Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    1/134

    Prepared for

    L I, WA

    Submied By

    J K* | A B | H B | J B

    Ry C | Ax G | K G | N H | A L

    D S | P Yg | C G | C G

    T My I I S

    My, CA. My 2012.

    G Dg y A B. A g y .

    *Cg (j@g.)

    LOPEZ ISLAND 2025sustainable transformations for resilience

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    2/134

    2

    TABLE OF CONTENTS

    Acknowledgements

    Executive Summary

    Ky D

    I

    Transportation

    C P

    Vg: S T O C A

    P P & R F

    P S & R

    Vg: jRIDESHARE Pg

    Vg: Pv R L

    Cg R

    Agriculture and Water

    C P

    Vg: J F

    Vg: W Sy LP P & R F

    P S & R

    Vg: S&S H F

    Cg R

    Waste

    C P

    P P A R F

    P S R

    Vg: S My Sg F

    Cg R

    4

    5

    7

    8

    14

    16

    25

    26

    28

    33

    46

    47

    48

    51

    55

    5961

    63

    73

    74

    75

    76

    79

    80

    88

    89

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    3/134

    3 -- -- -- -- --

    Electricity and Heating

    C P

    Vg: R S

    P P A R F

    Vg: Cy SP S R

    Vg: C G

    Cg R

    Conclusion

    Mx P S

    R Iv

    I A

    Appendices

    B R O S L-S A

    L S D B F O

    A P L Egy R

    Notes

    90

    91

    97

    99

    101102

    109

    110

    111

    112

    114

    114

    116

    117

    124

    125

    129

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    4/134

    4

    Acknowledgments

    T v gy, , g, vy y

    v, vy g. Sy B, R M, F V D P, V D,

    Dg P, B C, CB H, C A, T C, Dv Z, Tq E, N H-

    v g g L I. W

    W A, R B, A B, Pggy B, Z Bg, MR B, T C,

    V D, A Dy, S Fy, B Kv, R My, D My, Dy P, Dg P,

    Rx R, S D Ry, L Sy, J S, R S, G V D P, Ny W-

    , E Yg, Sv W, A L, C G, Hg By F, H

    C F, L B, Lv, L C C, L -

    , S J Pv T SG F g g vg

    , , g . I , S By, A L, H

    M, P Py, S D Ry, K Yv gy v

    g g y , y g.

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    5/134

    5

    EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

    L I, y 2,800 Pg S, .

    T g 2025 ,

    jy, y y. W gg , y,

    g , y g y L I,

    v .

    A g vv v y y, gg

    gg L g -

    y x v -y, y, y. W v vv

    y . O y xv g -

    v L I, y y

    g v v L x.

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    6/134

    6 -- -- -- -- --

    Rgg y , gg , -

    x, v y g

    . P y,

    y g v y, y, y

    y vy

    Host seasonal community events to promote local agriculture

    Localize the waste collecon system

    Collect and distribute treated sewage water from the Fisherman Bay sewage district for use

    in select crop irrigaon

    Create an energy interest group

    Create a value-add communal industrial kitchen

    Conduct a transportaon infrastructure climate change vulnerability assessment

    Implement Lopez Rocks & Rolls an informal rideshare program

    Improve bicycling infrastructure

    Promote local farmers through educaonal campaigns

    Parcipate in OPALCOs MORE program

    Conduct a solar resource site assessment

    Take advantage of Energy Eciency Snapshots from OPALCO

    Use available nancing for energy eciency improvements

    Build a co-op greenhouse

    Conserve energy and shi usage away from peak hours

    Increase the share of hybrid vehicles on the island

    Form a local agriculture advisory commiee

    1)

    2)

    3)

    4)

    5)

    6)

    7)

    8)

    9)

    10)

    11)

    12)

    13)

    14)

    15)

    16)

    17)

    Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    W g y y L I: transportaon; agriculture and water;

    waste; electricity and heang. W j , 17 L-

    g 2025

    jy. I v y, y,

    y, 17 :

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    7/134

    7

    KEY DEFINITIONS

    Sustainable Transformaons for ResilienceA x g g , -

    g j q vgg yg v y,

    y g, q , g . W g

    v g j . T -

    v, , y, v-

    g g y ,

    g, . Ty y v y v

    x v g. T g g v-

    y (STR g) v-

    g y . A

    gy x g g gg, g g

    , , .

    Culture, Heritage, and Tradion

    W g L I y, , g,

    y q

    g y v

    v . T y

    L

    gv y.

    Resilience and AdaptabilityTg ,

    y y, y, g-g , y, y

    g v y

    g. Ay

    y y, q

    ,

    , , ,

    g.

    Environmental Sustainability

    F , USEv P Agy -

    v y: Ev -

    y

    x v

    y, g ,

    q g-

    .

    I- , , g, g y v -

    y, . W y

    g :

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    8/134

    8

    INTRODUCTION

    AN ISLAND FOCUS...W v q g v

    y L I g

    y -

    v vyg L q

    g .

    W y

    L I q g, g

    , , y ,

    . I, -

    y

    g g g

    jy

    vg g L,

    L.

    W 30 q (gy

    q M), L I

    g S J Cy

    Pg S

    Wg . Dg ,

    , y y , L-

    vy gy

    y. T y ,

    g ,, v -

    [1].

    L 2,800

    v 5,500 g

    4 Jy. Ag 16

    S J Cy , L

    g y v 20 -

    3,400 y 2025 [2]. L g 56.8

    y y g

    g 37.2 [3]. T y

    Fg 1 g -

    vy g L . Fg

    2 g

    g g 50, g 50 59, g

    60 v, L, S J Cy, Wg-

    S, y. Dg x

    S J Cy g 65

    38 y y

    2020, gy 2.5 g x

    g [4]. S y v g

    Figure 1:

    Age prole of Lopex Island.

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    9/134

    9 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    L, ggg g L g

    g gg .

    Ag 2010 US C, L

    I 3,249 g ,

    (1,673) y v. By -

    , y 3 g W-

    g y v 2010. T

    vg j

    v. O-

    75 -

    , -

    25 ([3] [4]).

    M L I 2010

    $52,600, $5,000

    g $57,200 [5]. A -

    vy g vg

    g y L y

    vy . F x,

    L I g q 2012 j v $350,000

    [6],

    g $208,300 [7]. I ,

    L I gy y $0.50

    g g

    y . L I y

    y y , vy [1]. Ag 2010 , 21

    L I

    g 18 v US C vy

    v ( $15,000 $20,000 y

    y, g y ),

    15 Wg ([5] [8]). P

    v g, 51 y

    L I qy

    [9].

    T g , Fg 1, y

    g g

    . O q

    g - y

    . T y 4

    , y v

    g 16 y y

    16

    Wg. T y

    g L I

    [5].

    ...IN A GLOBAL CONTEXTT 21 y v g,

    , v g

    g I

    Figure 2:

    Age Category Comparison.

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    10/134

    10 -- -- -- -- --

    Rv v 200 y g. I -

    y v ,

    g, g, . H

    y v -

    , , v

    g. I x g g

    y L I.

    These shis are already underway. T, x-

    , g. S v v v

    8 1900 [10], g g

    y 350 y

    [11]. U

    CO2

    v

    [12]. T v v g g

    v 30 y g [13]. T 10 y

    1880 v

    14 y [14]. A gg y

    v ,

    x v g -

    y (,

    x, T W F, y H C-

    , y g).

    The world stands on the verge of global economic

    change. B, I, C v g

    US E U ,

    g- ([15]: A M

    CTO M P C) g-v

    v ([16]: I Sy R

    C I) g-gy

    ([17]: B y -

    ). T 2008 U S

    g , g y y-

    vy

    y (S, x, M v My

    y NOVA). T E

    y g

    E

    g vy g. A

    y g

    v [18] vg

    [19] y. Oq

    OPEC v [20],

    yg x,, g [21]

    v g

    g y g .

    Communies are already mobilizing in the face of

    these global paradigm shis.Ov 500 -vg

    v -

    y, -y, x

    x g y [22].

    H g vy v

    g y g [23]. C v ggv g

    g (, x: [24] [25] [26]).

    A - y gg

    (, x,

    D g y

    gy y 2050, C C I

    j N S). T

    v y y v y

    y y g v-

    , g-

    g v-

    vg . F

    , y

    g g jy

    v , y,

    v .

    Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    GUIDED BY PRIOR RESEARCHExv - y-

    , v , g

    y L I. I ,

    g y L

    I S J Cy. T I Ev-

    R E P N-

    Egy I C: A 10-y

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    11/134

    11 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    P v g y

    y y gy

    L I g v

    v y. I

    1998, S J Cy Cy Dv

    Pg D -v y v g

    2020, gy

    g v. F

    , g v

    L I S J Cy, g

    y, y,

    y y. O , y

    , v-

    g S J Cy -

    v .

    Sv - S J Cy

    v g . F,

    g -

    S J Cy H Sv T

    P xg v

    , y , , -

    . S, Ag R C-

    S J Cy 2011 -

    g g y g

    . T ,

    Gg F: A Ag Sg A-

    P S J Cy, v -

    g- ,

    , g L

    I g . T, S J Cy

    2004 g

    g

    y L

    v g, -,

    . T L I,

    g

    y , S J Cy W R

    Mg P. Fy, N P

    Cv C, Sx N

    Cv E P P

    2010 v y

    g , y

    y

    L I y y

    .

