Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Reply to Reeds Opp to Plffs Obj MTS Doc 525
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-reply-to-reeds-opp-to-plffs-obj-mts-doc-525 1/18
`
XGFDB AN CAIXBIXS
Zgebs
XGFDB AN CAIXBIXS………………………………………………………)))))))`
XGFDB AN GRXMAV@X@BS…))……………………………………………))))))``+```
@@) ZDG@IX@NNS GVB BIX@XDBH XA AFOBCX GIH
VBWRBSX XMB SXV@L@IE AN @IGHK@SSGFDB
B^@HBICB………………………………………………………………))3+=
@@@) ZDG@IX@NNS ZVAZBVDP ZVAZARHBH H@SCA^BVPai xmb VBBH HBNBIHGIXS OGI) 73$ 6:76…………………………)))=+7:
@ )̂ IB@D SGILBP‐S HBCDGVGX@AI$ GIH
B]M@F@XS —G‛ GIH —F‛…………………………………………)…))7:+73
^) CAICDRS@AI……$……………………………………………)))………)73
@) SXGXBKBIX AN NGCXS ………………………………………………)7+3
Cgsb =?77+c~+::8=2+GE+GOU Hacrkbix 262+7 N`dbh :2!77!76 Zgeb 7 an 3 Zgeb @H#?730>3
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Reply to Reeds Opp to Plffs Obj MTS Doc 525
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-reply-to-reeds-opp-to-plffs-obj-mts-doc-525 2/18
``
XGFDB AN GRXMAV@X@BS
Cgsbs Zgeb-s)
Fbpbib ~) Cadbkgi Sbcrv`xp Sbv~s$ @ic$=28 N6h 775:$ 77=6 -0xm C`v 70==)………………………………………………76
Fdg`v Naahs$ @ic) ~) Vgicmbvs Caxxai A`d $
>7: N 6h >>2$ >>5 -0xm C`v 70=:)………………………………………………76
Cgkfv`heb Bdbcxvai`cs Cavz) ~) KEG Bdbcxvai`cs$ @ic$665 NVH 373$ 367 -CH Cgd 6::8)……………………………………………5
Avv ~) Fgil an Gkbv`cg$ IX . SG$
6=2 N3h 5>2$ 55=+550 -0xm C`v 6::6)…………………………………………76
Avx`+Dazb ~) Sac`bhgh Bszgiadg hb Gr}`d`a Krxra p
Sbdn+@is) @isx) an Gkbv`cg$ @ic) ~) Sanxugvb gih @ina)@ihrs) Gss%i)$
Pbx` fp Kaddp$ Dxh) ~) Hbclbvs Arxhaav Cavz$
620 N3h 77:7$ 77:5 -0xm C`v 6::7)…………………………………………3$ 5$ =
NBHBVGD VRDBS AN C@^@D ZVACBHRVB
Zgeb-s)
Vrdb 6>-g)-7)-H)……………………………………………………………………2
Vrdb 6>-g)-7)………………………………………………………………………0
Vrdb 6>-b)-7)………………………………………………………………………5
Vrdb 38……………………………………………………………………………0
Fbibn`c`bic`g hb Zrbvxa V`ca$ 68= N3h 60$ 32 -7sx C`v 6::7)……………………=
6:= NSrzz6h 7:2=$ 7:>> -CH Cgd 6:::)……………………………………5
Xavvbs ~) C`xp an D)G)$ 28= N3h 7705$ 7676+73 -0xm C`v 6::=)…………………3
Cgsb =?77+c~+::8=2+GE+GOU Hacrkbix 262+7 N`dbh :2!77!76 Zgeb 6 an 3 Zgeb @H#?730>8
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Reply to Reeds Opp to Plffs Obj MTS Doc 525
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-reply-to-reeds-opp-to-plffs-obj-mts-doc-525 3/18
```
XGFDB AN GRXMAV@X@BS – Caix`irbh
NBHBVGD VRDBS AN C@^@D ZVACBHRVB
Zgeb-s)
Vrdb 35………………………………………………………………………8$ 5$ =
