8/9/2019 Lorzano vs Tabayag

1/16

Republic of the PhilippinesSUPREME COURT

Manila

SECOND DIVISION

G.R. No. 189647 February 6, !1

N"NC# T. $OR%"NO,Petitioner,vs.&U"N T"'"#"G, &R.,Respondent.

D E C I S I O N

RE#ES, J.:

Nature of the Petition

This is a petition for revie on certiorariunder Rule !" of the Rules of Court filed b# Nanc# T.$or%ano &petitioner' assailin( the Court of )ppeals &C)' Decision*dated March *+, -- andResolutiondated Septe/ber *0, -- in C)12.R. C3 No. +440 entitled 56uan Taba#a(, 6r.v. Nanc# T. $or%ano.5

The )ntecedent 7acts

The instant case ste//ed fro/ an a/ended co/plaint8for annul/ent of docu/ent andreconve#ance filed b# 6uan Taba#a(, 6r. &respondent' a(ainst the petitioner, doc9eted asCivil Case No. Ir18+0, ith the Re(ional Trial Court &RTC' of Iri(a Cit#.

The petitioner and the respondent are to of the children of the late 6uan Taba#a( &Taba#a('ho died on 6une , *. Taba#a( oned a parcel of land situated in Sto. Do/in(o, Iri(aCit# &sub:ect propert#'. Ri(ht after the burial of their father, the petitioner alle(edl# re;uestedfro/ her siblin(s that she be alloed to ta9e possession of and receive the inco/e

(enerated b# the sub:ect propert# until after her eldest son could (raduate fro/ colle(e. Thepetitioner

8/9/2019 Lorzano vs Tabayag

2/16

Republic of the PhilippinesSUPREME COURT

Manila

SECOND DIVISION

G.R. No. 189647 February 6, !1

N"NC# T. $OR%"NO,Petitioner,vs.&U"N T"'"#"G, &R.,Respondent.

D E C I S I O N

RE#ES, J.:

Nature of the Petition

This is a petition for revie on certiorariunder Rule !" of the Rules of Court filed b# Nanc# T.$or%ano &petitioner' assailin( the Court of )ppeals &C)' Decision*dated March *+, -- andResolutiondated Septe/ber *0, -- in C)12.R. C3 No. +440 entitled 56uan Taba#a(, 6r.v. Nanc# T. $or%ano.5

The )ntecedent 7acts

The instant case ste//ed fro/ an a/ended co/plaint8for annul/ent of docu/ent andreconve#ance filed b# 6uan Taba#a(, 6r. &respondent' a(ainst the petitioner, doc9eted asCivil Case No. Ir18+0, ith the Re(ional Trial Court &RTC' of Iri(a Cit#.

The petitioner and the respondent are to of the children of the late 6uan Taba#a( &Taba#a('ho died on 6une , *. Taba#a( oned a parcel of land situated in Sto. Do/in(o, Iri(aCit# &sub:ect propert#'. Ri(ht after the burial of their father, the petitioner alle(edl# re;uestedfro/ her siblin(s that she be alloed to ta9e possession of and receive the inco/e

(enerated b# the sub:ect propert# until after her eldest son could (raduate fro/ colle(e. Thepetitioner D to tilePetition'. 1

http://www.lawphil.net/judjuris/juri2012/feb2012/gr_189647_2012.html#fnt1http://www.lawphil.net/judjuris/juri2012/feb2012/gr_189647_2012.html#fnt2http://www.lawphil.net/judjuris/juri2012/feb2012/gr_189647_2012.html#fnt3http://www.lawphil.net/judjuris/juri2012/feb2012/gr_189647_2012.html#fnt3http://www.lawphil.net/judjuris/juri2012/feb2012/gr_189647_2012.html#fnt4http://www.lawphil.net/judjuris/juri2012/feb2012/gr_189647_2012.html#fnt1http://www.lawphil.net/judjuris/juri2012/feb2012/gr_189647_2012.html#fnt2http://www.lawphil.net/judjuris/juri2012/feb2012/gr_189647_2012.html#fnt3http://www.lawphil.net/judjuris/juri2012/feb2012/gr_189647_2012.html#fnt4

8/9/2019 Lorzano vs Tabayag

3/16

Republic of the PhilippinesSUPREME COURT

Manila

SECOND DIVISION

G.R. No. 189647 February 6, !1

N"NC# T. $OR%"NO,Petitioner,vs.&U"N T"'"#"G, &R.,Respondent.

