Upload
amit-bhalla
View
222
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/6/2019 Managing People 1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/managing-people-1 1/12
INTRODUCTION
This report is about a company named Semco that was created back in 1950s. The
company was established to manufacture centrifuges for the vegetable oils industry.
With the passage of time, the company has advanced itself by diversifying its range
and investing both money and resources in other bus iness sectors, expandingmajorly into the servicing area by forming associations and alliances with the global
leaders.
After having fruitful results in the areas of environmental consultancy area, facilities
management, inventory services, mobile maintenance services and real estate
consultancy, the company has become a global leader in the area of industrial
equipment and solutions for postal as well as document management.
But all this success and a position of being a global leader has been acquired by a
company that follows non-traditional ideas as well as approaches of management.
The company has achieved all the success and recognition without the leadership of a charismatic CEO as the company does not believe in traditional hierarchy to
perform the processes of decision making or problem solving. All the employees of
the company are provided with complete freedom not to express their views and
opinions but also to choose the way they want to work.
This report is about the kinds of strategies and approaches being followed by the
company for so many years that do not go with the traditional ways of management.
But the company is still placed on the position of being a global leader in its specific
area of business.
1. SEMCO¶s RELIANCE OF CLASSICAL MANAGEMENT
One of the most significant among the activities that are being performed by the
human beings is managing. According to Koontz and Weihrich (1990), Management
can be defined as the process of designing as well as maintaining an atmosphere in
which the individuals, performing collectively as teams, effectively and efficiently in
accomplishing the selected objectives and aims. Some of the different aspects that
can be included in the definition of management are:-
- Managers performing managerial activitie s of planning, staffing, organizing,
controlling as well as leading.
- Management is applied to all the managers of different levels of organizational
hierarchy
- People having the management control aims at creating the surplus
- Management is associated with productivity i.e. efficiency and effectiveness
Thus from above mentioned aspects included, the management can be said as
developing the bureaucracy that helps in deriving its significance from the demand of
8/6/2019 Managing People 1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/managing-people-1 2/12
strategic planning, co-ordination, directing and controlling the large as well as
complicated process of decision making. Basically, the management involves
acquiring the managerial proficiency and effectiveness in the below mentioned
significant areas:-
- Problem solving
- Human resources management
- Administration
- Organizational leadership
Firstly, the approach of management is all about solving the problems and issues
that emerge while struggling to accomplish the goals and aims set by an
organization. The process of problem solving can be performed by recognizing the
problem, analysing the identified problem and executing of remedies to the problems
faced by the managers.
Secondly, the concept of administration involves performing the laid down processes
for executing, controlling, communicating, delegating and management of the crisis.
Thirdly, the approach of human resource management must be based on the
strategic incorporation of human resources, evaluation of the employees and
exchange of perceptions among the employees and shareholders.
Last but not the least, the concept of organizational leadership needs to be
developed in accordance with interpersonal relationship, self-encouragement to
perform better, teamwork, emotional strength and maturity for handling the
circumstances, individual reliability as well as general skills of management.
1.1 Necessity of Management in any Organization
The managers or leaders within an organization are provided with the responsibility
and control to take actions that will help the individuals to perform better and to make
their best contributions for achieving the aims and goals set as a team. The concept
of having a traditional management hierarchy has been followed and adopted by
majority of the organizations ranging from small scale to large scale . The situation an
organization surviving might differ from others but the concept of having an
organizational hierarchy of management has been followed from many decades and
by most of the companies till today.
The evolution of management as a necessary, a distinct and a leading establishmentis marked as a significant event in the social history. Management is supposed to
remain a dominant as well as a basic establishment that is particularly charged with
making the assets of a company productive i.e. with the role of organizing the
economic advancement, exhibiting the basic spirit of today¶s world.
Classical Organizational Theory
8/6/2019 Managing People 1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/managing-people-1 3/12
There are two major theories that come under this category of management theories
i.e. the bureaucratic theory proposed by Max Weber and administrative theory
proposed by Henri Fayol.
