Methadone and Driving

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    1/83

    METHADONEAND

    DRIVING

    Laurel FarrellForensic [email protected]

    mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]
  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    2/83

    Are people taking

    methadone anddriving?

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    3/83

    Methadone prevalence in DUID cases

    New Hampshire Dept of Safety

    2007 Statistics

    52 cases were positivefor MethadoneApproximately 3%

    39 out of 52 highwayrelated; 4 MVA13 out of 52 OCME;3 fatal MVA

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    4/83

    Methadone prevalence in DUID cases

    NYSP

    Methadone identified in 3.6% of all DUID cases in the last 3 years

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    5/83

    Methadone prevalence in DUID cases

    Georgia Bureau of Investigation

    A 35% increase in the number of methadone identification in DUID cases - 8.7%+

    A 130% increase in the number of methadone identifications in PM cases 9.7%+

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    6/83

    Methadone prevalence in DUID casesWisconsin State Laboratory of Hygiene

    Methadone is the 7th

    most frequently identified drugIncreased from 2 5 % of drug positive cases

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    7/83

    Methadone prevalence in DUID CasesSouthwestern Institute of Forensic Sciences

    02468

    10

    12141618

    1 9

    8 9

    1 9 9 0

    1 9 9 1

    1 9 9 2

    1 9 9 3

    1 9 9 4

    1 9 9 5

    1 9 9

    6

    1 9 9 7

    1 9 9

    8

    1 9 9 9

    2 0 0 0

    2 0 0 1

    2 0 0 2

    2 0 0 3

    2 0 0 4

    2 0 0 5

    2 0 0

    6

    2 0 0 7

    2 0 0

    8 p

    r o j e c t e

    d

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    8/83

    Methadone Case Increase

    WA State

    050

    100150200250300350

    400450500

    1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006

    Drivers

    Deaths

    2006 - Methadone was detected in 7.4% of our 9789 cases.262 impaired drivers (5.4%) and 463 death investigation (10%) cases

    The 5th

    most frequently found drug other than ethanol in DUID cases

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    9/83

    2004 2005 SOFT/AAFS Survey of DRE LabsMost Frequently Encountered Drugs(no data from 3 labs; N = 39)

    26

    30

    37

    37

    39

    0 10 20 30 40

    Methamphetamine

    Hydrocodone

    Cocaine

    Benzodiazepines

    Cannabis

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    10/83

    2004-2005 SOFT/AAFS Survey of DRE LabsMost Frequently Encountered Drugs(no data from 3 labs; N = 39)

    4

    5

    8

    5

    10

    6

    12

    16

    26

    28

    0 5 10 15 20 25 30

    Butalbital

    Propoxyphene

    PCP

    MDMA

    Zolpidem

    Diphenhydramine

    Methadone

    Oxycodone

    Carisoprodol/meprobamate

    Morphine/Codeine

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    11/83

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    12/83

    History

    Introduced into the United States in 1947 asan analgesic by Eli Lilly and Company1964 began use in Methadone MaintenanceTreatmentSince 2000 it has been increasinglyprescribed for pain management

    Schedule II Controlled Substance Act

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    13/83

    Methadone Maintenance Therapy

    1999 20% of the estimated 810,000 heroin addictsreceive MMT = 162,000MMT:

    Individualized health careMedically prescribed opioidAdministered orally on a daily basisStrict program conditions and guidelines

    The patient remains physically dependent on aopioid but is freed from the uncontrolled, compulsive

    and disruptive behaviorImproved subject healthDecreased criminal activityIncreased employment

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    14/83

    U.S. Formulations

    Oral Solutions10 mg of methadonehydrochloride per mL.Methadose Oral

    ConcentrateCherry flavored liquidconcentrate.

    Methadose Sugar-Free Oral Concentrate(methadone hydrochlorideUSP) is a dye-free, sugar-free, unflavored liquidconcentrate of methadonehydrochloride.