NBHBVGD VRDBS AN B^@HBICB
Zgeb-s)
Vrdb 35-c)-7)…………………………………………………………………3$ 8$ 5
Vrdb 2>-c)-6)………………………………………………………………………3
Nbh) V) B~`h) ¥0:7-g)73
Nbh) V) B~`h) ¥=:7-c)73
Nbh) V) B~`h) ¥>:6………………………………………………………………73
Nbh) V) B~`h) ¥=:673
Cgsb =?77+c~+::8=2+GE+GOU Hacrkbix 262+7 N`dbh :2!77!76 Zgeb 3 an 3 Zgeb @H#?730>2
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Reply to Reeds Opp to Plffs Obj MTS Doc 525
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-reply-to-reeds-opp-to-plffs-obj-mts-doc-525 4/18
D`fbv`$ bx gd$ Zdg`ix`nns Vbzdp `i srzzavx an xmb`v Afobcx`ais gih Vbwrbsx xa Sxv`lb 7
7
6
3
8
2
>
5
=
0
7:
77
76
73
78
72
7>
75
7=
70
6:
67
66
63
68
62
6>
65
6=
Zm`d`z O Fbve$ Bswr`vb -ZG @H 0=>5)B+kg`d? zm`dofbveJekg`dcak
DGU ANN@CBS AN ZM@D@Z O FBVE
222 Gihavvg Edbi Carvx$ Sr`xb 76Dgngpbxxb M`dd$ ZG 70888+6237
Xbdbzmaib? ->7:) =62+3738 Ng}? ->7:) =38+5>20
Gxxavibp nav Zdg`ix`nns
RI@XBH SXGXBS H@SXV@CX CARVX
NAV XMB CBIXVGD H@SXV@CX AN CGD@NAVI@G$
SARXMBVI H@^@S@AI
D@SG D@FBV@$ bx gd$
Zdg`ix`nns$
~s
AVDP XG@X_$ bx gd$
Hbnbihgixs
?
??????????????
?????????
C@^@D GCX@AI IRKFBV?=?77+c~+::8=2+GE -GOU)
ZDG@IX@NNS VBZDP XA XMB
VBBH HBNBIHGIXS
AZZAS@X@AI XA ZDG@IX@NNS
AFOBCX@AIS GIH VBWRBSX XA
SXV@LB XMB HBCDGVGX@AIS AN
D@SG S@KKAIS GIH XMB
GXXGCMBH B]M@F@XS< D@SG
ZAD@CGSXVA< GIH ZAVX@AISAN IB@D SGILBP‐S
HBCDGVGX@AIS GIH GDD
GCCAKZGIP@IE B]M@F@XS
XMBVBXA
Hgxb an Mbgv`ie? Kgp 67$ 6:76X`kb an Mbgv`ie? 7:?:: gk
Dacgx`ai? Carvxvaak 7:H
@ SXGXBKBIX AN NGCXS?
Ai Gzv`d 8$ 6:76$ Vbbh Bdsb~`bv$ @ic$ Db}`sIb}`s V`sl gih @inavkgx`ai
Gigdpx`cs Evarz$ @ic$ Cma`cbZa`ix$ @ic$ Db}`sIb}`s$ Db}`sIb}`s Evarz
?
?
Cgsb =?77+c~+::8=2+GE+GOU Hacrkbix 262 N`dbh :2!77!76 Zgeb 7 an 73 Zgeb @H#?7302:
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Reply to Reeds Opp to Plffs Obj MTS Doc 525
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-reply-to-reeds-opp-to-plffs-obj-mts-doc-525 5/18
D`fbv`$ bx gd$ Zdg`ix`nns Vbzdp `i srzzavx an xmb`v Afobcx`ais gih Vbwrbsx xa Sxv`lb 6
7
6
3
8
2
>
5
=
0
7:
77
76
73
78
72
7>
75
7=
70
6:
67
66
63
68
62
6>
65
6=
Db}`sIb}`s V`sl Sadrx`ais$ @ic$ gih Sb`s`ix$ @ic h!f!g Gccrv`ix \—Vbbh
Hbnbihgixs‛[ n`dbh xmb`v Kax`ai nav Srkkgvp Orhekbix$ sbb Haclbx Irkfbv
\—HI‛[ 807 gih xmb Hbcdgvgx`ai an D`sg S`kkais u`xm xmvbb B}m`f`xs$ sbb HI 806<
xmb Hbcdgvgx`ai an D`sg Zad`cgsxva$ sbb HI 803 gih xmb Hbcdgvgx`ai an Ib`d Sgilbp
u`xm xua \6[ B}m`f`xs$ sbb HI 808+7