The theory proposed by Max Weber was based on a set of beliefs for an ideal
bureaucracy i.e.:-
- A rigid as well as official area of jurisdiction
- A firmly developed hierarchy of top and subordinate employees
- Management that depends on the written records
- Thorough as well as specialized training
- Management following stable and knowable rules and guidelines
Whereas the administrative theory proposed by Henry Fayol basically stresses on
the individual responsibilities of management at a much more granular level. In
simple words, the administrative theory of Henry Fayol is more directed towards the
different layers of management hierarchy. As proposed by fayol, the management of
an organization performs five different roles i.e. to predict and planning, organizing,
commanding, co-ordinating and controlling.
- Predicting and to develop plans is an act to forecast the future and perform
necessary actions in accordance with that.
- Organizing refers to developing the resources of an organization both human
assets as well as material resources.
- Commanding points out at keeping the actions and procedures of an
organization running
- Co-ordination refers to aligning as well a s harmonizing the efforts and actions
of the teams and groups within the organization- Controlling means that the activities mentioned above should be performed as
per the set rules and norms.
1.2 SEMCO¶s Reliance on Classical School of Management
Semco is an organization that deals in the areas of environmental consultancy area,
facilities management, inventory services, mobile maintenance services and real
estate consultancy. The company does not adopt or follow a traditional style of
management structure that includes different levels or layers of an organizational
hierarchy. The company has nearly 3000 employees working for it. In the recent
years, the company has gained huge success as well as recognition worldwide and
that too without any charismati c CEO at all.
The company has no traditional hierarchy present or existing within the organization
to perform processes like decision making or problem solving. Most of the decisions
of the company such as purchasing a new plant site or making an acquisition are
made by having a democratic voting method where all the employees can participate
and have their say. All the information whether it is related with the new
8/6/2019 Managing People 1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/managing-people-1 4/12
developments to be made or associated with the financial situation of the company is
made available to all the employees, thus promoting self control.
The company provides freedom to everyone who is working for the company to
participate and involve him or herself in every way. As said by Semler (CEO and
majority shareholder of the company), freedom is not an easy thing, rather it
introduces complex choices to be made. Still the office has no walls in order to
stimulate the process of information exchange.
There are four different circles included in the organizational structure of Semco
described as follows:-
- The innermost circle includes six counsellors serving as the executive team
and appointed as chairperson of the company every six months. Semler
having nearly 90 percent of the company¶s stake is one of these six
executives.
- The second circle includes the business unit managers or leaders. The main
role of these people is to act as a partner to the executives or counsellors.
- The third concentric circle includes the coordinates who perform the role of
being the first line mangers or superviso rs.
- The fourth circle includes everyone else working as an associate.
In addition to this, many different teams have been formed by the company such as
Nucleuses of Technology Innovation that perform as temporary project teams and
have no boss.
As mentioned above, the organizational structure of Semco is not exactly the same
as followed by majority of the companies, where there is one head and then the
team of executives lies. After that there are managers, supervisors and lower level
employees. Semco practices a way of structure that provides everyone with the
opportunities to get involved and participate in the core decisions of the company.
2. MOTIVATIONAL THEORIES & SEMCO
Motivation has always been a very popular subject to talk and discuss abou t
throughout history. But the area of motivation got treated with some kind of
seriousness when the time of Industrial Revolution arrived and it became an area of
concern and major interest to the business world. This was the first time that the
business took a systematic approach to develop an understanding that exhibits the
relationship between motivation and performance . There are three different
approaches that were developed at the time of industrial revolution as described
below:-
Classical approach
8/6/2019 Managing People 1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/managing-people-1 5/12
This is based on the central idea of controlling people like machines. This approach
mainly postulated that the people are basically lazy and should not be trusted. This
approach has basically originated from the negative perception of human behaviour.
This approach acquired dissatisfaction of the employees and led to the emergence
of new approach i.e. human relations approach.
Human relations approach
This approach has basically originated from the research, which revealed that the
organization is a social community or group where people are human beings that
have social as well as emotional needs.
This approach was unable to explain the relationship am ong different aspects and
teams, so led to the development of Systems approach.
Systems approach
This approach has basically originated from the lack of explanation provided by the
human relations approach regarding the interrelationship of different subgroups or
aspects.
Motivation and behaviour is complex. This approach stresses in the fact that the
whole is greater than the sum of individuals. This approach has gained a lot of
recognition because the other two approaches are too intense and have not taken
synergy into consideration.