    W y g

    L I qg v g,

    gy y g -

    qg qy v g-

    gy. Ev y -

    gy v

    (.g., , , ),

    y q - v

    gy (.g., y, -

    g , ). Tg

    j, g gy L I, g y, ,

    , g . T

    gy -

    g g gy v v

    L I. D Yg ,

    T P T Q, v

    v gy y

    v y y v .

    Ly L Egy Sy W?

    F W? y C H Fy

    2012 gv x vv -

    gy g

    g y. Fy, J W

    Nv 2011 S

    g y

    gy y -

    v g

    g g v g .

    T , v,

    - vL I , y, -

    y. T j

    , g , ,

    y g vg -

    y . W

    v -

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    12/134

    12 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    y- , y g,

    . T : T T

    H: F O Dy L R-

    y R H,

    g g y -y

    g - vv; C Ey

    Ly Sv L L Sy

    Cg gv

    g g

    y; Sv M T R

    Sy: T C-F Lvg

    Fg, Gy, -

    Fg, Gy,

    v v y; -

    L Uvy I I

    I Ev E (IIIEE) S, D T: I E,

    Egy Sy M T R

    Ly P Egy, Ly S-

    Dv: T My Tj,

    g -

    y g y IIIEE

    g g. T gy

    y

    y ,

    -, , y

    .

    , -

    L-

    Ax 1.

    T - -

    j y 11 My I I S

    My, CA. W j

    : g , - -

    , - , -

    y. Dg ,

    g L I,

    S J Cy, v

    - . O

    - -

    v x

    y j . I -M, 2012, v L I -

    g v . Dg y, y

    v, v,

    g, g -

    . T -

    v

    g

    q L I. Fg

    , y v-

    y y x

    g . T -

    g

    g .

    B vg ,

    vy y L

    y g

    . T vy L q-

    j

    , g ,, y g. A

    g , 73

    vy. B g

    g jy vy -

    y (.g., y v-

    g L, y-

    SCOPE AND METHODOLOGY OF ANALYSISL I yy, y,

    y, vy

    . T, y - y -

    y y. W y

    v L I y -

    g v L I y -

    v / L y vy L.T L

    2025 g

    L I -

    . Rgg ,

    y, , y g,

    y y gg -

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    13/134

    13 -- -- -- -- --

    vg L,

    vg L, .),

    vy y gv qv -

    v ,

    gg y

    vy . T, -v x

    v g -

    .

    T

    g

    j. T, y , -

    y, j

    , vv

    j. T v

    j ,

    . T URL

    y

    g v,

    g

    v -

    . R y v j

    : ://g..//

    Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    . Nx, y

    g

    jy. T

    . T g-

    , : 1) -; 2) g ;

    3) g

    -

    . W g

    g

    : v y, ,

    y . W

    . W gv

    1, 2, 3, ?

    (3 gyg g , ? y-

    g ). F gg g, -

    g g . W

    y

    L- (.g., y

    y) Ax 1. A

    j -

    . T vg, g

    q L

    , gg ,

    x g x v

    y .

    T y g

    L- -

    , qg ,

    x, g v-

    x

    g x. W y

    v v y,

    g v -

    .

    REPORT ROADMAPT v y

    L I

    g: ; g;

    ; y g. T

    yg v g

    y ,

    v

    g-

    . F x, g

    g , y g

    .

    E . F,

    qvy qvy

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    14/134

    T r a n s p o r t a t i o n

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    15/134

    15 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    Ey L g , vg , , ,

    g v . T

    L ,

    g, g. I 1920

    g L, g

    [27]. T v

    -y L

    . Zg

    g 5

    -y g

    v.

    L y v

    L .

    L y , , L

    Wg S Fy y

    vg L .

    Evg y

    L gv gg

    v x -

    v, g y

    v, gg g g,

    g y v. Hv,

    v y

    L, v vg -

    g g g y

    (.g., g

    ) g y y v-

    g .

    T -g

    L .

    B -

    v L, g ,

    , ,

    . W g

    v L -

    . T vy L -

    , g

    . W

    v ,

    g L

    .

    Fuel Tanker

    SOURCE: hp://2.bp.blogspot.

    com/_4WUPg88IbTU/S90FjA-q6UI/

    AAAAAAAAABo/63CcKoJcmfc/

    s1600/

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    16/134

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    17/134

    17 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    g $4.25 (

    $4.00, L $4.50),

    L y $1,900 y

    g, $100 y

    . Tg v vy,

    v A v -

    g v y, y vg

    vg .

    Hg g y v

    v vg g L.

    My L v g -

    , y -

    g. M Jg, g-

    L , g , y ,

    y . Hg

    y g

    g -

    [27]. W qy g -

    , x -

    g y v U.S. C . L

    700 v g -

    80 vv g. T

    g g

    y U.S.

    [5]. T g

    g v, S

    J Cy g y (://

    .j.g/) 2006/7,

    g, g g y

    x L. Nv,

    g g y -

    g y v . Rg

    , g- L , 20-y x C.B. H , A y

    .

    My y

    x, g yg

    L, . R

    vg L Vg yg -

    y v. Mv, y

    L y y,

    T L

    . Hv, , yg

    jy g

    . A yg- gg

    , ,

    yg . T -

    x -

    y y,

    y g g v

    g y g

    .

    T L vg g y. Hv, -

    v y y y

    , , L Vg, L S

    g . F,

    y y

    D , x -

    vg y

    . T xg -

    1.3 g--y

    g F By R, L R,

    W R, vy

    [29]. R g--y j

    , 4 5 , ADA -

    . T L Cy T

    N (LCTN), g L ,

    v vy y g

    g -

    y [30]. K

    Ty LCTN x LCTN

    , y q -

    g . T vy v g vg S J I Pv

    T, S J C-

    y L B. Ty g g

    y g xg L

    . My x

    gg g g g

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    18/134

    18 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    , g y gy g -

    v [31].

    Public Transportaon

    L y gy

    v L v y. T

    y

    v y . T L

    S D y y g

    v y

    g. F

    , Ax 2. T L

    S C S J Cy-

    8- v

    . V-

    v v v v 15 g , v yy

    - [32]. My

    x v x L;

    gg v . Ry W,

    x v y,

    v L x, g gg

    v [33].

    Gv v, y v

    L .

    P g vy

    S J Cy C H Sv

    T P 2010 [4] g

    y L g y

    v:

    Shule service between the ferry terminal and

    Lopez village

    Year-round small bus service islandwide

    Subsidized taxi service for medical appoint-ments and errands, serving low income se-

    niors and mobility-constrained individuals

    More frequent o-island Senior Center van

    trips for these purposes

    Allow broader use of the Senior Center vans

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    S ,

    -

    v gg

    - y

    .

    Commercial Transportaon

    T v g, -

    , , . W

    , v

    v y L , g

    L Vg M, T S,

    S D, L S Gv, US

    v. F y g

    v

    , v

    - v

    y g.

    T L Vg M (LVM) y -

    , , L.

    O A Dy y -

    v . I

    , I y . LVM g x

    vg $1,000 (y -

    )

    v y. N-

    S

    Bg . P , vgg 170

    , U S

    . T qy g -

    . D g y g

    L, LVM g vg 2 -

    , v ,

    x v LVM

    [34].

    LVM g , vgg 450

    500 g y g y -

    g 600 700 g y g

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    19/134

    19 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    . A q

    190,000 g. D

    v. D g

    g L, M.

    Dy . H

    y .

    R F, ,

    LVM g [34].

    T g L, L T S S J S

    Cy. S J Cy L

    T S y

    . M v

    T S v, y -

    g L Vg. T T S

    ggg 40 y -

    v y O I

    v ggg 120

    y () v

    y . I 2011,

    T S 432

    gg 291 g

    y L O. T -

    vy y, . S

    J Cy g- W

    Mg gg

    Ag, Og, 350 y. Cg

    y W Mg

    y Wv, S [35].

    S J S Cy y y -

    v L. Ty

    v y 30 y .

    B O I, y gy

    L v y O [35]. T -

    g y S J

    S L T S

    xg -

    g y. T W

    v g

    .

    L S & Gv, y B B-

    F, v

    L I g

    g . L S & Gv

    7,000 8,000 y y, g

    . M g

    gv $78,000. L S & Gv

    40,000 g y

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    20/134

    20 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    R F .

    T v y -

    g g g

    [36]. T W -

    L S & Gv .

    T L I S D

    -

    . T -

    5,800-g v

    S D g.

    Pg S D y gy v . T S D-

    g

    . I

    v y

    . D g

    y, y 3,500 g

    [37].

    A g v, U.S. P

    Sv v y

    y [38]. UPS, F Ex, -

    vy v v L gy

    g x y g.

