Mend & Make Do to Save Buying New; Decoding Messages of Austerity in a Consumer Culture

8/14/2019 Mend & Make Do to Save Buying New; Decoding Messages of Austerity in a Consumer Culture

1/93

! "!

!"#$%$%!&'"%()%***%+)%,&-"%./01#2%#"3*%("4)$1#2%5",,&2",%)6%&/,+"71+0%

1#%&%4)#,/5"7%4/8+/7"*%

%

% 612*9%

:&5",%;&08)7%

!4)8)20%("?&7+5"#+%)6%@")27&?A0%$%4)8)20%


2/93

! #!

$%&'()(*+,-.!!

!/0+1!*0%1+1!+1!*0%!)%12'*!,3!*0%!(2*0,)41!,)+5+-('!)%1%()&06!7*!0(1!8%%-!&,9:,1%;!

8

!!/0%!&,:H6IJ6!$2%!(&K-,@'%;5%9%-*!921*!('@(


3/93

! H!

!

HI


4/93

! T!

!

612*E%

QF0+)*?!U"VI?!8


5/93

! I!

DKL;>L;


6/93

! Z!

N#+7)$/4+1)#%

!

612*%O%

7-!*0%!-2)1%)+%1?!*0%!['%9%-*()

]O2*!,';!&',*0%1!()%!8%(1*'


7/93

! M!

J>HJD=%PKDB

7-!*0%!)%&%-*!:%)+,;!(-!('*%)-(*+=%!9%11(5%!0(1!8%%-!,33%)%;!8

1,2)&%!,3!+;+,9!(-;!:0)(1%!(-;!*0%!9%;+(!+1!('+=%!@+*0!-%@!%-*)%(*+%1!*,!Q;+5!3,)!

=+&*,)

0(=%!8%&,9%!@0(*!`(,',!b)+%)%!&(''1!(!Q5%-%)(*+=%!*0%9%4!X"NNMc"NMJdY!

/0%!&,-*%9:,)()

(-;!3(&+'+*(*%;!(!)%*2)-!*,!$7e?!)%21%!(-;!)%:(+)?!5),@+-5!


8/93

! V!

1*%:1!@0+&0!(**%9:*!*,!9,=%!;(+'

P0+'%!+-!*0%!F%&,-;!P,)';!P()!9%11(5%1!1+9+'()!*,!*0%1%!@%)%!&,992-+&(*%;!

;+)%&*'

3),9!5,=%)-9%-*!(-;!0(=%!8%%-!9%;+(*%;!3,)!*0%!9(\,)+*

*0),250!*0%!9(11!9%;+(6![-=+),-9%-*('!&,-&%)-1!1%%9!*,!8%!E2+&K'

*)(-13,)9%;!+-*,!-%@!,::,)*2-+*+%1!3,)!&,-129:*+,-?!*0%!&,-129%)!1,&+%*

%33,)*'%11'

,3!]%&,S:),;2&*1^!(-;!]5)%%-!('*%)-(*+=%1^6!/0%!3)(9+-5!&,-;+*+,-1!,3!*0%!9%;+(!

1%%9!*,!%>&'2;%!;%%:%)!;%8(*%?!&,-129%)+19!(::%()1!*,!8%!(!Q'+9+*S1+*2(*+,-4!

Xb)+%)%?!"NNZ!c"NMJdY!*0(*!;%*%)9+-%1!@0(*!+*!+1!:,11+8'%!*,!;+1&2116!O

3('1%!,::,1+*+,-!8%*@%%-!]%-=+),-9%-*(''

8%0(=+,2)?!@%!()%!;+1*)(&*%;!3),9!*0%!9,)%!&%-*)('!E2%1*+,-!,3!&,-129:*+,-!

+*1%'36!P('*%)!O%-\(9+-!1255%1*%;!*0(*!Q*0%!8,2)5%,+1!(::()(*21!,3!:),;2&*+,-!

(-;!:28'+&(*+,-!+1!&(:(8'%!,3!(11+9+'(*+-5?!+-;%%;!,3!:),:(5(*+-5!(-!(1*,-+10+-5!

(9,2-*!,3!)%=,'2*+,-()

9%-;4!@+*0!+*1!&'%()!+9:',)(*+,-!'52!*,!82


9/93

! N!

!

%

(N%

7!@+''!8%5+-!@+*0!9

*0+-K+-5.!

"6 /0(*!*0%!21%!,3!O)+*+10!:),:(5(-;(!+9(5%)

*0(*!9+50*!1255%1*!(8,2*!*0%!),'%!,3!*0%!:)%116!

C0(:*%)!T!:)%1%-*1!*0%!3+-;+-51!,3!9

3+-;+-516!

7-!C0(:*%)!I!7!9(K%!9


10/93

! "J!

!

HN!

3(&%6!

J","&74A%T/",+1)#,CK.U"4+1-",%

D)%!*0%!9%;+(!:)%1%-*+-5!(!&(1%!*0(*!@%!10,2';!)%;2&%!0,@!92&0!@%!&,-129%g!

h)!;,%1!*0%!&,-129%)!1,&+%*:',)+-5!*0%!:,*%-*+('!,3!21+-5!3+'9!3,,*(5%!,3!*0%!

AB!:(1*!(1!(!@(

3(&%!,3!&'+9(*%!&0(-5%!(-;!)%1,2)&%!;%:'%*+,-6!7-!:)%1%-*+-5!9(*%)+('!@0+&0!

)%=%('1!(!',@%)!%-%)5

*)

,3!(!1',@%)?!19(''%)!@,)';6!7!1%%!*0+1!(1!:()*!,3!9


11/93

! ""!

:),\%&*?!&(''%;!!QG%%'1!,3!G%1+'+%-&%4!92&0!,3!*0%!9(*%)+('!7!0(=%!;)(@-!2:,-!+1!

,33+&+('!5,=%)-9%-*!3+'9!3),9!*0%!F%&,-;!P,)';!P()!(+9%;!(*!&+=+'+(-1!,-!*0%!

0,9%!3),-*6!

/0+1!@,)K!0(1!8%%-!+-3'2%-&%;!8+1*+-5!1&0%;2'%!,3!1&)%%-+-51?!@0+&0!7!

0(=%!8%%-!+-*),;2&+-5!+-!&+-%9(1!(''!,=%)!*0%!AB6!F%=%)('!,3!*0%1%!0(=%!21%;!

@()*+9%!9(*%)+('6!7-!;+1&211+,-1!(3*%)@();1!*0(*!7!0(=%!3(&+'+*(*%;?!*0%!(2;+%-&%!

0(1!1:,-*(-%,21'

:%)&%+=%!9,)('!;%5)(;(*+,-!3),9!(-!%()'+%)!:%)+,;?!212(''

/0%!:(1*!&(-!('1,!:),=+;%!(!21%32'!&)+*+E2%!0,@%=%)?!%>:,1+-5!&0(-5%1!+-!1,&+('!

-,)91?!('',@+-5!(!9,)%!1,:0+1*+&(*%;!(-('4)8)20%

7*!+1!+-!*0+1!()%(!*0(*!)%'%=(-&%!*,!029(-!%&,',5

:(1*!-,*!,-'

()%?!+*!('1,!('',@1!21!*,!:%)&%+=%!;+33%)%-*!@(


12/93

! "#!

1*)2&*2)%;!+-!(!@(

!


13/93

! "H!

R1+"7&+/7"%J"-1"3%

%

612*W%

;A"%D)#+"5?)7&70%D/77"#40%)6%+A"%


14/93

! "T!

(**)(&*+,-!('1,!-,*%;!8

E2%1*+,-!,3!0,@!3()!8(&K!+1!(!'+=%!,-%!3,)!*0,1%!)%1+1*(-*!*,!(!9,;%)-!@,)';!,3!

%>&%116!b,)!*0,1%!,3!*0%!(-*+S&+=+'+a(*+,-!,)!(-()&0,S:)+9+*+=+1*!:%)12(1+,-1?!*0(*!

',-5%;!3,)!:(1*!+1!8%3,)%!0+1*,)

#JJZY6!!

G%&%-*':%)+%-&%1!,3!*0%!-(*+,-!;2)+-5!*0%!F%&,-;!

P,)';!P()?!@0+&0!0(1!8%%-!0%';!2:!(1!(!*,*%9!,3!8,*0!&,''%&*+=%!(&*+,-!(-;!

',@%)!+9:(&*!'+=+-56!D!@()*+9%!&,-1&+,21-%11!+-1:+)%;!8(9:'%!,3!&,992-+*

/0%!-,1*('5+&!%=,&(*+,-!,3!*0%!:%)+,;!0(1!0(;!)%1,-(-&%!3,)!*0%!9%;+(?!@0+&0!0(1!

)%&%-*'

)%@,)K%;!3,)!(-!%)(!,3!9,;%)-!&)+1%16!/0%!:28'+&!0(1!8%%-!%-&,2)(5%;!*,!]$+5!

3,)!m+&*,)

#JJM!(-;!L2'+1!i%>+1!Xi%>+1!ABY6!/,*('!)%&,);%;!)%12'*!@(1!"NT?!@0+&0!+-&'2;%;!)%:%*+*+,-1!+-!3+)1*!(-;!1281%E2%-*!

%;+*+,-1!,3!:(:%)16!

H!/0%!:0)(1%!(::%()%;!,=%)!"JJ!*+9%1!+-!AB!-(*+,-('!-%@1:(:%)1!8%*@%%-!L2'

#JJM!(-;!L2'+1!i%>+1!Xi%>+1!ABY6!/,*('!

)%&,);%;!)%12'*!@(1!""I?!@0+&0!+-&'2;%;!)%:%*+*+,-1!+-!3+)1*!(-;!1281%E2%-*!%;+*+,-1!,3!:(:%)16!


15/93

! "I!

&'+9(*%!&0(-5%?!3'2!%:+;%9+&1!(-;!%&,-,9+&!;%:)%11+,-6!W%)%!*0%

(&*+=+1*!:,1+*+,-1!&(''+-5!3,)!)%S',&('+1(*+,-?!&,992-+*

&,-129%)!)%1*)(+-*6!

/0%!&(9:(+5-+-5!5),2:!O'(&K,2*!O)+*(+-!X:)%=+,21'

XO'(&K,2*!O)+*(+-?!#JJNY6!/0%!&%'%8)+*

R21%29!0(1!9(;%!(-!('',*9%-*!+-!F*!L(9%141!`()K!*,!(&&,9:(-0+8+*+,-!

Q$+5!3,)!m+&*,)

R+&0(%'!`,''(-?!R+&0%''%!h8(9(!%1*(8'+10%;!(!m+&*,)

*0%!P0+*%!W,21%!XF0(@?!#JJNY6!/0%!O)+*+10!9,-()&041!5();%-%)1!9(;%!0%)!(!

Q5),@!

*,!(!@()*+9%!:',*!+-!*0%!1(9%!5),2-;1!XC0+**%-;%-?!#JJNl!$(=+%1?!#JJNY6!

F%%9+-5'

\,2)!+-!*0%!3(&%!,3!(-

)%9+>%;!+-*,!(!@%'*%)!,3!,*0%)!%>:)%11+,-1!@0+&0!(:%;!*0%!*1%**+-5!,3!*0%!,)+5+-('!82*!:,1%;!('*%)-(*%!+9:',)(*+,-1?!@+*0!*0%!O)+*+10!`,'+&%!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T!F%%!3+52)%!M!


16/93

! "Z!

%=%-!5%**+-5!+-!,-!*0%!(&*!@+*0!]e,2!0(=%!*0%!)+50*!ih/!*,!)%9(+-!1+'%-*^!+-!(!