The author has taken examples of two mostly recognized theories of motivation i.e.
Maslow¶s Hierarchy of Needs and Herzberg¶s Two Factor theory of motivation.
2.1 Motivational Theories
The author has mentioned tow of the widely recognized theories of motivation i.e.
Maslow¶s Hierarchy of Needs and Herzberg¶s Two Factor theory of motivation
described as follows:-
M aslow¶s H ierarchy of Needs
With experience it can be said that content theory is specifically r elevant in today¶s
business environment of fierce competition and increase in globalisation. A very well
recognized follower of the content theory is Abraham Maslow who put forward themotivational theory named as Maslow¶s Hierarchy of Needs. He stated that every
human being develops a hierarchy of needs ranging from the lower level to the
higher ones. These different levels or layers of hierarchy of needs become the
drivers or motivators during the state of deficiency. Once a lower level of hierarchy is
completely fulfilled, the tendency of an individual to climb up to the next level
increases i.e. to acquire higher level of needs. The concentration of an individual
increases once the lower set of needs are acquired. Maslow (1970) proposed a set
8/6/2019 Managing People 1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/managing-people-1 6/12
of five different levels in his theory of hierarchy of needs that are described as
follows:-
Psychological Needs
This level of hierarchy of needs is comprised of the most basic needs that are
required for survival including food, water, clothing, shelter and many more. Oncethese listed needs are satisfied, the tendency of fulfilling the higher set of needs
increases.
Safety or Security Needs
This includes the need for safety and developing a sense of security. People
exhibiting a high concern for this set of needs may select the roles that include less
risk. This set of needs include security as well as protection from both the physical
as well as emotional harm.
Social Needs
The tendency of the social needs arises once the lower set of needs is completely
fulfilled. This includes the need for affection, love, belonging and fulfilling the
relationship with the people associated.
Esteem Needs
Maslow believed that the individuals generally need to assess themselves in an
effective manner and they also desire that others should also value and respect
them. The self confidence of an individual grows when this set of needs is fulfilled.
People generally feel inferior, weak and worthless if these needs are not completely
met.
Self-actualization Needs
Once an individual acquired all the above mentioned four leve ls of hierarchy of
needs, the highest level of needs i.e. self actualization draws the attention. This set
of needs emphasize more on the problem areas that are associated with an
individual growth and the capability to have the peak experiences.
8/6/2019 Managing People 1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/managing-people-1 7/12
H erzberg Theory
A well known expert, Frederick Herzberg proposed a theory named as Two Factor
Theory. Herzberg (1987) described the relationship among the specific job
characteristics and motivation.
Motivation Factors
It includes the factors of job content such as responsibility, advancement,
accomplishment, recognition and the work itself. The level of job satisfaction arises
only if the motivators exist.
Hygiene Factors
It emphasizes more on the job related factors such as interpersonal relationships,
wages, working environment, policies of the company, technical supervision as well
as administration. The level of dissatisfaction increases if the hygiene factors are nottaken into consideration.
2.2 Relevance of above theories to SEMCO
SEMCO does not adopt or follow a traditional style of management structure that
includes different levels or layers of an organizational hierarchy. The company has
no traditional hierarchy present or existing within the organization to perform
processes like decision making or problem solving. The company provides freedom
to everyone who is working for the company to participate and involve him or herself
in every way. The company provides its employees with opportunities to participate
in the major decision making processes, thus encouraging them to perform better.Some of the motivational factors present in the SEMCO that are relevant to the
above mentioned theories are listed as follows: -
- Everyone associated and working in the company are provided with complete
freedom. This helps them in increasing the confidence as well as motivation
level of the employees. The employees are encouraged to participate in the
process of decision making and problem solving.
8/6/2019 Managing People 1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/managing-people-1 8/12
- The employees are provided with the freedom to decide their wages and
salaries. The salaries of an employee is made transparent to all other
employees, this everyone working in the company gets to know the pay
structure of each other. This helps in increasing the transparency among the
organization and enhancing the interpersonal relationships.
- The employees are also provided nearly 23 perc ent of the profits of thecompany and moreover this 23 percentage is also decided by the employees.
