Upload
lenga
View
221
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1
Macau Gaming Sector Report
September 25, 2012
Angela Han Lee—Analyst
(852) 3698-6318
John Mulcahy—Head of Research
(852) 3698-6889
“A rising tide lifts all boats” - secular growth remains intact SECTOR DESERVES RE-RATING FOR SHIFT TO MASS-MARKET
We believe the Macau gaming sector investment story is shifting from its VIP orientation
to a mass-market emphasis. As we believe the mass market is driven by supply, the
53% increase in hotel supply by 2015/2016 is a cornerstone of our view.
On the demand side, only 23% of China’s population currently qualifies for the Individual
Visit Scheme (IVS) to Hong Kong and Macau, and the pent-up demand from even a
modest proportion will underwrite mass-market growth. Further relaxation in visa policy
should unlock substantial growth in visitor arrivals to Macau.
To translate into fundamentals, we project the mass-market to grow at a 31.4% CAGR
during 2011-2014, while VIP gaming is expected to grow at a 10.8% CAGR. As a whole,
we forecast Macau’s gross gaming revenue (GGR) to grow at a 16.5% CAGR.
As mass-market produces c.3.7 times EBITDA margin than the VIP segment, the shift
will become visible in earnings, which we expect to enjoy CAGR of 37.7% from 2011 to
2014.
MARKET CONCERN IS OVERDONE AND UNDER-ESTIMATES MASS-MARKET PHE-
NOMENON
The market is estimating 12.8% year-on-year (YoY) growth in GRR in 2013 and 11.4%
in 2014, which we believe is too pessimistic. Compared to the market consensus, our
GGR estimate is 8.8% higher for 2013 at HK$333.6bn and 10.2% higher for 2014 at
HK$376.2bn.
Our earnings projections are similarly more optimistic: we expect net profit of six major
gaming operators to reach HK$58.7bn and HK$74.6bn in 2013 and 2014, which is
30.7% and 42.3% above the market consensus.
The consensus concern is overdone and the sector is regaining positive momentum: we
expect September GGR growth to be c.20% vs. 5.5% in August, inducing more confi-
dence into the sector.
TIME TO CHASE DEEP VALUE PLAYERS WITH NEAR-TERM CATALYSTS
Galaxy Entertainment (GEG) is our top pick for its consistently outperforming operating
figures.
Valuation laggards MGM China and SJM are also recommended. They are trading at
7.2% and 8.3% yield with net cash providing limited downside risk, while their upcoming
Cotai projects leave room for upside.
Wynn Macau also offers good value for its strong brand name and good operating effi-
ciency, and its YTD price underperformance provides scope for short-term catch-up in
valuation.
Figure 1: Coverage Summary
Target Upside
Ticker Rating Price Potential
(HK$) (%)
0880 HK BUY 18.30 12.1
1928 HK HOLD 29.20 2.1
0027 HK BUY 27.60 10.8
1128 HK BUY 23.90 14.9
6883 HK HOLD 35.20 5.7
2282 HK BUY 14.90 13.6
2013
Ticker PER EV/EBITDA Yield
(x) (x) (%)
0880 HK 9.1 6.7 8.3
1928 HK 11.1 10.1 6.3
0027 HK 11.7 9.4 -
1128 HK 12.8 10.1 4.8
6883 HK 11.9 8.1 -
2282 HK 8.4 7.0 7.2
Source: Bloomberg, CGIHK Research
September 25, 2012
Macau Gaming Sector
2
Figure 2: YTD share price performance
Source: Bloomberg, CGIHK Research, As of September 24, 2012
Figure 3: Comparable valuation table
Source: Bloomberg, CGIHK Research, As of September 24, 2012
Figure 4: Market share movement during the past five years
Source: Macau Business, CGIHK Research
3
Industry background
Macau, Las Vegas of the Orient, is the world’s largest gaming city with GGR of
MOP267.9bn in 2011, five times that of the Vegas Strip. One of the differences from
Las Vegas is Macau’s revenue composition, which is largely biased towards VIP table
gaming (2011: 73.2%, 1H12: 70.5%), followed by mass market table gaming and slot
machines. Baccarat is the most popular game in Macau.
Macau’s gambling history originates from 1847, when the Portuguese government
legalized gambling to generate more revenues from its colony. 90 years later, the gov-
ernment granted the monopoly casino concession to the Tai Xing Company in 1937,
which was taken over by Sociedade de Turismo e Diversoes de Macau (STDM) in
1962. STDM was then owned by Stanley Ho, Teddy Ip, Ip Hon and Henry Fok. The
company is now controlled by the Ho family.
The major breakthrough to create the modern Macau gaming sector occurred in 2001,
with the partial deregulation of the industry, when gaming concessions and sub-
concessions were granted to six operators, including a number of companies tracing
their origins to STDM. The extension of additional gaming rights has dramatically
transformed Macau from a VIP-focused gaming center to a more diverse location with
attractions for mass-market gamblers and tourists. With more mega-sized integrated
gaming resorts to be built in Macau, we believe mass market gaming will flourish,
supported by continuously increasing visitor arrivals from China - more cities under
the individual visit scheme (IVS) and infrastructure improvement - and increasing
disposable income (2007-2011 11.4% CAGR in urban households).
Figure 5: Macau gaming concessionaires and sub-concessionaires
Source: MGM China IPO Prospectus, CGIHK Research
Strong growth in mass market along
with increasing visitor arrivals due to:
1) more cities to be covered by IVS
2) Infrastructure improvement
4
Figure 6: Location of 35 casinos in Macau, operated by the six licensees
Source: DICJ, Google Earth, CGIHK Research
6
Market is cautious about the ever-growing Macau,
but we see such concern is overdone
In Macau, supply drives demand. Sands Macao, Wynn Macau, the Venetian Macao
and Galaxy Macau were milestones in the evolution of the Macau gaming industry. A
transformation in visitor arrivals and GGR followed the opening of new casinos. We
believe this was not merely good timing or coincidence, but the execution of a meticu-
lous strategy which led to sustained growth in gaming revenue. During 2000-2011
visitor arrivals to Macau grew at 11.8% CAGR and GGR increased much faster at
32.7% CAGR, or 17-fold to MOP268bn, which was five times of Macau’s nominal
GDP in 2000. Significant demand is created by supply of new casinos with diversified
service, in our view, and steady casino supply in long term in Cotai should continue
driving demand. This is not supply-side theory, but the reality of infrastructure and
capacity needed to absorb a continuously expanding volume of visitors. Without ac-
commodation, or distractions to attract them, visitors would not choose Macau as a
destination. The gaming industry has recognized that it must create capacity/supply so
that increasing numbers of Chinese tourists are attracted.
Opening of new casinos historically
drove visitor arrivals and GGR, and...
...Macau’s GGR in 2011 was 5x Macau’s
nominal GDP in 2000.
