52
Live Webinar March 28, 2013 www.technologytransfertactics.com – 877-729-0959

Live Webinar March 28, 2013 – 877-729-0959

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

Live Webinar March 28, 2013

www.technologytransfertactics.com – 877-729-0959

Page 2: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

MargaretK. Offermann, MD, PhD, Managing Partner at The Salutramed Group is a medical oncologist and biomedical researcher who has extensive senior leadership experience in academic, philanthropic and private healthcare settings. She is President-Elect for the Federation of American Societies for Experimental Biology (FASEB), a non-profit federation of 26 professional societies focused on the life sciences that collectively have over 100,000 members. FASEB serves as a major voice for the biomedical research community on Capital Hill and in policy settings. She is on the Board of Directors of Georgia Center for Research and Education (GaCORE), a non-profit organization that promotes cooperation between cancer clinicians, educators and researchers throughout the state of Georgia. She served as co-chair of the Committee of Scientific Researchers for Georgia Bio, helping scientists in academia and industry work together to advance promising discoveries with commercial potential. From 1989 to 2007, she served on the faculty of Emory University School of Medicine where she rose to the rank of Professor of Hematology and Oncology and served as co-director of the MD-PhD training program, Associate Director of the Postgraduate Training Program in Hematology and Oncology and Associate Director of the Winship Cancer Institute. Her research program explored innate antiviral immunity in endothelial cells and the molecular events in the pathogenesis of Kaposi's sarcoma, with funding from the National Institutes of Health, the American Cancer Society, the American Heart Association and other organizations.  From 2007-2010, she served as Deputy National Vice President for Research at the American Cancer Society, providing executive leadership for both intramural and extramural research programs for the largest non-profit, non-government funder of cancer research in the US. Through Salutramed Group, Inc, she served as founding medical director of the Mission Health System Cancer Center in Asheville, NC, a heath system rated by Reuters as one of the top 15 in the nation in 2012.  She received a BA in biochemistry from Mount Holyoke College, magna cum laude and her MD and PhD in biochemistry from the Medical College of Virginia. She did internship and residency in Internal Medicine at the University of Chicago Hospitals followed by training in Medical Oncology at the Dana Farber Cancer Institute and Harvard Medical School in Boston. She is board certified in Medical Oncology and Internal Medicine.

2

Page 3: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

T. Forcht (Teo) Dagi, MD, MPH, DMedSc, MBA is a neurosurgeon, neuro-intensivist, and veteran venture capitalist with extensive international experience . He has helped raise over $500 million in funds for portfolio companies and venture capital funds and has more than 15 years of successful experience in founding, managing and exiting companies in health care services and in the life sciences .He has operating experience in healthcare services, healthcare information technology, and the biomedical sector, and has served on boards of directors of publicly traded and privately held companies. Dr. Dagi serves as Professor, and Chairman of International Advisory Panel of the School of Medicine of Queen’s University Belfast, Northern Ireland (UK), and Visiting Professor at Harvard Medical School. He chairs the Committee on Perioperative Care of the American College of Surgery, and serves as a Director of the Council for Surgical and Perioperative Safety, and the Anesthesia Patient Safety Foundation. He lectures in the Harvard Business School on healthcare innovation and in the Biomedical Entrepreneurship Program at the Harvard-MIT Program in Health Sciences and Technology on new technology development, assessment, and commercialization. Dr. Dagi received an AB from Columbia University, his MD and MPH degrees from Johns Hopkins, and an MBA from the Wharton School. He was named the Joseph P. Kennedy, Jr., Fellow at Harvard, from which he also received a MTS degree in jurisprudence. He trained at the Massachusetts General Hospital and the Neurosurgical Unit of the Guy’s, Maudsley and King’s College Hospitals in London. He was President of the Georgia Neurosurgical Society and a Director of the American Association of Neurological Surgeons. Among other distinctions, he has been awarded the US Humanitarian Service Medal, and a DMedSc (Hon. Causae) from Queen’s University for contributions to medicine and public service. He was named the Sir Thomas and Edith Dixon Medalist for 2012 and was named to an ad hominem Fellowship in the Royal College of Surgeons Edinburgh in 2013. He is an editor of Neurosurgery and the Journal of Clinical Ethics, has published over 175 articles and co-authored or edited several books.

