83
METHODS OF ENTRY INTO INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS Ref : International Business…. P. Subba Rao International Business…. Francis Cherunilam (Pg. 497 -516)

Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

METHODS OF ENTRY INTO INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS Ref :International Business…. P. Subba RaoInternational Business…. Francis Cherunilam (Pg. 497 -516)

Page 2: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Foreign Market Analysis

Analyze alternative foreign markets

Assessing costs, benefits and risks

--Market potential..Population, ..GDP, ..Urban/rural, ..Purchasing power--Level of competition..No. & size of existing firms, ..Their relative strengths & weaknesses ..Their product, price & distribution strategies, ..Actual market conditions--Legal political environment..Companies should assess legal & political environment carefully--Socio-cultural influencesCompanies must consider socio-cultural carefully while deciding to go abroad

-- Costs..Direct costs involved in setting up operations in the global market..Opportunity cost loss of earning from alternative market--Benefits..High sales, profits..Low acquisition, manufacturing costs..Foreclosing of markets to competitors..Competitive advantage..Access to new technology..Cheap labor/resources in host country--RisksExchange rate fluctuations, Operating complexity, financial losses, Government action

Page 3: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Ownership advantages

Decision Factors in selecting the mode of entry

Location advantages

The following factors must be considered while deciding on the mode of entry

--- Derived by the company by owning resources.. e.g. TISCO owned its iron ore mines and coal mines. This grants the advantage of low cost producer to the company

--- Locational advantages in the host country motivates the Company to enter foreign markets through Direct Investment.

--- If locational advantages are more in the home country, them the Company enters foreign markets through exporting

Factors that provide locational advantage :

-- Customer needs, -- Logistic requirements preferences & tastes -- Cheap land acquisition cost-- Cheap labour -- Political stability -- Low cost raw materials -- Climatic conditionse.g.Siam Cement locating its factory in Thailand and exporting to Vietnam, Cambodia and Laotia

Page 4: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Internationalization advantages

--- Are those benefits that a company gets by manufacturing goods or rendering service in the host country by itself rather than contract arrangements with companies in the host country . --- Sometimes the cost of negotiating, monitoring, and enforcing an agreement with the host country would be difficult and costly . In such case the Company enters the host country through Direct Investment

--- If the company thinks that the transaction costs are low, and local companies in the host country can produce efficiently, without jeopardizing its interests, the company can enter the foreign market through contract Manufacturing, Franchising or Licensing e.g.Toyota enters foreign markets through direct investment and joint-ventures as the local companies in foreign countries cannot produce as efficiently as Toyota

Other factorsNeed for controlResource availabilityGlobal strategy

Page 5: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Exporting

InternationalLicensing

InternationalFranchising

Specialized Modes

Foreign Direct Investment

Decision Factors:Ownership advantagesLocation advantagesInternalization advantagesOther factors

Need for controlResource availabilityGlobal strategy

Choosing a Mode of Entry

Page 6: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Exporting

Page 7: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

EXPORT INVOLVEMENT

DIRECT EXPORTERS INDIRECT EXPORTERS

Own name and beneficiary Not on their own name, but supply direct to exporters

Exports

Page 8: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

12-8

Forms of Exporting

Indirect exporting

Intracorporatetransfers

Direct exporting

Page 9: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Indirect Exporting

… Exporting the products either in their original form or in the modified form to a foreign country through another domestic company

E.g.--- Various publishers in India including Himalaya Publishing House sell their products, i.e., books to various exporter in India, who in turn export these books to various foreign countries

Page 10: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Direct Exporting

… Selling the products in a foreign country directly through its distribution arrangements or through a host country’s company

E.g.--- Baskin Robins initially exported its ice-cream to Russia in 1990 and later opened 74 outlets with Russian partners. Finally it established its ice-cream factory in Russia

Page 11: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Intracorporate Transfers

… Selling of products by a company to its affiliated company in the host country (another country)E.g.--- Selling products by Hindustan Lever in India to Unilever in USA--- This transaction is treated as exports in India and imports in USA