Ai Gzv`d 6:$ 6:76$ Zdg`ix`nns vbszaihbh `i Azzas`x`ai xa xmb Vbbh
Hbnbihgixs Kax`ai nav Srkkgvp Orhekbix< H`szrxbh Ngcxs< gih Afobcx`ais gih
Vbwrbsx xa Sxv`lb xmb Hbcdgvgx`ais an D`sg S`kkais gih B}m`f`xs —G‛ xmvarem —C‛<
D`sg Zad`cgsxva< gih zavx`ais an Ib`d Sgilbp‐s Hbcdgvgx`ai gih B}m`f`xs —G‛ gih
—F‛ gxxgcmbh xmbvbxa
Xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs n`dbh gi azzas`x`ai cdg`k`ie xmbp uavlbh bihdbssdp
u`xm Zdg`ix`nns vbegvh`ie h`sca~bvp h`szrxbs gih xmb Zdg`ix`nns vbnrsbh xa cakzdp
gih uavl u`xm xmbk \Vbbh Azz zz 7+6$ ¾@[ Xm`s `s cakzdbxbdp rixvrb$ sbb xmb
Hbcdgvgx`ai an Zm`d̀ z O Fbve$ Bswr`vb n`dbh caicrvvbixdp mbvbu`xm \—Fbve Hbcd‛[ gx
zz 7+62$ B}fs —7 xmvarem —>8‛$ zz 6>+86:
Xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs cdg`k xmgx Zdg`ix`nns h`h iax kbbx gih cainbv zv`av xa
n`d`ie xmb`v Afobcx`ais gih Vbwrbsx xa Sxv`lb Maub~bv$ Zdg`ix`nns ubvb iax
vbwr`vbh xa ha sa Vbegvhdbss$ Zdg`ix`nns mgh sbix irkbvars dbxxbvs xa xmb Vbbh
Hbnbihgixs gih caihrcxbh g kbbx gih cainbv vbegvh`ie xmb h`sca~bvp h`szrxbs
@isxbgh an cakzdp`ie u`xm h`sca~bvp$ xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs n`dbh xmb`v Kax`ai nav
Cgsb =?77+c~+::8=2+GE+GOU Hacrkbix 262 N`dbh :2!77!76 Zgeb 6 an 73 Zgeb @H#?73027
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Reply to Reeds Opp to Plffs Obj MTS Doc 525
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-reply-to-reeds-opp-to-plffs-obj-mts-doc-525 6/18
D`fbv`$ bx gd$ Zdg`ix`nns Vbzdp `i srzzavx an xmb`v Afobcx`ais gih Vbwrbsx xa Sxv`lb 3
7
6
3
8
2
>
5
=
0
7:
77
76
73
78
72
7>
75
7=
70
6:
67
66
63
68
62
6>
65
6=
B}fs —75‛+—67‛$ zz 78=+720< B}fs —60‛+—3:‛$ zz 6:5+672< B}f —36‛$ zz 670+
666< B}fs —3>‛+—35‛$ zz 633+63>< B}fs —8:‛+—83‛$ zz 653+6=8< gih B}f —25‛
z 3==
@isxbgh an ghhvbss`ie xmb srfsxgix`~b `ssrbs arxd`ibh `i Zdg`ix`nns Afobcx`ais
gih Vbwrbsx xa Sxv`lb$ xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs d`x`egxb xmb afobcx`ais gs g Kax`ai xa
Cakzbd G Kax`ai xa Cakzbd `s iax fbnavb xm`s Carvx$ gs xmb Carvx mgs iax
evgixbh Zdg`ix`nns dbg~b xa n`db xmb`v Kax`ai xa Cakzbd xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs gs an
xm`s hgxb$ gih xmbvbnavb xmb Zdg`ix`nns mg~b iax fbbi gnnavhbh xmb azzavxri`xp xa n`db
sg`h Kax`ai
@@ ZDG@IX@NNS GVB BIX@XDBH XA AFOBCX GIH VBWRBSX
XMB SXV@L@IE AN @IGHK@SSGFDB B^@HBICB
Nbhbvgd Vrdbs an C`~`d Zvacbhrvb \— Nbh V C`~ Z‛[ 2>-c)-6) sxgxbs `i
zbvx`ibix zgvx?
