Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
m«f fHCflHGOVERNMENT OF INDIA
Q(;ll1:4(OI, q;;~ \i1M1:4IY,QR1:4rl'i 4?1IM(;I
MINISTRY OF ENVIRONMENT, FORESTS
& CLIMATE CHANGE
Regional Office (WCZ)Ground Floor, East WingNew Secretariat Building
Civil Lines, Nagpur - 440001Tel: 0712-2531319 (0)
0712-2531318 (F)E-mail: [email protected]
F.No:EC-275/RON/2017-NGP/ Date: 31.03.2017
To,
Scientist '0'Member SecretaryIA Division (Infra-2)Ministry of Environment, Forest & Climate ChangeIndira Paryavaran Bhawan,Aliganj, Jorbagh Road,New Oelhi-11 0003
Sub: Environmental clearance for Palladium Grand-II S.No. 17/1N2, Dhanori, Pune by MIs.Raojee Construction-reg.
Ref:SEIAA, Maharashtra vide letter no. SEAC-2014/CR-376/TC-3 dated 26.07.2016
Sir,I am directed to invite your kind attention on the above subject and letter under
reference. Monitoring report of compliance to conditions stipulated in environment clearance
accorded for Palladium Grand-II at S.No. 17/1N2, Dhanori, Pune by MIs. Raojee
Construction is enclosed herewith. Site inspection of the project has been carried out on
27.02.2017. Following observations were made during the site inspection:
Construction of the project is yet to start, hence the conditions stipulated in the
environmental clearance granted by SEIAA, Govt. of Maharashtra are yet to be
implemented. PA submitted that conditions stipulated will be implemented during
construction/operation of the project. Photographs showing the site of the project are
enclosed as Annexure-1.
Following partial compliances were observed:
General Condition for Post- Construction/Operation Phase:
Condition no. iv:
Details regarding submission of the documents to MPCB not provided.
Condition no. viii:Advertisement has been made, however the clause of seven days was not followed.
Condition no. x:
PA submitted that copy of the environmental clearance was submitted to Pune Municipal
Corporation. However the same was not submitted to any NGO.
This issues with the approval of APCCF (Central), Regional Office, Nagpur.
~-~"'~~Suresh Kumar Adapa
Scientist 'D'
Enel: as above
Copy to:1. Director RO HQ, Ministry of Environment, Forest & Climate Change, Government of
India, 1st Floor Agni Wing, Indira Paryavaran Shawan, Jorbagh Road, New Delhi-
110003
2. Director (Monitoring Cell), Ministry of Environment, Forest & Climate Change, Indira
Paryavaran Shawan, Aliganj, Jorbagh Road, New Delhi-11 0003
3. MIs Raojee Constructions, S.No. 1711N2, Dhanori, Pune - 4110154. Guard File
o ~V~\A. )M.V ~ \ \ ",>\ \J>rSuresh Kumar Adapa
Scientist'D'
Monitoring the Implementation of Environmental SafeguardsMinistry of Environment & Forest
Western Region, Regional Office, NagpurDATA SHEET
1. Project type: River - valley/ Mining / Construction Project-Residential cumIndustry I Thermal/Nuclear / Other Commercial Project(specify)
2. Name of the project Palladium Grand"3. Clearance letter ( s ) / OM No. and SEAC-2014/CR-376!TC-3 dated zs" July
Date 20164. Location S.No.17/1A12, Dhanori, Pune
a. District ( S ) Puneb. State ( s ) Maharashtrac. Latitude/ Longitude Latitude - 18°35'55.79"N
Longitude - 73°54'8.02"E5. Address for correspondence
a. Address of Concerned Project Mr.Gautam TingareChief Engineer ( with pin code & "Palladium Grand" S.No.17/1A12,Telephone / telex / fax numbers Dhanori, Pune
Mobile No.+919850660437
b. Address of Executive Project: Same as aboveEngineer/Manager(with pin code/ Fax numbers)
6. Salient featuresa. of the project It is a construction of residential and cum
commercial project. The design of this projectand utilities is thoroughly planned with theobjectives of providing facilities to the peoplekeeping the mind on sustainabledevelo~ment.
b. of the environmental Construction not yet started hence notmanagement plans applicable at this stage.