3

Page 4: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

Jack D. Capers, Jr. partner with King and Spalding in Atlanta, is a member of the firm’s Corporate Practice Group. Mr. Capers has experience in a wide variety of corporate transactions, including domestic and international mergers, acquisitions, tender offers, exchange offers, spin-offs and divestitures, joint ventures, strategic alliances, strategic investments and leveraged buy-outs. In addition, he has advised boards of directors, board committees and investment banking firms on matters relating to corporate governance issues, M&A transactions and takeover defenses. Mr. Capers was named one of The Best Lawyers in America 2012, one of America’s Leading Lawyers for Business 2012 by Chambers USA, and one of Georgia’s Super Lawyers 2012 by Atlanta Magazine.

4

Page 5: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

Russell M. Medford, M.D., Ph.D., founding Managing Partner of The Salutramed Group, Inc, (www.salutramed.com) an Atlanta, Boston and North Carolina based consulting firm that provides analysis and support for critical decision-making for senior life science executives, for foundation and institutional executives and for Boards of Directors. Salutramed Group advises on fundamental issues relating to corporate structure and growth, institutional strategy, risk mitigation, value creation, governance and public policy.  He has extensive experience in the development and translation of advanced science into novel, first-in-man therapeutics addressing critical unmet medical needs. Dr. Medford has built and led multiple research and development biotechnology companies, from early startup through IPO into advanced NASDAQ traded companies engaged in multiple, late-stage international clinical trials. These included the cardiovascular and metabolic disease company, AtheroGenics, Inc. (AGIX), as its scientific co-founder (as an Associate Professor of Medicine at the Emory University School of Medicine), advancing to corporate Board Director and CEO, raising over $500 million in both the private and public equities markets, and the antiviral company Inhibitex, Inc. (INHX) as a founding Board Director until its recent acquisition by a major pharmaceutical company for $2.5 billion. He is currently Chairman of Salutria Pharmaceuticals, LLC, developing new drugs for multiple sclerosis and other inflammatory diseases and is a member of the Board of Directors of Biotechnology Industry Organization (Washington DC), Georgia BIO, the National Health Museum and the Petit Institute of Bioscience and Bioengineering of the Georgia Institute of Technology.

5

Page 6: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

Technology Transfer Tactics Distance Learning Total Access Pass allows you to customize a distance learning program for your staff and faculty at a steeply discounted price with 4 convenient formats.

You can get details on our website at www.technologytransfertactics.com and click on Tech Transfer University on the left sidebar.

6

Page 7: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

By adopting proven best practices, you will achieve higher success rates, more effective use of staff time and patent budgets, and better relationships with faculty inventors. You’ll also slash wasted time and effort, bring a higher percentage of high-promise innovations forward, and enable more confident decision-making when faced with competing priorities. Our esteemed panel will discuss all four key elements that should inform your patent and start-up assessments.

7

Page 8: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

1. An Overview of Risk Mitigation and Value Creation for OTT Portfolio Management: Four Elements

2. The Role and Expectations of the Faculty Founder

3. Market, Technology and IP Assessment4. Corporate Structure and Management Team5. Approaching the Financial Community6. Summary and Conclusions

8

Page 9: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

1. An Overview of Risk Mitigation and Value Creation for OTT Portfolio Management: Four Elements

2. The Role and Expectations of the Faculty Founder

3. Market, Technology and IP Assessment4. Corporate Structure and Management Team5. Approaching the Financial Community6. Summary and Conclusions

9

Page 10: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

Multiple investment opportunities with limited investment resources demand a disciplined review of risk and return based on four key elements:

10

Page 11: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

Market

Intellectual Property

Technology

Business/Finance

11

Page 12: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

1/Risk

Val

ue

12

Page 13: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

1. An Overview of Risk Mitigation and Value Creation for OTT Portfolio Management: Four Elements

2. The Role and Expectations of the Faculty Founder

3. Market, Technology and IP Assessment4. Corporate Structure and Management Team5. Approaching the Financial Community6. Summary and Conclusions

13

Page 14: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

• The University’s most important and precious resource is its intellectual capital• faculty, postdoctoral fellows, students.