#JJN!!-(*+,-@+;%!!:,1*%)!!&(9:(+5-?!!X1%%!!*0%!!:0,*,5)(:0!!+-!!3+52)%!"ZY6!/0%!

52%))+''(!5();%-+-5!9,=%9%-*!+-!*0%!AB!0+\(&K%;!9+'+*():'+&+*'

)%3%)%-&%;!O)+*(+-41!@()*+9%!%>:%)+%-&%!XG%/,:!/+:1!3,)!/,250!/+9%1^!*(K+-5!F%&,-;!P,)';!P()!1',5(-1!(-;!1*+&K+-5!*0%9!

2:!(5(+-1*!*0%!&,-*%9:,)()

&0()(&*%)!R)1!F%@S(-;SF%@!@(1!)%&)%(*%;!3,)!*0%!#"1*!&%-*2)0+8+*+,-!(*!*0%!

R21%296!/0%!C%-*)%!3,)!D'*%)-(*+=%!/%&0-,',5

,3!*0%!-%%;!3,)!Q(-!2)5%-*!1%-1%!,3!&,99,-!:2):,1%?!9,)%!(K+-!*,!*0(*!@0+&0!

:%)*(+-%;!;2)+-5!P,)';!P()!/@,!*0(-!+-!(-

)%'(*+-5!*0%+)!&,-*%-*!*,!&,-*%9:,)()

&'+9(*%!&0(-5%?!@,2';!*0%!%>:%)+%-&%!,3!*0%!:(1*!0%':!,);+-()

+*1!*+*2'()!9%11(5%!(1!Q\21*!(1!%33%&*+=%!(!*,-+&!3,)!*0,1%!'(8,2)+-5!2-;%)!9,;%)-!

(->+%*+%1!(1!*0,1%!@0,!%-;2)%;!*0%!8'+*a4!XD-,-?!#JJN(.!-,!:(5%!-298%)Y6!!L+''!

i,)9(-41!3,)%@,);!*,!*0%!&,''%&*+,-!,3!3(&1+9+'%!'%(3'%*1!,3!F%&,-;!P,)';!P()!


17/93

! "M!

(;=+&%?!,#+*(=5(#'%(,*'%?!&,99%-*1!*0(*!Qc%d-&,2)(5+-5!:%,:'%41!

)%1,2)&%32'-%11!@+*0!1('=(5+-5!(-;!)%&

,@-!0+1*,)

*0%)%!0(1!8%%-!*0%!1255%1*+,-!3),9!1,9%!&(9:(+5-%)1!,3!(!@()*+9%!*D28)%

F%&,-;!P,)';!P()!:,'+&

b(@&%**!@)+*%!*0(*!Qc(d'*0,250!*0%!@,);!Q)(*+,-+-54!9(

(1!+*!+1!@+*0!+9(5%1!,3!;%:)+=(*+,-!(-;!)%1*)+&*+,-?!+*!+1!21%;!;%'+8%)(*%'

8%!=%)


18/93

! "V!

%>:,12)%!(*!(!5,=%)-9%-*('!'%=%'6!i+&0,'(1!F*%)-41!)%:,)*!3,)!*0%!AB!5,=%)-9%-*!

,-!*0%!%&,-,9+&1!,3!&'+9(*%!&0(-5%!%E2(*%;!*0%!&0(''%-5%!@+*0!*0%!Q5)%(*!@()14!

XF*%)-?!#JJZ.!=+?!IM#Y6!G,8%)*!W+)1&041!)%:,)*!3,)!*0%!AF!5,=%)-9%-*!,-!*0%!

:%(K+-5!,3!@,)';!,+'!:),;2&*+,-!%=,K%;!*0%!5,=%)-9%-*!)%1:,-1%!*,!*0%!F%&,-;!

P,)';!P()!(1!(!9%(12)%!,3!:,11+8'%!(-;!-%&%11()

AF!$%:()*9%-*!,3!$%3%-1%?!)%5();+-5!&'+9(*%!&0(-5%?!:'(&%;!%-=+),-9%-*('!

&,''(:1%!(1!(!-(*+,-('!;%3%-&%!+112%!XF&0@()*a!p!G(-;(''?!#JJHY6!D!)%&%-*!1:%%&0!

5+=%-!8

]3)%%!@,)';^!,-!*0%!&21:!,3!(-!+99+-%-*!F%&,-;!P,)';!P()!(1!(!:)%&%;%-*!3,)!(!

@,)';!3(&+-5!&'+9(*%!&0(-5%I6!/0%)%!@(1!(-!(-*%&%;%-*!*,,!+-!`)%1+;%-*!L+99

C()*%)41!21%!,3!@()!9%*(:0,)1!+-!;%1&)+8+-5!*0%!-%&%11()

%-%)5

D&*2('!5,=%)-9%-*!+-*%)=%-*+,-!*,!&2)8!&,-129:*+,-!+1!('9,1*!&,9:'%*%'

(81%-*!0,@%=%)6!b,)9%)!`)+9%!R+-+1*%)!/,-

@%!&,-129%!0(1!*,!&0(-5%?!82*!7!*0+-K!+*!+1!&,9:'%*%'

0(::%-4!XP(**1?!#JJNY6!h33+&+('!AB!:,'+&

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I!]P+-1*,-!C02)&0+''!(),21%;!*0+1!-(*+,-!+-!0%),+&!3(10+,-!*,!1(=%!&+=+'+1(*+,-!+-!P,)';!P()!/@,6!P%!0(=%!%=%)&%:*!:,'+*+&('!@+''?!82*!:,'+*+&('!

@+''!+1!(!)%-%@(8'%!)%1,2)&%6^!b),9!1:%%&0!8

!#JJN?!E2,*%;!+-!P%81*%)!!p!`(5-(9%-*(!X#JJNY6!


19/93

! "N!

(+):,)*!%>:(-1+,-Z?!&0%(:!3'+50*1M?!(-;!)%;2&+-5!*)(=%'V!:),&%%;!3),9!*0%!1(9%!

=+1+,-?!(-;!(''!)%=%('!*0(*!*0%!O)+*+10!@(

(&*+,-1!,3!5,=%)-9%-*?!9(:)%11%;!:28'+&!,:+-+,-!,3!*0%!

%'%&*,)(*%6!!D'(1*(+)!R&7-*,10!0(1!0+50'+50*%;!8,*0!@+;%!:28'+&!;+1:()(5%9%-*!,3!

:,'+*+&('!9,=%1!*,@();1!&2)8+-5!&,-129:*+,-!#'%!8%%-!&)+*+&('!,3!*0%!21%!,3!*0%!

F%&,-;!P,)';!P()!(1!(-!%>(9:'%!,3!Q(&&%:*%;!(21*%)+*

,33+&+('!&0(--%'1!XC(';%)?!"NZNl!k@%+-+5%)SO()5+%',@1K(?!#JJJl!i+&,'?!#JJNY6!7*!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Z!o,);,-!O),@-!1:%(K+-5!(*!*0%!(--2('!&,-3%)%-&%!,3!*0%!CO7!*,';!*0%!(2;+%-&%!*0(*!Q[=%-!(1!@%!:'(&%!1*)+&*!',&('!%-=+),-9%-*('!'+9+*1!,-!-,+1%!(-;!(+)!:,''2*+,-!

(-;!%-12)%!*0(*!(=+(*+,-!:(+*('+&1d6!

M!C'+9(*%!C0(-5%!1%&)%*()


20/93

! #J!

(::%()1!*0(*!&(''1!3,)!)%1*)(+-*!()%!%=%-!'%11!:,:2'()!@+*0!*0,1%!'+=+-5!+-!(!

&,-129%)!1,&+%*

*%&0-,',5

-,@?!(''!8%!9%*6!7-!,);%)!*,!&,-*+-2%!*,!9(K%!:),3+*1!(-;!3,)!*0,1%!:),3+*1!*,!

5),@?!D9%)+&(-!&,):,)(*+,-1!-%%;%;!*,!+-&)%(1%!*0%!(9,2-*!,3!-,-S%11%-*+('!

+*%91!*0%

&,-129%!9,)%!*0(-!*0%

&,-*+-2+-5!-%%;1?!+-1(*+(8'%!-%%;1!Xn(1&0?!"NMNY6!/0%!9,;%)-!(;=%)*+1+-5!

+-;21*)

!

7-!*0%!*)(;%!9(5(a+-%!V5"$'#;(5F(6*2#&;&'-?!m+&*,)!n%8,@!&(-;+;'


21/93

! #"!

:),;2&*+=%!%&,-,9

@*&1"$*(D;#11!Xc"VNNd!"NMJY!@0%)%!0%!:)%1%-*%;!0+1!&(1%!*0(*!A::%)!9+;;'%!&'(11!

D9%)+&(-1!;%3+-%;!*0%91%'=%1!(-;!*0%+)!1*(-;+-5!*0),250!&,-1:+&2,21!

&,-129:*+,-6!7-!"NII!n%8,@!;%1&)+8%;!*0+1!8%0(=+,2)!(1!%>+1*+-5!9,)%!@+;%'

*0),250,2*!1,&+%*1+5-+3+&(-&%!,3!,2)!'+=%1!+1!*,;(:)%11%;!+-!&,-129:*+,-!*%)9164!Xn%8,@?!"NII.!

MY6!/0%!K%

:)%112)%1!*,!&,-3,)9!*,!(&&%:*%;!1,&+('!1*(-;();1?!@0+&0!@,2';!'%(;!*0%!

+-;+=+;2('!*,!%>:)%11!*0%+)!+;%-*+*

3,,;!1%)=+-5?!0+1!0,88+%14!Xn%8,@?!"NII.!MY6!!!

!

7-!*0%!&,-129%)!1,&+%*


22/93

! ##!

F%%K+-5!12&0!:)+=(*%!1,'2*+,-1!9(

9%(-+-5?!(-;!(!)%;2&*+,-!+-!&,992-+*(&*'

&)%(*%!(-!Q%9:*

3,)91!12&0!(1!(;=%)*+1+-5!*0(*!%9(-(*%!(2*0,)+*

+1,'(*%;!+-;+=+;2('1!@+''!-,*!8%!%-,250!*,!&0(-5%!,)!%-;!&,-129%)!1,&+%*

i(*+,-16!/0%!)%:,)*!,3!*0%!R+''%--+29![&,1

*0%!7-*%)5,=%)-9%-*('!`(-%'!,-!C'+9(*%!C0(-5%?!*0(*!*0%!5',8('!&'+9(*%!+1!

@()9+-5!+1!Q2-%E2+=,&('4!(-;!Q9,1*!,3!*0%!,81%)=%;!+-&)%(1%!+-!5',8('!(=%)(5%!

*%9:%)(*2)%1!1+-&%!*0%!9+;S#J*0!&%-*2)

,81%)=%;!+-&)%(1%!+-!(-*0),:,5%-+&!5)%%-0,21%!5(1!&,-&%-*)(*+,-14!X#JJM.!I?!

"JY6!/0%!R+''%--+29![&,1


23/93

! #H!

)+&0%)!:,:2'(*+,-1!(1!*0%

1*(-;();164X#JJI.##Y6!

!

D1!*0%!A-+*%;!B+-5;,9!+1!,-%!,3!*0%!@,)';41!)+&0%1*!-(*+,-1"J!@%!9+50*!%>:%&*!+*!

*,!3,'',@!*0+1!:(**%)-6!h33+&+('!5,=%)-9%-*!1*(*+1*+&1!(::%()!*,!12::,)*!12&0!(-!