7. Break up of the project areaa. submergence area forest & Non forest
non-forestb. Others PART -I
8. Break up of the project affected Total Plot Area: 25,328 rn"Population with enumeration of Net Plot Area: 21,179 m2Those losing houses / dwelling units Non FSI: 21,591.05 m2 (Existing-7040.98m2,
Only agricultural land only, both Proposed-14,550.07m2)Dwellinq units & agricultural Land & FSI: 25,202.57m2 (Existing-10,442.02m2,
landless labourers/artisan Proposed-14760.55 m2)
a. I SC, ST/Adivasis Not Applicable
b. Others Not Applicable(Please indicate whether theseFigures are based on anyscientific And systematic surveycarried out Or only provisionalfigures, it a Survey is carriedout give details And years ofsurvey)
9. Financial detailsa. Project cost as originally planned and subsequent revised estimates and the year of
price reference:1. Total Cost of the Project Rs.29.88 Cr.b. Allocation made for environ- Rs. 160.8 Lakhs (capital)
mental management plans with Rs. 32.39 Lakhs (recurring)item wise and year wise Break-up.
c. Benefit cost ratio / Internal rateof Return and the year ofassessment
d. Whether ( c ) includes thecost of environmentalmanagement as shown in theabove.
e. Actual expenditure incurred on --the project so far
f. Actual expenditure incurred on --the environmental managementplans so far
10. Forest land requirement Not Applicablea. The status of approval for Not Applicable
diversion of forest land for non-forestry use
b. The status of clearing felling Not Applicablec. The status of compensatory Not Applicable
afforestation, it anyd. Comments on the viability & Not Applicable
sustainability of compensatoryafforestation program in thelight of actual field experienceso far
11. The status of clear felling in Non- Not Applicableforest areas (such as submergencearea of reservoir, approach roads), itany with quantitative information
12. Status of construction Construction not yet started
a. Date of commencement August 2016( Actual and/or planned)
b. Date of completion July 2022( Actual and/or planned)
13. Reasons for the delay if the Project is Not applicableyet to start
14 Dates of site visitsa. The dates on which the project -
was monitored by the RegionalOffice on previous Occasions, ifany
b. Date of site visit for this 27.02.2017monitoring report
15. Details of correspondence with As under.Project authorities for obtainingAction plans/information on Status ofcompliance to safeguards Other thanthe routine letters for Logistic supportfor site visits. (The first monitoringreport may contain the details of allthe Letters issued so far, but theLater reports may cover only theLetters issued subsequently.)
Letter from RO Reply from PA23.12.2016: PA submitted request for thecertified compliance report
22.02.2017: Letter issued for siteinspection.
Compliance status of conditions stipulated in environmental clearance accorded forPalladium Grand-II S.No. 17/1AJ2, Dhanori, Pune by MIs. Raojee Construction grantedby SEIAA, Govt. of Maharashtra vide letter no. SEAC-2014/CR-376/TC-3 dated26.07.2016
General Conditions for Pre-construction phase:-
S.No.
Condition Status
i. The environment clearance is issued to Construction is yet to be started. PAsubject to restricting total built up area of submitted application to MoEF&CC for35,451.16 sq.m. as approved by local expansion of the built up area fromplanning authority. 46793.62 sq.m (granted in environmental
clearance dated 26.07.2016) to 58666.85sq.m.
