History of European Ideas Official Journal of the International Society for the Study of European Ideas Sponsored by the European Cultural Foundation

_ ‘5

1 t Li!iiB .,

I

LIST OF CONTENTS AND AUTHOR INDEX FOR

VOLUME 6 (1985)

Pergamon Press

Oxford New York Beijing Frankfurt SBoPaulo Sydney Tokyo Toronto

Official Journal of the international Society for the Study of European Ideas

Sponsored by the European Cultural Foundation

Editor Associate Editor Ezra Talmor Sascha Talmor

Department of Philosophy, Haifa University, Mount Carmel, Haifa 31999, Israel

Board of Advisory Editors GUIDO ALMANSI, University ERICH HELLER, North- of East Anglia, England western Universrty. USA F.A.M. ALTING von GEUSAU, MARY HESSE, University Vice-President, European of Cambridge, England Cultural Foundation, JAMES JOLL, London Amsterdam School of Economics and MAX BELOFF, The University Political Science, College at Buckingham, England England EUGENE KAMENKA, JEAN-MARIE BENOTST, National University of College de France, France Australia, Australia LORD BRIGGS. University ABRAHAM KAPLAN, Haifa of Oxford, England University, Israel PETER BURKE, University PAUL OSKAR KRISTELLER, of Cambridge, England Columbia University, USA NOAM CHOMSKY, IRVING LAVIN, The

Massachusetts Institute of institute for Advanced Study, Technology, USA Princeton, USA MAURICE CRANSTON, HARRY LEVIN, Harvard London School of Economics University, USA and Political Science, England ROBERT MAUZI, Universite MARCEL DUBOIS, Hebrew de Paris-Sorbonne. France University, Jerusalem, Israel WOLFGANG J. MOMMSEN, PETER FRANCE, University German Historical Institute, of Edinburgh, Scotland England R. GEORIS, Secretary General, KOICHI OGAWA, Hokkaido

European Cultural Foundation, University, Japan Amsterdam J.G.A. POCOCK, The Johns DENYS HAY, University of Hopkins University. USA Edinburgh, Scotland

Publishing and Advertising Offices

RICHARD POPKIN, The Washlngton University in

St LOUIS. USA E. RAIMONDI, University of Bologna, Italy

PAUL RICOEUR, Universite de Paris-Sorbonne, France

DENIS de ROUGEMONT. Centre Europeen de la

Culture, Switzerland ERNST SCHULIN, Freiburg University, Federal

Republic of Germany CESARE SEGRE, lstituo dl Filologia Romanza, Italy JEAN STAROBINSKI,

Universrte de Geneve,

Switzerland PAUL VIALLANEIX, Universite de Clermont II, France

MICHEL VOVELLE, Universtte de Paris I, France HENRY WASSER.

City University of New York, USA

THEODORE ZELDIN, University of Oxford, England

CONTENTS - VOLUME 6

F. J. McLynn

G. A. J. Rogers

Jonathan Mendilow

Joan Todd and Joseph Cono

Reviews Madeleine V. Constable

Book Reviews Kenneth A. Lambert

Alice Browne

Ann Schofield 83

A. M. Suggate

Sheridan Gilley

Dominick Finello

George V. Strong

1

19

41

59

71

79

80

85

86

88

90

NUMBER 1

History and ideology The ideology of Jacobitism on the eve of the rising of 1745 - Part I

The basis of belief. Philosophy, science and religion in seventeenth-century England

Merrie England and the brave new world: two myths of the idea of empire

Vito and Collingwood on ‘tile conceit of scholars’

Guillaume Postel -Prophet of the Restitution of all Things -His Life and Thought by Marion L. Kuntz

Historical Explanation Reconsidered by Gordon Graham

Reason’s Disciples: Seventeenth-Century Eng- lish Feminists by Hilda L. Smith Feminism in Eighteenth-Century England by Katherine M. Rogers

Victorian Women: A Documentary Account of Women’s Lives in Nineteenth Century England, France and the United States, edited by Karen Olafson Hellerstein, Leslie Parker Hume and Karen M. Offen

