llth Education, 3, Mahapalika Marg, Mumbai on behalf of Secretary, Medical Education and Drugs Department, Government of Maharashtra. 2) Dr. P.H. Shingare Director, Medical Education

Minutes of Meeting of the Pravesh Niyantran Samiti (Medical Education) held under the Chairmanship of Justice D.K. Deshmukh (Retd.) on Friday, the llth January, 2013 at 3.00 p.m. in the Conference Hall, Office of Director, Technical Education, 3, Mahapalika Marg, Mumbai - 400 001

Following Mernbers and Officers were present:

1. Dr. Ravi Bapat Mernber

2. Dr. M.S. Kekre Member

3. Dr. Arun Jamkar Member and Vice-Chancellor, Maharashtra University of Health Sciences, Nashik

Invitees:

1) Shri A.M. Atram Dy. Secretary, on behalf of Secretary, Medical Education and Drugs Department, Government of Maharashtra.

2) Dr. P.H. Shingare Director, Medical Education and Research, Maharashtra State.

3) Shri R.B. Nakave Asst. Registrar on behalf of Registrar, Ma harashtra University of Health Science, Nashik

Shri I.S. Chahal Member Secretary and Secretary Medical Education and Drugs Department, Mantralaya granted leave of absence.

Shri P. E. Gaikwad, I.A.S. Office Secretary, Pravesh Niyantran Samiti, Mumbai was present.

Copies of Agenda along with copies of the relevant documents were circulated to the Members.

Item No. 1: To amrove and confirm Minutes of the Meetina of Pravesh Nivantran Samiti (Medical Education) held on Fridav, the 4th Januarv 2013 in the Office of Director Technical Education, Mum bai.

Minutes of the Meeting of Pravesh Niyantran Samiti - Medical Education held on Friday, the 4th January 2013 in the Conference Hall, Office of the Director, Technical Education, 3, Mahapalika Marg, Mumbai - 400 001 are approved and confirmed.

PNS(Medica1) llth January 2013

Item No. 2: To review action taken bv office on decisions arrived at in the previous meetinas.

Samiti perused the action taken report on the decisions arrived at by Samiti in its previous meeting held on 21St December, 2012 and 4th January, 2013 details of which are as below:-

Meeting on 21St December,

2012

Item No. 1

Item No. 3

Item No.4

Item No. 5(a)

Item No. 5(b) & 5(c)

Actionable Points

To convey the approval and confirmation of the Minutes of the Sarr~iti. To discuss and decide in respect of the report of Enquiry Committees - if any appointed by Government of Maharashtra vide its resolution dated 2gth November 2012. Letter dated 7th December 2012 received from Medical Education Department, Government of Maharashtra in respect of "National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test-2013" copy addressed to Director, DMER, Mumbai and copy endorsed to us. Letter dated 21St November 2012 received from Association of Managements of Unaided Private Medical and Dental Colleges of Maharashtra regarding draft brochure of APGM-APGD-CET-2012 for the admissions of Post Graduate Medical and Dental Courses for the Academic Year 2013-14. Letter dated llth December 2012 received from M.A. Rangoonwala

of Dental Sciences and Research Pune asking for permission to conduct CET-2013 for Minority Quota admission of lst year BDS course for the Academic Year 2013-14.

Action taken

Minutes of Meeting are displayed on the Website and Notice Board of Samiti on 31/12/2012.

Decision of the Samiti is display on the website and notice board on 31/12/2012.

Decision is conveyed to concerned Department by a separate letter dated 7/1/2013.

Decision is conveyed to respective Association by Separate letter dated 7/1/2013.

Decision is conveyed to respective College/Institute by Separate letter dated 71112013,

Meeting on 21* December,

2012

Item No. 5(d)

Item No. 5(e)

Item No. 6

Actionable Points

Letter dated 3oth November 2012 received from M.A. Rangoonwala College of Dental Sciences and Research Centre, Pune submitting brochure of CET-2013 for admissions of Post Graduate Dental Course for the Academic Year 2013-14. Letter dated 7th December 2012 received from Mr. Dipak N. Mane, Secretary, Akola District Congress Committee requesting to forward a complaint to Superintendent of Police (Rural), Solapur in connection with malpractices in admission of MBBS course for Academic Year 2012-13, citing therein that the matter happens . .

to be a type of 'Cyber Crime Dept.' Letter dated 3 0 ~ November 2012 received from Directorate of Medical Education and Research, Mumbai requesting for payment of T.A. / D.A. to the Representatives of PNS appointed in furtherance of Government Resolution NO. MED-2012/n.3. 9 o ~ / W T w r - ? , f2=rh ?%/P~/?oP?"

To consider and decide on the Verification Report on the status of NRI candidates admitted during Academic Year 2010-11 and 2012-13 on the basis of documents/relevant papers submitted by the Colleges/Institutes.

Action taken

Decision is conveyed to respective College/Institute by Separate letter dated 7/1/2013.

Decision is conveyed to concerned by Separate letter dated 7/1/2013.

Decision of the Samiti are displayed on the Website and Notice Board of Samiti on 31/12/2012. The decision is also conveyed to the respective College/Institute by a separate letter dated 7/1/2013.

Samiti noted and approved it.

Meeting on 4th January,

2013

Item

Actionable Points

To Consider, discuss and decide in respect of the reports of Enquiry Committees- appointed by Government of Maharashtra vide its resolution No. * P 0 P *.=. 3 0 9 / 7 3 ~ - ? , dated 2gTH Noverr~ ber 2012.

Action taken

Decision of the Samiti conveyed to the respective Colleges by email and Speed Post on 7/1/2013.

4 PNS(Medica1)

llth ~anuary 2013 Item No. 3: To mnsider and decide on replies submitted bv the

Colleqes/Institutes in respect of the show cause issued, as Der the decision taken bv the Samiti in its meetins held on 4th Januarv 2013

A) SMT. Kashibai Navale Medical Callwe and Hospital -Pune

Samiti had received complaints from students/parents with respect to the admissions in Private Unaided Institutions after CAP rounds in Academic Year 2012-13. Medical Education and Drugs Department of Government of Maharashtra vide its G.R. No. ? 0 ? 3/!7 .%. 3 o?/@WJl- 3, dated 29' November 2012 appointed the Enquiry Committees in furtherance of the decision of Samiti dated 8/11/2012 (at Item No. 5[a] & 5[b]).

Said committees were to enquire in to following aspects:-

) To consider all complaints in respect of admissions in Private Unaided Institutions (Medical and Dental) for the Academic Year 2012-13

2) To enquire into whether adequate and proper publicity was given by the Institutions for admissions after CAP round.

3) Whether adequate opportunity was given to students desirous of seeking admissions.

4) Whether Samiti schedule was followed.

5) Whether vacancies were filled in considering merit of students

6) Whether reservation rules were followed.

7) Whether guidelines per Government resolution No. WPM 1012/Pra.Kra. 165/12/Edu-2, dated 29/05/2012 along with the corrigendum dated 5/6/2012 were followed by Institutions.

Accordingly, in respect of this College Committee - A - submitted its report. Samiti perused the general remarks and findings of the committee - A, appointed under GR No. * ? 0 ? *.%. 3 o?mWJl-3, dated 29' November 2012. Findings of the Committee were communicated to the College vide office letter bearing No. PNS(Med)/Show Cause/Adm-2012/4010, dated 7th January 2013

3. Amongst other points in response to the show cause notice dated 7th January 2013 college has contended mainly as under :-

a) All admissions were done as per DMER, Schedule. b) The candidate Miss Ahire Snehal was offered the seat in General Quota, but

she refused. As a result she was given seat in OBC quota. General Quota seat was given to Abhishek Borle, the next candidate in the list. Because of this selection of candidate would not have changed.