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    15/83

    U.S. Formulations

    Tablets5 mg, 10 mgDolophine Hydrochloride

    Diskets (dispersible tablet)40 mg methadose wafersformulated with insoluble excipients to deter the use of this drug by injection

    Other:10mg/mL intensol

    Intended to be diluted with at least 1 ounce of liquid10 mg/mL , 50 mg/1mL and 50 mg/2mL ampoulesLinctus - 2mg/5mL used in the UK for treating coughing interminal disease

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    16/83

    Current Methadone Use

    32%

    39%

    24%

    5%

    2006 Distribution of Methadone

    5 mg & 10 mg Tablets

    (4,412,615 grams)Liquids (5,283,295grams)

    40 mg Diskettes(3,236,405 grams)

    All Others (665,224grams)

    Includes Methadone Treatment Programs

    Source: DEA ARCOS 04/2007

    DEA Office of Diversion Control Methadone Mortality Working Group

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    17/83

    Current Methadone Use

    DEA Office of Diversion Control Methadone Mortality Working Group

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    18/83

    Effects Analgesia - Pain relief Decreased Drug CravingRespiration depressedPupils constricted (miosis)ConstipationSubjective effects:

    DrowsinessLight HeadedDizzinessHeadache

    Suppressed cough reflex

    Decreased appetiteSweatingReduced sex driveA variety of hormonalchanges

    Low to

    moderatedoses

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    19/83

    Effects

    Slightly higher dosesEuphoriaMay experience restlessness and anxiety (dysphoria)

    AgitationConfusion

    DisorientationNausea and vomiting more common

    Highest dosesUnconsciousnessDecreased body temperature and blood pressureConstricted pupils often used as an indicator of ODRespiration rate now dangerously low and is the cause of death in ODCardiac Conduction Effects

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    20/83

    Effects

    Additive effects with other opioidsAdditive effects with Alcohol

    Additive effects with CNS Depressants

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    21/83

    Current Methadone Use

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    22/83

    Current Methadone Use

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    23/83

    Methadone-Associated MortalityMethadone Mortality Working Group DEA Diversion; April 2007

    Three Primary Scenarios:

    1) Accumulation to toxic levels of methadoneduring the start of opioid treatment or painmanagement due to overestimation of toleranceand methadones long, often variable, half -life.2) Misuse of diverted methadone by individuals

    with little or no opioid tolerance.3) Synergistic effects of methadone incombination with other CNS depressants(i.e., alcohol, benzodiazepines or other opioids).

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    24/83

    Miosis

    Laboratory StudiesWeinhold and Bigelow, 1993

    Methadone (50-60 mg p.o.).Peak miosis was best detected under moderately diminterior lighting 90 min after methadone

    Higgins etal, Clin Phamacol Ther. 198520 mg methadone to 28 males beginning MMTMiosis observed in all subjectsProportional to reported heroin use and years since firstopiate use

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    25/83

    Opioid Receptors

    1973 Discovery of opioid receptorsOpiate drugs work by mimickingnatural opiate-like molecules made andused in the brain.

    1975 - Identified the first endogenous brainopioids, called endorphins.

    Three major receptor subtypesMu (m)

    mu1 analgesiamu2 respiratory depression

    Kappa (k)

    Delta (d)Principally found in the central nervoussystem and the gastrointestinal tract

    www.biodavidson.edu

    PET scan of opiatereceptors in humanbrain

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    26/83

    Euphoria Reinforcing Effect

    Limbic systemMain regulator of emotionSurrounds the brain stem below the cerebral cortexOpiate receptors very dense

    EuphoriaOpioids are not rapidly removed as endorphins areActivate receptors for extended periodsIncreases dopamine level in nucleus accumbens

    Reinforcing effects seem to also be due to otherfactors not completely understood

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    27/83

    Pain

    Incidence2006 National Center for Health Statistics Report

    26% of Americans (76.5 million) over 20 years of age had pain

    of any sort that persisted for more than 24 hoursPain affects more Americans than diabetes, heart diseaseand cancer combined.