%>:%&*(*+,-6!D&&,);+-5!*,!*0%!h33+&%!,3!i(*+,-('!F*(*+1*+&1?!AB!0,21%0,';1!Q@%)%!

)%1:,-1+8'%!3,)!5)%%-0,21%!5(1!%9+11+,-1!*,*(''+-5!"I#!9+''+,-!*,--%1!,3!Ch#!

%E2+=('%-*!+-!#JJZ4!(!3(''!,-!*0%!:)%=+,21!

XO%-1,-?!"NNTl!"NNZY6!/0(*!*0%!)%;2&*+,-!,3!0,21%0,';!&,-129:*+,-!+-!)+&0!

+-;21*)+('!1,&+%*+%1!'+K%!*0%!AB!+1!(!:)%)%E2+1+*%!&,-;+*+,-!3,)!121*(+-(8+'+*

('1,!-%+*0%)!(!:,:2'()!,)!:28'+&(''

!

7!8%'+%=%!*0(*!,33+&+('!1*(*+1*+&1!12::,)*!*0%!(11%)*+,-!*0(*!*0%!AB!+1!(!&,-129%)!

1,&+%*

%&,1*0!'()5%1*!%&,-,9


24/93

! #T!

;+1*(-&%!*)(=%'!(-;!)2--+-5!(!:)+=(*%!&()6!/0%)%!()%!('1,!+-;+&(*+,-1!*0(*!@+*0+-!

*0%!&(*%5,):%-1+=%!(-;!%-%)5

+-*%-1+=%!+*%91?!3,)!%>(9:'%!+-!3,,;!@0%)%!1*(:'%!3,,;1!()%!:()*'

R,)%!)%&%-*!;(*(!+-;+&(*%1!*0(*.!Qc*d0%)%!0(1!8%%-!(-!2:@();!*)%-;!+-!*0%!=,'29%!

,3!0,21%0,';!%>:%-;+*2)%!+-!*0%!AB!,=%)!*0%!'(1*!HZ!:%-;+*2)%!@(1!#6M!*+9%1!5)%(*%)!*0(-!+-!"NM"4!

XW250%1?!#JJN.!V#Y6!!/0+1!)+1%!+-!%>:%-;+*2)%!0(1!)%12'*%;!+-!(-!+-&)%(1%!+-!*0%!

0,21%0,';!,@-%)10+:!,3!&,-129%)!;2)(8'%1?!*0%!:,11%11+,-!,3!@0+&0!+1!

&,99,-'

(-;!&,-&,9+*(-*!5)%%-0,21%!5(1!%9+11+,-16!

G%1%()&0!,-!*0%!:%)&%-*(5%!,3!0,21%0,';1!+-!*0%!AB!@+*0!=()+,21!;2)(8'%!5,,;1!

XR(&),)


25/93

! #I!

#JJM!*0%!,@-%)10+:!,3!(!;+5+*('!*%'%=+1+,-!1%)=+&%!X+-&'2;+-5!&(8'%?!1(*%''+*%!(-;!

;+5+*('Y!('1,!),1%!3),9!"Nt!*,!MMt""6!!

/0%1%!+-&)%(1%1!;,!1%%9!*,!8%!(&&,9:(-+%;!8

"NMJ!(-;!#JJZ!%-%)5

+-&)%(1%;!8

(9,2-*!,3!92-+&+:('!@(1*%!:),;2&%;!+-![-5'(-;!+-&)%(1%;!8

9+''+,-!*,--%16!VNt!,3!*0+1!@(1*%!@(1!:),;2&%;!;+)%&*':%-;(8'%!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

""!/0+1!+1!:),8(8'

*0%1%!+*%91!+1!-,*!)%&,);%;?!82*!+1!'+K%'*)(!%'%9%-*!,3!

%-%)5

"H!R2-+&+:('!@(1*%!('1,!+-&'2;%1!3'

&,''%&*%;!8


26/93

! #Z!

5,,;1!(-;!1%)=+&%1!@(1!:()*!,3!*0%!1*(*21!5+=+-5!E2('+*

&'%()!*0(*!m%8'%-!@(1!-,*!21+-5!*0%!@,);!@(1*%!(1!@%!@,2';!*,;(


27/93

! #M!

12&&%11g!W,@!;,!@%!)%=%)1%!*0%!9,9%-*29!,3!1%=%)('!&%-*2)+%1!,3!1*)255'%!(-;!

(&0+%=%9%-*g4!X"NNM.!TJY6!!

/0%!&'+9(*%!&0(-5%!&(9:(+5-%)!o%,)5%!R,-8+,*!0(1!9(;%!(!1+9+'()!:,+-*?!

121*(+-%;!%&,-,9+&!5),@*0!0(1!:),=+;%;!(!=%)

5),@*0!(-;!*0%!&,-129%)!1,&+%*

(21*%)+*


28/93

! #V!

;A"%M,04A)8)20%)6%+A"%4)#,/5"7%,)41"+0%

%

%

612*%Z%

/0%)%!+1!(!9%-*('!;+1:()+*

&,-&%)-1!(-;!%>0+8+*+-5!&,-129%)+1*!8%0(=+,2)6!F2&0!(-!+-&,-5)2+*

)%&,5-+1%;!8

;%1&)+:*,)16!7*!9(

#JJV.VVMY!(-;!Q&,5-+*+=%!:,'


29/93

! #N!

-,)9?!*0+1!+1!(-!+;%(!,3!-,)9('j(&&%:*(8'%!8%0(=+,2)!8(1%;!,-!@0(*!9,1*!:%,:'%!

#32"#;;

1+*2(*+,-6!/0%!1%&,-;!*

1,'2*+,-1!*,!:28'+&!:),8'%91!()%!3(=,2)%;!f!*0%!1+*2(*+,-!,3!&,-129%)!

1,=%)%+5-*%)&+1%!,3!&+*+a%-10+:!;%1&)+8%;!8


30/93

! HJ!

P%!0(=%!(')%(;

)%'(*+-5!*,!0,21%0,';!&,-129:*+,-!+-!*0%!AB?!;%1&)+:*+,-1!,3!@0(*!:%,:'%!*%-;!

*,!;,6!/0%!;%1&)+:*+=%!1,&+('!-,)91!)%'(*+-5!*,!&,-129%)!8%0(=+,2)!)%:)%1%-*!*0%!

1*(*21!E2,!+-!@0+&0!029(-!(&*+=+*

D11%119%-*?!#JJI.IY6!D-

1%*!,3!1,&+('!-,)91!3(=,2)+-5!(!0+50!&,-129:*+,-!'+3%1*

,3!)2'%1!:),=+;+-5!+-\2-&*+=%!1,&+('!-,)91!*,!52+;%!121*(+-(8'%!8%0(=+,2)6!P%!

9+50*!%>:%&*!*,!1%%!*0%1%!)2'%1!9(-+3%1*!*0),250!(!=()+%*

+-\2-&*+=%!-,)91!8,*0!*0),250!+*1!:),:(5(-;(!9%11(5%1!(-;!9(-;(*,)

)(*+,-1!:),=+;%1!(!&,-*%9:,)()(9:'%!,3!(!:),:,1%;!1%*!,3!)2'%1!*,!8%!

+9:,1%;!8

%()'+%)!3),9!/,-

;%9,-1*)(*%!*0(*!*0+1!+1!-,*!(!),'%!*0%!&2))%-*!5,=%)-9%-*!+1!+-*%)%1*%;!+-!

:'(

-,)91!)%5();+-5!)%;2&+-5!,)!('*%)+-5!&,-129:*+,-!:(**%)-1?!+-&'2;+-5!1*,::+-5!

3'


31/93

! H"!

8+,;%5)(;(8'%6!/0%!0+1*,)

9,=%9%-*1!*,@();1!*0%!%9(-&+:(*+,-!,3!1'(=%1!(-;!,3!3%9('%!1233)(5%6!/0%!

(&*+=+1*!)%21%!,3!F%&,-;!P,)';!P()!:),:(5(-;(!&(-!8%!1%%-!(1!)%&,5-+*+,-!,3!*0%!

:,@%)32'!+-\2-&*+=%!1,&+('!-,)91!&,-*(+-%;!+-!+*1!1',5(-1!(-;!*0%+)!:%)&%+=%;!

12&&%116!

B+'8,2)-%!p!`+&K%**!()%!;28+,21!(8,2*!*0%!12&&%11!*0(*!(&*+=+1*!&(9:(+5-1!0(=%!

*,;(

C2'*2)(''

(1!(!9,;%!,3!&,-129:*+,-64!X#JJV.!VVZY6!73!,2)!1,&+('!+-1*+*2*+,-1?!*0,1%!&(:(8'%!

,3!+-*),;2&+-5?!:),9,*+-5!,)!%-3,)&+-5!+-\2-&*+=%!1,&+('!-,)91?!()%!('1,!*+%;!*,!(!

9(*%)+('+1*!&,-129%)+19!*0%-!*0%!&,-*)(;+&*+,-!8%*@%%-!1,&+(''

8%0(=+,2)!(-;!:%)1,-('!%-=+),-9%-*('!&,-=+&*+,-!+1!3,)&%;!,-!*,!*0%!+-;+=+;2('?!

@+*0!:1

1:+)+*2('!1(*+13(&*+,-!(-;!,2)!%5,!1(*+13(&*+,-4!(1!n%8,@!1255%1*%;!X"NII.MY!+1?!

0,@%=%)?!,:%-!*,!E2%1*+,-6!/0%!('+%-(*%;!Q%9:*

C2109(-!1255%1*1!,*0%)@+1%6!/0+1!:%)&%:*+,-!,3!('+%-(*+,-!+1!&,)),8,)(*%;!8

*0%!@,)K!,3!%&,-,9+1*!G+&0();!n(

@+*0!)+1+-5!+-&,9%1!0(=%!8%%-!Q&(-&%''%;!,2*!8


32/93

! H#!

0()9,-+,21!1,&+('!)%'(*+,-10+:14!X#JJI.!HIY6!W%!8(1%1!*0+1!(-('

/0%!;%1&)+:*+=%!(-;!+-\2-&*+=%!1,&+('!-,)91!,3!,2)!1,&+%*

/0%)%!+1!(!&,-1*(-*!9%;+(!8())(5%!12::,)*+-5!&,-129:*+,-l!(!9%11(5%!*0(*!@%!

()%!'(&K+-5!1,9%*0+-5!*0(*!,-'

*0%)%!+1!(!;+1\2-&*+,-!8%*@%%-!:%,:'%41!8%'+%31!(-;!*0%+)!(&*+,-1!@0%-!(!:%)1,-('!

%-=+),-9%-*('!&,-=+&*+,-!:,+-*1!*,@();1!(21*%)+*

9(-:%)+%-&%!@0(*!0%!;%1&)+8%1!(1!Q)%(&*+=%!;%-+('4?!@0%)%!(::()%-*!

(@()%-%11!,3!+112%1!(),2-;!&,-129:*+,-!'%(;1!*,!9,)%!)(*0%)!*0(-!'%11!

&,-129:*+,-!XR()10(''?!#JJ"Y6!

Q7*!+1!(1!+3?4!o%,)5%!R,-8+,*!@)+*%1?!Q8

(1!@%!8%&,9%!9,)%!(@()%!,3!*0%!;(-5%)1!,3!&'+9(*%!&0(-5%!(-;!:%(K!,+'?!@%!()%!


33/93

! HH!