Supply constraint should be eased, driving demand
Figure 7: New casino openings drive visitor arrivals Figure 8: Macau GGR surges with increased supply
Source: DSEC, CGIHK Research Source: DICJ, CGIHK Research
7
Macau is suffering from supply constraints. Macau’s accommodation industry is
running at an unsustainably high occupancy rate, compared with other Asian regions
except Hong Kong and Singapore. Average hotel occupancy rate in 2011 was at a
historic high of 84.1%, while affordably good four-star and three-star hotels generated
even higher occupancy of 89.2% and 86.0%. Hotels in Macau are running at almost
100% occupancy in peak periods such as the Chinese New Year season, imposing a
cap on visitor arrivals and length of stay. Occupancy rates showed a sign of easing to
83.3% and 80% in 1Q12 and 2Q12, with c.10% increased hotel room supply from the
opening of Sands Cotai Central (SCC) Phase 1. We believe a c.7.5% increase in
rooms with Sands Cotai Central Phase 2 opening this month (September) will further
ease Macau’s occupancy level, but still not sufficient to cater to increasing visitor arri-
vals during peak seasons.
Hotel occupancy rate in Macau is one
of the highest, proving supply con-
straint.
Figure 9: Room supply and occupancy rate Figure 10: Regional hotel occupancy rates
Source: DSEC, CGIHK Research Source: DSEC, Wind, Bloomberg, CGIHK Research
More hotel rooms to be built in medium term. Several projects are in the pipeline to
be completed by 2016, which will add c.14,250 new rooms in Cotai. It will effectively
increase the hotel rooms supply by 53% from the current level of 26,800 rooms, fur-
ther easing the pressure in accommodating incoming tourists in Macau and effectively
enlarging their length of stay from the current low level of 1.3 nights. We believe that it
will be beneficial to the growth of the high-margin mass market gaming.
Hotel room supply will increase by 53%
with new properties opening in
2015/2016.
Fig
ure
11
: C
ota
i w
ith e
xis
ting a
nd in p
ipelin
e c
asin
os
Fig
ure
12
:Sch
ed
ule
of u
pcom
ing h
ote
ls/r
esort
s
Sourc
e:
Go
ogle
Eart
h,
CG
IHK
Researc
h
Sourc
e: C
om
pa
ny, C
GIH
K R
ese
arc
h
9
We are more optimistic about the saturation level than the market. The market is
concerned about the decelerating growth in visitor arrivals from China to Macau. Visi-
tor arrivals from China as a proportion of total visitor arrivals to Macau has been grow-
ing in the past five years, from 50.6% in 2008 to 57.7% in 2011, and further 59.7% in
1H12. Therefore, visitor arrivals from China are viewed as a key indicator of demand
for the Macau gaming sector. The stagnant growth of China visitor arrivals (1.8% YoY
in June, -0.3% YoY in July) is raising concerns, but the low penetration level will re-
main the main story of the Macau gaming sector. We believe the market’s concern is
overdone for the reasons discussed below.
China’s outbound departure to population (DTP) ratio has more potential up-
side. China’s outbound tourism is still at the exploratory stage, and we believe it will
continue growing steadily with the Chinese population’s increasing disposable income.
Our comparison of 30 countries’ DTP ratio suggests it is positively correlated to GDP
per capita adjusted to purchasing power parity. Therefore, with our belief that China’s
economy will continue growing at a faster pace than the population, we expect the
current DTP ratio (2010: 4.3%) has much room to improve with an increasing propor-
tion of middle-income class in China and more outbound trips will be made.
China’s DTP is still low at 4.3% in 2010,
which should increase along with its
GDP growth.
Demand side is not fully revealed; long journey to saturation
Figure 13: DTP vs. ppp GDP per capita in 2010
Source: World Bank, Wind, CGIHK Research
10
China’s DTP ratio to Macau is rising steadily. We believe Hong Kong and Macau
are the main beneficiaries of rising outbound tourism from China. Hong Kong and Ma-
cau are the main destinations for first-time outbound trippers, for the geographical and
cultural proximity, and Hong Kong and Macau respectively accounted for 40% and
28% of total departures to international destinations in China in 2011. The trend in the
number of trips is showing continuing improvement, proven by consistently increasing
DTP ratio for both Hong Kong and Macau from China during 2002-2011. In our view,
first-time travellers will support a continued increase in the DTP ratio to Hong Kong
and Macau, while re-visitors will be a further key to drive the Macau gaming industry in
the future.
Hong Kong and Macau are the first
destinations for China’s outbound tour-
ists.
Further easing visa policy should unlock more tourist flow. Only 300m Chinese
citizens are covered under the individual visit scheme (IVS) to Hong Kong and Macau.
As highlighted in the map (in purple), some tier-2 cities are not under IVS yet and only
23% of population are allowed to visit individually. With tightening economic and politi-
cal ties between China, Hong Kong and Macau, we do not expect further tightening
visa policies. But we do see considerable room for improvement in the future, when
the central government allows citizens of all tier-2 cities and wealthy tier-3 cities to
apply for visas directly without involving travel agencies.
Only 23% of Chinese citizens are under
IVS, and we expect further travel eas-
ing policy in long term.
Figure 14: China’s outbound departures Figure 15: China’s DTP to major destinations
Source: China National Tourism Administration, CGIHK Research Source: China National Tourism Administration, CGIHK Research
11
The Chinese government is relaxing the visa
application process in six cities (four tier-1
cities, Tianjin and Chongqing). Non-local
residents of those cities can apply visa or
passport directly in cities where they reside,
while previously they had to go back to their
original hometown, where they had Hukou
(residency permit) to make application. It will
save money and time for non-local residents
to get travel documents, with a positive effect
on tourist inflow to Macau and on gaming
revenue. Although the new policy has not yet
been activated, we see it as government’s
message to encourage interaction between
China, Hong Kong and Macau, supporting
our view of continuing visa policy relaxation.
Improving infrastructure should help mass market. With the railway system be-
coming more sophisticated in China, we expect traveling convenience will be en-
hanced. Guangzhou-Zhuhai Intercity Rail Transit’s Zhuhai Station will be available
from December 2012. It is situated next to the Gongbei border gate to Macau. We
believe this will shorten the traveling time from Guangzhou to Macau from 90min by
bus to 45min by train, and Guangzhou is one of China’s main transportation hubs.
In our view, the main beneficiary to the Macau gaming sector is the mass market seg-
ment. With lower time and travel cost from inner provinces to Zhuhai/Macau, we ex-
pect to see increases in visitor arrivals to Macau, along with improving connectivity of
Macau to other cities in China. Especially, it would effectively encourage re-visitors to
Macau, who have more sophisticated knowledge of gambling, directly contributing to
the growth of mass market gaming.
Improving infrastructure has positive
impact on mass market gaming, en-
couraging re-visitors to travel to Ma-
cau.
