Upload
others
View
5
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
__________________________________
Metal Mobility in Hydrothermal Fluids:
Insights from ab initio Molecular Dynamics Simulations
__________________________________
YUAN MEI
B.Eng. (2007), East China University of Science and Technology, Shanghai, China
This thesis is submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in
School of Earth and Environmental Sciences at
The University of Adelaide
November 2013 Adelaide, Australia
i
Table of Contents Abstract ............................................................................................v!
Declaration .....................................................................................vii!
Acknowledgements .........................................................................ix!
List of publications .........................................................................xi!
Chapter 1 ........................................................................................1!1.1! Metal mobility in hydrothermal fluids ......................................................................3!1.2! Experimental approaches ..........................................................................................6!1.3! Advances of ab initio MD simulation in Geochemistry............................................9!
1.3.1! Quantum Mechanics (QM) calculations...........................................................10!1.3.2! Classical Molecular Dynamics (MD) ...............................................................13!1.3.3! Ab initio (First principles) MD and free energy calculation ............................15!
1.4! Molecular simulation and experimental data interpretation....................................18!1.5! Research objectives .................................................................................................19!1.6! Thesis organization .................................................................................................20!1.7! References ...............................................................................................................21!
Chapter 2 ......................................................................................33 2.0 Abstract ..................................................................................................................35
2.1 Introduction .............................................................................................................36
2.1.1 Molecular understanding of metal transport in hydrothermal fluids................36
2.1.2 Experimental studies of Cu–Cl and Cu–HS/H2S complexes............................36
2.1.3 Molecular dynamics simulations of metal complexes in hydrothermal
geochemistry.....................................................................................................37
2.1.4 Aims..................................................................................................................37
2.2 Computational methods ..........................................................................................38
2.2.1 Car–Parrinello molecular dynamics simulations..............................................38
2.2.2 Ab initio thermodynamic integration and free energy calculations .................38
2.2.3 Correction of standard state and calculation of formation constants................40
2.3 Results .....................................................................................................................41
2.3.1 Ab initio molecular dynamic simulations.........................................................41
ii
2.3.2 Ab initio thermodynamic integration and free energy calculations..................43
2.3.3 Geometries of metastable Cu(I) complexes forming during distance constrained
MD....................................................................................................................46
2.4 Discussion ...............................................................................................................47
2.4.1 MD simulations vs. experiments ......................................................................47
2.4.2 Entropy and complex formation .......................................................................49
2.4.3 Thermodynamic properties...............................................................................49
2.4.4 Geological implications ....................................................................................51
2.5 Acknowledgement...................................................................................................51
2.6 References ...............................................................................................................52
Chapter 3 ......................................................................................55 3.0 Abstract ..................................................................................................................57
3.1 Introduction .............................................................................................................57
3.2 Methods...................................................................................................................58
3.2.1 Static quantum mechanical (QM) calculations.................................................58
3.2.2 Ab-initio molecular dynamics (MD) simulations.............................................58
3.2.3 Spectroscopic calculations................................................................................59
3.3 Results .....................................................................................................................59
3.3.1 Static quantum mechanical calculations...........................................................59
3.3.2 Ab-initio molecular dynamics (MD) simulation ..............................................59
3.3.3 Spectroscopic properties...................................................................................61
3.4. Discussion and conclusion ........................................................................................62
3.4.1 Static/COSMO vs. ab initio MD.......................................................................62
3.4.2 S3! as a ligand in gold transport........................................................................62
3.4.3 Geological implications ....................................................................................62
3.5 Acknowledgement...................................................................................................64
3.6 References ...............................................................................................................64
Chapter 4 ......................................................................................67!4.0! Abstract ...................................................................................................................70!4.1! Introduction .............................................................................................................71!
4.1.1! Metal transport in hydrothermal fluids and aims of this study.........................71!4.1.2! Experimental studies of Zn(II)-chloride speciation..........................................73!4.1.3! Computational chemistry studies of Zn(II)-Cl speciation ................................74!
iii
4.2! Methodology ...........................................................................................................75!4.2.1! Ab initio molecular dynamics simulation.........................................................75!4.2.2! Ab initio thermodynamic integration ...............................................................77!
4.3! Results .....................................................................................................................79!4.3.1! Ab initio molecular dynamic simulations.........................................................79!4.3.2! Ab initio thermodynamic integration and free energy calculations .................90!
4.4! Refitting solubility data for Zn(II)-Cl complexes ...................................................95!4.4.1! Data sources and methods ................................................................................95!4.4.2! Fitting procedure...............................................................................................96!4.4.3! Speciation of Zn(II)-Cl based on solubility experiments .................................99!
4.5! Discussion .............................................................................................................103!4.5.1! Speciation of Zn(II)-Cl complexes .................................................................103!4.5.2! Ab initio MD vs experiments .........................................................................106!
4.6! Acknowledgement.................................................................................................108!4.7! References .............................................................................................................108!
Chapter 5 ....................................................................................115!5.0! Abstract .................................................................................................................118!5.1! Introduction ...........................................................................................................119!
5.1.1! Controls on metal solubility in hydrothermal fluids.......................................119!5.1.2! Complexing and hydration of Cu(I) and Au(I) in hydrothermal brines and
vapors..............................................................................................................121!5.1.3! Computational chemistry studies of metal speciation ....................................122!5.1.4! Aim of study ...................................................................................................124!
5.2! Method: Ab initio molecular dynamics simulations .............................................125!5.2.1! Computational methods..................................................................................125!5.2.2! Choice of model systems for comparison with experimental studies ............129!
5.3! Results ...................................................................................................................130!5.3.1! Cu(I) and Au(I) complexing as a function of solution density and temperature ..
........................................................................................................................130!5.3.2! Hydration numbers of Na, Cl, Cu and Au ......................................................138!5.3.3! Na-O and Cl-O bond distances.......................................................................140!
5.4! Discussion .............................................................................................................141!5.4.1! The nature of neutral Cu(I) and Au(I) chloro-complexes...............................141!
iv
5.4.2! Density dependence of the charged or neutral complexes..............................142!5.4.3! Density dependence of hydration of ions and metal complexes.....................146!5.4.4! Translational entropy and the density dependence of hydrothermal reactions.....
........................................................................................................................148!5.5! Acknowledgement.................................................................................................150!5.6! References .............................................................................................................150!
Chapter 6 ....................................................................................159!6.1! d10 transition metal ions complexation..................................................................161!6.2! Metal complexation in mixed ligand solutions .....................................................162!6.3! Thermodynamic properties ...................................................................................162!6.4! Current limitation ..................................................................................................163!6.5! Perspective and future work..................................................................................165!6.6! Reference...............................................................................................................166!
Appendix A...................................................................................169!
Appendix B...................................................................................215!
Appendix C...................................................................................239!
Appendix D...................................................................................255!
Appendix E...................................................................................259!
Appendix F ...................................................................................263!
Appendix G ..................................................................................267!
Appendix H ..................................................................................271!
Appendix I ....................................................................................275!
v
Abstract Aqueous fluids are an important medium for transporting metals in the Earth’s crust, and are
responsible for the formation of many ore deposits. The nature and thermodynamic
properties of metal complexes in hydrothermal fluids plays a key role in controlling
elemental mobility and mineral solubility in natural and man-made systems. The bulk of our
knowledge on metal complexation in hydrothermal fluids originates from experimental
studies. Experimental studies at extreme conditions (i.e. high temperature and pressure) are
challenging; they can be carried on only over limited P-T-x conditions, and require an
accurate speciation model for interpretation. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations are
coming of age for studying metals in hydrothermal processes; the simulations can support
the interpretation of experiments; explore conditions beyond the range over which
experiments are available; and provide a molecular-level understanding of hydrothermal
metal mobility.
In this thesis, ab initio (first principles) molecular dynamics (MD) simulations based on
density functional theory were conducted to predict the stochiometries and geometries of
Cu(I), Au(I) and Zn(II) complexes in solutions with different ligands (Cl–, H2O/OH–, HS–
/H2S, S3–) at temperatures and pressures ranging from ambient to hydrothermal/magmatic
conditions. The important complexes related to metal transport in fluids with different
temperatures, pressures and ligand concentrations were simulated. The simulations
accurately reproduce the identities and geometries of metal complexes derived from
experimental studies, where available. The ab initio MD also demonstrates novel complexes
which have not yet been observed by experiments (i.e. CuCl(HS)–, AuS3(HS)–, AuS3(OH)–,
AuS3(H2O)).
vi
The thermodynamic properties of metal-ligand association/dissociation reactions of Cu(I)-
Cl-HS and Zn(II)-Cl complexes were investigated by distance-constrained MD simulations
using thermodynamic integration. The predicted equilibrium constants (logK) for the ligand
substitution reactions at high temperature (i.e. >= 300 ˚C) show good agreement (within 1-2
log units) with the experimental values. Although the slow kinetics at lower temperatures
(i.e. < 200 ˚C) leads to a decrease in the accuracy of the predicted logKs, MD simulations
can still reproduce the trends of the change of metal mobility successfully. The predictions
of the stoichiometry and thermodynamic properties demonstrate the potential of MD
simulations in studying metal mobility in hydrothermal fluids.
vii
Declaration I certify that this work contains no material which has been accepted for the award of any
other degree or diploma in any university or other tertiary institution and, to the best of my
knowledge and belief, contains no material previously published or written by another
person, except where due reference has been made in the text. In addition, I certify that no
part of this work will, in the future, be used in a submission for any other degree or diploma
in any university or other tertiary institution without the prior approval of the University of
Adelaide and where applicable, any partner institution responsible for the joint-award of this
degree.
I give consent to this copy of my thesis when deposited in the University Library, being
made available for loan and photocopying, subject to the provisions of the Copyright Act
1968.
The author acknowledges that copyright of published works contained within this thesis
resides with the copyright holder(s) of those works.
I also give permission for the digital version of my thesis to be made available on the web,
via the University’s digital research repository, the Library catalogue and also through web
search engines, unless permission has been granted by the University to restrict access for a
period of time.
Signature: Date: 18-Nov-2013
viii
ix
Acknowledgements My heart is always full of gratitude when I look back to the past three years and a half that I
spent on my PhD study. I was lucky to get into this exciting and inter-disciplinary project
which fits my academic background but also poses a challenge to my existing knowledge
and experience. I have achieved more than what I expected from a PhD, not only in the
academic research, but also in the benefits of diverse cultural exchange from different
background, as well as the charming personalities of my supervisors and colleagues.
I am greatly grateful to all my supervisors, Prof. Joël Brugger, Prof. David Sherman and Dr.
Weihua Liu, for taking me into the mysterious geochemistry world. With them I have
experienced systematic training from the laboratory to the field, from molecular dynamics
simulation to geochemical modelling, and from scientific paper writing to conference
presentation. Their board knowledge, countless curiosity and the endless passion into
science encouraged me to explore the unknown world. This thesis would not be completed
without their infinite patience and unreserved support.
I am thankful to my colleagues based in South Australian Museum, Dr. Barbara Etschmann,
Prof. Allan Pring, Dr. Fang Xia (now in CSIRO Clayton), Dr. Pascal Grundler (now in PSI
Switzerland) and Dr. Frank Reith for their helpful suggestions. I am also thankful to Dr.
Denis Testemale in ESRF/CNRS and Dr. Stacey Borg in CSIRO for sharing ideas. It was
great time to study in Adelaide, many thanks to School of Earth and Environmental
Sciences for providing administrations, and South Australian Museum for office and
laboratories. Thanks a lot to the School of Earth Sciences in University of Bristol for
organising my study with Prof. David Sherman in Bristol, UK.
x
I would like to acknowledge eResearchSA (Adelaide), iVEC (Perth) and BlueCrystal
(Bristol, UK) for the access of high performance computing facilities. I also appreciate
Australian Synchrotron and ESRF for provision of synchrotron XAS beamtime and lab
facilities. This thesis has been examined by Prof. Julian Gale and Prof. Terry Seward, whose
helpful reviews and comments are greatly appreciated.
I appreciate Australian government and the University of Adelaide for providing IPRS
Scholarship and CSIRO for the Minerals Down Under Flagship Postgraduate Scholarship to
support my PhD study. This project is also supported by Australian Research Council (ARC)
under discovery project DP0878903.
Last but not least, I thank all my families in China for their support and encouragements.
Particularly, to my dear husband Dr. Yuan Tian for accompanying me in Adelaide. Yuan’s
solid support from both life and study enable me to finish this thesis on time at better quality.
Thanks for Yuan’s constant love during my whole PhD.
xi
List of publications This PhD thesis is of publication format. Four papers constructed this PhD thesis, including
TWO PUBLISHED PAPERS
1 Yuan Mei*; David M Sherman; Weihua Liu; Joël Brugger*, Complexation of gold in
S3–-rich hydrothermal fluids: Evidence from ab-initio molecular dynamics simulations,
Chemical Geology, 2013, 347, 34-42
2 Yuan Mei; David M Sherman; Weihua Liu; Joël Brugger, Ab initio molecular
dynamics simulation and free energy exploration of copper(I) complexation by chloride
and bisulfide in hydrothermal fluids, Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 2013, 102, 45-
64
ONE SUBMITTED MANUSCRIPT:
3 Yuan Mei; David M Sherman; Weihua Liu; Joël Brugger, The effect of solution
density on ion hydration and metal complexation: ab initio molecular dynamics
simulation of Cu(I) and Au(I) in chloride brines (25-1000 °C, 1-5000 bar), accepted
pending revisions in Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta
ONE MANUSCRIPT PREPARED FOR SUBMISSION
4 Yuan Mei; David M Sherman; Weihua Liu; Joël Brugger, thermodynamic properties of
Zn-Cl complexation from ab initio MD simulation, to be submitted to a geochemistry
journal.
OTHER PUBLICATIONS RELATED TO THIS THESIS:
SUBMITTED MANUSCRIPT
A Yuan Tian; Barbara Etschmann; Yuan Mei; Pascal Groundler; Denis Testemale; Yung
Ngothai; Joël Brugger, Speciation and thermodynamic properties of Manganese (II)
xii
chloride complexes in hydrothermal fluids: in situ XAS study, accepted pending
revisions in Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta
REFEREED JOURNAL PAPERS
B Yuan Tian; Barbara Etschmann; Weihua Liu; Yuan Mei; Denis Testemale; Brian
O'Neil; Nick Rae; David Sherman; Yung Ngothai; Stacey Borg; Joël Brugger,
Speciation of Nickel (II) chloride complexes in hydrothermal fluids: in situ XAS study,
Chemical Geology, 2012, 334, 345-363
C Weihua Liu, Stacey Borg, Barbara Etschmann, Yuan Mei, Joël Brugger, An XAS study
of speciation and thermodynamic properties of aqueous zinc bromide complexes at 25–
150 °C, Chemical Geology, 2012, 298-299, 57–69
REFEREED CONFERENCE ABSTRACTS
D Yuan Mei, David M Sherman, Weihua Liu and Joël Brugger, Speciation and
thermodynamic properties of d10 transition metals: insights from ab-initio Molecular
Dynamics simulations, 34th International Geological Congress (IGC) 2012, August
2012, Brisbane, Australia
E Yuan Mei, David M Sherman, Joël Brugger, Weihua Liu, Zn-Cl Complexation in
Magmatic-Hydrothermal Solutions: Stability Constants from Ab initio Molecular
Dynamics, Goldschmidt Conference 2012, June 2012, Montreal, Canada
F Yuan Mei, David M Sherman, Joël Brugger, Weihua Liu, Ab initio molecular
dynamics simulation of copper(I) complexation in chloride/sulfide fluids, Goldschmidt
Conference 2011, August 2011, Prague, Czech Republic
G Weihua Liu, Barbara Etschmann, Denis Testemale, Yuan Mei, Jean-Louis Hazemann,
Kirsten Rempel, Harald Müller, Joël Brugger, Which Ligand is the most Import for
Gold Transport in Hydrothermal Fluids? An in situ XAS Study in Mixed-Ligand
Solutions, Goldschmidt Conference 2013, August 2013, Florence, Italy
xiii
H Weihua Liu, Stacey Borg, Barbara Etschmann, Yuan Mei, Denis Testemale, David
Sherman and Joël Brugger, Molecular-level understanding of metal transport in
hydrothermal ore fluids: in situ experiments and ab initio molecular dynamic
simulations, 34th International Geological Congress (IGC) 2012, August 2012,
Brisbane, Australia
I David M Sherman, Yuan Mei, Metal Complexation in Hydrothermal Fluids: Insights
from Ab initio Molecular Dynamics, Goldschmidt Conference 2011, August 2011,
Prague, Czech Republic
xiv
1
_____________________________________
Chapter 1
Introduction
_____________________________________
2
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
3
1.1 Metal mobility in hydrothermal fluids
Most of the World’s metals resources (Fe, Mn, Au, Cu, Zn, Co, Pb, U, Mo, etc) are mined
from hydrothermal ore deposits. Metals concentrations form as a result of the flow of
aqueous fluids within the Earth Crust, and the ability of these fluids to re-distribute metals
(Seward and Barnes, 1997). Understanding the mobility of metals in hydrothermal fluids
underlies our knowledge of not only natural systems, such as the formation of ore deposits
in the Earth’s Crust and water-rock interactions in geothermal systems, but also industrial
processes such as corrosion in power plants, hydrometallurgy, and material synthesis and
catalysis.
Ore-forming fluids cover wide ranges of temperature (25 to >600 °C), pressure (0.1 to >500
MPa), and compositions (from pure water to complex composition with up to >50 mol%
salt such as NaCl, KCl, CaCl2), and it is known that metals are dissolved and transported in
hydrothermal fluids by forming aqueous complexes with various ligands (e.g. Cl–, HS–, NH3,
OH–, CH3COO–; review in Seward and Barnes, 1997). In addition, the coordination
geometry of aqueous complexes can also change as a function of temperature, pressure, and
fluid composition; this will affect the stability of the nature and stability of the dominant
complexes, which in turn affects the solubility of metals in the fluids. Therefore, in order to
understand the behavior of metals in hydrothermal fluids and provide thermodynamic data
for numerical modeling of metal mobility in various natural and man-made hydrothermal
systems, it is crucial to understand coordination and stability of aqueous metal complexes in
hydrothermal fluids at different T, P and salinity conditions.
Based on available field and laboratory observations, sulfur and chlorine species are
considered to play a prominent role in metal dissolution, transport and deposition in
hydrothermal fluids (Seward and Barnes, 1997). For instance, it is recognized that copper
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
4
(I)-chloride (e.g., Crerar and Barnes, 1976; Hemley et al., 1992; Seyfried and Ding 1993;
Xiao et al., 1998; Liu W et al., 2001; Hack and Mavrogenes, 2006) and copper (I)-
hydrosulfides complexes (e.g., Crerar and Barnes, 1976; Mountain and Seward, 1999; 2003)
are most likely responsible for copper transport in aqueous fluids; Au(I) hydrosulfide
complexes dominate Au transport in most hydrothermal environments (Seward, 1973;
Stefánsson and Seward, 2004; review in Williams-Jones et al., 2009). Another sulfur ligand,
the blue trisulfur ion S3–, was found in S-rich solutions at P > 0.5 GPa and T > 250 °C
(Giggenbach 1971; Pokrovski and Dubrovinsky, 2011). Quantum chemical calculations and
molecular dynamics simulations show that this ligand is likely to play an important role in
Au and Cu transport (Tossell, 2012; Mei et al., 2013b; Chapter 3 of this thesis).
The formation of metal complexes in hydrothermal fluids is affected by many factors,
including temperature, pressure and chemical properties of fluids (i.e., ligand concentration,
and redox and pH conditions). Temperature and pressure affect complexing mainly by
changing the properties of water as a solvent (Seward and Barnes, 1997; Seward and
Driesner, 2004). The structure of water (hydrogen bonding network; clustering) changes
significantly as temperature and pressure change; as a result, the macroscopic properties of
water (i.e. dipole moment, dielectric constant (DC), ion product constant (Kw)) change,
which affects the solvation, stability, stoichiometry, and coordination of metal complexes in
solution. The effect of temperature in metal complexation is illustrated by considering the
stability of cobalt-chloride complexes. Co(II) complexes show a decrease in coordination
number from six- (octahedral) to four-fold (tetrahedral) with increasing temperature (Liu W
et al., 2011a). Increasing NaCl concentration has a similar effect as increasing temperature:
the predominant Co(II)-Cl complex changes from octahedral CoCl(H2O)5+ to tetrahedral
CoCl42–. As a result of this change in coordination, cobalt solubility shows a complex
evolution with temperature for example (Figure 1.1, Liu W et al., 2011a). Also note that
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
5
speciation models based on extrapolations from room-temperature experiments would lead
to poor predictions, since Co(II) speciation at T > ~200˚C is dominated by tetrahedral
complexes that are not stable at room temperature.
Figure 1.1 Solubility of CoS2-CoS in 3 m NaCl solutions as a function of temperature (Liu
W et al., 2011a) (magenta for Co, green for Cl, red for O and pink for H).
Pressure also is expected to affect coordination chemistry. This is illustrated for example by
Suleimenov et al. (2004)’s UV-Vis study of aqueous Ni chloride complexes in supercritical
brines showed significant blueshift of measured spectra with change of pressure from 300 to
900 bar at constant temperature, which indicated the change from tetrahedral to octahedral
coordination of nickel species. The redox and pH conditions can also control metal
solubility because they affect the nature of the ligands. This is especially true in the case of
sulfur. HS– is the predominant S species in reduced, alkaline conditions, and the stable range
of pH and redox changes with temperature (Figs 1.2a,b). Further complexity of sulfur
geochemistry is introduced by the possible stability of “exotic” S species under high
pressure, such as the polysulfur ions S3– (Pokrovski and Dubrovinsky, 2011; Figure 1.2c).
Heating and/or decompression of hydrothermal fluids can lead to phase separation, which
also changes the complexation of metals and leads to the re-distribution of metals in the
0.001
0.01
0.1
1
10
100
Co
Con
cent
ratio
n (p
pm)
300200100Temperature (!C)
"#$%&'()'*+(*%+,-%$'.(+'#//'0('$*%1-%$
"#$%&'()'()/2'0(0/3
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
6
vapor and liquid phases (Williams-Jones and Heinrich, 2005; Pudack et al., 2009). In the
past decades, numerous experimental and theoretical studies have been conducted to
investigate metal chloride and bisulfide complexes under hydrothermal conditions. In the
following sections some relevant studies will be briefly reviewed, and the aims of this PhD
project will be outlined.
Figure 1.2 pH-redox diagrams of sulfur species (0.1 m SO42–) at 25 °C, 1 bar (a), 300 °C,
500 bar (b) and 350 °C, 5k bar (c) calculated using the Geochemist’s Workbench (Bethke,
2008) using the data in Suleimenov and Seward, (1997) for (a,b) and Pokrovski and
Dubrovinsky, (2011) for (c).
1.2 Experimental approaches
Many experimental studies have been conducted to investigate the stability and coordination
structure of aqueous metal complexes under hydrothermal conditions relevant to
hydrothermal ore systems (Ulmer and Barnes, 1987; McKibben and Williams, 1989;
Hemley et al., 1992; Seward and Barnes, 1997; Liu W et al., 2008). These studies used a
variety of experimental methods, including solubility, spectroscopy using Ultraviolet-
Visible-Near Infrared (UV-Vis-NIR) and X-ray radiations, and potentiometric approaches.
Solubility experiments have provided us with the bulk of the knowledge about metal
behavior under hydrothermal conditions relevant for the formation of ore deposits (e.g.,
McKibben and Williams, 1989; Wood and Samson, 1998; Fleet and Knipe, 2000; Zezin et
!"# !$# !%#
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
7
al., 2007; Liu W et al., 2008). These experiments measure directly the concentrations of
dissolved metals at equilibrium with a known mineral (or mineral assemblage) in solutions
of known and well-constrained chemistry. Series of measurements conducted under varying
conditions (e.g., P,T, ligand concentration, pH) can be interpreted to recover the
stoichiometries and stability constants of metal complexes. These quantitative
thermodynamic properties, gathered from simplified experimental systems, can be used to
model metal transport in complex hydrothermal fluids (Crerar et al., 1985; Ulmer and
Barnes, 1987).
Solubility measurements provide direct information on the concentrations of metals that can
be carried in a specific fluid under given P,T conditions, but they do not provide a direct
insight into the molecular-level structure of the aqueous complexes responsible for metal
mobility. On the other hand, spectroscopic methods, such as UV-Vis spectroscopy and in
particular X-ray Absorption Spectroscopy (XAS) are sensitive to aspects of the electronic
structure of the aqueous complexes, and are hence capable of providing information on the
coordination structure of the species in solution. For example, when forming a metal
complex, the d-orbitals of transition metal ions split, and these changes in d-orbital energies
are reflected in the electronic spectra (e.g. UV-Vis) (Ulmer and Barnes, 1987; Janes and
Moore, 2004). As metal complexes form with specific geometries that reflect the ligand-
field splitting, the measured UV-Vis spectra allow to study the coordination geometry of
these complexes.
Understanding of the coordination geometry of complexes is essential for the setup of the
correct speciation model to interpret experimental data, because this geometry limits the
possible stoichiometries of the complexes. A typical example is the speciation of copper (I)
in chloride brines. By 2007, the consensus arising from a large body of experimental work
was that CuCl(aq) and CuCl2– were the main Cu complexes in brines, with CuCl4
3– stable at
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
8
high salinity and low temperature (reviewed in Brugger et al., 2007). However, synchrotron-
based XAS studies (Fulton et al., 2001; Brugger et al., 2007) showed that CuCl43– is not
stable in solution under any conditions, a surprising result given that the CuCl43– moiety is
found in many solids that crystallize from salty solutions. Instead, low temperature
(<200 °C), high salinity solutions contain trigonal planar CuCl32–, while under all other
conditions linear complexes (CuCl2- and CuCl(H2O)(aq) predominate. These results were
cross-proofed independently by an ab initio MD study (Sherman, 2007). Based on this new
understanding of the coordination chemistry of Cu(I) chloro complexes as a function of
temperature and salinity, Brugger et al. (2007) re-interpretation earlier UV-Vis (Liu W et al.,
2002) and solubility (Xiao et al., 1998; Liu W et al., 2001) data. This enabled the
construction of a self-consistent thermodynamic model, which greatly improved our
understanding of Cu transport in hydrothermal fluids (Liu W et al. 2008).
Synchrotron-based XAS has proved to be a powerful tool to study metal species at
molecular level (review in Brugger et al., 2010). In particular, the development of
spectroscopic autoclaves for in situ XAS measurement of solutions up to supercritical
conditions has made it possible to directly determine the structure of aqueous complexes at
high PT (e.g., Seward et al., 1996; Fulton et al., 2001; Testemale et al., 2005, Liu et al.,
2007; Tian et al., 2012). In the past decade a number of in situ studies have investigated the
geometries, speciation and thermodynamic properties of aqueous transition metal complexes
at elevated temperatures and pressures, such as Zn(II)-Cl (Mayanovic et al., 1999; Liu W et
al., 2007), Fe(II)-Cl (Liu W et al., 2007; Testemale et al., 2009), Co(II)-Cl (Liu W et al.,
2011a), Mn(II)-Br (Chen et al., 2005a,b), Ni(II)-Cl (Hoffmann et al., 1999); Zn(II)-Br (Liu
W et al., 2012a; Appendix C of this thesis), Cd(II)-Cl (Bazarkina et al., 2010); Cu(I)-Cl
(Brugger et al., 2007; Liu W et al., 2008); Cu(I)-HS (Etschmann et al., 2010); Au(I)-Cl
(Pokrovski et al., 2009a); Au(I)-HS (Pokrovski et al., 2009b); Ag(I)-Cl (Pokrovski et al.,
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
9
2013). Synchrotron XAS based studies have shed light on the detailed molecular-level
understanding of these systems, and refine or confirm the interpretation of the available
experimental data.
Experimental studies have provided the majority of the available structural and
thermodynamic data that underpin our understanding of metal mobility under hydrothermal
conditions. However, there are still some limitations of experimental methods used for the
determination of structural information: 1) The PT condition of in situ experiments are
limited by technical difficulties, such as corrosion and mechanical properties to withstand
high PT. 2) Every experimental method has its intrinsic limitations. For example, UV-Vis
only provide indirect information about the structure of the metal complexes; and XAS is
not able to see the second coordination shell, and ligands with similar numbers of electrons
can be difficult to distinguish (e.g., Cl– and HS–). 3) It would be desirable to have
independent crosscheck and molecular models to help interpret experimental data. With the
advances of high-performance computing techniques, molecular dynamics simulation has
come to age as an alternative and complementary approach to study metal speciation at
molecular level in hydrothermal fluids under and beyond experimental conditions.
1.3 Advances of ab initio MD simulation in Geochemistry
The theories and approaches of molecular simulations are demonstrated briefly in Figure 1.3,
which shows the theories, various approaches and output information in those methods. In
the past decades, numerous studies based on Quantum Mechanics (QM) calculations and
Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations have been conducted, which provided knowledge of
speciation, thermodynamic properties and spectroscopic properties of mineral surface,
aqueous metal complexes and melting systems (review in Sherman, 2001).
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
10
Figure 1.3 Theories and approaches of molecular simulation methods.
1.3.1 Quantum Mechanics (QM) calculations As shown in Figure 1.3, quantum mechanics (or first principles) calculations are based on
solving the Schrödinger equation (Eq. 1.1).
!! = "! (1.1)
where H is the Hamiltonian operator, ! is the wavefunction, E is the total energy of the
system. In QM calculations, E is the internal energy and the thermodynamic properties can
be predicted via statistical mechanics if all the values of E for all the possible states of the
system were known. However, for all but the simplest system, the Schrödinger equation
does not have an analytic solution. In quantum chemistry, the computation of the energy and
the wavefunction of an average-size molecule is a formidable task that is alleviated by the
Born–Oppenheimer (BO) approximation (Born and Oppenheimer, 1927). Density functional
theory (DFT) was developed in the physics community and for many years was neglected
by computational chemists (Thomas, 1927; Parr and Yang, 1989). In the past decade,
however, improvements in the formalism have allowed electronic structure calculations on
very large systems and it is now a standard tool for inorganic and physical chemists (Lee et
al., 1988; Parr and Yang, 1989). DFT is an exact theorem with unknown solution so the
=
Structure Physical properties Thermodynamics Kinetics Spectroscopy …
F = ma
Quantum Mechanics
Forcefield
Empirical Potential
Classical Molecular Dynamics
Ab initio/First principle Molecular Dynamics
e.g., CPMD
Interatomic Potential
Static calculation, @ 0 Kelvin, gas phase
+ Continuum Model
e.g., COSMO @ T in solution
Approximation (Hartree-Fock or DFT)
+
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
11
Kohn-Sham approximation (Kohn and Sham, 1965) has to be used for most practical
calculations. The Kohn–Sham equation is the Schrödinger equation of a fictitious system of
non-interacting particles (typically electrons) that generate the same density as any given
system of interacting particles (Kohn and Sham, 1965; Parr and Yang, 1989). Most
geochemical problems are of a sufficient complexity to warrant the use of density functional
theory.
Transition metal ions in group BII in the periodic table (e.g., Zn2+, Cd2+, Hg2+) were
extensively investigated by QM, as the fully occupied d-orbitals in those metal ions renders
electronic structure calculations much easier than for metals with unpaired electrons. For
example, Tossell (1991) calculated the structures, stabilities and spectroscopic properties of
Zn(II)-Cl complexes in aqueous solutions by Hartree-Fock methods. Using the same
methods, Butterworth et al. (1992) studied Cd(II)-Cl, Cd(II)-Br, Zn(II)-Cl species in
aqueous solution, and Tossell and Vaughan (1993) Zn(II) and Cd(II) bisulfide aqueous
complexes. Asthagiri et al., (2004) investigated the hydration structure of aqueous dications
of alkaline earth and Zn2+ by quantum chemical calculations between the ion and its first-
shell water molecules and used a dielectric continuum model to supply for outer-shell
contribution. These calculations gave the following optimized geometries: six-fold
structures for Zn2+, Cd2+, Hg2+ aqua complexes (e.g., Zn(H2O)62+, Cd(H2O)6
2+, Hg(H2O)62+)
and four- or six-fold structure for Zn2+, Cd2+, Hg2+ chloride complexes (e.g., Zn(H2O)2Cl2,
Cd(H2O)4Cl2, Cd(H2O)Cl3). The structural properties are in good agreement with
experimental studies by X-ray diffraction (Ohtaki et al., 1974, 1976; Tabata and Ozutsumi,
1992) and XAS (D’Angelo et al., 2002; Liu W et al., 2007; Bazarkina et al., 2010;
Migliorati et al., 2011). QM calculations also indicate a hydration number of 6 for Cl–, and
the loss of hydration water of Cl– explained why forming complex is favored by increasing
of entropy (Sherman, 2001; 2007). Cations in group BI (Cu+, Ag+, Au+) with fully occupied
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
12
d-orbitals share similar electronic structures as ions in group BII, but the QM calculations of
their aquo species (Feller et al., 1999) gave different structures, with two-fold Cu(H2O)2+
and Au(H2O)2+, and three-fold (Ag(H2O)3
+) complexes being stable.
To simulate the complexation for transition metals ions with open-shell configurations (e.g.,
Mn, Ni, Fe), spin-unrestricted calculation is usually needed and the electronic configuration
is defined by multiplicity (i.e. to distinguish wavefunctions that only have different
orientation of angular spin momenta, defined as 2S+1, where S is the angular spin
momentum). By comparing the structural properties calculated at certain spin configuration,
the d-orbital configuration related to coordination chemistry can be understood. For
example, the high-spin ground state of Fe3+ aqua complex was confirmed by calculated the
electronic structure of Fe(H2O)63+ (Harris et al., 1997). Electronic structure study of the
manganese minerals rhodochrosite (MnCO3) indicates a high spin (5 unpaired electrons)
Mn2+ configuration (Sherman, 2009), which has been adopted to optimize geometries of
Mn-Cl and Mn-Br complexes and finally cross-proofed by synchrotron XAS measurement
(Appendix A in this thesis). Although there are still uncertainties of DFT in assessing the
spin-state splitting for transition metals (Harvey, 2004), DFT can be an inexpensive and
useful method to predict spin-states and related geometric and energetic properties. QM was
also employed for investigating s- (e.g., Ca, Mg, Sr by Feller, 1999) and p- (e.g., Sb by
Tossell, 1994) block metals of geological interest.
Quantum mechanics calculations relate to the ideal gas phase, or use a “Polarizable
Continuum Model” to represent the solvent (e.g., COnductor-like Screening MOdel
(COSMO), Klamt and Schuurmann, 1993 in Figure 1.3). Simulation of aqueous solutions is
challenging because of the dipole and hydrogen bond of water molecules, and the properties
of water changes dramatically with changing of T and P (i.e. dielectric constant, Debye and
Hückel, 1923). In molecular dynamics simulations (MD), water molecules are used to
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
13
represent the solvation. Two approaches based on different level of theory - classical MD
and ab initio (or first principles) MD were applied to simulation aqueous systems at variable
temperatures and pressures.
1.3.2 Classical Molecular Dynamics (MD)
In classical MD, the atomic interactions are described using empirical inter-atomic
potentials, which normally consists of a long-range Coulombic force and a short-range
repulsive/attractive force (Sherman, 2001). For example, Equation (1.2) is widely employed
to describe the interaction Uij between ions i and j:
(1.2)
where qi and qj are the charges of ions i and j; #ij and $ij are the potential parameters; rij is
the distance between ions i and j. The potential parameters for ions i and j can be calculated
by Equation (1.3) with known parameters for a single ion:
!
" ij = " i" j and
!
" ij =" i +" j
2 (1.3)
In Equation (1.2), Lennard-Jones potential (first term of Eq. 1.2) describes short-range
interactions (Verlet, 1967) and Coulombic term (second term of Eq. 1.2) describes long-
range interactions.
For the simulations of aqueous fluids, water molecules are significant but also difficult to
describe accurately. A number of rigid water molecule models (i.e. O-H bond length and H-
O-H bond angle are fixed) have been developed for classical MD simulations (e.g., MCY by
Matsuoka et al., 1976; TIPS2 and TIP4P by Jorgensen 1982; Jorgensen et al., 1983; SPC
and SPC/E by Berendsen et al. 1987). The SPC (Simple Point Charge) and SPC/E
(Extended Simple Point Charge) (Berendsen et al., 1987) water models were used in many
!
Uij = 4" ij# ij
rij
$
% & &
'
( ) )
12
*# ij
rij
$
% & &
'
( ) )
6+
,
- -
.
/
0 0
+qiq j
rij
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
14
studies because of their simplicity and computational efficiency. For example, Driesner et al.
(1998) investigated the change of ion pairing, hydration and bond distances as functions of
temperature, pressure and fluid density in NaCl solutions from ambient to supercritical
conditions. Sherman and Collings (2002) used the SPC/E model for water together with
some empirical values from Smith and Dang (1994) for Lennard-Jones potentials to
simulate the nature of concentrated sodium chloride and water mixtures under various
temperatures, pressures and salinities and the MD results showed good correspondence to
the experimental solution densities and phase diagram. A few previous studies have used
classical MD to predict the physical and chemical properties of NaCl fluids, such as
densities, ion pairing and ion hydration, conductance, phase diagram, and dielectric
constants (Oelkers and Helgeson, 1993; Smith and Dang, 1994; Cui and Harris, 1995;
Driesner et al., 1998; John, 1998; Lee et al., 1998; Sherman and Collings, 2002; Chialvo and
Simonson, 2003).
The advantage of classical MD is that large scale simulations can be conducted to
investigate the chemical and physical processes over relatively long times (i.e. several
nanosecond) and for large simulation sizes (i.e. thousand to million particles; more than one
phase), which can help to explain many important questions in geochemistry such as
mineral formation, crystal growth, phase separation, surface absorption, etc. For example,
the calcite-water interface and the nucleation of calcium carbonate have been investigated
by force-field and molecular dynamics simulations (Raiteri et al., 2010; Raiteri and Gale,
2010). A new force-field model was developed, that accurately predicted the
thermodynamics of aqueous CaCO3 system, and led to the development of a nonclassical
model for the nucleation of CaCO3 nanoparticles via a liquid-like phase (Demichelis et al.,
2011).
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
15
Classical MD has been applied with great success to predict the properties of solutions of
alkali and alkaline earth metals, for which electrostatic interactions are predominant
(Sherman, 2001). However, to describe the interatomic interactions involving transition
metals like Cu, Ni, or Au (Sherman, 2010), more complicated models which beyond the
simple pairwise model of classical MD are required. For such systems, the interatomic
interactions need to be described by complexed force-fields models, or quantum
mechanically. The development of plane-wave pseudopotential methods for electronic
structure calculations enables us to conduct ab initio MD simulation to investigate transition
metals.
1.3.3 Ab initio (First principles) MD and free energy calculation
Ab initio MD simulations treat atomic interactions following the principles of quantum
mechanics using density functional theory (Fig. 1.3). For example, in the Car-Parrinello
method (Car and Parrinello, 1985), the electronic wavefunctions were incorporated into the
MD scheme by defining the extended Lagrangian (Eq. 1.4):
!
L = 12i
" µ d 3r ˙ # i$%
2+ 1
2I" M I
˙ R I2 + 1
2v" µ& ˙ ' &
2 (E[{#i},{Ri},{'&}] (1.4)
The first term implements the constraint that the one-electron Kohn–Sham orbitals (
!
" i) are
orthonormal with Lagrange multipliers; the second term is the classical kinetic energy of the
nuclei with mass M and coordinates R; the third is the kinetic energy of the wavefunctions
with fictitious mass µ; the fourth term is the Kohn-Sham total energy that is a function of the
electronic charge density (as function of the orbitals
!
" i), nuclear positions (Ri) and external
constraints on the system (%&). Current CPU capacity allows us to calculate systems for
simulation time up to several dozen picoseconds with hundreds of atoms (discussed in Mei
et al., 2013a;b; Chapter 2,3,4 in this thesis).
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
16
Over the past decade, ab initio MD has been employed to predict the aqueous speciation of
transition metals with d10 electronic structures in hydrothermal fluids. For instance, Harris et
al. (2003) determined Zn(II) speciation in chloride-rich brines (Cl– concentration up to
7.4 m) at 25 °C and 300 °C, which indicates stable octahedral structures with one or two
chloride ions complexed at low temperature and tetrahedral clusters with three or four
chloride ions. Sherman (2007) explored the speciation of Cu(I) chloro-complexes and found
that the linear CuCl2– complex predominates at hydrothermal conditions instead of the
tetrahedral CuCl43– complex proposed by the UV-Vis study (Liu W et al., 2002). This result
was confirmed independently by the XAS study of Brugger et al. (2007). Since Sherman
(2007)’s seminal study, more speciation and geometry studies of transition metals in
hydrothermal fluids by ab initio MD achieved good agreement with experiments (Table 1.1).
Table 1.1 Bond distances of metal complexes - comparing MD with XAS
Bond distance (Å)¶ Metal complexes MD XAS
CuCl2–
2.15 (Sherman, 2007) 2.13 (Mei et al., 2013a; Chapter 2)
2.152(7) (Brugger et al., 2007) 2.12–2.13 (Fulton et al., 2000a,b)
Cu(HS)2– 2.16 (Mei et al., 2013a; Chapter 2) 2.149(9) (Etschmann et al., 2010)
AuCl2– 2.27-2.32 (Chapter 5) 2.267(4) (Pokrovski et al., 2009a)
Au(HS)2– 2.36 (Liu X et al., 2011b) 2.29(1) (Pokrovski et al., 2009b)
¶ Distances of metal (Cu, Au) and ligand (Cl or S)
However, these qualitative studies have a limited practical impact on the understanding of
the mobility of transition metals in hydrothermal fluids. To predict metal transport in
complex natural and engineered environments, we need to know the thermodynamic
properties of the related metal complexes. This is a crucial challenge for MD simulations. In
principle, thermodynamic properties could be derived by observing equilibria among
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
17
aqueous complexes over periods of times much larger than the ligand exchange reaction
rates. Since these rates lies in the ns to "s range for the aqua- and chloride complexes of
transitions metals (Table 11.4 in Burgess 1978; Sharps et al., 1993), such calculations are
currently out of reach of ab initio MD methods. Two techniques were developed in the last
few years, namely, metadynamics (Laio and Parrinello, 2002; Alessandro and Francesco,
2008) and thermodynamic integration (Sprik, 1998; Sprik and Giovanni, 1998), to get
around this problem and to calculate the free energy surface of chemical reactions related to
forming metal complexes (Sherman, 2010). Metadynamics can be used both for
reconstructing the free energy of complexes and for accelerating rare events, eliminating the
need to conduct long simulations (Laio and Parrinello, 2002; Alessandro and Francesco,
2008). Thermodynamic integration is employed to calculate the free energy of reaction with
predefined reaction coordinates (e.g., change of bond distance, angle, coordination number,
etc; Sprik 1998; Sprik and Giovanni, 1998). In geochemistry, Van Sijl et al. (2010)
conducted metadynamics calculation to explore the free energy surface of Ti(IV) aqua
complexes at 300 K and 1000 K by constraining the coordination number of Ti-O, which
indicates a stable 5-fold Ti(IV) aqua complex at room temperature an 6-fold aqua complex
at 1000K. The study of the stability of Ag(I)-Cl complexes (Liu X et al., 2012b)
qualitatively explored the free energy surface of dissociation reactions from 3-fold AgCl32–
to 2-fold AgCl2– complex, indicating a unstable trigonal plannar AgCl3
2– at room
temperature. It could be extremely time-consuming to obtain a converged free energy
surface for calculating thermodynamics properties quantitatively. The mechanism of growth
and dissolution of barite surface was studied by metadynamics and the free energy surface
was obtained by a sequence of umbrella sampling (Stack et al., 2012). With predefined
reaction path, thermodynamic integration with coordination number constraint was
employed to investigate the hydration mechanisms of Zn2+ (Liu X et al., 2011c), Al3+ (Liu X
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
18
et al., 2010a) and Cu2+ (Liu X et al., 2010b). The complexation and free energies of aqua-
and chloride-complexes of U(VI) were studied by Bühl and coworkers (Bühl et al., 2006,
2008; Bühl and Golubnychiy, 2007) using distances constraint thermodynamic integration
by fixing the bond distances of uranium–chloride and uranium–oxygen. The free energy
studies mentioned above show the potential of predicting thermodynamic properties by MD
simulation. These studies show that thermodynamic integration can provide quantitative to
semi-quantitative information about the energetics of aqueous complexes over wide ranges
of P,T and solution compositions. Because the association/dissociation reactions of metal
complexes can be described as the change of metal-ligand distances, in this thesis, we used
distance constraint thermodynamic integration to calculate the free energy of Cu-Cl-HS
(Mei et al. 2013a; Chapter 2) and Zn-Cl (Chapter 4) complexes under hydrothermal
conditions.
1.4 Molecular simulation and experimental data interpretation
In geochemistry, molecular simulations are also used to interpret experimental results,
especially in processing synchrotron-based XAS data. Palmer et al. (1996) developed a
method to generate the EXAFS spectra directly from molecular dynamics trajectories and
applied it to strontium chloride solutions. Classical MD was used to support the
interpretation of first-shell structures of Ni2+-aqua- and -chlorocomplexes in supercritical
fluids from EXAFS data (Wallen et al. 1998; Hoffmann et al. 1999). Pasquarello et al. (2001)
studied the structure of the hydrated Cu(II) complex by neutron diffraction and first-
principles MD, and claimed a fivefold coordination of the first solvation shell of the Cu(II)
aqua ion. Peacock and Sherman (2005) measured the EXAFS spectra of Copper (II)
sorption onto goethite, hematite and lepidocrocite to investigate the coordination structure
of inner-sphere complexes as well as the iron oxide surface, and then interpret the EXAFS
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
19
data by DFT-based quantum mechanical calculation. Similar DFT calculations were also
conducted to optimized geometries of Ni(II) and Mn(II) complexes for simulating XANES
spectra and comparing with experiments (Tian et al., 2012; Appendix A, B of this thesis).
Ab initio MD was also combined with hydrothermal experiments of Ag-Cl complexes
(Pokrovski et al., 2013). With the advances in computational facilities and theoretical
algorithms, MD simulation is increasingly used to explore hydrothermal fluids at the
molecular level (Sherman, 2010). The combination of MD and synchrotron-based XAS
provides an unprecedented detailed view of metal speciation in geochemical systems. The
resulting increase in confidence of the speciation model also improves the confidence in the
quantitative thermodynamic interpretation of the experimental data.
1.5 Research objectives
The aim of this project was to use molecular simulations to obtain molecular-level
understanding of metal mobility in hydrothermal fluids, in particular, to understand the
complexation and stability of gold(I), copper(I) and zinc(II) in chloride and bisulfide rich
fluids over a wide range of temperatures and pressures. More specifically, the main
objectives of the project are:
1. Calculate metal (Cu(I), Au(I), Zn(II)) speciation in hydrothermal chloride- and
bisulfide-rich fluids, and address the significance of these ligands in transporting
these metals in hydrothermal fluids.
2. Test the hypothesis that S3– is a good ligand for Au(I), and predict the nature and
geometry of the most likely complexes to form;
3. Predict the formation constants for Cu(I) and Zn(II) complexes using
thermodynamic integration in MD simulations, and compare them to existing
experimental data;
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
20
4. Study the nature of second-shell complexing for Cu(I) and Au(I) chloride
complexes, and the change of their speciation and hydration as a function of fluid
density in conditions ranging from room-temperature to low density magmatic
hydrothermal vapours;
5. Obtain a better understanding of gold, copper and zinc mobility in hydrothermal
fluids.
1.6 Thesis organization
The main body of this thesis consists of four chapters (chapters 2-5). Chapter 2
demonstrates the ab initio MD study of copper(I) complexation by chloride and bisulfide in
hydrothermal fluids, and assesses the ability of thermodynamic integration to provide
thermodynamic properties for the ligand formation reactions. Chapter 3 describes the
complexation of gold in S3– rich hydrothermal fluids by MD simulation. Chapter 4
investigates the mobility of zinc in chloride-rich fluids via MD, and uses this information to
reinterpret existing solubility experiments and provide self-consistent thermodynamic
properties for Zn(II) chlorocomplexes. Chapter 5 reveals the effect of solution density on
ion association and hydration, and the role of configurational entropy in driving changes in
speciation and complex free energies as a function of P and T. The overall conclusions and
future work perspectives are discussed in Chapter 6.
Some other publications relevant to this thesis are included in the Appendixes. In Appendix
A, QM was applied to optimize the geometry of Mn(II)-Cl and Mn(II)-Br clusters, and
classical MD was conducted to reveal the effect of second shell water in XANES spectra. In
Appendixes B-C, I conducted DFT calculation to optimize the geometry of Ni(II)-Cl and
Zn(II)-Br complexation and applied it to ab initio XANES calculations. Appendixes D-I are
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
21
peer-reviewed conference abstracts that have been presented in international conference as
oral presentation by myself (D, E, F) and my co-supervisors (G, H, I).