    Duration1999-2002 Study of people over 20 years of age

    12% pain for 1-3 months14% pain for 3-12 months42% pain for more than one year

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    28/83

    Opioids vs Pain

    Analgesia reducedsensitivity to painOpioids bring pain relief byinterfering with the painperception pathway in the

    nervous systemSpinal cordInterfere with transmission of thepain messages between neurons -preventing them from reachingthe brainInterrupt the descending messagefrom the brain to the spinal cord

    BrainEmotional and hormonal aspectsChanges the subjective messagereceived; still feel the pain but itno longer bothers you

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    29/83

    Tolerance

    Chronic useLeads to changes in the nervous system

    Develops quite rapidlyDoes not occur for all pharmacological effects

    to the same extent or at the same rateNo or minimal tolerance to constipating effects ormiosis

    Significant loss of tolerance may occur asquickly as three days without methadoneAfter 5 days the body has essentially eliminated thedrug and any drug intake should progress as if starting a dosing program

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    30/83

    Tolerance

    Mechanisms responsible for toleranceIncreased rate of metabolism

    Drug disposition toleranceAn increase in liver enzymes

    Classical conditioning (effect of environmental cues)Changes in nerve cells

    Adaptive mechanism to return the organism to homeostasisGradual increase in cell firing ratecAMP production increases to pre-opioid level

    Example: 50 mg has proven fatal; 180mg/day in MMT; up to 780 mg/day in rare

    instances

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    31/83

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    32/83

    Withdrawal

    AnalgesiaRespiratory depressionEuphoriaRelaxation and sleepTranquilizationDecreased blood pressure

    ConstipationPupil constrictionHypothermiaDrying of secretionsReduced sex driveFlushed and warm skin

    Pain and irritabilityPanting and yawningDysphoria and depressionRestlessness and insomniaFearfulness and hostilityIncreased blood pressureDiarrheaPupil dilationHyperthermiaTearing, runny noseSpontaneous ejaculationChilliness and gooseflesh

    Acute Action Withdrawal Sign

    Psychopharmacology by Meyer and Quenzer

    Symptoms generally develop more slowly and are lessacutely severe than those of morphine and heroinwithdrawal, but are usually more prolonged.

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    33/83

    Withdrawal

    Rapeli et al, BMC Psychiatry, 2006, Feb 24;6:9Evaluated cognitive function during the first few weeksof abstinenceSubjects with opioid dependencePerformed significantly worse in tests measuringcomplex working memory, executive function, and fluidintelligenceCorrelation with days in withdrawal

    Indicated a general deficit in higher order cognition

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    34/83

    Pharmacokinetics

    The action of the body on the drugAbsorption, Distribution, Metabolism, and Elimination

    Good Oral bioavailability = 36 99%Peak plasma levels 1-4 hours

    Volume of distribution = 4-6.7 L/kgLong Half-Life 8-59 hoursMetabolism: liver

    CYP450: 2B6, 2C19, 3A4 (primary), 2C9, 2D6 (minor)

    Excretion: feces, urine

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    35/83

    Pharmacokinetics

    Long Half-Life 8-59hours

    Compared to morphineat avg of 3 hours

    Good Oral bioavailability36-99%

    Compared to morphine at20-40%

    Large Volume of

    Distribution

    Due to its chemical structureAlmost as effective as IV

    Large VD =distribution intotissues; lipid solubleLess reports of a rush effect

    Allows the drug to be given once dailyMuch longer than the analgesiceffect, typically 6 8 hoursRisk of additional doses being consumedfor pain leading to respiratory

    depression

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    36/83

    Pharmacokinetics

    Metabolism: liver Enzymes - CYP450: 1A2, 2B6, 2C19,

    3A4 (primary), 2C9, 2D6 (minor),

    Drug-drug interactionsThese enzymes are used to metabolize large numbers of drugs3A4 approximately 2/3 of the PDR

    Competitors two drugs using the same enzymeInhibitors = generally will reduce metabolism; increaseMethadone levels

    Examples: Zithromax, Erythromycin, Sertraline,

    Cimetidine, Prilosec, acute alcohol

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    37/83

    Pharmacokinetics

    Metabolism: liverEnzymes - CYP450: 1A2, 2B6, 2C19,

    3A4 (primary), 2C9, 2D6 (minor),

    Drug-drug interactionsInducers = generally will result in more rapidmetabolism decreasing effects of Methadone