Page 12: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

CLASSIFICATIONS OF EXPORTERS

SIZE PRODUCT LINE

LEGAL STATUS

DESTINATION FREQUENCY

SMALL LARGE

PROPRIETY

PARTNERSHIP

PVT. LTD

PUB. LTD OCCASIONAL BRISK

SINGLE PRODUCT

MULTIPLE PRODUCTS

SINGLE MULTIPLE

Page 13: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Considerations for Exporting

Governmental policies

Marketing concerns

Logistical considerations

Distribution issues

--- export policies--- import policies--- export financing--- foreign exchange

--- image--- distribution network--- responsiveness to the customer--- customer awareness--- customer preferences

--- physical distribution costs--- warehousing costs--- packaging costs--- transporting costs--- inventory carrying costs

--- own distribution network--- network of host country’s companies

Page 14: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

An export management company (EMC) is a firm that acts as its client's export department by managing the legal, financial, and logistical details of exporting, and providing advice about consumer needs and available distribution channels in the foreign markets the exporter wants to penetrate.

Export Management Company

Co-operative Society

The domestic companies desire to export the goods from a cooperative society, which undertakes exporting operation of its members

International trading company

This company is engaged in directly exporting and importing. It buys goods from domestic companies and exports

Manufacturers’ Agents

They work on commission basis. They solicit domestic orders for foreign companies

Types of Export Intermediaries

Page 15: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Manufacturers’ export agents

Work on a commission basis. They sell domestic manufacturers’ products in foreign markets and act as their foreign sales department

Export and Import Brokers

These brokers bridge the gap between exporters and importers and bring these parties together

Freight Forwarders

Freight Forwarders help the domestic manufacturer in exporting their goods by performing various functions like physical transportation of goods , arranging customs documents and arranging transportation services

Types of Export Intermediaries

Page 16: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Advantages• Relatively low financial exposure• Permit gradual market entry• Acquire knowledge about local market• Avoid restrictions on foreign investment

Disadvantages• Vulnerability to tariffs and NTBs• Logistical complexities• Potential conflicts with distributors

Advantages/Disadvantages of Exporting

Page 17: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

International Licensing

Page 18: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Foreign companies who have entered the Indian

market by licensing

--- The IFB washing machine was manufactured in India under license from Bosch of Germany

--- The US multinational General Electric (GE) has licensed it patented technology to a small scale unit in India, established for the manufacture of high density discharge (HID) fittings

--- Nike International Ltd. , the worlds largest sports shoe and apparel company entered the Indian market in mid-1990s by licensing. Sierra Industrial Enterprises Ltd. The licensee was to invest in setting up the complete quality control, marketing and distribution operations and will pay Nike 5 per cent royalty on ex-factory price of footwear and apparel for the use of brand name

--- Arvind brands (Arvind Mills)owns the marketing rights for the leading US brands like Arrow, Lee and Wrangler

Page 19: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

12-19

Licensing

Licensing is when a firm, called the licensor, leases the right to use its intellectual property—technology, work methods, patents, copyrights, brand names, or trademarks—to another firm, called the licensee, in return for a fee.

Xerox, inventor of the photocopier , licensed its xerographic know-how to Fuji-Xerox. In return, Fuji-Xerox paid Xerox, a royalty fee equal to 5% of net sales revenue that Fuji-Xerox earned from the sale photocopiers based on Xerox’s patented know-how

Trademark licensing

--- names or logo of designers--- literary characters--- sports teams --- movies & stars

Appear on clothing, games, food & beverages gifts & novelties, toys & home furnishings

Page 20: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Licensor

License Fee

Licensee

Manufacturer and Markets

One or more countries as per agreement

Country A

Country B

Licensing : Concept and practice

Page 21: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

LICENSOR

Licensing Process

PROVIDES THE RIGHT TO USE INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY AND

BRAND NAME

USES THE INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY TO PRODUCE PRODUCTS FOR SALE

