1
Clostridioides difficile is among the top 5 pathogens identified as urgent public health threats by the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. 1 Key risk factors for CDI are low diversity of the gut microbiota and low levels of microbiota-derived protective secondary bile acids, which have direct inhibitory activity against C. difficile (Figure 1). 2,3 Current antibiotic therapies for CDI may cause more damage to the gut microbiota 4-5 and increase the risk of recurrence of CDI, which is ~25% after treatment of a first infection. 4 Ridinilazole is an investigational, oral antibiotic with a microbiome-sparing profile that is highly specific and bactericidal against C. difficile. 5,6 In a Phase 2 clinical study, ridinilazole treatment demonstrated a higher rate of sustained clinical response (clinical cure at end of treatment and no recurrence within 30 days) compared to oral vancomycin. 7 This sustained clinical response was driven by a marked reduction in rates of recurrent CDI in the ridinilazole group, 7 which was coincident with preservation of protective secondary bile acids with ridinilazole compared to vancomycin (Figure 2). 8 This poster presents a subsequent shotgun metagenomic analysis that measured the differential effect of ridinilazole and vancomycin on fecal microbiota diversity, composition, and gene function associated with the production of protective secondary bile acids. In this metagenomic analysis of fecal samples from a Phase 2 clinical trial, ridinilazole treatment for CDI had minimal impact on the α-diversity and composition of the gut microbiota. Ridinilazole treatment preserved the potential of the microbiota to produce protective secondary bile acids. In contrast, vancomycin treatment was associated with dramatic changes in the microbiota composition and potential to produce protective secondary bile acids. These results are coincident with previous bile acid analysis in fecal samples (Figure 2) and provide a mechanistic rationale for the lower rate of recurrence of CDI observed with ridinilazole compared to vancomycin in this Phase 2 study. 3 Ridinilazole is currently being evaluated in two Phase 3 studies for the treatment of CDI. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This study was sponsored by Summit (Oxford) Limited. Medical writing and editorial assistance was provided by Peloton Advantage, LLC, Parsippany, NJ, USA, and funded by Summit (Oxford) Limited. REFERENCES 1. US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Antibiotic resistance threats in the United States; 2019. 2. Seekatz AM, Young VB. J Clin Invest. 2014;124(10): 4182-4189. 3. Winston JA, Theriot CM. Anaerobe. 2016;41:44-50. 4. Kelly CP. Clin Microbiol Infect. 2012;18(suppl 6):21-27. 5. Goldstein EJ, et al. Antimicrob Agents Chemother. 2013;57(10):4872-4876. 6. Corbett D, et al. J Antimicrob Chemother. 2015;70(6):1751-1756. 7. Vickers RJ, et al. Lancet Infect Dis. 2017;17(7):735-744. 8. Qian X, et al. Am J Physiol Gastrointest Liver Physiol. 2020;319(2). 9. Sekse C, et al. Front Microbiol. 2017;8:2029. 10. Heinken A et al. Microbiome. 2019;7:75. INTRODUCTION Metagenomic Analysis of the Differential Impact of Ridinilazole and Vancomycin on the Gut Microbiota in a Phase 2 Study Esther Duperchy 1 , Albert Pallejà 2 , Oksana Lukjancenko 2 , Nikolaj Sørensen 2 , Henrik B. Nielsen 2 , David J. Powell 1 1 Summit Therapeutics, Abingdon, UK; 2 Clinical Microbiomics, København, Denmark Learn more about the Phase 3 trials at www.ricodifytrial.com /eu Figure 7. Relative Abundance of Reported bai Gene Carriers Figure 6. Relative Abundance of Reported bsh Gene Carriers Bubbles represent the relative abundance of potential bsh gene carriers for each individual patient’s sample (1 sample per column). Table 1. Change From Baseline to End of Treatment in bsh and bai Genes Relative Abundance Ridinilazole Vancomycin Median Paired % Change P Value Median Paired % Change P Value bsh gene + 8% 0.54 - 89% 0.0064 bai operon genes 0% 0.28 - 100% 0.0017 Figure 4. Median α-Diversity Shannon Index and Phyla Relative Abundance Figure 2. Bile Acid Composition in Stool Samples From Healthy Controls and Patients With CDI Treated With Ridinilazole or Vancomycin Adapted with permission from Qian X et al, Am J Physiol Gastrointest Liver Physiol, 2020. 