Figure 16: Regions and cities under IVS
Source: Google Earth, CGIHK Research
12
In the longer term, Macau is building a light rail transit (LRT) system covering the Ma-
cau Peninsula, Taipa and Cotai, linking all tourist attractions and major casinos in Ma-
cau. It is scheduled to launch in late 2015, and one of its terminals will be Gongbei
border gate, facilitating inbound tourists from Zhuhai. When all these railways are con-
nected we believe Macau will be capable of accommodating increasing numbers of
tourists. It confirms our view that Macau has much work to do on the supply side to
unlock the potential demand.
Macau’s LRT Phase 1 will be completed
in late 2015, adjacent to Gongbei bor-
der gate.
Figure 17: High speed railway network in China and Zhuhai Station Figure 18: Macau LRT route map (planned)
Source: SJM Presentation, CGIHK Research Source: DICJ, Google Earth, CGIHK Research
13
Still a cyclical play?
Historically, Macau gaming has been cyclical. The in-
dustry is commonly considered to be recession-proof, be-
cause gambling is an addictive habit and not income-
elastic. There is a presumption that the current weak eco-
nomic situation should have no impact on Macau and that
Macau’s current slow growth should be attributed to other
reasons, such as saturation.
We disagree with this argument. Data for the last five years
suggests the growth of the Macau gaming sector is posi-
tively correlated to the China’s GDP growth
(correlation=0.60). We believe the relatively mild GGR
growth in 2012 is a reflection of the slower growth in China,
and that it should accelerate with the recovery of the econ-
omy.
Figure 19: YoY growth of Macau GGR and China GDP
Source: DICJ, Wind, CGIHK Research
VIP gaming segment is cyclical. The VIP gaming segment is making a c.70% contri-
bution to the Macau gaming sector, and its volatile characteristics influence the cycli-
cality of the whole Macau gaming sector. For the same five-year period, the VIP seg-
ment YoY growth had a higher correlation of 0.63 to China GDP growth than the
whole Macau sector growth.
VIP gaming growth is positively corre-
lated to China’s GDP growth because:
Figure 20: YoY growth of VIP GGR and China GDP Figure 21: YoY growth of VIP GGR and Guangdong export
Source: DICJ, Wind, CGIHK Research Source: DICJ, Wind, CGIHK Research
14
The VIP gaming segment is mainly driven by Chinese VIP patrons, half of whom are
from Guangdong Province. It is estimated that most players from Guangdong Prov-
ince are business owners exporting manufactured products. Their time and inclination
to gamble is logically affected by their business performance. As a result, VIP gaming
growth and Guangdong export growth showed an even higher positive correlation of
0.75.
During hard times junket operators tend to be more careful in extending credit to VIP
players. VIP players play on credit in Macau and repay junket operators after they
return home. With a deteriorating economic environment and tight liquidity, it is to be
expected that junket operators would tighten their credit policy.
We believe the current slowdown in the VIP gaming segment is compounded by other
factors. A considerable portion (c.30%) of VIP players are government officials and
SOE managers. We consider they are seeking a low profile during the sensitive gov-
ernment transition period and demand from this segment could pick up late this year
or in 2013, when the political transition is completed.
1) Most VIP patrons are business
owners …
2) Junket operators tighten credit
policy for safer play …
3) Some SOE managers and officials
become more cautious during tran-
sition period.
Mass market gaming is more resilient to economic cycles. Its growth has a much
weaker correlation with China’s GDP growth (correlation=0.38), while it showed
stronger positive relationship with mainland visitor arrivals to Macau
(correlation=0.54). We believe the number could be even higher if the most recent
growth numbers were factored in, pointing to a significant boom after several integrat-
ed casinos opened in 2007.
Mass market is less correlated to GDP
growth but visitor arrivals.
Figure 22: YoY growth of mass market GGR and China GDP Figure 22: YoY growth of mass market GGR and China visitor arrivals
Source: DICJ, Wind, CGIHK Research Source: DICJ, DSEC, CGIHK Research
15
The resilience to the economic cycle can be easily explained: the trip to Hong Kong
and Macau is typically planned for a long time and budgets are mostly from savings.
The traveling cost to Hong Kong and Macau is generally considered not expensive
and people believe they can recover their transportation cost by purchasing luxury or
daily products at lower prices than in China. Therefore, we believe the decision to
travel to Macau is not directly influenced by short-term fears of reduced income, ex-
plaining why the mass gaming market has been growing fast at 43.3% and 35.1% in
1Q12 and 2Q12, while VIP gaming only grew at 23.7% and 7.5% YoY.
People’s trip plan to Hong Kong and
Macau is less sensitive to economic
environment.
The sector will become less cyclical in the future. So far, the VIP gaming segment
has been the Macau gaming sector’s main growth driver, but the picture is changing
gradually. From 4Q11, the mass market gaming segment delivered faster growth than
the VIP gaming segment due to 1) VIP segment was impacted by a weaker economy,
and 2) positive momentum in mass market gaming sustained with more visitor inflows
to mega integrated resorts such as Galaxy Macau. With faster growth in the latter we
expect increasing contribution from more cycle-resistant mass market gaming seg-
ment, and the whole sector will be less vulnerable to economic cycles. The planned
new integrated resorts in Cotai, to be commissioned in 2015-2016, will attract more
visitor arrivals to those properties, driving up the sector’s growth in the long term.
Contribution from more resilient mass
market segment is increasing.
Figure 23: YoY growth of Macau GGR and China GDP
Source: DICJ, CGIHK Research
16
VIP gaming recovery is happening. We expect the bottoming of China’s economy
will leave scope for the VIP gaming segment to regain growth momentum soon, given
the trend among international and domestic governments to kick-start their econo-
mies. China has taken some fiscal and monetary action, but more is expected after
the political transition is completed. Junket operators are normalizing their credit poli-
cies based on expectations of further easing policies, providing more liquidity to VIP
gamblers. VIP gaming’s pick-up in the last few weeks has already been confirmed by
some casino operators, and we expect the positive trend to be sustained, with full
recovery next year when the political and economic situations stabilise.
Limited risk from putative regional competitors. Several regions are trying to de-
velop casino businesses in attempts to replicate Macau’s gaming success. But we see
that it is unlikely to happen for the following reasons:
Matsu Islands (Taiwan): Geographical proximity from China (1.5hour from Fuzhou
on ferry) and famous for good natural environment. Currently no infrastructure or
reputation to attract gamblers. Still needs c.5 years to build a casino.
Vladivostok (Russia): Geographical proximity (1-1.5hour flight from Haerbin), and
easier to hire Chinese-speaking labor. Still under reviewing period and as yet no
firm plan. Extreme weather conditions and no tourist infrastructure are disad-
vantages.
Singapore, Cambodia and Philippines: Relatively far from Greater China, and
normally catering to wealthy individuals in South-East Asia such as Singapore,
Malaysia and Indonesia.