IN HIS COUNTRY AND BRAND NAME

PAYS ROYALTIES TO THE LICENSOR FOR USING THE INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY AND BRAND NAME

RECEIVES ROYALTY MONEY

LICENSEE

Page 22: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

12-22

Basic Issues in International Licensing

• Specifying the boundaries of the agreement• Determining compensation• Establishing rights, privileges, and constraints• Specifying the duration of the contract

Page 23: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Boundaries of the Agreement

Should be clearly defined. They determine which rights and privileges are being conveyed in the agreement

E.g.-- Pepsi-Cola granted license Heineken of Netherlands with exclusive right of producing and selling Pepsi-Cola in Netherlands

-- Pepsi-Cola supplies concentrated Cola syrup and Heineken adds carbonated water to produce beverage

-- Pepsi-cola can grant license to other companies in Netherlands to produce other products of Pepsi, like Potato chips

Basic Issues in International Licensing

Determination of Royalty

The most important factor in deciding the license is the payment of royalty by the licensee to the licensor.

Page 24: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Basic Issues in International Licensing

Determining Rights, Privileges and Constraints

Another important factor, in granting license is determining clearly and specifically the Rights, privileges and constraints to reduce hurdles in the implementation of the agreement.

E.g.-- Indian licensee of Aiwa TV uses interior inputs in order to reduce price to boost sales and profits would be damaging the image of the Japanese Licensor

Dispute settlement mechanism

The licensor and licensee should clearly mention the mechanism to settle disputes.

E.g.-- Settlement of disputes in courts is costly time consuming and hinders business interests

Page 25: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Agreement Duration

The two parties of the agreement specify the duration of the agreement. .

E.g.-- Tokyo Disneyland demanded a 100 year licensing agreement with The Walt Disney Company

Basic Issues in International Licensing

Page 26: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Advantages• Low financial risks• Low-cost way to assess market potential • Avoid tariffs, NTBs, restrictions on foreign investment• Licensee provides knowledge of local markets• Reduces risk of exposure to government intervention

Disadvantages• Limited market opportunities/profits• Dependence on licensee• Potential conflicts with licensee• Possibility of creating future competitor

Advantages/ Disadvantages of Licensing

Page 27: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

FRANCHISING

FRANCHISOR

SELECT

FRANCHISEE

FRANCHISEE FEE

Well known creator with brand command can become strong franchisor

Encashes on past and present effort

Invests in all the resources

Page 28: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Franchising

A franchising agreement allows an independent entrepreneur or organization, called the franchisee, to operate a business under the name of another, called the franchisor, in return for a fee.

The franchisor provides the following service to the franchisee

--- trade mark

--- operating systems

--- continuous support systems like,

… advertising

… employee training

… reservation services

… quality assurance programmes

Page 29: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Franchising

Franchising is a form of “ in which a parent company (the franchisor) grants another independent identity (the franchisee) the right to do business in a prescribed manner . This can take the form of selling the franchisor’s products, using its name, production and marketing techniques, or general business approach.

One of the common forms of franchising involves the franchisor supplying an important ingredient ( part, material, etc.) for the finished product.

E.g.

--- Coca Cola supplying the syrup to the bottlers.

Page 30: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Major forms of franchising

Manufacturer -retailer systems

Manufacturer -wholesaler systems

Service- retailer systems

Automobile dealership

Soft drink companies

Lodging services and fast food outlets

Reverse franchise agreements

ITC hotels franchised two of its hotels in Bangkok and Hongkong, to ITT Sheraton Holding, in exchange the franchise for Sheraton in India

Page 31: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Basic Issues in International Franchising

• The franchisor has been successful in his home country --- McDonald was successful in USA due to popular menu and fast and efficient services

• Are these success factors transferable to foreign locations?

--- The factors for success of McDonald are later transferred to other countries

• Has franchising been a successful domestic strategy?

