Click here to load reader
Upload
nguyenphuc
View
212
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Printed Friday, March 09, 2012
Michigan unions mobilize to protect bargaining
rights
BY JACK LESSENBERRY
BLADE OMBUDSMAN
LANSING, Mich. -- For the past year, labor unions in Michigan have faced a state government that is
more unfriendly than at any other time since the New Deal. They've watched a solidly Republican
Legislature pass bill after bill chipping away at union strength.
This week, Michigan lawmakers passed a law that prohibits school districts from deducting union dues.
They passed another law designed to prevent graduate student research assistants from unionizing.
Last year, another tough new bill gave appointed emergency managers the right to dissolve or change
collective-bargaining contracts as they see fit. Increasingly -- and despite Gov. Rick Snyder's opposition
-- GOP legislators are talking about trying to make Michigan a "right to work" state that would ban the
union shop.
Now, finally, unions are striking back -- in a way that has stunned even some of their supporters. This
week, a coalition of the state's largest unions announced a major drive for a state constitutional
amendment that would protect collective bargaining.
The coalition is determined to get the measure on the November ballot. If it passes, it could be the
biggest victory for labor in decades.
"We want to get this state back to what has been our normal way of doing business since the 1930s:
collective bargaining," said one of the state labor movement's elder statesmen, who didn't want to be
identified lest he steal the thunder of those who are leading the movement today.
There had been rumors that labor might try to place an amendment on the ballot designed to prevent
lawmakers from adopting right-to-work legislation. But the unions are going for something far beyond
that.
Todd Cook, the head of the umbrella labor organization called We the People, said the proposed
amendment would forbid right-to-work laws and a lot more. "It would provide protection against all
attacks on collective bargaining," he said at a news conference this week.
The proposed amendment says: "The Legislature's exercise of its power to enact laws relative to the
hours and conditions of employment shall not abridge, impair, or limit the right to collectively bargain for
wages, hours, and other terms of employment that exceed minimum levels established by the
Legislature."
Page 1 of 3Toledo Blade - Jack Lessenberry
3/9/2012http://www.toledoblade.com/JackLessenberry/2012/03/09/Michigan-unions-mobilize-to-pro...
Nothing, in other words, could prevent collective bargaining or throw out contracts collectively arrived at,
no matter what.
The amendment also protects the right to bargain collectively for state and other government
employees.
The proposal is seen as virtually certain to get the 322,609 valid signatures needed to get on the ballot,
because most or all Michigan labor unions have pledged to help collect them.
Should that happen, and should this amendment be approved by a majority of voters in November, it
would apparently nullify several major pieces of Snyder-era legislation.
The sweeping powers the state's emergency managers now have to ignore union contracts would end.
The law outlawing unions for university graduate students would be null and void. Laws aimed at
weakening teacher unions would likely be invalid.
Zack Pohl, We the People's spokesman, said unions were willing to spend what they need to spend to
get the amendment certified for the ballot and then passed, though he wouldn't discuss how much. He
added that "we fully expect we'll have lots of enemies" who will spend heavily to try to get voters to
defeat the amendment.
It wouldn't be surprising if Governor Snyder is partly blaming his fellow Republicans in the Legislature for
bringing this on themselves. He has steadfastly opposed efforts to make Michigan a right-to-work state,
saying they are an unnecessary distraction.
Yet lawmakers have been so gleefully eager to sock it to unions that they paid no attention. Opponents
of the amendment could sue, saying the proposed language is too broad to be legal because it changes
two different sections of the state constitution.
But union sources indicated they'd discussed that prospect with their attorneys and feel they are on solid
ground.
The labor elder statesman was heartened by the proposal and by labor fighting back. "Collective
bargaining is so important to the citizens of Michigan," he said. "It's what made us a middle-class
society. You know, we've worked with Republicans as well as Democrats.
"[Former Gov. John] Engler believed in collective bargaining. Mitt Romney's father, George, signed
legislation giving public employees the right to bargain. It's only this stupid, mean-spirited bunch who are
making an assault on our way of life," he said.
David Hecker, the leader of the Michigan chapter of the American Federation of Teachers, said that
when the Legislature passed the law preventing school districts from deducting union dues, "it could not
have been a worse day."
"But you know what?" he said in an email to his membership. "Things turned around when I went into
our board room and saw staff taking petitions out to be signed. We will win, because for our children and
communities we have no other choice."
Page 2 of 3Toledo Blade - Jack Lessenberry
3/9/2012http://www.toledoblade.com/JackLessenberry/2012/03/09/Michigan-unions-mobilize-to-pro...
Labor has a lot at stake here. If the amendment fails, it could be a fatal blow to Michigan's union
movement.
But kicking even a shrinking hornet's nest is often a bad idea. If this amendment succeeds, the anti-
union forces in Michigan's Legislature are likely to find out why in a forceful way.
Jack Lessenberry, a member of the journalism faculty at Wayne State University in Detroit and The
Blade's ombudsman, writes on issues and people in Michigan.
Contact him at: [email protected]
Copyright 2012 The Blade. By using this service, you accept the terms of our privacy statement and our visitor
agreement. Please read them.
The Toledo Blade Company, 541 N. Superior St., Toledo, OH 43660, (419) 724-6000
To contact a specific department or an individual person, click here.
The Toledo Times ®
Page 3 of 3Toledo Blade - Jack Lessenberry
3/9/2012http://www.toledoblade.com/JackLessenberry/2012/03/09/Michigan-unions-mobilize-to-pro...