Korea and Japan: non-Chinese speaking would be a disadvantage in catering to
the needs of Chinese gamblers.
We are bullish on the sector’s long-term prospects, and valuation is attractive.
All Macau gaming companies are now profitable after huge capital expenditure for
casino property construction, and PER valuation methodology is gaining more traction
than EV/EBITDA multiples. We also take PER as our primary metric for valuation
combined with DCF methodology. The Macau gaming sector is trading at 11.1x PER
on our 2013 forecast, at the historically low range valuation level, despite our view that
growth potential remains intact with 37.7% earnings CAGR during 2011-2014. Gaming
companies are also offering relatively high yield of 4.8% on average, providing down-
side protection. In an environment of concerns about long-term growth stability, we
see upside risk based on likely earnings upgrades, and we recommend investors ac-
cumulate to benefit from eventual re-rating.
Some casino operators confirmed VIP
gaming segment is picking up.
Macau is still the king in Asia as a gam-
bling center; competitiveness of other
regions is limited.
Secular growth in long term and the
sector valuation is attractive.
Recommendation
17
Galaxy Entertainment [0027.HK, TP: HK$27.60, BUY] GEG’s execution capability was well proven by the successful opening of Galaxy Ma-
cau and its consistently outperforming StarWorld compared with other Macau Penin-
sula casinos. We like the company for its strong operation and large landbank, already
approved for casino building. Its large revenue exposure to VIP gaming implies more
room for margin improvement in the future during the transition from a VIP-centric
model to mass-market focus. Given its strong earnings growth, the 11.7x 2013 PER
offers more upside potential.
SJM [0880.HK, TP: HK$18.30, BUY] Despite its loss in market share, Macau gaming doyen Dr. Stanley Ho’s SJM is still the
market leader with the longest gaming history in Macau. Its self-operated casinos are
outperforming the market, while third-party casinos are underperforming. The contri-
bution from self-operated casinos will increase, with another casino to be built in Cotai
and SJM can relocate gaming tables from third-party casinos to self-operated casinos.
It is also considering an application for Parcels 7&8 in Cotai in the future. Its 9.1x
PER, 8.3% yield and strong cash position limits the downside, and its market-leading
position qualifies SJM as a Macau proxy and income source from dividends.
MGM China [2282.HK, TP: HK$14.90, BUY] MGM is “small but beautiful”. Although the market has discounted the stock consist-
ently after its IPO in June 2011, we believe this is not justified. It has the smallest mar-
ket share but it generates good returns. The market should realize this superior earn-
ings track record in due course and the expected Cotai land approval should spark a
re-rating. It is also trading as cheaply as SJM at 8.4x PER and 7.2% yield.
Top pick of the sector
Largest operator with high yield
Small but high operating efficiency,
decent yield
18
Wynn Macau [1128.HK, TP: HK$23.90, BUY] Good operator with unquestionable brand name. It is preferred by VIP and premium
mass gamblers. Its earnings underperformed the sector recently but we see upside in
its Cotai property opening in 2016. It is the underperformer in terms of YTD share
price movement, although it has historically been trading at premium to its peers with
the highest ROE. We expect the company will catch up to enjoy sector re-rating in
near term. The company is trading at 12.8x PER and 4.8% yield.
Sands China [1928.HK, TP: HK$29.20, HOLD] With the largest exposure to the mass-market segment, Sands China will be the first
beneficiary of our mass market growth story. But it is trading at 11.1x PER, in line with
the industry average, while we doubt SCC can become as iconic as Galaxy Macau,
due to the lack of speciality either design or service: it is large but not special. Current
valuation appears fair, in our view, while the next catalyst will be the Parcel 3 opening
– its success depending on the uniqueness of its property.
Melco Crown [6883.HK, MPEL.US, TP: HK$35.20, HOLD] Relatively new company taking modern culture concept into the gaming industry. City
of Dreams and the House of Dancing Water have become firm tourist attractions. But
Macao Studio City has not yet obtained a gaming license and this will be difficult to
achieve given all other operators are still queuing. We are sceptical about their future
plans to expand to the Philippines, Matsu Islands and Russia, since we believe Macau
still offers the best opportunity for gaming growth. Additionally, its zero-dividend policy
and 15% net debt:equity ratio by the end of 2012 do not look attractive compared with
other gaming companies. It is trading at 11.9x PER and we believe the current valua-
tion is too rich.
Good brand catering to wealthy individ-
uals.
Focuses on high-margin mass market
gaming, but already priced in.
Its new property might not have casino,
no much catalyst from Macau, valua-
tion looks rich.
19
Galaxy Entertainment [0027.HK]
We reiterate our BUY rating on GEG with a target price of HK$27.60.
Outperforming 1H12. Net profit was up from HK$378m in 1H11 to HK$3.45bn in
1H12, on a 107.2% YoY growth in revenue to HK$28.3bn. Growth of 290.9% YoY in
high-margin mass market revenue to HK$4.4bn (vs. 99.1% growth in VIP segment to
HK$21.3bn) contributed to net margin improvement from 2.8% in 1H11 to 12.2% in
1H12. No dividend was recommended.
Expect strong growth in 2012E. We forecast 2012 revenue to grow by 43.2% to
HK$58.99bn and net profit rose 103.6% YoY to and HK$6.12bn, due mainly to the full
-year contribution from Galaxy Macau. With strong operating cash flow, we expect
GEG to be in a net cash position by the end of 2012, from 31.1% net debt:equity ratio
at the end of 2011. With projects in pipeline such as Galaxy Macau Phase 2, we ex-
pect no dividend payout for the foreseeable future.
Earnings growth to remain resilient in longer term. On the transition from VIP
gaming model to mass-market focus, we expect margins to keep improving in the long
term from 7.3% in 2011 to 16% in 2014. During this period we expect EPS to grow at
a 58.6% CAGR. Apart from the strong performance in Galaxy Macau and StarWorld,
we see most upside potential in new properties coming from 2015, such as Galaxy
Macau Phase 2, 3 and 4.
Target price maintained at HK$27.60. We keep our target price unchanged, which
implies 13x PER and 10.7x EV/EBITDA for 2013. Given our DCF-derived value of
HK$32.30 per share, we are convinced that GEG is deeply undervalued at present,
with further upside when factoring in Galaxy Macau Phase 3 and 4 projects.
Maintain BUY, undemanding valuation. GEG is trading at 11.7x PER and 9.4x EV/
EBITDA on our 2013 forecast, at historical mid-range trading level. Backed by its
strong fundamentals, GEG has led the recent rally in gaming stocks, and we expect
the momentum to be sustained in the long term for its continuous margin improve-
ment. We expect the immediate catalysts are 1) strong 3Q11 results and 2) the sale
of Permira’s 5.95% holding, which is an overhang. Permira has reduced its holding,
and the residual stake is likely to be sold at some point, as the private equity group
has owned the stake in GEG for five years, with an entry level of HK$8.42.