:%)12(;+-5!,2)1%'=%1!*0(*!*0%1%!:),8'%91!&(--,*!8%!)%('!,-%16!73!*0%

12)%'

(11,&+(*%;!@+*0!*0%!:),9,*+,-!,3!1,&+('!-,)916!7-!*0%+)!%;+*,)+('!&0,+&%1!

)%5();+-5!@0+&0!%'%9%-*1!,3!029(-!(&*+,-!(-;!8%0(=+,2)!()%!:)%1%-*%;?!(-;!+-!

75B!*0,1%!%'%9%-*1!()%!:)%1%-*%;?!*0%!9%;+(!,2*'%*1!0(=%!(!:,@%)32'!),'%!+-!*0%!

&)%(*+,-!(-;!9(+-*%-(-&%!,3!8,*0!;%1&)+:*+=%!(-;!+-\2-&*+=%!1,&+('!-,)916!!/0%

()%!(-!2-*+)+-5!@0+1:%)!:)%1%-*+-5!(-;!+-*%):)%*+-5!*0%!@,)';6!

/0%!9%;+(!35";%!*021!0(=%!(!),'%!+-!:%)12(;+-5!*0%!:28'+&!,3!*0%!)%('!1%)+,21-%11!

,3!%&,',5+&('!:),8'%91!(-;!*0(*!(&*+,-1!;%*)+9%-*('!*,!*0%!:'(-%*()

$2(-%!['5+-?!X"NNH.!TJTY!:)%1%-*1!(!;%1&)+:*+,-!,3!*0%!9%;+(!+-!,2)!:)%1%-*!

Q+-;21*)+('!%)(4!(-;!0,@!*0%!9%;+(!,3!(-!Q%&,',5+&('!%)(4!@,2';!;+33%)6!7-!*0%!

+-;21*)+('!%)(.!Qc*d0%!9(11!9%;+(!()%!;,9+-(*%;!8

+-3,)9(*+,-!(-;!9%11(5%1!+-&'2;+-5!*0%!+9:,)*(-&%!,3!%&,',5+&('!(::),(&0%1!*,!

'+=+-546!X['5+-!;,%1!-,*!:)%1%-*!0,@!*0%!Q8('(-&%;!;+%*4!@,2';!8%!;%*%)9+-%;Y6!


34/93

! HT!

['5+-41!;%1&)+:*+,-!10()%1!*0%!(**+*2;%!,3!;%*%)9+-+1*!(-('

-,)!;+;!+*!%-&,2)(5%!9,)('!)%1:,-1+8+'+*

:'(

9()K%*+-5!(-;!&,):,)(*%!:28'+&!)%'(*+,-1!+-!,);%)!*,!9(-+:2'(*%!&,-129%)!

8%0(=+,2)!8

[@%-!"NMZ?!"NVVY6!!/0%!9(-+:2'(*+,-1!,3!(;=%)*+1%9%-*!&,9%!(1!'+**'%!12):)+1%!

*,!*0%+)!9,;%)-!(2;+%-&%?!%=%-!@0%)%!*0%

D;,)-,!&,-1+;%)%;!*0%!9(11!9%;+(41!+-3'2%-&%!*,!8%!(!9,)%!5%-%)('!

%-;,)1%9%-*!,3!&,-129%)+196!7*!;,%1!-,*!-%%;!*,!12::,)*!(-

:()*+&2'()!,)!*,!:),9,*%!(-

)%9%98%)!=%)


35/93

! HI!

8%&(21%!Qc%d=%-!+3!*0%

+*1%'3_4!C2109(-!X"NNJY?!('1,?!)%9()K1!*0(*!*0%!&,-129%)!'+3%S1*

+1!*0%!Q:),;2&*4!9(-23(&*2)%;!8

%1:,21%?!,2)!(&*+,-1!@+''!*%-;?!0


36/93

! HZ!

;%=%',:%;!(!]:),:(5(-;(!9,;%'^!*,!%>:'(+-!0,@!*0+1!(::),=('!,:%)(*%16!7*!

1+9:'

12::,)*+=%!,3!*0,1%!5,('1!@+''!8%!9,)%!'+K%'

(1!*0%

3)(9%@,)K!,3!)%('+*

[;@();1!32)*0%)!1255%1*1!*0(*!*0%!9%;+(!:),9,*%1!Q(!821+-%11S3)+%-;'

=('2%14!*0(*!1%)=%!&,):,)(*%!&,-129%)+19!(-;!;+1&,2)(5%!*0%!&(:(&+*

n(a()3%';!p!R%)*,-!X"NTV.!"MY!;%1&)+8%!0,@!*0%!9%;+(!&(-!8%!1%%-!*,!%-3,)&%!

1,&+('!-,)91!8

D-!+-\2-&*+=%!1,&+('!-,)9!)%:)%1%-*1!*0%!:28'+&!9,)('+*


37/93

! HM!

8%0(=+,2)!;%=+(-*!*,!*0+1?!8,*0!+-!,-%1%'3!(-;!+-!,*0%)16!/0%!:,@%)!,3!*0%!

+-\2-&*+=%!-,)9!)%9(+-1!-%=%)*0%'%11!+-!@0(*!+1!Q:28'+&'

,-%!+1!%=%)!&(''%;!2:,-!*,!:28'+&('':)%11!,-%41!,:+-+,-!,-!*0%!(&&%:*(8'%!

8%0(=+,2)!+-!*0%!1+*2(*+,-?!,-%!921*!%+*0%)!(33+)9!*0%!(2*0,)+*

;2('!9,)('+*

/0+1!@,2';!,-'

9,)('+*(9:'%!(!-%@1:(:%)!%1:,21%1!(-!%;+*,)+('!:,'+&

%&,',5+&('!&,-&%)-?!0(1!(-!%-=+),-9%-*!1%&*+,-?!(-!%-=+),-9%-*!&,))%1:,-;%-*?!

)2-1!()*+&'%1!,-!%*0+&('!(-;!',@!+9:(&*!'+=+-5?!1:%&+('!+-E2+)+%1!+-*,!&'+9(*%!

&0(-5%!(-;!+1!(!9%98%)!,3!*0%!]i%@1:(:%)1!F2::,)*!G%&

&',*0+-5?!:),:%)*

*0%!)%(;%)10+:!@+*0!*('%1!,3!&,-1:+&2,21!&,-129:*+,-!*0%-!*0%!-%@1:(:%)1!9(

%>0+8+*!(!&%)*(+-!;2('!9,)('+*

+*1!(11,&+(*%;!1*(*21!X"VNNY6!


38/93

! HV!

P0+'%!*0%!(2;+%-&%!0(1!8%%-!%;2&(*%;!(8,2*!%-=+),-9%-*('!:),8'%91?!*0%

('1,!8%!(33%&*%;!8

@,)';6!/0%

1,9%*0+-5!(8,2*!*0%94!X"NTV."VY6!!

/0%!9%;+(!*021!)%+-3,)&%1!*0%!=('2%1S(&*+,-!5(:?!8

(2;+%-&%!3%%'!*0(*!*0%

@()9+-5!+-!(!-%@1:(:%)!()*+&'%!Q!3(+'%;!*,!+-1:+)%!9%!*,!(&*+=+*

%=+;%-&%!*0(*!(-


39/93

! HN!

+-;+=+;2('j1,&+('!&,-3'+&*!8%*@%%-!*0%!;%1+)%!,3!029(-!8%+-51!*,!'+=%!(-;!*0+-K!+-!

)%(1,-(8'


40/93

! TJ!

J","&74A%!"+A)$)8)20%

%

612*%]%

7!;%&+;%;!*,!21%!-%@1:(:%)!)%:,)*+-5!(1!(!;(*(!1,2)&%!3,)!)%1%()&0+-5!*0%!21%!,3!

*0%!:0)(1%!Q9(K%!;,!(-;!9%-;46!/0+1!+99%;+(*%'*2('!&,-*%-*6!C,-*%-*!D-('/0%!9%*0,;!@(1!2-,8*)21+=%?!1,!7?!(1!*0%!)%1%()&0%)?!@,2';!-,*!(33%&*!*0%!;(*(!

*0(*!7!21%;6!!7-!,*0%)!@,);1!*0%!9(*%)+('!+1!-,-S)%(&*+=%?!+*!@(1!(')%(;

@,)';!(-;!-,*!&)%(*%;!3,)!*0%!:2):,1%1!,3!*0+1!)%1%()&0!XO)


41/93

! T"!

)%3%)%-&%!8(&K!*,!*0%!,)+5+-('!1(9:'%?!@0+&0!&,2';!8%!)%&)%(*%;!8

128*)(&*+,-!,)!%>*%-1+,-!,3!*0%!&)+*%)+(6!

R2&0!,3!*0%!+-3,)9(*+,-!5(*0%)%;!@,2';!8%!%>:'+&+*!(-;!,8\%&*+=%'

@,2';!3,)9!*0%!82+';+-5!8',&K1!,3!(-!(-('*1!@,2';!:),=+;%!(!)+&0%)!1%*!,3!+-3,)9(*+,-6!

C,;+-5!*0%!;(*(!3,)!@0%*0%)!*0%!*%)9!@(1!21%;!(-;j,)!&,-1+;%)%;!+-!:,1+*+=%?!

-%5(*+=%!,)!-%2*)('!*%)91!@,2';!+-=,'=%!(!&%)*(+-!(9,2-*!,3!+-*%):)%*(*+,-6!

u2('+*(*+=%!(::)%&+(*+,-!@,2';!('1,!8%!-%&%11()

9,*+=(*+,-1!1%%9%;!*,!8%!8%0+-;!*0%!21%!,3!*0%!:0)(1%!+-!(-!()*+&'%l!(-;!@0%*0%)!

(-!()*+&'%!(::%()%;!*,!8%!(;=,&(*+-5!*0(*!*0%!)%(;%)!(-;j,)!5%-%)('!:28'+&!

10,2';!1%%K!*,!)%;2&%!*0%+)!&,-129:*+,-6!h-!+-+*+('!)%=+%@!+*!8%&(9%!&'%()!*0(*!

,*0%)!+-3,)9(*+,-!1,250*!(-;!&,;%;!3,)!@+*0+-!*0%!()*+&'%1?!@0%*0%)!*0%!:+%&%!

)%3%)%-&%;!*0%!F%&,-;!P,)';!P()!,)!-,*!(-;!@0%*0%)!*0%!()*+&'%!:),9,*%;!

5,,;1!,)!1%)=+&%1!(=(+'(8'%!3,)!1('%!@,2';!1,9%*+9%1!8%!%>:'+&+*!(-;!1,9%*+9%1!

+9:'+&+*6!!D!E2('+*(*+=%!(-('

()*+&'%1!+-!*0%!1(9:'%!@,2';!-%%;!*,!8%!:)%1%-*%;!+-!,);%)!*,!12::,)*!9

\2;5%9%-*16!


42/93

! T#!

!/0%!8(1%!,3!E2(-*+*(*+=%!;(*(!@,2';!-%=%)*0%'%11!:),=+;%!(!1*),-5!8(1%!3),9!

@0+&0!*,!82+';!*0%!E2('+*(*+=%!(-('

XO)

(-('

(=(+'(8'%!3,)!*0%!)%1%()&0?!-%&%11+*(*%;!*0(*!(!19(''%)!1%*!,3!1,2)&%!9(*%)+('!8%!

;%3+-%;!3),9!*0%!:,*%-*+(''

)%1%()&0!&,2';!8%!3,)9%;6!

7!;%&+;%;!*,!&,-1+;%)!,-'

C7*(>01*$A*$l!C7*(G"'!(-;!C7*(M*B1(5F(27*()5$;%l!C7*(C&?*1!(-;!C7*(G"'%#&%:*+,-(''


43/93

! TH!