1.7 References Alessandro, L. and Francesco, L. G., 2008. Metadynamics: a method to simulate rare events
and reconstruct the free energy in biophysics, chemistry and material science.
Reports on Progress in Physics 71, 126601.
Armellini, F. J. and Tester, J. W., 1993. Solubility of sodium chloride and sulfate in sub-and
supercritical water vapor from 450–550 °C and 100–250 bar. Fluid Phase Equilibria
84, 123-142.
Asthagiri, D., Pratt, L. R., Paulaitis, M. E., and Rempe, S. B., 2004. Hydration structure and
free energy of biomolecularly specific aqueous dications, including Zn2+ and first
transition row metals. Journal of the American Chemical Society 126, 1285-1289.
Bazarkina, E. F., Pokrovski, G. S., Zotov, A. V., and Hazemann, J.-L., 2010. Structure and
stability of cadmium chloride complexes in hydrothermal fluids. Chemical Geology
276, 1-17.
Berendsen, H. J. C., Grigera, J. R., and Straatsma, T. P., 1987. The missing term in effective
pair potentials. The Journal of Physical Chemistry 91, 6269-6271.
Bethke, C. M., 2008. Geochemical and biogeochemical reaction modelling. Cambridge
Univ. Press, Cambridge, UK.
Born, M. and Oppenheimer, R., 1927. Zur quantentheorie der molekeln. Annalen der Physik
389, 457-484 (in German).
Brugger, J., Etschmann, B., Liu, W., Testemale, D., Hazemann, J. L., Emerich, H., van Beek,
W., and Proux, O., 2007. An XAS study of the structure and thermodynamics of
Cu(I) chloride complexes in brines up to high temperature (400 °C, 600 bar).
Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 71, 4920-4941.
Bühl, M. and Golubnychiy, V., 2007. Binding of Pertechnetate to Uranyl(VI) in Aqueous
Solution. A Density Functional Theory Molecular Dynamics Study. ChemInform 38
Bühl, M., Kabrede, H., Diss, R., and Wipff, G., 2006. Effect of Hydration on Coordination
Properties of Uranyl(VI) Complexes. A First-Principles Molecular Dynamics Study.
Journal of the American Chemical Society 128, 6357-6368.
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
22
Bühl, M., Sieffert, N., Golubnychiy, V., and Wipff, G., 2008. Density Functional Theory
Study of Uranium(VI) Aquo Chloro Complexes in Aqueous Solution. The Journal of
Physical Chemistry A 112, 2428-2436.
Burgess, J., 1978. Metal ions in solution. Published by Ellis Horwood Ltd. Chichester and
distributed by John Wiley and Sons, Chichester and New York. 481 pp.
Butterworth, P., Hillier, I. H., Burton, N. A., Vaughan, D. J., Guest, M. F., and Tossell, J. A.,
1992. Calculations of the structures, stabilities, Raman spectra, and NMR spectra of
cadmium halide hydroxide (CdCln(OH2)a2-n, CdBrn(OH2)a
2-n), and zinc chloride
hydroxide (ZnCln(OH2)a2-n) species in aqueous solution. The Journal of Physical
Chemistry 96, 6494-6500.
Car, R. and Parrinello, M., 1985. Unified Approach for Molecular Dynamics and Density-
Functional Theory. Physical Review Letters 55, 2471-2474.
Chen, Y., Fulton, J., and Partenheimer, W., 2005a. A XANES and EXAFS Study of
Hydration and Ion Pairing in Ambient Aqueous MnBr2 Solutions. Journal of
Solution Chemistry 34, 993-1007.
Chen, Y., Fulton, J. L., and Partenheimer, W., 2005b. The Structure of the Homogeneous
Oxidation Catalyst, Mn(II)(Br-1)x, in Supercritical Water:# An X-ray Absorption
Fine-Structure Study. Journal of the American Chemical Society 127, 14085-14093.
Chialvo, A. and Simonson, J., 2003. Aqueous NaCl pair association from liquidlike to
steamlike densities along near-critical isotherms. The Journal of Chemical Physics
118, 7921.
Collins, C. R., Sherman, D. M., and Ragnarsdottir, K. V., 1999. Surface Complexation of
Hg2+ on Goethite: Mechanism from EXAFS Spectroscopy and Density Functional
Calculations. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science 219, 345-350.
Crerar, D. A. and Barnes, H., 1976. Ore solution chemistry; V, Solubilities of chalcopyrite
and chalcocite assemblages in hydrothermal solution at 200 degrees to 350 degrees
C. Economic Geology 71, 772-794.
Crerar, D. A., Susak, N., Borcsik, M., and Schwartz, S., 1978. Solubility of the buffer
assemblage pyrite+ pyrrhotite+ magnetite in NaCl solutions from 200 to 350 °C.
Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 42, 1427-1437.
Crerar, D. A, Wood, S., Brantley, S., and Bocarsly, A., 1985. Chemical controls on
solubility of ore-forming minerals in hydrothermal solutions. Canadian Mineralogist
23, 333-352.
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
23
Cui, S. and Harris, J., 1995. Solubility of sodium chloride in supercritical water: A
molecular dynamics study. The Journal of Physical Chemistry 99, 2900-2906.
D’Angelo, P., Benfatto, M., Della Longa, S., and Pavel, N. V., 2002. Combined XANES
and EXAFS analysis of Co2+, Ni2+, and Zn2+ aqueous solutions. Physical Review B
66, 064209.
Debye, P. and Hückel, E., 1923. The theory of electrolytes. I. Lowering of freezing point
and related phenomena (In German). Physikalische Zeitschrift 24, 185–206.
Demichelis, R., Raiteri, P., Gale, J. D., Quigley, D., and Gebauer, D., 2011. Stable
prenucleation mineral clusters are liquid-like ionic polymers. Nature
communications 2, 590.
Driesner, T., Seward, T. M., and Tironi, I. G., 1998. Molecular dynamics simulation study
of ionic hydration and ion association in dilute and 1 molal aqueous sodium chloride
solutions from ambient to supercritical conditions. Geochimica et Cosmochimica
Acta 62, 3095-3107.
Etschmann, B. E., Liu, W., Testemale, D., Müller, H., Rae, N. A., Proux, O., Hazemann, J.
L., and Brugger, J., 2010. An in situ XAS study of copper(I) transport as
hydrosulfide complexes in hydrothermal solutions (25-592 °C, 180-600 bar):
Speciation and solubility in vapor and liquid phases. Geochimica et Cosmochimica
Acta 74, 4723-4739.
Feller, D. F., Glendening, E. D., and De Jong, W. A., 1999. Structures and Binding
Enthalpies of M+ (H2O)(n) Clusters, M= Cu, Ag, Au. Journal of Chemical Physics
110, 1475-1491.
Fleet, M. E. and Knipe, S. W., 2000. Solubility of Native Gold in H-O-S Fluids at 100–
400 °C and High H2S Content. Journal of Solution Chemistry 29, 1143-1157.
Fritz, J. J., 1981. Representation of the solubility of copper(I) chloride in solutions of
various aqueous chlorides. The Journal of Physical Chemistry 85, 890-894.
Fulton, J. L., Darab, J. G., and Hoffmann, M. M., 2001. X-ray absorption spectroscopy and
imaging of heterogeneous hydrothermal mixtures using a diamond microreactor cell.
Review of Scientific Instruments 72, 2117-2122.
Fulton, J. L., Hoffmann, M. M., and Darab, J. G., 2000a. An X-ray absorption fine structure
study of copper(I) chloride coordination structure in water up to 325 °C. Chemical
Physics Letters 330, 300-308.
Fulton, J. L., Hoffmann, M. M., Darab, J. G., Palmer, B. J., and Stern, E. A., 2000b.
Copper(I) and Copper(II) Coordination Structure under Hydrothermal Conditions at
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
24
325 °C:# An X-ray Absorption Fine Structure and Molecular Dynamics Study. The
Journal of Physical Chemistry A 104, 11651-11663.
Giggenbach, W., 1971. Blue solutions of sulfur in water at elevated temperatures. Inorganic
Chemistry 10, 1306-1308.
Hack, A. C. and Mavrogenes, J. A., 2006. A synthetic fluid inclusion study of copper
solubility in hydrothermal brines from 525 to 725 C and 0.3 to 1.7 GPa. Geochimica
et Cosmochimica Acta 70, 3970-3985.
Harris, D., Loew, G. H., and Komornicki, A., 1997. Structure and Relative Spin-State
Energetics of [Fe(H2O)6]3+: A Comparison of UHF, Møller-Plesset, Nonlocal DFT,
and Semiempircal INDO/S Calculations. The Journal of Physical Chemistry A 101,
3959-3965.
Harris, D. J., Brodholt, J. P., and Sherman, D. M., 2003. Zinc complexation in hydrothermal
chloride brines: Results from ab initio molecular dynamics calculations. The Journal
of Physical Chemistry A 107, 1050-1054.
Harvey, J., 2004. DFT Computation of Relative Spin-State Energetics of Transition Metal
Compounds, Principles and Applications of Density Functional Theory in Inorganic
Chemistry I. Springer Berlin Heidelberg.
Heinrich, C. A. and Seward, T. M., 1990. A spectrophotometric study of aqueous iron(II)
chloride complexing from 25 to 200 °C. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 54,
2207-2221.
Hemley, J. J., Cygan, G. L., Fein, J. B., Robinson, G. R., and D'Angelo, W. M., 1992.
Hydrothermal ore-forming processes in the light of studies in rock-buffered systems;
I Iron-copper-zinc-lead sulfide solubility relations. Economic Geology 87, 1-22.
Hoffmann, M. M., Darab, J. G., Palmer, B. J., and Fulton, J. L., 1999. A transition in the
Ni2+ complex structure from six-to four-coordinate upon formation of ion pair
species in supercritical water: An X-ray absorption fine structure, near-infrared, and
molecular dynamics study. The Journal of Physical Chemistry A 103, 8471-8482.
Janes, R., Moore, E., and Abel, E. W., 2004. Metal-ligand bonding. Royal Society of
Chemistry, Cambridge.
John P, B., 1998. Molecular dynamics simulations of aqueous NaCl solutions at high
pressures and temperatures. Chemical Geology 151, 11-19.
Jorgensen, W. L., 1982. Revised TIPS for simulations of liquid water and aqueous solutions.
The Journal of Chemical Physics 77, 4156.
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
25
Jorgensen, W. L., Chandrasekhar, J., Madura, J. D., Impey, R. W., and Klein, M. L., 1983.
Comparison of simple potential functions for simulating liquid water. The Journal of
Chemical Physics 79, 926.
Klamt, A. and Schuurmann, G., 1993. COSMO: a new approach to dielectric screening in
solvents with explicit expressions for the screening energy and its gradient. Journal
of the Chemical Society, Perkin Transactions 2, 799-805.
Kohn, W. and Sham, L. J., 1965. Self-Consistent Equations Including Exchange and
Correlation Effects. Physical Review 140, A1133-A1138.
Laio, A. and Parrinello, M., 2002. Escaping free-energy minima. Proceedings of the
National Academy of Sciences 99, 12562-12566.
Lee, S., Cummings, P., Simonson, J., and Mesmer, R., 1998. Molecular dynamics
simulation of the limiting conductance of NaCl in supercritical water. Chemical
Physics Letters 293, 289-294.
Lee, C., Yang, W., and Parr, R. G., 1988. Development of the Colle-Salvetti correlation-
energy formula into a functional of the electron density. Physical Review B 37, 785-
789.
Liu, W., Borg, S., Etschmann, B., Mei, Y., and Brugger, J., 2012a. An XAS study of
speciation and thermodynamic properties of aqueous zinc bromide complexes at 25–
150 °C. Chemical Geology 298–299, 57-69.
Liu, W., Borg, S. J., Testemale, D., Etschmann, B., Hazemann, J.-L., and Brugger, J., 2011a.
Speciation and thermodynamic properties for cobalt chloride complexes in
hydrothermal fluids at 35–440 °C and 600 bar: An in-situ XAS study. Geochimica
et Cosmochimica Acta 75, 1227-1248.
Liu, W., Brugger, J., Etschmann, B., Testemale, D., and Hazemann, J. L., 2008. The
solubility of nantokite (CuCl(s)) and Cu speciation in low-density fluids near the
critical isochore: An in-situ XAS study. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 72,
4094-4106.
Liu, W., Brugger, J., McPhail, D. C., and Spiccia, L., 2002. A spectrophotometric study of
aqueous copper(I)-chloride complexes in LiCl solutions between 100 °C and 250 °C.
Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 66, 3615-3633.
Liu, W., Etschmann, B., Foran, G., Shelley, M., and Brugger, J., 2007. Deriving formation
constants for aqueous metal complexes from XANES spectra: Zn2+ and Fe2+ chloride
complexes in hypersaline solutions. American Mineralogist 92, 761-770.
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
26
Liu, W., McPhail, D. C., and Brugger, J., 2001. An experimental study of copper(I)-chloride
and copper(I)-acetate complexing in hydrothermal solutions between 50 °C and
250 °C and vapor-saturated pressure. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 65, 2937-
2948.
Liu, X., Lu, X., Jan Meijer, E., and Wang, R., 2010a. Hydration mechanisms of Cu2+: Tetra-,
penta- or hexa-coordinated? Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics 12, 10801-10804.
Liu, X., Lu, X., Meijer, E. J., Wang, R., and Zhou, H., 2010b. Acid dissociation
mechanisms of Si(OH)4 and Al(H2O)63+ in aqueous solution. Geochimica et
Cosmochimica Acta 74, 510-516.
Liu, X., Lu, X., Wang, R., and Zhou, H., 2012b. Silver speciation in chloride-containing
hydrothermal solutions from first principles molecular dynamics simulations.
Chemical Geology 294–295, 103-112.
Liu, X., Lu, X., Wang, R., Zhou, H., and Xu, S., 2011b. Speciation of gold in
hydrosulphide-rich ore-forming fluids: Insights from first-principles molecular
dynamics simulations. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 75, 185-194.
Loucks, R. R. and Mavrogenes, J. A., 1999. Gold Solubility in Supercritical Hydrothermal
Brines Measured in Synthetic Fluid Inclusions. Science 284, 2159-2163.
Mayanovic, R. A., Anderson, A. J., Bassett, W. A., and Chou, I., 1999. XAFS
measurements on zinc chloride aqueous solutions from ambient to supercritical
conditions using the diamond anvil cell. Journal of Synchrotron Radiation 6, 195-
197.
McKibben, M. A. and Williams, A. E., 1989. Metal speciation and solubility in saline
hydrothermal fluids; an empirical approach based on geothermal brine data.
Economic Geology 84, 1996-2007.
Mei, Y., Sherman, D. M., Liu, W., and Brugger, J., 2013a. Ab initio molecular dynamics
simulation and free energy exploration of copper(I) complexation by chloride and
bisulfide in hydrothermal fluids. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 102, 45-64.
Mei, Y., Sherman, D. M., Liu, W., and Brugger, J., 2013b. Complexation of gold in S3–-rich
hydrothermal fluids: Evidence from ab-initio molecular dynamics simulations.
Chemical Geology 347, 34-42.
Migdisov, A. A., Williams-Jones, A., and Suleimenov, O., 1999. Solubility of chlorargyrite
(AgCl) in water vapor at elevated temperatures and pressures. Geochimica et
Cosmochimica Acta 63, 3817-3827.
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
27
Migliorati, V., Mancini, G., Chillemi, G., Zitolo, A., and D'Angelo, P., 2011. Effect of the
Zn2+ and Hg2+ Ions on the Structure of Liquid Water. The Journal of Physical
Chemistry A 115, 4798-4803.
Mountain, B. W. and Seward, T. M., 1999. The hydrosulphide/sulphide complexes of
copper(I): experimental determination of stoichiometry and stability at 22 °C and
reassessment of high temperature data. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 63, 11-29.
Mountain, B. W. and Seward, T. M., 2003. Hydrosulfide/sulfide complexes of copper(I):
Experimental confirmation of the stoichiometry and stability of Cu(HS)2! to elevated
temperatures. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 67, 3005-3014.
Oelkers, E. H. and Helgeson, H. C., 1993. Multiple ion association in supercritical aqueous
solutions of single electrolytes. Science 261, 888.
Ohtaki, H., Maeda, M., and Ito, S., 1974. X-ray diffraction studies of aqueous solutions of
cadmium perchlorate and sodium tetraiodocadmate. Bulletin of the Chemical Society
of Japan 47, 2217-2221.
Ohtaki, H., Yamaguchi, T., and Maeda, M., 1976. X-ray diffraction studies of the structures
of hydrated divalent transition-metal ions in aqueous solution. Bulletin of the
Chemical Society of Japan 49, 701-708.
Palmer, B. J., Pfund, D. M., and Fulton, J. L., 1996. Direct Modeling of EXAFS Spectra
from Molecular Dynamics Simulations. The Journal of Physical Chemistry 100,
13393-13398.
Pan, P. and Susak, N. J., 1989. Co(II)-chloride and -bromide complexes in aqueous
solutions up to 5 m NaX and 90 °C: Spectrophotometric study and geological
implications. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 53, 327-341.
Parr, R. G. and Yang, W., 1989. Density-functional theory of atoms and molecules. Oxford
university press.
Pasquarello, A., Petri, I., Salmon, P. S., Parisel, O., Car, R., Toth, E., Powell, D. H., Fischer,
H. E., Helm, L., and Merbach, A., 2001. First Solvation Shell of the Cu(II) Aqua Ion:
Evidence for Fivefold Coordination. Science 291, 856-859.
Peacock, C. L. and Sherman, D. M., 2005. Copper(II) sorption onto goethite, hematite, and
lepidocrocite: A surface complexation model based on ab initio molecular
geometries and EXAFS spectroscopy. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 69, 5141-
5142.
Pokrovski, G. S. and Dubrovinsky, L. S., 2011. The S3– ion is stable in geological fluids at
elevated temperatures and pressures. Science 331, 1052-1054.
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
28
Pokrovski, G. S., Roux, J., Ferlat, G., Jonchiere, R., Seitsonen, A. P., Vuilleumier, R., and
Hazemann, J.-L., 2013. Silver in geological fluids from in situ X-ray absorption
spectroscopy and first-principles molecular dynamics. Geochimica et Cosmochimica
Acta 106, 501-523.
Pokrovski, G. S., Tagirov, B. R., Schott, J., Bazarkina, E. F., Hazemann, J.-L., and Proux,
O., 2009a. An in situ X-ray absorption spectroscopy study of gold-chloride
complexing in hydrothermal fluids. Chemical Geology 259, 17-29.
Pokrovski, G. S., Tagirov, B. R., Schott, J., Hazemann, J.-L., and Proux, O., 2009b. A new
view on gold speciation in sulfur-bearing hydrothermal fluids from in situ X-ray
absorption spectroscopy and quantum-chemical modeling. Geochimica et
Cosmochimica Acta 73, 5406-5427.
Pudack, C., Halter, W. E., Heinrich, C. A., and Pettke, T., 2009. Evolution of Magmatic
Vapor to Gold-Rich Epithermal Liquid: The Porphyry to Epithermal Transition at
Nevados de Famatina, Northwest Argentina. Economic Geology 104, 449-477.
Ruaya, J. and Seward, T., 1986. The stability of chlorozinc (II) complexes in hydrothermal
solutions up to 350 C. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 50, 651-661.
Seward, T. M., 1976. The stability of chloride complexes of silver in hydrothermal solutions
up to 350 °C. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 40, 1329-1341.
Seward, T. M., 1973. Thio complexes of gold and the transport of gold in hydrothermal ore
solutions. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 37, 379-399.
Seward, T. M. and Barnes, H. L., 1997. Metal transport by hydrothermal ore fluids. In:
Barnes, H. L. (Ed.), Geochemistry of Hydrothermal Ore Deposits. Wiley, New York.
Seward, T. M., Henderson, C. M. B., Charnock, J. M., and Dobson, B. R., 1996. An X-ray
absorption (EXAFS) spectroscopic study of aquated Ag+ in hydrothermal solutions
to 350 °C. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 60, 2273-2282.
Sharps, J. A., Brown Jr, G. E., and Stebbins, J. F., 1993. Kinetics and mechanism of ligand
exchange of Au (III), Zn(II), and Cd(II) chlorides in aqueous solution: An NMR
study from 28–98°C. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 57, 721-731.
Sherman, D. M., 2001. Quantum Chemistry and Classical Simulations of Metal Complexes
in Aqueous Solutions. Reviews in Mineralogy and Geochemistry 42, 273-317.
Sherman, D. M., 2007. Complexation of Cu+ in Hydrothermal NaCl Brines: Ab initio
molecular dynamics and energetics. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 71, 714-722.
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
29
Sherman, D. M. and Collings, M. D., 2002. Ion association in concentrated NaCl brines
from ambient to supercritical conditions: results from classical molecular dynamics
simulations. Geochemical Transactions 3, 102-107.
Smith, D. E. and Dang, L. X., 1994. Computer simulations of NaCl association in
polarizable water. The Journal of Chemical Physics 100, 3757-3766.
Sprik, M., 1998. Coordination numbers as reaction coordinates in constrained molecular
dynamics. Faraday Discussions 110, 437-445.
Sprik, M. C., Giovanni, 1998. Free energy from constrained molecular dynamics. Journal of
Chemical Physics 109, 7737-7744.
Stack, A. G., Raiteri, P., and Gale, J. D., 2012. Accurate Rates of the Complex Mechanisms
for Growth and Dissolution of Minerals Using a Combination of Rare-Event
Theories. Journal of the American Chemical Society 134, 11-14.
Suleimenov, O. M., 2004. Simple, compact, flow-through, high temperature high pressure
cell for UV-Vis spectrophotometry. Review of Scientific Instruments 75, 3363-3364.
Suleimenov, O. M. and Seward, T. M., 2000. Spectrophotometric measurements of metal
complex formation at high temperatures: the stability of Mn (II) chloride species.
Chemical Geology 167, 177-192.
Suleimenov, O. M. and Seward, T. M., 1997. A spectrophotometric study of hydrogen
sulphide ionisation in aqueous solutions to 350 °C. Geochimica et Cosmochimica
Acta 61, 5187-5198.
Tabata, M. and Ozutsumi, K., 1992. Equilibrium and EXAFS Studies of Mercury (II)
Porphyrin in Aqueous Solution. Bulletin of the Chemical Society of Japan 65, 1438-
1444.
Testemale, D., Argoud, R., Geaymond, O., and Hazemann, J. L., 2005. High pressure/high
temperature cell for X-ray absorption and scattering techniques. Review of Scientific
Instruments 76, 043905.
Testemale, D., Brugger, J., Liu, W., Etschmann, B., and Hazemann, J. L., 2009. In-situ X-
ray absorption study of Iron (II) speciation in brines up to supercritical conditions.
Chemical Geology 264, 295-310.
Tian, Y., Etschmann, B., Liu, W., Borg, S., Mei, Y., Testemale, D., O'Neill, B., Rae, N.,
Sherman, D. M., Ngothai, Y., Johannessen, B., Glover, C., and Brugger, J., 2012.
Speciation of nickel (II) chloride complexes in hydrothermal fluids: In situ XAS
study. Chemical Geology 334, 345-363.
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
30
Tossell, J. A., 1991. Calculations of the structures, stabilities, and Raman and zinc NMR
spectra of zinc aqua chloride ZnCln(OH2)a2-n species in aqueous solution. The
Journal of Physical Chemistry 95, 366-371.
Tossell, J. A., 1994. The speciation of antimony in sulfidic solutions: a theoretical study.
Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 58, 5093-5104.
Tossell, J. A., 2012. Calculation of the properties of the S3! radical anion and its complexes
with Cu+ in aqueous solution. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 95, 79-92.
Tossell, J. A. and Vaughan, D. J., 1993. Bisulfide complexes of zinc and cadmium in
aqueous solution: Calculation of structure, stability, vibrational, and NMR spectra,
and of speciation on sulfide mineral surfaces. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 57,
1935-1945.
Thomas, L. H., 1927. The calculation of atomic fields. Mathematical Proceedings of the
Cambridge Philosophical Society 23, 542-548.
Ulmer, G. C. and Barnes, H. L., 1987. Hydrothermal experimental techniques. John Wiley
and Sons, New York.
Van Sijl, J., Allan, N. L., Davies, G. R., and van Westrenen, W., 2010. Titanium in
subduction zone fluids: First insights from ab initio molecular metadynamics
simulations. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 74, 2797-2810.
Verlet, L., 1967. Computer "experiments" on classical fluids. I. Thermodynamical
properties of Lennard-Jones molecules. Physical Review 159, 98.
Wallen, S. L., Palmer, B. J., and Fulton, J. L., 1998. The ion pairing and hydration structure
of Ni2+ in supercritical water at 425 °C determined by X-ray absorption fine
structure and molecular dynamics studies. The Journal of Chemical Physics 108,
4039-4046.
Williams-Jones, A. E., Bowell, R. J., and Migdisov, A. A., 2009. Gold in Solution. Elements
5, 281-287.
Williams-Jones, A. E. and Heinrich, C. A., 2005. 100th Anniversary Special Paper: Vapor
Transport of Metals and the Formation of Magmatic-Hydrothermal Ore Deposits.
Economic Geology 100, 1287-1312.
Wood, S. and Samson, I., 1998. Solubility of ore minerals and complexation of ore metals in
hydrothermal solutions. Reviews in Economic Geology 10, 33-80.
Xiao, Z., Gammons, C. H., and Williams-Jones, A. E., 1998. Experimental study of copper(I)
chloride complexing in hydrothermal solutions at 40 to 300 °C and saturated water
vapor pressure. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 62, 2949-2964.
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
31
Zeng, Y., Wang, F., and Ai, R., 1997. Solubility of gold in the SiO2-NaCl-H2O system at
300 °C and 50 MPa. Science in China Series D: Earth Sciences 40, 485-490.
Zezin, D. Y., Migdisov, A. A., and Williams-Jones, A. E., 2007. The solubility of gold in
hydrogen sulfide gas: An experimental study. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 71,
3070-3081.
Zezin, D. Y., Migdisov, A. A., and Williams-Jones, A. E., 2011. The solubility of gold in
H2O–H2S vapour at elevated temperature and pressure. Geochimica et
Cosmochimica Acta 75, 5140-5153.
CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
32
33
_____________________________________
Chapter 2 Ab initio Molecular Dynamics Simulation and Free Energy
Exploration of Copper (I) Complexation by Chloride and
Bisulfide in Hydrothermal Fluids
Yuan Mei1, 2, 3, David M Sherman2, Weihua Liu3 and Joël Brugger1,4,*
1 School of Earth and Environmental Sciences, The University of Adelaide, Adelaide, SA 5005,
Australia
2 Department of Earth Sciences, University of Bristol, Bristol, BS8 1RJ, UK
3 CSIRO Earth Science and Resource Engineering, Clayton, VIC 3168, Australia
4 South Australian Museum, North Terrace, SA 5000, Australia
Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 2013, 102, 45-64.
(Copyright of this paper belongs to Elsevier Ltd.)
_____________________________________
34
!"#"$%$&"'()'*+",(-.,/0' 1/"2$'()'3#0$-' *4' /&/"/('%(2$5+2#-'67&#%/5.'./%+2#"/(&'#&6')-$$'$&$-87'$902(-#"/(&'()'5(00$-:;<'5(%02$9#"/(&'
47'5,2(-/6$'#&6'4/.+2)/6$'/&',76-(",$-%#2')2+/6.'
3+42/5#"/(&'!"#"+.''
'
3+42/5#"/(&'=$"#/2.'>$/?'@A?'!,$-%#&?'=A'>A?'B/+?'CA?'#&6'D-+88$-?'EA?'FGHIA'*4'/&/"/('%(2$5+2#-'67&#%/5.'
./%+2#"/(&'#&6')-$$'$&$-87'$902(-#"/(&'()'5(00$-:;<'5(%02$9#"/(&'47'5,2(-/6$'#&6'4/.+2)/6$'/&'
,76-(",$-%#2')2+/6.A'J$(5,/%/5#'$"'K(.%(5,/%/5#'*5"#'HGF?'LMNOLA'
'
!"#$%&'(%)#&*+"#*%),'D7' ./8&/&8' ",$' !"#"$%$&"' ()' *+",(-.,/0?' $#5,' #+",(-' 5$-"/)/$.' ",#"' ",$/-' ."#"$6' 5(&"-/4+"/(&' "(' ",$' 0+42/5#"/(&' /.' #55+-#"$' #&6' ",#"'0$-%/../(&'/.'8-#&"$6')(-'",$'0+42/5#"/(&'"('4$'/&52+6$6'/&'",$'5#&6/6#"$P.'",$./.A'
Q#%$'()'K(N*+",(-' @+#&'>$/'
K(&"-/4+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' =$R$2(0$6' 5(%0+"#"/(' %$",(6.?' 5(&6+5"$6' #22' %(2$5+2#-' ./%+2#"/(&.A' D+/2"' 8$(5,$%/5#2'%(6$2'#&6'S-("$'%#&+.5-/0"A'
!/8&#"+-$'
'
=#"$' FLNE+2NHI'
'
Q#%$'()'K(N*+",(-' =#R/6'>'!,$-%#&'
K(&"-/4+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$6'S/",'6$R$2(0/&8'5(%0+"#"/('%$",(6.'#&6'%#&+.5-/0"'$R#2+#"/(&A'
'
!/8&#"+-$'
'
=#"$' FLNE+2NHI'
'
Q#%$'()'K(N*+",(-' C$/,+#'B/+'
K(&"-/4+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$6'S/",'4+/26/&8'8$(5,$%/5#2'%(6$2'#&6'S-("$'0#-"'()'",$'%#&+.5-/0"A'
'
!/8&#"+-$'
'
=#"$' FLNE+2NHI'
'
Q#%$'()'K(N*+",(-' E(T2'D-+88$-'
'K(&"-/4+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$6'S/",'4+/26/&8'8$(5,$%/5#2'%(6$2'#&6'%#&+.5-/0"'$R#2+#"/(&A'*5"/&8'#.'5(--$.0(&6/&8'#+",(-A'
!/8&#"+-$'
'
=#"$' FLNE+2NHI'
'
CHAPTER 2. Cu-Cl-HS COMPLEXATION
35
A Mei, Y., Sherman, D.M., Liu, W. & Brugger, J. (2012) Ab initio molecular dynamics simulation and free energy exploration of copper(I) complexation by chloride and bisulfide in hydrothermal fluids. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, v. 102, pp. 45-64
NOTE:
This publication is included on pages 35-54 in the print copy of the thesis held in the University of Adelaide Library.
It is also available online to authorised users at:
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.gca.2012.10.027
55
_____________________________________
Chapter 3
Complexation of Gold in S3--Rich Hydrothermal Fluids:
Evidence from ab-initio Molecular Dynamics Simulations
Yuan Mei1, 2,*, David M. Sherman3, Weihua Liu2 and Joël Brugger1,4,*
1Tectonics, Resources and Exploration (TRaX), School of Earth and Environmental Sciences, The
University of Adelaide, Adelaide, SA 5005, Australia
2CSIRO Earth Science and Resource Engineering, Clayton, VIC 3168, Australia
3School of Earth Sciences, University of Bristol, Bristol, BS8 1RJ, UK
4South Australian Museum, North Terrace, SA 5000, Australia
Chemical Geology, 2013, 347, 34-42.
(Copyright of this paper belongs to Elsevier Ltd.)
_____________________________________
56
!"#"$%$&"'()'*+",(-.,/0' 1/"2$'()'3#0$-' 4(%02$5#"/(&' ()' 6(27' /&' !89:-/;,' ,<7-(",$-%#2' )2+/7.=' >?/7$&;$' )-(%' #@:/&/"/(' %(2$;+2#-'
7<&#%/;.'./%+2#"/(&.'
3+@2/;#"/(&'!"#"+.''
'
3+@2/;#"/(&'A$"#/2.' B$/C' DEC' !,$-%#&C' AE' BEC' F/+C' GEC' #&7' H-+66$-C' IEC' JKL8E' 4(%02$5#"/(&' ()' 6(27' /&' !89:-/;,',<7-(",$-%#2')2+/7.='>?/7$&;$')-(%'#@:/&/"/('%(2$;+2#-'7<&#%/;.'./%+2#"/(&.E'4,$%/;#2'M$(2(6<'8NOC'8N:NJE''
!"#$%&'(%)#&*+"#*%),'H<' ./6&/&6' ",$' !"#"$%$&"' ()' *+",(-.,/0C' $#;,' #+",(-' ;$-"/)/$.' ",#"' ",$/-' ."#"$7' ;(&"-/@+"/(&' "(' ",$' 0+@2/;#"/(&' /.' #;;+-#"$' #&7' ",#"'0$-%/../(&'/.'6-#&"$7')(-'",$'0+@2/;#"/(&'"('@$'/&;2+7$7'/&'",$';#&7/7#"$P.'",$./.E'
Q#%$'()'4(:*+",(-' D+#&'B$/'
4(&"-/@+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' A$?$2(0$7' ;(%0+"#"/(' %$",(7.C' ;(&7+;"$7' #22' %(2$;+2#-' ./%+2#"/(&.E' H+/2"' 6$(;,$%/;#2'%(7$2'#&7'R-("$'%#&+.;-/0"E'*;"/&6'#.';(--$.0(&7/&6'#+",(-E'
!/6&#"+-$'
'
A#"$' JN:I+2:L8'
'
Q#%$'()'4(:*+",(-' A#?/7'B'!,$-%#&'
4(&"-/@+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$7'R/",'7$?$2(0/&6';(%0+"#"/('%$",(7.'#&7'%#&+.;-/0"'$?#2+#"/(&E'
'
!/6&#"+-$'
'
A#"$' JN:I+2:L8'
'
Q#%$'()'4(:*+",(-' G$/,+#'F/+'
4(&"-/@+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$7'R/",'@+/27/&6'6$(;,$%/;#2'%(7$2'#&7'%#&+.;-/0"'$?#2+#"/(&E'
'
!/6&#"+-$'
'
A#"$' JN:I+2:L8'
'
Q#%$'()'4(:*+",(-' I(S2'H-+66$-'
'4(&"-/@+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$7'R/",'@+/27/&6'6$(;,$%/;#2'%(7$2'#&7'%#&+.;-/0"'$?#2+#"/(&E'*;"/&6'#.';(--$.0(&7/&6'#+",(-E'
!/6&#"+-$'
'
A#"$' JN:I+2:L8'
'
CHAPTER 3. Au-S3 COMPLEXATION
57
,
NOTE:
This publication is included on pages 57-65 in the print copy of the thesis held in the University of Adelaide Library.
It is also available online to authorised users at:
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.chemgeo.2013.03.019
A Mei, Y., Sherman, D.M., Liu, W. & Brugger, J. (2013) Complexation of gold in S3-rich hydrothermal fluids: evidence from ab-initio molecular dynamics simulations. Chemical Geology, v. 347, pp. 34-42
CHAPTER 3. Au-S3 COMPLEXATION
66
67
_____________________________________
Chapter 4
Zinc mobility in chloride-rich hydrothermal fluids: insights
from ab initio molecular dynamics simulation
Yuan Mei1, 2,*, Weihua Liu2, David M. Sherman3 and Joël Brugger1,4,*
1Tectonics, Resources and Exploration (TRaX), School of Earth and Environmental Sciences, The
University of Adelaide, Adelaide, SA 5005, Australia
2CSIRO Earth Science and Resource Engineering, Clayton, VIC 3168, Australia
3School of Earth Sciences, University of Bristol, Bristol, BS8 1RJ, UK
4South Australian Museum, North Terrace, SA 5000, Australia
_____________________________________
68
!"#"$%$&"'()'*+",(-.,/0' 1/"2$'()'3#0$-' 4/&5' %(6/2/"7' /&' 5,2(-/8$9-/5,' ,78-(",$-%#2' )2+/8.:' /&./;,".' )-(%' #6' /&/"/(' %(2$5+2#-' 87&#%/5.'
./%+2#"/(&'
3+62/5#"/(&'!"#"+.''
'
3+62/5#"/(&'<$"#/2.' =$/>'?@>' A/+>'B@>'!,$-%#&>'<@'=@>' #&8'C-+;;$->' D@>' 4/&5'%(6/2/"7' /&' 5,2(-/8$9-/5,',78-(",$-%#2')2+/8.:' /&./;,".' )-(%' #6' /&/"/(' %(2$5+2#-' 87&#%/5.' ./%+2#"/(&>' 3-$0#-/&;' )(-' .+6%/../(&' "(' #';$(5,$%/."-7'E(+-@''
'
!"#$%&'(%)#&*+"#*%),'C7' ./;&/&;' ",$' !"#"$%$&"' ()' *+",(-.,/0>' $#5,' #+",(-' 5$-"/)/$.' ",#"' ",$/-' ."#"$8' 5(&"-/6+"/(&' "(' ",$' 0+62/5#"/(&' /.' #55+-#"$' #&8' ",#"'0$-%/../(&'/.';-#&"$8')(-'",$'0+62/5#"/(&'"('6$'/&52+8$8'/&'",$'5#&8/8#"$F.'",$./.@'
G#%$'()'H(9*+",(-' ?+#&'=$/'
H(&"-/6+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' <$I$2(0$8' 5(%0+"#"/(' %$",(8.>' 5(&8+5"$8' #22' %(2$5+2#-' ./%+2#"/(&.@' C+/2"' ;$(5,$%/5#2'%(8$2'#&8'J-("$'%#&+.5-/0"@'
!/;&#"+-$'
'
<#"$' KL9D+29MN'
'
G#%$'()'H(9*+",(-' B$/,+#'A/+'
H(&"-/6+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' O$9)/""$8' $P0$-/%$&"#2' 8#"#>' #../."$8' J/",' 6+/28/&;' ;$(5,$%/5#2' %(8$2' #&8' J-("$' 0#-"' ()' ",$'%#&+.5-/0"@''
!/;&#"+-$'
'
<#"$' KL9D+29MN'
'
G#%$'()'H(9*+",(-' <#I/8'='!,$-%#&'
H(&"-/6+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$8'J/",'8$I$2(0/&;'5(%0+"#"/('%$",(8.'#&8'%#&+.5-/0"'$I#2+#"/(&@'
'
!/;&#"+-$'
'
<#"$' KL9D+29MN'
'
G#%$'()'H(9*+",(-' D(Q2'C-+;;$-'
'H(&"-/6+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' O$9)/""$8' $P0$-/%$&"#2' 8#"#>' #../."$8' J/",' 6+/28/&;' ;$(5,$%/5#2' %(8$2' #&8' %#&+.5-/0"'$I#2+#"/(&@'
!/;&#"+-$'
'
<#"$' KL9D+29MN'
'
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
69
Zinc mobility in chloride-rich hydrothermal fluids:
insights from ab initio molecular dynamics simulation
Yuan Mei1,2, Weihua Liu2*, David M Sherman3, Joël Brugger1,4*
1 Tectonics, Resources and Exploration (TRaX), School of Earth and Environmental
Sciences, The University of Adelaide, Adelaide, SA 5005, Australia
2 CSIRO Earth Science and Resource Engineering, Clayton, VIC 3168, Australia
3 Department of Earth Sciences, University of Bristol, Bristol, BS8 1RJ, UK
4 South Australian Museum, North Terrace, SA 5000, Australia
*Corresponding authors: [email protected], [email protected]
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
70
4.0 Abstract
The speciation and thermodynamic properties of metal complexes in hydrothermal
solutions plays a key role in controlling element mobility and mineral solubility in natural
and engineered systems. Ab initio molecular dynamics simulations were conducted to
investigate the stoichiometry, speciation and thermodynamic properties of Zn(II) chloride
complexes from ambient to hydrothermal-magmatic conditions up to 600 °C, 2 kbar. MD
simulations gave an octahedral geometry for the Zn(II)-aqua complexes (Zn(H2O)62+) at
25 °C, 1 bar. In contrast, tetrahedral complexes (ZnCln(H2O)4-n2-n; n=1-4) formed when
chloride bonded to Zn(II). Dehydration of the [ZnCl3–] complex was also observed with
increasing temperature, resulting in the trigonal planar ZnCl3– complexes becoming more
important at 600 °C. As Zn(II) is a small ion with a high charge, the ligand exchange rate
(!s) of Zn(II)-Cl is far beyond the time scale we can simulate in MD (ps); metastable
species may persist for lifetimes beyond the simulation time. Therefore, thermodynamic
integration is necessary to evaluate the relative stabilities of different Zn(II)-Cl complexes.
However, thermodynamic integration based on constraint (Zn-Cl bond distances) MD
simulations enable us to calculate energetic properties and the free energy of binding
between Zn(II) and Cl–.
The properties for the formation of Zn(II)-Cl complexes predicted at 200, 350 and
600 °C via ab initio thermodynamic integration show the same trends compared to those
obtained via the refitting of existing experimental data. The predicted stability constants
(log K) for ZnCl2 and [ZnCl3–] at 350 °C are in excellent agreement with refitted data
(within one log unit), which shows the potential of MD simulation in studying metal
complexation in hydrothermal conditions. The experimental data and the ab initio
thermodynamic properties both confirm the stability of the high order ZnCl42- complex even
at T > 400 °C, and the increase stability of [ZnCl3-] at T 600 °C.
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
71
4.1 Introduction
4.1.1 Metal transport in hydrothermal fluids and aims of this study
Most of the world’s resources of transition metals such as Zn, Pb, Cu, Au, Ag, Co or Fe
come from hydrothermal ore deposits. The speciation of metal complexes in hydrothermal
brines plays a key role in controlling metal mobility and mineral solubility in natural and
man-made hydrothermal environments. Chlorine is one of the main elements involved in the
complexing of metals in hydrothermal systems; therefore, understanding metal speciation in
Cl-bearing hydrothermal fluids is required for modeling metal transport in natural
hydrothermal fluids (Seward and Barnes, 1997; Brugger et al. 2010).
Experimental measurements of metal speciation in hydrothermal fluids is a major challenge,
however, and semi-empirical equations of state (e.g., the HKF[1] model, Tanger and
Helgeson, 1988) are extensively used to estimate thermodynamic properties of aqueous
complexes over wide P,T ranges. These methods allow to extrapolate experimental data
collected over a limited P,T range.
In recent years, computational chemistry approaches such as molecular dynamics (MD)
simulation are playing more significant roles in studying metal complexation in
hydrothermal fluids. MD simulations help to understand speciation and support
interpretation of experimental data qualitatively (Sherman, 2010). Taking advantage of the
development of high performance computing facilities, ab initio (or first principles) MD
simulations based on density functional theory (DFT) are coming of age in studying metal
speciation and thermodynamic properties of hydrothermal fluids. In the last few years, ab
initio MD has been employed to predict the speciation and thermodynamic properties of
transition metals complexes with different ligands (e.g., Zn(II)-Cl (Harris et al., 2003),
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
72
Cu(I)-Cl (Sherman, 2007), Au(I)-HS (Liu X et al., 2011), Ag(I)-Cl (Liu X et al., 2012;
Pokrovski et al., 2013), Cu-HS-Cl!(Mei et al., 2013a), Au(I)-HS/OH/S3 (Mei et al., 2013b),
which demonstrates the potential of ab initio MD in exploring metal behavior in
hydrothermal fluids.
MD simulations can provide quantitative thermodynamic properties through methods such
as metadynamics (Laio and Parrinello, 2002) or thermodynamic integration (Sprik 1998;
Sprik and Giovanni, 1998). Recently, Mei et al. (2013a) demonstrated that thermodynamic
integration can be used to provide accurate predictions of Cu(I) transport in chloride-
hydrosulfide solutions.
In this study, we use ab initio molecular dynamics simulations to improve our
understanding of Zn(II) transport in chloride brines up to magmatic hydrothermal conditions
(to 600 °C, 2 kbar). Zn(II) was chosen because a number of experimental studies show
significant discrepancies in the predicted speciation at elevated temperature. In addition,
MD simulations are particularly well suited for studying Zn(II) complexes as the lower
computing costs were requried because of its well-defined electronic, which makes it
amendable to computation intensive techniques such as thermodynamic integration.
Specifically, this study aims to 1) understand the nature and stoichiometry of Zn(II)-Cl
complexes, and in particular explore the stability of the high order ZnCl42– complex at high
temperature; 2) calculate the Gibbs free energies of reactions for the formations of different
Zn(II)-Cl complexes; 3) provide new values of thermodynamic properties for the simulation
of Zn(II) transport that are consistent with existing experimental data as well as the results
from the MD simulations.
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
73
4.1.2 Experimental studies of Zn(II)-chloride speciation
Several experimental studies have provided thermodynamic properties for Zn(II)-Cl
complexes at high temperature since the 1980s (e.g., Ruaya and Seward, 1986; Bourcier and
Barnes, 1987; Wesolowski et al., 1998). Ruaya and Seward (1986) measured the solubility
of AgCl(s) in aqueous Zn(II)-HCl solutions from 100-300 °C at water vapor-saturated
pressure, and provided formation constants for Zn-Cl species based on the decreased AgCl
solubility due to complexing between Zn and chloride when HCl (0.3 - 3.5 m) was added to
0.1 m Zn solutions. Therefore their data are dependent on the reliability of the properties of
Ag–Cl complexes, which have been improved in the past decades (Zotov et al., 1995;
Pokrovski et al., 2013). Bourcier and Barnes (1987) measured solubility of zincite (ZnO;
200-350 °C) and smithsonite (ZnCO3; 100 and 150 °C) in 0-5 m NaCl solutions where pH
was buffered by fixing pCO2(g). Wesolowski et al. (1998) also measured the solubility of
zincite in acidic chloride solutions and provided the formation constants for ZnCl+ and
ZnCl2(aq) at 200 °C. These three studies have similar values for the formation of ZnCl2(aq),
however their log K values differ by more than one log unit for the formation of ZnCl+,
ZnCl3– and ZnCl4
2–. Figure 4.1 shows the changes of Zn(II)-Cl speciation as a function of
temperature and Cl– concentration calculated from different sources. Ruaya and Seward
(1986)’s study (Fig. 4.1a) and the SUPCRT database (Fig. 4.1c, Johnson et al., 1992)
indicate predominant ZnCl42– over a wide range of temperature in Cl– rich fluids. In contrast,
Bourcier and Barnes (1987) (Fig. 4.1b) suggested that ZnCl42– is a minor species above
100 °C, with ZnCl3– being the predominant species in high-temperature brines.
This dichotomy is also reflected by spectroscopic studies. Several in-situ Raman (Buback,
1983) and XAS (Anderson et al., 1998; Mayanovic et al., 1999; Bassett et al., 2000) studies
suggest that ZnCl42– predominates in highly saline fluids at high temperature. For example,
the diamond anvil cell EXAFS study of Mayanovic et al. (1999) concluded that ZnCl42– is
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
74
the predominant complex in a 1 m ZnC12/6m NaCl solution at 800 MPa from 25 to 660 °C,
while ZnC12(H2O)2(aq) was predominant in a 2 m ZnC12 solution over the same T range.
Similarly, XAS studies of natural hypersaline (36 wt% NaCl equiv) fluid inclusions
indicated that the dominant complex was tetrahedral ZnCl42– at temperatures up to 430 °C
(Anderson et al., 1998). Liu W et al. (2012a) also confirmed the stability of the ZnBr42–
complex up to 150 °C. In contrast, a recent XAS study of Cd-chloride complexation (20-
450 °C, 600 bar) by Bazarkina et al. (2010) found no evidence for the stability of CdCl42– at
high temperature. Consequently, they doubt that ZnCl42– exists at elevated temperature,
pointing to the difficulty of distinguishing between the O and Cl ligands via XAS for first-
row transition metals.
Figure 4.1 Comparison of Zn(II)-Cl speciation in chloride solutions as function of
temperature and Cl– concentration from (a) Ruaya and Seward (1986), (b) Bourcier and
Barnes (1987) and (c) SUPCRT database (Johnson et al., 1992).
4.1.3 Computational chemistry studies of Zn(II)-Cl speciation
A number of quantum mechanical studies have investigated the nature, geometry, and
qualitative relative stabilities of ZnCln(H2O)a2-n complexes in aqueous solution. Based on
static calculations, Tossell (1991) showed ZnCl42– to be tetrahedral with bond distances of
2.31 Å, compared with the value of 2.30 Å by X-Ray diffraction study of aqueous Zn-Cl
solution (Kruh and Standley, 1962). The classical MD study of Zn-Cl (Harris et al., 2001)
!" !#$% !# !$% & $% #
%&
#&&
#%&
"&&
"%&
'&&
()*+,+-(.
/011
/0-(1/0-("2,34
/0-('.
/0-(5..
!" !#$% !# !$% & $% #
%&
#&&
#%&
"&&
"%&
'&&
()*+,+-(.
/011
/0-(1
/0-("2,34
/0-(5..
SUPCRTBourcierRuaya
!" !#$% !# !$% & $% #&
%&
#&&
#%&
"&&
"%&
'&&
()*+,+-(.