BUY
Close: HK$24.90 (Sept 25, 2012)
Target Price: HK$27.60 (+11%)
Price Performance
Market Cap US$13,452.9m
Shares Outstanding 4,192.5m
Auditor PWC
Free Float 47.8%
52W range HK$8.69-25.95
3M average daily T/O US$46.7m
Major Shareholding Management (48.0%)
Source: Company, Bloomberg
Angela Han Lee—Analyst
(852) 3698-6318
John Mulcahy—Head of Research
(852) 3698 6889
2010 2011 2012E 2013E 2014E
Turnover (HK$m) 19,262 41,186 58,991 67,771 76,337
Net profit (HK$m) 898 3,004 6,116 8,974 12,229
Net margin (%) 4.7 7.3 10.4 13.2 16.0
EPS (HK$) 0.23 0.73 1.45 2.13 2.90
Change (%) (21.9) 219.3 99.3 46.7 36.3
PER (x) 109.2 34.2 17.2 11.7 8.6
Yield (%) - - - - -
Source: Company, CGIHK Research
Macau Gaming Sector
20
Valuation assumptions.
In our DCF model we included our projection for free cash flow from existing properties until 2022, when the current gaming li-
cense expires.
We included the net present value of Galaxy Macau Phase 2 until 2022, which is HK$7.34 per share. Galaxy Macau Phase 2 is
still under construction to open in mid-2015.
We did not include the value of Galaxy Macau Phase 3 and 4, which has not yet broken ground.
Figure 24: GEG’s ownership
Source: Company, Capital IQ, CGIHK Research
Ownership structure
22
Key valuation metrics
Figure 25: Revenue/Operating profit/Net profit Figure 26: Revenue Breakdown
Source: Company, CGIHK Research Source: Company, CGIHK Research Figure 27: Margins Figure 28: ROE/ROA
Source: Company, CGIHK Research Source: Company, CGIHK Research Figure 29: PER band Figure 30: PBR band
Source: Company, Bloomberg, CGIHK Research Source: Company, Bloomberg, CGIHK Research
23
SJM Holdings [0880.HK]
We initiate coverage with a BUY rating on SJM and a target price of HK$18.30.
Relatively weak 1H12 because of third party casinos. Net profit was up by 28%
YoY to HK$3.41bn in 1H12, while revenue grew at 3.9% YoY to HK$39.26bn. Gaming
revenue was only up by 3.8% YoY to HK$38.96bn, dragged down by underperforming
third-party casinos, although Grand Lisboa outperformed the industry with 22.2% YoY
growth in revenue and 37.6% YoY growth in net profit. HK$0.10 interim dividend per
share was announced, up by 25% YoY, translating into a 16.2% payout ratio.
Some pick-up in 2H12 but little surprise expected. With scandals in the New Cen-
tury Hotel, SJM has moved 40 tables from Greek Mythology, the third-party casino
operated in the hotel. The 40 tables were to be allocated to Grand Lisboa’s VIP gam-
ing area, which has consistently outperformed the industry. We believe this will im-
prove the company’s gaming volume, but our outlook for third party casinos remains
cautious for 2H12 , given increased competition from SCC Phase 2. For 2012, we
expect revenue to grow at 7.8% to HK$81.98bn and net profit to rise 30.7% YoY to
HK$6.93bn.
Still the long-term leader. Despite the increasing competition from Cotai players,
SJM remains the market leader with 25-26% share, and Dr. Stanley Ho retains his
powerful influence in Macau. Its self-promoted casinos have delivered satisfactory
results so far and Grand Lisboa still has a particularly strong reputation in China. The
contribution from self-promoted casinos will gradually increase in the long term, since
upcoming projects will be self-promoted. Also, SJM holds 30% of total gaming tables
in Macau, which implies more room for improvement in table yields, with tables more
productively relocated to outperforming casinos in the future.
Sites 1&2, Parcels 7&8 for approval. SJM’s main disadvantage is its lack of a Cotai
presence. However, this obstacle will be eliminated when its Cotai land grants are
approved. Site 2, next to Macau Dome and Wynn Cotai, is expected to be approved
soon, in late 2012 or early 2013, for which we estimate the NPV at HK$4.60 per
share. Site 1 is also queuing for the approval after Site 2, and the management has
indicated an interest in applying for Parcels 7&8. Although the contribution from these
projects is beyond our forecast horizon, we view them as long-term revenue and profit
drivers.
BUY
Close: HK$16.32 (Sept 25, 2012)
Target Price: HK$18.30 (+12%)
Price Performance
Market Cap US$11,665.0m
Shares Outstanding 5,546.6m
Auditor Deloitte
Free Float 32.9%
52W range HK$10.08-17.61
3M average daily T/O US$12.6m
Major Shareholding STDM (55.0%)
Source: Company, Bloomberg
Angela Han Lee—Analyst
(852) 3698-6318
John Mulcahy—Head of Research
(852) 3698 6889
2010 2011 2012E 2013E 2014E
Turnover (HK$m) 57,585 76,058 81,975 90,635 99,732
Net profit (HK$m) 3,559 5,308 6,934 9,893 12,772
Net margin (%) 6.2 7.0 8.5 10.9 12.8
EPS (HK$) 0.69 0.96 1.26 1.80 2.32
Change (%) 281.5 39.4 30.7 42.7 29.1
PER (x) 23.6 16.9 13.0 9.1 7.0
Yield (%) 2.1 4.5 5.8 8.3 10.7
Source: Company, CGIHK Research
Macau Gaming Sector
24
Target price at HK$18.30. We used our DCF model to derive our target price, implying 10.2x PER and 8.4x EV/EBITDA for 2013.
Our projection for the target price does not include the potential value of upcoming projects such as Sites 1&2, leaving scope for up-
grading in medium term when there is more clarity on the projects.
Initiate with BUY, dividend play. SJM is trading at 9.1x PER and 6.7x EV/EBITDA on our 2013 forecast, a c.20% discount to the
industry average, implying limited downside risk. Beyond its attractive valuation, the 8.3% forward yield provides a good return for
long-term dividend investors. SJM’s balance sheet is the strongest in the sector with a cash cushion of HK$14.9bn with all debt paid
back by the end of this year. Management confirmed the current payout ratio is sustainable, which we assume to be 75%, as in 2011.
SJM has been trading at a discount to its peers, due mainly to the perceived lack of catalysts. Backed by the government’s imminent
land grant, we believe SJM’s valuation will gradually pick up further and the value of new projects leaves scope for re-rating in the
long term.
Valuation assumptions.
In our DCF model, we included our projection for free cash flow from existing properties until 2020, when the current gaming li-
cense expires.
We did not include the value of Sites 1&2, which has not yet been approved.
Our Site 2 NPV estimation of HK$4.60 per share will be an accretion to our target price, to be included when SJM obtains its land
grant.
