Upload
nocompromisewtruth
View
221
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/2/2019 Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of LexisNexis Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgement Doc 4
1/17
7
3
:
?
9
0
2
1
;
7=
77
73
7:
7?
79
70
7271
7;
3=
37
33
3:
3?
39
30
32
31
E]G KN ZY]]LS_ L@ DIQKZNIQKZ EZFJGZINL. JP77%==?19 GB !GFRq+
FGEIZ @. EjJGCI !JG ZCN 7=?010+FEjJgciMel`l.jleELSSKZLN & @LISZ_ISDD]?39 Egshit ZtsiitZgn @sgnjkzjl$ Jgdk`lsnkg ;?7=9%3?13_idi}alni6 ?79.301.2===@gjzkekdi6 ?79.301.2933
EKJAGID C. EKDDIS !]sl Agj Pkji+ECEkddisMel`l.jleELSSKZLN & @LISZ_IS DD]73;= Gpinyi l` tai Geiskjgz
Nir [lsh$ Nir [lsh 7=7=?%==9=_idi}alni6 373.?01.1==;@gjzkekdi6 373.?01.2;==
Gttlsni{z `ls Siio Idzipkis Knj.$ DiqkzNiqkz Skzh gnoKn`lsegtkln Gngd{tkjz Bsly} Knj.$ DiqkzNiqkz$ Knj.$
DiqkzNiqkz Skzh Zldytklnz$ Knj.$ DiqkzNiqkzJalkji]lknt$ Knj.$ DiqkzNiqkz Zikzknt$ Knj.$ o,c,gGjjysknt$ gno DiqkzNiqkz Bsly} Knj.
YNK_IO Z_G_IZ OKZ_SKJ_ JLYS_
JIN_SGD OKZ_SKJ_ L@ JGDK@LSNKG
ZLY_AISN OKPKZKLN
DKZG DKCISK$ it gd.$]dgkntk``z$
p.
LSD[ _GK_V$ it gd.$
Oi`inogntz.
Jgzi Nl. JP77%==?19 GB !GFRq+EIELSGNOYE L@ ]LKN_Z GNOGY_ALSK_KIZ KN ZY]]LS_ L@DIQKZNIQKZ OI@INOGN_ZEL_KLN @LS ZYEEGS[FYOBEIN_
Ogti6 Eg{ 7?$ 3=73_kei6 7=6== g.e.Fyobi6 Aln. Gnosir F. Bykd`lso]dgji6 Jlystslle 7=O
Jgzi 1677%jp%==?19%GB%GFR Oljyeint ?;7%7 @kdio =?,=?,73 ]gbi 7 l` 72 ]gbi KO*677;1?
8/2/2019 Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of LexisNexis Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgement Doc 4
2/17
7
3
:
?
9
0
2
1
;
7=
77
73
7:
7?
79
70
7271
7;
3=
37
33
3:
3?
39
30
32
31
E]G KN ZY]]LS_ L@ DIQKZNIQKZ EZFJGZINL. JP77%==?19 GB !GFRq+
k
_GCDI L@ JLN_IN_Z
]gbiK. KN_SLOYJ_KLN...........................................................................................7
KK. Z_G_IEIN_ L@ @GJ_Z..............................................................................3
G. Gjjysknt Si}lstz ...................................................................................3
C. Gjjysknt Si}lstz Gsi Nlt Jlnzyeis Si}lstz Ynois tai@JSG ....................................................................................................9
J. _ai Zigsjaiz gno Si}lstz Syn c{ tai Zgnhi{ @kse.............................1
KKK. DIBGD Z_GNOGSO.....................................................................................;
KP. DIBGD GSBYEIN_ ..................................................................................7=
G. _ai DiqkzNiqkz Oi`inogntz Gsi Intktdio tl Zyeegs{ FyobeintCijgyzi _ai{ Gsi Nlt Jlnzyeis Si}lstknb Gbinjkiz Pkz%%pkztai ]dgkntk``z$ Gno Oko Nlt ]slpkoi g Jlnzyeis Si}lst ln]dgkntk``z ..............................................................................................7=
JLNJDYZKLN........................................................................................................7?
Jgzi 1677%jp%==?19%GB%GFR Oljyeint ?;7%7 @kdio =?,=?,73 ]gbi 3 l` 72 ]gbi KO*677;19
8/2/2019 Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of LexisNexis Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgement Doc 4
3/17
7
3
:
?
9
0
2
1
;
7=
77
73
7:
7?
79
70
7271
7;
3=
37
33
3:
3?
39
30
32
31
E]G KN ZY]]LS_ L@ DIQKZNIQKZ EZFJGZINL. JP77%==?19 GB !GFRq+
kk
_GCDI L@ GY_ALSK_KIZ
]gbi!z+
JGZIZ
Gnoiszln p. Dkcist{ Dlcc{$ Knj.$
?22 Y.Z. 3?3 !7;10+ .............................................................................................;
Jgpgdkisi p. Cyshi$9= @.:o 7=::$ 7;;9 RD 7:033; !9ta Jks. 7;;9+ !}is jyskge+...........................7:
Jidltiq Jls}. p. Jgtsitt?22 Y.Z. :72 !7;10+ .......................................................................................;$ 7=
Jleigyq p. Cslrn & Rkddkgezln _lcgjjl Jl.$;79 @.3o 730? !;ta Jks. 7;;=+ ............................................................................77
Oynjgn p. Rgdhis$9:: Y.Z. 702 !3==7+ ...........................................................................................77
@lssizt p. Zijysio @ynoknb$ Knj.$Nl. =9%J%7:3?$ 3==2 RD 17121 !I.O. Rkz. Fgn. 1$ 3==2+................................7:
K}}ldktl p. RNZ$ Knj.$10? @.3o ??= !2ta Jks. 7;11+ ..............................................................................7:
Egtzyzaktg Idij. Knoyz. Jl. p. VinktaSgokl Jls}.$?29 Y.Z. 92? !7;10+. ......................................................................................;$ 7=
Einoi p. Oyn & Csgoztsiit$ Knj.$02= @.3o 73; !;ta Jks. 7;13+..............................................................................7:
Nkzzgn @ksi & Egskni Knz. Jl. p. @sktv Jl.37= @.:o 7=;; !;ta Jks. 3===+............................................................................7=
Z_G_Y_IZ &SYDIZ
79 Y.Z.J. 7017 it ziw. ....................................................................................................7$ 9 7017g!o+.............................................................................................................7 7017g!o+!7+ ......................................................................................................77 7017c ...............................................................................................................73
@io. S. Jkp. ].
90!j+...................................................................................................................... ;
@ioisgd _sgoi Jleekzzkln$ ?= [igsz l` Iq}iskinji Rkta tai @gks JsioktSi}lstknb Gjt$ Fyd{ 3=77$ gpgkdgcdi gtatt}6,,rrr.`tj.blp,lz,3=77,=2,77=23=`jsgsi}lst.}o` .......................................73
Jgzi 1677%jp%==?19%GB%GFR Oljyeint ?;7%7 @kdio =?,=?,73 ]gbi : l` 72 ]gbi KO*677;10
8/2/2019 Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of LexisNexis Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgement Doc 4
4/17
7
3
:
?
9
0
2
1
;
7=
77
73
7:
7?
79
70
7271
7;
3=
37
33
3:
3?
39
30
32
31
E]G KN ZY]]LS_ L@ DIQKZNIQKZ EZFJGZINL. JP77%==?19 GB !GFRq+
7
K. KN_SLOYJ_KLNGn g``kdkgti l` tai DiqkzNiqkz Oi`inogntz
7ziddz si}lstz$ jgddio Gjjysknt
si}lstz$ tagt jle}kdi kn`lsegtkln gclyt knokpkoygdz osgrn `sle }ycdkjd{ gno
jleeisjkgdd{ gpgkdgcdi ogtg. ]dgkntk``z gddibi tagt }iszlnz ls intktkiz gzzljkgtio
rkta Os. _gktv ls Es. Zgnhi{ }ysjagzio Gjjysknt zigsjaiz ls si}lstz ln ]dgkntk``z
Dkcisk gno Lztiddg gno taisig`tis }ycdkzaio tai kn`lsegtkln lctgknio gz }gst l` g
jlnjistio }iszlngd gno }ldktkjgd jge}gkbn gbgknzt ]dgkntk``z. Zyja }ycdkjgtkln$ tai{
jdgke$ dio tl g pgskit{ l` ogegbiz.