6+27-4
/011
/0-(1
/0-("2,34
/0-('.
/0-(5..
(a) (b) (c)
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
75
suggested the existence of both ZnCl3(H2O)– (predominant) and ZnCl42– at 600 °C and
2k bar. Harris et al. (2003) investigated the speciation and geometries of Zn(II)-Cl
complexes at 25 and 300 °C using ab initio MD simulation, and demonstrated stable
octahedral [ZnCln(H2O)6-n]2-n (n=1,2) complexes at low temperature, and tetrahedral
[ZnCln(H2O)4-n]2-n (n=3,4) complexes in concentrated Cl– brines (up to 7.4 m Cl–) over the
temperature range of 25-300 °C. A recent MD study has revised the calculations, and
proposed that ZnCl42– exists in 3 m NaCl at 625 °C and 15 kbar (Sherman, 2010). However,
due to the limitation of computing capacity, the simulations were only conducted for around
one picosecond, too short to reach the equilibrium state, as the ligand exchange rate for
Zn(II)-Cl are in the magnitude of ~300 µs at 25 °C (Sharps et al., 1993). The exchange rate
for Zn(II)-H2O is faster than Zn(II)-Cl (~30 ns, Sharps et al., 1993), but the magnitude is
still outside the computational capabilities for ab initio MD. To overcome this limitation,
Liu X et al. (2011) used thermodynamic integration with a coordination number constraint
to investigate the hydration mechanism of Zn2+. The free energy profile of the aqua-zinc(II)
complexes indicates the change of coordination number from 6 at room temperature to 4-5
at 620-1000 K. In natural fluids, Zn(II) concentrations correlate with chlorinities (Yardley
2005), and chloride complexes are expected to be the main form of Zn(II) in many ore-
forming fluids. A central aim of this study is to use thermodynamic integration to estimate
the properties of Zn(II)-Cl complexes over a wide range of P,T conditions.
4.2 Methodology
4.2.1 Ab initio molecular dynamics simulation
In this study, ab initio MD simulations were performed by using the Car-Parrinello (CP)
molecular dynamics code CPMD (Car and Parrinello, 1985). Car-Parrinello molecular
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
76
dynamics simulations implement density functional theory using a plane-wave basis set and
pseudo-potentials for the core electrons plus the nucleus. The PBE exchange-correlation
functional (Perdew et al., 1996) was employed with a cutoff of gradient correction 5$10-5.
Lin et al. (2012) showed that the energy profiles for liquid water calculated by PBE agree
very well with higher-level ab initio calculations (MP2, CCSD). Plane-wave cutoffs of
25 Ry (340.14 eV) were used together with Vanderbilt ultrasoft pseudo-potentials in CPMD
package generated using the valence electron configuration 3d104s2 for Zn (Laasonen et al.,
1993). Molecular dynamics simulations were conducted in the NVT ensemble (Sherman,
2007). A time-step of 3 a.u. (0.073 fs) was used to stabilize the simulations. Temperatures
were controlled by the Nosé thermostat for both the ions and electrons. The target fictitious
kinetic energies (keyword EKINC in CPMD code) were obtained by taking the converged
value of a 10,000-steps’ simulation with no defined Nosé thermostat for electrons. Fictitious
electron mass of 400 a.u. (3.644$10–28 kg) was used to obtain convergence of the energy of
the total CP-Hamiltonians.
The initial atomic configurations of each simulation were generated by classical MD using
the SPC/E potential for water (Berendsen et al., 1987; Smith and Dang, 1994) and
approximate pair potentials derived from finite cluster calculations for Zn-O and Zn-Cl
(Harris et al., 2001). As listed in Table 4.1, MD simulations No. 1-4 were conducted with
1 Zn2+, 2 Na+, 4 Cl– and 55 H2O in the simulation box corresponding to the fluids of 4 molar
Cl–. To investigate the stability of Zn(II)-Cl complexes with different number of chloride
ligands, five simulations were performed at each T-P condition with the initial
configurations of ZnCln2-n (n = 0, 1, 2, 3, 4). Simulation 5 was conducted with 10 Cl– and
initial configuration of ZnCl3(H2O)– and ZnCl42– to test the stability of tetrahedral ZnCl4
2–
complex in chloride rich fluids.
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
77
Table 4.1 Solution composition, temperature, pressure and density of Zn(II)-Cl simulations
Job No. Solution composition T
(˚C) P
(bar) Box size
(Å) Density (g/cm3)
1 1 Zn, 2 Na, 4 Cl, 55 H2O 25 1 12.193 1.14 2 1 Zn, 2 Na, 4 Cl, 55 H2O 200 14 12.658 1.02 3 1 Zn, 2 Na, 4 Cl, 55 H2O 350 500 13.235 0.89 4 1 Zn, 2 Na, 4 Cl, 55 H2O 600 2000 13.848 0.78 5 1 Zn, 8 Na, 10 Cl, 55 H2O 600 2000 14.040 0.96
Periodic boundary conditions were used to eliminate surface effects. The computing costs of
ab initio simulations were discussed in Mei et al. (2013a); consequently, in this study,
simulation boxes with 172-184 atoms were chosen to provide manageable computation
times while enabling the simulation of realistic solution compositions. MD simulations were
performed from ambient to hydrothermal-magmatic conditions (Table 4.1). The fluid
densities were chosen to correspond to the equation of state of NaCl fluids at the same ionic
strength at the pressure and temperature of interest (Driesner, 2007; Driesner and Heinrich,
2007). All simulations were run for more than 10 picoseconds. To obtain the time average
of the geometric and stoichiometric information, radial distribution functions (RDF) of Zn-
Cl and Zn-O pairs and their integrals (reflecting the time averaged coordination number)
were calculated by using VMD (Humphrey et al, 1996).
4.2.2 Ab initio thermodynamic integration
Ab initio MD simulations gave qualitative information about the relative stability of some
species. However, since the ligand exchanges (timeframe of "s for Zn-Cl and ns for Zn-H2O)
cannot be observed during the short MD simulation (e.g., less than 10 ps), the distribution of
species with close energies cannot be retrieved from these calculations. To estimate the
stability of Zn(II)-Cl complexes quantitatively, thermodynamic integration (Resat, 1993;
Sprik and Ciccotti, 1998) was employed to evaluate energetic properties.
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
78
As described in our previous study (Mei et al., 2013a), to calculate the binding free energy
between Zn2+ and Cl–, a series of Zn-Cl distance constraint calculations were performed by
constraining Zn-Cl distances along predefined reaction paths. The constraint force was
recorded during the simulation time by sampling possible configurations of Zn(II)-Cl
complexes and the surrounding solvent and ions at each distance-constraint, and the mean
constraint force f(r) at fixed distances r was obtained by computing the average of the
constraint force. Here, f(r) is the force necessary to maintain the chloride ion at a distance r
from the Zn2+ ion, where r varies from ‘infinity’ (i.e., negligible interaction between Zn2+
and Cl– ions) to a bonded state (~2.2 Å). In each series of distance-constrained calculation,
the simulation parameters were kept identical in the constrained and unconstrained
simulations. All the constrained simulations were calculated for more than 5 ps, including
0.7 ps for stablization (Bühl et al., 2006; 2008). Then the mean forces f(r) as a function of
constrained Zn-Cl distances (r) from ~2.2 Å to 5 Å were obtained. The change in free
energy for the reaction was derived by integrating f(r) with respect to the constrained
distance (r) (Bühl et al., 2006; 2008; Sprik and Ciccotti, 1998):
(4.1)
To test the stability of ZnCl42– at 600 °C, the free energy of the association reaction
[ZnCl3–] + Cl– = [ZnCl4
2–] (4.2)
was calculated. As ZnCl42– dissociates to [ZnCl3
–] at 600 °C according to unconstrained MD
simulations, all Zn-Cl distances were constrained in this series of calculation (Mei et al.,
2013a). Three of the Zn-Cl distances were constrained at the distance 2.3 Å, the other Zn-Cl
distance was constrained along the reaction path, with values from 2.3 to 5.0 Å. Free energy
surface of Zn-Cl association reactions were calculated at the temperature of 200 °C, 350 °C
and 600 °C.
!
"Aa# b = $ f (r) dra
b%
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
79
As the free energy surface of Zn-Cl association reactions were calculated by thermodynamic
integration, the stability constants of different Zn-Cl species could be derived. We
conducted calculations at constant volume, so that the Helmholtz free energies were
obtained. Similarly to Mei et al. (2013a), the Gibbs free energies of the reaction were
approximated by assuming:
'rG = 'Aa!b (4.3)
After activity correction, the formation constants were calculated from
(4.4)
4.3 Results
4.3.1 Ab initio molecular dynamic simulations
Ab initio MD simulations of Zn(II)-Cl complexes were conducted at different temperatures
and pressures with varying initial configurations. At ambient conditions (25 °C, 1 bar), the
number of Cl– complexed to Zn2+ (from 0 to 4 in the initial configuration; simulations 1a-e)
does not change during the first 14 ps. MD simulation 1a was started with an octahedral
Zn(H2O)62+ structure (Fig. 4.2a); the calculations reveal steady state Zn-O distances of
2.13 Å and a Debye-Waller factor of 0.023 Å. In the following, we use Debye-Waller
factors to provide uncertainties on bond distance (Campbell et al, 1999). Observation of the
dynamic Zn-Cl distances confirms that Cl- did not complex to Zn2+ during the simulation
(Fig. 4.3a). Simulation 1b was started with an octahedral structure, ZnCl(H2O)5+; two water
molecules dissociated after 4.3 ps, resulting in the formation of a tetrahedral complex
ZnCl(H2O)3+, with a Zn-Cl distance of 2.25±0.010 Å and Zn-O distances of 1.99±0.005 Å
(Fig. 4.2c). The Zn-O bond distances are shorter in ZnCl(H2O)3+ than in Zn(H2O)6
2+, as
!
"rG# = $RT lnK#
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
80
expected for a transition from octahedral to tetrahedral geometry. In simulations 1c, 1d and
1e, Zn(II)-Cl complexes kept the same structure as the initial configuration with no Cl-Cl
exchange (Fig. 4.3). The Zn-Cl and Zn-O bond distances are listed in Table 4.2. The
dynamic Zn-Cl distances shown in Figure 4.3 indicate that the species Zn(H2O)62+
(Fig. 4.2a), ZnCl(H2O)3+ (Fig. 4.2c), ZnCl2(H2O)2 (Fig. 4.2d), ZnCl3(H2O)– (Fig. 4.2e),
ZnCl42– (Fig. 4.2f) can be (meta)stable at 25 °C, 1 bar over ps time lengths, reflecting the
slow kinetics of the ligand exchange reactions between Zn2+ and Cl– ions. In terms of
geometry, the only stable octahedral complex was the Zn(H2O)62+ aqua-complex (Fig. 4.2a).
Once Cl– complexes to Zn2+, the structure changes from octahedral to tetrahedral within a
few ps (Figs. 4.2c,d,e,f).
Figure 4.2 Snapshot of Zn(II)-Cl complexes
!"
#$
%&
'() '*) '+) ',)
'-) '.) '/)
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
81
Table 4.2 Geometrical details of Zn(II)-Cl complexes by MD simulations
T, P Job No.
Simulation time (ps)
Initial configuration Final species dZn-Cl
(Å) dZn-O (Å)
1a 14.51 Zn(H2O)62+ Zn(H2O)6
2+ - 2.13
1b 14.51 ZnCl(H2O)5+ ZnCl(H2O)3
+ 2.25 1.99
1c 14.51 ZnCl2(H2O)20 ZnCl2(H2O)2
0 2.27 1.99
1d 14.51 ZnCl3(H2O)– ZnCl3(H2O)– 2.26 2.05
25 ˚C, 1 bar
1e 14.51 ZnCl42– ZnCl4
2– 2.30 -
2a 14.51 Zn(H2O)62+ ZnCl(H2O)3
+ 2.23 2.00
2b 14.80 ZnCl(H2O)5+ ZnCl2(H2O)2
0 2.24 2.01
2c 14.51 ZnCl2(H2O)20 ZnCl2(H2O)2
0 2.24 2.03
2d 15.53 ZnCl3(H2O)– ZnCl3(H2O)– 2.25 2.03
200 ˚C, 14 bar
2e 14.51 ZnCl42– ZnCl4
2– 2.30 -
3a 14.51 Zn(H2O)62+ ZnCl(H2O)3
+ 2.21 2.02
3b 14.51 ZnCl(H2O)5+ ZnCl(H2O)3
+ 2.22 2.03
3c 14.51 ZnCl2(H2O)20 ZnCl2(H2O)2
0 2.23 2.06
3d 14.51 ZnCl3(H2O)– ZnCl3(H2O)–
& ZnCl3– (minor) 2.28 2.11
350 ˚C, 500 bar
3e 14.51 ZnCl42– ZnCl4
2– 2.29 -
4a 14.62 Zn(H2O)62+ ZnCl2(H2O)2
0 2.20 2.14
4b 16.52 ZnCl(H2O)5+ ZnCl2(H2O)2
0 2.21 2.07
4c 17.63 ZnCl2(H2O)20 ZnCl3(H2O)–
& ZnCl3– (major) 2.22 2.21
4d 17.63 ZnCl3(H2O)– ZnCl2(H2O)20 2.22 2.08
600 ˚C, 2000 bar
4e 17.49 ZnCl42– ZnCl3(H2O)–
& ZnCl3– (major) 2.23 2.32
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
82
Figure 4.3 Dynamic distances of Zn-Cl in the simulations at 25 ˚C with different initial
configurations
12
10
8
6
4
2
014121086420
25˚C
Zn(H2O)62+
12
10
8
6
4
2
014121086420
25˚C
ZnCl(H2O)3+
ZnCl(H2O)4+
ZnCl(H2O)5+
4
3
2
114121086420
25˚C
ZnCl42-
12
10
8
6
4
2
014121086420
25˚C
ZnCl2(H2O)2
12
10
8
6
4
2
014121086420
25˚C
ZnCl3(H2O)-
Simulation time (ps)
Zn-C
l dis
tanc
es (Å
)
(a)(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
83
Simulation 2a shows that at 200 °C, 14 bar (saturation pressure), the octahedral aqua
complex Zn(H2O)62+ becomes unstable. Zn(H2O)6
2+ first loses two water molecules, and
then one Cl– complexed to Zn2+ and replaced one of the remaining 4 waters to form the
tetrahedral complex ZnCl(H2O)3+ (Fig. 4.2c, Fig. 4.4a). Ligand (Cl–) association and water
dissociation reactions are also observed in simulation 2b, which was started with the initial
species ZnCl(H2O)5+ (Fig. 4.4b). One water molecule dissociated at the beginning of the
MD run, resulting in the ZnCl(H2O)4+ complex. This species lasted for ~1 ps until one water
molecule dissociated and tetrahedral ZnCl(H2O)3+ formed. As shown in Figure 4.4b, after
~7 ps, one Cl– ligand replaced one water molecule and ZnCl2(H2O)20 (Fig. 4.2d) formed as
the final species, with Zn-O and Zn-Cl distances of 2.01±0.012 Å and 2.24±0.007 Å,
respectively. In simulations 2c, 2d and 2e, similarly to simulation 1, the number of chlorides
remained the same as in the initial configuration during the whole simulation: ZnCl2(H2O)20
(Fig. 4.4c), ZnCl3(H2O)– (with 4% of ZnCl3–, Figs. 4.2f, 4.4d) and ZnCl4
2– (Figs. 4.2g, 4.4e).
The Zn-Cl and Zn-O bond distances are listed in Table 4.2. The MD simulations at 200 °C
indicate that rather than the unstable Zn(H2O)62+ aqua ion, tetrahedral Zn(II)-Cl complexes
with 1-4 Cl– can exist in chloride-rich fluids. The MD simulations at 200 °C also show
faster kinetics than simulations at room temperature, as Cl-H2O ligand exchange reactions
could be observed in 15 ps simulations (Fig. 4.4b).
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
84
Figure 4.4 Dynamic distances of Zn-Cl in the simulations at 200 ˚C with different initial
configurations.
12
10
8
6
4
2
014121086420
200˚C
ZnCl2(H2O)2 ZnCl(H2O)3+
ZnCl(H2O)4+
12
10
8
6
4
2
014121086420
200˚C
ZnCl2(H2O)2
12
10
8
6
4
2
014121086420
200˚C
Zn(H2O)62+
ZnCl(H2O)3+
4
3
2
114121086420
200˚C
ZnCl42-
12
10
8
6
4
2
014121086420
200˚C
ZnCl3(H2O)-
ZnCl3-
Zn-C
l dis
tanc
es (Å
)
Simulation time (ps)
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
85
At 350 °C, 500 bar, the octahedral aqua complex Zn(H2O)62+ was also found to be unstable
in a 4 m Cl solutions, similarly to the 200 °C case. Three water molecules in Zn(H2O)62+
dissociated gradually and one Cl– ligand complexed to Zn2+ to form the tetrahedral
ZnCl(H2O)3+ complex (Fig. 4.5a) with intermediate species of Zn(H2O)4
2+ (Fig. 4.2b). In
simulations 3b and 3c (Figs. 4.5b, 4.5c), the number of Cl– does not change during the
simulation, and the tetrahedral geometries are maintained throughout the simulations. In
simulation 3d with the starting structure of ZnCl3(H2O)–, the number of Cl– does not change
during the simulation, but sometimes one water molecule left the complex to form trigonal
ZnCl3– (22% of [ZnCl3
-] complex). Simulation 3e (Fig. 4.5e) shows that ZnCl42– is stable at
350 °C in a 4 m Cl solution, with an average Zn-Cl bond distance of 2.29±0.014 Å. MD
simulations under hydrothermal conditions (200 and 350 °C) indicate that the Zn2+-aqua
complex exists as tetrahedral Zn(H2O)42+ (Fig. 4.2b), but not as octahedral complex in Cl-
poor fluids; this species is not stable in Cl-rich fluids as water molecules will be replaced by
chloride. Four tetrahedral complexes (ZnCln(H2O)4-n2-n; n=1,2,3,4) were observed in Zn-Cl
fluids.
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
86
Figure 4.5 Dynamic distances of Zn-Cl in the simulations at 350 ˚C with different initial
configurations.
12
10
8
6
4
2
014121086420
350˚C
ZnCl3(H2O)- & ZnCl3-
12
10
8
6
4
2
014121086420
Zn(H2O)42+ &
Zn(H2O)52+ ZnCl(H2O)3
+
350˚C
4
3
2
114121086420
350˚C
ZnCl42-
12
10
8
6
4
2
014121086420
350˚C
ZnCl(H2O)3+
12
10
8
6
4
2
014121086420
350˚C
ZnCl2(H2O)2
Zn-C
l dis
tanc
es (Å
)
Simulation time (ps)
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
87
MD simulations at 600 °C, 2 kbar were conducted to investigate the behavior of Zn(II)-Cl
complexes under magmatic hydrothermal conditions. As seen in Figure 4.6, the kinetics of
ligand-exchange reactions at 600 °C is faster than at lower temperatures. In simulation 4a,
the initial octahedral complex Zn(H2O)62+ changed to tetrahedral Zn(H2O)4
2+ (Fig. 4.2b)
quickly, then two Cl– complexed to Zn2+ by successive replacement of H2O ligands, forming
the neutral complex ZnCl2(H2O)20 (Fig. 4.2d). Simulation 4b also gave a stable
configuration of ZnCl2(H2O)20 (Fig. 4.6), with one more Cl– complexed to Zn2+ in ~5 ps.
Simulation 4c was started with ZnCl2(H2O)20, and the predominant species are tetrahedral
ZnCl3(H2O)– (Fig. 4.2e, 44%) and trigonal planar ZnCl3– (Fig. 4.2f, 56%) with one more
chloride complexing to zinc after about 5 ps (Fig. 6c). Simulation 4d contained ZnCl3–,
ZnCl3(H2O)– and ZnCl2(H2O)20 complexes, with several ligand exchanges observed during
17 ps. Simulation 4e shows that ZnCl42– may be not stable under these condition (Fig. 4.6e),
since one chloride dissociated to from tetrahedral ZnCl3(H2O)– (44%) and trigonal planar
ZnCl3– (56%).
The dehydration of the [ZnCl3–] complex with increasing temperature, i.e. the increase in
the relative stability of the ZnCl3– form versus the ZnCl3(H2O)– form, as a function of
temperature is summarized in Figure 4.7. To calculate the average number of waters bonded
to [ZnCl3–] (n of ZnCl3(H2O)n
–), a distance cut-off of 2.75 Å was selected; the uncertainties
reflect the change in hydration within a distance of ±0.25 Å (i.e. 2.75±0.25 Å). Hydration
numbers decrease from 1 to 0.98, 0.79, and 0.44 at 25 °C, 200 °C, 350 °C, and 600 °C,
respectively.
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
88
Figure 4.6 Dynamic distances of Zn-Cl in the simulations at 600 ˚C with different initial
configurations.
12
10
8
6
4
2
01614121086420
600˚C
ZnCl42- ZnCl3(H2O)- & ZnCl3
-
12
10
8
6
4
2
01614121086420
600˚C
ZnCl3- ZnCl2(H2O)2
ZnCl3(H2O)-
ZnCl3-
ZnCl2(H2O)2
12
10
8
6
4
2
01614121086420
ZnCl2(H2O)2
600˚C
ZnCl3(H2O)- & ZnCl3-
12
10
8
6
4
2
01614121086420
600˚C
ZnCl(H2O)3+ ZnCl2(H2O)2
12
10
8
6
4
2
014121086420
600˚C
ZnCl(H2O)3+
ZnCl2(H2O)2
Zn(H2O)42+
Simulation time (ps)
Zn-C
l dis
tanc
es (Å
)
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
89
Figure 4.7 Radial distribution function (RDF, blue curves) and coordination number (CN,
red curves) of Zn-O of ZnCl3(H2O)n– complexes in selected MD simulations. The error of
No is calculated within distance width of 0.5 Å.
1.0
0.5
0.06420
2
1
0
(e) 600˚C, Sim_4e, 13.2 ps
1.0
0.5
0.06420
2
1
0
(d) 600˚C, Sim_4c, 12.5 ps
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.06420
4
3
2
1
0
(c) 350˚C, Sim_3d, 14.5 ps
Zn-O
Rad
ial D
istri
butio
n Fu
nctio
n (R
DF)
Zn-O C
oordination Num
ber (CN
)
Zn-O Distances (Å)
3.0
2.0
1.0
0.06420
4
3
2
1
0
(b) 200˚C, Sim_2d, 15.5 ps
4.0
3.0
2.0
1.0
0.06420
4
3
2
1
0
(a) 25˚C, Sim_1d, 14.5 ps
CN RDF
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
90
In Cl-rich fluids (simulation 5, Cl– concentration of 10 m), when starting with an initial
configuration of ZnCl3(H2O)–, tetrahedral ZnCl3(H2O)– and trigonal planar ZnCl3–
predominate with short presence (~2 ps) of tetrahedral ZnCl42– (Fig. 4.8a). The simulation
started with tetrahedral ZnCl42– gives shows the ZnCl4
2–, ZnCl3(H2O)– and ZnCl3– species
over the 27.4 ps simulation time, with at least one observable Cl-Cl ligand exchange
(Fig. 4.8).
Figure 4.8 Dynamic distances of Zn-Cl in the simulations at 600 ˚C in 10 m Cl– solutions
with different initial configurations (a) ZnCl3(H2O)–, (b) ZnCl42–.
4.3.2 Ab initio thermodynamic integration and free energy calculations
MD simulations results listed in the previous section gave us a basic idea about the
speciation of Zn(II)-Cl complexes from ambient to hydrothermal-magmatic conditions; the
simulations also help to understand qualitatively the stability of certain Zn(II)-Cl complexes
12
10
8
6
4
2
02826242220181614121086420
ZnCl42-
600˚C
ZnCl3(H2O)- & ZnCl3-
12
10
8
6
4
2
02826242220181614121086420
ZnCl3(H2O)- & ZnCl3-
ZnCl42-
600˚C
Zn-C
l dis
tanc
es (Å
)
Simulation time (ps)
(a)
(b)
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
91
under different conditions. In principle, formation constants for the Zn(II) complexes could
be derived from the ratio of abundance of the complexes in solutions where at least two
complexes co-exist. In order to achieve this, the ligand exchange reactions must happen at a
rate much faster than the simulation time. However, in the MD simulations described above,
the constant number of complexed chloride in many simulations (e.g., 1a-e, 2c-e, 3b-e)
suggests a slow kinetics of chloride-exchange reactions. The time scale of MD simulation is
small comparing with the exchange rate of Cl– ligand with Zn2+ in aqueous solution at room
temperature (~300 µs for Cl–, Sharps et al., 1993). Although the kinetics at high temperature
is faster and ligand exchange can be observed in some simulations (e.g., 2a-b, 3a, 4a-e, 5a-
b), the statistics of ratio of different species is not good enough to calculate the stability of
the complexes. Consequently, we used thermodynamic integration to predict the energetic
properties and help to estimate the relative stabilities of Zn(II)-Cl complexes (semi)-
quantitatively.
Ab initio thermodynamic integration was applied at 200, 350 and 600 °C to obtain the free
energy of ligand exchange reactions. Using the same solution composition as listed in
Table 4.1 (No. 2-4), constrained MD simulations were performed by fixing Zn-Cl distances.
Figure 4.9 shows an example of calculating the free energy of reaction (4.7) (substitution of
a water ligand by a chloride) through thermodynamic integration.
Zn(H2O)3Cl+ + H2O = Zn(H2O)42+ + Cl– (4.7)
The Helmholz free energy (!Aa!b) of reaction (4.7) at 350 °C was obtained by integrating
the constraint mean force with respect to the constrained Zn-Cl distances. The force is near
zero (5.25 kJ‧Å-1‧mol-1) at 2.20 Å - the distance corresponding to the equilibrated Zn-Cl
bond distance in the MD simulation. With increasing Zn-Cl distance, an external force must
be applied in order to maintain a given Zn-Cl distance because of the attraction between
Zn2+ and Cl–. The maximum absolute value of the constraint force is reached at a distance of
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
92
2.6 Å (-106.1 kJ‧Å-1‧mol-1), then the absolute magnitude of the force decreases with
increasing Zn-Cl distances. The constraint force becomes zero again at a distance of ~3.2 Å,
and becomes slightly positive in the range of 3.2-4.3 Å, which results from the outer
solvation shell and reflects the activation barrier for the ion exchange reaction. Beyond the
Zn-Cl distance of 4.5 Å, the force between Zn2+ and Cl– is negligible. Considering the size
of the simulation box (13.235 Å at 350 °C), the distances of 4.5-5.0 Å can be recognized as
“safe” distance beyond which the interaction between Zn2+ and Cl– ligand can be neglected
(Mei et al., 2013a).
Figure 4.9 Constraint mean force and the integral of reaction (4.7) at 350 ˚C, 500 bar
Integration of the mean constraint force along the reaction coordinates gives a free energy
difference of +39.7 kJ‧mol–1 for reaction (4.7). The free energies for the stepwise formation
of [ZnCln2-n] (n=1,2,3,4) complexes were calculated at 200, 350 and 600 °C (Fig. 4.10).
!"#$
!"$$
!%$
!&$
!'$
!#$
$
#$
'$
&$
()$')(')$*)(*)$#)(#)$+,!-./01234,56/789
#)#$/8
#)&$/8
#)%$/8
()$$/8
:/;/+,7</+,7<#:9*-.=/=/<# #:9'
#=/=/-.!!"#
!$#
!%#
!&#
>//7?@/8!"/AB.!"
!"9
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
93
Figure 4.10 Free energy surface of Zn-Cl dissociation reactions.
At 200 °C, positive energies of 22 to 24 kJ‧mol–1 were obtained the substitution of a
chloride by a water in the tetrahedral ZnCl(H2O)3+, ZnCl2(H2O)2(aq) and ZnCl3(H2O)–
complexes, which reflects the strong tendency of Zn(H2O)42+ to react with Cl– to form
!"
#"
$"
%"
&"
'"
("
"
)("
$*"%*$%*"&*$&*"'*$'*"
+++,-./'01&234+4+/'0+5+,-./'01%
'4+4+23)+
+++,-./'01'23'+4+/'0+5++,-./'01&2344+23)+
+++,-./'0123&)+4+/'0+5++,-./'01'23'+4+23
)+
+++,-23%')+4+/'0+5++,-./'0123&
)+4+23)++
.61++#""+!2
$"
%"
&"
'"
("
"
)("$*"%*$%*"&*$&*"'*$'*"
.71+++&$"!2
+++,-./'01&234+4+/'0+5+,-./'01%
'4+4+23)+
+++,-./'01'23'+4+/'0+5++,-./'01&2344+23)+
+++,-./'0123&)+4+/'0+5++,-./'01'23'+4+23
)+
+++,-23%')+4+/'0+5++,-./'0123&
)+4+23)++
%"
&"
'"
("
"
)("$*"%*$%*"&*$&*"'*$'*"
.81++'""!2
+++,-./'01&234+4+/'0+5+,-./'01%
'4+4+23)+
+++,-./'01'23'+4+/'0+5++,-./'01&2344+23)+
+++,-./'0123&)+4+/'0+5++,-./'01'23'+4+23
)+
+++,-23%')+4+/'0+5++,-./'0123&
)+4+23)++
9+.:;<=>31
,-)23+?@AB8-6CA+.D1
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
94
tetrahedral [ZnCln(H2O)4-n]n-2 (n=1,2,3) complexes. The positive free energies of
12.3 kJ‧mol–1 for the ZnCl42– complexes also indicates the preference of forming 4-Cl
tetrahedral complex in the simulated 4 m chloride solution, but the energy gained in
replacing the last water is not as strong as for the previous ([ZnCln(H2O)4-n]n-2; n=1,2,3)
steps.
The free energies for step-wise formation constants at 350 °C show similar trends as at
200 °C: tetrahedral [ZnCln(H2O)4-n]n-2 (n=1,2,3,4) complexes are preferred, with strong
tendency of Zn2+ to react with 1-3 Cl–. The hydration change for the ZnCl3– and
ZnCl3(H2O)– complexes is neglected at 600 °C as the solvent exchange is fast (less than
1 ps). As shown in Figure 4.10c, Zn(II)-Cl complexes of [ZnCln(H2O)4-n]n-2 (n=1,2,3,4) are
also favored at 600 °C, but the relatively smaller energies of stepwise formation for
ZnCl3(H2O)– and ZnCl42– indicate that those two species are not as stable as ZnCl(H2O)3
+
and ZnCl2(H2O)2(aq); these results are consistent with the unconstrained MD shown in
Figure 4.6.
The results of the distance constraint thermodynamic integration for the Zn-Cl association
reactions are listed in Table 4.3. Three versions of Gibbs free energies of reaction are listed:
'rG(P,T) is the Gibbs free energy of the reactions calculated from thermodynamic
integration (i.e., in a 4 m Cl solution), 'rG(,c(P,T) is the Gibbs free energy with
concentration correction (i.e., infinite dilution at the P,T of the simulation), and 'rG((Pr,Tr)
is the standard state Gibbs free energy under Pr = 1 bar, Tr = 25 °C (Mei et al., 2013a). The
errors of 'rG(P,T) are calculated from the standard deviation of the force integral within the
distance range of 4 to 5 Å. log K((P,T) values of the reactions which form different Zn(II)
complexes were calculated according to Equation (4.4).
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
95
Table 4.3 Gibbs free energy of reaction and stability constants of the Zn-Cl association
reactions
Reaction T (˚C) 'rG(P,T) (kJ/mol)
'rG(,c(P,T) (kJ/mol)
'rG((Pr,Tr) (kJ/mol) logK!(P,T)
Zn2+ + Cl– = ZnCl+ 200 -23.2±1.6 -14.4 -23.4 2.58±0.18 ZnCl+ + Cl– = ZnCl2(aq) 200 -23.3±1.6 -15.8 -19.5 2.16±0.18 ZnCl2(aq) + Cl– = ZnCl3
– 200 -22.4±1.9 -16.9 -17.4 1.92±0.21 ZnCl3
– + Cl– = ZnCl42– 200 -12.3±3.2 -12.3 -8.5 0.94±0.35
Zn2+ + Cl– = ZnCl+ 350 -39.7±1.0 -28.0 -62.4 5.23±0.08 ZnCl+ + Cl– = ZnCl2(aq) 350 -32.3±2.7 -22.4 -40.0 3.35±0.23 ZnCl2(aq) + Cl– = ZnCl3
– 350 -37.9±1.7 -30.7 -31.7 2.66±0.14 ZnCl3
– + Cl– = ZnCl42– 350 -15.0±3.9 -15.0 -11.3 0.95±0.33
Zn2+ + Cl– = ZnCl+ 600* -67.4±3.1 -51.1 -98.8 5.91±0.19 ZnCl+ + Cl– = ZnCl2(aq) 600 -66.1±2.6 -52.2 -76.5 4.58±0.16 ZnCl2(aq) + Cl– = ZnCl3
– 600 -39.9±2.4 -29.8 -31.3 1.87±0.14 ZnCl3
– + Cl– = ZnCl42– 600 -21.2±4.7 -21.2 -15.4 0.92±0.28
*bdot parameter at 500 ˚C
4.4 Refitting solubility data for Zn(II)-Cl complexes
4.4.1 Data sources and methods
In this section, we attempted to reinterpret the available solubility data of Ruaya and Seward
(1986) (R&S) and Bourcier and Barnes (1987) (B&B) to get a consistent thermodynamic
dataset for zinc chloride complexes that can describe both datasets. We aim to reconcile
both studies by fitting both datasets using a unified model and use the MD results to choose
the speciation model. Further impetus for refitting the solubility measured by R&S and
B&B is provided by the availability of improved thermodynamic properties for some of the
solids and aqueous species required in the interpretation of the experimental solubilities
(Table 4.4). These new data may affect the refined log K data for the Zn(II) chloride
complexes.
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
96
Table 4.4 Species included in the solubility calculations.
Species Source New data
ZnO ZnCO3 AgCl
Zincite (ZnO(s)) Wesolowski et al., 1998 Yes % Smithsonite (ZnCO3(s)) Preis et al., 2000 Yes % Chlorargyrite (AgCl(s)) Zotov et al., 1995 Yes % HCl(aq) Tagirov, 1997 Yes % % % ZnCli
(2-i) Fitted in the analysis % % % Zn(OH)+ and Zn(OH)2(aq) Bénézeth et al., 2002 Yes % % AgCl(aq), AgCl2
–, AgCl32– Zotov et al., 1995 Yes %
NaCl(aq) Svenjensky et al. 1997 No NaCO3
- Smith and Martell, 1976 No % % NaHCO3(aq) Smith and Martell, 1976 No % % CO2(g) Pankratz, 1982 No % % H2CO3(aq) No % % Basis species are: Ag+, Cl-, H+, HCO3
-, Na+, Zn2+ % species are used in the model
4.4.2 Fitting procedure
The fitting was conducted according to the procedure illustrated in Figure 4.11.
Figure 4.11 Schematic view of the procedure used to fit the solubility data of B&B and
R&S simultaneously.
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
97
Table 4.5 Modified Ryzhenko-Bryzgalin (MRB) equation of state parameters for Zn-Cl complexes fitted in this study (Ryzhenko et al., 1985; Shvarov and Bastrakov, 1999).
Reaction pK25˚C A B
ZnCl+ = Zn2+ + Cl– -0.46 0.50 210.60 ZnCl2(aq) = Zn2+ + 2Cl– -0.40 2.60 -554.20 ZnCl3
– = Zn2+ + 3Cl– -3.20 1.10 731.90 ZnCl4
2– = Zn2+ + 4Cl– -0.10 3.50 -1020.70
(i) A thermodynamic model was set-up to calculate the solubility in each experiment, based
on full distribution of species calculations. The model includes the species listed in
Table 4.5. The relevant mass action, mass balance and charge balance equations were
solved using an implementation of the EQBRM code in Matlab (Anderson and Crerar, 1993;
Brugger et al., 2007). As in previous studies (e.g., Liu et al., 2001), an extended Debye-
Hückel expression (Helgeson, 1969) was used to calculated individual molal activity
coefficient for charged species:
, (4.8)
where A! and B! are the Debye-Hückel solvent parameters taken from Helgeson and Kirkham
(1974);
!
˙ a n is the distance of closest approach of ion n, and is given a value of 5 Å for
divalent and trivalent ions, and 4.0 Å for monovalent ions, except for H+ and Zn2+ which are
given values of 9 and 6 Å, respectively (Kielland 1937); is the effective ionic strength
using the molal scale; ! is a mole fraction to molality conversion factor; and B!,SALT is the
extended-term parameter (b-dot coefficient) for NaCl (B&B) and HCl (R&S) solutions
taken from Helgeson et al. (1981).
(ii) Initially, each isothermal dataset was fitted individually ((1) in Fig. 11). At each
temperature, the formation constants of the four possible Zn(II) chloride complexes (i.e.,
!
log(" n ) = #A"Zn
2I 1 / 2
1+ B" ˙ a nI 1 / 2 + B" ,SALT I +$
!
I
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
98
ZnClx2-x, x = 1-4) were optimized using the nonlinear least squares simplex method (Nelder
and Mead, 1965), so as to minimize the difference between the solubilities calculated using
the model (
!
yi ) and the experimental solubilities (
!
yi0). In order to provide the same
weighting for the two experimental studies (irrespective of the number of individual
solubility measurements in each dataset), the minimized residual function R was defined as:
!
R = 1nexp
log(yi ) " log(yi0)( )2
i
nexp
#exp
R& S /B&B
# (4.9)
Maps of the residual R were calculated as a function of log K (ZnClx2-x) around the
optimized values, and plotted in two dimensions to examine the uncertainties in the derived
log K values. These uncertainties are estimated as log K ranges around optimized values at
an approximate confidence level of 95% for non-linear regression (e.g., cuprite solubility
experiments of Liu et al. 2001). To calculate the 95% confidence level for the isothermal fits,
we used the relationship (Draper and Smith, 1998):
!
R95% = Rmin 1+p
n " pF(p,n " p,1"#)
$ % &
' ( ) (4.10)
where p is the number of degrees of freedom, n the number of independent measurements,
and F is the F-distribution; for p = 4, n ~40, " = 0.05, F = 2.6, and
!
R95% " Rmin #1.3.
The residual maps obtained for the 200 °C dataset are shown in Figure 4.12; similar maps
were obtained at each temperature. At 200 °C, only minimum values for the formation
constants of ZnCl42– and ZnCl2(aq) can be given; the range of values for the formation of
ZnCl3– changes dramatically as a function of the ZnCl4
2- value. Only the formation constant
of ZnCl2(aq) is fixed within ~1.5 log unit.
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
99
Figure 4.12 The residual maps of fitting the 200 °C solubility data
(iii) In order to minimize the uncertainty in the values of log K (ZnClx2-x) resulting from the
large number of possible species, we performed a new analysis in which all datasets (all
temperatures) were included ((2) in Fig. 4.11). In this approach, instead of fitting log K’s at
each temperature, we optimized the parameter for the 4 Zn(II) chlorocomplexes in the
modified Ryzhenko-Bryzgalin (MRB) equation of state (Ryzhenko et al., 1985; Shvarov and
Bastrakov, 1999):
!
pK(P,T ) =298.15T
pK(298.15K ,1bar)+ B(P,T ) A+BT
"
# $
%
& '
B(P,T ) = 11.0107 logKw (P,T )(T 298.15K logKw (298.15K,1bar)( ) (4.11)
A and B are empirical parameters, and Kw(P,T) is the dissociation of water. Ki(25 °C,1bar)
for ZnCl+ and ZnCl42– were fixed to the values of 0.46 and 0.10, respectively, from Liu et al.
(2007); all the other EOS parameters were allowed to vary during the least square fit.
4.4.3 Speciation of Zn(II)-Cl based on solubility experiments
The results of the new fitting are shown in Figure 4.13, and the MRB parameters in
Table 4.5. In general the calculated and experimental data are within error. Note that fits
using the HCl0 data from Ruaya and Seward (1987) provides better fits at high Cl
LogK
(ZnC
l 42–)
LogK(ZnCl2(aq)) = 0
LogK(ZnCl +) LogK(ZnCl3–)
LogK
(ZnC
l 42–)
LogK(ZnCl +) LogK(ZnCl3–)
Red volume: 95% con!dence level
0
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.2
0.22
0
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.6
0.7
LogK(ZnCl2(aq)) = -3.93
!"# !$#
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
100
concentrations, although the refined properties and speciations are very similar. This may be
due to the fact that Ruaya and Seward (1987) used a similar chemical system (AgCl(s)) to
measure HCl association.
Figure 4.13 Results of the new fitting of the solubility data of B&B and R&S. Red circles
represent experimental data and the lines represent fitted data.
At 100 °C, with the best fit for ZnCl42– and maximal values for other species, the speciation
shows the increased predominance of ZnCl42– as chloride concentration increases
(Fig. 4.13a). At 150 °C, ZnCl42– still predominates in high chloride concentration solution,
and ZnCl3– becomes more important in solutions of ~1-2 m Cl– (Fig. 4.13b). At 200 °C, as
shown in Fig. 4.13c, ZnCl3– becomes predominant in most solutions, while ZnCl4
2– acts as
the second important species at chloride concentrations > 1 m. Our fitting of 350 °C data
gives different results for B&B and R&S (Fig. 4.13d). The fitting based on B&B data
suggests predominant species of ZnCl3– at lower chloride concentration (~ less than 1 m)
10 100 10110
10
10
Zn_t
ot [m
]
10 100 1010
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
10010
10
10
Ag_t
ot [m
]
R&S1986 @ 100
1000
0.4
0.6
0.8
10 100 10110
10
10B&B1988, smithsonite @ 150
10 100 1010
0.4
0.6
0.8
10010
10
10
10R&S1986 @ 150
1000
0.4
0.6
0.8
10 100 10110
10
10
10 100 1010
0.4
0.6
0.8
10010
10
10
1000
0.4
0.6
0.8
10010
10
10
10
1000
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
10010
10
10
100
1000
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
Zn
–
4
!"# !$# !%# !&#
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
101
and ZnCl42– at high chloride concentration (~ more than 1 m), while the fitting results of
R&S data indicates ZnCl3– predominates in all chloride concentration ranges.
The formation constants from the solubility studies of Ruaya and Seward (1986) and
Bourcier and Barnes (1987) are compiled in Table 4.6, and compared with the properties
resulting from our new fit and MD simulations. The new Ryzhenko model for each Zn(II)-
Cl species based on our fitting is plotted as a function of temperature (Fig. 4.14). The log K
values from different studies show the same trend as change of temperature. It is noticed
that fitted values at 350 °C are very close to log K obtained by MD simulation (log K value
of 8.57 for ZnCl2(aq) and 11.23 for ZnCl3–). The excellent agreement at 350 °C shows the
potential of MD simulation in applying to the prediction of log K at high temperature.
Despite the over-fitting problem, our fitting agree with the original studies in that the
ZnCl42– is an important species in highly saline solutions at low temperature, and ZnCl3
– is
predominant species at 350 °C. This is also generally in agreement with the MD results.
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
102
Table 4.6 The log formation constants for zinc(II) chloride complexes
T (˚C)
Zn2+ + Cl– = ZnCl+
Zn2+ + 2Cl– = ZnCl2
0 Zn2+ + 3Cl– = ZnCl3
– Zn2+ + 4Cl– = ZnCl4
2– Reference
1.80±0.01 1.92±0.01 1.36±0.01 2.04±0.01 R&S* 1.2±0.1 1.9±0.1 2.3±0.1 1.4±0.1 B&B* 100
1.02 (<1.7) <1.7 <1.7 1.01 (0.8-
1.2) Refit§
2.89±0.01 2.96±0.01 2.02±0.02 3.21±0.01 R&S* 2.1±0.2 3.0±0.1 3.8±0.1 2.7±0.2 B&B* 150 2.13 (1.9-2.3) <3 3 (2.7-3.2) 1.97 (<2.5) Refit§
4.01±0.01 3.98±0.02 3.00±0.10 4.23±0.01 R&S* 3.1±0.3 4.3±0.2 5.2±0.2 4.4±0.3 B&B* 2.5±0.1 4.2±0.1 W&B&P 2.58 4.74 6.66 7.6 MD§
200
2.26 (1.8-2.6) <3.7 4.42 (4.2-
4.6) 3.19 (<3.7) Refit§
4.4±0.3 5.6±0.2 6.7±0.2 6.0±0.2 B&B*¶ 250¶ 4.96 (4.8-
5.1) <5.8 7.16 (7.0-7.3)
5.94 (5.5-6.2) HCh*¶
275¶ 5.82±0.02 6.73±0.02 - 7.54±0.02 R&S*¶ 5.7±0.4 7.2±0.2 8.1±0.2 7.4±0.2 B&B*
300 5.6 (4.0-6.0) <7.2 8.1 (8.0-8.3) Refit§ 8.00±0.10 9.54±0.10 - - R&S* 7.0±0.6 9.3±0.5 9.3±0.5 7.7±0.6 B&B* 5.22 8.57 11.23 12.18 MD§ 350
<6.3 9.4 (8.8-9.8)
11.4 (11.1-11.7) <10.5 Refit§
600¶ 5.91 10.49 12.36 13.28 MD§
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
103
Figure 4.14 LogKs as function of temperature
4.5 Discussion
4.5.1 Speciation of Zn(II)-Cl complexes
MD simulations of Zn-Cl solutions show the stability of the 6-fold aqua-species Zn(H2O)62+
at room temperature, in agreement with previous MD studies (Harris et al., 2003; Liu X et
al., 2011). When one Cl– complexes to Zn2+, however, the MD simulations gave the 4-fold
tetrahedral complex ZnCl(H2O)3+ from ambient to hydrothermal conditions, different from
the octahedral ZnCl(H2O)5+ complex at 25 °C demonstrated by Harris et al. (2003). As
shown in Figure 1b, two waters are released and the Zn(II) complex changes from
ZnCl(H2O)5+ to ZnCl(H2O)3
+ in ~4 ps, so the simulation by Harris et al. (2003) conducted
for only one picosecond is not long enough to observe the steady state of Zn-Cl at room
temperature.
12
10
8
6
4
2
040035030025020015010050
(c) ZnCl3–
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
040035030025020015010050
(d) ZnCl42–
10
8
6
4
2
040035030025020015010050
(b) ZnCl20
8
6
4
2
040035030025020015010050
(a) ZnCl+
R_S; B_B; Refit; new_Ryz; MD; Poly(new_Ryz)
Temperature (˚C) Temperature (˚C)
logK
logK
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
104
There were some discrepancies in the interpretation of the experimental studies by Ruaya
and Seward (1986) and Bourcier and Barnes (1987) at 300 °C: ZnCl3– is the important
species according to Bourcier and Barnes (1987) (Fig. 4.15a), and ZnCl42– (no ZnCl3
–)
predominates in the study by Ruaya and Seward (1986) (Fig. 4.15b). Our new fitting results
(Fig. 4.15c) indicate that ZnCl42– is the most important species in most solutions ([Cl–] >
0.05 m).
Figure 4.15 Speciation plot at 300˚C from different datasets
The change of Zn(II)-Cl speciation with temperature is also calculated using the
thermodynamic properties from the MD simulations. The MD simulations suggest that both
ZnCl3– and ZnCl4
2– are important species in many solutions (Fig. 4.16) from 200-600 °C. At
200 °C, ZnCl3– accounts for more than 40% of Zn(II) in [Cl–] of ~0.02-0.2 m, and ZnCl4
2–
predominates in [Cl–] of > 0.2 m (Fig. 4.16a); while ZnCl3– predominates at 350 °C over
most of the Cl concentration range, together with ZnCl42– preferred when [Cl–] > 1 m
(Fig. 4.16b). Similar trends are found at 600 °C, with ZnCl20 more important at lower [Cl–]
of <0.02 m (Fig. 4.16c). For [ZnCl3–], the speciation also changes with temperature as the
first-shell hydration (i.e. number of water n in first shell of ZnCl3(H2O)n– complex)
decreases with increasing temperature (Fig. 4.7).
100
80
60
40
20
0
x10-6
0.001 0.01 0.1 1
B&B 300˚C 100
80
60
40
20
0
x10-6
0.001 0.01 0.1 1
R&S 300˚C 100
80
60
40
20
0x1
0-6
0.001 0.01 0.1 1
New fit 300˚C
Concentration of Zn2+
ZnCl+
ZnCl20
ZnCl3_
ZnCl42–
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
105
Figure 4.16 Speciation plot at 200, 350, 600˚C from MD simulations
The refit of experiment data at low temperature (& 350 °C, Figs. 4.13, 4.15c) also suggests
the predominance of the ZnCl42– species. A similar complex, ZnBr4
2–, has been confirmed
by XAS study at temperature of 25-150 °C in Br-brines (Liu W et al., 2012b). MD results
are also fully consistent with the high stability of the charged ZnCl42– complex even at
elevated temperature.