—Afobcx`ai Xmgx g Ngcx @s Iax Srzzavxbh fp Ghk`ss`fdb B~`hbicb G zgvxp kgp afobcx xmgx xmb kgxbv`gd c`xbh xa srzzavx av h`szrxb g ngcx
cgiiax fb zvbsbixbh `i g navk xmgx uardh fb ghk`ss`fdb `i b~`hbicb‛
Vrdb 35 —e`~bs xbbxm‛ xa Vrdb 6>‐s h`scdasrvb vbwr`vbkbixs fp navf`hh`ie xmb
rsb gx g mbgv`ie av xv`gd an gip ̀ inavkgx`ai xmgx ̀ s iax zvazbvdp h`scdasbh Xavvbs ~
C`xp an DG$ 28= N3h 7705$ 7676+73 -0xm
C`v 6::=) -c`x`ie Pbx` fp Kaddp$ Dxh ~
Hbclbvs Arxhaav Cavz$ 620 N3h 77:7$ 77:> -0xm C`v 6::7)) Vrdb 35-c)-7) `s g
Srkkgvp Orhekbix Fbve Hbcd gx zz 2+75$ 67 $ ¾¾ 0$ 77+76$ 78+70$ 63+62< 60 +
36$ 88$ B}f —3‛$ zz >:+>3< B}fs —>+=‛$ zz 5:+=3< B}f —73‛$ zz 767+76><
Cgsb =?77+c~+::8=2+GE+GOU Hacrkbix 262 N`dbh :2!77!76 Zgeb 3 an 73 Zgeb @H#?73026
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Reply to Reeds Opp to Plffs Obj MTS Doc 525
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-reply-to-reeds-opp-to-plffs-obj-mts-doc-525 7/18
D`fbv`$ bx gd$ Zdg`ix`nns Vbzdp `i srzzavx an xmb`v Afobcx`ais gih Vbwrbsx xa Sxv`lb 8
7
6
3
8
2
>
5
=
0
7:
77
76
73
78
72
7>
75
7=
70
6:
67
66
63
68
62
6>
65
6=
—sbdn+b}bcrx`ie$‛ —grxakgx`c‛ sgicx`ai hbs`eibh xa zva~`hb g sxvaie `ihrcbkbix nav
h`scdasrvb @h -wrax`ie Nbh V C`~ Z 35 gh~`savp cakk`xxbb‐s iaxb -7003)) Xmb
aidp b}cbzx`ais xa Vrdb 35-c)-7)‐s b}cdrs`ai sgicx`ai gzzdp `n xmb ng`drvb xa
h`scdasb `s srfsxgix`gddp orsx`n`bh av mgvkdbss Nbh V C`~ Z 35-c)-7)
Zdg`ix`nns kbx gih cainbvvbh u`xm K`cmgbd F K`ddbv$ Bswr`vb gih @vbib
Zbvxsa~slp ai Gzv`d 8$ 6:76 a~bv xmb h`sca~bvp `ssrbs$ frx caixvgvp xa Kv K`ddbv‐s
—20‛ –—>6‛$ zz 302+87:
Gxxgcmbh xa xmb Hbcdgvgx`ai an K`cmgbd F K`ddbv$ Bswr`vb `s Gccrv`ix‐s
vbszaisbs xa Zdg`ix`nns @ixbvvaegxav`bs Gccrv`ix vbszaisb xa @ixbvvaegxav`bs —7‛
gih —6‛ vbegvh`ie `ih`~`hrgds xmgx kgp mg~b h`sca~bvgfdb `inavkgx`ai aidp vbnbv xa
Lb~`i Nadbdp$ Obii`nbv Orie gih D`ihg Cdgvl Xmbvb `s gfsadrxbdp ia kbix`ai an
D`sg S`kkais$ B}m`f`xs —G‛$ —F‛$ —C‛ gxxgcmbh xa D`sg S`kkais Hbcdgvgx`ai av
D`sg Zad`cgsxva$ gih ia hacrkbixs ubvb zva~`hbh `i vbszaisb xa Zdg`ix`nns Vbwrbsx
nav Zvahrcx`ai an Hacrkbixs Xmb fgdgicb an xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs h`h iax vbszaih
av gisubv aib @ixbvvaegxavp$ Ghk`ss`ai av Vbwrbsx nav Zvahrcx`ai an Hacrkbixs
gih `isxbgh gssbvxbh fa`dbvzdgxb afobcx`ais
D`lbu`sb$ `i xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs @i`x`gd H`scdasrvbs$ xmb aidp `ih`~`hrgds
igkbh ubvb geg`i Lb~`i Nadbp$ Obii`nbv Orie$ gih D`ihg Cdgvl Xmb Vbbh
Hbnbihgixs h`h iax h`scdasb D`sg S`kkais$ B}m`f`xs —G‛$ —F‛$ —C‛ gxxgcmbh xa
sxgxbkbix$ ia gevbbkbix ugs kbx$ sbb Fbve‐s Hbcd gx zz 66+68$ ¾¾85+2:$ B}fs