_ai siegknknb jdgkez gbgknzt tai DiqkzNiqkz Oi`inogntz gsi gdd cgzio ln tai
nltkln tagt Gjjysknt zigsjaiz ls si}lstz gsi jlnzyeis si}lstz rktakn tai eignknb
l` tai @gks Jsiokt Si}lstknb Gjt !79 Y.Z.J. 7017 it ziw. !@JSG+8 79 Y.Z.J.
7017g!o++ gno sidgtio ztgti dgr. _ai DiqkzNiqkz Oi`inogntz gsi intktdio tl
zyeegs{ fyobeint ln gdd siegknknb jdgkez.
Gz g egttis l` knokz}ytgcdi `gjt$ niktais tai zigsjaiz nls tai si}lstz gt kzzyi
kn takz jgzi gsi jlnzyeis si}lstzgz tagt tise kz oi`knio kn tai @JSG$ gno nlni l`
taie rgz zldo c{ gn{ DiqkzNiqkz Oi`inognt. Gdd l` tai si}lstz kn kzzyi risi zldo
tl Oi`inognt Zgnhi{ c{ KSCZigsja$ DDJ$ g jle}gn{ knoi}inoint l` taiDiqkzNiqkz Oi`inogntz. _ai jlntsgjt citriin Zgnhi{ gno KSC gno tai jlntsgjt
citriin KSC gno tai DiqkzNiqkz intkt{ tagt egkntgknz tai Gjjysknt ogtgcgzi igja
}slpkoio tagt gn{ Gjjysknt si}lst tagt ekbat ci `ysnkzaio rgz nltg jlnzyeis
si}lst gno rlydo nltci yzio `ls tai hknoz l` idkbkckdkt{ oitisekngtklnz tagt oi`kni
jlnzyeis si}lstz. Nlni l` tai DiqkzNiqkz Oi`inogntz taisi`lsi iq}ijtio ls
kntinoio ls jlydo agpi iq}ijtio ls kntinoio tai si}lstz tl ci zl yzio. @ls tai zgei
7Gz iq}dgknio kn taiks Eltkln tl Okzekzz !Oljhit Nl. :17+$ tai @kszt
Geinoio Jle}dgknt !@GJ+ ngeiz gz tai Siio Oi`inogntz nyeislyz intktkizrakja iktais ol nlt iqkzt ls rakja risi nlt sidgtio kn gn{ rg{ tl tai jlnoyjtgddibio kn tai @GJ. @ls zke}dkjkt{$ alripis$ takz Eltkln si`isz tl talzi ngeiointktkiz jlddijtkpid{ gz tai DiqkzNiqkz Oi`inogntz.
Jgzi 1677%jp%==?19%GB%GFR Oljyeint ?;7%7 @kdio =?,=?,73 ]gbi ? l` 72 ]gbi KO*677;12
8/2/2019 Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of LexisNexis Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgement Doc 4
5/17
7
3
:
?
9
0
2
1
;
7=
77
73
7:
7?
79
70
7271
7;
3=
37
33
3:
3?
39
30
32
31
E]G KN ZY]]LS_ L@ DIQKZNIQKZ EZFJGZINL. JP77%==?19 GB !GFRq+
3
sigzlnz tagt tai Jlyst bsgntio zyeegs{ fyobeint kn `gpls l` Oi`inognt Kntidkyz$
zyeegs{ fyobeint zalydo ci bsgntio aisi.
KK. Z_G_IEIN_ L@ @GJ_ZZyczkokgskiz l` Siio Idzipkis Knj. gsi digoknb }slpkoisz l` bdlcgd kn`lsegtkln
oskpin zispkjiz gno zldytklnz cigsknb tai DiqkzNiqkz csgno. !Ztgtieint l`
Ynjlntslpistio @gjtz !Y@+ Nl. 7.+ Lni l` tai intktkiz tagt ]dgkntk``z ngeio gz g
Oi`inognt kn takz jgzi kz DiqkzNiqkz Zikzknt$ Knj. o,c,g Gjjysknt. !Ko.+ _aisi kz
nl jls}lsgtkln hnlrn gz DiqkzNiqkz Zikzknt$ Knj.$ o,c,g Gjjysknt. !Y@ Nl. 3.+
Alripis$ g jle}gn{ tain hnlrn gz Zikzknt Knj.$ ydtkegtid{ lrnio c{ Siio
Idzipkis Knj.$ kn 3==; l}isgtio g ogtgcgzi `sle rakja Gjjysknt csgnoio si}lstz
risi }si}gsio.3 !Y@ Nl. :.+ _agt jle}gn{ kz jyssintd{ hnlrn gz DiqkzNiqkz Skzh
Ogtg Egngbieint$ Knj. !DNSOEK+. !Y@ Nl. ?.+
G. Gjjysknt Si}lstzKn 3==;$ DNSOEKz `dgbzak} }sloyjt dkni rgz Gjjysknt$ g zykti l` lndkni
kn`lsegtkln }sloyjtz. !Y@ Nl. 9.+ Si}lstz gno zispkjiz cigsknb tai Gjjysknt csgno
ok``isio kn tai t{}iz l` kn`lsegtkln tai{ jlntgknio$ cyt gdd Gjjysknt%csgnoio si}lstz
risi }si}gsio `sle kn`lsegtkln alyzio kn tai Gjjysknt ogtgcgzi. !Y@ Nl. 0.+_ai Gjjysknt }sloyjtz gsi hnlrn }skegskd{ gz tlldz `ls dljgtknb }iszlnz$
pisk`{knb kointkt{$ gno oitijtknb sgyo. !Y@ Nl. 1.+ Gjjyskntz zyczjsk}tkln
jyztleisz knjdyoi egn{ dgr in`lsjieint gbinjkiz$ oict jlddijtlsz$ }gjhgbi
oidkpis{ zispkjiz gno dgr `ksez$ gelnb ltaisz. !Y@ Nl. ;.+ Gjjysknt }sloyjtz
jlntgkn }skegskd{ }ycdkj sijlso gno jleeisjkgdd{ gpgkdgcdi kn`lsegtkln gclyt
knokpkoygdz gzziecdio `sle g dgsbi nyecis l` zlysjiz. !Y@ Nl. 7=.+
_ai Gjjysknt ogtgcgzi jlntgknz kn`lsegtkln `sle g rkoi pgskit{ l` zlysjiz$
zyja gz tidi}alni oksijtls{ dkztknbz$ sigd }sl}ist{ sijlsoz$ YJJ gno zijsitgs{ l`
3Zknji Fgnygs{ 7$ 3=7=$ tai Gjjysknt ogtgcgzi agz ciin l}isgtio gno zldo c{
g jle}gn{ hnlrn gz DiqkzNiqkz Skzh Zldytklnz @D Knj. !Y@ Nl. 2.+
Jgzi 1677%jp%==?19%GB%GFR Oljyeint ?;7%7 @kdio =?,=?,73 ]gbi 9 l` 72 ]gbi KO*677;11
8/2/2019 Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of LexisNexis Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgement Doc 4
6/17
7
3
:
?
9
0
2
1
;
7=
77
73
7:
7?
79
70
7271
7;
3=
37
33
3:
3?
39
30
32
31
E]G KN ZY]]LS_ L@ DIQKZNIQKZ EZFJGZINL. JP77%==?19 GB !GFRq+
:
ztgti `kdknbz$ }sl`izzklngd dkjinziz$ zidijtio jlyst `kdknbz$ gno jsiokt aigois ogtg.