Other transition metals (Cd, Hg) in the same group as Zn(II) share the same close shell d-
electronic configuration (d10), yet the structures and coordinations of these complexes are
different. For example, a maximum number of 3 Cl– coordinates to Cd(II) in hypersaline
solutions (Bazarkina et al., 2010); and Hg2+ has both four-fold tetrahedral and two-fold
linear complexes (Huheey et al., 1983). The size of the M2+ (M=Zn, Cd, Hg) ions increases
(Zn2+ < Cd2+ < Hg2+), and the energy difference between the (n-1)d-(n)s-(n)p orbitals of
these ions decreases with increasing ion size (Orgel, 1958; Fisher and Drago, 1975). This
leads to different hybridization of (n-1)d-(n)s-(n)p orbitals. The large energy separation
between the 3d and 4s orbitals in Zn2+ favors the sp3 hybridization of Zn(II), and accounts
for the high stability of the symmetric tetrahedral ZnCl42– and ZnBr4
2– structures (Huheey et
al., 1983). In contrast, the close energy of the 5d and 6s orbitals in Hg(II) allows d-s
hybridization and the formation of linear complexes (e.g., HgCl2, Orgel, 1958; Huheey et al.,
1983). The predominance of CdCl2(aq) and CdCl3– (Bazarkina et al., 2010) may relate to the
100
80
60
40
20
0
x10-6
0.001 0.01 0.1 1
MD 600˚C 100
80
60
40
20
0
x10-6
0.001 0.01 0.1 1
MD 350˚C 100
80
60
40
20
0
x10-6
0.001 0.01 0.1 1
MD 200˚C
Concentration of Zn2+
ZnCl+
ZnCl20
ZnCl3_
ZnCl42–
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
106
hybridization of 4d5s5p orbitals favoring distorted tetrahedral complexes such as
CdCl3(H2O)–.
4.5.2 Ab initio MD vs experiments
The formation constants generated using MD and thermodynamic integration are usually
close to those derived from the experiments. In particular, the MD results at 350 °C for
ZnCl2(aq) and ZnCl3– are in excellent agreement with the experimentally derived log Ks
(within one log units, Table 4.6). However, at lower temperature (25 °C and 200 °C), the
discrepancies become larger (up to 2 log units). Because the kinetics of solvent exchange
(~30 ns for H2O, Table 11.4 in Burgess 1978) and ligand exchange for Zn(II) complexes is
slow at low temperature (~300 µs for Cl–, Sharps et al., 1993), it is possible that MD
simulation does not sample all the configurations at lower temperature. At high temperature,
because the kinetics is faster than at low temperature, the simulated structure of the species
and energy of ligand exchange is closer to the equilibrium state; therefore the calculated
log Ks are more reliable.
As detailed in section 5.1, ab initio MD simulations are able to accurately predict, to a
semiquantitative level, the nature and relative stabilities of the predominant Zn(II)
complexes up to high pressures and temperatures. In practice, thermodynamic properties for
these complexes are required to simulate (i) the gradients in minerals solubilities occurring
through complex processing (e.g., fluid mixing, fluid-rock interaction, cooling, phase
separation) and (ii) the amount of Zn that can be transported under specific conditions. In
many studies, gradients are the key result of reactive transport calculations, since these
determine, for example, where ore deposition or scaling will occur. Approximations of
amounts (mass balance) within one order of magnitude are accurate enough in many
applications. In order to test the ability of the thermodynamic properties obtained from the
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
107
MD simulations to provide useful information for reactive transport modeling, we
extrapolated MRB parameters from the MD results. These MD-based properties were then
used to calculate the mineral solubilities in the experiments of Ruaya and Seward (1986)
and Bourcier and Barnes (1987) (Fig. 4.17).
Figure 4.17 Fit of the experimental data of Bourcier and Barnes (1987) and Ruaya and
Seward (1987) based on parameters extrapolated from the MD results. Red circles represent
experimental data and the lines represent fitted data.
The MD-derived properties reproduce accurately the gradients in ZnCO3(s) and ZnO(s)
solubilities with [Cl–] measured by Bourcier and Barnes (1987) at 100-350 °C. At
temperatures of 100, 150, 200 °C, the amount of total dissolved Zn predicted by MD-based
properties is up to one order of magnitude difference from experiments data; at 350 °C, this
difference is significantly smaller (factor ~2). The overestimated Zn(II) solubility may be
caused by the overestimation of the stability of ZnCl42–, as MD gives relatively high value
10 100 10110
10
10
100
Zn_t
ot [m
]
10 100 1010
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
10010
10
10
10
Ag_t
ot [m
]
R&S1986 @ 100
1000
0.4
0.6
0.8
10 100 10110
10
10
100
10 100 1010
0.4
0.6
0.8
10010
10
10
10
10 100 10110
10
10
100
10 100 1010
0.4
0.6
0.8
10010
10
10
1000
0.4
0.6
0.8
10010
10
100
1000
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
10010
10
10
100
1000
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
Zn
–
4
1000
0.4
0.6
0.8
!"# !$# !%# !&#
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
108
of log Ks for ZnCl42– (Table 4.6). For R&S data, the Ag solubilities calculated using the
MD-retrieved parameters shows good agreement (within experimental uncertainty) at high
[Cl–] of > 1 m. It is noticeable that the new fit for both B&B and R&S are very close to the
experimental data at 350 °C.
4.6 Acknowledgement
Research funding was provided by the Australian Research Council (ARC) to JB
(DP0878903), and the Minerals Down Under Flagship to WL. We are grateful to T. Seward
and W. Bourcier for discussing their experimental solubility data. The MD calculations
were supported by iVEC through the use of advanced computing resources located in Perth,
Australia, and the computational facilities of the Advanced Computing Research Centre in
University of Bristol, UK. This paper is part of Yuan Mei’s PhD thesis. YM acknowledges
the University of Adelaide for IPRS scholarship and CSIRO Minerals Down Under Flagship
for a scholarship top-up.
4.7 References Anderson, A. J., Mayanovic, R. A., and Bajt, S., 1995. Determination of the local structure
and speciation of zinc in individual hypersaline fluid inclusions by micro-XAFS.
The Canadian Mineralogist 33, 499-508.
Anderson, A. J., Mayanovic, R. A., and Bajt, S., 1998. A microbeam XAFS study of
aqueous chlorozinc complexing to 430 degrees C in fluid inclusions from the
Knaumuehle granitic pegmatite, Saxonian granulite massif, Germany. The Canadian
Mineralogist 36, 511-524.
Anderson, G. M. and Crerar, D. A., 1993. Thermodynamics in geochemistry: The
equilibrium model. Oxford University Press New York.
Bazarkina, E. F., Pokrovski, G. S., Zotov, A. V., and Hazemann, J.-L., 2010. Structure and
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
109
stability of cadmium chloride complexes in hydrothermal fluids. Chemical Geology
276, 1-17.
Bénézeth, P., Palmer, D. A., Wesolowski, D. J., and Xiao, C., 2002. New measurements of
the solubility of zinc oxide from 150 to 350 C. Journal of Solution Chemistry 31,
947-973.
Berendsen, H. J. C., Grigera, J. R., and Straatsma, T. P., 1987. The missing term in effective
pair potentials. The Journal of Physical Chemistry 91, 6269-6271.
Bourcier, W. L. and Barnes, H. L., 1987. Ore solution chemistry; VII, Stabilities of chloride
and bisulfide complexes of zinc to 350 degrees C. Economic Geology 82, 1839-1863.
Brugger, J., 2007. BeerOz, a set of Matlab routines for the quantitative interpretation of
spectrophotometric measurements of metal speciation in solution. Computers &
geosciences 33, 248-261.
Brugger, J., Pring, A., Reith, F., Ryan, C., Etschmann, B., Liu, W. H., O'Neill, B., and
Ngothai, Y., 2010. Probing ore deposits formation: New insights and challenges
from synchrotron and neutron studies. Radiation Physics and Chemistry 79, 151-161.
Bühl, M., Kabrede, H., Diss, R., and Wipff, G., 2006. Effect of Hydration on Coordination
Properties of Uranyl(VI) Complexes. A First-Principles Molecular Dynamics Study.
Journal of the American Chemical Society 128, 6357-6368.
Bühl, M., Sieffert, N., Golubnychiy, V., and Wipff, G., 2008. Density Functional Theory
Study of Uranium(VI) Aquo Chloro Complexes in Aqueous Solution. The Journal of
Physical Chemistry A 112, 2428-2436.
Car, R. and Parrinello, M., 1985. Unified Approach for Molecular Dynamics and Density-
Functional Theory. Physical Review Letters 55, 2471-2474.
Draper, N. R. and Smith, H., 1998. Applied regression analysis. Wiley, New York.
Driesner, T., 2007. The system H2O–NaCl. Part II: Correlations for molar volume, enthalpy,
and isobaric heat capacity from 0 to 1000°C, 1 to 5000bar, and 0 to 1 XNaCl.
Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 71, 4902-4919.
Driesner, T. and Heinrich, C. A., 2007. The system H2O–NaCl. Part I: Correlation formulae
for phase relations in temperature–pressure–composition space from 0 to 1000 °C, 0
to 5000bar, and 0 to 1 XNaCl. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 71, 4880-4901.
Driesner, T., Seward, T. M., and Tironi, I. G., 1998. Molecular dynamics simulation study
of ionic hydration and ion association in dilute and 1 molal aqueous sodium chloride
solutions from ambient to supercritical conditions. Geochimica et Cosmochimica
Acta 62, 3095-3107.
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
110
Harris, D. J., Brodholt, J. P., Harding, J. H., and Sherman, D. M., 2001. Molecular dynamics
simulation of aqueous ZnCl2 solutions. Molecular Physics 99, 825-833.
Harris, D. J., Brodholt, J. P., and Sherman, D. M., 2003. Zinc complexation in hydrothermal
chloride brines: Results from ab initio molecular dynamics calculations. Journal of
Physical Chemistry A 107, 1050-1054.
Helgeson, H. C., 1969. Thermodynamics of hydrothermal systems at elevated temperatures
and pressures. American Journal of Science 267, 729-804.
Helgeson, H. C. and Kirkham, D. H., 1974. Theoretical prediction of the thermodynamic
behavior of aqueous electrolytes at high pressures and temperatures; II, Debye-
Hückel parameters for activity coefficients and relative partial molal properties.
American Journal of Science 274, 1199-1261.
Helgeson, H. C., Kirkham, D. H., and Flowers, G. C., 1981. Theoretical prediction of the
thermodynamic behavior of aqueous electrolytes by high pressures and temperatures;
IV, Calculation of activity coefficients, osmotic coefficients, and apparent molal and
standard and relative partial molal properties to 600 degrees C and 5kb. American
Journal of Science 281, 1249-1516.
Humphrey, W., Dalke, A., and Schulten, K., 1996. VMD: visual molecular dynamics.
Journal of molecular graphics 14, 33-38.
Kielland, J., 1937. Individual activity coefficients of ions in aqueous solutions. Journal of
the American Chemical Society 59, 1675-1678.
Kruh, R. F. and Standley, C. L., 1962. An X-Ray diffraction study of aqueous zinc chloride
solutions. Inorganic Chemistry 1, 941-943.
Laasonen, K., Pasquarello, A., Car, R., Lee, C., and Vanderbilt, D., 1993. Car-Parrinello
molecular dynamics with Vanderbilt ultrasoft pseudopotentials. Physical Review B
47, 10142-10153.
Lin, I. C., Seitsonen, A. P., Tavernelli, I., and Rothlisberger, U., 2012. Structure and
Dynamics of Liquid Water from ab Initio Molecular Dynamics—Comparison of
BLYP, PBE, and revPBE Density Functionals with and without van der Waals
Corrections. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 8, 3902-3910.
Liu, W., Borg, S., Etschmann, B., Mei, Y. and Brugger, J., 2012. An XAS study of
speciation and thermodynamic properties of aqueous zinc bromide complexes at 25-
150 °C. Chemical Geology, 298-299, 57-69.
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
111
Liu, W., Etschmann, B., Foran, G., Shelley, M., and Brugger, J., 2007. Deriving formation
constants for aqueous metal complexes from XANES spectra: Zn2+ and Fe2+ chloride
complexes in hypersaline solutions. American Mineralogist 92, 761-770.
Liu, W., McPhail, D. C., and Brugger, J., 2001. An experimental study of copper(I)-chloride
and copper(I)-acetate complexing in hydrothermal solutions between 50 °C and
250 °C and vapor-saturated pressure. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 65, 2937-
2948.
Liu, X., Lu, X., Wang, R., and Meijer, E. J., 2011. Understanding hydration of Zn2+ in
hydrothermal fluids with ab initio molecular dynamics. Physical Chemistry
Chemical Physics 13, 13305-13309.
Liu, X., Lu, X., Wang, R., and Zhou, H., 2012. Silver speciation in chloride-containing
hydrothermal solutions from first principles molecular dynamics simulations.
Chemical Geology 294–295, 103-112.
Martell, A. E. and Smith, R. M., 1976. Critical stability constants, Vol. 4: Inorganic
complexes. Plenum Press.
Mayanovic, R. A., Anderson, A. J., Bassett, W. A., and Chou, I., 1999. XAFS
measurements on zinc chloride aqueous solutions from ambient to supercritical
conditions using the diamond anvil cell. Journal of Synchrotron Radiation 6, 195-
197.
Mei, Y., Sherman, D. M., Liu, W., and Brugger, J., 2013a. Ab initio molecular dynamics
simulation and free energy exploration of copper(I) complexation by chloride and
bisulfide in hydrothermal fluids. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 102, 45-64.
Mei, Y., Sherman, D. M., Liu, W., and Brugger, J., 2013b. Complexation of gold in S3--rich
hydrothermal fluids: Evidence from ab-initio molecular dynamics simulations.
Chemical Geology 347, 34-42.
Nelder, J. A. and Mead, R., 1965. A simplex method for function minimization. The
computer journal 7, 308-313.
Pankratz, L. B., 1982. Thermodynamic properties of elements and oxides. Volume 672 of
Bulletin United States. Bureau of Mines.
Perdew, J. P., Burke, K., and Ernzerhof, M., 1996. Generalized Gradient Approximation
Made Simple. Physical Review Letters 77, 3865-3868.
Pokrovski, G. S., Roux, J., Ferlat, G., Jonchiere, R., Seitsonen, A. P., Vuilleumier, R., and
Hazemann, J.-L., 2013. Silver in geological fluids from in situ X-ray absorption
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
112
spectroscopy and first-principles molecular dynamics. Geochimica et Cosmochimica
Acta 106, 501-523.
Preis, W., Königsberger, E., and Gamsjäger, H., 2000. Solid-solute phase equilibria in
aqueous solution. XII. Solubility and thermal decomposition of smithsonite. Journal
of solution chemistry 29, 605-618.
Resat, H. M., Mihaly, 1993. Studies on free energy calculations. I. Thermodynamic
integration using a polynomial path. The Journal of Chemical Physics 99, 6052-6061.
Ruaya, J. and Seward, T., 1986. The stability of chlorozinc (II) complexes in hydrothermal
solutions up to 350 C. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 50, 651-661.
Ruaya, J. R. and Seward, T. M., 1987. The ion-pair constant and other thermodynamic
properties of HCl up to 350°C. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 51, 121-130.
Ryzhenko, B., Bryzgalin, O., Artamkina, I. Y., Spasennykh, M. Y., and Shapkin, A., 1985.
An electrostatic model for the electrolytic dissociation of inorganic substances
dissolved in water. Geochem. Intern 22, 138-144.
Seward, T. M. and Barnes, H. L., 1997. Metal transport by hydrothermal ore fluids. In:
Barnes, H. L. (Ed.), Geochemistry of Hydrothermal Ore Deposits. Wiley, New York.
Sharps, J. A., Brown Jr, G. E., and Stebbins, J. F., 1993. Kinetics and mechanism of ligand
exchange of Au (III), Zn(II), and Cd(II) chlorides in aqueous solution: An NMR
study from 28–98°C. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 57, 721-731.
Sherman, D. M., 2007. Complexation of Cu+ in Hydrothermal NaCl Brines: Ab initio
molecular dynamics and energetics. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 71, 714-722.
Sherman, D. M. and Collings, M. D., 2002. Ion association in concentrated NaCl brines
from ambient to supercritical conditions: results from classical molecular dynamics
simulations. Geochemical Transactions 3, 102-107.
Shvarov, Y. V. and Bastrakov, E., 1999. HCh: a software package for geochemical
equilibrium modelling. User’s Guide Record/25 (Australian Geological Survey
Organisation, Canberra, 1999).
Smith, D. E. and Dang, L. X., 1994. Computer simulations of NaCl association in
polarizable water. The Journal of Chemical Physics 100, 3757-3766.
Smith, R. M. and Martell, A. E., 1976. Critical stability constants, Vol. 4: inorganic
complexes. Plenum Press.
Sprik, M., 1998. Coordination numbers as reaction coordinates in constrained molecular
dynamics. Faraday Discussions 110, 437-445.
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
113
Sprik, M. and Ciccotti, G., 1998. Free energy from constrained molecular dynamics.
Journal of Chemical Physics 109, 7737-7744
Sverjensky, D., Shock, E., and Helgeson, H., 1997. Prediction of the thermodynamic
properties of aqueous metal complexes to 1000 °C and 5 kb. Geochimica et
Cosmochimica Acta 61, 1359-1412.
Tagirov, B. R., Zotov, A. V., and Akinfiev, N. N., 1997. Experimental study of dissociation
of HCl from 350 to 500 °C and from 500 to 2500 bars: Thermodynamic properties
of HCl°(aq). Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 61, 4267-4280.
Tossell, J. A., 1991. Calculations of the structures, stabilities, and Raman and zinc NMR
spectra of zinc aqua chloride ZnCln(OH2)a2-n species in aqueous solution. The
Journal of Physical Chemistry 95, 366-371.
Wesolowski, D. J., Bénézeth, P., and Palmer, D. A., 1998. ZnO Solubility and Zn2
Complexation by Chloride and Sulfate in Acidic Solutions to 290 °C with In-Situ pH
Measurement. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 62, 971-984.
Yardley, B.W.D. (2005) Metal concentrations in crustal fluids and their relationship to ore
formation. Economic Geology, 100, 613-632.
Zotov, A. V., Kudrin, A. V., Levin, K. A., Shikina, N. D., and Var’yash, L. N., 1995.
Experimental studies of the solubility and complexing of selected ore elements (Au,
Ag, Cu, Mo, As, Sb, Hg) in aqueous solutions, Fluids in the Crust. Springer.
CHAPTER 4. Zn(II)-Cl COMPLEXATION
114
115
_____________________________________
Chapter 5
Metal complexation and ion hydration in low density
hydrothermal fluids:
ab initio molecular dynamics simulation of Cu(I) and Au(I)
in chloride solutions (25-1000 °C, 1-5000 bar)
Yuan Mei1, 2,*, Weihua Liu2, David M. Sherman3 and Joël Brugger1,4,*
1Tectonics, Resources and Exploration (TRaX), School of Earth and Environmental Sciences, The
University of Adelaide, Adelaide, SA 5005, Australia
2CSIRO Earth Science and Resource Engineering, Clayton, VIC 3168, Australia
3School of Earth Sciences, University of Bristol, Bristol, BS8 1RJ, UK
4South Australian Museum, North Terrace, SA 5000, Australia
_____________________________________
116
!"#"$%$&"'()'*+",(-.,/0' 1/"2$'()'3#0$-' 4(&'#..(5/#"/(&'#&6'%$"#2'5(%02$7#"/(&' /&' 2(8'6$&./"9',96-(",$-%#2' )2+/6.:'#;' /&/"/('%(2$5+2#-'
69&#%/5.'./%+2#"/(&'()'<+=4>'#&6'*+=4>'/&'5,2(-/6$'.(2+"/(&.'=?@ABCCC'D<E'BA@CCC';#->'
3+;2/5#"/(&'!"#"+.''
'
3+;2/5#"/(&'F$"#/2.' G$/E'HIE'J/+E'KIE'!,$-%#&E'FI'GIE'#&6'L-+MM$-E'NIE' 4(&'#..(5/#"/(&'#&6'%$"#2'5(%02$7#"/(&' /&'2(8' 6$&./"9' ,96-(",$-%#2' )2+/6.:' #;' /&/"/('%(2$5+2#-' 69&#%/5.' ./%+2#"/(&' ()'<+=4>' #&6' *+=4>' /&'5,2(-/6$'.(2+"/(&.' =?@ABCCC'D<E'BA@CCC';#->E'!+;%/""$6' "('O$(5,/%/5#'$"'<(.%(5,/%/5#'*5"#E'+&6$-'-$P/$8''
'
!"#$%&'(%)#&*+"#*%),'L9' ./M&/&M' ",$' !"#"$%$&"' ()' *+",(-.,/0E' $#5,' #+",(-' 5$-"/)/$.' ",#"' ",$/-' ."#"$6' 5(&"-/;+"/(&' "(' ",$' 0+;2/5#"/(&' /.' #55+-#"$' #&6' ",#"'0$-%/../(&'/.'M-#&"$6')(-'",$'0+;2/5#"/(&'"(';$'/&52+6$6'/&'",$'5#&6/6#"$Q.'",$./.I'
R#%$'()'<(A*+",(-' H+#&'G$/'
<(&"-/;+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' F$P$2(0$6'5(%0+"#"/('%$",(6.'#&6'5(&6+5"$6'#22'%(2$5+2#-'./%+2#"/(&.I'L+/2"'M$(5,$%/5#2'%(6$2'#&6'8-("$'%#&+.5-/0"I'
!/M&#"+-$'
'
F#"$' ?SAN+2ABT'
'
R#%$'()'<(A*+",(-' K$/,+#'J/+'
<(&"-/;+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$6'8/",';+/26/&M'M$(5,$%/5#2'%(6$2'#&6'%#&+.5-/0"'$P#2+#"/(&I'
!/M&#"+-$'
'
F#"$' ?SAN+2ABT'
'
R#%$'()'<(A*+",(-' F#P/6'G'!,$-%#&'
<(&"-/;+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$6'8/",'6$P$2(0/&M'5(%0+"#"/('%$",(6.'#&6'%#&+.5-/0"'$P#2+#"/(&I'
'
!/M&#"+-$'
'
F#"$' ?SAN+2ABT'
'
R#%$'()'<(A*+",(-' N(U2'L-+MM$-'
'<(&"-/;+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$6'8/",';+/26/&M'M$(5,$%/5#2'%(6$2'#&6'%#&+.5-/0"'$P#2+#"/(&I'*5"/&M'#.'5((-$.0(&6/&M'#+",(-I''
!/M&#"+-$'
'
F#"$' ?SAN+2ABT'
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
117
Metal complexation and ion hydration in low density
hydrothermal fluids:
ab initio molecular dynamics simulation of Cu(I) and
Au(I) in chloride solutions (25-1000 °C, 1-5000 bar)
Yuan Meia,b, Weihua Liub, David M Shermanc and Joël Bruggera,d
a Tectonics, Resources and Exploration (TRaX), School of Earth and Environmental
Sciences, The University of Adelaide, Adelaide, SA 5005, Australia
b CSIRO Earth Science and Resource Engineering, Clayton, VIC 3168, Australia
c School of Earth Sciences, University of Bristol, Bristol, BS8 1RJ, UK
d South Australian Museum, North Terrace, SA 5000, Australia
*Corresponding author: [email protected]
US English
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
118
5.0 Abstract Low-density supercritical fluids are suspected of being able to transport metals, but it is
unclear what the speciation/complexation would be in such conditions. In this work, we
used ab initio molecular dynamics simulations to investigate the complexation and ion
association of Au+ and Cu+ in NaCl fluids as a function of solution density, from ambient to
supercritical conditions (to 1000 ˚C, 5000 bar). Cu(I) and Au(I) form distorted linear
complexes with two chloride ligands (i.e., CuCl2– and AuCl2
–) in subcritical chloride brines.
We have discovered that these charged complexes remain in high density supercritical fluids
even at high temperature; however, with decreasing density, these complexes become
progressively neutralized by ion association with Na+ to form low-charge (NanCuCl2)n-1 and
(NanAuCl2)n-1 complexes. In these species, the Na+ ion is very weakly bonded in the outer
coordination sphere, resulting in highly disordered structures and fast (few picoseconds
comparing to exchange rate of ns to "s for the aqua- and chloride complexes of transitions
metals) exchange among coordinated and solvent Na+ ions. Yet, thermodynamic models to
predict the solubility of metals in low-density magmatic or metamorphic fluids must
account for these species. In addition, we found that the number of water molecules (i.e., the
hydration number) surrounding the Cu+, Au+, Na+ and Cl– ions decreases linearly when fluid
density decreases, supporting empirical thermodynamic models that correlate the stability
constants of complexation reactions with solvent density. The traditional Born-Model
description explains the ion association as resulting from the decreased dielectric constant of
the solvent. However at a molecular level, the increase in translational entropy associated
with ion dehydration is the main contributor to changes of the solvation properties of
aqueous fluids at high P, T.
Keywords: molecular dynamics, hydrothermal fluids, coordination spheres, hydration,
aqueous metal complexes, translational entropy, gold and copper deposits.
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
119
5.1 Introduction
5.1.1 Controls on metal solubility in hydrothermal fluids
Investigating metal speciation and solubility of minerals in hydrothermal fluids is important
for understanding the mobility of metals in geological fluids (e.g., leading to the formation
of hydrothermal ore deposits) and in engineered systems (e.g., geothermal production wells;
hydrometallurgy; corrosion in power plants). To accurately model the dissolution, transport
and deposition of metals from hydrothermal fluids, one needs to know the identity,
stoichiometry and thermodynamic properties of aqueous metals species under wide ranges
of temperature, pressure and fluid composition. In popular numerical modeling packages,
changes in free energy of the complexes are calculated using semi-empirical equations,
based on electrostatic theory and empirical correlations with bulk solvent properties such as
density and Dielectric Constant (DC; e.g., Debye and Hückel 1923; Helgeson and Kirkham,
1974). For metal transport under hydrothermal conditions, much of our understanding relies
on mineral solubility data, conducted under limited ranges of conditions, and providing
mostly a macroscopic understanding. Over the past 30 years, these data have been
complemented by a growing number of in situ spectroscopic studies, in particular X-ray
absorption spectroscopy (XAS), that provide us with a molecular-level understanding of
metal speciation over a wide range of conditions (reviews in Brugger et al. 2010; Seward
and Driesner 2004). In addition, with the advance of supercomputing technology and
computational chemistry, molecular dynamics simulations are also providing us with a
deeper insight into the molecular-level structures, dynamics, and energetics of fluids and
solutes (e.g., Driesner, 1998; Liu et al., 2011b; Mei et al., 2013a,b; Sherman, 2007, 2010).
The description of solution chemistry and mineral solubility in hydrothermal systems relies
on the concept of aqueous metal complexes and their coordination structure. A coordination
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
120
complex (also called ‘inner sphere complex’, or ‘contact ion pair’) consists of an ion
surrounded by bound molecules known as ligands (e.g., Co(II)Cl42-). In general, a central
atom and its ligand are bonded by covalent bonds. Depending on the nature and strength of
these bonds, coordination complexes can have more or less rigid geometries. For example,
for divalent transition metals, UV-Vis and XAS studies have shown that with increasing
temperature, the metal chloride complexes show a transition from octahedral to tetrahedral-
like structures, with a reduction in the number of coordinated waters and an increase in the
number of halide ligands (e.g., Bazarkina et al. 2010; Hoffman et al., 1999; Liu et al., 2007;
2011a; 2012a; Susak and Crerar, 1985; Testemale et al., 2009; Tian et al., 2012). An outer-
sphere complex (also known as ‘solvent-shared ion-pair’) denotes a complex between a
solvated complex and an anion or cation (e.g., [Co(III)(NH3)6]Cl3(aq), where 6 NH3 are
bonded in the inner sphere and 3 Cl- in the outer sphere; House 2012). The interactions
between the central atom and the ions in the outer sphere are primarily electrostatic.
Outer-sphere complexes are often difficult to characterize experimentally under
hydrothermal conditions, but the formation of outer-sphere complexes is one of the major
factors affecting metal solubilities with increasing temperature and decrease in fluid
densities. In general, the formation of neutral complexes at high temperature or low fluid
density (e.g., vapor) is explained in terms of low DC of the solvent (e.g., Barnes 1997). In
fluids with low DC, charged species become rather unstable, and the formation of outer-
sphere complexes (e.g., CuCl2– + Na+ = CuCl2Na(aq)) provides a mechanism that can
account for high metal contents in low DC hydrothermal fluids (Zajacz et al., 2011).
Water itself can act as a ligand, forming aqua ions and coordination complexes (e.g.,
octahedral Co(H2O)62+; tetrahedral CoCl2(H2O)2(aq); Liu et al. 2011a). Coordination
complexes are associated through hydrogen bonding with other water molecules in a
secondary solvation shell. This second solvation shell is usually highly disordered, but it can
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
121
play a first order role in controlling mineral solubility. For example, the XAS study by Liu
et al. (2008) showed that the solubility of CuCl(s) (nantokite) near the critical density of
water at 420 °C, 290-400 bar is explained with a [H2O-Cu-Cl](aq) complex hydrated by
approximately two additional water molecules in the second coordination shell. In water
vapor, the fugacity of water (
!
f H2O) appears to control metal transport and mineral solubility
(Archibald et al., 2001; 2002; Williams-Jones et al., 2002); hence the hydration of ions is
important in understanding the metal speciation and transport for both vapors and
supercritical fluids.
5.1.2 Complexing and hydration of Cu(I) and Au(I) in hydrothermal brines
and vapors
The Cu(I) and Au(I) ions share a d10 electronic structure, and linear halide and hydrosulfide
complexes of these two ions prevail over a wide range of temperature, pressure and salinity.
For Cu(I)-Cl complexes, early solubility studies (Crerar et al., 1978; Hemley et al., 1992;
Seyfried and Ding 1993) suggested a neutral CuCl(aq); however in situ XAS measurements
of natural and synthetic fluid inclusions (Berry et al., 2006; Mavrogenes et al., 2002) and
model solutions (Brugger et al., 2007; Fulton et al., 2000a,b), backed up by molecular
dynamic simulations (Mei et al., 2013a; Sherman, 2007), all pointed to linear species
(CuCl2–) being predominant up to 600 °C. The CuCl(aq) complex also has a linear structure
([H2O-Cu-Cl](aq)), with an oxygen atom from a water molecule in the first shell (Fulton et
al., 2000a,b; Liu et al. 2008; Sherman 2007). Similarly, the predominant Au species in
chloride solutions at elevated temperatures also has a linear structure (AuCl2–; Pokrovski et
al., 2009; Stefánsson and Seward, 2003).
In the past decade, a considerable number of experiments have been carried out to
investigate Cu(I) and Au(I) solubility in water vapor, and partitioning between
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
122
liquid/vapor/melt (e.g., Archibald et al., 2001, 2002; Etschmann et al., 2010; Frank et al.
2011; Lerchbaumer and Audétat 2012; Liu et al., 2008; Pokrovski et al., 2005; Rempel et
al., 2012; Simon et al., 2005, 2006; Zajacz et al., 2010, 2011). In particular, a few studies
have investigated the identity and hydration of Cu(I) and Au(I) species in the vapor and low
density supercritical phases. Archibald et al. (2001) conducted Au solubility experiments in
subcritical, HCl-bearing water vapor at 300-360 °C and 144 bar, and suggested five
(300 °C) and three (360 °C) water molecules around AuCl(g). A sister study of Cu(I)
solubility (Archibald et al., 2002) found 7.6 and 6.1 waters around a Cu3Cl3(aq) cluster at
320 and 280 °C, respectively. Liu et al. (2008) concluded that the solubility of nantokite
(CuCl(s)) in supercritical water across the critical isochore (density of 0.19–0.42 g/cm3) at
420 °C, 290-400 bar, is explained by a [H2O-Cu-Cl](aq) complex with two extra water
molecules in the second shell. Zezin et al. (2007; 2011) suggested AuS(H2O)n in H2S-water
with n = 2.3 at 300 °C and 2.2 at 365 °C. Zajacz et al., (2010; 2011) conducted solubility
experiments to investigate Au and Cu transport in magmatic volatile phases (1000 °C,
1500 bar). They suggested on the basis of solubility measurements backed by static
quantum chemical calculations that Au(I) and Cu(I) are transported as neutral species in
high T, low density supercritical-magmatic fluids, due to the formation of outer-sphere
complexes with alkali ions (e.g., neutral complexes NaAuCl2(aq), NaAu(HS)2(aq) and
NaCuCl2(aq)). Such outer sphere alkali complexing increased the solubility of Au and Cu in
high-T chloride and/or H2S bearing vapors by a factor of up to over an order of magnitude
compared to that in alkali-chloride free fluids (Zajacz et al., 2010; 2011).
5.1.3 Computational chemistry studies of metal speciation
A few previous studies have used classical MD to predict the physical and chemical
properties of NaCl fluids, such as densities, ion pairing and ion hydration, conductance,
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
123
phase diagram, and DC (Chialvo and Simonson, 2003; Cui and Harris, 1995; Driesner et al.,
1998; Giberti et al., 2013; Hassan, 2011; John, 1998; Lee et al., 1998; Oelkers and
Helgeson, 1993; Sherman and Collings, 2002; Smith and Dang, 1994; Zahn, 2004). In
classical MD, the atomic interactions are described using empirical inter-atomic potentials
(e.g., Lennard-Jones potentials; Verlet, 1967). Classical MD has been applied with great
success to predict the properties of solutions of alkali and alkaline earth metals, for which
electrostatic interactions are predominant. For example, Driesner et al. (1998) investigated
the change of ion pairing, hydration and bond distances as functions of temperature,
pressure and fluid density in NaCl solutions from ambient to supercritical conditions.
However, to investigate complexation and hydration of transition metals such as Cu(I) and
Au(I), interatomic interactions cannot be accurately accounted for by simple pairwise
models (Sherman, 2010). One option is to use ab initio MD, in which atomic interactions
are treated following the principles of quantum mechanics. Density functional theory (DFT)
is a popular approximation method for solving the Kohn-Sham equation. For Cu(I) and
Au(I), recent studies have shown that static DFT calculations provide good agreement with
experiments for the structure (geometry and bond distances) of Cu(I) and Au(I) chloride
complexes (Pokrovski et al. 2009; Zajacz et al. 2011). However, such “static” quantum
chemical calculations are conducted in the ideal gas phase, and are not able to sample the
configuration degrees of freedom as required in simulation of condensed fluids as a function
of pressure and temperature. In the present study, we used the ab initio Car-Parrinello MD
method, which solves the classical equations of motion as in classical MD, but treats the
inter-atomic interactions quantum mechanically using DFT (Car and Parrinello, 1985). In
the past few years, ab initio MD has been employed to predict the aqueous speciation and
hydration number of transition metals with d10 electronic structure; for example, Zn(II)-Cl
(Harris et al., 2003), Cu(I)-Cl (Sherman, 2007), Au(I)-HS (Liu et al., 2011b), Ag(I)-Cl (Liu
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
124
et al., 2012b; Pokrovski et al., 2013), Cu-HS-Cl (Mei et al., 2013a), Au(I)-HS/OH/S3 (Mei
et al., 2013b). These studies report excellent agreement between the predicted nature and
geometry of the complexes and available experimental studies. In a breakthrough study, Mei
et al. (2013a) also demonstrated that thermodynamic properties for important Cu(I) chloride
and bisulfide complexes can be derived from ab initio MD simulations; the properties
compare well with the experimental ones, and, most importantly, enable accurate
predictions of the mineral solubility gradients as a function of P, T and solution
composition. Altogether, these recent studies show that ab initio MD methods have come of
age for the simulation of transition metals in aqueous fluids over a wide P, T range.
Accurate MD simulations provide a unique tool to address the lack of systematic
investigation of the dependence of complexation and hydration of these species on
macroscopic parameters such as fluid density, over conditions varying from liquid-like to
vapor-like. The MD results allow us to explore the molecular-level mechanisms affecting
Cu(I) and Au(I) chloride complexing and solvation as a function of changes in temperature
and solution density.
5.1.4 Aim of study
This paper uses ab initio molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to quantify the effects of P
and T (as the main parameters affecting solution density and DC of the solvent) on the
complexation and hydration of metal complexes. We chose Cu(I) and Au(I) chloride
complexes because of the large amount of experimental and MD studies available on these
systems; the high level of agreement between experimental and MD results demonstrates
the accuracy of the MD methods used in this study. In addition, Cu(I) and Au(I) form inner
sphere [MCl2–] coordination complexes that are stable over wide ranges in P, T and solution
composition, providing an ideal model system to study the effect of the complexation and
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
125
hydration within the outer coordination sphere as a function of T and P, in the liquid phase
as well as in the supercritical phase, with solution densities ranging from liquid-like
(1.2 g/cm3) to vapor-like (0.1 g/cm3). Specifically, we want to investigate 1) if and under
what conditions the linear CuCl2– and AuCl2
– chloride complexes are actually paired with
another cation (e.g., Na+) to form a neutral outer sphere complex; and 2) if and how the
hydration numbers of Au(I) and Cu(I) (as well as Na+ and Cl–) change with fluid density
and temperature.
5.2 Method: Ab initio molecular dynamics simulations
5.2.1 Computational methods
Ab initio MD simulations of Cu(I) and Au(I) complexes at different densities (i.e., P, T
conditions) were performed using the Car-Parrinello MD code “CPMD” (Car and
Parrinello, 1985), which implements DFT using a plane-wave basis set and pseudo-
potentials for the core electrons plus the nucleus. The PBE exchange correlation-functional
(Perdew et al., 1996) was employed with a cutoff of gradient correction 5$10-5. Plane-wave
cutoffs of 25 Ry (340.14 eV) were used together with Vanderbilt ultrasoft pseudo-potentials
in CPMD package (Laasonen et al., 1993). A time-step of 3 a.u. (0.073 fs) was used to
stabilize the simulations. The MD simulations were conducted in an NVT ensemble (i.e.
constant composition, volume and temperature). Temperatures were controlled by a Nosé
thermostat for both the ions and electrons. Most simulations contained four Cl–, one Au+ or
one Cu+, and three Na+ atoms to balance the charge in the solution. The pressures of the
simulated systems were evaluated using the equation-of-state of NaCl solutions as
implemented in the SOWAT code (Driesner, 2007; Driesner and Heinrich, 2007) based on a
total equivalent NaCl salinity of 4 molal. To obtain time averages of the geometric and
stoichiometric information, radial distribution functions (RDF) and their integrals (related to
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
126
coordination number) for different atom pairs were calculated by VMD (Humphrey et al,
1996).
Although the formal Cu or Au concentrations are one molal, the simulations represent dilute
solutions with respect to Cu or Au (no Cu-Cu or Au-Au interaction), because there is only
one Cu or Au atom in each box. Most of the simulation systems listed in Tables 5.1 and 5.2
are under-saturated with respect to NaCl(s), except for some low-density fluids for which
the NaCl concentrations exceed the solubility limit. For instance, the solubility of NaCl(s)
reaches only 1.04 molal at 1000 °C, 1500 bar. In theory, the chloride concentration needs to
be diluted by adding more water in the simulation box to represent the real fluid. But in
practice, as discussed by Mei et al. (2013a), increasing the number of particles increases the
simulation time dramatically, causing simulations to become prohibitively costly in terms of
computing time.
Table 5.1 Simulation details and geometrical properties of Cu-Cl complexes in a box
containing 1 Cu+, 3 Na+, 4 Cl- and 55 H2O. Time step is 3 a.u. (0.0726 fs). All the
simulations were preformed for more than 29 picoseconds (400,000 steps)
T (˚C)
P (bar)*
Box size (Å)
Density (g/cm3)
Simulation time (ps) Stoichiometry¶
dCu-Cl (Å)
dNa-O
(Å) dCl-O (Å)
Cl-Cu-Cl angle(˚)
25 1 12.110 1.18 42.81 [CuCl3]–2 2.21 2.38 3.16 -
300 500 13.034 0.95 29.86 [CuCl2Na0.26]–0.74 2.11 2.35 3.22 164.6(7.7)
300 1000 12.886 0.98 29.02 [CuCl2Na0.13]–0.87 2.12 2.34 3.21 163.5(9.9)
300 2000 12.683 1.03 29.02 [CuCl2Na0.09]–0.91 2.12 2.35 3.24 164.7(8.4)
500 600 14.658 0.67 29.02 [CuCl2Na0.25]–0.75 2.12 2.35 3.26 160.3(11.7)
500 1000 14.030 0.76 29.02 [CuCl2Na0.28]–0.72 2.12 2.34 3.26 161.2(10.1)
500 2000 13.434 0.87 29.86 [CuCl2Na0.16]–0.84 2.11 2.35 3.24 161.1(11.3)
1000 1500 19.290 0.29 29.75 [CuCl2Na0.68]–0.32 2.11 2.35 3.32 153.6(14.9)
1000 2500 15.609 0.55 29.60 [CuCl2Na0.31]–0.69 2.14 2.33 3.34 157.0(12.3)
1000 5000 14.128 0.74 34.32 [CuCl2Na0.41]–0.59 2.13 2.33 3.31 157.1(13.7)
* Evaluated from the equation-of-state of NaCl fluids at the same ionic strength using the SoWat code (Driesner, 2007; Driesner and Heinrich, 2007).
¶ Based on the number of Na atoms within 4 Å of a Cu atom.
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
127
In this study, an ab initio MD simulation of the Cu-Cl system with 173 particles (55 H2O,
1 Cu+, 3 Na+, 4 Cl–, reflecting [Cl–] of 4 molal) at a density of 0.29 g/cm3 (box size 19.29 Å)
required ~750 CPU hours per picosecond, while a simulation involving 341 particles (111
H2O, 1 Cu+, 3 Na+, 4 Cl–, reflecting [Cl–] of 2 molal) cost more than 3,500 CPU hours for
one picosecond.
Table 5.2 Simulation details and geometrical properties of Au-Cl complexes in a box with
1 Au+, 3 Na+, 4 Cl- and 55 H2O. Time step is 3 a.u. (0.0726 fs). All the simulations were
preformed for more than 29 picoseconds (400,000 steps)
T (˚C)
P (bar)*
Box size (Å)
Density (g/cm3)
Simulation time (ps) Stoichiometry¶
dAu-Cl (Å)
dNa-O
(Å) dCl-O (Å)
Cl-Au-Cl angle(˚)
300 500 13.034 1.05 32.65 [AuCl2Na0.21]–0.79 2.28 2.35 3.25 169.5(5.4)
500 600 14.658 0.74 32.43 [AuCl2Na0.29]–0.71 2.27 2.35 3.27 166.7(7.2)
500 2000 13.434 0.96 32.65 [AuCl2Na0.24]–0.76 2.29 2.35 3.27 167.1(7.1)
1000 1500 19.290 0.32 31.93 [AuCl2Na0.50]–0.50 2.32 2.34 3.32 159.2(10.7)
1000 2500 15.609 0.61 33.38 [AuCl2Na0.30]–0.70 2.30 2.33 3.32 162.9(8.8)
1000 5000 14.128 0.82 32.65 [AuCl2Na0.32]–0.68 2.30 2.34 3.32 163.8(9.6)
* Evaluated from the equation-of-state for NaCl fluids at the same ionic strength using the SoWat code (Driesner, 2007; Driesner and Heinrich, 2007).
¶ Based on the number of Na atoms within 4 Å of a Au atom.
Two simulations at the same density (Cu-Cl system at the density of 0.29 g/cm3) but with
different numbers of water molecules (55 vs. 111) were conducted to test the impact of box
size on the results. The Cu-Na and Cl-Na pair distribution functions (Fig. 5.1a) show
different intensities because in the simulation with the larger box, the Cu+, Cl– and Na+ ions
are diluted compared with the MD of the smaller box. However, the RDF integrals showing
the number of Na+ surrounding the Cu+/Cl– ions for both simulations overlap, indicating a
small effect of the box size and dilution of the salt concentration from 4 to 2 molal.
Similarly, the hydration numbers of Na+ and Cl– in the simulations with different box sizes
agree well (Fig. 5.1b). Since the number of oxygens is about the same in a unit box (same
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
128
solution density), the interactions of water with Cl- and Na+ are expected to be independent
from the box size. The slight differences in the integrals of RDF result in calculated
hydration number that are still very close (error <0.2) within a distance of 3 Å for Na-O and
3.6 Å for Cl-O (see 5.3.3 for choosing distance cut-off); these differences represent the
magnitude of the uncertainty for the hydration number in our calculations, related mainly to
the finite calculation time. Since the simulation of the smaller box is able to represent the
features in the bigger box, we conducted simulations with 55 H2O. To observe the behavior
of the charge-balanced ions (Na+) in the second-shell, long runs (> 20 ps) are necessary,
since the atoms in the second-shell are more disordered than those in the first-shell.
Figure 5.1 Small box vs. large box: the differences on RDF (left axes, solid curves) and
coordination number (right axes, dashed curves).
4
3
2
1
0
RD
F
54321Pair distance (Å)
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
Hydration num
ber
Na-O Cl-O
(b)
80
60
40
20
0
RD
F
654321
5
4
3
2
1
0
Coordination num
ber
Cu-Na Cl-Na
thick lines: small box (1Cu + 3Na + 4Cl + 55H2O) thin lines: large box (1Cu + 3Na + 4Cl + 111H2O)
(a)
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
129
5.2.2 Choice of model systems for comparison with experimental studies
In addition to the simulations aimed at exploring systematically the effect of solution
density on the complexation and hydration of Au(I) and Cu(I) chlorocomplexes (Tables 5.1
and 5.2), five simulations were conducted at different T, P corresponding to specific
experimental studies for direct comparison (Table 5.3).
Table 5.3 Simulation details for runs aimed at comparing with experimental studies.
No. Simulation box T (˚C)
P (bar)‡
Box size (Å)
Density (g/cm3) Stoichiometry dCu/Au-Cl
(Å) dCu/Au-O
(Å) Angle
(˚)
1* 1Cu, 3Na, 4Cl, 55H2O 1000 1500 19.290 0.29 [CuCl2Na0.7]–0.3 2.11 - 155.4(13.4) 2¶ 1Cu, 1Cl, 55H2O 420 290 20.830 0.20 CuCl(H2O)0 2.09 1.93 164.1(8.6) 3¶ 1Cu, 1Cl, 55H2O 420 400 15.808 0.46 CuCl(H2O)0 2.10 1.94 163.1(8.8)
4§ 1Au, 1Cl, 55H2O 340 139§ 27.186 0.10' AuCl(H2O)0 2.23 2.11 168.9(6.0)
5** 1Au, 1Cl, 55H2O 340 139 13.694 0.79 AuCl(H2O)0 2.24 2.08 168.9(6.1)
Reference: *Zajacz et al., 2011; ¶Liu et al., 2008; §Archibald et al., 2001, vapor phase; **Archibald et al., 2001, liquid phase ‡Pressures evaluated from equation-of-state of NaCl fluids at the same ionic strength using the SoWat code (Driesner, 2007; Driesner and Heinrich, 2007). ' Evaluated from the equation-of-state of the vapor phase using the pure water density of 0.082 g/cm3; the density of the AuCl solution is 0.10 g/cm3.
MD Simulation of Cu(I) chloride complexes at a density of 0.29 g/cm3 at 1000 °C,
corresponding to a pressure of 1500 bar (No. 1) were performed to compare with the
experimental study by Zajacz et al. (2011). Simulations 2 and 3 were conducted at 420 °C
and pressures of 290 and 400 bar for comparison with the nantokite solubility, XANES and
EXAFS data of Liu et al. (2008). The fluid densities shown in Table 5.3 are slightly higher
than those listed by Liu et al. (2008), because the MD simulation were conducted at higher
salt concentrations (1 molal Cu and 1 molal Cl) compared with real fluids. It is also notable
that as the simulation box contained only one Cu and one Cl atoms, Cu-Cu and Cl-Cl
interactions are negligible, reflecting the relatively dilute nature of the solutions studied by
Liu et al. (2008). Simulation 4 was performed to compare with the experimental study by
Archibald et al. (2001) of Au chloride solubility in water vapor (340 °C, 139 bar); a solution
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
130
density of 0.10 g/cm3 was chosen by using the pure water density of 0.082 g/cm3 and adding
one Au and Cl atoms to the simulation box (Table 5.3, No. 4). Simulation 5 was conducted
to represent the liquid phase at the same temperature of 340 °C; the density was chosen at
0.79 g/cm3 according to equation-of-state of NaCl fluids at the same ionic strength
(Driesner, 2007; Driesner and Heinrich, 2007). All these simulations were conducted for
more than 29 ps (400,000 simulation steps).