:*5E;*!X(!F2-;(

&0,+&%1!@%)%!9(;%!+-!,);%)!*,!*)

-(*+,-('!&,=%)(5%!(-;!)%(;%)10+:!+6%6!*0,1%!@+*0!*0%!@+;%1*!:28'+&!+-3'2%-&%6!7!

@(1!('1,!K%%-!*,!-,*!'+9+*!*0%!*+*'%1!&0,1%-!*,!*0,1%!:%)&%+=%;!*,!8%!(11,&+(*%;!

@+*0!(!:()*+&2'()!1,&+('!;%9,5)(:0+&6!

/0%!32''!'+1*!,3!-+-%*%%-!-%@1:(:%)!*+*'%1!@(1.!

/0%!$(+':)%11! b+-(-&+('!/+9%1! /0%!7-;%:%-;%-*! /0%!7-;%:%-;%-*!,-!F2-;(


44/93

! TT!

F2-;(:)%11! F2-;(

(@()%!*0(*!(!',-5+*2;+-('!1*2;

*0%!;(*(!+-&'2;+-5!(-

&0,1%-!3,)!*0%!1(9:'%?!8%5+--+-5!,-!"T*0!L2'

#JJN6!/0+1!)%&%-*!:%)+,;!@,2';!0(=%!)%'%=(-&%!3,)!*0,1%!(&*+=%!&2))%-*'

+112%1!,3!121*(+-(8'%!&,-129:*+,-6!/0%!;2)(*+,-!@,2';!&,=%)!*0%!,&&(1+,-1!,3!

1,9%!1+5-+3+&(-*!-%@1@,)*0

F&+%-&%!(-;!/%&0-,',5


45/93

! TI!

&)2-&04!('',@+-5!*0%!+-3'2%-&%!,3!*0+1!1+5-+3+&(-*!%&,-,9+&!%=%-*!*,!8%!

)%:)%1%-*%;6!!

7-!;)(@+-5!,-!(!1:%&+3+%;!1%*!,3!9(*%)+('?!AB!-(*+,-('!-%@1:(:%)1!X@+*0!

&,9:)%0%-1+8'%!&)+*%)+(!3,)!+-&'21+,-Y!@+*0+-!(!*@,S


46/93

! TZ!

-%@1:(:%)1!+-!#JJV!*0(-!;(+'

*0%!12)=%

1(9:'%!1255%1*+-5!*0(*!;2)+-5!*0%!:%)+,;?!,-!(=%)(5%?!,=%)!#J!9+''+,-!:%,:'%!

)%(;!(!;(+'

32)*0%)!:,+-*!*,!@,)K!8


47/93

! TM!

1,9%!3,)91!,3!+-*%):)%*(*+,-!*0(*!=+%@+-5!*0%!,)+5+-('!-%@1:(:%)1!X,)!3(&1+9+'%1!

*0%)%,3Y!@,2';!0(=%!('',@%;6!!i%>+1AB!:)%1%-*1!-%@1!9(*%)+('!+-!*%>*!3,)9(*!

X-,*!(1!)%:),;2&*+,-1!,3!*0%!,)+5+-('!-%@1:(:%)!:(5%1Y?!*0%)%3,)%!+*!;,%1!-,*!

5+=%!*0%!()*+&'%!+-!*0%!&,-*%>*!,3!,*0%)!-%@1!1*,)+%1?!@0+&0!12)),2-;%;!+*?!

:),=+;+-5!9,)%!+-3,)9(*+,-!,-!*0%!1+5-+3+&(-&%!(::'+%;!*,!*0%!()*+&'%6!$%*(+'1!,3!

*0%!-%@1:(:%)!1%&*+,-!(-;!:(5%!-298%)!,-!@0+&0!*0%!()*+&'%!@(1!:)%1%-*%;!()%!

5+=%-!@0+&0!('',@1!1,9%!+-*%):)%*(*+,-!,3!*0%!1+5-+3+&(-&%!,3!*0%!()*+&'%!*,!8%!

(::)%0%-;%;6!i%>+1AB!;,%1!-,*!:),=+;%!+-3,)9(*+,-!,-!*0%!-298%)!,3!&,'29-!

+-&0%1!*0(*!*0%!()*+&'%!,&&2:+%;?!*0+1!+1!(!&,99,-!@(

1*(*+1*+&!+*!10()%1!@+*0!&,'29-!+-&0%1!(!8'2-*-%11?!@0+&0!;,%1!-,*!)%3'%&*!0,@!

92&0!,3!(-!()*+&'%!+1!(&*2(''

3,)9%;!(!21%32'!1,2)&%!3,)!*0%!E2('+*(*+=%!(-('


48/93

! TV!

F%()&0+-5!3,)!*0%!:0)(1%!Q9(K%!;,!(-;!9%-;4!7-!i%>+1AB!@+*0+-!*0%!1(9:'%!

&)+*%)+(!1*(*%;!:),=+;%;!*0%!;(*(1%*!*,!8%!&,;%;?!(!*,*('!,3!H"J!()*+&'%16!7!(')%(;

0(;!1,9%!+;%(!,3!@0(*!%'%9%-*1!7!@,2';!&,;%!3,)!@+*0+-!*0%!()*+&'%1?!82*!;%&+;%;!

*,!;,!(!19(''!*%1*!)2-!,3!*0%!&,;+-5!8%3,)%!:),&%%;+-5!*,!:),5)%11!*0),250!*0%!

%-*+)%!H"J6!7!*,,K!(!32''!9,-*0!3),9!%(&0!,3!*0%!

+-1*(-*!3%%'!3,)!*0%!=()+(*+,-1!,3!*

:()*+&2'()!K%

1*((9+-(*+,-!,3!*0%!21%!,3!:0)(1%1!12&0!(1!*0%1%!&,2';!:),=+;%!

(11+1*(-&%!+-!9(K+-5!E2('+*(*+=%!\2;5%9%-*1!(8,2*!*0%!(**+*2;%!,3!*0%!()*+&'%16!

/0%!%'%9%-*1!,3!*0%!()*+&'%1?!@0+&0!@%)%!)%&,);%;!3,)!&,;+-5?!@%)%.!

"6 i%@1:(:%)!/+*'%!#6 $(*%!,3!:28'+&(*+,-!H6 i%@1:(:%)!1%&*+,-!T6 `(5%!-298%)!I6 i298%)!,3!@,);1!+-!()*+&'%!Z6 $,%1!*0%!()*+&'%!9%-*+,-!*0%!F%&,-;!P,)';!P()g!M6 $,%1!*0%!()*+&'%!)%3%)!*,!(!:()*+&2'()!8(&K5),2-;!Q&)+1+14g!P0+&0g!


49/93

! TN!

V6 W,@!+1!*0%!:0)(1%!Q9(K%!;,!(-;!9%-;4!&,-1+;%)%;!+-!*0%!()*+&'%g!N6 $,%1!*0%!()*+&'%!:),9,*%!*0%!)%(;%)!(-;j,)!5%-%)('!:28'+&!*,!)%;2&%!*0%+)!&,-129:*+,-g!

"J6$,%1!*0%!()*+&'%!:),9,*%!(-

-,*!('@(-%@1:(:%)1!@%)%!)%3+-%;!*,!(!5%-%)+&!'+1*!X1%%!D::%-;+>!77Y6!

/0%!1+>*0!E2%1*+,-!@0+'%!(::()%-*'

*0%!()*+&'%1!;+;!-,*!)%3%)!*,!*0%!F%&,-;!P,)';!P()!82*!;+;!9(K%!)%3%)%-&%1!*,!

0,@!]o)(-^!,)!]o)(--

,3!*0%!:(1*!+-&'2;+-5!*0%!b+)1*!P,)';!P()?!]*0%!"NHJ1^?!]*0%!;%:)%11+,-^?!Q*0%!

1%=%-*+%1^?!]"NIJ1!(21*%)+*

*0%!F%&,-;!P,)';!P()6!W,@%=%)!)%3%)%-&%1!*,!*0%!@(

&,-1+;%)!*,!8%!)%3%)%-&%1!*,!*0%!F%&,-;!P,)';!P()!2-'%11!,*0%)!()*+&'%!&,-*%-*!

1255%1*%;!,*0%)@+1%6!


50/93

! IJ!

/0%!1%=%-*0!E2%1*+,-!)%E2+)%;!(!&%)*(+-!(9,2-*!,3!+*%)(*+=%!:),&%11!+-!,);%)!*,!

;%*%)9+-%!(!&,-*),''%;!'+1*!,3!Q&)+1%14!*,!@0+&0!*0%!()*+&'%1!9+50*!)%3%)!(-;!@0+&0!

7!9+50*!',,K!,2*!3,)6!/,!(-!+-+*+('!+;%(!,3!\21*!&,;+-5!3,)!Q%&,-,9+&4!*,!+-&'2;%!

()*+&'%1!)%3%))+-5!*,!*0%!&)%;+*S&)2-&0?!)%&%11+,-?!;%:)%11+,-?!1*)(+*%-%;!

%&,-,9+&!*+9%1!%*&6l!(-;!Q%-=+),-9%-*('4!*,!+-&'2;%!()*+&'%1!)%3%))+-5!*,!&'+9(*%!

&0(-5%?!*0%!-%&%11+*

8%&(9%!-%&%11()

*,!%-%)5

1,6!

7!+-+*+(''

Q;%1&)+:*+=%4!+-!*0%!9(--%)!,3!G%(1,-!(-;!o()&+(!X#JJMY!0(;!1,9%!(::%('?!(1!+*!

@,2';!(;;!5)(;(*+,-1!*,!*0%!(-1@%)?!:%)0(:1!,33%)+-5!(!9,)%!(&&2)(*%!

)%-;%)+-56!h-!32)*0%)!)%3'%&*+,-!0,@%=%)?!*0%!(-('


51/93

! I"!

,=%)!0,@!*0%!*%)9!@(1!&,-1+;%)%;!@,2';!)%E2+)%!E2,*(*+,-1!3),9!*0%!,)+5+-('!

1,2)&%1!*,!(::%()!+-!9

/0%!-+-*0!E2%1*+,-!:),=%;!*0%!,-%!)%E2+)+-5!*0%!9,1*!@,)K!*,!1%%K!,2*!+9:'+%;!

9%(-+-51!,3!@0(*!0(;!8%%-!@)+**%-6!R(-

*%)9!Q9(K%!;,!(-;!9%-;4!+-!)%1:,-1%!*,!*0%!%+50*0!E2%1*+,-!:'+&+*!

1255%1*+,-1!*0(*!*0%!)%(;%)!,)!5%-%)('!:28'+&!(&*2(''

i%=%)*0%'%11!*0+1!;+;!,3*%-!(::%()!*,!8%!(-!+9:'+&+*!:()*!,3!*0%!()*+&'%?!1,!@,2';!

8%!&,;%;!(1!Q

/0%!*%-*0!E2%1*+,-!('1,!,33%)%;!2:!1,9%!;+33+&2'*+%1!,3!+-*%):)%*(*+,-?!('*0,250!+-!

9(-

;+;Y!@+*0!(!8,,K!,)!+*%9!'+1*%;!@+*0!,)!@+*0,2*!(!:)+&%?!+*!@(1!+-1*(-*'

(1!:'+&+*'

10,:1?!$7e!,)!)%:(+)!%E2+:9%-*?!&,2)1%1!,-!'%()-+-5!1K+''1!(-;!)(@!9(*%)+('16!7-!