•
ii. This environmental clearance is issued PA agreed to comply with.subject to land use verification. Localauthority/ planning authority shouldensure this with request to Rules,Regulations, Notifications, GovernmentResolution, Circulars, etc. issued if anyJudgments/ orders issued by Hon'bleHigh Court, Hon'ble NGT, Hon'bleSupreme Court regarding DCRprovisions, Environmental issuesapplicable in this matter should beverified. PP should submit exactly thesame plans appraised by concernedSEAC and SEIAA. If any discrepancyfound in the plans submitted or detailsprovided in the above para may bereported to Environmental Department.The Environmental Clearance issuedwith respect to the environmentalconsideration and it does not mean thatState Level Impact Assessment Authority(SEIAA) approved the proposed landuse.
iii. E- Waste shall be disposed through PA agreed to comply with.Authorized Vender as per E- waste (Management and Handling) Rules, 2011
IV. Separate DG set to be provided for PA agreed to comply with.building' K'
v. Occupancy certificate should be issued PA submitted that drinking water and sewerto the project by Local Planning Authority line will be provided before occupancy.only after ensuring availability of drinkingwater and connectivity of the sewer lineto the project site.
VI. This Environmental Clearance is issued As per the environmental clearance grantedsubject to obtaining NOC from Forestry & to the project, there are no eco-sensitive
vii. PP has to abide by the conditions PA agreed to comply with.stipulated by SEAC & SEIAA
VIII. The height, Construction built up area ofproposed construction shall be inaccordance with the existing FSI/FAR PA agreed to comply with.norms of the urban local body & it shouldensure the same along with surveynumber before approving layout plan &before according commencementcertificate to proposed work. Planapproving authority should also ensurethe zoning permissibility for the proposedproject as per the approved developmentplan of the area
S.No.
Wild Life angle including clearance from zones within 10 km of the project.the standing committee of the NationalBoard for Wild Life as if applicable & thisEnvironmental Clearance does notnecessarily implies that Forestry & WildLife clearance granted to the projectwhich will be considered separately onmerit.
StatusCondition
ix. "Consent for establishment" shall be MPCB granted consent to establish for theobtained from Maharashtra Pollution project vide letter no. Format 1.0JBOJROHQControl Board under air Water Act and a ICE/CC-9699 dated 09.08.2016.copy shall be submitted to theEnvironment department before start ofany construction work at the site.
x. All required sanitary and hygienicmeasures should be in place before PA submitted that drinking water and toiletstarting construction activities and to be facilities will be provided prior to start ofmaintained throughout the construction construction activities.phase.
General Condition for Construction Phase:Construction of the project is yet to be started. Photographs showing the site are enclosedas Annexure-1.
General Condition for Post- Construction/Operation Phase:
S. No. Condition Statusi. Project proponent shall ensure Construction of the project is yet to be
completion of STP, MSW disposal started.facility, green belt development, priorto occupation of the buildings. Nophysical occupation or allotment willbe given unless all above saidenvironmental infrastructure is
installed and made functionalincluding water requirement in Para.2.Prior certification from appropriateauthority shall be obtained.
II. Wet garbage should be treated by Construction of the project is yet to beorganic waste convertor and treated started.waste (manure) should be utilized inthe existing premises for gardening.And no wet garbage will be disposedoutside the premises. Local authorityshould ensure this.
iii. Local body should ensure that no Construction of the project is yet to beoccupation certification is issued prior started.to operation of STPI MSW site etc.with due permission of MPCB.
iv. A complete set of all documents Partly complied.submitted to the department should Details regarding submission of thebe forwarded to the MPCB. documents to MPCB not provided.
v. In the case of any change(s) in thescope of the project, the project wouldrequire a fresh appraisal by thisDepartment.
PA agreed to comply with.
vi. A separate environment management PA agreed to comply with.cell with qualified staff shall be set upfor implementation of the stipulatedenvironmental safeguards
vii. Separate funds shall be allocated for As per the details submitted, PA earmarkedimplementation of environmental an amount of Rs. 160.8 Lakhs (capital) andprotection measures/EMP along with Rs. 32.39 Lakhs (recurring) foritem-wise breaks-up. These cost shall environment protection measures.be included as part of the project cost.The funds earmarked for theenvironment protection measuresshall not be diverted for otherpurposes and year-wise expenditureshould reported to the MPCB & thisdepartment.