William Temple: An Archbishop for all Seasons by Charles W. Lowry

The Nonconformist Conscience Chapel and Poli- tics, 187&7914 by D. W. Bebbington

The 1 yre and the Oaten Flute: Garcilaso and the Pastoral by Dario Fernandez-Morera

The Making of a New Europe. R. W. Seton- Watson and the Last Years of Austria-Hungary by H. Seton-Watson and C. Seton-Watson

iii

CONTENTS

G. W. F. Hegel - The Berlin Phenomenology edited and translated with introduction and explanatory notes by M. J. Petry

Kathleen Wright

Nancy N. Barker

John E. Weakland 96

Critical Note Marie Roberts

Announcements

Timothy Kenyon

Edmond D. Cocks

M. Glouberman

F. J. McLynn

Reviews John K. Graham

Ann Loades

Book Reviews Linda Kirk

Michael Maidan

91

94

95

99

101

i Editorial

105 Labour - natural, property - artificial: the radical insights of Gerrard Winstanley

129

153

173

189 History of utopia and the utopianism of history

201 The Philosophical Frontiers of Christian The- ology: Essays Presented to D. M. MacKinnon edited by Brian Hebblethwaite and Stewart Sutherland

207

208

209

Class, Ideology, and the Rights of Nobles during the French Revolution by Patrice Higonnet

Victims, Authority, and Terror: The Parallel Deaths of d’orleans, Custine, Bailly, and Malesherbes by George Armstrong Kelly

A Fourteenth-Century Scholar and Primate. Richard FitzRalph in Oxford, Avignon and Armagh by Katherine Walsh

‘Rosicrucianism or Cross-rosism’ in Hegel’s Phenomenolog y

NUMBER 2

Land’s end

Descartes’ proto-critique

The ideology of Jacobitism - Part II

From Paracelsus to Newton. Magic and the Making of Modern Science by Charles Webster

David Hume: Common-sense Moralist, Scep- tical Metaphysician by David Fate Norton

After Virtue: A Study in Moral Theory by Alasdair Maclntyre

iv

Marie Robeas 232

John W. Murphy 214

Susan Hardman 216

Gary W. Shanafelt 218

T. W, Heyck

Alice Browne

Christopher J. Berry

Critical Note Edward Gray

Ezra Taimor

279

220

222

225

231

233

CONTENTS

The Rhetoric of Criticism: From Hobbes to Coleridge by Sascha Talmor

Pragmatism and Sociology by Emiie Durkheim

Moderate Puritans and the Elizabethan Church by Peter Lake

Napoleon’s Great Adversaries, The Archduke Charles and the Austrian Army, 1792-t814 by Gunther E. Rothenberg

From Clergyman to Don: The Rise of the Academic Profession in Njneteenth-Center Oxford by A. J. Engei

Eve and the New .Jerusalem: Socialism and Feminism in the Nineteenth Century by Barbara Taylor

The Young Hegelians. An Anthology edited by Lawrence S. Stepelevich

The relevance of ‘Liberty’ in the Encyclop8die - past and present editions

Books Received

Cadmos, Nos. 28/29 (hiver 1984iprintemps 1985)

NUMBER 3

Europe in a Changing

235 Editorial

The Historical Context Peter Burke 237

Ernst Schulin 253

Victor G. Kiernan 267

Jaroslav Krejci 287

The Cultural Context Peter France 297

world

European views of world history from Giovio to Voltaire

European expansion in early modern times. Changing views on colonial history

Class and ideology: the bourgeoisie and its historians

From ideal types to multidimensional concepts: the concept of the ‘nation‘ in a changing Europe

Western European civilisation and its mountain frontiers (1750-1850)