Ownership structure
Figure 31: SJM’s ownership
Source: Company, HKEx, Capital IQ, CGIHK Research
26
Key valuation metrics
Figure 32: Revenue/Operating profit/Net profit Figure 33: Revenue Breakdown
Source: Company, CGIHK Research Source: Company, CGIHK Research
Figure 34: Margins Figure 35: ROE/ROA
Source: Company, CGIHK Research Source: Company, CGIHK Research
Figure 36: PER band Figure 37: PBR band
Source: Company, Bloomberg, CGIHK Research Source: Company, Bloomberg, CGIHK Research
27
MGM China [2282.HK] We reiterate our BUY rating on MGM China with a target price of HK$14.90.
Strong 1H12, outperformer in revenue and earnings after GEG. Net profit was up
by 37.7% YoY to HK$2.63bn in 1H12. Its revenue (after charging junket commission)
grew by 11.2% YoY to HK$10.79bn, maintaining its market share at c.10%. Strong
revenue growth (16.4%) in the mass market segment was the key to the margin im-
provement, from 17.8% in 1H11 to 22.2% in 1H12. No dividend was recommended.
Further pick-up in 2H12 due to expansion. We expect its topline growth to remain
strong and the VIP gaming area expansion on Level Two should further consolidate
its strong position in serving wealthy individuals. We believe an additional 40 VIP ta-
bles with new junkets should protect its market share from the opening of SCC Phase
2. For 2012 we expect revenue to grow by 17.1% YoY to HK$32.45bn and net profit
by 51.1% to HK$4.96bn, in line with management guidance of 15-20% revenue
growth. For the longer term we project 29% EPS CAGR during 2011-2014.
Long-term catalyst on the way. Wynn Macau obtained a land grant for Cotai in May
2012, and MGM China is next in line. This is likely by the end of 2012 and the man-
agement expects to break ground by then with a plan to complete by late 2015.
Target price at HK$14.90. We maintain an unchanged target price, driven by our
DCF model for the existing property, MGM Macau. It implies 9.3x PER and 7.4x EV/
EBITDA for 2013. Our projection for the target price does not include the potential
value of its Cotai project, leaving scope for upgrading by its NPV of HK$3.10 per
share after it obtains land grant.
Maintain BUY, compelling value play. MGM China is trading at 8.4x PER and 7.0x
EV/EBITDA on our 2013 forecast, a c.30% discount to Wynn Macau, which we be-
lieve is the closest comparable. They both have their sole casino in Macau Peninsula
with a strong focus on premium service, and seeking exposure in Cotai. However,
MGM China has often been overlooked by the market since listing in June 2011 be-
cause of its small market share. We believe the market will begin paying more atten-
tion in future to its small but solid growth outperforming the industry, narrowing the
valuation gap in the long term. As a catalyst, we expect the land grant in Cotai to trig-
ger a re-rating, once the value of the new property is factored into its target price. In
addition, the 7.2% forward yield provides a good return, for which we assume 60%
payout ratio in 2012 (2011: 95%) backed by its net cash position from 2011.
BUY
Close: HK$13.12 (Sept 25, 2012)
Target Price: HK$14.90 (+14%)
Price Performance
Market Cap US$6,424.7m
Shares Outstanding 3,800.0m
Auditor Deloitte
Free Float 21.6%
52W range HK$7.60-14.76
3M average daily T/O US$4.1m
Major Shareholding MGM Resorts
(51.0%)
Source: Company, Bloomberg
Angela Han Lee—Analyst
(852) 3698-6318
John Mulcahy—Head of Research
(852) 3698 6889
2010 2011 2012E 2013E 2014E
Turnover (HK$m) 16,608 27,719 32,450 36,686 41,133
Net profit (HK$m) 1,566 3,279 4,955 5,954 7,040
Net margin (%) 9.4 11.8 15.3 16.2 17.1
EPS (HK$) 0.41 0.86 1.30 1.57 1.85
Change (%) N.A. 109.4 51.1 20.2 18.2
PER (x) 31.8 15.2 10.1 8.4 7.1
Yield (%) 0.0 6.2 6.0 7.2 8.5
Source: Company, CGIHK Research
Macau Gaming Sector
28
Valuation assumptions.
In our DCF model we included our projection for free cash flow from existing property until 2020, when the current gaming li-
cense expires.
We did not include the value of its Cotai project, which has not yet been approved.
Our estimate of the Cotai project’s NPV of HK$3.10 per share will be an accretion to our target price, to be included when MGM
China obtains its land grant.
Ownership structure
Figure 38: MGM China’s ownership
Source: Company, HKEx CGIHK Research
30
Key valuation metrics
Figure 39: Revenue/Operating profit/Net profit Figure 40: Revenue Breakdown
Source: Company, CGIHK Research Source: Company, CGIHK Research Figure 41: Margins Figure 42: ROE/ROA
Source: Company, CGIHK Research Source: Company, CGIHK Research
Figure 43: PER band Figure 44: PBR band
Source: Company, Bloomberg, CGIHK Research Source: Company, Bloomberg, CGIHK Research
31
Wynn Macau [1128.HK]
We reiterate our BUY rating on Wynn Macau with a target price of HK$23.90.
Weak 1H12 topline as expected but healthy earnings growth. Net profit was up by
38.3% YoY to HK$3.34bn in 1H12. Its revenue (after charging junket commission)
stayed flat with 0.6% YoY growth to HK$14.42bn. While revenue from VIP gaming
and slot machines had a slight decline, the mass-market growth was more stable at
8%, driving up overall revenue growth and margin improvement, from 13% in 1H11 to
18% in 1H12. No dividend was recommended.
No surprise in 2012. We believe Wynn Macau will continue underperforming in
2H12. We expect some recovery in gaming revenue growth from its lower base last
year, but increasing competition from SCC Phase 2 should put some pressure on its
junket commission rate, which has always been higher than the industry level. We
project operating profit to grow by 23.4% YoY in 2012, but increased interest expens-
es with new loans to finance the Cotai construction should undermine net profit
growth this year. We expect net profit to grow at 9.6% YoY to HK$6.49bn in 2012.
New project under construction. Wynn Macau obtained its Cotai land grant in May
2012, and increased its credit facility by US$2.3bn. It is expected to double existing
gaming capacity by the time of completion in 2016. We project its NPV at HK$6.00
per share.
Target price at HK$23.90. We keep our target price unchanged, which implies 14.7x
PER and 11.1x EV/EBITDA for 2013. Given our DCF-derived value of HK$27.30 per
share, we believe Wynn Macau is undervalued.
Maintain BUY, laggard but good operator. Wynn Macau is trading at 12.8x PER
and 10.1x EV/EBITDA on our 2013 forecast, a historically low trading level. Its share
price has underperformed its Macau peers this year. However, Wynn is still a valuable
brand with good expertise in gaming resort management; good operating efficiency;
industry-high ROE (2013: 89.3%); and decent dividend yield (2013: 4.8%). We affirm
our positive view on the company and recommend investors chase the laggard, with
the price likely to gain momentum in the short term.