!Y@ Nl. 77.+ _ai dgttis jlnzkztz l` `kdiz$ yzygdd{ }si}gsio c{ jsiokt cysigyz tagt
}slpkoi kn`lsegtkln zyja gz knokpkoygd ngeiz$ ngei pgskgntz$ jyssint gno `lseis
goosizziz$ gno zljkgd zijyskt{ nyecisz. !Y@ Nl. 73.+
]iszlnz rkta gjjizz tl tai Gjjysknt ogtgcgzi jgn jlnoyjt g }iszln zigsja
c{ zy}}d{knb jsktiskg hnlrn tl tai yzis$ zyja gz ngei$ goosizz$ ls k` gdsigo{ hnlrn
c{ tai yzis$ zljkgd zijyskt{ nyecis. !Y@ Nl. 7:.+ G }iszln zigsja sitskipiz
zidijtio kn`lsegtkln gzzljkgtio rkta gdd ngeiz kn tai ogtgcgzi egtjaknb tai jsktiskg
zy}}dkio c{ tai yzis. Yzisz jgn tain zidijt g sitysnio ngei tl sitskipi ogtgcgzi
kn`lsegtkln gzzljkgtio rkta tagt }gstkjydgs sitysnio ngei. !Y@ Nl. 7?.+ _ai t{}iz
l` kn`lsegtkln sitysnio pgskiz oi}inoknb ln tai t{}i l` Gjjysknt si}lst zidijtio
gno tai nyecis l` sijlsoz gzzljkgtio rkta tai zidijtio ngei. !Y@ Nl. 79.+ Zljkgd
zijyskt{ nyecisz kn tai Gjjysknt ogtgcgzi gsi okz}dg{io tl yzisz lnd{ kn tsynjgtio
`lse !`kszt `kpi okbktz+ yndizz tai yzis kz g dgr in`lsjieint gbinj{ ls lni l` g
dkektio nyecis l` z}ijkgdd{ wygdk`kio jyztleisz.
_ai Gjjysknt ogtgcgzi oliz nlt jlntgkn }dgjiz l` cksta8 eltaisz egkoin
ngeiz8 . . . knjlei8 cgnhknb kn`lsegtkln8 . . . jsiokt jgsoz . . .8 knzysgnji sijlsoz8XlsU eiokjgd sijlsoz . . . !Y@ Nl. 70.+ _ai ogtgcgzi knjdyoiz jlnzyeisz XaUlei
}skjiz gno pgdyiz lnd{ tl tai iqtint tagt zyja kn`lsegtkln kz `lyno kn }ycdkjd{
gpgkdgcdi oljyeintz$ zyja gz sijlsoio elstbgbiz ls tgq gzzizzeint slddz. !Y@ Nl.
72.+ _ai ogtgcgzi oliz nlt jlntgkn jsiokt sijlsoz knjdyoknb cyt nlt dkektio tl
dlgnz rkta cgnhz gno ltais intktkiz gdtalyba tai ogtgcgzi jgn jlntgkn }ycdkjd{ `kdio
zijyskt{ knztsyeintz$ zyja gz g oiio l` tsyzt ls g YJJ%7. !Y@ Nl. 71.+
Nlni l` tai intktkiz lrnio oksijtd{ ls knoksijtd{ c{ Siio Idzipkis Knj.
}si}gsi jsiokt si}lstz. !Y@ Nl. 37.+ Zlei jle}gnkiz lrnio oksijtd{ ls
knoksijtd{ c{ Siio Idzipkis Knj.$ zyja gz DiqkzNiqkz Skzh Zjsiinknb Zldytklnz Knj.
!DNSZZK+$ ol }si}gsi ie}dl{eint cgjhbslyno zjsiinknb si}lstz tagt gsi
jlnzyeis si}lstz gz oi`knio c{ tai @JSG. !Y@ Nl. 33.+ Alripis$ gdd si}lstz
Jgzi 1677%jp%==?19%GB%GFR Oljyeint ?;7%7 @kdio =?,=?,73 ]gbi 0 l` 72 ]gbi KO*677;1;
8/2/2019 Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of LexisNexis Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgement Doc 4
7/17
7
3
:
?
9
0
2
1
;
7=
77
73
7:
7?
79
70
7271
7;
3=
37
33
3:
3?
39
30
32
31
E]G KN ZY]]LS_ L@ DIQKZNIQKZ EZFJGZINL. JP77%==?19 GB !GFRq+
?
zldo c{ jle}gnkiz lrnio oksijtd{ ls knoksijtd{ c{ Siio Idzipkis Knj. tagt gsi
iq}ijtio ls kntinoio tl ci yzio `ls jsiokt$ knzysgnji ls idkbkckdkt{ oitisekngtklnz
gsi zldo c{ intktkiz ltais tagn DNSOEK gno gsi }si}gsio yzknb ogtgcgziz ltais tagn
tai Gjjysknt ogtgcgzi. !Y@ Nl. 3:.+
Yzisz jlydo gjwyksi si}lstz binisgtio yzknb tai Gjjysknt ogtgcgzi kn zipisgd
ok``isint rg{z. !Y@ Nl. 32.+ DNSOEK zldo Gjjysknt si}lstz tl zyczjskcisz ral
ago intisio kntl gbsiieintz rkta DNSOEK ls gn g``kdkgtio jle}gn{. !Y@ Nl. 31.+
Nlni l` tai _gktv ls Zgnhi{ Oi`inogntz ago gjjlyntz rkta DNSOEK ynois rakja
DNSOEK zldo taie Gjjysknt si}lstz. !Y@ Nl. 3;.+
Kn gooktkln$ DNSOEK intisio kntl gbsiieintz rkta ltais kn`lsegtkln
}slpkoisz !siziddisz+ ynois rakja tai siziddisz jlydo syn zigsjaiz gbgknzt tai
Gjjysknt ogtgcgzi tl jsigti si}lstz tagt tai siziddisz$ nlt DNSOEK$ zldo tl taiks
lrn jyztleisz ynois iktais taiks lrn csgno ls tai Gjjysknt csgno. !Y@ Nl. :=.+
Lni zyja Gjjysknt siziddis rgz KSCzigsja$ DDJ !KSC+. !Y@ Nl. :7.+ KSC ziddz
kn`lsegtkln zispkjiz tl tai }skpgti knpiztkbgtls gno }sljizz zispis zyc%egshit. !Ko.+
Oi`inognt _ai Zgnhi{ @kse ago gn gjjlynt rkta KSC tagt }isekttio _ai Zgnhi{
@kse tl }ysjagzi`sle KSC si}lstz jsigtio yzknb tai Gjjysknt ogtgcgzi. !Y@ Nl.:38 Oijdgsgtkln l` Dkzg Zkeelnz kn Zy}}lst l` DiqkzNiqkz Oi`inogntz Eltkln `ls
Zyeegs{ Fyobeint !Zkeelnz Oijd.+ Iq. G !gbsiieint intisio kntl citriin
_ai Zgnhi{ @kse gno KSC$ ogtio @icsygs{ 37$ 3==2+.+
Gjjysknt si}lstz gsi kntinoio tl bkpi yzisz rlshgcdi digoz tl aid} kointk`{
gno dljgti g }gstkjydgs knokpkoygd$ nlt tl }slpkoi oi`knktkpi kn`lsegtkln gclyt gn
knokpkoygd. !Y@ Nl. 3?.+ _ai si}lstz taiezidpiz sijlbnkvi tai ynjistgkntkiz
knaisint kn takz zlst l` zigsja. !Y@ Nl. 39.+ _ai{ kointk`{ Ngeiz Gzzljkgtio
Rkta tai Zycfijt$ ]lzzkcdi Gzzljkgtiz$ ]lzzkcdi Sidgtkpiz$ itj. !Ko.+ Kn
gooktkln$ tai ogtg zlysjiz taiezidpiz jlei rkta jistgkn sijlbnkvio dkektgtklnz.
!Y@ Nl. 30.+ Gjjysknt si}lstz knjdyoi tai `lddlrknb nltkji6
Jgzi 1677%jp%==?19%GB%GFR Oljyeint ?;7%7 @kdio =?,=?,73 ]gbi 2 l` 72 ]gbi KO*677;;=
8/2/2019 Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of LexisNexis Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgement Doc 4
8/17
7
3
:
?
9
0
2
1
;
7=
77
73
7:
7?
79
70
7271
7;
3=
37
33
3:
3?
39
30
32
31
E]G KN ZY]]LS_ L@ DIQKZNIQKZ EZFJGZINL. JP77%==?19 GB !GFRq+
9
Ke}lstgnt. _ai ]ycdkj Sijlsoz gno jleeisjkgdd{gpgkdgcdi ogtg zlysjiz yzio ln si}lstz agpi isslsz. Ogtgkz zleitkeiz intisio }llsd{$ }sljizzio knjlssijtd{ gno kzbinisgdd{ nlt `sii `sle oi`ijt. _akz z{ztie zalydo nlt cisidkio y}ln gz oi`knktkpid{ gjjysgti. Ci`lsi sid{knb lngn{ ogtg takz z{ztie zy}}dkiz$ kt zalydo ci knoi}inointd{pisk`kio. @ls Zijsitgs{ l` Ztgti oljyeintz$ tai `lddlrknbogtg kz `ls kn`lsegtkln }ys}lziz lnd{ gno kz nlt gn l``kjkgdsijlso. Jistk`kio jl}kiz eg{ ci lctgknio `sle tagtknokpkoygd Ztgtiz Oi}gsteint l` Ztgti.