viii. The project management shall Partly complied.advertise at least in two local Advertisement has been made, howevernewspapers widely circulated in the the clause of seven days was not followed.region around the project, one ofwhich shall be in the Marathi languageof the local concerned within sevendays of issue of this letter, informingthat the project has been accordedenvironmental clearance and copiesof clearance letter are available withthe Maharashtra Pollution ControlBoard and may also be seen at
Websitehttp://envis.maharashtra.gov.in.
at
IX. Project management should submit PA submitted status of the project videhalf yearly compliance reports in letter dated 30.12.2016.respect of the stipulated priorenvironment clearance terms andconditions in hard & soft copies to theMPCB & this department, on 1st June& 1st December of each calendaryear.
x. A copy of the clearance letter shall be Partly complied.sent by proponent to the concerned PA submitted that copy of theMunicipal Corporation and the local environmental clearance was submitted toNGO, if any, from whom Pune Municipal Corporation. However thesuggestions/representations, if any, same was not submitted to any NGO.were received while processing theproposal. The clearance letter shallalso be put on the website of thecompany by the proponent.
xi. The proponent shall upload the status Construction of the project is yet to beof compliance of the stipulated EC started.conditions, including results ofmonitored data on their website andshall update the same periodically. Itshall simultaneously be sent to theRegional Office of MoEF, therespective Zonal Office of CPCS andthe SPCS. The criteria pollutant levelsnamely; SPM, RSPM, S02, NOx(ambient levels as well as stackemissions) or critical sectoralparameters, indicated for the projectshall be monitored and displayed at aconvenient location near the maingate of the company in the publicdomain.
xii. The project proponent shall also PA submitted status of the project videsubmit six monthly reports on the letter dated 30.12.2016.status of compliance of the stipulatedEC conditions including results ofmonitored data (both in hard copiesas well as bye-mail) to the respectiveRegional office of MoEF, therespective Zonal Office of CPCS andthe SPCB.
XIII. The environmental statement for each Construction of the project not started.financial year ending 31st March inForm-Vas is mandated to besubmitted by the project proponent tothe concerned State Pollution ControlBoard as prescribed under theEnvironment (Protection) Rules, 1986,as amended subsequently, shall alsobe put on the website of the companyalong with the status of compliance ofEC conditions and shall also be sentto the respective Regional Offices ofMoEF bye-mail.
4.
This environmental clearance is beingissued without prejudice to the actioninitiated under EP Act or any courtcase pending in the court of law & itdoes not mean that project proponenthas not violated in any environmentallaws in the past & whatever decisionunder EP Act or of the Hon'ble courtwill be binding on the projectproponent. Hence this clearance doesnot give immunity to the projectproponent in the case filed againsthim, if any or action initiated under EPAct.
PA agreed to comply with
5. In case of submission of falsedocument and noncompliance ofstipulated conditions,Authority/Environment department willrevoke or suspend the Environmentalclearance without any intimation andinitiate appropriate legal action underEnvironmental protection Act, 1986.
PA agreed to comply with
6. The Environment departmentreserves the right to add any stringentcondition or to revoke the clearance ifcondition stipulated is notimplemented to the satisfaction of thedepartment or for that matter, for otheradministration reason.
PA agreed to comply with
7. Validity of Environment Clearance:The environment Clearance accordedshall be valid for a period of 5 years.
As per MoEF & CC Notification dated 29m
April 2015, Environmental Clearance shallbe valid for a period of 7 years.
8. In case any deviation or alteration inthe proposed from those submitted to
PA agreed to comply withthis department for clearance, freshreference should be made to the
10/2-3
department to assess the adequacy ofthe condition(s) imposed and toincorporate additional environmentalprotection measures required, if any.