The members of teams of Technology Innovation gain royalties on the
accomplishment of the goals associated with their projects. This helps in
satisfying the motivational needs of the employees.
3. EMPOWERMENT
(http://humanresources.about.com/od/managementandleadership/tp/empowerment.htm )
The approach of empowerment has gained a lot of recognition and attention from the
researchers and experts. Empowerment can be said as the process that is
performed by the managers of enabling and helping the co-workers to accomplish
the set goals. The process of sharing the information is an essential requirement for
another aspect i.e. encouraging the employees to decentralize the decision making
and wider employee involvement. When the top management employees pass the
control down, the employees are provided with the control and power to build
decisions in the below mentioned areas: -
M anagement of Personnel
Employees can be offered with control to set their schedules of working, training and
vacations; establishment of the assignments to the employees and setting the
performance standards; conducting the performance appraisals of employees and
administer discipline; recruiting new employees etc.
Redesigning the Work Processes
Employees of an organization should be motivated to recognize the issues and
problems associated with the work processes and then looking for the reasons
behind such issues. The employees should be empowered to select and test the
solutions investigated, transforming the processes and examining the outcomes.
Many organizations have been using performance enhancement processes such as
continuous improvement methods, Total quality management, business process re -
engineering and six sigma etc.
General M anagement F unctions
Some of the general functions that are performed by the management can be
controlled by the employees themselves. This includes developing plans, controlling
the budgets (investments), interacting with the suppliers and other stakeholders and
performing the process of problem solving.
8/6/2019 Managing People 1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/managing-people-1 9/12
Benefits of Employee Empowerment
The working environment of an organization exhibits its values, objectives, vision as
well leadership style. The level of the empowerment of an employee within an
organization can be assessed by the kinds of decision making powers being
assigned to the employees and also from the working environment of a company
that motivates and accepts the new ideas and perceptions of its employees. Some of
the benefits of employee empowerment as described by Cichetti (2010) are: -
E m ployee Satisfaction
Providing appropriate powers to the employees is not only a wise management
approach but also a tool for increasing the satisfaction level among the workers. By
empowering the employees, a sense of ownership and belonging can be developed
among them that can help in yielding effective outcomes for the company. Based on
the responses of the employees a California based company Jupiter Networks has
been ranked number 6 out of 125 employers to be the best places to work in the
Silicon Valley. This exhibits the level of employee satisfaction achieved by the
company by empowering them.
Better c ustomer Service
Along with rewards and incentives from the management of a company, the
employees feel the need of acquiring a limited level of control and transparency to
solve the problems for delivering better customer services. As cited by Weiser
Security Services, when the employees are being motivated to participate in the
process of decision making, they feel more important and look forward in performing
better than before, thus increasing the productivity.
E m ployee Retention
By recognizing and acknowledging the efforts and perceptions of the employees, a
company can develop an environment of respect, honour and satisfaction. Many
experts have noticed that the companies following this kind of leadership style attract
the employees who are loyal and are willing to stay with the same company for
longer periods.
3.1 Relevance of Empowerment to SEMCO
The company provides freedom to everyone who is working for the company toparticipate and involve him or herself in every way. The company provides its
employees with opportunities to participate in the major decision making processes,
thus encouraging them to perform better. Some of the factors as cited in the case
study exhibiting the relevance of empowerment of employees to Semco are
described as follows:-
8/6/2019 Managing People 1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/managing-people-1 10/12
- The company provides its employees with the authority to decide whether
they want to work as full-time or part-time workers. There are many
employees who work under a contract term or for other firms as well. This
helps the company in encouraging the level of entrepreneurship among the
employees.
- The employees are provided with the freedom to decide their wages andsalaries. The salaries of an employee is made transparent to all other
employees, this everyone working in the company gets to know the pay
structure of each other. This helps in increasing the transparency among the
organization and enhancing the interpersonal relationships.
- The employees are provided with the control to identify the opportunities
available in the market. The strategies of the company are developed and
implemented in accordance with the opportunities recognized by the
employees.
- The employees are empowered to participate in the process of decision
making when the company plans to explore and expand its range of products
and services.
4. CASE STUDY OF SIMILAR COMPANY (GOOGLE)
The company that has similar kind of management style as that of Semco is Google.