5.3 Results
5.3.1 Cu(I) and Au(I) complexing as a function of solution density and
temperature
MD simulation of Cu-Cl (Table 5.1) at 25 °C gave a three-fold triangular planar complex
CuCl32– with the Cu-Cl distances of 2.21 Å, in accordance with previous experimental
(Brugger et al., 2007; Liu et al., 2008) and theoretical studies (Sherman 2007; Mei et al.,
2013a). At elevated T and P, two-fold distorted linear complexes MCl2– (M=Cu/Au) were
found in simulations of Cu-Cl and Au-Cl solutions, with the Cu-Cl distances of 2.11-2.14 Å
(Table 5.1) and Au-Cl distances of 2.27-2.32 Å (Table 5.2), in good agreement with
previous experimental studies: Cu-Cl distance of 2.152(7) Å by Brugger et al. (2007) and
2.12-2.13 Å by Fulton et al. (2000a,b); Au-Cl distance of 2.27-2.28 Å by Pokrovski et al.
(2009).
The configurations of MCl2– (M=Cu/Au) complexes with surrounding Na+/Cl– ions were
investigated along the simulation time at different P, T conditions to test if and how the
MCl2– complexes form neutral species as a function of fluid density and temperature. The
results show that charged species (i.e., MCl2–) predominate in high-density fluids (
≥ 0.7 g/cm3), even in high-temperature supercritical fluids. In low density fluids, however,
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
131
the probability of forming the neutral species MNaCl2(aq) and larger clusters such as
MNanClm1+n-m increases. Selected snapshots of the Cu-Cl simulation at 1000 °C, 1500 bar
(density 0.29 g/cm3, Table 5.1; Table 5.3, No. 1) reveal that the neutral CuNaCl2(aq) species
does not display a well-characterized geometry (e.g., configurations at 10.97 and 15.8 ps;
Figs. 5.2a,b). The simulation also occasionally shows charged species and larger clusters;
for example at 24.5 ps (Figs. 5.2c,d) the CuCl2– cluster is weakly linked to a NaCl(aq)
cluster. Over the next 0.7 ps, this cluster evolves into a CuNa2Cl3(aq) cluster (Figs. 2d-g). A
similar situation is found for the Na+ ions in this solution; the neutral cluster NaCl(aq) is
present at 10.97 ps (Fig. 5.2a), but at 15.8 ps the Na2Cl2(aq) cluster formed (Fig. 5.2b). At
24.5 ps, the simulation contains a Na2Cl+ cluster in addition to a NaCuCl2(aq) cluster.
Figure 5.2 Cu+ and Na+ local structures at 1000 ˚C, 1500 bar (0.29 g/cm3). (a-c) Selected
snapshots of simulations. (d-g) Example of dynamic transformation of Cu(I) ion pairs.
!"#!!!"#$%"&'(!$(!)*+,-!%"./0$.12!3$45!6!2!0$.1!3$45
!$#!!!"#$%"&'(!$(!)7+8!%"./0$.12!3$45!6!0$2.12!3$45
!%#!!!"#$%"&'(!$(!29+7!%":./.12;<=0$.1!3$45!6!0$2.16
!"
#$
#%
&'()*+,- &'(.)+,- &'(/0+,- &)(&1+,-!"# !$# !%# !&#
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
132
The dynamic distances between the Cu and Na atoms as a function of simulation time also
indicate the extent of Na+ pairing with CuCl2–. The evolutions of Cu-Na distances and
instantaneous coordination numbers for three simulations at three different T, P conditions,
with fluid densities ranging from 0.29 to 1.03 g/cm3 are shown in Figure 5.3.
Figure 5.3 Cu-Na distance vs simulation time (left) and instantaneous coordination number
(distance cutoff = 4 Å) together with running average as a red line (right).
At a density of 0.29 g/cm3 (1000 °C, 1500 bar; Figs. 5.3a,b), there is at least one Na+ ion at
a distance of ~3 to 5 Å from Cu+. The closest Na+ ions exchange at a very fast rate (longest
residence time < 15 ps) comparing with the exchange rates which lie in the ns to "s range
for the aqua- and chloride complexes of transitions metals (Table 11.4 in Burgess 1978;
Sharps et al., 1993). For short periods (< 3 ps), two or three Na+ ions get close to Cu+,
forming large clusters (e.g., Fig. 5.2g). The running average of instantaneous coordination
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
Cu-
Na
dist
ance
(Å)
302520151050
(c)
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0302520151050
Simulation time (ps)
(e)
18
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0302520151050
(a)3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
302520151050
(b)
0.70
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
302520151050
(d)
0.26
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
302520151050
Simulation time (ps)
(f)
0.10
1000˚C, 1500 bar 0.29 g/cm
3
500˚C, 600 bar 0.67 g/cm
3
Instantaneous coordination number
300˚C, 2k bar 1.03 g/cm
3
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
133
number gave an average number of 0.70 Na+ surrounding Cu+ (within 4 Å). In contrast, at
the density of 0.67 g/cm3 (Figs. 5.3c,d), Cu+ and Na+ only bind together occasionally, with
an average of 0.26 Na+ within 4 Å of Cu+. In the simulation at 300 °C, 2000 bar (Figs. 3e,f),
with a density of 1.03 g/cm3, there is less chance for Na+ to complex to Cu+, which is also
confirmed by the instantaneous coordination number (0 is predominant, as shown in
Fig. 5.3f).
Figure 5.4a shows the Cu-Na RDF at different temperatures and densities (solid lines),
together with the integrals of the selected distribution functions, representing the number of
Na+ surrounding Cu+ (NNa(Cu)) (dashed lines). There is a clear trend that the height of the
RDF peak and NNa(Cu) decrease with increasing density. At a density of 0.29 g/cm3
(1000 °C, 1500 bar), there is a large peak between 2.5 and 4.5 Å, and NNa(Cu) is close to one
at the distance of ~4.5 Å. This shows the predominance of the neutral species (e.g.,
CuNaCl2(aq)), although the width of the RDF shows that Na+ is only weakly bound. The
distribution functions of Cu-Na agree with the distance plots shown in Figure 5.3b,
indicating there are more neutral complexes in low-density fluids and more charged
complexes in high-density fluids.
For Au+, the Au-Na RDF and their integrals indicate that an analogous neutral species,
NaAuCl2(aq), predominates at low density (0.32 g/cm3), with an average of 0.5 Na+ within
4 Å of Au+ (Table 5.2). The number of Na+ surrounding Au+ decreases to 0.21 with an
increase of density to 1.05 g/cm3.
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
134
Figure 5.4 Radial distribution functions and the integrals of Cu-Na, Cl-Na, Na-O, Cl-O
pairs at different solution densities (see Table 5.1 for temperatures and pressures).
In addition to the neutral MNaCl2(aq) (M=Cu,Au) complexes, the MD simulations also
show that Na+ and Cl– form a number of neutral ion pairs in low-density fluids (e.g.,
!"#
!"$
%"#
%"$
$"#
$"$
&'()*+,-
#"$."$/"$!"$%"$&'()*01234567*89:
%$
;
<
=
>
#
.
/
!
%
$
?@0A431B5*5CD
E7A*BF*&'
**$"!;*GH6D/
**$"##*GH6D/
**$">=*GH6D/
**$"=.*GH6D/
**$"=>*GH6D/
**$"<=*GH6D/
**$";#*GH6D/
**$";<*GH6D/
**%"$/*GH6D/
**%"%<*GH6D/
.$
/#
/$
!#
!$
%#
%$
#
$
&'(I4*+,-
#"$."$/"$!"$%"$&'(I4*01234567*89:
!"$
%"#
%"$
$"#
$"$
ICDE7A*BF*I
4*2CAABC5070*E@*&'*
***$"!;*GH6D/
***$"##*GH6D/
***$">=*GH6D/
***$"=.*GH6D/
***$"=>*GH6D/
***$"<=*GH6D/
***$";#*GH6D/
***$";<*GH6D/
***%"$/*GH6D/
***%"%<*GH6D/
>
#
.
/
!
%
$
I4()*+,-
."$/"$!"$%"$I4()*01234567*89:
%$
;
<
=
>
#
.
/
!
%
$
?@0A431B5*5CD
E7A*BF*I4
***$"!;*GH6D/
***$"##*GH6D/
***$">=*GH6D/
***$"=.*GH6D/
***$"=>*GH6D/
***$"<=*GH6D/
***$";#*GH6D/
***$";<*GH6D/
***%"$/*GH6D/
***%"%<*GH6D/
%!
%$
<
>
.
!
$
&C(I4*+,-
>#./!%
&C(I4*01234567*89:
!"$
%"#
%"$
$"#
$"$ICDE7A*BF*I
4*2CAABC5070*E@*&C
**$"!;*GH6D/
**$"##*GH6D/
**$">=*GH6D/
**$"=.*GH6D/
**$"=>*GH6D/
**$"<=*GH6D/
**$";#*GH6D/
**$";<*GH6D/
**%"$/*GH6D/
**%"%<*GH6D/
84:
8E:
86:
80:
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
135
Figs. 5.2a,b). Since there are 3 Na+ and 4 Cl– in the simulation box, it would be difficult to
show each Cl-Na distances. Here we calculating the RDF of Cl-Na pairs and the number of
Na+ surrounding Cl– (NNa(Cl)). The RDF peaks of both Cl-Na pairs decrease with an increase
in density, and NNa(Cl) decreases, too (Fig. 5.4b). At 1000 °C, 1500 bar, NNa(Cl) is ~1,
corresponding to the NaCl(aq) species shown in Figure 5.2. In contrast, the Cl-Na RDF peak
almost disappears at room temperature, consistent with the predominance of the Na+ and Cl–
aqua ions. The classical MD simulations of NaCl solutions of Driesner et al. (1998) showed
that aqua ions account for 63.3% Na or Cl at room temperature (density of 1.02 g/cm3); at
380 °C (density of 0.55 g/cm3) this proportion decreases to 12.8%, neutral ion pairs (NaCl0,
Na2Cl20, Na3Cl3
0, Na4Cl40) contribute 49.8% and charged clusters (Na2Cl+, NaCl2
–, Na3Cl2+,
Na2Cl3–, Na4Cl3
+, Na3Cl4–) contribute 37.4% to total solute species. Hence, our ab initio
calculations confirm the results of earlier classical calculations in emphasizing the
importance of the neutral NaCl(aq) species, together with short-lived, larger clusters for
understanding the properties of high temperature brines (Driesner et al., 1998).
To further illustrate the relationship between fluid density and the number of Na+
surrounding Cu(I) and Au(I) complexes (NNa(Cu), NNa(Au)), as well as Na-Cl ion pairing
(NNa(Cl)), quantitative values of NNa(X) were obtained from RDF plots. One problem in
defining NNa(X) is to choose an appropriate distance cutoff. The distance cutoff is usually set
at the shoulder of the integral of the RDF plot, and can vary slightly with temperature (e.g.,
Driesner et al., 1998). In this study, we chose to fix the distance cutoff for all temperatures,
to avoid bias in the temperature trends. A cutoff distance at 3 Å was set for the Cl-Na pair
according to Figure 5.4b, where the shoulder in Cl-Na RDF is clearly seen. For the Cu-Na
distribution function, the RDF peak is not very sharp and the data are affected by significant
noise, making it difficult to define the cutoff distance. Yet we need to find a safe cutoff
distance that includes the possible bonding Cu-Na pairs but excludes the random Na
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
136
movement and the impact of different box size. As shown in Figure 5.4a, the RDF peak
appears at ~3 Å for low densities and ~3.5 Å for high densities. A cutoff distance of 4 Å
was chosen to calculate both NNa(Cu) and NNa(Au).
Plots of number of Na+ surrounding Cu+ or Cl– as a function of density (Fig. 5.5a) show
good linear relationships, with correlation coefficients (R2) of 0.84 for NNa(Cu) and 0.90 for
NNa(Cl). A similar correlation holds for Au, with correlation coefficients of 0.87 for NNa(Au)
and 0.97 for NNa(Cl) (Fig. 5.5b). As the density of NaCl-H2O fluids is well constrained (e.g.,
equation-of-states by Duan et al., 1995; Driesner 2007; Driesner and Heinrich 2007), the
correlations versus solution density were significantly better than the correlation with the
DC of pure water.
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
137
Figure 5.5 The number of Na surrounding Cu/Cl (a) and Au/Cl (b), and the hydration
number of Na/Cl/Cu (c) and Na/Cl/Au (d) as function of solution density
!"#
!"$
!"%
!"&
!"!
'()*+,-./-'0-1(,,.(23425-6(768-9
:
;"&;";;"!!"<!"#!"=!"$!">!"%!"?
@+214AB-957C)?:
- DC-E-%"!-F--DC-E-?"!-F
!"#
!"=
!"$
!">
!"%
!"?
!"&
!";
'()*+,-./-'0-1(,,.(23425-G(768--9
-:
;";;"!!"<!"#!"=!"$!">!"%!"?@+214AB-957C)?:
- --DC-E-%"!-F- ---DC-E-?"!-F
#
=
$
>
%
?
&
;
HB3,0A4.2-2()*+,-./-'076876(
;"&;";;"!!"<!"#!"=!"$!">!"%!"?
@+214AB-957C)?:
-DC-E-?"!-F--DC-E-?"$-F-DC-E-%">-F
=
$
>
%
?
&
;
HB3,0A4.2-2()*+,-./-'07687G(
;";;"!!"<!"#!"=!"$!">!"%!"?@+214AB-957C)?:
- --DC-E-?"!-F- ---DC-E-?"$-F- --DC-E-%">-F
!"#
!$#
!%#
!&#
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
138
5.3.2 Hydration numbers of Na, Cl, Cu and Au
The number of water molecules surrounding Na (Hyd(Na)) and Cl (Hyd(Cl)) increases with
increasing solution density (Figs. 5.4c,d). For example, there are ~5 waters surrounding Na
at a density of 1.18 g/cm3, but the number decreases to ~2 at a density of 0.29 g/cm3
(Figs. 5.4c). The hydration numbers of Na+ and Cl– in Au-Cl solutions gave similar results.
To calculate the hydration of Na+ and Cl–, distances of 3 Å and 3.6 Å, respectively, were
chosen according to the RDF plot (Figs. 5.4c,d). The hydration numbers of Cu+ and Au+
were calculated with a cutoff distance of 4.5 Å. The calculated hydration numbers are
plotted as a function of solution density in Figs. 5.5(c,d). Good linear correlations between
the hydration number of Na+, Cl–, Cu+ and density were obtained. For Cu-Cl fluids, linear
correlation coefficient R2 of 0.97, 0.99 and 0.99 for Hyd(Na), Hyd(Cl) and Hyd(Cu) were
obtained (Fig. 5.5c); and Au-Cl solutions gave R2 of 0.95, 0.99 and 0.99 for Hyd(Na), Hyd(Cl)
and Hyd(Au) , respectively (Fig. 5.5d).
The simulations of 1 Cu, 1 Cl and 55 H2O at temperature of 420 °C and densities of 0.20
and 0.46 g/cm3 (No. 2,3 in Table 5.3) gave the predominant complex of CuCl(H2O)(aq),
consistent with the interpretation of the experiments (Liu et al., 2008). In the calculation of
the hydration number of Cu+ and Cl–, the first shell water in the CuCl(H2O)0 complex was
excluded. The hydration numbers of Cu+ and Cl– both increase with increasing density
(Fig. 5.6). Specifically, there are 2.86 water molecule surrounding CuCl(H2O)0 at a density
of 0.20 g/cm3 (400 °C, 290 bar, vapor-like fluids); this hydration number increases by ~2
(4.63 water molecules) at a density of 0.46 g/cm3 (400 °C, 400 bar). The hydration number
of Cl– increased from 0.92 (0.20 g/cm3) to 1.39 (0.46 g/cm3).
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
139
Figure 5.6 Instantaneous hydration numbers of Cu and Cl at different T, P conditions.
The simulation of Au-Cl in both vapor and liquid phases (Table 5.3, No. 4,5) gave a
predominant species of AuCl(H2O)0. Figure 5.7 shows the instantaneous hydration numbers
of Au+ and Cl–, excluding the first shell water in the AuCl(H2O)0 complex. In simulation 5,
which represents the AuCl(H2O)0 complex in a liquid phase with a density of 0.79 g/cm3,
MD gave a hydration number of six for the second-shell (within 4.5 Å of Au; Fig. 5.7a). In
contrast, in a vapor phase (equivalent pure water density of 0.082 g/cm3; AuCl fluid density
of 0.10 g/cm3) at identical P, T, simulation 4 gave a hydration number of two in the second-
shell (Fig. 5.7c), i.e. a total hydration number of three. The hydration of chloride also
decreased dramatically from liquid to vapor phase (from 1.9 to 0.5, Figs. 5.7b,d). Based on
measurements of Au(s) solubility in HCl-bearing steam, Archibald et al. (2001) concluded
that the total hydration number for the Au(I) complex decreased from 5 to 3 as temperature
increased from 300 to 360 °C at constant pressure, agreeing with our conclusion that the
hydration of Cu/Au complexes decreased with decreasing density (since at the same
5
4
3
2
1
0
20151050
1.39
(d)
4
3
2
1
0
2520151050
0.92
(b)7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
2520151050
2.86
(a)
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
120151050
4.63
(c)
Simulation time (ps) Simulation time (ps)
Instantaneous hydration number of C
l
400˚C, 290 bar 0.20 g/cm
3
Inst
anta
neou
s hy
drat
ion
num
ber o
f Cu
400˚C, 400 bar 0.46 g/cm
3
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
140
pressure, density decreases with increasing temperature). Archibald et al. (2001) obtained a
total hydration number of four at 340 °C, compared to three in the MD simulations.
Figure 5.7 Instantaneous hydration numbers of Au and Cl in coexisting liquid phase and
vapor phases at 340 °C
5.3.3 Na-O and Cl-O bond distances
Whereas the hydration numbers of the Na+ and Cl– ions are correlated with solution density,
the Na-O and Cl-O bond distances are correlated with temperature. The Na-O distances
decrease from 2.38 Å at 25 °C to ~2.33 Å at 1000 °C (Tables 5.1 and 5.2). On the other
hand, Cl-O distances increase from 3.16 Å at 25 °C to ~3.32 Å at 1000 °C. The same trends
were discovered by Driesner (1998) by classical MD simulations, in which Na-O distances
decreased by 0.03 Å (from 2.26 to 2.23 Å) and Cl-O distances increased by 0.02 Å (from
3.22 to 3.24 Å) over a temperature increase from 27 to 317 °C.
Simulation time (ps) Simulation time (ps)
Instantaneous hydration number of C
lInst
anta
neou
s hy
drat
ion
num
ber o
f Au
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
302520151050
2.11
(c)3
2
1
0
302520151050
0.49
(d)340˚C, 139 bar
vapor phase, 0.10 g/cm3
5
4
3
2
1
0
302520151050
1.89
(b)11
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2302520151050
5.94
(a)340˚C, 139 bar
liquid phase, 0.79 g/cm3
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
141
5.4 Discussion
5.4.1 The nature of neutral Cu(I) and Au(I) chloro-complexes
A few studies have demonstrated experimentally that the solubility of Cu and Au in low
density, high temperature supercritical fluids (1000 °C, 1500 bar, 0.29 g/cm3) is dependent
upon the nature and concentration of alkali ions, a fact that can be explained by the
formation of neutral species such as MCl2Na(aq) (M=Au,Cu) (Zajacz et al. 2010, 2011).
Zajacz et al. (2011) also report static quantum chemical calculations for linear Cu(I)
chloride and bisulfide complexes, suggesting that the NaCuCl2(aq) and NaCuClHS(aq)
species are inner sphere complexes. These calculations relate to the ideal gas phase, or use a
“Polarizable Continuum Model” to represent the solvent, which is characterized by its DC
(Cossi et al., 1996). The calculations are performed for selected complex stoichiometries,
which have been observed in the MD calculations in this study. Both static and MD
calculations present the geometry of CuNaCl2 with Na occurs sideways from the center Cu
atom of the linear CuCl2– complex (Fig. 5.2ab) with close agreement of the Cu-Na distance
(2.73 Å by static calculations vs 3.00 Å by MD according to Fig. 5.4a). The results of these
calculations suggest that an ion pair with Na+ in a well-defined position explain the
solubility data.
The static calculations, however, could not predict the disorder and residence time of this
configuration neither that other fundamentally different geometries appear with a
statistically significant likelihood, while the picture arising from our ab initio MD
simulations provided more details: i) explicit inclusion of the water molecules in MD
simulations results in CuCl2– having a distorted linear geometry, consistent with the
experimental measurements, even in the absence of Na+ within the first or second
coordination shells (see also Mei et al. 2013a). This shows that the hydration has a large
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
142
effect on the complex geometry, so that MD simulations with explicit water molecules
provide a better prediction of the structures than the static calculations based on continuum
solvent models. ii) Although the MD simulations show the predominance of a neutral
MCl2Na(aq) ion pair in low density, high temperature solutions at conditions similar to the
experiments of Zajacz et al. (2010, 2011), the nature of the complex differs fundamentally
from the picture suggested by static quantum mechanical calculations. The Na+ ion is only
weakly bonded (weak electrostatic bonding), as shown by the large range in M-Na
distances, the lack of definite coordination geometry for the neutral ion pair, and extremely
fast exchange rate of the bonded Na+ (< 15 ps) (Figs. 5.2, 5.3). These exchange rates are fast
relative for example to the H2O residence times for divalent aqua-ions, with range from
0.2 ns for Cu2+ to 30 µs for Ni2+ (Table 11.4 in Burgess 1978). Therefore we suggest that
Na+ is loosely bounded in the outer coordination sphere. The MD simulations also
demonstrate that atoms bounded at the outer sphere (or second shell) are unlikely to be
detected by EXAFS studies (e.g., Brugger et al., 2007; Fulton et al., 2000a,b; Liu et al.,
2001, 2008 for Cu), because of the highly disordered nature of the Cu-Na bond.
5.4.2 Density dependence of the charged or neutral complexes
When dealing with metal speciation in hydrothermal fluids, one of the fundamental
assumptions is that in supercritical fluids, neutral species will predominate over charged
species, because of a dramatic decrease in the DC of water with increasing temperature
(Barnes, 1997). Our ab initio MD simulations accurately reproduce the expected trend
towards a predominance of neutral clusters over charged complexes with decreasing fluid
density and DC. This trend has been demonstrated before for NaCl brines on the basis of
classical MD studies (e.g., Driesner et al., 1998; Sherman and Collings, 2002), showing an
increase in the stability of large clusters in supercritical fluids. For example, the Na2Cl2(aq)
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
143
cluster is important in NaCl fluids at temperature of 380 °C and density of 0.55 g/cm3
(Driesner et al., 1998).
Our systematic ab initio calculations reveal a negative linear dependency of the degree of
formation of the neutral species MCl2Na(aq) with solution density. Charged complexes
(e.g., CuCl2– and AuCl2
–) are predominant at high densities (> 0.7 g/cm3), even at high
temperature (Fig. 5.5), and neutral complexes are predominant at low densities. These
simulations confirm the interpretation of in situ experimental XAS data accumulated in the
last decade (e.g., Brugger et al., 2007; Fulton et al., 2000a, 2000b; Liu et al., 2008 for Cu),
which emphasize the stability of the linear [CuCl2–] structure over a wide range of
temperatures and pressures. In general, the majority of solubility data is also consistent with
a predominance of CuCl2– (e.g. Liu et al., 2001; Var'yash, 1992; Xiao et al., 1998). For low-
density fluids, the available data also agree to the predominance of neutral species (Zajacz et
al., 2011). Similarly for the Au(I)-chloride system, the MD results compare well to the
available experimental data that suggest that AuCl2– predominates in high-density fluids
(e.g, Pokrovski et al., 2009; Seward, 1973; Stefánsson and Seward, 2003), while
NaAuCl2(aq) is predominant in low density supercritical fluids (Zajacz et al., 2010).
Our MD results have showed that the MD simulations are capable of revealing the loosely-
bonded atoms in the outer coordination sphere of a complex, the key to understand the
neutrality of the species in the high-temperature, low-density fluids. In contrast, in situ
spectroscopic methods such as XAS failed to detect the second shell (Liu et al., 2008).
Because of the fast exchange of Na+ in the NaMCl2(aq) complexes, the ratio of NaMCl2(aq)
to MCl2– species is well constrained by the MD calculations. The linear relationship
observed as a function of fluid density (Figs. 5.5a,b) further allows to extrapolate the MD
results to different P,T conditions. We used these facts to calculate Gibbs free energies of
reaction (5.1) (
!
"rGNaMCl2 (aq )# ) for the formation of the neutral complexes:
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
144
Na+ + MCl2– = NaMCl2(aq) (M=Cu, Au) (5.1)
The mass action equation for reaction (5.1) is:
!
K ="NaMCl2 (aq )
"Na + # "MCl2$
=[NaMCl2 (aq)][MCl2
$]•% NaMCl2 (aq )"Na +%MCl2$
(5.2)
The Gibbs free energy of reaction (5.1) is:
!
"rGNaMCl2 (aq)# = $RT lnK = $RT ln
[NaMCl2 (aq)] % &NaMCl2 (aq)[MCl2
$ ] %'Na+ % &MCl2$ (5.3)
where "i and !i are the activity and activity coefficients of species i, respectively;
!
[NaMCl2 (aq)] = NNa(M ) , and
!
[MCl2"] = 1" NNa(M ) ;
!
NNa(M ) values are obtained from the
linear relationships shown in Figure 5.5. The activity of Na+ (
!
"Na + ) and the activity
coefficients
!
"MCl2– and
!
"NaMCl2 (aq ) (Tables 5.4, 5.5) were calculated based on distribution of
species calculations performed using the HCh software (Shvarov and Bastrakov 1999). The
Gibbs free energies of formation from the elements for NaMCl2(aq) (
!
" fGNaMCl2 (aq)#
) was
retrieved using the Gibbs free energy of formation of Na+ and MCl2– (Equation 5.1) taken
from Johnson et al. (1992) (Na+), Liu and McPhail (2005) (CuCl2–), and Akinfiev and Zotov
(2001) (AuCl2–). These
!
" fGNaMCl2 (aq)#
values were used to regress Helgeson-Kirkham-
Flowers (HKF) equation of state parameters (Tanger and Helgeson, 1988) using the OptimB
software (Shvarov, 1993). These HKF parameters are listed in Table 5.6, and can be used to
estimate the degree of association in high density (( 0.4 g/cm3) fluids up to 1000 ˚C, 5 kbar.
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
145
Table 5.4 Fitting of thermodynamic properties of the reaction Na+ + CuCl2
– = NaCuCl2(aq).
T (˚C)
P (bar)
ρ g/cm3
NNa(Cu) (Fit)
!
"CuCl2#
!
"Na +
!
"NaCuCl2 (aq )
!
"rG (kJ/mol) logK
25 1 1.18 0.01 0.64 1.74 0.91 12.0 -2.1 300 500 0.95 0.16 0.31 0.62 0.92 0.367 -0.033 300 1000 0.98 0.14 0.34 0.72 0.92 2.21 -0.20
300 2000 1.03 0.11 0.37 0.85 0.91 4.90 -0.45 500 600 0.67 0.35 0.03 0.028 0.93 -41.1 2.8
500 1000 0.76 0.29 0.14 0.17 0.93 -18.1 1.2 500 2000 0.87 0.22 0.25 0.39 0.92 -6.26 0.42
1000 2500 0.55 0.43 0.12 0.076 0.94 -45.7 1.9 1000 5000 0.74 0.30 0.21 0.21 0.93 -23.5 0.97
Table 5.5 Fitting of thermodynamic properties of the reaction Na+ + AuCl2– = NaAuCl2(aq)
T (˚C)
P (bar)
ρ g/cm3
NNa(Au) (Fit)
!
"AuCl2#
!
"Na +
!
"NaAuCl2 (aq )
!
"rG (kJ/mol)
logK
25 1 1.31 0.11 0.67
1.66 0.91 5.65 -0.99 300 500 1.05 0.20 0.34
0.61 0.92 -0.578 0.053
300 1000 1.09 0.19 0.37
0.71 0.92 0.919 -0.084 300 2000 1.14 0.17 0.038 0.83 0.91 2.69 -0.25 500 600 0.74 0.31 0.04
0.029 0.93 -38.5 2.6
500 1000 0.84 0.28 0.16
0.17 0.93 -16.8 1.1 500 2000 0.96 0.24 0.28
0.39 0.92 -6.32 0.43
1000 2500 0.61 0.36 0.14
0.081 0.94 -41.0 1.7 1000 5000 0.82 0.29 0.23
0.21 0.93 -21.2 0.87
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
146
Table 5.6 Equation-of-state parameters and standard partial molal properties (HKF
parameters) for the NaCuCl2(aq) and NaAuCl2(aq) complexes regressed from the MD
results.
Parameters NaCuCl2(aq) NaAuCl2(aq)
!
" f G Pr ,Tr
0 (Cal mol–1) -117956 -98036
!
S Pr ,Tr
0 (Cal mol–1 K–1) 72.166 54.218
a1 (Cal mol–1 bar–1)$10 -8.4582 -5.9176
a2 (Cal mol-1)$10–2 93.5847 94.2553
a3 (Cal mol–1 bar–1) -33.1580 -17.7597
a4 (Cal mol-1)$10–4 -6.6478 -6.6755
c1 (Cal mol–1) -1.2859 29.2502
c2 (Cal K mol–1) $10–4 12.7302 30.5724
!
"Pr ,Tr (Cal mol–1) $10–5 -0.0006 0.0384
5.4.3 Density dependence of hydration of ions and metal complexes
The number of water molecules (i.e., the hydration number) surrounding Cu+, Au+, Na+ and
Cl– ions decreases linearly when fluid density decreases (Figs. 5.5c,d). The decrease of
hydration number with the decrease of density has been demonstrated in previous
experimental (Archibald et al., 2001, 2002) and theoretical studies (e.g., Driesner et al.,
1998; Hemley et al., 1992; Seward and Driesner, 2004; Sherman, 2007). Note that in
contrast to the density dependence of the hydration number, the Na-O and Cl-O distances
change with temperature rather than density (see section 5.3.3). The decrease of Na-O
distances with increasing temperature may result from the faster kinetics at high temperature
increasing the attractive force of Na+ and negative charged oxygen in H2O (recognized as
O2– ions). Similarly, the increasing kinetics at high temperature increases the repulsive force
of Cl– and O2– ionic pairs, which lead to the increase of Cl-O distances.
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
147
There are numerous experimental studies on the solubility of NaCl(s) and hydration of NaCl
ion pairs in water vapor (see reviews of Palmer et al., 2004). In these studies, a linear trend
was established between the solubility of NaCl(s) and the density of the water, with the
intersection of Y axis as concentration constants, and the slope being interpreted as
hydration numbers (e.g., Armellini et al., 1993; Palmer et al., 2004):
CNaCl = logKc + n H2O log #, (5.4)
where CNaCl is the concentration of NaCl in the fluid, n is the number of hydration waters
and # is the density of water. Equation (5.4) is valid for an ideal gas. This approach has been
used to interpret the solubility of Ag(I) and Cu(I) in subcritical water vapor (Archibald et
al., 2002; Migdisov et al., 1999; Williams-Jones et al., 2002) and in supercritical water near
the critical isochore (Liu et al., 2008). Equation (5.4) implies that the hydration number is
independent of density at a given temperature. Our results and other MD studies (Driesner et
al., 1998; Lee et al., 1998; see reviews in Seward and Driesner, 2004) all suggest that
hydration numbers should decrease with fluid density, and therefore the hydration number
implied from the regression of experimental salt solubility (Equation 5.4) is not accurate at a
given temperature, although it may indicate a first-order estimation. For example, our MD
results of the hydration number of Cu are 1.6 at 290 bar and 2.5 at 420 bar at 400 °C,
comparable to the experimental values (2.8 including the water complexes to CuCl, Liu et
al., 2008). Similarly the MD results of the Au-Cl system in vapor phase (hydration number
of 3 at 340 °C) are also comparable to the experimental values (hydration number of 5 at
300 °C to 3 at 360 °C) of Archibald et al. (2001).
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
148
5.4.4 Translational entropy and the density dependence of hydrothermal
reactions
It is well documented that the free energies of reactions involving aqueous complexes often
vary in a linear fashion with water density (as related to pressure) at fixed temperature
(Anderson et al., 1991; Dolej) and Manning, 2010; Manning 1998). Our MD data provide a
simple explanation for this empirical observation, by revealing a linear correlation (i.e.,
hydration number ~ a + b*s) between the solution density and the hydration number of Cu(I)
and Au(I) complexes that show no evidence for significant change in stoichiometry and
geometry over the investigated P, T range. Consequently, the empirical correlation between
Log K and water density can be explained by assuming that the change in configurational
entropy is proportional to the change in hydration number:
!
"rG = "rH #T"rS= "rH #T(a + b$s)= #RT lnK
so : lnK ="rH #Ta +Tb$
RT~ $ @ constant T
(5.5)
Since the hydration numbers of Na and Cl decline with the decrease of density (increase of
volume), the Cl/Na hydration ions may have smaller volume at high density, and the volume
would increase upon release of the hydration waters to solution, e.g.,
(5.6)
To explain how the charged complexes control the solubility and metal (e.g., Cu, Au)
transport in supercritical and fluids, We considered the 1st shell hydration for the following
chemical reaction:
CuNaCl2 + m H2O ! CuCl2– + Na•(H2O)m
+ (5.7)
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
149
At high density, Na+ attracts more water to form hydration ions (m ( 3 when density ( 0.9),
so the preferred reaction direction is to form the charged complexes CuCl2–. At low density,
the hydration water of Na ions is released (m & 2 when density & 0.5 g/cm3), so the
preferred reaction direction is to form neutral complex CuNaCl2(aq). The entropy of the left
side in Equation (5.7) is higher than the right side because it is more disordered. The loss of
hydration water of Cl and Na may contribute to the formation of large CuNanClm1+n-m
clusters because of the smaller steric effects and smaller ion volumes at lower densities.
Archibald et al. (2001; 2002) suggested that the solubilities of Au and Cu decreased with
increasing temperature as a result of decreasing hydration number, which is consistent with
the results from our MD simulations. In fluids with low chloride concentrations, the less
hydrated Cl– ions (i.e., hydration of 0.5 at fluid density of 0.1 g/cm3, Table 5.3, No. 4) at
lower density may affect metal solubility. In low-density chloride-rich fluids, Zajacz et al.
(2010) noticed that at a constant Cl (NaCl + HCl) concentration of 0.75 m, gold solubility
increased with the increasing of NaCl/(NaCl+HCl) ratio to 0.5, and then decreased with
higher ratio of NaCl. The solubility experiment by Zajacz et al. (2010) provides the
evidence of dominance of the AuNaCl2 comolex, which is proofed by our MD simulations
show that the stronger ion pairing and existence of neutral NaCl (aq) species.
The traditional Born-Model description explains the increase in ion association with
decreasing solution density as resulting from the decrease in dielectric constant of the
solvent (Born 1920; Seward and Barnes, 1997). A molecular description, however, explains
the ion association as resulting from the increase in translational entropy of products relative
to the reactants. The translation entropy of the products is greater than that of the reactants
since the hydration waters surrounding Na+ are liberated. Because of the increase in
translational entropy, the ion association is favored by temperature. Moreover, the entropy
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
150
of liberated water molecules will increase with decreasing fluid density; consequently, the
ion association is favored by decreasing fluid density.
5.5 Acknowledgement
Research funding was provided by the Australian Research Council (ARC) to JB
(DP0878903), and the Minerals Down Under Flagship to WL. The MD calculations were
supported by iVEC through the use of advanced computing resources located in Perth,
Australia, and the computational facilities of the Advanced Computing Research Centre in
University of Bristol, UK. This paper is part of Yuan Mei’s PhD thesis. YM acknowledges
the University of Adelaide for IPRS scholarship and CSIRO Minerals Down Under Flagship
for a scholarship top-up.
5.6 References Akinfiev, N. N. and Zotov, A. V., 2001. Thermodynamic description of chloride,
hydrosulfide, and hydroxo complexes of Ag(I), Cu(I), and Au(I) at temperatures of
25-500°C and pressures of 1-2000 bar. Geochemistry International 39, 990-1006.
Anderson, G. M., Castet, S., Schott, J., and Mesmer, R. E., 1991. The density model for
estimation of thermodynamic parameters of reactions at high temperatures and
pressures. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 55, 1769-1779.
Archibald, S. M., Migdisov, A. A., and Williams-Jones, A. E., 2001. The stability of Au-
chloride complexes in water vapor at elevated temperatures and pressures.
Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 65, 4413-4423.
Archibald, S. M., Migdisov, A. A., and Williams-Jones, A. E., 2002. An experimental study
of the stability of copper chloride complexes in water vapor at elevated temperatures
and pressures. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 66, 1611-1619.
Armellini, F. J. and Tester, J. W., 1993. Solubility of sodium chloride and sulfate in sub-and
supercritical water vapor from 450–550 °C and 100–250 bar. Fluid Phase Equilibria
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
151
84, 123-142.
Barnes, H. L., 1997. Geochemistry of Hydrothermal Ore Deposits. Wiley, New York. 795
pp.
Bazarkina, E. F., Pokrovski, G. S., Zotov, A. V., and Hazemann, J. L., 2010. Structure and
stability of cadmium chloride complexes in hydrothermal fluids. Chemical Geology
276, 1-17.
Berry, A. J., Hack, A. C., Mavrogenes, J. A., Newville, M., and Sutton, S. R., 2006. A
XANES study of Cu speciation in high-temperature brines using synthetic fluid
inclusions. American Mineralogist 91, 1773-1782.
Born, M., 1920. Volumen und Hydratationswärme der Ionen. Zeitschrift für Physik 1, 45-48.
Brugger, J., Etschmann, B., Liu, W., Testemale, D., Hazemann, J. L., Emerich, H., van Beek,
W., and Proux, O., 2007. An XAS study of the structure and thermodynamics of
Cu(I) chloride complexes in brines up to high temperature (400°C, 600bar).
Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 71, 4920-4941.
Brugger, J., Pring, A., Reith, F., Ryan, C., Etschmann, B., Liu, W.H., O'Neill, B., and
Ngothai, Y. (2010) Probing ore deposits formation: New insights and challenges
from synchrotron and neutron studies. Radiation Physics and Chemistry 79, 151-161.
Burgess, J., (1978). Metal Ions in Solution. Published by Ellis Horwood Ltd, Chichester and
distributed by John Wiley and Sons, Chichester and New York. 481 pp.
Car, R. and Parrinello, M., 1985. Unified Approach for Molecular Dynamics and Density-
Functional Theory. Physical Review Letters 55, 2471-2474.
Chialvo, A. and Simonson, J., 2003. Aqueous NaCl pair association from liquid-like to
steam-like densities along near-critical isotherms. The Journal of Chemical Physics
118, 7921.
Cossi, M., Barone, V., Cammi, R., and Tomasi, J., 1996. Ab initio study of solvated
molecules: a new implementation of the polarizable continuum model. Chemical
Physics Letters 255, 327-335.
Crerar, D. A., Susak, N., Borcsik, M., and Schwartz, S., 1978. Solubility of the buffer
assemblage pyrite + pyrrhotite + magnetite in NaCl solutions from 200 to 350 °C.
Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 42, 1427-1437.
Cui, S. and Harris, J., 1995. Solubility of sodium chloride in supercritical water: A
molecular dynamics study. The Journal of Physical Chemistry 99, 2900-2906.
Debye, P. and Hückel, E., 1923. The theory of electrolytes. I. Lowering of freezing point
and related phenomena (In German). Physikalische Zeitschrift 24, 185–206.
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
152
Dolejs, D. and Manning, C. E., 2010. Thermodynamic model for mineral solubility in
aqueous fluids: theory, calibration and application to model fluid-flow systems.
Geofluids 10, 20-40.
Driesner, T., 2007. The system H2O–NaCl. Part II: Correlations for molar volume, enthalpy,
and isobaric heat capacity from 0 to 1000°C, 1 to 5000bar, and 0 to 1 XNaCl.
Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 71, 4902-4919.
Driesner, T. and Heinrich, C. A., 2007. The system H2O–NaCl. Part I: Correlation formulae
for phase relations in temperature–pressure–composition space from 0 to 1000°C, 0
to 5000bar, and 0 to 1 XNaCl. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 71, 4880-4901.
Driesner, T., Seward, T. M., and Tironi, I. G., 1998. Molecular dynamics simulation study
of ionic hydration and ion association in dilute and 1 molal aqueous sodium chloride
solutions from ambient to supercritical conditions. Geochimica et Cosmochimica
Acta 62, 3095-3107.
Etschmann, B. E., Liu, W., Testemale, D., Müller, H., Rae, N. A., Proux, O., Hazemann, J.
L., and Brugger, J., 2010. An in situ XAS study of copper(I) transport as
hydrosulfide complexes in hydrothermal solutions (25-592 °C, 180-600 bar):
Speciation and solubility in vapor and liquid phases. Geochimica et Cosmochimica
Acta 74, 4723-4739.
Frank, M. R., Simon, A. C., Pettke, T., Candela, P. A., and Piccoli, P. M., 2011. Gold and
copper partitioning in magmatic-hydrothermal systems at 800 degrees C and 100
MPa. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 75, 2470-2482.
Fulton, J. L., Hoffmann, M. M., and Darab, J. G., 2000a. An X-ray absorption fine structure
study of copper(I) chloride coordination structure in water up to 325 °C. Chemical
Physics Letters 330, 300-308.
Fulton, J. L., Hoffmann, M. M., Darab, J. G., Palmer, B. J., and Stern, E. A., 2000b.
Copper(I) and Copper(II) Coordination Structure under Hydrothermal Conditions at
325 °C:# An X-ray Absorption Fine Structure and Molecular Dynamics Study. The
Journal of Physical Chemistry A 104, 11651-11663.
Giberti, F., Tribello, G. A., and Parrinello, M., 2013. Transient Polymorphism in NaCl.
Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 9, 2526-2530.
Hack, A. C. and Mavrogenes, J. A., 2006. A synthetic fluid inclusion study of copper
solubility in hydrothermal brines from 525 to 725 C and 0.3 to 1.7 GPa. Geochimica
et Cosmochimica Acta 70, 3970-3985.
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
153
Harris, D. J., Brodholt, J. P., and Sherman, D. M., 2003. Zinc complexation in hydrothermal
chloride brines: Results from ab initio molecular dynamics calculations. Journal of
Physical Chemistry A 107, 1050-1054.
Hassan, S. A., 2011. Microscopic mechanism of nanocrystal formation from solution by
cluster aggregation and coalescence. The Journal of chemical physics 134, 114508.
Helgeson, H. and Kirkham, D. H., 1974. Theoretical prediction of the thermodynamic
behavior of aqueous electrolytes at high pressures and temperatures: II. Debye-
Hückel parameters for activity coefficients and relative partial molal properties.
American Journal of Science 274, 1199-1261.
Hemley, J., Cygan, G., Fein, J., Robinson, G., and d'Angelo, W., 1992. Hydrothermal ore-
forming processes in the light of studies in rock-buffered systems; I, Iron-copper-
zinc-lead sulfide solubility relations. Economic Geology 87, 1-22.
Hoffmann, M. M., Darab, J. G., Palmer, B. J., and Fulton, J. L., 1999. A transition in the
Ni2+ complex structure from six- to four-coordinate upon formation of ion pair
species in supercritical water: An X-ray absorption fine structure, near-infrared, and
molecular dynamics study. Journal of Physical Chemistry 103, 8471-8482.
House, J. E., 2012. Inorganic Chemistry. Elsevier Academic Press (second edition). 848 pp.
Humphrey, W., Dalke, A., and Schulten, K., 1996. VMD: visual molecular dynamics.
Journal of Molecular Graphics 14, 33-38.
John P, B., 1998. Molecular dynamics simulations of aqueous NaCl solutions at high
pressures and temperatures. Chemical Geology 151, 11-19.
Johnson, J. W., Oelkers, E. H., and Helgeson, H. C., 1992. SUPCRT92: A software package
for calculating the standard molal thermodynamic properties of minerals, gases,
aqueous species, and reactions from 1 to 5000 bar and 0 to 1000˚C. Computers
Geosciences 18, 899-947.
Laasonen, K., Pasquarello, A., Car, R., Lee, C., and Vanderbilt, D., 1993. Car-Parrinello
molecular dynamics with Vanderbilt ultrasoft pseudopotentials. Physical Review B
47, 10142-10153.
Lee, S., Cummings, P., Simonson, J., and Mesmer, R., 1998. Molecular dynamics
simulation of the limiting conductance of NaCl in supercritical water. Chemical
Physics Letters 293, 289-294.
Lerchbaumer, L. and Audétat, A., 2012. High Cu concentrations in vapor-type fluid
inclusions: An artifact? Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 88, 255-274.
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
154
Liu, W., Borg, S., Etschmann, B., Mei, Y., and Brugger, J., 2012a. An XAS study of
speciation and thermodynamic properties of aqueous zinc bromide complexes at 25–
150 °C. Chemical Geology 298–299, 57-69.
Liu, W., Borg, S. J., Testemale, D., Etschmann, B., Hazemann, J.-L., and Brugger, J., 2011a.
Speciation and thermodynamic properties for cobalt chloride complexes in
hydrothermal fluids at 35–440°C and 600bar: An in-situ XAS study. Geochimica et
Cosmochimica Acta 75, 1227-1248.
Liu, W., Brugger, J., Etschmann, B., Testemale, D., and Hazemann, J.-L., 2008. The
solubility of nantokite (CuCl(s)) and Cu speciation in low-density fluids near the
critical isochore: An in-situ XAS study. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 72,
4094-4106.
Liu, W., Etschmann, B., Foran, G., Shelly, M., Foran, G., and Brugger, J., 2007. Deriving
formation constants for aqueous metal complexes from XANES spectra: Zn(II) and
Fe(II) chloride complexes in hypersaline solutions. American Mineralogist 92, 761-
770.
Liu, W. and McPhail, D. C., 2005. Thermodynamic properties of copper chloride complexes
and copper transport in magmatic-hydrothermal solutions. Chemical Geology 221,
21-39.
Liu, W., McPhail, D. C., and Brugger, J., 2001. An experimental study of copper(I)-chloride
and copper(I)-acetate complexing in hydrothermal solutions between 50 °C and
250 °C and vapor-saturated pressure. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 65, 2937-
2948.
Liu, X., Lu, X., Wang, R., and Zhou, H., 2012b. Silver speciation in chloride-containing
hydrothermal solutions from first principles molecular dynamics simulations.
Chemical Geology 294–295, 103-112.
Liu, X., Lu, X., Wang, R., Zhou, H., and Xu, S., 2011b. Speciation of gold in
hydrosulphide-rich ore-forming fluids: Insights from first-principles molecular
dynamics simulations. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 75, 185-194.
Manning, C. E., 1998. Fluid composition at the blueschist - eclogite transition in the model
system Na2O-MgO-Al2O3-SiO2-H2O-HCl. Schweizerische Mineralogische Und
Petrographische Mitteilungen 78, 225-242.
Mavrogenes, J. A., Berry, A. J., Newville, M., and Sutton, S. R., 2002. Copper speciation in
vapor-phase fluid inclusions from the Mole Granite, Australia. American
Mineralogist 87, 1360-1364.
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
155
Mei, Y., Sherman, D. M., Liu, W., and Brugger, J., 2013a. Ab initio molecular dynamics
simulation and free energy exploration of copper(I) complexation by chloride and
bisulfide in hydrothermal fluids. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 102, 45-64.
Mei, Y., Sherman, D. M., Liu, W., and Brugger, J., 2013. Complexation of gold in S3–-rich
hydrothermal fluids: Evidence from ab-initio molecular dynamics simulations.
Chemical Geology 347, 34-42.
Migdisov, A. A., Williams-Jones, A., and Suleimenov, O., 1999. Solubility of chlorargyrite
(AgCl) in water vapor at elevated temperatures and pressures. Geochimica et
Cosmochimica Acta 63, 3817-3827.
Oelkers, E. H. and Helgeson, H. C., 1993. Multiple ion association in supercritical aqueous
solutions of single electrolytes. Science 261, 888.
Palmer, D. A., Simonson, J., and Jensen, J., 2004. Partitioning of electrolytes to steam and
their solubilities in steam. Aqueous systems at elevated temperatures and pressures:
New York, Elsevier, 409-439.
Perdew, J. P., Burke, K., and Ernzerhof, M., 1996. Generalized Gradient Approximation
Made Simple. Physical Review Letters 77, 3865-3868.
Pokrovski, G. S., Roux, J., Hazemann, J.-L., and Testemale, D., 2005. An X-ray absorption
spectroscopy study of argutite solubility and aqueous Ge(IV) speciation in
hydrothermal fluids to 500 °C and 400 bar. Chemical Geology 217, 127-145.
Pokrovski, G. S., Tagirov, B. R., Schott, J., Bazarkina, E. F., Hazemann, J.-L., and Proux,
O., 2009. An in situ X-ray absorption spectroscopy study of gold-chloride
complexing in hydrothermal fluids. Chemical Geology 259, 17-29.
Pokrovski, G. S., Roux, J., Ferlat, G., Jonchiere, R., Seitsonen, A. P., Vuilleumier, R., and
Hazemann, J.-L., 2013. Silver in geological fluids from in situ X-ray absorption
spectroscopy and first-principles molecular dynamics. Geochimica et Cosmochimica
Acta 106, 501-523.