!Ko.+
C. Gjjysknt Si}lstz Gsi Nlt Jlnzyeis Si}lstz Ynoistai @JSG.
DNSOEKz kntint gno iq}ijtgtkln kn l``isknb Gjjysknt }sloyjtz `ls zgdi rgz
tagt tai Gjjysknt }sloyjtz risi nlt jlnzyeis si}lstz rktakn tai eignknb l` tai
@gks Jsiokt Si}lstknb Gjt$ 79 Y.Z.J. 7017$ it ziw. !tai @JSG+. !Y@ Nl. :?.+
_ai `lddlrknb dgnbygbi g}}igsz ln tai ric}gbi tagt jgn ci `lyno gt
rrr.Gjjysknt.jle gno ltais Gjjysknt ric}gbiz !zii$ i.b. rrr.Gjjysknt.jle$
att}z6,,zijysi.gjjysknt.jle,g}},c}z,egkn$ itj.+6
_ai Gjjysknt zispkjiz gsi nlt }slpkoio c{ jlnzyeissi}lstknb gbinjkiz$ gz tagt tise kz oi`knio kn tai @gks
Jsiokt Si}lstknb Gjt !79 Y.Z.J. 7017$ it ziw.+!@JSG+ gno ol nlt jlnztktyti jlnzyeis si}lstz$ gztagt tise kz oi knio kn tai @JSG. Gjjlsoknbd{$ taiGjjysknt zispkji eg{ nlt ci yzio kn raldi ls kn }gst gz g`gjtls kn oitiseknknb idkbkckdkt{ `ls jsiokt$ knzysgnji$ie}dl{eint ls `ls ltais idkbkckdkt{ oitisekngtkln
}ys}lziz tagt rlydo wygdk`{ tai zispkji gz g jlnzyeissi}lst ynois tai @JSG.
!Y@ Nl. :9.+ _akz zgei dgnbygbi kz gdzl knjdyoio ln tai jyztleis zkbn%kn }gbi.
Ziiatt}z6,,zijysi.gjjysknt.jle,g}},c}z,egkn. !Y@ Nl. :0.+ @ls zijyskt{ }ys}lziz$
Gjjysknt jyztleisz jgn gjjizz tai Gjjysknt }sloyjt lnd{ `sle takz zkbn%kn }gbi.
!Ko.+
Kn ktz ztgnogso `lse zyczjsk}tkln gbsiieintz rkta ktz ino%yzisz$ DNSOEK
siwyksio zyja yzisz tl gbsii !g+ tagt Gjjysknt si}lstz risi nlt jlnzyeis si}lstz
rktakn tai eignknb l` tai @JSG$ gno !c+ tagt tai yzisz rlydo nlt yzi Gjjysknt
Jgzi 1677%jp%==?19%GB%GFR Oljyeint ?;7%7 @kdio =?,=?,73 ]gbi 1 l` 72 ]gbi KO*677;;7
8/2/2019 Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of LexisNexis Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgement Doc 4
9/17
7
3
:
?
9
0
2
1
;
7=
77
73
7:
7?
79
70
7271
7;
3=
37
33
3:
3?
39
30
32
31
E]G KN ZY]]LS_ L@ DIQKZNIQKZ EZFJGZINL. JP77%==?19 GB !GFRq+
0
si}lstz kn oitiseknknb g jlnzyeisz idkbkckdkt{ `ls jsiokt$ knzysgnji ie}dl{eint ls
`ls gn{ ltais }ys}lzi tagt rlydo jgyzi Gjjysknt si}lstz tl ci tsigtio gz jlnzyeis
si}lstz rktakn tai eignknb l` tai @JSG. !Y@ Nl. :28 Zkeelnz Oijd. Iq. C.+
Rakdi zlei l` tai rlsoknb kn takz `lse agz jagnbio lpis tkei$ tai izzintkgd
zycztgnji l` taizi }slpkzklnz agz siegknio tai zgei. !Y@ Nl. :1.+ Gelnb ltais
taknbz$ talzi gbsiieintz siwyksi igja jyztleis$ gz g jlnoktkln tl lctgkn gn{
Gjjysknt ogtg }sloyjt tl gbsii kn Zijtkln 3!pkkk+ tagt6
_ai DN Zispkjiz }slpkoio }yszygnt tl takz Gbsiieint gsinlt }slpkoio c{ jlnzyeis si}lstknb gbinjkiz$ gz tagttise kz oi`knio c{ tai @gks Jsiokt Si}lstknb Gjt$ 79Y.Z.J. 7017 it ziw. !@JSG+ gno ol nlt jlnztktytijlnzyeis si}lstz$ gz tagt tise kz oi`knio ynois tai
@JSG. Gjjlsoknbd{$ DN Zispkjiz eg{ nlt ci yzio knraldi ls kn }gst gz g `gjtls kn oitiseknknb idkbkckdkt{ `lsjsiokt$ knzysgnji$ ie}dl{eint ls gnltais }isekzzkcdi
}ys}lzi ynois tai @JSG. @ystais$ !G+ Jyztleis jistk`kiztagt kt rkdd nlt yzi gn{ l` tai kn`lsegtkln kt sijikpiztaslyba tai DN Zispkjiz `ls gn{ l` tai `lddlrknb
}ys}lziz6 !7+ kn iztgcdkzaknb g jlnzyeisz idkbkckdkt{ `lsjsiokt ls knzysgnji tl ci yzio }skegskd{ `ls }iszlngd$`gekd{ ls alyzialdo }ys}lziz ls kn jlnnijtkln rkta taisipkir ls jlddijtkln l` gn iqkztknb jsiokt gjjlynt l` gjlnzyeis8 !3+ `ls ie}dl{eint }ys}lziz8 !:+ knjlnnijtkln rkta g oitisekngtkln l` g jlnzyeiszidkbkckdkt{ `ls g dkjinzi ls ltais cini`kt bsgntio c{ g
blpisneint gbinj{8 !?+ gz g }ltintkgd knpiztls ls zispkjis$ls jyssint knzysis$ kn jlnnijtkln rkta g pgdygtkln l`$ lsgzzizzeint l` jsiokt ls }si}g{eint skzhz gzzljkgtio rkta$gn iqkztknb jsiokt lcdkbgtkln8 ls !9+ `ls gn{ ltais }ys}lzioiieio tl ci g }isekzzkcdi }ys}lzi ynois tai @JSG8 . . .
!Y@ Nl. :;.+
Raisi DNSOEK intisio kntl gbsiieintz rkta siziddisz ral zldo si}lstz
binisgtio yzknb tai Gjjysknt ogtgcgzi$ DNSOEK siwyksio zyja siziddisz tl knjdyoi
kn tai siziddisz gbsiieintz rkta taiks ino%yzisz dgnbygbi si`dijtknb tai zgei
ynoisztgnoknb gno yzi siztskjtkln `lyno kn DNSOEKz gbsiieintz rkta ktz ino%
yzisz. !Y@ Nl. ?=.+ _akz kz kddyztsgtio c{ tai Zi}tiecis :$ 3==3 Gjjysknt Zispkjiz
Si%Ziddis Gbsiieint citriin KSC gno DNSOEKz }sioijizzls !tai Si%Ziddis
Gbsiieint+. !Y@ Nl. ?78 Zkeelnz Oijd. Iq. J.+ Kn tai Si%Ziddis Gbsiieint$
DNSOEK bsgntio KSC g dkjinzi tl ci gn gytalskvio si%ziddis l` Gjjysknt Zispkjiz
Jgzi 1677%jp%==?19%GB%GFR Oljyeint ?;7%7 @kdio =?,=?,73 ]gbi ; l` 72 ]gbi KO*677;;3
8/2/2019 Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of LexisNexis Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgement Doc 4
10/17
7
3
:
?
