1
The Center for Family and Demographic Research at Bowling Green State University has core funding from the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (R24HD050959-01). Family Demographic and Research Center for Bowling Green State University Marriage Intentions Among Never Married Japanese Individuals Sayaka Kawamura Department of Sociology Bowling Green State University [email protected] • Average ages at first marriage in Japan have been steadily increasing, and they are among the oldest in the world (Raymo & Iwasawa, 2008) • In 2008, average ages at first marriage were ▪ 30 years for men ▪ 29 years for women (Statistics Bureau, Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications, 2009) • Proportion of those who have never married has also been increasing (Raymo & Iwasawa, 2008) • About 26% of men and 14% of women ages 35-39 were never married in 2000 (Raymo & Iwasawa, 2008) • Overwhelming majorities of Japanese young single men and women expect to marry someday (e.g., Kaneko et al., 2008; Raymo & Iwasawa, 2008) • What factors are associated with marriage intentions among never married Japanese men and women? Background Positive Factors Associated with Marriage Intentions • Marriage has a symbolic importance as a marker of adulthood (Lebra, 1984; Yamada & Shirakawa, 2008) • Marriage and childbearing are strongly connected in Japan, with nonmarital births accounting for roughly 2% of all births (e.g., Lebra, 1984; Tsuya & Mason, 1995;Tsuya & Bumpass, 2004) Negative Factors Associated with Marriage Intentions • Women’s educational attainment has greatly improved (e.g., Raymo & Iwasawa, 2005) • Traditional gender relationships remain strong (e.g., Tsuya & Bumpass, 2004) • The specialization framework is supported in Japan; women’s economic resources are negatively associated with the transition to marriage (e.g., Ono, 2003, Raymo & Iwasawa, 2005) Hypotheses • H1: Positive attitudes toward the importance of marriage in life are positively associated with marriage intentions • H2: The desire to have a child is positively related to marriage intentions • H3: Gender and economic resources interact: ▪ Women’s economic resources are negatively associated with marriage intentions ▪ Men’s economic resources are positively related to marriage intentions • The Japan 2000 National Survey on Family and Economic Conditions (Tsuya, Bumpass, & Rindfuss, 2008, N = 4,482) • Never married men and women ages 20-39 (n = 1,793) • Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) regression models were estimated • Interactions between gender and economic resources were tested Data and Methods • A strong belief in the importance of marriage was positively related to marriage intentions • The desire to have a child was positively and strongly associated with marriage intentions • Women were more likely than men to intend to marry • There was no significant interaction between gender and economic resources • Age was negatively associated with marriage intentions • Factors associated with marriage intentions did not differ greatly for singles in 20s and 30s (results not shown) • Among women, those with college degrees were more likely to intend to marry, compared to those who have completed high school (result not shown) Findings Limitations • Never married individuals in their 40s were not included because of small sample sizes • Cross-sectional data did not allow tests of the causal order between some key factors (e.g., desire to have children, belief in importance of marriage, and marriage intentions) Conclusion • Japanese singles still report relatively strong marriage intentions • Women have stronger marriage intentions than men, regardless of the persistence of gendered domestic responsibilities for Japanese married women • A strong desire for parenthood is a very powerful factor in predicting marriage intentions among Japanese singles Figure 3 Educational Attainment and Employment Status Figure 2 Importance of Marriage and Desire to Have a Child 1=strongly disagree to 5=strongly agree 1=definitely not to 5=definitely yes Figure 1 Marriage Intentions “Do you want to get married someday?” 1=definitely not to 5=definitely yes Table 1 OLS Regression Models Predicting Marriage Intentions Independent Variables b SE Gender (women=1) 0.129 *** 0.04 Age (in years) -0.013 ** 0.004 Importance of marriage for men 0.072 *** 0.02 Importance of marriage for women 0.104 *** 0.02 Desires to have a child 0.460 *** 0.02 Dating status (1=yes) 0.270 *** 0.04 Educational attainment Junior high school 0.117 0.08 Professional training -0.005 0.05 Junior college 0.037 0.05 College or more 0.107 * 0.04 Other -0.005 0.21 Employment status Full-time -0.097 0.66 Not working -0.136 * 0.07 Other -0.363 ** 0.14 Income < 1 million Japanese yen -0.078 0.05 1-1.99 million Japanese yen -0.132 ** 0.05 4-5.99 million Japanese yen or more 0.008 0.06 Co-residence with parents (1 = yes) 0.019 0.04 Urban residence in childhood (1 = yes) -0.033 0.04 Current geographic size Large metropolitan cities -0.031 0.04 Small cities/towns -0.049 0.05 Rural areas -0.023 0.05 Gender role attitudes 0.009 0.02 Success in work (1=yes) 0.097 0.05 Spending time with family (1=yes) 0.186 *** 0.04 Intercept 1.882 *** 0.17 Adjusted R-square Source: The Japan 2000 National Survey on Family and Economic Conditions p < .10, * p < .05, ** p < .01, *** p < .001. Full Model 0.4399 s

Marriage Intentions Among Never Married Japanese … in predicting marriage intentions among Japanese singles Figure 3 Educational Attainment and Employment Status Figure 2

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

The Center for Family and Demographic Research at Bowling Green State University has core funding from the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (R24HD050959-01).