Rempel, K. U., Liebscher, A., Meixner, A., Romer, R. L., and Heinrich, W., 2012. An
experimental study of the elemental and isotopic fractionation of copper between
aqueous vapour and liquid to 450 °C and 400 bar in the CuCl-NaCl-H2O and CuCl-
NaHS-NaCl-H2O systems. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 94, 199-216.
Seward, T. M., 1973. Thio complexes of gold and the transport of gold in hydrothermal ore
solutions. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 37, 379-399.
Seward, T. M. and Barnes, H. L., 1997. Metal transport by hydrothermal ore fluids. In:
Barnes, H. L. (Ed.), Geochemistry of Hydrothermal Ore Deposits. Wiley, New York.
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
156
Seward, T. and Driesner, T., 2004. Hydrothermal solution structure: Experiments and
computer simulations. In: Palmer, D. A., Fernández-Prini, R., and Havey, A. H.
Eds.), Aqueous Systems at Elevated Temperatures and Pressures. Elsevier.
Seyfried, W. and Ding, K., 1993. The effect of redox on the relative solubilities of copper
and iron in Cl-bearing aqueous fluids at elevated temperatures and pressures: An
experimental study with application to subseafloor hydrothermal systems.
Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 57, 1905-1917.
Sharps, J. A., Brown Jr, G. E., and Stebbins, J. F., 1993. Kinetics and mechanism of ligand
exchange of Au (III), Zn(II), and Cd(II) chlorides in aqueous solution: An NMR
study from 28–98°C. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 57, 721-731.
Shvarov, Y. V., 1993. UT-HEL: IBM Computer Code for Calculating the HKF revised
Equation of State Parameters for Aqueous Species. Moscow State University.
Shvarov, Y. and Bastrakov, E., 1999. HCh: a software package for geochemical modelling.
User's guide. AGSO record 1999/25, 60 pp.
Sherman, D. M., 2007. Complexation of Cu+ in Hydrothermal NaCl Brines: Ab initio
molecular dynamics and energetics. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 71, 714-722.
Sherman, D. M., 2010. Metal complexation and ion association in hydrothermal fluids:
insights from quantum chemistry and molecular dynamics. Geofluids 10, 41-57.
Sherman, D. M. and Collings, M. D., 2002. Ion association in concentrated NaCl brines
from ambient to supercritical conditions: results from classical molecular dynamics
simulations. Geochemical Transactions 3, 102-107.
Simon, A. C., Pettke, T., Candela, P. A., Piccolli, P. M., and Heinrich, C. A., 2006. Copper
partitioning in a melt-vapor-brine-magnetite-pyrrhotite assemblage. Geochimica Et
Cosmochimica Acta 70, 5583-5600.
Simon, A. C., Frank, M. R., Pettke, T., Candela, P. A., Piccoli, P. M., and Heinrich, C. A.,
2005. Gold partitioning in melt-vapor-brine systems. Geochimica Et Cosmochimica
Acta 69, 3321-3335.
Smith, D. E. and Dang, L. X., 1994. Computer simulations of NaCl association in
polarizable water. The Journal of Chemical Physics 100, 3757-3766.
Stefánsson, A. and Seward, T. M., 2003. Stability of chloridogold(I) complexes in aqueous
solutions from 300 to 600 °C and from 500 to 1800 bar. Geochimica et
Cosmochimica Acta 67, 4559-4576.
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
157
Susak, N., and Crerar, D.A., 1985. Spectra and coordination changes of transition metals in
hydrothermal solutions: Implications for ore genesis. Geochimica et Cosmochimica
Acta 49, 555-564.
Tanger, J. C. I. and Helgeson, H. C., 1988. Calculation of the thermodynamic and transport
properties of aqueous species at high pressures and temperatures: Revised equations
of state for the standard partial molal properties of ions and electrolytes. American
Journal of Science 288, 19-98.
Testemale, D., Brugger, J., Liu, W., Etschmann, B., and Hazemann, J. L., 2009. In-situ X-
ray absorption study of Iron (II) speciation in brines up to supercritical conditions.
Chemical Geology 264, 295-310.
Tian, Y., Etschmann, B., Liu, W., Borg, S., Mei, Y., Testemale, D., O'Neill, B., Rae, N.,
Sherman, D. M., Ngothai, Y., Johannessen, B., Glover, C., and Brugger, J., 2012.
Speciation of nickel (II) chloride complexes in hydrothermal fluids: In situ XAS
study. Chemical Geology 334, 345-363.
Var'yash, L. N., 1992. Cu(I) complexing in NaCl solutions at 300 and 350°C. Geochemistry
International 29, 84-92.
Verlet, L., 1967. Computer "experiments" on classical fluids. I. Thermodynamical
properties of Lennard-Jones molecules. Physical Review 159, 98.
Williams-Jones, A. E., Migdisov, A. A., Archibald, S. M., and Xiao, Z., 2002. Vapor-
transport of ore metals. Water-rock interaction: a tribute to David A. Crerar:
Geochemical Society Special Publication 7, 279-305.
Xiao, Z., Gammons, C. H., and Williams-Jones, A. E., 1998. Experimental study of copper(I)
chloride complexing in hydrothermal solutions at 40 to 300°C and saturated water
vapor pressure. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 62, 2949-2964.
Zahn, D., 2004. Atomistic Mechanism of NaCl Nucleation from an Aqueous Solution.
Physical Review Letters 92, 040801.
Zajacz, Z., Seo, J. H., Candela, P. A., Piccoli, P. M., Heinrich, C. A., and Guillong, M.,
2010. Alkali metals control the release of gold from volatile-rich magmas. Earth and
Planetary Science Letters 297, 50-56.
Zajacz, Z., Seo, J. H., Candela, P. A., Piccoli, P. M., and Tossell, J. A., 2011. The solubility
of copper in high-temperature magmatic vapors: A quest for the significance of
various chloride and sulfide complexes. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 75,
2811-2827.
CHAPTER 5. CHARGE OR NEUTRAL COMPLEXES
158
Zezin, D. Y., Migdisov, A. A., and Williams-Jones, A. E., 2007. The solubility of gold in
hydrogen sulfide gas: An experimental study. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 71,
3070-3081.
Zezin, D. Y., Migdisov, A. A., and Williams-Jones, A. E., 2011. The solubility of gold in
H2O–H2S vapour at elevated temperature and pressure. Geochimica et
Cosmochimica Acta 75, 5140-5153.
159
_____________________________________
Chapter 6
Conclusion ____________________________________
160
CHAPTER 6. CONCLUSION
161
The major contribution of this PhD thesis is to demonstrate the potential of ab initio
molecular dynamics simulations in investigating speciation, geometries, stoichiometries and
thermodynamic properties of transition metal complexes responsible for the transport of
these metals in hydrothermal fluids.
6.1 d10 transition metal ions complexation
Ab initio MD conducted in this thesis predicted the complexation of Cu+, Au+ and Zn2+ ions
in chlorine- and sulfur-rich fluids successfully. These ions share a similar electronic
configuration, in that their d-orbitals are all fully occupied (closed shell). MD simulations
are particularly well suited for studying d10-metal complexes because of well-defined
electronic configurations and lower computing costs for spin-restricted systems. In
simulations of Zn-Cl, ab initio MD predicted the stability of tetrahedral [ZnCln(H2O)4-n]2-n
complexes from ambient to hydrothermal conditions. Tetrahedral complexes are very
common in transition metal ions; complexation and geometry can be explained by crystal-
field theory (Janes et al., 2004). The fully occupied electronic configuration of Zn2+ results
in no crystal-field stabilization energy (CFSE); tetrahedral complexes are favored by large
ligands such as Cl–, Br– and I– with such d10 ions. However, despite the fact that metal ions
in group BI (e.g., Cu+, Au+) share the same electronic configuration as the Zn2+ ion, their
complexes have different coordination and structures. For Au+ and Cu+ complexes, ab initio
MD gave linear ML2– complexes (e.g., CuCl2
–, Cu(HS)2–, AuCl2
–, Au(S3)2–, Au(S3)(HS)–,
etc) in most conditions (except CuCl32– in hypersaline fluids at low temperature (<200˚C)).
The linear aqueous species ML(H2O)0 are also observed as intermediate structures (Chapter
2, Mei et al., 2013a) or in solutions with low ligand concentrations (Chapter 5). Orgel (1958)
suggested that the stability of the linear configuration for these ions results from the
CHAPTER 6. CONCLUSION
162
hybridization among (n-1)d orbitals (
!
dz 2 ) and ns and np (pz) orbitals that have similar
energies in these metals (review by Huheey et al., 1983).
Hence, the structural properties obtained from ab initio MD are in good agreement with the
available experimental studies, and are consistent with the theory of complex formation.
6.2 Metal complexation in mixed ligand solutions
In most experimental studies of metal mobility in hydrothermal fluids, a single ligand (in
addition to H2O as water acts as solvent) was included in each experiment because 1) simple
systems help to understand the fundamentals of individual ligand-forming reactions;
2) adding more constraints makes data interpretation easier and provides more precise
results. However, in real fluids several ligands may compete for the metals. For example,
both Cl– and HS– play important role in hydrothermal fluids, but few studies investigated the
transport of metals in solutions containing both Cl– and HS– mixture (e.g., Etschmann et al.,
2010). MD provides a molecular-level understanding of metal complexation and is well
suited for the study of mixed ligand systems. For example, we studied Cu(I) complexation
in Cl– and HS– fluids in Chapter 2 and Au(I) complexation in high pressure sulfur-rich fluids
with the ligands S3–, HS– and OH– in Chapter 3. These studies succeeded in identifying
novel metal complexes (e.g., mix-ligand complex Cu(HS)Cl–) and in providing
thermodynamic properties for some of these species. Hence, ab initio MD can expand our
knowledge of metal behavior in real fluids, and provide critical information to guide the
design of experimental studies aimed at testing the MD predictions.
6.3 Thermodynamic properties
One of the most significant contributions of this thesis is to demonstrate the potential of ab
initio MD for calculating thermodynamic properties for the formation of transition metal
CHAPTER 6. CONCLUSION
163
complexes under hydrothermal conditions (Chapter 2, 4; Mei et al., 2013a). The approach of
distance constraint thermodynamic integration employed in this thesis enables us to
measure the force and free energy of ligand-association/dissociation reactions directly at
molecular level. For the simulations at high temperatures (i.e. ( 300 ˚C), the thermodynamic
properties obtained by ab initio MD are in good agreements with experimental values (i.e.
with in 1-2 log units). Because of the fast kinetics at high temperatures, it is more likely that
the system will be approaching equilibrium at high temperature within the time scale of ab
initio MD (picoseconds) for the complexes studied. Although larger uncertainties appear at
low temperatures, the MD results are still comparable with the experiments, and, most
importantly, enable to reproduce the mineral solubility gradients as a function of P, T and
solution composition. As experimental studies designed to obtain thermodynamic properties
at high T, P are highly demanding and may have significant uncertainties (Chapter 4), ab
initio MD is coming of age for obtaining thermodynamic properties and validating and
guiding experimental studies.
6.4 Current limitations
The ab initio MD simulations demonstrated in this thesis show the potential of
computational approaches for studying metal mobility in hydrothermal fluids. However, the
current methods still have significant limitations. One major limitation is that current
computational resources limit the scale of the simulations. For example, ab initio MD
simulations in this thesis were conducted for ~200 particles and up to ~40 ps. Although
current performance of ab initio MD has improved significantly compared with the time
scale of a few picoseconds in the past (e.g., Harris et al., 2003; Sherman, 2007), it is still
difficult to reproduce the equilibrium of many chemical reactions in such a short time
(picoseconds). As the kinetics of ligand exchange reactions is faster at high temperatures,
CHAPTER 6. CONCLUSION
164
the predictions of speciation and thermodynamic properties gave better agreements
compared to experiments (i.e. ( 300 ˚C, Mei et al., 2013a; Chapter 2; Chapter 4), but the
simulations at lower temperature (i.e. < 200 ˚C) still need to be improved. The size of the
box (or the number of particles) also affects the accuracy of the simulation. As ab initio MD
simulations with only a small number of particles (i.e. magnitude of several hundreds) are
affordable currently (Chapter 5), the simulation systems at this scale reflect a solution with
high concentrations of metal and ligands (several molal), which bring significant errors in
accounting for activity coefficients to get standard state properties (infinite dilution).
Another source of uncertainty comes from the computational methods. As there is no
analytical solution for the Schrödinger equation (Chapter 1, Equation 1.1), the accuracy of
the MD simulation depends on the approximation methods used to describe the
wavefunction. For example, the pseudo-potentials used in the Car-Parrinello methods is not
as accurate as methods such as CCSD(T) (coupled-cluster perturbation theory with single,
double and triple excitations from the Hartree–Fock determinant), which currently
represents the “gold standard” of molecular quantum chemistry (Tossell, 2012). However,
the accurate CCSD(T) method is only affordable for small molecule calculations, and it is
not (yet) feasible to conduct simulations for a large and disordered system (e.g., metal in
hydrothermal fluid) at such a high level of theory. Instead, the pseudo-potentials,
particularly ultra-soft pseudo-potential with the Car-Parrinello method used in this thesis
gave reasonably accurate results within affordable CPU hours: this method reproduces
accurately the geometry of the complexes, and provides quantitative to semi quantitative
thermodynamic properties. Simulation of mineral solubility based on these properties
provide predictions of solubility within an order of magnitude of experimental data, and
accurately reproduce solubility gradients as a function of P, T, and ligand concentrations.
The latter feature is key to simulations of metal transport in natural and engineered systems.
CHAPTER 6. CONCLUSION
165
All of these issues will become less predominant in the future with the development of more
efficient simulation methods and improvements in computational capacity (e.g., use of
GPU). Hence, we expect that the capacity of ab initio MD to reproduce real solutions and
get more reliable results will improve quickly, and this method will become a pillar to
underpin our understanding of metal mobility in hydrothermal systems.
6.5 Perspective and future work
MD simulations in this thesis focus on the metal-ligand complexation in aqueous solutions.
MD simulations will play an important role in exploring key aspects of the geochemistry of
hydrothermal systems and deciphering the complicated chemistry that leads, for example, to
the formation of ore deposits.
The acidity of aqueous solutions is an essential variable in controlling metal dissolution and
precipitation. As chloride and bisulfide are two important ligands in metal transport, the
effect of pH on these ions needs to be well understood. Experimental studies show that the
pKa of H2S(aq) changes with changes of T, P (Suleimenov and Seward, 1997), while there
is a controversy of the pKa of HCl in hydrothermal fluids (Frantz and Marshall, 1984;
Tagirov et al., 1997). A DFT based MD method opens the way to calculating pKa with a
high level of accuracy (Sulpizi and Sprik, 2008; 2010).
Redox potential is another important part of metal mobility as some metals exist in the Earth
as different valences (e.g., Cu(I) and Cu(II); Fe(II) and Fe(III); U(IV) and U(VI)). Redox
potentials can also be calculated by quantum mechanical simulations (e.g., Cheng et al.,
2009). The computational results can be used to interpret previous existing data (for
example, in Chapter 4), cross-proof experimental results, and evaluate the gradient by
making pH-redox diagrams (i.e. change of speciation as a function of pH and redox,
Figure 1.2).
CHAPTER 6. CONCLUSION
166
Many of the Earth systems include more than one phase, for example, the mineral-water
interface (solid-liquid phase), volcanic gas and lava (vapor-melt), phase separation upon
cooling or decompression when fluids rise in the crust (liquid-vapor). The ab initio MD
methods used in this thesis are too computationally intensive to simulate systems with
different phases. One realistic approach is combining the classical MD and ab initio MD:
for the large scale simulations, the simulation of individual phases will be treated as ab
initio MD, and these results will be used to construct the parameters of force-field classical
MD (Demichelis et al., 2012). Then classical MD will be employed to give a global view
about molecular properties at the scale of thousands of particles and several nanoseconds for
systems containing both liquid and vapor phases.
6.6 Reference Demichelis, R., Raiteri, P., Gale, J. D., Quigley, D., and Gebauer, D., 2011. Stable
prenucleation mineral clusters are liquid-like ionic polymers. Nature
communications 2, 590.
Etschmann, B. E., Liu, W., Testemale, D., Müller, H., Rae, N. A., Proux, O., Hazemann, J.
L., and Brugger, J., 2010. An in situ XAS study of copper(I) transport as
hydrosulfide complexes in hydrothermal solutions (25-592 °C, 180-600 bar):
Speciation and solubility in vapor and liquid phases. Geochimica et Cosmochimica
Acta 74, 4723-4739.
Frantz, J. D. and Marshall, W. L., 1984. Electrical conductances and ionization constants of
salts, acids, and bases in supercritical aqueous fluids; I, Hydrochloric acid from 100
degrees to 700 degrees C and at pressures to 4000 bars. American Journal of Science
284, 651-667.
Harris, D. J., Brodholt, J. P., and Sherman, D. M., 2003. Zinc complexation in hydrothermal
chloride brines: Results from ab initio molecular dynamics calculations. Journal of
Physical Chemistry A 107, 1050-1054.
CHAPTER 6. CONCLUSION
167
Huheey, J. E., Keiter, E. A., Keiter, R. L., and Medhi, O. K., 1983. Inorganic chemistry:
principles of structure and reactivity. Harper & Row New York. page 464-467
Janes, R., Moore, E., and Abel, E. W., 2004. Metal-ligand bonding. Royal Society of
Chemistry, Cambridge.
Mei, Y., Sherman, D. M., Liu, W., and Brugger, J., 2013a. Ab initio molecular dynamics
simulation and free energy exploration of copper(I) complexation by chloride and
bisulfide in hydrothermal fluids. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 102, 45-64.
Mei, Y., Sherman, D. M., Liu, W., and Brugger, J., 2013b. Complexation of gold in S3--rich
hydrothermal fluids: Evidence from ab-initio molecular dynamics simulations.
Chemical Geology 347, 34-42.
Orgel, L. E., 1958. 843. Stereochemistry of metals of the B sub-groups. Part I. Ions with
filled d-electron shells. Journal of the Chemical Society (Resumed) 0, 4186-4190.
Sherman, D. M., 2007. Complexation of Cu+ in Hydrothermal NaCl Brines: Ab initio
molecular dynamics and energetics. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 71, 714-722.
Suleimenov, O. M. and Seward, T. M., 1997. A spectrophotometric study of hydrogen
sulphide ionisation in aqueous solutions to 350 °C. Geochimica et Cosmochimica
Acta 61, 5187-5198.
Sulpizi, M. and Sprik, M., 2008. Acidity constants from vertical energy gaps: density
functional theory based molecular dynamics implementation. Physical Chemistry
Chemical Physics 10, 5238-5249.
Sulpizi, M. and Sprik, M., 2010. Acidity constants from DFT-based molecular dynamics
simulations. Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 22, 284116.
Tagirov, B. R., Zotov, A. V., and Akinfiev, N. N., 1997. Experimental study of dissociation
of HCl from 350 to 500°C and from 500 to 2500 bars: Thermodynamic properties of
HCl°(aq). Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 61, 4267-4280.
Tossell, J. A., 2012. Calculation of the properties of the S3! radical anion and its complexes
with Cu+ in aqueous solution. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 95, 79-92.
CHAPTER 6. CONCLUSION
168
169
_____________________________________
Appendix A
Speciation and thermodynamic properties of Manganese (II) chloride complexes in hydrothermal fluids: in situ XAS study
_____________________________________
170
!"#"$%$&"'()'*+",(-.,/0' 1/"2$'()'3#0$-' !0$4/#"/(&' #&5' ",$-%(56&#%/4' 0-(0$-"/$.' ()' 7#&8#&$.$' 9::;' 4,2(-/5$' 4(%02$<$.' /&'
,65-(",$-%#2')2+/5.='!"#$!%&'>*!'."+56'
3+?2/4#"/(&'!"#"+.''
'
3+?2/4#"/(&'@$"#/2.' 1/#&A' BCA' D".4,%#&&A' ECA' 7$/A' BCA' F-+&52$-A' 3CA' 1$."$%#2$A' @CA' G#H$%#&&A' ICJKCA' D22/(""A' 3CA'L8(",#/A'BCA'E-+88$-A'ICA#!0$4/#"/(&'#&5' ",$-%(56&#%/4'0-(0$-"/$.'()'7#&8#&$.$' 9::;'4,2(-/5$'4(%02$<$.' /&' ,65-(",$-%#2' )2+/5.=' !"# $!%&' >*!' ."+56C' 9+&5$-' -$M/$N' )(-' F$(4,/%/4#'O(.%(4,/%/4#'*4"#;'
!"#$%&'(%)#&*+"#*%),'E6' ./8&/&8' ",$' !"#"$%$&"' ()' *+",(-.,/0A' $#4,' #+",(-' 4$-"/)/$.' ",#"' ",$/-' ."#"$5' 4(&"-/?+"/(&' "(' ",$' 0+?2/4#"/(&' /.' #44+-#"$' #&5' ",#"'0$-%/../(&'/.'8-#&"$5')(-'",$'0+?2/4#"/(&'"('?$'/&42+5$5'/&'",$'4#&5/5#"$P.'",$./.C'
L#%$'()'3-/&4/0#2'*+",(-'9O#&5/5#"$;' B+#&'1/#&'
O(&"-/?+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' @$./8&$5' #&5' 0$-)(-%$5' $<0$-/%$&".A' /&"$-0-$"$5' #&5' 0-(4$..$5' >*!' 5#"#A' #&5' N-("$'%#&+.4-/0"C'
'
!/8&#"+-$'
'
@#"$' QRJI+2JST'
'
L#%$'()'O(J*+",(-' E#-?#-#'D".4,%#&&'
O(&"-/?+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$5'N/",'$<0$-/%$&".A'#&5'%#&+.4-/0"'$M#2+#"/(&C'
!/8&#"+-$''
@#"$' QRJI+2JST'
'
L#%$'()'O(J*+",(-' B+#&'7$/'
O(&"-/?+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' 3$-)(-%$5'@U1'4#24+2#"/(&.A'#&5'N-("$'",$'@U1'0#-"'()'",$'%#&+.4-/0"C'
!/8&#"+-$'
'
@#"$' QRJI+2JST'
'
L#%$'()'O(J*+",(-' 3#.4#2'F-+&52$-'
O(&"-/?+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$5' N/",' .#%02$' %#"$-/#2' .6&",$./.' #&5' ."-+4"+-#2' %$#.+-$%$&".A' #&5' %#&+.4-/0"'$M#2+#"/(&C'
!/8&#"+-$'
'
@#"$' QRJI+2JST'
'
171
!
!
Name of Co-Author Denis Testemale
Contribution to the Paper Assisted with experiments, and manuscript evaluation.
Signature
Date 24-Jul-13
Name of Co-Author Jean-Louis Hazeman
Contribution to the Paper Assisted with experiments.
Signature
Date 24-Jul-13
Name of Co-Author Peter Elliott
Contribution to the Paper Assisted with sample material structural measurements, and manuscript evaluation.
Signature
Date 24-Jul-13
Name of Co-Author Yung Ngothai
Contribution to the Paper Assisted with manuscript evaluation.
Signature
Date 24-Jul-13
Name of Co-Author Joël Brugger
Contribution to the Paper Assisted with experiments and experimental design, and manuscript evaluation.
Acting as corresponding author.
Signature
Date 24-Jul-13
172
APPENDIX A
173
Speciation and thermodynamic properties of Manganese (II)
chloride complexes in hydrothermal fluids: in situ XAS study
Yuan Tian1, 2, Barbara Etschmann2, 3, Yuan Mei2, 3, 4, Pascal V. Grundler2, 3†, Denis
Testemale5, Jean-Louis Hazeman5, Peter Elliott2, Yung Ngothai1, Joël Brugger2, 3*
1. School of Chemical Engineering, The University of Adelaide, Adelaide 5000,
South Australia, Australia
2. Division of Mineralogy, South Australian Museum, Adelaide 5000, South
Australia, Australia
3. Tectonics, Resources and Exploration (TRaX), School of Earth and
Environmental Sciences, The University of Adelaide, Adelaide 5000, South
Australia, Australia
4. CSIRO Earth Science and Resource Engineering, Clayton, Victoria, 3168,
Australia
5. Institut Neel, Département MCMF, 38042 Grenoble, France; and FAME
beamline, ESRF, 38043 Grenoble, France
† Present address: Laboratory for Nuclear Materials, Paul Scherrer Institute, CH-
5232 Villigen PSI, Switzerland
* Corresponding author: [email protected]
APPENDIX A
174
Abstract The speciation of Mn(II) in acidic brines under a wide range of conditions (30-550 ˚C,
600 bar, 0.100 - 10.344 m chloride and 0.110 - 2.125 m bromide) was investigated using in
situ X-ray Absorption Spectroscopy (XAS). Increasing temperature and/or salinity results in
a structural change of the Mn(II) complexes from octahedral to (distorted) tetrahedral.
Octahedral species predominate at room temperature within the whole salinity range and
persist up to ~400 ˚C in low salinity solutions (mCl < 1 m), and tetrahedral species become
significant above 300 ˚C. A combination of EXAFS refinements, Density Functional Theory
calculations and ab initio XANES simulations shows that at temperatures ( 400 ˚C, the
highest order chlorocomplex predominating in high salinity solutions (mCl > 3 m, Cl:Mn
ratio > 53) is MnCl3(H2O)-, and that a lower order chlorocomplex, MnCl2(H2O)2(aq), is the
predominant species in low salinity solutions (mCl < 0.5 m, Cl:Mn ratio < 10). A similar
result was also found in Mn bromide solutions: MnBr3(H2O)- and MnBr2(H2O)2(aq) are the
dominant species at 500 ˚C in high salinity solutions (e.g., 2.125 m, Br:Mn ratio = 33.73)
and in low salinity solutions (e.g., 0.110 m, Br:Mn ratio = 2.04), respectively. XANES
spectra of Mn(II) chloride solutions were used to retrieve formation constants of
MnCl2(H2O)2(aq) and MnCl3(H2O)- at 600 bar. The speciation and thermodynamic model of
this study are consistent with previous solubility and UV-Vis spectroscopic studies.
Keywords: XAS, speciation, thermodynamic properties, Mn(II) chloride complexes,
coordination change, EXAFS, XANES, hydrothermal fluids.
APPENDIX A
175
1 Introduction
Manganese is the second most abundant transition element in the Earth’s crust. It is highly
mobile in hydrothermal systems, occurring in high concentrations in geothermal waters,
with values up to 59 ppm Mn recorded in Mid Oceanic Ridge fluids with Cl concentrations
close to that of seawater (~0.5 m Cl; James et al., 1995) and values up to 1900 ppm in
hypersaline brines (>5 m Cl; Salton Sea, McKibben and Williams, 1989). In general, Mn
concentrations in natural fluids increase with increasing temperature and increasing chlorine
concentrations, and hypersaline magmatic brines can carry in excess of one wt% Mn
(Yardley, 2005). The formation of much of the world’s Mn resources is related to shallow
hydrothermal circulation and interaction with surface waters (Brugger and Gieré, 1999;
Brugger and Meisser 2006; Cornell and Schütte, 1995; Roy, 1992), but due to its mobility,
Mn is an important metal in many hydrothermal processes (e.g. epithermal deposits; Davies
et al., 2008).
Accurate modeling of the transport and deposition of Mn under hydrothermal conditions is
required to improve predictive mineral exploration and to increase the efficiency of mineral
and metallurgical processing techniques (e.g., Seward and Driesner, 2004; Brugger et al.,
2010). Understanding Mn transport and deposition relies on our knowledge of the aqueous
complexes responsible for the mobility of Mn in hydrothermal fluids and on the availability
of thermodynamic properties for each of these species as a function of pressure, temperature,
and fluid composition (Seward and Barnes, 1997). Mn is widely accepted to exist mainly in
the form of the Mn(II) aqua ion and Mn(II) chloro complexes in hydrothermal waters
(Gammons and Seward, 1996; Yardley, 2005), and a number of studies have been carried
out to investigate Mn(II) aqueous speciation over a wide range of conditions using different
techniques (Table 1).
APPENDIX A
176
At temperatures to 300 ˚C, there is good agreement that the Mn2+ aqua ion, [Mn(H2O)6]2+
(e.g., Koplitz et al., 1994) and low order octahedral chlorocomplexes (mainly MnCl+)
predominate in acidic waters containing up to ~1 m Cl. MnCl+ was identified on the basis of
potentiometric (Libu+ and Tialowska, 1975), electron spin resonance (Wheat and Carpenter,
1988), solubility (Gammons and Seward, 1996) and spectrophotometric (Libu+ and
Tialowska, 1975; Suleimenov and Seward, 2000) measurements. In highly saline solutions
(Cl >> 2 m) and with increasing temperature (150-300 ˚C), octahedral MnCl2(aq) becomes an
important complex; however no evidence for a higher order Mn(II) chloride complex, e.g.,
MnCl3- and MnCl4
2- was found in solutions up to 300 ˚C (Gammons and Seward, 1996;
Suleimenov and Seward, 2000). Boctor (1985) found that Mn(II) speciation was dominated
by MnCl2(aq) in supercritical solutions with low Cl:Mn ratio (2-7) over the temperature range
400 to 700 ˚C at 1 and 2 kbar. At higher Cl:Mn ratios (Cl:Mn >> 7), Uchida et al. (1995,
2003) and Uchida and Tsutsui (2000) concluded that MnCl3- was the predominant species in
2 mole/(kg H2O) (m) NaCl solutions at similar T-P conditions.
XAS studies of Mn complexing with halide ions at ambient conditions confirmed the
existence of a series of six-fold octahedral Mn(II) species [MnXn(H2O)(6-n)](2-n)+ (X = Cl and
Br; n=0, 1, 2) in solutions containing 0.10 – 4.95 m MnCl2, 0.10 – 5.2 m MnBr2 and 0.05 – 6
m MnBr2 (Beagley et al., 1991; Chen et al., 2005a). Currently, there is no XAS
characterization of the structure of Mn(II) chloroaqua complexes in aqueous solutions under
hydrothermal conditions, but Chen et al. (2005b) reported a structural transition of Mn(II)
bromoaqua complexes from octahedral at room-T, 1 bar to tetrahedral under supercritical
conditions (400 ˚C, 310 bar, 0.4 - 1.2 m Brtot). The highest order complex identified was
MnBr3(H2O)-, similarly to the MnCl3(H2O)- complex found in concentrated 2 m NaCl
solutions at high temperature (Uchida et al., 1995, 2003; Uchida and Tsutsui, 2000).
APPENDIX A
177
Table 1 Previous studies of aqueous Mn(II) speciation under ambient and hydrothermal
conditions.
T, P and composition Species identified Reference
Solubility
400 – 700 °C at 1 and 2 kbar, Cl:Mn ratio = 2 – 7 MnCl2(aq) Boctor,1985
25 – 275 °C at Psat, 4 < pH < 10 Mn2+, MnHCO3+, MnCO3(aq),
Mn(OH)CO3, Mn(OH)2(aq) Wolfram and Krupp, 1996
25 – 300 °C at Psat, 0.01-6.0 m HCl and Cl:Mn ratio ≥ 2 Mn2+, MnCl+, MnCl2(aq)
Gammons and Seward, 1996
400 – 600 °C at 1 kbar, 2 m NaCl MnCl3- Uchida et al., 1995
300 – 800 °C at 1 kbar, 0.5 – 1 kbar at 600 °C, 2 m NaCl MnCl2(aq), MnCl3
- Uchida and Tsutsui, 2000
300 – 800 °C at 1 kbar, 2 m NaCl MnCl2(aq), MnCl3- Uchida et al., 2003
Electron Spin Resonance spectroscopy
20 °C at 1 bar, 50 ppb – 15 ppm Mn in marine and lacustrine pore waters
Mn2+, MnCl+, MnSO4(aq), MnCO3(aq), Mn(HCO3)+ Carpenter, 1983
50 – 170 °C at 1 – 100 bar, & 1.0 m Cl Mn2+, MnCl+, MnSO4(aq) Wheat and Carpenter, 1988
Potentiometry and UV spectroscopy
25 °C at 1 bar, 0.01m Cl Mn2+, MnCl+ Libu+ and Tialowska, 1975
UV-Vis spectroscopy
25 – 250 °C at Psat, 0.9 m Mn(ClO4)2 with 0.01 m HClO4
Mn(H2O)62+ Koplitz et al., 1994
25 – 300 °C at Psat, 0.022 – 0.80 m Cl Mn2+, MnCl+, MnCl2(aq)
Suleimenov and Seward, 2000
XAS spectroscopy Ambient conditions, 0.1 m (n-
C4H9)NXO4 (X=Cl, Br) in hexamethylphosphoric triamide
solution
MnCl+, MnCl2(aq), MnCl3-, MnBr+,
MnBr2(aq), MnClBr(aq), MnCl2Br- Ozutsumi et al., 1994
Ambient conditions, 0.10 – 4.95 m MnCl2, 0.10 – 5.2 m MnBr2
Mn(H2O)62+, MnCl(H2O)5
+, MnCl2(H2O)4(aq), MnBr(H2O)5
+, MnBr2(H2O)4(aq)
Beagley et al., 1991
Ambient conditions, 0.05 – 6 m MnBr2
Mn(H2O)62+, MnBr(H2O)5
+, MnBr2(H2O)4(aq)
Chen et al., 2005a
25 – 400 °C at 1 – 310 bar, 0.4 – 1.2 m Br
and Cl:Mn ratio = 2 – 6
Mn(H2O)62+, MnBr(H2O)3
+, MnBr2(H2O)2(aq), MnBr3(H2O)- Chen et al., 2005b
This study provides a molecular-level understanding of Mn(II) chloride complexing in
chloride solutions (0.100 m & Cltot & 10.344 m) by in situ XAS analysis over a wide
APPENDIX A
178
temperature range (30 to 550 ˚C, 600 bar). The experimental results are supported by
Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations. This study aims to: i) map the effects of
temperature and salinity on the coordination changes of Mn(II) chloroaqua complexes;
ii) identify whether high order tetrahedral Mn(II) chloroaqua complexes exist at elevated
temperatures and determine the structure (stoichiometry and geometry) of the predominant
Mn(II) complexes by EXAFS refinements, DFT calculations and ab initio XANES
simulations; iii) establish a Mn(II) speciation model that is consistent with the available
experimental data (e.g., Suleimenov and Seward, 2000).
2 Materials and methods
2.1 Experimental samples
Millipore® doubly deionized water and analytical grade chemicals (MnCl2•4H2O(s),
MnBr2•4H2O(s), NaCl(s), NaBr(s), HCl(aq), HBr(aq), LiCl(s)) purchased from Sigma-Aldrich
were used without further treatment. All sample solutions were prepared by dissolving
MnCl2•4H2O(s) or MnBr2•4H2O(s) in Millipore® doubly deionized water, slightly acidified
with HCl/HBr to prevent hydrolysis of Mn2+ (Table 2). Accurately weighed amounts of
NaCl(s)/NaBr(s) were added to prepare a series of solutions with the desired chloride/bromide
concentration. LiCl(s) was used to achieve the highest chloride concentration (solution 8,
10.344 m Cltot). Distribution of species calculations performed using the HCh package
(Shvarov and Bastrakov, 1999) confirm that the hydrolysis of Mn2+ can be neglected
throughout the temperature range in this study based on the thermodynamic properties of
Mn(OH)+ from Shock et al. (1997) and of Mn(OH)2(aq) from Wolfram and Krupp (1996).
APPENDIX A
179
Table 2 List of sample solutions.
Solution No. Mn [m] NaCl [m] HCl [m] Total Cl [m] Cl:Mn molar ratio
1 0.050 0 0.0003 0.100 2.00
11 0.050 0.054 0.0026 0.157 3.14
6 0.050 0.154 0.0026 0.257 5.14
13 0.051 0.411 0.0026 0.516 10.12
7 0.053 0.941 0.0027 1.050 19.81
12 0.056 2.001 0.0043 2.117 37.80
9 0.058 2.959 0.0028 3.078 53.07
14 0.061 3.982 0.0028 4.107 67.33
3 0.064 5.000 0.0029 5.131 80.17
Solution No. Mn [m] LiCl [m] HCl [m] Total Cl [m] Cl:Mn molar ratio
8 0.141 10.045 0.0167 10.344 73.36
Solution No. Mn [m] NaBr [m] HBr [m] Total Br [m] Br:Mn molar ratio
5 0.054 0 0.0016 0.110 2.04
15 0.105 0.990 0.0043 1.204 11.47
4 0.063 1.997 0.0016 2.125 33.73
The oxygen- and moisture-sensitive solid compound tetraethylammonium
tetrachloromanganate(II), (NEt4)2MnCl4(s), which contains tetrahedral [MnCl4] moieties
(Cotton et al., 1962; Mahoui et al. 1996), was synthesized for use as a solid standard. Details
of the synthesis procedures, and crystal structure solution and refinement are given in the
Supplementary Information (SI). For standards containing Mn in octahedral coordination,
rhodochrosite (MnCO3) from the Sweet Home Mine, Colorado (South Australian Museum
collection number G9806; [MnO6] moieties; Maslen et al., 1995) and MnCl2•4H2O(s)
(Sigma-Aldrich; [MnCl2(H2O)4] moieties; Zalkin et al., 1964; El Saffar and Brown, 1971)
were used. The identity of these standards was confirmed via X-ray powder diffraction.
APPENDIX A
180
2.2 XAS Measurements
XAS measurements were conducted at beamline BM-30B (FAME) at the European
Synchrotron Research Facility (ESRF) (see SI for details). The spectroscopic cell developed
by the Laboratoire de Cristallographie, CNRS, Grenoble was used for the XAS
measurements (Testemale et al., 2005). The autoclave was equipped with three 1.5 mm
thick beryllium windows that allow collection of fluorescence and transmission signals
concurrently up to a pressure of 750 bar. The sample solution was enclosed inside a glassy
carbon tube, and the pressure was transmitted to the sample by two glassy carbon pistons
using He as a medium. The Mn contents of the high purity beryllium (Brush Wellman grade
PF60) were & 0.01 wt%, and baseline XAS data show that the Mn signals from the Be
windows and scattering off the autoclave components are negligible.
The solution temperature was calibrated using XAS to measure the density of water as a
function of the thermocouple temperature at 600 bar (Etschmann et al., 2010; Borg et al.,
2012). The mass attenuation coefficients from Chantler (1995) (8.55 keV) and the water
densities tabulated in the NIST database (Lemmon et al., 2000) were used in the
calculations. The temperatures used throughout this paper are the calibrated temperatures,
with estimated precisions better than ± 5 ˚C.
2.3 Extended X-ray Absorption Fine-Structure (EXAFS) data analysis
EXAFS fluorescence data were analyzed by the HORAE package (Ravel and Newville,
2005), using the procedure outlined in Etschmann et al. (2010). EXAFS calculations were
performed using FEFF8 (Ankudinov et al., 1998). Based on the FLUO
(http://www.aps.anl.gov/~haskel/fluo.html) and BOOTH (Booth and Bridges, 2003)
algorithms, self-absorption is negligible, and therefore raw data were used in the XANES
and EXAFS analysis. A ‘spike’ at about 6596 eV (~3.6 Å-1 in k-space), present on all Mn(II)
spectra (feature F in Figures 1-3), is attributed to a multielectron excitation (KMII,III
APPENDIX A
181
transition; Chen et al., 2005a). Removal of this feature had negligible effect on the EXAFS
refinements, thus the raw spectra were analyzed without further correction. All EXAFS
refinements were performed based on k2-weighted data in R-space using a Hanning window.
2.4 Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations
DFT calculations were performed using the Amsterdam Density Functional program,
ADF2010.02 (Te Velde et al., 2001) to optimize the geometries for the proposed Mn(II)
complexes. The basis functions are localized Slater-type orbitals. The Vosko-Wilk-Nusair
parameterization (Vosko et al., 1980) was used for Local Density Approximation, the
exchange functional of Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof (Perdew et al., 1996) generalized gradient
approximation was used to calculate the exchange-correlation energy (Parr and Yang, 1989).
For all atoms, an uncontracted triple-zeta basis set was used with polarization functions
(Van Lenthe and Baerends, 2003). Frozen core orbitals (Mn: 1s, 2s, 2p; Cl: 1s, 2s, 2p; Br: 1s,
2s, 2p, 3s, 3p and O: 1s) were applied during the calculations to reduce the computational
time (Peacock and Sherman, 2004; Te Velde et al., 2001). All calculations were done using
the spin-unrestricted formalism to account for the five unpaired 3d-electrons of Mn(II)
(Sherman, 2009). The Conductor-like Screening model (COSMO) (Klamt and Schuurmann,
1993; Pye and Ziegler, 1999) was employed to account for long-range solvation in aqueous
solutions under hydrothermal conditions (Sherman, 2007; 2010; Tossell 2012). In COSMO
models, each atom is surrounded by a sphere of radius Ra = 1.17 $ RavDW (where Ra
vDW is the
van der Waals radius of the atom) as optimized by Klamt et al. (1998) in order to define a
molecular cavity; radii of 2.1 Å for Mn, 1.72 Å for O, 1.3 Å for H, and 2.05 Å for Cl and Br
were used. Outside of this cavity, the solvent is represented as a dielectric continuum. A
dielectric constant of 10 and a solvent radius of 1.3 Å were applied to represent
hydrothermal fluids at 500 ˚C, 600 bar (Fernandez et al., 1997).
APPENDIX A
182
2.5 Ab initio X-ray Absorption Near Edge Structure (XANES)
simulations
Ab initio XANES simulations were conducted using the FDMNES program (Joly, 2001)
following the method described in recent studies of metal complexing (Brugger et al., 2007;
Testemale et al., 2009; Etschmann et al., 2010; Liu et al., 2011, 2012; Borg et al., 2012;
Tian et al., 2012; Tooth et al., 2012). FDMNES calculates the photo-absorption cross
section using two different methods: i) multiple scattering theory, which uses the Muffin
Tin (MT) approximation to evaluate the inter-atomic potentials; and ii) the Finite Difference
Method (FDM), which avoids the limitations of the MT approximation by allowing a free
potential shape (Joly, 2001). To compare to the experimental spectra, the calculated raw
data were convoluted to account for the broadening of the features caused by experimental
resolution, core-hole life-time, inelastic plasmon interactions with the photoelectron, and
Fermi energy. Details of convolution parameters are provided in the SI.
3 Qualitative analysis of XAS spectra
3.1 Effect of temperature
The Mn K-edge XAS spectra of the two solutions containing the lowest and highest Cl
concentrations (S1: 0.10 m Cl and S8: 10.34 m Cl) are shown in Figure 1 as a function of
temperature at 600 bar. With increasing temperature, the changes in XANES spectra include:
i) the intensity of the pre-edge (feature A) increases; ii) the shoulder (feature B) at the lower
energy side of the white line becomes more prominent; iii) the intensity of the white line
(feature C) decreases and its position shifts towards lower energy; and iv) reduced intensity
of the oscillation in the 6570 to 6610 eV range (features E and F). This evolution is similar
to that observed for Mn2+ in bromide solutions (Chen et al., 2005a, b) and for some other
divalent transition metals in halide solutions (e.g., Fe2+ in chloride solutions, Testemale et
al., 2009; Co2+ in chloride and bromide solutions, Liu et al., 2011; Ni2+ in chloride and
APPENDIX A
183
bromide solutions, Hoffman et al., 1999, Tian et al., 2012; Cd2+ in chloride solutions,
Barzakina et al., 2010), and reflects a structural transition from octahedral to tetrahedral.
Figure 1 XANES spectra of S1 (0.100 m Cl) and S8 (10.344 m Cl) as a function of
temperature from 30 to 550 oC (a and b). The growth of the pre-edge peak at about 6540 eV
is shown in the insets upon heating. EXAFS spectra in k-space of S1 and S8 with increasing
temperature (c), and R-space spectra of of S1 and S8 at two extreme temperatures (30 and
550 oC) compared with those of Mn solid reference compounds – MnCO3(s) and
(NEt4)2MnCl4(s).
APPENDIX A
184
The transition from octahedral to tetrahedral–like structures occurs at higher temperatures
for S1 than for S8 (Figure 1a). For solution S1, only small spectral changes can be observed
in the XANES and EXAFS spectra from 25 ˚C to 200 ˚C (Figure 1a, c), implying that
octahedral complexes are largely dominant over this temperature range. Spectra of S1
change dramatically upon heating from 200 to 500 ˚C, but show only subtle systematic
changes upon further heating to 550 ˚C. In contrast, the spectra of solution S8 change
rapidly from 30 to 300 ˚C, but evolve slowly at temperatures above 300 ˚C (Figure 1b, d),
which suggests that Mn speciation in this solution is dominated by a single species at
T > 300 ˚C. The Fourier-transformed spectra reflect the radial distribution function around
Mn2+ ions, and the main peaks for MnCO3(s) and (NEt4)2MnCl4(s) correspond to six Mn-O
and four Mn-Cl bonds, respectively (Figure 1d). The centroids of the main peaks of the S1
and S8 solutions are close to those of MnCO3(s) at 30 ˚C, and move to larger R values at
550 ˚C, close to (NEt4)2MnCl4(s). The increase of bond distances to neighboring ligands
upon heating is related to a chlorination process, which results in the replacement of H2O by
Cl- in the first shell of Mn2+ associated with a structural transition from six-coordination to
four-coordination.
The XANES pre-edge feature is strongly indicative of the local geometry of Mn(II) (Chen et
al., 2005a, b; Farges, 2005; Chalmin et al., 2009). The pre-edge peak is due to the 1s,3d
transition that is forbidden in symmetrical sites; a small pre-edge in octahedrally
coordinated environments is related to a weak electric quadrupole caused by distortion and
p-d hybridization (e.g., MnCl2•4H2O(s); feature A in Figure 2a; Shulman et al., 1976; Westre
et al., 1997). Intense pre-edges are characteristic of electric dipole transitions, such as those
allowed in tetrahedral symmetry (de Groot et al., 2009; Shulman et al., 1976; Westre et al.,
1997; Yamamoto, 2008). Hence the pre-edge data are consistent with octahedral complexes
APPENDIX A
185
dominating at low temperature (Figure 2a) and tetrahedral complexes at high temperature
(Figure 2c).
Figure 2 XANES spectra of Mn(II) chloride solutions as a function of salinity from 0.100 to
10.344 m Cl at (a) 100 oC, (b) 300 oC and (c) 500 oC,. The growth of pre-edge peak at
around 6540 eV with increasing chloride concentration are shown in insets. XANES spectra
of Mn reference compounds – MnCl2.4H2O(s) and (NEt4)2MnCl4(s) are also shown in (a) and
(c) for comparison. All features are labelled in (b,c), same labels apply to (a).
APPENDIX A
186
3.2 Effect of salinity
Mn K-edge XANES spectra are shown as a function of salinity at fixed temperatures (100,
300 and 500 ˚C in Figure 2). The effect of increasing salinity from 3.078 to 10.344 m at
100 ˚C is small (Figure 2a): it results in a slight decrease of white line intensity, an energy
shift (1.6 eV) of the white line peak to lower energy and the growth of a band at ~6575 eV.
The XANES spectra of the highest salinity solution (S8) resemble that of MnCl2•4H2O(s)
(Figure 2a), containing octahedral MnCl2(H2O)4 moieties. Hence, octahedral species
dominate Mn speciation at low temperature throughout the whole salinity range (Farges,
2005; Chalmin et al., 2009).
The effect of salinity is more pronounced at elevated temperatures, in particular at 300 ˚C
(Figure 2b). S1 has a typical octahedral spectrum, while the spectrum of S8 is characteristic
of tetrahedral-like coordination. At 500 ˚C, Mn exists in tetrahedral-like complexes, with
XANES spectra similar to that of (NEt4)2MnCl4(s) (Figure 2c), and no spectral changes occur
upon further heating to 550 ˚C (Figures 1a, b). At ( 500 ˚C, the solutions can be categorized
into two groups based on the shape of the white line (feature C) and intensities of the
features B and E: the low salinity (S1, S11, and S6) and high salinity groups (S14, S3, and
S8). In particular, feature E is strongest for (NEt4)2MnCl4(s), is significant for solutions of
the high salinity group, but is absent for the low salinity group (Figure 2c). These
differences suggest that two tetrahedral species with a different ratio of water to chloride
ligands dominate Mn(II) speciation in low and high salinity solutions at high temperature. A
similar situation was found for Co(II) chlorocomplexes at 440 ˚C, with tetrahedral
CoCl2(H2O)2(aq) and CoCl42- complexes dominating in low and high salinity solutions,
respectively (Liu et al., 2011).
APPENDIX A
187
3.3 XANES spectra of bromide solutions
The spectral evolution of the Mn(II) bromide solutions follows a similar trend to that of the
Mn-Cl solutions (Figure 3). Two isosbestic points at ~6565 and 6583 eV in the XANES
spectra of both chloride and bromide solutions support the structural transition from
octahedral to tetrahedral-like as a function of both temperature and salinity (Figures 1-3).