    Examples: Phenytoin , St. Johns Wort,Carbamazepine, abstaining chronic alcoholic

    Isoenzyme 2D6 is subject to genetic polymorphismRapid metabolizers and Slow metabolizers

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    38/83

    Pharmacokinetics

    Excretion:feces, urine

    Saliva, beast

    milk, hair,amnioticfluid, nails

    Primary metabolites:EDDP - inactiveEMDP - inactive

    Minor metabolites:Methadol - activeNormethadol - active

    Additional metaboliteshave been identified

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    39/83

    Blood Toxicology

    Acute Oral Dosing (15-120 mg) 0.075 0.86 mg/L

    Chronic Oral Dosing (100 - >200mg) 0.57 1.06 mg/L

    DUI 0.05 0.64 mg/LMed Examiner 0.02 5.3 mg/L

    Concentration ranges of subject groups overlapDetermination of impairment from bloodtoxicology alone is not possible

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    40/83

    POTENTIALDEFENSES IN

    METHADONE DUID

    CASES

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    41/83

    Defense:The impairment is not due to the Methadone butto the pain I am suffering

    Scientific LiteraturePain deteriorated performance more than oralopioid treatment in cancer patients

    Increase in reaction time correlated to painintensity and not opioid doseAbility to maintain lane position impaired inpain patients compared to controls

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    42/83

    Defense:The impairment is not due to the Methadone but tothe pain I am suffering

    Documentation

    DRE EvaluationDocument performance impairment at the time of drivingEvaluation questions: Are you sick or injured? andAre you under the care of a physician?

    Comprehensive toxicologyDocumentation of prescribed drugs and no otherimpairing drugs

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    43/83

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    44/83

    Defense:The impairment is not due to the Methadone butto the other psychological disorders

    Documentation

    DRE EvaluationDocument performance impairment at the time of drivingEvaluation questions: Are you sick or injured? Areyou under the care of a physician? Do you have anyphysical defects?

    Comprehensive toxicologyDocumentation of prescribed drugs and no otherimpairing drugs

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    45/83

    Defense:

    In MMT and on a stable dose of Methadone

    Scientific Literature

    No significant performance decrements in laboratorytests:

    Memory testVigilance and simple reaction timeVisual functioning

    Compensatory, pursuit, and critical trackingNo decrement in maintaining lane position, speed andreaction time in a 75 minute driving simulator testLiterature Reviews that conclude that opioids do notimpair driving in the opioid-dependent person

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    46/83

    DocumentationDRE Evaluation

    Document performance impairment at the time of drivingEvaluation questions: Are you under the care of a physician?

    Methadone doseInquire how long the subject has been on the current doseScientific Literature

    Impairment with 30%increase in doseScientific literature

    Impaired psychomotor speed, decision making, inhibitorymechanisms, logical reasoning

    Defense:In MMT and on a stable dose of Methadone

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    47/83

    DocumentationComprehensive toxicology

    Documentation of no other drugs being

    consumed

    Defense:In MMT and on a stable dose of Methadone

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    48/83

    Methadone and Polydrug Use

    Search for Methadoneonly cases:I put the request out to all 400+DREs and so far all methadonecases involved other drugs Dan Mulleneaux, Region Irepresentative to TAP

    Not one of the cases came back Methadone alone NYSP Sgt.Doug Paquette Region III TAPRepresentative

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    49/83

    Methadone and Polydrug Use

    2007 - 52 cases (3%) positiveBlood level ranges = 29-836 ng/ml73% males

    18-81 y; Avg 38

    27% females21-44 y; Avg 31

    79% polydrug use19 (37%) w/Benzo17 (33%) w/Cannabis8 (15%) w/Cocaine8 (15%) w/Opioid

    Polydrug use with methadone

    4 drugs13% 1 Drug 21%

    2 Drugs45%

    3 Drugs21%

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    50/83

    Methadone and Polydrug Use in DWI CasesSouthwestern Institute of Forensic Sciences