9. The above stipulation would be PA agreed to comply withenforced among others under theWater(prevention and control ofpollution)act 1974, The air(preventionand control of pollution) act, 1981,The Environment (protection)act,1986 and rules their under,Hazardous waste(management andhandling) rules,1989 and it'samendment, the public liabilityinsurance act,1981 and it'samendment
10. Any appeal against this environmental PA agreed to comply with.clearance shall lie with the NationalEnvironmental Appellate Authority, ifpreferred within 30 days as prescribedunder section 11 of the NationalEnvironmental Appellate Act.1997.
\Y~3
Summary Note
1. Implementation of Conditions:
Site inspection of the project has been carried out on 27.02.2017. Construction of the
project is yet to start, hence the conditions stipulated in the environmental clearance
granted by SEIAA, Govt. of Maharashtra are yet to be implemented. PA submitted that
conditions stipulated will be implemented during construction/operation of the project.
Photographs showing the site of the project are enclosed as Annexure-1.
Following partial compliances were observed:
General Condition for Post- Construction/Operation Phase:
Condition no. iv:
Details regarding submission of the documents to MPCB not provided.
Condition no. viii:
Advertisement has been made, however the clause of seven days was not followed.
Condition no. x:
PA submitted that copy of the environmental clearance was submitted to Pune Municipal
Corporation. However the same was not submitted to any NGO.
2. Review w.r.t to MOEFs letter dated 30.5.2012:
The above mentioned report is prepared after site visit on 27.02.2017 for the expansion
of Palladium Grand-II S.No. 17/1N2, Dhanori, Pune.
3. Court Cases and show cause/closure notices:
PA submitted undertakings thata. No show cause notices issued by MPCB are pending against the project.
MPCB issued Consent to Establish for the project vide letter no. Format
1.0/80/ROHQ/CE/CC-9699 dated 09.08.2016.
Additional Chief Secretary, Environment Department, Government of Maharashtra vide
letter no. SEAC-III-2014/CR-376fTC-3 dated 29.11.2014 issued directions under Section
5 of Environment Protection Act' 1986 stating that building construction activity started
without obtaining environmental clearance.
PA vide letter dated 24.12.2014 submitted a reply to the above directions.
Principal Secretary Environment Department, Government of Maharashtra vide letter no.
SEAC-III-2014/Cr-376/TC-3 dated 26.05.2015 withdrawn the proposed directions stating
that construction built up area 16538.69 sq.m. is less than 20000sq.m., hence
environmental clearance was not required. It was concluded that there was no cause of
violation as prescribed in EIA Notification 2006 and accordingly proposed directions
issued hereby withdrawn. . r ..~I'.~('..m \3 \t:lJSURr:s 5~r.ITtt§':t> - /,-PA
t{ ~ I -..•' "fs~;:r-..r ST '," 12/~r, '::,1;';~,,'l,-g t~,,:j'1·P~.l /G3
W.!h:rtr, "'f~ \;',. r"". IF'". -l'-n-t' rt_c>:,;;_: cr;- ':~_:.,.''(,,~,-'~ -:'_~' ",;~~
r~r_··:l. r ~i~:-·-i~(;( lt~;/~)7C~t r ,INci~;!
Annexure-1
Photographs of the project site
Date: 27.02.2017
We Mis. Raojee Constructions for the project Palladium Grand II, S. No. 17/1A/2, Dhanori, Punehereby submit costing for Environment Management Plan:
Operation phase Capital Cost: Rs.160.8 Lacs approx. and Operation & Maintenance Cost: Rs. 32.39
Lacs/annum approx.
