RoderickMeyer RonaldMiddleton AndrewMizoguchi MasatoMody ApurvaMollenauer JamesPadan UziPetry BrianPleasant WayneRalston WilliamRan MosheResheff GuyRhodes ValentineRobinson GeneRoehr WaltRzeszewski TedSantacesaria ClaudioSatapathy DurgaSater GlenScaringi VitoScarpa CarlSchwartz RandallSegal YossiSellars MalcolmShan Tie-JunShimada ShusakuShirali ChetSkaar HelgeSmith SteveStamatelos George
Stambaugh KarlStanwood KenStewart MichaelStruhsaker PaulSydor JohnTappenden ChrisTateishi KimiyaTavormina JoeThomas RaymondThompson PaulTrinkwon DavidVan Waes NicoVarma SubirWachira MuyaWang ArthurWang Chao-ChunWang LeiWang XiaofengWard BobWhitehead PhilipWhiting RobertWilliams David GWise CurtWiss JohnYanover VladimirZuniga Juan Carlos
The following 18 peopleregistered attendance atless than 6 intervals anddid not meet theattendance criteria
Alspaugh MatthewCarlo JimFalconer DavidFoley MarkFoster RobertGupta AlokHancock DaleHarel HaimKhanna AmarpalKreig AndrewMonk AntonNadeau JamesOng Ling ChuenRafie ManouchehrRibner David BWheatley Chuck FYang S MichaelYurtkuran Erol
Motion 5
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MAC based on802161-0001r4bullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
Appendix E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
4
Concerning conference fees Marks asked that everyone pay the $140 by close of business todayso that he can check registration status tomorrow
Marks presented an update on the 80216 server and explained the process to upload files
Scott Marin as 80216 secretary commended Task Group chairs and attendance book people forthe good job of keeping the attendance books up to date In an informal pole attendees showedstrong support for the new multiple book approach
Regarding the TG1 MAC group Carl Eklund reported good progress in resolving comments AWednesday evening session is planned to continue comment resolution Eklund reported that theTG1 MAC group has decided to use a 48-bit MAC address instead of a 64-bit address Eklundexpressed some concern with the completeness of the document citing that no comments had beenreceived on the last 100 pages Eklund stated that the document is in much better shape than onMonday and expected to have an even better document by Friday Marks asked if changes ofinterest to TG3 had been made Eklund responded that TG3 requirements had been considered andcited as examples the additions of options for ARQ and shorter frames
Regarding the TG1 PHY Jay Klein stated that the 58 comments had been resolved and that thegroup was now resolving TBDs Klein stated that the plan is to continue with TBDs after a jointmeeting with the TG1 MAC group Klein was hopeful that a new version would be ready byFriday for release as a letter ballot
Regarding TG2 Andy McGregor explained that a decision had been reached that coexistenceanalysis can be based on individual transmitter emissions and TG2 decided that it was unnecessaryto aggregate emitters Coordination triggers had been agreed The grouprsquos goal is to handle all editsby Thursday The TG2 task group has requested a joint meeting with TG1 PHY at 800amThursday this was agreed to an arranged Andy McGregor reported that Marianna Goldhammerhad presented an update from ETSI TM4 and noted that TG2 expected to prepare a liaison reply
Regarding TG3 Brain Kiernan explained that TG3 had been working through comments receivedon the functional requirements and that work would continue at a Wednesday evening meeting from1930-2200 Kiernan further noted that TG3 plans to complete the characteristics and evaluationcriteria by the end of week Kiernan also noted that TG3 plans to develop a call for contributionson models (channel and traffic) and a call for preliminary abstracts on PHY proposals TG3 hadreceived a liaison letter from ETSI BRAN and Kiernan noted that TG3 needed to appoint a liaisonperson from TG3 to ETSI BRAN Kiernan announced a joint TG1TG3 meeting tomorrow nightand a joint TG3WirelessHUMANtrade meeting at 800-900 tomorrow
Regarding WirelessHUMANtrade Durga Sataphy reported completing review of the sevencontributions and that consensus had been reached to use 80211a and ETSI HIPERLAN2 as abasis for a PHY Satapathy further explained that the draft PAR states that the MAC would drawfrom the 80216 MAC Satapathy noted that WirelessHUMANtrade is developing the Five Criteriadocument Marks asked if the PAR required use of the stated standards Satapathy said no
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
5
In a charge to Task Groups Marks asked groups to submit meeting minutes by the end of theweek and to propose motions at future 80216 plenary meetings using only documents from theserver
Regarding ITU-R Joint Rapporteurs Group (JRG) 8A-9B Joseacute Costa reviewed document IEEE80216l-0016 Marks highlighted the importance of liaison with the ITU-R
Jay Klein reported on ETSI BRAN HIPERACCESS Liaison
Marks explained that ETSI BRAN 80211 and 80215 now share password protected documentsMarks also stated that 80216 must decide whether to share password protected documents withETSI BRAN By IEEE procedure working group letter ballot documents are considered draftstandards and must therefore be copyrighted and protected
Marks reported that a letter (document IEEE 80216l-0025) had been received from Andrew Kreigpresident of the Wireless Communications Association The letter announced the appointment ofDemos Kostas as liaison from WCA to 80216
Under new business Scott Marin expressed concern and the potential to abuse the editorialprocess to influence documents
Motion1 Scott Marin 2nd Brian Petry That the 80216 Chairman establishes written guidelines(boundaries) for editors that among other things explains what editors can and cannot do
Motion1 passes without objection Marks took an action to present draft editorial rules forapproval at the closing plenary
Marks adjourned the midweek plenary at 1810
3 Friday 15 September 2000 Closing PlenaryAt 1005 Roger Marks called the meeting to order
Marks presented a draft agenda The agenda (See Appendix C) was approved without objection
Marks reported a few bugs with the registration fees that may need to be fixed and asked people tocheck their hotel statements carefully
Marks displayed the server page and explained the organization and ways to uses the server
Marks announced that 80216 Vice Chair Lou Olsen had resigned and that a new vice chair wouldbe elected at 80216 Session 10 Marks appointed Brian Petry as Acting Vice Chair until theelection Brian Petry accepted the appointment (and said hersquod continue to push for cookies atbreaks)
Marks displayed logo_bpng which had been introduced in a previous message to the 80216 e-mail reflector
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
6
The above logo was approved without objection
Regarding WirelessHUMANtrade Durga Satapathy reported a decision to use the 80216 MAC anda PHY based on ETSI BRAN HIPERLAN2 and 80211a (See presentation in Appendix C)Satapathy also reported completion of a draft project authorization request (PAR) and presentedthe draft
Motion2 Durga Satpathy 2nd Drayt Avera to accept the 91500 version of theWirelessHUMANtrade PAR (serverspublicWirelessHUMAN PAR 2000-09-15doc) with somelatitude to adjust text before submission to the 802 Executive Committee
The proposed WirelessHUMANtrade PAR be forwarded to the IEEE 802 SEC at least 30 days priorto the start of the following IEEE 802 Plenary session subject to a comments from IEEE 80211and 80215 and a comment revision process on the 80216 email reflector
Marks asked that the PAR be changed from a ldquoNew Standardrdquo to a ldquoSupplementrdquo The change wasaccepted without objection
Motion2amended Durga Satpathy 2nd Drayt Avera to accept the 91500 version of theWirelessHUMANtrade PAR (serverspublicWirelessHUMAN PAR 2000-09-15doc) with somelatitude to adjust text before submission to executive committee and that the type of document be asupplement rather than a new standard
The proposed WirelessHUMANtrade PAR be forwarded to the IEEE 802 SEC at least 30 days priorto the start of the following IEEE 802 Plenary session subject to a comments from IEEE 80211and 80215 and a comment revision process on the 80216 email reflector
Motion3 to amend Motion2 Tom Kolze 2nd Chet Sharali to amend Motion2 by addingDOCSIS 11 to the PAR Where it says ldquoMAC 80216rdquo to add ldquoDOCSIS 11rdquo
By token vote 3 for 15 against Motion3 fails
By token vote 23 for 1 against 4 abstain Motion2 as amended passes The approveddocument is IEEE 80216h-0013r0
Marks congratulated the WirelessHUMANtrade study group for reaching this stage in their work
Regarding TG1 MAC Carl Eklund reported that TG1 received several hundred comments on thedraft specification and used most of the meeting time to resolve the comments A major emphasis
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
7
was placed on removing the PHY dependencies from the MAC Eklund noted that a joint meetingwas held with TG3 in which many misunderstandings were discussed
Regarding the TG1 PHY John Liebetreu presented a summary (See Appendix C)
Motion4 John Liebetreu 2nd not needed to initiate a Working Group Review of the IEEE802161 working document number 802161-0001r4 (to be constructed by incorporating theresolved comments listed in document number 802161-0009 into 802161-0001r3) Thereview is set to begin September 29 and to end October 30 2000 See call for comments 802161-0005
By voice vote all for Motion4 passes
Marks reviewed the additional call for contributions on 802161rsquos open technical issues noting adue date of 30 October 2000 and that convergence layer text for IP Ethernet and ATM will besubmitted by Carl Eklund Glen Sater and Ken Stanwood respectively
Regarding TG2 Andy McCregor presented the meeting minutes (IEEE 802162c-0022) and notedfour recommendations from the meeting 1) to use a more formal call for comments 2) to invitecomments from other organizations such as WCA NSMA RABC and ARIB 3) to formally askfor comments from the Broadband Wireless Association of the UK and 4) to put the next draft ofthe coexistence practice on the public side of the IEEE 80216 web site
Marks asked TG2 to remove the copyright notice from their working document and not call thedocument a draft until a later stage in the process
Regarding TG3 Brian Kiernan reported (see Appendix C) adoption of the TG3 functionalrequirements document development of evaluation criteria and development of a call forcontributions In addition TG3 adopted the TG1 MAC and formed the TG3 MAC Ad Hoccommittee to review the TG1 MAC
Motion5 Brian Kiernan 2nd not needed Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bull Establish a common 80216 MAC based on 802161-0001r4
bull Require each 80216 task group to define its mandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMAC
bull Shall ensure backward compatibility and maintenance of the common MAC and
bull Shall strive to ensure forward compatibility of the common MAC
By token vote 24 for 0 against 1 abstain Motion5 passes See Appendix E
Marks acknowledged several organizational issues that must be worked Marks will try to resolveas many issues as possible by the November meeting
Regarding upcoming meetings Marks noted that the next meeting (Session 10) will be in TampaFlorida and that the opportunity exists to extend the Task Group meetings to Friday morning orMonday morning Marks also noted the possibility of joint meetings with other 802 workinggroups
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
8
Marks noted that Session 11 is scheduled for 22 to 26 January 2001 in Tel Aviv Israel hosted byBreezeCOM
Marks noted that Session 13 (May 7-11 2000) will be a joint meeting with 80211 and 80215 andpossibly ETSI BRAN Marks noted his desire to hold interim meetings together with other 802groups
Marks asked for a straw pole as to those in favor of meeting Sundays none for and about 20against
Regarding Liaison Marks noted that ETSI BRAN recommended that Demos Kostas act as contactin both directions Marks plans to reply using Demos Kostas in both directions
Marks noted that as of this week 80216 members and observers now have access to a mirror ofall ETSI BRAN documents Marks will send out information to members and observers on how toaccess the documents
Regarding liaison with ETSI BRAN Marks showed a draft liaison letter (80216l-00_28doc)
Motion6 Marks 2nd Brian Petry to approve draft letter presented by Marks (document IEEE80216l-0028)
Motion7 Brian Petry Brian Kiernan to amend motion6 by replacing we appoint Dr Kostas asour informal contact person for the information exchange with for a contact person wethereby appointing no contact person
Motion7 by voice vote all for Motion7 passes
Motion6 by voice vote several for one opposed Motion6 passes
Scott Marin 80216 secretary had to leave the meeting and George Fishel took over as secretary
Andy McGregor presented a draft liaison letter by TG2 David Trinkwon proposed an amendmentto letter The letter as amended was approved by voice vote
Gene Robinson from the regulatory affairs committee presented three draft letters to regulatorybodies of the US Canada and the UK The letters were edited by Marks The letters wereapproved by unanimous voice vote
Brian Petry indicated that a document containing a draft editorial policy and procedures is on theserver Brian Petry said that anyone wishing to be an editor should read the document Thechairman requested that members give information to Brian on the editorial process
At 1228 Marks adjourned Session9
4 AcknowledgementsThe 80216 secretary would like to thank the sub-group chairs (Carl Eklund Jay Klein AndyMcGregor Brian Kiernan and Durga Satapathy) and the people who took care of the attendancebooks for each group (Juan Zuniga Carl Bushue and Drayt Avera) The multiple attendance bookapproach seemed to work well due mainly to the help of the above people
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
9
Respectfully
Scott Marin
80216 Secretary
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
10
Appendix A Opening Plenary Presentations
Opening Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Opening Plenary Meeting AgendaMonday 11 September 2000 1400-1515
See Opening Plenary presentation slidesOpening of Session 9 and of Opening Plenary Meeting 1400Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Opening Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule of meetings for the week Marks V
Membership and Voting 1410Rights of members observers and others Marks IAttendance list procedure Marin IVoting token procedure Marin I
Announcements 1415Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks ILogistics rooms breaks etc Marks IIndividual and Anti-Trust Marks IIEEE 80216 Patent Policies and Procedures Marks I
Approvals 1425Minutes of Session 8 (IEEE 80216-0017) Marks V
802161 1430Report Marks IEditing Mollenauer Petry 802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1440Report McGregor I
802163 1450Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1500Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1510Voting in Task Groups and Study Groups Marks I
New Business 1513
Closing 1515Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
11
Agenda for the Week
80216 Session 9 AgendaSchedule (tentative)
Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMo
n
RAWCONKeynote Address
Ballroom A-D120-150 pm
(80216 RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster
Session530-700 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCON Lunch1230-130 pm
(80216 RegistrantsInvited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster
Session530-700 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon 5
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG3Salon GH8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
12
Chairmans Opening Plenary Presentation
IEEE 80216 Session 9 Opening Plenary Meeting
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
NoneDate Submitted
2000-09-11Source
Roger Marks Voice +1-303-497-3037NIST Fax +1-303-497-7828325 Broadway MC 81300 E-mail marksnistgovBoulder CO 80303
VenueSession 9 Opening Plenary
Base DocumentNone
PurposeThis presentation is to be inserted in the Session 9 minutes
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) ororganization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to addamend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creationof an IEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contributionand at the IEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor alsoacknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16 iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including thestatement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms andconditions for the purpose of implementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chairltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt as early as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentsnoticesgt
IEEE 80216Working Group on
Broadband Wireless Access(BWA)
Session 9Opening Plenary
11 September 2000
200-315 pm
Session Opening
bull Call to Order
bull Welcome
80216 Officers
bull Chair Roger Marks
bull Vice Chair Lou Olsen
bull Secretary Scott Marin
Agenda
bull Presentation of 80216 OpeningPlenary Agendandash Chair asks for unanimous consent to
approve
bull Schedule of meetings for the weekndash Chair asks for unanimous consent to
approve
Rights of Allbull To subscribe to the 80216 Email Reflector
(stds-802-16) and thereby be notified ofdocument publication meetings minutes
bull To post to stds-802-16 in accordance with thereflector rules
bull To examine documents unless copyrightconcerns prohibit it
bull To contribute documents in response to aCall for Contributions
bull To attend and participate in 80216 meetingsif registered
bull To join the Sponsor Balloting Pool
IEEE and IEEE SA Membership
bull Members are encouraged to join IEEEIEEE Standards Association and IEEEComputer Society
bull Such membership is not required forWorking Group Membership ObserverStatus or Sponsor Ballot PoolGroup
Sponsor Ballot PoolGroup
bull Balloting Pool is being constructed
bull Future 80216 draft standards will beballoted by a Balloting Group drawn frommembers of the 80216 Balloting Pool
bull To join the 80216 Balloting Pool use theform on the web
bull Members of IEEE Standards Association[IEEE or CS + $10] can participate in BallotGroup without paying special fee
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
13
Rights of Members amp Observers
bull To examine draft standardsbull To participate in Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To examine the votes of Working
Group membersbull To examine the Member and Observer
contact databases
Exclusive Rights of Membershipbull To make or second a motion at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote if and only if present at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote in 80216 Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To vote by email on any issue involving
80216 or its subsidiariesbull To lodge complaints about Working Group
operation with the 802 Executive Committeebull To petition the 802 Executive Committee in
writing
Attendance Listbull Recorded at each ldquomeeting intervalrdquo
ndashAfternoon MonTueWedThundashMorning TueWedThuFri
ndashEvening Thu
ndashSelf-declared ldquosubstantially allrdquo of meetingndashSession ldquoParticipationrdquo 75 of meeting intervals
bull =will round down to 6
bull Attendance recorded in parallel meetingsndashvoting credit for presence at either
bull Attendance is public recordndashattendance will be reported on webndashcontact info will not be posted (just company)
Secretaryrsquos Announcementsbull Scott Marin
ndash Attendance books (four of them)
bull Write your namebull If new and unregistered insert business
card in pocketbull Initial and keep the book movingbull Remember your book and page number
ndash Voting tokensbull Printed on badge for Membersbull Raise to vote
Registration
bull $140
bull Registration fee form at front deskndashHotel guest charge to roomndashOthers credit card
bull Receive copy of form as receipt
Document Distributionbull Server http10001bull Run DHCPbull Use 10BaseT or 100BaseTXbull Use 80211b or 80211 DSSS Wireless
bull Upload files using anonymous ftp
bull Flash Card may be available
Logistics
bull Meeting Roomsndash Vary throughout the week
bull Breaksndash Always in large room (E or D)
bull RAWCON events
Individuality
bull In IEEE standards meetingsparticipation is by individualndash you do not represent a company or
organization
bull Membership belongs to the individualnot an organization and may not betransferred
Legal and Anti-Trust
bull Any discussions that relate to thevalidity or cost of patent use shall beavoided
bull Any discussions or any materialrelating to an ongoing litigation shallbe avoided
bull Any discussions of pricing or issuesthat would violate US antitrust lawsshall be avoided
IEEE 80216 Patent Policybull IEEE 80216 operates under the Patent Policy of
the IEEE Standards Association as set forth inClause 6 of the IEEE-SA Standards BoardBylaws This policy includes the statement
bull IEEE standards may include the known use ofpatent(s) including patent applications if there istechnical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and providedthe IEEE receives assurance from the patentholder that it will license applicants underreasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standard
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
14
IEEE 80216 Patent Policy (cont)bull IEEE 80216 interprets in the opinion of the standards-
developing committee as in the opinion of the members of theWorking Group Early disclosure to the Working Groupparticipants of patent information that might be relevant to thestandard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and to increase the likelihood that the draftpublication will be approved for publication IEEE 80216 strivesto make such information available as soon as possible forconsideration by individual members in their voting decisionsHowever in its meetings and electronic forums IEEE 80216does not permit discussions concerning the validity orapplicability of intellectual property claims The only role a patentclaim plays in Working Group discussions concerns ensuringcompliance to the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures
bull Justification for the inclusion of technology is limited to thetechnical merits of the technology
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresAnyone whether participating in IEEE 80216 or notshould notify the Chair of any patents (granted orunder application and regardless of the assignee orthe patent nationality) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved byIEEE 80216 Such notification should be in written orelectronic form (email is preferred) and need notmake any statement concerning enforcement orlicensing The Chair will presume that suchnotification is intended for public release and will assoon as practical post it to the web along with otherPatent Notices On File with IEEE 80216 The Chairand the Working Group will take no positionregarding the validity or applicability of any patents
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresWritten contributions to IEEE 80216 standards development willnot be accepted without an acknowledgement of familiarity with theIEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures Thisacknowledgement will be part of the mandatory contribution coversheet and will read
ldquoThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policyand Procedures (Version )
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information thatmight be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce thepossibility for delays in the development process andincrease the likelihood that the draft publication will beapproved for publication Please notify the Chair as early aspossible in written or electronic form of any patents (grantedor under application) that may cover technology that is underconsideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 TheChair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 websiterdquo
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresThe Chair once formally notified and once apotentially relevant draft standard exists shallwrite to the identified party and request that aLetter of Assurance be filed with the Chair forforwarding to the IEEE-SA Patent Committee inaccordance with the instructions in the IEEE-SAStandards Board Operations Manual A samplerequest letter and response letter are availableWhen the Patent Committee has accepted theletter as a Letter of Assurance informationregarding the letter will be indexed in the Recordsof IEEE Standards-Related Patents
Approval of Minutes
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to
ndash approve Document IEEE 80216-0017(Minutes of Session 8)
TG1 (802161)bull Air Interface for Fixed Broadband
Wireless Access Systemsbull 10-66 GHz
bull Chair Roger Marksbull Editor Jim MollenauerBrian Petrybull MAC Chair Carl Eklundbull PHY Chair Jay Klein
TG1 Goals for Week
ndashStay on Development PlanbullInitiative Working Group Letter BallotbullSeek approval at Closing Plenary
ndashMACbullComment resolutionbullMeet with TG3
ndashPHYbullComment resolutionbullOther contributionsbullMeet with TG2
TG2 (802162)ndashCoexistence of Broadband Wireless
Access Systems
ndashCo-Chair Andy McGregorndashCo-Chair Leland LangstonndashVice Chair Reacutemi Chayer
ndashEditor Vito Scaringindash Secretary Reza Arefi
TG3 (802163)bull Broadband Wireless Access Systems
in Licensed Bands from 2 to 11 GHzbull Chair Brian Kiernanbull Vice Chair Carl Bushuebull Secretary Dean Changbull Functional Requirements
ndashBrian PetryndashGeorge Fishel
WirelessHUMANTM Study Group
bull Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed MetropolitanArea Networks
bull Chair Durga Satapathybull Secretary Sanjay Moghe
bull Chartered at Session 6bull Renewed at Session 8bull Writing a PAR
bull To coordinate with 80211 and 80215
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
15
Charge to Task Groupsbull Complete the task on your agenda
ndashUpdate agenda on bulletin board
bull Prepare for next meetingndashCall for Contributions etc
bull Prepare for Closing Plenary
ndashAll motions to be in writingbull Document everything
ndash submit documents before you leavendash provide document index on bulletin board
bull Presentations to server 2 hours in advance
Voting in Task Groups
bull Only 80216 Voting Members may vote in taskGroup meetingsndashShow Voting Token
bull All present are eligible to vote at Study Groupmeetings
New Business
bull Request for New Business items
Adjournment
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to adjournthis meeting of Working Group 80216until the Midweek Plenaryndash(5-6 pm on Wednesday 13 September)
TG2 Status Report
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 1
IEEE 802162 Activities
Recommended Practice forCoexistence of BroadbandWireless Access Systems
Co-chairs Leland Langston Andy McGregor
Vice Chair Remi ChayerEditor Vito Scaringi
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 2
Activities since San DiegoMeeting
bull R7 of draft Practice issued late July
bull Several input docs and comments receivedbull Teleconference held Sept 7th ndash 8 participants
ndashSignificant discussion on content
bull R8 of draft Practice available Sept 11th
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 3
Plans for Denver
bull Close issue of single vs multiple interferers
bull Review doc for consistency amp completenessbull Present summary to joint TG1TG2bull Post R9 in week of Sept 18th
bull Seeking comments from any 80216 participant
bull TARGET TG ballot following Tampa meeting
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
16
Appendix B Midweek Plenary Presentations
Midweek Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Midweek Plenary Meeting AgendaWednesday 13 September 2000 1700-1800
Opening of Midweek Plenary Meeting 1700Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Midweek Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule Update Marks V
Announcements 1705
Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IAttendance books badges etc Marin I
802161 1710
Report Marks I802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1720Report McGregor I
802163 1730
Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1740
Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1745
Liaison 1750
ITU Costa ETSI BRAN Klein
Closing 1755
New Business (Marin Editorial Process) Marks VAdjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
17
Agenda for the Week as revised at the Midweek Plenary
80216 Session 9 Agenda Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMon
RAWCONKeynoteAddress
Ballroom A-D
120-150 pm(80216
RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCONLunch
1230-130pm
(80216Registrants
Invited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon G
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon H
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG16-730 pmSalon E
TG3Salon E
8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
TG3730-10 pm
Salon E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
18
Appendix C Closing Plenary Presentations
Closing Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Closing Plenary Meeting AgendaFriday 15 September 2000 10 am -1200 noon
Opening 1000Call to Order Marks IAgenda Marks V
Announcements 1003Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IVice Chair Marks I80216 Logo Marks D
WirelessHUMAN 1010Report Satapathy IPAR Approval Satapathy V
802161 1025Report Marks I802161 Working Group Review Marks V
802162 1050Report McGregor IFinal Task Group Review McGregor IMotions McGregor V
802163 1110Report Kiernan IMotions Kiernan V
Future Meetings 1130
Session 10 6-10 November 2000 Hyatt Regency Tampa Tampa Florida USA Marks ISunday Monday Friday at Session 10 Marks DSession 11 22-26 January 2001 Tel Aviv Israel Marks ISession 12 12-15 March 2001 Hyatt Regency Hilton Head South Carolina USA Marks ISession 13 7-11 May 2001 Orlando Florida USA along with IEEE 80211 and 80215 Marks I
Liaison 1135
ETSI BRANnotification of 802161 status and offer of password Marks V
Regulatory Agency notifications Robinson V
New Business 114080216 Editorial Policy MarinPetry V
Closing 1200
Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
19
WirelessHUMANtrade Closing Presentation[Insert Document Title Here]
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
[The appropriate coordinator normally the Task Group Chair will fill in this number after obtaining it from the 80216 Chair The
document number will match that of the base contribution with ldquoprdquo replacing ldquocrdquo For example 802161p-00nn]Date Submitted
[2000-07-13]Source
[Durga Satapathy] [Voice(913) 534-6338] [Sprint] [Fax (913) 534-6522] [7101 College Blvd Suite 1436 B] mailto[durgasatapathymailsprintcom [Overland Park KS 66210]
Venue
[IEEE 80216 Session 8]Base Document
[If this presentation illustrates an 80216 document cite the document number and URL lthttpieee802org16hellipgt]Purpose
[WirelessHUMAN Study Group report at closing plenary]Notice
This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s)The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw materialcontained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creation of anIEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution and at theIEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor also acknowledges and acceptsthat this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including the statementldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developingcommittee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purpose ofimplementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chair ltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt asearly as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology that is under consideration by or has beenapproved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentslettersgt
IEEE 80216 Plenary Report
Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed Metropolitan Area Network
(WirelessHUMANTM) Study Group
Durga P Satapathy
WirelessHUMANTM Update
bull Reviewed 8 contributions
bull Achieved consensus on selecting standardsto utilizemodifyndashMAC 80216ndashPHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
bull Drafted PAR and 5 criteria
WirelessHUMANTM PAR Scope This standard specifies the physical layer and media access control
layer of the air interface of interoperable fixed broadband wirelessmetropolitan area network systems including point-to-multipoint Thestandard enables access to data video and voice services with qualityof service in unlicensed bands designated for public network access Itwill focus on the 5-6 GHz range and may be applied to unlicensedbands between 2 and 11 GHz The WirelessHUMAN standard willutilize or modify applicable elements from the following
MAC 80216
PHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
The development of the WirelessHUMAN standard will follow thetimeline as shown in Appendix A
WirelessHUMANTM Timeline
bull Call For Proposals for WirelessHUMAN PHYMAC Nov 2000)ndash PHY Modifications of 80211a HIPERLAN2ndash MAC Modifications of 80216
bull Review proposals Jan 2001
bull Select candidate proposals at Interim meeting Feb 2001bull Decision on specific modifications March 2001
bull First Draft Standard May 2001
bull Comment Resolutions July 2001
bull Second Draft Standard Sep 2001bull Finalize WirelessHUMAN Standard Nov 2001
Purpose of Proposed Project
To enable rapid worldwide deployment of innovative cost-effectiveand interoperable multi-vendor broadband wireless metropolitan areanetwork products operating in the unlicensed bands To facilitatecompetition in broadband access by providing fixed wirelessalternatives to wireline broadband access Identify techniques totolerate interference in the unlicensed bands facilitate strategies forcoexistence with other unlicensed band systems such as 80211a andmaximize the carrying capacity of the unlicensed bands Encourageconsistent worldwide allocation and accelerate the commercializationof unlicensed broadband wireless access spectrum Utilization ofunlicensed frequencies will address a market that includes residencesSmall Office-Home Office (SOHO) telecommuters and Small andMedium Enterprises (SME)
WirelessHUMAN Study Group Participants
Sprint RF Solutions Agilent Technologies
Intel Breezecom Adaptive BroadbandNokia Transcomm Inc Cabletron
Ericsson BNA Systems WirelessHomeLucent Escape Carleton UniversityIntracom Malibu Networks Carnegie Mellon UniversityProxim Ultracom Georgia Institute of TechnologyWaveIP Harris Corporation HRL Laboratories LLCN Band Com Wireless Inc Western MultiplexCoreon Inc Cabletron systems Communications Research Center
Runcom Magnolia Broadband Yokogawa Electric CoInnowave ECI
Motion
The proposed WirelessHUMANTM PARbe accepted
TG1 MAC ClosingPresentation
(TG1 MAC reportppt)
1 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
TG1 MAC group
bull Resolved comments received during Final TaskGroup review
bull Major effort to remove any particular PHYdependence from the MAC
bull Process of adding features useful for TG3requirments started
bull Meeting with TG3
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
20
2 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
Important MAC decisions
bull Adoption of EUI-48 addresses (previouslyEUI-64)
bull Addition of error control to MAC layer(previously defined in TC layer of PHY B)
bull Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes into asingle mode
bull Redesigned DL MAP message for higherspectral efficiency
TG1 PHY ClosingPresentation
Document Number80216pp-
TitlePHY TG1 Report at Session 9
Date Submitted
91500Source
Jay KleinVenue
Denver September 2000Base Document
None
PurposeReport
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist the IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the
contributing individual(s) or organization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after furtherstudy The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by 80216
IEEE Patent Policy
The contributor is familiar with the IEEE Patent Policy which is set forth in the IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylawslthttpstandards ieeeorgguidesbylawsgt and includes the statement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s)
including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developing committee and provided theIEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standardrdquo
PHY TG1 Report Session 9
Jay KleinEnsemble Communications
Documents Submitted
bull 802161pc-0044 (2000-09-07) Recommendation onLMDS Radio Propagation Channel Models
bull 802161c-0007 (2000-09-10)FEC Parameterization for Data Transport (Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0006 (2000-09-08)FEC Parameterization for Control Channel Information(Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0004 (2000-09-01)Frequency Synthesizer Model Parameters (Lars Lindh andHans Somerma)
Documents Submitted ndash cont
bull 802161c-0003 (2000-09-01)Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes in802161 (Ken Stanwood)
bull 802161c-0001 (2000-08-08)Summary of Open PHY Issues in IEEE 802161-0001 (Jeff Foerster)
Work done
bull All editorial comments resolved
bull All technical comments reviewed andresolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull TBDs resolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull Met with MAC group for ldquosynchronizingrdquo
TG3 Closing Presentation
802163 Task Group Reportbull Finished and Adopted Functional
Requirements Document except for editorialsndashOutput Comment database on server
bull Developed an initial List of EvaluationCriteria for PHY proposal evaluations FullCriteria to be developed at next meeting
bull Issuing two calls for contributionsndashPreliminary PHY proposalsndashDeployment Traffic and Propagation
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS
bull Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull Session 10 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband WirelessAccess will be held on 6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA In orderto assist in the evaluation of air interface proposals the 802163 Task Groupinvites contributions addressing the following issues
lang Traffic and deployment models based on single and multi-cellsystems
lang Channel propagation model
bull Contributions must be submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt Submissions will beconsidered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible followingreceipt for public access on the 80216 Web Site Email your contribution tothe 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernanltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 Chair Roger Marksltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS - Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull The Task Group 3 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access is preparing to define the PHY protocols for abroadband wireless access air interface specification for frequencies from 2 through 11 GHz The specification will be based on submittedcontributions with increasing detail required as the process progresses Mergers and improvements will be encouraged with final selectionscheduled for June 2001
bull The TG3 Task Group invites the submission of initial contributions representing proposed PHY solutions Contributors will be grantedagenda time during 80216 Working Group Session 10 (6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA) to present and discuss the merits oftheir proposals Only submissions to session 10 will be eligible for invitation to submit more detailed proposals to session 11 Eachproposal will be allocated equal agenda time on Tuesday November 7 If time permits the allocations will be 15 minutes of presentationfollowed by 15 minutes of discussion Submissions must follow the guidelines below
lang Include a descriptive titlelang Include an overview and a reference model that describes functions including interfaces to other layerslang Describe the benefits of the proposed PHY including any unique featureslang Describe any drawbacks of the proposed PHY
bull Explain how the submitted PHY relates to existing standards such as ITU-R JRG 8A-9B IEEE 80211 DOCSIS 11 ETSI HiperLAN orothers If it is based on an existing standard what differences occur due to BWA characteristics
lang Emphasize the scalability of the proposed PHY to deal efficiently with various data types as described in the 802163Functional Requirements Document
lang Include a statement on intellectual property rights and how 80216 may utilize the proposed PHY in a standard
bull The proposals will be evaluated based on criteria in the Evaluation Table below However at this initial stage contributions are not expectedto address in detail the discussion items in that table instead aiming for the more general description as outlined above Each of the VotingMembers of 80216 are eligible to participate in the evaluation if present Submitters receiving a combined score of 6 or better (out of 10) inany criterion in the Evaluation Table will be invited to submit more a detailed contribution for Session 11 (January 22-26 2001 in Tel AvivIsrael) Note that submissions need not represent a complete PHY but may focus on specific components
bull Contributions will be considered only if submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216 Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt The template requires a cover page and a narrative
bull Submissions will be considered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible following receipt for public access on the 80216Web Site lthttpieee802org16gt
bull Email your contribution to the 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernan ltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 ChairRoger Marks ltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
802163 Task Group Report
bull Officially Adopted TG1 MAC as TG3 DraftMAC
bull Create TG3 MAC Ad Hoc to review TG1MAC and provide TG3 Comments
bull Two Motions for the Working GroupndashLiaison to ETSI BRAN sub11 GHz WGndashEstablishment of 80216 Common MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
21
Motion 1
That the 80216 Working Group appoint ChetShirali as a liaison to the ETSI BRAN sub11GHz Working Group
Motion 2
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MACbullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
22
Appendix D Attendance at Session9Session9 was an interim session The 75 interval attendance criteria for Session 9 was 6 ormore intervals Please contact the 80216 Secretary (smarinixnetcomcom) if you feel yourattendance has been recorded incorrectly
The following 126 peopleregistered attendance at 6or more intervals and metthe attendance criteria
Aboukarr BakriAn SongArefi RezaArunachalam ArunAvera DraytAvivi EliAyyagari DeepakBaragar IanBaseghi BehshadBaugh CR (Rick)Belfiore CarlosBenyamin-Seeyar AnaderBushue CarlBuskila BaruchChan RebeccaChang DeanChayer ReacutemiCondie MaryCornelius JamesCosta JoseacuteCrilly Jr William JDoherty EdwardEdmonston BrainEidson BrianEklund CarlEl-Damhougy HeshamFishel GeorgeFoerster JeffreyGarrison G JackGesbert DavidGoldhammer MariannaGuillemette PhilGupta RakeshHadad ZionHall EricHamilton MichaelHammons RogerHatim BayaHebron YoanHilberman DanHosur SrinathHsuan YiHudson ThomasHum ColemanHunter WayneJacobsen EricJamali Hamadi
Jorgensen JacobKang InchulKasslin MikaKiernan BrianKim JohnKitroser ItzikKlein JayKolze ThomasKostas DemosKwak Byung-JaeKwak JoeLangley John BLangston J LelandLeiba YigalLewis BarryLicardie SergioLiebetreu JohnLindh LarsLo TitusMarin ScottMarks RogerMcCallister RonMcGregor AndyMcMullin RoderickMeyer RonaldMiddleton AndrewMizoguchi MasatoMody ApurvaMollenauer JamesPadan UziPetry BrianPleasant WayneRalston WilliamRan MosheResheff GuyRhodes ValentineRobinson GeneRoehr WaltRzeszewski TedSantacesaria ClaudioSatapathy DurgaSater GlenScaringi VitoScarpa CarlSchwartz RandallSegal YossiSellars MalcolmShan Tie-JunShimada ShusakuShirali ChetSkaar HelgeSmith SteveStamatelos George
Stambaugh KarlStanwood KenStewart MichaelStruhsaker PaulSydor JohnTappenden ChrisTateishi KimiyaTavormina JoeThomas RaymondThompson PaulTrinkwon DavidVan Waes NicoVarma SubirWachira MuyaWang ArthurWang Chao-ChunWang LeiWang XiaofengWard BobWhitehead PhilipWhiting RobertWilliams David GWise CurtWiss JohnYanover VladimirZuniga Juan Carlos
The following 18 peopleregistered attendance atless than 6 intervals anddid not meet theattendance criteria
Alspaugh MatthewCarlo JimFalconer DavidFoley MarkFoster RobertGupta AlokHancock DaleHarel HaimKhanna AmarpalKreig AndrewMonk AntonNadeau JamesOng Ling ChuenRafie ManouchehrRibner David BWheatley Chuck FYang S MichaelYurtkuran Erol
Motion 5
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MAC based on802161-0001r4bullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
Appendix E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
5
In a charge to Task Groups Marks asked groups to submit meeting minutes by the end of theweek and to propose motions at future 80216 plenary meetings using only documents from theserver
Regarding ITU-R Joint Rapporteurs Group (JRG) 8A-9B Joseacute Costa reviewed document IEEE80216l-0016 Marks highlighted the importance of liaison with the ITU-R
Jay Klein reported on ETSI BRAN HIPERACCESS Liaison
Marks explained that ETSI BRAN 80211 and 80215 now share password protected documentsMarks also stated that 80216 must decide whether to share password protected documents withETSI BRAN By IEEE procedure working group letter ballot documents are considered draftstandards and must therefore be copyrighted and protected
Marks reported that a letter (document IEEE 80216l-0025) had been received from Andrew Kreigpresident of the Wireless Communications Association The letter announced the appointment ofDemos Kostas as liaison from WCA to 80216
Under new business Scott Marin expressed concern and the potential to abuse the editorialprocess to influence documents
Motion1 Scott Marin 2nd Brian Petry That the 80216 Chairman establishes written guidelines(boundaries) for editors that among other things explains what editors can and cannot do
Motion1 passes without objection Marks took an action to present draft editorial rules forapproval at the closing plenary
Marks adjourned the midweek plenary at 1810
3 Friday 15 September 2000 Closing PlenaryAt 1005 Roger Marks called the meeting to order
Marks presented a draft agenda The agenda (See Appendix C) was approved without objection
Marks reported a few bugs with the registration fees that may need to be fixed and asked people tocheck their hotel statements carefully
Marks displayed the server page and explained the organization and ways to uses the server
Marks announced that 80216 Vice Chair Lou Olsen had resigned and that a new vice chair wouldbe elected at 80216 Session 10 Marks appointed Brian Petry as Acting Vice Chair until theelection Brian Petry accepted the appointment (and said hersquod continue to push for cookies atbreaks)
Marks displayed logo_bpng which had been introduced in a previous message to the 80216 e-mail reflector
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
6
The above logo was approved without objection
Regarding WirelessHUMANtrade Durga Satapathy reported a decision to use the 80216 MAC anda PHY based on ETSI BRAN HIPERLAN2 and 80211a (See presentation in Appendix C)Satapathy also reported completion of a draft project authorization request (PAR) and presentedthe draft
Motion2 Durga Satpathy 2nd Drayt Avera to accept the 91500 version of theWirelessHUMANtrade PAR (serverspublicWirelessHUMAN PAR 2000-09-15doc) with somelatitude to adjust text before submission to the 802 Executive Committee
The proposed WirelessHUMANtrade PAR be forwarded to the IEEE 802 SEC at least 30 days priorto the start of the following IEEE 802 Plenary session subject to a comments from IEEE 80211and 80215 and a comment revision process on the 80216 email reflector
Marks asked that the PAR be changed from a ldquoNew Standardrdquo to a ldquoSupplementrdquo The change wasaccepted without objection
Motion2amended Durga Satpathy 2nd Drayt Avera to accept the 91500 version of theWirelessHUMANtrade PAR (serverspublicWirelessHUMAN PAR 2000-09-15doc) with somelatitude to adjust text before submission to executive committee and that the type of document be asupplement rather than a new standard
The proposed WirelessHUMANtrade PAR be forwarded to the IEEE 802 SEC at least 30 days priorto the start of the following IEEE 802 Plenary session subject to a comments from IEEE 80211and 80215 and a comment revision process on the 80216 email reflector
Motion3 to amend Motion2 Tom Kolze 2nd Chet Sharali to amend Motion2 by addingDOCSIS 11 to the PAR Where it says ldquoMAC 80216rdquo to add ldquoDOCSIS 11rdquo
By token vote 3 for 15 against Motion3 fails
By token vote 23 for 1 against 4 abstain Motion2 as amended passes The approveddocument is IEEE 80216h-0013r0
Marks congratulated the WirelessHUMANtrade study group for reaching this stage in their work
Regarding TG1 MAC Carl Eklund reported that TG1 received several hundred comments on thedraft specification and used most of the meeting time to resolve the comments A major emphasis
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
7
was placed on removing the PHY dependencies from the MAC Eklund noted that a joint meetingwas held with TG3 in which many misunderstandings were discussed
Regarding the TG1 PHY John Liebetreu presented a summary (See Appendix C)
Motion4 John Liebetreu 2nd not needed to initiate a Working Group Review of the IEEE802161 working document number 802161-0001r4 (to be constructed by incorporating theresolved comments listed in document number 802161-0009 into 802161-0001r3) Thereview is set to begin September 29 and to end October 30 2000 See call for comments 802161-0005
By voice vote all for Motion4 passes
Marks reviewed the additional call for contributions on 802161rsquos open technical issues noting adue date of 30 October 2000 and that convergence layer text for IP Ethernet and ATM will besubmitted by Carl Eklund Glen Sater and Ken Stanwood respectively
Regarding TG2 Andy McCregor presented the meeting minutes (IEEE 802162c-0022) and notedfour recommendations from the meeting 1) to use a more formal call for comments 2) to invitecomments from other organizations such as WCA NSMA RABC and ARIB 3) to formally askfor comments from the Broadband Wireless Association of the UK and 4) to put the next draft ofthe coexistence practice on the public side of the IEEE 80216 web site
Marks asked TG2 to remove the copyright notice from their working document and not call thedocument a draft until a later stage in the process
Regarding TG3 Brian Kiernan reported (see Appendix C) adoption of the TG3 functionalrequirements document development of evaluation criteria and development of a call forcontributions In addition TG3 adopted the TG1 MAC and formed the TG3 MAC Ad Hoccommittee to review the TG1 MAC
Motion5 Brian Kiernan 2nd not needed Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bull Establish a common 80216 MAC based on 802161-0001r4
bull Require each 80216 task group to define its mandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMAC
bull Shall ensure backward compatibility and maintenance of the common MAC and
bull Shall strive to ensure forward compatibility of the common MAC
By token vote 24 for 0 against 1 abstain Motion5 passes See Appendix E
Marks acknowledged several organizational issues that must be worked Marks will try to resolveas many issues as possible by the November meeting
Regarding upcoming meetings Marks noted that the next meeting (Session 10) will be in TampaFlorida and that the opportunity exists to extend the Task Group meetings to Friday morning orMonday morning Marks also noted the possibility of joint meetings with other 802 workinggroups
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
8
Marks noted that Session 11 is scheduled for 22 to 26 January 2001 in Tel Aviv Israel hosted byBreezeCOM
Marks noted that Session 13 (May 7-11 2000) will be a joint meeting with 80211 and 80215 andpossibly ETSI BRAN Marks noted his desire to hold interim meetings together with other 802groups
Marks asked for a straw pole as to those in favor of meeting Sundays none for and about 20against
Regarding Liaison Marks noted that ETSI BRAN recommended that Demos Kostas act as contactin both directions Marks plans to reply using Demos Kostas in both directions
Marks noted that as of this week 80216 members and observers now have access to a mirror ofall ETSI BRAN documents Marks will send out information to members and observers on how toaccess the documents
Regarding liaison with ETSI BRAN Marks showed a draft liaison letter (80216l-00_28doc)
Motion6 Marks 2nd Brian Petry to approve draft letter presented by Marks (document IEEE80216l-0028)
Motion7 Brian Petry Brian Kiernan to amend motion6 by replacing we appoint Dr Kostas asour informal contact person for the information exchange with for a contact person wethereby appointing no contact person
Motion7 by voice vote all for Motion7 passes
Motion6 by voice vote several for one opposed Motion6 passes
Scott Marin 80216 secretary had to leave the meeting and George Fishel took over as secretary
Andy McGregor presented a draft liaison letter by TG2 David Trinkwon proposed an amendmentto letter The letter as amended was approved by voice vote
Gene Robinson from the regulatory affairs committee presented three draft letters to regulatorybodies of the US Canada and the UK The letters were edited by Marks The letters wereapproved by unanimous voice vote
Brian Petry indicated that a document containing a draft editorial policy and procedures is on theserver Brian Petry said that anyone wishing to be an editor should read the document Thechairman requested that members give information to Brian on the editorial process
At 1228 Marks adjourned Session9
4 AcknowledgementsThe 80216 secretary would like to thank the sub-group chairs (Carl Eklund Jay Klein AndyMcGregor Brian Kiernan and Durga Satapathy) and the people who took care of the attendancebooks for each group (Juan Zuniga Carl Bushue and Drayt Avera) The multiple attendance bookapproach seemed to work well due mainly to the help of the above people
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
9
Respectfully
Scott Marin
80216 Secretary
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
10
Appendix A Opening Plenary Presentations
Opening Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Opening Plenary Meeting AgendaMonday 11 September 2000 1400-1515
See Opening Plenary presentation slidesOpening of Session 9 and of Opening Plenary Meeting 1400Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Opening Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule of meetings for the week Marks V
Membership and Voting 1410Rights of members observers and others Marks IAttendance list procedure Marin IVoting token procedure Marin I
Announcements 1415Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks ILogistics rooms breaks etc Marks IIndividual and Anti-Trust Marks IIEEE 80216 Patent Policies and Procedures Marks I
Approvals 1425Minutes of Session 8 (IEEE 80216-0017) Marks V
802161 1430Report Marks IEditing Mollenauer Petry 802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1440Report McGregor I
802163 1450Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1500Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1510Voting in Task Groups and Study Groups Marks I
New Business 1513
Closing 1515Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
11
Agenda for the Week
80216 Session 9 AgendaSchedule (tentative)
Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMo
n
RAWCONKeynote Address
Ballroom A-D120-150 pm
(80216 RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster
Session530-700 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCON Lunch1230-130 pm
(80216 RegistrantsInvited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster
Session530-700 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon 5
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG3Salon GH8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
12
Chairmans Opening Plenary Presentation
IEEE 80216 Session 9 Opening Plenary Meeting
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
NoneDate Submitted
2000-09-11Source
Roger Marks Voice +1-303-497-3037NIST Fax +1-303-497-7828325 Broadway MC 81300 E-mail marksnistgovBoulder CO 80303
VenueSession 9 Opening Plenary
Base DocumentNone
PurposeThis presentation is to be inserted in the Session 9 minutes
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) ororganization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to addamend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creationof an IEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contributionand at the IEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor alsoacknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16 iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including thestatement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms andconditions for the purpose of implementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chairltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt as early as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentsnoticesgt
IEEE 80216Working Group on
Broadband Wireless Access(BWA)
Session 9Opening Plenary
11 September 2000
200-315 pm
Session Opening
bull Call to Order
bull Welcome
80216 Officers
bull Chair Roger Marks
bull Vice Chair Lou Olsen
bull Secretary Scott Marin
Agenda
bull Presentation of 80216 OpeningPlenary Agendandash Chair asks for unanimous consent to
approve
bull Schedule of meetings for the weekndash Chair asks for unanimous consent to
approve
Rights of Allbull To subscribe to the 80216 Email Reflector
(stds-802-16) and thereby be notified ofdocument publication meetings minutes
bull To post to stds-802-16 in accordance with thereflector rules
bull To examine documents unless copyrightconcerns prohibit it
bull To contribute documents in response to aCall for Contributions
bull To attend and participate in 80216 meetingsif registered
bull To join the Sponsor Balloting Pool