D E C I S I O N

RE#ES, J.:

Nature of the Petition

This is a petition for revie on certiorariunder Rule !" of the Rules of Court filed b# Nanc# T.$or%ano &petitioner' assailin( the Court of )ppeals &C)' Decision*dated March *+, -- andResolutiondated Septe/ber *0, -- in C)12.R. C3 No. +440 entitled 56uan Taba#a(, 6r.v. Nanc# T. $or%ano.5

The )ntecedent 7acts

The instant case ste//ed fro/ an a/ended co/plaint8for annul/ent of docu/ent andreconve#ance filed b# 6uan Taba#a(, 6r. &respondent' a(ainst the petitioner, doc9eted asCivil Case No. Ir18+0, ith the Re(ional Trial Court &RTC' of Iri(a Cit#.

The petitioner and the respondent are to of the children of the late 6uan Taba#a( &Taba#a('ho died on 6une , *. Taba#a( oned a parcel of land situated in Sto. Do/in(o, Iri(aCit# &sub:ect propert#'. Ri(ht after the burial of their father, the petitioner alle(edl# re;uestedfro/ her siblin(s that she be alloed to ta9e possession of and receive the inco/e

(enerated b# the sub:ect propert# until after her eldest son could (raduate fro/ colle(e. Thepetitioner

8/9/2019 Lorzano vs Tabayag

4/16

Republic of the PhilippinesSUPREME COURT

Manila

SECOND DIVISION

G.R. No. 189647 February 6, !1

N"NC# T. $OR%"NO,Petitioner,vs.&U"N T"'"#"G, &R.,Respondent.

D E C I S I O N

RE#ES, J.:

Nature of the Petition

This is a petition for revie on certiorariunder Rule !" of the Rules of Court filed b# Nanc# T.$or%ano &petitioner' assailin( the Court of )ppeals &C)' Decision*dated March *+, -- andResolutiondated Septe/ber *0, -- in C)12.R. C3 No. +440 entitled 56uan Taba#a(, 6r.v. Nanc# T. $or%ano.5

The )ntecedent 7acts

The instant case ste//ed fro/ an a/ended co/plaint8for annul/ent of docu/ent andreconve#ance filed b# 6uan Taba#a(, 6r. &respondent' a(ainst the petitioner, doc9eted asCivil Case No. Ir18+0, ith the Re(ional Trial Court &RTC' of Iri(a Cit#.

The petitioner and the respondent are to of the children of the late 6uan Taba#a( &Taba#a('ho died on 6une , *. Taba#a( oned a parcel of land situated in Sto. Do/in(o, Iri(aCit# &sub:ect propert#'. Ri(ht after the burial of their father, the petitioner alle(edl# re;uestedfro/ her siblin(s that she be alloed to ta9e possession of and receive the inco/e

(enerated b# the sub:ect propert# until after her eldest son could (raduate fro/ colle(e. Thepetitioner

8/9/2019 Lorzano vs Tabayag

5/16

Republic of the PhilippinesSUPREME COURT

Manila

SECOND DIVISION

G.R. No. 189647 February 6, !1

N"NC# T. $OR%"NO,Petitioner,vs.&U"N T"'"#"G, &R.,Respondent.