Google is a USA based MNC that performs its operations in the areas of Internet
search, cloud computing and advertising technologies. The company develops many
internet based products and services and provide them to the customers globally.
The foundation of Google was laid down by Larry Page and Sergey Brin while both
of them were attending the Stanford University as PhD students.
The motto of the company is µDon¶t be evil¶ and the company has always operated
on it. This moral code helps in guiding the employees as Google only holds them
accountable to management to a certain extent. In order to keep the spirit of
innovation on which the company was founded, the employees are mainly
accountable to themselves. According to the surveys performed by Fortune
magazine, Google has been ranked as the fourth most admired companies to work
for. The major reason behind such recognition is the cross-functional organizational
structure of the company that has been maintained with the help of stellar leadership
and innovative techniques of management.
Features of Google¶s Organizational Structure
The employees of the company are provided with the freedom to spend 70 percent
of their time and assets on the on-going projects, 20 percent on the similar
assignments of their own choice and remaining 10 percent on any new project in
based on their desires. This ¶70-20-10¶ rule exhibits a managerial guideline, but it
also empowers the employees to take calculated risks. The executives of the
company motivate the employees as well as the managers to work together rather
8/6/2019 Managing People 1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/managing-people-1 11/12
than via any formal channels. The senior executives of Google work closely with co-
employees and other teams in a form of cross-functional structure of management.
The open communication approach followed by Google also contributes to improve
the working of the company as it is one of the most considerable features of the
company.
Instead of the company setting any goals, Google facili ties and supports its
employees to fulfil their objectives as set by themselves. The leaders of the company
are act as a source of inspiration for the employees and empower them with powers
of decision making. The goals are set and assessed by the employees of Google on
quarterly basis.
Effects of Google¶s Organizational Structure
The leadership style followed by the company allows its workforce to change the
factors of their jobs when required. Employees are motivated to lead themselves,
assess their performances and then suggest for actions to improve them. The
leaders at Google want their employees to think large and loud and have open
communication regarding their goals and plans to accomplish their visions. The
organizational structure of the company promotes the transparency as the
employees must witness everything and contribute to the decision making
processes. All the employees of the company are provided with an access to any
meeting going in the organization.
Benefits of Google¶s Organizational Structure
The methods and leadership style followed by Google helps the company to attract
the talented and skilled workers as the management of the company emphasizes on
controlling via shared vision. Google allows its workers to set as well as benchmark
their own performance standards. Thus, these open policies developed by Google
get translated into a unique organizational framework, thus inspiring good nature as
well as guidance.
5. REFERENCES
Aquinas, P. (2005), ³Principle of Management´, pp: 79 -86, Anmol Publication.
Burnes B. (2004), ³Managing Change: A Strategic Approach to OrganisationalDynamics´, 3
rdedition, London, Prentice Hall.
Carter, J. (2009), ³Managers Empowering Employees´, American Journal of
Business Ad ministration, pp: 39-44,Science Publications
Cichetti, J. (2010), ³Benefits of Employee Empowerment´, Sage Publications, CA.
8/6/2019 Managing People 1
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/managing-people-1 12/12
Freeman, R. & Stoner, J. (2003), ³Management´, 6th
Edition, Prentice-Hall, New
Delhi.
Herzberg, F. (1987), 'One more time: How do you motivate employees?', Harvard
Business Review, Vol. 65 Issue 5, p109-120.
Johnson G. & Scholes K. (2002), ³Exploring Corporate Strategy´, 6th Edition, London,Prentice Hall.
Koontz, H. & Weihrich, H. (1990), ³Essentials of Management´, 5th Edition, McGraw-
Hill.
Maslow, A. (1970), µMotivation and Personality¶, New York: Harper. pp. 236.
Osborne, D. & Plastrik, P. (2000), ³Employee Empowerment´, The Reinventor¶s
Fieldbook.
Tripathi, P. & Reddy, P. (2008), ³Principle of Managemen´, 4th Edition, Tata McGraw-
Hill, pp: 165-176.
Vise, D. (2005), ³The Google Story´, Bantam Dell.
www.google.com/coporate
www.semco.com
http://www.bnet.com/article/models-for-people-management-best-buy-google-ge-semco/237201