    13% 5%

    19%

    6%52%

    14%

    Benzos Only

    Opiates Only

    Methadone Only

    COOH-THC Only

    Combo Drugs

    Contain CNSStimulants

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    51/83

    WA - High Prevalence of Other

    Drugs (98% - drivers)

    0.000

    0.100

    0.200

    0.3000.400

    0.500

    0.600

    O p i a t e s

    & O p i o

    i d s

    B e n z

    o d i a z

    e p i n e

    T r i c y

    c l i c

    S t i m

    u l a n t s

    A n t i h

    i s t a m

    i n e s

    S S R I

    s T H

    C

    S o m a

    A n t i - C

    o n v u l s a

    n t s

    O t h e

    r n o

    n e

    Post Mortem

    Drivers

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    52/83

    WA DRE Cases

    Methadone only significant finding32 cases

    Males 75%

    Age 40 (mean) 42 (median)Methadone concentration:

    0.26 mg/L mean 0.27 mg/L median42% involved in a MV collision

    Most commonly involved collisions with parked cars45% arrested for erratic driving (significantweaving)

    (1/3 of which were so bad, reported by cell phonecallers)

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    53/83

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    54/83

    WA DRE Cases

    DRE Testing Results

    Admissions: 78% Admitted using methadone31% Opiate Treatment Program34% Chronic Pain

    Test

    Walk and Turn

    One Leg Stand

    Romberg Balance

    Time Estmate

    Finger to Nose Generally Poor performance

    Performance

    5/8

    3/4

    Avg 2" sway

    Widely Variable

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    55/83

    INDIVIDUAL

    CASEEXAMPLES

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    56/83

    Pain Patient

    35 year old maleCollided with vehicle in same lane of travel

    Officers noted defendant sitting in hisvehicle nodding offRepeatedly asked the same questions

    DRE noted slurred speech, watery eyesand droopy eyelids

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    57/83

    Pain Patient

    Romberg Balance: 2-3 inches of swaySubject asked to repeat test (total 4)Estimated 30 secs as:

    36, 45, 10, 76 seconds

    Walk and Turn - 6/8 cluesLegs noticeably shaking

    One Leg Stand 3/4Finger to Nose - 5/6

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    58/83

    Pain Patient

    Admissions30 mg Methadone chronic pain3 hours before stop

    Blood Toxicology: 0.27 mg/L methadoneEDDP, caffeine, nicotine

    OutcomePhysician testified that methadone does not impairdrivingConvicted DUID

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    59/83

    Pez Dispenser

    20 year old male, single vehicle accidentSubject claimed he slid off the road due tosnow and ice (Actual temp - 56 F.)Subject had thick, slurredspeech, staggered and had difficultystandingDescribed as on the nod

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    60/83

    Romberg Balance swayed 3 front to back and 2 side to side

    Head tilted back so far he looked like a PezDispenser

    Walk & Turn Stumbled during instructionstwice, missed heel to toe every step, stoppedafter the turn (8/8)

    One-Leg-Stand repeatedly put his foot downand held onto wall for balance (4/4)

    Finger to nose only touched his nose 1/6 (with

    his knuckle) (6/6)

    Pez Dispenser

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    61/83

    Pupil size:Room Light: 3.0 mm (within normal)Darkness: 3.0 mm (constricted)

    Direct Light: 2.5 mm (within normal)Little to no reaction to lightPulse: 54, 56, 56 (normal = 60-90)BP: 128/68 (normal 120-140/60-90)Muscle Tone: Flaccid

    Pez Dispenser

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    62/83

    AdmissionsUnknown amount of methadone

    provided by a

    friend

    Blood Toxicology: 0.05 mg/L methadoneEDDP

    Pleaded guilty to DUI Drugs

    Pez Dispenser

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    63/83

    Implausible Deniability36 year old female, subject of multiple cellphone callers to 911Had struck a guardrail wiping out entire

    right side of her carWeaving back and forth across multiplelanesDisoriented and unaware she had been

    involved in a collisionDRE noted droopy eyelids, and constrictedpupilsSubject was very agitated