• Pro-active, effective and appropriate founder/faculty involvement is a key value driver in the value-risk assessment for any TTO portfolio assessment.• Technology and Science – initial definitions and structure• Intellectual property – initial patent filings and claims structure• Market and Competitive landscape – initial technical expertise• Business/finance – managing expectations

• An understanding of the motivation, commitment and expectations of the faculty/founder is critical and impacts all four valuation elements

14

Page 15: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

Traditional career advancement is based on success with publications and grants

As extramural funding environment has worsened, more faculty are looking to the commercial sector as a way to support their research

15

Page 16: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

16

Page 17: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

17

Page 18: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

While some faculty have discoveries that have commercial potential, most don’t have the skill-sets needed to advance their discoveries to a commercially viable endpoint

Most also don’t have the skills needed to assess the market opportunity

18

T. Forcht Dagi, MD
Fixed spacing
Page 19: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

• The goals of conflict of interest policies in medicine are to – Protect the integrity of professional

judgment– Preserve scientific integrity and maintain

objectivity– Preserve public trust– Avoid the need to remediate bias or

mistrust after the fact

19

Page 20: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

Funding of Biomedical Research has increasingly been supported by the commercial sector :

industry, accounted for 58% of all expenditures in 2007.

JAMA. 2010;303(2):137-143

20

Page 21: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

• Make it easy to do the right thing• Have clear, consistent rules as well as

checks and balances to protect the integrity of research and the trust in the results

• Don’t make regulations so burdensome that important clinical research is delayed or deferred

• Make sure rules are promulgated, understood and accepted by stakeholders

21

Page 22: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

1. An Overview of Risk Mitigation and Value Creation for OTT Portfolio Management: Four Elements

2. The Role and Expectations of the Faculty Founder

3. Market, Technology and IP Assessment4. Corporate Structure and Management Team5. Approaching the Financial Community6. Summary and Conclusions

22

Page 23: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

How should tech transfer offices do the initial assessment of potential inventions using limited resources?

Does the technology/science/product address a critical unmet need and market opportunity?

Does the technology/science/product data justify embarking on a development/commercialization plan?

23

Page 24: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

How large is the opportunity? Are clients attainable? Can you articulate the need and explain why it

exists? What does your technology offer in terms of a

solution? What alternative solutions exist? What

substitutes? If not for your technology, what would the

customers do?

24

Page 25: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

Who sells the product or solutions? What do similar products or solutions sell for? Can you project your margins? Why should someone buy your product or

solution rather than your competitions’? What makes you think they will? How are you differentiated? How are you better? Do you offer savings, convenience, better

experience, better outcomes or something else?

25

Page 26: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

Describe your customers Do they now buy anything similar to

your product or service? What are sales of your nearest

competitors or comparable companies?

Which analysts in the market write and cover your specific areas?

What do the say about your products or solutions?

26

Page 27: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

Why did you develop this product? Who will manufacture it? How much will that cost? How will you know it works? What if it doesn’t? How will you know whether it is ready? What do you need to do to finish the project? When you finish, is it stand-alone or does it

need other products or services to create value?

If so, are they accessible to you? Who controls them?

27

Page 28: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

On what basis do clients by this product? How do you know? What are the most important reasons they

buy? If not your product, whose would they buy? How will you tell your clients about the

product? What will make them buy it? How will you keep others from displacing

you?

28

Page 29: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

Is there a proprietary position that protects the business and allows the product to return value to the investor and/or the university?

Have you obtained a freedom to operate opinion?

29

Page 30: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

What is proof of concept for you product or service? What makes it proof of concept? Will you need prototypes? Who will make them? How will you test them? What will the tests be designed to do? Are there standards of proof which, once reached, will be taken

objective as evidence of risk reduction?

30

Page 31: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

What processes are needed within the company to meet external or industry standards?

Where are the guidelines? Are there regulatory requirements? Who enforces them? How will you obtain the necessary

expertise to meet these requirements? Are there special licenses or permissions

that must be obtained to proceed?

31

Page 32: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

What special resources might you need, including complying raw materials, resources or expertise?

How long will it take to demonstrate proof of concept and what will it cost?

After proof of principle, what is the next step in commercialization?

What do you need to accomplish to have a product you can bring to market and how long will that take?

32

Page 33: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

Does anyone have claim to any part of your invention or technology?