7 © 2021 Summit Therapeutics Inc. Trademarks, registered or otherwise, are the property of their respective owners. Figure 1. Role of Bile Acid Metabolism in C. difficile Infection The microbiota produces secondary bile acids through two successive reactions: (1) deconjugation by bacteria that carry the bile salt hydrolase (bsh) gene and (2) 7-α-dehydroxylation by bacteria that carry the bile acid inducible (bai) genes. 4 This analysis evaluated clinical samples from a Phase 2, randomized, double-blind, clinical study that compared the efficacy of 10-day oral ridinilazole (200 mg bid) or vancomycin (125 mg qid) as CDI treatment (NCT02092935). DNA extracted from stool samples collected from 43 patients at baseline (BSL) and end of treatment (EOT) was analyzed by metagenomic shotgun sequencing on an Illumina platform. For microbiome profiling, shotgun metagenomics is now considered the method of choice over 16S sequencing (Figure 3). 6,7 α-Diversity was measured with the Shannon index, which considers both the number of bacterial species (richness) and their relative abundance (evenness). Statistical analysis was performed on paired samples at BSL and EOT (ridinilazole, n=23; vancomycin, n=20) using Wilcoxon signed rank tests. P values were corrected for multiple testing to control the false discovery rate (FDR) at a level of 10%, as indicated. METHODS Figure 3. Microbiome Profiling Using Shotgun Metagenomic vs 16S rRNA Gene Amplicon Sequencing Microbiota Composition: α-Diversity and Relative Abundance of Bacterial Phyla At EOT, ridinilazole treatment was associated with ~3 times lower impact on microbiota α-diversity (-10% vs BSL; P=0.43) than vancomycin (-35% vs BSL; P=0.00001) (Figure 4). At the phylum level, at ridinilazole EOT, a 1.7-fold reduction in Firmicutes and a 1.5-fold increase in Bacteroidetes (P=0.08) was observed. In contrast, at vancomycin EOT, >16,000-fold and 27-fold reductions in Bacteroidetes (FDR P= 0.003) and Actinobacteria (FDR P=0.0005) were observed, respectively, concomitantly with a 5-fold expansion of Proteobacteria (FDR P=0.0005). At the genus level, at ridinilazole EOT, only a significant reduction of Clostridioides was observed (-28-fold change [FC]; FDR P=0.05). This corresponded to a reduction in C. difficile species, targeted by ridinilazole. In contrast, vancomycin therapy resulted in significant ≥2-fold decreases in 23 different bacterial genera, including Bacteroides (-69,723-FC; FDR P=0.003), Blautia (-47,710-FC; FDR P=0.002), and Bifidobacterium (-93-FC; FDR P=0.007), all considered good commensals (Figure 5). Microbiota Metabolic Potential to Produce Protective Secondary Bile Acids Based on the literature, numerous bacterial taxa in the gut can perform the reaction of deconjugation of conjugated primary bile acids (via bsh gene products) while only a few bacterial species can perform the 7-a-dehydroxylation (via bai gene products) to generate the protective secondary bile acids. 10 These bacterial taxa were still present in most patients after ridinilazole therapy but were not detected or strongly reduced in most patients after vancomycin therapy when compared to BSL (Figures 6 and 7). Moreover, at ridinilazole EOT, the relative abundance of both bsh and bai genes were similar to BSL, +8% and +0%, respectively. In contrast, at vancomycin EOT, a significant 89% reduction of the relative abundance of bsh genes (P=0.006) and a 100% reduction of bai genes (P=0.002) were reported (Table 1). RESULTS CONCLUSIONS Adapted with permission from Sekse et al, Front Microbiol, 2017. 9 The phyla abundance % is indicated for phyla median relative abundance >2%. Analysis with all samples. Figure 5. Median Log 2 Fold Changes (FC) of Prevalent Genera at Baseline vs EOT Only genera with a log 2 median ratio >1 (doubled abundance) present in at least 50% of the patients at BSL or detected in at least 2 samples after vancomycin treatment are shown. Analysis of BSL-EOT paired samples. Bubbles represent the relative abundance of potential bai gene carriers for each individual patient’s sample (1 sample per column). Ridinilazole is an investigational compound that is not approved by any regulatory body. Poster #2515 Amplicon from 16S rRNA gene 3 different genomes, e.g. Klebsiella pneumoniae Enterococcus faecalis Clostridium scindens Shotgun Metagenomic Sequencing bai genes blaKPC gene Microbiome composition to species level e.g. Klebsiella pneumoniae Microbiome resistance to antimicrobials e.g. blaKPC gene confers resistance to carbapenem Microbiome function e.g. bai genes involved in production of secondary bile acids Microbiome composition to genus level e.g. Klebsiella 16S Amplicon Sequencing