IEEE and IEEE SA Membership
bull Members are encouraged to join IEEEIEEE Standards Association and IEEEComputer Society
bull Such membership is not required forWorking Group Membership ObserverStatus or Sponsor Ballot PoolGroup
Sponsor Ballot PoolGroup
bull Balloting Pool is being constructed
bull Future 80216 draft standards will beballoted by a Balloting Group drawn frommembers of the 80216 Balloting Pool
bull To join the 80216 Balloting Pool use theform on the web
bull Members of IEEE Standards Association[IEEE or CS + $10] can participate in BallotGroup without paying special fee
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
13
Rights of Members amp Observers
bull To examine draft standardsbull To participate in Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To examine the votes of Working
Group membersbull To examine the Member and Observer
contact databases
Exclusive Rights of Membershipbull To make or second a motion at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote if and only if present at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote in 80216 Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To vote by email on any issue involving
80216 or its subsidiariesbull To lodge complaints about Working Group
operation with the 802 Executive Committeebull To petition the 802 Executive Committee in
writing
Attendance Listbull Recorded at each ldquomeeting intervalrdquo
ndashAfternoon MonTueWedThundashMorning TueWedThuFri
ndashEvening Thu
ndashSelf-declared ldquosubstantially allrdquo of meetingndashSession ldquoParticipationrdquo 75 of meeting intervals
bull =will round down to 6
bull Attendance recorded in parallel meetingsndashvoting credit for presence at either
bull Attendance is public recordndashattendance will be reported on webndashcontact info will not be posted (just company)
Secretaryrsquos Announcementsbull Scott Marin
ndash Attendance books (four of them)
bull Write your namebull If new and unregistered insert business
card in pocketbull Initial and keep the book movingbull Remember your book and page number
ndash Voting tokensbull Printed on badge for Membersbull Raise to vote
Registration
bull $140
bull Registration fee form at front deskndashHotel guest charge to roomndashOthers credit card
bull Receive copy of form as receipt
Document Distributionbull Server http10001bull Run DHCPbull Use 10BaseT or 100BaseTXbull Use 80211b or 80211 DSSS Wireless
bull Upload files using anonymous ftp
bull Flash Card may be available
Logistics
bull Meeting Roomsndash Vary throughout the week
bull Breaksndash Always in large room (E or D)
bull RAWCON events
Individuality
bull In IEEE standards meetingsparticipation is by individualndash you do not represent a company or
organization
bull Membership belongs to the individualnot an organization and may not betransferred
Legal and Anti-Trust
bull Any discussions that relate to thevalidity or cost of patent use shall beavoided
bull Any discussions or any materialrelating to an ongoing litigation shallbe avoided
bull Any discussions of pricing or issuesthat would violate US antitrust lawsshall be avoided
IEEE 80216 Patent Policybull IEEE 80216 operates under the Patent Policy of
the IEEE Standards Association as set forth inClause 6 of the IEEE-SA Standards BoardBylaws This policy includes the statement
bull IEEE standards may include the known use ofpatent(s) including patent applications if there istechnical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and providedthe IEEE receives assurance from the patentholder that it will license applicants underreasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standard
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
14
IEEE 80216 Patent Policy (cont)bull IEEE 80216 interprets in the opinion of the standards-
developing committee as in the opinion of the members of theWorking Group Early disclosure to the Working Groupparticipants of patent information that might be relevant to thestandard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and to increase the likelihood that the draftpublication will be approved for publication IEEE 80216 strivesto make such information available as soon as possible forconsideration by individual members in their voting decisionsHowever in its meetings and electronic forums IEEE 80216does not permit discussions concerning the validity orapplicability of intellectual property claims The only role a patentclaim plays in Working Group discussions concerns ensuringcompliance to the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures
bull Justification for the inclusion of technology is limited to thetechnical merits of the technology
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresAnyone whether participating in IEEE 80216 or notshould notify the Chair of any patents (granted orunder application and regardless of the assignee orthe patent nationality) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved byIEEE 80216 Such notification should be in written orelectronic form (email is preferred) and need notmake any statement concerning enforcement orlicensing The Chair will presume that suchnotification is intended for public release and will assoon as practical post it to the web along with otherPatent Notices On File with IEEE 80216 The Chairand the Working Group will take no positionregarding the validity or applicability of any patents
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresWritten contributions to IEEE 80216 standards development willnot be accepted without an acknowledgement of familiarity with theIEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures Thisacknowledgement will be part of the mandatory contribution coversheet and will read
ldquoThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policyand Procedures (Version )
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information thatmight be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce thepossibility for delays in the development process andincrease the likelihood that the draft publication will beapproved for publication Please notify the Chair as early aspossible in written or electronic form of any patents (grantedor under application) that may cover technology that is underconsideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 TheChair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 websiterdquo
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresThe Chair once formally notified and once apotentially relevant draft standard exists shallwrite to the identified party and request that aLetter of Assurance be filed with the Chair forforwarding to the IEEE-SA Patent Committee inaccordance with the instructions in the IEEE-SAStandards Board Operations Manual A samplerequest letter and response letter are availableWhen the Patent Committee has accepted theletter as a Letter of Assurance informationregarding the letter will be indexed in the Recordsof IEEE Standards-Related Patents
Approval of Minutes
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to
ndash approve Document IEEE 80216-0017(Minutes of Session 8)
TG1 (802161)bull Air Interface for Fixed Broadband
Wireless Access Systemsbull 10-66 GHz
bull Chair Roger Marksbull Editor Jim MollenauerBrian Petrybull MAC Chair Carl Eklundbull PHY Chair Jay Klein
TG1 Goals for Week
ndashStay on Development PlanbullInitiative Working Group Letter BallotbullSeek approval at Closing Plenary
ndashMACbullComment resolutionbullMeet with TG3
ndashPHYbullComment resolutionbullOther contributionsbullMeet with TG2
TG2 (802162)ndashCoexistence of Broadband Wireless
Access Systems
ndashCo-Chair Andy McGregorndashCo-Chair Leland LangstonndashVice Chair Reacutemi Chayer
ndashEditor Vito Scaringindash Secretary Reza Arefi
TG3 (802163)bull Broadband Wireless Access Systems
in Licensed Bands from 2 to 11 GHzbull Chair Brian Kiernanbull Vice Chair Carl Bushuebull Secretary Dean Changbull Functional Requirements
ndashBrian PetryndashGeorge Fishel
WirelessHUMANTM Study Group
bull Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed MetropolitanArea Networks
bull Chair Durga Satapathybull Secretary Sanjay Moghe
bull Chartered at Session 6bull Renewed at Session 8bull Writing a PAR
bull To coordinate with 80211 and 80215
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
15
Charge to Task Groupsbull Complete the task on your agenda
ndashUpdate agenda on bulletin board
bull Prepare for next meetingndashCall for Contributions etc
bull Prepare for Closing Plenary
ndashAll motions to be in writingbull Document everything
ndash submit documents before you leavendash provide document index on bulletin board
bull Presentations to server 2 hours in advance
Voting in Task Groups
bull Only 80216 Voting Members may vote in taskGroup meetingsndashShow Voting Token
bull All present are eligible to vote at Study Groupmeetings
New Business
bull Request for New Business items
Adjournment
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to adjournthis meeting of Working Group 80216until the Midweek Plenaryndash(5-6 pm on Wednesday 13 September)
TG2 Status Report
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 1
IEEE 802162 Activities
Recommended Practice forCoexistence of BroadbandWireless Access Systems
Co-chairs Leland Langston Andy McGregor
Vice Chair Remi ChayerEditor Vito Scaringi
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 2
Activities since San DiegoMeeting
bull R7 of draft Practice issued late July
bull Several input docs and comments receivedbull Teleconference held Sept 7th ndash 8 participants
ndashSignificant discussion on content
bull R8 of draft Practice available Sept 11th
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 3
Plans for Denver
bull Close issue of single vs multiple interferers
bull Review doc for consistency amp completenessbull Present summary to joint TG1TG2bull Post R9 in week of Sept 18th
bull Seeking comments from any 80216 participant
bull TARGET TG ballot following Tampa meeting
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
16
Appendix B Midweek Plenary Presentations
Midweek Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Midweek Plenary Meeting AgendaWednesday 13 September 2000 1700-1800
Opening of Midweek Plenary Meeting 1700Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Midweek Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule Update Marks V
Announcements 1705
Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IAttendance books badges etc Marin I
802161 1710
Report Marks I802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1720Report McGregor I
802163 1730
Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1740
Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1745
Liaison 1750
ITU Costa ETSI BRAN Klein
Closing 1755
New Business (Marin Editorial Process) Marks VAdjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
17
Agenda for the Week as revised at the Midweek Plenary
80216 Session 9 Agenda Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMon
RAWCONKeynoteAddress
Ballroom A-D
120-150 pm(80216
RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCONLunch
1230-130pm
(80216Registrants
Invited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon G
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon H
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG16-730 pmSalon E
TG3Salon E
8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
TG3730-10 pm
Salon E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
18
Appendix C Closing Plenary Presentations
Closing Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Closing Plenary Meeting AgendaFriday 15 September 2000 10 am -1200 noon
Opening 1000Call to Order Marks IAgenda Marks V
Announcements 1003Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IVice Chair Marks I80216 Logo Marks D
WirelessHUMAN 1010Report Satapathy IPAR Approval Satapathy V
802161 1025Report Marks I802161 Working Group Review Marks V
802162 1050Report McGregor IFinal Task Group Review McGregor IMotions McGregor V
802163 1110Report Kiernan IMotions Kiernan V
Future Meetings 1130
Session 10 6-10 November 2000 Hyatt Regency Tampa Tampa Florida USA Marks ISunday Monday Friday at Session 10 Marks DSession 11 22-26 January 2001 Tel Aviv Israel Marks ISession 12 12-15 March 2001 Hyatt Regency Hilton Head South Carolina USA Marks ISession 13 7-11 May 2001 Orlando Florida USA along with IEEE 80211 and 80215 Marks I
Liaison 1135
ETSI BRANnotification of 802161 status and offer of password Marks V
Regulatory Agency notifications Robinson V
New Business 114080216 Editorial Policy MarinPetry V
Closing 1200
Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
19
WirelessHUMANtrade Closing Presentation[Insert Document Title Here]
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
[The appropriate coordinator normally the Task Group Chair will fill in this number after obtaining it from the 80216 Chair The
document number will match that of the base contribution with ldquoprdquo replacing ldquocrdquo For example 802161p-00nn]Date Submitted
[2000-07-13]Source
[Durga Satapathy] [Voice(913) 534-6338] [Sprint] [Fax (913) 534-6522] [7101 College Blvd Suite 1436 B] mailto[durgasatapathymailsprintcom [Overland Park KS 66210]
Venue
[IEEE 80216 Session 8]Base Document
[If this presentation illustrates an 80216 document cite the document number and URL lthttpieee802org16hellipgt]Purpose
[WirelessHUMAN Study Group report at closing plenary]Notice
This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s)The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw materialcontained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creation of anIEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution and at theIEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor also acknowledges and acceptsthat this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including the statementldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developingcommittee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purpose ofimplementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chair ltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt asearly as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology that is under consideration by or has beenapproved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentslettersgt
IEEE 80216 Plenary Report
Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed Metropolitan Area Network
(WirelessHUMANTM) Study Group
Durga P Satapathy
WirelessHUMANTM Update
bull Reviewed 8 contributions
bull Achieved consensus on selecting standardsto utilizemodifyndashMAC 80216ndashPHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
bull Drafted PAR and 5 criteria
WirelessHUMANTM PAR Scope This standard specifies the physical layer and media access control
layer of the air interface of interoperable fixed broadband wirelessmetropolitan area network systems including point-to-multipoint Thestandard enables access to data video and voice services with qualityof service in unlicensed bands designated for public network access Itwill focus on the 5-6 GHz range and may be applied to unlicensedbands between 2 and 11 GHz The WirelessHUMAN standard willutilize or modify applicable elements from the following
MAC 80216
PHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
The development of the WirelessHUMAN standard will follow thetimeline as shown in Appendix A
WirelessHUMANTM Timeline
bull Call For Proposals for WirelessHUMAN PHYMAC Nov 2000)ndash PHY Modifications of 80211a HIPERLAN2ndash MAC Modifications of 80216
bull Review proposals Jan 2001
bull Select candidate proposals at Interim meeting Feb 2001bull Decision on specific modifications March 2001
bull First Draft Standard May 2001
bull Comment Resolutions July 2001
bull Second Draft Standard Sep 2001bull Finalize WirelessHUMAN Standard Nov 2001
Purpose of Proposed Project
To enable rapid worldwide deployment of innovative cost-effectiveand interoperable multi-vendor broadband wireless metropolitan areanetwork products operating in the unlicensed bands To facilitatecompetition in broadband access by providing fixed wirelessalternatives to wireline broadband access Identify techniques totolerate interference in the unlicensed bands facilitate strategies forcoexistence with other unlicensed band systems such as 80211a andmaximize the carrying capacity of the unlicensed bands Encourageconsistent worldwide allocation and accelerate the commercializationof unlicensed broadband wireless access spectrum Utilization ofunlicensed frequencies will address a market that includes residencesSmall Office-Home Office (SOHO) telecommuters and Small andMedium Enterprises (SME)
WirelessHUMAN Study Group Participants
Sprint RF Solutions Agilent Technologies
Intel Breezecom Adaptive BroadbandNokia Transcomm Inc Cabletron
Ericsson BNA Systems WirelessHomeLucent Escape Carleton UniversityIntracom Malibu Networks Carnegie Mellon UniversityProxim Ultracom Georgia Institute of TechnologyWaveIP Harris Corporation HRL Laboratories LLCN Band Com Wireless Inc Western MultiplexCoreon Inc Cabletron systems Communications Research Center
Runcom Magnolia Broadband Yokogawa Electric CoInnowave ECI
Motion
The proposed WirelessHUMANTM PARbe accepted
TG1 MAC ClosingPresentation
(TG1 MAC reportppt)
1 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
TG1 MAC group
bull Resolved comments received during Final TaskGroup review
bull Major effort to remove any particular PHYdependence from the MAC
bull Process of adding features useful for TG3requirments started
bull Meeting with TG3
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
20
2 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
Important MAC decisions
bull Adoption of EUI-48 addresses (previouslyEUI-64)
bull Addition of error control to MAC layer(previously defined in TC layer of PHY B)
bull Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes into asingle mode
bull Redesigned DL MAP message for higherspectral efficiency
TG1 PHY ClosingPresentation
Document Number80216pp-
TitlePHY TG1 Report at Session 9
Date Submitted
91500Source
Jay KleinVenue
Denver September 2000Base Document
None
PurposeReport
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist the IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the
contributing individual(s) or organization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after furtherstudy The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by 80216
IEEE Patent Policy
The contributor is familiar with the IEEE Patent Policy which is set forth in the IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylawslthttpstandards ieeeorgguidesbylawsgt and includes the statement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s)
including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developing committee and provided theIEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standardrdquo
PHY TG1 Report Session 9
Jay KleinEnsemble Communications
Documents Submitted
bull 802161pc-0044 (2000-09-07) Recommendation onLMDS Radio Propagation Channel Models
bull 802161c-0007 (2000-09-10)FEC Parameterization for Data Transport (Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0006 (2000-09-08)FEC Parameterization for Control Channel Information(Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0004 (2000-09-01)Frequency Synthesizer Model Parameters (Lars Lindh andHans Somerma)
Documents Submitted ndash cont
bull 802161c-0003 (2000-09-01)Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes in802161 (Ken Stanwood)
bull 802161c-0001 (2000-08-08)Summary of Open PHY Issues in IEEE 802161-0001 (Jeff Foerster)
Work done
bull All editorial comments resolved
bull All technical comments reviewed andresolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull TBDs resolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull Met with MAC group for ldquosynchronizingrdquo
TG3 Closing Presentation
802163 Task Group Reportbull Finished and Adopted Functional
Requirements Document except for editorialsndashOutput Comment database on server
bull Developed an initial List of EvaluationCriteria for PHY proposal evaluations FullCriteria to be developed at next meeting
bull Issuing two calls for contributionsndashPreliminary PHY proposalsndashDeployment Traffic and Propagation
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS
bull Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull Session 10 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband WirelessAccess will be held on 6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA In orderto assist in the evaluation of air interface proposals the 802163 Task Groupinvites contributions addressing the following issues
lang Traffic and deployment models based on single and multi-cellsystems
lang Channel propagation model
bull Contributions must be submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt Submissions will beconsidered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible followingreceipt for public access on the 80216 Web Site Email your contribution tothe 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernanltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 Chair Roger Marksltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS - Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull The Task Group 3 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access is preparing to define the PHY protocols for abroadband wireless access air interface specification for frequencies from 2 through 11 GHz The specification will be based on submittedcontributions with increasing detail required as the process progresses Mergers and improvements will be encouraged with final selectionscheduled for June 2001
bull The TG3 Task Group invites the submission of initial contributions representing proposed PHY solutions Contributors will be grantedagenda time during 80216 Working Group Session 10 (6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA) to present and discuss the merits oftheir proposals Only submissions to session 10 will be eligible for invitation to submit more detailed proposals to session 11 Eachproposal will be allocated equal agenda time on Tuesday November 7 If time permits the allocations will be 15 minutes of presentationfollowed by 15 minutes of discussion Submissions must follow the guidelines below
lang Include a descriptive titlelang Include an overview and a reference model that describes functions including interfaces to other layerslang Describe the benefits of the proposed PHY including any unique featureslang Describe any drawbacks of the proposed PHY
bull Explain how the submitted PHY relates to existing standards such as ITU-R JRG 8A-9B IEEE 80211 DOCSIS 11 ETSI HiperLAN orothers If it is based on an existing standard what differences occur due to BWA characteristics
lang Emphasize the scalability of the proposed PHY to deal efficiently with various data types as described in the 802163Functional Requirements Document
lang Include a statement on intellectual property rights and how 80216 may utilize the proposed PHY in a standard
bull The proposals will be evaluated based on criteria in the Evaluation Table below However at this initial stage contributions are not expectedto address in detail the discussion items in that table instead aiming for the more general description as outlined above Each of the VotingMembers of 80216 are eligible to participate in the evaluation if present Submitters receiving a combined score of 6 or better (out of 10) inany criterion in the Evaluation Table will be invited to submit more a detailed contribution for Session 11 (January 22-26 2001 in Tel AvivIsrael) Note that submissions need not represent a complete PHY but may focus on specific components
bull Contributions will be considered only if submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216 Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt The template requires a cover page and a narrative
bull Submissions will be considered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible following receipt for public access on the 80216Web Site lthttpieee802org16gt
bull Email your contribution to the 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernan ltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 ChairRoger Marks ltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
802163 Task Group Report
bull Officially Adopted TG1 MAC as TG3 DraftMAC
bull Create TG3 MAC Ad Hoc to review TG1MAC and provide TG3 Comments
bull Two Motions for the Working GroupndashLiaison to ETSI BRAN sub11 GHz WGndashEstablishment of 80216 Common MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
21
Motion 1
That the 80216 Working Group appoint ChetShirali as a liaison to the ETSI BRAN sub11GHz Working Group
Motion 2
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MACbullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
22
Appendix D Attendance at Session9Session9 was an interim session The 75 interval attendance criteria for Session 9 was 6 ormore intervals Please contact the 80216 Secretary (smarinixnetcomcom) if you feel yourattendance has been recorded incorrectly
The following 126 peopleregistered attendance at 6or more intervals and metthe attendance criteria
Aboukarr BakriAn SongArefi RezaArunachalam ArunAvera DraytAvivi EliAyyagari DeepakBaragar IanBaseghi BehshadBaugh CR (Rick)Belfiore CarlosBenyamin-Seeyar AnaderBushue CarlBuskila BaruchChan RebeccaChang DeanChayer ReacutemiCondie MaryCornelius JamesCosta JoseacuteCrilly Jr William JDoherty EdwardEdmonston BrainEidson BrianEklund CarlEl-Damhougy HeshamFishel GeorgeFoerster JeffreyGarrison G JackGesbert DavidGoldhammer MariannaGuillemette PhilGupta RakeshHadad ZionHall EricHamilton MichaelHammons RogerHatim BayaHebron YoanHilberman DanHosur SrinathHsuan YiHudson ThomasHum ColemanHunter WayneJacobsen EricJamali Hamadi
Jorgensen JacobKang InchulKasslin MikaKiernan BrianKim JohnKitroser ItzikKlein JayKolze ThomasKostas DemosKwak Byung-JaeKwak JoeLangley John BLangston J LelandLeiba YigalLewis BarryLicardie SergioLiebetreu JohnLindh LarsLo TitusMarin ScottMarks RogerMcCallister RonMcGregor AndyMcMullin RoderickMeyer RonaldMiddleton AndrewMizoguchi MasatoMody ApurvaMollenauer JamesPadan UziPetry BrianPleasant WayneRalston WilliamRan MosheResheff GuyRhodes ValentineRobinson GeneRoehr WaltRzeszewski TedSantacesaria ClaudioSatapathy DurgaSater GlenScaringi VitoScarpa CarlSchwartz RandallSegal YossiSellars MalcolmShan Tie-JunShimada ShusakuShirali ChetSkaar HelgeSmith SteveStamatelos George
Stambaugh KarlStanwood KenStewart MichaelStruhsaker PaulSydor JohnTappenden ChrisTateishi KimiyaTavormina JoeThomas RaymondThompson PaulTrinkwon DavidVan Waes NicoVarma SubirWachira MuyaWang ArthurWang Chao-ChunWang LeiWang XiaofengWard BobWhitehead PhilipWhiting RobertWilliams David GWise CurtWiss JohnYanover VladimirZuniga Juan Carlos
The following 18 peopleregistered attendance atless than 6 intervals anddid not meet theattendance criteria
Alspaugh MatthewCarlo JimFalconer DavidFoley MarkFoster RobertGupta AlokHancock DaleHarel HaimKhanna AmarpalKreig AndrewMonk AntonNadeau JamesOng Ling ChuenRafie ManouchehrRibner David BWheatley Chuck FYang S MichaelYurtkuran Erol
Motion 5
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MAC based on802161-0001r4bullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
Appendix E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
6
The above logo was approved without objection
Regarding WirelessHUMANtrade Durga Satapathy reported a decision to use the 80216 MAC anda PHY based on ETSI BRAN HIPERLAN2 and 80211a (See presentation in Appendix C)Satapathy also reported completion of a draft project authorization request (PAR) and presentedthe draft
Motion2 Durga Satpathy 2nd Drayt Avera to accept the 91500 version of theWirelessHUMANtrade PAR (serverspublicWirelessHUMAN PAR 2000-09-15doc) with somelatitude to adjust text before submission to the 802 Executive Committee
The proposed WirelessHUMANtrade PAR be forwarded to the IEEE 802 SEC at least 30 days priorto the start of the following IEEE 802 Plenary session subject to a comments from IEEE 80211and 80215 and a comment revision process on the 80216 email reflector
Marks asked that the PAR be changed from a ldquoNew Standardrdquo to a ldquoSupplementrdquo The change wasaccepted without objection
Motion2amended Durga Satpathy 2nd Drayt Avera to accept the 91500 version of theWirelessHUMANtrade PAR (serverspublicWirelessHUMAN PAR 2000-09-15doc) with somelatitude to adjust text before submission to executive committee and that the type of document be asupplement rather than a new standard
The proposed WirelessHUMANtrade PAR be forwarded to the IEEE 802 SEC at least 30 days priorto the start of the following IEEE 802 Plenary session subject to a comments from IEEE 80211and 80215 and a comment revision process on the 80216 email reflector
Motion3 to amend Motion2 Tom Kolze 2nd Chet Sharali to amend Motion2 by addingDOCSIS 11 to the PAR Where it says ldquoMAC 80216rdquo to add ldquoDOCSIS 11rdquo
By token vote 3 for 15 against Motion3 fails
By token vote 23 for 1 against 4 abstain Motion2 as amended passes The approveddocument is IEEE 80216h-0013r0
Marks congratulated the WirelessHUMANtrade study group for reaching this stage in their work
Regarding TG1 MAC Carl Eklund reported that TG1 received several hundred comments on thedraft specification and used most of the meeting time to resolve the comments A major emphasis
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
7
was placed on removing the PHY dependencies from the MAC Eklund noted that a joint meetingwas held with TG3 in which many misunderstandings were discussed
Regarding the TG1 PHY John Liebetreu presented a summary (See Appendix C)
Motion4 John Liebetreu 2nd not needed to initiate a Working Group Review of the IEEE802161 working document number 802161-0001r4 (to be constructed by incorporating theresolved comments listed in document number 802161-0009 into 802161-0001r3) Thereview is set to begin September 29 and to end October 30 2000 See call for comments 802161-0005
By voice vote all for Motion4 passes
Marks reviewed the additional call for contributions on 802161rsquos open technical issues noting adue date of 30 October 2000 and that convergence layer text for IP Ethernet and ATM will besubmitted by Carl Eklund Glen Sater and Ken Stanwood respectively
Regarding TG2 Andy McCregor presented the meeting minutes (IEEE 802162c-0022) and notedfour recommendations from the meeting 1) to use a more formal call for comments 2) to invitecomments from other organizations such as WCA NSMA RABC and ARIB 3) to formally askfor comments from the Broadband Wireless Association of the UK and 4) to put the next draft ofthe coexistence practice on the public side of the IEEE 80216 web site
Marks asked TG2 to remove the copyright notice from their working document and not call thedocument a draft until a later stage in the process
Regarding TG3 Brian Kiernan reported (see Appendix C) adoption of the TG3 functionalrequirements document development of evaluation criteria and development of a call forcontributions In addition TG3 adopted the TG1 MAC and formed the TG3 MAC Ad Hoccommittee to review the TG1 MAC
Motion5 Brian Kiernan 2nd not needed Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bull Establish a common 80216 MAC based on 802161-0001r4
bull Require each 80216 task group to define its mandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMAC
bull Shall ensure backward compatibility and maintenance of the common MAC and
bull Shall strive to ensure forward compatibility of the common MAC
By token vote 24 for 0 against 1 abstain Motion5 passes See Appendix E
Marks acknowledged several organizational issues that must be worked Marks will try to resolveas many issues as possible by the November meeting
Regarding upcoming meetings Marks noted that the next meeting (Session 10) will be in TampaFlorida and that the opportunity exists to extend the Task Group meetings to Friday morning orMonday morning Marks also noted the possibility of joint meetings with other 802 workinggroups
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
8
Marks noted that Session 11 is scheduled for 22 to 26 January 2001 in Tel Aviv Israel hosted byBreezeCOM
Marks noted that Session 13 (May 7-11 2000) will be a joint meeting with 80211 and 80215 andpossibly ETSI BRAN Marks noted his desire to hold interim meetings together with other 802groups
Marks asked for a straw pole as to those in favor of meeting Sundays none for and about 20against
Regarding Liaison Marks noted that ETSI BRAN recommended that Demos Kostas act as contactin both directions Marks plans to reply using Demos Kostas in both directions
Marks noted that as of this week 80216 members and observers now have access to a mirror ofall ETSI BRAN documents Marks will send out information to members and observers on how toaccess the documents
Regarding liaison with ETSI BRAN Marks showed a draft liaison letter (80216l-00_28doc)
Motion6 Marks 2nd Brian Petry to approve draft letter presented by Marks (document IEEE80216l-0028)
Motion7 Brian Petry Brian Kiernan to amend motion6 by replacing we appoint Dr Kostas asour informal contact person for the information exchange with for a contact person wethereby appointing no contact person
Motion7 by voice vote all for Motion7 passes
Motion6 by voice vote several for one opposed Motion6 passes
Scott Marin 80216 secretary had to leave the meeting and George Fishel took over as secretary
Andy McGregor presented a draft liaison letter by TG2 David Trinkwon proposed an amendmentto letter The letter as amended was approved by voice vote
Gene Robinson from the regulatory affairs committee presented three draft letters to regulatorybodies of the US Canada and the UK The letters were edited by Marks The letters wereapproved by unanimous voice vote
Brian Petry indicated that a document containing a draft editorial policy and procedures is on theserver Brian Petry said that anyone wishing to be an editor should read the document Thechairman requested that members give information to Brian on the editorial process
At 1228 Marks adjourned Session9
4 AcknowledgementsThe 80216 secretary would like to thank the sub-group chairs (Carl Eklund Jay Klein AndyMcGregor Brian Kiernan and Durga Satapathy) and the people who took care of the attendancebooks for each group (Juan Zuniga Carl Bushue and Drayt Avera) The multiple attendance bookapproach seemed to work well due mainly to the help of the above people
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
9
Respectfully
Scott Marin
80216 Secretary
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
10
Appendix A Opening Plenary Presentations
Opening Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Opening Plenary Meeting AgendaMonday 11 September 2000 1400-1515
See Opening Plenary presentation slidesOpening of Session 9 and of Opening Plenary Meeting 1400Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Opening Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule of meetings for the week Marks V
Membership and Voting 1410Rights of members observers and others Marks IAttendance list procedure Marin IVoting token procedure Marin I
Announcements 1415Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks ILogistics rooms breaks etc Marks IIndividual and Anti-Trust Marks IIEEE 80216 Patent Policies and Procedures Marks I
Approvals 1425Minutes of Session 8 (IEEE 80216-0017) Marks V
802161 1430Report Marks IEditing Mollenauer Petry 802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1440Report McGregor I
802163 1450Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1500Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1510Voting in Task Groups and Study Groups Marks I
New Business 1513
Closing 1515Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
11
Agenda for the Week
80216 Session 9 AgendaSchedule (tentative)
Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMo
n
RAWCONKeynote Address
Ballroom A-D120-150 pm
(80216 RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster
Session530-700 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCON Lunch1230-130 pm
(80216 RegistrantsInvited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster
Session530-700 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon 5
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG3Salon GH8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
12
Chairmans Opening Plenary Presentation
IEEE 80216 Session 9 Opening Plenary Meeting
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
NoneDate Submitted
2000-09-11Source
Roger Marks Voice +1-303-497-3037NIST Fax +1-303-497-7828325 Broadway MC 81300 E-mail marksnistgovBoulder CO 80303
VenueSession 9 Opening Plenary
Base DocumentNone
PurposeThis presentation is to be inserted in the Session 9 minutes
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) ororganization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to addamend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creationof an IEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contributionand at the IEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor alsoacknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16 iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including thestatement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms andconditions for the purpose of implementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chairltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt as early as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentsnoticesgt
IEEE 80216Working Group on
Broadband Wireless Access(BWA)
Session 9Opening Plenary
11 September 2000
200-315 pm
Session Opening
bull Call to Order
bull Welcome
80216 Officers
bull Chair Roger Marks
bull Vice Chair Lou Olsen
bull Secretary Scott Marin
Agenda
bull Presentation of 80216 OpeningPlenary Agendandash Chair asks for unanimous consent to
approve
bull Schedule of meetings for the weekndash Chair asks for unanimous consent to
approve
Rights of Allbull To subscribe to the 80216 Email Reflector
(stds-802-16) and thereby be notified ofdocument publication meetings minutes
bull To post to stds-802-16 in accordance with thereflector rules
bull To examine documents unless copyrightconcerns prohibit it
bull To contribute documents in response to aCall for Contributions
bull To attend and participate in 80216 meetingsif registered
bull To join the Sponsor Balloting Pool
IEEE and IEEE SA Membership
bull Members are encouraged to join IEEEIEEE Standards Association and IEEEComputer Society
bull Such membership is not required forWorking Group Membership ObserverStatus or Sponsor Ballot PoolGroup
Sponsor Ballot PoolGroup
bull Balloting Pool is being constructed
bull Future 80216 draft standards will beballoted by a Balloting Group drawn frommembers of the 80216 Balloting Pool
bull To join the 80216 Balloting Pool use theform on the web
bull Members of IEEE Standards Association[IEEE or CS + $10] can participate in BallotGroup without paying special fee
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
13
Rights of Members amp Observers
bull To examine draft standardsbull To participate in Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To examine the votes of Working
Group membersbull To examine the Member and Observer
contact databases
Exclusive Rights of Membershipbull To make or second a motion at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote if and only if present at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote in 80216 Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To vote by email on any issue involving
80216 or its subsidiariesbull To lodge complaints about Working Group
operation with the 802 Executive Committeebull To petition the 802 Executive Committee in
writing
Attendance Listbull Recorded at each ldquomeeting intervalrdquo
ndashAfternoon MonTueWedThundashMorning TueWedThuFri
ndashEvening Thu
ndashSelf-declared ldquosubstantially allrdquo of meetingndashSession ldquoParticipationrdquo 75 of meeting intervals
bull =will round down to 6
bull Attendance recorded in parallel meetingsndashvoting credit for presence at either
bull Attendance is public recordndashattendance will be reported on webndashcontact info will not be posted (just company)
Secretaryrsquos Announcementsbull Scott Marin
ndash Attendance books (four of them)
bull Write your namebull If new and unregistered insert business
card in pocketbull Initial and keep the book movingbull Remember your book and page number
ndash Voting tokensbull Printed on badge for Membersbull Raise to vote
Registration
bull $140
bull Registration fee form at front deskndashHotel guest charge to roomndashOthers credit card
bull Receive copy of form as receipt
Document Distributionbull Server http10001bull Run DHCPbull Use 10BaseT or 100BaseTXbull Use 80211b or 80211 DSSS Wireless
bull Upload files using anonymous ftp
bull Flash Card may be available
Logistics
bull Meeting Roomsndash Vary throughout the week
bull Breaksndash Always in large room (E or D)
bull RAWCON events
Individuality
bull In IEEE standards meetingsparticipation is by individualndash you do not represent a company or
organization
bull Membership belongs to the individualnot an organization and may not betransferred
Legal and Anti-Trust
bull Any discussions that relate to thevalidity or cost of patent use shall beavoided
bull Any discussions or any materialrelating to an ongoing litigation shallbe avoided
bull Any discussions of pricing or issuesthat would violate US antitrust lawsshall be avoided
IEEE 80216 Patent Policybull IEEE 80216 operates under the Patent Policy of
the IEEE Standards Association as set forth inClause 6 of the IEEE-SA Standards BoardBylaws This policy includes the statement
bull IEEE standards may include the known use ofpatent(s) including patent applications if there istechnical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and providedthe IEEE receives assurance from the patentholder that it will license applicants underreasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standard
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
14
IEEE 80216 Patent Policy (cont)bull IEEE 80216 interprets in the opinion of the standards-
developing committee as in the opinion of the members of theWorking Group Early disclosure to the Working Groupparticipants of patent information that might be relevant to thestandard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and to increase the likelihood that the draftpublication will be approved for publication IEEE 80216 strivesto make such information available as soon as possible forconsideration by individual members in their voting decisionsHowever in its meetings and electronic forums IEEE 80216does not permit discussions concerning the validity orapplicability of intellectual property claims The only role a patentclaim plays in Working Group discussions concerns ensuringcompliance to the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures
bull Justification for the inclusion of technology is limited to thetechnical merits of the technology
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresAnyone whether participating in IEEE 80216 or notshould notify the Chair of any patents (granted orunder application and regardless of the assignee orthe patent nationality) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved byIEEE 80216 Such notification should be in written orelectronic form (email is preferred) and need notmake any statement concerning enforcement orlicensing The Chair will presume that suchnotification is intended for public release and will assoon as practical post it to the web along with otherPatent Notices On File with IEEE 80216 The Chairand the Working Group will take no positionregarding the validity or applicability of any patents
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresWritten contributions to IEEE 80216 standards development willnot be accepted without an acknowledgement of familiarity with theIEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures Thisacknowledgement will be part of the mandatory contribution coversheet and will read
ldquoThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policyand Procedures (Version )
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information thatmight be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce thepossibility for delays in the development process andincrease the likelihood that the draft publication will beapproved for publication Please notify the Chair as early aspossible in written or electronic form of any patents (grantedor under application) that may cover technology that is underconsideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 TheChair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 websiterdquo
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresThe Chair once formally notified and once apotentially relevant draft standard exists shallwrite to the identified party and request that aLetter of Assurance be filed with the Chair forforwarding to the IEEE-SA Patent Committee inaccordance with the instructions in the IEEE-SAStandards Board Operations Manual A samplerequest letter and response letter are availableWhen the Patent Committee has accepted theletter as a Letter of Assurance informationregarding the letter will be indexed in the Recordsof IEEE Standards-Related Patents
Approval of Minutes
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to
ndash approve Document IEEE 80216-0017(Minutes of Session 8)
TG1 (802161)bull Air Interface for Fixed Broadband
Wireless Access Systemsbull 10-66 GHz
bull Chair Roger Marksbull Editor Jim MollenauerBrian Petrybull MAC Chair Carl Eklundbull PHY Chair Jay Klein
TG1 Goals for Week
ndashStay on Development PlanbullInitiative Working Group Letter BallotbullSeek approval at Closing Plenary
ndashMACbullComment resolutionbullMeet with TG3
ndashPHYbullComment resolutionbullOther contributionsbullMeet with TG2
TG2 (802162)ndashCoexistence of Broadband Wireless
Access Systems
ndashCo-Chair Andy McGregorndashCo-Chair Leland LangstonndashVice Chair Reacutemi Chayer
ndashEditor Vito Scaringindash Secretary Reza Arefi
TG3 (802163)bull Broadband Wireless Access Systems
in Licensed Bands from 2 to 11 GHzbull Chair Brian Kiernanbull Vice Chair Carl Bushuebull Secretary Dean Changbull Functional Requirements
ndashBrian PetryndashGeorge Fishel
WirelessHUMANTM Study Group
bull Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed MetropolitanArea Networks
bull Chair Durga Satapathybull Secretary Sanjay Moghe
bull Chartered at Session 6bull Renewed at Session 8bull Writing a PAR
bull To coordinate with 80211 and 80215
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
15
Charge to Task Groupsbull Complete the task on your agenda
ndashUpdate agenda on bulletin board
bull Prepare for next meetingndashCall for Contributions etc
bull Prepare for Closing Plenary
ndashAll motions to be in writingbull Document everything
ndash submit documents before you leavendash provide document index on bulletin board
bull Presentations to server 2 hours in advance
Voting in Task Groups
bull Only 80216 Voting Members may vote in taskGroup meetingsndashShow Voting Token
bull All present are eligible to vote at Study Groupmeetings
New Business
bull Request for New Business items
Adjournment
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to adjournthis meeting of Working Group 80216until the Midweek Plenaryndash(5-6 pm on Wednesday 13 September)
TG2 Status Report
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 1
IEEE 802162 Activities
Recommended Practice forCoexistence of BroadbandWireless Access Systems
Co-chairs Leland Langston Andy McGregor
Vice Chair Remi ChayerEditor Vito Scaringi
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 2
Activities since San DiegoMeeting
bull R7 of draft Practice issued late July
bull Several input docs and comments receivedbull Teleconference held Sept 7th ndash 8 participants
ndashSignificant discussion on content
bull R8 of draft Practice available Sept 11th
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 3
Plans for Denver
bull Close issue of single vs multiple interferers
bull Review doc for consistency amp completenessbull Present summary to joint TG1TG2bull Post R9 in week of Sept 18th
bull Seeking comments from any 80216 participant
bull TARGET TG ballot following Tampa meeting
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
16
Appendix B Midweek Plenary Presentations
Midweek Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Midweek Plenary Meeting AgendaWednesday 13 September 2000 1700-1800
Opening of Midweek Plenary Meeting 1700Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Midweek Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule Update Marks V
Announcements 1705
Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IAttendance books badges etc Marin I
802161 1710
Report Marks I802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1720Report McGregor I
802163 1730
Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1740
Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1745
Liaison 1750
ITU Costa ETSI BRAN Klein
Closing 1755
New Business (Marin Editorial Process) Marks VAdjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
17
Agenda for the Week as revised at the Midweek Plenary
80216 Session 9 Agenda Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMon
RAWCONKeynoteAddress
Ballroom A-D
120-150 pm(80216
RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCONLunch
1230-130pm
(80216Registrants
Invited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon G
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon H
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG16-730 pmSalon E
TG3Salon E
8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
TG3730-10 pm
Salon E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
18
Appendix C Closing Plenary Presentations
Closing Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Closing Plenary Meeting AgendaFriday 15 September 2000 10 am -1200 noon
Opening 1000Call to Order Marks IAgenda Marks V
Announcements 1003Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IVice Chair Marks I80216 Logo Marks D
WirelessHUMAN 1010Report Satapathy IPAR Approval Satapathy V
802161 1025Report Marks I802161 Working Group Review Marks V
802162 1050Report McGregor IFinal Task Group Review McGregor IMotions McGregor V
802163 1110Report Kiernan IMotions Kiernan V
Future Meetings 1130
Session 10 6-10 November 2000 Hyatt Regency Tampa Tampa Florida USA Marks ISunday Monday Friday at Session 10 Marks DSession 11 22-26 January 2001 Tel Aviv Israel Marks ISession 12 12-15 March 2001 Hyatt Regency Hilton Head South Carolina USA Marks ISession 13 7-11 May 2001 Orlando Florida USA along with IEEE 80211 and 80215 Marks I
Liaison 1135
ETSI BRANnotification of 802161 status and offer of password Marks V
Regulatory Agency notifications Robinson V
New Business 114080216 Editorial Policy MarinPetry V
Closing 1200
Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
19
WirelessHUMANtrade Closing Presentation[Insert Document Title Here]
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
[The appropriate coordinator normally the Task Group Chair will fill in this number after obtaining it from the 80216 Chair The
document number will match that of the base contribution with ldquoprdquo replacing ldquocrdquo For example 802161p-00nn]Date Submitted
[2000-07-13]Source
[Durga Satapathy] [Voice(913) 534-6338] [Sprint] [Fax (913) 534-6522] [7101 College Blvd Suite 1436 B] mailto[durgasatapathymailsprintcom [Overland Park KS 66210]
Venue
[IEEE 80216 Session 8]Base Document
[If this presentation illustrates an 80216 document cite the document number and URL lthttpieee802org16hellipgt]Purpose
[WirelessHUMAN Study Group report at closing plenary]Notice
This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s)The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw materialcontained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creation of anIEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution and at theIEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor also acknowledges and acceptsthat this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including the statementldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developingcommittee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purpose ofimplementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chair ltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt asearly as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology that is under consideration by or has beenapproved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentslettersgt
IEEE 80216 Plenary Report
Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed Metropolitan Area Network
(WirelessHUMANTM) Study Group
Durga P Satapathy
WirelessHUMANTM Update
bull Reviewed 8 contributions
bull Achieved consensus on selecting standardsto utilizemodifyndashMAC 80216ndashPHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
bull Drafted PAR and 5 criteria
WirelessHUMANTM PAR Scope This standard specifies the physical layer and media access control
layer of the air interface of interoperable fixed broadband wirelessmetropolitan area network systems including point-to-multipoint Thestandard enables access to data video and voice services with qualityof service in unlicensed bands designated for public network access Itwill focus on the 5-6 GHz range and may be applied to unlicensedbands between 2 and 11 GHz The WirelessHUMAN standard willutilize or modify applicable elements from the following
MAC 80216
PHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
The development of the WirelessHUMAN standard will follow thetimeline as shown in Appendix A
WirelessHUMANTM Timeline
bull Call For Proposals for WirelessHUMAN PHYMAC Nov 2000)ndash PHY Modifications of 80211a HIPERLAN2ndash MAC Modifications of 80216
bull Review proposals Jan 2001
bull Select candidate proposals at Interim meeting Feb 2001bull Decision on specific modifications March 2001
bull First Draft Standard May 2001
bull Comment Resolutions July 2001
bull Second Draft Standard Sep 2001bull Finalize WirelessHUMAN Standard Nov 2001
Purpose of Proposed Project
To enable rapid worldwide deployment of innovative cost-effectiveand interoperable multi-vendor broadband wireless metropolitan areanetwork products operating in the unlicensed bands To facilitatecompetition in broadband access by providing fixed wirelessalternatives to wireline broadband access Identify techniques totolerate interference in the unlicensed bands facilitate strategies forcoexistence with other unlicensed band systems such as 80211a andmaximize the carrying capacity of the unlicensed bands Encourageconsistent worldwide allocation and accelerate the commercializationof unlicensed broadband wireless access spectrum Utilization ofunlicensed frequencies will address a market that includes residencesSmall Office-Home Office (SOHO) telecommuters and Small andMedium Enterprises (SME)
WirelessHUMAN Study Group Participants
Sprint RF Solutions Agilent Technologies
Intel Breezecom Adaptive BroadbandNokia Transcomm Inc Cabletron
Ericsson BNA Systems WirelessHomeLucent Escape Carleton UniversityIntracom Malibu Networks Carnegie Mellon UniversityProxim Ultracom Georgia Institute of TechnologyWaveIP Harris Corporation HRL Laboratories LLCN Band Com Wireless Inc Western MultiplexCoreon Inc Cabletron systems Communications Research Center
Runcom Magnolia Broadband Yokogawa Electric CoInnowave ECI
Motion
The proposed WirelessHUMANTM PARbe accepted
TG1 MAC ClosingPresentation
(TG1 MAC reportppt)
1 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
TG1 MAC group
bull Resolved comments received during Final TaskGroup review
bull Major effort to remove any particular PHYdependence from the MAC
bull Process of adding features useful for TG3requirments started
bull Meeting with TG3
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
20
2 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
Important MAC decisions
bull Adoption of EUI-48 addresses (previouslyEUI-64)
bull Addition of error control to MAC layer(previously defined in TC layer of PHY B)
bull Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes into asingle mode
bull Redesigned DL MAP message for higherspectral efficiency
TG1 PHY ClosingPresentation
Document Number80216pp-
TitlePHY TG1 Report at Session 9
Date Submitted
91500Source
Jay KleinVenue
Denver September 2000Base Document
None
PurposeReport
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist the IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the
contributing individual(s) or organization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after furtherstudy The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by 80216
IEEE Patent Policy
The contributor is familiar with the IEEE Patent Policy which is set forth in the IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylawslthttpstandards ieeeorgguidesbylawsgt and includes the statement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s)
including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developing committee and provided theIEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standardrdquo
PHY TG1 Report Session 9
Jay KleinEnsemble Communications
Documents Submitted
bull 802161pc-0044 (2000-09-07) Recommendation onLMDS Radio Propagation Channel Models
bull 802161c-0007 (2000-09-10)FEC Parameterization for Data Transport (Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0006 (2000-09-08)FEC Parameterization for Control Channel Information(Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0004 (2000-09-01)Frequency Synthesizer Model Parameters (Lars Lindh andHans Somerma)
Documents Submitted ndash cont
bull 802161c-0003 (2000-09-01)Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes in802161 (Ken Stanwood)
bull 802161c-0001 (2000-08-08)Summary of Open PHY Issues in IEEE 802161-0001 (Jeff Foerster)
Work done
bull All editorial comments resolved
bull All technical comments reviewed andresolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull TBDs resolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull Met with MAC group for ldquosynchronizingrdquo
TG3 Closing Presentation
802163 Task Group Reportbull Finished and Adopted Functional
Requirements Document except for editorialsndashOutput Comment database on server