--- The franchisor may have been successful in home country before going for international franchising

. Foreign investors should come forward for introducing the product on franchising basis

Page 32: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Yum! Brands Franchise Opportunities

Page 33: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Franchising

Advantages

• Low financial risks• Low-cost way to assess market potential• Avoid tariffs, NTBs, restrictions on foreign

investment• Maintain more control than with licensing• Franchisee provides knowledge of local market

Disadvantages

• Limited market opportunities/profits• Dependence on franchisee• Potential conflicts with franchisee• Possibility of creating future competitor

Page 34: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Specialized Entry Modes

Contract manufacturing

Turnkeyproject

Managementcontract

Page 35: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

CONTRACT MANUFACTURING

Under contract manufacturing, a company doing international marketing contracts with firms in foreign companies to manufacture or assemble the products while retaining the responsibility of marketing the product.

There are a number of multinationals and affiliates of multinationals which employ this strategy in India in respect of some of the products they market, like, Park Davis, Hindustan Unilever, Ponds, etc.

Godrej Soaps

..DETTOL for Reckitt and Coleman

..CLEARTON for Nicholas Laboratories

..JHONSON’S BABY SOAP for Johnson & Johnson

..PONDS DREANFLOWER, COLD CREAN, AND SANDLEWOOD FOR Ponds

Page 36: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

CONTRACT MANUFACTURING

Some companies outsource their part or entire production and concentrate on marketing

--- Nike has contracted with a number of factories in South East Asia to produce its athletic footwear and it concentrates on marketing.

--- Bata Shoe also contracted with a number of cobblers to produce its footwear and it concentrated on marketing

--- Mega Toys --- a Los Angeles Company contracts with Chinese plants to produce toys and mega Toys concentrates on marketing

Page 37: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

CONTRACT MANUFACTURING

Supply

A well-known marketing company

Manufacturers – China/India/ASEAN

Selects

Page 38: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Advantages of Contract Manufacturing

--- The company does not have to commit resources for set up production

facilities

--- It frees the company from risk of investing in foreign countries

--- If idle production capacity is readily available in the foreign country, it enables the marketer to get started immediately

--- The cost of production by contract manufacturing is lower than if it were manufacture by the international firm on account of low wages, lower overheads, tax concessions

--- It is a less risky way to start business ; if the business does not pick up sufficiently, dropping it is easy; but if the company had established its own production facilities, , the exit would be difficult

Page 39: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Disadvantages of Contract Manufacturing

--- In some cases, there will be loss of potential profits from manufacturing

--- Reduced control over manufacturing process (may affect quality, delivery schedules, etc.)

--- Contract manufacturing also has the risk of developing potential competitors.

--- It would not be suitable in cases of high tech products and cases which involve technical secrets

--- Reduce learning potential

--- Potential public relations problems

Page 40: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Conclusion

Contract manufacturing is an opportunity for developing country firms to increase their business by manufacturing products for sale in foreign markets , by the contracting firm.

India has enormous potential to benefit from the global outsourcing trend. More and more foreign firms are entering into contract manufacturing agreements with Indian Firms, particularly for marketing products abroad.

Page 41: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

MANAGEMENT CONTRACTS

--- A Management Contract is an agreement between two companies, whereby one company provides … managerial assistance … technical expertise … specialized services

--- To the second company of the agreement for a certain period in return for monetary compensation in the form of : … A flat fees … Percentage over sales … Performance bonus based on based on profitability, sales growth, production or quality measures

--- Management contracts are mostly due to government intervention

e.g.… Saudi Arabian Govt. requesting former owners to manage Armco… Delta (USA) , Air France and KLM (Dutch) often provide technical and managerial assistance to small airlines companies owned by Governments

Page 42: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

12-42

Advantages/Disadvantages Management Contracts

Advantages• Focus firm’s resources on its area of contracts• Minimal financial exposure

Disadvantages• Potential returns limited by contract expertise• May unintentionally transfer proprietary knowledge and techniques to

contractee

Page 43: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

TURNKEY PROJECTS

--- A turnkey project is a contract under which a firm agrees to fully design, construct and equip a manufacturing/business/service facility and turn the project over to the purchaser when it is ready for operation, … for a remuneration --- The forms of remuneration includes : … a fixed price … payment on cost plus basis

e.g.Indonesian turnkey project for construction of a sugar factory to a Japanese firm