The structural transition for Mn(II) complexes occurs at higher temperature in Br than in Cl
solutions for similar halide concentrations, as it did for Co(II) (Liu et al., 2011). At 400 ˚C,
Linear Combination Fits (LCF) in Athena, (Ravel and Newville, 2005; 6519 to 6589 eV)
show that in the dilute solutions S5 (0.110 m Br) and S1 (0.100 m Cl), tetrahedral species
account for 57% and 71%, respectively; in the more concentrated solutions S4 (2.125 m Br)
and S12 (2.117 m Cl), tetrahedral species account for 63% and 80%, respectively. Note that
at 500 ˚C the solutions with the lowest and highest Br contents (0.110 - 2.125 m Br) show
only slight differences and a similar feature E (Figure 3c).
APPENDIX A
188
Figure 3 XANES spectra of S5 (0.110 m Br) and S4 (2.125 m Br) as a function of
temperature from 30 to 500 oC (a and b). The representative individual XANES spectra are
shown in (c) with the pre-edge region shown in the inset.
4 EXAFS refinements
EXAFS analysis constrained the coordination number and bond distances for Mn(II)
chloride and bromide complexes. An S02 value of 0.68 was obtained by fitting the EXAFS
data of (NEt4)2MnCl4(s) and solution S1 (0.050 m MnCl2) at 30 ˚C and 1 bar (SI, section
APPENDIX A
189
4.1). This value is similar to that of 0.72 used in the study of Mn-bromide complexing by
Chen et al. (2005a, b), and was used in all subsequent EXAFS refinements.
The -E0 parameter accounts for a misalignment of energy between theoretical calculations
and experiments (Kelly et al., 2008). Metal-ligand distances are strongly correlated with
-E0 (Bunker, 2010), and in some cases assigning different -E0 to different ligands can
result in more physically significant fits (Kelly et al., 2008). In this case, using a single -E0
to fit the 500 ˚C data for S1 (0.100 m Cl), assuming a coordination number of four
(Section 3), resulted in poor agreement (R-factor > 0.50, an order of magnitude higher than
refinements reported in Table 3) and in a Mn-O distance of 2.27 Å, far longer than the room
temperature octahedral Mn-O distance of 2.16 Å, but close to the tetrahedral Mn-Cl distance
of 2.31 Å, suggesting that O and Cl are interchangeable during the fitting. Therefore,
different -E0 values were used for the Mn-Cl and Mn-O scattering shells. In order to limit
the number of fit parameters, the -E0 values were determined from fitting the standards
(NEt4)2MnCl4(s) [-E0(Mn-Cl) = 6.1(7)] and Mn(H2O)62+ [solution S1 at 30 ˚C, 1 bar;
-E0(Mn-O) = -0.9(7)]. The two -E0 values were allowed to vary within the error range
obtained on the standards for each individual fit; a similar approach was used by Mayanovic
et al. (2002, 2009).
4.1 Mn-Cl solutions
4.1.1 Solutions with one dominant coordination geometry
XANES analysis showed that octahedral complexes dominate Mn(II) speciation at low-T
and tetrahedral complexes at high-T (Figure 2). The EXAFS fit of S1 at 30 ˚C (Table 3 and
Figure 4) confirms that the octahedral Mn(H2O)62+ complex (6.1(4) water) is the
predominant species in chloride-poor solutions (e.g., Chen et al., 2005a), and the number of
water ligands for solutions containing 0.100 – 3.078 m Cl at 30 ˚C were around 6 within
error (SI, Table S4). Attempts to add one chloride into the first octahedral shell resulted in a
APPENDIX A
190
statistically worse fit (i.e. the change in reduced $2 for the two fits is greater than two
standard deviations, as defined by Kelly et al., (2008; equation 19). The refined Mn-O bond
distance of 2.16(1) Å is in good agreement with the literature value of 2.169(7) Å (Chen et
al., 2005a) for the Mn(II) hexaaqua complex in a 0.05 m MnBr2 solution at 25 ˚C and 1 bar.
With increasing salinity, the presence of chloride within the octahedral complex was
detectable for solutions with chloride concentrations ( 4.107 m at 30 ˚C, ( 2.117 m at
100 ˚C, and all chloride concentrations at T ( 200 ˚C (SI). The refined Mn-O and Mn-Cl
bond lengths for solution S8 at 100 ˚C are 2.17(2) Å and 2.49(2) Å, respectively, in
excellent agreement with the averaged Mn-O lengths of 2.20(2) Å and Mn-Cl length of
2.49(2) Å of MnCl2•4H2O(s) (Zalkin et al., 1964; El Saffar and Brown, 1971) and of MnCl2
solutions (Beagley et al., 1991).
Figure 4 Experimental (blue dashed line) and fitted (red solid line) EXAFS spectra of S1
(0.100 m Cl) and S8 (10.344 m Cl) at 30 ˚C and 500 ˚C in (a) k-space and (b) R-space. All
fits are shown with k2 weighting.
APPENDIX A
191
Table 3 Summary of EXAFS refinements of selected Mn chloride and bromide solutions at
extreme temperatures at 600 bar.
Mn-O interaction Mn-Cl interaction T
(˚C) !E0 (eV) NO RMn-O
(Å) "O
2(Å2#10-
3) !E0 (eV) NCl RMn-Cl
(Å) "Cl
2(Å2#10-
3)
R-range k-range R-
factor $2
S1, 0.100 m Cl, Cl:Mn molar ratio = 2.00
30 -1.0 6.1(4) 2.16(1) 4.6(1.0) - - - - 1-4.3 2.2-11 0.016 16.84
100 -1.6 6.2(4) 2.15(1) 6.5(1.3) - - - - 1-4.3 2.2-10.5 0.019 14.64
500 -1.6 2.1(3) 2.13(5) 9.6(6.2) 6.8 1.9(3) 2.33(1) 7.4(3.0) 1-3 2.2-11 0.015 17.94
550 -1.6 2.0(6) 2.15(10) 13(16) 6.8 2.0(6) 2.32(2) 6.2(4.2) 1-3 2.2-11 0.034 10.72
S3, 5.131 m Cl, Cl:Mn molar ratio = 80.17
30 -1.1 5.1(4) 2.16(1) 5.6(1.1) 6.8 0.9(4) 2.53(3) 7(5) 1-4.5 2.2-11 0.022 12.18
500 -1.6 1.0(4) 2.14(10) 5.9(1.0)* 6.5 3.0(4) 2.37(2) 5.9(1.0)* 1-3 2.2-10 0.013 8.27
S8, 10.344 m Cl, Cl:Mn molar ratio = 73.36
30 -0.3 4.4(5) 2.18(2) 6.1(1.3) 5.4 1.6(5) 2.51(2) 5.5(2.8) 1-4.7 2.2-11 0.024 12.28
100 -1.6 4.0(4) 2.17(2) 7.5(1.4) 5.4 2.0(4) 2.49(2) 7.9(2.3) 1-4.3 2.2-11 0.019 14.51
500 -1.6 1.0(3) 2.13(5) 7.3(1.0)* 6.2 3.0(3) 2.37(1) 7.3(1.0)* 1-3 2.2-11 0.016 16.13
550 -1.6 1.0(4) 2.12(10) 8.1(1.0)* 6.2 3.0(4) 2.37(2) 8.1(1.0)* 1-3 2.2-11 0.013 12.32
S5, 0.110 m Br, Br:Mn molar ratio = 2.04
30 -1.7(8) 6.4(5) 2.15(1) 5.1(1.3) -1.7(8) † - - - 1-4.3 2.2-11.0 0.028 10.57
500 -1.8(2.6) 2.2(1.1) 2.14(3) 16(12) -1.8(2.6) † 1.7(7) 2.43(1) 6.1(3.4) 1-3 2.2-10.5 0.026 5.52
S4, 2.125 m Br, Br:Mn molar ratio = 33.73
30 0.8(1.3) 5.6(8) 2.18(2) 6(3)* 0.8(1.3) † 0.2(4) 2.40(21) 6(3)* 1-4.3 2.2-9.8 0.039 14.99
500 -3.3(2.9) 1.3(5) 2.14(4) 9.8(2.9)* -3.3(2.9) † 3.0(1.1) 2.43(2) 9.8(2.9)* 1-3 2.2-10.5 0.059 5.96
* Debye-waller factor set to be identical for Mn-O and Mn-Cl interactions.
† -E0 set to be identical for Mn-O and Mn-Br interactions.
Please see detailed EXAFS refinements of all sample solutions from 30 to 550˚C in the supplementary
information.
The coordination number of Mn was constrained to be four for all EXAFS refinements of
solutions at 500 ˚C and 550 ˚C (Section 3). For the weakly saline solutions (0.100 & mCltot &
0.257), the numbers of water and chloride were both around two, revealing predominance of
the MnCl2(H2O)2(aq) complex. At high salinity, the best fit was MnCl3.0(4)O1.0(4) for all
solutions with ≥5.131 m Cltot (Table 3), consistent with the MnBr3.4(1.6)O0.9(4) average
ligation identified by Chen et al. (2005b). The refined Mn-Cl bond length was 2.37(1) Å for
solution S8 at 500 ˚C (Figure 4; Table 3), identical to that of 2.37(1) Å for (NEt4)2MnCl4(s);
the fitted Mn-O bond length was 2.13(5) Å, within error of the room-T bonds length of
APPENDIX A
192
2.18(2) Å for S8 and 2.16(1) Å for S1. EXAFS refinement using a MnCl4 model resulted in
a statistically worse fit.
4.1.2 Solutions with mixed octahedral and tetrahedral complexes
Based on the XANES data, most chloride solutions contain mixtures of octahedral and
tetrahedral complexes at intermediate temperatures (200 – 450 ˚C). As each complex has
different Mn-O and Mn-Cl distances, Cl/O ratio, and Debye-Waller factors, parameter
under-determination is a problem. To reduce the number of fit parameters, EXAFS data at
intermediate temperatures for each solution were analyzed assuming that they consist of a
mixture of the species that exist at low (100 ˚C; octahedral coordination) and high
temperatures (500 ˚C; tetrahedral coordination). For each solution, the fraction of tetrahedral
and octahedral species was derived from XANES data via LCF (SI, section 4.2, Table S5).
These fractions were fixed in the EXAFS refinements and the Mn-Cl and Mn-O bond
lengths and corresponding Debye-Waller factors were fitted, and represent average values
of octahedral and tetrahedral complexes in each solution. A summary of EXAFS
refinements of all Mn chloride solutions (30 – 550 ˚C) can be seen in the SI (Table S4).
A contraction of the Mn-Cl bond length with increasing temperature for each solution is
noticeable. For example, the representative octahedral Mn-Cl bond length of 2.51(2) Å at
30 ˚C is around 0.14 Å longer than a typical tetrahedral Mn-Cl bond length of 2.37(2) Å at
500 ˚C (Solution S8, Table 3). The Mn-O bond distances of low salinity solutions (0.100 –
0.516 m) remain constant (2.16(1) Å) from 30 to 300 ˚C. This is inconsistent with the ~3%
increase in the Mn-O bond length for Mn(H2O)62+ (Cl-free perchlorate solutions, 25-250 ˚C)
interpreted by Koplitz et al. (1994) on the basis of UV-Vis spectroscopy. This discrepancy
may result from the omission of small amounts of tetrahedral complexes at high temperature
in Koplitz et al.’s analysis. For most other solutions there seems to be a small contraction of
APPENDIX A
193
the Mn-O bond distances from room-T to 500 ˚C (~0.05 Å), although this is not statistically
significant due to the relatively large errors at high temperature. The changes in O and Cl
ligation numbers as a function of temperature further illustrates the coordination change
from octahedral at 30 and 100 ˚C to tetrahedral at 450 and 500 ˚C for both S11 and S14,
with the structural transition happening at higher temperature (300–450 ˚C) for S11
compared to 200–400 ˚C for S14 (Figures 5a, b). At 300 and 400 ˚C, increasing salinity
causes a decrease in coordination number and an increase in the number of Cl ligands
(Figure 5c, d).
Figure 5 Number of oxygen (water molecule; red circles with error bars) and chloride (blue
triangles with error bars) ligands in the first shell of Mn2+ as a function of temperature for (a)
S11 (0.157 m Cl) and (b) S14 (4.107 m Cl) and as a function of chloride concentration (in
log scale) at (c) 300 ˚C and (d) 400 ˚C based on the EXAFS refinements (Table 3) and the
predictions (dashed lines) based upon the thermodynamic properties in Table 5.
APPENDIX A
194
4.2 Mn-Br solutions
Mn-Br EXAFS spectra were fitted following a similar strategy to the Mn-Cl solutions,
except for the use of a single -E0 for each refinement as it is easier to distinguish between
the Mn-O and Mn-Br scattering paths. The radial distribution function shows two distinct
peaks corresponding to the presence of O and Br within the first shell of Mn for solutions S5
(0.110 m Br) and S4 (2.125 m Br) at 500 ˚C (Figure 6b). The refined Mn-O bond length of
2.15(1) Å for S5 at 30 ˚C is identical to the bond lengths in the counterpart chloride
solutions, and with those refined by Chen et al. (2005a, b). At 500 ˚C, the best fit model of
MnBr3.0(1.1)O1.3(5) for solution S4 (2.125 m Br) is similar to the MnBr3.4(1.6)O0.9(4) model
identified by Chen et al. (2005b) at 400 ˚C and 310 bar (Table 3). The best fit model of
MnBr1.7(7)O2.2(1.1) for the low salinity solution S5 at 500 ˚C is also consistent with
MnBr1.9(2.4)O1.7(1.3) in a 0.2 m MnBr2 solution at 400 ˚C and 310 bar by Chen et al. (2005b).
The Mn-O and Mn-Br bond lengths refined in this study (Table 3) for tetrahedral Mn(II)
complexes are within error of those derived by Chen et al. (2005b). There is no obvious Mn-
O bond length contraction upon heating, but the Mn-Br bond length contraction expected
for a change from octahedral to tetrahedral coordination was observed: for solution S15, the
Mn-Br bond length of 2.58(5) Å) at 100 ˚C is 0.13 Å longer than the typical tetrahedral Mn-
Br bond length of 2.45(2) Å obtained at 500 ˚C.
APPENDIX A
195
Figure 6 Experimental (blue dashed line) and fitted (red solid line) EXAFS spectra of S5
(0.110 m Br) and S4 (2.125 m Br) at 30 ˚C and 500 ˚C in (a) k-space and (b) R-space. All
fits are shown with k2 weighting.
5 DFT calculations
The results of geometry optimization by DFT for the proposed Mn(II) complexes are
summarized in Table 4, with detailed structural information listed in the SI (Table S7). The
optimized Mn-O and Mn-Br bond distances were generally longer than the refined EXAFS
distances, while Mn-Cl distances were slightly shorter than the EXAFS distances (e.g.,
2.16 Å for Mn-O by EXAFS at 30 ˚C in 0.100 m Cl solution and 2.21 Å for DFT; 2.37 Å for
Mn-Cl by EXAFS at 500 ˚C in 10.344 m Cl solution and 2.34 Å for DFT). These
discrepancies are in-line with the expected accuracy of the DFT calculations (e.g., Bühl and
Kabrede 2006). The most important result from the DFT calculations is that the trends in the
variation of the experimental bond lengths are accurately reproduced: a small contraction
APPENDIX A
196
occurs when geometry changes from octahedral to tetrahedral, and the Mn-O, Mn-Cl and
Mn-Br bond lengths increase with increasing number of halide ligands within the same
coordination geometry.
Table 4 Bond distances for the manganese (II) clusters optimized by DFT. Where several
identical ligands are present, the value represents the average distance, with the standard
deviation given in parentheses.
Mn(II) Cluster Geometry Mn-O (Å) Mn-Cl (Å)
Mn(H2O)62+ Octahedral 2.21(2) -
MnCl(H2O)5+ Octahedral 2.26(1) 2.366
MnCl2(H2O)4 (aq) (cis) Octahedral 2.30(2) 2.429(2) MnCl2(H2O)4 (aq) (trans) Octahedral 2.287(6) 2.44(4)
MnCl(H2O)3+ Tetrahedral 2.129(1) 2.255
MnCl2(H2O)2 (aq) Tetrahedral 2.178(8) 2.291(1)
MnCl3(H2O)- Tetrahedral 2.232 2.338(5)
MnCl42- Tetrahedral - 2.381
MnBr(H2O)5+ Octahedral 2.25(1) 2.549
MnBr2(H2O)4 (aq) (cis) Octahedral 2.29(2) 2.599(4)
MnBr2(H2O)4 (aq) (trans) Octahedral 2.264(8) 2.64(13)
MnBr(H2O)3+ Tetrahedral 2.129(1) 2.414
MnBr2(H2O)2 (aq) Tetrahedral 2.17(2) 2.458(2)
MnBr3(H2O)- Tetrahedral 2.221 2.501(7)
MnBr42- Tetrahedral - 2.549
6 Ab initio XANES simulations
6.1 Simulations for solid standards
Calculations for Mn(II) solid standards were performed to assess the ability of XANES
simulations to reproduce the spectral features of known Mn(II) structures (Figure 7). The
compounds contain octahedral and tetrahedral moieties: octahedral [MnO6] in MnCO3(s),
APPENDIX A
197
octahedral [MnCl2(H2O)4] in MnCl2•4H2O(s), and tetrahedral [MnCl4] in (NEt4)2MnCl4(s).
For MnCO3(s), calculation with a radius of 6 Å using the FDM method reproduced the key
spectral features well (Figure 7a). Note that the raw spectrum (dotted line) reproduced well
the region of feature F, but the convolution process (solid line) smoothes out the sharp band
at ~6596 eV. This 6596 eV band is not due multielectron excitations, since multielectron
excitations are not taken into account in the calculations. For MnCl2•4H2O(s) and
(NEt4)2MnCl4(s), the calculated spectra with a radius of 3 Å using the FDM method was in
good agreement with the experimental spectrum except for a missing Feature B.
Calculations using larger radii (6 Å for MnCl2•4H2O(s) by FDM; 7 Å for (NEt4)2MnCl4(s) by
MT approximation) improved the agreement of feature B (Figure 7b, c). Therefore,
feature B for MnCl2•4H2O(s) and (NEt4)2MnCl4(s) is strongly affected by contributions from
beyond the first shell. Feature B is related to the 1s,4p electronic transition (Chen et al.,
2005a, b), and hence reflects a strong interaction between metal cation and the surrounding
ligands. Overall, the agreement for the standards inspires confidence that ab initio XANES
simulations can be used to explore the structure of Mn(II) in solution.
APPENDIX A
198
Figure 7 Experimental and calculated (both raw and convoluted) XANES spectra for Mn
model compounds: (a) MnCO3(s), (b) MnCl2.4H2O(s), and (c) (NEt4)2MnCl4(s). Open circles
are experimental spectra; the calculated raw spectra (‘raw’) and the convoluted spectra
(‘conv’) with different calculation radius using different methods (FDM: Finite Difference
Method, MS: multiple scattering theory) are shown. All features are labelled in (c), and
labels reemphasize only specific features in (a,b).
APPENDIX A
199
6.2 Simulations of aqueous complexes
The calculated XANES spectra based on DFT-optimized geometries for a series of
octahedral species with increasing Cl substitution exhibit a consistent trend with the spectral
evolution observed experimentally at low temperature with increasing salinity (Figure 8a):
the increase in pre-edge peak (inset in Figure 8a) and slight decrease in white line intensity,
the shift of white line to lower energy, and reduced oscillation of features D and E were
correctly reproduced. The inclusion of H atoms in the calculations affects mainly the
intensity of the pre-edge peak: the calculated pre-edge for the [Mn(H2O)6] moiety was over-
estimated compared to that for [MnO6] (Figure 8a). As these calculations were based on a
single rigid configuration and the H atoms are disordered (Testemale et al., 2009), the
overall effect of the H atoms on the XANES spectrum is expected to be small (e.g., Liu et
al., 2012). For tetrahedral species, increasing the number of Cl ligands from one to four
resulted in the following systematic changes in the calculated XANES spectra:
i) progressive growth of feature E, ii) decreased intensity of feature D, and iii) shifted
feature D to lower energy leading to a slimmer white line. These trends were consistent with
the evolution of experimental spectra at 500 ˚C when salinity increased from 0.100 to
10.344 m (Figures 2c and 8b). In particular, the intensity of feature E strongly depends on
the chloride ligation number of the predominant species: the more Cl- complexed to Mn2+,
the larger the bump is. Hence, comparison with the feature E for (NEt4)2MnCl4(s), which is
more intense than those of the aqueous solutions at 500 ˚C (Figure 2c), suggests that the Cl
ligation number of the aqueous solutions at 500 ˚C is less than four. In addition, the
intensity of features C and E for [MnCl4] are higher compared to the experimental spectrum
of S8 at 500 ˚C and feature C is broader and the intensity of feature E in [MnCl(H2O)3] did
not match that of the experimental spectrum of S1 at 500 ˚C (Figure 8b). Therefore, the best
agreement with the experimental spectra of S1 and S8 at 500 ˚C is obtained by the
APPENDIX A
200
calculated spectra of [MnCl2(H2O)2] and [MnCl3(H2O)], respectively. The XANES spectra
of the bromide solutions S5 (0.110 m Br) and S4 (2.125 m Br) at 500 ˚C were well
reproduced by the calculations for the [MnBr2(H2O)2] and [MnBr3(H2O)] clusters,
respectively, although the shape and intensity of feature C and E are less distinguishable
than in the counterpart Mn chloride complexes (Figure 8b). The main disagreement between
experimental and calculated spectra for tetrahedral complexes is a double peak for the white
line on the calculated spectra, instead of the experimental broad asymmetrical peak
(Figure 8b). The reason could be that no thermal and structural disorders were taken into
account for the XANES calculations; the absence of the second hydration shell may also
contribute to this discrepancy (Figure S3b in SI).
Figure 8 Experimental XANES spectra of some representative Mn solutions and calculated
XANES spectra of Mn-Cl-O clusters based on DFT-optimized structures (see text for
details). The calculated raw spectra were labelled as ‘raw’.
APPENDIX A
201
Overall, the XANES simulations confirm the result of the EXAFS analysis that stepwise
substitution of H2O by Cl- occurs within the octahedral coordination sphere around Mn2+
with increasing chlorinity at low temperatures (30 – 100 ˚C), and that MnCl2(H2O)2(aq) and
MnCl3(H2O)- predominate Mn speciation in low and high salinity solutions at elevated
temperatures (i.e., 450 – 500 ˚C).
7 Discussion: Mn(II) speciation in chloride brines
7.1 Nature of Mn(II) chlorocomplexes
The combination of XANES analysis (Section 3), EXAFS refinements (Section 4) and
DFT/ab initio XANES simulations (Sections 5/6) presents a complete picture of the
coordination changes of Mn(II) chloride complexes from ambient to supercritical conditions.
At low temperature, chloride anions replace some water groups within an octahedral
complex with increasing Cl- concentration. At 10.344 m Cltot, 1.6(5) Cl- at 30 ˚C and 2.0(5)
Cl- at 100 ˚C are bonded to Mn2+ (Table 3), indicating that a series of octahedral complexes
are present, e.g., MnCl(H2O)5+ and MnCl2(H2O)4(aq). Higher order octahedral complexes
such as MnCl3(H2O)3- and MnCl4(H2O)2
2- may exist in highly concentrated chloride
solutions from room-T to around 200 ˚C, but these complexes are minor species because
octahedral complexes transform to tetrahedral quickly upon heating above 100 ˚C and they
were not detected in our system (salinity: 0.100 – 10.344 m Cl) or in the UV-Vis
experiments of Suleimenov and Seward (2000). Thus, the octahedral complexes
Mn(H2O)62+, MnCl(H2O)5
+, and MnCl2(H2O)4(aq) were included in our final model.
The role of solvent on determining the coordination geometry of the Mn(II) halogenide
complexes was illustrated by Ozutsumi et al. (1994), who identified a series of five-fold
halogenated Mn(II) complexes in a hexamethylphosphoric triamide solution at room
temperature (dielectric constant ~30). In contrast, in Cl- or Br-bearing aqueous solutions,
APPENDIX A
202
Mn(II) complexes exhibit a coordination change from octahedral to tetrahedral upon heating
and/or increasing salinity. Chen et al. (2005b) identified a family of four-coordinated
species: MnBr(H2O)3+, MnBr2(H2O)2(aq) and MnBr3(H2O)-, but found no evidence for the
fully halogenated complex MnBr42-. Similarly, the highest order chloride complex we can
identify by combining XANES and EXAFS data was not MnCl42- but MnCl3(H2O)-. Hence,
the available data suggest that MnCl42- is only a minor species for Mn transport in brines up
to 10 m Cltot. Similarly, MnCl(H2O)3+ is only a minor species in very dilute solutions, and
Mn(II) speciation in Cl-bearing solutions at elevated temperatures (≥ 450 ˚C) consists
mainly of two tetrahedral complexes: MnCl2(H2O)2(aq) and MnCl3(H2O)- with the ratio of
the two species strongly depending on the total Cl- concentration and the Cl:Mn molar ratio.
Similar to the results for the Mn-Cl system, the EXAFS analysis for the Mn-Br system
confirm that: i) tetrahedral Mn(II) bromoaqua complexes dominate Mn speciation at 500 ˚C
and 600 bar; ii) MnBr2(H2O)2(aq) and MnBr3(H2O)- are the predominant species in solutions
with low and high Br concentrations, respectively; and iii) MnBr3(H2O)- is the highest order
Mn(II) bromocomplex that could be identified in all bromide solutions of this study.
Throughout all temperature and salinity ranges, no evidence of Mn hydroxide complexes
has been found and Mn speciation is controlled by halide complexes only, consistent with
speciation calculations conducted using the thermodynamic properties of Mn(OH)+ from
Shock et al (1997) and Mn(OH)2(aq) regressed from solubility data of Wolfram and Krupp
(1996) (Table 6).
7.2 Thermodynamic analysis
Normalized fluorescence XANES spectra of Mn(II) chloride solutions with a chlorinity
range of 0.100 - 5.131 m were used to derive formation constants for Mn(II) chloride
complexes following the method described in previous studies (Liu et al., 2007, 2011, 2012;
APPENDIX A
203
Testemale et al., 2009; Etchmann et al., 2011; Tian et al. 2012) using the BeerOz package
(Brugger 2007).
Three octahedral complexes and two tetrahedral complexes were included in the Mn
speciation model: Mn(H2O)62+, MnCl(H2O)5
+, MnCl2(H2O)4(aq), MnCl2(H2O)2(aq) and
MnCl3(H2O)-. In this analysis, we assume that the MnCl+ and MnCl2(aq) species identified in
previous studies at low temperatures (& 300 ˚C) have an octahedral geometry. Modified
Ryzhenko-Bryzgalin (MRB) parameters (Ryzhenko et al., 1985) for MnCl(H2O)5+ and
MnCl2(H2O)4(aq) were regressed using the optimC program (Shvarov, 2008) from the
following datasets and weighting scheme (Figures 10a, b; Table 6). For MnCl(H2O)5+, the
data derived from the solubility experiments of Gammons and Seward (1996) were given a
weighting of 0.5 at 25 ˚C and 50 ˚C, because of difficulties in equilibrating solubility
experiments at low temperature. The remaining data points (Libu+ and Tialowska 1975;
Carpenter 1983; Wheat and Carpenter 1988; Gammons and Seward, 1996; Suleimenov and
Seward, 2000) were given the weighting of 1.0. For MnCl2(H2O)4(aq), the UV-Vis data of
Suleimenov and Seward (2000) and the solubility data of Gammons and Seward (1996)
were given weightings of 1.0 and 0.8, respectively, to slightly emphasize the newest results.
The formation constants of NaCl(aq) and HCl(aq) were taken from Sverjensky et al. (1997)
and Tagirov et al. (2001), respectively.
As XANES simulations confirmed that the experimental XANES spectra of S1 at 30 ˚C, S3
at 100 ˚C, S8 at 100 ˚C, S1 and S8 at 500 ˚C were representative of the octahedral and
tetrahedral species Mn(H2O)62+, MnCl(H2O)5
+, MnCl2(H2O)4(aq), MnCl2(H2O)2(aq) and
MnCl3(H2O)-, respectively, the spectra of these species were fixed from their corresponding
experimental spectra. The idea is to limit the number of unknown parameters in the model
in order to retrieve formation constants for the two tetrahedral complexes MnCl2(H2O)2(aq)
and MnCl3(H2O)-. As tetrahedral complexes are unstable at low temperatures (30 and
APPENDIX A
204
100 ˚C), only the last four datasets (200 - 450 ˚C) were used for XANES fitting. The
formation constants for octahedral species were extrapolated from the MRB equation of
state, and fixed during the analysis. The refined formation constants for MnCl2(H2O)2(aq) and
MnCl3(H2O)- are listed in Table 5. The uncertainties in the fitted log K values were
estimated at the 90% confidence level based on residual maps using the F-distribution
factors given by Draper and Smith (1998).
Table 5 Formation constants of the aqueous species at 600 bar used in thermodynamic
analysis
Species 30 ˚C 100 ˚C 200 ˚C 300 ˚C 400 ˚C 450 ˚C References
HCl(aq) -0.78 -0.96 -0.33 0.79 2.33 3.51 Tagirov et al. (1997)
NaCl(aq) -0.83 -0.54 -0.04 0.61 1.57 2.45 Sverjensky et al. (1997)
MnCl(H2O)5+ 0.15 0.86 2.04 3.39 5.34 7.02
Libu+ and Tialowska (1975) Carpenter (1983)
Wheat and Carpenter (1988) Gammons and Seward (1996)
Suleimenov and Seward (2000)
MnCl2(H2O)4(aq) -5.66 -1.73 1.64 3.98 6.59 8.72 Gammons and Seward (1996) Suleimenov and Seward (2000)
MnCl2(H2O)2(aq) - - 1.04 (<1.55) 4.05(25) 7.52(15) 10.6(5) Fitted in this study
MnCl3(H2O)- - - 0.80 (<1.17) 3.76(25) 7.60(18) 11.2(3) Fitted in this study
The calculated Mn(II) speciation from 200 to 450 ˚C is shown in Figure 9. At 200 ˚C,
octahedral species predominate Mn speciation; at 300 ˚C tetrahedral species represent less
than 30% of all species from 0 to 0.8 m Cl, consistent with the findings of Suleimenov and
Seward (2000); at 400 ˚C octahedral species still persist in low salinity solutions but
tetrahedral species become predominant with increasing Cl concentration; and at 450 ˚C the
octahedral species are negligible, and only two tetrahedral species exist with the fraction of
APPENDIX A
205
each species depending on the total Cl concentration. The average ligation numbers
calculated using the properties in Table 5 are in good agreement with the EXAFS refined
stoichiometries (Figure 5), providing additional evidence that the refined formation
constants of MnCl2(H2O)2(aq) and MnCl3(H2O)- are valid.
Figure 9 Speciation as a function of chlorinity based on the refined thermodynamic
properties in Table 5 at (a) 200 °C, (b) 300 °C, (c) 400 and (d) 450 °C and 600 bar.
To further test the validity of the thermodynamic model presented here, we checked the
compatibility of the properties of MnCl2(H2O)2(aq) and MnCl3(H2O)- with the data obtained
by Boctor (1985) and Uchida and Tsutsui (2000) at higher temperatures and pressures. In
this analysis, we assume that the MnCl2(aq) and MnCl3- species identified in these two
solubility studies at 1 and 2 kbar from 400 ˚C to 800 ˚C have a tetrahedral geometry. The
equilibrium constants for the reaction MnSiO3(s) + HCl(aq) = MnCl2(aq) + SiO2(s) + H2O at 1
and 2 kbar from 400 to 700 ˚C (Boctor, 1985) were converted to cumulative formation
APPENDIX A
206
constants for MnCl2(aq) using the thermodynamic properties of MnSiO3(s) from Robie et al.
(1978), HCl(aq) from Tagirov et al (1997) and SiO2(s) from Helgeson et al. (1978).
Attempting to fit all the data using MRB or HKF resulted in unrealistic pressure parameters,
i.e. the extrapolations predicted that the speciation was much more pressure sensitive in the
0-1000 bar region than experiments suggest, making the predictions 1-2.5 orders of
magnitude higher than the experimental data at 1 kbar (Figure 10c). Thus, in the final
analysis, the 1 kbar dataset of Boctor (1985) was discarded, and MRB parameters of
MnCl2(H2O)2(aq) were regressed from the combination of our data (weighting of 1.0; Table 5)
and the 2 kbar solubility data from Boctor (1985) (weighting of 0.5 applied for data at 400 –
500 ˚C; and 1.0 for 550 – 700 ˚C). The 1 kbar equilibrium constants for the reaction
MnCl2(aq) + Cl- = MnCl3- (Uchida and Tsutsui 2000) were converted to cumulative
formation constants for MnCl3- by extrapolating the formation constants of MnCl2(aq) to 1
kbar at 400 – 600 ˚C using the newly regressed MRB parameters of MnCl2(H2O)2(aq) (Table
6). Similarly, MRB parameters of MnCl3(H2O)- were regressed from the combination of our
data (Table 5) and the 1 kbar solubility data from Uchida and Tsutsui (2000) by equal
weighting. The refined formation constants of MnCl3(H2O)- at 600 bar in this study are
consistent with the 1 kbar data derived from Uchida and Tsutsui (2000) (Figure 10d). The
refined MRB parameters of the four Mn species are listed in Table 6 and calculated
formation constants of MnCl2(H2O)2(aq) and MnCl3(H2O)- at 150 – 800 ˚C from water
saturated pressure (Psat) to 2 kbar are shown in Table 7. Overall, the speciation and
thermodynamic model of this study are not only self-consistent but also compatible with
previous studies (e.g., Boctor, 1985; Gammons and Seward 1996; Suleimenov and Seward
2000; Uchida and Tsutsui 2000).
APPENDIX A
207
Table 6. MRB parameters (A(zz/a) and B(zz/a)) for Mn(OH)2(aq), MnCl(H2O)5+,
MnCl2(H2O)4(aq), MnCl2(H2O)2(aq) and MnCl3(H2O)-.
Species log K(298K) A(zz/a) B(zz/a)
Mn(OH)2(aq) 9.450 1.806 -748.90
MnCl(H2O)5+ 0.242 1.276 -191.18
MnCl2(H2O)4(aq) -5.293 0.263 963.32
MnCl2(H2O)2(aq) -6.936 1.000 679.76
MnCl3(H2O)- -4.627 2.303 -295.96
Figure 10 Formation constants (log K) of (a) MnCl(H2O)5+ determined by experimental
data of Libu+ and Tialowska (1975), Carpenter (1983), Wheat and Carpenter (1988),
Gammons and Seward (1996) and Suleimenov and Seward (2000); (b) MnCl2(H2O)4(aq)
determined by experimental data of Gammons and Seward (1996) and Suleimenov and
Seward (2000); (c) MnCl2(H2O)2(aq) determined by this study and derived from 1 and 2 kbar
data of Boctor (1985); (d) MnCl3(H2O)- determined by this study and derived from the
1 kbar data of Uchida and Tsutsui (2000). The solid lines represent fits to these
experimental data using the modified Ryzhenko–Bryzgalin (MRB) model (Ryzhenko et al.,
1985) with MRB parameters listed in Table 6.
APPENDIX A
208
Table 7 Formation constants for MnCl2(H2O)2(aq) and MnCl3(H2O)- from 150 to 800 ˚C at
water saturated pressure (Psat), 500 bar, 1000 bar and 2000 bar based on the properties in
Table 6. Note: MnCl2(H2O)2(aq) and MnCl3(H2O)- are unstable at low temperatures, and only
data from 150 to 800 ˚C are listed.
T (˚C) Psat 500 bar 1000 bar 2000 bar
MnCl2(H2O)2(aq)
150 -0.31 -0.79 -1.20 -1.87
200 1.58 1.00 0.54 -0.18
250 3.36 2.60 2.02 1.20
300 5.32 4.15 3.37 2.38
350 8.27 5.88 4.68 3.44
400 - 8.23 6.05 4.42
450 - 12.44 7.56 5.36
500 - - 9.27 6.28
600 - - 12.81 8.06
700 - - - 9.69
800 - - - 11.08
MnCl3(H2O)-
150 -0.44 -0.74 -0.99 -1.40
200 1.18 0.78 0.46 -0.03
250 2.89 2.31 1.88 1.26
300 4.89 3.93 3.29 2.49
350 7.91 5.83 4.78 3.69
400 - 8.43 6.41 4.90
450 - 13.03 8.26 6.12
500 - - 10.42 7.37
600 - - 15.19 9.94
700 - - - 12.49
800 - - - 14.85
7.3 Comparison with Fe(II) chloride complexing Like other first row divalent transition metals (e.g., Fe, Co, Ni, Zn, Cu; Collings et al. 2000;
Brugger et al. 2001; Liu et al. 2007, 2011, 2012; Testemale et al. 2009; Tian et al., 2012),
the stability of tetrahedral complexes is promoted both by increasing temperature and
APPENDIX A
209
chlorinity. Compared with Fe(II) chloride complexation, the octahedral to tetrahedral
structural transition occurs at higher temperature for Mn(II) complexes (Testemale et al.,
2009). The highest order chloride complex identified in this study is the tri-chloro mono-
aqua complex MnCl3(H2O)- with MnCl42- being unstable through all T-P-salinity range. In
contrast, the fully chlorinated tetrahedral complex [FeCl4]2- has high stability, being the
dominant species in concentrated brines at elevated temperature (Testemale et al., 2009).
Tetrahedral Mn chloroaqua species (MnCl2(H2O)2(aq) and MnCl3(H2O)-) are largely
responsible for the high mobility of Mn in Cl-rich fluids in the Earth’s crust.
Acknowledgement: This research was undertaken on the FAME beamline at ESRF, France. The authors thank
the ESRF-CRG for the beamtime, and Australian International Synchrotron Access Program for travel funding.
Research funding was provided by the Australian Research Council to J.B. (grant DP0878903). The authors
thank Prof. David Sherman for his help on DFT calculations. The authors thank Dr Yves Joly for his
suggestions on the XANES simulations. The FDMNES calculations were supported by iVEC through the use
of the EPIC advanced computing resource located in Perth, Australia. Y.T. acknowledges the University of
Adelaide for ASI scholarship.
References Ankudinov, A.L., Ravel, B., Rehr, J.J., Conradson, S.D., 1998. Real-space multiple-scattering calculation and
interpretation of X-ray-absorption near-edge structure. Physical Review B 58, 7565-7576.
Beagley, B., McAuliffe, C.A., Smith, S.P.B., White, E.W., 1991. EXAFS studies of aqueous solutions of
manganese(II) chloride and bromide: structural variations with concentration and interactions with
solvent. Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 3, 7919.
Boctor, N.Z., 1985. Rhondonite solubility and thermodynamic properties of aqueous MnCl2 in the system
MnO-SiO2-HCl-H2O. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 49, 565-575.
Booth, C. H. and Bridges, F., 2003. Improved self-absorption correction for fluorescence measurements of
extended X-ray absorption fine-structure. The 12th international conference on X-ray absorption fine
structure (XAFS XII). Physica Scripta T115, 202–204.
Borg, S., Liu, W., Etschmann, B., Tian, Y., Brugger, J., 2012. An XAS study of molybdenum speciation in
hydrothermal chloride solutions from 25–385 ˚C and 600 bar. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 92,
292-307.
Brugger, J., 2007. BeerOz, a set of Matlab routines for the quantitative interpretation of spectrophotometric
measurements of metal speciation in solution. Computers & Geosciences 33, 248-261.
APPENDIX A
210
Brugger, J., Black, J., McPhail, D.C., and Spiccia, L., 2001. Complexation of metal ions in brines: application
of electronic spectroscopy in the study of the Cu(II)-LiCl-H2O system between 25 and 90 ˚C.
Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 65, 2691-2708.
Brugger, J., Etschmann, B., Liu, W., Testemale, D., Hazemann, J.L., Emerich, H., van Beek, W., Proux, O.,
2007. An XAS study of the structure and thermodynamics of Cu(I) chloride complexes in brines up to
high temperature (400 ˚C, 600 bar). Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 71, 4920-4941.
Brugger, J. and Gieré, R., 1999. As, Sb, and Ce enrichment in minerals from a metamorphosed Fe-Mn deposit
(Val Ferrera, Eastern Swiss Alps). Canadian Mineralogist 37, 37-52.
Brugger, J., Pring, A., Reith, F., Ryan, C., Etschmann, B., Liu, W., O'Neill, B., Ngothai, Y., 2010. Probing ore
deposits formation: New insights and challenges from synchrotron and neutron studies. Radiation
Physics and Chemistry 79, 151-161.
Brugger, J. and Meisser, N., 2006. Manganese-rich assemblages in the Barrhorn Unit, Turtmanntal, Central
Alps, Switzerland. Canadian Mineralogist, 44, 229-248.
Bunker, G., 2010. Introduction to XAFS: A Practical Guide to X-ray Absorption Fine Structure Spectroscopy,
1st ed. Cambridge University Press, New York.
Bühl, M., Kabrede, H., 2006. Geometries of Transition-Metal Complexes from Density-Functional Theory.
Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2, 1282-1290.
Chalmin, E., Farges, F., Brown, G., 2009. A pre-edge analysis of Mn K-edge XANES spectra to help
determine the speciation of manganese in minerals and glasses. Contributions to Mineralogy and
Petrology 157, 111-126.
Chantler, J., 1995. Theoretical form factor, attenuation, and scattering tabulation for Z = 1–92 from E = 1–10
eV to E = 0.4–1.0 MeV. Journal of Physical and Chemical Reference Data 24, 71–591.
Chen, Y., Fulton, J., Partenheimer, W., 2005a. A XANES and EXAFS study of hydration and ion pairing in
ambient aqueous MnBr2 solutions. Journal of Solution Chemistry 34, 993-1007.
Chen, Y., Fulton, J.L., Partenheimer, W., 2005b. The structure of the homogeneous oxidation catalyst,
Mn(II)(Br-1)x, in supercritical water: an X-ray absorption fine-structure study. Journal of the
American Chemical Society 127, 14085-14093.
Carpenter, R., 1983. Quantitative electron spin resonance (ESR) determinations of forms and total amounts of
Mn in aqueous environmental samples. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 47, 875-885.
Collings, M. D., Sherman, D. M., and Ragnarsdottir, K. V., 2000. Complexation of Cu2+ in oxidised NaCl
brines from 25 C to 175 ˚C : results from in situ EXAFS spectroscopy. Chemical Geology 167, 65-73.
Cotton, F. A., Goodgame, D. M. L., Goodgame, M., 1962. Absorption Spectra and Electronic Structures of
Some Tetrahedral Manganese(II) Complexes. Journal of the American Chemical Society 84(2), 167-
172
Cornell, D. H. and Schütte, S. S., 1995. A volcanic-exhalative origin for the world's largest (Kalahari)
Manganese field. Mineralium Deposita 30, 146-151.
Davies, A. G. S., Cooke, D. R., and Gemmell, J. B., 2008. Hydrothermal breccias and veins at the Kelian gold
mine, Kalimantan, Indonesia: Genesis of a large epithermal gold deposit. Economic Geology 103,
717-757
APPENDIX A
211
de Groot, F., Vanko, G., Glatzel, P., 2009. The 1s X-ray absorption pre-edge structures in transition metal
oxides. Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 21, 104207.
Draper, N. R., and Smith, H., 1998. Applied Regression Analysis. John Wiley & Sons, New York.
El Saffar, Z.M., Brown, G.M., 1971. The structure of manganese dichloride tetrahydrate: a neutron diffraction
study. Acta Crystallographica Section B 27, 66-73.
Etschmann, B.E., Black, J.R., Grundler, P.V., Borg, S., Brewe, D., McPhail, D.C., Spiccia, L., Brugger, J.,
2011. Copper(I) speciation in mixed thiosulfate-chloride and ammonia-chloride solutions: XAS and
UV-Visible spectroscopic studies. RSC Advance 1, 1554-1566.
Etschmann, B.E., Liu, W., Testemale, D., Müller, H., Rae, N.A., Proux, O., Hazemann, J.L., Brugger, J., 2010.
An in situ XAS study of copper(I) transport as hydrosulfide complexes in hydrothermal solutions (25-
592 ˚C, 180-600 bar): speciation and solubility in vapor and liquid phases. Geochimica et
Cosmochimica Acta 74, 4723-4739.
Farges, F., 2005. Ab initio and experimental pre-edge investigations of the Mn K-edge XANES in oxide-type
materials. Physical Review B 71, 155109.
Fernandez, D. P., Goodwin, A. R. H., Lemmon, E. W., Sengers, J. M. H. L., and Williams, R. C., 1997. A
Formulation for the Static Permittivity of Water and Steam at Temperatures from 238 K to 873 K at
Pressures up to 1200 MPa, Including Derivatives and Debye-Hückel Coefficients. Journal of Physical
and Chemical Reference Data 26, 1125-1166.
Gammons, C.H., Seward, T.M., 1996. Stability of manganese (II) chloride complexes from 25 to 300 ˚C.
Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 60, 4295-4311.
Helgeson, H.C., Delany, J.M., Nesbitt, H.W., 1978. Summary and critique of the thermodynamic properties of
rock - forming minerals. American Journal of Science 278A, 1-229.
James, R. H., Elderfield, H., and Palmer, M. R., 1995. The chemistry of hydrothermal fluids from the broken
spur site, 29˚N Mid-Atlantic Ridge. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 59, 651-659.
Joly, Y., 2001. X-ray absorption near-edge structure calculations beyond the muffin-tin approximation.
Physical Review B 63, 125120.
Kelly, S. D., Hesterberg, D., and Ravel, B., 2008. Analysis of soils and minerals using X-ray absorption
spectroscopy. In Methods of Soil Analysis. Part 5. Mineralogical Methods. SSSA Book Series No. 5.
(eds. A.L. Ulery and L.R. Drees). pp. 387–463.
Klamt, A., Jonas, V., Bürger, T., and Lohrenz, J. C. W., 1998. Refinement and Parametrization of COSMO-RS.
The Journal of Physical Chemistry A 102, 5074-5085.
Klamt, A. and Schuurmann, G., 1993. COSMO: a new approach to dielectric screening in solvents with
explicit expressions for the screening energy and its gradient. Journal of the Chemical Society, Perkin
Transactions 2, 799-805.
Koplitz, L.V., Kim, K., McClure, D.S., 1994. Temperature Dependence of 10Dq for Aqueous
HexaaquomanganeseHexaaquomanganese(II). Inorganic Chemistry 33, 702-704.
Libu+, Z., Tia.owska, H., 1975. Stability and nature of complexes of the type MCl+ in aqueous solution
(M=Mn, Co, Ni, and Zn). Journal of Solution Chemistry 4, 1011-1022.
Lemmon, E. W., McLinden, M. O. and Friend, D. G. 2000. Thermophysical properties of fluid systems. In
NIST Chemistry WebBook, NIST Standard Reference Database (eds. W. G. Mallard and P. J.
APPENDIX A
212
Linstrom). National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD. Available from:
http://webbook.nist.gov.
Liu, W., Etschmann, B., Foran, G., Shelley, M., Brugger, J., 2007. Deriving formation constants for aqueous
metal complexes from XANES spectra: Zn2+ and Fe2+ chloride complexes in hypersaline solutions.
American Mineralogist 92, 761-770.
Liu, W., Borg, S.J., Testemale, D., Etschmann, B., Hazemann, J.-L., Brugger, J., 2011. Speciation and
thermodynamic properties for cobalt chloride complexes in hydrothermal fluids at 35–440 ˚C and
600bar: An in-situ XAS study. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 75, 1227-1248.
Liu, W., Borg, S., Etschmann, B., Mei, Y., Brugger, J., 2012. An XAS study of speciation and thermodynamic
properties of aqueous zinc bromide complexes at 25-150 ˚C. Chemical Geology 298–299, 57-69.
Mahoui, A., Lapasset, J., Moret, J., Saint Gregoire, P., 1996. Bis(tetraethylammonium) Tetrachlorometallates,
[(C2H5)4N]2[MCl4], where M = Hg, Cd, Zn. Acta Crystallographica Section C 52, 2671-2674.
Maslen, E.N., Streltsov, V.A., Streltsova, N.R., Ishizawa, N., 1995. Electron density and optical anisotropy in
rhombohedral carbonates. III. Synchrotron X-ray studies of CaCO3, MgCO3 and MnCO3. Acta
Crystallographica Section B 51, 929-939.
Mayanovic, R.A., Anderson, A.J., Bassett, W.A., Chou, I.M., 2009. The structure and stability of aqueous
rare-earth elements in hydrothermal fluids: New results on neodymium(III) aqua and chloroaqua
complexes in aqueous solutions to 500 ˚C and 520 MPa. Chemical Geology 259, 30-38.