bull Developed an initial List of EvaluationCriteria for PHY proposal evaluations FullCriteria to be developed at next meeting
bull Issuing two calls for contributionsndashPreliminary PHY proposalsndashDeployment Traffic and Propagation
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS
bull Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull Session 10 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband WirelessAccess will be held on 6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA In orderto assist in the evaluation of air interface proposals the 802163 Task Groupinvites contributions addressing the following issues
lang Traffic and deployment models based on single and multi-cellsystems
lang Channel propagation model
bull Contributions must be submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt Submissions will beconsidered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible followingreceipt for public access on the 80216 Web Site Email your contribution tothe 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernanltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 Chair Roger Marksltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS - Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull The Task Group 3 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access is preparing to define the PHY protocols for abroadband wireless access air interface specification for frequencies from 2 through 11 GHz The specification will be based on submittedcontributions with increasing detail required as the process progresses Mergers and improvements will be encouraged with final selectionscheduled for June 2001
bull The TG3 Task Group invites the submission of initial contributions representing proposed PHY solutions Contributors will be grantedagenda time during 80216 Working Group Session 10 (6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA) to present and discuss the merits oftheir proposals Only submissions to session 10 will be eligible for invitation to submit more detailed proposals to session 11 Eachproposal will be allocated equal agenda time on Tuesday November 7 If time permits the allocations will be 15 minutes of presentationfollowed by 15 minutes of discussion Submissions must follow the guidelines below
lang Include a descriptive titlelang Include an overview and a reference model that describes functions including interfaces to other layerslang Describe the benefits of the proposed PHY including any unique featureslang Describe any drawbacks of the proposed PHY
bull Explain how the submitted PHY relates to existing standards such as ITU-R JRG 8A-9B IEEE 80211 DOCSIS 11 ETSI HiperLAN orothers If it is based on an existing standard what differences occur due to BWA characteristics
lang Emphasize the scalability of the proposed PHY to deal efficiently with various data types as described in the 802163Functional Requirements Document
lang Include a statement on intellectual property rights and how 80216 may utilize the proposed PHY in a standard
bull The proposals will be evaluated based on criteria in the Evaluation Table below However at this initial stage contributions are not expectedto address in detail the discussion items in that table instead aiming for the more general description as outlined above Each of the VotingMembers of 80216 are eligible to participate in the evaluation if present Submitters receiving a combined score of 6 or better (out of 10) inany criterion in the Evaluation Table will be invited to submit more a detailed contribution for Session 11 (January 22-26 2001 in Tel AvivIsrael) Note that submissions need not represent a complete PHY but may focus on specific components
bull Contributions will be considered only if submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216 Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt The template requires a cover page and a narrative
bull Submissions will be considered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible following receipt for public access on the 80216Web Site lthttpieee802org16gt
bull Email your contribution to the 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernan ltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 ChairRoger Marks ltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
802163 Task Group Report
bull Officially Adopted TG1 MAC as TG3 DraftMAC
bull Create TG3 MAC Ad Hoc to review TG1MAC and provide TG3 Comments
bull Two Motions for the Working GroupndashLiaison to ETSI BRAN sub11 GHz WGndashEstablishment of 80216 Common MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
21
Motion 1
That the 80216 Working Group appoint ChetShirali as a liaison to the ETSI BRAN sub11GHz Working Group
Motion 2
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MACbullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
22
Appendix D Attendance at Session9Session9 was an interim session The 75 interval attendance criteria for Session 9 was 6 ormore intervals Please contact the 80216 Secretary (smarinixnetcomcom) if you feel yourattendance has been recorded incorrectly
The following 126 peopleregistered attendance at 6or more intervals and metthe attendance criteria
Aboukarr BakriAn SongArefi RezaArunachalam ArunAvera DraytAvivi EliAyyagari DeepakBaragar IanBaseghi BehshadBaugh CR (Rick)Belfiore CarlosBenyamin-Seeyar AnaderBushue CarlBuskila BaruchChan RebeccaChang DeanChayer ReacutemiCondie MaryCornelius JamesCosta JoseacuteCrilly Jr William JDoherty EdwardEdmonston BrainEidson BrianEklund CarlEl-Damhougy HeshamFishel GeorgeFoerster JeffreyGarrison G JackGesbert DavidGoldhammer MariannaGuillemette PhilGupta RakeshHadad ZionHall EricHamilton MichaelHammons RogerHatim BayaHebron YoanHilberman DanHosur SrinathHsuan YiHudson ThomasHum ColemanHunter WayneJacobsen EricJamali Hamadi
Jorgensen JacobKang InchulKasslin MikaKiernan BrianKim JohnKitroser ItzikKlein JayKolze ThomasKostas DemosKwak Byung-JaeKwak JoeLangley John BLangston J LelandLeiba YigalLewis BarryLicardie SergioLiebetreu JohnLindh LarsLo TitusMarin ScottMarks RogerMcCallister RonMcGregor AndyMcMullin RoderickMeyer RonaldMiddleton AndrewMizoguchi MasatoMody ApurvaMollenauer JamesPadan UziPetry BrianPleasant WayneRalston WilliamRan MosheResheff GuyRhodes ValentineRobinson GeneRoehr WaltRzeszewski TedSantacesaria ClaudioSatapathy DurgaSater GlenScaringi VitoScarpa CarlSchwartz RandallSegal YossiSellars MalcolmShan Tie-JunShimada ShusakuShirali ChetSkaar HelgeSmith SteveStamatelos George
Stambaugh KarlStanwood KenStewart MichaelStruhsaker PaulSydor JohnTappenden ChrisTateishi KimiyaTavormina JoeThomas RaymondThompson PaulTrinkwon DavidVan Waes NicoVarma SubirWachira MuyaWang ArthurWang Chao-ChunWang LeiWang XiaofengWard BobWhitehead PhilipWhiting RobertWilliams David GWise CurtWiss JohnYanover VladimirZuniga Juan Carlos
The following 18 peopleregistered attendance atless than 6 intervals anddid not meet theattendance criteria
Alspaugh MatthewCarlo JimFalconer DavidFoley MarkFoster RobertGupta AlokHancock DaleHarel HaimKhanna AmarpalKreig AndrewMonk AntonNadeau JamesOng Ling ChuenRafie ManouchehrRibner David BWheatley Chuck FYang S MichaelYurtkuran Erol
Motion 5
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MAC based on802161-0001r4bullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
Appendix E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
7
was placed on removing the PHY dependencies from the MAC Eklund noted that a joint meetingwas held with TG3 in which many misunderstandings were discussed
Regarding the TG1 PHY John Liebetreu presented a summary (See Appendix C)
Motion4 John Liebetreu 2nd not needed to initiate a Working Group Review of the IEEE802161 working document number 802161-0001r4 (to be constructed by incorporating theresolved comments listed in document number 802161-0009 into 802161-0001r3) Thereview is set to begin September 29 and to end October 30 2000 See call for comments 802161-0005
By voice vote all for Motion4 passes
Marks reviewed the additional call for contributions on 802161rsquos open technical issues noting adue date of 30 October 2000 and that convergence layer text for IP Ethernet and ATM will besubmitted by Carl Eklund Glen Sater and Ken Stanwood respectively
Regarding TG2 Andy McCregor presented the meeting minutes (IEEE 802162c-0022) and notedfour recommendations from the meeting 1) to use a more formal call for comments 2) to invitecomments from other organizations such as WCA NSMA RABC and ARIB 3) to formally askfor comments from the Broadband Wireless Association of the UK and 4) to put the next draft ofthe coexistence practice on the public side of the IEEE 80216 web site
Marks asked TG2 to remove the copyright notice from their working document and not call thedocument a draft until a later stage in the process
Regarding TG3 Brian Kiernan reported (see Appendix C) adoption of the TG3 functionalrequirements document development of evaluation criteria and development of a call forcontributions In addition TG3 adopted the TG1 MAC and formed the TG3 MAC Ad Hoccommittee to review the TG1 MAC
Motion5 Brian Kiernan 2nd not needed Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bull Establish a common 80216 MAC based on 802161-0001r4
bull Require each 80216 task group to define its mandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMAC
bull Shall ensure backward compatibility and maintenance of the common MAC and
bull Shall strive to ensure forward compatibility of the common MAC
By token vote 24 for 0 against 1 abstain Motion5 passes See Appendix E
Marks acknowledged several organizational issues that must be worked Marks will try to resolveas many issues as possible by the November meeting
Regarding upcoming meetings Marks noted that the next meeting (Session 10) will be in TampaFlorida and that the opportunity exists to extend the Task Group meetings to Friday morning orMonday morning Marks also noted the possibility of joint meetings with other 802 workinggroups
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
8
Marks noted that Session 11 is scheduled for 22 to 26 January 2001 in Tel Aviv Israel hosted byBreezeCOM
Marks noted that Session 13 (May 7-11 2000) will be a joint meeting with 80211 and 80215 andpossibly ETSI BRAN Marks noted his desire to hold interim meetings together with other 802groups
Marks asked for a straw pole as to those in favor of meeting Sundays none for and about 20against
Regarding Liaison Marks noted that ETSI BRAN recommended that Demos Kostas act as contactin both directions Marks plans to reply using Demos Kostas in both directions
Marks noted that as of this week 80216 members and observers now have access to a mirror ofall ETSI BRAN documents Marks will send out information to members and observers on how toaccess the documents
Regarding liaison with ETSI BRAN Marks showed a draft liaison letter (80216l-00_28doc)
Motion6 Marks 2nd Brian Petry to approve draft letter presented by Marks (document IEEE80216l-0028)
Motion7 Brian Petry Brian Kiernan to amend motion6 by replacing we appoint Dr Kostas asour informal contact person for the information exchange with for a contact person wethereby appointing no contact person
Motion7 by voice vote all for Motion7 passes
Motion6 by voice vote several for one opposed Motion6 passes
Scott Marin 80216 secretary had to leave the meeting and George Fishel took over as secretary
Andy McGregor presented a draft liaison letter by TG2 David Trinkwon proposed an amendmentto letter The letter as amended was approved by voice vote
Gene Robinson from the regulatory affairs committee presented three draft letters to regulatorybodies of the US Canada and the UK The letters were edited by Marks The letters wereapproved by unanimous voice vote
Brian Petry indicated that a document containing a draft editorial policy and procedures is on theserver Brian Petry said that anyone wishing to be an editor should read the document Thechairman requested that members give information to Brian on the editorial process
At 1228 Marks adjourned Session9
4 AcknowledgementsThe 80216 secretary would like to thank the sub-group chairs (Carl Eklund Jay Klein AndyMcGregor Brian Kiernan and Durga Satapathy) and the people who took care of the attendancebooks for each group (Juan Zuniga Carl Bushue and Drayt Avera) The multiple attendance bookapproach seemed to work well due mainly to the help of the above people
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
9
Respectfully
Scott Marin
80216 Secretary
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
10
Appendix A Opening Plenary Presentations
Opening Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Opening Plenary Meeting AgendaMonday 11 September 2000 1400-1515
See Opening Plenary presentation slidesOpening of Session 9 and of Opening Plenary Meeting 1400Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Opening Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule of meetings for the week Marks V
Membership and Voting 1410Rights of members observers and others Marks IAttendance list procedure Marin IVoting token procedure Marin I
Announcements 1415Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks ILogistics rooms breaks etc Marks IIndividual and Anti-Trust Marks IIEEE 80216 Patent Policies and Procedures Marks I
Approvals 1425Minutes of Session 8 (IEEE 80216-0017) Marks V
802161 1430Report Marks IEditing Mollenauer Petry 802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1440Report McGregor I
802163 1450Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1500Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1510Voting in Task Groups and Study Groups Marks I
New Business 1513
Closing 1515Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
11
Agenda for the Week
80216 Session 9 AgendaSchedule (tentative)
Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMo
n
RAWCONKeynote Address
Ballroom A-D120-150 pm
(80216 RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster
Session530-700 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCON Lunch1230-130 pm
(80216 RegistrantsInvited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster
Session530-700 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon 5
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG3Salon GH8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
12
Chairmans Opening Plenary Presentation
IEEE 80216 Session 9 Opening Plenary Meeting
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
NoneDate Submitted
2000-09-11Source
Roger Marks Voice +1-303-497-3037NIST Fax +1-303-497-7828325 Broadway MC 81300 E-mail marksnistgovBoulder CO 80303
VenueSession 9 Opening Plenary
Base DocumentNone
PurposeThis presentation is to be inserted in the Session 9 minutes
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) ororganization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to addamend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creationof an IEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contributionand at the IEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor alsoacknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16 iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including thestatement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms andconditions for the purpose of implementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chairltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt as early as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentsnoticesgt
IEEE 80216Working Group on
Broadband Wireless Access(BWA)
Session 9Opening Plenary
11 September 2000
200-315 pm
Session Opening
bull Call to Order
bull Welcome
80216 Officers
bull Chair Roger Marks
bull Vice Chair Lou Olsen
bull Secretary Scott Marin
Agenda
bull Presentation of 80216 OpeningPlenary Agendandash Chair asks for unanimous consent to
approve
bull Schedule of meetings for the weekndash Chair asks for unanimous consent to
approve
Rights of Allbull To subscribe to the 80216 Email Reflector
(stds-802-16) and thereby be notified ofdocument publication meetings minutes
bull To post to stds-802-16 in accordance with thereflector rules
bull To examine documents unless copyrightconcerns prohibit it
bull To contribute documents in response to aCall for Contributions
bull To attend and participate in 80216 meetingsif registered
bull To join the Sponsor Balloting Pool
IEEE and IEEE SA Membership
bull Members are encouraged to join IEEEIEEE Standards Association and IEEEComputer Society
bull Such membership is not required forWorking Group Membership ObserverStatus or Sponsor Ballot PoolGroup
Sponsor Ballot PoolGroup
bull Balloting Pool is being constructed
bull Future 80216 draft standards will beballoted by a Balloting Group drawn frommembers of the 80216 Balloting Pool
bull To join the 80216 Balloting Pool use theform on the web
bull Members of IEEE Standards Association[IEEE or CS + $10] can participate in BallotGroup without paying special fee
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
13
Rights of Members amp Observers
bull To examine draft standardsbull To participate in Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To examine the votes of Working
Group membersbull To examine the Member and Observer
contact databases
Exclusive Rights of Membershipbull To make or second a motion at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote if and only if present at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote in 80216 Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To vote by email on any issue involving
80216 or its subsidiariesbull To lodge complaints about Working Group
operation with the 802 Executive Committeebull To petition the 802 Executive Committee in
writing
Attendance Listbull Recorded at each ldquomeeting intervalrdquo
ndashAfternoon MonTueWedThundashMorning TueWedThuFri
ndashEvening Thu
ndashSelf-declared ldquosubstantially allrdquo of meetingndashSession ldquoParticipationrdquo 75 of meeting intervals
bull =will round down to 6
bull Attendance recorded in parallel meetingsndashvoting credit for presence at either
bull Attendance is public recordndashattendance will be reported on webndashcontact info will not be posted (just company)
Secretaryrsquos Announcementsbull Scott Marin
ndash Attendance books (four of them)
bull Write your namebull If new and unregistered insert business
card in pocketbull Initial and keep the book movingbull Remember your book and page number
ndash Voting tokensbull Printed on badge for Membersbull Raise to vote
Registration
bull $140
bull Registration fee form at front deskndashHotel guest charge to roomndashOthers credit card
bull Receive copy of form as receipt
Document Distributionbull Server http10001bull Run DHCPbull Use 10BaseT or 100BaseTXbull Use 80211b or 80211 DSSS Wireless
bull Upload files using anonymous ftp
bull Flash Card may be available
Logistics
bull Meeting Roomsndash Vary throughout the week
bull Breaksndash Always in large room (E or D)
bull RAWCON events
Individuality
bull In IEEE standards meetingsparticipation is by individualndash you do not represent a company or
organization
bull Membership belongs to the individualnot an organization and may not betransferred
Legal and Anti-Trust
bull Any discussions that relate to thevalidity or cost of patent use shall beavoided
bull Any discussions or any materialrelating to an ongoing litigation shallbe avoided
bull Any discussions of pricing or issuesthat would violate US antitrust lawsshall be avoided
IEEE 80216 Patent Policybull IEEE 80216 operates under the Patent Policy of
the IEEE Standards Association as set forth inClause 6 of the IEEE-SA Standards BoardBylaws This policy includes the statement
bull IEEE standards may include the known use ofpatent(s) including patent applications if there istechnical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and providedthe IEEE receives assurance from the patentholder that it will license applicants underreasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standard
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
14
IEEE 80216 Patent Policy (cont)bull IEEE 80216 interprets in the opinion of the standards-
developing committee as in the opinion of the members of theWorking Group Early disclosure to the Working Groupparticipants of patent information that might be relevant to thestandard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and to increase the likelihood that the draftpublication will be approved for publication IEEE 80216 strivesto make such information available as soon as possible forconsideration by individual members in their voting decisionsHowever in its meetings and electronic forums IEEE 80216does not permit discussions concerning the validity orapplicability of intellectual property claims The only role a patentclaim plays in Working Group discussions concerns ensuringcompliance to the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures
bull Justification for the inclusion of technology is limited to thetechnical merits of the technology
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresAnyone whether participating in IEEE 80216 or notshould notify the Chair of any patents (granted orunder application and regardless of the assignee orthe patent nationality) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved byIEEE 80216 Such notification should be in written orelectronic form (email is preferred) and need notmake any statement concerning enforcement orlicensing The Chair will presume that suchnotification is intended for public release and will assoon as practical post it to the web along with otherPatent Notices On File with IEEE 80216 The Chairand the Working Group will take no positionregarding the validity or applicability of any patents
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresWritten contributions to IEEE 80216 standards development willnot be accepted without an acknowledgement of familiarity with theIEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures Thisacknowledgement will be part of the mandatory contribution coversheet and will read
ldquoThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policyand Procedures (Version )
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information thatmight be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce thepossibility for delays in the development process andincrease the likelihood that the draft publication will beapproved for publication Please notify the Chair as early aspossible in written or electronic form of any patents (grantedor under application) that may cover technology that is underconsideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 TheChair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 websiterdquo
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresThe Chair once formally notified and once apotentially relevant draft standard exists shallwrite to the identified party and request that aLetter of Assurance be filed with the Chair forforwarding to the IEEE-SA Patent Committee inaccordance with the instructions in the IEEE-SAStandards Board Operations Manual A samplerequest letter and response letter are availableWhen the Patent Committee has accepted theletter as a Letter of Assurance informationregarding the letter will be indexed in the Recordsof IEEE Standards-Related Patents
Approval of Minutes
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to
ndash approve Document IEEE 80216-0017(Minutes of Session 8)
TG1 (802161)bull Air Interface for Fixed Broadband
Wireless Access Systemsbull 10-66 GHz
bull Chair Roger Marksbull Editor Jim MollenauerBrian Petrybull MAC Chair Carl Eklundbull PHY Chair Jay Klein
TG1 Goals for Week
ndashStay on Development PlanbullInitiative Working Group Letter BallotbullSeek approval at Closing Plenary
ndashMACbullComment resolutionbullMeet with TG3
ndashPHYbullComment resolutionbullOther contributionsbullMeet with TG2
TG2 (802162)ndashCoexistence of Broadband Wireless
Access Systems
ndashCo-Chair Andy McGregorndashCo-Chair Leland LangstonndashVice Chair Reacutemi Chayer
ndashEditor Vito Scaringindash Secretary Reza Arefi
TG3 (802163)bull Broadband Wireless Access Systems
in Licensed Bands from 2 to 11 GHzbull Chair Brian Kiernanbull Vice Chair Carl Bushuebull Secretary Dean Changbull Functional Requirements
ndashBrian PetryndashGeorge Fishel
WirelessHUMANTM Study Group
bull Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed MetropolitanArea Networks
bull Chair Durga Satapathybull Secretary Sanjay Moghe
bull Chartered at Session 6bull Renewed at Session 8bull Writing a PAR
bull To coordinate with 80211 and 80215
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
15
Charge to Task Groupsbull Complete the task on your agenda
ndashUpdate agenda on bulletin board
bull Prepare for next meetingndashCall for Contributions etc
bull Prepare for Closing Plenary
ndashAll motions to be in writingbull Document everything
ndash submit documents before you leavendash provide document index on bulletin board
bull Presentations to server 2 hours in advance
Voting in Task Groups
bull Only 80216 Voting Members may vote in taskGroup meetingsndashShow Voting Token
bull All present are eligible to vote at Study Groupmeetings
New Business
bull Request for New Business items
Adjournment
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to adjournthis meeting of Working Group 80216until the Midweek Plenaryndash(5-6 pm on Wednesday 13 September)
TG2 Status Report
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 1
IEEE 802162 Activities
Recommended Practice forCoexistence of BroadbandWireless Access Systems
Co-chairs Leland Langston Andy McGregor
Vice Chair Remi ChayerEditor Vito Scaringi
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 2
Activities since San DiegoMeeting
bull R7 of draft Practice issued late July
bull Several input docs and comments receivedbull Teleconference held Sept 7th ndash 8 participants
ndashSignificant discussion on content
bull R8 of draft Practice available Sept 11th
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 3
Plans for Denver
bull Close issue of single vs multiple interferers
bull Review doc for consistency amp completenessbull Present summary to joint TG1TG2bull Post R9 in week of Sept 18th
bull Seeking comments from any 80216 participant
bull TARGET TG ballot following Tampa meeting
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
16
Appendix B Midweek Plenary Presentations
Midweek Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Midweek Plenary Meeting AgendaWednesday 13 September 2000 1700-1800
Opening of Midweek Plenary Meeting 1700Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Midweek Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule Update Marks V
Announcements 1705
Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IAttendance books badges etc Marin I
802161 1710
Report Marks I802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1720Report McGregor I
802163 1730
Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1740
Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1745
Liaison 1750
ITU Costa ETSI BRAN Klein
Closing 1755
New Business (Marin Editorial Process) Marks VAdjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
17
Agenda for the Week as revised at the Midweek Plenary
80216 Session 9 Agenda Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMon
RAWCONKeynoteAddress
Ballroom A-D
120-150 pm(80216
RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCONLunch
1230-130pm
(80216Registrants
Invited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon G
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon H
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG16-730 pmSalon E
TG3Salon E
8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
TG3730-10 pm
Salon E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
18
Appendix C Closing Plenary Presentations
Closing Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Closing Plenary Meeting AgendaFriday 15 September 2000 10 am -1200 noon
Opening 1000Call to Order Marks IAgenda Marks V
Announcements 1003Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IVice Chair Marks I80216 Logo Marks D
WirelessHUMAN 1010Report Satapathy IPAR Approval Satapathy V
802161 1025Report Marks I802161 Working Group Review Marks V
802162 1050Report McGregor IFinal Task Group Review McGregor IMotions McGregor V
802163 1110Report Kiernan IMotions Kiernan V
Future Meetings 1130
Session 10 6-10 November 2000 Hyatt Regency Tampa Tampa Florida USA Marks ISunday Monday Friday at Session 10 Marks DSession 11 22-26 January 2001 Tel Aviv Israel Marks ISession 12 12-15 March 2001 Hyatt Regency Hilton Head South Carolina USA Marks ISession 13 7-11 May 2001 Orlando Florida USA along with IEEE 80211 and 80215 Marks I
Liaison 1135
ETSI BRANnotification of 802161 status and offer of password Marks V
Regulatory Agency notifications Robinson V
New Business 114080216 Editorial Policy MarinPetry V
Closing 1200
Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
19
WirelessHUMANtrade Closing Presentation[Insert Document Title Here]
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
[The appropriate coordinator normally the Task Group Chair will fill in this number after obtaining it from the 80216 Chair The
document number will match that of the base contribution with ldquoprdquo replacing ldquocrdquo For example 802161p-00nn]Date Submitted
[2000-07-13]Source
[Durga Satapathy] [Voice(913) 534-6338] [Sprint] [Fax (913) 534-6522] [7101 College Blvd Suite 1436 B] mailto[durgasatapathymailsprintcom [Overland Park KS 66210]
Venue
[IEEE 80216 Session 8]Base Document
[If this presentation illustrates an 80216 document cite the document number and URL lthttpieee802org16hellipgt]Purpose
[WirelessHUMAN Study Group report at closing plenary]Notice
This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s)The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw materialcontained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creation of anIEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution and at theIEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor also acknowledges and acceptsthat this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including the statementldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developingcommittee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purpose ofimplementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chair ltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt asearly as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology that is under consideration by or has beenapproved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentslettersgt
IEEE 80216 Plenary Report
Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed Metropolitan Area Network
(WirelessHUMANTM) Study Group
Durga P Satapathy
WirelessHUMANTM Update
bull Reviewed 8 contributions
bull Achieved consensus on selecting standardsto utilizemodifyndashMAC 80216ndashPHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
bull Drafted PAR and 5 criteria
WirelessHUMANTM PAR Scope This standard specifies the physical layer and media access control
layer of the air interface of interoperable fixed broadband wirelessmetropolitan area network systems including point-to-multipoint Thestandard enables access to data video and voice services with qualityof service in unlicensed bands designated for public network access Itwill focus on the 5-6 GHz range and may be applied to unlicensedbands between 2 and 11 GHz The WirelessHUMAN standard willutilize or modify applicable elements from the following
MAC 80216
PHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
The development of the WirelessHUMAN standard will follow thetimeline as shown in Appendix A
WirelessHUMANTM Timeline
bull Call For Proposals for WirelessHUMAN PHYMAC Nov 2000)ndash PHY Modifications of 80211a HIPERLAN2ndash MAC Modifications of 80216
bull Review proposals Jan 2001
bull Select candidate proposals at Interim meeting Feb 2001bull Decision on specific modifications March 2001
bull First Draft Standard May 2001
bull Comment Resolutions July 2001
bull Second Draft Standard Sep 2001bull Finalize WirelessHUMAN Standard Nov 2001
Purpose of Proposed Project
To enable rapid worldwide deployment of innovative cost-effectiveand interoperable multi-vendor broadband wireless metropolitan areanetwork products operating in the unlicensed bands To facilitatecompetition in broadband access by providing fixed wirelessalternatives to wireline broadband access Identify techniques totolerate interference in the unlicensed bands facilitate strategies forcoexistence with other unlicensed band systems such as 80211a andmaximize the carrying capacity of the unlicensed bands Encourageconsistent worldwide allocation and accelerate the commercializationof unlicensed broadband wireless access spectrum Utilization ofunlicensed frequencies will address a market that includes residencesSmall Office-Home Office (SOHO) telecommuters and Small andMedium Enterprises (SME)
WirelessHUMAN Study Group Participants
Sprint RF Solutions Agilent Technologies
Intel Breezecom Adaptive BroadbandNokia Transcomm Inc Cabletron
Ericsson BNA Systems WirelessHomeLucent Escape Carleton UniversityIntracom Malibu Networks Carnegie Mellon UniversityProxim Ultracom Georgia Institute of TechnologyWaveIP Harris Corporation HRL Laboratories LLCN Band Com Wireless Inc Western MultiplexCoreon Inc Cabletron systems Communications Research Center
Runcom Magnolia Broadband Yokogawa Electric CoInnowave ECI
Motion
The proposed WirelessHUMANTM PARbe accepted
TG1 MAC ClosingPresentation
(TG1 MAC reportppt)
1 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
TG1 MAC group
bull Resolved comments received during Final TaskGroup review
bull Major effort to remove any particular PHYdependence from the MAC
bull Process of adding features useful for TG3requirments started
bull Meeting with TG3
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
20
2 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
Important MAC decisions
bull Adoption of EUI-48 addresses (previouslyEUI-64)
bull Addition of error control to MAC layer(previously defined in TC layer of PHY B)
bull Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes into asingle mode
bull Redesigned DL MAP message for higherspectral efficiency
TG1 PHY ClosingPresentation
Document Number80216pp-
TitlePHY TG1 Report at Session 9
Date Submitted
91500Source
Jay KleinVenue
Denver September 2000Base Document
None
PurposeReport
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist the IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the
contributing individual(s) or organization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after furtherstudy The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by 80216
IEEE Patent Policy
The contributor is familiar with the IEEE Patent Policy which is set forth in the IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylawslthttpstandards ieeeorgguidesbylawsgt and includes the statement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s)
including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developing committee and provided theIEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standardrdquo
PHY TG1 Report Session 9
Jay KleinEnsemble Communications
Documents Submitted
bull 802161pc-0044 (2000-09-07) Recommendation onLMDS Radio Propagation Channel Models
bull 802161c-0007 (2000-09-10)FEC Parameterization for Data Transport (Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0006 (2000-09-08)FEC Parameterization for Control Channel Information(Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0004 (2000-09-01)Frequency Synthesizer Model Parameters (Lars Lindh andHans Somerma)
Documents Submitted ndash cont
bull 802161c-0003 (2000-09-01)Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes in802161 (Ken Stanwood)
bull 802161c-0001 (2000-08-08)Summary of Open PHY Issues in IEEE 802161-0001 (Jeff Foerster)
Work done
bull All editorial comments resolved
bull All technical comments reviewed andresolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull TBDs resolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull Met with MAC group for ldquosynchronizingrdquo
TG3 Closing Presentation
802163 Task Group Reportbull Finished and Adopted Functional
Requirements Document except for editorialsndashOutput Comment database on server
bull Developed an initial List of EvaluationCriteria for PHY proposal evaluations FullCriteria to be developed at next meeting
bull Issuing two calls for contributionsndashPreliminary PHY proposalsndashDeployment Traffic and Propagation
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS
bull Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull Session 10 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband WirelessAccess will be held on 6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA In orderto assist in the evaluation of air interface proposals the 802163 Task Groupinvites contributions addressing the following issues
lang Traffic and deployment models based on single and multi-cellsystems
lang Channel propagation model
bull Contributions must be submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt Submissions will beconsidered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible followingreceipt for public access on the 80216 Web Site Email your contribution tothe 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernanltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 Chair Roger Marksltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS - Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull The Task Group 3 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access is preparing to define the PHY protocols for abroadband wireless access air interface specification for frequencies from 2 through 11 GHz The specification will be based on submittedcontributions with increasing detail required as the process progresses Mergers and improvements will be encouraged with final selectionscheduled for June 2001
bull The TG3 Task Group invites the submission of initial contributions representing proposed PHY solutions Contributors will be grantedagenda time during 80216 Working Group Session 10 (6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA) to present and discuss the merits oftheir proposals Only submissions to session 10 will be eligible for invitation to submit more detailed proposals to session 11 Eachproposal will be allocated equal agenda time on Tuesday November 7 If time permits the allocations will be 15 minutes of presentationfollowed by 15 minutes of discussion Submissions must follow the guidelines below
lang Include a descriptive titlelang Include an overview and a reference model that describes functions including interfaces to other layerslang Describe the benefits of the proposed PHY including any unique featureslang Describe any drawbacks of the proposed PHY
bull Explain how the submitted PHY relates to existing standards such as ITU-R JRG 8A-9B IEEE 80211 DOCSIS 11 ETSI HiperLAN orothers If it is based on an existing standard what differences occur due to BWA characteristics
lang Emphasize the scalability of the proposed PHY to deal efficiently with various data types as described in the 802163Functional Requirements Document
lang Include a statement on intellectual property rights and how 80216 may utilize the proposed PHY in a standard
bull The proposals will be evaluated based on criteria in the Evaluation Table below However at this initial stage contributions are not expectedto address in detail the discussion items in that table instead aiming for the more general description as outlined above Each of the VotingMembers of 80216 are eligible to participate in the evaluation if present Submitters receiving a combined score of 6 or better (out of 10) inany criterion in the Evaluation Table will be invited to submit more a detailed contribution for Session 11 (January 22-26 2001 in Tel AvivIsrael) Note that submissions need not represent a complete PHY but may focus on specific components
bull Contributions will be considered only if submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216 Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt The template requires a cover page and a narrative
bull Submissions will be considered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible following receipt for public access on the 80216Web Site lthttpieee802org16gt
bull Email your contribution to the 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernan ltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 ChairRoger Marks ltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
802163 Task Group Report
bull Officially Adopted TG1 MAC as TG3 DraftMAC
bull Create TG3 MAC Ad Hoc to review TG1MAC and provide TG3 Comments
bull Two Motions for the Working GroupndashLiaison to ETSI BRAN sub11 GHz WGndashEstablishment of 80216 Common MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
21
Motion 1
That the 80216 Working Group appoint ChetShirali as a liaison to the ETSI BRAN sub11GHz Working Group
Motion 2
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MACbullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
22
Appendix D Attendance at Session9Session9 was an interim session The 75 interval attendance criteria for Session 9 was 6 ormore intervals Please contact the 80216 Secretary (smarinixnetcomcom) if you feel yourattendance has been recorded incorrectly
The following 126 peopleregistered attendance at 6or more intervals and metthe attendance criteria
Aboukarr BakriAn SongArefi RezaArunachalam ArunAvera DraytAvivi EliAyyagari DeepakBaragar IanBaseghi BehshadBaugh CR (Rick)Belfiore CarlosBenyamin-Seeyar AnaderBushue CarlBuskila BaruchChan RebeccaChang DeanChayer ReacutemiCondie MaryCornelius JamesCosta JoseacuteCrilly Jr William JDoherty EdwardEdmonston BrainEidson BrianEklund CarlEl-Damhougy HeshamFishel GeorgeFoerster JeffreyGarrison G JackGesbert DavidGoldhammer MariannaGuillemette PhilGupta RakeshHadad ZionHall EricHamilton MichaelHammons RogerHatim BayaHebron YoanHilberman DanHosur SrinathHsuan YiHudson ThomasHum ColemanHunter WayneJacobsen EricJamali Hamadi
Jorgensen JacobKang InchulKasslin MikaKiernan BrianKim JohnKitroser ItzikKlein JayKolze ThomasKostas DemosKwak Byung-JaeKwak JoeLangley John BLangston J LelandLeiba YigalLewis BarryLicardie SergioLiebetreu JohnLindh LarsLo TitusMarin ScottMarks RogerMcCallister RonMcGregor AndyMcMullin RoderickMeyer RonaldMiddleton AndrewMizoguchi MasatoMody ApurvaMollenauer JamesPadan UziPetry BrianPleasant WayneRalston WilliamRan MosheResheff GuyRhodes ValentineRobinson GeneRoehr WaltRzeszewski TedSantacesaria ClaudioSatapathy DurgaSater GlenScaringi VitoScarpa CarlSchwartz RandallSegal YossiSellars MalcolmShan Tie-JunShimada ShusakuShirali ChetSkaar HelgeSmith SteveStamatelos George
Stambaugh KarlStanwood KenStewart MichaelStruhsaker PaulSydor JohnTappenden ChrisTateishi KimiyaTavormina JoeThomas RaymondThompson PaulTrinkwon DavidVan Waes NicoVarma SubirWachira MuyaWang ArthurWang Chao-ChunWang LeiWang XiaofengWard BobWhitehead PhilipWhiting RobertWilliams David GWise CurtWiss JohnYanover VladimirZuniga Juan Carlos
The following 18 peopleregistered attendance atless than 6 intervals anddid not meet theattendance criteria
Alspaugh MatthewCarlo JimFalconer DavidFoley MarkFoster RobertGupta AlokHancock DaleHarel HaimKhanna AmarpalKreig AndrewMonk AntonNadeau JamesOng Ling ChuenRafie ManouchehrRibner David BWheatley Chuck FYang S MichaelYurtkuran Erol
Motion 5
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MAC based on802161-0001r4bullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
Appendix E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
8
Marks noted that Session 11 is scheduled for 22 to 26 January 2001 in Tel Aviv Israel hosted byBreezeCOM
Marks noted that Session 13 (May 7-11 2000) will be a joint meeting with 80211 and 80215 andpossibly ETSI BRAN Marks noted his desire to hold interim meetings together with other 802groups
Marks asked for a straw pole as to those in favor of meeting Sundays none for and about 20against
Regarding Liaison Marks noted that ETSI BRAN recommended that Demos Kostas act as contactin both directions Marks plans to reply using Demos Kostas in both directions
Marks noted that as of this week 80216 members and observers now have access to a mirror ofall ETSI BRAN documents Marks will send out information to members and observers on how toaccess the documents
Regarding liaison with ETSI BRAN Marks showed a draft liaison letter (80216l-00_28doc)
Motion6 Marks 2nd Brian Petry to approve draft letter presented by Marks (document IEEE80216l-0028)
Motion7 Brian Petry Brian Kiernan to amend motion6 by replacing we appoint Dr Kostas asour informal contact person for the information exchange with for a contact person wethereby appointing no contact person
Motion7 by voice vote all for Motion7 passes
Motion6 by voice vote several for one opposed Motion6 passes
Scott Marin 80216 secretary had to leave the meeting and George Fishel took over as secretary
Andy McGregor presented a draft liaison letter by TG2 David Trinkwon proposed an amendmentto letter The letter as amended was approved by voice vote
Gene Robinson from the regulatory affairs committee presented three draft letters to regulatorybodies of the US Canada and the UK The letters were edited by Marks The letters wereapproved by unanimous voice vote
Brian Petry indicated that a document containing a draft editorial policy and procedures is on theserver Brian Petry said that anyone wishing to be an editor should read the document Thechairman requested that members give information to Brian on the editorial process
At 1228 Marks adjourned Session9
4 AcknowledgementsThe 80216 secretary would like to thank the sub-group chairs (Carl Eklund Jay Klein AndyMcGregor Brian Kiernan and Durga Satapathy) and the people who took care of the attendancebooks for each group (Juan Zuniga Carl Bushue and Drayt Avera) The multiple attendance bookapproach seemed to work well due mainly to the help of the above people
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
9
Respectfully
Scott Marin
80216 Secretary
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
10
Appendix A Opening Plenary Presentations
Opening Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Opening Plenary Meeting AgendaMonday 11 September 2000 1400-1515
See Opening Plenary presentation slidesOpening of Session 9 and of Opening Plenary Meeting 1400Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Opening Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule of meetings for the week Marks V
Membership and Voting 1410Rights of members observers and others Marks IAttendance list procedure Marin IVoting token procedure Marin I
Announcements 1415Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks ILogistics rooms breaks etc Marks IIndividual and Anti-Trust Marks IIEEE 80216 Patent Policies and Procedures Marks I
Approvals 1425Minutes of Session 8 (IEEE 80216-0017) Marks V
802161 1430Report Marks IEditing Mollenauer Petry 802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1440Report McGregor I
802163 1450Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1500Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1510Voting in Task Groups and Study Groups Marks I
New Business 1513
Closing 1515Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
11
Agenda for the Week
80216 Session 9 AgendaSchedule (tentative)
Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMo
n
RAWCONKeynote Address
Ballroom A-D120-150 pm
(80216 RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster
Session530-700 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCON Lunch1230-130 pm
(80216 RegistrantsInvited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster
Session530-700 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon 5
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG3Salon GH8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
12
Chairmans Opening Plenary Presentation
IEEE 80216 Session 9 Opening Plenary Meeting
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
NoneDate Submitted
2000-09-11Source
Roger Marks Voice +1-303-497-3037NIST Fax +1-303-497-7828325 Broadway MC 81300 E-mail marksnistgovBoulder CO 80303
VenueSession 9 Opening Plenary
Base DocumentNone
PurposeThis presentation is to be inserted in the Session 9 minutes
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) ororganization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to addamend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creationof an IEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contributionand at the IEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor alsoacknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16 iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including thestatement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms andconditions for the purpose of implementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chairltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt as early as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentsnoticesgt
IEEE 80216Working Group on
Broadband Wireless Access(BWA)
Session 9Opening Plenary
11 September 2000
200-315 pm
Session Opening
bull Call to Order
bull Welcome
80216 Officers
bull Chair Roger Marks
bull Vice Chair Lou Olsen
bull Secretary Scott Marin
Agenda
bull Presentation of 80216 OpeningPlenary Agendandash Chair asks for unanimous consent to
approve
bull Schedule of meetings for the weekndash Chair asks for unanimous consent to
approve
Rights of Allbull To subscribe to the 80216 Email Reflector
(stds-802-16) and thereby be notified ofdocument publication meetings minutes
bull To post to stds-802-16 in accordance with thereflector rules
bull To examine documents unless copyrightconcerns prohibit it
bull To contribute documents in response to aCall for Contributions
bull To attend and participate in 80216 meetingsif registered
bull To join the Sponsor Balloting Pool
IEEE and IEEE SA Membership
bull Members are encouraged to join IEEEIEEE Standards Association and IEEEComputer Society
bull Such membership is not required forWorking Group Membership ObserverStatus or Sponsor Ballot PoolGroup
Sponsor Ballot PoolGroup
bull Balloting Pool is being constructed
bull Future 80216 draft standards will beballoted by a Balloting Group drawn frommembers of the 80216 Balloting Pool
bull To join the 80216 Balloting Pool use theform on the web
bull Members of IEEE Standards Association[IEEE or CS + $10] can participate in BallotGroup without paying special fee
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
13
Rights of Members amp Observers
bull To examine draft standardsbull To participate in Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To examine the votes of Working
Group membersbull To examine the Member and Observer
contact databases
Exclusive Rights of Membershipbull To make or second a motion at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote if and only if present at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote in 80216 Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To vote by email on any issue involving
80216 or its subsidiariesbull To lodge complaints about Working Group
operation with the 802 Executive Committeebull To petition the 802 Executive Committee in
writing
Attendance Listbull Recorded at each ldquomeeting intervalrdquo
ndashAfternoon MonTueWedThundashMorning TueWedThuFri
ndashEvening Thu
ndashSelf-declared ldquosubstantially allrdquo of meetingndashSession ldquoParticipationrdquo 75 of meeting intervals
bull =will round down to 6
bull Attendance recorded in parallel meetingsndashvoting credit for presence at either
bull Attendance is public recordndashattendance will be reported on webndashcontact info will not be posted (just company)
Secretaryrsquos Announcementsbull Scott Marin
ndash Attendance books (four of them)
bull Write your namebull If new and unregistered insert business
card in pocketbull Initial and keep the book movingbull Remember your book and page number
ndash Voting tokensbull Printed on badge for Membersbull Raise to vote
Registration
bull $140
bull Registration fee form at front deskndashHotel guest charge to roomndashOthers credit card
bull Receive copy of form as receipt
Document Distributionbull Server http10001bull Run DHCPbull Use 10BaseT or 100BaseTXbull Use 80211b or 80211 DSSS Wireless
bull Upload files using anonymous ftp
bull Flash Card may be available
Logistics
bull Meeting Roomsndash Vary throughout the week
bull Breaksndash Always in large room (E or D)
bull RAWCON events
Individuality
bull In IEEE standards meetingsparticipation is by individualndash you do not represent a company or
organization
bull Membership belongs to the individualnot an organization and may not betransferred
Legal and Anti-Trust
bull Any discussions that relate to thevalidity or cost of patent use shall beavoided
bull Any discussions or any materialrelating to an ongoing litigation shallbe avoided
bull Any discussions of pricing or issuesthat would violate US antitrust lawsshall be avoided
IEEE 80216 Patent Policybull IEEE 80216 operates under the Patent Policy of
the IEEE Standards Association as set forth inClause 6 of the IEEE-SA Standards BoardBylaws This policy includes the statement
bull IEEE standards may include the known use ofpatent(s) including patent applications if there istechnical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and providedthe IEEE receives assurance from the patentholder that it will license applicants underreasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standard
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
14
IEEE 80216 Patent Policy (cont)bull IEEE 80216 interprets in the opinion of the standards-
developing committee as in the opinion of the members of theWorking Group Early disclosure to the Working Groupparticipants of patent information that might be relevant to thestandard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and to increase the likelihood that the draftpublication will be approved for publication IEEE 80216 strivesto make such information available as soon as possible forconsideration by individual members in their voting decisionsHowever in its meetings and electronic forums IEEE 80216does not permit discussions concerning the validity orapplicability of intellectual property claims The only role a patentclaim plays in Working Group discussions concerns ensuringcompliance to the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures
bull Justification for the inclusion of technology is limited to thetechnical merits of the technology
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresAnyone whether participating in IEEE 80216 or notshould notify the Chair of any patents (granted orunder application and regardless of the assignee orthe patent nationality) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved byIEEE 80216 Such notification should be in written orelectronic form (email is preferred) and need notmake any statement concerning enforcement orlicensing The Chair will presume that suchnotification is intended for public release and will assoon as practical post it to the web along with otherPatent Notices On File with IEEE 80216 The Chairand the Working Group will take no positionregarding the validity or applicability of any patents
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresWritten contributions to IEEE 80216 standards development willnot be accepted without an acknowledgement of familiarity with theIEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures Thisacknowledgement will be part of the mandatory contribution coversheet and will read
ldquoThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policyand Procedures (Version )
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information thatmight be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce thepossibility for delays in the development process andincrease the likelihood that the draft publication will beapproved for publication Please notify the Chair as early aspossible in written or electronic form of any patents (grantedor under application) that may cover technology that is underconsideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 TheChair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 websiterdquo
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresThe Chair once formally notified and once apotentially relevant draft standard exists shallwrite to the identified party and request that aLetter of Assurance be filed with the Chair forforwarding to the IEEE-SA Patent Committee inaccordance with the instructions in the IEEE-SAStandards Board Operations Manual A samplerequest letter and response letter are availableWhen the Patent Committee has accepted theletter as a Letter of Assurance informationregarding the letter will be indexed in the Recordsof IEEE Standards-Related Patents
Approval of Minutes
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to
ndash approve Document IEEE 80216-0017(Minutes of Session 8)
TG1 (802161)bull Air Interface for Fixed Broadband
Wireless Access Systemsbull 10-66 GHz
bull Chair Roger Marksbull Editor Jim MollenauerBrian Petrybull MAC Chair Carl Eklundbull PHY Chair Jay Klein
TG1 Goals for Week
ndashStay on Development PlanbullInitiative Working Group Letter BallotbullSeek approval at Closing Plenary
ndashMACbullComment resolutionbullMeet with TG3
ndashPHYbullComment resolutionbullOther contributionsbullMeet with TG2
TG2 (802162)ndashCoexistence of Broadband Wireless
Access Systems
ndashCo-Chair Andy McGregorndashCo-Chair Leland LangstonndashVice Chair Reacutemi Chayer
ndashEditor Vito Scaringindash Secretary Reza Arefi
TG3 (802163)bull Broadband Wireless Access Systems
in Licensed Bands from 2 to 11 GHzbull Chair Brian Kiernanbull Vice Chair Carl Bushuebull Secretary Dean Changbull Functional Requirements
ndashBrian PetryndashGeorge Fishel
WirelessHUMANTM Study Group
bull Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed MetropolitanArea Networks
bull Chair Durga Satapathybull Secretary Sanjay Moghe
bull Chartered at Session 6bull Renewed at Session 8bull Writing a PAR
bull To coordinate with 80211 and 80215
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
15
Charge to Task Groupsbull Complete the task on your agenda
ndashUpdate agenda on bulletin board
bull Prepare for next meetingndashCall for Contributions etc