Page 44: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Advantages/Disadvantages of Turnkey Projects

Advantages• Focus firm’s resources on its area of expertise• Avoid all long-term operational risks

Disadvantages• Financial risks

– Cost overruns• Construction risks

– Delays– Problems with suppliers

Page 45: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT

Investor

Any country

Money

ROI

Project/Technology/Trade

Short term/ Long term

Page 46: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Foreign Direct Investment

• Building new facilities (the greenfield strategy)• Buying existing assets in a foreign country (acquisition strategy)• Participating in a joint venture

FDI without alliance

Companies enter the international markets through FDI , invest money, establish manufacturing and marketing facilities rough ownership and control

Greenfield Strategy

Starting the operations of the company from scratch in foreign country

--- market survey--- selection the location---buys or lease land--- creates new facilities--- erects the machinery--- remits or transfers human resources--- starts the operations and marketing activities e.g. Fuji in South Carolina, Mercedes-Benz in Alabama, Nissan in England

Page 47: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Greenfield VentureGreenfield VentureNew Wholly-Owned Subsidiary –

Most costly & complex of entry alternatives. Achieves greatest degree of control. Potentially most profitable, if successful. Maintain control over technology, marketing and

distribution.May need to acquire expertise & knowledge that is relevant to host country.

Could require hiring host country nationals or consultants at high cost.

Page 48: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

STRATEGIC ALLIANCES

Page 49: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Ranbaxy &

Glaxo SmithKline

Have a strategic alliance for R & D

PHARMACEUTICALS INDUSTRY

Syneron Medical (Israel)

& Suchita Numed

For marketing the formers aesthetic products in India

Strategic Alliances

SEMICONDUCTOR INDUSTRY

Samsung Electronics Company &

IBM Korea

Have a strategic alliance for R & D

Page 50: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Apple Computer &

IBM

Have formed an alliance for development of software and hardware technology for a new generation of desktop computers

COMPUTER INDUSTRY

IBM &

STET (Italy)&

Nippon Telegraph & Telephone

(Japan)

To develop computer communication services

Strategic Alliances

IBM &

Ericson (Sweden)

To explore the linking of data-management technology with digital switching technology

Page 51: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Isuzu Motors Ltd &

Fuji Heavy Industries Ltd.

Have set up a joint plant in the US which can build cars for Fuji and trucks for Isuzu in the same line

AUTOMOBILE INDUSTRY

Strategic Alliances

-- Some Japanese automakers have joined forces with foreign big names like General Motors and Chrysler-- The European car manufacturers are also teaming up to enhance their competitiveness , often in one-off projects to produce, say, an engine of transmission.

Page 52: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Tatas &

TFR

Tatas & TFR , a leading French leather finisher and European marketer for Tatas to integrate with the exact colour, texture, and other requirements of large European buyers, while TFR will provide the existing marketing network, links to key buyers, its name and reputation and knowledge of the latest fashion trends.

Strategic Alliances

Tata Tea &

Tetley

To take advantage of the expertise of Tetley to market tea abroad

LEATHER GOODS INDUSTRY

BEVERAGE INDUSTRY

Page 53: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

International Strategic Alliances

• Strategic Alliance– refers to any type of cooperative agreements between

two or more firms who are potential or actual competitors.

– Can take multiple forms including: JVs, R&D collaborations, piggy backing, sourcing relationships, etc.

Page 54: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

• In general, any relationship that involves mutual dependence and shared decision making between two or more firms can be characterized as a strategic alliance.

• It differs from traditional JVs in that:– strategic alliances are increasingly between firms in

the industrialized nations– the focus is on creation of new products and

technologies rather than the distribution of existing ones

International Strategic Alliances

Page 55: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Why Strategic Alliances?