D E C I S I O N

RE#ES, J.:

Nature of the Petition

This is a petition for revie on certiorariunder Rule !" of the Rules of Court filed b# Nanc# T.$or%ano &petitioner' assailin( the Court of )ppeals &C)' Decision*dated March *+, -- andResolutiondated Septe/ber *0, -- in C)12.R. C3 No. +440 entitled 56uan Taba#a(, 6r.v. Nanc# T. $or%ano.5

The )ntecedent 7acts

The instant case ste//ed fro/ an a/ended co/plaint8for annul/ent of docu/ent andreconve#ance filed b# 6uan Taba#a(, 6r. &respondent' a(ainst the petitioner, doc9eted asCivil Case No. Ir18+0, ith the Re(ional Trial Court &RTC' of Iri(a Cit#.

The petitioner and the respondent are to of the children of the late 6uan Taba#a( &Taba#a('ho died on 6une , *. Taba#a( oned a parcel of land situated in Sto. Do/in(o, Iri(aCit# &sub:ect propert#'. Ri(ht after the burial of their father, the petitioner alle(edl# re;uestedfro/ her siblin(s that she be alloed to ta9e possession of and receive the inco/e

(enerated b# the sub:ect propert# until after her eldest son could (raduate fro/ colle(e. Thepetitioner

8/9/2019 Lorzano vs Tabayag

6/16

Republic of the PhilippinesSUPREME COURT

Manila

SECOND DIVISION

G.R. No. 189647 February 6, !1

N"NC# T. $OR%"NO,Petitioner,vs.&U"N T"'"#"G, &R.,Respondent.

D E C I S I O N

RE#ES, J.:

Nature of the Petition

This is a petition for revie on certiorariunder Rule !" of the Rules of Court filed b# Nanc# T.$or%ano &petitioner' assailin( the Court of )ppeals &C)' Decision*dated March *+, -- andResolutiondated Septe/ber *0, -- in C)12.R. C3 No. +440 entitled 56uan Taba#a(, 6r.v. Nanc# T. $or%ano.5

The )ntecedent 7acts

The instant case ste//ed fro/ an a/ended co/plaint8for annul/ent of docu/ent andreconve#ance filed b# 6uan Taba#a(, 6r. &respondent' a(ainst the petitioner, doc9eted asCivil Case No. Ir18+0, ith the Re(ional Trial Court &RTC' of Iri(a Cit#.

The petitioner and the respondent are to of the children of the late 6uan Taba#a( &Taba#a('ho died on 6une , *. Taba#a( oned a parcel of land situated in Sto. Do/in(o, Iri(aCit# &sub:ect propert#'. Ri(ht after the burial of their father, the petitioner alle(edl# re;uestedfro/ her siblin(s that she be alloed to ta9e possession of and receive the inco/e

(enerated b# the sub:ect propert# until after her eldest son could (raduate fro/ colle(e. Thepetitioner

8/9/2019 Lorzano vs Tabayag

7/16

Republic of the PhilippinesSUPREME COURT

Manila

SECOND DIVISION

G.R. No. 189647 February 6, !1

N"NC# T. $OR%"NO,Petitioner,vs.&U"N T"'"#"G, &R.,Respondent.

D E C I S I O N

RE#ES, J.:

Nature of the Petition

This is a petition for revie on certiorariunder Rule !" of the Rules of Court filed b# Nanc# T.$or%ano &petitioner' assailin( the Court of )ppeals &C)' Decision*dated March *+, -- andResolutiondated Septe/ber *0, -- in C)12.R. C3 No. +440 entitled 56uan Taba#a(, 6r.v. Nanc# T. $or%ano.5

The )ntecedent 7acts

The instant case ste//ed fro/ an a/ended co/plaint8for annul/ent of docu/ent andreconve#ance filed b# 6uan Taba#a(, 6r. &respondent' a(ainst the petitioner, doc9eted asCivil Case No. Ir18+0, ith the Re(ional Trial Court &RTC' of Iri(a Cit#.