bull Prepare for Closing Plenary
ndashAll motions to be in writingbull Document everything
ndash submit documents before you leavendash provide document index on bulletin board
bull Presentations to server 2 hours in advance
Voting in Task Groups
bull Only 80216 Voting Members may vote in taskGroup meetingsndashShow Voting Token
bull All present are eligible to vote at Study Groupmeetings
New Business
bull Request for New Business items
Adjournment
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to adjournthis meeting of Working Group 80216until the Midweek Plenaryndash(5-6 pm on Wednesday 13 September)
TG2 Status Report
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 1
IEEE 802162 Activities
Recommended Practice forCoexistence of BroadbandWireless Access Systems
Co-chairs Leland Langston Andy McGregor
Vice Chair Remi ChayerEditor Vito Scaringi
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 2
Activities since San DiegoMeeting
bull R7 of draft Practice issued late July
bull Several input docs and comments receivedbull Teleconference held Sept 7th ndash 8 participants
ndashSignificant discussion on content
bull R8 of draft Practice available Sept 11th
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 3
Plans for Denver
bull Close issue of single vs multiple interferers
bull Review doc for consistency amp completenessbull Present summary to joint TG1TG2bull Post R9 in week of Sept 18th
bull Seeking comments from any 80216 participant
bull TARGET TG ballot following Tampa meeting
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
16
Appendix B Midweek Plenary Presentations
Midweek Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Midweek Plenary Meeting AgendaWednesday 13 September 2000 1700-1800
Opening of Midweek Plenary Meeting 1700Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Midweek Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule Update Marks V
Announcements 1705
Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IAttendance books badges etc Marin I
802161 1710
Report Marks I802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1720Report McGregor I
802163 1730
Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1740
Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1745
Liaison 1750
ITU Costa ETSI BRAN Klein
Closing 1755
New Business (Marin Editorial Process) Marks VAdjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
17
Agenda for the Week as revised at the Midweek Plenary
80216 Session 9 Agenda Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMon
RAWCONKeynoteAddress
Ballroom A-D
120-150 pm(80216
RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCONLunch
1230-130pm
(80216Registrants
Invited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon G
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon H
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG16-730 pmSalon E
TG3Salon E
8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
TG3730-10 pm
Salon E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
18
Appendix C Closing Plenary Presentations
Closing Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Closing Plenary Meeting AgendaFriday 15 September 2000 10 am -1200 noon
Opening 1000Call to Order Marks IAgenda Marks V
Announcements 1003Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IVice Chair Marks I80216 Logo Marks D
WirelessHUMAN 1010Report Satapathy IPAR Approval Satapathy V
802161 1025Report Marks I802161 Working Group Review Marks V
802162 1050Report McGregor IFinal Task Group Review McGregor IMotions McGregor V
802163 1110Report Kiernan IMotions Kiernan V
Future Meetings 1130
Session 10 6-10 November 2000 Hyatt Regency Tampa Tampa Florida USA Marks ISunday Monday Friday at Session 10 Marks DSession 11 22-26 January 2001 Tel Aviv Israel Marks ISession 12 12-15 March 2001 Hyatt Regency Hilton Head South Carolina USA Marks ISession 13 7-11 May 2001 Orlando Florida USA along with IEEE 80211 and 80215 Marks I
Liaison 1135
ETSI BRANnotification of 802161 status and offer of password Marks V
Regulatory Agency notifications Robinson V
New Business 114080216 Editorial Policy MarinPetry V
Closing 1200
Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
19
WirelessHUMANtrade Closing Presentation[Insert Document Title Here]
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
[The appropriate coordinator normally the Task Group Chair will fill in this number after obtaining it from the 80216 Chair The
document number will match that of the base contribution with ldquoprdquo replacing ldquocrdquo For example 802161p-00nn]Date Submitted
[2000-07-13]Source
[Durga Satapathy] [Voice(913) 534-6338] [Sprint] [Fax (913) 534-6522] [7101 College Blvd Suite 1436 B] mailto[durgasatapathymailsprintcom [Overland Park KS 66210]
Venue
[IEEE 80216 Session 8]Base Document
[If this presentation illustrates an 80216 document cite the document number and URL lthttpieee802org16hellipgt]Purpose
[WirelessHUMAN Study Group report at closing plenary]Notice
This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s)The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw materialcontained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creation of anIEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution and at theIEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor also acknowledges and acceptsthat this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including the statementldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developingcommittee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purpose ofimplementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chair ltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt asearly as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology that is under consideration by or has beenapproved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentslettersgt
IEEE 80216 Plenary Report
Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed Metropolitan Area Network
(WirelessHUMANTM) Study Group
Durga P Satapathy
WirelessHUMANTM Update
bull Reviewed 8 contributions
bull Achieved consensus on selecting standardsto utilizemodifyndashMAC 80216ndashPHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
bull Drafted PAR and 5 criteria
WirelessHUMANTM PAR Scope This standard specifies the physical layer and media access control
layer of the air interface of interoperable fixed broadband wirelessmetropolitan area network systems including point-to-multipoint Thestandard enables access to data video and voice services with qualityof service in unlicensed bands designated for public network access Itwill focus on the 5-6 GHz range and may be applied to unlicensedbands between 2 and 11 GHz The WirelessHUMAN standard willutilize or modify applicable elements from the following
MAC 80216
PHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
The development of the WirelessHUMAN standard will follow thetimeline as shown in Appendix A
WirelessHUMANTM Timeline
bull Call For Proposals for WirelessHUMAN PHYMAC Nov 2000)ndash PHY Modifications of 80211a HIPERLAN2ndash MAC Modifications of 80216
bull Review proposals Jan 2001
bull Select candidate proposals at Interim meeting Feb 2001bull Decision on specific modifications March 2001
bull First Draft Standard May 2001
bull Comment Resolutions July 2001
bull Second Draft Standard Sep 2001bull Finalize WirelessHUMAN Standard Nov 2001
Purpose of Proposed Project
To enable rapid worldwide deployment of innovative cost-effectiveand interoperable multi-vendor broadband wireless metropolitan areanetwork products operating in the unlicensed bands To facilitatecompetition in broadband access by providing fixed wirelessalternatives to wireline broadband access Identify techniques totolerate interference in the unlicensed bands facilitate strategies forcoexistence with other unlicensed band systems such as 80211a andmaximize the carrying capacity of the unlicensed bands Encourageconsistent worldwide allocation and accelerate the commercializationof unlicensed broadband wireless access spectrum Utilization ofunlicensed frequencies will address a market that includes residencesSmall Office-Home Office (SOHO) telecommuters and Small andMedium Enterprises (SME)
WirelessHUMAN Study Group Participants
Sprint RF Solutions Agilent Technologies
Intel Breezecom Adaptive BroadbandNokia Transcomm Inc Cabletron
Ericsson BNA Systems WirelessHomeLucent Escape Carleton UniversityIntracom Malibu Networks Carnegie Mellon UniversityProxim Ultracom Georgia Institute of TechnologyWaveIP Harris Corporation HRL Laboratories LLCN Band Com Wireless Inc Western MultiplexCoreon Inc Cabletron systems Communications Research Center
Runcom Magnolia Broadband Yokogawa Electric CoInnowave ECI
Motion
The proposed WirelessHUMANTM PARbe accepted
TG1 MAC ClosingPresentation
(TG1 MAC reportppt)
1 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
TG1 MAC group
bull Resolved comments received during Final TaskGroup review
bull Major effort to remove any particular PHYdependence from the MAC
bull Process of adding features useful for TG3requirments started
bull Meeting with TG3
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
20
2 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
Important MAC decisions
bull Adoption of EUI-48 addresses (previouslyEUI-64)
bull Addition of error control to MAC layer(previously defined in TC layer of PHY B)
bull Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes into asingle mode
bull Redesigned DL MAP message for higherspectral efficiency
TG1 PHY ClosingPresentation
Document Number80216pp-
TitlePHY TG1 Report at Session 9
Date Submitted
91500Source
Jay KleinVenue
Denver September 2000Base Document
None
PurposeReport
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist the IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the
contributing individual(s) or organization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after furtherstudy The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by 80216
IEEE Patent Policy
The contributor is familiar with the IEEE Patent Policy which is set forth in the IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylawslthttpstandards ieeeorgguidesbylawsgt and includes the statement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s)
including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developing committee and provided theIEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standardrdquo
PHY TG1 Report Session 9
Jay KleinEnsemble Communications
Documents Submitted
bull 802161pc-0044 (2000-09-07) Recommendation onLMDS Radio Propagation Channel Models
bull 802161c-0007 (2000-09-10)FEC Parameterization for Data Transport (Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0006 (2000-09-08)FEC Parameterization for Control Channel Information(Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0004 (2000-09-01)Frequency Synthesizer Model Parameters (Lars Lindh andHans Somerma)
Documents Submitted ndash cont
bull 802161c-0003 (2000-09-01)Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes in802161 (Ken Stanwood)
bull 802161c-0001 (2000-08-08)Summary of Open PHY Issues in IEEE 802161-0001 (Jeff Foerster)
Work done
bull All editorial comments resolved
bull All technical comments reviewed andresolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull TBDs resolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull Met with MAC group for ldquosynchronizingrdquo
TG3 Closing Presentation
802163 Task Group Reportbull Finished and Adopted Functional
Requirements Document except for editorialsndashOutput Comment database on server
bull Developed an initial List of EvaluationCriteria for PHY proposal evaluations FullCriteria to be developed at next meeting
bull Issuing two calls for contributionsndashPreliminary PHY proposalsndashDeployment Traffic and Propagation
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS
bull Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull Session 10 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband WirelessAccess will be held on 6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA In orderto assist in the evaluation of air interface proposals the 802163 Task Groupinvites contributions addressing the following issues
lang Traffic and deployment models based on single and multi-cellsystems
lang Channel propagation model
bull Contributions must be submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt Submissions will beconsidered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible followingreceipt for public access on the 80216 Web Site Email your contribution tothe 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernanltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 Chair Roger Marksltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS - Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull The Task Group 3 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access is preparing to define the PHY protocols for abroadband wireless access air interface specification for frequencies from 2 through 11 GHz The specification will be based on submittedcontributions with increasing detail required as the process progresses Mergers and improvements will be encouraged with final selectionscheduled for June 2001
bull The TG3 Task Group invites the submission of initial contributions representing proposed PHY solutions Contributors will be grantedagenda time during 80216 Working Group Session 10 (6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA) to present and discuss the merits oftheir proposals Only submissions to session 10 will be eligible for invitation to submit more detailed proposals to session 11 Eachproposal will be allocated equal agenda time on Tuesday November 7 If time permits the allocations will be 15 minutes of presentationfollowed by 15 minutes of discussion Submissions must follow the guidelines below
lang Include a descriptive titlelang Include an overview and a reference model that describes functions including interfaces to other layerslang Describe the benefits of the proposed PHY including any unique featureslang Describe any drawbacks of the proposed PHY
bull Explain how the submitted PHY relates to existing standards such as ITU-R JRG 8A-9B IEEE 80211 DOCSIS 11 ETSI HiperLAN orothers If it is based on an existing standard what differences occur due to BWA characteristics
lang Emphasize the scalability of the proposed PHY to deal efficiently with various data types as described in the 802163Functional Requirements Document
lang Include a statement on intellectual property rights and how 80216 may utilize the proposed PHY in a standard
bull The proposals will be evaluated based on criteria in the Evaluation Table below However at this initial stage contributions are not expectedto address in detail the discussion items in that table instead aiming for the more general description as outlined above Each of the VotingMembers of 80216 are eligible to participate in the evaluation if present Submitters receiving a combined score of 6 or better (out of 10) inany criterion in the Evaluation Table will be invited to submit more a detailed contribution for Session 11 (January 22-26 2001 in Tel AvivIsrael) Note that submissions need not represent a complete PHY but may focus on specific components
bull Contributions will be considered only if submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216 Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt The template requires a cover page and a narrative
bull Submissions will be considered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible following receipt for public access on the 80216Web Site lthttpieee802org16gt
bull Email your contribution to the 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernan ltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 ChairRoger Marks ltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
802163 Task Group Report
bull Officially Adopted TG1 MAC as TG3 DraftMAC
bull Create TG3 MAC Ad Hoc to review TG1MAC and provide TG3 Comments
bull Two Motions for the Working GroupndashLiaison to ETSI BRAN sub11 GHz WGndashEstablishment of 80216 Common MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
21
Motion 1
That the 80216 Working Group appoint ChetShirali as a liaison to the ETSI BRAN sub11GHz Working Group
Motion 2
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MACbullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
22
Appendix D Attendance at Session9Session9 was an interim session The 75 interval attendance criteria for Session 9 was 6 ormore intervals Please contact the 80216 Secretary (smarinixnetcomcom) if you feel yourattendance has been recorded incorrectly
The following 126 peopleregistered attendance at 6or more intervals and metthe attendance criteria
Aboukarr BakriAn SongArefi RezaArunachalam ArunAvera DraytAvivi EliAyyagari DeepakBaragar IanBaseghi BehshadBaugh CR (Rick)Belfiore CarlosBenyamin-Seeyar AnaderBushue CarlBuskila BaruchChan RebeccaChang DeanChayer ReacutemiCondie MaryCornelius JamesCosta JoseacuteCrilly Jr William JDoherty EdwardEdmonston BrainEidson BrianEklund CarlEl-Damhougy HeshamFishel GeorgeFoerster JeffreyGarrison G JackGesbert DavidGoldhammer MariannaGuillemette PhilGupta RakeshHadad ZionHall EricHamilton MichaelHammons RogerHatim BayaHebron YoanHilberman DanHosur SrinathHsuan YiHudson ThomasHum ColemanHunter WayneJacobsen EricJamali Hamadi
Jorgensen JacobKang InchulKasslin MikaKiernan BrianKim JohnKitroser ItzikKlein JayKolze ThomasKostas DemosKwak Byung-JaeKwak JoeLangley John BLangston J LelandLeiba YigalLewis BarryLicardie SergioLiebetreu JohnLindh LarsLo TitusMarin ScottMarks RogerMcCallister RonMcGregor AndyMcMullin RoderickMeyer RonaldMiddleton AndrewMizoguchi MasatoMody ApurvaMollenauer JamesPadan UziPetry BrianPleasant WayneRalston WilliamRan MosheResheff GuyRhodes ValentineRobinson GeneRoehr WaltRzeszewski TedSantacesaria ClaudioSatapathy DurgaSater GlenScaringi VitoScarpa CarlSchwartz RandallSegal YossiSellars MalcolmShan Tie-JunShimada ShusakuShirali ChetSkaar HelgeSmith SteveStamatelos George
Stambaugh KarlStanwood KenStewart MichaelStruhsaker PaulSydor JohnTappenden ChrisTateishi KimiyaTavormina JoeThomas RaymondThompson PaulTrinkwon DavidVan Waes NicoVarma SubirWachira MuyaWang ArthurWang Chao-ChunWang LeiWang XiaofengWard BobWhitehead PhilipWhiting RobertWilliams David GWise CurtWiss JohnYanover VladimirZuniga Juan Carlos
The following 18 peopleregistered attendance atless than 6 intervals anddid not meet theattendance criteria
Alspaugh MatthewCarlo JimFalconer DavidFoley MarkFoster RobertGupta AlokHancock DaleHarel HaimKhanna AmarpalKreig AndrewMonk AntonNadeau JamesOng Ling ChuenRafie ManouchehrRibner David BWheatley Chuck FYang S MichaelYurtkuran Erol
Motion 5
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MAC based on802161-0001r4bullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
Appendix E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
9
Respectfully
Scott Marin
80216 Secretary
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
10
Appendix A Opening Plenary Presentations
Opening Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Opening Plenary Meeting AgendaMonday 11 September 2000 1400-1515
See Opening Plenary presentation slidesOpening of Session 9 and of Opening Plenary Meeting 1400Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Opening Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule of meetings for the week Marks V
Membership and Voting 1410Rights of members observers and others Marks IAttendance list procedure Marin IVoting token procedure Marin I
Announcements 1415Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks ILogistics rooms breaks etc Marks IIndividual and Anti-Trust Marks IIEEE 80216 Patent Policies and Procedures Marks I
Approvals 1425Minutes of Session 8 (IEEE 80216-0017) Marks V
802161 1430Report Marks IEditing Mollenauer Petry 802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1440Report McGregor I
802163 1450Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1500Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1510Voting in Task Groups and Study Groups Marks I
New Business 1513
Closing 1515Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
11
Agenda for the Week
80216 Session 9 AgendaSchedule (tentative)
Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMo
n
RAWCONKeynote Address
Ballroom A-D120-150 pm
(80216 RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster
Session530-700 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCON Lunch1230-130 pm
(80216 RegistrantsInvited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster
Session530-700 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon 5
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG3Salon GH8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
12
Chairmans Opening Plenary Presentation
IEEE 80216 Session 9 Opening Plenary Meeting
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
NoneDate Submitted
2000-09-11Source
Roger Marks Voice +1-303-497-3037NIST Fax +1-303-497-7828325 Broadway MC 81300 E-mail marksnistgovBoulder CO 80303
VenueSession 9 Opening Plenary
Base DocumentNone
PurposeThis presentation is to be inserted in the Session 9 minutes
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) ororganization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to addamend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creationof an IEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contributionand at the IEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor alsoacknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16 iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including thestatement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms andconditions for the purpose of implementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chairltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt as early as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentsnoticesgt
IEEE 80216Working Group on
Broadband Wireless Access(BWA)
Session 9Opening Plenary
11 September 2000
200-315 pm
Session Opening
bull Call to Order
bull Welcome
80216 Officers
bull Chair Roger Marks
bull Vice Chair Lou Olsen
bull Secretary Scott Marin
Agenda
bull Presentation of 80216 OpeningPlenary Agendandash Chair asks for unanimous consent to
approve
bull Schedule of meetings for the weekndash Chair asks for unanimous consent to
approve
Rights of Allbull To subscribe to the 80216 Email Reflector
(stds-802-16) and thereby be notified ofdocument publication meetings minutes
bull To post to stds-802-16 in accordance with thereflector rules
bull To examine documents unless copyrightconcerns prohibit it
bull To contribute documents in response to aCall for Contributions
bull To attend and participate in 80216 meetingsif registered
bull To join the Sponsor Balloting Pool
IEEE and IEEE SA Membership
bull Members are encouraged to join IEEEIEEE Standards Association and IEEEComputer Society
bull Such membership is not required forWorking Group Membership ObserverStatus or Sponsor Ballot PoolGroup
Sponsor Ballot PoolGroup
bull Balloting Pool is being constructed
bull Future 80216 draft standards will beballoted by a Balloting Group drawn frommembers of the 80216 Balloting Pool
bull To join the 80216 Balloting Pool use theform on the web
bull Members of IEEE Standards Association[IEEE or CS + $10] can participate in BallotGroup without paying special fee
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
13
Rights of Members amp Observers
bull To examine draft standardsbull To participate in Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To examine the votes of Working
Group membersbull To examine the Member and Observer
contact databases
Exclusive Rights of Membershipbull To make or second a motion at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote if and only if present at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote in 80216 Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To vote by email on any issue involving
80216 or its subsidiariesbull To lodge complaints about Working Group
operation with the 802 Executive Committeebull To petition the 802 Executive Committee in
writing
Attendance Listbull Recorded at each ldquomeeting intervalrdquo
ndashAfternoon MonTueWedThundashMorning TueWedThuFri
ndashEvening Thu
ndashSelf-declared ldquosubstantially allrdquo of meetingndashSession ldquoParticipationrdquo 75 of meeting intervals
bull =will round down to 6
bull Attendance recorded in parallel meetingsndashvoting credit for presence at either
bull Attendance is public recordndashattendance will be reported on webndashcontact info will not be posted (just company)
Secretaryrsquos Announcementsbull Scott Marin
ndash Attendance books (four of them)
bull Write your namebull If new and unregistered insert business
card in pocketbull Initial and keep the book movingbull Remember your book and page number
ndash Voting tokensbull Printed on badge for Membersbull Raise to vote
Registration
bull $140
bull Registration fee form at front deskndashHotel guest charge to roomndashOthers credit card
bull Receive copy of form as receipt
Document Distributionbull Server http10001bull Run DHCPbull Use 10BaseT or 100BaseTXbull Use 80211b or 80211 DSSS Wireless
bull Upload files using anonymous ftp
bull Flash Card may be available
Logistics
bull Meeting Roomsndash Vary throughout the week
bull Breaksndash Always in large room (E or D)
bull RAWCON events
Individuality
bull In IEEE standards meetingsparticipation is by individualndash you do not represent a company or
organization
bull Membership belongs to the individualnot an organization and may not betransferred
Legal and Anti-Trust
bull Any discussions that relate to thevalidity or cost of patent use shall beavoided
bull Any discussions or any materialrelating to an ongoing litigation shallbe avoided
bull Any discussions of pricing or issuesthat would violate US antitrust lawsshall be avoided
IEEE 80216 Patent Policybull IEEE 80216 operates under the Patent Policy of
the IEEE Standards Association as set forth inClause 6 of the IEEE-SA Standards BoardBylaws This policy includes the statement
bull IEEE standards may include the known use ofpatent(s) including patent applications if there istechnical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and providedthe IEEE receives assurance from the patentholder that it will license applicants underreasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standard
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
14
IEEE 80216 Patent Policy (cont)bull IEEE 80216 interprets in the opinion of the standards-
developing committee as in the opinion of the members of theWorking Group Early disclosure to the Working Groupparticipants of patent information that might be relevant to thestandard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and to increase the likelihood that the draftpublication will be approved for publication IEEE 80216 strivesto make such information available as soon as possible forconsideration by individual members in their voting decisionsHowever in its meetings and electronic forums IEEE 80216does not permit discussions concerning the validity orapplicability of intellectual property claims The only role a patentclaim plays in Working Group discussions concerns ensuringcompliance to the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures
bull Justification for the inclusion of technology is limited to thetechnical merits of the technology
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresAnyone whether participating in IEEE 80216 or notshould notify the Chair of any patents (granted orunder application and regardless of the assignee orthe patent nationality) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved byIEEE 80216 Such notification should be in written orelectronic form (email is preferred) and need notmake any statement concerning enforcement orlicensing The Chair will presume that suchnotification is intended for public release and will assoon as practical post it to the web along with otherPatent Notices On File with IEEE 80216 The Chairand the Working Group will take no positionregarding the validity or applicability of any patents
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresWritten contributions to IEEE 80216 standards development willnot be accepted without an acknowledgement of familiarity with theIEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures Thisacknowledgement will be part of the mandatory contribution coversheet and will read
ldquoThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policyand Procedures (Version )
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information thatmight be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce thepossibility for delays in the development process andincrease the likelihood that the draft publication will beapproved for publication Please notify the Chair as early aspossible in written or electronic form of any patents (grantedor under application) that may cover technology that is underconsideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 TheChair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 websiterdquo
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresThe Chair once formally notified and once apotentially relevant draft standard exists shallwrite to the identified party and request that aLetter of Assurance be filed with the Chair forforwarding to the IEEE-SA Patent Committee inaccordance with the instructions in the IEEE-SAStandards Board Operations Manual A samplerequest letter and response letter are availableWhen the Patent Committee has accepted theletter as a Letter of Assurance informationregarding the letter will be indexed in the Recordsof IEEE Standards-Related Patents
Approval of Minutes
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to
ndash approve Document IEEE 80216-0017(Minutes of Session 8)
TG1 (802161)bull Air Interface for Fixed Broadband
Wireless Access Systemsbull 10-66 GHz
bull Chair Roger Marksbull Editor Jim MollenauerBrian Petrybull MAC Chair Carl Eklundbull PHY Chair Jay Klein
TG1 Goals for Week
ndashStay on Development PlanbullInitiative Working Group Letter BallotbullSeek approval at Closing Plenary
ndashMACbullComment resolutionbullMeet with TG3
ndashPHYbullComment resolutionbullOther contributionsbullMeet with TG2
TG2 (802162)ndashCoexistence of Broadband Wireless
Access Systems
ndashCo-Chair Andy McGregorndashCo-Chair Leland LangstonndashVice Chair Reacutemi Chayer
ndashEditor Vito Scaringindash Secretary Reza Arefi
TG3 (802163)bull Broadband Wireless Access Systems
in Licensed Bands from 2 to 11 GHzbull Chair Brian Kiernanbull Vice Chair Carl Bushuebull Secretary Dean Changbull Functional Requirements
ndashBrian PetryndashGeorge Fishel
WirelessHUMANTM Study Group
bull Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed MetropolitanArea Networks
bull Chair Durga Satapathybull Secretary Sanjay Moghe
bull Chartered at Session 6bull Renewed at Session 8bull Writing a PAR
bull To coordinate with 80211 and 80215
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
15
Charge to Task Groupsbull Complete the task on your agenda
ndashUpdate agenda on bulletin board
bull Prepare for next meetingndashCall for Contributions etc
bull Prepare for Closing Plenary
ndashAll motions to be in writingbull Document everything
ndash submit documents before you leavendash provide document index on bulletin board
bull Presentations to server 2 hours in advance
Voting in Task Groups
bull Only 80216 Voting Members may vote in taskGroup meetingsndashShow Voting Token
bull All present are eligible to vote at Study Groupmeetings
New Business
bull Request for New Business items
Adjournment
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to adjournthis meeting of Working Group 80216until the Midweek Plenaryndash(5-6 pm on Wednesday 13 September)
TG2 Status Report
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 1
IEEE 802162 Activities
Recommended Practice forCoexistence of BroadbandWireless Access Systems
Co-chairs Leland Langston Andy McGregor
Vice Chair Remi ChayerEditor Vito Scaringi
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 2
Activities since San DiegoMeeting
bull R7 of draft Practice issued late July
bull Several input docs and comments receivedbull Teleconference held Sept 7th ndash 8 participants
ndashSignificant discussion on content
bull R8 of draft Practice available Sept 11th
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 3
Plans for Denver
bull Close issue of single vs multiple interferers
bull Review doc for consistency amp completenessbull Present summary to joint TG1TG2bull Post R9 in week of Sept 18th
bull Seeking comments from any 80216 participant
bull TARGET TG ballot following Tampa meeting
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
16
Appendix B Midweek Plenary Presentations
Midweek Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Midweek Plenary Meeting AgendaWednesday 13 September 2000 1700-1800
Opening of Midweek Plenary Meeting 1700Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Midweek Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule Update Marks V
Announcements 1705
Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IAttendance books badges etc Marin I
802161 1710
Report Marks I802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1720Report McGregor I
802163 1730
Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1740
Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1745
Liaison 1750
ITU Costa ETSI BRAN Klein
Closing 1755
New Business (Marin Editorial Process) Marks VAdjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
17
Agenda for the Week as revised at the Midweek Plenary
80216 Session 9 Agenda Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMon
RAWCONKeynoteAddress
Ballroom A-D
120-150 pm(80216
RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCONLunch
1230-130pm
(80216Registrants
Invited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon G
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon H
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG16-730 pmSalon E
TG3Salon E
8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
TG3730-10 pm
Salon E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
18
Appendix C Closing Plenary Presentations
Closing Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Closing Plenary Meeting AgendaFriday 15 September 2000 10 am -1200 noon
Opening 1000Call to Order Marks IAgenda Marks V
Announcements 1003Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IVice Chair Marks I80216 Logo Marks D
WirelessHUMAN 1010Report Satapathy IPAR Approval Satapathy V
802161 1025Report Marks I802161 Working Group Review Marks V
802162 1050Report McGregor IFinal Task Group Review McGregor IMotions McGregor V
802163 1110Report Kiernan IMotions Kiernan V
Future Meetings 1130
Session 10 6-10 November 2000 Hyatt Regency Tampa Tampa Florida USA Marks ISunday Monday Friday at Session 10 Marks DSession 11 22-26 January 2001 Tel Aviv Israel Marks ISession 12 12-15 March 2001 Hyatt Regency Hilton Head South Carolina USA Marks ISession 13 7-11 May 2001 Orlando Florida USA along with IEEE 80211 and 80215 Marks I
Liaison 1135
ETSI BRANnotification of 802161 status and offer of password Marks V
Regulatory Agency notifications Robinson V
New Business 114080216 Editorial Policy MarinPetry V
Closing 1200
Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
19
WirelessHUMANtrade Closing Presentation[Insert Document Title Here]
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
[The appropriate coordinator normally the Task Group Chair will fill in this number after obtaining it from the 80216 Chair The
document number will match that of the base contribution with ldquoprdquo replacing ldquocrdquo For example 802161p-00nn]Date Submitted
[2000-07-13]Source
[Durga Satapathy] [Voice(913) 534-6338] [Sprint] [Fax (913) 534-6522] [7101 College Blvd Suite 1436 B] mailto[durgasatapathymailsprintcom [Overland Park KS 66210]
Venue
[IEEE 80216 Session 8]Base Document
[If this presentation illustrates an 80216 document cite the document number and URL lthttpieee802org16hellipgt]Purpose
[WirelessHUMAN Study Group report at closing plenary]Notice
This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s)The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw materialcontained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creation of anIEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution and at theIEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor also acknowledges and acceptsthat this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including the statementldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developingcommittee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purpose ofimplementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chair ltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt asearly as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology that is under consideration by or has beenapproved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentslettersgt
IEEE 80216 Plenary Report
Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed Metropolitan Area Network
(WirelessHUMANTM) Study Group
Durga P Satapathy
WirelessHUMANTM Update
bull Reviewed 8 contributions
bull Achieved consensus on selecting standardsto utilizemodifyndashMAC 80216ndashPHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
bull Drafted PAR and 5 criteria
WirelessHUMANTM PAR Scope This standard specifies the physical layer and media access control
layer of the air interface of interoperable fixed broadband wirelessmetropolitan area network systems including point-to-multipoint Thestandard enables access to data video and voice services with qualityof service in unlicensed bands designated for public network access Itwill focus on the 5-6 GHz range and may be applied to unlicensedbands between 2 and 11 GHz The WirelessHUMAN standard willutilize or modify applicable elements from the following
MAC 80216
PHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
The development of the WirelessHUMAN standard will follow thetimeline as shown in Appendix A
WirelessHUMANTM Timeline
bull Call For Proposals for WirelessHUMAN PHYMAC Nov 2000)ndash PHY Modifications of 80211a HIPERLAN2ndash MAC Modifications of 80216
bull Review proposals Jan 2001
bull Select candidate proposals at Interim meeting Feb 2001bull Decision on specific modifications March 2001
bull First Draft Standard May 2001
bull Comment Resolutions July 2001
bull Second Draft Standard Sep 2001bull Finalize WirelessHUMAN Standard Nov 2001
Purpose of Proposed Project
To enable rapid worldwide deployment of innovative cost-effectiveand interoperable multi-vendor broadband wireless metropolitan areanetwork products operating in the unlicensed bands To facilitatecompetition in broadband access by providing fixed wirelessalternatives to wireline broadband access Identify techniques totolerate interference in the unlicensed bands facilitate strategies forcoexistence with other unlicensed band systems such as 80211a andmaximize the carrying capacity of the unlicensed bands Encourageconsistent worldwide allocation and accelerate the commercializationof unlicensed broadband wireless access spectrum Utilization ofunlicensed frequencies will address a market that includes residencesSmall Office-Home Office (SOHO) telecommuters and Small andMedium Enterprises (SME)
WirelessHUMAN Study Group Participants
Sprint RF Solutions Agilent Technologies
Intel Breezecom Adaptive BroadbandNokia Transcomm Inc Cabletron
Ericsson BNA Systems WirelessHomeLucent Escape Carleton UniversityIntracom Malibu Networks Carnegie Mellon UniversityProxim Ultracom Georgia Institute of TechnologyWaveIP Harris Corporation HRL Laboratories LLCN Band Com Wireless Inc Western MultiplexCoreon Inc Cabletron systems Communications Research Center
Runcom Magnolia Broadband Yokogawa Electric CoInnowave ECI
Motion
The proposed WirelessHUMANTM PARbe accepted
TG1 MAC ClosingPresentation
(TG1 MAC reportppt)
1 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
TG1 MAC group
bull Resolved comments received during Final TaskGroup review
bull Major effort to remove any particular PHYdependence from the MAC
bull Process of adding features useful for TG3requirments started
bull Meeting with TG3
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
20
2 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
Important MAC decisions
bull Adoption of EUI-48 addresses (previouslyEUI-64)
bull Addition of error control to MAC layer(previously defined in TC layer of PHY B)
bull Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes into asingle mode
bull Redesigned DL MAP message for higherspectral efficiency
TG1 PHY ClosingPresentation
Document Number80216pp-
TitlePHY TG1 Report at Session 9
Date Submitted
91500Source
Jay KleinVenue
Denver September 2000Base Document
None
PurposeReport
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist the IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the
contributing individual(s) or organization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after furtherstudy The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by 80216
IEEE Patent Policy
The contributor is familiar with the IEEE Patent Policy which is set forth in the IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylawslthttpstandards ieeeorgguidesbylawsgt and includes the statement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s)
including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developing committee and provided theIEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standardrdquo
PHY TG1 Report Session 9
Jay KleinEnsemble Communications
Documents Submitted
bull 802161pc-0044 (2000-09-07) Recommendation onLMDS Radio Propagation Channel Models
bull 802161c-0007 (2000-09-10)FEC Parameterization for Data Transport (Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0006 (2000-09-08)FEC Parameterization for Control Channel Information(Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0004 (2000-09-01)Frequency Synthesizer Model Parameters (Lars Lindh andHans Somerma)
Documents Submitted ndash cont
bull 802161c-0003 (2000-09-01)Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes in802161 (Ken Stanwood)
bull 802161c-0001 (2000-08-08)Summary of Open PHY Issues in IEEE 802161-0001 (Jeff Foerster)
Work done
bull All editorial comments resolved
bull All technical comments reviewed andresolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull TBDs resolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull Met with MAC group for ldquosynchronizingrdquo
TG3 Closing Presentation
802163 Task Group Reportbull Finished and Adopted Functional
Requirements Document except for editorialsndashOutput Comment database on server
bull Developed an initial List of EvaluationCriteria for PHY proposal evaluations FullCriteria to be developed at next meeting
bull Issuing two calls for contributionsndashPreliminary PHY proposalsndashDeployment Traffic and Propagation
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS
bull Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull Session 10 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband WirelessAccess will be held on 6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA In orderto assist in the evaluation of air interface proposals the 802163 Task Groupinvites contributions addressing the following issues
lang Traffic and deployment models based on single and multi-cellsystems
lang Channel propagation model
bull Contributions must be submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt Submissions will beconsidered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible followingreceipt for public access on the 80216 Web Site Email your contribution tothe 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernanltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 Chair Roger Marksltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS - Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull The Task Group 3 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access is preparing to define the PHY protocols for abroadband wireless access air interface specification for frequencies from 2 through 11 GHz The specification will be based on submittedcontributions with increasing detail required as the process progresses Mergers and improvements will be encouraged with final selectionscheduled for June 2001
bull The TG3 Task Group invites the submission of initial contributions representing proposed PHY solutions Contributors will be grantedagenda time during 80216 Working Group Session 10 (6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA) to present and discuss the merits oftheir proposals Only submissions to session 10 will be eligible for invitation to submit more detailed proposals to session 11 Eachproposal will be allocated equal agenda time on Tuesday November 7 If time permits the allocations will be 15 minutes of presentationfollowed by 15 minutes of discussion Submissions must follow the guidelines below
lang Include a descriptive titlelang Include an overview and a reference model that describes functions including interfaces to other layerslang Describe the benefits of the proposed PHY including any unique featureslang Describe any drawbacks of the proposed PHY
bull Explain how the submitted PHY relates to existing standards such as ITU-R JRG 8A-9B IEEE 80211 DOCSIS 11 ETSI HiperLAN orothers If it is based on an existing standard what differences occur due to BWA characteristics
lang Emphasize the scalability of the proposed PHY to deal efficiently with various data types as described in the 802163Functional Requirements Document
lang Include a statement on intellectual property rights and how 80216 may utilize the proposed PHY in a standard
bull The proposals will be evaluated based on criteria in the Evaluation Table below However at this initial stage contributions are not expectedto address in detail the discussion items in that table instead aiming for the more general description as outlined above Each of the VotingMembers of 80216 are eligible to participate in the evaluation if present Submitters receiving a combined score of 6 or better (out of 10) inany criterion in the Evaluation Table will be invited to submit more a detailed contribution for Session 11 (January 22-26 2001 in Tel AvivIsrael) Note that submissions need not represent a complete PHY but may focus on specific components
bull Contributions will be considered only if submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216 Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt The template requires a cover page and a narrative
bull Submissions will be considered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible following receipt for public access on the 80216Web Site lthttpieee802org16gt
bull Email your contribution to the 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernan ltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 ChairRoger Marks ltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
802163 Task Group Report
bull Officially Adopted TG1 MAC as TG3 DraftMAC
bull Create TG3 MAC Ad Hoc to review TG1MAC and provide TG3 Comments
bull Two Motions for the Working GroupndashLiaison to ETSI BRAN sub11 GHz WGndashEstablishment of 80216 Common MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
21
Motion 1
That the 80216 Working Group appoint ChetShirali as a liaison to the ETSI BRAN sub11GHz Working Group
Motion 2
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MACbullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
22
Appendix D Attendance at Session9Session9 was an interim session The 75 interval attendance criteria for Session 9 was 6 ormore intervals Please contact the 80216 Secretary (smarinixnetcomcom) if you feel yourattendance has been recorded incorrectly
The following 126 peopleregistered attendance at 6or more intervals and metthe attendance criteria
Aboukarr BakriAn SongArefi RezaArunachalam ArunAvera DraytAvivi EliAyyagari DeepakBaragar IanBaseghi BehshadBaugh CR (Rick)Belfiore CarlosBenyamin-Seeyar AnaderBushue CarlBuskila BaruchChan RebeccaChang DeanChayer ReacutemiCondie MaryCornelius JamesCosta JoseacuteCrilly Jr William JDoherty EdwardEdmonston BrainEidson BrianEklund CarlEl-Damhougy HeshamFishel GeorgeFoerster JeffreyGarrison G JackGesbert DavidGoldhammer MariannaGuillemette PhilGupta RakeshHadad ZionHall EricHamilton MichaelHammons RogerHatim BayaHebron YoanHilberman DanHosur SrinathHsuan YiHudson ThomasHum ColemanHunter WayneJacobsen EricJamali Hamadi
Jorgensen JacobKang InchulKasslin MikaKiernan BrianKim JohnKitroser ItzikKlein JayKolze ThomasKostas DemosKwak Byung-JaeKwak JoeLangley John BLangston J LelandLeiba YigalLewis BarryLicardie SergioLiebetreu JohnLindh LarsLo TitusMarin ScottMarks RogerMcCallister RonMcGregor AndyMcMullin RoderickMeyer RonaldMiddleton AndrewMizoguchi MasatoMody ApurvaMollenauer JamesPadan UziPetry BrianPleasant WayneRalston WilliamRan MosheResheff GuyRhodes ValentineRobinson GeneRoehr WaltRzeszewski TedSantacesaria ClaudioSatapathy DurgaSater GlenScaringi VitoScarpa CarlSchwartz RandallSegal YossiSellars MalcolmShan Tie-JunShimada ShusakuShirali ChetSkaar HelgeSmith SteveStamatelos George
Stambaugh KarlStanwood KenStewart MichaelStruhsaker PaulSydor JohnTappenden ChrisTateishi KimiyaTavormina JoeThomas RaymondThompson PaulTrinkwon DavidVan Waes NicoVarma SubirWachira MuyaWang ArthurWang Chao-ChunWang LeiWang XiaofengWard BobWhitehead PhilipWhiting RobertWilliams David GWise CurtWiss JohnYanover VladimirZuniga Juan Carlos
The following 18 peopleregistered attendance atless than 6 intervals anddid not meet theattendance criteria
Alspaugh MatthewCarlo JimFalconer DavidFoley MarkFoster RobertGupta AlokHancock DaleHarel HaimKhanna AmarpalKreig AndrewMonk AntonNadeau JamesOng Ling ChuenRafie ManouchehrRibner David BWheatley Chuck FYang S MichaelYurtkuran Erol
Motion 5
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MAC based on802161-0001r4bullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
Appendix E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
10
Appendix A Opening Plenary Presentations
Opening Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Opening Plenary Meeting AgendaMonday 11 September 2000 1400-1515
See Opening Plenary presentation slidesOpening of Session 9 and of Opening Plenary Meeting 1400Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Opening Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule of meetings for the week Marks V
Membership and Voting 1410Rights of members observers and others Marks IAttendance list procedure Marin IVoting token procedure Marin I
Announcements 1415Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks ILogistics rooms breaks etc Marks IIndividual and Anti-Trust Marks IIEEE 80216 Patent Policies and Procedures Marks I
Approvals 1425Minutes of Session 8 (IEEE 80216-0017) Marks V
802161 1430Report Marks IEditing Mollenauer Petry 802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1440Report McGregor I
802163 1450Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1500Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1510Voting in Task Groups and Study Groups Marks I
New Business 1513
Closing 1515Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
11
Agenda for the Week
80216 Session 9 AgendaSchedule (tentative)
Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMo
n
RAWCONKeynote Address
Ballroom A-D120-150 pm
(80216 RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster
Session530-700 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCON Lunch1230-130 pm
(80216 RegistrantsInvited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster
Session530-700 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon 5
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG3Salon GH8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
12
Chairmans Opening Plenary Presentation
IEEE 80216 Session 9 Opening Plenary Meeting
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
NoneDate Submitted
2000-09-11Source
Roger Marks Voice +1-303-497-3037NIST Fax +1-303-497-7828325 Broadway MC 81300 E-mail marksnistgovBoulder CO 80303
VenueSession 9 Opening Plenary
Base DocumentNone
PurposeThis presentation is to be inserted in the Session 9 minutes
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) ororganization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to addamend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creationof an IEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contributionand at the IEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor alsoacknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16 iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including thestatement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms andconditions for the purpose of implementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chairltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt as early as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentsnoticesgt
IEEE 80216Working Group on
Broadband Wireless Access(BWA)
Session 9Opening Plenary
11 September 2000
200-315 pm
Session Opening
bull Call to Order
bull Welcome
80216 Officers
bull Chair Roger Marks
bull Vice Chair Lou Olsen
bull Secretary Scott Marin
Agenda
bull Presentation of 80216 OpeningPlenary Agendandash Chair asks for unanimous consent to
approve
bull Schedule of meetings for the weekndash Chair asks for unanimous consent to
approve
Rights of Allbull To subscribe to the 80216 Email Reflector
(stds-802-16) and thereby be notified ofdocument publication meetings minutes
bull To post to stds-802-16 in accordance with thereflector rules
bull To examine documents unless copyrightconcerns prohibit it
bull To contribute documents in response to aCall for Contributions
bull To attend and participate in 80216 meetingsif registered
bull To join the Sponsor Balloting Pool
IEEE and IEEE SA Membership
bull Members are encouraged to join IEEEIEEE Standards Association and IEEEComputer Society
bull Such membership is not required forWorking Group Membership ObserverStatus or Sponsor Ballot PoolGroup
Sponsor Ballot PoolGroup
bull Balloting Pool is being constructed
bull Future 80216 draft standards will beballoted by a Balloting Group drawn frommembers of the 80216 Balloting Pool
bull To join the 80216 Balloting Pool use theform on the web
bull Members of IEEE Standards Association[IEEE or CS + $10] can participate in BallotGroup without paying special fee
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
13
Rights of Members amp Observers
bull To examine draft standardsbull To participate in Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To examine the votes of Working
Group membersbull To examine the Member and Observer
contact databases
Exclusive Rights of Membershipbull To make or second a motion at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote if and only if present at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote in 80216 Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To vote by email on any issue involving
80216 or its subsidiariesbull To lodge complaints about Working Group
operation with the 802 Executive Committeebull To petition the 802 Executive Committee in
writing
Attendance Listbull Recorded at each ldquomeeting intervalrdquo
ndashAfternoon MonTueWedThundashMorning TueWedThuFri
ndashEvening Thu
ndashSelf-declared ldquosubstantially allrdquo of meetingndashSession ldquoParticipationrdquo 75 of meeting intervals
bull =will round down to 6
bull Attendance recorded in parallel meetingsndashvoting credit for presence at either
bull Attendance is public recordndashattendance will be reported on webndashcontact info will not be posted (just company)
Secretaryrsquos Announcementsbull Scott Marin
ndash Attendance books (four of them)
bull Write your namebull If new and unregistered insert business
card in pocketbull Initial and keep the book movingbull Remember your book and page number
ndash Voting tokensbull Printed on badge for Membersbull Raise to vote
Registration
bull $140
bull Registration fee form at front deskndashHotel guest charge to roomndashOthers credit card
bull Receive copy of form as receipt
Document Distributionbull Server http10001bull Run DHCPbull Use 10BaseT or 100BaseTXbull Use 80211b or 80211 DSSS Wireless
bull Upload files using anonymous ftp
bull Flash Card may be available
Logistics
bull Meeting Roomsndash Vary throughout the week
bull Breaksndash Always in large room (E or D)
bull RAWCON events
Individuality
bull In IEEE standards meetingsparticipation is by individualndash you do not represent a company or
organization
bull Membership belongs to the individualnot an organization and may not betransferred
Legal and Anti-Trust
bull Any discussions that relate to thevalidity or cost of patent use shall beavoided
bull Any discussions or any materialrelating to an ongoing litigation shallbe avoided
bull Any discussions of pricing or issuesthat would violate US antitrust lawsshall be avoided
IEEE 80216 Patent Policybull IEEE 80216 operates under the Patent Policy of
the IEEE Standards Association as set forth inClause 6 of the IEEE-SA Standards BoardBylaws This policy includes the statement
bull IEEE standards may include the known use ofpatent(s) including patent applications if there istechnical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and providedthe IEEE receives assurance from the patentholder that it will license applicants underreasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standard
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
14
IEEE 80216 Patent Policy (cont)bull IEEE 80216 interprets in the opinion of the standards-
developing committee as in the opinion of the members of theWorking Group Early disclosure to the Working Groupparticipants of patent information that might be relevant to thestandard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and to increase the likelihood that the draftpublication will be approved for publication IEEE 80216 strivesto make such information available as soon as possible forconsideration by individual members in their voting decisionsHowever in its meetings and electronic forums IEEE 80216does not permit discussions concerning the validity orapplicability of intellectual property claims The only role a patentclaim plays in Working Group discussions concerns ensuringcompliance to the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures
bull Justification for the inclusion of technology is limited to thetechnical merits of the technology
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresAnyone whether participating in IEEE 80216 or notshould notify the Chair of any patents (granted orunder application and regardless of the assignee orthe patent nationality) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved byIEEE 80216 Such notification should be in written orelectronic form (email is preferred) and need notmake any statement concerning enforcement orlicensing The Chair will presume that suchnotification is intended for public release and will assoon as practical post it to the web along with otherPatent Notices On File with IEEE 80216 The Chairand the Working Group will take no positionregarding the validity or applicability of any patents
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresWritten contributions to IEEE 80216 standards development willnot be accepted without an acknowledgement of familiarity with theIEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures Thisacknowledgement will be part of the mandatory contribution coversheet and will read
ldquoThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policyand Procedures (Version )
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information thatmight be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce thepossibility for delays in the development process andincrease the likelihood that the draft publication will beapproved for publication Please notify the Chair as early aspossible in written or electronic form of any patents (grantedor under application) that may cover technology that is underconsideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 TheChair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 websiterdquo
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresThe Chair once formally notified and once apotentially relevant draft standard exists shallwrite to the identified party and request that aLetter of Assurance be filed with the Chair forforwarding to the IEEE-SA Patent Committee inaccordance with the instructions in the IEEE-SAStandards Board Operations Manual A samplerequest letter and response letter are availableWhen the Patent Committee has accepted theletter as a Letter of Assurance informationregarding the letter will be indexed in the Recordsof IEEE Standards-Related Patents
Approval of Minutes
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to
ndash approve Document IEEE 80216-0017(Minutes of Session 8)
TG1 (802161)bull Air Interface for Fixed Broadband
Wireless Access Systemsbull 10-66 GHz
bull Chair Roger Marksbull Editor Jim MollenauerBrian Petrybull MAC Chair Carl Eklundbull PHY Chair Jay Klein
TG1 Goals for Week
ndashStay on Development PlanbullInitiative Working Group Letter BallotbullSeek approval at Closing Plenary
ndashMACbullComment resolutionbullMeet with TG3
ndashPHYbullComment resolutionbullOther contributionsbullMeet with TG2
TG2 (802162)ndashCoexistence of Broadband Wireless
Access Systems
ndashCo-Chair Andy McGregorndashCo-Chair Leland LangstonndashVice Chair Reacutemi Chayer
ndashEditor Vito Scaringindash Secretary Reza Arefi
TG3 (802163)bull Broadband Wireless Access Systems
in Licensed Bands from 2 to 11 GHzbull Chair Brian Kiernanbull Vice Chair Carl Bushuebull Secretary Dean Changbull Functional Requirements
ndashBrian PetryndashGeorge Fishel
WirelessHUMANTM Study Group
bull Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed MetropolitanArea Networks
bull Chair Durga Satapathybull Secretary Sanjay Moghe
bull Chartered at Session 6bull Renewed at Session 8bull Writing a PAR
bull To coordinate with 80211 and 80215
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
15
Charge to Task Groupsbull Complete the task on your agenda
ndashUpdate agenda on bulletin board
bull Prepare for next meetingndashCall for Contributions etc
bull Prepare for Closing Plenary
ndashAll motions to be in writingbull Document everything
ndash submit documents before you leavendash provide document index on bulletin board
bull Presentations to server 2 hours in advance
Voting in Task Groups
bull Only 80216 Voting Members may vote in taskGroup meetingsndashShow Voting Token
bull All present are eligible to vote at Study Groupmeetings
New Business
bull Request for New Business items
Adjournment
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to adjournthis meeting of Working Group 80216until the Midweek Plenaryndash(5-6 pm on Wednesday 13 September)
TG2 Status Report
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 1
IEEE 802162 Activities
Recommended Practice forCoexistence of BroadbandWireless Access Systems
Co-chairs Leland Langston Andy McGregor
Vice Chair Remi ChayerEditor Vito Scaringi
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 2
Activities since San DiegoMeeting
bull R7 of draft Practice issued late July
bull Several input docs and comments receivedbull Teleconference held Sept 7th ndash 8 participants
ndashSignificant discussion on content
bull R8 of draft Practice available Sept 11th
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 3
Plans for Denver
bull Close issue of single vs multiple interferers
bull Review doc for consistency amp completenessbull Present summary to joint TG1TG2bull Post R9 in week of Sept 18th
bull Seeking comments from any 80216 participant
bull TARGET TG ballot following Tampa meeting
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
16
Appendix B Midweek Plenary Presentations
Midweek Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Midweek Plenary Meeting AgendaWednesday 13 September 2000 1700-1800
Opening of Midweek Plenary Meeting 1700Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Midweek Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule Update Marks V
Announcements 1705
Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IAttendance books badges etc Marin I
802161 1710
Report Marks I802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1720Report McGregor I
802163 1730
Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1740
Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1745
Liaison 1750
ITU Costa ETSI BRAN Klein
Closing 1755
New Business (Marin Editorial Process) Marks VAdjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
17
Agenda for the Week as revised at the Midweek Plenary
80216 Session 9 Agenda Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMon
RAWCONKeynoteAddress
Ballroom A-D
120-150 pm(80216
RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCONLunch
1230-130pm
(80216Registrants
Invited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon G
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon H
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG16-730 pmSalon E
TG3Salon E
8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
TG3730-10 pm
Salon E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
18
Appendix C Closing Plenary Presentations
Closing Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Closing Plenary Meeting AgendaFriday 15 September 2000 10 am -1200 noon
Opening 1000Call to Order Marks IAgenda Marks V
Announcements 1003Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IVice Chair Marks I80216 Logo Marks D
WirelessHUMAN 1010Report Satapathy IPAR Approval Satapathy V
802161 1025Report Marks I802161 Working Group Review Marks V
802162 1050Report McGregor IFinal Task Group Review McGregor IMotions McGregor V
802163 1110Report Kiernan IMotions Kiernan V
Future Meetings 1130
Session 10 6-10 November 2000 Hyatt Regency Tampa Tampa Florida USA Marks ISunday Monday Friday at Session 10 Marks DSession 11 22-26 January 2001 Tel Aviv Israel Marks ISession 12 12-15 March 2001 Hyatt Regency Hilton Head South Carolina USA Marks ISession 13 7-11 May 2001 Orlando Florida USA along with IEEE 80211 and 80215 Marks I
Liaison 1135
ETSI BRANnotification of 802161 status and offer of password Marks V
Regulatory Agency notifications Robinson V
New Business 114080216 Editorial Policy MarinPetry V
Closing 1200
Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
19
WirelessHUMANtrade Closing Presentation[Insert Document Title Here]
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
[The appropriate coordinator normally the Task Group Chair will fill in this number after obtaining it from the 80216 Chair The
document number will match that of the base contribution with ldquoprdquo replacing ldquocrdquo For example 802161p-00nn]Date Submitted
[2000-07-13]Source
[Durga Satapathy] [Voice(913) 534-6338] [Sprint] [Fax (913) 534-6522] [7101 College Blvd Suite 1436 B] mailto[durgasatapathymailsprintcom [Overland Park KS 66210]
Venue
[IEEE 80216 Session 8]Base Document
[If this presentation illustrates an 80216 document cite the document number and URL lthttpieee802org16hellipgt]Purpose
[WirelessHUMAN Study Group report at closing plenary]Notice
This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s)The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw materialcontained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creation of anIEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution and at theIEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor also acknowledges and acceptsthat this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including the statementldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developingcommittee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purpose ofimplementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chair ltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt asearly as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology that is under consideration by or has beenapproved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentslettersgt
IEEE 80216 Plenary Report
Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed Metropolitan Area Network
(WirelessHUMANTM) Study Group
Durga P Satapathy
WirelessHUMANTM Update
bull Reviewed 8 contributions
bull Achieved consensus on selecting standardsto utilizemodifyndashMAC 80216ndashPHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
bull Drafted PAR and 5 criteria
WirelessHUMANTM PAR Scope This standard specifies the physical layer and media access control
layer of the air interface of interoperable fixed broadband wirelessmetropolitan area network systems including point-to-multipoint Thestandard enables access to data video and voice services with qualityof service in unlicensed bands designated for public network access Itwill focus on the 5-6 GHz range and may be applied to unlicensedbands between 2 and 11 GHz The WirelessHUMAN standard willutilize or modify applicable elements from the following
MAC 80216
PHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
The development of the WirelessHUMAN standard will follow thetimeline as shown in Appendix A
WirelessHUMANTM Timeline
bull Call For Proposals for WirelessHUMAN PHYMAC Nov 2000)ndash PHY Modifications of 80211a HIPERLAN2ndash MAC Modifications of 80216
bull Review proposals Jan 2001
bull Select candidate proposals at Interim meeting Feb 2001bull Decision on specific modifications March 2001
bull First Draft Standard May 2001
bull Comment Resolutions July 2001
bull Second Draft Standard Sep 2001bull Finalize WirelessHUMAN Standard Nov 2001
Purpose of Proposed Project
To enable rapid worldwide deployment of innovative cost-effectiveand interoperable multi-vendor broadband wireless metropolitan areanetwork products operating in the unlicensed bands To facilitatecompetition in broadband access by providing fixed wirelessalternatives to wireline broadband access Identify techniques totolerate interference in the unlicensed bands facilitate strategies forcoexistence with other unlicensed band systems such as 80211a andmaximize the carrying capacity of the unlicensed bands Encourageconsistent worldwide allocation and accelerate the commercializationof unlicensed broadband wireless access spectrum Utilization ofunlicensed frequencies will address a market that includes residencesSmall Office-Home Office (SOHO) telecommuters and Small andMedium Enterprises (SME)
WirelessHUMAN Study Group Participants
Sprint RF Solutions Agilent Technologies
Intel Breezecom Adaptive BroadbandNokia Transcomm Inc Cabletron
Ericsson BNA Systems WirelessHomeLucent Escape Carleton UniversityIntracom Malibu Networks Carnegie Mellon UniversityProxim Ultracom Georgia Institute of TechnologyWaveIP Harris Corporation HRL Laboratories LLCN Band Com Wireless Inc Western MultiplexCoreon Inc Cabletron systems Communications Research Center
Runcom Magnolia Broadband Yokogawa Electric CoInnowave ECI
Motion
The proposed WirelessHUMANTM PARbe accepted
TG1 MAC ClosingPresentation
(TG1 MAC reportppt)
1 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
TG1 MAC group
bull Resolved comments received during Final TaskGroup review
bull Major effort to remove any particular PHYdependence from the MAC
bull Process of adding features useful for TG3requirments started
bull Meeting with TG3
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
20
2 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
Important MAC decisions
bull Adoption of EUI-48 addresses (previouslyEUI-64)
bull Addition of error control to MAC layer(previously defined in TC layer of PHY B)
bull Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes into asingle mode
bull Redesigned DL MAP message for higherspectral efficiency
TG1 PHY ClosingPresentation
Document Number80216pp-
TitlePHY TG1 Report at Session 9
Date Submitted
91500Source
Jay KleinVenue
Denver September 2000Base Document
None
PurposeReport
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist the IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the
contributing individual(s) or organization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after furtherstudy The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by 80216
IEEE Patent Policy
The contributor is familiar with the IEEE Patent Policy which is set forth in the IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylawslthttpstandards ieeeorgguidesbylawsgt and includes the statement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s)
including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developing committee and provided theIEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standardrdquo
PHY TG1 Report Session 9
Jay KleinEnsemble Communications
Documents Submitted
bull 802161pc-0044 (2000-09-07) Recommendation onLMDS Radio Propagation Channel Models
bull 802161c-0007 (2000-09-10)FEC Parameterization for Data Transport (Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0006 (2000-09-08)FEC Parameterization for Control Channel Information(Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0004 (2000-09-01)Frequency Synthesizer Model Parameters (Lars Lindh andHans Somerma)
Documents Submitted ndash cont
bull 802161c-0003 (2000-09-01)Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes in802161 (Ken Stanwood)
bull 802161c-0001 (2000-08-08)Summary of Open PHY Issues in IEEE 802161-0001 (Jeff Foerster)
Work done
bull All editorial comments resolved
bull All technical comments reviewed andresolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull TBDs resolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull Met with MAC group for ldquosynchronizingrdquo
TG3 Closing Presentation
802163 Task Group Reportbull Finished and Adopted Functional
Requirements Document except for editorialsndashOutput Comment database on server
bull Developed an initial List of EvaluationCriteria for PHY proposal evaluations FullCriteria to be developed at next meeting
bull Issuing two calls for contributionsndashPreliminary PHY proposalsndashDeployment Traffic and Propagation
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS
bull Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull Session 10 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband WirelessAccess will be held on 6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA In orderto assist in the evaluation of air interface proposals the 802163 Task Groupinvites contributions addressing the following issues
lang Traffic and deployment models based on single and multi-cellsystems
lang Channel propagation model
bull Contributions must be submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt Submissions will beconsidered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible followingreceipt for public access on the 80216 Web Site Email your contribution tothe 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernanltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 Chair Roger Marksltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS - Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull The Task Group 3 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access is preparing to define the PHY protocols for abroadband wireless access air interface specification for frequencies from 2 through 11 GHz The specification will be based on submittedcontributions with increasing detail required as the process progresses Mergers and improvements will be encouraged with final selectionscheduled for June 2001
bull The TG3 Task Group invites the submission of initial contributions representing proposed PHY solutions Contributors will be grantedagenda time during 80216 Working Group Session 10 (6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA) to present and discuss the merits oftheir proposals Only submissions to session 10 will be eligible for invitation to submit more detailed proposals to session 11 Eachproposal will be allocated equal agenda time on Tuesday November 7 If time permits the allocations will be 15 minutes of presentationfollowed by 15 minutes of discussion Submissions must follow the guidelines below
lang Include a descriptive titlelang Include an overview and a reference model that describes functions including interfaces to other layerslang Describe the benefits of the proposed PHY including any unique featureslang Describe any drawbacks of the proposed PHY
bull Explain how the submitted PHY relates to existing standards such as ITU-R JRG 8A-9B IEEE 80211 DOCSIS 11 ETSI HiperLAN orothers If it is based on an existing standard what differences occur due to BWA characteristics
lang Emphasize the scalability of the proposed PHY to deal efficiently with various data types as described in the 802163Functional Requirements Document
lang Include a statement on intellectual property rights and how 80216 may utilize the proposed PHY in a standard
bull The proposals will be evaluated based on criteria in the Evaluation Table below However at this initial stage contributions are not expectedto address in detail the discussion items in that table instead aiming for the more general description as outlined above Each of the VotingMembers of 80216 are eligible to participate in the evaluation if present Submitters receiving a combined score of 6 or better (out of 10) inany criterion in the Evaluation Table will be invited to submit more a detailed contribution for Session 11 (January 22-26 2001 in Tel AvivIsrael) Note that submissions need not represent a complete PHY but may focus on specific components
bull Contributions will be considered only if submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216 Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt The template requires a cover page and a narrative
bull Submissions will be considered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible following receipt for public access on the 80216Web Site lthttpieee802org16gt
bull Email your contribution to the 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernan ltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 ChairRoger Marks ltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
802163 Task Group Report
bull Officially Adopted TG1 MAC as TG3 DraftMAC
bull Create TG3 MAC Ad Hoc to review TG1MAC and provide TG3 Comments
bull Two Motions for the Working GroupndashLiaison to ETSI BRAN sub11 GHz WGndashEstablishment of 80216 Common MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
21
Motion 1
That the 80216 Working Group appoint ChetShirali as a liaison to the ETSI BRAN sub11GHz Working Group
Motion 2
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MACbullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
22
Appendix D Attendance at Session9Session9 was an interim session The 75 interval attendance criteria for Session 9 was 6 ormore intervals Please contact the 80216 Secretary (smarinixnetcomcom) if you feel yourattendance has been recorded incorrectly
The following 126 peopleregistered attendance at 6or more intervals and metthe attendance criteria
Aboukarr BakriAn SongArefi RezaArunachalam ArunAvera DraytAvivi EliAyyagari DeepakBaragar IanBaseghi BehshadBaugh CR (Rick)Belfiore CarlosBenyamin-Seeyar AnaderBushue CarlBuskila BaruchChan RebeccaChang DeanChayer ReacutemiCondie MaryCornelius JamesCosta JoseacuteCrilly Jr William JDoherty EdwardEdmonston BrainEidson BrianEklund CarlEl-Damhougy HeshamFishel GeorgeFoerster JeffreyGarrison G JackGesbert DavidGoldhammer MariannaGuillemette PhilGupta RakeshHadad ZionHall EricHamilton MichaelHammons RogerHatim BayaHebron YoanHilberman DanHosur SrinathHsuan YiHudson ThomasHum ColemanHunter WayneJacobsen EricJamali Hamadi
Jorgensen JacobKang InchulKasslin MikaKiernan BrianKim JohnKitroser ItzikKlein JayKolze ThomasKostas DemosKwak Byung-JaeKwak JoeLangley John BLangston J LelandLeiba YigalLewis BarryLicardie SergioLiebetreu JohnLindh LarsLo TitusMarin ScottMarks RogerMcCallister RonMcGregor AndyMcMullin RoderickMeyer RonaldMiddleton AndrewMizoguchi MasatoMody ApurvaMollenauer JamesPadan UziPetry BrianPleasant WayneRalston WilliamRan MosheResheff GuyRhodes ValentineRobinson GeneRoehr WaltRzeszewski TedSantacesaria ClaudioSatapathy DurgaSater GlenScaringi VitoScarpa CarlSchwartz RandallSegal YossiSellars MalcolmShan Tie-JunShimada ShusakuShirali ChetSkaar HelgeSmith SteveStamatelos George
Stambaugh KarlStanwood KenStewart MichaelStruhsaker PaulSydor JohnTappenden ChrisTateishi KimiyaTavormina JoeThomas RaymondThompson PaulTrinkwon DavidVan Waes NicoVarma SubirWachira MuyaWang ArthurWang Chao-ChunWang LeiWang XiaofengWard BobWhitehead PhilipWhiting RobertWilliams David GWise CurtWiss JohnYanover VladimirZuniga Juan Carlos
The following 18 peopleregistered attendance atless than 6 intervals anddid not meet theattendance criteria
Alspaugh MatthewCarlo JimFalconer DavidFoley MarkFoster RobertGupta AlokHancock DaleHarel HaimKhanna AmarpalKreig AndrewMonk AntonNadeau JamesOng Ling ChuenRafie ManouchehrRibner David BWheatley Chuck FYang S MichaelYurtkuran Erol
Motion 5
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MAC based on802161-0001r4bullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
Appendix E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
11
Agenda for the Week
80216 Session 9 AgendaSchedule (tentative)
Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMo
n
RAWCONKeynote Address
Ballroom A-D120-150 pm
(80216 RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster
Session530-700 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCON Lunch1230-130 pm
(80216 RegistrantsInvited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster
Session530-700 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon 5
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG3Salon GH8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
12
Chairmans Opening Plenary Presentation
IEEE 80216 Session 9 Opening Plenary Meeting
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
NoneDate Submitted
2000-09-11Source
Roger Marks Voice +1-303-497-3037NIST Fax +1-303-497-7828325 Broadway MC 81300 E-mail marksnistgovBoulder CO 80303
VenueSession 9 Opening Plenary
Base DocumentNone
PurposeThis presentation is to be inserted in the Session 9 minutes
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) ororganization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to addamend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creationof an IEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contributionand at the IEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor alsoacknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16 iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including thestatement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms andconditions for the purpose of implementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chairltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt as early as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentsnoticesgt
IEEE 80216Working Group on
Broadband Wireless Access(BWA)
Session 9Opening Plenary
11 September 2000
200-315 pm
Session Opening
bull Call to Order
bull Welcome
80216 Officers
bull Chair Roger Marks
bull Vice Chair Lou Olsen
bull Secretary Scott Marin
Agenda
bull Presentation of 80216 OpeningPlenary Agendandash Chair asks for unanimous consent to
approve
bull Schedule of meetings for the weekndash Chair asks for unanimous consent to
approve
Rights of Allbull To subscribe to the 80216 Email Reflector
(stds-802-16) and thereby be notified ofdocument publication meetings minutes
bull To post to stds-802-16 in accordance with thereflector rules
bull To examine documents unless copyrightconcerns prohibit it
bull To contribute documents in response to aCall for Contributions
bull To attend and participate in 80216 meetingsif registered
bull To join the Sponsor Balloting Pool
IEEE and IEEE SA Membership
bull Members are encouraged to join IEEEIEEE Standards Association and IEEEComputer Society
bull Such membership is not required forWorking Group Membership ObserverStatus or Sponsor Ballot PoolGroup
Sponsor Ballot PoolGroup
bull Balloting Pool is being constructed
bull Future 80216 draft standards will beballoted by a Balloting Group drawn frommembers of the 80216 Balloting Pool
bull To join the 80216 Balloting Pool use theform on the web
bull Members of IEEE Standards Association[IEEE or CS + $10] can participate in BallotGroup without paying special fee
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
13
Rights of Members amp Observers
bull To examine draft standardsbull To participate in Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To examine the votes of Working
Group membersbull To examine the Member and Observer
contact databases
Exclusive Rights of Membershipbull To make or second a motion at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote if and only if present at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote in 80216 Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To vote by email on any issue involving
80216 or its subsidiariesbull To lodge complaints about Working Group
operation with the 802 Executive Committeebull To petition the 802 Executive Committee in
writing
Attendance Listbull Recorded at each ldquomeeting intervalrdquo
ndashAfternoon MonTueWedThundashMorning TueWedThuFri
ndashEvening Thu
ndashSelf-declared ldquosubstantially allrdquo of meetingndashSession ldquoParticipationrdquo 75 of meeting intervals
bull =will round down to 6
bull Attendance recorded in parallel meetingsndashvoting credit for presence at either
bull Attendance is public recordndashattendance will be reported on webndashcontact info will not be posted (just company)
Secretaryrsquos Announcementsbull Scott Marin
ndash Attendance books (four of them)
bull Write your namebull If new and unregistered insert business
card in pocketbull Initial and keep the book movingbull Remember your book and page number
ndash Voting tokensbull Printed on badge for Membersbull Raise to vote
Registration
bull $140
bull Registration fee form at front deskndashHotel guest charge to roomndashOthers credit card
bull Receive copy of form as receipt
Document Distributionbull Server http10001bull Run DHCPbull Use 10BaseT or 100BaseTXbull Use 80211b or 80211 DSSS Wireless
bull Upload files using anonymous ftp
bull Flash Card may be available
Logistics
bull Meeting Roomsndash Vary throughout the week
bull Breaksndash Always in large room (E or D)
bull RAWCON events
Individuality
bull In IEEE standards meetingsparticipation is by individualndash you do not represent a company or
organization
bull Membership belongs to the individualnot an organization and may not betransferred
Legal and Anti-Trust
bull Any discussions that relate to thevalidity or cost of patent use shall beavoided
bull Any discussions or any materialrelating to an ongoing litigation shallbe avoided
bull Any discussions of pricing or issuesthat would violate US antitrust lawsshall be avoided
IEEE 80216 Patent Policybull IEEE 80216 operates under the Patent Policy of
the IEEE Standards Association as set forth inClause 6 of the IEEE-SA Standards BoardBylaws This policy includes the statement
bull IEEE standards may include the known use ofpatent(s) including patent applications if there istechnical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and providedthe IEEE receives assurance from the patentholder that it will license applicants underreasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standard
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
14
IEEE 80216 Patent Policy (cont)bull IEEE 80216 interprets in the opinion of the standards-
developing committee as in the opinion of the members of theWorking Group Early disclosure to the Working Groupparticipants of patent information that might be relevant to thestandard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and to increase the likelihood that the draftpublication will be approved for publication IEEE 80216 strivesto make such information available as soon as possible forconsideration by individual members in their voting decisionsHowever in its meetings and electronic forums IEEE 80216does not permit discussions concerning the validity orapplicability of intellectual property claims The only role a patentclaim plays in Working Group discussions concerns ensuringcompliance to the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures
bull Justification for the inclusion of technology is limited to thetechnical merits of the technology
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresAnyone whether participating in IEEE 80216 or notshould notify the Chair of any patents (granted orunder application and regardless of the assignee orthe patent nationality) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved byIEEE 80216 Such notification should be in written orelectronic form (email is preferred) and need notmake any statement concerning enforcement orlicensing The Chair will presume that suchnotification is intended for public release and will assoon as practical post it to the web along with otherPatent Notices On File with IEEE 80216 The Chairand the Working Group will take no positionregarding the validity or applicability of any patents
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresWritten contributions to IEEE 80216 standards development willnot be accepted without an acknowledgement of familiarity with theIEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures Thisacknowledgement will be part of the mandatory contribution coversheet and will read
ldquoThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policyand Procedures (Version )
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information thatmight be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce thepossibility for delays in the development process andincrease the likelihood that the draft publication will beapproved for publication Please notify the Chair as early aspossible in written or electronic form of any patents (grantedor under application) that may cover technology that is underconsideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 TheChair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 websiterdquo
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresThe Chair once formally notified and once apotentially relevant draft standard exists shallwrite to the identified party and request that aLetter of Assurance be filed with the Chair forforwarding to the IEEE-SA Patent Committee inaccordance with the instructions in the IEEE-SAStandards Board Operations Manual A samplerequest letter and response letter are availableWhen the Patent Committee has accepted theletter as a Letter of Assurance informationregarding the letter will be indexed in the Recordsof IEEE Standards-Related Patents
Approval of Minutes
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to
ndash approve Document IEEE 80216-0017(Minutes of Session 8)
TG1 (802161)bull Air Interface for Fixed Broadband
Wireless Access Systemsbull 10-66 GHz
bull Chair Roger Marksbull Editor Jim MollenauerBrian Petrybull MAC Chair Carl Eklundbull PHY Chair Jay Klein
TG1 Goals for Week
ndashStay on Development PlanbullInitiative Working Group Letter BallotbullSeek approval at Closing Plenary
ndashMACbullComment resolutionbullMeet with TG3
ndashPHYbullComment resolutionbullOther contributionsbullMeet with TG2
TG2 (802162)ndashCoexistence of Broadband Wireless
Access Systems
ndashCo-Chair Andy McGregorndashCo-Chair Leland LangstonndashVice Chair Reacutemi Chayer
ndashEditor Vito Scaringindash Secretary Reza Arefi
TG3 (802163)bull Broadband Wireless Access Systems
in Licensed Bands from 2 to 11 GHzbull Chair Brian Kiernanbull Vice Chair Carl Bushuebull Secretary Dean Changbull Functional Requirements
ndashBrian PetryndashGeorge Fishel
WirelessHUMANTM Study Group
bull Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed MetropolitanArea Networks
bull Chair Durga Satapathybull Secretary Sanjay Moghe
bull Chartered at Session 6bull Renewed at Session 8bull Writing a PAR
bull To coordinate with 80211 and 80215
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
15
Charge to Task Groupsbull Complete the task on your agenda
ndashUpdate agenda on bulletin board
bull Prepare for next meetingndashCall for Contributions etc
bull Prepare for Closing Plenary
ndashAll motions to be in writingbull Document everything
ndash submit documents before you leavendash provide document index on bulletin board
bull Presentations to server 2 hours in advance
Voting in Task Groups
bull Only 80216 Voting Members may vote in taskGroup meetingsndashShow Voting Token
bull All present are eligible to vote at Study Groupmeetings
New Business
bull Request for New Business items
Adjournment
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to adjournthis meeting of Working Group 80216until the Midweek Plenaryndash(5-6 pm on Wednesday 13 September)
TG2 Status Report
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 1
IEEE 802162 Activities
Recommended Practice forCoexistence of BroadbandWireless Access Systems
Co-chairs Leland Langston Andy McGregor
Vice Chair Remi ChayerEditor Vito Scaringi
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 2
Activities since San DiegoMeeting
bull R7 of draft Practice issued late July
bull Several input docs and comments receivedbull Teleconference held Sept 7th ndash 8 participants
ndashSignificant discussion on content
bull R8 of draft Practice available Sept 11th
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 3
Plans for Denver
bull Close issue of single vs multiple interferers
bull Review doc for consistency amp completenessbull Present summary to joint TG1TG2bull Post R9 in week of Sept 18th
bull Seeking comments from any 80216 participant
bull TARGET TG ballot following Tampa meeting
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
16
Appendix B Midweek Plenary Presentations
Midweek Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Midweek Plenary Meeting AgendaWednesday 13 September 2000 1700-1800
Opening of Midweek Plenary Meeting 1700Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Midweek Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule Update Marks V
Announcements 1705
Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IAttendance books badges etc Marin I
802161 1710
Report Marks I802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1720Report McGregor I
802163 1730
Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1740
Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1745
Liaison 1750
ITU Costa ETSI BRAN Klein
Closing 1755
New Business (Marin Editorial Process) Marks VAdjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
17
Agenda for the Week as revised at the Midweek Plenary
80216 Session 9 Agenda Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMon
RAWCONKeynoteAddress
Ballroom A-D
120-150 pm(80216
RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCONLunch
1230-130pm
(80216Registrants
Invited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon G
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon H
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG16-730 pmSalon E
TG3Salon E
8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
TG3730-10 pm
Salon E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
18
Appendix C Closing Plenary Presentations
Closing Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Closing Plenary Meeting AgendaFriday 15 September 2000 10 am -1200 noon
Opening 1000Call to Order Marks IAgenda Marks V
Announcements 1003Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IVice Chair Marks I80216 Logo Marks D
WirelessHUMAN 1010Report Satapathy IPAR Approval Satapathy V
802161 1025Report Marks I802161 Working Group Review Marks V
802162 1050Report McGregor IFinal Task Group Review McGregor IMotions McGregor V
802163 1110Report Kiernan IMotions Kiernan V
Future Meetings 1130
Session 10 6-10 November 2000 Hyatt Regency Tampa Tampa Florida USA Marks ISunday Monday Friday at Session 10 Marks DSession 11 22-26 January 2001 Tel Aviv Israel Marks ISession 12 12-15 March 2001 Hyatt Regency Hilton Head South Carolina USA Marks ISession 13 7-11 May 2001 Orlando Florida USA along with IEEE 80211 and 80215 Marks I
Liaison 1135
ETSI BRANnotification of 802161 status and offer of password Marks V
Regulatory Agency notifications Robinson V
New Business 114080216 Editorial Policy MarinPetry V
Closing 1200
Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
19
WirelessHUMANtrade Closing Presentation[Insert Document Title Here]
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
[The appropriate coordinator normally the Task Group Chair will fill in this number after obtaining it from the 80216 Chair The
document number will match that of the base contribution with ldquoprdquo replacing ldquocrdquo For example 802161p-00nn]Date Submitted
[2000-07-13]Source
[Durga Satapathy] [Voice(913) 534-6338] [Sprint] [Fax (913) 534-6522] [7101 College Blvd Suite 1436 B] mailto[durgasatapathymailsprintcom [Overland Park KS 66210]
Venue
[IEEE 80216 Session 8]Base Document
[If this presentation illustrates an 80216 document cite the document number and URL lthttpieee802org16hellipgt]Purpose
[WirelessHUMAN Study Group report at closing plenary]Notice
This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s)The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw materialcontained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creation of anIEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution and at theIEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor also acknowledges and acceptsthat this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including the statementldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developingcommittee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purpose ofimplementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chair ltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt asearly as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology that is under consideration by or has beenapproved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentslettersgt
IEEE 80216 Plenary Report
Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed Metropolitan Area Network
(WirelessHUMANTM) Study Group
Durga P Satapathy
WirelessHUMANTM Update
bull Reviewed 8 contributions
bull Achieved consensus on selecting standardsto utilizemodifyndashMAC 80216ndashPHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
bull Drafted PAR and 5 criteria
WirelessHUMANTM PAR Scope This standard specifies the physical layer and media access control
layer of the air interface of interoperable fixed broadband wirelessmetropolitan area network systems including point-to-multipoint Thestandard enables access to data video and voice services with qualityof service in unlicensed bands designated for public network access Itwill focus on the 5-6 GHz range and may be applied to unlicensedbands between 2 and 11 GHz The WirelessHUMAN standard willutilize or modify applicable elements from the following
MAC 80216
PHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
The development of the WirelessHUMAN standard will follow thetimeline as shown in Appendix A
WirelessHUMANTM Timeline
bull Call For Proposals for WirelessHUMAN PHYMAC Nov 2000)ndash PHY Modifications of 80211a HIPERLAN2ndash MAC Modifications of 80216
bull Review proposals Jan 2001
bull Select candidate proposals at Interim meeting Feb 2001bull Decision on specific modifications March 2001
bull First Draft Standard May 2001
bull Comment Resolutions July 2001
bull Second Draft Standard Sep 2001bull Finalize WirelessHUMAN Standard Nov 2001
Purpose of Proposed Project
To enable rapid worldwide deployment of innovative cost-effectiveand interoperable multi-vendor broadband wireless metropolitan areanetwork products operating in the unlicensed bands To facilitatecompetition in broadband access by providing fixed wirelessalternatives to wireline broadband access Identify techniques totolerate interference in the unlicensed bands facilitate strategies forcoexistence with other unlicensed band systems such as 80211a andmaximize the carrying capacity of the unlicensed bands Encourageconsistent worldwide allocation and accelerate the commercializationof unlicensed broadband wireless access spectrum Utilization ofunlicensed frequencies will address a market that includes residencesSmall Office-Home Office (SOHO) telecommuters and Small andMedium Enterprises (SME)
WirelessHUMAN Study Group Participants
Sprint RF Solutions Agilent Technologies
Intel Breezecom Adaptive BroadbandNokia Transcomm Inc Cabletron
Ericsson BNA Systems WirelessHomeLucent Escape Carleton UniversityIntracom Malibu Networks Carnegie Mellon UniversityProxim Ultracom Georgia Institute of TechnologyWaveIP Harris Corporation HRL Laboratories LLCN Band Com Wireless Inc Western MultiplexCoreon Inc Cabletron systems Communications Research Center
Runcom Magnolia Broadband Yokogawa Electric CoInnowave ECI
Motion
The proposed WirelessHUMANTM PARbe accepted
TG1 MAC ClosingPresentation
(TG1 MAC reportppt)
1 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
TG1 MAC group
bull Resolved comments received during Final TaskGroup review
bull Major effort to remove any particular PHYdependence from the MAC
bull Process of adding features useful for TG3requirments started
bull Meeting with TG3
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
20
2 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
Important MAC decisions
bull Adoption of EUI-48 addresses (previouslyEUI-64)
bull Addition of error control to MAC layer(previously defined in TC layer of PHY B)
bull Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes into asingle mode
bull Redesigned DL MAP message for higherspectral efficiency
TG1 PHY ClosingPresentation
Document Number80216pp-
TitlePHY TG1 Report at Session 9
Date Submitted
91500Source
Jay KleinVenue
Denver September 2000Base Document
None
PurposeReport
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist the IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the
contributing individual(s) or organization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after furtherstudy The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by 80216
IEEE Patent Policy
The contributor is familiar with the IEEE Patent Policy which is set forth in the IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylawslthttpstandards ieeeorgguidesbylawsgt and includes the statement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s)
including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developing committee and provided theIEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standardrdquo
PHY TG1 Report Session 9
Jay KleinEnsemble Communications
Documents Submitted
bull 802161pc-0044 (2000-09-07) Recommendation onLMDS Radio Propagation Channel Models
bull 802161c-0007 (2000-09-10)FEC Parameterization for Data Transport (Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0006 (2000-09-08)FEC Parameterization for Control Channel Information(Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0004 (2000-09-01)Frequency Synthesizer Model Parameters (Lars Lindh andHans Somerma)
Documents Submitted ndash cont
bull 802161c-0003 (2000-09-01)Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes in802161 (Ken Stanwood)
bull 802161c-0001 (2000-08-08)Summary of Open PHY Issues in IEEE 802161-0001 (Jeff Foerster)
Work done
bull All editorial comments resolved
bull All technical comments reviewed andresolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull TBDs resolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull Met with MAC group for ldquosynchronizingrdquo
TG3 Closing Presentation
802163 Task Group Reportbull Finished and Adopted Functional
Requirements Document except for editorialsndashOutput Comment database on server
bull Developed an initial List of EvaluationCriteria for PHY proposal evaluations FullCriteria to be developed at next meeting
bull Issuing two calls for contributionsndashPreliminary PHY proposalsndashDeployment Traffic and Propagation
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS
bull Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull Session 10 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband WirelessAccess will be held on 6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA In orderto assist in the evaluation of air interface proposals the 802163 Task Groupinvites contributions addressing the following issues
lang Traffic and deployment models based on single and multi-cellsystems
lang Channel propagation model
bull Contributions must be submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt Submissions will beconsidered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible followingreceipt for public access on the 80216 Web Site Email your contribution tothe 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernanltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 Chair Roger Marksltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS - Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull The Task Group 3 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access is preparing to define the PHY protocols for abroadband wireless access air interface specification for frequencies from 2 through 11 GHz The specification will be based on submittedcontributions with increasing detail required as the process progresses Mergers and improvements will be encouraged with final selectionscheduled for June 2001
bull The TG3 Task Group invites the submission of initial contributions representing proposed PHY solutions Contributors will be grantedagenda time during 80216 Working Group Session 10 (6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA) to present and discuss the merits oftheir proposals Only submissions to session 10 will be eligible for invitation to submit more detailed proposals to session 11 Eachproposal will be allocated equal agenda time on Tuesday November 7 If time permits the allocations will be 15 minutes of presentationfollowed by 15 minutes of discussion Submissions must follow the guidelines below
lang Include a descriptive titlelang Include an overview and a reference model that describes functions including interfaces to other layerslang Describe the benefits of the proposed PHY including any unique featureslang Describe any drawbacks of the proposed PHY
bull Explain how the submitted PHY relates to existing standards such as ITU-R JRG 8A-9B IEEE 80211 DOCSIS 11 ETSI HiperLAN orothers If it is based on an existing standard what differences occur due to BWA characteristics
lang Emphasize the scalability of the proposed PHY to deal efficiently with various data types as described in the 802163Functional Requirements Document
lang Include a statement on intellectual property rights and how 80216 may utilize the proposed PHY in a standard
bull The proposals will be evaluated based on criteria in the Evaluation Table below However at this initial stage contributions are not expectedto address in detail the discussion items in that table instead aiming for the more general description as outlined above Each of the VotingMembers of 80216 are eligible to participate in the evaluation if present Submitters receiving a combined score of 6 or better (out of 10) inany criterion in the Evaluation Table will be invited to submit more a detailed contribution for Session 11 (January 22-26 2001 in Tel AvivIsrael) Note that submissions need not represent a complete PHY but may focus on specific components
bull Contributions will be considered only if submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216 Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt The template requires a cover page and a narrative
bull Submissions will be considered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible following receipt for public access on the 80216Web Site lthttpieee802org16gt
bull Email your contribution to the 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernan ltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 ChairRoger Marks ltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
802163 Task Group Report
bull Officially Adopted TG1 MAC as TG3 DraftMAC
bull Create TG3 MAC Ad Hoc to review TG1MAC and provide TG3 Comments
bull Two Motions for the Working GroupndashLiaison to ETSI BRAN sub11 GHz WGndashEstablishment of 80216 Common MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
21
Motion 1
That the 80216 Working Group appoint ChetShirali as a liaison to the ETSI BRAN sub11GHz Working Group
Motion 2
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MACbullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
22
Appendix D Attendance at Session9Session9 was an interim session The 75 interval attendance criteria for Session 9 was 6 ormore intervals Please contact the 80216 Secretary (smarinixnetcomcom) if you feel yourattendance has been recorded incorrectly
The following 126 peopleregistered attendance at 6or more intervals and metthe attendance criteria
Aboukarr BakriAn SongArefi RezaArunachalam ArunAvera DraytAvivi EliAyyagari DeepakBaragar IanBaseghi BehshadBaugh CR (Rick)Belfiore CarlosBenyamin-Seeyar AnaderBushue CarlBuskila BaruchChan RebeccaChang DeanChayer ReacutemiCondie MaryCornelius JamesCosta JoseacuteCrilly Jr William JDoherty EdwardEdmonston BrainEidson BrianEklund CarlEl-Damhougy HeshamFishel GeorgeFoerster JeffreyGarrison G JackGesbert DavidGoldhammer MariannaGuillemette PhilGupta RakeshHadad ZionHall EricHamilton MichaelHammons RogerHatim BayaHebron YoanHilberman DanHosur SrinathHsuan YiHudson ThomasHum ColemanHunter WayneJacobsen EricJamali Hamadi
Jorgensen JacobKang InchulKasslin MikaKiernan BrianKim JohnKitroser ItzikKlein JayKolze ThomasKostas DemosKwak Byung-JaeKwak JoeLangley John BLangston J LelandLeiba YigalLewis BarryLicardie SergioLiebetreu JohnLindh LarsLo TitusMarin ScottMarks RogerMcCallister RonMcGregor AndyMcMullin RoderickMeyer RonaldMiddleton AndrewMizoguchi MasatoMody ApurvaMollenauer JamesPadan UziPetry BrianPleasant WayneRalston WilliamRan MosheResheff GuyRhodes ValentineRobinson GeneRoehr WaltRzeszewski TedSantacesaria ClaudioSatapathy DurgaSater GlenScaringi VitoScarpa CarlSchwartz RandallSegal YossiSellars MalcolmShan Tie-JunShimada ShusakuShirali ChetSkaar HelgeSmith SteveStamatelos George
Stambaugh KarlStanwood KenStewart MichaelStruhsaker PaulSydor JohnTappenden ChrisTateishi KimiyaTavormina JoeThomas RaymondThompson PaulTrinkwon DavidVan Waes NicoVarma SubirWachira MuyaWang ArthurWang Chao-ChunWang LeiWang XiaofengWard BobWhitehead PhilipWhiting RobertWilliams David GWise CurtWiss JohnYanover VladimirZuniga Juan Carlos
The following 18 peopleregistered attendance atless than 6 intervals anddid not meet theattendance criteria
Alspaugh MatthewCarlo JimFalconer DavidFoley MarkFoster RobertGupta AlokHancock DaleHarel HaimKhanna AmarpalKreig AndrewMonk AntonNadeau JamesOng Ling ChuenRafie ManouchehrRibner David BWheatley Chuck FYang S MichaelYurtkuran Erol
Motion 5
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MAC based on802161-0001r4bullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
Appendix E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
12
Chairmans Opening Plenary Presentation
IEEE 80216 Session 9 Opening Plenary Meeting
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
NoneDate Submitted
2000-09-11Source
Roger Marks Voice +1-303-497-3037NIST Fax +1-303-497-7828325 Broadway MC 81300 E-mail marksnistgovBoulder CO 80303
VenueSession 9 Opening Plenary
Base DocumentNone
PurposeThis presentation is to be inserted in the Session 9 minutes
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) ororganization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to addamend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creationof an IEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contributionand at the IEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor alsoacknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16 iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including thestatement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms andconditions for the purpose of implementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chairltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt as early as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentsnoticesgt
IEEE 80216Working Group on
Broadband Wireless Access(BWA)
Session 9Opening Plenary
11 September 2000
200-315 pm
Session Opening
bull Call to Order
bull Welcome
80216 Officers
bull Chair Roger Marks
bull Vice Chair Lou Olsen
bull Secretary Scott Marin
Agenda
bull Presentation of 80216 OpeningPlenary Agendandash Chair asks for unanimous consent to
approve
bull Schedule of meetings for the weekndash Chair asks for unanimous consent to
approve
Rights of Allbull To subscribe to the 80216 Email Reflector
(stds-802-16) and thereby be notified ofdocument publication meetings minutes
bull To post to stds-802-16 in accordance with thereflector rules
bull To examine documents unless copyrightconcerns prohibit it
bull To contribute documents in response to aCall for Contributions
bull To attend and participate in 80216 meetingsif registered
bull To join the Sponsor Balloting Pool
IEEE and IEEE SA Membership
bull Members are encouraged to join IEEEIEEE Standards Association and IEEEComputer Society
bull Such membership is not required forWorking Group Membership ObserverStatus or Sponsor Ballot PoolGroup
Sponsor Ballot PoolGroup
bull Balloting Pool is being constructed
bull Future 80216 draft standards will beballoted by a Balloting Group drawn frommembers of the 80216 Balloting Pool
bull To join the 80216 Balloting Pool use theform on the web
bull Members of IEEE Standards Association[IEEE or CS + $10] can participate in BallotGroup without paying special fee
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
13
Rights of Members amp Observers
bull To examine draft standardsbull To participate in Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To examine the votes of Working
Group membersbull To examine the Member and Observer
contact databases
Exclusive Rights of Membershipbull To make or second a motion at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote if and only if present at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote in 80216 Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To vote by email on any issue involving
80216 or its subsidiariesbull To lodge complaints about Working Group
operation with the 802 Executive Committeebull To petition the 802 Executive Committee in
writing
Attendance Listbull Recorded at each ldquomeeting intervalrdquo
ndashAfternoon MonTueWedThundashMorning TueWedThuFri
ndashEvening Thu
ndashSelf-declared ldquosubstantially allrdquo of meetingndashSession ldquoParticipationrdquo 75 of meeting intervals
bull =will round down to 6
bull Attendance recorded in parallel meetingsndashvoting credit for presence at either
bull Attendance is public recordndashattendance will be reported on webndashcontact info will not be posted (just company)
Secretaryrsquos Announcementsbull Scott Marin
ndash Attendance books (four of them)
bull Write your namebull If new and unregistered insert business
card in pocketbull Initial and keep the book movingbull Remember your book and page number
ndash Voting tokensbull Printed on badge for Membersbull Raise to vote
Registration
bull $140
bull Registration fee form at front deskndashHotel guest charge to roomndashOthers credit card
bull Receive copy of form as receipt
Document Distributionbull Server http10001bull Run DHCPbull Use 10BaseT or 100BaseTXbull Use 80211b or 80211 DSSS Wireless
bull Upload files using anonymous ftp
bull Flash Card may be available
Logistics
bull Meeting Roomsndash Vary throughout the week
bull Breaksndash Always in large room (E or D)
bull RAWCON events
Individuality
bull In IEEE standards meetingsparticipation is by individualndash you do not represent a company or
organization
bull Membership belongs to the individualnot an organization and may not betransferred
Legal and Anti-Trust
bull Any discussions that relate to thevalidity or cost of patent use shall beavoided
bull Any discussions or any materialrelating to an ongoing litigation shallbe avoided
bull Any discussions of pricing or issuesthat would violate US antitrust lawsshall be avoided
IEEE 80216 Patent Policybull IEEE 80216 operates under the Patent Policy of
the IEEE Standards Association as set forth inClause 6 of the IEEE-SA Standards BoardBylaws This policy includes the statement
bull IEEE standards may include the known use ofpatent(s) including patent applications if there istechnical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and providedthe IEEE receives assurance from the patentholder that it will license applicants underreasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standard