For Raojee Constructions
Authorized Signatory
~~e@CONSTRUCTIONS
S. No. 1711AJ2, Dhanori, Pune - 411015, T: +91 20 27028222 / 23 E: [email protected]
AFFIDAVIT
SHIRISH DASNURKAR&: ASSOCIATES
architects & designerGovernment Approved Valuer No. F - 12093
2.110 t/ tel 7I hereby state that for the Project Pallidium Grand II at Palladium Grand II, S. No. 17/lA/2,Dhanori, Pune, Maharashtra, have obtained Previous sanction vide CC/4364/06 dated 15-03-2007 for the plot admeasuring 25,328.62 m2 for FS118,678.48 m2• The plot potential wasnot exceeding 20,000 m2
• The Promoter completed construction and obtained OCC-BCO/3Dt 08112/2008, BeOIl Dt 04/0412009, BCO/39 Dt 06110/2009, OCCIl134110 Dt 31103/2011for following area:
FSl- 10442.02 m2
Non FSI- 7040.98 m2
Total BUA- . 17483.00 m2
Floor-wise breakup of constructed buildings is as follows:
SrNo Building Configuration Floors FSI Non FSI Totaltype BUA
1 15tfloor 312.26 174.10 486.362nd floor 314.59 176.66 491.253rd floor 312.26 174.10 486.36
A P+7 4tl1floor 314.59 176.66 491.255th floor 312.26 174.10 486.36e" floor 314.59 176.66 491.25in floor 312.26 173.23 485.49
2 1st floor 312.26 174.10 486.362nd floor 314.59 176.66 491.253rd floor 312.26 174.10 486.36
B P+7 4t floor 314.59 176.66 491.2551nfloor 312.26 174.10 486.366th floor 314.59 176.66 491.25in floor 312.26 173.23 485.49
3 1SI floor 288.40 153.87 442.272na floor 288.40 165.02 453.423ra floor 288.40 153.87 442.27
C P+7 4111floor 288.40 165.02 453.4251n floor 288.40 153.87 442.276111floor 288.40 165.02 453.42in floor 288.40 153.88 442.28
4 1st floor 288.40 153.87 442.272nd floor 288.40 165.02 453.423ra floor 288.40 153.87 442.27
D P+7 41nfloor 288.40 165.02 453.425111floor 288.40 153.87 442.2761hfloor 288.40 165.02 453.42ih floor 288.40 153.88 442.28
Jfc/23
35 Laxmi Park Colony, Above Hotel Saragam, Navi Peth, Pune - 411030. Ph : 020 - 245~0461 /62/63. Fax: 020 - 24535323, E-mail: [email protected]@bsnl.ln
5 15t floor 288.40 153.87 442.272nd floor 288.40 165.02 453.423fd floor 288.40 153.87 442.27
J P+7 4tn floor 288.40 165.02 453.42s" floor 288.40 153.87 442.276th floor 288.40 165.02 453.42T" floor 288.40 153.88 442.28
6 CLUB G 314.00 314.00HOUSE
7 PODIUM STILT -- 944.31 914.31
Total 1 10442.02 7040.98 17483.00I Services
Total 2Grandtotal(1+2)
This for your information & record.
SHIRISH DASNURKAR(ARCHITECT) \~CA/86j10074. V"" ~WI
Date: 27.02.2017
We Mis. Raojee Constructions hereby undertake that, there is no show-cause notice issued by MPCB
for the project Palladium Grand II, S. No. 17/1A/2, Dhanori, Pune
On behalf of Mis Raojee Constructions the undersigned is agreed to comply with the condition No.
il, iv, vi, vii, viii of preconstruction phase, condition No. (v) of post construction phase and conditionNo.4 to 10 of the Environmental Clearance granted by SEIAA, Environment Department,
Government of Maharashtra vide letter no. SEAC-2014/CR-376/TC-3 dated 26th July 2016
For Raojee Constructions
Authorized Signatory
~~eeCONSTRUCilONS S. No. 1711Al2, Dhanori, Pune - 411015, T: +91 20 27028222 / 23 E: [email protected]
Date: 27.02.2017
We M/s. Raojee Constructions for the project Palladium Grand II, S. No. 17/1A/2, Dhanori, Punehereby undertake:
Green belt area developed till date is 180 m2r open space is 1161.31 m2 and 60 no. of trees of 11
species are already planted on site.