5 PIVS(Medical)

llth January 2013 4. Contentions of the College/Institute are not acceptable for the following

reasons:-

The Samiti perused the affidavit filed by said Snehal Ahire. It is dated 9.1.2013. The said affidavit thus appears to have been obtained after thought. Contention of the College that the selection of candidate would not have changed can not be accepted, because it was for the College authority to admit the students against seat in a particular quota. College has not done this. The findings of the Committee therefore needs to be confirmed.

Samiti therefore confirms the findings of Enquiry Committee that the reservation rules were not followed by this College. The admission process was thus not fair, transparent & merit based and reservation rules having not followed in the right perspective. Samiti therefore disapproves all the adrr~issions i.e. 07 done by the College/Institute after the last "Common Admission Process" (CAP) round of MHT-CET-2012 for the Academic Year 2012-13. Samiti recommends to Government of Maharashtra to direct the said College/Institute to cancel the admissions after last CAP round of MHT-CET-2012.

5. Considering the number of resultant vacancies, Samiti decides to suggest Government of Maharashtra to consider moving the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, New Delhi for permissions to fill in the resultant vacancies, extension of cut-off-date and also praying their in that all admissions even after CAP rounds be brought under "Common Admission Process" only.

B) MIMER' s Medical Collese Taleciaon Pune.

1. Samiti had received complaints from students/parents with respect to the admissions in Private Unaided Institutions after CAP rounds in Academic Year 2012-13. Medical Education and Drugs Department of Government of Maharashtra vide its G.R. No. ? 0 ? 3/5T .v. 2 ~?/@TWJT- 3, dated 2gM November 2012 appointed the Enquiry Committees in furtherance of the decision of Samiti dated 8/11/2012 (at Item No. 5[a] & 5[b]).








6 PNS(Medica1)

llth ~anuary 2013 7) Whether guidelines per Government resolution No. WPM 1012/Pra.Kra.

165/12/Edu-2, dated 29/05/2012 along with the corrigendum dated 5/6/2012 were followed by Institutions.

2. Accordingly, in respect of this College Committee - A - submitted its report. Samiti perused the general remarks and findings of the committee - A, appointed under GR No. * ? 0 ? ?/ST.$. 3 O Y ~ W ~ T - ? , dated 2gth Woverr~ber 2012. Findings of the Committee were communicated to the College vide office letter bearing No. PNS(Med)/Show Cause/Adm-2012/4010, dated 7th January 2013


a) There is no rule for maintaining attendance record for counseling. b) That it will be maintained next time. c) ST category candidate Samreen Khanam Hameed Khan cancelled her

admission on 30th September due to her personal problem. Against her seat SC Candidate has been admitted. Wadate Sushautak Suresh who was present in the campus. On 30/9/2012 at 2200 hrs. admissions were given to those who were present. This is in formed on 4/10/2012 to PNS.

4. Contentions of the College/Institute are not acceptable for the following reasons:-

One an hand college says "There is no rule for maintaining attendance record for counseling". On the other hand College says ' That it will be maintained next time". Contentions are thus after thought and not honest. The fact that the attendance were not being marked compels us to conclude that the procedure being followed was violating basic principles of transparency, fairness and reasonability.

Contentions that on 30/09/2012 at 22:OO hrs admissions were given to those who were present and the said thing was informed to Samiti can not be accepted being after thought. 'The fact that admissions were being given after working hours till late night on 30/09/2012, shows dishonest motives of the College and further shows that the College even did not wish to adopt the transparency in the process.

Resultantly Samiti therefore confirms the findings of Enquiry Committee that non meritorious students were admitted by the institute. 'The admission process was not fair, transparent and merit based. Sarrliti therefore disapproves all admissions i.e. 06 done by the College/Institute after the last "Common Admission Process" (CAP) round of MHT-CET-2012 for the Academic Year 2012-13. Samiti recommends to Government of Maharashtra to direct the said College/Institute to cancel the admissions after last CAP round of MHT-CET-2012.

5. Considering the number of resultant vacancies, Samiti decides to suggest Government of Maharashtra to consider moving the Hon'ble Supreme Court of

7 PNS(Medica1)

llth ~anuary 2013 India, New Delhi for permissions to fill in the resultant vacancies extension of cut-off-date and also praying their in that all admissions even after CAP rounds be brought under 'Common Admission Process" only.

C) Institute of Medical Science and research, Mavani, Satara.

1. Samiti had received complaints from students/parents with respect to the admissions in Private Unaided Institutions after CAP rounds in Academic Year 2012-13. Medical Education and Drugs Department of Government of Maharashtra vide its G.R. No. + P 0 P ?h.s. 3 O~ /~~VWJI -? , dated 2gth November 2012 appointed the Enquiry Committees in furtherance of the decision of Samiti dated 8/11/2012 (at Item No. 5[a] & 5[b]).


1) To consider all complaints in respect of admissions in Private Unaided Institutions (Medical and Dental) for the Academic Year 2012-13






7) Whether guidelines per Government resolution No. WPM 1012/Pra. Kra. 165/12/Edu-2, dated 29/05/2012 along with the corrigendum dated 5/6/2012 were followed by Institutions.

2. Accordingly, in respect of this College Committee - A - submitted its report. Samiti perused the general remarks and findings of the committee - A, appointed under GR No. - P 0 9 *.?#if;. 3 o?/@r+Vr-?, dated 2gth November 2012. Findings of the Committee were communicated to the College vide office letter bearing No. PNS(Med)/Show Cause/Adm-2012/4010, dated 7th January 2013


a) Findings of the Hon'ble inquiry committee is totally perverse and without applying mind and hence liable to be rejected in toto.

b) College has submitted website access statistics report ( C - panel report )

c) Most of the complaints were made after 3oth September 2012 and which were after thought and filed due to instigation by Jayant Jain.

",

8 PNS(Medica1)

llth January 2013 d) Out of 31 students only 3 students namely a) IVahida Shaikh b) Sadiya

Rawool c) Morris Christie appeared before committee. 28 Students failed to appeare before Committee.

e) Institute prayes that the complaints as well as report dated on 07/01/2013 by the enquiry committee be quashed and rejected in toto and admission made after second round of Asso- CET 2012 be approved.


) Fee refunded by post dated cheque to Nahida shaikh in view of cancellation of her admission for betterment resulted into her not getting the admission in any college. This College is thus responsible for the inconvenience caused to the said student.

Findings of the Committee that a) Vacancy position after conclusion of 2nd round was not reported to Samiti, b) Out of 85 candidates 29 Applications were rejected without proper reasons. (e.g. CVC and NCL, Medical Certificate.), c) Attendance record was not kept on 27/9/2012, d) The List of students prepared on 26/9/2012 on the basis of which admissions were done was defective. This defective List was used for admission of 34 candidates on 27/9/2012, e) Injustice to meritorious students. are not responded to by the Institute adequately, properly, and reasonably.

In light of foregoing, Samiti therefore confirms the findings of Enquiry Committee as under :-

1) Fee refunded by post dated cheque to Nahida shaikh in view of cancellation her admission for betterment resulted into her not getting the admission in any college.

2) Vacancy position after conclusion of 2nd round was not reported to PNS. 3) Out of 85 candidates 29 Applications were rejected without proper

reasons. (e.g. CVC and NCL, Medical Certificate.) 4) Attendance record was not kept on 27/9/2012. 5) The List of students prepared on 26/9/2012 on the basis of which

admissions were done was defective. This defective List was used for admission of 34 candidates on 27/9/2012.

6) Injustice was done to meritorious students.

The admission process was thus not fair, transparent & merit based. Samiti therefore disapproves all the admissions i.e. 38 done by the College/Institute after the last "Common Admission Process" (CAP) round of Asso-CET-2012 for the Academic Year 2012-13. Samiti recommends to Government of Maharashtra to direct the said College/Institute to cancel the admissions after last CAP round of Asso-CET-2012.