Metagenomic Analysis of the Differential Impact of

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Metagenomic Analysis of the Differential Impact of

INTRODUCTION• Clostridioides difficile is among the top 5 pathogens identified as urgent public health

threats by the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.1

• Key risk factors for CDI are low diversity of the gut microbiota and low levels of microbiota-derived protective secondary bile acids, which have direct inhibitory activity against C. difficile (Figure 1).2,3

• Current antibiotic therapies for CDI may cause more damage to the gut microbiota4-5 and increase the risk of recurrence of CDI, which is ~25% after treatment of a first infection.4

• Ridinilazole is an investigational, oral antibiotic with a microbiome-sparing profile that is highly specific and bactericidal against C. difficile.5,6

• In a Phase 2 clinical study, ridinilazole treatment demonstrated a higher rate of sustained clinical response (clinical cure at end of treatment and no recurrence within 30 days) compared to oral vancomycin.7

• This sustained clinical response was driven by a marked reduction in rates of recurrent CDI in the ridinilazole group,7 which was coincident with preservation of protective secondary bile acids with ridinilazole compared to vancomycin (Figure 2).8

• This poster presents a subsequent shotgun metagenomic analysis that measured the differential effect of ridinilazole and vancomycin on fecal microbiota diversity, composition, and gene function associated with the production of protective secondary bile acids.

CONCLUSIONS• In this metagenomic analysis of fecal samples from a Phase 2 clinical trial, ridinilazole treatment for CDI had minimal impact on the α-diversity and composition of the

gut microbiota.

• Ridinilazole treatment preserved the potential of the microbiota to produce protective secondary bile acids.

• In contrast, vancomycin treatment was associated with dramatic changes in the microbiota composition and potential to produce protective secondary bile acids.

• These results are coincident with previous bile acid analysis in fecal samples (Figure 2) and provide a mechanistic rationale for the lower rate of recurrence of CDI observed with ridinilazole compared to vancomycin in this Phase 2 study.3

• Ridinilazole is currently being evaluated in two Phase 3 studies for the treatment of CDI.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This study was sponsored by Summit (Oxford)

Limited. Medical writing and editorial assistance was provided by Peloton Advantage, LLC, Parsippany, NJ, USA, and funded by Summit (Oxford) Limited.

REFERENCES 1. US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Antibiotic resistance threats in the United States; 2019. 2. Seekatz AM, Young VB. J Clin Invest. 2014;124(10):

4182-4189. 3. Winston JA, Theriot CM. Anaerobe. 2016;41:44-50. 4. Kelly CP. Clin Microbiol Infect. 2012;18(suppl 6):21-27. 5. Goldstein EJ, et al. Antimicrob Agents Chemother. 2013;57(10):4872-4876. 6. Corbett D, et al. J Antimicrob Chemother. 2015;70(6):1751-1756. 7. Vickers RJ, et al. Lancet Infect Dis. 2017;17(7):735-744. 8. Qian X, et al. Am J Physiol Gastrointest Liver Physiol. 2020;319(2).9. Sekse C, et al. Front Microbiol. 2017;8:2029. 10. Heinken A et al. Microbiome. 2019;7:75.

The height of each stacked bar represents the α-diversity.

INTRODUCTION

Metagenomic Analysis of the Differential Impact of Ridinilazole and Vancomycin on the Gut Microbiota in a Phase 2 StudyEsther Duperchy1, Albert Pallejà2, Oksana Lukjancenko2, Nikolaj Sørensen2, Henrik B. Nielsen2, David J. Powell1

1Summit Therapeutics, Abingdon, UK; 2Clinical Microbiomics, København, Denmark

Learn more about the Phase 3 trials at www.ricodifytrial.com/eu

Figure 7. Relative Abundance of Reported bai Gene Carriers

Figure 6. Relative Abundance of Reported bsh Gene Carriers

Bubbles represent the relative abundance of potential bsh gene carriers for each individual patient’s sample (1 sample per column).

Table 1. Change From Baseline to End of Treatment in bsh and bai Genes Relative Abundance

Ridinilazole Vancomycin

Median Paired % Change P Value Median Paired % Change P Value

bsh gene + 8% 0.54 - 89% 0.0064

bai operon genes 0% 0.28 - 100% 0.0017

Figure 4. Median α-Diversity Shannon Index and Phyla Relative Abundance

Figure 2. Bile Acid Composition in Stool Samples From Healthy Controls and Patients With CDI Treated With Ridinilazole or Vancomycin

Adapted with permission from Qian X et al, Am J Physiol Gastrointest Liver Physiol, 2020.7

© 2021 Summit Therapeutics Inc. Trademarks, registered or otherwise, are the property of their respective owners.