Mayanovic, R.A., Jayanetti, S., Anderson, A.J., Bassett, W.A., Chou, I.M., 2002. The Structure of Yb3+ Aquo
Ion and Chloro Complexes in Aqueous Solutions at Up to 500 ˚C and 270 MPa. The Journal of
Physical Chemistry A 106, 6591-6599.
McKibben, M. A. and Williams, A. E., 1989. Metal speciation and solubility in saline hydrothermal fluids - an
empirical-approach based on geothermal brine data. Economic Geology 84, 1996-2007
Newville, M., Ravel, B., Haskel, D., Rehr, J.J., Stern, E.A., Yacoby, Y., 1995. Analysis of multiple-scattering
XAFS data using theoretical standards. Physica B 208, 154-156.
Ozutsumi, K., Abe, Y., Takahashi, R., Ishiguro, S.-i., 1994. Chloro and Bromo Complexation of the
Manganese(II) Ion and Solvation Structure of the Manganese(II), Iron(II), Cobalt(II), Nickel(II),
Copper(II), and Zinc(II) Ions in Hexamethylphosphoric Triamide. The Journal of Physical Chemistry
98, 9894-9899.
Parr, R. G. and Yang, W., 1989. Density-functional theory of atoms and molecules. Oxford University Press,
USA, New York.
Peacock, C. L. and Sherman, D. M., 2004. Copper(II) sorption onto goethite, hematite and lepidocrocite: a
surface complexation model based on ab initio molecular geometries and EXAFS spectroscopy.
Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 68, 2623-2637.
Perdew, J. P., Burke, K., and Ernzerhof, M., 1996. Generalized Gradient Approximation Made Simple.
Physical Review Letters 77, 3865-3868.
Pye, C. C. and Ziegler, T., 1999. An implementation of the conductor-like screening model of solvation within
the Amsterdam density functional package. Theoretical Chemistry Accounts: Theory, Computation,
and Modeling (Theoretica Chimica Acta) 101, 396-408.
APPENDIX A
213
Ravel, B., Newville, M., 2005. ATHENA, ARTEMIS, HEPHAESTUS: data analysis for X-ray absorption
spectroscopy using IFEFFIT. Journal of Synchrotron Radiation 12, 537-541.
Robie, R.A., Hemingway, B.S., Fisher, J.R., 1978. Thermodynamic properties of minerals and related
substances at 298. 15 K and 1 bar (105 pascals) pressure and at higher temperatures, USGS-Bulletin-
1452.
Roy, S., 1992. Environments and processes of manganese deposition. Economic Geology 87, 1218-1236.
Ryzhenko, B. N., Bryzgalin, O. V., Artamkina, I. Y., Spasennykh, M. Y., and Shapkin, A. I., 1985. An
electrostatic model for the electrolytic dissociation of inorganic substances dissolved in water.
Geochemistry International 22, 138-144.
Seward, T.M., Barnes,H.L.,1997. Metal transport by hydrothermal ore fluids. In: Barnes,H.L. (Ed.),
Geochemistry of Hydrothermal Ore Deposits.Wiley, New York, pp. 435–486
Seward, T.M., Driesner, T., 2004. Hydrothermal solution structure: experiments and computer simulations. In:
Palmer, D.A., Fernández-Prini, R., Harvery, A.H. (Eds.), Aqueous Systems at Elevated Temperatures
and Pressure. Elsevier Academic Press, pp. 149–182.
Sherman, D. M., 2007. Complexation of Cu+ in Hydrothermal NaCl Brines: Ab initio molecular dynamics and
energetics. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 71, 714-722.
Sherman, D. M., 2009. Electronic structures of siderite (FeCO3) and rhodochrosite (MnCO3): Oxygen K-edge
spectroscopy and hybrid density functional theory. American Mineralogist 94, 166-171.
Sherman, D. M., 2010. Metal complexation and ion association in hydrothermal fluids: insights from quantum
chemistry and molecular dynamics. Geofluids 10, 41-57.
Shock, E.L., Sassani, D.C., Willis, M., Sverjensky, D.A., 1997. Inorganic species in geologic fluids:
Correlations among standard molal thermodynamic properties of aqueous ions and hydroxide
complexes. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 61, 907-950.
Shulman, G.R., Yafet, Y., Eisenberger, P., and Blumberg, W.E., 1976. Observations and interpretation of X-
ray absorption edges in iron compounds and proteins. Proceedings of the National Academy of
Sciences of the United States of America 73, 1384–1388.
Shvarov, Y. V., 2008. HCh: New potentialities for the thermodynamic simulation of geochemical systems
offered by windows. Geochemistry International 46, 834-839.
Shvarov, Y.V., Bastrakov, E.N., 1999. HCh, a software package for geochemical equilibrium modeling: user’s
guide. Record 1999/25. Australian Geological Survey Organisation.
Suleimenov, O.M., Seward, T.M., 2000. Spectrophotometric measurements of metal complex formation at
high temperatures: the stability of Mn(II) chloride species. Chemical Geology 167, 177-192.
Sverjensky, D.A., Shock, E.L., Helgeson, H.C., 1997. Prediction of the thermodynamic properties of aqueous
metal complexes to 1000 ˚C and 5 kb. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 61, 1359-1412.
Tagirov, B. R., Zotov, A. V., and Akinfiev, N. N., 1997. Experimental study of dissociation 685 of HCl from
350 to 500 ˚C and 500 to 2500 bars; thermodynamic properties of HCloaq. Geochimica et
Cosmochimica Acta 61, 4267-4280.
Testemale, D., Argoud, R., Geaymond, O., Hazemann, J.L., 2005. High pressure high temperature cell for X-
ray absorption and scattering techniques. Review of Scientific Instruments 76, 043905.
APPENDIX A
214
Testemale, D., Brugger, J., Liu, W., Etschmann, B., Hazemann, J.-L., 2009. In-situ X-ray absorption study of
iron(II) speciation in brines up to supercritical conditions. Chemical Geology 264, 295-310.
Te Velde, G., Bickelhaupt, F. M., Baerends, E. J., Fonseca Guerra, C., van Gisbergen, S. J. A., Snijders, J. G.,
and Ziegler, T., 2001. Chemistry with ADF. Journal of Computational Chemistry 22, 931-967.
Tian, Y., Etschmann, B., Liu, W., Borg, S., Mei, Y., Testemale, D., O'Neill, B., Rae, N., Sherman, D. M.,
Ngothai, Y., Johannessen, B., Glover, C., and Brugger, J., 2012. Speciation of nickel (II) chloride
complexes in hydrothermal fluids: In situ XAS study. Chemical Geology 334, 345-363.
Tooth, B., Etschmann, B., Pokrovski, G., Testemale, D., Hazemann, J.-L., Grundler, P. and Brugger, J. 2012.
Bismuth speciation in hydrothermal fluids: an X-ray absorption spectroscopy and solubility study.
Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 101, 156-172.
Tossell, J. A., 2012. Calculation of the properties of the S3! radical anion and its complexes with Cu+ in
aqueous solution. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 95, 79-92.
Uchida, E., Goryozono, Y., Naito, M., Yamagami, M., 1995. Aqueous speciation of iron and manganese
chlorides in supercritical hydrothermal solutions. Geochemical Journal 29, 175-188.
Uchida, E., Haitani, T., Suetsugu, T., Kashima, T., Tsutsui, K., 2003. Experiments on the Element Distribution
between the Granodiorite JG-1a and 2M NaCl Hydrothermal Solution at Temperatures of 300 to 800
˚C and a Pressure of 1 kb. Resource Geology 53, 155-161.
Uchida, E., Tsutsui, K., 2000. Cation Leaching from the Basalt JB–1a by 2M NaCl Hydrothermal Solutions.
Resource Geology 50, 93-102.
Van Lenthe, E. and Baerends, E. J., 2003. Optimized Slater-type basis sets for the elements 1–118. Journal of
Computational Chemistry 24, 1142-1156.
Vosko, S. H., Wilk, L., and Nusair, M., 1980. Accurate spin-dependent electron liquid correlation energies for
local spin density calculations: a critical analysis. Canadian Journal of Physics 58, 1200-1211.
Westre, T.E., Kennepohl, P., DeWitt, J.G., Hedman, B., Hodgson, K.O., Solomon, E.I., 1997. A multiplet
analysis of Fe K-edge 1s → 3d pre-edge features of iron complexes. Journal of the American
Chemical Society 119, 6297-6314.
Wheat, C.G., Carpenter, R., 1988. MnCl+ and MnSO4 association constants to 170 ˚C. Journal of Solution
Chemistry 17, 467-480.
Wolfram, O., Krupp, R.E., 1996. Hydrothermal solubility of rhodochrosite, Mn (II) speciation, and
equilibrium constants. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 60, 3983-3994.
Yamamoto, T., 2008. Assignment of pre-edge peaks in K-edge X-ray absorption spectra of 3d transition metal
compounds: electric dipole or quadrupole? X-Ray Spectrometry 37, 572-584.
Yardley, B. W. D., 2005. Metal concentrations in crustal fluids and their relationship to ore formation.
Economic Geology 100, 613-632.
Zalkin, A., Forrester, J.D., Templeton, D.H., 1964. The Crystal Structure of Manganese Dichloride
Tetrahydrate. Inorganic Chemistry 3, 529-533.
215
_____________________________________
Appendix B
Speciation of Nickel (II) chloride complexes in
hydrothermal fluids: in situ XAS study
_____________________________________
216
!"#"$%$&"'()'*+",(-.,/0' 1/"2$'()'3#0$-' !0$4/#"/(&'()'5/46$2'7889'4,2(-/:$'4(%02$;$.'/&',<:-(",$-%#2')2+/:.='!"#$%&''>*!'."+:<'
3+?2/4#"/(&'!"#"+.''
'
3+?2/4#"/(&'@$"#/2.' 1/#&A' BCA' D".4,%#&&A' ECA' F/+A' GCA' E(-HA' !CA' I$/A' BCA' 1$."$%#2$A' @CA' JK5$/22A' ECA' L#$A' 5CA'!,$-%#&A' @CICA' 5H(",#/A' BCA' M(,#&&$..$&A' ECA' N2(O$-A' PCA' E-+HH$-A' MCA' QRSQC' !0$4/#"/(&' ()'&/46$2'7889'4,2(-/:$'4(%02$;$.'/&',<:-(",$-%#2')2+/:.='8&'./"+'>*!'."+:<C'()*+%,-.#/*0.012'TTUA'TUVWTXTC''
!"#$%&'(%)#&*+"#*%),'E<' ./H&/&H' ",$' !"#"$%$&"' ()' *+",(-.,/0A' $#4,' #+",(-' 4$-"/)/$.' ",#"' ",$/-' ."#"$:' 4(&"-/?+"/(&' "(' ",$' 0+?2/4#"/(&' /.' #44+-#"$' #&:' ",#"'0$-%/../(&'/.'H-#&"$:')(-'",$'0+?2/4#"/(&'"('?$'/&42+:$:'/&'",$'4#&:/:#"$Y.'",$./.C'
5#%$'()'3-/&4/0#2'*+",(-'7P#&:/:#"$9' B+#&'1/#&'
P(&"-/?+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' @$./H&$:' #&:' 0$-)(-%$:' $;0$-/%$&".A' /&"$-0-$"$:' #&:' 0-(4$..$:' >*!' :#"#A' #&:' Z-("$'%#&+.4-/0"C'
'
!/H&#"+-$'
'
@#"$' QUWM+2WST'
'
5#%$'()'P(W*+",(-' E#-?#-#'D".4,%#&&'
P(&"-/?+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$:'Z/",'$;0$-/%$&".A'#&:'%#&+.4-/0"'$O#2+#"/(&C'
'
!/H&#"+-$''
@#"$' QUWM+2WST'
'
5#%$'()'P(W*+",(-' G$/,+#'F/+'
P(&"-/?+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$:'Z/",'$;0$-/%$&".A'#&:'%#&+.4-/0"'$O#2+#"/(&C'
!/H&#"+-$'
'
@#"$' QUWM+2WST'
'
5#%$'()'P(W*+",(-' !"#4$<'E(-H'
P(&"-/?+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$:'Z/",'$;0$-/%$&".A'#&:'%#&+.4-/0"'$O#2+#"/(&C'
!/H&#"+-$'
'
@#"$' QUWM+2WST'
'
217
!
!
Name of Co-Author Yuan Mei
Contribution to the Paper Performed DFT calculations, and wrote the DFT part of the manuscript.
Signature
Date 24-Jul-13
Name of Co-Author Denis Testemale
Contribution to the Paper Assisted with experimental design, and manuscript evaluation.
Signature
Date 24-Jul-13
Name of Co-Author Brian O’Neil
Contribution to the Paper Assisted with experimental design, and manuscript evaluation.
Signature
Date 24-Jul-13
Name of Co-Author Nick Rae
Contribution to the Paper Assisted with experiments.
Signature
Date 24-Jul-13
Name of Co-Author David Sherman
Contribution to the Paper Supported DFT calculations, and manuscript evaluation.
Signature
Date 24-Jul-13
Name of Co-Author Yung Ngothai
Contribution to the Paper Assisted manuscript evaluation.
Signature
Date 24-Jul-13
218
!
!
Name of Co-Author Bernt Johannessen
Contribution to the Paper Assisted with experiments, and manuscript evaluation.
Signature
Date 24-Jul-13
Name of Co-Author Chris Glover
Contribution to the Paper Assisted with experiments, and manuscript evaluation.
Signature
Date 24-Jul-13
Name of Co-Author Joël Brugger
Contribution to the Paper Assisted with experiments and experimental design and manuscript evaluation.
Acting as corresponding author.
Signature
Date 24-Jul-13
APPENDIX B
219
A Tian, Y., Etschmann, B., Liu, W., Borg, S., Mei, Y., Testemale, D., O'Neill, B., Rae, N., Sherman, D.M., Ngothai, Y., Johannessen, B., Glover, C. & Brugger, J. (2012) Speciation of nickel (II) chloride complexes in hydrothermal fluids: in situ XAS study. Chemical Geology, v. 334, pp. 345-363
NOTE:
This publication is included on pages 219-237 in the print copy of the thesis held in the University of Adelaide Library.
It is also available online to authorised users at:
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.chemgeo.2012.10.010
APPENDIX B
238
239
_____________________________________
Appendix C
An XAS study of speciation and
thermodynamic properties of aqueous zinc
bromide complexes at 25–150 °C
_____________________________________
240
!"#"$%$&"'()'*+",(-.,/0' 1/"2$'()'3#0$-' *&'4*!'."+56'()'.0$7/#"/(&'#&5'",$-%(56&#%/7'0-(0$-"/$.'()'#8+$(+.'9/&7':-(%/5$'7(%02$;$.'
#"'<=>?=@'AB'
3+:2/7#"/(&'!"#"+.''
'
3+:2/7#"/(&'C$"#/2.' D/+E'FGE'H(-IE'!GE'J".7,%#&&E'HGE'K$/E'LGE'#&5'H-+II$-E'MGE'<@?<G'*&'4*!'."+56'()'.0$7/#"/(&'#&5' ",$-%(56&#%/7' 0-(0$-"/$.' ()' #8+$(+.' 9/&7' :-(%/5$' 7(%02$;$.' #"' <=>?=@' ABG' B,$%/7#2'N$(2(I6'<OP><OOE'=QRSOG'
!"#$%&'(%)#&*+"#*%),'H6' ./I&/&I' ",$' !"#"$%$&"' ()' *+",(-.,/0E' $#7,' #+",(-' 7$-"/)/$.' ",#"' ",$/-' ."#"$5' 7(&"-/:+"/(&' "(' ",$' 0+:2/7#"/(&' /.' #77+-#"$' #&5' ",#"'0$-%/../(&'/.'I-#&"$5')(-'",$'0+:2/7#"/(&'"(':$'/&72+5$5'/&'",$'7#&5/5#"$T.'",$./.G'
U#%$'()'B(R*+",(-' F$/,+#'D/+'
B(&"-/:+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' C$./I&$5' $;0$-/%$&".E' 7(&5+7"$5' $;0$-/%$&".' #&5' V-("$' 0#-"' ()' ",$' %#&+.7-/0"G' *7"/&I' #.'7(--$.0(&5/&I'#+",(-G'
!/I&#"+-$'
'
C#"$' <WRM+2R?X'
'
U#%$'()'B(R*+",(-' !"#7$6'H(-I'
B(&"-/:+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$5'V/",'$;0$-/%$&".E'#&5'V-("$'0#-"'()'",$'%#&+.7-/0"G'
!/I&#"+-$' C#"$' <WRM+2R?X'
'
U#%$'()'B(R*+",(-' H#-:#-#'J".7,%#&&'
B(&"-/:+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$5'V/",'$;0$-/%$&".E'#&5'V-("$'0#-"'()'",$'%#&+.7-/0"G'
!/I&#"+-$''
C#"$' <WRM+2R?X'
'
U#%$'()'B(R*+",(-' L+#&'K$/'
'B(&"-/:+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' 3$-)(-%$5'CY1'7#27+2#"/(&.E'#&5'V-("$'./%+2#"/(&'0#-"'()'",$'%#&+.7-/0"G'
!/I&#"+-$'
'
C#"$' <WRM+2R?X'
'
U#%$'()'B(R*+",(-' M(Z2'H-+II$-'
B(&"-/:+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$5'V/",'$;0$-/%$&".'#&5'$;0$-/%$&"#2'5$./I&'#&5'V-("$'0#-"'()'",$'%#&+.7-/0"G'
'
!/I&#"+-$'
'
C#"$' <WRM+2R?X'
APPENDIX C
241
NOTE:
This publication is included on pages 241-253 in the print copy of the thesis held in the University of Adelaide Library.
It is also available online to authorised users at:
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.chemgeo.2011.12.018
A Liu, W., Borg, S., Etschmann, B., Mei, Y. & Brugger, J. (2012) An XAS study of speciation and thermodynamic properties of aqueous zinc bromide complexes at 25-150°C. Chemical Geology, 298-299, pp. 57-69
APPENDIX C
254
255
_____________________________________
Appendix D
Speciation and thermodynamic properties of
d10 transition metals: insights from ab-initio
Molecular Dynamics simulations
_____________________________________
256
!"#"$%$&"'()'*+",(-.,/0' 1/"2$'()'3#0$-' !0$4/#"/(&' #&5' ",$-%(56&#%/4' 0-(0$-"/$.' ()' 578' "-#&./"/(&' %$"#2.9' /&./:,".' )-(%' #;</&/"/('
=(2$4+2#-'>6&#%/4.'./%+2#"/(&.'
3+;2/4#"/(&'!"#"+.''
'
3+;2/4#"/(&'>$"#/2.'=$/?'@A?'!,$-%#&?'>A'=A?'B/+?'CA?'#&5'D-+::$-?'EA?'F87FA'!0$4/#"/(&'#&5'",$-%(56&#%/4'
0-(0$-"/$.'()'578'"-#&./"/(&'%$"#2.9'/&./:,".')-(%'#;</&/"/('=(2$4+2#-'>6&#%/4.'./%+2#"/(&.?'GH",'
I&"$-&#"/('J$(2(:/4#2'K(&:-$..'LIJKM?'*+:+."'F87F?'D-/.;#&$?'*+."-#2/#A'
'
!"#$%&'(%)#&*+"#*%),'D6' ./:&/&:' ",$' !"#"$%$&"' ()' *+",(-.,/0?' $#4,' #+",(-' 4$-"/)/$.' ",#"' ",$/-' ."#"$5' 4(&"-/;+"/(&' "(' ",$' 0+;2/4#"/(&' /.' #44+-#"$' #&5' ",#"'0$-%/../(&'/.':-#&"$5')(-'",$'0+;2/4#"/(&'"(';$'/&42+5$5'/&'",$'4#&5/5#"$N.'",$./.A'
O#%$'()'K(<*+",(-' @+#&'=$/'
K(&"-/;+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' >$P$2(0$5' 4(%0+"#"/(' %$",(5.' #&5' 0$-)(-%$5' %(2$4+2#-' ./%+2#"/(&A' D+/2"' :$(4,$%/4#2'%(5$2?'Q-("$'%#&+.4-/0"'#&5'0-$.$&"$5'/&'4(&)$-$&4$A'
!/:&#"+-$'
'
>#"$' FH<E+2<7G'
'
O#%$'()'K(<*+",(-' >#P/5'='!,$-%#&'
K(&"-/;+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$5'Q/",'5$P$2(0/&:'4(%0+"#"/('%$",(5'#&5'%#&+.4-/0"'$P#2+#"/(&A'
!/:&#"+-$'
'
>#"$' FH<E+2<7G'
'
O#%$'()'K(<*+",(-' C$/,+#'B/+'
K(&"-/;+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$5'Q/",';+/25/&:':$(4,$%/4#2'%(5$2'#&5'%#&+.4-/0"'$P#2+#"/(&A'
!/:&#"+-$'
'
>#"$' FH<E+2<7G'
'
O#%$'()'K(<*+",(-' E(R2'D-+::$-'
'K(&"-/;+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$5'Q/",';+/25/&:':$(4,$%/4#2'%(5$2'#&5'%#&+.4-/0"'$P#2+#"/(&A'
!/:&#"+-$'
'
>#"$' FH<E+2<7G'
'
APPENDIX D
257
A Mei, Y., Sherman, D., Liu, W. & Brugger, J. (2012) Speciation and thermodynamic properties of d10 transition metals: insights from ab-initio molecular dynamics simulations. International Geological Congress(IGC), August, Brisbane, Australia
NOTE:
This publication is included on page 257 in the print copy of the thesis held in the University of Adelaide Library.
APPENDIX D
258
259
_____________________________________
Appendix E
Zn-Cl Complexation in Magmatic-
Hydrothermal Solutions: Stability Constants
from Ab initio Molecular Dynamics
_____________________________________
260
!"#"$%$&"'()'*+",(-.,/0' 1/"2$'()'3#0$-' 4&562' 6(%02$7#"/(&' /&' 8#9%#"/:5' ;<=-(",$-%#2' !(2+"/(&.>' !"#?/2/"<' 6(&."#&".' )-(%' *?' /&/"/('
8(2$:+2#-'@<&#%/:.'
3+?2/:#"/(&'!"#"+.''
'
3+?2/:#"/(&'@$"#/2.' 8$/A' BCA' !,$-%#&A' @C' 8CA' D-+99$-A' ECA' #&=' F/+A' GCA' HIJHC' 4&562' 6(%02$7#"/(&' /&' 8#9%#"/:5';<=-(",$-%#2' !(2+"/(&.>' !"#?/2/"<' 6(&."#&".' )-(%' *?' /&/"/(' 8(2$:+2#-' @<&#%/:.A' K(2=.:,%/="'6(&)$-$&:$'HIJHA'E+&$'HIJHA'8(&"-$#2A'6#&#=#'
!"#$%&'(%)#&*+"#*%),'D<' ./9&/&9' ",$' !"#"$%$&"' ()' *+",(-.,/0A' $#:,' #+",(-' :$-"/)/$.' ",#"' ",$/-' ."#"$=' :(&"-/?+"/(&' "(' ",$' 0+?2/:#"/(&' /.' #::+-#"$' #&=' ",#"'0$-%/../(&'/.'9-#&"$=')(-'",$'0+?2/:#"/(&'"('?$'/&:2+=$='/&'",$':#&=/=#"$L.'",$./.C'
M#%$'()'6(5*+",(-' B+#&'8$/'
6(&"-/?+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' @$N$2(0$=' :(%0+"#"/(' %$",(=.' #&=' 0$-)(-%$=' %(2$:+2#-' ./%+2#"/(&C' D+/2"' 9$(:,$%/:#2'%(=$2'#&='O-("$'%#&+.:-/0"C'
!/9&#"+-$'
'
@#"$' HP5E+25JQ'
'
M#%$'()'6(5*+",(-' @#N/='8'!,$-%#&'
6(&"-/?+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$='O/",'=$N$2(0/&9':(%0+"#"/('%$",(='#&='%#&+.:-/0"'$N#2+#"/(&C'
!/9&#"+-$'
'
@#"$' HP5E+25JQ'
'
M#%$'()'6(5*+",(-' E(R2'D-+99$-'
'6(&"-/?+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$='O/",'?+/2=/&9'9$(:,$%/:#2'%(=$2'#&='%#&+.:-/0"'$N#2+#"/(&C'
!/9&#"+-$'
'
@#"$' HP5E+25JQ'
'
M#%$'()'6(5*+",(-' G$/,+#'F/+'
6(&"-/?+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$='O/",'?+/2=/&9'9$(:,$%/:#2'%(=$2'#&='%#&+.:-/0"'$N#2+#"/(&C'
!/9&#"+-$'
'
@#"$' HP5E+25JQ'
'
APPENDIX E
261
Goldschmidt 2012 Conference Abstracts
Mineralogical Magazine | www.minersoc.org
Zn-Cl Complexation in Magmatic-Hydrothermal Solutions: Stability
Constants from Ab initio Molecular Dyamics
YUAN MEI1,2*, DAVID M SHERMAN3, JOËL BRUGGER1, WEIHUA LIU2
1School of Earth and Environmental Sciences, The University of Adelaide, Adelaide, SA 5005, Australia,
2CSIRO Earth Science and Resource Engineering, Clayton, VIC 3168, Australia
3Department of Earth Sciences, University of Bristol, Bristol, BS8 1RJ, UK
[email protected] (* presenting author)
The speciation of metal complexes in hydrothermal brines plays a key role in controlling the mobility and solubility of minerals in natural and man-made fluids. Experimental measurements of metal speciation is a major challenge, however, and semi-empirical equations of state (e.g., the HKF[1] model) have been needed to estimate thermodynamic properties of hydrothermal fluids. Now, however, we can apply Ab initio (quantum mechanical) molecular dynamics simulations, based on density functional theory, to predict the speciation of metal complexes in hydrothermal fluids as a function of temperature, pressure and fluid composition. Using thermodynamic integration and metadynamics techniques, these simulations can yield stability constants for metal complex formation at conditions that are experimentally inaccessible.
In this study, we investigated the species of zinc chloride
complexes via ab initio Car-Parrinello Molecular Dynamics (CPMD) simulations for ZnCl2-NaCl-H2O system with Cl- concentration of 4 m from ambient to hydrothermal-magmatic conditions. At both 25˚C and 350˚C, the MD simulations indicate that Zn-Cl complex changed from initial structure octahedral ZnCl(H2O)5
+ to tetrahedral ZnCl(H2O)3
+ after 4 picosecond (ps). However, the ligand change of chloride cannot be observed. Since Zn2+ has higher charge, the binding between Zn2+ and Cl- is stronger, the ions exchange can be hardly observed via short MD simulation (< 10 ps). Thermodynamic integration is a realistical approach to evaluate entropic properties. To calculate the binding free energy between Zn2+ and Cl-, thermodynamic integration based on constraint CPMD simulations were conducted by constraining the Zn-Cl bond distances. The constraint systems reached the state of equilibrium within 1 ps. The mean forces of forming Zn-Cl bond at the different distances from 2 Å to 5 Å were calculated over 5 ps, and the change in free energy was derived by integrating the mean force vs distance. The integral gave binding free energies of -6.75 kJ/mol at 25˚C, 1 bar and -75.52 kJ/mol at 350˚C, 500 bar for reaction Zn2+ + Cl- = ZnCl+. The predicted logKs of that reaction are 1.18 at 25˚C and 6.08 at 350˚C, in good agreement with the experimental values (0.20 and 6.87, respectively, from revised HKF model[1]). Having established our methodology, we will now investigate ZnCl complexation at the extreme temperatures of magmatic-hydrothermal fluids.
[1] Sverjensky et al., (1997) Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, 61, 1359–
1421
APPENDIX E
262
263
_____________________________________
Appendix F
Ab initio molecular dynamics simulation of
copper(I) complexation in chloride/sulfide
fluids _____________________________________
264
!"#"$%$&"'()'*+",(-.,/0' 1/"2$'()'3#0$-' *4'/&/"/('%(2$5+2#-'67&#%/5.'./%+2#"/(&'()'5(00$-89:'5(%02$;#"/(&'/&'5,2(-/6$<.+2)/6$')2+/6.'
3+42/5#"/(&'!"#"+.''
'
3+42/5#"/(&'=$"#/2.' >$/?' @A?' !,$-%#&?' =A' >A?' B-+CC$-?' DA?' #&6' E/+?' FA?' GHIIA' *4' /&/"/(' %(2$5+2#-' 67&#%/5.'./%+2#"/(&' ()' 5(00$-89:' 5(%02$;#"/(&' /&' 5,2(-/6$<.+2)/6$' )2+/6.?' J(26.5,%/6"' K(&)$-$&5$' GHII?'*+C+."'GHII?'3-#C+$?'KL$5,'M$0+42/5'!
"#$%&'!(&)$'*+#$*&),!B7' ./C&/&C' ",$' !"#"$%$&"' ()' *+",(-.,/0?' $#5,' #+",(-' 5$-"/)/$.' ",#"' ",$/-' ."#"$6' 5(&"-/4+"/(&' "(' ",$' 0+42/5#"/(&' /.' #55+-#"$' #&6' ",#"'0$-%/../(&'/.'C-#&"$6')(-'",$'0+42/5#"/(&'"('4$'/&52+6$6'/&'",$'5#&6/6#"$N.'",$./.A'
O#%$'()'K(P*+",(-' @+#&'>$/'
K(&"-/4+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' =$Q$2(0$6' 5(%0+"#"/(' %$",(6.' #&6' 0$-)(-%$6' %(2$5+2#-' ./%+2#"/(&A' B+/2"' C$(5,$%/5#2'%(6$2?'R-("$'%#&+.5-/0"'#&6'0-$.$&"$6'/&'5(&)$-$&5$A'
!/C&#"+-$'
'
=#"$' GSPD+2PIT'
'
O#%$'()'K(P*+",(-' =#Q/6'>'!,$-%#&'
K(&"-/4+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$6'R/",'6$Q$2(0/&C'5(%0+"#"/('%$",(6'#&6'%#&+.5-/0"'$Q#2+#"/(&A'
!/C&#"+-$'
'
=#"$' GSPD+2PIT'
'
O#%$'()'K(P*+",(-' D(U2'B-+CC$-'
'K(&"-/4+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$6'R/",'4+/26/&C'C$(5,$%/5#2'%(6$2'#&6'%#&+.5-/0"'$Q#2+#"/(&A'
!/C&#"+-$'
'
=#"$' GSPD+2PIT'
'
O#%$'()'K(P*+",(-' F$/,+#'E/+'
K(&"-/4+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$6'R/",'4+/26/&C'C$(5,$%/5#2'%(6$2'#&6'%#&+.5-/0"'$Q#2+#"/(&A'
!/C&#"+-$'
'
=#"$' GSPD+2PIT'
'
APPENDIX F
265
Goldschmidt Conference Abstracts
Mineralogical Magazine www.minersoc.org
1447
Ab initio molecular dynamics simulation of copper(I) complexation
in chloride/sulfide fluids YUAN MEI1,2,3, DAVID M SHERMAN2, JOËL BRUGGER1
AND WEIHUA LIU3 1School of Earth and Environmental Sciences, The University
of Adelaide, Adelaide, SA 5000, Australia
2Department of Earth Sciences, University of Bristol, Bristol, BS8 1RJ, UK
3CSIRO Earth Science and Resource Engineering, Clayton, VIC 3168, Australia Chloride and hydrosulfide are the primary ligands
believed to control the transport of copper in hydrothermal fluids. Recent studies of Cu complexation in hydrothermal Cl-, HS- solutions have been done using X-ray Absorption Spectroscopy (XAS). However, coordination numbers have a large uncertainty and are strongly correlated with Debye-Waller factors; moreover, it is very difficult to distinguish between chloride and sulfur ligands. Ab initio molecular dynamics simulations based on density functional theory enable us to interpret EXAFS results and, potentially, predict stability constants of metal complexes.
In this study, we investigated the species of copper(I) complexes via ab initio Car-Parrinello Molecular Dynamics simulations for copper(I) solutions with different hydrosulfide/chloride ratios at 500bar and 600K. Calculations were done using Vanderbilt ultrasoft pseudopotentials and the PBE exchange-correlation functional.
In the absence of Cl-ligands, copper forms a Cu(HS)2-
complex with a Cu-S bond length of 2.17 Å (vs. an expt. value of 2.15 Å); moreover, the S-Cu-S bond angle is ~162°, in excellent agreement with experiment (150-160°). In the presence of excess chloride, however, we find that Cu forms previously unknown Cu(HS)Cl- and (minor) CuCl2(HS)-2 complexes. Such complexes would be difficult to resolve from CuCl2
- or Cu(HS)2- using EXAFS. We also explored the
complexation of Cu in a low density (0.29 g/cm3), high T (1273K) fluid (vapour). Here, we find that Cu forms Cu(HS)2
- (not the neutral CuHS, as expected). We tentatively suggest that charged complexes may be significant in high temperature, low density fluids.
Ultimately, we hope to predict stability constants of metal complexes. To this end, we are testing metadynamics and thermodynamic integration with respect to metal-ligand distances or coordination numbers. Using these techniques, we estimate the free energy difference between CuCl2
- + HS- and CuCl(HS)- + Cl- to be ~40 KJ/mol.
APPENDIX F
266
267
_____________________________________
Appendix G
Which Ligand is the most Import for Gold
Transport in Hydrothermal Fluids? An in situ
XAS Study in Mixed-Ligand Solutions _____________________________________
268
!"#"$%$&"'()'*+",(-.,/0' 1/"2$'()'3#0$-' 4(2$5+2#-62$7$2'+&8$-."#&8/&9'()'%$"#2'"-#&.0(-"'/&',:8-(",$-%#2'(-$')2+/8.;'/&'./"+'$<0$-/%$&".'
#&8'#='/&/"/('%(2$5+2#-'8:&#%/5'./%+2#"/(&.'
3+=2/5#"/(&'!"#"+.''
'
3+=2/5#"/(&'>$"#/2.'?/+@'AB@'C".5,%#&&@'DB@'1$."$%#2$@'>B@'4$/@'EB@'F#G$%#&&@'HB@'I$%0$2@'JB@'4K$22$-@'FB@'#&8'
D-+99$-@'HB@'LMNOB'A,/5,'2/9#&8'/.'",$'%(."'/%0(-"')(-'9(28'"-#&.0(-"'/&',:8-(",$-%#2')2+/8.P'*&'
/&'./"+'Q*!'."+8:'/&'5(%0$"/"/7$'./"+#"/(&.@'R(28.5,%/8"'LMNO@'*+9+."'LMNO@'S2(-$&5$@'T"#2:B'
!"#$%&'(%)#&*+"#*%),'D:' ./9&/&9' ",$' !"#"$%$&"' ()' *+",(-.,/0@' $#5,' #+",(-' 5$-"/)/$.' ",#"' ",$/-' ."#"$8' 5(&"-/=+"/(&' "(' ",$' 0+=2/5#"/(&' /.' #55+-#"$' #&8' ",#"'0$-%/../(&'/.'9-#&"$8')(-'",$'0+=2/5#"/(&'"('=$'/&52+8$8'/&'",$'5#&8/8#"$U.'",$./.B'
V#%$'()'W(6*+",(-' A$/,+#'?/+'
W(&"-/=+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' >$./9&$8'#&8'0$-)(-%$8'$<0$-/%$&".@'X-("$'%#&+.5-/0"'#&8'0-$.$&"$8'/&'5(&)$-$&5$B'
!/9&#"+-$'
'
>#"$' LY6H+26NO'
'
V#%$'()'W(6*+",(-' D#-=#-#'C".5,%#&&'
'W(&"-/=+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$8'X/",'$<0$-/%$&".'#&8'%#&+.5-/0"'$7#2+#"/(&B'
!/9&#"+-$''
>#"$' LY6H+26NO'
'
V#%$'()'W(6*+",(-' >$&/.'1$."$%#2$'
'W(&"-/=+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$8'X/",'$<0$-/%$&".'#&8'%#&+.5-/0"'$7#2+#"/(&B'
!/9&#"+-$'
'
>#"$' LY6H+26NO'
'
V#%$'()'W(6*+",(-' E+#&'4$/'
W(&"-/=+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' 3$-)(-%$8'4>'5#25+2#"/(&.'#&8'#../."$8'X/",'%#&+.5-/0"'$7#2+#"/(&B'
!/9&#"+-$'
'
>#"$' LY6H+26NO'
'
'
269
!
!
Name of Co-Author Jean-Louis Hazemann
Contribution to the Paper Assisted with experiments.
Signature
Date 24-Jul-13
Name of Co-Author Kirsten Rempel
Contribution to the Paper Assisted with experiments.
Signature
Date 24-Jul-13
Name of Co-Author Harald Müeller
Contribution to the Paper Assisted with experiments.
Signature
Date 24-Jul-13
Name of Co-Author Joël Brugger
Contribution to the Paper Assisted with experiments and manuscript evaluation.
Signature
Date 24-Jul-13
!"#$%&'%(&)*+,-&. /$"0)1&+23%4"5$#"00
(&0,.26+,2&0%,&%,-$%7"8$. *3323,$9%:2,-%$;8$.2#$0,3%"09%#"0+3<.28,%$=">+",2&0?
@2A0",+.$ B",$ CD)/+>)EF
!"#$%&'%(&)*+,-&. G2.3,$0%H$#8$>
%(&0,.26+,2&0%,&%,-$%7"8$. *3323,$9%:2,-%$;8$.2#$0,3%"09%#"0+3<.28,%$=">+",2&0?
@2A0",+.$ B",$ CD)/+>)EF
!"#$%&'%(&)*+,-&. 4".">9%IJ$>>$.
%(&0,.26+,2&0%,&%,-$%7"8$. *3323,$9%:2,-%$;8$.2#$0,3%"09%#"0+3<.28,%$=">+",2&0?
@2A0",+.$ B",$ CD)/+>)EF
!"#$%&'%(&)*+,-&. /&K>%L.+AA$.
%(&0,.26+,2&0%,&%,-$%7"8$. *3323,$9%:2,-%$;8$.2#$0,3%"09%#"0+3<.28,%$=">+",2&0?
@2A0",+.$ B",$ CD)/+>)EF
APPENDIX G
270
Goldschmidt2013 Conference Abstracts
!!!"#$%&'()*")'+,-./012"11324#$%#5+"6217"288"9"16
1627
Which ligand is the most important for gold transport in hydrothermal
fluids? An in situ XAS study in mixed-ligand solutions
WEIHUA LIU1, BARBARA ETSCHMANN2,4, DENIS TESTEMALE5, YUAN MEI1,3,
JEAN-LOUIS HAZEMANN5, KIRSTEN REMPEL6, HARALD MÜLLER7 AND JOËL BRUGGER2,3
1 CSIRO Earth Science and Resource Engineering, Australia, ([email protected])
2 South Australian Museum, Australia 3 School of Earth and Environmental Sciences and 4School of
Chemical Engineering, University of Adelaide, Australia 5Institut Néel, Département MCMF and FAME beamline,
ESRF, France 6Department of Applied Geology, Curtin University, Perth,
Australia 7ESRF, Grenoble, France
Gold transport and deposition in hydrothermal ore fluids is dependent on the identity and stability of predominating aqueous gold complexes. Gold(I) bisulfide (e.g., Au(HS)2
-) and in some instances Au(I) chloride complexes are widely acknowledged to account for Au transport in ore fluids.
This study investigates the potential of the unconventional ligands Br- and NH3 to increase Au mobility. This was achieved by determining the predominant Au species in hydrothermal fluids with binary mixed ligands (Br- - Cl-, Br- - HS-, HS- - NH3), and measuring their structural properties using in situ Synchrotron X-ray Absorption Spectroscopy (XAS). The capacity of XAS to follow the progress of ligand exchange reactions was demonstrated at room temperature, where the Au(III)Br4
- complex was found to predominate in mixed Br-/Cl- solutions (Br-/Cl- = 0.1-1), with average ligand numbers derived from XAS in good agreement with a recent UV-Vis study (Usher et al.., 2009, Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 73, 3359-3380). At temperatures up to 400 oC and at 600 bar, the XAS measurements show that Au(I) – HS- complexes are the only stable Au species in mixed HS-/Br- and HS-/NH3 fluids (HS-/Br- = 0.1; HS-/NH3 = 0.2), indicating that hydrosulfide is the most important ligand for Au transport in the hydrothermal fluid under our experimental conditions, i.e., hydrosulfide complexes outcompete bromide and ammine complexes in S-bearing fluids. These results are comparable to solubility and speciation calculations based on the available thermodynamic data.
271
_____________________________________
Appendix H
Molecular-level understanding of metal transport
in hydrothermal ore fluids: in situ experiments
and ab initio molecular dynamic simulations _____________________________________
272
!"#"$%$&"'()'*+",(-.,/0' 1/"2$'()'3#0$-' 4(2$5+2#-62$7$2'+&8$-."#&8/&9'()'%$"#2'"-#&.0(-"'/&',:8-(",$-%#2'(-$')2+/8.;'/&'./"+'$<0$-/%$&".'
#&8'#='/&/"/('%(2$5+2#-'8:&#%/5'./%+2#"/(&.'
3+=2/5#"/(&'!"#"+.''
'
3+=2/5#"/(&'>$"#/2.'?/+@'AB@'C(-9@'!B@'D".5,%#&&@'CB@'4$/@'EB@'1$."$%#2$@'>B@'!,$-%#&@'>B'4B@'#&8'C-+99$-@'FB@'
GHIGB'4(2$5+2#-62$7$2'+&8$-."#&8/&9'()'%$"#2'"-#&.0(-"'/&',:8-(",$-%#2'(-$')2+/8.;'/&'./"+'
$<0$-/%$&".'#&8'#='/&/"/('%(2$5+2#-'8:&#%/5'./%+2#"/(&.@'JK",'L&"$-&#"/('M$(2(9/5#2'
N(&9-$..'OLMNP@'*+9+."'GHIG@'C-/.=#&$@'*+."-#2/#B'
'
!"#$%&'(%)#&*+"#*%),'C:' ./9&/&9' ",$' !"#"$%$&"' ()' *+",(-.,/0@' $#5,' #+",(-' 5$-"/)/$.' ",#"' ",$/-' ."#"$8' 5(&"-/=+"/(&' "(' ",$' 0+=2/5#"/(&' /.' #55+-#"$' #&8' ",#"'0$-%/../(&'/.'9-#&"$8')(-'",$'0+=2/5#"/(&'"('=$'/&52+8$8'/&'",$'5#&8/8#"$Q.'",$./.B'
R#%$'()'N(6*+",(-' A$/,+#'?/+'
N(&"-/=+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' >$./9&$8'#&8'0$-)(-%$8'$<0$-/%$&".@'S-("$'%#&+.5-/0"'#&8'0-$.$&"$8'/&'5(&)$-$&5$B'
!/9&#"+-$'
'
>#"$' GK6F+26IJ'
'
R#%$'()'N(6*+",(-' !"#5$:'C(-9'
'N(&"-/=+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$8'S/",'$<0$-/%$&".'#&8'%#&+.5-/0"'$7#2+#"/(&B'
!/9&#"+-$'
'
>#"$' GK6F+26IJ'
'
R#%$'()'N(6*+",(-' C#-=#-#'D".5,%#&&'
'N(&"-/=+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$8'S/",'$<0$-/%$&".'#&8'%#&+.5-/0"'$7#2+#"/(&B'
!/9&#"+-$''
>#"$' GK6F+26IJ'
'
R#%$'()'N(6*+",(-' E+#&'4$/'
N(&"-/=+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' 3$-)(-%$8'4>'5#25+2#"/(&.@'#&8'#../."$8'S/",'%#&+.5-/0"'$7#2+#"/(&B'
!/9&#"+-$'
'
>#"$' GK6F+26IJ'
'
273
!
!
Name of Co-Author Denis Testemale
Contribution to the Paper Assisted with experiments.
Signature
Date 24-Jul-13
Name of Co-Author David M Sherman
Contribution to the Paper Supported MD calculations.
Signature
Date 24-Jul-13
Name of Co-Author Joël Brugger
Contribution to the Paper Assisted with experiments and manuscript evaluation.
Signature
Date 24-Jul-13
APPENDIX H
274
A NOTE:
This publication is included on page 274 in the print copy of the thesis held in the University of Adelaide Library.
A Liu, W., Borg, S., Etschmann, B., Mei, Y., Testemale, D., Sherman, D. & Brugger, J. (2012) Molecular-level understanding of metal transport in hydrothermal ore fluids: in situ experiments and ab initio molecular dynamic simulations. International Geological Congress(IGC), August, Brisbane, Australia
275
_____________________________________
Appendix I
Metal Complexation in Hydrothermal Fluids: Insights from Ab Initio Molecular Dynamics
_____________________________________
276
!"#"$%$&"'()'*+",(-.,/0' 1/"2$'()'3#0$-' 4$"#2'5(%02$6#"/(&'/&'789-(",$-%#2':2+/9.;'<&./=,".')-(%'*>'<&/"/('4(2$?+2#-'@8&#%/?.'
3+>2/?#"/(&'!"#"+.''
'
3+>2/?#"/(&'@$"#/2.' !,$-%#&A'@B'4BA'#&9'4$/A'CBA'DEFFB'4$"#2'5(%02$6#"/(&' /&'789-(",$-%#2':2+/9.;' <&./=,".')-(%'
*>' <&/"/(' 4(2$?+2#-' @8&#%/?.A' G(29.?,%/9"' 5(&)$-$&?$' DEFFA' *+=+."' DEFFA' 3-#=+$A' 5H$?,'
I$0+>2/?''
!"#$%&'(%)#&*+"#*%),'J8' ./=&/&=' ",$' !"#"$%$&"' ()' *+",(-.,/0A' $#?,' #+",(-' ?$-"/)/$.' ",#"' ",$/-' ."#"$9' ?(&"-/>+"/(&' "(' ",$' 0+>2/?#"/(&' /.' #??+-#"$' #&9' ",#"'
0$-%/../(&'/.'=-#&"$9')(-'",$'0+>2/?#"/(&'"('>$'/&?2+9$9'/&'",$'?#&9/9#"$K.'",$./.B'
'
L#%$'()'5(M*+",(-' @#N/9'4'!,$-%#&'
5(&"-/>+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' @$N$2(0$9'?(%0+"#"/('%$",(9.'#&9'0$-)(-%$9'%(2$?+2#-' ./%+2#"/(&A'O-("$'%#&+.?-/0"'#&9'
0-$.$&"$9'/&'?(&)$-$&?$B'
!/=&#"+-$'
'
@#"$' DPMQ+2MFR'
'
L#%$'()'5(M*+",(-' C+#&'4$/'
5(&"-/>+"/(&'"('",$'3#0$-' *../."$9'O/",'?(%0+"#"/('%$",(9'9$N$2(0/&='#&9'9#"#'?(22$?"/&=B'
!/=&#"+-$'
'
@#"$' DPMQ+2MFR'
'
'
'
'
APPENDIX I
277
Goldschmidt Conference Abstracts
Mineralogical Magazine www.minersoc.org
1855
Metal complexation in hydrothermal fluids: Insights from ab initio
molecular dynamics DAVID M. SHERMAN1* AND YUAN MEI1,2
1School of Earth Sciences, University of Bristol, Bristol BS8 1RJ, UK (*correspondence: [email protected])
2School of Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of Adelaide, Adelaide SA 5000, Australia Complexation of metals by Cl- and HS- ligands in
hydrothermal fluids is a fundamental process in the evolution of the Earth’s crust and the formation of ore deposits. Current thermodynamic models of complexation equilibria under hydrothermal conditions depend on extrapolations of experimental data using equations of state based on the Born model of solvation. Thermodynamic parameters for aqueous species are often provisional estimates based on systematic correlations between fundamental properties such as entropy, volume, ionic radius etc. Computational molecular simulations, however, can be used to test current thermodynamic models, predict metal speciation, and even estimate thermodynamic properties. For a condensed fluid, molecular dynamics simulations can be used to sample the configurational degrees of freedom in order to predict properties as a function of pressure and temperature. Simulations of dilute solutions, however, require very large systems (1000’s of atoms) and very long (> 1 ns) simulation times; such calculations are only practical by treating the atomic interactions using classical two- or three-body interatomic potentials. However, classical potentials seem to be unreliable for describing metal-ligand interactions, especially for transition metals and metalloids such as Sn+2, Au+3, Cu+2 and Cu+. ‘Ab initio molecular dynamics’ treats the molecular motions classically but the atomic interactions quantum mechanically. Although these simulations are only practical for systems with 100’s of atoms over short times (< 100 ps), they are giving fundamental new insights on metal speciation in hydrothermal fluids. Here, we describe simulations of Cu, Zn, Sn, Au, and Ni in NaCl- and HS-bearing aqueous fluids up to 350 °C. We show that predicted structures and speciation are in close agreement with experiment. Based on our simulations, we propose that the major driving force for metal complexation in hydrothermal fluids is the change in translational entropy between reactants and products. Entropies and free energies of complex formation can be estimated using thermodynamic integration and metadynamics. Applications of these techniques to Zn-Cl and Cu-Cl-HS stability constants will be presented.
APPENDIX I
278