9 PNS(Medica1)

llm January 2013 5. Considering the large number of resultant vacancies, Samiti decides to suggest

Government of IYaharashtra to consider moving the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, New Delhi for permissions to fill in the resultant vacancies, extension of cut-off-date and also praying their in that all admissions even after CAP rounds be brought under "Common Admission Process" only.

D) Ashwini Rural Medical Colleae and Hos~ital, Sola~ur.

1. Samiti had received complaints from students/parents with respect to the admissions in Private Unaided Institutions after CAP rounds in Academic Year 2012-13. Medical Education and Drugs Department of Government of Maharashtra vide its G.R. No. *Sf ? 0 ? 3 h - 5 . 3 o?/@'Em- 3 , dated 2gth November 2012 appointed the Enquiry Committees in furtherance of the decision of Samiti dated 8/11/2012 (at Item No. 5[a] & 5[b]).



2). To enquire into whether adequate and proper publicity was given by the Institutions for admissions after CAP round.

3) Whether adequate opportunity was given to students desirous of seeking a'dmissions.




7) Whether guidelines per Government resolution No. WPM 1012/Pra.Kra. 165/12/Edu-2, dated 29/05/2012 along with the corrigend~~m dated 5/6/2012 were followed by Institutions.

2. Accordingly, in respect of this College Committee - A - submitted its report. Samiti perused the general remarks and findings of the committee - A, appointed under GR No. ipds% ? 0 ? ?/ST .5. 3 ~ Y ~ w - 3 , dated 2gth November 2012. Findings of the Committee were communicated to the College vide office letter bearing No. PNS(Med)/Show Cause/Adm-2012/4010, dated 7th January 2013

3. Amongst other points in response to the show cause notice dated 7' January 2013 college has contended mainly as under :-

a) Vacancies were declared on website. b) Reservation rules were not mentioned in AMUPMDC broacher. c) Applications were accepted as per PNS direction. d) Institute conducted admission process for the first time, did not know about

maintaining attendance records at the time of counseling.

", e) Admission Process conducted in transparent manner &was merit based.



Attendance sheets were not kept by the Institute at the time of counseling. This is admitted by the college. It is beyond the ordinary expectation of prudent mankind to believe in the fact that out of 290 only 8 students were present for counseling even if alternatively it is considered that the adequate and proper publicity was given by the College. Contention that the Institute conducted the process for first time and did not know about maintenance of attendance sheet being put forth after thought can not be accepted. These contentions could have been raised before the Enquiry Committees also.

Following findings of the Committee are not properly, adequately and reasonably answered by the College a) Admitted non meritorious students, b) Applications send by speed post and email were not accepted by the College.

I n light of above, Samiti therefore confirms the findings of Enquiry Committee as under:-

a) College admitted non Meritorious Students. b) Reservatior~ rules were not followed. c) Applications sent by speed post and email were not accepted by college. d) Attendance record was not kept at the time of counseling

The admission process was thus not fair, transparent & merit based and reservation rules having not followed in the right perspective. Samiti therefore disapproves all the admissions i.e. 07 done by the College/Institute after the last "Common Admission Process" (CAP) round of Asso-CET-2012 for the Academic Year 2012-13. Samiti recommends to Government of Maharashtra to direct the said College/Institute to cancel the admissions after last CAP round of Asso-CET- 2012.

5. Considering the nurrlber of resultant vacancies, Samiti decides to suggest Government of Maharashtra to consider moving the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, New Delhi for permissions to fill in the resultant vacancies, extension of cut-off-date and also praying their in that all admissions even after CAP rounds be brought under "Common Admission Process" only.

E) Terna Medical Collecre, Navi Mumbai.

1. Samiti had received complaints from students/parents with respect to the admissions in Private Unaided Institutions after CAP rounds in Academic Year 2012-13. Medical Education and Drugs Department of Government of Maharashtra vide its G.R. No. P 0 P .TG.$o 9mWJl- P, dated 2gth

11 PNS(Medica1)

llth ~anuary 2013 November 2012 appointed the Enquiry Committees in furtherance of the decision of Samiti dated 8/11/2012 (at Item No. 5[a] & 5[b]).









2. Accordingly, in respect of this College Committee - A - submitted its report. Samiti perused the general remarks and findings of the committee - A, appointed under GR No. p 0 p ?/b .%. 3 o 9 m E P I - 9 , dated 2gth November 2012. Findings of the Committee were communicated to the College vide office letter bearing No. PNS(Med)/Show Cause/Adm-2012/4010, dated 7th January 2013


a) Attendance was taken of only 5 admitted candidates. b) Reservation rules were followed. c) Admission process was done on 30/09/2012 instead of 29/09/2012.


Contention that attendance was taken of only 5 admitted candidates and reservation rules were followed being put forth after thought and not being supported by any corroborative evidence cant be accepted. Findings of the Committee that admission process conducted on 29/09/2012 for filling 05 seats was not transparent is not adequately, properly and reasonably and justly responded to by the College. It is observed that the advertisement for filling in vacancies in Indiar~ Express and Loksatta was published on 15/09/2012 and not on 22/09/2012 as contented by the College. College has not submitted any documentary evidence in support of its claim.

Findings of the Committee that the College admitted non meritorious students in respect of complaint of 1) Krina Shah, 2) Harshvardhan Savne, 3)

12 PNS(Medica1)

llth January 2013 Mithali Salve, 4) Ajit Yadav, 5) Dhara Parmar, 6) Monica Chavan, Krejiya Joy, 7) Lubna Rizwan, 8) A.F. Quereshi are also not properly, reasonably and adequately responded to by the College. Contention of the College that the said students were not present for counseling can not be accepted for want of any supportive, corroborative and sufficient evidence.

I n view of the above, Samiti therefore confirms the findings of Enquiry Comrrlittee as under :-

a) 5 candidates were admitted without giving advertisement. b) Admitted non Meritorious Students. c) Attendance report was not maintained at the time of counseling. d) Reservation rules were 'not followed.

The admission process was thus not fair, transparent & merit based. Samiti therefore disapproves all the admissions i.e. 10 done by the College/Institute after the last 'Common Admission Process" (CAP) round of Asso-CET-2012 for the Acaderr~ic Year 2012-13. Sarrliti recommends to Government of Maharashtra to direct the said College/Institute to cancel the admissions after last CAP round of Asso-CET-2012.

5. Considering the number of resultant vacancies, Samiti decides to suggest Government of Maharashtra to consider moving the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, New Delhi for permissions to fill in the resultant vacancies, extension of cut-off-date and also praying their in that all admissions even after CAP rounds be brought under 'Common Admission Process" only.

F) Sinhsad Dental Collese and Hos~ital Vadqaon, Pune.

1 Samiti had received complaints from students/parents with respect to the admissions in Private Unaided Institutions after CAP rounds in Academic Year 2012-13. Medical Education and Drugs Department of Government of Maharashtra vide its G.R. No. p 0 p P/?T .s. B o3m~- 3, dated 2gth November 2012 appointed the Enquiry Committees in furtherance of the decision of Samiti dated 8/11/2012 (at Item No. 5[a] & 5[b]).

Said committee were to enquire in to following aspects:-







13 PNS(Medica1)

llth January 2013 7) Whether guidelines per Government resolution No. WPM 1012/Pra.Kra.


2. Accordingly, in respect of this College Committee - A - submitted its report. Samiti perused the general remarks and findings of the committee - A, appointed under GR No. \- ? 0 ? ?/!T.B. 3 osmw-?, dated 29" November 2012. Findings of the Committee were communicated to the College vide office letter bearing No. PIVS(Med)/Show Cause/Adm-2012/4010, dated 7th January 2013


a) No direction from PlVS for maintaining attendance records for counseling round.

b) There was no other claimant for any of the category seats who reported to college.