The petitioner and the respondent are to of the children of the late 6uan Taba#a( &Taba#a('ho died on 6une , *. Taba#a( oned a parcel of land situated in Sto. Do/in(o, Iri(aCit# &sub:ect propert#'. Ri(ht after the burial of their father, the petitioner alle(edl# re;uestedfro/ her siblin(s that she be alloed to ta9e possession of and receive the inco/e

(enerated b# the sub:ect propert# until after her eldest son could (raduate fro/ colle(e. Thepetitioner

8/9/2019 Lorzano vs Tabayag

8/16

Republic of the PhilippinesSUPREME COURT

Manila

SECOND DIVISION

G.R. No. 189647 February 6, !1

N"NC# T. $OR%"NO,Petitioner,vs.&U"N T"'"#"G, &R.,Respondent.

D E C I S I O N

RE#ES, J.:

Nature of the Petition

This is a petition for revie on certiorariunder Rule !" of the Rules of Court filed b# Nanc# T.$or%ano &petitioner' assailin( the Court of )ppeals &C)' Decision*dated March *+, -- andResolutiondated Septe/ber *0, -- in C)12.R. C3 No. +440 entitled 56uan Taba#a(, 6r.v. Nanc# T. $or%ano.5

The )ntecedent 7acts

The instant case ste//ed fro/ an a/ended co/plaint8for annul/ent of docu/ent andreconve#ance filed b# 6uan Taba#a(, 6r. &respondent' a(ainst the petitioner, doc9eted asCivil Case No. Ir18+0, ith the Re(ional Trial Court &RTC' of Iri(a Cit#.

The petitioner and the respondent are to of the children of the late 6uan Taba#a( &Taba#a('ho died on 6une , *. Taba#a( oned a parcel of land situated in Sto. Do/in(o, Iri(aCit# &sub:ect propert#'. Ri(ht after the burial of their father, the petitioner alle(edl# re;uestedfro/ her siblin(s that she be alloed to ta9e possession of and receive the inco/e

(enerated b# the sub:ect propert# until after her eldest son could (raduate fro/ colle(e. Thepetitioner

8/9/2019 Lorzano vs Tabayag

9/16

Republic of the PhilippinesSUPREME COURT

Manila

SECOND DIVISION

G.R. No. 189647 February 6, !1

N"NC# T. $OR%"NO,Petitioner,vs.&U"N T"'"#"G, &R.,Respondent.

D E C I S I O N

RE#ES, J.:

Nature of the Petition

This is a petition for revie on certiorariunder Rule !" of the Rules of Court filed b# Nanc# T.$or%ano &petitioner' assailin( the Court of )ppeals &C)' Decision*dated March *+, -- andResolutiondated Septe/ber *0, -- in C)12.R. C3 No. +440 entitled 56uan Taba#a(, 6r.v. Nanc# T. $or%ano.5

The )ntecedent 7acts

The instant case ste//ed fro/ an a/ended co/plaint8for annul/ent of docu/ent andreconve#ance filed b# 6uan Taba#a(, 6r. &respondent' a(ainst the petitioner, doc9eted asCivil Case No. Ir18+0, ith the Re(ional Trial Court &RTC' of Iri(a Cit#.

The petitioner and the respondent are to of the children of the late 6uan Taba#a( &Taba#a('ho died on 6une , *. Taba#a( oned a parcel of land situated in Sto. Do/in(o, Iri(aCit# &sub:ect propert#'. Ri(ht after the burial of their father, the petitioner alle(edl# re;uestedfro/ her siblin(s that she be alloed to ta9e possession of and receive the inco/e

(enerated b# the sub:ect propert# until after her eldest son could (raduate fro/ colle(e. Thepetitionertent as abovestated &par. 4, Co/plaint, )nne> ). to Petition'.