For Raojee Constructions
Authorized Signatory
~~eeCONSTRUCTIONS
S. No. 17I1A12, Dhanori, Pune - 411015, T: +912027028222/23 E: [email protected]
GOVERNl\:U.N'r 01( MAIlARASJiTRA
Tel. No. ; 2279 3 )32fax No, : 22R! 3947
S'EAC-III·2014lCR-376lTC-3Environment Department,217 (Annex). Mantralaya,Mumhai - 4Q0032 ,Date: tot~·111/2014
By F"x! RP ADI Speed Post
To
~Ojit'e Constructions.S. No. 17/1Al2" Dhanori,Pune 41 t015.
Sd~h. ~ - PJ"~JOSed Uf~~~~~n'YUvrJlffi:~ (P) A~t~1«' _r.w. F.IANotification dtd. J4.9.1006
\VHERF.AS, itwas obligatory on your part to obtain prior Environment Clearance from the CompetentAuthority, as per the ElA Notification dtd. 14.9200fi" before startlng any building construction activity.
A I'D WHEREAS, you have applied for EnviromneTltal Clearance for proposed Residential &COIIlIII\,:n;ial project "Palladium Grand" Village Dhanori, Tehsil. Havcli, District. Pune, During the 20thmeeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee held 011 4th to 7th November 2014, it was observedthat you have started the construction activity without obtaining prior Environment Clearance from theGovernment of Maharashtra. This amounts to violation of the EIA Notification 2006.
NOW THEREFORE, in view' of the above non-compliance, you are hereby directed to show cause asunder
a) \\ihy your building construct ~OIl activity ~h811 not be stopped forthwith for the violation ofEnvironment Impact Assessment Notification dtd. 14.9.2006~ issued by the Mini. try of Environment& Forest, Government of India, for not obtaining prior Environmental Clearance Irom the CompetentAuthority I Govcmmcur of Maharashtra?
b) \Vhy further legal action shall not be il1litial.cdagainst you under the provisions of the environment(Protection) Act, 19.86 and Rules made there under? -- --~ -- ---You arc also di{:!.:l.:\.j;;d.Jcuwhm it..y{fL1H~p·ly-".V'ilhiir15-du)"sf:romUl.e rec-eipt O(thisProposed Directions,
tal mg which, this office has no option than to initiate stringent legal action against }I'OIlancillding stoppage ofyour construction activity, which please be noted.
~~V'(Medha badgiI)
Arldl, Chief Secretary,Environment Department
•
0/6
To,The Principal Secretary,Environment Department,Government of Maharashtra,Mantralaya - vlumbai.
Date: 24.12.2014
Subject Reply to show cause noticc for' Our residential project "PalladiumGrand 1(" by Mis. Raojcc Constructionsat Palladium Grand n, S. ]\'0.1711Al2, Dhanori, Pune, Maharashtra.
Reference Show cau e notice No.SEAC-Ill-2014/CR-376JTC-3
Dear Sir.
This has reference to the above subject and Mo\1 of 20lhSEAC III Agenda lor Item No. 49.We have presented our ease during SEAr meetings, ill which the SEA( III has noted omconstruction activity as violation.
With respect to the above. we would like to clanfy as under.
I) \\'c have received ~L\ sanction vide No. PRllJNAlSIVI52120U6 dated ~8.08.2006 tromCollector office, Punc.
2) Initially there were PG67 (Partly) reservation on said plot admeasuring 11,680.048Sq.m ..hence plot potential was less .
.,) A" pl:r the above approval we got sanction for our plot measuring 15.J28.6:2Sq.l11. videCC no. l'C/29 I 8/07 dated 28.12.2007 for FSI 10442.02Sq.m. & NOll FSI 57X2.67Sq.l1l.total RL1,'\ I6224.69Sq.m. Since VvC were not crossing the designated threshold limit of20.000 Sq.rn, we had not applied for EC. We had started construction activityaccordingly.
4) further. the said reservation was relocated by PMC;TP vide letter no. IPS IS 13/1 3/E1'sanction dated 13.02.2014. and same plot is thereby now available for furtherdevelopment.