    AIR TRANSPORTATIONAv v

    g S J I 1940.T P L L A

    v g

    v. L A -

    y v , , -

    , . I 2010

    18,250 , -

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    21/134

    21 -- -- -- -- --

    . Pv g j -

    v 28 [29]. Pv

    jy . O ,

    v y

    [39].

    F L g v, K-

    A v y g

    I R F By [40]. S

    J A g g Bg

    A [41] I A v -

    , , g L

    [42]. F gy , A

    N v v L

    [43].

    Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    WSF v

    - v v. T g-

    y v y 6 y

    g $30 -y $100 g g [45]. Hv,

    v jy WSF v

    .

    WSF y gy v -

    v (L, S, O, S J) -

    q g A. T g

    g y y, -

    g vy

    WSF x v v. T

    g g - . Cy,

    v x L

    y . Hv, v

    v A [46],

    v

    SOURCE: Port of Lopez

    (hp://www.portoopez.com/index.htm)

    WATER TRANSPORTATION

    M L - Wg S Fy (WSF), v

    , , - v,

    x v. I Ex S

    J I x v S J

    I [44]. R v -

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    22/134

    22 -- -- -- -- --

    y v. Ex

    y y g Sg 2012 WSF

    Sg T [46,

    47]. O vg, 5 6 jy

    L q v y -

    , jy L qg 25

    g , g . Tv-

    A I-5 v

    g

    M P [47]. B A S v

    g x:

    A 50

    y v v

    A y

    [48].

    WSF v q

    v g y

    v y. T q

    g y. D q y, y

    x

    g v

    g . T L

    y ,

    g

    . B , WSF v y

    [46]. WSF y

    v y v -

    .

    S L g -

    WSF g v- g

    g - g; ,

    y v x-

    v g. T 1 ( x g) -

    W 2012 .W 72- g

    v -, -v ,

    y g A

    $10 y $40 v y [46].

    Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    SOURCE: IBike USA/Canada

    (hp://ibike.org/ibike/salish/

    essay/5-San%20Juan%20Island.

    htm)

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    23/134

    23 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    $12.05 W-

    $14.05 W- y

    $15.45 My

    $26.15 Dv 14 v

    $29.00 Dv 22 v

    Price Passenger type

    I 2011, A-L y g -

    150,348 v, 106,924 v -

    g, 37,194 g [49]. T g

    L y

    , 2008 Wg-

    S T C vy

    A/S J y xy.

    Ag vy, v g-

    y y , g y 109

    . A 90 g

    g

    . R y

    34

    63 . I

    63 g -

    y [50].

    B 2011 v v

    g y ,

    - L -

    , L

    70,000 y v 2011. I

    L 1,500,

    vg 3.9 y

    v 2011. T -

    y g

    - , vy g L. My L

    vy

    y y

    y

    v .

    TRANSPORTATION FUELS CONSUMPTIONA q L

    y

    : v g v v

    Wg S Fy. C q (-

    , g ) y y q (g, )

    y y v

    g v. I T, y g

    v , gy

    g v.

    L g q : g,

    , , g . G -

    y

    g g.

    P g y y g. O y, S J P,

    . I 2011, S J P

    321,870 g L [51]. A-

    g 6,000 g,

    vg .

    R F g q

    g v v

    v y S J Cy. L v

    Rx R R F . L v

    g x R F g

    g yg

    $0.50 - g

    . R F

    , 2,300-g vy

    , 9,000-g g ,

    9,800-g . T

    g. R F

    g L, L Vg

    M, - W Ly, I S

    L [52].

    R F g 250,000

    g g y, vgg

    100,000 g -

    TABLE 1: Selected WSF winter 2012 westbound single-use

    full fares. SOURCE: Washington State Ferries

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    24/134

    24 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    FIGURE 3: 2011 Esmates of Liq-

    uid Fuel Imports to Lopez

    y, vgg

    . Hg y vg 40,000 g y. I

    y, v gy,

    y g

    y [52]. S v L Vg

    M, v,

    , 2

    [34]. T L S D

    6,000 g [53], L S

    Gv 40,000 g [36],

    g g, xv,

    g. Fg 3 -

    q L 2011.

    Tg v v -

    g g , yL -

    . R

    q -

    q S Fy. M-

    v, y gy v

    . R vy

    vg 54 g-

    . Tg

    x vy

    , g L y. Gv

    L 250,000

    g y g R F ,

    500,000

    g y, L

    .

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    25/134

    25

    Community Transportaon Opons: Insights from Lopez Resident

    Christopher Aiken, San Juan County Mobility Manager

    I x I S J

    Cy My Mg. S vg , y y I v

    L - v y g

    y . I y

    , I v g v g-

    g

    x y

    .

    A I v L, y

    y q -

    gg , ,v - . Ny

    S J Cy

    g. I g -

    y vg

    , I ,

    I g: g

    y y g ,

    y, v

    . I y ,

    , v, - -vg -

    gg q

    y y,

    .

    Rgy x y y -

    g, I y y g -

    y. S J Cy y v g

    Wg S D T-

    g

    q .F L, g

    v

    v g -

    v . T g

    v vy

    v, g x, y, yg vy

    v, xg v, yg

    g. W g -

    q

    v.

    W , . S J

    Cy :

    v g gg , v

    y g g

    , g

    v v. W

    - g v - ,

    g

    . I g

    j , I y

    gg v y

    L.

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    26/134

    26

    [transportation]

    POTENTIAL PROBLEM AREAS AND RISKS FACTORS

    A yg L I q vg , gg

    v y 2012 2025. T v g: y, , g, g

    v, .

    FUEL PRICEA vy g- -

    L I 2025. F, x

    g

    gy v x 13 y. T US Egy

    I Agy g

    y 2 3

    y 2025, y -

    y- , yg

    M E,

    C, US, Mx, E y

    I, g , v

    g y 2025. T y-v-y -

    2-3 y 5

    6 y 30-90

    g y 2025, L I

    2025 2012 . I L

    y g- -

    vy y ,

    g v-

    g L I, ,

    , y g v

    Wg. T v y -

    - ; g

    B T S, US -

    20 42

    [54]. Ag g

    , g

    , g,

    g, y v. Ly,

    v v g

    L I , y

    L y, ,

    gv g

    .

    FUEL SUPPLYT - L I

    y. F, y y

    g v

    g L I,

    y

    . S, vy g

    q g, y

    g ,

    v x g-

    g. A , g v g g -

    L I [52]. Hvy g-

    g- g

    y y.

    BOTTLENECKST x j -

    y -

    : v y. D- v

    v. A g y

    v y

    , .

    B jy L

    I y v y

    , y (.g.,

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    27/134

    27 -- -- -- -- --

    , y ) -

    y v. R g y v

    L I g 2025. I v -

    y v , vy

    Wg S Fy v g v, , v -

    y v (

    ) L.

    Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    POPULATION AND DEMOGRAPHICSSg g g, y -

    S J Cy g

    gg L,

    L I . A

    y gg v - y 2025, y

    x v g

    g y

    x. T gg

    q v

    , g v -

    v. I , S

    J Cy y y 30

    y 2025 [4]. T ,

    y -

    L v y, y y v

    . I

    y L v

    y. I g

    g y

    y y, v

    g

    y y L I

    -

    v .

    CLIMATE CHANGE AND THE

    ENVIRONMENTC g v y

    x L I x v

    , y -

    , , g g, .

    B gg L

    I , gg y

    2012 Wg,

    I C Vy C Cg

    T Sy I

    P N. T -

    - g

    y gg . F, v

    v

    g y, jy

    20 y,

    x g

    , y g . S-

    , g

    y g v,

    v .

    T, v

    y . T y L I,

    ,

    v x v.

    DISASTER RESPONSED, -,

    v L I

    v. N,

    v

    gg -

    vg v

    .

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    28/134

    28

    [transportation]

    Potential Solutions and Recommendations

    T v v y L I. T

    , , , x-

    g . W v L-

    g , x v y,

    , y L, , v x. F

    , . F

    q , y x .

    Recommend Go for Implementaon:

    C g vy

    I L R & R g

    Iv yg

    I y v

    Recommend Further Research:

    B y v y xg v

    S

    I v- g

    Recommend Hold at this Time:

    I v

    Ex g y

    I g y Dvy y-

    1)

    2)

    3)

    4)

    5)

    6)

    7)

    (4)

    8)

    9)10)

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    29/134

    29 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    CONDUCT A TRANSPORTATION INFRASTRUCTURE CLIMATE CHANGE VULNERABIL-

    ITY ASSESSMENT

    Climate change is a global reality with local consequences, L I . T -

    2012 Wg S , L I

    g vy , g , ,g , , . My y x g v-

    y , v L I .

    L y, Wg S D

    T S J Cy P W D.

    1

    Recommendaon:Go

    Ag v -

    g vy ,

    y g,

    g g y

    L g- . T -

    , g -

    v,

    L I -

    g vy .