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
14
IEEE 80216 Patent Policy (cont)bull IEEE 80216 interprets in the opinion of the standards-
developing committee as in the opinion of the members of theWorking Group Early disclosure to the Working Groupparticipants of patent information that might be relevant to thestandard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and to increase the likelihood that the draftpublication will be approved for publication IEEE 80216 strivesto make such information available as soon as possible forconsideration by individual members in their voting decisionsHowever in its meetings and electronic forums IEEE 80216does not permit discussions concerning the validity orapplicability of intellectual property claims The only role a patentclaim plays in Working Group discussions concerns ensuringcompliance to the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures
bull Justification for the inclusion of technology is limited to thetechnical merits of the technology
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresAnyone whether participating in IEEE 80216 or notshould notify the Chair of any patents (granted orunder application and regardless of the assignee orthe patent nationality) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved byIEEE 80216 Such notification should be in written orelectronic form (email is preferred) and need notmake any statement concerning enforcement orlicensing The Chair will presume that suchnotification is intended for public release and will assoon as practical post it to the web along with otherPatent Notices On File with IEEE 80216 The Chairand the Working Group will take no positionregarding the validity or applicability of any patents
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresWritten contributions to IEEE 80216 standards development willnot be accepted without an acknowledgement of familiarity with theIEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures Thisacknowledgement will be part of the mandatory contribution coversheet and will read
ldquoThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policyand Procedures (Version )
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information thatmight be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce thepossibility for delays in the development process andincrease the likelihood that the draft publication will beapproved for publication Please notify the Chair as early aspossible in written or electronic form of any patents (grantedor under application) that may cover technology that is underconsideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 TheChair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 websiterdquo
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresThe Chair once formally notified and once apotentially relevant draft standard exists shallwrite to the identified party and request that aLetter of Assurance be filed with the Chair forforwarding to the IEEE-SA Patent Committee inaccordance with the instructions in the IEEE-SAStandards Board Operations Manual A samplerequest letter and response letter are availableWhen the Patent Committee has accepted theletter as a Letter of Assurance informationregarding the letter will be indexed in the Recordsof IEEE Standards-Related Patents
Approval of Minutes
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to
ndash approve Document IEEE 80216-0017(Minutes of Session 8)
TG1 (802161)bull Air Interface for Fixed Broadband
Wireless Access Systemsbull 10-66 GHz
bull Chair Roger Marksbull Editor Jim MollenauerBrian Petrybull MAC Chair Carl Eklundbull PHY Chair Jay Klein
TG1 Goals for Week
ndashStay on Development PlanbullInitiative Working Group Letter BallotbullSeek approval at Closing Plenary
ndashMACbullComment resolutionbullMeet with TG3
ndashPHYbullComment resolutionbullOther contributionsbullMeet with TG2
TG2 (802162)ndashCoexistence of Broadband Wireless
Access Systems
ndashCo-Chair Andy McGregorndashCo-Chair Leland LangstonndashVice Chair Reacutemi Chayer
ndashEditor Vito Scaringindash Secretary Reza Arefi
TG3 (802163)bull Broadband Wireless Access Systems
in Licensed Bands from 2 to 11 GHzbull Chair Brian Kiernanbull Vice Chair Carl Bushuebull Secretary Dean Changbull Functional Requirements
ndashBrian PetryndashGeorge Fishel
WirelessHUMANTM Study Group
bull Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed MetropolitanArea Networks
bull Chair Durga Satapathybull Secretary Sanjay Moghe
bull Chartered at Session 6bull Renewed at Session 8bull Writing a PAR
bull To coordinate with 80211 and 80215
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
15
Charge to Task Groupsbull Complete the task on your agenda
ndashUpdate agenda on bulletin board
bull Prepare for next meetingndashCall for Contributions etc
bull Prepare for Closing Plenary
ndashAll motions to be in writingbull Document everything
ndash submit documents before you leavendash provide document index on bulletin board
bull Presentations to server 2 hours in advance
Voting in Task Groups
bull Only 80216 Voting Members may vote in taskGroup meetingsndashShow Voting Token
bull All present are eligible to vote at Study Groupmeetings
New Business
bull Request for New Business items
Adjournment
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to adjournthis meeting of Working Group 80216until the Midweek Plenaryndash(5-6 pm on Wednesday 13 September)
TG2 Status Report
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 1
IEEE 802162 Activities
Recommended Practice forCoexistence of BroadbandWireless Access Systems
Co-chairs Leland Langston Andy McGregor
Vice Chair Remi ChayerEditor Vito Scaringi
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 2
Activities since San DiegoMeeting
bull R7 of draft Practice issued late July
bull Several input docs and comments receivedbull Teleconference held Sept 7th ndash 8 participants
ndashSignificant discussion on content
bull R8 of draft Practice available Sept 11th
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 3
Plans for Denver
bull Close issue of single vs multiple interferers
bull Review doc for consistency amp completenessbull Present summary to joint TG1TG2bull Post R9 in week of Sept 18th
bull Seeking comments from any 80216 participant
bull TARGET TG ballot following Tampa meeting
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
16
Appendix B Midweek Plenary Presentations
Midweek Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Midweek Plenary Meeting AgendaWednesday 13 September 2000 1700-1800
Opening of Midweek Plenary Meeting 1700Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Midweek Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule Update Marks V
Announcements 1705
Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IAttendance books badges etc Marin I
802161 1710
Report Marks I802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1720Report McGregor I
802163 1730
Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1740
Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1745
Liaison 1750
ITU Costa ETSI BRAN Klein
Closing 1755
New Business (Marin Editorial Process) Marks VAdjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
17
Agenda for the Week as revised at the Midweek Plenary
80216 Session 9 Agenda Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMon
RAWCONKeynoteAddress
Ballroom A-D
120-150 pm(80216
RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCONLunch
1230-130pm
(80216Registrants
Invited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon G
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon H
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG16-730 pmSalon E
TG3Salon E
8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
TG3730-10 pm
Salon E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
18
Appendix C Closing Plenary Presentations
Closing Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Closing Plenary Meeting AgendaFriday 15 September 2000 10 am -1200 noon
Opening 1000Call to Order Marks IAgenda Marks V
Announcements 1003Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IVice Chair Marks I80216 Logo Marks D
WirelessHUMAN 1010Report Satapathy IPAR Approval Satapathy V
802161 1025Report Marks I802161 Working Group Review Marks V
802162 1050Report McGregor IFinal Task Group Review McGregor IMotions McGregor V
802163 1110Report Kiernan IMotions Kiernan V
Future Meetings 1130
Session 10 6-10 November 2000 Hyatt Regency Tampa Tampa Florida USA Marks ISunday Monday Friday at Session 10 Marks DSession 11 22-26 January 2001 Tel Aviv Israel Marks ISession 12 12-15 March 2001 Hyatt Regency Hilton Head South Carolina USA Marks ISession 13 7-11 May 2001 Orlando Florida USA along with IEEE 80211 and 80215 Marks I
Liaison 1135
ETSI BRANnotification of 802161 status and offer of password Marks V
Regulatory Agency notifications Robinson V
New Business 114080216 Editorial Policy MarinPetry V
Closing 1200
Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
19
WirelessHUMANtrade Closing Presentation[Insert Document Title Here]
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
[The appropriate coordinator normally the Task Group Chair will fill in this number after obtaining it from the 80216 Chair The
document number will match that of the base contribution with ldquoprdquo replacing ldquocrdquo For example 802161p-00nn]Date Submitted
[2000-07-13]Source
[Durga Satapathy] [Voice(913) 534-6338] [Sprint] [Fax (913) 534-6522] [7101 College Blvd Suite 1436 B] mailto[durgasatapathymailsprintcom [Overland Park KS 66210]
Venue
[IEEE 80216 Session 8]Base Document
[If this presentation illustrates an 80216 document cite the document number and URL lthttpieee802org16hellipgt]Purpose
[WirelessHUMAN Study Group report at closing plenary]Notice
This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s)The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw materialcontained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creation of anIEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution and at theIEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor also acknowledges and acceptsthat this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including the statementldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developingcommittee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purpose ofimplementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chair ltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt asearly as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology that is under consideration by or has beenapproved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentslettersgt
IEEE 80216 Plenary Report
Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed Metropolitan Area Network
(WirelessHUMANTM) Study Group
Durga P Satapathy
WirelessHUMANTM Update
bull Reviewed 8 contributions
bull Achieved consensus on selecting standardsto utilizemodifyndashMAC 80216ndashPHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
bull Drafted PAR and 5 criteria
WirelessHUMANTM PAR Scope This standard specifies the physical layer and media access control
layer of the air interface of interoperable fixed broadband wirelessmetropolitan area network systems including point-to-multipoint Thestandard enables access to data video and voice services with qualityof service in unlicensed bands designated for public network access Itwill focus on the 5-6 GHz range and may be applied to unlicensedbands between 2 and 11 GHz The WirelessHUMAN standard willutilize or modify applicable elements from the following
MAC 80216
PHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
The development of the WirelessHUMAN standard will follow thetimeline as shown in Appendix A
WirelessHUMANTM Timeline
bull Call For Proposals for WirelessHUMAN PHYMAC Nov 2000)ndash PHY Modifications of 80211a HIPERLAN2ndash MAC Modifications of 80216
bull Review proposals Jan 2001
bull Select candidate proposals at Interim meeting Feb 2001bull Decision on specific modifications March 2001
bull First Draft Standard May 2001
bull Comment Resolutions July 2001
bull Second Draft Standard Sep 2001bull Finalize WirelessHUMAN Standard Nov 2001
Purpose of Proposed Project
To enable rapid worldwide deployment of innovative cost-effectiveand interoperable multi-vendor broadband wireless metropolitan areanetwork products operating in the unlicensed bands To facilitatecompetition in broadband access by providing fixed wirelessalternatives to wireline broadband access Identify techniques totolerate interference in the unlicensed bands facilitate strategies forcoexistence with other unlicensed band systems such as 80211a andmaximize the carrying capacity of the unlicensed bands Encourageconsistent worldwide allocation and accelerate the commercializationof unlicensed broadband wireless access spectrum Utilization ofunlicensed frequencies will address a market that includes residencesSmall Office-Home Office (SOHO) telecommuters and Small andMedium Enterprises (SME)
WirelessHUMAN Study Group Participants
Sprint RF Solutions Agilent Technologies
Intel Breezecom Adaptive BroadbandNokia Transcomm Inc Cabletron
Ericsson BNA Systems WirelessHomeLucent Escape Carleton UniversityIntracom Malibu Networks Carnegie Mellon UniversityProxim Ultracom Georgia Institute of TechnologyWaveIP Harris Corporation HRL Laboratories LLCN Band Com Wireless Inc Western MultiplexCoreon Inc Cabletron systems Communications Research Center
Runcom Magnolia Broadband Yokogawa Electric CoInnowave ECI
Motion
The proposed WirelessHUMANTM PARbe accepted
TG1 MAC ClosingPresentation
(TG1 MAC reportppt)
1 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
TG1 MAC group
bull Resolved comments received during Final TaskGroup review
bull Major effort to remove any particular PHYdependence from the MAC
bull Process of adding features useful for TG3requirments started
bull Meeting with TG3
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
20
2 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
Important MAC decisions
bull Adoption of EUI-48 addresses (previouslyEUI-64)
bull Addition of error control to MAC layer(previously defined in TC layer of PHY B)
bull Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes into asingle mode
bull Redesigned DL MAP message for higherspectral efficiency
TG1 PHY ClosingPresentation
Document Number80216pp-
TitlePHY TG1 Report at Session 9
Date Submitted
91500Source
Jay KleinVenue
Denver September 2000Base Document
None
PurposeReport
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist the IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the
contributing individual(s) or organization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after furtherstudy The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by 80216
IEEE Patent Policy
The contributor is familiar with the IEEE Patent Policy which is set forth in the IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylawslthttpstandards ieeeorgguidesbylawsgt and includes the statement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s)
including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developing committee and provided theIEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standardrdquo
PHY TG1 Report Session 9
Jay KleinEnsemble Communications
Documents Submitted
bull 802161pc-0044 (2000-09-07) Recommendation onLMDS Radio Propagation Channel Models
bull 802161c-0007 (2000-09-10)FEC Parameterization for Data Transport (Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0006 (2000-09-08)FEC Parameterization for Control Channel Information(Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0004 (2000-09-01)Frequency Synthesizer Model Parameters (Lars Lindh andHans Somerma)
Documents Submitted ndash cont
bull 802161c-0003 (2000-09-01)Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes in802161 (Ken Stanwood)
bull 802161c-0001 (2000-08-08)Summary of Open PHY Issues in IEEE 802161-0001 (Jeff Foerster)
Work done
bull All editorial comments resolved
bull All technical comments reviewed andresolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull TBDs resolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull Met with MAC group for ldquosynchronizingrdquo
TG3 Closing Presentation
802163 Task Group Reportbull Finished and Adopted Functional
Requirements Document except for editorialsndashOutput Comment database on server
bull Developed an initial List of EvaluationCriteria for PHY proposal evaluations FullCriteria to be developed at next meeting
bull Issuing two calls for contributionsndashPreliminary PHY proposalsndashDeployment Traffic and Propagation
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS
bull Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull Session 10 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband WirelessAccess will be held on 6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA In orderto assist in the evaluation of air interface proposals the 802163 Task Groupinvites contributions addressing the following issues
lang Traffic and deployment models based on single and multi-cellsystems
lang Channel propagation model
bull Contributions must be submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt Submissions will beconsidered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible followingreceipt for public access on the 80216 Web Site Email your contribution tothe 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernanltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 Chair Roger Marksltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS - Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull The Task Group 3 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access is preparing to define the PHY protocols for abroadband wireless access air interface specification for frequencies from 2 through 11 GHz The specification will be based on submittedcontributions with increasing detail required as the process progresses Mergers and improvements will be encouraged with final selectionscheduled for June 2001
bull The TG3 Task Group invites the submission of initial contributions representing proposed PHY solutions Contributors will be grantedagenda time during 80216 Working Group Session 10 (6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA) to present and discuss the merits oftheir proposals Only submissions to session 10 will be eligible for invitation to submit more detailed proposals to session 11 Eachproposal will be allocated equal agenda time on Tuesday November 7 If time permits the allocations will be 15 minutes of presentationfollowed by 15 minutes of discussion Submissions must follow the guidelines below
lang Include a descriptive titlelang Include an overview and a reference model that describes functions including interfaces to other layerslang Describe the benefits of the proposed PHY including any unique featureslang Describe any drawbacks of the proposed PHY
bull Explain how the submitted PHY relates to existing standards such as ITU-R JRG 8A-9B IEEE 80211 DOCSIS 11 ETSI HiperLAN orothers If it is based on an existing standard what differences occur due to BWA characteristics
lang Emphasize the scalability of the proposed PHY to deal efficiently with various data types as described in the 802163Functional Requirements Document
lang Include a statement on intellectual property rights and how 80216 may utilize the proposed PHY in a standard
bull The proposals will be evaluated based on criteria in the Evaluation Table below However at this initial stage contributions are not expectedto address in detail the discussion items in that table instead aiming for the more general description as outlined above Each of the VotingMembers of 80216 are eligible to participate in the evaluation if present Submitters receiving a combined score of 6 or better (out of 10) inany criterion in the Evaluation Table will be invited to submit more a detailed contribution for Session 11 (January 22-26 2001 in Tel AvivIsrael) Note that submissions need not represent a complete PHY but may focus on specific components
bull Contributions will be considered only if submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216 Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt The template requires a cover page and a narrative
bull Submissions will be considered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible following receipt for public access on the 80216Web Site lthttpieee802org16gt
bull Email your contribution to the 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernan ltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 ChairRoger Marks ltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
802163 Task Group Report
bull Officially Adopted TG1 MAC as TG3 DraftMAC
bull Create TG3 MAC Ad Hoc to review TG1MAC and provide TG3 Comments
bull Two Motions for the Working GroupndashLiaison to ETSI BRAN sub11 GHz WGndashEstablishment of 80216 Common MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
21
Motion 1
That the 80216 Working Group appoint ChetShirali as a liaison to the ETSI BRAN sub11GHz Working Group
Motion 2
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MACbullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
22
Appendix D Attendance at Session9Session9 was an interim session The 75 interval attendance criteria for Session 9 was 6 ormore intervals Please contact the 80216 Secretary (smarinixnetcomcom) if you feel yourattendance has been recorded incorrectly
The following 126 peopleregistered attendance at 6or more intervals and metthe attendance criteria
Aboukarr BakriAn SongArefi RezaArunachalam ArunAvera DraytAvivi EliAyyagari DeepakBaragar IanBaseghi BehshadBaugh CR (Rick)Belfiore CarlosBenyamin-Seeyar AnaderBushue CarlBuskila BaruchChan RebeccaChang DeanChayer ReacutemiCondie MaryCornelius JamesCosta JoseacuteCrilly Jr William JDoherty EdwardEdmonston BrainEidson BrianEklund CarlEl-Damhougy HeshamFishel GeorgeFoerster JeffreyGarrison G JackGesbert DavidGoldhammer MariannaGuillemette PhilGupta RakeshHadad ZionHall EricHamilton MichaelHammons RogerHatim BayaHebron YoanHilberman DanHosur SrinathHsuan YiHudson ThomasHum ColemanHunter WayneJacobsen EricJamali Hamadi
Jorgensen JacobKang InchulKasslin MikaKiernan BrianKim JohnKitroser ItzikKlein JayKolze ThomasKostas DemosKwak Byung-JaeKwak JoeLangley John BLangston J LelandLeiba YigalLewis BarryLicardie SergioLiebetreu JohnLindh LarsLo TitusMarin ScottMarks RogerMcCallister RonMcGregor AndyMcMullin RoderickMeyer RonaldMiddleton AndrewMizoguchi MasatoMody ApurvaMollenauer JamesPadan UziPetry BrianPleasant WayneRalston WilliamRan MosheResheff GuyRhodes ValentineRobinson GeneRoehr WaltRzeszewski TedSantacesaria ClaudioSatapathy DurgaSater GlenScaringi VitoScarpa CarlSchwartz RandallSegal YossiSellars MalcolmShan Tie-JunShimada ShusakuShirali ChetSkaar HelgeSmith SteveStamatelos George
Stambaugh KarlStanwood KenStewart MichaelStruhsaker PaulSydor JohnTappenden ChrisTateishi KimiyaTavormina JoeThomas RaymondThompson PaulTrinkwon DavidVan Waes NicoVarma SubirWachira MuyaWang ArthurWang Chao-ChunWang LeiWang XiaofengWard BobWhitehead PhilipWhiting RobertWilliams David GWise CurtWiss JohnYanover VladimirZuniga Juan Carlos
The following 18 peopleregistered attendance atless than 6 intervals anddid not meet theattendance criteria
Alspaugh MatthewCarlo JimFalconer DavidFoley MarkFoster RobertGupta AlokHancock DaleHarel HaimKhanna AmarpalKreig AndrewMonk AntonNadeau JamesOng Ling ChuenRafie ManouchehrRibner David BWheatley Chuck FYang S MichaelYurtkuran Erol
Motion 5
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MAC based on802161-0001r4bullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
Appendix E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
13
Rights of Members amp Observers
bull To examine draft standardsbull To participate in Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To examine the votes of Working
Group membersbull To examine the Member and Observer
contact databases
Exclusive Rights of Membershipbull To make or second a motion at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote if and only if present at any meeting
of 80216 or its subsidiariesbull To vote in 80216 Working Group Letter
Ballotsbull To vote by email on any issue involving
80216 or its subsidiariesbull To lodge complaints about Working Group
operation with the 802 Executive Committeebull To petition the 802 Executive Committee in
writing
Attendance Listbull Recorded at each ldquomeeting intervalrdquo
ndashAfternoon MonTueWedThundashMorning TueWedThuFri
ndashEvening Thu
ndashSelf-declared ldquosubstantially allrdquo of meetingndashSession ldquoParticipationrdquo 75 of meeting intervals
bull =will round down to 6
bull Attendance recorded in parallel meetingsndashvoting credit for presence at either
bull Attendance is public recordndashattendance will be reported on webndashcontact info will not be posted (just company)
Secretaryrsquos Announcementsbull Scott Marin
ndash Attendance books (four of them)
bull Write your namebull If new and unregistered insert business
card in pocketbull Initial and keep the book movingbull Remember your book and page number
ndash Voting tokensbull Printed on badge for Membersbull Raise to vote
Registration
bull $140
bull Registration fee form at front deskndashHotel guest charge to roomndashOthers credit card
bull Receive copy of form as receipt
Document Distributionbull Server http10001bull Run DHCPbull Use 10BaseT or 100BaseTXbull Use 80211b or 80211 DSSS Wireless
bull Upload files using anonymous ftp
bull Flash Card may be available
Logistics
bull Meeting Roomsndash Vary throughout the week
bull Breaksndash Always in large room (E or D)
bull RAWCON events
Individuality
bull In IEEE standards meetingsparticipation is by individualndash you do not represent a company or
organization
bull Membership belongs to the individualnot an organization and may not betransferred
Legal and Anti-Trust
bull Any discussions that relate to thevalidity or cost of patent use shall beavoided
bull Any discussions or any materialrelating to an ongoing litigation shallbe avoided
bull Any discussions of pricing or issuesthat would violate US antitrust lawsshall be avoided
IEEE 80216 Patent Policybull IEEE 80216 operates under the Patent Policy of
the IEEE Standards Association as set forth inClause 6 of the IEEE-SA Standards BoardBylaws This policy includes the statement
bull IEEE standards may include the known use ofpatent(s) including patent applications if there istechnical justification in the opinion of thestandards-developing committee and providedthe IEEE receives assurance from the patentholder that it will license applicants underreasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standard
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
14
IEEE 80216 Patent Policy (cont)bull IEEE 80216 interprets in the opinion of the standards-
developing committee as in the opinion of the members of theWorking Group Early disclosure to the Working Groupparticipants of patent information that might be relevant to thestandard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and to increase the likelihood that the draftpublication will be approved for publication IEEE 80216 strivesto make such information available as soon as possible forconsideration by individual members in their voting decisionsHowever in its meetings and electronic forums IEEE 80216does not permit discussions concerning the validity orapplicability of intellectual property claims The only role a patentclaim plays in Working Group discussions concerns ensuringcompliance to the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures
bull Justification for the inclusion of technology is limited to thetechnical merits of the technology
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresAnyone whether participating in IEEE 80216 or notshould notify the Chair of any patents (granted orunder application and regardless of the assignee orthe patent nationality) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved byIEEE 80216 Such notification should be in written orelectronic form (email is preferred) and need notmake any statement concerning enforcement orlicensing The Chair will presume that suchnotification is intended for public release and will assoon as practical post it to the web along with otherPatent Notices On File with IEEE 80216 The Chairand the Working Group will take no positionregarding the validity or applicability of any patents
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresWritten contributions to IEEE 80216 standards development willnot be accepted without an acknowledgement of familiarity with theIEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures Thisacknowledgement will be part of the mandatory contribution coversheet and will read
ldquoThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policyand Procedures (Version )
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information thatmight be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce thepossibility for delays in the development process andincrease the likelihood that the draft publication will beapproved for publication Please notify the Chair as early aspossible in written or electronic form of any patents (grantedor under application) that may cover technology that is underconsideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 TheChair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 websiterdquo
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresThe Chair once formally notified and once apotentially relevant draft standard exists shallwrite to the identified party and request that aLetter of Assurance be filed with the Chair forforwarding to the IEEE-SA Patent Committee inaccordance with the instructions in the IEEE-SAStandards Board Operations Manual A samplerequest letter and response letter are availableWhen the Patent Committee has accepted theletter as a Letter of Assurance informationregarding the letter will be indexed in the Recordsof IEEE Standards-Related Patents
Approval of Minutes
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to
ndash approve Document IEEE 80216-0017(Minutes of Session 8)
TG1 (802161)bull Air Interface for Fixed Broadband
Wireless Access Systemsbull 10-66 GHz
bull Chair Roger Marksbull Editor Jim MollenauerBrian Petrybull MAC Chair Carl Eklundbull PHY Chair Jay Klein
TG1 Goals for Week
ndashStay on Development PlanbullInitiative Working Group Letter BallotbullSeek approval at Closing Plenary
ndashMACbullComment resolutionbullMeet with TG3
ndashPHYbullComment resolutionbullOther contributionsbullMeet with TG2
TG2 (802162)ndashCoexistence of Broadband Wireless
Access Systems
ndashCo-Chair Andy McGregorndashCo-Chair Leland LangstonndashVice Chair Reacutemi Chayer
ndashEditor Vito Scaringindash Secretary Reza Arefi
TG3 (802163)bull Broadband Wireless Access Systems
in Licensed Bands from 2 to 11 GHzbull Chair Brian Kiernanbull Vice Chair Carl Bushuebull Secretary Dean Changbull Functional Requirements
ndashBrian PetryndashGeorge Fishel
WirelessHUMANTM Study Group
bull Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed MetropolitanArea Networks
bull Chair Durga Satapathybull Secretary Sanjay Moghe
bull Chartered at Session 6bull Renewed at Session 8bull Writing a PAR
bull To coordinate with 80211 and 80215
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
15
Charge to Task Groupsbull Complete the task on your agenda
ndashUpdate agenda on bulletin board
bull Prepare for next meetingndashCall for Contributions etc
bull Prepare for Closing Plenary
ndashAll motions to be in writingbull Document everything
ndash submit documents before you leavendash provide document index on bulletin board
bull Presentations to server 2 hours in advance
Voting in Task Groups
bull Only 80216 Voting Members may vote in taskGroup meetingsndashShow Voting Token
bull All present are eligible to vote at Study Groupmeetings
New Business
bull Request for New Business items
Adjournment
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to adjournthis meeting of Working Group 80216until the Midweek Plenaryndash(5-6 pm on Wednesday 13 September)
TG2 Status Report
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 1
IEEE 802162 Activities
Recommended Practice forCoexistence of BroadbandWireless Access Systems
Co-chairs Leland Langston Andy McGregor
Vice Chair Remi ChayerEditor Vito Scaringi
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 2
Activities since San DiegoMeeting
bull R7 of draft Practice issued late July
bull Several input docs and comments receivedbull Teleconference held Sept 7th ndash 8 participants
ndashSignificant discussion on content
bull R8 of draft Practice available Sept 11th
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 3
Plans for Denver
bull Close issue of single vs multiple interferers
bull Review doc for consistency amp completenessbull Present summary to joint TG1TG2bull Post R9 in week of Sept 18th
bull Seeking comments from any 80216 participant
bull TARGET TG ballot following Tampa meeting
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
16
Appendix B Midweek Plenary Presentations
Midweek Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Midweek Plenary Meeting AgendaWednesday 13 September 2000 1700-1800
Opening of Midweek Plenary Meeting 1700Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Midweek Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule Update Marks V
Announcements 1705
Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IAttendance books badges etc Marin I
802161 1710
Report Marks I802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1720Report McGregor I
802163 1730
Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1740
Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1745
Liaison 1750
ITU Costa ETSI BRAN Klein
Closing 1755
New Business (Marin Editorial Process) Marks VAdjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
17
Agenda for the Week as revised at the Midweek Plenary
80216 Session 9 Agenda Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMon
RAWCONKeynoteAddress
Ballroom A-D
120-150 pm(80216
RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCONLunch
1230-130pm
(80216Registrants
Invited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon G
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon H
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG16-730 pmSalon E
TG3Salon E
8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
TG3730-10 pm
Salon E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
18
Appendix C Closing Plenary Presentations
Closing Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Closing Plenary Meeting AgendaFriday 15 September 2000 10 am -1200 noon
Opening 1000Call to Order Marks IAgenda Marks V
Announcements 1003Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IVice Chair Marks I80216 Logo Marks D
WirelessHUMAN 1010Report Satapathy IPAR Approval Satapathy V
802161 1025Report Marks I802161 Working Group Review Marks V
802162 1050Report McGregor IFinal Task Group Review McGregor IMotions McGregor V
802163 1110Report Kiernan IMotions Kiernan V
Future Meetings 1130
Session 10 6-10 November 2000 Hyatt Regency Tampa Tampa Florida USA Marks ISunday Monday Friday at Session 10 Marks DSession 11 22-26 January 2001 Tel Aviv Israel Marks ISession 12 12-15 March 2001 Hyatt Regency Hilton Head South Carolina USA Marks ISession 13 7-11 May 2001 Orlando Florida USA along with IEEE 80211 and 80215 Marks I
Liaison 1135
ETSI BRANnotification of 802161 status and offer of password Marks V
Regulatory Agency notifications Robinson V
New Business 114080216 Editorial Policy MarinPetry V
Closing 1200
Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
19
WirelessHUMANtrade Closing Presentation[Insert Document Title Here]
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
[The appropriate coordinator normally the Task Group Chair will fill in this number after obtaining it from the 80216 Chair The
document number will match that of the base contribution with ldquoprdquo replacing ldquocrdquo For example 802161p-00nn]Date Submitted
[2000-07-13]Source
[Durga Satapathy] [Voice(913) 534-6338] [Sprint] [Fax (913) 534-6522] [7101 College Blvd Suite 1436 B] mailto[durgasatapathymailsprintcom [Overland Park KS 66210]
Venue
[IEEE 80216 Session 8]Base Document
[If this presentation illustrates an 80216 document cite the document number and URL lthttpieee802org16hellipgt]Purpose
[WirelessHUMAN Study Group report at closing plenary]Notice
This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s)The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw materialcontained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creation of anIEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution and at theIEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor also acknowledges and acceptsthat this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including the statementldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developingcommittee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purpose ofimplementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chair ltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt asearly as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology that is under consideration by or has beenapproved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentslettersgt
IEEE 80216 Plenary Report
Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed Metropolitan Area Network
(WirelessHUMANTM) Study Group
Durga P Satapathy
WirelessHUMANTM Update
bull Reviewed 8 contributions
bull Achieved consensus on selecting standardsto utilizemodifyndashMAC 80216ndashPHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
bull Drafted PAR and 5 criteria
WirelessHUMANTM PAR Scope This standard specifies the physical layer and media access control
layer of the air interface of interoperable fixed broadband wirelessmetropolitan area network systems including point-to-multipoint Thestandard enables access to data video and voice services with qualityof service in unlicensed bands designated for public network access Itwill focus on the 5-6 GHz range and may be applied to unlicensedbands between 2 and 11 GHz The WirelessHUMAN standard willutilize or modify applicable elements from the following
MAC 80216
PHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
The development of the WirelessHUMAN standard will follow thetimeline as shown in Appendix A
WirelessHUMANTM Timeline
bull Call For Proposals for WirelessHUMAN PHYMAC Nov 2000)ndash PHY Modifications of 80211a HIPERLAN2ndash MAC Modifications of 80216
bull Review proposals Jan 2001
bull Select candidate proposals at Interim meeting Feb 2001bull Decision on specific modifications March 2001
bull First Draft Standard May 2001
bull Comment Resolutions July 2001
bull Second Draft Standard Sep 2001bull Finalize WirelessHUMAN Standard Nov 2001
Purpose of Proposed Project
To enable rapid worldwide deployment of innovative cost-effectiveand interoperable multi-vendor broadband wireless metropolitan areanetwork products operating in the unlicensed bands To facilitatecompetition in broadband access by providing fixed wirelessalternatives to wireline broadband access Identify techniques totolerate interference in the unlicensed bands facilitate strategies forcoexistence with other unlicensed band systems such as 80211a andmaximize the carrying capacity of the unlicensed bands Encourageconsistent worldwide allocation and accelerate the commercializationof unlicensed broadband wireless access spectrum Utilization ofunlicensed frequencies will address a market that includes residencesSmall Office-Home Office (SOHO) telecommuters and Small andMedium Enterprises (SME)
WirelessHUMAN Study Group Participants
Sprint RF Solutions Agilent Technologies
Intel Breezecom Adaptive BroadbandNokia Transcomm Inc Cabletron
Ericsson BNA Systems WirelessHomeLucent Escape Carleton UniversityIntracom Malibu Networks Carnegie Mellon UniversityProxim Ultracom Georgia Institute of TechnologyWaveIP Harris Corporation HRL Laboratories LLCN Band Com Wireless Inc Western MultiplexCoreon Inc Cabletron systems Communications Research Center
Runcom Magnolia Broadband Yokogawa Electric CoInnowave ECI
Motion
The proposed WirelessHUMANTM PARbe accepted
TG1 MAC ClosingPresentation
(TG1 MAC reportppt)
1 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
TG1 MAC group
bull Resolved comments received during Final TaskGroup review
bull Major effort to remove any particular PHYdependence from the MAC
bull Process of adding features useful for TG3requirments started
bull Meeting with TG3
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
20
2 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
Important MAC decisions
bull Adoption of EUI-48 addresses (previouslyEUI-64)
bull Addition of error control to MAC layer(previously defined in TC layer of PHY B)
bull Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes into asingle mode
bull Redesigned DL MAP message for higherspectral efficiency
TG1 PHY ClosingPresentation
Document Number80216pp-
TitlePHY TG1 Report at Session 9
Date Submitted
91500Source
Jay KleinVenue
Denver September 2000Base Document
None
PurposeReport
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist the IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the
contributing individual(s) or organization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after furtherstudy The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by 80216
IEEE Patent Policy
The contributor is familiar with the IEEE Patent Policy which is set forth in the IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylawslthttpstandards ieeeorgguidesbylawsgt and includes the statement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s)
including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developing committee and provided theIEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standardrdquo
PHY TG1 Report Session 9
Jay KleinEnsemble Communications
Documents Submitted
bull 802161pc-0044 (2000-09-07) Recommendation onLMDS Radio Propagation Channel Models
bull 802161c-0007 (2000-09-10)FEC Parameterization for Data Transport (Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0006 (2000-09-08)FEC Parameterization for Control Channel Information(Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0004 (2000-09-01)Frequency Synthesizer Model Parameters (Lars Lindh andHans Somerma)
Documents Submitted ndash cont
bull 802161c-0003 (2000-09-01)Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes in802161 (Ken Stanwood)
bull 802161c-0001 (2000-08-08)Summary of Open PHY Issues in IEEE 802161-0001 (Jeff Foerster)
Work done
bull All editorial comments resolved
bull All technical comments reviewed andresolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull TBDs resolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull Met with MAC group for ldquosynchronizingrdquo
TG3 Closing Presentation
802163 Task Group Reportbull Finished and Adopted Functional
Requirements Document except for editorialsndashOutput Comment database on server
bull Developed an initial List of EvaluationCriteria for PHY proposal evaluations FullCriteria to be developed at next meeting
bull Issuing two calls for contributionsndashPreliminary PHY proposalsndashDeployment Traffic and Propagation
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS
bull Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull Session 10 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband WirelessAccess will be held on 6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA In orderto assist in the evaluation of air interface proposals the 802163 Task Groupinvites contributions addressing the following issues
lang Traffic and deployment models based on single and multi-cellsystems
lang Channel propagation model
bull Contributions must be submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt Submissions will beconsidered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible followingreceipt for public access on the 80216 Web Site Email your contribution tothe 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernanltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 Chair Roger Marksltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS - Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull The Task Group 3 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access is preparing to define the PHY protocols for abroadband wireless access air interface specification for frequencies from 2 through 11 GHz The specification will be based on submittedcontributions with increasing detail required as the process progresses Mergers and improvements will be encouraged with final selectionscheduled for June 2001
bull The TG3 Task Group invites the submission of initial contributions representing proposed PHY solutions Contributors will be grantedagenda time during 80216 Working Group Session 10 (6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA) to present and discuss the merits oftheir proposals Only submissions to session 10 will be eligible for invitation to submit more detailed proposals to session 11 Eachproposal will be allocated equal agenda time on Tuesday November 7 If time permits the allocations will be 15 minutes of presentationfollowed by 15 minutes of discussion Submissions must follow the guidelines below
lang Include a descriptive titlelang Include an overview and a reference model that describes functions including interfaces to other layerslang Describe the benefits of the proposed PHY including any unique featureslang Describe any drawbacks of the proposed PHY
bull Explain how the submitted PHY relates to existing standards such as ITU-R JRG 8A-9B IEEE 80211 DOCSIS 11 ETSI HiperLAN orothers If it is based on an existing standard what differences occur due to BWA characteristics
lang Emphasize the scalability of the proposed PHY to deal efficiently with various data types as described in the 802163Functional Requirements Document
lang Include a statement on intellectual property rights and how 80216 may utilize the proposed PHY in a standard
bull The proposals will be evaluated based on criteria in the Evaluation Table below However at this initial stage contributions are not expectedto address in detail the discussion items in that table instead aiming for the more general description as outlined above Each of the VotingMembers of 80216 are eligible to participate in the evaluation if present Submitters receiving a combined score of 6 or better (out of 10) inany criterion in the Evaluation Table will be invited to submit more a detailed contribution for Session 11 (January 22-26 2001 in Tel AvivIsrael) Note that submissions need not represent a complete PHY but may focus on specific components
bull Contributions will be considered only if submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216 Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt The template requires a cover page and a narrative
bull Submissions will be considered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible following receipt for public access on the 80216Web Site lthttpieee802org16gt
bull Email your contribution to the 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernan ltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 ChairRoger Marks ltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
802163 Task Group Report
bull Officially Adopted TG1 MAC as TG3 DraftMAC
bull Create TG3 MAC Ad Hoc to review TG1MAC and provide TG3 Comments
bull Two Motions for the Working GroupndashLiaison to ETSI BRAN sub11 GHz WGndashEstablishment of 80216 Common MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
21
Motion 1
That the 80216 Working Group appoint ChetShirali as a liaison to the ETSI BRAN sub11GHz Working Group
Motion 2
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MACbullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
22
Appendix D Attendance at Session9Session9 was an interim session The 75 interval attendance criteria for Session 9 was 6 ormore intervals Please contact the 80216 Secretary (smarinixnetcomcom) if you feel yourattendance has been recorded incorrectly
The following 126 peopleregistered attendance at 6or more intervals and metthe attendance criteria
Aboukarr BakriAn SongArefi RezaArunachalam ArunAvera DraytAvivi EliAyyagari DeepakBaragar IanBaseghi BehshadBaugh CR (Rick)Belfiore CarlosBenyamin-Seeyar AnaderBushue CarlBuskila BaruchChan RebeccaChang DeanChayer ReacutemiCondie MaryCornelius JamesCosta JoseacuteCrilly Jr William JDoherty EdwardEdmonston BrainEidson BrianEklund CarlEl-Damhougy HeshamFishel GeorgeFoerster JeffreyGarrison G JackGesbert DavidGoldhammer MariannaGuillemette PhilGupta RakeshHadad ZionHall EricHamilton MichaelHammons RogerHatim BayaHebron YoanHilberman DanHosur SrinathHsuan YiHudson ThomasHum ColemanHunter WayneJacobsen EricJamali Hamadi
Jorgensen JacobKang InchulKasslin MikaKiernan BrianKim JohnKitroser ItzikKlein JayKolze ThomasKostas DemosKwak Byung-JaeKwak JoeLangley John BLangston J LelandLeiba YigalLewis BarryLicardie SergioLiebetreu JohnLindh LarsLo TitusMarin ScottMarks RogerMcCallister RonMcGregor AndyMcMullin RoderickMeyer RonaldMiddleton AndrewMizoguchi MasatoMody ApurvaMollenauer JamesPadan UziPetry BrianPleasant WayneRalston WilliamRan MosheResheff GuyRhodes ValentineRobinson GeneRoehr WaltRzeszewski TedSantacesaria ClaudioSatapathy DurgaSater GlenScaringi VitoScarpa CarlSchwartz RandallSegal YossiSellars MalcolmShan Tie-JunShimada ShusakuShirali ChetSkaar HelgeSmith SteveStamatelos George
Stambaugh KarlStanwood KenStewart MichaelStruhsaker PaulSydor JohnTappenden ChrisTateishi KimiyaTavormina JoeThomas RaymondThompson PaulTrinkwon DavidVan Waes NicoVarma SubirWachira MuyaWang ArthurWang Chao-ChunWang LeiWang XiaofengWard BobWhitehead PhilipWhiting RobertWilliams David GWise CurtWiss JohnYanover VladimirZuniga Juan Carlos
The following 18 peopleregistered attendance atless than 6 intervals anddid not meet theattendance criteria
Alspaugh MatthewCarlo JimFalconer DavidFoley MarkFoster RobertGupta AlokHancock DaleHarel HaimKhanna AmarpalKreig AndrewMonk AntonNadeau JamesOng Ling ChuenRafie ManouchehrRibner David BWheatley Chuck FYang S MichaelYurtkuran Erol
Motion 5
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MAC based on802161-0001r4bullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
Appendix E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
14
IEEE 80216 Patent Policy (cont)bull IEEE 80216 interprets in the opinion of the standards-
developing committee as in the opinion of the members of theWorking Group Early disclosure to the Working Groupparticipants of patent information that might be relevant to thestandard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and to increase the likelihood that the draftpublication will be approved for publication IEEE 80216 strivesto make such information available as soon as possible forconsideration by individual members in their voting decisionsHowever in its meetings and electronic forums IEEE 80216does not permit discussions concerning the validity orapplicability of intellectual property claims The only role a patentclaim plays in Working Group discussions concerns ensuringcompliance to the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures
bull Justification for the inclusion of technology is limited to thetechnical merits of the technology
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresAnyone whether participating in IEEE 80216 or notshould notify the Chair of any patents (granted orunder application and regardless of the assignee orthe patent nationality) that may cover technology thatis under consideration by or has been approved byIEEE 80216 Such notification should be in written orelectronic form (email is preferred) and need notmake any statement concerning enforcement orlicensing The Chair will presume that suchnotification is intended for public release and will assoon as practical post it to the web along with otherPatent Notices On File with IEEE 80216 The Chairand the Working Group will take no positionregarding the validity or applicability of any patents
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresWritten contributions to IEEE 80216 standards development willnot be accepted without an acknowledgement of familiarity with theIEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures Thisacknowledgement will be part of the mandatory contribution coversheet and will read
ldquoThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policyand Procedures (Version )
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information thatmight be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce thepossibility for delays in the development process andincrease the likelihood that the draft publication will beapproved for publication Please notify the Chair as early aspossible in written or electronic form of any patents (grantedor under application) that may cover technology that is underconsideration by or has been approved by IEEE 80216 TheChair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 websiterdquo
IEEE 80216 Patent ProceduresThe Chair once formally notified and once apotentially relevant draft standard exists shallwrite to the identified party and request that aLetter of Assurance be filed with the Chair forforwarding to the IEEE-SA Patent Committee inaccordance with the instructions in the IEEE-SAStandards Board Operations Manual A samplerequest letter and response letter are availableWhen the Patent Committee has accepted theletter as a Letter of Assurance informationregarding the letter will be indexed in the Recordsof IEEE Standards-Related Patents
Approval of Minutes
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to
ndash approve Document IEEE 80216-0017(Minutes of Session 8)
TG1 (802161)bull Air Interface for Fixed Broadband
Wireless Access Systemsbull 10-66 GHz
bull Chair Roger Marksbull Editor Jim MollenauerBrian Petrybull MAC Chair Carl Eklundbull PHY Chair Jay Klein
TG1 Goals for Week
ndashStay on Development PlanbullInitiative Working Group Letter BallotbullSeek approval at Closing Plenary
ndashMACbullComment resolutionbullMeet with TG3
ndashPHYbullComment resolutionbullOther contributionsbullMeet with TG2
TG2 (802162)ndashCoexistence of Broadband Wireless
Access Systems
ndashCo-Chair Andy McGregorndashCo-Chair Leland LangstonndashVice Chair Reacutemi Chayer
ndashEditor Vito Scaringindash Secretary Reza Arefi
TG3 (802163)bull Broadband Wireless Access Systems
in Licensed Bands from 2 to 11 GHzbull Chair Brian Kiernanbull Vice Chair Carl Bushuebull Secretary Dean Changbull Functional Requirements
ndashBrian PetryndashGeorge Fishel
WirelessHUMANTM Study Group
bull Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed MetropolitanArea Networks
bull Chair Durga Satapathybull Secretary Sanjay Moghe
bull Chartered at Session 6bull Renewed at Session 8bull Writing a PAR
bull To coordinate with 80211 and 80215
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
15
Charge to Task Groupsbull Complete the task on your agenda
ndashUpdate agenda on bulletin board
bull Prepare for next meetingndashCall for Contributions etc
bull Prepare for Closing Plenary
ndashAll motions to be in writingbull Document everything
ndash submit documents before you leavendash provide document index on bulletin board
bull Presentations to server 2 hours in advance
Voting in Task Groups
bull Only 80216 Voting Members may vote in taskGroup meetingsndashShow Voting Token
bull All present are eligible to vote at Study Groupmeetings
New Business
bull Request for New Business items
Adjournment
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to adjournthis meeting of Working Group 80216until the Midweek Plenaryndash(5-6 pm on Wednesday 13 September)
TG2 Status Report
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 1
IEEE 802162 Activities
Recommended Practice forCoexistence of BroadbandWireless Access Systems
Co-chairs Leland Langston Andy McGregor
Vice Chair Remi ChayerEditor Vito Scaringi
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 2
Activities since San DiegoMeeting
bull R7 of draft Practice issued late July
bull Several input docs and comments receivedbull Teleconference held Sept 7th ndash 8 participants
ndashSignificant discussion on content
bull R8 of draft Practice available Sept 11th
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 3
Plans for Denver
bull Close issue of single vs multiple interferers
bull Review doc for consistency amp completenessbull Present summary to joint TG1TG2bull Post R9 in week of Sept 18th
bull Seeking comments from any 80216 participant
bull TARGET TG ballot following Tampa meeting
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
16
Appendix B Midweek Plenary Presentations
Midweek Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Midweek Plenary Meeting AgendaWednesday 13 September 2000 1700-1800
Opening of Midweek Plenary Meeting 1700Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Midweek Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule Update Marks V
Announcements 1705
Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IAttendance books badges etc Marin I
802161 1710
Report Marks I802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1720Report McGregor I
802163 1730
Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1740
Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1745
Liaison 1750
ITU Costa ETSI BRAN Klein
Closing 1755
New Business (Marin Editorial Process) Marks VAdjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
17
Agenda for the Week as revised at the Midweek Plenary
80216 Session 9 Agenda Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMon
RAWCONKeynoteAddress
Ballroom A-D
120-150 pm(80216
RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCONLunch
1230-130pm
(80216Registrants
Invited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon G
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon H
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG16-730 pmSalon E
TG3Salon E
8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
TG3730-10 pm
Salon E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
18
Appendix C Closing Plenary Presentations
Closing Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Closing Plenary Meeting AgendaFriday 15 September 2000 10 am -1200 noon