4. Contentions of the College/Institute are not acceptable for the following reasons: -

Contentions that no directions were issued from the Samiti for maintenance of attendance records for counseling round is not acceptable having raised after thought. The fact that such records were not kept shows that the College was not keen in maintenance of transparency in the process seriously and honestly. Contention that there was no other claimant for any other category seats who reported to College is also not adequate, proper, just and reasonable for arriving at the conclusion that reservation rules were being observed in right perspective.

Samiti therefore confirms the findings of Enquiry Committee as under :-

a) Attendance record was not maintained. b) Reservation rules were not followed c) Admitted non Meritorious Students.

The admission process was thus not fair, transparent & merit based and reservation rules having not followed in the right perspective. Samiti therefore disapproves all the admissions i.e. 35 done by the College/Institute after the last "Common Admission Process" (CAP) round of MHT-CET-2012 for the Academic Year 2012-13. Samiti recommends to Government of Maharashtra to direct the said College/Institute to cancel the admissions afier last CAP round of MHT-CET- 2012.

5. Considering the large number of resultant vacancies, Sarr~iti decides to suggest Government of Maharashtra to consider moving the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, New Delhi for permissions to fill in the resultant vacancies, extension of

14 PNS(Medica1)

1 lm January 2013 cut-off-date and also praying their in that all admissions even after CAP rounds be brought under 'Common Admission Process" only.

G) Terna Dental Colleae, Navi Mumbai.

1 Samiti had received complaints from students/parents with respect to the admissions in Private Unaided Institutions after CAP rounds in Academic Year 2012-13. Medical Education and Drugs Department of Government of Maharashtra vide its G.R. No. * ? 0 ? 3 h .V. 2 o?/f%W- 3, dated 2gth November 2012 appointed the Enquiry Committees in furtherance of the decision of Samiti dated 8/11/2012 (at Item No. 5[a] & 5[b]).




3) Whether adequate opportunity was given to students desirous of seeking , admissions.





2. Accordingly, in respect of this College Committee - A - submitted its report. Samiti perused the general remarks and findings of the committee - A, appointed under GR No. mr ? Q ? 3h.V.2 o?/f%W-3, dated 2gth November 2012. Findings of the Committee were communicated to the College vide office letter bearing No. PNS(Med)/Show CauseIAdm-2012/4010, dated 7th January 2013


a) Attendance was taken on 28/09/2012. b) On 30/09/2012 no body was present from merit list prepared earlier. c) Two Candidates were admitted who were present that day.


Contention that attendance was taken on 28/09/2012, and on 30/09/2012 nobody was present from merit list prepared earlier, and 2 candidates were admitted who were present that day are not properly, reasonably, adequately explained and are

15 PNS(Medica1)

llth January 2013 put forth after thought. Further the findings of the Committee that College committed irregularities in admission process on 30/9/2012 while filling vacant seats without advertisement and findings of the Committee that the College admitted non meritorious students are not properly, adequately and reasonably responded to by the College.

I n view of the above, Samiti therefore confirms the findings of Enquiry Committee as under :-

a) Attendance record was not maintained. b) Irregularities in admission process on 30/9/2012 for filling 2 seats. (Without

advertisement) c) Admitted non Meritorious Students.



H) YMT Dental Colleqe, Navi Mumbai.

1. Samiti had received complaints from studentsfparents with respect to the admissions in Private Unaided Institutions after CAP rounds in Academic Year 2012-13. Medical Education and Drugs Department of Government of Maharashtra vide its G.R. No. ? 0 ? 3/5T .s. 9 03/@VWl- 3, dated 2gth November 2012 appointed the Enquiry Committees in furtherance of the decision of Samiti dated 8/11/2012 (at Item No. 5[a] & 5[b]).


1) To consider all complaints in respect of adrr~issions in Private Unaided Institutions (Medical and Dental) for the Academic Year 2012-13






16 PNS(Medica1)

llth January 2013 7) Whether guidelines per Government resolution No. WPM 1012/Pra.Kra.


2. Accordingly, in respect of this College Committee - A - subrr~itted its report. Samiti perused the general remarks and findings of the committee - A, appointed under GR No. + P 0 P ?/ST .sf;. 9 o9/@m- 7, dated 2gth November 2012. Findings of the Committee were communicated to the College vide office letter bearing No. PNS(Med)/Show CausefAdm-2012/4010, dated 7th January 2013


a) Attendance record was maintained. b) Candidates were absent at the time of counseling.


Contentions that attendance record was maintained is not acceptable since it happens to have been put forth after thought. Finding of the Committee that the College admitted non meritorious students is not properly, adequately and reasonably responded to by the College. This apart these points could have been raised before the Enquiry Committee earlier.


a) Attendance record was not maintained. b) Admitted non Meritorious Students.

The admission process was thus not fair, transparent & merit based. Samiti therefore disapproves all the admissions i.e. 17 done by the College/Institute after the last 'Common Admission Process" (CAP) round of Asso-CET-2012 for the Academic Year 2012-13. Samiti recommends to Government of Maharashtra to direct the said College/Institute to cancel the admissions after last CAP roi.~nd of Asso-CET-2012.

5. Considering the large number of resultant vacancies, Samiti decides to suggest Government of Maharashtra to consider moving the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, New Delhi for permissions to fill in the resultant vacancies, extension of cut-off-date and also praying their in that all admissions even after CAP rounds be brought under "Common Admission Process" only.


I) M.G.M. Dental Collecre, Navi Mumbai.

1 Samiti had received complaints from studentslparents with respect to the admissions in Private Unaided Institutions after CAP rounds in Academic Year 2012-13. Medical Education and Drugs Department of Government of Maharashtra vide its G.R. No. P 0 P ?/b.$.$ o?mVW3T-?, dated 2gth November 2012 appointed the Enquiry Committees in furtherance of the decision of Samiti dated 8/11/2012 (at Item No. 5[a] & 5[b]).


) To consider all complaints in respect of admissions in Private Unaided Institutions (Medical and Dental) for the Acaderr~ic Year 2012-13







2. Accordingly, in respect of this College Committee - A - submitted its report. Samiti perused the general remarks and findings of the committee - A, appointed under GR No. - P 0 P ?/b .$. $ 0 9mw-3, dated 2gth November 2012. Findings of the Committee were communicated to the College vide office letter bearing No. PNS(Med)/Show Cause/Adm-2012/4010, dated 7th January 2013

& I


a) Attendance record was kept, copies attached.


The contention happens to be having raised after thought since it is not answered as to why then the record was not shown to the Committee. Contentions therefore are not acceptable. Further the findings of the Committee that receipt of applications were being given by the College is not properly, adequately and reasonably responded to by the College

18 PIVS(Medica1)

1la January 2013 Samiti therefore confirms the findings of Enquiry Committee as under :-

a) Attendance record was not maintained. b) Receipt of application was not given by college.


5. Considering the large number of resultant vacancies, Samiti decides to suggest Government of Maharashtra to consider moving the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, New Delhi for permissions to fill in the resultant vacancies, extension of

k ,P cut-off-date and also praying their in that all admissions even after CAP rounds

be brought under "Common Admission Process" only. J Yocrita Dental Collecie, Khed, Ratnaairi.

1 Samiti had received complaints from students/parents with respect to the admissions in Private Unaided Institutions after CAP rounds in Academic Year 2012-13. Medical Education and Drugs Department of Government of Maharashtra vide its G.R. No. ? 0 ? ?/sr .%. 3 oY/@RT-?, dated 29" November 2012 appointed the Enquiry Committees in furtherance of the decision of Samiti dated 8/11/2012 (at Item No. 5[a] & 5[b]).


1) To consider .all complaints in respect of admissions in Private Unaided Institutions (Medical and Dental) for the Academic Year 2012-13






7) Whether guidelines per Government resolution No. WPM 1012/Pra,Kra. 165/12/Edu-2, dated 29/05/2012 along with the corrigendum dated 5/6/2012 were followed by Institutions.