*0+1!7!3,'',@%;!*0%!+-&'21+,-!,3!1%&,-;S0(-;!5,,;1?!&()S8,,*!1('%1!(-;!1%&,-;S

0(-;!10,:1!(1!3%(*2)%1!,3!&,-129%)!1,&+%*

X#JJV.!#TMY!(-;!D8%)&),98+%!p!P();!X#JJJ.!HI"Y?!(-;!*0%!)%9()K!,3!n%8,@!

X"NII.!VY!*0(*!*0%!Q0,9%!:,@%)!*,,'1!(-;!*0%!@0,'%!];,S+*S


52/93

! I#!

()%!%>&%''%-*!%>(9:'%1!,3!]%>:%-1+=%^!&,-129:*+,-446!W,@%=%)!)%3%)%-&%1!1,'%'

*,!1@(::+-5?!10()+-5!(-;!0,9%!)%:(+)!,)!)%9,;%''+-5!@+*0,2*!(-

:2)&0(1%1!8%+-5!9(;%!@%)%!9()K%;!(1!Q-,46!!

/0%1%!1%&,-;!3+=%!E2%1*+,-1!(''!)%E2+)%;!=()+,21!;%5)%%1!,3!+-*%):)%*(*+,-!,-!9

:()*6!D1!*0%!1,'%!)%1%()&0%)j&,;%)!7!;+;!-,*!3(&%!*0%!)+1K1!,3!+-*%)S&,;%)!

)%'+(8+'+*

@(1!'%3*!@+*0!*0%!+112%!,3!+-*)(S&,;%)!)%'+(8+'+*

8+(1%1!9+50*!8%!;+152+1%;S!:()*+&2'()'

i,*!0(=+-5!,*0%)!&,;%)1!:)%=%-*%;!(-

)%:),;2&+8+'+*

,3!&,;+-5?!7!0(=%!9(;%!(-!,:%-!1*(*%9%-*!(5(+-1*!@0+&0!9

3),9!*0%!,)+5+-('!()*+&'%1!+-!9

E2('+*(*+=%!+-*%):)%*(*+,-?!1*(*+1*+&('!(-('


53/93

! IH!

P1#$1#2,%

%

612*%^%

%


54/93

! IT!

!

D/77"#40%)6%+A"%?A7&,"%_5&'"%$)%$%5"#$\%

/0%!;%&+1+,-1!*,!21%!AB!-(*+,-('!-%@1:(:%)1!(-;!*,!3,&21!,-!*0%!:0)(1%!Q9(K%!

;,!(-;!9%-;4!)%&%+=%;!1,9%!+-+*+('!\21*+3+&(*+,-!+-!*0%!@%('*0!,3!9(*%)+('!3,2-;6!!

7-!*0%!:%)+,;!H"J!()*+&'%1!3%(*2)%;!*0%!:0)(1%?!,3!*0,1%!HM!21%;!*0%!:0)(1%!+-!

*0%+)!0%(;'+-%6!/0%!(=%)(5%!'%-5*0!,3!()*+&'%!@(1!MJV!@,);1"I6!/0+1!ZI!

3%(*2)%;!*0%!:0)(1%!+-!(-!()*+&'%!*+*'%6!/0%!9%(-!(-;!9%;+(-!(=%)(5%!'%-5*0!,3!

()*+&'%1!+-!(''!*0%1%!:(:%)1!@(1!8%',@!*0(*!3,)!*0%!%-*+)%!1(9:'%?!%>&%:*!+-!*0%!

&(1%!,3!C7*(M*B1(5F(27*()5$;%!()*+&'%?!@0+&0!@(1!\21*!,=%)!*0%!9%;+(-6!C7*(G"'!

(-;!C7*(M*B1(5F(27*()5$;%!()%!*0%!-(*+,-41!9,1*!)%(;!-%@1:(:%)1!@+*0!"Zt!,3!

*0%!:,:2'(*+,-!&'(+9+-5!*,!)%(;!*0%9!,-!(-

!/0+1!+1!*0%!9%;+(-!3+52)%l!*0%!()+*09%*+&!9%(-!+1!0+50%)!(*!V"V6MH!82*!1K%@%;!8


55/93

! II!

C7*(,&$$5$!3%(*2)%;!"H!1*,)+%1!21+-5!*0%!:0)(1%!X@+*0!+*!(::%()+-5!+-!*0%!()*+&'%!

*+*'%!T!*+9%1Y?!9(K+-5!*0%!R+)),)!o),2:!*0%!9,1*!1+5-+3+&(-*!)%;*,:!*(8',+;!21%)6!

D!3(&*,)!%9:0(1+1%;!8:)%11!5),2:1!10,@%)!=%)

()*+&'%!*+*'%Y?!C7*(JOE$*11!3%(*2)%;!*0%!:0)(1%!+-!#Z!;+33%)%-*!1*,)+%1!XT!*+9%1!+-!

*0%!*+*'%Y6!/0%!,#&;(5'(G"'%#

JOE$*11!*+*'%6!!

/0%!8),(;10%%*!-%@1:(:%)1!(''!3%(*2)%;!*0%!:0)(1%!9,)%!,3*%-!*0(-!*0%!)%;*,:1?!

82*!@+*0!(!@+;%!=()+(-&%!(&),11!*0%!;+33%)%-*!*+*'%16!i,-%!,3!*0%!8),(;10%%*1!()%!

)%(;!8

"NIY6!/0%!8&'#'3(C&?*1!3%(*2)%;!*0%!:0)(1%!,-!"M!,&&(1+,-1?!*@+&%!+-!*0%!*+*'%!

,3!*0%!()*+&'%6!C7*(4'%*E*'%*'2!,-!#J!,&&(1+,-1!X-%=%)!+-!(-!()*+&'%!*+*'%Y?!C7*(

4'%*E*'%*'2(5'(G"'%#:0)(1%6!/0%!:0)(1%!(::%()%;!+-!(-!()*+&'%!*+*'%!""!*+9%1?!*0%!9,1*!3)%E2%-*!,3!(''!

*0%!-%@1:(:%)16!/0+1!@(1!@%+50*%;!;2%!*,!*0%!3(&*!*0(*!C7*(!"#$%'!8%5(-!(!

&,'29-!*+*'%;!Q9(K%!;,!(-;!9%-;4!+-!*0%!3(9+'


56/93

! IZ!

*0)+3*

:0)(1%6!C7*(C&?*1!:28'+10%;!TM!()*+&'%1!21+-5!+*!X+-!*0%!*+*'%!,-!H!,&&(1+,-1Yl!C7*(

G"'%#


57/93

!

!

"#!

!!!"#$%&$%'()*+,%-!%.,/"01+2%!+./(,"3#%/4+%54,.2+%*6%3+725.5+,%/"/1+$%


58/93

!

!

"$!

!!!"#$%8$%.3%.).1#.)./+9%:"+7%-!%/4+%3()*+,%-!%3+725.5+,%2/-,"+2%(2"3#%/4+%54,.2+%.0,-22%/4+%2.)51+%5+,"-9


59/93

!

! "#!

$%&!'&()*%!+,!-.*/0'&1!,&-*2./()!*%&!3%.-1&!4-./&5!,.+6!7#!8+.51!*+!"9":;!$%&!

1%+.*&1*!3/&0&!8-1!-!.&-5&.!'&**&.!/(!!"#$%&'()*'+!-56+(/1%/()!*%&6!,+.!-(!

&-.'/&.!-.*/0'&!+(!*%&!*+3!*&-!*+8&'1!-4-/'-


60/93

!

! CH!

B; ^6


61/93

!

! CB!

!

/,0!)12)"345#()-/)%+-(,#%)56).#$%&'()%#*+,-.)3%,.0)-(,0,.'7)4#+8-9-7-06!)

:#*+,-.%)(3.)*7-*;$,%#)/(-4)%+'(+)-/)7,%++*%&.A!8&.&!-6-')-6-*&5!-1!>'/,&1*D'&A;!

]&0+(1/5&./()!*%&!1&0*/+(!&'&6&(*1!*%/1!8-D=!-''+8&5!-!0'&-.&.!3/0*2.&!*+!&6&.)&!


62/93

!

! C7!

8%/0%!1&&6&5!6+.&!/(!'/(&!8/*%!*%&!/63.&11/+(!)-/(&5!7,/#%+67#?)*'+#0-(6)

!

!


63/93

!

! C:!

@8#):#*-.9)A-(79)A'()'.9)B-.+#4&-('(6)B(,%#%)

V(&!+,!*%&!1*+(&!-)&A!FQ25-%=!7HH#I!CJ!-(5!>*%&!5-.@!-)&1A!F]&/5=!7HH9I!B#J;!!

!O1!&d3&0*&5!6-(D!+,!*%&!1*+./&1!F""eJ!8&.&!0+(0&.(&5!8/*%!3-.*/02'-.![0./1&1\!

*%-*!6/)%*!'&-5!1+6&+(&!*+!6-@&!5+!-(5!6&(5;!N&4&.-'!-.*/0'&1!FPPJ!6&(*/+(&5!

6+.&!*%-(!+(&=!.&,'&0*/()!-!1&(1&!+,!3-(/0!+4&.!*%/()1!(+*!


64/93

!

! CP!

!3.&1&(*&5!-1!&(4/.+(6&(*-'!-.&!+,*&(!6+*/4-*&5!&0+(+6D=!1+0/-'!0+(,+.6/*D!

+.!1/63'&!0+(4&(/&(0&A!FQ+8&''!&*!-'=!B##RI!B7BJ;!

S112&1!+,!)'+.&-5!Y1Z@/(*!


65/93

!

! C"!

D+2()1*&.1!-.&!'&-.(/()!*+!i6-@&!5+i!-1!*%&!0.&5/*!0.2(0%!


66/93

!

! CC!

V*%&.!-.*/0'&1!.&,'&0*!-!5/1-3+/(*6&(*!8/*%!&0+(+6/0!1/*2-*/+(1!*%-*!'+8&.!+(&=!

*+!"'5#!*+!6-@&!5+=!.-*%&.!*%-(!0+(*/(2&!%/)%!0+(1263*/+(!'/,&1*D'&1I!>_O?SlS^N!

-.&!"'5*+/!*+!.&5/10+4&.!*%&!4-'2&1!+,!*%./,*!-(5!6-@&`5+`-(5`6&(5!-1!*%&!0.&5/*!

0.2(0%!*-@&1!%+'5;A!FT-6L&!'/4&!/(!120%!-!*%.+8-8-D!1+0/&*D;!Sa5!.&-''D!

&(0+2.-)&!+*%&.1!*+!a6-@&!5+!-(5!6&(5a;A!N-D1!+(&!-(5!iSA4&!-'8-D1!


67/93

!

! CR!

E26Y*Z+!+.5&.!N+'5!V2*I!W+8!S!N2.4/4&5!O!o&-.!V,!


68/93

!

! C9!

K+*!N%+33/()=!


69/93

!

! C#!

/(!N-*2.5-D=!N2(5-D!+.!8&&@&(5!&5/*/+(1B9!+,!*%&!(&813-3&.1!U!":e!+,!*%&!

-.*/0'&1!-33&-.&5!+(!E21*!*8+!5-D1!+,!*%&!8&&@;!:9!+,!*%&!-.*/0'&1!-33&-.&5!+(!-!

_./5-D;!$%/1!3.&3+(5&.-(0&!+,!8&&@&(5!3-3&.1!-'1+!)/4&1!1+6&!/(5/0-*/+(!+,!*%&!

1*-*21!-00+.5&5!*%&!3%.-1&;!$%&!8&&@&(5!3-3&.1!*&(5!6+.&!*+8-.51!'/,&1*D'&=!