9
0
2
1
;
7=
77
73
7:
7?
79
70
7271
7;
3=
37
33
3:
3?
39
30
32
31
E]G KN ZY]]LS_ L@ DIQKZNIQKZ EZFJGZINL. JP77%==?19 GB !GFRq+
2
tl tai }skpgti knpiztkbgtkpi knoyzts{$ cgkd clnozein gno }a{zkjgd gzzit si}lzzizzkln
jle}gnkiz. !Y@ Nl. ?3.+ DNSOEK gno KSC iq}sizzd{ gbsiio kn ]gsgbsg}a ;
tagt6
YZI DKEK_G_KLNZ
Si%Ziddis z}ijk`kjgdd{ gbsiiz tagt Si%Ziddisz jyztleiszrkdd jle}d{ rkta tai `lddlrknb yzi dkektgtklnz ln tai yzil` tai Gjjysknt Zispkjiz6 !g+ nlt tl yzi tai GjjyskntZispkjiz `ls gn{ }isekttio }ys}lzi jlpisio c{ tai @gksJsiokt Si}lstknb Gjt !79 Y.Z.J. Zij. 7017 it ziw.+8!c+ nlt tl yzi tai Gjjysknt Zispkjiz ltais tagn }yszygnt tlgn iqji}tkln l` tai }skpgj{ }slpkzklnz l` tai Bsgee%Digja%Cdkdi{ Gjt !79 Y.Z.J. Zij. 01=7 it ziw.+8 !j+ nlt tlyzi tai Gjjysknt Zispkjiz kn pkldgtkln l` tai Oskpisz]skpgj{ ]sltijtkln Gjt !71 Y.Z.J. Zijtkln 3237 it ziw.+8gno !o+ zyja ltais dibkzdgtkln tagt eg{ ci ingjtio kn tai
`ytysi tagt XDNSOEKU oitisekniz dkektz tai yzi l` taiGjjysknt Zispkjiz c{ tai Jyztleisz.
!Ko.+
_ai KSC Si%Ziddis Gbsiieint }slpkoiz kn ]gsgbsg}a 2 tagt DNSOEK zagdd
zldid{ ci siz}lnzkcdi `ls tai }slpkzkln l` tai Gjjysknt Zispkji tl tai Si%Ziddis$ cyt
eghiz jdigs tagt KSC zagdd ci siz}lnzkcdi `ls gdd gjtkpktkiz gno jlztz gzzljkgtio
rkta egshitknb$ }slz}ijtknb$ wygdk`{knb jyztleisz$ zgdiz$ zgdiz zy}}lst gno
jlntsgjtknb rkta tai Jyztleisz. _ai Jyztleisz rkdd jlntsgjt oksijtd{ rkta Si%Ziddis. !Y@ Nl. ?:.+
_ai gbsiieint citriin KSC gno _ai Zgnhi{ @kse ynois rakja _ai Zgnhi{
@kse sgn tai zigsjaiz gno si}lstz oizjskcio gclpi iq}sizzd{ }slpkoiz6
@ls tai }ys}lziz l` takz Gbsiieint$ KSCzigsja kz nlt gjlnzyeis si}lstknb gbinj{$ gz tagt tise kz oi`knio kntai @JSG. Gjjlsoknbd{$ !G+ Jyztleis jistk`kiz tagt ktrkdd nlt yzi gn{ l` tai kn`lsegtkln kt sijikpiz taslybaKSCZigsja Zispkjiz `ls gn{ l` tai `lddlrknb }ys}lziz6!7+ kn iztgcdkzaknb g jlnzyeisz idkbkckdkt{ `ls jsiokt lsknzysgnji tl ci yzio }skegskd{ `ls }iszlngd$ `gekd{ lsalyzialdo }ys}lziz ls kn jlnnijtkln rkta tai sipkir lsjlddijtkln l` gn iqkztknb jsiokt gjjlynt l` g jlnzyeis8!3+ `ls ie}dl{eint }ys}lziz8 !:+ kn jlnnijtkln rkta goitisekngtkln l` g jlnzyeisz idkbkckdkt{ `ls g dkjinzi lsltais cini`kt bsgntio c{ g blpisneint gbinj{8 !?+ gz g
}ltintkgd knpiztls zispkjis$ ls jyssint knzysis$ knjlnnijtkln rkta g pgdygtkln l`$ ls gzzizzeint l` jsiokt ls
}si}g{eint skzhz gzzljkgtio rkta$ gn iqkztknb jsiokt
Jgzi 1677%jp%==?19%GB%GFR Oljyeint ?;7%7 @kdio =?,=?,73 ]gbi 7= l` 72 ]gbi KO*677;;:
8/2/2019 Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of LexisNexis Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgement Doc 4
11/17
7
3
:
?
9
0
2
1
;
7=
77
73
7:
7?
79
70
7271
7;
3=
37
33
3:
3?
39
30
32
31
E]G KN ZY]]LS_ L@ DIQKZNIQKZ EZFJGZINL. JP77%==?19 GB !GFRq+
1
lcdkbgtkln8 ls !9+ `ls gn{ ltais }ys}lzi oiieio tl ci g}isekzzkcdi }ys}lzi ynois tai @JSG
!Y@ Nl. ??.+
J. _ai Zigsjaiz gno Si}lstz Syn c{ tai Zgnhi{ @kse.DNSOEKz sijlsoz l` zigsjaiz gbgknzt tai Gjjysknt ogtgcgzi knokjgti tai
zyczjskcis ls siziddis c{ rakja tai zigsja rgz egoi. !Y@ Nl. ?;.+ Sijlsoz l`
zigsjaiz c{ siziddisz$ zyja gz KSC$ knokjgti rakja l` tai siziddisz jyztleisz
knktkgtio tai zigsja c{ tai siziddis. !Y@ Nl. 97.+ Kt kz tayz }lzzkcdi tl oitisekni
`sle DNSOEKz sijlsoz rakja zigsjaiz gno si}lstz KSC zldo tl _ai Zgnhi{ @kse.
!Y@ Nl. 93.+
G yzis KO tagt rgz gzzkbnio tl Nikd Zgnhi{ rgz yzio tl syn tai `lddlrknb
zigsjaiz rkta KSC6
!g+ dgzt ngei 5 Dkcisk gno `kszt ngei 5 Dkzg$ Csint !ayzcgno+ ls Pknjint
!ynhnlrn+. _ai zigsja t{}iz risi6 ]iszln$ Cyzknizz$ Jlyst$ Jkpkd$ Jskekngd$
Egsskgbi & Okplsji$ gno Jle}siainzkpi ]iszln. _ai zigsjaiz risi syn ln
Egsja 70$ 3==;8 G}skd 0$ 3==;8 G}skd 79$ 3==;8 G}skd 7;$ 3==;8 gno Eg{ 2$ 3==;
!Y@ Nl. 9:.+.!c+ dgzt ngei 5 Lztiddg gno `kszt ngei 5 Dkzg$ @sgnh !ayzcgno+ ls Egskl
!ynhnlrn+. _ai zigsja t{}iz risi6 ]iszln gno Jle}siainzkpi ]iszln. _ai
zigsjaiz risi syn ln G}skd 7:$ 3==;$ gno G}skd 7;$ 3==;. !Ko.+
Rakdi tai }lknt agz nl cigsknb ln tai siegknknb jdgkez$ kt kz rlsta nltknb
tagt tai KSC gjjlynt aido c{ tai _ai Zgnhi{ @kse oko nlt }isekt sitskipgd `sle tai
Gjjysknt ogtgcgzi l` `ydd zljkgd zijyskt{ nyecisz. !Y@ Nl. ?9.+ Nlni l` tai zigsja
sizydtz ls si}lstz sitysnio kn siz}lnzi tl tai zigsjaiz oizjskcio knjdyoio tai `ydd
zljkgd zijyskt{ nyecis l` ]dgkntk`` Dkcisk ls ]dgkntk`` Lztiddg.:
!Y@ Nl. ?1.+
:_akz eltkln kz cgzio ln tai `gjt tagt Gjjysknt si}lstz gsi nlt jlnzyeis
si}lstz$ gno zl tai zlysji `sle rakja Oi`inognt Zgnhi{ gddibiod{ lctgknio tai `yddzljkgd zijyskt{ nyecisz l` ]dgkntk``z Dkcisk gno Lztiddg kz kssidipgnt. Nlnitaidizz$
!@lltnlti jlntknyiz ln niqt }gbi.+
Jgzi 1677%jp%==?19%GB%GFR Oljyeint ?;7%7 @kdio =?,=?,73 ]gbi 77 l` 72 ]gbi KO*677;;?