2. Accordingly, in respect of this College Committee - A - submitted its report. Samiti perused the general remarks and findings of the committee - A, appointed under GR No. * ? 0 9 .%. 3 OY/~%$TJT- ?, dated 29" November 2012. Findings of the Committee were communicated to the College vide office letter bearing No. PNS(Med)/Show CausefAdm-2012/4010, dated 7th January 2013

PNS(Medica1) 11" January 2013


a) There were no Asso. - CET candidates present at the time of admissions, hence admitted MHT CET candidate against above seats.


The College used combined list of MHT-CET and Asso-CET during the admission process which was against the set procedure. Contention of the College that there were no Asso-CET candidates present at the time of admission, hence admitted MHT-CET candidate is not acceptable being put forth after thought. The findings of the Committee that college adrr~itted non meritorious students is not responded to by the College

I adequately, properly and reasonably. The findings of the Committee that College did not follow Samiti schedule is also not responded to by the College adequately, properly and reasonably.


a) Combined (MHT CET + ASSO. CIT) merit list was referred while admissions which is against the set procedure. ,

b) Admitted Low Meritorious Students. c) PNS schedule was not followed.

'The admission process was thus not fair, transparent & merit based. Samiti therefore disapproves all the admissions i.e. 41 done by the College/Institute after the last "Common Admission Process" (CAP) round of Asso-CET-2012 for the Academic Year 2012-13. Samiti recommends to Government of Maharashtra to direct the said College/Institute to cancel the admissions after last CAP round of Asso-CET-2012.


K) Ulhas Patil Medical Collese, Jalclaon.

1. Samiti had received complaints from students/parents with respect to the admissions in Private Unaided Institutions after CAP rounds in Academic Year 2012-13. Medical Education and Drugs Department of Government of Maharashtra vide its G.R. No. P 0 P 3 h . 3 . 3 O Y ~ W - 3 , dated 2gth November 2012 appointed the Enquiry Committees in furtherance of the decision of Samiti dated 8/11/2012 (at Item No. 5[a] & 5[b]).

20 PIVS(Medical)

1la January 2013 Said committees were to enquire in to following aspects:-








2. Accordingly, in respect of this College Committee - B - submitted its report. Samiti perused the general remarks and findings of the committee - A, appointed under GR No. ? 0 ? ?/ST .sf;. 3 o%mWJl-?, dated 29' November 2012. Findings of the Committee were communicated to the College vide office letter bearing No. PWS(Med)/Show CauseIAdm-2012/4010, dated 7th January 2013


a) As per the minutes of the meeting of PNS dated 14/08/2012 the schedule declared was followed.


Contention that the schedule of Samiti dated 14/08/2012 was followed is not acceptable, since it remains the fact that the College did not follow the subsequent schedule. Subsequent Schedule was approved by the Samiti in a meeting of September 2012. The schedule was subsequent and thus a revised one. The said subsequent schedule was followed by other colleges also. College did not follow the said schedule and resultantly did not follow the subsequent procedures as per the said schedule. This resulted in desiring students being denied the opportunity of seeking admissions leave a side the non meritorious students being admitted in the College.


a) PNS Schedule was not followed.

2 1 PNS(Medica1)

llth January 2013 The admission process was thus not fair, transparent & merit based.

Samiti therefore disapproves all the admissions i.e. 19 done by the College/Institute after the last "Common Admission Process" (CAP) round of Asso-CET-2012 for the Academic Year 2012-13. Samiti recommends to Government of Maharashtra to direct the said College/Institute to cancel the admissions after last CAP round of Asso-CET-2012.

5. Considering the large nurrlber of resultant vacancies, Samiti decides to suggest Government of Maharashtra to consider moving the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, New Delhi for permissions to fill in the resultant vacancies, extension of cut-off-date and also praying their in that all admissions even after CAP rounds be brought under 'Common Admission Process" only.

L) Dr. Vasantrao Pawar Medical Collese, Nashik.

1. Samiti had received complaints from students/parents with respect to the admissions in Private Unaided Institutions after CAP rounds in Academic Year 2012-13. Medical Education and Drugs Department of Government of Maharashtra vide its G.R. No. ydk& P 0 P PD .%. 3 O Y ~ W - P, dated 2gth November: 2012 appointed the Enquiry Committees in furtherance of the decision of Samiti dated 8/11/2012 (at Item No. 5[a] & 5[b]).








7) Whether guidelines per Government resolution No. WPM 1012/Pra.Kra. 165/12/Edu-2, dated 29/05/2012 along with the corrige~idum dated 5/6/2012 were followed by Institutions.

2. Accordingly, in respect of this College Committee - B - submitted its report. Samiti perused the general remarks and findings of the committee - A, appointed under GR No. P 0 P .%. 3 0 Y m W - P, dated 2gth November 2012. Findings of the Committee were communicated to the College vide office letter bearing No. PNS(Med)/Show Cause/Adm-2012/4010, dated 7th January 2013

22 PNS(Medica1)

llth January 2013 3. Amongst other points in response to the show cause notice dated

7th January 2013 college has contended mainly as under :-

a) Vacancy position was displayed on website on 25/09/2012.

b) Reservation rules were followed by institute.


Contention that the vacancy position was displayed on website on 25/09/2012 and reservation rules were followed having put forth after thought can not be accepted. The contentions are not supported by any corroborative evidence; and are not answered adequately, properly and reasonably. It is not answered as to why these contentions were not put forth before the Enquiry Committee.


a) Vacancy position was not Published properly b) Reservation rules were not followed.

The admission process was thus not fair, transparent & merit based and reservation rules having not followed in the right perspective. Samiti therefore disapproves all the adrr~issions i.e. 09 done by the College/Institute after the last "Common Admission Process" (CAP) round of Asso-CET-2012 for the Academic Year 2012-13. Samiti recommends to Government of Maharashtra to direct the said College/Institute to cancel the admissions after last CAP round of Asso-CET- 2012.


M) A.C.P.M. Medical Colleae, Dhule.

1 Samiti had received complaints from students/parents with respect to the admissions in Private Unaided Institutions after CAP rounds in Academic Year 2012-13. Medical Education and Drugs Department of Government of Maharashtra vide its G.R. No. * P 0 P 3 f i .sf;. 3 o%/@m- 3, dated 29' November 2012 appointed the Enquiry Committees in furtherance of the decision of Samiti dated 8/11/2012 (at Item No. 5[a] & 5[b]).



23 PNS(Medica1)

llth January 2013 2) To enquire into whether adequate and proper publicity was given by the

Institutions for admissions after CAP round.





7) Whether guidelines per Government resolution IVo. WPM 1012/Pra,Kra. 165/12/Edu-2, dated 29/05/2012 along with the corrigendum dated 5/6/2012 were followed by Institutions.

2. Accordingly, in respect of this College Committee - B - submitted its report. Samiti perused the general remarks and findings of the committee - A, appointed under GR No. rqd&# p 0 p .*. 3 03/f?T6T~l-?, dated 2gth November 2012. Findings of the Committee were communicated to the College vide office letter bearing No. PNS(Med)/Show CausefAdm-2012/4010, dated 7th January 2013


a) Advertisement was given in news paper ' Dainik Sakal" on 16/09/2012.


Contentions put forth being after thought can not be accepted. It is not answered as to why this f a d was not brought before the Enquiry Committee earlier. Further finding of the Committee that merit was not maintained is not adequately, properly and reasonably responded to by the College.


a) Merit was not maintained.

'The admission process was thus not fair, transparent & merit based. Samiti therefore disapproves all the admissions i.e. 02 done by the College/Institute after the last "Common Admission Process" (CAP) round of Asso-CET-2012 for the Academic Year 2012-13. Samiti recommends to Government of Maharashtra to dired the said College/Institute to cancel the admissions after last CAP round of Asso-CET-2012.