BUY
Close: HK$20.80 (Sept 25, 2012)
Target Price: HK$23.90 (+15%)
Price Performance
Market Cap US$13,904.8m
Shares Outstanding 5,817.6m
Auditor Ernst & Young
Free Float 27.7%
52W range HK$14.62-25.50
3M average daily T/O US$15.9m
Major Shareholding Wynn Resorts
(72.3%)
Source: Company, Bloomberg
Angela Han Lee—Analyst
(852) 3698-6318
John Mulcahy—Head of Research
(852) 3698 6889
2010 2011 2012E 2013E 2014E
Turnover (HK$m) 28,776 38,213 42,832 47,209 51,913
Net profit (HK$m) 4,422 5,921 6,488 8,429 10,002
Net margin (%) 15.4 15.5 15.1 17.9 19.3
EPS (HK$) 0.85 1.14 1.25 1.62 1.93
Change (%) 107.3 34.1 9.7 29.9 18.7
PER (x) 24.5 18.2 16.6 12.8 10.8
Yield (%) 3.7 5.8 4.0 4.8 5.7
Source: Company, CGIHK Research
Macau Gaming Sector
32
Valuation assumptions.
In our DCF model, we included our projection for free cash flow from existing property until 2022, when the current gaming li-
cense expires.
We included the net present value of Cotai project until 2022, which is HK$6.00 per share. Its Cotai project is still under construc-
tion to open in 2016.
Ownership structure
Figure 45: Wynn Macau’s ownership
Source: Company, HKEx, CGIHK Research
34
Key valuation metrics
Figure 46: Revenue/Operating profit/Net profit Figure 47: Revenue Breakdown
Source: Company, CGIHK Research Source: Company, CGIHK Research Figure 48: Margins Figure 49: ROE/ROA
Source: Company, CGIHK Research Source: Company, CGIHK Research Figure 50: PER band Figure 51: PBR band
Source: Company, Bloomberg, CGIHK Research Source: Company, Bloomberg, CGIHK Research
35
Sands China [1928.HK]
We initiate coverage with a HOLD rating on Sands China with target price of
HK$29.20.
Weak 1H12 mainly for one-off item. Net profit was down by 18.5% YoY to
US$439.8m in 1H12. Its revenue grew faster than the industry with 23.7% YoY growth
to US$2.92bn, due to its strategy of expanding VIP gaming segment in the Plaza Ma-
cao. However, one-off impairment charge of US$143.7m occurred, because of 1) the
capitalized construction cost on Parcels 7&8 which was not approved for Sands Chi-
na’s use, and 2) the closure of the Cirque du Soleil “ZAiA” show at the Venetian Ma-
cao. As a result, net margin deteriorated from 22.9% in 1H11 to 15.1% in 1H12. No
dividend was recommended.
SCC Phase 2 opened in September, but we expect no surprise. SCC Phase 1
opening was not as impressive as Galaxy Macau’s, and we see SCC as a big but not
attractive property. With more casino properties being built in Macau the uniqueness
(“WOW Factor”) of those properties is important in capturing the flow of mass-market
players. With no iconic features we expect SCC to take longer to ramp-up than the
market had expected. We forecast 38.2% revenue growth and 36.2% net profit growth
in 2012.
Good mass market player with Parcel 3 under construction. Although its 2012
margins will be under pressure for one-off items, Sands China is a good operator with
more focus on mass market. Even though the company has gained some market
share in the VIP gaming segment, we still project it to generate around 65% of its
gaming revenue from the VIP segment, compared with the 70% industry level. The
next catalyst for Sands China is its Parcel 3 project, which will break ground in No-
vember and a completion deadline of April 2016. Parcel 3 will be known as “The Pa-
risian” and will have a replica of Eiffel Tower, which should differentiate it as a tourist
attraction.
Target price at HK$29.20. We used our DCF model to derive our target price, imply-
ing 11.3x PER and 10.2x EV/EBITDA for 2013. Our projection for the target price
does not include the potential value of Parcel 3, leaving scope for upgrading in the
medium term when there is more clarity on the Cotai project.
HOLD
Close: HK$28.60 (Sept 25, 2012)
Target Price: HK$29.20 (+2%)
Price Performance
Market Cap US$29,675.5m
Shares Outstanding 8,051.8m
Auditor PWC
Free Float 29.7%
52W range HK$14.90-33.05
3M average daily T/O US$49.1m
Major Shareholding Las Vegas Sands
(70.3%)
Source: Company, Bloomberg
Angela Han Lee—Analyst
(852) 3698-6318
John Mulcahy—Head of Research
(852) 3698 6889
2010 2011 2012E 2013E 2014E
Turnover (US$m) 4,142 4,881 6,746 9,921 11,825
Net profit (US$m) 666 1,133 1,543 2,672 3,369
Net margin (%) 16.1 23.2 22.9 26.9 28.5
EPS (HK$) 0.64 1.09 1.49 2.58 3.25
Change (%) 150.1 69.7 36.0 73.2 26.1
PER (x) 44.4 26.1 19.2 11.1 8.8
Yield (%) 0.0 4.1 3.6 6.3 7.9
Source: Company, CGIHK Research
Macau Gaming Sector
36
Initiate with HOLD, fairly valued with no near-term catalyst. Sands China is trading at 11.1x PER and 10.1x EV/EBITDA on our
2013 forecast, at a slight premium to the industry average. For its brand name with experience in gaming resort management, the
stock has always traded at a premium. However, our DCF model suggests the current share price has factored in the upside. There is
no basis for an extremely negative view, as we see Parcel 3 as a potential long-term catalyst and SCC should ramp-up gradually, so
we recommend long-term investors to hold.
Valuation assumptions.
In our DCF model, we included our projection for free cash flow from existing property including SCC until 2022, when the current
gaming license expires.
We did not include the value of Parcel 3 project, which is still preparing for construction to open in 2016, as SCC Phase 2B and
Phase 3 are still in progress.
Ownership structure
Figure 52: Sands China’s ownership
Source: Company, HKEx, CGIHK Research
38
Key valuation metrics
Figure 53: Revenue/Operating profit/Net profit Figure 54: Revenue Breakdown
Source: Company, CGIHK Research Source: Company, CGIHK Research Figure 55: Margins Figure 56: ROE/ROA
Source: Company, CGIHK Research Source: Company, CGIHK Research Figure 57: PER band Figure 58: PBR band
Source: Company, Bloomberg, CGIHK Research Source: Company, Bloomberg, CGIHK Research
39
Melco Crown [6883.HK]
We initiate coverage with a HOLD rating on Melco Crown and a target price of
HK$35.20.
In line 1H12. Net profit was up from US$73.8m in 1H11 to US$204.4m in 1H12, while
revenue (after charging junket commission) was up by 11.3% YoY to US$1.97bn.