Figure 1. Role of Bile Acid Metabolism in C. difficile Infection

The microbiota produces secondary bile acids through two successive reactions: (1) deconjugation by bacteria that carry the bile salt hydrolase (bsh) gene and (2) 7-α-dehydroxylation by bacteria that carry the bile acid inducible (bai) genes.4

METHODS• This analysis evaluated clinical samples from a Phase 2, randomized, double-blind, clinical study that

compared the efficacy of 10-day oral ridinilazole (200 mg bid) or vancomycin (125 mg qid) as CDI treatment (NCT02092935).

• DNA extracted from stool samples collected from 43 patients at baseline (BSL) and end of treatment (EOT) was analyzed by metagenomic shotgun sequencing on an Illumina platform.

• For microbiome profiling, shotgun metagenomics is now considered the method of choice over 16S sequencing (Figure 3).6,7

• α-Diversity was measured with the Shannon index, which considers both the number of bacterial species (richness) and their relative abundance (evenness).

• Statistical analysis was performed on paired samples at BSL and EOT (ridinilazole, n=23; vancomycin, n=20) using Wilcoxon signed rank tests. P values were corrected for multiple testing to control the false discovery rate (FDR) at a level of 10%, as indicated.

METHODS

Figure 3. Microbiome Profiling Using Shotgun Metagenomic vs 16S rRNA Gene Amplicon Sequencing

Microbiota Composition: α-Diversity and Relative Abundance of Bacterial Phyla

• At EOT, ridinilazole treatment was associated with ~3 times lower impact on microbiota α-diversity(-10% vs BSL; P=0.43) than vancomycin (-35% vs BSL; P=0.00001) (Figure 4).

• At the phylum level, at ridinilazole EOT, a 1.7-fold reduction in Firmicutes and a 1.5-fold increase in Bacteroidetes (P=0.08) was observed. In contrast, at vancomycin EOT, >16,000-fold and 27-fold reductions in Bacteroidetes (FDR P= 0.003) and Actinobacteria (FDR P=0.0005) were observed, respectively, concomitantly with a 5-fold expansion of Proteobacteria (FDR P=0.0005).

• At the genus level, at ridinilazole EOT, only a significant reduction of Clostridioides was observed (-28-fold change [FC]; FDR P=0.05). This corresponded to a reduction in C. difficile species, targeted by ridinilazole. In contrast, vancomycin therapy resulted in significant ≥2-fold decreases in 23 different bacterial genera, including Bacteroides (-69,723-FC; FDR P=0.003), Blautia (-47,710-FC; FDR P=0.002), and Bifidobacterium (-93-FC; FDR P=0.007), all considered good commensals (Figure 5).

Microbiota Metabolic Potential to Produce Protective Secondary Bile Acids

• Based on the literature, numerous bacterial taxa in the gut can perform the reaction of deconjugation of conjugated primary bile acids (via bsh gene products) while only a few bacterial species can perform the 7-a-dehydroxylation (via bai gene products) to generate the protective secondary bile acids.10

• These bacterial taxa were still present in most patients after ridinilazole therapy but were not detected or strongly reduced in most patients after vancomycin therapy when compared to BSL (Figures 6 and 7).

• Moreover, at ridinilazole EOT, the relative abundance of both bsh and bai genes were similar to BSL, +8% and +0%, respectively. In contrast, at vancomycin EOT, a significant 89% reduction of the relative abundance of bsh genes (P=0.006) and a 100% reduction of bai genes (P=0.002) were reported (Table 1).

RESULTS

CONCLUSIONS

Adapted with permission from Sekse et al, Front Microbiol, 2017.9

The phyla abundance % is indicated for phyla median relative abundance >2%. Analysis with all samples.

Figure 5. Median Log2 Fold Changes (FC) of Prevalent Genera at Baseline vs EOT

Only genera with a log2 median ratio >1 (doubled abundance) present in at least 50% of the patients at BSL or detected in at least 2 samples after vancomycin treatment are shown. Analysis of BSL-EOT paired samples.

Bubbles represent the relative abundance of potential bai gene carriers for each individual patient’s sample (1 sample per column).

Ridinilazole is an investigational compound that is not approved by any regulatory body.

Poster #2515

Amplicon from 16S rRNA gene3 different genomes, e.g. Klebsiella pneumoniae Enterococcus faecalis Clostridium scindens

Shotgun Metagenomic Sequencing

bai genes

blaKPC gene

Microbiome composition to species levele.g. Klebsiella pneumoniae

Microbiome resistance to antimicrobialse.g. blaKPC gene confers resistance to carbapenem

Microbiome functione.g. bai genes involved in production of secondary bile acids

Microbiome composition to genus levele.g. Klebsiella

16S Amplicon Sequencing