Do you have permission to commercialize it?

Are there any conditions on commercialization?

Are there any elements needed for commercialization that you do not yet or cannot control?

Have you obtained a clear freedom-to-operate opinion?

33

Page 34: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

1. An Overview of Risk Mitigation and Value Creation for OTT Portfolio Management: Four Elements

2. The Role and Expectations of the Faculty Founder

3. Market, Technology and IP Assessment4. Corporate Structure and Management

Team5. Approaching the Financial Community6. Summary and Conclusions 34

Page 35: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

Do you have a company already formed? What is the nature of the company – LLC, PC,

Sub-chapter C, Sub-chapter S? Where is it domiciled? Have you fulfilled all the necessary formalities

in establishing the company? Who is on the management team? What is the team’s experience and track

record? Who is full time and who not? What is the makeup of the board of directors? Who else needs to be hired and when?

35

Page 36: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

What is the vision you have for the company?

What will it do? Do you want to build a company around

your technology or license it? Do you have a technology platform to

generate other related products? Is the platform proven? Do you plan to run your company for ever,

or sell it? Who are the logical acquirers, and why?

36

Page 37: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

Objectives: Attract investors Find a partner Identify a protectable market niche Position and sell product Gain market share Sell the company/asset Go public

37

Page 38: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

Important truths: Properly organized company builds

credibility Investors/buyers won’t buy trouble Time to close is crucial for

investors/buyers Poor management = no deal You will pay for your mistakes Avoid spending scarce resources to solve

avoidable problems38

Page 39: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

1. Do It Right▪ Use good advisors▪ Maintain corporate formalities▪ Use proper accounting

39

Page 40: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

2. Create Capital Structure To Promote Success Restrict stock to inventors, owners and

employees Maintain control over shares Require stockholders to be party to a

stockholders agreement Maintain pro forma model of distribution

of proceeds from sale of company/asset

40

Page 41: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

3. Install Good Management Good management builds credibility in

all things (value, relationship, prospects, etc.)

Investors/buyers prefer good management over good assets

Check frequently to make sure things are working

Make changes if not

41

Page 42: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

4. Acquire and Maintain Clear Title to IP Control development of IP Get invention agreements from

inventors/employees Monitor freedom to operate Protect trade secrets Manage patent filings Take action against infringing IP

42

Page 43: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

5. Maintain Good Records Enables company to respond quickly to

opportunities Adds to credibility of management Ready for diligence by investors/buyers

43

Page 44: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

Last and Best Advice:

Keep It Simple

44

Page 45: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

1. An Overview of Risk Mitigation and Value Creation for OTT Portfolio Management: Four Elements

2. The Role and Expectations of the Faculty Founder

3. Market, Technology and IP Assessment4. Corporate Structure and Management Team5. Approaching the Financial Community6. Summary and Conclusions

45

Page 46: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

What is your projected budget for the next 18 months and 3 years?

What milestones will be achieved over that time and with those funds?

What value will be created through the achievement of each milestone? Can you calculate an ROI or step-up in valuation for

subsequent financing rounds? How much can you raise from grants and other non-

dilutive sources? Can you earn anything from your product or solution

over that time? When do you think you might start seeing revenue? When do you think you might break even?

46

Page 47: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

What are the near and medium term milestones in the development of the product or company, and how will the company or university finance to those milestones?

How do you know these are the milestones? What happens with each one? What can go wrong in this roadmap? In what way does each milestone reduce the risks of failure?

47

Page 48: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

What is the time required to reach each milestone? How do you know? Do you have the expertise to implement to each milestone? If not, where will you find it? Describe the ideal team to develop the product Why is that the ideal team?

48

Page 49: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

1. An Overview of Risk Mitigation and Value Creation for OTT Portfolio Management: Four Elements

2. The Role and Expectations of the Faculty Founder

3. Market, Technology and IP Assessment4. Corporate Structure and Management Team5. Approaching the Financial Community6. Summary and Conclusions

49

Page 50: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

Market

Intellectual Property

Technology

Business/Finance

50

Page 51: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

1/Risk

Val

ue

51

Page 52: Live Webinar March 28, 2013  – 877-729-0959

Utilize the public chat at the bottom left of your screen to submit your question. The panel will address them in the order they are

received.

Thank You!

52