5) Now. thereby aggregate construction area is 46,7l)3Ji2 Sq.mt.t FSJ - 25.202.57 "Ion rSI-21,)91.05)
6) lienee we have only now accordingly come within the purview and accordingly appliedfor Fuvironmcut clearance on 17.10.2014.EttviwlIlTIcnl clearance application submittedlor total construction area46.793.62 Sq.mt .(F~I NON rSI)
7) So. in view or the above tactual position we request you to not consider the sameviolation for our case.
~~~~JI ••", I -i.JL"'O ••..,S
S.No. 1711N2, Dhanon, Pune- 411015, T: +91 2027028222123 E: raojeeconslructions@gmailcom
Ii) We also request you to give LIS an opportunity to explain and clurify the SUllie ill personalhearing.
I.ookingforward for your positive reply.
Ihanking ) ou in anticipation.
GOVERNMENT OF MAHARASHTRA
Tel. No. : 2279 3132Fax No. : 2281 3947
SEAC-II1-20 14/CR-376rrC-3Environment Department217, Annex Building, MantralayaMadam Cama Road, Mumbai - 400032Date : ~(; /05/ 20 t 5
By Speed Post! RPAD I Hand DeliveryTo, .
1\.4' ;~ee Constructions.~'0~J~IN2, Dhanori,
Pune411015.
Sub : Withdrawal of Proposed Directions issued u/s 5 of the Environment (P) Act, 1986.r.w, Environment Impact Assessment Notification dtd. 14.9.2006.
Ref.:- l. Proposed Directions issued vide letter dtd. 29.11.2014.2. Your reply dtd. 24.12.2014.3. Circular issued by the Environment Department, G.o.M. dtd. 21. 4. 2015.4. Personal hearing extended to you on 19.5.2015.5. Certificate submitted by Architect vide letter dtd. 25.5.2015
We refer to the minutes of the 20lh meeting ofSEAC-IIJ held on 41hto 71h November 2014 wherein yourproposed Residential & Commercial project "Palladium Grand" VilIage Dhanori, Tehsil. Haveli, District. Punewas referred to the Environment Department to verify the issue of violation of the Environment (P) Act, 1986 r.w.EtA Notification 2006.
Accordingly, the Proposed Directions were issued vide above ref.(I). We also refer to your replysubmitted vide above ref. (2), which was scrutinized and followed by personal hearing extended to you on19.5.2015 before the Principal Secretary, Environment Department.
During the course of hearing, your representative has submitted that you have applied for EC on17.10.2014 for proposed total BUA admeasuring 46793.62 m2. Your representative also submitted that you havecarried out construction of total BUA admeasuring 16538.69 m2 at site (i.e. below 20000 m2), which is certifiedby your Architect.
We also refer to the recent Circular dtd. 21.4.2015 issued by the Environment Department, G .0.M. bytaking cognizance of the Orders dtd. 24.3.2014 & 18.12.2014 passed by Hon'ble High Court in the matter ofG lomore Construction and others V /s Union of India stating "Proposed construction projects wherein projectproponent has undertaken total construction below 20000 m2 may not be considered as a violation of EIANotification 0/2006 (amended time to time) and read with OM of Mo.E.F. dtd. 12.12.2012 & 27.6.2013 ...
In view of the documents submitted by your representative vide letter dtd. 24.12.2014, additionalinformation submitted during the course of personal hearing which is certified by your Architect vide leter dtd.25.5.2015 followed by a Circular dtd. 21.4.2015 issued by the Environment Department. G.o.M. and detailedscrutiny thereof, it has been observed that you have carried out the construction of total BUA admeasuring16538.69 m2, which is less than 20000 m2. Therefore, it is hereby concluded that there is no case of violation asprescribed in the EIA Notification, 2006 and accordingly the Proposed Directions issued vide above ref.( I) ishereby withdrawn.
In case, any discrepancies are observed in these documents, necessary action will be initiated against youunder the provisions of Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 read with EIA Notification dt. 14.09.2006, whichplease be noted. ~-
~1S1lr(Sitararn Ku tte)
Principal Secretary,