FamilyDemographic

and

ResearchCen

ter

for

Bowling Green State University

Marriage Intentions Among Never Married Japanese IndividualsSayaka KawamuraDepartment of SociologyBowling Green State [email protected]

•AverageagesatfirstmarriageinJapanhavebeensteadilyincreasing,andtheyareamongtheoldestintheworld(Raymo&Iwasawa,2008)

•In2008,averageagesatfirstmarriagewere▪30yearsformen▪29yearsforwomen

(StatisticsBureau,MinistryofInternalAffairsandCommunications,2009)•Proportionofthosewhohavenevermarriedhasalsobeenincreasing(Raymo&Iwasawa,2008)

•About26%ofmenand14%ofwomenages35-39werenevermarriedin2000(Raymo&Iwasawa,2008)

•OverwhelmingmajoritiesofJapaneseyoungsinglemenandwomenexpecttomarrysomeday(e.g.,Kanekoetal.,2008;Raymo&Iwasawa,2008)

•WhatfactorsareassociatedwithmarriageintentionsamongnevermarriedJapanesemenandwomen?

Background

Positive Factors Associated with Marriage Intentions•Marriagehasasymbolicimportanceasamarkerofadulthood(Lebra,1984;Yamada&Shirakawa,2008)

•MarriageandchildbearingarestronglyconnectedinJapan,withnonmaritalbirthsaccountingforroughly2%ofallbirths(e.g.,Lebra,1984;Tsuya&Mason,1995;Tsuya&Bumpass,2004)

Negative Factors Associated with Marriage Intentions•Women’seducationalattainmenthasgreatlyimproved(e.g.,Raymo&Iwasawa,2005)

•Traditionalgenderrelationshipsremainstrong(e.g.,Tsuya&Bumpass,2004)

•ThespecializationframeworkissupportedinJapan;women’seconomicresourcesarenegativelyassociatedwiththetransitiontomarriage(e.g.,Ono,2003,Raymo&Iwasawa,2005)

Hypotheses

•H1:Positiveattitudestowardtheimportanceofmarriageinlifearepositivelyassociatedwithmarriageintentions

•H2:Thedesiretohaveachildispositivelyrelatedtomarriageintentions•H3:Genderandeconomicresourcesinteract:▪Women’seconomicresourcesarenegativelyassociatedwith marriageintentions▪Men’seconomicresourcesarepositivelyrelatedtomarriage intentions

•TheJapan2000NationalSurveyonFamilyandEconomicConditions(Tsuya,Bumpass,&Rindfuss,2008,N=4,482)

•Nevermarriedmenandwomenages20-39(n=1,793)•OrdinaryLeastSquares(OLS)regressionmodelswereestimated•Interactionsbetweengenderandeconomicresourcesweretested

Data and Methods

•Astrongbeliefintheimportanceofmarriagewaspositivelyrelatedtomarriageintentions

•Thedesiretohaveachildwaspositivelyandstronglyassociatedwithmarriageintentions

•Womenweremorelikelythanmentointendtomarry•Therewasnosignificantinteractionbetweengenderandeconomicresources

•Agewasnegativelyassociatedwithmarriageintentions•Factorsassociatedwithmarriageintentionsdidnotdiffergreatlyforsinglesin20sand30s(resultsnotshown)

•Amongwomen,thosewithcollegedegreesweremore likelytointendtomarry,comparedtothosewhohavecompletedhighschool(resultnotshown)

Findings

Limitations•Nevermarriedindividualsintheir40swerenotincludedbecauseofsmallsamplesizes

•Cross-sectionaldatadidnotallowtestsofthecausalorderbetweensomekeyfactors(e.g.,desiretohavechildren,beliefinimportanceofmarriage,andmarriageintentions)

Conclusion•Japanesesinglesstillreportrelativelystrongmarriageintentions

•Womenhavestrongermarriageintentionsthanmen,regardlessofthepersistenceofgendereddomesticresponsibilitiesforJapanesemarriedwomen

•AstrongdesireforparenthoodisaverypowerfulfactorinpredictingmarriageintentionsamongJapanesesingles

Figure 3EducationalAttainmentandEmploymentStatus

Figure 2ImportanceofMarriageandDesiretoHaveaChild

1=strongly disagreeto5=strongly agree 1=definitely notto5=definitely yes

Figure 1MarriageIntentions“Doyouwanttogetmarriedsomeday?”

1=definitely notto5=definitely yes

Table 1OLSRegressionModelsPredictingMarriageIntentionsTable 1: OLS Regression Models Predicting on Marriage Intentions

Independent Variables b SE

Gender (women=1) 0.129 *** 0.04

Age (in years) -0.013 ** 0.004

Importance of marriage for men 0.072 *** 0.02

Importance of marriage for women 0.104 *** 0.02

Desires to have a child 0.460 *** 0.02

Dating status (1=yes) 0.270 *** 0.04

Educational attainment

Junior high school 0.117 0.08

Professional training -0.005 0.05

Junior college 0.037 0.05

College or more 0.107 * 0.04

Other -0.005 0.21

Employment status

Full-time -0.097 0.66

Not working -0.136 * 0.07

Other -0.363 ** 0.14

Income

< 1 mill ion Japanese yen -0.078 0.05

1-1.99 mill ion Japanese yen -0.132 ** 0.05

4-5.99 mill ion Japanese yen or more 0.008 0.06

Co-residence with parents (1 = yes) 0.019 0.04

Urban residence in childhood (1 = yes) -0.033 0.04

Current geographic size

Large metropolitan cities -0.031 0.04

Small cities/towns -0.049 0.05

Rural areas -0.023 0.05

Gender role attitudes 0.009 0.02

Success in work (1=yes) 0.097 ✝ 0.05

Spending time with family (1=yes) 0.186 *** 0.04

Intercept 1.882 *** 0.17

Adjusted R-square

Source: The Japan 2000 National Survey on Family and Economic Conditions

✝p < .10, *p < .05, **p < .01, ***p < .001.

Full Model

0.4399

s