8/2/2019 Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of LexisNexis Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgement Doc 4
12/17
7
3
:
?
9
0
2
1
;
7=
77
73
7:
7?
79
70
7271
7;
3=
37
33
3:
3?
39
30
32
31
E]G KN ZY]]LS_ L@ DIQKZNIQKZ EZFJGZINL. JP77%==?19 GB !GFRq+
;
KKK. DIBGD Z_GNOGSOZyeegs{ fyobeint kz g}}sl}skgti raisi$ sigoknb tai sijlso kn `gpls l` tai
nln%elpknb }gst{$ taisi kz nl binykni kzzyi gz tl gn{ egtiskgd `gjt$ gno tai
elpgnt kz intktdio tl fyobeint gz g egttis l` dgr. @io. S. Jkp. ]. 90!j+8 Jidltiq
Jls}. p. Jgtsitt$ ?22 Y.Z. :72$ :33%3: !7;10+. G okz}yti eyzt ci gz tl g egtiskgd
`gjt tl }sipint zyeegs{ fyobeint. Gnoiszln p. Dkcist{ Dlcc{$ Knj.$ ?22 Y.Z. 3?3$
3?1 !7;10+. Egtiskgd `gjtz gsi talzi tagt gsi nijizzgs{ tl tai }sll` ls oi`inzi l` g
jdgke$ gz oitiseknio c{ si`isinji tl zycztgntkpi dgr. Ko. G binykni kzzyi l`
egtiskgd `gjt iqkztz lnd{ k` zy``kjkint ipkoinji kz }sizintio zyja tagt g sigzlngcdi
`gjt `knois jlydo oijkoi kn `gpls l` tai nlnelpknb }gst{. Egtzyzaktg Idij. Knoyz.
Jl. p. VinktaSgokl Jls}.$ ?29 Y.Z. 92?$ 910 !7;10+. Gn{ gddibio kzzyi l` `gjt
eyzt ci binykni. Rain tai elpknb }gst{ agz jgsskio ktz cysoin ynois Sydi 90!j+$
ktz l}}lnint eyzt ol elsi tagn zke}d{ zalr tagt taisi kz zlei eitg}a{zkjgd olyct
gz tl tai egtiskgd `gjtz. Ko. Elsilpis$ tai }gst{ ziihknb tl l}}lzi zyeegs{
fyobeint eyzt ol elsi tagn kntsloyji zlei ipkoinji$ g zjkntkddg l` ipkoinji$
ls ipkoinji tagt kz nlt zkbnk`kjgntXd{U }slcgtkpi. Gnoiszln$ ?22 Y.Z. gt 3?2$ 3?;$
!@lltnlti jlntknyio `sle }sipklyz }gbi.+
tai Jlyst eg{ rkza tl hnlr raitais Es. Zgnhi{ lctgknio talzi nyecisz `sle gn{l` tai DiqkzNiqkz Oi`inogntz. Ai oko nlt. Nikd Zgnhi{ agz jln`kseio tagt ailctgknio tai zl%jgddio }iszlngd kointk`{knb kn`lsegtkln sibgsoknb Dkciskknjdyoknb ais `ydd Zljkgd Zijyskt{ nyecis gno ogti l` cksta oksijtd{ `sle jlystsijlso kn`lsegtkln$ gno nlt `sle lni l` tai DiqkzNiqkz Oi`inogntz. !Y@ Nlz. 9?%90.+ Gttgjaio gz Iqakckt G tl tai Oijdgsgtkln l` Nikd Zgnhi{ kn Zy}}lst l`Diqkzniqkz Oi`inogntz Eltkln `ls Zyeegs{ Fyobeint !Zgnhi{ Oijd.+ kz tai kztai Oijdgsgtkln l` Dkzg Dkcisk tagt rgz }ycdkjgdd{ `kdio c{ Ez. Dkcisk lnZi}tiecis 37$ 3==0$ kn g jskekngd gjtkln cslybat gbgknzt ais kn Zgn Cisngsoknl$Jgdk`lsnkg !Jgzi @RP =31===+. Kn ais oijdgsgtkln$ Ez. Dkcisk zit `lsta ais `ydd
ynsiogjtio zljkgd zijyskt{ nyecis$ ais ogti l` cksta$ ais egsskgbi akztls{ !gdlnbrkta egkoin ngeiz gno ais ayzcgnoz ngei+ gno zlei }lstkln l` ais jskekngdakztls{. Gooktklngdd{$ gttgjaio gz Iqakckt C tl tai Zgnhi{ Oijdgsgtkln gsioljyeintz tagt Es. Zgnhi{ lctgknio `sle tai `kdiz l` tai Y.Z. Cgnhsy}tj{ Jlyst kntai Jintsgd Okztskjt l` Jgdk`lsnkg. _alzi gsi jl}kiz l` jlyst oljyeintz rakja Ez.Dkcisk }ycdkjgdd{ `kdio kn g cgnhsy}tj{ gjtkln !Cgnhsy}tj{ ]itktkln Nl. 06=3%ch%331?9%]J+. _ai oljyeintz$ rakja gsi `kdio kn siogjtio `lse$ knjdyoio `yddynsiogjtio zljkgd zijyskt{ nyecisz sidgtio tl Ez. Dkcisk.
Jgzi 1677%jp%==?19%GB%GFR Oljyeint ?;7%7 @kdio =?,=?,73 ]gbi 73 l` 72 ]gbi KO*677;;9
8/2/2019 Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of LexisNexis Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgement Doc 4
13/17
7
3
:
?
9
0
2
1
;
7=
77
73
7:
7?
79
70
7271
7;
3=
37
33
3:
3?
39
30
32
31
E]G KN ZY]]LS_ L@ DIQKZNIQKZ EZFJGZINL. JP77%==?19 GB !GFRq+
7=
397. _ayz$ XrUaisi tai sijlso tghin gz g raldi jlydo nlt digo g sgtklngd tskis l`
`gjt tl `kno `ls tai nlnelpknb }gst{$ taisi kz nl binykni kzzyi `ls tskgd.
Egtzyzaktg$ ?29 Y.Z. gt 912 !kntisngd jktgtkln lekttio+. Zyeegs{ fyobeint kz
g}}sl}skgti raisi$ gz aisi$ tai nlnelpknb }gst{ `gkdz tl eghi g zy``kjkint zalrknb
ln gn izzintkgd idieint l` akz jgzi `ls rakja ai cigsz tai cysoin l` }sll`. Jidltiq$
?22 Y.Z. gt :33%3:.
_ai knktkgd cysoin kz ln tai elpknb }gst{ tl oielnztsgti gn gczinji l` g
binykni kzzyi l` egtiskgd `gjt. Ko. Lnji tagt cysoin kz eit$ tai nln%elpknb }gst{
eyzt }sloyji inlyba ipkoinji tl sicyt tagt jdgke gno jsigti g binykni kzzyi l`
egtiskgd gjt. Ko. Yndizz tai nln%elpknb }gst{ eiitz takz cysoin$ tai eltkln rkdd
ci bsgntio. Nkzzgn @ksi & Egskni Knz. Jl. p. @sktv Jl.$ 37= @.:o 7=;;$ 77=: !;ta
Jks. 3===+.
KP. DIBGD GSBYEIN__ai lnd{ siegknknb jgyziz l` gjtkln gbgknzt tai DiqkzNiqkz Oi`inogntz gsi
tai _rid`ta taslyba Zkqtiinta Jgyziz l` Gjtkln$ igja l` rakja kz cgzio iqjdyzkpid{
ln tai @JSG gno ktz Jgdk`lsnkg ztgti iwykpgdintz !tai JJSGG gno tai KJSGG+.
Cgzio y}ln tai ynjlntslpistio `gjtz zit `lsta gclpi$ tai DiqkzNiqkz Oi`inogntz gsiintktdio tl zyeegs{ fyobeint kn ktz `gpls `ls tai `lddlrknb sigzlnz.