5. Considering the large number of resultant vacancies, Samiti decides to suggest Government of Maharashtra to consider moving the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, New Delhi for permissions to fill in the resultant vacancies, extension of cut-off-date and also praying their in that all admissions even after CAP rounds be brought under 'Common Admission Process" only.

24 PNS(Medica1)

llth January 2013 N) Pad. Dr. V.V. Patil Medical Colleae. Ahmednasar.

1. Samiti had received complaints from students/parents with respect to the admissions in Private Unaided Institutions after CAP rounds in Academic Year 2012-13. Medical Education and Drugs Department of Government of Maharashtra vide its G.R. No. 9- P 0 P ?/k .m. 3 03/h$fJT- 3, dated 29" November 2012 appointed the Enquiry Cornmittees in furtherance of the decision of Samiti dated 8/11/2012 (at Item No. 5[a] & 5[bJ).





4) Whether Samiti schedule was followed. 5) Whether vacancies were filled in considering merit of students 6) Whether reservation rules were followed. 7) Whether guidelines per Government resolution No. WPM 1012/Pra.Kra.


2. Accordingly, in respect of this College Committee - B - submitted its report. Samiti perused the general remarks and findings of the cornmittee - A, appointed under GR No. - P 0 P m.5.3 ~ ? / @ R T T - ? , dated 29" November 2012. Findings of the Committee were communicated to the College vide office letter bearing No. PNS(Med)/Show Cause/Adm-2012/4010, dated 7th January 2013


a) Candidate viz. Abbas Patanwala reported at 2.00 pm and accepted that he was late.


It has been observed by Committee per the annexure C of the College (Important directions given to applicant in news papers, College website and on Notice board - No. 6 - counseling was to start at sharp 1400 hrs. Students were expected to mark their attendance in register between 900 to 1330 hrs. I n view of this the candidate doest not render him self in elibible for the counseling/interview merely because he attended at 1400 hrs. It is to be noted that though he accepted he was late; he has not withdrawn the complaint. I n light of the above findings need to be confirmed.

25 PIVS(Medica1)

llth January 2013 Samiti therefore confirms the findings of Enquiry Committee as under :-

a) Abbas Pathanwala was present for counseling at 2.00 O'clock, he was not considered for admission.

The process followed by College resulted in denial of admission to a needy and desirous student. The admission process was thus not fair, transparent & merit based. Samiti therefore disapproves all the admissions i.e. 09 done by the College/Institute after the last "Common Admission Process" (CAP) round of Asso-CET-2012 for the Academic Year 2012-13. Samiti recommends to Government of Maharashtra to direct the said College/Institute to cancel the admissions after last CAP round of Asso-CET-2012.

5. Considering the number of resultant vacancies, Samiti decides to suggest Government of Maharashtra to consider moving the Honfble Supreme Court of India, New Delhi for permissions to fill in the resultant vacancies, extension of cut-off-date and also praying their in that all admissions even after CAP rounds be brought under 'Common Admission Process" only.

0) M.G.V. K.B.H. Dental Colleae, Nashik.

1. Samiti had received complaints from studentsfparents with respect to the admissions in Private Unaided Institutions after CAP rounds in Academic Year 2012-13. Medical Education and Drugs Department of Government of Maharashtra vide its G.R. No. &Jf P 0 P .%. 3 OY/@W- 7 , dated 2gth November 2012 appointed the Enquiry Committees in furtherance of the decision of Samiti dated 8/11/2012 (at Item No. 5[a] & 5[b]).








7) Whether guidelines per Government resolution No. WPM 1012/Pra,Kra. 165/12/Edu-2, dated 29/05/2012 along with the corrigendum dated 5/6/2012 were followed by Institutions.

2. Accordingly, in respect of this College Committee - B - submitted its report. Samiti perused the general remarks and findings of the committee - A, appointed under GR No. P 0 P 7 h .B. 3 0 s/@m- 7 , dated 29' November 2012. Findings of the Committee were communicated to the College vide office letter bearing No. PNS(Med)/Show CausefAdm-2012/4010, dated 7th January 20 13 .-',


a) Advertisement was published on 16/09 & 17/09/2012 in Dainik Sakal & Indian Express .

b) PNS schedule was followed. c) Attendance of 22/09/2012, 25/09/2012 and 28/09/2012 for counseling

round was kept.

4. Contentions of the College/lnstitute are not acceptable for the following reasons:-

Contentions happen to have put forth after thought. They could have been raised before Enquiry Committee. This was not been done by the College. 'The Contentions are not supported by proper and adequate documentary evidence.

I n view of the above, Samiti therefore confirms the findings of Enquiry Committee as under :-

a) Vacancy Position was not Properly Published. b) PNS Schedule was not followed.

'The admission process was thus not fair, transparent & merit based. Samiti therefore disapproves all the admissions i.e. 16 done by the College/Institute after the last 'Common Admission Process" (CAP) round of Asso-CET-2012 for the Academic Year 2012-13. Samiti recommends to Government of Maharashtra to direct the said College/Institute to cancel the admissions after last CAP round of Asso-CET-2012.

5. Considering the large number of resultant vacancies, Samiti decides to suggest Government of Maharashtra to consider moving the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, New Delhi for permissions to fill in the resultant vacancies, extension of cut-off-date and also praying their in that all admissions even after CAP rounds be brought under 'Common Admission Process" only.

P) N.K.P. Salve Medical Colleae, Naqpur.

1. Samiti had received complaints from studentsjparents with respect to the admissions in Private Unaided Institutions after CAP rounds in Academic Year 2012-13. Medical Education and Drugs Department of Government of Maharashtra vide its G.R. No. - P 0 ? T ~ . B . 2 0 9 / @ T m - T , dated 2gth November 2012 appointed the Enquiry Committees in furtherance of the decision of Samiti dated 8/11/2012 (at Item No. 5[a] & 5[b]).


27 PIVS(Medica1)

llth January 2013 1 To consider all complaints in respect of admissions in Private Unaided

Institutions (Medical and Dental) for the Academic Year 2012-13



4) Whether Sarr~iti schedule was followed.




2. Accordingly, in respect of this College Committee - C - submitted its report. Samiti perused the general remarks and findings of the committee - A, appointed under GR No. p Q p ?.b .s. 9 Q?/@w- 41, dated 2gth November 2012. Findings of the Committee were communicated to the College vide office letter bearing No. PIVS(Med)/Show Cause/Adm-2012/4010, dated 7th January 2013


a) Vacancy position was displayed on website on 25/09/2012. b) All the complaints were after thought. c) 23 candidates were present on 28/09/2012 for vacancy round, because of

wide publicity only. d) Dean of the College has vide his letter No.

NKP/Dean/Stud/Sec/0129/2012, dated 8/1/2013 has requested for 10 days to submit the explanation to the findings of the Enquiry Committee. He has further requested to supply a copy of report of Enquiry Committee to enable him to prepare a reply.

4. It is to be noted that the show cause notice was issued to the College on 7/1/2013. Replies were sought before 10/01/2013. The college was also supplied the relevant information on 10/01/2013 immediately after it was demanded to by the representative of the College. The College has submitted its reply on 10/01/2013 which bears the date 8/1/2013. This shows that the reply was ready but handed over PNS at the latter date. The reply no where asks for more time to reply. Therefore at this juncture it is not necessary to grant more time to the applicant College for submission of a reply again. Samiti feels that time allowed for responding to the show cause notice was fair, proper and a reasonable period. Samiti therefore, rejects the request for extension of further time to respond again.



College has submitted that vacancy position was displayed on website on 25/09/2012. Findings of the Committee in respect of complaints is that vacancy position was not properly displayed on 24/09/2012. The submission of the college thus confirms that it has not displayed vacancy position on 24/09/2012. The contention that 23 candidates were present on 28/09/2012 for vacancy round because of wide publicity only, can not be considered being put forth after thought.' 'This contention could have been raised before the Enquiry Committee. Fact that complainants complained that vacancy position was not properly published on 24/09/2012 and the fact that Institute admittedly published vacancy position on 25/09/2012 shows that as on 24/09/2012 students were kept un aware of the admission process that was being followed by the College. Thus there was no proper publication of vacancies giving chances of non meritorious students being admitted.

