17
Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron IN-SITU VERIFICATION OF MOBILE PIT-TAG DETECTION SYSTEMS -- Trawls and Birds

Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron IN-SITU VERIFICATION

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron IN-SITU VERIFICATION

Luther B. WayRichard D. Ledgerwood

Brad A. RyanAnd

April S. Cameron

Luther B. WayRichard D. Ledgerwood

Brad A. RyanAnd

April S. Cameron

IN-SITU VERIFICATION OF MOBILE PIT-TAG

DETECTION SYSTEMS--

Trawls and Birds

IN-SITU VERIFICATION OF MOBILE PIT-TAG

DETECTION SYSTEMS--

Trawls and Birds

Page 2: Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron IN-SITU VERIFICATION

“Electric barge”

Tow Vessels (91m between wings)

• Large Pair-trawl (freshwater)

Ledgerwood, R. D. J. W. Ferguson, B. A. Ryan, E. M. Dawley, and E. P. Nunnallee. In press. A Surface Trawl to Detect Migrating Juvenile Salmonids Tagged with Passive Integrated Transponder tags. NAJFM

Page 3: Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron IN-SITU VERIFICATION

1996 400KHz PIT-tag Detector

Front View

Rear View

Detection Tunnels

Weight 650 lbs.

About 4-ft cube

Page 4: Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron IN-SITU VERIFICATION

400 kHz detectors400 kHz detectors18” diameter,

1999

3-pipe bundle of 10” diameter,

1998

Page 5: Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron IN-SITU VERIFICATION

134.2 kHz, 2000“Funnel Tests”

134.2 kHz, 2000“Funnel Tests”

0 45

0 1 0

1 6 3

2 14 11

3 7 5

4 1 1

5 1 0

30 20 50

degrees

spacing

Test tape configuration

Test tape configuration

Page 6: Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron IN-SITU VERIFICATION

Small trawl and electronics

Page 7: Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron IN-SITU VERIFICATION

2-coil antenna used 2001-present2-coil antenna used 2001-present

Page 8: Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron IN-SITU VERIFICATION

Detection Rates of Pit-tagsAttached to a Test Tape, 2001

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

Spacing of Adjacent Tags (cm)

Det

ectio

n R

ate,

(%

)

0° 45°

30 61 91 122 152

508

71

1,324

612

921

278

130

59

35

28

Page 9: Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron IN-SITU VERIFICATION

Test tape pass location3 April 03

Test tape pass location3 April 03

20 cm from antenna wall

Coil 00: 98%

Coil 01: 98%

20 cm from antenna wall

Coil 00: 98%

Coil 01: 98%

Centered in antenna

Coil 00: 32%

Coil 01: 58%

Centered in antenna

Coil 00: 32%

Coil 01: 58%

Page 10: Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron IN-SITU VERIFICATION

Large TrawlWhit Patten-style Electronics

Large TrawlWhit Patten-style Electronics

Master/Slave configurationMaster/Slave configuration

Page 11: Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron IN-SITU VERIFICATION

Weak-sister chartWeak-sister chart

Master slave effectMaster slave effect

Master/Slave Comparison

0

20

40

60

80

100

Weak Master Strong Master

Det

ecte

d (%

)

Coil 00, n = 66 Coil 01, n = 114

Slave

Slave

Master

Master

Page 12: Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron IN-SITU VERIFICATION

Ryan, B. A., J. W. Ferguson, R. D. Ledgerwood, and E. P. Nunnallee. 2001. Detection of passive integrated transponder tags from juvenile salmonids on piscivorus bird colonies in the Columbia River Basin. North American Journal of Fisheries Management (21:417-421).

Page 13: Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron IN-SITU VERIFICATION

4-coil flat-plate antenna4-coil flat-plate antenna

4 transceivers

mounted in the jeep

Bird colony detections

Page 14: Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron IN-SITU VERIFICATION

Density grid of test tagsDensity grid of test tags

28 21

18 19 2027 22

26 2315 16 17

25 24

11 12 13 14

4 3

8 9 10

5 6 7

2 1

28 21

18 19 2027 22

26 2315 16 17

25 24

11 12 13 14

4 3

8 9 10

5 6 7

2 1

Page 15: Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron IN-SITU VERIFICATION

“Sand Flea”Mechanical PIT-tag harvester

(1998)

“Sand Flea”Mechanical PIT-tag harvester

(1998)

Idea: Evaluate recovery of PIT-tags “missed” by the jeep system. Woops.

Idea: Evaluate recovery of PIT-tags “missed” by the jeep system. Woops.

Page 16: Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron IN-SITU VERIFICATION

Crescent Island“Mechanical Verification”

Crescent Island“Mechanical Verification”

Post-Jeep Detections

817 525

15568

11842

0

4000

8000

12000

16000

20000

2001 2002

Detection Year

Tot

al T

ags

Biomark Detections Total Detections

Page 17: Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron Luther B. Way Richard D. Ledgerwood Brad A. Ryan And April S. Cameron IN-SITU VERIFICATION

• Needed is a way to regulate the rate at which the test tape is passed through the center of the detection antenna

• END

• On a pass-through detection system, the test tape needs to be passed through the center of the detection antenna

• Where the concentration of tags is great, as on bird nesting islands, inter-detector collisions need to be minimized by adjustments to the circuitry.

• All PIT-tag detection systems need a quantitative measurement of detection efficiency

ConclusionsConclusions