Opening 1000Call to Order Marks IAgenda Marks V
Announcements 1003Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IVice Chair Marks I80216 Logo Marks D
WirelessHUMAN 1010Report Satapathy IPAR Approval Satapathy V
802161 1025Report Marks I802161 Working Group Review Marks V
802162 1050Report McGregor IFinal Task Group Review McGregor IMotions McGregor V
802163 1110Report Kiernan IMotions Kiernan V
Future Meetings 1130
Session 10 6-10 November 2000 Hyatt Regency Tampa Tampa Florida USA Marks ISunday Monday Friday at Session 10 Marks DSession 11 22-26 January 2001 Tel Aviv Israel Marks ISession 12 12-15 March 2001 Hyatt Regency Hilton Head South Carolina USA Marks ISession 13 7-11 May 2001 Orlando Florida USA along with IEEE 80211 and 80215 Marks I
Liaison 1135
ETSI BRANnotification of 802161 status and offer of password Marks V
Regulatory Agency notifications Robinson V
New Business 114080216 Editorial Policy MarinPetry V
Closing 1200
Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
19
WirelessHUMANtrade Closing Presentation[Insert Document Title Here]
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
[The appropriate coordinator normally the Task Group Chair will fill in this number after obtaining it from the 80216 Chair The
document number will match that of the base contribution with ldquoprdquo replacing ldquocrdquo For example 802161p-00nn]Date Submitted
[2000-07-13]Source
[Durga Satapathy] [Voice(913) 534-6338] [Sprint] [Fax (913) 534-6522] [7101 College Blvd Suite 1436 B] mailto[durgasatapathymailsprintcom [Overland Park KS 66210]
Venue
[IEEE 80216 Session 8]Base Document
[If this presentation illustrates an 80216 document cite the document number and URL lthttpieee802org16hellipgt]Purpose
[WirelessHUMAN Study Group report at closing plenary]Notice
This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s)The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw materialcontained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creation of anIEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution and at theIEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor also acknowledges and acceptsthat this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including the statementldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developingcommittee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purpose ofimplementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chair ltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt asearly as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology that is under consideration by or has beenapproved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentslettersgt
IEEE 80216 Plenary Report
Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed Metropolitan Area Network
(WirelessHUMANTM) Study Group
Durga P Satapathy
WirelessHUMANTM Update
bull Reviewed 8 contributions
bull Achieved consensus on selecting standardsto utilizemodifyndashMAC 80216ndashPHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
bull Drafted PAR and 5 criteria
WirelessHUMANTM PAR Scope This standard specifies the physical layer and media access control
layer of the air interface of interoperable fixed broadband wirelessmetropolitan area network systems including point-to-multipoint Thestandard enables access to data video and voice services with qualityof service in unlicensed bands designated for public network access Itwill focus on the 5-6 GHz range and may be applied to unlicensedbands between 2 and 11 GHz The WirelessHUMAN standard willutilize or modify applicable elements from the following
MAC 80216
PHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
The development of the WirelessHUMAN standard will follow thetimeline as shown in Appendix A
WirelessHUMANTM Timeline
bull Call For Proposals for WirelessHUMAN PHYMAC Nov 2000)ndash PHY Modifications of 80211a HIPERLAN2ndash MAC Modifications of 80216
bull Review proposals Jan 2001
bull Select candidate proposals at Interim meeting Feb 2001bull Decision on specific modifications March 2001
bull First Draft Standard May 2001
bull Comment Resolutions July 2001
bull Second Draft Standard Sep 2001bull Finalize WirelessHUMAN Standard Nov 2001
Purpose of Proposed Project
To enable rapid worldwide deployment of innovative cost-effectiveand interoperable multi-vendor broadband wireless metropolitan areanetwork products operating in the unlicensed bands To facilitatecompetition in broadband access by providing fixed wirelessalternatives to wireline broadband access Identify techniques totolerate interference in the unlicensed bands facilitate strategies forcoexistence with other unlicensed band systems such as 80211a andmaximize the carrying capacity of the unlicensed bands Encourageconsistent worldwide allocation and accelerate the commercializationof unlicensed broadband wireless access spectrum Utilization ofunlicensed frequencies will address a market that includes residencesSmall Office-Home Office (SOHO) telecommuters and Small andMedium Enterprises (SME)
WirelessHUMAN Study Group Participants
Sprint RF Solutions Agilent Technologies
Intel Breezecom Adaptive BroadbandNokia Transcomm Inc Cabletron
Ericsson BNA Systems WirelessHomeLucent Escape Carleton UniversityIntracom Malibu Networks Carnegie Mellon UniversityProxim Ultracom Georgia Institute of TechnologyWaveIP Harris Corporation HRL Laboratories LLCN Band Com Wireless Inc Western MultiplexCoreon Inc Cabletron systems Communications Research Center
Runcom Magnolia Broadband Yokogawa Electric CoInnowave ECI
Motion
The proposed WirelessHUMANTM PARbe accepted
TG1 MAC ClosingPresentation
(TG1 MAC reportppt)
1 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
TG1 MAC group
bull Resolved comments received during Final TaskGroup review
bull Major effort to remove any particular PHYdependence from the MAC
bull Process of adding features useful for TG3requirments started
bull Meeting with TG3
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
20
2 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
Important MAC decisions
bull Adoption of EUI-48 addresses (previouslyEUI-64)
bull Addition of error control to MAC layer(previously defined in TC layer of PHY B)
bull Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes into asingle mode
bull Redesigned DL MAP message for higherspectral efficiency
TG1 PHY ClosingPresentation
Document Number80216pp-
TitlePHY TG1 Report at Session 9
Date Submitted
91500Source
Jay KleinVenue
Denver September 2000Base Document
None
PurposeReport
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist the IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the
contributing individual(s) or organization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after furtherstudy The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by 80216
IEEE Patent Policy
The contributor is familiar with the IEEE Patent Policy which is set forth in the IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylawslthttpstandards ieeeorgguidesbylawsgt and includes the statement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s)
including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developing committee and provided theIEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standardrdquo
PHY TG1 Report Session 9
Jay KleinEnsemble Communications
Documents Submitted
bull 802161pc-0044 (2000-09-07) Recommendation onLMDS Radio Propagation Channel Models
bull 802161c-0007 (2000-09-10)FEC Parameterization for Data Transport (Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0006 (2000-09-08)FEC Parameterization for Control Channel Information(Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0004 (2000-09-01)Frequency Synthesizer Model Parameters (Lars Lindh andHans Somerma)
Documents Submitted ndash cont
bull 802161c-0003 (2000-09-01)Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes in802161 (Ken Stanwood)
bull 802161c-0001 (2000-08-08)Summary of Open PHY Issues in IEEE 802161-0001 (Jeff Foerster)
Work done
bull All editorial comments resolved
bull All technical comments reviewed andresolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull TBDs resolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull Met with MAC group for ldquosynchronizingrdquo
TG3 Closing Presentation
802163 Task Group Reportbull Finished and Adopted Functional
Requirements Document except for editorialsndashOutput Comment database on server
bull Developed an initial List of EvaluationCriteria for PHY proposal evaluations FullCriteria to be developed at next meeting
bull Issuing two calls for contributionsndashPreliminary PHY proposalsndashDeployment Traffic and Propagation
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS
bull Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull Session 10 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband WirelessAccess will be held on 6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA In orderto assist in the evaluation of air interface proposals the 802163 Task Groupinvites contributions addressing the following issues
lang Traffic and deployment models based on single and multi-cellsystems
lang Channel propagation model
bull Contributions must be submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt Submissions will beconsidered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible followingreceipt for public access on the 80216 Web Site Email your contribution tothe 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernanltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 Chair Roger Marksltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS - Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull The Task Group 3 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access is preparing to define the PHY protocols for abroadband wireless access air interface specification for frequencies from 2 through 11 GHz The specification will be based on submittedcontributions with increasing detail required as the process progresses Mergers and improvements will be encouraged with final selectionscheduled for June 2001
bull The TG3 Task Group invites the submission of initial contributions representing proposed PHY solutions Contributors will be grantedagenda time during 80216 Working Group Session 10 (6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA) to present and discuss the merits oftheir proposals Only submissions to session 10 will be eligible for invitation to submit more detailed proposals to session 11 Eachproposal will be allocated equal agenda time on Tuesday November 7 If time permits the allocations will be 15 minutes of presentationfollowed by 15 minutes of discussion Submissions must follow the guidelines below
lang Include a descriptive titlelang Include an overview and a reference model that describes functions including interfaces to other layerslang Describe the benefits of the proposed PHY including any unique featureslang Describe any drawbacks of the proposed PHY
bull Explain how the submitted PHY relates to existing standards such as ITU-R JRG 8A-9B IEEE 80211 DOCSIS 11 ETSI HiperLAN orothers If it is based on an existing standard what differences occur due to BWA characteristics
lang Emphasize the scalability of the proposed PHY to deal efficiently with various data types as described in the 802163Functional Requirements Document
lang Include a statement on intellectual property rights and how 80216 may utilize the proposed PHY in a standard
bull The proposals will be evaluated based on criteria in the Evaluation Table below However at this initial stage contributions are not expectedto address in detail the discussion items in that table instead aiming for the more general description as outlined above Each of the VotingMembers of 80216 are eligible to participate in the evaluation if present Submitters receiving a combined score of 6 or better (out of 10) inany criterion in the Evaluation Table will be invited to submit more a detailed contribution for Session 11 (January 22-26 2001 in Tel AvivIsrael) Note that submissions need not represent a complete PHY but may focus on specific components
bull Contributions will be considered only if submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216 Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt The template requires a cover page and a narrative
bull Submissions will be considered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible following receipt for public access on the 80216Web Site lthttpieee802org16gt
bull Email your contribution to the 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernan ltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 ChairRoger Marks ltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
802163 Task Group Report
bull Officially Adopted TG1 MAC as TG3 DraftMAC
bull Create TG3 MAC Ad Hoc to review TG1MAC and provide TG3 Comments
bull Two Motions for the Working GroupndashLiaison to ETSI BRAN sub11 GHz WGndashEstablishment of 80216 Common MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
21
Motion 1
That the 80216 Working Group appoint ChetShirali as a liaison to the ETSI BRAN sub11GHz Working Group
Motion 2
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MACbullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
22
Appendix D Attendance at Session9Session9 was an interim session The 75 interval attendance criteria for Session 9 was 6 ormore intervals Please contact the 80216 Secretary (smarinixnetcomcom) if you feel yourattendance has been recorded incorrectly
The following 126 peopleregistered attendance at 6or more intervals and metthe attendance criteria
Aboukarr BakriAn SongArefi RezaArunachalam ArunAvera DraytAvivi EliAyyagari DeepakBaragar IanBaseghi BehshadBaugh CR (Rick)Belfiore CarlosBenyamin-Seeyar AnaderBushue CarlBuskila BaruchChan RebeccaChang DeanChayer ReacutemiCondie MaryCornelius JamesCosta JoseacuteCrilly Jr William JDoherty EdwardEdmonston BrainEidson BrianEklund CarlEl-Damhougy HeshamFishel GeorgeFoerster JeffreyGarrison G JackGesbert DavidGoldhammer MariannaGuillemette PhilGupta RakeshHadad ZionHall EricHamilton MichaelHammons RogerHatim BayaHebron YoanHilberman DanHosur SrinathHsuan YiHudson ThomasHum ColemanHunter WayneJacobsen EricJamali Hamadi
Jorgensen JacobKang InchulKasslin MikaKiernan BrianKim JohnKitroser ItzikKlein JayKolze ThomasKostas DemosKwak Byung-JaeKwak JoeLangley John BLangston J LelandLeiba YigalLewis BarryLicardie SergioLiebetreu JohnLindh LarsLo TitusMarin ScottMarks RogerMcCallister RonMcGregor AndyMcMullin RoderickMeyer RonaldMiddleton AndrewMizoguchi MasatoMody ApurvaMollenauer JamesPadan UziPetry BrianPleasant WayneRalston WilliamRan MosheResheff GuyRhodes ValentineRobinson GeneRoehr WaltRzeszewski TedSantacesaria ClaudioSatapathy DurgaSater GlenScaringi VitoScarpa CarlSchwartz RandallSegal YossiSellars MalcolmShan Tie-JunShimada ShusakuShirali ChetSkaar HelgeSmith SteveStamatelos George
Stambaugh KarlStanwood KenStewart MichaelStruhsaker PaulSydor JohnTappenden ChrisTateishi KimiyaTavormina JoeThomas RaymondThompson PaulTrinkwon DavidVan Waes NicoVarma SubirWachira MuyaWang ArthurWang Chao-ChunWang LeiWang XiaofengWard BobWhitehead PhilipWhiting RobertWilliams David GWise CurtWiss JohnYanover VladimirZuniga Juan Carlos
The following 18 peopleregistered attendance atless than 6 intervals anddid not meet theattendance criteria
Alspaugh MatthewCarlo JimFalconer DavidFoley MarkFoster RobertGupta AlokHancock DaleHarel HaimKhanna AmarpalKreig AndrewMonk AntonNadeau JamesOng Ling ChuenRafie ManouchehrRibner David BWheatley Chuck FYang S MichaelYurtkuran Erol
Motion 5
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MAC based on802161-0001r4bullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
Appendix E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
15
Charge to Task Groupsbull Complete the task on your agenda
ndashUpdate agenda on bulletin board
bull Prepare for next meetingndashCall for Contributions etc
bull Prepare for Closing Plenary
ndashAll motions to be in writingbull Document everything
ndash submit documents before you leavendash provide document index on bulletin board
bull Presentations to server 2 hours in advance
Voting in Task Groups
bull Only 80216 Voting Members may vote in taskGroup meetingsndashShow Voting Token
bull All present are eligible to vote at Study Groupmeetings
New Business
bull Request for New Business items
Adjournment
bull Chair asks unanimous consent to adjournthis meeting of Working Group 80216until the Midweek Plenaryndash(5-6 pm on Wednesday 13 September)
TG2 Status Report
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 1
IEEE 802162 Activities
Recommended Practice forCoexistence of BroadbandWireless Access Systems
Co-chairs Leland Langston Andy McGregor
Vice Chair Remi ChayerEditor Vito Scaringi
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 2
Activities since San DiegoMeeting
bull R7 of draft Practice issued late July
bull Several input docs and comments receivedbull Teleconference held Sept 7th ndash 8 participants
ndashSignificant discussion on content
bull R8 of draft Practice available Sept 11th
11 September 2000 IEEE 802162 3
Plans for Denver
bull Close issue of single vs multiple interferers
bull Review doc for consistency amp completenessbull Present summary to joint TG1TG2bull Post R9 in week of Sept 18th
bull Seeking comments from any 80216 participant
bull TARGET TG ballot following Tampa meeting
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
16
Appendix B Midweek Plenary Presentations
Midweek Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Midweek Plenary Meeting AgendaWednesday 13 September 2000 1700-1800
Opening of Midweek Plenary Meeting 1700Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Midweek Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule Update Marks V
Announcements 1705
Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IAttendance books badges etc Marin I
802161 1710
Report Marks I802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1720Report McGregor I
802163 1730
Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1740
Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1745
Liaison 1750
ITU Costa ETSI BRAN Klein
Closing 1755
New Business (Marin Editorial Process) Marks VAdjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
17
Agenda for the Week as revised at the Midweek Plenary
80216 Session 9 Agenda Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMon
RAWCONKeynoteAddress
Ballroom A-D
120-150 pm(80216
RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCONLunch
1230-130pm
(80216Registrants
Invited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon G
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon H
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG16-730 pmSalon E
TG3Salon E
8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
TG3730-10 pm
Salon E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
18
Appendix C Closing Plenary Presentations
Closing Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Closing Plenary Meeting AgendaFriday 15 September 2000 10 am -1200 noon
Opening 1000Call to Order Marks IAgenda Marks V
Announcements 1003Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IVice Chair Marks I80216 Logo Marks D
WirelessHUMAN 1010Report Satapathy IPAR Approval Satapathy V
802161 1025Report Marks I802161 Working Group Review Marks V
802162 1050Report McGregor IFinal Task Group Review McGregor IMotions McGregor V
802163 1110Report Kiernan IMotions Kiernan V
Future Meetings 1130
Session 10 6-10 November 2000 Hyatt Regency Tampa Tampa Florida USA Marks ISunday Monday Friday at Session 10 Marks DSession 11 22-26 January 2001 Tel Aviv Israel Marks ISession 12 12-15 March 2001 Hyatt Regency Hilton Head South Carolina USA Marks ISession 13 7-11 May 2001 Orlando Florida USA along with IEEE 80211 and 80215 Marks I
Liaison 1135
ETSI BRANnotification of 802161 status and offer of password Marks V
Regulatory Agency notifications Robinson V
New Business 114080216 Editorial Policy MarinPetry V
Closing 1200
Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
19
WirelessHUMANtrade Closing Presentation[Insert Document Title Here]
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
[The appropriate coordinator normally the Task Group Chair will fill in this number after obtaining it from the 80216 Chair The
document number will match that of the base contribution with ldquoprdquo replacing ldquocrdquo For example 802161p-00nn]Date Submitted
[2000-07-13]Source
[Durga Satapathy] [Voice(913) 534-6338] [Sprint] [Fax (913) 534-6522] [7101 College Blvd Suite 1436 B] mailto[durgasatapathymailsprintcom [Overland Park KS 66210]
Venue
[IEEE 80216 Session 8]Base Document
[If this presentation illustrates an 80216 document cite the document number and URL lthttpieee802org16hellipgt]Purpose
[WirelessHUMAN Study Group report at closing plenary]Notice
This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s)The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw materialcontained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creation of anIEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution and at theIEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor also acknowledges and acceptsthat this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including the statementldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developingcommittee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purpose ofimplementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chair ltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt asearly as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology that is under consideration by or has beenapproved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentslettersgt
IEEE 80216 Plenary Report
Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed Metropolitan Area Network
(WirelessHUMANTM) Study Group
Durga P Satapathy
WirelessHUMANTM Update
bull Reviewed 8 contributions
bull Achieved consensus on selecting standardsto utilizemodifyndashMAC 80216ndashPHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
bull Drafted PAR and 5 criteria
WirelessHUMANTM PAR Scope This standard specifies the physical layer and media access control
layer of the air interface of interoperable fixed broadband wirelessmetropolitan area network systems including point-to-multipoint Thestandard enables access to data video and voice services with qualityof service in unlicensed bands designated for public network access Itwill focus on the 5-6 GHz range and may be applied to unlicensedbands between 2 and 11 GHz The WirelessHUMAN standard willutilize or modify applicable elements from the following
MAC 80216
PHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
The development of the WirelessHUMAN standard will follow thetimeline as shown in Appendix A
WirelessHUMANTM Timeline
bull Call For Proposals for WirelessHUMAN PHYMAC Nov 2000)ndash PHY Modifications of 80211a HIPERLAN2ndash MAC Modifications of 80216
bull Review proposals Jan 2001
bull Select candidate proposals at Interim meeting Feb 2001bull Decision on specific modifications March 2001
bull First Draft Standard May 2001
bull Comment Resolutions July 2001
bull Second Draft Standard Sep 2001bull Finalize WirelessHUMAN Standard Nov 2001
Purpose of Proposed Project
To enable rapid worldwide deployment of innovative cost-effectiveand interoperable multi-vendor broadband wireless metropolitan areanetwork products operating in the unlicensed bands To facilitatecompetition in broadband access by providing fixed wirelessalternatives to wireline broadband access Identify techniques totolerate interference in the unlicensed bands facilitate strategies forcoexistence with other unlicensed band systems such as 80211a andmaximize the carrying capacity of the unlicensed bands Encourageconsistent worldwide allocation and accelerate the commercializationof unlicensed broadband wireless access spectrum Utilization ofunlicensed frequencies will address a market that includes residencesSmall Office-Home Office (SOHO) telecommuters and Small andMedium Enterprises (SME)
WirelessHUMAN Study Group Participants
Sprint RF Solutions Agilent Technologies
Intel Breezecom Adaptive BroadbandNokia Transcomm Inc Cabletron
Ericsson BNA Systems WirelessHomeLucent Escape Carleton UniversityIntracom Malibu Networks Carnegie Mellon UniversityProxim Ultracom Georgia Institute of TechnologyWaveIP Harris Corporation HRL Laboratories LLCN Band Com Wireless Inc Western MultiplexCoreon Inc Cabletron systems Communications Research Center
Runcom Magnolia Broadband Yokogawa Electric CoInnowave ECI
Motion
The proposed WirelessHUMANTM PARbe accepted
TG1 MAC ClosingPresentation
(TG1 MAC reportppt)
1 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
TG1 MAC group
bull Resolved comments received during Final TaskGroup review
bull Major effort to remove any particular PHYdependence from the MAC
bull Process of adding features useful for TG3requirments started
bull Meeting with TG3
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
20
2 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
Important MAC decisions
bull Adoption of EUI-48 addresses (previouslyEUI-64)
bull Addition of error control to MAC layer(previously defined in TC layer of PHY B)
bull Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes into asingle mode
bull Redesigned DL MAP message for higherspectral efficiency
TG1 PHY ClosingPresentation
Document Number80216pp-
TitlePHY TG1 Report at Session 9
Date Submitted
91500Source
Jay KleinVenue
Denver September 2000Base Document
None
PurposeReport
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist the IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the
contributing individual(s) or organization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after furtherstudy The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by 80216
IEEE Patent Policy
The contributor is familiar with the IEEE Patent Policy which is set forth in the IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylawslthttpstandards ieeeorgguidesbylawsgt and includes the statement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s)
including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developing committee and provided theIEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standardrdquo
PHY TG1 Report Session 9
Jay KleinEnsemble Communications
Documents Submitted
bull 802161pc-0044 (2000-09-07) Recommendation onLMDS Radio Propagation Channel Models
bull 802161c-0007 (2000-09-10)FEC Parameterization for Data Transport (Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0006 (2000-09-08)FEC Parameterization for Control Channel Information(Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0004 (2000-09-01)Frequency Synthesizer Model Parameters (Lars Lindh andHans Somerma)
Documents Submitted ndash cont
bull 802161c-0003 (2000-09-01)Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes in802161 (Ken Stanwood)
bull 802161c-0001 (2000-08-08)Summary of Open PHY Issues in IEEE 802161-0001 (Jeff Foerster)
Work done
bull All editorial comments resolved
bull All technical comments reviewed andresolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull TBDs resolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull Met with MAC group for ldquosynchronizingrdquo
TG3 Closing Presentation
802163 Task Group Reportbull Finished and Adopted Functional
Requirements Document except for editorialsndashOutput Comment database on server
bull Developed an initial List of EvaluationCriteria for PHY proposal evaluations FullCriteria to be developed at next meeting
bull Issuing two calls for contributionsndashPreliminary PHY proposalsndashDeployment Traffic and Propagation
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS
bull Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull Session 10 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband WirelessAccess will be held on 6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA In orderto assist in the evaluation of air interface proposals the 802163 Task Groupinvites contributions addressing the following issues
lang Traffic and deployment models based on single and multi-cellsystems
lang Channel propagation model
bull Contributions must be submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt Submissions will beconsidered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible followingreceipt for public access on the 80216 Web Site Email your contribution tothe 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernanltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 Chair Roger Marksltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS - Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull The Task Group 3 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access is preparing to define the PHY protocols for abroadband wireless access air interface specification for frequencies from 2 through 11 GHz The specification will be based on submittedcontributions with increasing detail required as the process progresses Mergers and improvements will be encouraged with final selectionscheduled for June 2001
bull The TG3 Task Group invites the submission of initial contributions representing proposed PHY solutions Contributors will be grantedagenda time during 80216 Working Group Session 10 (6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA) to present and discuss the merits oftheir proposals Only submissions to session 10 will be eligible for invitation to submit more detailed proposals to session 11 Eachproposal will be allocated equal agenda time on Tuesday November 7 If time permits the allocations will be 15 minutes of presentationfollowed by 15 minutes of discussion Submissions must follow the guidelines below
lang Include a descriptive titlelang Include an overview and a reference model that describes functions including interfaces to other layerslang Describe the benefits of the proposed PHY including any unique featureslang Describe any drawbacks of the proposed PHY
bull Explain how the submitted PHY relates to existing standards such as ITU-R JRG 8A-9B IEEE 80211 DOCSIS 11 ETSI HiperLAN orothers If it is based on an existing standard what differences occur due to BWA characteristics
lang Emphasize the scalability of the proposed PHY to deal efficiently with various data types as described in the 802163Functional Requirements Document
lang Include a statement on intellectual property rights and how 80216 may utilize the proposed PHY in a standard
bull The proposals will be evaluated based on criteria in the Evaluation Table below However at this initial stage contributions are not expectedto address in detail the discussion items in that table instead aiming for the more general description as outlined above Each of the VotingMembers of 80216 are eligible to participate in the evaluation if present Submitters receiving a combined score of 6 or better (out of 10) inany criterion in the Evaluation Table will be invited to submit more a detailed contribution for Session 11 (January 22-26 2001 in Tel AvivIsrael) Note that submissions need not represent a complete PHY but may focus on specific components
bull Contributions will be considered only if submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216 Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt The template requires a cover page and a narrative
bull Submissions will be considered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible following receipt for public access on the 80216Web Site lthttpieee802org16gt
bull Email your contribution to the 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernan ltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 ChairRoger Marks ltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
802163 Task Group Report
bull Officially Adopted TG1 MAC as TG3 DraftMAC
bull Create TG3 MAC Ad Hoc to review TG1MAC and provide TG3 Comments
bull Two Motions for the Working GroupndashLiaison to ETSI BRAN sub11 GHz WGndashEstablishment of 80216 Common MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
21
Motion 1
That the 80216 Working Group appoint ChetShirali as a liaison to the ETSI BRAN sub11GHz Working Group
Motion 2
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MACbullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
22
Appendix D Attendance at Session9Session9 was an interim session The 75 interval attendance criteria for Session 9 was 6 ormore intervals Please contact the 80216 Secretary (smarinixnetcomcom) if you feel yourattendance has been recorded incorrectly
The following 126 peopleregistered attendance at 6or more intervals and metthe attendance criteria
Aboukarr BakriAn SongArefi RezaArunachalam ArunAvera DraytAvivi EliAyyagari DeepakBaragar IanBaseghi BehshadBaugh CR (Rick)Belfiore CarlosBenyamin-Seeyar AnaderBushue CarlBuskila BaruchChan RebeccaChang DeanChayer ReacutemiCondie MaryCornelius JamesCosta JoseacuteCrilly Jr William JDoherty EdwardEdmonston BrainEidson BrianEklund CarlEl-Damhougy HeshamFishel GeorgeFoerster JeffreyGarrison G JackGesbert DavidGoldhammer MariannaGuillemette PhilGupta RakeshHadad ZionHall EricHamilton MichaelHammons RogerHatim BayaHebron YoanHilberman DanHosur SrinathHsuan YiHudson ThomasHum ColemanHunter WayneJacobsen EricJamali Hamadi
Jorgensen JacobKang InchulKasslin MikaKiernan BrianKim JohnKitroser ItzikKlein JayKolze ThomasKostas DemosKwak Byung-JaeKwak JoeLangley John BLangston J LelandLeiba YigalLewis BarryLicardie SergioLiebetreu JohnLindh LarsLo TitusMarin ScottMarks RogerMcCallister RonMcGregor AndyMcMullin RoderickMeyer RonaldMiddleton AndrewMizoguchi MasatoMody ApurvaMollenauer JamesPadan UziPetry BrianPleasant WayneRalston WilliamRan MosheResheff GuyRhodes ValentineRobinson GeneRoehr WaltRzeszewski TedSantacesaria ClaudioSatapathy DurgaSater GlenScaringi VitoScarpa CarlSchwartz RandallSegal YossiSellars MalcolmShan Tie-JunShimada ShusakuShirali ChetSkaar HelgeSmith SteveStamatelos George
Stambaugh KarlStanwood KenStewart MichaelStruhsaker PaulSydor JohnTappenden ChrisTateishi KimiyaTavormina JoeThomas RaymondThompson PaulTrinkwon DavidVan Waes NicoVarma SubirWachira MuyaWang ArthurWang Chao-ChunWang LeiWang XiaofengWard BobWhitehead PhilipWhiting RobertWilliams David GWise CurtWiss JohnYanover VladimirZuniga Juan Carlos
The following 18 peopleregistered attendance atless than 6 intervals anddid not meet theattendance criteria
Alspaugh MatthewCarlo JimFalconer DavidFoley MarkFoster RobertGupta AlokHancock DaleHarel HaimKhanna AmarpalKreig AndrewMonk AntonNadeau JamesOng Ling ChuenRafie ManouchehrRibner David BWheatley Chuck FYang S MichaelYurtkuran Erol
Motion 5
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MAC based on802161-0001r4bullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
Appendix E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
16
Appendix B Midweek Plenary Presentations
Midweek Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Midweek Plenary Meeting AgendaWednesday 13 September 2000 1700-1800
Opening of Midweek Plenary Meeting 1700Call to Order Marks IPresentation and Approval of 80216 Midweek Plenary Agenda Marks VSchedule Update Marks V
Announcements 1705
Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IAttendance books badges etc Marin I
802161 1710
Report Marks I802161 MAC Eklund 802161 PHY Klein
802162 1720Report McGregor I
802163 1730
Report Kiernan I
WirelessHUMAN 1740
Report Satapathy I
Charge to Task Groups Marks 1745
Liaison 1750
ITU Costa ETSI BRAN Klein
Closing 1755
New Business (Marin Editorial Process) Marks VAdjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
17
Agenda for the Week as revised at the Midweek Plenary
80216 Session 9 Agenda Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMon
RAWCONKeynoteAddress
Ballroom A-D
120-150 pm(80216
RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCONLunch
1230-130pm
(80216Registrants
Invited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon G
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon H
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG16-730 pmSalon E
TG3Salon E
8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
TG3730-10 pm
Salon E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
18
Appendix C Closing Plenary Presentations
Closing Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Closing Plenary Meeting AgendaFriday 15 September 2000 10 am -1200 noon
Opening 1000Call to Order Marks IAgenda Marks V
Announcements 1003Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IVice Chair Marks I80216 Logo Marks D
WirelessHUMAN 1010Report Satapathy IPAR Approval Satapathy V
802161 1025Report Marks I802161 Working Group Review Marks V
802162 1050Report McGregor IFinal Task Group Review McGregor IMotions McGregor V
802163 1110Report Kiernan IMotions Kiernan V
Future Meetings 1130
Session 10 6-10 November 2000 Hyatt Regency Tampa Tampa Florida USA Marks ISunday Monday Friday at Session 10 Marks DSession 11 22-26 January 2001 Tel Aviv Israel Marks ISession 12 12-15 March 2001 Hyatt Regency Hilton Head South Carolina USA Marks ISession 13 7-11 May 2001 Orlando Florida USA along with IEEE 80211 and 80215 Marks I
Liaison 1135
ETSI BRANnotification of 802161 status and offer of password Marks V
Regulatory Agency notifications Robinson V
New Business 114080216 Editorial Policy MarinPetry V
Closing 1200
Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
19
WirelessHUMANtrade Closing Presentation[Insert Document Title Here]
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
[The appropriate coordinator normally the Task Group Chair will fill in this number after obtaining it from the 80216 Chair The
document number will match that of the base contribution with ldquoprdquo replacing ldquocrdquo For example 802161p-00nn]Date Submitted
[2000-07-13]Source
[Durga Satapathy] [Voice(913) 534-6338] [Sprint] [Fax (913) 534-6522] [7101 College Blvd Suite 1436 B] mailto[durgasatapathymailsprintcom [Overland Park KS 66210]
Venue
[IEEE 80216 Session 8]Base Document
[If this presentation illustrates an 80216 document cite the document number and URL lthttpieee802org16hellipgt]Purpose
[WirelessHUMAN Study Group report at closing plenary]Notice
This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s)The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw materialcontained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creation of anIEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution and at theIEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor also acknowledges and acceptsthat this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including the statementldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developingcommittee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purpose ofimplementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chair ltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt asearly as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology that is under consideration by or has beenapproved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentslettersgt
IEEE 80216 Plenary Report
Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed Metropolitan Area Network
(WirelessHUMANTM) Study Group
Durga P Satapathy
WirelessHUMANTM Update
bull Reviewed 8 contributions
bull Achieved consensus on selecting standardsto utilizemodifyndashMAC 80216ndashPHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
bull Drafted PAR and 5 criteria
WirelessHUMANTM PAR Scope This standard specifies the physical layer and media access control
layer of the air interface of interoperable fixed broadband wirelessmetropolitan area network systems including point-to-multipoint Thestandard enables access to data video and voice services with qualityof service in unlicensed bands designated for public network access Itwill focus on the 5-6 GHz range and may be applied to unlicensedbands between 2 and 11 GHz The WirelessHUMAN standard willutilize or modify applicable elements from the following
MAC 80216
PHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
The development of the WirelessHUMAN standard will follow thetimeline as shown in Appendix A
WirelessHUMANTM Timeline
bull Call For Proposals for WirelessHUMAN PHYMAC Nov 2000)ndash PHY Modifications of 80211a HIPERLAN2ndash MAC Modifications of 80216
bull Review proposals Jan 2001
bull Select candidate proposals at Interim meeting Feb 2001bull Decision on specific modifications March 2001
bull First Draft Standard May 2001
bull Comment Resolutions July 2001
bull Second Draft Standard Sep 2001bull Finalize WirelessHUMAN Standard Nov 2001
Purpose of Proposed Project
To enable rapid worldwide deployment of innovative cost-effectiveand interoperable multi-vendor broadband wireless metropolitan areanetwork products operating in the unlicensed bands To facilitatecompetition in broadband access by providing fixed wirelessalternatives to wireline broadband access Identify techniques totolerate interference in the unlicensed bands facilitate strategies forcoexistence with other unlicensed band systems such as 80211a andmaximize the carrying capacity of the unlicensed bands Encourageconsistent worldwide allocation and accelerate the commercializationof unlicensed broadband wireless access spectrum Utilization ofunlicensed frequencies will address a market that includes residencesSmall Office-Home Office (SOHO) telecommuters and Small andMedium Enterprises (SME)
WirelessHUMAN Study Group Participants
Sprint RF Solutions Agilent Technologies
Intel Breezecom Adaptive BroadbandNokia Transcomm Inc Cabletron
Ericsson BNA Systems WirelessHomeLucent Escape Carleton UniversityIntracom Malibu Networks Carnegie Mellon UniversityProxim Ultracom Georgia Institute of TechnologyWaveIP Harris Corporation HRL Laboratories LLCN Band Com Wireless Inc Western MultiplexCoreon Inc Cabletron systems Communications Research Center
Runcom Magnolia Broadband Yokogawa Electric CoInnowave ECI
Motion
The proposed WirelessHUMANTM PARbe accepted
TG1 MAC ClosingPresentation
(TG1 MAC reportppt)
1 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
TG1 MAC group
bull Resolved comments received during Final TaskGroup review
bull Major effort to remove any particular PHYdependence from the MAC
bull Process of adding features useful for TG3requirments started
bull Meeting with TG3
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
20
2 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
Important MAC decisions
bull Adoption of EUI-48 addresses (previouslyEUI-64)
bull Addition of error control to MAC layer(previously defined in TC layer of PHY B)
bull Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes into asingle mode
bull Redesigned DL MAP message for higherspectral efficiency
TG1 PHY ClosingPresentation
Document Number80216pp-
TitlePHY TG1 Report at Session 9
Date Submitted
91500Source
Jay KleinVenue
Denver September 2000Base Document
None
PurposeReport
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist the IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the
contributing individual(s) or organization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after furtherstudy The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by 80216
IEEE Patent Policy
The contributor is familiar with the IEEE Patent Policy which is set forth in the IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylawslthttpstandards ieeeorgguidesbylawsgt and includes the statement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s)
including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developing committee and provided theIEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standardrdquo
PHY TG1 Report Session 9
Jay KleinEnsemble Communications
Documents Submitted
bull 802161pc-0044 (2000-09-07) Recommendation onLMDS Radio Propagation Channel Models
bull 802161c-0007 (2000-09-10)FEC Parameterization for Data Transport (Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0006 (2000-09-08)FEC Parameterization for Control Channel Information(Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0004 (2000-09-01)Frequency Synthesizer Model Parameters (Lars Lindh andHans Somerma)
Documents Submitted ndash cont
bull 802161c-0003 (2000-09-01)Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes in802161 (Ken Stanwood)
bull 802161c-0001 (2000-08-08)Summary of Open PHY Issues in IEEE 802161-0001 (Jeff Foerster)
Work done
bull All editorial comments resolved
bull All technical comments reviewed andresolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull TBDs resolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull Met with MAC group for ldquosynchronizingrdquo
TG3 Closing Presentation
802163 Task Group Reportbull Finished and Adopted Functional
Requirements Document except for editorialsndashOutput Comment database on server
bull Developed an initial List of EvaluationCriteria for PHY proposal evaluations FullCriteria to be developed at next meeting
bull Issuing two calls for contributionsndashPreliminary PHY proposalsndashDeployment Traffic and Propagation
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS
bull Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull Session 10 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband WirelessAccess will be held on 6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA In orderto assist in the evaluation of air interface proposals the 802163 Task Groupinvites contributions addressing the following issues
lang Traffic and deployment models based on single and multi-cellsystems
lang Channel propagation model
bull Contributions must be submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt Submissions will beconsidered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible followingreceipt for public access on the 80216 Web Site Email your contribution tothe 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernanltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 Chair Roger Marksltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS - Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull The Task Group 3 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access is preparing to define the PHY protocols for abroadband wireless access air interface specification for frequencies from 2 through 11 GHz The specification will be based on submittedcontributions with increasing detail required as the process progresses Mergers and improvements will be encouraged with final selectionscheduled for June 2001
bull The TG3 Task Group invites the submission of initial contributions representing proposed PHY solutions Contributors will be grantedagenda time during 80216 Working Group Session 10 (6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA) to present and discuss the merits oftheir proposals Only submissions to session 10 will be eligible for invitation to submit more detailed proposals to session 11 Eachproposal will be allocated equal agenda time on Tuesday November 7 If time permits the allocations will be 15 minutes of presentationfollowed by 15 minutes of discussion Submissions must follow the guidelines below
lang Include a descriptive titlelang Include an overview and a reference model that describes functions including interfaces to other layerslang Describe the benefits of the proposed PHY including any unique featureslang Describe any drawbacks of the proposed PHY
bull Explain how the submitted PHY relates to existing standards such as ITU-R JRG 8A-9B IEEE 80211 DOCSIS 11 ETSI HiperLAN orothers If it is based on an existing standard what differences occur due to BWA characteristics
lang Emphasize the scalability of the proposed PHY to deal efficiently with various data types as described in the 802163Functional Requirements Document
lang Include a statement on intellectual property rights and how 80216 may utilize the proposed PHY in a standard
bull The proposals will be evaluated based on criteria in the Evaluation Table below However at this initial stage contributions are not expectedto address in detail the discussion items in that table instead aiming for the more general description as outlined above Each of the VotingMembers of 80216 are eligible to participate in the evaluation if present Submitters receiving a combined score of 6 or better (out of 10) inany criterion in the Evaluation Table will be invited to submit more a detailed contribution for Session 11 (January 22-26 2001 in Tel AvivIsrael) Note that submissions need not represent a complete PHY but may focus on specific components
bull Contributions will be considered only if submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216 Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt The template requires a cover page and a narrative
bull Submissions will be considered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible following receipt for public access on the 80216Web Site lthttpieee802org16gt
bull Email your contribution to the 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernan ltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 ChairRoger Marks ltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
802163 Task Group Report
bull Officially Adopted TG1 MAC as TG3 DraftMAC
bull Create TG3 MAC Ad Hoc to review TG1MAC and provide TG3 Comments
bull Two Motions for the Working GroupndashLiaison to ETSI BRAN sub11 GHz WGndashEstablishment of 80216 Common MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
21
Motion 1
That the 80216 Working Group appoint ChetShirali as a liaison to the ETSI BRAN sub11GHz Working Group
Motion 2
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MACbullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
22
Appendix D Attendance at Session9Session9 was an interim session The 75 interval attendance criteria for Session 9 was 6 ormore intervals Please contact the 80216 Secretary (smarinixnetcomcom) if you feel yourattendance has been recorded incorrectly
The following 126 peopleregistered attendance at 6or more intervals and metthe attendance criteria
Aboukarr BakriAn SongArefi RezaArunachalam ArunAvera DraytAvivi EliAyyagari DeepakBaragar IanBaseghi BehshadBaugh CR (Rick)Belfiore CarlosBenyamin-Seeyar AnaderBushue CarlBuskila BaruchChan RebeccaChang DeanChayer ReacutemiCondie MaryCornelius JamesCosta JoseacuteCrilly Jr William JDoherty EdwardEdmonston BrainEidson BrianEklund CarlEl-Damhougy HeshamFishel GeorgeFoerster JeffreyGarrison G JackGesbert DavidGoldhammer MariannaGuillemette PhilGupta RakeshHadad ZionHall EricHamilton MichaelHammons RogerHatim BayaHebron YoanHilberman DanHosur SrinathHsuan YiHudson ThomasHum ColemanHunter WayneJacobsen EricJamali Hamadi
Jorgensen JacobKang InchulKasslin MikaKiernan BrianKim JohnKitroser ItzikKlein JayKolze ThomasKostas DemosKwak Byung-JaeKwak JoeLangley John BLangston J LelandLeiba YigalLewis BarryLicardie SergioLiebetreu JohnLindh LarsLo TitusMarin ScottMarks RogerMcCallister RonMcGregor AndyMcMullin RoderickMeyer RonaldMiddleton AndrewMizoguchi MasatoMody ApurvaMollenauer JamesPadan UziPetry BrianPleasant WayneRalston WilliamRan MosheResheff GuyRhodes ValentineRobinson GeneRoehr WaltRzeszewski TedSantacesaria ClaudioSatapathy DurgaSater GlenScaringi VitoScarpa CarlSchwartz RandallSegal YossiSellars MalcolmShan Tie-JunShimada ShusakuShirali ChetSkaar HelgeSmith SteveStamatelos George
Stambaugh KarlStanwood KenStewart MichaelStruhsaker PaulSydor JohnTappenden ChrisTateishi KimiyaTavormina JoeThomas RaymondThompson PaulTrinkwon DavidVan Waes NicoVarma SubirWachira MuyaWang ArthurWang Chao-ChunWang LeiWang XiaofengWard BobWhitehead PhilipWhiting RobertWilliams David GWise CurtWiss JohnYanover VladimirZuniga Juan Carlos
The following 18 peopleregistered attendance atless than 6 intervals anddid not meet theattendance criteria
Alspaugh MatthewCarlo JimFalconer DavidFoley MarkFoster RobertGupta AlokHancock DaleHarel HaimKhanna AmarpalKreig AndrewMonk AntonNadeau JamesOng Ling ChuenRafie ManouchehrRibner David BWheatley Chuck FYang S MichaelYurtkuran Erol
Motion 5
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MAC based on802161-0001r4bullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
Appendix E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
17
Agenda for the Week as revised at the Midweek Plenary
80216 Session 9 Agenda Morning Afternoon Evening
TG1330-5 pmSalon E
TG2330-5 pmColorado
RoomMon
RAWCONKeynoteAddress
Ballroom A-D
120-150 pm(80216
RegistrantsInvited)
80216OpeningPlenary
2-315 pmSalon E TG3
330-5 pmNebraska
Room
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Banquet700-1000 pm
with RAWCON Panel Session830-1000 pm
(buy ticket from RAWCON)
TG1 MACSalon E
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 MACSalon E
130 pm-4 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
8 am-1230 pm
TG1 PHYSalon G
130 pm-4 pm
TG2Nebraska Room8 am-1230 pm
TG2Nebraska Room130 pm-530 pm
TG3The View
8 am-1230 pm
TG3The View
130 pm-530 pm
Tue
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-1230 pm
RAWCONLunch
1230-130pm
(80216Registrants
Invited)
WirelessHUMANSalon F
130 pm-4 pm
RAWCONExhibitionReceptionPoster Session
530-700 pm(80216 Registrants Invited)
RAWCON Panel Session700-900 pm
(80216 Registrants Invited)
TG1 MACSalon G
8 am-5 pm
TG1 PHYSalon H
8 am-5 pm
TG2Salon 4
8 am-5 pm
TG16-730 pmSalon E
TG3Salon E
8 am-5 pm
Wed
WirelessHUMANSalon F
8 am-5 pm
80216MidweekPlenary5-6 pm
TG3730-10 pm
Salon E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
18
Appendix C Closing Plenary Presentations
Closing Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Closing Plenary Meeting AgendaFriday 15 September 2000 10 am -1200 noon
Opening 1000Call to Order Marks IAgenda Marks V
Announcements 1003Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IVice Chair Marks I80216 Logo Marks D
WirelessHUMAN 1010Report Satapathy IPAR Approval Satapathy V
802161 1025Report Marks I802161 Working Group Review Marks V
802162 1050Report McGregor IFinal Task Group Review McGregor IMotions McGregor V
802163 1110Report Kiernan IMotions Kiernan V
Future Meetings 1130
Session 10 6-10 November 2000 Hyatt Regency Tampa Tampa Florida USA Marks ISunday Monday Friday at Session 10 Marks DSession 11 22-26 January 2001 Tel Aviv Israel Marks ISession 12 12-15 March 2001 Hyatt Regency Hilton Head South Carolina USA Marks ISession 13 7-11 May 2001 Orlando Florida USA along with IEEE 80211 and 80215 Marks I
Liaison 1135
ETSI BRANnotification of 802161 status and offer of password Marks V
Regulatory Agency notifications Robinson V
New Business 114080216 Editorial Policy MarinPetry V
Closing 1200
Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
19
WirelessHUMANtrade Closing Presentation[Insert Document Title Here]
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
[The appropriate coordinator normally the Task Group Chair will fill in this number after obtaining it from the 80216 Chair The
document number will match that of the base contribution with ldquoprdquo replacing ldquocrdquo For example 802161p-00nn]Date Submitted
[2000-07-13]Source
[Durga Satapathy] [Voice(913) 534-6338] [Sprint] [Fax (913) 534-6522] [7101 College Blvd Suite 1436 B] mailto[durgasatapathymailsprintcom [Overland Park KS 66210]
Venue
[IEEE 80216 Session 8]Base Document
[If this presentation illustrates an 80216 document cite the document number and URL lthttpieee802org16hellipgt]Purpose
[WirelessHUMAN Study Group report at closing plenary]Notice
This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s)The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw materialcontained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creation of anIEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution and at theIEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor also acknowledges and acceptsthat this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including the statementldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developingcommittee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purpose ofimplementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chair ltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt asearly as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology that is under consideration by or has beenapproved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentslettersgt
IEEE 80216 Plenary Report
Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed Metropolitan Area Network
(WirelessHUMANTM) Study Group
Durga P Satapathy
WirelessHUMANTM Update
bull Reviewed 8 contributions
bull Achieved consensus on selecting standardsto utilizemodifyndashMAC 80216ndashPHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
bull Drafted PAR and 5 criteria
WirelessHUMANTM PAR Scope This standard specifies the physical layer and media access control
layer of the air interface of interoperable fixed broadband wirelessmetropolitan area network systems including point-to-multipoint Thestandard enables access to data video and voice services with qualityof service in unlicensed bands designated for public network access Itwill focus on the 5-6 GHz range and may be applied to unlicensedbands between 2 and 11 GHz The WirelessHUMAN standard willutilize or modify applicable elements from the following
MAC 80216
PHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
The development of the WirelessHUMAN standard will follow thetimeline as shown in Appendix A
WirelessHUMANTM Timeline
bull Call For Proposals for WirelessHUMAN PHYMAC Nov 2000)ndash PHY Modifications of 80211a HIPERLAN2ndash MAC Modifications of 80216
bull Review proposals Jan 2001
bull Select candidate proposals at Interim meeting Feb 2001bull Decision on specific modifications March 2001
bull First Draft Standard May 2001
bull Comment Resolutions July 2001
bull Second Draft Standard Sep 2001bull Finalize WirelessHUMAN Standard Nov 2001
Purpose of Proposed Project
To enable rapid worldwide deployment of innovative cost-effectiveand interoperable multi-vendor broadband wireless metropolitan areanetwork products operating in the unlicensed bands To facilitatecompetition in broadband access by providing fixed wirelessalternatives to wireline broadband access Identify techniques totolerate interference in the unlicensed bands facilitate strategies forcoexistence with other unlicensed band systems such as 80211a andmaximize the carrying capacity of the unlicensed bands Encourageconsistent worldwide allocation and accelerate the commercializationof unlicensed broadband wireless access spectrum Utilization ofunlicensed frequencies will address a market that includes residencesSmall Office-Home Office (SOHO) telecommuters and Small andMedium Enterprises (SME)