    Implementaon:

    T j q

    : P, A, S. Dg

    , y

    v j- g . T

    L I

    , vy, v

    g ggy, -

    , ,

    g , y. T

    PROS CONS

    Cy

    F g vy -

    y x y L I

    Pv y y -

    v

    Vy q vy

    , y ( x

    v y

    )

    Pj g q v

    v g ,

    L I g y

    v g g , ,

    ,

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    U (.., xg vg -

    ) y g

    U y y

    y -

    S y q

    g g

    y, ,

    >

    >

    >

    ENVIRONMENTAL

    SUSTAINABILITY

    RESILIENCE&

    ADAPTABILITY

    CULTURAL

    ACCEPTABILITY

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    30/134

    30 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    x g

    g vy -

    L I -

    . Ex

    L I :

    O j , y

    L I

    v v

    . T

    .

    I , v

    v L -

    v, , g, v, ,

    yg y

    vy . T j

    . T -

    , g

    y v

    v g.

    T g

    g vy

    g y, ,

    gy. T

    v v

    q g,v,

    gv gy. T

    gg v

    .

    IMPLEMENT LOPEZ ROCKS & ROLLS

    (AN INFORMAL RIDESHARE PROGRAM)

    2Bg g y , L I

    g L R & R. I y L, -

    y, v. T g -

    g g - gg vg g

    g . I -gg / g v .g.

    Wy g g g g ? Ag g

    y g y g v -

    y g v , , y, gv y gy

    y g .

    >

    >

    >

    Pg 83-86 Uvy Wg-

    C S E Sy:

    ,

    T C-M Ey-B

    Mg T N: ;

    T US D T F-

    Hgy A: , g .

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    31/134

    31 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    L R R L g -

    y , vg, g , v L M, -

    jRIDESHARE, jy g g . W g

    y jRIDESHARE, g q L qg

    g. P- y - LVM, y

    , g , y q gg (.., y x). T v g v , $10,000

    [55]. Sgg v , g ,

    y v, gy q g. Pvg y v

    y q g y y g -

    g [56].

    PROS CONS

    L g g y g

    v

    R v R

    (, , g, , .)

    P

    C g , ,

    v v

    >

    >>

    >

    >

    Rq v L, x,

    g v

    C - v g

    My q g v

    My q gg

    -

    >

    >

    >

    >

    T vg

    L R & R,

    g xy g .Dy. . . . .$16.65

    Wy. . .$83.25

    My. . $333

    Yy. . . .$3,996

    Average Cost of Single Occupancy Vehicle

    Commung in the U.S.:

    MODE DAILY ($)C-2 . . . . .$6.11

    C-3 . . . . .$8.14

    C-4 . . . . .$9.16

    Potenal Savings Per Day

    Versus Driving Alone

    [SOURCE: Volpe Center, US DOT, 2010, Federal Highway Administraons, D.C. (Ridesharing Opons Analysis and Praconers

    Toolkit)]

    Ag V C g

    ,

    v y $4,000, g vg

    $3.00/g ( g

    gy g ). Rg

    - 2-

    $1,466 vg. Rg g, v,

    y y v

    xg gvg , , L M-

    , I .

    ENVIRONMENTAL

    SUSTAINABILITY

    RESILIENCE&

    ADAPTABILITY

    CULTURAL

    ACCEPTABILITY

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    32/134

    32 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    Recommendaon:GOD g v,

    g L R

    R g

    v

    .

    Implementaon:

    W L I

    L R R -

    g:

    PHASE I: Installaon of Lopez Rocks & Rolls sign-

    posts in designated safe and accessible locaons

    that do not require addional road engineering

    for car-pull outs>

    >

    >

    A v

    A v v gg ( v-

    g ). Sgg

    v

    g, gy g

    .

    I gg g -

    -

    -

    Iy ( jRIDESHARE)

    Ev y g

    y

    > A v v g

    -

    -

    -

    Av y

    C , v g-

    j, v

    g , ,

    -

    Av g I

    Wy .g

    PHASE II: Program promoon /

    adversement

    PHASE III: Other promoonal acvies / programs

    >

    >

    P -- ----

    y

    M y, .g. g , g

    v v vg y g

    (P q g

    y vg g)

    -

    -

    R g -

    (: )

    Rv g g

    , v L R &

    R

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    33/134

    33

    sjRIDESHARE PROGRAM

    Ev y L M S J Cyg v x-

    , jRIDESHARE g

    2006 v Cy

    . T

    g gy j GO

    G M Cy, C

    , v

    y , g 20-

    S F D v.

    T jRIDESHARE g

    y vy g

    g v. T S J CyC T

    Fy H v y v

    g y

    g. T vy x, g 5 g

    . M. M v

    gg v -

    g y gy g

    . T g

    y , q

    gg.

    T jRIDESHARE g y

    22 g S J Cy,

    g, v 15 .

    M. M gg g

    g vg

    , . S

    g g

    .

    I, I R y y

    y, y M.M.

    L A S

    g, g g ,

    .j.g.

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    34/134

    34 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    PROS CONS

    L L v

    P y v v yE L I v y

    Iv gg vy y

    I vy L I

    P y vy, qy

    ( ), yg -g

    E-

    >

    >>

    >

    >

    >

    >

    Wg xv

    P y g g g

    T x q

    Sy q

    , y g

    y y g g

    Sgg y q

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    IMPROVE BICYCLING INFRASTRUCTURE3Cyg, y v , y g -

    v , v y g v ,

    , y. Hv, y /

    gg yg v . W gg . F, L I P Sy,

    C R, F By R, M By R, v y , y

    g . S, L I y y

    L S L Vg. T, L I y gg , gv

    , y g y v.

    T qy y-

    g y, -

    y y D. T G 2011

    P, Og. H y

    y v-

    1990 2040 v-

    g, v v ( -

    y g yg), vg

    [57]. H -

    vg 3.8

    1.2 1, g g

    v v . I ,

    vy $1 v y

    v () $1.2 $3.8

    vg,

    g y -

    g yg [57]. T v ,

    g x g.

    ENVIRONMENTAL

    SUSTAINABILITY

    RESILIENCE&

    ADAPTABILITY

    CULTURAL

    ACCEPTABILITY

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    35/134

    35 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    Recommendaon:GOW yg

    v jy x

    y g, g

    y , vg y y.

    W y -

    v yg L.

    Implementaon:

    S J Cy P W 1.7-

    g g v j-

    g F By R y g.

    T j q q

    g--y 24 y

    g 19

    g [58]. T j

    [1].

    W g g g

    y y

    g

    y / v j. S

    y j, y

    v (y

    y ) x y, ,

    g , ,

    y y q . T -

    v gg

    g. T y,

    y , -

    g , ,

    vg g q. T j y

    q g-

    g .

    Dyg gg ,

    gv , y

    g y v, v,

    g .

    T gg g y vgg y

    y gy gg. W gg

    g :

    Figure 4: Conceptual framework of

    the cost-benet analysis

    (not including benets of fuel sav-

    ings)

    Source: [57]

    1) Conduct a needs assessment:

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    A v y

    y gg, g -

    y y

    Dv By M P, g

    yg L

    P g

    Iv g xg

    O y

    gg

    2) Calculate costs and obtain funding:

    Ag N C Tx C

    Gv (NCTCOG),

    g g g $150-

    $200 [59]. Sy, D CD T

    F T Eqv (FTE)

    g y [60]. Dg

    y q, gg

    v -

    , g v

    .

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    36/134

    36 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    3) Install signage:

    A v ,

    , gg ( v-

    g ).

    INCREASE THE SHARE OF HYBRID OR ELECTRIC VEHICLES ON THE ISLAND

    4A y I v xv gg y v

    y v g v. H g y --

    v L I y v.

    T y, -, v v, y

    Uvy M Dg Ty [61]. T

    g , y v v v 2012. T

    y $5,000 y 60 5 , 10,000 v

    y, 15 y v , 6 (V [61], [62], [63], [64]).

    $20,445 $24,760 $36,050 $39,995

    28.5 /g 49.5 /g 3.4 /W* 2.0 /W + 30 /g

    $7,500 $7,500

    $60.84 / $2,000 y v $8,000 y v $8,000 y v

    3000 y 8 y 8 y 8

    Toyota Matrix L(convenonal)

    MSRP

    Eciency

    Tax credits

    Maintenance

    Lifeme ownership

    & operang cost

    (avg $6.00/gal &

    $0.08/kWh)

    Lifeme ownership& operang cost

    (avg $4.50/gal &

    $0.12/kWh)

    $42,150 $38,672 $34,848 $47,538

    $37,038 $35,729 $35,991 $46,761

    Toyota Prius Two(hybrid)

    Nissan Leaf SV(electric)

    Chevrolet Volt (plug-in hybrid)

    Table 2: Cost Comparison of Convenonal, Hybrid, and Electric Vehicles

    SOURCE: [61], [62], [63], [64

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    37/134

    37 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    Electric Recommendaon:HOLD

    Hybrid Recommendaon:GO

    W g y v-

    L I. W y v g

    , y v g

    , y g

    >

    >

    >

    PROS CONS

    R q

    R y -

    y

    L g g

    R g -

    R L I

    y g y y

    M

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    Ly v g g

    v

    Rq

    Hg y xg y

    g g g ,

    y g y y,

    y yg y

    g g

    HYBRID

    ENVIRONMENTAL

    SUSTAINABILITY

    RESILIENCE&

    ADAPTABILITY

    CULTURAL

    ACCEPTABILITY

    PROS CONS

    ALL ELECTRIC

    E q

    Rv y -

    y

    L g g

    R g -

    R L I

    y g y y

    M

    g

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    C OPALCO

    y (OPALCO y

    y v y L)

    C y

    x x

    v gg

    Ly v g g

    v

    L g g g

    Lg gg ,

    xy

    By yy v

    Rq

    Exg v g g y

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    ENVIRONMENTAL

    SUSTAINABILITY

    RESILIENCE&

    ADAPTABILITY

    CULTURAL

    ACCEPTABILITY

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    38/134

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    39/134

    39 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    PROS CONS

    A

    R v ,

    v

    R g-

    gI vy

    Pv v, - v v

    v v, g g

    I y y, , ,

    L -gy 911 *

    *Dg 911 -gy y vx [4].