7ro/ The alle(ations of the co/plaint as set forth above, as ell as inhe ;uestioned Order;uoted earlier, e a(ree ith respondent :ud(e that the co/plaint states no cause of actionupon hich to render :ud(/ent in favor of petitioner, even assu/in( S the said alle(ations to

http://www.lawphil.net/judjuris/juri2012/feb2012/gr_189647_2012.html#fnt1http://www.lawphil.net/judjuris/juri2012/feb2012/gr_189647_2012.html#fnt2http://www.lawphil.net/judjuris/juri2012/feb2012/gr_189647_2012.html#fnt3http://www.lawphil.net/judjuris/juri2012/feb2012/gr_189647_2012.html#fnt3http://www.lawphil.net/judjuris/juri2012/feb2012/gr_189647_2012.html#fnt4http://www.lawphil.net/judjuris/juri2012/feb2012/gr_189647_2012.html#fnt1http://www.lawphil.net/judjuris/juri2012/feb2012/gr_189647_2012.html#fnt2http://www.lawphil.net/judjuris/juri2012/feb2012/gr_189647_2012.html#fnt3http://www.lawphil.net/judjuris/juri2012/feb2012/gr_189647_2012.html#fnt4

8/9/2019 Lorzano vs Tabayag

10/16

Republic of the PhilippinesSUPREME COURT

Manila

SECOND DIVISION

G.R. No. 189647 February 6, !1

N"NC# T. $OR%"NO,Petitioner,vs.&U"N T"'"#"G, &R.,Respondent.

D E C I S I O N

RE#ES, J.:

Nature of the Petition

This is a petition for revie on certiorariunder Rule !" of the Rules of Court filed b# Nanc# T.$or%ano &petitioner' assailin( the Court of )ppeals &C)' Decision*dated March *+, -- andResolutiondated Septe/ber *0, -- in C)12.R. C3 No. +440 entitled 56uan Taba#a(, 6r.v. Nanc# T. $or%ano.5

The )ntecedent 7acts

The instant case ste//ed fro/ an a/ended co/plaint8for annul/ent of docu/ent andreconve#ance filed b# 6uan Taba#a(, 6r. &respondent' a(ainst the petitioner, doc9eted asCivil Case No. Ir18+0, ith the Re(ional Trial Court &RTC' of Iri(a Cit#.

The petitioner and the respondent are to of the children of the late 6uan Taba#a( &Taba#a('ho died on 6une , *. Taba#a( oned a parcel of land situated in Sto. Do/in(o, Iri(aCit# &sub:ect propert#'. Ri(ht after the burial of their father, the petitioner alle(edl# re;uestedfro/ her siblin(s that she be alloed to ta9e possession of and receive the inco/e

(enerated b# the sub:ect propert# until after her eldest son could (raduate fro/ colle(e. Thepetitioner

8/9/2019 Lorzano vs Tabayag

11/16

Republic of the PhilippinesSUPREME COURT

Manila

SECOND DIVISION

G.R. No. 189647 February 6, !1

N"NC# T. $OR%"NO,Petitioner,vs.&U"N T"'"#"G, &R.,Respondent.

D E C I S I O N

RE#ES, J.:

Nature of the Petition

This is a petition for revie on certiorariunder Rule !" of the Rules of Court filed b# Nanc# T.$or%ano &petitioner' assailin( the Court of )ppeals &C)' Decision*dated March *+, -- andResolutiondated Septe/ber *0, -- in C)12.R. C3 No. +440 entitled 56uan Taba#a(, 6r.v. Nanc# T. $or%ano.5

The )ntecedent 7acts

The instant case ste//ed fro/ an a/ended co/plaint8for annul/ent of docu/ent andreconve#ance filed b# 6uan Taba#a(, 6r. &respondent' a(ainst the petitioner, doc9eted asCivil Case No. Ir18+0, ith the Re(ional Trial Court &RTC' of Iri(a Cit#.

The petitioner and the respondent are to of the children of the late 6uan Taba#a( &Taba#a('ho died on 6une , *. Taba#a( oned a parcel of land situated in Sto. Do/in(o, Iri(aCit# &sub:ect propert#'. Ri(ht after the burial of their father, the petitioner alle(edl# re;uestedfro/ her siblin(s that she be alloed to ta9e possession of and receive the inco/e

(enerated b# the sub:ect propert# until after her eldest son could (raduate fro/ colle(e. Thepetitioner

8/9/2019 Lorzano vs Tabayag

12/16

Republic of the PhilippinesSUPREME COURT

Manila

SECOND DIVISION

G.R. No. 189647 February 6, !1

N"NC# T. $OR%"NO,Petitioner,vs.&U"N T"'"#"G, &R.,Respondent.