V

Marion Leathers Kuntz

311 Postel and his idea of progress and Utopian reality

Madeleine V. Constable

325 Tradition and innovation: Venice from the post- Reformation to Napoleon

Veronique M. F&i 341 In the shadow of the immigrant’s dream

Reviews Jtirgen Georg Backhaus

349 On the migration of skills and ideas

Ezra Talmor 355 In praise of pluralism

Book Reviews Sheridan Gilley 359 The Face of the Past: The Preservation of the

Medieval Inheritance in Victorian England, Charles Dellheim

Christopher J. Berry

Donald Ft. Kelley

Ivan Strenski

F. J. McLynn 364

Charles B. Schmitt

Robert A. Dodgshon

Bob Scribner

Elfrieda Dubois 372

360

361

362

365

366

367

369

370

375

377

CONTENTS

Hegel: An Introduction, Second . Edition, Raymond Plant

Law and Revolution. The Formation of the Western Legal Tradition, Harold J. Berman

Ritual, Religion and the Sacred: Selections from the ‘Annales: Economies, Societes, Civilisa- tions: Volume 7, edited by Robert Forster and Orest Ranum

Henry Stubbe, Radical Protestantism and the Early Enlightenment, James R. Jacob

The Making of a Ruling Class. The Glamorgan Gentry 1640-1790, Philip Jenkins

Studies in Tudor and Stuart Politics and Govern- ment, G. R. Elton

Theophrastus redivivus, Edizione prima a cura di Guido Canziani e Gianni Paganini

The Historical Geography of Scotland since 1707, D. Turnock

Kultur der einfachen Leute. Bayerisches Volks- leben von 16. biszum 79. Jahrhundert, edited by Richard van Dulmen

La Regle de perfection. The Rule of Perfection, Benoit de Canfield

Announcements

Books Received

vi

CONTENTS

NUMBER 4

SPECIAL ISSUE

Europe and its Encounter with the Amerindians

Dario Fernandez- Morera

Humberto E. Robles

Cornelius J. Jaenen

Sabine MacCormack 421

Rolena Adorn0

James Lockhart

Reviews Benjamin C. Sax

Book Reviews John E. Weakland

i

iii

379

385

405

447

465

483

487

488

491

493

Editorial - international Society for the Study of European Ideas (ISSEI)

The Maxwell Prizes in European intellectual history

Europe and its encounter with the Amerindians: an introduction

The first voyage around the world: from Pigafetta to Garcia Marquez

France’s America and Amerindians: image and reality

The fall of the Incas: a historiographical dilemma

The rhetoric of resistance: the ‘talking’ book of Felipe Guaman Poma

Some Nahua concepts in postconquest guise

Marxism and history: the current debate

The Murdered Magicians. The Templars and Their Myth, Peter Partner

ii sovrano pontefice, Paolo Prodi

Books Received

Announcements

List of contents and author index for Volume 6, 1985

vii

AdOrno, R. 447

Backhau&, J.G. 344 Barker, k.N. 44, 95 fjerry, C.3. 222, ml browne, A. 80, 22U Llurke, P. 237

Cocks, E.D. i29 Cono, J. 59 Coustable, M.V. 71, 325

Dodgshon, R.A. 3b9 Dubois, E. 372

Fernanaez-horera, D. 379 E‘inelio, D. && P&i, V.M. 341 France, P. 297

Gilley, S. 86, 359 Glouberman, Pi. 153 Graham, J.K. 189 tiray, 8, 225

Hardman, S, 216 Heyck, T.W. 219

Jaenen, C.J. 405

Keiley, D.&. 361 henyon, ‘I. 103 Uernan, V.G. 267

kirk, L. 2U7, 2Ub kreJci, J. 287 kuntz, M.L. 3il

Lambert, K.A. 74 Loaves, A. 201 Lockhart, J. 465

k&cGormack, 5. 421 kdiau, M. 2u4

kc~ynn, F.J. 1, 173, 364, 365, 366 kendilow, J. 41 hurphy, J.W. 214

Roberts, k. 99, 212 Robles, H.E. 365 Rogers, G.A.J. 14

Sax, B.C. 463 Schmitt, C.B. 367 Schorield, A. 83 Schulin, E. 253 Scribner, b. 37u Shanakelt, G.W. 218 Strenski, I. 362 Strong, G.V. 40 Suggate, A.N. 8s

lalmor, L. 235, 355 Toad, J. 54

Weakiand, J.L. Yb, 487 Wright, K. 4i

ix