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    Rq g v

    x

    Rq g, g, yg v

    y

    Cv v v g y

    >

    >

    >

    Recommendaon:RESEARCHW g

    , g

    g . P g

    v vy

    g, g,

    g . S J Cy v g g -

    v g

    Wg D T g

    S C v

    j y -

    v [65]. Fg gg

    g g - L

    L . T g

    -

    y v -

    .

    Areas of Further Research:

    Rgg g v -

    y v v

    ,

    v vy

    L vg

    v.

    T y v-

    vy , L ,

    , g

    xg g

    y v. Ay,

    q g g g

    L vy

    g.

    Gy, L v -

    S J O ,

    v

    x v. C y

    v v v -

    gy

    y v.

    ENVIRONMENTALSUSTAINABILITY

    RESILIENCE&ADAPTABILITY

    CULTURALACCEPTABILITY

    unknown

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    40/134

    40 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    W v L?

    W y g

    ?

    H qy /v v ?

    S

    y v - -

    ?

    S v

    x ?

    Schedule informaon:

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    S L I y -

    v v?

    I :W y

    ?

    H y

    ? By / ?

    W y v

    ?

    W v g/ y/ -

    y ?

    Mobility Coordinator:

    >

    >>

    >

    >

    H y v v?

    C L v

    v ?

    H y v v?W y v

    v?

    W v v v -

    y?

    H v v -

    ? W v g?

    W v

    x v?

    Van Numbers and Operaon:

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    H - ?

    W y v? Evy?

    Evy ?

    H g? W

    ?

    W v ? W

    ?

    W v ?

    Logiscs:

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    41/134

    41 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    START A FUEL IMPORT AND DISTRIBUTION INTERNSHIP6

    A T P R F P A , g v (Rx R,

    / R F) g y

    L I. T g- g g- L

    I y yg M. R . T

    R F g g

    , g v g M.

    R .

    PROS CONS

    E

    L I

    Pv g v -

    g yC v v

    R F

    >

    >

    >

    Rq / R F

    y gg

    W y q R F v -

    y y

    >

    >

    Recommendaon:RESEARCHW g ,

    , g

    y g L I, v

    v v y

    , -

    .

    Areas of Further Research:

    Sg y q x

    L M. R

    g . I ,

    M. R g

    ? I , g

    v

    g ?

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    42/134

    42 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    IMPLEMENT VEHICLE-SHARE PROGRAMS7A g v g g (.., g v y

    v, y g g y v) v x

    L I. B vv g , g y

    g y. Hv, g g -

    y v y j g v

    y v L g. T g g v

    g g L I.

    PROS CONS

    Pv - -

    y

    A g v

    R v

    g v

    P y

    Pv y

    y v v

    g y

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    D g- vy (

    v y v g g

    L I)

    Rq y gy v

    P g -

    g v

    Rq y, v ,

    , v

    >

    >

    >

    >

    Recommendaon:RESEARCHA g, v g

    g L I

    gv -

    . F x, SUV

    v vg g

    y y

    v. I , g v y

    x L I -

    (.g., Z). I ,

    v y gv y y v, y -

    g gv v yg

    v v g

    x y

    Areas of Further Research:B L I

    , y v

    g. H y

    v, y

    v y ? H -

    y ,

    v, j -

    g? H v

    , v , y -

    , ? T

    g v g-

    , g g

    -I . I

    y v y

    g

    q, L-

    .

    ENVIRONMENTAL

    SUSTAINABILITY

    RESILIENCE&

    ADAPTABILITY

    CULTURAL

    ACCEPTABILITY

    unknownunknown

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    43/134

    43 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    EXPAND USAGE OF SCHOOL BUS SYSTEM FOR PUBLIC

    TRANSPORTATION8T x x y y.

    T v y , y g

    y g y g v. Hv, v xg y v y g y

    y, vg j y, g . T

    v y y xg -

    vg v v y y g g .

    PROS CONS

    Mx y v

    Pv v L

    I, y y y v

    g ( x v)Sg g g-

    C j

    Py v

    x v

    ( v v)

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    D vg g gv

    v v

    C g v

    g Nvgg gv g g-

    g

    S g

    Wg S y , v,

    v

    M Dv U

    g

    T v g y

    A D A

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    Recommendaon:HOLDW y x

    v, y

    g g. B v

    , yg g

    v y y

    .

    ENVIRONMENTALSUSTAINABILITY

    RESILIENCE&ADAPTABILITY

    CULTURALACCEPTABILITY

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    44/134

    44 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    IMPLEMENT A COMMERCIAL FREIGHT COORDINATION SYSTEM9A , L I vy

    jy g (.g., , v, .). T

    L I , y g , , y. T -y v gv

    v, x L . O y , x-

    , v y g. T y

    y g g v y

    g g L I g v ,

    vy g v L.

    PROS CONS

    Iv y g

    - vO y , -

    g g L I

    -y v

    -y v

    D

    L x

    y -

    g/vg

    >

    >

    >

    >

    N v

    v j

    Rq v

    C g vy xy

    - - v

    W y q v

    v , g

    v g y g

    y g y

    >

    >

    >

    >

    Recommendaon:HOLDB

    , g g

    v y, g- ,

    y ,

    g g

    y.

    ENVIRONMENTAL

    SUSTAINABILITY

    RESILIENCE&

    ADAPTABILITY

    CULTURAL

    ACCEPTABILITY

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    45/134

    45 -- -- -- -- --

    DIVERSIFYING COMMUNITY-SCALE MARINE TRANSPORT10F y L , WSF v y gg . T

    y v, v gg vg

    v y y, v y.

    Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    PROS CONS

    Q

    N E

    F F

    >

    >

    >

    Exv

    I gy

    S

    S-

    F

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    Solar-powered

    boats

    PROS CONS

    Q

    N E

    F FS C

    >

    >

    >

    >

    W

    D

    y-

    C-v

    Rq x

    y

    >

    >

    >

    >

    Community-owned sail-boats

    PROS CONS

    R D WSF> Hg v

    Rq D WSF v

    W ,

    -

    vg

    g [66]

    >

    >>

    >

    Independent

    passenger-only ferry

    service

    Solar-powered Boats Recommendaon:HOLD

    Community-owned Sailboats Recommendaon:HOLD

    Independent Passenger-only Ferry Service Recommendaon: HOLD

    ENVIRONMENTAL

    SUSTAINABILITY

    RESILIENCE&

    ADAPTABILITY

    CULTURAL

    ACCEPTABILITY

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    46/134

    46

    W v L M 2012 g g L v vy . H L -

    .

    PERSPECTIVES FROM RESIDENTS OF LOPEZ

    Ferry Tales

    Fy g Sy C vy g g

    v y gg WSF y

    L. Rgg vy, L R Wg g, W

    y / A M. V, y y//

    y g? Sy C y L x -

    v y . S y y , L

    g L y .

    Oil PressureW g v v v R-

    F, Rx R. B L, M. R vg g

    , g . L y v x vy y gv

    y v L q . W , v

    v, y y vg v. M.

    R g L. H x g

    g g .

    Biker Beware

    O yg, L S D yg vy

    q g v

    g g x yg . S B Ev v

    y y y v . H gg y

    gg y , g g . A

    , y y -

    v y.

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    47/134

    47

    [transportation]

    Concluding Remarks

    D g g y L,

    v y -

    . Rg , vy g

    qy, gg ,

    g- /

    g, g

    , g.

    T v , -

    v

    y L I. S

    x g g vy , g

    y v , -

    g y, vg

    yg- . O -

    qg -

    ; , g y

    v L I v g

    ,

    g g

    .

    Mvg y

    v y

    - ,

    g , -

    q v -

    . I

    , g -

    . T

    L I,

    g

    . Rg -

    q g y

    y , , g-, . I g, g

    , g

    g, g x g-

    vy

    L I x -

    . T x ,

    g, , ,

    y .

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    48/134

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    49/134

    49 -- -- -- -- --

    Hy, L I x , y g

    v v E.

    I 19 y 20 -

    g v -

    -

    y v. Ty, - , yg,

    g g g

    v. L v , ,

    vy vg, y y

    jy . L v-

    y -g x y [67].

    Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    50/134

    50 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    1) Current land use paerns:C

    S J Cy ,

    g y.

    Ay, 2007 USDA C Ag g -

    S J Cy. T, g -

    y

    xg g

    .