G. _ai DiqkzNiqkz Oi`inogntz Gsi Intktdio tl Zyeegs{Fyobeint Cijgyzi _ai{ Gsi Nlt Jlnzyeis Si}lstknbGbinjkiz Pkz%%pkz tai ]dgkntk``z$ Gno Oko Nlt ]slpkoig Jlnzyeis Si}lst ln ]dgkntk``z.
Igja l` tai siegknknb jgyziz l` gjtkln gbgknzt tai DiqkzNiqkz Oi`inogntz kz
cgzio y}ln tai dibgd jagsgjtiskvgtkln l` tai si}lstz gt kzzyi kn takz dktkbgtkln gz
jlnzyeis si}lstz gz tagt tise kz oi`knio kn tai @JSG gno yzio kn tai JJSGG
gno tai KJSGG. _aisi gsi nl `gjtz tagt zy}}lst tagt jagsgjtiskvgtkln kt kz jdigs gz
g egttis l` dgr tagt tai Gjjysknt si}lstz gt kzzyi gsi nlt jlnzyeis si}lstz$ gno
tayz tai DiqkzNiqkz Oi`inogntz gsi intktdio tl zyeegs{ fyobeint gz tl igja l` tai
siegknknb jgyziz l` gjtkln gbgknzt taie.
Jgzi 1677%jp%==?19%GB%GFR Oljyeint ?;7%7 @kdio =?,=?,73 ]gbi 7: l` 72 ]gbi KO*677;;0
8/2/2019 Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of LexisNexis Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgement Doc 4
14/17
7
3
:
?
9
0
2
1
;
7=
77
73
7:
7?
79
70
7271
7;
3=
37
33
3:
3?
39
30
32
31
E]G KN ZY]]LS_ L@ DIQKZNIQKZ EZFJGZINL. JP77%==?19 GB !GFRq+
77
Raitais g jleeynkjgtkln jlnztktytiz g jlnzyeis si}lst kz blpisnio c{ tai
dgnbygbi l` tai ztgtyti. Zii Oynjgn p. Rgdhis$ 9:: Y.Z. 702$ 723 !3==7+ !Ri
cibkn$ gz gdrg{z$ rkta tai dgnbygbi l` tai ztgtyti.+. Ynois tai @JSG$ rkta ltais
dkektgtklnz nlt sidipgnt tl takz eltkln$
_ai tise jlnzyeis si}lst eignz gn{ rskttin$ lsgd$ ls ltaisjleeynkjgtkln l` gn{ kn`lsegtkln c{ g jlnzyeis si}lstknbgbinj{ cigsknb ln g jlnzyeisz jsiokt rlstaknizzXjsioktrlstaknizzU$ jsiokt ztgnoknb$ jsiokt jg}gjkt{$ jagsgjtis$binisgd si}ytgtkln$ }iszlngd jagsgjtiskztkjz$ ls eloi l` dkpknbrakja kz yzio ls iq}ijtio tl ci yzio ls jlddijtio kn raldi ls kn
}gst`ls tai }ys}lzi l` zispknb gz g `gjtls kn iztgcdkzaknb taijlnzyeisz idkbkckdkt{ ls
!G+ jsiokt ls knzysgnji tl ci yzio }skegskd{ `ls }iszlngd$`gekd{$ ls alyzialdo }ys}lziz8
!C+ ie}dl{eint }ys}lziz8 ls
!J+ gn{ ltais }ys}lzi gytalskvio ynois X79 Y.Z.J. 7017cU.
79 Y.Z.J. 7017g!o+!7+ !ie}agzkz gooio+.
Gz sijlbnkvio c{ takz Jlystz sijint sydknb ln tai Kntidkyz eltkln `ls
zyeegs{ fyobeint$ tai Nknta Jksjykt agz aido tagt kn`lsegtkln `ysnkzaio tl g takso
}gst{ rkdd ci jlnztsyio gz g jlnzyeis si}lst lnd{ k` tai `ysnkzais l` tai si}lst
iq}ijtz tai yzis tl yzi tai si}lst `ls g }ys}lzi }isekzzkcdi ynois tai @JSG$rktalyt sibgso tl tai ydtkegti }ys}lzi tl rakja tai si}lst kz gjtygdd{ }yt.
Jleigyq p. Cslrn & Rkddkgezln _lcgjjl Jl.$ ;79 @.3o 730?$ 732:%2? !;ta Jks.
7;;=+ !jktknbAigta p. Jsiokt Cysigy l` Zaiskogn$ 071 @.3o 0;:$ 0;0 !7=ta Jks.
7;1=++.
_ai @_Jz kntis}sitgtkln l` tai @JSG kz kn gjjlso.?
Kn ktz ztg`` si}lst$ tktdio
?= [igsz l` Iq}iskinji rkta tai @gks Jsiokt Si}lstknb Gjt$ tai @_J iq}dgknio
?Rkta tai }gzzgbi l` tai Jlnzyeis @kngnjkgd ]sltijtkln Gjt$ gytalskt{ tl
kzzyi kntis}sitkpi bykognji ynois tai @JSG tsgnz`issio `sle tai @_J tl taiJlnzyeis @kngnjkgd ]sltijtkln Cysigy !J@]C+. Gjjlsoknbd{$ ln Fyd{ 30$ 3=77$tai @_J sizjknoio gdd l` ktz jleeintgs{. _ai J@]C agz {it tl kzzyi jleeintgs{ynois tai @JSG. Sibgsodizz$ tai @_Jz }skls jleeintgs{ kz sidipgnt tl takz gjtklngno kz intksid{ jlnzkztint rkta tai dgr l` tai Nknta Jksjykt.
Jgzi 1677%jp%==?19%GB%GFR Oljyeint ?;7%7 @kdio =?,=?,73 ]gbi 7? l` 72 ]gbi KO*677;;2
8/2/2019 Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of LexisNexis Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgement Doc 4
15/17
7
3
:
?
9
0
2
1
;
7=
77
73
7:
7?
79
70
7271
7;
3=
37
33
3:
3?
39
30
32
31
E]G KN ZY]]LS_ L@ DIQKZNIQKZ EZFJGZINL. JP77%==?19 GB !GFRq+
73
tagt raisi tai `ysnkzais l` kn`lsegtkln6 agz tghin sigzlngcdi zti}z tl knzysi tagt
tai si}lst kz nlt yzio `ls Xg }isekzzkcdi }ys}lzi ynois tai @JSGU$ gno k` kt niktais
hnlrz l`$ nls jgn sigzlngcd{ gntkjk}gti zyja yzi$ tai si}lst zalydo nlt ci oiieio g
jlnzyeis si}lst c{ pkstyi l` yziz ci{lno tai intkt{"z jlntsld. @ioisgd _sgoi
Jleekzzkln$ ?= [igsz l` Iq}iskinji Rkta tai @gks Jsiokt Si}lstknb Gjt$ Fyd{
3=77$ gt 33$ gpgkdgcdi gt att}6,,rrr.`tj.blp,lz,3=77,=2,77=23=`jsgsi}lst.}o`. Kn
tagt zgei si}lst$ tai @_J oijdgsiz tagt XtUai intkt{ zy}}d{knb tai si}lst ekbat
iztgcdkza tagt kt oliz nlt sigzlngcd{ gntkjk}gti zyja yzi l` tai si}lst c{ siwyksknb
tai sijk}kint tl jistk`{ tagt tai si}lst rkdd nlt ci yzio tl oitisekni idkbkckdkt{ `ls g
}isekzzkcdi }ys}lzi$ c{ gyoktknb si}lst sijk}kintz `ls jle}dkgnji$ gno c{ tghknb
g}}sl}skgti gjtkln gbgknzt talzi ral pkldgti zyja jistk`kjgtkln. Ko. gt 33%3:.