• Rising R&D Costs

• Shortening Product Life Cycles

• Growing Barriers to Market Entry

• Increasing Need for Global Scale Economies

• Expanding Importance of Global Standards

• Forms the basis of Building and Sustaining Competitive Advantage in Industries undergoing major Transitions

Page 56: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Managing International Alliances

• The Logic of Collaboration

– Identifying when, where, and why to collaborate– An alliance is usually one of several options for

pursuing a strategic goal; it is never an end in itself– Strategic Goals: Product Exchange; Corporate Learning

& Market Positioning– Cost-Benefit Tradeoffs– Alternatives to Collaboration: Self-Sufficiency; Buying

the Inputs or Skills; Full Acquisition.

Page 57: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Key Issues in Managing International Alliances

• Selecting Partners– Knowing how to maximize benefits and minimize risks

of partnerships– Complementary needs and assets

• Structuring Alliances– Choosing organizational forms that provide incentives

for success– Contracts vs. Equity Relationships

Page 58: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

• Building Alliance Networks– Creating a system of reinforcing alliances, and

avoiding chaos– Network Design: Is the whole greater than the sum

of the parts?

Who controls the network? & Where is competitive advantage created?

• Alliance Dynamics– Managing with an eye to the forces for change in a

relationship

Key Issues in Managing International Alliances

Page 59: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

• Limits to Alliances– Recognizing the constraints on collaborative

strategies– Organizational Constraints; Strategic Gridlock;

Dependence

• The Role of Governments– Antitrust laws– Host government intervention

Key Issues in Managing International Alliances

Page 60: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

CONCLUSION

It has been pointed out that as the business environment both locally and internationally, becomes increasingly competitive, companies will have more reasons and will find more ways to form strategic alliances . As that happens, strategic alliances will not only be a logical alternative but a key to survival in business. Management experts predict that in the not too distant future, alliances will be a necessity not only of individual companies but also for orderly development of entire industries and that companies in mature slow growth industries will increasingly look for strategic alliances for survival

Page 61: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Advantages• High profit potential• Maintain control over operations• Acquire knowledge of local market• Avoid tariffs and NTBs

Disadvantages• High financial and managerial investments• Higher exposure to political risk• Vulnerability to restrictions on foreign investment• Greater managerial complexity

Foreign Direct Investment

Page 62: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

JOINT VENTURE

Partner one from Country A Partner two from Country B

New Venture

Joint commitment

Page 63: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

MERGERS & ACQUISITIONS

Page 64: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

9-64 © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited.

Choice of International Entry Mode

Can be very costly.

Legal and regulatory requirements may present barriers to foreign ownership.

Usually require complex and costly negotiations.

Potentially disparate corporate culture.

Enable firms to make most rapid international expansion.

Acquisitions

Page 65: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

TAKE-OVERS

Page 66: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

COUNTER TRADE

Counter Trade

Pure Barter Buy Back Counter Purchase

Product-to-product exchange

Buy the end product from the

host partner

Exchange of goods in various countries

until foreign exchange is found

Page 67: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Why Use Countertrade?

• Lack of money• Lack of value of money• Nonconvertibility of currency• Offset financial risk

• Other factors that make it more efficient to exchange goods directly than to use money as an intermediary

• As a competitive strategy• Excellent mechanism to get a foothold into foreign

markets

Page 68: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Major Drawbacks

“Instead of there being a double coincidence of wants, there is likely to be a want of coincidence; so that, unless a hungry tailor happens to find an undraped farmer, who has both food and a desire for a pair of pants, neither can make a trade.” Paul Samuelson

• Transactions purely bilateral in nature and thus are not competitive

• Trade is formulated on the basis of the willingness to countertrade and not on economic considerations

• Creates economic inefficiencies

Page 69: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Types of Countertrade

• Counter purchase or parallel barter (46%)– Involves both cash & kind transactions– Parallel reciprocity (a special case)

• Buyback (11%)– Technology in return for finished goods– Levi Strauss in Hungary

• Offset (27.5%)– Cost offsets through investments– Can be in multiple forms– Common in high cost deals (defense)

• Swaps (11%)– Debt for debt swaps– Debt for equity swaps– Debt for product swaps– Debt for education swaps