*%-(!(&81!8/*%!'+*1!+,!6-)-g/(&!-(5!12-1!/*!/1!Y0Z+(13/02+21!0+(1263*/+(!/1!)+/()!*+!


70/93

!

! RH!

6+(*%1!-(5!


71/93

!

! RB!

0+(1263*/+(!*%-*!S!+2*'/(&5!&-.'/&.;!$%&!'-.)&!(26.&0&11/+(/1*-A!Fl+4&**=!7HH9f!T+''/(1=!

7HH#f!O(+(;=!7HH#,J!=!*%&!>,.2)-'/1*-A!FQ+%(1*+(=!7HH9J=!*%&!32.4&D+.!+,!>0.-1%/+(A!

FV.6&.+5=!7HH9J;!>.&0&11/+(!)/4&1!&4&.D!-33&-.-(0&!+,!


72/93

!

! R7!

]&520/()!0+(1263*/+(=!+.!-*!'&-1*!'00#'(*+/!*+!/1!6&.&'D!,-1%/+(-


73/93

!"#$%&'("#)

!

*(+,-.)

!

"#$!$#%!&'!($(!)$!*+,%!*$#%-!)%..(!-$/!)$!0$!.%''1!2$#'/*%!.%''1!*+,%!0$!+#0!

*%#034!56+#.$#1!7889:!;8

!


74/93

!

! 9=!

>/?(!)@%!A%2$#0!B$?.0!B+?!)@%!($C%?#*%#)!+00?%''%0!D/%')&$#'!$E!?%'$/?2%!

'2+?2&)-1!#+)&$#+.!?%'&.&%#2%!+#0!2$**/#&)-!'$.&0+?&)-!$#!)@%!@$*%!E?$#)!F&)@!+!

G?$G+(+#0+!2+*G+&(#!)@+)!'$/(@)!)$!@+?#%''!G/H.&2!$G&$#3!I)!&''/%0!+!'%?&%'!$E!

E&.*'1!G$')%?'1!G/H.&2+)&$#'1!?+0&$!H?$+02+')'!+#0!*$?%1!)@+)!2$**/#&2+)%0!+!'%)!

$E!J/#2)&C%!'$2&+.!#$?*'!+GG?$G?&+)%!)$!)@%!'&)/+)&$#!)@%!2$/#)?-!E+2%03!

!

K@%'%!F%?%!+22$*G+#&%0!@$F%C%?!H-!+!'%?&%'!$E!.+F'1!*+#0+)$?-!?%D/&?%*%#)'!

+#0!%#E$?2%0!2$#0&)&$#'!'/2@!+'!)?+C%.!?%')?&2)&$#'!+#0!)@%!?+)&$#(!$E!E$$01!E/%.!

+#0!2.$)@(3!L+#-!$E!)@%'%!@%.G%0!)$!%#'/?%!'$2&+.!%D/&)-!H-!.&*&)(!)@%!+H&.&)-!

$E!E+#2&+.!F%+.)@!+.$#%!)$!+EE$?0!G?&C&.%(%0!')+)/'3!K@%-!+.'$!?%D/&?%0!+!

?%')?&2)&$#!$E!G%?'$#+.!E?%%0$*'!+#0!+!2%#)?+.&'(!$E!G$F%?!!)@%!')+)%!)@+)!&'!

/#G$G/.+?!$/)'&0%!$E!F+?)&*%!+#0!F+'!#$)!%#)&?%.-!G$G/.+?!F&)@!

!

K@%!J/#2)&$#'!+#0!)@%!?%')?&2)&$#'!F%?%!+.'$!*+0%!)$!+!G$G/.+)&$#!)@+)!+.?%+0-!

.&C%0!+!.&E%1!.+?(%.-1!*$?%!E?/(+.!)@+#!*$')!!)@%!?&2@!#+)&$#'!)$0+-3!ME)%?!)@%!F+?1!

+#0!)@%!%#0!$E!G$')NF+?!?+)&$#(!)@%!OP!*$C%0!E?$*!+/')%?&)-!)$!H%2$*%!+!

2$#'/*%?!'$2&%)-3!

!

K@%!(.$H+.!G@%#$*%#+!$E!)@%!2$#'/*%?!'$2&%)-!!)@%!G$')NF+?!F$?.0!H?$/(@)!

E+#2&+.!F%+.)@!)$!)@%!2$?G$?+)&$#'!$E!)@%!?&2@!#+)&$#'!+#0!+!G'-2@$.$(&2+.!

+''+/.)!$#!)@%!*'!$E!)@%!G/H.&23!I#!$?0%?!)$!*+)+!+#0!?%+'%!G?$E&)'1!)@%!

2$?G$?+)&$#'!@+0!)$!%#'/?%!)@+)!*$?%!+#0!*$?%!G%$G.%!F$/.0!H/-!*$?%!+#0!

*$?%!)@('3!K@%-!F$/.0!0$!'$!)@?$/(@!+0C%?)&'(1!F@&2@!'$/(@)!)$!')&.!


75/93

!

! 9Q!

'+)&+H.%!#%%0'!E$?!2$#'/*%?!($$0'3!K@%!*$0%.!$E!2$#'/*G)&$#!+'!+!H+'&2!

H%@+C&$/?!F+'!+.'$!%#2$/?+(%0!@$F%C%?!H-!E?+*(!)@%!F$?.0!!%2$#$*&2!

)%?*'3!R$F%?E/.!)%?%')'!G?$*$)%0!+!#+??+)&C%!$E!%2$#$*&2!(?$F)@1!H+'%0!$#!

?%+'(!G?$E&)'!E?$*!*+''!G?$0/2)&$#!'/GG$?)%0!H-!*+''!2$#'/*G)&$#!+'!)@%!

$#%!)?/%!F+-!$E!/#0%?')+#0(!@/*+#!0%C%.$G*%#)3!K@%!*+''!*%0&+!?%E.%2)'!

+#0!G?$*$)%'!)@$'%!)%?%')'3!

!

L-!+#+.-'&'!$E!@$F!)@%!*%''+(%'!$E!A%2$#0!B$?.0!B+?!G?$G+(+#0+!+H$/)!)@?&E)!

(%)!)?%+)%0!!)@%!*+''!*%0&+!$E!)$0+-!?%C%+.!@$F!*%''+(%'!2$/#)%?!)$!)@%!

)%#%)'!$E!)@%!2$#'/*%?!'$2&%)-!+?%!#%(+)%01!#%/)?+.&'%0!$?!0&'*&''%03!M'!B+.)%?!

S%#J+*!@+'!'/((%')%0!$E!)@%!H$/?(%$&'!+GG+?+)/'!$E!G/H.&2+)&$#1!$/?!

#%F'G+G%?'!+''&*&.+)%!+!?+0&2+.!*%''+(%1!$E)%#!G?$*$)%!&)1!F&)@$/)!+00?%''(!

)@%!E/#0+*%#)+.!D/%')&$#'!)@+)!*%''+(%!G$'%'3!!

!

K@%!0&''$#+#2%!H%)F%%#!G%$G.%4'!%#C&?$#*%#)+.!H%.&%E'!+#0!)@%&?!+2)/+.!

H%@+C&$/?'1!)@%!*+''!+2)&$#!!)@%!E+2%!$E!+#!%+?)@N'@+))%?(!'&)/+)&$#!&'!

+((?+C+)%01!&E!#$)!!G+?)!#/?)/?%0!H-!)@%!*%0&+3!B@&.%!)@%!*%0&+!?%*+'!+#!

+0C$2+)%!$E!)@%!%2$#$*&2!E?+*(!$E!?%+.&)-1!+#0!+!G?$0/2)!$E!)@$'%!F@$!E?+*%!&)!

'$!N!&)!F&..!#%C%?!+22/?+)%.-!?%E.%2)!)@%!H%@+C&$/?!#%2%''+?-!)$!?%'G$#0!)$!2.&*+)%!

2@+#(%1!?%'$/?2%!0%G.%)&$#1!)@%!2$..+G'%!$E!H&$0&C%?'&)-1!G$C%?)-1!(.$H+.!%D/&)-!

+#0!*+#-!$)@%?!G?$H.%*'3!

!


76/93

!

! 9T!

K@%!'G&?+)&$#!$E!)@%!A%2$#0!B$?.0!B+?1!$?!(%#%?+..-!$E!+!*$?%!E?/(+.!G+')1!0$%'!

@+C%!+!.$)!$E!2/??%#2-!@$F%C%?3!M2?$''!)@%!#%F'G+G%?'!!)@%!'+*G.%1!!'%C%?+.!

$E!)@%!+?)&2.%'!E%+)/?%01!)@%!+GG%+.!)$!+!'&*G.%?1!.%''!*+)%?&+.&')&2!G+')!@+'!%C&0%#)!

%#%?(-3!O'%E/.!F$?,!*&(@)!H%!0$#%!!H?%+,(!)@%!2/??%#)!$E!2?%%G(!#$?*+.2-1!

)@%!&0%+!)@+)!@$F!F%!.&C%!#$F!&'!#$?*+.!+#0!#$)!+2)/+..-!/#&D/%!!@/*+#!

@&')$?-3!IE!G+?)!$E!)@%!G?$H.%*!&'!F@+)!F%!2$#'&0%?!+'!U#$?*+.1V!)@%#!)@%!0&EE%?%#)!

'$2&+.!#$?*'!$E!$/?!$F#!?%2%#)!G+')!*&(@)!$EE%?!+#!')?/2)&C%!.%''$#3!!B%!*/')!

@$F%C%?1!+'!S?+#(F-#!+#0!6$G,'!5#303:!79

%#%?(-!'$2&%)-!F&)@$/)!+0C$2+)(!($(!H+2,!$?!?%)/?#(!)$!)@%!G+')3!

!

I#!)@%!F%%,'!)@+)!I!2$*G.%)%!*-!0&''%?)+)&$#1!)@%?%!&'!*$?%!%C&0%#2%!$E!)@%!

(%#%?+)&C%!)@%*%!+GG%+?(3!K@%!0%G+?)*%#)!')$?%!W$@#!X%F&'!&'!)$!G/H.&'@!+!

H$$,.%)!!"#$%&'%"(&%)$(&*%+,&"-$&%.'/%-0$%!'&$/(%0')$!5M#$#1!788YH

A%G)%*H%?!)@&'!-%+?!+#0!!)@%!'+*%!*$#)@!Z?%%#!R+?)-!2+#0&0+)%!A&+#!S%??-!

F&..!?%.%+'%!!$(&%1-2!5788Y@+C%!'/((%')%0!)@+)!"\2]$#'/*%?!'$2&%)-^!0&'+GG%+?'!0/?(!%2$#$*&2!

0$F#)/?#'!+#0!G$.&)&2+.!2?&'%'43!A+0.-!)@%!?%2%#)!2?%0&)!2?/#2@!'/((%')'!)@+)!&)!&'!


77/93

!

! 99!

)@%!2$#'/*%?!'$2&%)-1!F@&2@!&'!?%'&.&%#)1!+#0!'/GG$?)%0!H-!G$F%?E/.!)%?%')'!

F@$!F&..!'G%#0!F@+)!&)!)+,%'!)$!,%%G!&)!+E.$+)3!

M#+.-'&'!$E!)@%'%!+?)&2.%'!@+'!&2+)%0!)@+)!)@%!*+''!*%0&+!$EE%?'!+#!/#)&?(!