Stronger growth in earnings is due to the rising operating leverage, after turning a net
loss into net profit in 2011. It is relocating tables from Altira to City of Dreams, which
has a higher table yield, optimizing facility efficiency. No dividend was recommended.
No surprise in 2H12. We expect 2H12 performance will be in line with 1H12, and
project revenue growth at 9.1% to US$5.62bn and net profit to grow 50.8% YoY to
US$444m. Slower YoY growth in earnings is attributable to increasing construction
cost for Macao Studio City.
Uncertainty in Macao Studio City and its future plan. In July 2012, Macau Studio
City received a permit to restart construction of the project, in which Melco Crown has
60% equity interest. Despite the management’s promise the land grant was approved
without a gaming license. Although the management is confident of obtaining it, we
are less optimistic, and rate the chances quite low. The Macau government said all
casino operators will own a casino in Cotai, and MGM China and SJM are still queu-
ing after the approval to Wynn Macau. Melco Crown already runs City of Dreams in
Cotai, so we believe the licensing priority will go to MGM China and SJM. Outside
Macau, Melco Crown is actively working to open casinos in the Philippines, Taiwan
and Russia. Although these could be good businesses, we prefer operators focusing
in Macau, which is the regional/global centre of casino gambling and an established
reputation and infrastructure.
Target price at HK$35.20. Our DCF-driven target price implies 12.6x PER and 8.3x
EV/EBITDA for 2013. The target price includes the potential value of the non-gaming
Macau Studio City until 2030, which is independent from the expiry date of gaming
sub-concession.
HOLD
Close: HK$33.30 (Sept 25, 2012)
Target Price: HK$35.20 (+6%)
Price Performance
Market Cap US$7,115.1m
Shares Outstanding 1,658.1m
Auditor Deloitte
Free Float 32.0%
52W range HK$22.40-43.00
3M average daily T/O US$34,137.7
Major Shareholding Crown (33.7%)
Melco (33.7%)
Source: Company, Bloomberg
Angela Han Lee—Analyst
(852) 3698-6318
John Mulcahy—Head of Research
(852) 3698 6889
2010 2011 2012E 2013E 2014E
Turnover (US$m) 3,601 5,153 5,619 6,106 6,688
Net profit (US$m) (11) 295 444 593 826
Net margin (%) (0.3) 5.7 7.9 9.7 12.4
EPS (HK$) (0.05) 1.43 2.10 2.80 3.90
Change (%) n.a. n.a. 47.2 33.3 39.5
PER (x) (648.9) 23.4 15.9 11.9 8.5
Yield (%) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Source: Company, CGIHK Research
Macau Gaming Sector
40
Initiate with HOLD, rich valuation in our view. Melco Crown is trading at 11.9x PER and 8.1x EV/EBITDA on our 2013 forecast, in
line with the industry average. We do not see any near-term catalyst in the company and Macao Studio City is less likely to have a
gaming area, in our opinion, which diverges from consensus. Moreover, we do not take its expansion in other regions as a positive
point, as these new locations will require large capex but without the returns offered by Macau: Taiwan’s Matsu Island stil l needs to
build up its infrastructure and reputation and it will take much longer to realize the return to investors. For these reasons we see lim-
ited upside from the current price.
Valuation assumptions.
In our DCF model, we included our projection for free cash flow from existing property until 2022, when the current gaming li-
cense expires, and from Macao Studio City until 2030.
We did not include the potential return from its investment in the Philippines, Taiwan and Russia.
Ownership structure
Figure 56: Melco Crown’s ownership
Source: Company, HKEx, CGIHK Research
42
Key valuation metrics
Figure 57: Revenue/Operating profit/Net profit Figure 58: Revenue Breakdown
Source: Company, CGIHK Research Source: Company, CGIHK Research
Figure 59: Margins Figure 60: ROE/ROA
Source: Company, CGIHK Research Source: Company, CGIHK Research
Figure 61: PER band Figure 62: PBR band
Source: Company, Bloomberg, CGIHK Research Source: Company, Bloomberg, CGIHK Research
43
DISCLAIMER
For private perusal only. This report (including any information attached) is issued by China Galaxy International Securities (Hong Kong) Co.,
Limited, one of the subsidiaries of the China Galaxy International Financial Holdings Limited, to individual addressee whether they are pro-
fessional investor, institutional client or otherwise, in good faith from sources believed to be reliable but no representation or warranty
(expressly or implied) is made as to their accuracy, correctness and/or completeness. Where any part of the information, opinions or esti-
mates contained herein reflects the personal views and opinions of the analyst who prepared this report, such views and opinions may not
correspond to the published view of China Galaxy International Financial Holdings Limited and any of its subsidiaries. This report shall not be
construed as an offer, invitation or solicitation to buy or sell any securities of the company or companies referred to herein. All opinions and
estimates reflect the judgment of the analyst on the date of this report and are subject to change without notice.
Please take note that member companies of China Galaxy International Financial Holdings Limited (including but not limited to China Galaxy
International Securities (Hong Kong) Co., Ltd) and/or their directors, officers, agents and employees (“the Relevant Parties”) may have an
interest in securities of the company or companies referred to in this report. The Relevant Parties hereby disclaim any of their liabilities aris-
ing from the inaccuracy, incorrectness and incompleteness of this report and its attachment(s) and/or any action or omission made in reli-
ance thereof. Accordingly, this report must be read in conjunction with this disclaimer.
COPYRIGHT RESERVED
China Galaxy International Securities (Hong Kong) Co. Limited, CE No.AXM459, Room 3501-3507, 35/F, Cosco Tower, Grand Millennium
Plaza, 183 Queen’s Road Central, Sheung Wan, Hong Kong. General line: 3698-6888.
Analyst Certification The research analyst who is primarily responsible for the content of this research report, in whole or in part, certifies that with respect to the
securities or issuer covered in this report: (1) all of the views expressed accurately reflect his or her personal views about the subject, securi-
ties or issuer; and (2) no part of his or her compensation was, is, or will be, directly or indirectly, related to the specific views expressed by the
analyst in this report.
Besides, the analyst confirms that neither the analyst nor his/her associates (as defined in the code of conduct issued by The Hong Kong
Securities and Futures Commission) (1) have dealt in or traded in the stock(s) covered in this research report within 30 calendar days prior to
the date of issue of this report; (2) will deal in or trade in the stock(s) covered in this research report three business days after the date of issue
of this report; (3) serve as an officer of any of the Hong Kong listed companies covered in this report; and (4) have any financial interests in
the Hong Kong listed companies covered in this report.
Explanation on Equity Ratings
BUY: We expect the total return on the stock to exceed 20% over a 12 to 18 month horizon.
HOLD: We expect the total return on the stock will be between 0% to 20% over a 12 to 18 month horizon.
SELL: We expect the total return on the stock will be less than 0% over a 12 to 18 month horizon.