Cgsb =?77+c~+::8=2+GE+GOU Hacrkbix 262 N`dbh :2!77!76 Zgeb 8 an 73 Zgeb @H#?73023
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Reply to Reeds Opp to Plffs Obj MTS Doc 525
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-reply-to-reeds-opp-to-plffs-obj-mts-doc-525 8/18
D`fbv`$ bx gd$ Zdg`ix`nns Vbzdp `i srzzavx an xmb`v Afobcx`ais gih Vbwrbsx xa Sxv`lb 2
7
6
3
8
2
>
5
=
0
7:
77
76
73
78
72
7>
75
7=
70
6:
67
66
63
68
62
6>
65
6=
D`sg S`kkais Hbcdgvgx`ai av D`sg Zad`cgsxva Xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs gverkbixs
vbegvh`ie xmb Vrdb 6>-n) cainbvbicb ng`d Fbcgrsb xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs ubvb
oa`ibh `i xm`s sr`x gnxbv xmb Vrdb 6> Scmbhrd`ie avhbv$ xmbp ubvb xa zvahrcb xmb`v
@i`x`gd H`scdasrvbs u`xm`i xm`vxp \3:[ hgps an fb`ie sbv~bh$ sbb Nbh V C`~ Z
6>-g)-7)-H)
Gx ia x`kb$ h`h xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs xglb xmb vbwr`vbh sxbzs xa srzzdbkbix
xmb`v vbszaisbs xa xmb`v @i`x`gd H`scdasrvbs av xmb`v H`sca~bvp vbszaisbs xa `icdrhb
xmb igkbs D`sg S`kkais av gip an xmb hacrkbixs gxxgcmbh xa Ks S`kkais
Hbcdgvgx`ai av D`sg Zad`cgsxva gs u`xibssbs$ av h`sca~bvgfdb `inavkgx`ai @i ngcx
B}m`f`x —G‛ xa D`sg S`kkais Hbcdgvgx`ai `s Xahh Sgilbp gih xmb Sgilbp N`vk$
@ic‐s gzzd`cgx`ai u`xm @VFSbgvcm$ DDC Ai zgeb 8$ Gvx`cdb —N‛ `x sxgxbs —Cbvxg`i
rsbvs -—Grxmav`bh Rsbvs‛) kgp fb gfdb xa afxg`i nrdd -i`ib h`e`x) sac`gd sbcrv`xp
irkfbvs gih v`~bvs d`cbisb irkfbvs umbi gzzvazv`gxb -—SSI‛) xmvarem sakb
@VFSbgvcm Sbv~`cbs Aidp xmasb rsbvs xmgx gvb u`xm`i xmb Grxmav`bh Rsbv d`s
fbdau$ gih xmgx rsb SSI‐s nav gi Grxmav`bh Rsb `hbix`n`bh fbdau$ wrgd`np gs
Grxmav`bh rsbvs Xa wrgd`np gs gi Grxmav`bh Rsbv$ Crsxakbv krsx `hbix`np gih
cbvx`np xmgx `xs frs`ibss `s u`xm`i xmb Grxmav`bh Rsbv D`sx fbdau gih `xs rsb an
SSI‐s `s u`xm`i xmb Grxmav`bh Rsbv D`sx Fbdau‛ Xahh Sgilbp kgvlbh —axmbv
zrfd`c av zv`~gxb bix`xp nav xmb zrvzasb an hbxbcx`ie$ `i~bsx`egx`ie av zvb~bix`ie
nvgrh – Ub gvb Dbegd @i~bsx`egxavs nav Gxxavibps . @isrvgicb Cakzgi`bs `i C`~`
Cgsb =?77+c~+::8=2+GE+GOU Hacrkbix 262 N`dbh :2!77!76 Zgeb 2 an 73 Zgeb @H#?73028
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Reply to Reeds Opp to Plffs Obj MTS Doc 525
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-reply-to-reeds-opp-to-plffs-obj-mts-doc-525 9/18
D`fbv`$ bx gd$ Zdg`ix`nns Vbzdp `i srzzavx an xmb`v Afobcx`ais gih Vbwrbsx xa Sxv`lb >
7
6
3
8
2
>
5
=
0
7:
77
76
73
78
72
7>
75
7=
70
6:
67
66
63
68
62
6>
65
6=
D`x`egx`ai kgxxbvs –cv`k`igd ‛$ um`cm wrgd`n`bh xmb Sgilbp‐s xa afxg`i nrdd Sac`gd