D E C I S I O N

RE#ES, J.:

Nature of the Petition

This is a petition for revie on certiorariunder Rule !" of the Rules of Court filed b# Nanc# T.$or%ano &petitioner' assailin( the Court of )ppeals &C)' Decision*dated March *+, -- andResolutiondated Septe/ber *0, -- in C)12.R. C3 No. +440 entitled 56uan Taba#a(, 6r.v. Nanc# T. $or%ano.5

The )ntecedent 7acts

The instant case ste//ed fro/ an a/ended co/plaint8for annul/ent of docu/ent andreconve#ance filed b# 6uan Taba#a(, 6r. &respondent' a(ainst the petitioner, doc9eted asCivil Case No. Ir18+0, ith the Re(ional Trial Court &RTC' of Iri(a Cit#.

The petitioner and the respondent are to of the children of the late 6uan Taba#a( &Taba#a('ho died on 6une , *. Taba#a( oned a parcel of land situated in Sto. Do/in(o, Iri(aCit# &sub:ect propert#'. Ri(ht after the burial of their father, the petitioner alle(edl# re;uestedfro/ her siblin(s that she be alloed to ta9e possession of and receive the inco/e

(enerated b# the sub:ect propert# until after her eldest son could (raduate fro/ colle(e. Thepetitioner

8/9/2019 Lorzano vs Tabayag

13/16

Republic of the PhilippinesSUPREME COURT

Manila

SECOND DIVISION

G.R. No. 189647 February 6, !1

N"NC# T. $OR%"NO,Petitioner,vs.&U"N T"'"#"G, &R.,Respondent.

D E C I S I O N

RE#ES, J.:

Nature of the Petition

This is a petition for revie on certiorariunder Rule !" of the Rules of Court filed b# Nanc# T.$or%ano &petitioner' assailin( the Court of )ppeals &C)' Decision*dated March *+, -- andResolutiondated Septe/ber *0, -- in C)12.R. C3 No. +440 entitled 56uan Taba#a(, 6r.v. Nanc# T. $or%ano.5

The )ntecedent 7acts

The instant case ste//ed fro/ an a/ended co/plaint8for annul/ent of docu/ent andreconve#ance filed b# 6uan Taba#a(, 6r. &respondent' a(ainst the petitioner, doc9eted asCivil Case No. Ir18+0, ith the Re(ional Trial Court &RTC' of Iri(a Cit#.

The petitioner and the respondent are to of the children of the late 6uan Taba#a( &Taba#a('ho died on 6une , *. Taba#a( oned a parcel of land situated in Sto. Do/in(o, Iri(aCit# &sub:ect propert#'. Ri(ht after the burial of their father, the petitioner alle(edl# re;uestedfro/ her siblin(s that she be alloed to ta9e possession of and receive the inco/e

(enerated b# the sub:ect propert# until after her eldest son could (raduate fro/ colle(e. Thepetitioner

8/9/2019 Lorzano vs Tabayag

14/16

Republic of the PhilippinesSUPREME COURT

Manila

SECOND DIVISION

G.R. No. 189647 February 6, !1

N"NC# T. $OR%"NO,Petitioner,vs.&U"N T"'"#"G, &R.,Respondent.

D E C I S I O N

RE#ES, J.:

Nature of the Petition

This is a petition for revie on certiorariunder Rule !" of the Rules of Court filed b# Nanc# T.$or%ano &petitioner' assailin( the Court of )ppeals &C)' Decision*dated March *+, -- andResolutiondated Septe/ber *0, -- in C)12.R. C3 No. +440 entitled 56uan Taba#a(, 6r.v. Nanc# T. $or%ano.5

The )ntecedent 7acts

The instant case ste//ed fro/ an a/ended co/plaint8for annul/ent of docu/ent andreconve#ance filed b# 6uan Taba#a(, 6r. &respondent' a(ainst the petitioner, doc9eted asCivil Case No. Ir18+0, ith the Re(ional Trial Court &RTC' of Iri(a Cit#.