    2) Consumpon Trends:Sy -

    .

    P

    -

    - - gg

    x g

    . C L -

    y g g -

    y - g

    .

    3) Economic Challenges: T g

    g

    yg y.

    T g y -y v gy g

    L.

    4) Regulatory Challenges: Rgy g

    y y

    y- -

    g g. L

    g y y

    v j y.

    T -g g y

    y. Nx, x -

    y. Fy,

    y,

    v y, -

    y,

    v vg

    y L y 2025.

    Sv g y g L:

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    51/134

    51

    [agriculture and water]

    CURRENT PRACTICES

    CURRENT LAND USE PATTERNS

    T g - L I

    v y. A ,

    v y 20

    y. T v

    . Cy 160

    vy L. T 2007 USDA

    C Ag S J Cy

    vg y 74 .

    Hv, v y, v

    g

    vy 20 [67].Cy v -

    j

    v 100 , 99

    . I

    , y

    g L , y

    v gg yg [67].

    FIGURE 5. SOURCE: United States Department of Agriculture, Naonal Agricultural Stascs Service

    T g x g -

    g v g

    g yg. T

    g v y g,

    Hg y S&S H

    F. Cy, 26 x v-

    , , vg L [68]. A -

    g

    v x g , ,

    y,

    q .

    I y L I y g g

    y

    g . R .

    R x yg v-

    gg

    g gg

    vy. My v yg

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    52/134

    52 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    g v

    y,

    y q,

    . T yg v

    v

    g vy qy

    x . Hv, yg

    , y v

    , g qy v

    [1].

    Hyg qy O

    S Tx A (RCW 84.34) g. T x gg

    y y -

    . T

    ,

    gg v

    .

    Cv g

    g g

    L y. L I S J

    Cy v v

    gg .

    T S J Pv T S J

    Cy L B v g

    v g v: g

    v

    g g

    v. Rg O S

    Tx A (RCW 84.34)

    v v / g-

    g

    g. I , g g y

    y v.

    M v L j

    y g

    FIGURE 6. SOURCE: United States Department of Agriculture, Naonal Agricultural Stascs Service

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    53/134

    53 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    jy L I g-

    g g [67]. T

    N R Cv Sv -

    34 y g S J

    Cy [69]. T vy

    S J Cy vg y g g

    ( g

    g) [70].

    CURRENT CONSUMPTION TRENDSC L vy -

    g ,

    gg

    y . T -

    g LVM gy .

    Ov, g

    g , y

    v Lv g, Cy S-

    Ag (CSA) g, ,

    gg y

    g . S vy

    g y

    g. B Gy L I g-

    g . L

    Vg M, g

    , L- . S L

    y y- , ,

    v . Hv,

    v (.g., LVM) y g

    , -

    y

    .

    I yg ,

    vy y L y L-

    . T , -

    y , -

    y g y g

    . Hg S, S&S H-

    F, y -

    y g y ,

    g [71]. S

    g g y

    y g

    q v g: g, g, yg

    g -

    ; vy g

    ; g g

    g v,

    y - j [1]

    A L y -

    , g vy,

    , / v y g

    g x -.

    I v, L

    g g y

    q y. A Dy LVM

    L y -

    v g v . B

    Kv B Gy

    y 5-6 y v

    y g

    y y g gg

    [72].

    I , y

    v , y

    , . L

    I , , g -

    v

    v vy, vy

    . A , -

    v y -

    v L. W

    y y v- , vy

    y , v g, ,

    g , . Ny, y

    L I v y

    , y

    v.

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    54/134

    54 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    T x . W y g y 1950 g

    g -

    y v -v, ,

    y L -

    y ( Fg 7 ). Sg F

    J Fy F

    Wgy g vy,

    y - S. L -

    - .

    FIGURE 7. SOURCE: United

    States Department of Agriculture,

    Naonal Agricultural Stascs

    Service

    CURRENT ECONOMIC CHALLENGES

    Land Acquision:

    T g L --

    v v g

    g. T v

    S J Cy $1,759/

    1964 $8,691/ 2007, j

    [73]. Wy , y y , jy

    g L. My

    v

    v y

    y. Cv

    v

    y. Yg

    v -

    g . D y,

    g g y gg

    vy yg g

    y.

    N J J Fy F x

    g -

    y y yg . H

    g

    , -

    v ,

    H v q, -

    g vy y vy

    q g [74].

    Infrastructure:

    I , g L

    q

    g, (), ,g q, , g .

    T xv gg

    g

    . F g

    g

    y -

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    55/134

    55

    Jones Family Farm

    I 10 y L I, JFy F (JFF) x x

    yg y v .

    N J v

    vy - gg -

    .

    JFF y 3 : , g-

    v g USDA

    , g, , -

    ; g 3 y

    3 v y ;

    g vg y

    Pg S. JFF g g -

    . Ty

    g (

    ).

    I v N, JFF

    gg g g v

    vy . H

    g x y

    S J Cy. JFF

    v S J Cy S. S

    S J Cy g

    S g -

    . Ty L g.

    Ng

    JFF g. T

    300 y

    y y g

    v . N -

    g v v

    x

    g v

    g g v

    . H

    g v

    y .

    L y L, g-

    gg v-

    g y: W

    g,

    g g vy gg,

    g y g

    v. N, I

    v v v g, y vg

    g. I

    v -

    g , y ,

    g y

    .

    N v vy g vg

    g ,

    g v -

    vg. H y g L

    I gg

    , vy y

    y y .

    F J Fy F, v

    .j.

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    56/134

    56 -- -- -- -- --

    g . Sy B

    R M L Cy L

    T x

    v-

    v gg

    v .Cv g -

    q g . F

    v q g

    q g g. Ag

    , g gg

    q

    .

    Inputs:

    O L y v

    , S G F S My.Y L I x

    y 26.44 g N

    O A A, S-

    T v v 37 y,

    g g, xv

    , y . A

    v g -

    g q

    g.

    I, y y

    g .

    Iv x g

    g g -

    g

    g

    v . S

    vg

    xg

    y

    y.

    F 30 q , L

    I g vy -

    , gg y y y

    . S x

    x - g v

    g. M

    . A

    v gg , -

    g, y, v gg, y

    g g

    g . My v - v y y yg

    g

    . My y

    g - .

    Distribuon and Storage:

    D L g

    g g /x

    y. D

    y L S J

    Cy, S P N y . A ,

    g -

    y y .

    A , LVM v jy

    . D , B

    -v -

    gy .

    F y g , g

    S y y g

    Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    57/134

    57 -- -- -- -- --

    g Ogy G

    Cy Eg, Og. D y

    S J Cy

    gg, v L

    v

    . Iv g g

    -. W v g

    g g g

    , y x

    .

    W LVM B g

    g - -

    y, - y

    - . N J

    y g x yS J Cy S -

    y v g

    L.

    Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    REGULATORY CHALLENGESAy

    y

    g. Uy,

    L I.

    Tg v, g- -

    g , g ,

    g . My

    gy

    g v,

    v g y y. O

    y, W g

    y g y g qy

    y. Ev g

    y g qy v.

    W y yg [74].

    Ex y g

    v y v

    x, y y v

    g L . P

    y

    g g- g y,

    g

    L I. F x,

    U- y g L y y y v

    y g

    q [75]. I

    , y

    y g ;

    y v

    v g

    . Exg g y

    g y

    gg .

    Hg j gy g.

    S L vy

    vg -

    vy. T gg , v,

    g g

    . T g-

    , g .

    M g

    g

    . I ,

    S J Cy Sj

    v , [-

    y g ] (Cy C

    18.40.240). Pv y,

    , x, g

    18.30.040.

    Hv, g v

    y g . F v

    y -

    g y

    g g [68].

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    58/134

    58 -- -- -- -- --

    A v L I, g

    y y C U F

    Ag Pg gg L

    g g -

    . A g g Ag-

    C U Tx Pg, AgR C C Pggy B

    g, O

    g , y,

    y / g-

    g g . T S J J

    -

    y -

    g

    y

    g . Hv, Cy A

    C Z , T y y ,

    g. I v

    [76].

    Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    59/134

    59

    Water Story on Lopez : Is there enough?

    W S J Cy vy vy v v

    v g. A

    , v -

    g L I:

    (26.44 ), g -

    g, xv (14 ),

    [80].

    W v qy,

    x g g

    q g L I.

    Hv,

    L Vg

    W Sy R R y y g. I vy

    , L

    y g /

    g. M , 44 81

    vy , ,

    , g y q-

    . O 37 v

    g , y y

    x g

    g 35 g/ 6,000 g/.

    W

    x, y

    y g L I.

    F By W A

    vy L I, v

    Vg . Wg

    S D Egy

    g g gg

    gy yg

    g, L v vg Wg S x

    v. T

    5,000 g y

    g yg g

    vg Egy. T v

    q

    g g

    g g ,

    L

    g, g g -

    y -

    . M v ,

    y y gv

    gy y g.

    T y

    g S J Cy v

    g v v

    y g g

    . T vg

    , , y, g y,

    g y [80]. U-

    y

    g g

    g. Ig g

    qy. Evy

    y, y g

    qy / g.