WirelessHUMAN Study Group Participants
Sprint RF Solutions Agilent Technologies
Intel Breezecom Adaptive BroadbandNokia Transcomm Inc Cabletron
Ericsson BNA Systems WirelessHomeLucent Escape Carleton UniversityIntracom Malibu Networks Carnegie Mellon UniversityProxim Ultracom Georgia Institute of TechnologyWaveIP Harris Corporation HRL Laboratories LLCN Band Com Wireless Inc Western MultiplexCoreon Inc Cabletron systems Communications Research Center
Runcom Magnolia Broadband Yokogawa Electric CoInnowave ECI
Motion
The proposed WirelessHUMANTM PARbe accepted
TG1 MAC ClosingPresentation
(TG1 MAC reportppt)
1 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
TG1 MAC group
bull Resolved comments received during Final TaskGroup review
bull Major effort to remove any particular PHYdependence from the MAC
bull Process of adding features useful for TG3requirments started
bull Meeting with TG3
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
20
2 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
Important MAC decisions
bull Adoption of EUI-48 addresses (previouslyEUI-64)
bull Addition of error control to MAC layer(previously defined in TC layer of PHY B)
bull Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes into asingle mode
bull Redesigned DL MAP message for higherspectral efficiency
TG1 PHY ClosingPresentation
Document Number80216pp-
TitlePHY TG1 Report at Session 9
Date Submitted
91500Source
Jay KleinVenue
Denver September 2000Base Document
None
PurposeReport
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist the IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the
contributing individual(s) or organization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after furtherstudy The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by 80216
IEEE Patent Policy
The contributor is familiar with the IEEE Patent Policy which is set forth in the IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylawslthttpstandards ieeeorgguidesbylawsgt and includes the statement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s)
including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developing committee and provided theIEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standardrdquo
PHY TG1 Report Session 9
Jay KleinEnsemble Communications
Documents Submitted
bull 802161pc-0044 (2000-09-07) Recommendation onLMDS Radio Propagation Channel Models
bull 802161c-0007 (2000-09-10)FEC Parameterization for Data Transport (Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0006 (2000-09-08)FEC Parameterization for Control Channel Information(Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0004 (2000-09-01)Frequency Synthesizer Model Parameters (Lars Lindh andHans Somerma)
Documents Submitted ndash cont
bull 802161c-0003 (2000-09-01)Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes in802161 (Ken Stanwood)
bull 802161c-0001 (2000-08-08)Summary of Open PHY Issues in IEEE 802161-0001 (Jeff Foerster)
Work done
bull All editorial comments resolved
bull All technical comments reviewed andresolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull TBDs resolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull Met with MAC group for ldquosynchronizingrdquo
TG3 Closing Presentation
802163 Task Group Reportbull Finished and Adopted Functional
Requirements Document except for editorialsndashOutput Comment database on server
bull Developed an initial List of EvaluationCriteria for PHY proposal evaluations FullCriteria to be developed at next meeting
bull Issuing two calls for contributionsndashPreliminary PHY proposalsndashDeployment Traffic and Propagation
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS
bull Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull Session 10 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband WirelessAccess will be held on 6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA In orderto assist in the evaluation of air interface proposals the 802163 Task Groupinvites contributions addressing the following issues
lang Traffic and deployment models based on single and multi-cellsystems
lang Channel propagation model
bull Contributions must be submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt Submissions will beconsidered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible followingreceipt for public access on the 80216 Web Site Email your contribution tothe 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernanltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 Chair Roger Marksltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS - Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull The Task Group 3 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access is preparing to define the PHY protocols for abroadband wireless access air interface specification for frequencies from 2 through 11 GHz The specification will be based on submittedcontributions with increasing detail required as the process progresses Mergers and improvements will be encouraged with final selectionscheduled for June 2001
bull The TG3 Task Group invites the submission of initial contributions representing proposed PHY solutions Contributors will be grantedagenda time during 80216 Working Group Session 10 (6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA) to present and discuss the merits oftheir proposals Only submissions to session 10 will be eligible for invitation to submit more detailed proposals to session 11 Eachproposal will be allocated equal agenda time on Tuesday November 7 If time permits the allocations will be 15 minutes of presentationfollowed by 15 minutes of discussion Submissions must follow the guidelines below
lang Include a descriptive titlelang Include an overview and a reference model that describes functions including interfaces to other layerslang Describe the benefits of the proposed PHY including any unique featureslang Describe any drawbacks of the proposed PHY
bull Explain how the submitted PHY relates to existing standards such as ITU-R JRG 8A-9B IEEE 80211 DOCSIS 11 ETSI HiperLAN orothers If it is based on an existing standard what differences occur due to BWA characteristics
lang Emphasize the scalability of the proposed PHY to deal efficiently with various data types as described in the 802163Functional Requirements Document
lang Include a statement on intellectual property rights and how 80216 may utilize the proposed PHY in a standard
bull The proposals will be evaluated based on criteria in the Evaluation Table below However at this initial stage contributions are not expectedto address in detail the discussion items in that table instead aiming for the more general description as outlined above Each of the VotingMembers of 80216 are eligible to participate in the evaluation if present Submitters receiving a combined score of 6 or better (out of 10) inany criterion in the Evaluation Table will be invited to submit more a detailed contribution for Session 11 (January 22-26 2001 in Tel AvivIsrael) Note that submissions need not represent a complete PHY but may focus on specific components
bull Contributions will be considered only if submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216 Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt The template requires a cover page and a narrative
bull Submissions will be considered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible following receipt for public access on the 80216Web Site lthttpieee802org16gt
bull Email your contribution to the 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernan ltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 ChairRoger Marks ltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
802163 Task Group Report
bull Officially Adopted TG1 MAC as TG3 DraftMAC
bull Create TG3 MAC Ad Hoc to review TG1MAC and provide TG3 Comments
bull Two Motions for the Working GroupndashLiaison to ETSI BRAN sub11 GHz WGndashEstablishment of 80216 Common MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
21
Motion 1
That the 80216 Working Group appoint ChetShirali as a liaison to the ETSI BRAN sub11GHz Working Group
Motion 2
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MACbullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
22
Appendix D Attendance at Session9Session9 was an interim session The 75 interval attendance criteria for Session 9 was 6 ormore intervals Please contact the 80216 Secretary (smarinixnetcomcom) if you feel yourattendance has been recorded incorrectly
The following 126 peopleregistered attendance at 6or more intervals and metthe attendance criteria
Aboukarr BakriAn SongArefi RezaArunachalam ArunAvera DraytAvivi EliAyyagari DeepakBaragar IanBaseghi BehshadBaugh CR (Rick)Belfiore CarlosBenyamin-Seeyar AnaderBushue CarlBuskila BaruchChan RebeccaChang DeanChayer ReacutemiCondie MaryCornelius JamesCosta JoseacuteCrilly Jr William JDoherty EdwardEdmonston BrainEidson BrianEklund CarlEl-Damhougy HeshamFishel GeorgeFoerster JeffreyGarrison G JackGesbert DavidGoldhammer MariannaGuillemette PhilGupta RakeshHadad ZionHall EricHamilton MichaelHammons RogerHatim BayaHebron YoanHilberman DanHosur SrinathHsuan YiHudson ThomasHum ColemanHunter WayneJacobsen EricJamali Hamadi
Jorgensen JacobKang InchulKasslin MikaKiernan BrianKim JohnKitroser ItzikKlein JayKolze ThomasKostas DemosKwak Byung-JaeKwak JoeLangley John BLangston J LelandLeiba YigalLewis BarryLicardie SergioLiebetreu JohnLindh LarsLo TitusMarin ScottMarks RogerMcCallister RonMcGregor AndyMcMullin RoderickMeyer RonaldMiddleton AndrewMizoguchi MasatoMody ApurvaMollenauer JamesPadan UziPetry BrianPleasant WayneRalston WilliamRan MosheResheff GuyRhodes ValentineRobinson GeneRoehr WaltRzeszewski TedSantacesaria ClaudioSatapathy DurgaSater GlenScaringi VitoScarpa CarlSchwartz RandallSegal YossiSellars MalcolmShan Tie-JunShimada ShusakuShirali ChetSkaar HelgeSmith SteveStamatelos George
Stambaugh KarlStanwood KenStewart MichaelStruhsaker PaulSydor JohnTappenden ChrisTateishi KimiyaTavormina JoeThomas RaymondThompson PaulTrinkwon DavidVan Waes NicoVarma SubirWachira MuyaWang ArthurWang Chao-ChunWang LeiWang XiaofengWard BobWhitehead PhilipWhiting RobertWilliams David GWise CurtWiss JohnYanover VladimirZuniga Juan Carlos
The following 18 peopleregistered attendance atless than 6 intervals anddid not meet theattendance criteria
Alspaugh MatthewCarlo JimFalconer DavidFoley MarkFoster RobertGupta AlokHancock DaleHarel HaimKhanna AmarpalKreig AndrewMonk AntonNadeau JamesOng Ling ChuenRafie ManouchehrRibner David BWheatley Chuck FYang S MichaelYurtkuran Erol
Motion 5
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MAC based on802161-0001r4bullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
Appendix E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
18
Appendix C Closing Plenary Presentations
Closing Plenary Agenda
80216 Session 9 Closing Plenary Meeting AgendaFriday 15 September 2000 10 am -1200 noon
Opening 1000Call to Order Marks IAgenda Marks V
Announcements 1003Registration Marks IDocument distribution Marks IVice Chair Marks I80216 Logo Marks D
WirelessHUMAN 1010Report Satapathy IPAR Approval Satapathy V
802161 1025Report Marks I802161 Working Group Review Marks V
802162 1050Report McGregor IFinal Task Group Review McGregor IMotions McGregor V
802163 1110Report Kiernan IMotions Kiernan V
Future Meetings 1130
Session 10 6-10 November 2000 Hyatt Regency Tampa Tampa Florida USA Marks ISunday Monday Friday at Session 10 Marks DSession 11 22-26 January 2001 Tel Aviv Israel Marks ISession 12 12-15 March 2001 Hyatt Regency Hilton Head South Carolina USA Marks ISession 13 7-11 May 2001 Orlando Florida USA along with IEEE 80211 and 80215 Marks I
Liaison 1135
ETSI BRANnotification of 802161 status and offer of password Marks V
Regulatory Agency notifications Robinson V
New Business 114080216 Editorial Policy MarinPetry V
Closing 1200
Adjournment of Opening Plenary Marks V
I=Information D=Discussion V=Vote
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
19
WirelessHUMANtrade Closing Presentation[Insert Document Title Here]
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
[The appropriate coordinator normally the Task Group Chair will fill in this number after obtaining it from the 80216 Chair The
document number will match that of the base contribution with ldquoprdquo replacing ldquocrdquo For example 802161p-00nn]Date Submitted
[2000-07-13]Source
[Durga Satapathy] [Voice(913) 534-6338] [Sprint] [Fax (913) 534-6522] [7101 College Blvd Suite 1436 B] mailto[durgasatapathymailsprintcom [Overland Park KS 66210]
Venue
[IEEE 80216 Session 8]Base Document
[If this presentation illustrates an 80216 document cite the document number and URL lthttpieee802org16hellipgt]Purpose
[WirelessHUMAN Study Group report at closing plenary]Notice
This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s)The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw materialcontained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creation of anIEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution and at theIEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor also acknowledges and acceptsthat this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including the statementldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developingcommittee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purpose ofimplementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chair ltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt asearly as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology that is under consideration by or has beenapproved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentslettersgt
IEEE 80216 Plenary Report
Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed Metropolitan Area Network
(WirelessHUMANTM) Study Group
Durga P Satapathy
WirelessHUMANTM Update
bull Reviewed 8 contributions
bull Achieved consensus on selecting standardsto utilizemodifyndashMAC 80216ndashPHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
bull Drafted PAR and 5 criteria
WirelessHUMANTM PAR Scope This standard specifies the physical layer and media access control
layer of the air interface of interoperable fixed broadband wirelessmetropolitan area network systems including point-to-multipoint Thestandard enables access to data video and voice services with qualityof service in unlicensed bands designated for public network access Itwill focus on the 5-6 GHz range and may be applied to unlicensedbands between 2 and 11 GHz The WirelessHUMAN standard willutilize or modify applicable elements from the following
MAC 80216
PHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
The development of the WirelessHUMAN standard will follow thetimeline as shown in Appendix A
WirelessHUMANTM Timeline
bull Call For Proposals for WirelessHUMAN PHYMAC Nov 2000)ndash PHY Modifications of 80211a HIPERLAN2ndash MAC Modifications of 80216
bull Review proposals Jan 2001
bull Select candidate proposals at Interim meeting Feb 2001bull Decision on specific modifications March 2001
bull First Draft Standard May 2001
bull Comment Resolutions July 2001
bull Second Draft Standard Sep 2001bull Finalize WirelessHUMAN Standard Nov 2001
Purpose of Proposed Project
To enable rapid worldwide deployment of innovative cost-effectiveand interoperable multi-vendor broadband wireless metropolitan areanetwork products operating in the unlicensed bands To facilitatecompetition in broadband access by providing fixed wirelessalternatives to wireline broadband access Identify techniques totolerate interference in the unlicensed bands facilitate strategies forcoexistence with other unlicensed band systems such as 80211a andmaximize the carrying capacity of the unlicensed bands Encourageconsistent worldwide allocation and accelerate the commercializationof unlicensed broadband wireless access spectrum Utilization ofunlicensed frequencies will address a market that includes residencesSmall Office-Home Office (SOHO) telecommuters and Small andMedium Enterprises (SME)
WirelessHUMAN Study Group Participants
Sprint RF Solutions Agilent Technologies
Intel Breezecom Adaptive BroadbandNokia Transcomm Inc Cabletron
Ericsson BNA Systems WirelessHomeLucent Escape Carleton UniversityIntracom Malibu Networks Carnegie Mellon UniversityProxim Ultracom Georgia Institute of TechnologyWaveIP Harris Corporation HRL Laboratories LLCN Band Com Wireless Inc Western MultiplexCoreon Inc Cabletron systems Communications Research Center
Runcom Magnolia Broadband Yokogawa Electric CoInnowave ECI
Motion
The proposed WirelessHUMANTM PARbe accepted
TG1 MAC ClosingPresentation
(TG1 MAC reportppt)
1 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
TG1 MAC group
bull Resolved comments received during Final TaskGroup review
bull Major effort to remove any particular PHYdependence from the MAC
bull Process of adding features useful for TG3requirments started
bull Meeting with TG3
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
20
2 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
Important MAC decisions
bull Adoption of EUI-48 addresses (previouslyEUI-64)
bull Addition of error control to MAC layer(previously defined in TC layer of PHY B)
bull Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes into asingle mode
bull Redesigned DL MAP message for higherspectral efficiency
TG1 PHY ClosingPresentation
Document Number80216pp-
TitlePHY TG1 Report at Session 9
Date Submitted
91500Source
Jay KleinVenue
Denver September 2000Base Document
None
PurposeReport
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist the IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the
contributing individual(s) or organization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after furtherstudy The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by 80216
IEEE Patent Policy
The contributor is familiar with the IEEE Patent Policy which is set forth in the IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylawslthttpstandards ieeeorgguidesbylawsgt and includes the statement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s)
including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developing committee and provided theIEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standardrdquo
PHY TG1 Report Session 9
Jay KleinEnsemble Communications
Documents Submitted
bull 802161pc-0044 (2000-09-07) Recommendation onLMDS Radio Propagation Channel Models
bull 802161c-0007 (2000-09-10)FEC Parameterization for Data Transport (Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0006 (2000-09-08)FEC Parameterization for Control Channel Information(Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0004 (2000-09-01)Frequency Synthesizer Model Parameters (Lars Lindh andHans Somerma)
Documents Submitted ndash cont
bull 802161c-0003 (2000-09-01)Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes in802161 (Ken Stanwood)
bull 802161c-0001 (2000-08-08)Summary of Open PHY Issues in IEEE 802161-0001 (Jeff Foerster)
Work done
bull All editorial comments resolved
bull All technical comments reviewed andresolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull TBDs resolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull Met with MAC group for ldquosynchronizingrdquo
TG3 Closing Presentation
802163 Task Group Reportbull Finished and Adopted Functional
Requirements Document except for editorialsndashOutput Comment database on server
bull Developed an initial List of EvaluationCriteria for PHY proposal evaluations FullCriteria to be developed at next meeting
bull Issuing two calls for contributionsndashPreliminary PHY proposalsndashDeployment Traffic and Propagation
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS
bull Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull Session 10 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband WirelessAccess will be held on 6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA In orderto assist in the evaluation of air interface proposals the 802163 Task Groupinvites contributions addressing the following issues
lang Traffic and deployment models based on single and multi-cellsystems
lang Channel propagation model
bull Contributions must be submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt Submissions will beconsidered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible followingreceipt for public access on the 80216 Web Site Email your contribution tothe 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernanltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 Chair Roger Marksltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS - Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull The Task Group 3 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access is preparing to define the PHY protocols for abroadband wireless access air interface specification for frequencies from 2 through 11 GHz The specification will be based on submittedcontributions with increasing detail required as the process progresses Mergers and improvements will be encouraged with final selectionscheduled for June 2001
bull The TG3 Task Group invites the submission of initial contributions representing proposed PHY solutions Contributors will be grantedagenda time during 80216 Working Group Session 10 (6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA) to present and discuss the merits oftheir proposals Only submissions to session 10 will be eligible for invitation to submit more detailed proposals to session 11 Eachproposal will be allocated equal agenda time on Tuesday November 7 If time permits the allocations will be 15 minutes of presentationfollowed by 15 minutes of discussion Submissions must follow the guidelines below
lang Include a descriptive titlelang Include an overview and a reference model that describes functions including interfaces to other layerslang Describe the benefits of the proposed PHY including any unique featureslang Describe any drawbacks of the proposed PHY
bull Explain how the submitted PHY relates to existing standards such as ITU-R JRG 8A-9B IEEE 80211 DOCSIS 11 ETSI HiperLAN orothers If it is based on an existing standard what differences occur due to BWA characteristics
lang Emphasize the scalability of the proposed PHY to deal efficiently with various data types as described in the 802163Functional Requirements Document
lang Include a statement on intellectual property rights and how 80216 may utilize the proposed PHY in a standard
bull The proposals will be evaluated based on criteria in the Evaluation Table below However at this initial stage contributions are not expectedto address in detail the discussion items in that table instead aiming for the more general description as outlined above Each of the VotingMembers of 80216 are eligible to participate in the evaluation if present Submitters receiving a combined score of 6 or better (out of 10) inany criterion in the Evaluation Table will be invited to submit more a detailed contribution for Session 11 (January 22-26 2001 in Tel AvivIsrael) Note that submissions need not represent a complete PHY but may focus on specific components
bull Contributions will be considered only if submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216 Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt The template requires a cover page and a narrative
bull Submissions will be considered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible following receipt for public access on the 80216Web Site lthttpieee802org16gt
bull Email your contribution to the 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernan ltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 ChairRoger Marks ltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
802163 Task Group Report
bull Officially Adopted TG1 MAC as TG3 DraftMAC
bull Create TG3 MAC Ad Hoc to review TG1MAC and provide TG3 Comments
bull Two Motions for the Working GroupndashLiaison to ETSI BRAN sub11 GHz WGndashEstablishment of 80216 Common MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
21
Motion 1
That the 80216 Working Group appoint ChetShirali as a liaison to the ETSI BRAN sub11GHz Working Group
Motion 2
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MACbullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
22
Appendix D Attendance at Session9Session9 was an interim session The 75 interval attendance criteria for Session 9 was 6 ormore intervals Please contact the 80216 Secretary (smarinixnetcomcom) if you feel yourattendance has been recorded incorrectly
The following 126 peopleregistered attendance at 6or more intervals and metthe attendance criteria
Aboukarr BakriAn SongArefi RezaArunachalam ArunAvera DraytAvivi EliAyyagari DeepakBaragar IanBaseghi BehshadBaugh CR (Rick)Belfiore CarlosBenyamin-Seeyar AnaderBushue CarlBuskila BaruchChan RebeccaChang DeanChayer ReacutemiCondie MaryCornelius JamesCosta JoseacuteCrilly Jr William JDoherty EdwardEdmonston BrainEidson BrianEklund CarlEl-Damhougy HeshamFishel GeorgeFoerster JeffreyGarrison G JackGesbert DavidGoldhammer MariannaGuillemette PhilGupta RakeshHadad ZionHall EricHamilton MichaelHammons RogerHatim BayaHebron YoanHilberman DanHosur SrinathHsuan YiHudson ThomasHum ColemanHunter WayneJacobsen EricJamali Hamadi
Jorgensen JacobKang InchulKasslin MikaKiernan BrianKim JohnKitroser ItzikKlein JayKolze ThomasKostas DemosKwak Byung-JaeKwak JoeLangley John BLangston J LelandLeiba YigalLewis BarryLicardie SergioLiebetreu JohnLindh LarsLo TitusMarin ScottMarks RogerMcCallister RonMcGregor AndyMcMullin RoderickMeyer RonaldMiddleton AndrewMizoguchi MasatoMody ApurvaMollenauer JamesPadan UziPetry BrianPleasant WayneRalston WilliamRan MosheResheff GuyRhodes ValentineRobinson GeneRoehr WaltRzeszewski TedSantacesaria ClaudioSatapathy DurgaSater GlenScaringi VitoScarpa CarlSchwartz RandallSegal YossiSellars MalcolmShan Tie-JunShimada ShusakuShirali ChetSkaar HelgeSmith SteveStamatelos George
Stambaugh KarlStanwood KenStewart MichaelStruhsaker PaulSydor JohnTappenden ChrisTateishi KimiyaTavormina JoeThomas RaymondThompson PaulTrinkwon DavidVan Waes NicoVarma SubirWachira MuyaWang ArthurWang Chao-ChunWang LeiWang XiaofengWard BobWhitehead PhilipWhiting RobertWilliams David GWise CurtWiss JohnYanover VladimirZuniga Juan Carlos
The following 18 peopleregistered attendance atless than 6 intervals anddid not meet theattendance criteria
Alspaugh MatthewCarlo JimFalconer DavidFoley MarkFoster RobertGupta AlokHancock DaleHarel HaimKhanna AmarpalKreig AndrewMonk AntonNadeau JamesOng Ling ChuenRafie ManouchehrRibner David BWheatley Chuck FYang S MichaelYurtkuran Erol
Motion 5
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MAC based on802161-0001r4bullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
Appendix E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
19
WirelessHUMANtrade Closing Presentation[Insert Document Title Here]
IEEE 80216 Presentation Submission Template (Rev 8)Document Number
[The appropriate coordinator normally the Task Group Chair will fill in this number after obtaining it from the 80216 Chair The
document number will match that of the base contribution with ldquoprdquo replacing ldquocrdquo For example 802161p-00nn]Date Submitted
[2000-07-13]Source
[Durga Satapathy] [Voice(913) 534-6338] [Sprint] [Fax (913) 534-6522] [7101 College Blvd Suite 1436 B] mailto[durgasatapathymailsprintcom [Overland Park KS 66210]
Venue
[IEEE 80216 Session 8]Base Document
[If this presentation illustrates an 80216 document cite the document number and URL lthttpieee802org16hellipgt]Purpose
[WirelessHUMAN Study Group report at closing plenary]Notice
This document has been prepared to assist IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s)The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw materialcontained herein
ReleaseThe contributor grants a free irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creation of anIEEE Standards publication to copyright in the IEEErsquos name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution and at theIEEErsquos sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication The contributor also acknowledges and acceptsthat this contribution may be made public by IEEE 80216
IEEE 80216 Patent PolicyThe contributor is familiar with the IEEE 80216 Patent Policy and Procedures (Version 10) lthttpieee802org16iprpatentspolicyhtmlgt including the statementldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s) including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developingcommittee and provided the IEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purpose ofimplementing the standardrdquo
Early disclosure to the Working Group of patent information that might be relevant to the standard is essential to reduce the possibility for delays in thedevelopment process and increase the likelihood that the draft publication will be approved for publication Please notify the Chair ltmailtorbmarksieeeorggt asearly as possible in written or electronic form of any patents (granted or under application) that may cover technology that is under consideration by or has beenapproved by IEEE 80216 The Chair will disclose this notification via the IEEE 80216 web sitelthttpieee802org16iprpatentslettersgt
IEEE 80216 Plenary Report
Wireless High-Speed Unlicensed Metropolitan Area Network
(WirelessHUMANTM) Study Group
Durga P Satapathy
WirelessHUMANTM Update
bull Reviewed 8 contributions
bull Achieved consensus on selecting standardsto utilizemodifyndashMAC 80216ndashPHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
bull Drafted PAR and 5 criteria
WirelessHUMANTM PAR Scope This standard specifies the physical layer and media access control
layer of the air interface of interoperable fixed broadband wirelessmetropolitan area network systems including point-to-multipoint Thestandard enables access to data video and voice services with qualityof service in unlicensed bands designated for public network access Itwill focus on the 5-6 GHz range and may be applied to unlicensedbands between 2 and 11 GHz The WirelessHUMAN standard willutilize or modify applicable elements from the following
MAC 80216
PHY 80211a HIPERLAN2
The development of the WirelessHUMAN standard will follow thetimeline as shown in Appendix A
WirelessHUMANTM Timeline
bull Call For Proposals for WirelessHUMAN PHYMAC Nov 2000)ndash PHY Modifications of 80211a HIPERLAN2ndash MAC Modifications of 80216
bull Review proposals Jan 2001
bull Select candidate proposals at Interim meeting Feb 2001bull Decision on specific modifications March 2001
bull First Draft Standard May 2001
bull Comment Resolutions July 2001
bull Second Draft Standard Sep 2001bull Finalize WirelessHUMAN Standard Nov 2001
Purpose of Proposed Project
To enable rapid worldwide deployment of innovative cost-effectiveand interoperable multi-vendor broadband wireless metropolitan areanetwork products operating in the unlicensed bands To facilitatecompetition in broadband access by providing fixed wirelessalternatives to wireline broadband access Identify techniques totolerate interference in the unlicensed bands facilitate strategies forcoexistence with other unlicensed band systems such as 80211a andmaximize the carrying capacity of the unlicensed bands Encourageconsistent worldwide allocation and accelerate the commercializationof unlicensed broadband wireless access spectrum Utilization ofunlicensed frequencies will address a market that includes residencesSmall Office-Home Office (SOHO) telecommuters and Small andMedium Enterprises (SME)
WirelessHUMAN Study Group Participants
Sprint RF Solutions Agilent Technologies
Intel Breezecom Adaptive BroadbandNokia Transcomm Inc Cabletron
Ericsson BNA Systems WirelessHomeLucent Escape Carleton UniversityIntracom Malibu Networks Carnegie Mellon UniversityProxim Ultracom Georgia Institute of TechnologyWaveIP Harris Corporation HRL Laboratories LLCN Band Com Wireless Inc Western MultiplexCoreon Inc Cabletron systems Communications Research Center
Runcom Magnolia Broadband Yokogawa Electric CoInnowave ECI
Motion
The proposed WirelessHUMANTM PARbe accepted
TG1 MAC ClosingPresentation
(TG1 MAC reportppt)
1 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
TG1 MAC group
bull Resolved comments received during Final TaskGroup review
bull Major effort to remove any particular PHYdependence from the MAC
bull Process of adding features useful for TG3requirments started
bull Meeting with TG3
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
20
2 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
Important MAC decisions
bull Adoption of EUI-48 addresses (previouslyEUI-64)
bull Addition of error control to MAC layer(previously defined in TC layer of PHY B)
bull Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes into asingle mode
bull Redesigned DL MAP message for higherspectral efficiency
TG1 PHY ClosingPresentation
Document Number80216pp-
TitlePHY TG1 Report at Session 9
Date Submitted
91500Source
Jay KleinVenue
Denver September 2000Base Document
None
PurposeReport
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist the IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the
contributing individual(s) or organization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after furtherstudy The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by 80216
IEEE Patent Policy
The contributor is familiar with the IEEE Patent Policy which is set forth in the IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylawslthttpstandards ieeeorgguidesbylawsgt and includes the statement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s)
including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developing committee and provided theIEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standardrdquo
PHY TG1 Report Session 9
Jay KleinEnsemble Communications
Documents Submitted
bull 802161pc-0044 (2000-09-07) Recommendation onLMDS Radio Propagation Channel Models
bull 802161c-0007 (2000-09-10)FEC Parameterization for Data Transport (Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0006 (2000-09-08)FEC Parameterization for Control Channel Information(Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0004 (2000-09-01)Frequency Synthesizer Model Parameters (Lars Lindh andHans Somerma)
Documents Submitted ndash cont
bull 802161c-0003 (2000-09-01)Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes in802161 (Ken Stanwood)
bull 802161c-0001 (2000-08-08)Summary of Open PHY Issues in IEEE 802161-0001 (Jeff Foerster)
Work done
bull All editorial comments resolved
bull All technical comments reviewed andresolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull TBDs resolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull Met with MAC group for ldquosynchronizingrdquo
TG3 Closing Presentation
802163 Task Group Reportbull Finished and Adopted Functional
Requirements Document except for editorialsndashOutput Comment database on server
bull Developed an initial List of EvaluationCriteria for PHY proposal evaluations FullCriteria to be developed at next meeting
bull Issuing two calls for contributionsndashPreliminary PHY proposalsndashDeployment Traffic and Propagation
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS
bull Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull Session 10 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband WirelessAccess will be held on 6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA In orderto assist in the evaluation of air interface proposals the 802163 Task Groupinvites contributions addressing the following issues
lang Traffic and deployment models based on single and multi-cellsystems
lang Channel propagation model
bull Contributions must be submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt Submissions will beconsidered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible followingreceipt for public access on the 80216 Web Site Email your contribution tothe 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernanltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 Chair Roger Marksltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS - Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull The Task Group 3 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access is preparing to define the PHY protocols for abroadband wireless access air interface specification for frequencies from 2 through 11 GHz The specification will be based on submittedcontributions with increasing detail required as the process progresses Mergers and improvements will be encouraged with final selectionscheduled for June 2001
bull The TG3 Task Group invites the submission of initial contributions representing proposed PHY solutions Contributors will be grantedagenda time during 80216 Working Group Session 10 (6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA) to present and discuss the merits oftheir proposals Only submissions to session 10 will be eligible for invitation to submit more detailed proposals to session 11 Eachproposal will be allocated equal agenda time on Tuesday November 7 If time permits the allocations will be 15 minutes of presentationfollowed by 15 minutes of discussion Submissions must follow the guidelines below
lang Include a descriptive titlelang Include an overview and a reference model that describes functions including interfaces to other layerslang Describe the benefits of the proposed PHY including any unique featureslang Describe any drawbacks of the proposed PHY
bull Explain how the submitted PHY relates to existing standards such as ITU-R JRG 8A-9B IEEE 80211 DOCSIS 11 ETSI HiperLAN orothers If it is based on an existing standard what differences occur due to BWA characteristics
lang Emphasize the scalability of the proposed PHY to deal efficiently with various data types as described in the 802163Functional Requirements Document
lang Include a statement on intellectual property rights and how 80216 may utilize the proposed PHY in a standard
bull The proposals will be evaluated based on criteria in the Evaluation Table below However at this initial stage contributions are not expectedto address in detail the discussion items in that table instead aiming for the more general description as outlined above Each of the VotingMembers of 80216 are eligible to participate in the evaluation if present Submitters receiving a combined score of 6 or better (out of 10) inany criterion in the Evaluation Table will be invited to submit more a detailed contribution for Session 11 (January 22-26 2001 in Tel AvivIsrael) Note that submissions need not represent a complete PHY but may focus on specific components
bull Contributions will be considered only if submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216 Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt The template requires a cover page and a narrative
bull Submissions will be considered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible following receipt for public access on the 80216Web Site lthttpieee802org16gt
bull Email your contribution to the 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernan ltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 ChairRoger Marks ltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
802163 Task Group Report
bull Officially Adopted TG1 MAC as TG3 DraftMAC
bull Create TG3 MAC Ad Hoc to review TG1MAC and provide TG3 Comments
bull Two Motions for the Working GroupndashLiaison to ETSI BRAN sub11 GHz WGndashEstablishment of 80216 Common MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
21
Motion 1
That the 80216 Working Group appoint ChetShirali as a liaison to the ETSI BRAN sub11GHz Working Group
Motion 2
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MACbullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
22
Appendix D Attendance at Session9Session9 was an interim session The 75 interval attendance criteria for Session 9 was 6 ormore intervals Please contact the 80216 Secretary (smarinixnetcomcom) if you feel yourattendance has been recorded incorrectly
The following 126 peopleregistered attendance at 6or more intervals and metthe attendance criteria
Aboukarr BakriAn SongArefi RezaArunachalam ArunAvera DraytAvivi EliAyyagari DeepakBaragar IanBaseghi BehshadBaugh CR (Rick)Belfiore CarlosBenyamin-Seeyar AnaderBushue CarlBuskila BaruchChan RebeccaChang DeanChayer ReacutemiCondie MaryCornelius JamesCosta JoseacuteCrilly Jr William JDoherty EdwardEdmonston BrainEidson BrianEklund CarlEl-Damhougy HeshamFishel GeorgeFoerster JeffreyGarrison G JackGesbert DavidGoldhammer MariannaGuillemette PhilGupta RakeshHadad ZionHall EricHamilton MichaelHammons RogerHatim BayaHebron YoanHilberman DanHosur SrinathHsuan YiHudson ThomasHum ColemanHunter WayneJacobsen EricJamali Hamadi
Jorgensen JacobKang InchulKasslin MikaKiernan BrianKim JohnKitroser ItzikKlein JayKolze ThomasKostas DemosKwak Byung-JaeKwak JoeLangley John BLangston J LelandLeiba YigalLewis BarryLicardie SergioLiebetreu JohnLindh LarsLo TitusMarin ScottMarks RogerMcCallister RonMcGregor AndyMcMullin RoderickMeyer RonaldMiddleton AndrewMizoguchi MasatoMody ApurvaMollenauer JamesPadan UziPetry BrianPleasant WayneRalston WilliamRan MosheResheff GuyRhodes ValentineRobinson GeneRoehr WaltRzeszewski TedSantacesaria ClaudioSatapathy DurgaSater GlenScaringi VitoScarpa CarlSchwartz RandallSegal YossiSellars MalcolmShan Tie-JunShimada ShusakuShirali ChetSkaar HelgeSmith SteveStamatelos George
Stambaugh KarlStanwood KenStewart MichaelStruhsaker PaulSydor JohnTappenden ChrisTateishi KimiyaTavormina JoeThomas RaymondThompson PaulTrinkwon DavidVan Waes NicoVarma SubirWachira MuyaWang ArthurWang Chao-ChunWang LeiWang XiaofengWard BobWhitehead PhilipWhiting RobertWilliams David GWise CurtWiss JohnYanover VladimirZuniga Juan Carlos
The following 18 peopleregistered attendance atless than 6 intervals anddid not meet theattendance criteria
Alspaugh MatthewCarlo JimFalconer DavidFoley MarkFoster RobertGupta AlokHancock DaleHarel HaimKhanna AmarpalKreig AndrewMonk AntonNadeau JamesOng Ling ChuenRafie ManouchehrRibner David BWheatley Chuck FYang S MichaelYurtkuran Erol
Motion 5
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MAC based on802161-0001r4bullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
Appendix E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
20
2 copy NOKIA 1999 FILENAMsPPT DATE NN
Important MAC decisions
bull Adoption of EUI-48 addresses (previouslyEUI-64)
bull Addition of error control to MAC layer(previously defined in TC layer of PHY B)
bull Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes into asingle mode
bull Redesigned DL MAP message for higherspectral efficiency
TG1 PHY ClosingPresentation
Document Number80216pp-
TitlePHY TG1 Report at Session 9
Date Submitted
91500Source
Jay KleinVenue
Denver September 2000Base Document
None
PurposeReport
NoticeThis document has been prepared to assist the IEEE 80216 It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the
contributing individual(s) or organization(s) The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after furtherstudy The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add amend or withdraw material contained herein
ReleaseThe contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by 80216
IEEE Patent Policy
The contributor is familiar with the IEEE Patent Policy which is set forth in the IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylawslthttpstandards ieeeorgguidesbylawsgt and includes the statement ldquoIEEE standards may include the known use of patent(s)
including patent applications if there is technical justification in the opinion of the standards-developing committee and provided theIEEE receives assurance from the patent holder that it will license applicants under reasonable terms and conditions for the purposeof implementing the standardrdquo
PHY TG1 Report Session 9
Jay KleinEnsemble Communications
Documents Submitted
bull 802161pc-0044 (2000-09-07) Recommendation onLMDS Radio Propagation Channel Models
bull 802161c-0007 (2000-09-10)FEC Parameterization for Data Transport (Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0006 (2000-09-08)FEC Parameterization for Control Channel Information(Alok Gupta)
bull 802161c-0004 (2000-09-01)Frequency Synthesizer Model Parameters (Lars Lindh andHans Somerma)
Documents Submitted ndash cont
bull 802161c-0003 (2000-09-01)Combining Burst FDD and FSDD modes in802161 (Ken Stanwood)
bull 802161c-0001 (2000-08-08)Summary of Open PHY Issues in IEEE 802161-0001 (Jeff Foerster)
Work done
bull All editorial comments resolved
bull All technical comments reviewed andresolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull TBDs resolved to level required to supportWorking Group Review
bull Met with MAC group for ldquosynchronizingrdquo
TG3 Closing Presentation
802163 Task Group Reportbull Finished and Adopted Functional
Requirements Document except for editorialsndashOutput Comment database on server
bull Developed an initial List of EvaluationCriteria for PHY proposal evaluations FullCriteria to be developed at next meeting
bull Issuing two calls for contributionsndashPreliminary PHY proposalsndashDeployment Traffic and Propagation
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS
bull Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull Session 10 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband WirelessAccess will be held on 6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA In orderto assist in the evaluation of air interface proposals the 802163 Task Groupinvites contributions addressing the following issues
lang Traffic and deployment models based on single and multi-cellsystems
lang Channel propagation model
bull Contributions must be submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt Submissions will beconsidered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible followingreceipt for public access on the 80216 Web Site Email your contribution tothe 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernanltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 Chair Roger Marksltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
bull 802163 Task Groupbull CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS - Session 10
bull Deadline 30 October 2000
bull The Task Group 3 of the IEEE 80216 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access is preparing to define the PHY protocols for abroadband wireless access air interface specification for frequencies from 2 through 11 GHz The specification will be based on submittedcontributions with increasing detail required as the process progresses Mergers and improvements will be encouraged with final selectionscheduled for June 2001
bull The TG3 Task Group invites the submission of initial contributions representing proposed PHY solutions Contributors will be grantedagenda time during 80216 Working Group Session 10 (6-10 November 2000 in Tampa Florida USA) to present and discuss the merits oftheir proposals Only submissions to session 10 will be eligible for invitation to submit more detailed proposals to session 11 Eachproposal will be allocated equal agenda time on Tuesday November 7 If time permits the allocations will be 15 minutes of presentationfollowed by 15 minutes of discussion Submissions must follow the guidelines below
lang Include a descriptive titlelang Include an overview and a reference model that describes functions including interfaces to other layerslang Describe the benefits of the proposed PHY including any unique featureslang Describe any drawbacks of the proposed PHY
bull Explain how the submitted PHY relates to existing standards such as ITU-R JRG 8A-9B IEEE 80211 DOCSIS 11 ETSI HiperLAN orothers If it is based on an existing standard what differences occur due to BWA characteristics
lang Emphasize the scalability of the proposed PHY to deal efficiently with various data types as described in the 802163Functional Requirements Document
lang Include a statement on intellectual property rights and how 80216 may utilize the proposed PHY in a standard
bull The proposals will be evaluated based on criteria in the Evaluation Table below However at this initial stage contributions are not expectedto address in detail the discussion items in that table instead aiming for the more general description as outlined above Each of the VotingMembers of 80216 are eligible to participate in the evaluation if present Submitters receiving a combined score of 6 or better (out of 10) inany criterion in the Evaluation Table will be invited to submit more a detailed contribution for Session 11 (January 22-26 2001 in Tel AvivIsrael) Note that submissions need not represent a complete PHY but may focus on specific components
bull Contributions will be considered only if submitted using Revision 8 or higher of the 80216 Document Submission Templatelthttpieee802org16docs802_16_templatedocgt The template requires a cover page and a narrative
bull Submissions will be considered non-confidential and will be posted as soon as possible following receipt for public access on the 80216Web Site lthttpieee802org16gt
bull Email your contribution to the 802163 Task Group Chair Brian Kiernan ltbriankiernaninterdigitalcomgt with a copy to 80216 ChairRoger Marks ltmarksnistgovgt for receipt by the deadline of 30 October 2000
802163 Task Group Report
bull Officially Adopted TG1 MAC as TG3 DraftMAC
bull Create TG3 MAC Ad Hoc to review TG1MAC and provide TG3 Comments
bull Two Motions for the Working GroupndashLiaison to ETSI BRAN sub11 GHz WGndashEstablishment of 80216 Common MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
21
Motion 1
That the 80216 Working Group appoint ChetShirali as a liaison to the ETSI BRAN sub11GHz Working Group
Motion 2
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MACbullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
22
Appendix D Attendance at Session9Session9 was an interim session The 75 interval attendance criteria for Session 9 was 6 ormore intervals Please contact the 80216 Secretary (smarinixnetcomcom) if you feel yourattendance has been recorded incorrectly
The following 126 peopleregistered attendance at 6or more intervals and metthe attendance criteria
Aboukarr BakriAn SongArefi RezaArunachalam ArunAvera DraytAvivi EliAyyagari DeepakBaragar IanBaseghi BehshadBaugh CR (Rick)Belfiore CarlosBenyamin-Seeyar AnaderBushue CarlBuskila BaruchChan RebeccaChang DeanChayer ReacutemiCondie MaryCornelius JamesCosta JoseacuteCrilly Jr William JDoherty EdwardEdmonston BrainEidson BrianEklund CarlEl-Damhougy HeshamFishel GeorgeFoerster JeffreyGarrison G JackGesbert DavidGoldhammer MariannaGuillemette PhilGupta RakeshHadad ZionHall EricHamilton MichaelHammons RogerHatim BayaHebron YoanHilberman DanHosur SrinathHsuan YiHudson ThomasHum ColemanHunter WayneJacobsen EricJamali Hamadi
Jorgensen JacobKang InchulKasslin MikaKiernan BrianKim JohnKitroser ItzikKlein JayKolze ThomasKostas DemosKwak Byung-JaeKwak JoeLangley John BLangston J LelandLeiba YigalLewis BarryLicardie SergioLiebetreu JohnLindh LarsLo TitusMarin ScottMarks RogerMcCallister RonMcGregor AndyMcMullin RoderickMeyer RonaldMiddleton AndrewMizoguchi MasatoMody ApurvaMollenauer JamesPadan UziPetry BrianPleasant WayneRalston WilliamRan MosheResheff GuyRhodes ValentineRobinson GeneRoehr WaltRzeszewski TedSantacesaria ClaudioSatapathy DurgaSater GlenScaringi VitoScarpa CarlSchwartz RandallSegal YossiSellars MalcolmShan Tie-JunShimada ShusakuShirali ChetSkaar HelgeSmith SteveStamatelos George
Stambaugh KarlStanwood KenStewart MichaelStruhsaker PaulSydor JohnTappenden ChrisTateishi KimiyaTavormina JoeThomas RaymondThompson PaulTrinkwon DavidVan Waes NicoVarma SubirWachira MuyaWang ArthurWang Chao-ChunWang LeiWang XiaofengWard BobWhitehead PhilipWhiting RobertWilliams David GWise CurtWiss JohnYanover VladimirZuniga Juan Carlos
The following 18 peopleregistered attendance atless than 6 intervals anddid not meet theattendance criteria
Alspaugh MatthewCarlo JimFalconer DavidFoley MarkFoster RobertGupta AlokHancock DaleHarel HaimKhanna AmarpalKreig AndrewMonk AntonNadeau JamesOng Ling ChuenRafie ManouchehrRibner David BWheatley Chuck FYang S MichaelYurtkuran Erol
Motion 5
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MAC based on802161-0001r4bullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
Appendix E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
21
Motion 1
That the 80216 Working Group appoint ChetShirali as a liaison to the ETSI BRAN sub11GHz Working Group
Motion 2
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MACbullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
22
Appendix D Attendance at Session9Session9 was an interim session The 75 interval attendance criteria for Session 9 was 6 ormore intervals Please contact the 80216 Secretary (smarinixnetcomcom) if you feel yourattendance has been recorded incorrectly
The following 126 peopleregistered attendance at 6or more intervals and metthe attendance criteria
Aboukarr BakriAn SongArefi RezaArunachalam ArunAvera DraytAvivi EliAyyagari DeepakBaragar IanBaseghi BehshadBaugh CR (Rick)Belfiore CarlosBenyamin-Seeyar AnaderBushue CarlBuskila BaruchChan RebeccaChang DeanChayer ReacutemiCondie MaryCornelius JamesCosta JoseacuteCrilly Jr William JDoherty EdwardEdmonston BrainEidson BrianEklund CarlEl-Damhougy HeshamFishel GeorgeFoerster JeffreyGarrison G JackGesbert DavidGoldhammer MariannaGuillemette PhilGupta RakeshHadad ZionHall EricHamilton MichaelHammons RogerHatim BayaHebron YoanHilberman DanHosur SrinathHsuan YiHudson ThomasHum ColemanHunter WayneJacobsen EricJamali Hamadi
Jorgensen JacobKang InchulKasslin MikaKiernan BrianKim JohnKitroser ItzikKlein JayKolze ThomasKostas DemosKwak Byung-JaeKwak JoeLangley John BLangston J LelandLeiba YigalLewis BarryLicardie SergioLiebetreu JohnLindh LarsLo TitusMarin ScottMarks RogerMcCallister RonMcGregor AndyMcMullin RoderickMeyer RonaldMiddleton AndrewMizoguchi MasatoMody ApurvaMollenauer JamesPadan UziPetry BrianPleasant WayneRalston WilliamRan MosheResheff GuyRhodes ValentineRobinson GeneRoehr WaltRzeszewski TedSantacesaria ClaudioSatapathy DurgaSater GlenScaringi VitoScarpa CarlSchwartz RandallSegal YossiSellars MalcolmShan Tie-JunShimada ShusakuShirali ChetSkaar HelgeSmith SteveStamatelos George
Stambaugh KarlStanwood KenStewart MichaelStruhsaker PaulSydor JohnTappenden ChrisTateishi KimiyaTavormina JoeThomas RaymondThompson PaulTrinkwon DavidVan Waes NicoVarma SubirWachira MuyaWang ArthurWang Chao-ChunWang LeiWang XiaofengWard BobWhitehead PhilipWhiting RobertWilliams David GWise CurtWiss JohnYanover VladimirZuniga Juan Carlos
The following 18 peopleregistered attendance atless than 6 intervals anddid not meet theattendance criteria
Alspaugh MatthewCarlo JimFalconer DavidFoley MarkFoster RobertGupta AlokHancock DaleHarel HaimKhanna AmarpalKreig AndrewMonk AntonNadeau JamesOng Ling ChuenRafie ManouchehrRibner David BWheatley Chuck FYang S MichaelYurtkuran Erol
Motion 5
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MAC based on802161-0001r4bullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
Appendix E
2000-10-02 IEEE 80216-0020
22
Appendix D Attendance at Session9Session9 was an interim session The 75 interval attendance criteria for Session 9 was 6 ormore intervals Please contact the 80216 Secretary (smarinixnetcomcom) if you feel yourattendance has been recorded incorrectly
The following 126 peopleregistered attendance at 6or more intervals and metthe attendance criteria
Aboukarr BakriAn SongArefi RezaArunachalam ArunAvera DraytAvivi EliAyyagari DeepakBaragar IanBaseghi BehshadBaugh CR (Rick)Belfiore CarlosBenyamin-Seeyar AnaderBushue CarlBuskila BaruchChan RebeccaChang DeanChayer ReacutemiCondie MaryCornelius JamesCosta JoseacuteCrilly Jr William JDoherty EdwardEdmonston BrainEidson BrianEklund CarlEl-Damhougy HeshamFishel GeorgeFoerster JeffreyGarrison G JackGesbert DavidGoldhammer MariannaGuillemette PhilGupta RakeshHadad ZionHall EricHamilton MichaelHammons RogerHatim BayaHebron YoanHilberman DanHosur SrinathHsuan YiHudson ThomasHum ColemanHunter WayneJacobsen EricJamali Hamadi
Jorgensen JacobKang InchulKasslin MikaKiernan BrianKim JohnKitroser ItzikKlein JayKolze ThomasKostas DemosKwak Byung-JaeKwak JoeLangley John BLangston J LelandLeiba YigalLewis BarryLicardie SergioLiebetreu JohnLindh LarsLo TitusMarin ScottMarks RogerMcCallister RonMcGregor AndyMcMullin RoderickMeyer RonaldMiddleton AndrewMizoguchi MasatoMody ApurvaMollenauer JamesPadan UziPetry BrianPleasant WayneRalston WilliamRan MosheResheff GuyRhodes ValentineRobinson GeneRoehr WaltRzeszewski TedSantacesaria ClaudioSatapathy DurgaSater GlenScaringi VitoScarpa CarlSchwartz RandallSegal YossiSellars MalcolmShan Tie-JunShimada ShusakuShirali ChetSkaar HelgeSmith SteveStamatelos George
Stambaugh KarlStanwood KenStewart MichaelStruhsaker PaulSydor JohnTappenden ChrisTateishi KimiyaTavormina JoeThomas RaymondThompson PaulTrinkwon DavidVan Waes NicoVarma SubirWachira MuyaWang ArthurWang Chao-ChunWang LeiWang XiaofengWard BobWhitehead PhilipWhiting RobertWilliams David GWise CurtWiss JohnYanover VladimirZuniga Juan Carlos
The following 18 peopleregistered attendance atless than 6 intervals anddid not meet theattendance criteria
Alspaugh MatthewCarlo JimFalconer DavidFoley MarkFoster RobertGupta AlokHancock DaleHarel HaimKhanna AmarpalKreig AndrewMonk AntonNadeau JamesOng Ling ChuenRafie ManouchehrRibner David BWheatley Chuck FYang S MichaelYurtkuran Erol
Motion 5
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MAC based on802161-0001r4bullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
Appendix E
Motion 5
Moved that the 80216 Working Group
bullEstablish a common 80216 MAC based on802161-0001r4bullRequire each 80216 Task Group to define itsmandatory and optional sub-sets of the commonMACbullShall ensure backward compatibility andmaintenance of the common MACbullShall strive to ensure forward compatibility of thecommon MAC
Appendix E
![Proposal to host IEEE 802.16 Interi m Session # 75 in ......[IEEE 802.16 Presentation Submission Template (Rev. 9.2)] Document Number: IEEE S802.16-11/0002 Date Submitted: 2011-03-14](https://img.dokumen.tips/doc/110x75/5f9a4e304a99154f0e363c65/proposal-to-host-ieee-80216-interi-m-session-75-in-ieee-80216-presentation.jpg)
![Minutes of 802.16 Session #3 [Unapproved] · 1999-10-22 Minutes: 802.16 Meeting#3 802.16-99/08r0 80216-99_08r0.doc 10 Appendix B, Agenda for Opening Plenary 802.16 Session #3 Agenda](https://img.dokumen.tips/doc/110x75/5fad8d3d8973a15bcd789366/minutes-of-80216-session-3-unapproved-1999-10-22-minutes-80216-meeting3-80216-9908r0.jpg)