The petitioner and the respondent are to of the children of the late 6uan Taba#a( &Taba#a('ho died on 6une , *. Taba#a( oned a parcel of land situated in Sto. Do/in(o, Iri(aCit# &sub:ect propert#'. Ri(ht after the burial of their father, the petitioner alle(edl# re;uestedfro/ her siblin(s that she be alloed to ta9e possession of and receive the inco/e

(enerated b# the sub:ect propert# until after her eldest son could (raduate fro/ colle(e. Thepetitioner

8/9/2019 Lorzano vs Tabayag

15/16

Republic of the PhilippinesSUPREME COURT

Manila

SECOND DIVISION

G.R. No. 189647 February 6, !1

N"NC# T. $OR%"NO,Petitioner,vs.&U"N T"'"#"G, &R.,Respondent.

D E C I S I O N

RE#ES, J.:

Nature of the Petition

This is a petition for revie on certiorariunder Rule !" of the Rules of Court filed b# Nanc# T.$or%ano &petitioner' assailin( the Court of )ppeals &C)' Decision*dated March *+, -- andResolutiondated Septe/ber *0, -- in C)12.R. C3 No. +440 entitled 56uan Taba#a(, 6r.v. Nanc# T. $or%ano.5

The )ntecedent 7acts

The instant case ste//ed fro/ an a/ended co/plaint8for annul/ent of docu/ent andreconve#ance filed b# 6uan Taba#a(, 6r. &respondent' a(ainst the petitioner, doc9eted asCivil Case No. Ir18+0, ith the Re(ional Trial Court &RTC' of Iri(a Cit#.

The petitioner and the respondent are to of the children of the late 6uan Taba#a( &Taba#a('ho died on 6une , *. Taba#a( oned a parcel of land situated in Sto. Do/in(o, Iri(aCit# &sub:ect propert#'. Ri(ht after the burial of their father, the petitioner alle(edl# re;uestedfro/ her siblin(s that she be alloed to ta9e possession of and receive the inco/e

(enerated b# the sub:ect propert# until after her eldest son could (raduate fro/ colle(e. Thepetitioner

8/9/2019 Lorzano vs Tabayag

16/16

Republic of the PhilippinesSUPREME COURT

Manila

SECOND DIVISION

G.R. No. 189647 February 6, !1

N"NC# T. $OR%"NO,Petitioner,vs.&U"N T"'"#"G, &R.,Respondent.

D E C I S I O N

RE#ES, J.:

Nature of the Petition

This is a petition for revie on certiorariunder Rule !" of the Rules of Court filed b# Nanc# T.$or%ano &petitioner' assailin( the Court of )ppeals &C)' Decision*dated March *+, -- andResolutiondated Septe/ber *0, -- in C)12.R. C3 No. +440 entitled 56uan Taba#a(, 6r.v. Nanc# T. $or%ano.5

The )ntecedent 7acts

The instant case ste//ed fro/ an a/ended co/plaint8for annul/ent of docu/ent andreconve#ance filed b# 6uan Taba#a(, 6r. &respondent' a(ainst the petitioner, doc9eted asCivil Case No. Ir18+0, ith the Re(ional Trial Court &RTC' of Iri(a Cit#.

The petitioner and the respondent are to of the children of the late 6uan Taba#a( &Taba#a('ho died on 6une , *. Taba#a( oned a parcel of land situated in Sto. Do/in(o, Iri(aCit# &sub:ect propert#'. Ri(ht after the burial of their father, the petitioner alle(edl# re;uestedfro/ her siblin(s that she be alloed to ta9e possession of and receive the inco/e

(enerated b# the sub:ect propert# until after her eldest son could (raduate fro/ colle(e. Thepetitioner