The Enquiry Committee report resultantly needs to be confirmed.


1) Vacancy Position was not Properly Published on 24/9/2012

College not having followed the proper procedure resulted in to unfair, unjust, not merit based and not transparent admissions. Samiti therefore disapproves all the admissions i.e. 11 done by the College/Institute after the last "Common Admission Process" (CAP) round of Asso-CET-2012 for the Academic Year 2012-13. Samiti recommends to Government of Maharashtra to direct the said College/Institute to cancel the admissions after last CAP round of Asso-CET- 2012.


Q) Dr. P.D. Memorial Medical Collecre, Amravati.

1. Samiti had received complaints from students/parents with respect to the admissions in Private Unaided Institutions after CAP rounds in Academic Year 2012-13. Medical Education and Drugs Department of Government of Maharashtra vide its G.R. No. - P 0 P ?/ST . 3 . 3 o9/@w~r- 3, dated 2gth November 2012 appointed the Enquiry Committees in furtherance of the decision of Sarr~iti dated 8/11/2012 (at Item No. 5[a] & 5[b]).


29 PNS(Medica1)

llth January 2013 1) To consider all complaints in respect of admissions in Private Unaided

Institutions (Medical and Dental) for the Academic Year 2012-13






7) Whether guidelines per Government resolution IVo. WPM 1012/PramKra. 165/12/Edu-2, dated 29/05/2012 along with the corrigendum dated 5/6/2012 were followed by Institutions.

Accordingly, in respect of this College Committee - C - submitted its report. Samiti perused the general remarks and findings of the committee - A, appointed under GR No. + ? 0 ? ?h .%. 3 oQ,/fhWJT-?, dated 2gth November 2012. Findings of the Committee were communicated to the College vide office letter bearing No. PNS(Med)/Show CauselAdm-2012/4010, dated 7th January 2013


a) Candidate from Reserved Category has to submit Caste Validity Certificate at the time of admission as per MUHS letter dated 31/7/2012. Action to reject admission to Abdul Rehaman Abdul Bashir for want of CVC, from OBC Category is Justifiable.


Samiti observed that one Mr. Abdul Bashir Mohd. Ismail was allotted to Ashvini Rural Medical College, Solapur in first round. I n second round he was allotted to this College. He therefore cancelled the admission which was offered to him in first round. But this college rejected the admission for want of Caste Validity Certificate (CVC). Committee after enquiry felt that it would have been in the fittest of the things had the college considered the request of the applicant.

College is however has taken a stand that as per University letter dated 31/07/2012 submission of CVC was necessary and therefore action of rejecting the admission to the said students was justifiable.

I n view of the fact that the student was duly admitted in Ashivini Rural Medical College, Solapur during first round and in view of the fact that he cancelled the admission for betterment purposes he was allotted to this college, College could have considered his case; resulting an admission to a deserving candidate; provisionally till the production of CVC at a later date suitably.


Saniiti therefore confirms the findings of Enquiry Committee as under :-

a) Injustice has been done to the candidate and his case should have been considered by the college.

Considering the letter and spirits of the rules and the set parameters of procedures being followed this admission process was thus not fair, transparent & merit based. Samiti therefore disapproves all the admissions i.e. 04 done by the College/Institute after the last "Common Admission Process" (CAP) round of Asso-CET-2012 for the Academic Year 2012-13. Samiti recommends to Government of Maharashtra to direct the said College/Institute to cancel the admissions after last CAP round of Asso-CET-2012.

5. Considering the nurr~ber of resultant vacancies, Saniiti decides to suggest Government of Maharashtra to consider moving the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, New Delhi for permissions to fill in the resultant vacancies, extension of cut-off-date and also praying their in that all admissions even after CAP rounds be brought under "Common Admission Process" only.

Samiti also perused the reports of Committees in respect of following Colleges:-

) Dadasaheb Kalmegh Dental College, Nagpur 2) C.S.M.S.S. Dental College, Aurangabad. 3) M.I.D.S.R. Dental College, Latur 4) Y.C.M.M. and R.D.F.S. Dental College, Ahmednagar

After deliberations, Samiti approves the finding of the Enquiry Committees.

Item No. 4: To mnsider and decide on the letterslre~resentations received:-

a 1 Item No. 4(a) : Letter dated 5th Januaw 2013 received from M.A.

Ranaoonwala Colleae of Dental Sciences & Research Centre, Pune in resmct of the decision taken bv the Samiti in its meetina held on 21* December 2012 (at Item No. 5rbl& 5rcl) reaardincl mnduct of CET-2013 for Minoritv Ouota admissions for Post Graduate MDS course and first vear BDS course for the Academic Year 2013-14.

Samiti perused the letter No. MARDC/Adm/PNS/4656/13, dated 5/1/2013. ~ l b b

After deliberation, Samiti concluded to by the existing orders of Hon'ble courts. Brochure to be submitted IU DW I

31 PIVS(Medica1)

llth January 2013 Item No. 4(bl: Letters dated 27th December 2012 and 2"* Januarv 2013

received from Dean, Government Medical Collecre, NaaDur and Dr. S.A. Dhole, res~ectivelv resarding mal~ractices durins admissions aclainst vacant seats of merit auota in Academic Year 2011-12 in Dr. P. D. Memorial Medical Colleqe, Amravati

Samiti perused the letter under reference.

Applicant Dr. S.A. Dhole has lodged the complaint to Samiti against malpractices during admissions by Dr. P.D. Memorial Medical College, Amravati for Academic Year 2011-12 dated 21/12/2012. Samiti perused the letter dated 21/12/2012 addressed to said applicant by Dean, Government Medical College, Nagpur. Samiti also perused letter dated 2/1/2013addressed to Samiti by the said applicant and letter dated 3/12/2012 addressed to Secretary, Medical Education and Drugs Department.

Samiti notes that the complaint is about admissions of Academic Year 2011-12. Since the academic year is already over, the points raised by said applicant do not survive they being after thought. Samiti therefore files the application. Inform the applicant, accordingly.

Item No. 4(cI : Letter dated 7th Januarv 2013 received from Homoeo~athic Medical Colleae, Sanaamner, Ahmednasar reauestina to ~ e r m i t admissions of first year B.H.M.S. course in 15% NRI Ouota on the basis of GUJCET-2012 for the Academic Year 2012-13.


The College/Tnstitute can admit the students appearing MHT-CET-2012 and/or Asso-CET-2012 and those who are other wise eligible for the first year B.H.M.S. course admissions. Hence the request made by the aforesaid College/Institute to admit students on the basis of performance of candidate in GUJ-CET-2012 for Academic Year 2012-13 can not be considered. 'The request is therefore rejected.

Item No. 4(d) : Letter dated 7th Januarv 2013 received from Chairman, Enauirv Committee - A and Dean, B.J. Government Medical Colleae, Pune reauestins for ~avment of T.A. / D.A. to Committee - A a~min ted in furtherance of Government Resolution No. MED-2012h .T. 3 O Q ~ W T - P , f&d% PQ/ P P/P 0 P P. claiming honorarium and other incidental exDenses amountinq to Rs. 1,55,000/-.


Samiti in its meeting held on 21e December 2012 (at Item No. 5[e]) had decided as under:-

32 PIVS(Medical)

llth January 2013 'Samiti decides that the said matter i.e. payment of T.A./DA. of

the Representatives of the Samiti appointed under Government Resolution No. MED-2012/ . . 9 0 ?/%?w- ?, f&T% ? ? / P P / ? o P?. fo/warded to Government of Maharashtra for uts

consideration. After receipt of the same it be placed before Samiti for its consideration. "

Government of Maharashtra in Medical Education and Drugs Department, Mumbai to consider it early.