Aisi$ taisi kz nl okz}yti tagt tai DiqkzNiqkz Oi`inogntz oko nlt gno jlydo
nlt agpi iq}ijtio tagt tai kn`lsegtkln gt kzzyi aisi jlydo agpi ciin yzio `ls g
}ys}lzi }isekzzkcdi ynois tai @JSG. Kn tai Siziddis Gbsiieint$ KSC rgz dkektio
tl ziddknb Gjjysknt Zispkjisz tl tai }skpgti knpiztkbgtkpi knoyzts{$ cgkd clnozein
gno }a{zkjgd gzzit si}lzzizzkln jle}gnkiz.9
!Y@ Nl. ?38 Zkeelnz Oijd. Iq. J.+
KSC rgz nlt gytalskvio tl zidd Gjjysknt Zispkjiz tl t{}kjgd jlnzyeis si}lst yziszzyja gz dinoisz$ knzysgnji ynoisrsktisz ls ie}dl{isz. !Y@ Nl. ?3.+ _ai
DiqkzNiqkz Oi`inogntz siwyksio KSC tl bit gbsiieintz `sle KSCz yzisz tagt tai{
rlydo nlt zl yzi si}lstz binisgtio sle tai Gjjysknt ogtgcgzi. !Y@ Nl. ?=.+
KSCz jlntsgjt rkta _ai Zgnhi{ @kse jlntgknio tagt siwyksio yzi siztskjtkln. !Y@
Nl. ??.+
9_ai `gjt tagt tai Zgnhi{ Oi`inogntz oko nlt lctgkn tai si}lstz `sle tai
DiqkzNiqkz Oi`inogntz cyt sgtais `sle KSC kz cgzkz gdlni tl bsgnt zyeegs{fyobeint kn `gpls l` tai DiqkzNiqkz Oi`inogntz ln tai _akstiinta gno @lystiintaJgyziz l` Gjtkln$ rakja gddibi tagt DiqkzNiqkz }slpkoio jsiokt si}lstz tlyngytalskvio takso }gstkiz rktalyt g }isekzzkcdi }ys}lzi kn pkldgtkln l` 79Y.Z.J. 7017c. !@GJ :?7%0?.+ Zknji tai DiqkzNiqkz Oi`inogntz oko nlt ziddgn{ si}lstz gt kzzyi kn tai jgzi tl tai Zgnhi{ Oi`inogntz$ gn{ lcdkbgtklnz tagt]dgkntk``z jdgke gslzi `sle tai zgdi l` tai si}lstz gslzi ln tai }gst l` KSC gz taisi}lstz zldi ziddis.
Jgzi 1677%jp%==?19%GB%GFR Oljyeint ?;7%7 @kdio =?,=?,73 ]gbi 79 l` 72 ]gbi KO*677;;1
8/2/2019 Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of LexisNexis Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgement Doc 4
16/17
7
3
:
?
9
0
2
1
;
7=
77
73
7:
7?
79
70
7271
7;
3=
37
33
3:
3?
39
30
32
31
E]G KN ZY]]LS_ L@ DIQKZNIQKZ EZFJGZINL. JP77%==?19 GB !GFRq+
7:
@ls talzi ral }ysjagzi si}lstz `sle DNSOEK$ tai Gjjysknt riczkti
knjdyoio gn iq}sizz rgsnknb tagt Gjjysknt si}lstz gsi nlt jlnzyeis si}lstz$ gno g
siwyksieint tagt gn{ oksijt }ysjagzis l` gn Gjjyskt si}lst tl iq}sizzd{ gbsii tl takz
tsigteint. !Y@ Nlz. :9$ :0.+ _akz kz jlnzkztint rkta tai aldoknb knEinoi p. Oyn
& Csgoztsiit$ Knj.$ 02= @.3o 73; !;ta Jks. 7;13+$ raisi tai jlyst aido tagt tai
JJSGG rgz nlt pkldgtio cijgyzi Oyn & Csgoztsiit siwyksiXUo tagt ktz zyczjskcisz
zkbn gn gbsiieint tagt tai{ rkdd yzi si}lstz ln cyzknizziz lnd{ gz g cgzkz `ls jsiokt
tl cyzknizziz kn taiks jg}gjktkiz gz zyja. Ko. gt 7:3.
Einoi rgz oijkoio ynois Jgdk`lsnkg dgr$ cyt ktz sigzlnknb agz ciin g}}dkio
tl tai @JSG gz ridd. Zii@lssizt p. Zijysio @ynoknb$ Knj.$ Nl. =9%J%7:3?$ 3==2
RD 17121 !I.O. Rkz. Fgn. 1$ 3==2+. Kn@lssizt$ tai okztskjt jlyst sydio tagt tai
si}lst gt kzzyi rgz nlt g jlnzyeis si}lst cijgyzi tai jlntsgjt citriin tai
oi`inognt gno tai jle}gn{ iq}sizzd{ }slpkoio tagt tai ogtg kn tai si}lst rgz nlt
jlddijtio `ls jsiokt }ys}lziz gno kz nlt kntinoio tl ci knokjgtkpi l` gn{ jlnzyeisz
jsiokt rlstaknizz$ jsiokt ztgnoknb$ jsiokt jg}gjkt{$ ls ltais jagsgjtiskztkjz dkztio kn
Zijtkln 0=:!o+ l` tai @gks Jsiokt Si}lstknb Gjt. Ko.$ gt 38 zii gdzl Jgpgdkisi p.
Cyshi$ 9= @.:o 7=::$ 7;;9 RD 7:033;$ gt : !9ta Jks. 7;;9+ !}is jyskge+ !taisidipgnt wyiztkln kn oitiseknknb raitais g jsiokt si}lst kz g jlnzyeis si}lst
`gddknb rktakn tai zjl}i l` tai @JSG kz raitais tai si}lst rgz }si}gsio `ls gn
inyeisgtio @JSG }ys}lzi+8K}}ldktl p. RNZ$ Knj.$ 10? @.3o ??=$ ??;%9= !2ta Jks.
7;11+ !zgei+.
Knoiio$ tai ynokz}ytio sidipgnt `gjtz aisi zalr elsi tagn fyzt tagt tai
DiqkzNiqkz Oi`inogntz oko nlt gno jlydo nlt agpi iq}ijtio tagt tai kn`lsegtkln gt
kzzyi aisi jlydo agpi ciin yzio `ls gn idkbkckdkt{ oitisekngtkln l` tai t{}i tagt
wygdk`kiz g si}lst gz g jlnzyeis si}lst. _ai ynokz}ytio `gjtz zalr tagt tai
}ysjagzis l` tai Gjjysknt si}lstz aisi !tai Zgnhi{ Oi`inogntz$ taslyba KSC+
niktais kntinoio tl nls yzio tai si}lstz kn g rg{ tagt rlydo eghi taie jlnzyeis
Jgzi 1677%jp%==?19%GB%GFR Oljyeint ?;7%7 @kdio =?,=?,73 ]gbi 70 l` 72 ]gbi KO*677;;;
8/2/2019 Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of LexisNexis Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgement Doc 4
17/17
7
3
:
?
9
0
2
1
;
7=
77
73
7:
7?
79
70
7271
7;
3=
37
33
3:
3?
39
30
32
31
E]G KN ZY]]LS_ L@ DIQKZNIQKZ EZFJGZI NL JP77%==?19 GB !GFRq+
7?
si}lstz. _ai zke}di sigdkt{ kz tagt ragtipis idzi takz jgzi ekbat ci gclyt$ kt agz
nltaknb ragtzlipis tl ol rkta tai tisez l` ls tai }ldkj{ ynoisd{knb tai @JSG.
JLNJDYZKLN
@ls igja l` tai sigzlnz zit `lsta gclpi$ tai DiqkzNiqkz Oi`inogntzsiz}ijt`ydd{ siwyizt tagt tai Jlyst bsgnt ktz Eltkln `ls Zyeegs{ Fyobeint gz tl gdd
siegknknb jdgkez gbgknzt taie.
Ogtio6 G}skd ?$ 3=73 FGEIZ @. EjJGCIELSSKZLN & @LISZ_ISDD]
C{6 ,z Fgeiz @. EjJgciFgeiz @. EjJgci
Gttlsni{z `ls Siio Idzipkis Knj.$DiqkzNiqkz Skzh gno Kn`lsegtklnGngd{tkjz Bsly} Knj.$ DiqkzNiqkz$Knj.$ DiqkzNiqkz Skzh Zldytklnz$ Knj.$DiqkzNiqkz Jalkji]lknt$ Knj.$DiqkzNiqkz Zikzknt$ Knj.$ o,c,gGjjysknt$ gno DiqkzNiqkz Bsly} Knj.
Jgzi 1677%jp%==?19%GB%GFR Oljyeint ?;7%7 @kdio =?,=?,73 ]gbi 72 l` 72 ]gbi KO*673===