    Fy, g v

    L. F v g q

    y

    . My -

    g . E -

    2000 40,990 C/y j

    64,477 C/y 2020 [81]. Ag -

    2,500, 16.4 C/y/ 123

    g/y/. By , vg

    Wg S 300 g/y/

    . I , g Wg S

    D Egy y -

    2009, L

    y vg - g

    y

    g gy .

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    60/134

    60

    Hv, g

    g xg v .

    F x, x vg

    g 2003 L Vg W

    Sy R g 37

    y y - y. A - v

    -

    L, g . I ,

    g g

    , v v, y

    q yg g .

    My x g

    g . S

    v x-

    , y g g

    q. Ly, vg L .

    T y /v -

    L I: L Lgy

    Lg Sy P. S

    y g

    y . Uy,

    y yy

    g v

    y. R My 2009 , T

    C S D Sy S J

    Cy, Wg g xg

    g y

    y v g v

    , v,

    $25/g y.

    D

    g, , -

    g q L,

    L I . T

    g, , x-

    g v . Fy, gy g g

    400-500 g

    y y F By g

    . T -

    W . Pg

    y g

    g g g

    v g, ,

    g.

    Fisherman Bay sewage treatment facility.

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    61/134

    61

    [agriculture and water]

    POTENTIAL PROBLEM AREAS AND RISKS FACTORS

    Gv g - v, x g

    g vy L I

    x 30 y. S

    y -

    y g g

    g v

    L y y . T

    , v, g g

    g .

    ECONOMIC VIABILITYI gy

    y v g,

    x -

    . Pv - gy

    g- y

    g. L y yg - g . Py

    yg v v

    y -

    g g gy y gg g

    [67]. Mv, g g

    g , -

    y x -

    v

    .

    SOIL FERTILITYT vy yg y g

    g- y g

    . T -

    y. Ag , y

    q y

    g g,

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    62/134

    62 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    gy .

    CLIMATE CHANGEC g y gg

    L. P g

    N O A A- I P C

    Cg (IPCC), x,

    -

    . T

    1.5 P N g

    , 20-60 y . T

    IPCC j g

    g . T

    S-

    g. M y, D

    Fy, g x x10 . B J

    Ag, v, g x

    y 10 20 [77]. T

    g 0 g-

    v 10 . W

    y g g,

    x. H, g

    y

    v v. T

    y g -v L I.

    Mv, ,

    j y -

    g g. S g

    g , ,

    gg y, , y

    g

    g y g.

    COMMODITY SHOCKSL y x gg

    g

    . G y

    g -

    . F ,

    x L y

    g q

    y . A -

    x , g

    2 3 -y 2025 [78]. T

    g g

    . I -

    , xv L

    q vg

    . T y

    g. Mv, g

    g

    . T xv. Rg

    .

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    63/134

    63

    [agriculture and water]

    POTENTIAL SOLUTIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

    T x g g y

    L. Ty g y gg , g, y y-

    g g, g / .

    Recommend Go for Implementaon:

    F g vy

    P g g

    H y v g

    C v-

    B - g

    Recommend Further Research: R g

    F g

    I g

    S GMO-F L I

    C

    1)

    5)

    6)

    8)

    9)

    2)

    3)

    4)

    7)

    10)

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    64/134

    64 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    1 FORM A LOCAL AGRICULTURE ADVISORY COMMITTEE

    POTENTIAL SOLUTIONS FOR LAND USE AND INFRASTRUCTURE 13

    T vy Wg S S RCW84.34.145: T y gv y v g v

    g y y v vy y g -

    g y v , g-

    , 84.34 RCW. T vy gv

    v gg v . Hv, y y

    v y , qy, g

    v [79]. A g , vy x.

    PROS

    C

    Ag g

    g y x g

    L I

    P g y y -

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    Recommendaon:GOW . U , vy q.

    Hv, , gv y y v . B vy

    v g y v x y,

    y y y v.

    CONS

    P yM g vv y

    2

    REFORM ZONING LAWS

    T g

    . R g q. T -

    v v . S g

    q gg , y S J Cy Cv P

    y . T S J Cy Cv P [L

    ] y v g, , vy

    ENVIRONMENTAL

    SUSTAINABILITY RESILIENCE&

    ADAPTABILITY

    CULTURAL

    ACCEPTABILITYnot applicable

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    65/134

    65 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    v . T v y v g

    v . T C 18 S J C,

    T S J Cy Cv P g g

    g g vg y v. T g

    g v x g v, -

    g .

    PROS

    C g g g

    Ay

    Iv g

    >

    >

    >

    >

    CONS

    A

    Recommendaon:RESEARCHW L x y

    g g

    . Mv,

    g y y- y

    g g y y.

    O , Rg Zg L

    g y y. T

    y y -

    , y g P g

    g g y g.

    Cg v

    y g

    g, gg g

    v v

    .

    3 FORM AGRICULTURE PARTNERSHIPS WITH RESEARCH INSTITUTIONSL y Uvy Wg (UW)

    g g v g g.

    Cy UW Cg Ev y gy x Fy H.T g C Cg I g xg g P

    N g gg g . T L

    g C Cg I G. T g

    y xg Fy H y , vg L gg

    .

    ENVIRONMENTAL

    SUSTAINABILITY

    RESILIENCE&

    ADAPTABILITY

    CULTURAL

    ACCEPTABILITY

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    66/134

    66 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    PROS

    F y L- g-

    g g

    P g

    j g L

    (y)A g x

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    CONS

    L yg vy -

    (j g )

    F j g

    vy g

    C Fy H

    Recommendaon:RESEARCHW gg L x y

    . D x-

    y

    g , Cg Ev-

    y g L.

    T - gg

    g- g g

    L. T q v

    q Uvy

    x gg y -

    . A

    L x , g

    -

    .

    4IMPLEMENT A FARMER SPONSORSHIP PROGRAM

    T g g yg g L. T

    y gg - - g L g,

    . T g yg -

    g .

    POTENTIAL SOLUTIONS FOR LABOR CHALLENGES 4

    PROS

    Eggg - -

    y g y L

    S y yg

    y L

    I

    y

    y

    B gg

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    CONS

    F y y g v

    ( )

    P v-x g g

    ENVIRONMENTAL

    SUSTAINABILITY

    RESILIENCE&

    ADAPTABILITY

    CULTURAL

    ACCEPTABILITY

    unknown

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    67/134

    67 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    Recommendaon:RESEARCHW L g g

    g. T F S g

    y vg

    y. T g -

    g y y g yg

    g y

    y gg . T

    v g .

    F, g -

    y L v. Hv,

    v y q y g -

    y g. F x,

    v, v g-

    v -

    y , g

    g y v-

    y.

    Eventual Implementaon:

    I L g v -

    y, y g

    . F,

    g g -

    vg g -

    g. T g

    y

    v - y -

    v Lv T g

    g y v g . A g

    g

    ggg

    -

    g g -

    vg

    . T g xg

    L R y

    v y -

    g v g.

    POTENTIAL SOLUTIONS FOR COMMUNITY BUYIN: MAKING LAST

    ING CHANGE 57

    T vyg

    g y

    g . D , g

    g

    , v,

    . T

    L I

    - . O y

    vg jv: -

    g , g ,

    g . T v y -

    v

    gg. I

    , g

    x g v.

    ENVIRONMENTAL

    SUSTAINABILITY

    RESILIENCE&

    ADAPTABILITY

    CULTURAL

    ACCEPTABILITY

    unknown

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    68/134

    68 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    5 PROMOTE LOCAL FARMERS THROUGH EDUCATIONAL CAMPAIGNSE g y Lv v y

    g yg , v

    y. Bg g gg y

    g y g-x - - g.

    PROS

    P g

    K y y

    B y

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    CONS

    T y g q

    Ly v

    Recommendaon:GOW L g g

    g. A g

    y g xg v

    . T

    y

    -.

    E Cg v -

    y g y g v-

    y . B y g g,

    g ,

    y , y g, -

    g, -y, g.

    W gg y

    vy y -

    g g. Hg

    v . S

    y

    x g g vy v. I y, g

    y

    . Ov , y -

    .

    6HOST SEASONAL COMMUNITY EVENTS TO PROMOTE LOCAL AGRICULTURE

    T v g -

    . Ev - g g g

    y g . T g y y

    g. I g g y, y y g, gg

    .

    ENVIRONMENTAL

    SUSTAINABILITY

    RESILIENCE&

    ADAPTABILITY

    CULTURAL

    ACCEPTABILITY

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    69/134

    69 -- -- -- -- --

    PROS

    P y g

    U

    >

    >

    >

    CONS

    C gg g

    Recommendaon:GOW L

    y v y . T

    v y

    g vg v

    g y y-

    . S Cy Ev y g- Cy C

    y

    -, , . A g

    g g

    y g

    v g y. T

    v . A

    v g y, y x .

    7 SUPPORT A GMOFREE LOPEZ ISLANDT v gy g

    . A y -gy -

    v g g gy , g L

    g - g y g g

    .