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    64/83

    Implausible Deniability

    Romberg balance 2 circular sway andestimated 21 seconds to be 30Walk & Turn Unable to stand withoutsway, 10 steps up, 9 back, 8/8 clues (talkednon-stop)One-Leg-Stand swayed, hopped , put footdown, used arms 4/4Finger to nose 4/6

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    65/83

    Implausible Deniability

    Pupil size:Room Light: 2.5 mm (within normal)Darkness: 3.0 mm (constricted)

    Direct Light: 2.0 mm (within normal)Little to no reaction to light

    Pulse: 92, 96, 96 (normal = 60-90)

    BP: 156/108 (normal 120-140/60-90)Muscle Tone: Normal

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    66/83

    Implausible Deniability

    AdmissionsMethadone at 7:30 am (15 hours prior to stop)

    Opiate treatment program claimed no one at theclinic told her it would impair her

    She continued to insist that she was not impaired

    Blood Toxicology: 0.35 mg/L methadone

    EDDP, caffeineConvicted of DUI Drugs

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    67/83

    Asleep at the Wheel

    53 year old female, subject of a Drunk Driver to 911Witness:

    Driver cut her off on a bridge

    Pulled over - Still there 1.5 hours laterSlumped over the wheelCar still on and in drive

    Initial officer:Difficulty keeping her eyes openSlurred SpeechHGN present; failed walk and turn

    BrAC = 0.00%

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    68/83

    Asleep at the Wheel

    Romberg balance 4 sway front to back and 3 sway side -to-side; estimated 34seconds to be 30

    Walk & Turn Unable to stand withoutsway, missed heel-to-toe on almost allsteps, used arms for balanceOne-Leg-Stand swayed, put foot

    down, used arms stopped for safety onboth legsFinger to nose missed touching herfingertip to nose on all six attempts

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    69/83

    Asleep at the WheelEyes - BloodshotHGN (immediate onset) and VGNPupil size:

    Room Light: 4.5 mm (within normal)Darkness: 5.0 mm (within normal)Direct Light: 3.0 mm (within normal)

    Little to no reaction to light

    Pulse: 102, 98, 100 (elevated; normal = 60-90)BP: 114/82 (low; normal 120-140/60-90)Muscle Tone: Flaccid

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    70/83

    Asleep at the Wheel

    AdmissionsOne 10 mg Methadone at 11:00 a.m. (7 hours prior)One 5 mg Klonopin at 4 or 5 p.m. (2-3 hrs prior)Got pills from another person

    DRE Opinion: CNS Depressant

    Toxicology: Urine

    Positive Methadone & Quetiapine (Seroquel)Clonazepam was not detected in the urine

    Elevated negative screen was not confirmed

    Active DUID Case

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    71/83

    Common Poly

    50 year old maleAuto AccidentStruck car waiting to make a left turn

    Responding Officer:ShakingDroopy, Reddened EyesLethargic - Slow to answer questionsInitial SFSTs:

    No HGN or VGNWalk and Turn Failed test; Body TremorsOne Leg Stand Discontinued for safety

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    72/83

    Common Poly

    Romberg balance 2 circularsway, estimated 15 seconds to be 30, eyelidand body tremors

    Walk & Turn Could not maintainbalance, missed heel-to-toe on almost allsteps, used arms for balanceOne-Leg-Stand swayed, put foot

    down, used arms; leg tremorsFinger to nose missed touching fingertipto nose on all six attempts; eyelid and legtremors

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    73/83

    Common Poly

    Eyes watery with reddened conjunctiva

    Pupil size:Room Light: 2.5 mm (within normal)Darkness: 5.0 mm (within normal)Direct Light: 1.5 mm (constricted)

    Normal reaction to light

    Pulse: 96, 104, 100 (normal = 60-90)BP: 192/84 (normal 120-140/60-90)

    Muscle Tone: Normal

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    74/83

    Common Poly

    Admissions: Furosemide (Lasix)