Page 70: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

• Clearing Arrangements– Extend over long period– Involve basket of goods– Held as deposits representing purchasing power

(credit - debit account)

• Switch Trading (4.5%)– A type of clearing arrangement where credit can

be sold or transferred to a third party

Page 71: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Advantages and Disadvantages of Entry Modes

Entry Mode Advantage Disadvantage

Exporting Ability to realize location andexperience curve economies

High transport costsTrade barriersProblems with local marketing agents

Turnkeycontracts

Ability to earn returns fromprocess technology skills incountries where FDI isrestricted

Creating efficient competitorsLack of long-term market presence

Licensing Low development costs andrisks

Lack of control over technologyInability to realize location and

experience curve economiesInability to engage in global strategic

coordination

Page 72: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Advantages and Disadvantages of Entry Modes

Entry Mode Advantage Disadvantage

Franchising Low development costs andrisks

Lack of control over qualityInability to engage in global strategic

coordination

Jointventures

Access to local partner’sknowledge

Sharing development costs andrisks

Politically acceptable

Lack of control over technologyInability to engage in global strategic

coordinationInability to realize location and

experience economies

Whollyownedsubsidiaries

Protection of technologyAbility to engage in global

strategic coordinationAbility to realize location and

experience economies

High costs and risks

Page 73: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

12-73

Chapter Objectives 1

• Discuss how firms analyze foreign markets• Outline the process by which firms choose their

mode of entry into a foreign market• Describe forms of exporting and the types of

intermediaries available to assist firms in exporting their goods

Page 74: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

12-74

Chapter Objectives 2

• Identify the basic issues in international licensing and discuss the advantages and disadvantages of licensing

• Identify the basic issues in international franchising and discuss the advantages and disadvantages of franchising

Page 75: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

12-75

Chapter Objectives 3

• Analyze contract manufacturing, management contracts, and turnkey projects as specialized entry modes for international business

• Characterize the greenfield and acquisition forms of FDI

Page 76: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

12-76

Foreign Market Analysis

• Assess alternative markets• Evaluate the respective costs, benefits, and

risks of entering each• Select those that hold the most potential for

entry or expansion

Page 77: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

12-77

Table 12.1 Factors in Assessing New Market Opportunities

• Product-market dimensions• Major product-market

differences• Structural characteristics of

national market• Competitor analysis

• Potential target markets• Relevant trends• Explanation of change• Success factors• Strategic options

Page 78: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Choice of Entry Modes• Exporting

– Direct vs Indirect

• Contractual Agreements– Licensing, Franchising, etc.

• Equity Based– Joint Ventures– Wholly Owned Subsidiary

• Strategic Alliance

Page 79: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Choosing the Mode of Entry

• Decision Criteria for Mode of Entry– Market Size and Growth– Risk– Government Regulations– Competitive Environment– Local Infrastructure

Page 80: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Choosing the Mode of Entry (cont)

• Company Objectives• Need for Control• Internal Resources, Assets, and Capabilities• Flexibility• Mode of Entry Choice : A Transaction Cost

Explanation

Page 81: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

Market Entry Decisions

• Foreign Market Selection

• Timing & Order of Entry

• Market Expansion Strategies

• Mode of Entry Decisions

Page 82: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

9-82

Identify International

Opportunities

ExploreResources & Capabilities

Use Core Competence

StrategicCompetitiveness

Outcomes

International Strategies

Modes of Entry

IncreasedMarket Size

Return on Investment

Economies of Scale and Learning

Location Advantage

InternationalBus.-LevelStrategy

Multidomestic Strategy

GlobalStrategy

Transnational Strategy

Exporting

Establishment of New Sub.

Licensing

StrategicAlliances

Acquisition

Higher Performance

Returns

Innovation

International Strategy Opportunities & Outcomes

Management Problems, Risk,

and First Steps

Management Problems, Risk,

and First Steps

Page 83: Methods of Entry in International Business - MLN

CONTRACT MANUFACTURING