Samiti directs the office to communicate the above decision to the concerned.

I tem No. 41eI: Letter dated 4th Januarv 2013 received from Association of Manaaement of Unaided Private Medical and Dental Colleaes of Maharashtra reaardina PG Medical and Dental CET-2013. (Ref. - Meetina dated 21.12.2012 - Asenda Item No. 5ral I

Samiti perused and noted the letter under reference. Court orders to be obeyed.

I tem No. 4(fl: Letter dated 26th December 2012 received from Maharashtra Sthte Private Nursins Schools and Calleqes Manasement Association, Auranaa bad com~laining aaainst the Universitv for Elisibilitv fees recoverins from the students admitted asainst NRI auota.


After deliberations, Samiti decides that the aspect of recovery of Eligibility fees by the University does not come within the purview of Samiti. Samiti directs the office to communicate this to the applicant accordingly.

I tem No. 4(al: Letter dated 1 2 ~ ~ December 2012 received from Mr. Hemantkumar Gaianan Gharat, Mumbai askina the transfer of the student admitted in M.G.M. Medical Colleae, Auransabad ta M.G.M. Medical Colleae, Kamothe, Navi Mumbai.

Samiti perused the letter under reference. It is observed that aforesaid College/Institute happens to be the Deemed

University.

After deliberations, Samiti decides that the aspect of transfer of students from one college to another College Deemed University does not come within the purview of Samiti. Samiti directs the office to inform the applicant, accordingly.

Item No. 5:

33 PNS(Medica1)

llth ~anuary 2013 To review disposal of work - Proposals in respect of admissions in 15% NRI Ouota for the Academic Year 2012-13.

Samiti perused the present Scenario - in respect of admissions done in 15% NRI Quota by the Colleges/Institutes for the Academic Year 2012-13. the details of which are as under:

Course : M.B.B.S.

; d W '

(a)

1

2

6

7

9

10

11

12

01 0 01 0 1 - % a U

(b)

MBBS Oool

Ooo2

MBBS 0003

MBBS 0004

MBBS 0005

MBBS 0006

MBBS Ooo7

MBBS 0008

MBBS Ooo9

MBBS Oo10

MBBS Ool'

MBBS Ool2

01 0 01 - - 0 U Y- O

B 1

(c) K.J. Somaiya Medical College & Research Centre, Sion, Mumbai Terna Medical College & Hospital, NeruI, Navi Mumbai

MIMER, Medical College, Talegaon Dabhade, Pune

Dr. Vasantrao Pawar Medical College, Nashik

A.C.P.M. Medical College, Dhule

NKP Salve Institute of Medical Sciences & Research Centre, Nagpur Dr.Punjabrao Deshmukh Memorial Medical College, Arnravati

M.I.M.S.R. Medical College, Latur

Padmashri Dr. Vithalrao Vikhe Patil Medical College, Ahmednagar Smt Kashibai Navale Medical College, Narhe, Pune Godavari Foundation's Dr. Ulhas Patil Medical CollegeJalgaon Institute of Medical Sciences & Research, Khatav, Satara

3 15% Quota 0

B 2

(dl

50

100

120

150

100

100

150

100

100

100

(el

8

15

15

18

15

23

15

15

23

15

15

15

(9

8

2

4

2

0

3

11

2

1

1

0

0

(g)

0

0

4

0

0

1

11

2

1

1

0

0

(h)

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

(i)

0

0

4

0

0

1

11

2

1

1

0

0

(j)

0

13

11

16

15

20

4

13

22

14

15

15

f + j = e

8

15

15

18

15

23

15

15

23

15

15

15

Ashwini Rural Medical

TOTAL (A) :

Gourn : B.D.S.

34 PNS(Medica1)

llth January 2013

Tota,

f + j = e

15

207

3 S 0'

2

Q ul r ~

(el

15

207

al 15% Quota

P 3 - al - rn al 8 i - x w

Ul z 0 3

8 a rc

- (a) (b) (c) (dl (el (9 (g) (h) (i)

Shri Vasantdada Patil 1 BDS Dental College & Hospital, 40 6 1 0 0 0 OOol

sangli M G V's KBH Dental

2 BDS College & Hospital, 100 15 1 0 0 0 Ooo2 Nashik BDS 0003

15% Quota

E,

1$ ' C I d a

9

10

44

Y.M.T. Dental College, Navi Murnbai

BDS S.M.B.T. Dental College, 0004 Sangarnner, Ahmednagar 15 1 0 0 0 14

UI

% P % j p . w zeL*

L

(g)

0

20

100

6

c" u

d p u d . 8 g d g g 3 5 Z E p q a

(h)

0

0

15

BDS 0005

BDS Ooo6

BDS 0007

BDS 0009

BDS 0010

5 5s z a l

L

(i)

0

20

1

M.A. Rangaonwala Dental College, Pune Pandit Deendayal Upadhyay Dental College, Solapur Tatyasaheb Kore Dental College, Kolhapur

W S Dental College, Amravati

VSPM Dental College Nagpur

2 F e z

- E m m ; q r p (j)

5

163

1

40

60

50

100

0

15

6

9

8

15

1

15

4

1

4

2

14

0

0

1

3

2

15

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

1

3

2

0

2

8

3

13

15

6

9

7

15

V)z

(a)

lo

-

After deliberations, Samiti directs the Colleges/Institutes to submit their proposals for approval of admissions in 15% NRI Quota alongwith the relevant documents within 15 days in respect of those who still have not submitted the same to Samiti.

SUB TOTAL : A + B

a ul a

c " ~ OU U

(b)

BDS 0011

BDS 0012

3110

a ul a - - 0 U u- 0

i m z

(c) Ch. Shahu Maharaj Shikshan Sanstha's Dental College, Aurangabad Terna Dental College & Hospital, Navi Mumbai

0

0

0

0

12

13

l4

468

14

0

8

15

- m Y

f + j = e

15

BDS

BDS

BDS 0015

1

15

7 ---

15 l5

l7

l8

19

20

138

15% Quota 3 0

0

0

0

15

15

15

15

W $

0 5 6 % z a P

(0

2

(dl

100

0

0

0

Mahatma Gandhi Missions Dental College, Navi Mumbai Annasaheb Chudaman Patil Memorial Dental College, Dhule Sinhgad Dental College, Pune

Swargiya Dadasaheb

BDS 0016

BDS 0018

BDS 0019

BDs Oo20

BDS Oo2'

46

= 2 p)Ez

' E m m ; 3 > g

(j)

13

100

TOTAL : B

0

(el

15

100

100

100

MIDSR Dental College, Latur

Saraswati Dhanwantri Dental College, Parbhani

Y.C.M.DentalCollege, Ahmednagar Shivtej Arogya Seva Snastha Yogita Dental College & Hospital Dr. Hedgewar Smruti Rugna Seva Mandal College, Hingoli

0

13 15

15

15

15

1740

(9

2

100

100

100

100

50

46

2

261

(g)

2

15

15

15

15

8

330

(h)

0

0

94

468

0 ------

0

4

14

7

4

26

0

4

13

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

26

4

13

0

0

167 261

11

1

8

4

15

15

15

8

36 PNS(Medica1)

llth January 2013 Item No. 6 : Anv Other matter with the permission to the Chair.

Nil.

Next meeting of Pravesh Niyantran Samiti (Medical Education) will be decide in due course of time. /

Date: C F * t 9 - J ~ H Q P ~ Q.-0 L ' 3 (D.K. DESHMUKH) CHAIRMAN

Documents

llth Education, 3, Mahapalika Marg, Mumbai on behalf of Secretary, Medical Education and Drugs Department, Government of Maharashtra. 2) Dr. P.H. Shingare Director, Medical Education