    Controlled Substance in car: Marijuana

    DRE Opinion: Cannabis

    Urine Toxicology:Methadone

    7-aminoclonazepam

    Active DUID Case

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    75/83

    Non-compliant MMT

    32 yo, maleSubject leaves MMT clinic; ~10 mins. later hitsand kills a 69 year old male pedestrian who iscrossing street.Subject Statements:

    Never saw the pedestrianHad placed a coffee between his legs and when helooked up the pedestrian was in his windshield

    WitnessesComing from both directions could see pedestrian

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    76/83

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    77/83

    Non-compliant MMT

    Day of Accident:No one notes anything unusual about subject;does not appear impairedSubject states that methadone does not have anyaffect on him and that he did not feel tired~7 hours after the crash subject is noticed fallingasleep in lobby at PDSubject states that he smoked pot about 1 weekagoSubjects attitude - very matter of fact showinglittle emotionSubject signs medical release forms

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    78/83

    Non-compliant MMT

    Methadone Doses

    5/1/2007

    75

    100

    125

    150

    175

    200

    225

    250

    275

    7 / 2 2

    / 2 0 0

    8 / 1 6

    / 2 0 0

    9 / 1 0

    / 2 0 0

    1 0 / 5 /

    2 0 0

    1 0 / 3 0

    / 2 0 0

    1 1 / 2 4

    / 2 0 0

    1 2 / 1 9

    / 2 0 0

    1 / 1 3

    / 2 0 0

    2 / 7 / 2 0

    0 6

    3 / 4 / 2 0

    0 6

    3 / 2 9

    / 2 0 0

    4 / 2 3

    / 2 0 0

    5 / 1 8

    / 2 0 0

    6 / 1 2

    / 2 0 0

    7 / 7 / 2 0

    0 6

    8 / 1 / 2 0

    0 6

    8 / 2 6

    / 2 0 0

    9 / 2 0

    / 2 0 0

    1 0 / 1 5

    / 2 0 0

    1 1 / 9 /

    2 0 0

    1 2 / 4 /

    2 0 0

    1 2 / 2 9

    / 2 0 0

    1 / 2 3

    / 2 0 0

    2 / 1 7

    / 2 0 0

    3 / 1 4

    / 2 0 0

    4 / 8 / 2 0

    0

    5 / 3 / 2 0

    0

    5 / 2 8

    / 2 0 0

    6 / 2 2

    / 2 0 0

    7 / 1 7

    / 2 0 0

    D o s e

    RED = Methadone dose when noncompliant

    positive for additional drug

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    79/83

    Non-compliant MMT

    Blood Toxicology:Alcohol - None Detected

    Delta-9-THC = NegativeDelta-9-Carboxy-THC= 18 ng/mlMethadone = 754 ng/ml

    Case Disposition Grand JuryTragic accident but no crime had beencommitted

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    80/83

    Summary of Case Examples

    Impairment may occur in individuals undera doctors careLow dose in a nave individual can be

    impairingPatients may not be properly informedMethadone patients may be non-compliantPolydrug use is commonMethadone in DUID prescribed forpain, MMT and through diversion

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    81/83

    In Conclusion

    Methadone can impair performanceFactors that must be considered:

    Reason for Use Pain, MMT, DiversionHealth of subjectHistory of Use a recent change?

    TolerancePolydrug Use

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    82/83

    Impairment can not bedetermined by quantitative

    blood toxicology alone.

    Paired with the observationsof a DRE, a determination

    of impairment can be made.

  • 8/8/2019 Methadone and Driving

    83/83

    Thank you

    Toxicologists:Lisa Callahan, GADr. Michael Wagner, NH

    Colleen Scarneo, NHDr. Jeanne Beno, NYJennifer Limoges, NYDr. Julia Pearson, VADr. Fiona Couper, WALaura Liddicoat, WIS

    DREs:Dan Mulleneaux, AZSgt. Doug Paquette, NYSP

    Sgt. Joe Reff, WatertownPD, NYAlan Bell, NiskayunaPD, NY