    PROS

    P g g A L-g GMO

    -

    P g

    >>

    >

    >>

    CONS

    Cg g W q y- , y

    vg

    Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    ENVIRONMENTAL

    SUSTAINABILITY

    RESILIENCE&

    ADAPTABILITY

    CULTURAL

    ACCEPTABILITYunknownunknown

    ENVIRONMENTAL

    SUSTAINABILITY

    RESILIENCE&

    ADAPTABILITY

    CULTURAL

    ACCEPTABILITY

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    70/134

    70 -- -- -- -- --

    Recommendaon:RESEARCH

    Areas for Further Research:

    F y g GMO

    F L. S v

    GMO v .

    T, v -GMO

    L. Sy, -GMO

    g

    y. T GMO- L

    y g g y

    g g g

    . Hv, y y- y L gy

    g y y.

    POTENTIAL SOLUTIONS FOR SHARING COSTS / RESOURCES 810

    Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    I , , v ,

    g .

    8 CREATE A VALUEADD COMMUNAL INDUSTRIAL KITCHENT g y

    v , g v. Pg y

    y , , v .

    Ex v- v q g j g g. Cg vg g v

    .

    PROS

    L

    E y g -

    S q

    Kg g y

    v

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    CONS

    Bg vg q g

    (.g., , y, g)

    A g vg

    v g

    Eq g

    Fg g q g

    ENVIRONMENTAL

    SUSTAINABILITY

    RESILIENCE&

    ADAPTABILITY

    CULTURAL

    ACCEPTABILITY

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    71/134

    71 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    Recommendaon:GOW g -

    y y

    g g g g

    g R Wg. I

    j, g y g

    y

    g .

    U , L

    g g

    y y

    y y

    9 BUILD A COOP GREENHOUSEA - g v g L ggy y-

    g . A g g y

    g g . T v

    y gv y, y g g .

    PROS

    S

    R

    Kg g y v

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    CONS

    Ry g

    g

    S, , y g

    A g g vg g v g

    Recommendaon:GOW y

    g L. L

    g, g , y, g x,

    . Fg g j

    y

    . T g

    g vv

    g. A -

    , g, v

    (.., g g, y ,

    g , .), vg, y . T v

    v y g -

    g

    g.

    ENVIRONMENTAL

    SUSTAINABILITY

    RESILIENCE&

    ADAPTABILITY

    CULTURAL

    ACCEPTABILITY

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    72/134

    72 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    10 CONSTRUCT COMMUNAL ROADSIDE STANDS FOR LOCAL FARMERST y g y gg g-

    y . A L Vg C -

    y v y vg g g . Mg g vy g, g v ,

    Cy C x -

    . F g g v v.

    C g vgg g v y

    g y v

    x. C yg , vy

    v g v g.

    PROS

    Cy =

    S

    L

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    >

    CONS

    C

    Ay g g

    C

    vg y v v -

    g (

    )

    Recommendaon:RESEARCHW xg

    g g g. I -

    y y

    g.

    ENVIRONMENTAL

    SUSTAINABILITY

    RESILIENCE&

    ADAPTABILITY

    CULTURAL

    ACCEPTABILITY

    unknown

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    73/134

    73

    S&S Homestead Farm

    S&S H F g x vy

    L I. B --

    , g , L I y -

    y v y y

    v g, , vg,

    g qy g . I , H-

    g S E S,

    y g y g

    v x y .

    I , . T

    x y g, g

    vg

    g y, y, Hg y

    g vg

    g, -g x -

    g. T

    g g, ,

    y y

    . T y

    y , v. W

    y g -

    g, - y

    -, g g y

    q y g.

    Ty vyg , vg,

    y, y. Ayg

    y-g

    g v. Ty

    y y, y y

    . Hg y

    , y -

    y . I

    y x , Hg

    y x . T x

    y, .

    F , Hg E

    g vy , vg, g.

    C v gg y v

    , qy

    . Ty g y

    . By .

    B g y g, S&S H F

    vy

    gy . Hg v

    gy g

    y g g y

    vg -

    y vg gy . O

    y -

    v ,

    v . Y

    , yg v.

    M :

    ://..g/.

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    74/134

    74

    [agriculture and water]

    CONCLUDING REMARKS

    Ov, L y g g

    y. My y

    v y

    y g y g

    L vg

    g. O v -

    v g v-

    v g y,

    g y v g-

    , v g

    y y. T

    g y -q

    y g y

    y, vy, y -

    .

    T g L - -g qy g

    . T

    , g

    , yg -

    y v gy g

    , g gy g

    y g v g-

    y g y

    y. A , L y

    g y y g -

    g g

    - . I

    gg y -

    g vy

    y L.

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    75/134

    W a s t e

    Ov v L, y

    v -

    y v jy

    L y v v. I

    , g-

    y-, y g, g g .

    A ,

    g -

    g - xv.

    T y v

    g , g g-

    y g g

    v .

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    76/134

    76

    [waste]

    CURRENT PRACTICES

    B, v g v g: gg; y; g

    ; g ; . L y y v jy - v , x g .

    SOLID WASTE: GARBAGEOv , L

    y v

    g, ggg -

    v g v

    y .

    S J Cy -v g y S J S

    Cy. M v

    v y

    y L T S

    y . Rg

    , y

    v v, g

    gg y.

    T T S y gg

    -g y y . W Mg-, v y g

    L I,

    O I. C

    L T S 40 y. W

    Mg y y gg

    -g O vy

    y, g . O

    , gg 120

    y ( / )

    A. Nx gg

    A S,

    . Fy -

    y Ag,

    Og xy 350 L.

    B v y

    2002, L T S

    . L

    ,

    g . A -

    v g T B D

    g g

    y S W D D

    L I. D , g

    y g :

    - y g . A

    g , g

    v 1200 g v $100,000

    x x y

    - g. F

    gg g, y v ://

    .g..

    Ev L v

    y, v -. P-

    g L ,

    gg ,

    S J Cy y g-

    W Mg. T g-

    g L g

    v W Mg

    , v

    g L .

    T L T S gy

    g , vg -y

    v . T -

    g y y y,

    y v

    y.

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    77/134

    77 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    SOLID WASTE: RECYCLABLESTg S J Cy , L

    y W Mg

    y g gg (

    g - ). A gg, L

    ,

    g , , y-

    . T v g

    y , y

    v y y,

    y . A-

    g L T S Lg y

    2011, 291 -g y -

    L I. S ,

    y y ,

    Sg Rv Ryg y Bg, WA,

    -g y

    W Mg Cy y W-

    v, S. A yg g-, qy y y

    y y-

    . T, y

    L y y

    ,

    .

    GREEN WASTE: YARD CLIPPINGS AND

    FOOD SCRAPSN S J Cy S Cy

    W Mg Cy

    y g

    . O

    vy, g jy y

    y g -

    y, g, g, -g

    g -. T jy

    , g ,

    g , g .

    W y g

    vy ,

    v v - -

    y, g , g y-

    , v

    ,

    v y.

    T L S Gv y -

    xy 5,000 y y g

    . B g gy -

    , g -. T

    qy

    B C. [36]. B

    Take it or Leave it shed, an

    informal freesycle space located

    at the Lopez Transfer Staion.

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    78/134

    78 -- -- -- -- --

    HAZARDOUS WASTE:

    CHEMICALS AND EWASTEEy x ( , , -

    , , .) (-)

    gg

    , v - T S. T

    , v, -g -y y O-

    I. T L T S

    v -

    g y,

    O y.

    Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste -- Electricity / Heang -- Conclusions

    SEPTIC WASTET F By S D

    g 150

    L Vg L S. Tg

    ,

    xy 400,000-500,000

    g , -

    g y . W

    v

    ,

    g g (x ).

    O F By S D, L-

    1,000-g q

    g. F , -

    3,500-g

    F By

    g . T -

    g A y

    y, . T g y

    vg y

    g , y g . T 100,000

    120,000 g

    y.

    x,

    1/3 , 1/3 1/3 ,

    2,000 y x y

    $30/ y.

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    79/134

    79

    [waste]

    POTENTIAL PROBLEM AREAS AND RISKS FACTORS

    I g

    gg, L y--yv y y . B

    g:

    gy v y y

    v L. T

    , y y

    g y v y -

    v v

    yg

    g . T

    .

    B y q

    x: . A g

    , g y -

    g , g. T

    g , 25

    v g

    CO2 ( ), g

    g.

    M y, L

    y -

    y -g gy v

    . A g g

    L, gy (

    F By S-

    g D) y v

    g g. T y -

    g vg

    g . L g,

    , v - gy y

    y .

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    80/134

    80

    POTENTIAL SOLUTIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

    [waste]

    N y L I y . T -

    6 j j :

    Recommend Go for Implementaon:

    L y

    C g

    Recommend Further Research:

    C g

    Recommend Hold at this Time:

    L

    C g

    U g g

    Hv gy g y g

    1)

    2)

    3)

    (1)

    4)

    5)

    6)

  • 7/25/2019 Lopez Island: Case Study in Transitioning to A Sustainable Community

    81/134

    81 -- -- -- -- --Welcome -- Transportaon -- Agriculture / Water -- Waste --