F@&'G%?!!'/GG$?)!$E!)@+)!2$#'/*%?&')!')+)/'!D/$1!%C%#!H%#%+)@!'/GG$?)&C%!+#)&N

2$#'/*%?&')!2$**%#)!&)!2+#!')&..!H%!@%+?0!'$))$!C$2%3!

!

!

*(+,)-/


78/93

!

! 9_!

0(1%("+23456)

! )

*(+,-7)

)

MH%?2?$*H&%1!`3!a!B+?0%1!M3!%)!+.3!57888

M#$#3!5788Y+

M#$#3!5788YH


79/93

!

! 9Y!

M#$#3!5788Y0

M#$#3!5788YE3S3!5h0'3

S%#J+*!B+.)%?!5eY;=

S%#'$#1!W3!5eYYT

S%))'1!63!5788_+&'2$/?'%!$E!6%?$&2!b$#'/*G)&$#!!)@%!"B@$.%!h+?)@!b+)+.$(44!!E'A/(":%'.%='(6A)$/%=A:-A/$!788;j!;j!GG3!7_;N;e;!

S.+2,$/)!S?&)+!5788Y


80/93

!

! _8!

S?+#(F-#1!S3!a!6$G,'1!g3!5#303

S?-*+#1!M3!5788e

b+*H%?1!g3!5788_


81/93

!

! _e!

b/??+#1!W31!>$/(.+'1!M3!a!B@+##%.1!Z3!"K@%!G$.&)&2+.!%2$#$*-!$E!)@%!@/*+#!)%?%')!')$?-4!5eY_8

>+C&%'1!b3!5788Y

>/?#(1!M3!5eYY7

h0F+?0'1!>+C&0!5eYYQ

?9),:$J%1(Y"/&:;%D9@0J%`%F!m$?,:!B&..&+*!L$??$F!h.(!>3!5eYY;

hF%#1!A3!5eY9T

k%')(%?1!X3!5eYQ93S3!5h0'3D$"&$/1!`%F!m$?,:!`%F!R?%''!


82/93

!

! _7!

k?&%0+#1!S%))-!5eY_;

k?&%?%1!R3!5eYYT\eY98]

Z?%%#1!b3!5788Y

6+#.$#1!L3!57889

6+?)1!b3!57889

6%H%?(1!g3!57889

6)$#1!h3!a!Z$$0*+#1!L3!5788Y%G+?)*%#)!$E!Z%$(?+G@-1!R+G%?!ue73!\I#)%?#%)]!X$#0$#:!P(4'!b$..%(%3!MC+&.+H.%!E?$*:!c@))G:ddFFF3,2.3+23/,d'2@$$.'d''GGd(%$(?+G@-d?%'%+?2@d%G0dF$?,(3@)*.f!\M22%''%0!M/(/')!78)@!788Y]!

6&?'2@1!g3X31!S%p0%,1!g3!a!B%#0.(1!g3!5788Q$!M*%?&2+#'!b$#'/*%!)$$!L/2@s4!!A2@$?1!W3S3!a!6$.)1!>3S3!5h0'3


83/93

!

! _;!

6$G,'1!g$H!5788_

I#)%?($C%?#*%#)+.!R+#%.!$#!b.&*+)%!b@+#(%!57889"6961!1F==%Q'A/-0%C66$66)$(-%D$,'/-!\I#)%?#%)]3!MC+&.+H.%!E?$*:!c@))G:ddFFF3&G2232@dG0Ed+''%''*%#)N?%G$?)d+?=dF(ed+?=NF(eN'G*3G0Ef3!\M22%''%0!eQ!M/(/')!788Y]!!

IG'$'!L$?&!57889

W+2$H'1!L3!5eYY9

W$F%..1!g3!%)!+.!5eYY9Imj!6%))&%!W/0+@!%[G.$?%'!+!F$?.0!$E!@+#0!2?+E)%0!.+*G'@+0%'!+#0!F$?,'@$G!H/&.)!?$H$)'4!!)@%!Q9("(@9":%39)$61!7;?0!L+-!788Y1!'3!6$/'%!a!6$*%1!G3T!

P+##%?1!M3!a!Z$*%'1!L3!5eYYQ

H%.&%E'1!2$#2%?#1!+#0!%#C&?$#*%#)+..-!?%'G$#'&H.%!H%@+C&$?4!!E'A/(":%'.%>A69($66%D$6$"/@0!Te!5788_


84/93

!

! _=!

P#&(@)1!P+)@%?%!57889

P-#+')$#1!>3!57889/9-"9(%KLSWNWL!5X$#0$#:!S.$$*'H/?-

X+2%-1!b3!+#0!X$#(*+#1!>3!5eYY9

X+,$EE1!Z3!a!W$@#'$#1!L3!5eY_8

X+-+?01!g3!5788Q

X+p+?E%.01!R3!a!L%?)$#1!g3!5eY=_

`$C%*H%?!788_1!G3!Y7!

L2Z?$)@%?1!b3!5eY_9

A)+)&')&2'dR+.(?+C%!L+2L&..+#!L+?'@+..1!Z3!5788e


85/93

!

! _Q!

L$#H&$)1!Z3!5788Q

L$#H&$)1!Z3!5788TA/(9(

`$?*+#1!W3!5k$?%F$?0

l?*%?$01!P3!5788_

l'.%-1!M3!5eYYQ

R$F%..1!K3!a!g$'%#1!>3!5788Y

g%-#$.0'1!g3!5788_


86/93

!

! _T!

A+##%1!b3!57887

?"-A/&";%>/$"#."6-!5788Y

A2@$?1!W3S3!5eYYY

A2$))1!W3!5eYY8

A2@F+?)p1!R3!a!g+#0+..1!M3!5788;/9-"9(1!Q)@!h0&)&$#1!X$#0$#:!g$/).%0(%!

A%.F+-1!W3!5788_

A@%G@%?01!R+/.!5eYY_

A@&EE$?01!b3!5788Y

A&**'1!M3!5788_

K/#')+..1!W3!5788_


87/93

!

! _9!

*%%)'!)@%*!5+#0!0&'2$C%?'!)@%!$/)'&0%!.$$!333

K/?#%?1!W3!5788Y

B&..&+*'$#1!W3!5eY9_

B$$0'1!g3!a!A*&)@1!>3!5788_

B?&(@)1!R3!5eY_Q

m$/#(1!B31!6F+#(1!P31!L2>$#+.01!A3!a!l+)%'1!b3!"A/')++H.%!2$#'/*G)&$#:!(?%%#!2$#'/*%?!H%@+C&$/?!F@%#!G/?2@+'(!G?$0/2)'4!!?A6-"9("5:$%8$7$:',)$(-!W/.-!788_!

y%?p+#1!W3!5788_/9-"9(B%D"-9'(9(


88/93

!

! __!

944:#;(('?)"*)=%%&'?23?("#')

)

!

*(+,-@)

!

e3 I*G%?&+.!B+?!L/'%/*!G$')%?!"X%''$#'!E?$*!6&')$?-!`$3;4!/)&.&'(!)@%!($C%?#*%#)!G?$G+(+#0+!G$')%?!!"Z$!K@?$/(@!m$/?!B+?0?$H%4!H-!>$#&+!`+'2@%#!E$?!)@%!S$+?0!$E!K?+0%1!23eY=;!\Rgl1!I`k!e;de==de]3!R@$)$(?+G@%0!H-!)@%!+/)@$?!+)!6$.H$?#!/#0%?(?$/#0!')+)&$#1!_)@!MG?&.!788Y!

73 HA"/&9"(%U$$#$(&%!"$!I)o4!OA!A%2$#0!B$?.0!B+?!G?$G+(+#0+!G$')%?!H-!W3!6$F+?0!L&..%?!23!eY=;3!"M.%[+!

b@/#(4'!g%2%''&$#!b@&241!G@$)$(?+G@-!H-!L+))!I?F!')-.(!H-!A)%G@!A)%C%#'1!+?)F$?,'!H-!M#0-!A*&)@1!

;3 I*G%?&+.!B+?!L/'%/*!'@$G1!G@$)$(?+G@%0!H-!)@%!+/)@$?!eT)@!W/#%!788Y!=3 I*G%?&+.!B+?!L/'%/*!'@$G1!G@$)$(?+G@%0!H-!)@%!+/)@$?!eT)@!W/#%!788Y!Q3 KN'@&?)!"`$F!R+#&2!+#0!k?%+,!l/)4!5zeQ

@))G:dd)-G%)%%'3)@?%+0.%''32$*!T3 I*G%?&+.!B+?!L/'%/*!'@$G1!G@$)$(?+G@%0!H-!+/)@$?!eT)@!W/#%!788Y!93 39)$%4A-!*+(+p%1!MG?&.!;8)@NL+-!T)@!788Y!_3 b@+?)!'@$F(!+?)&2.%'!H-!#%F'G+G%?!)&).%3!Y3 b@+?)!'@$F(!#/*H%?!$E!')$?&%'!H-!G/H.&2+)&$#!*$#)@!e83R&%!2@+?)!e!'@$F(!#/*H%?!$E!')$?&%'!H-!#%F'G+G%?!'%2)&$#!ee3R&%!2@+?)!7!'@$F(!#/*H%?!$E!')$?&%'!H-!#%F'G+G%?!'%2)&$#!!


89/93

!

! _Y!

e73HA"/&9"(%U$$#$(&%!"$!+#0!L%#0!N!6$/'%@$.0!M0C&2%!

b%#)?%41!S$+?0!$E!K?+0%j!6LAl1!23eY=;!e=3k?$#)!2$C%?!$E!E")9$T6%!9(96-/;%'.%Q''&!5l.&C%?1!788_

L&')?-!$E!k$$0!&''/%0!g+)&$#!S$$,!E$?!)@%!-%+?!eYQ=NeYQ=3!

eQ3I*G%?&+.!B+?!L/'%/*!'@$G1!G@$)$(?+G@%0!H-!)@%!+/)@$?!eT)@!W/#%!788Y!eT3!OP!R$.&2%!E$?2%'!G$')%?!E?$*!R$.&2%!R.%0(%!'%?&%':!"m$/!6+C%!)@%!g&(@)!

`lK!)$!?%*+!A&.%#)41!G@$)$(?+G@%0!H-!+/)@$?!$#!MG?&.!e')!788Y!$#!F+-!)$!Z78!G?$)%')!+)!)@%!S+#,!$E!h#(.+#03!!!

e93L+,%!>$!+#0!L%#0!A@$GG%?!5{e=3Q8

e_3L+,%!>$!+#0!L%#0!*/(!5{93Q8

eY3L+,%!>$!+#0!L%#0!)%+!)$F%.!5{Y3Q8


90/93

!

!

"#!

"#!

!""#$%&'())*((

+,--#$.( +/0./1#( 23-&04( 2356&,$( 2&$3$7#( 2,,%(

$%&'()! *+,! -./'&%! -).,0+)12!$34%!5!630&! $01'()11! -334!73(,8&%!

93&0/(1! *+,1! ! -).,0+)12!6,%&)! 9.18! -:!;))+'(

93//)(,! $33


91/93

!

!

"V!

"V!

8#..#15( 9,.,1&$:( ;#! ! -).,0+)12!T)N1!

L)M')N!

W3/)2!-).,0+)1! ! ! :O2!-).,0+)1!

! ! P0.+4'.(!W3/)!

U.J)1!

W301)!5!W3/)! ! ! ;3+

! ! ! U+3D)+,%2!R(1'4)!

:+.B

! ! !

! ! ! ;))


92/93

!

! "#!

!

!"#$%&'%


93/93

!

!

!"#$&(%

Documents

Mend & Make Do to Save Buying New; Decoding Messages of Austerity in a Consumer Culture