Sbcrv`xp irkfbvs$ caixvgvp xa xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs cdg`ks
Xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs cdg`k xmbp h`h iax xrvi a~bv gip an xmb vbwrbsxbh
hacrkbixs fbcgrsb g Zvaxbcx`~b Avhbv ugs iax `i zdgcb Xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs
iau cdg`k xmgx `x ugs Zdg`ix`nns vbszais`f`d`xp xa n`db xmb Zvaxbcx`~b Avhbv fb`ie
saremx fp xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs Xm`s `s drh`cvars Xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs sbix g
hvgnx an xmb`v zvazasbh Zvaxbcx`~b Avhbv ai Nbfvrgvp 3$ 6:76 Kv Fbve gzzva~bh
xm`s hvgnx Gnxbv x̀ kb mgh eaib fp$ ai Nbfvrgvp 66$ 6:76 Kv Fbve uvaxb xa xmb
Vbbh Hbnbihgixs gsl`ie nav g sxgxrs an xmb Zvaxbcx`~b Avhbv Xmb zvaxbcx`~b avhbv
ugs ib~bv n`dbh fp xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs K`cmgbd F K`ddbv Vbszaihbh ai Kgvcm
8$ 6:76 sbih`ie g sbcaih cazp an xmb zvazasbh zvaxbcx`~b avhbv xa Kv Fbve gih
gxxavibps nav gdd hbnbihgixs vbwrbsx`ie b~bvpaib xa vb~`bu `x$ dbx m`k -Kv K`ddbv)
liau an gip cmgiebs gih `n gdd zgvx`bs ubvb `i gevbbkbix Kv Fbve geg`i uvaxb
fgcl ai Kgvcm 8$ 6:76 e`~`ie m`s grxmav`gx`ai xa `izrx m`s bdbcxvai`c s`eigxrvb
xmgx mb h`h iax h`sgevbb u`xm xmb caixbixs an xmb zvazasbh zvaxbcx`~b avhbv av u`xm
Vbbh‐s Vbwrbsx Kv Fbve vbcb`~bh giaxmbv Bkg`d nvak Kv K`ddbv sxgx`ie mb mgh
vbcb`~bh vbszaisbs gih gevbbkbixs xa sx`zrdgxb nvak Kv Fbve gih Kv Cadbi$
Carisbd nav xmb Sgilbp Hbnbihgixs$ frx ugs gug`x`ie vbszaisbs nvak Avdp Xg`x
gih mbv gxxavibp Obnnvbp Crii`iemgk Kv K`ddbv ugs gsl`ie Ks Xg`x gih Kv
Crii`iemgk xa zdbgsb cakzdp u`xm m`s vbwrbsx Xa hgxb$ xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs
Cgsb =?77+c~+::8=2+GE+GOU Hacrkbix 262 N`dbh :2!77!76 Zgeb > an 73 Zgeb @H#?73022
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Reply to Reeds Opp to Plffs Obj MTS Doc 525
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-reply-to-reeds-opp-to-plffs-obj-mts-doc-525 10/18
D`fbv`$ bx gd$ Zdg`ix`nns Vbzdp `i srzzavx an xmb`v Afobcx`ais gih Vbwrbsx xa Sxv`lb 5
7
6
3
8
2
>
5
=
0
7:
77
76
73
78
72
7>
75
7=
70
6:
67
66
63
68
62
6>
65
6=
ib~bv n`dbh xmb`v vbwrbsx nav xmb Zvaxbcx`~b Avhbv Gx ia x`kb$ hrv`ie h`scrss`ais
u`xm Kv K`ddbv$ h`h Kv K`ddbv b~bv gsl Kv Fbve av sxgxb `x ugs Kv Fbve‐s
vbszais`f`d`xp xa n`db nav g zvaxbcx`~b avhbv ai fbmgdn an xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs Iav
uardh Kv Fbve mg~b gevbbh xa srcm
622+656< gih B}fs —88‛+—8>‛$ zz 6=2+386
Rihbv Vrdb 35-c)-7) an xmb Nbhbvgd Vrdbs an C`~`d Zvacbhrvb$ g zgvxp `s
ebibvgddp zvbcdrhbh nvak rs`ie b~`hbicb iax h`scdasbh gs vbwr`vbh rihbv Vrdb
6>-b)-7)7 Sbb Cgkfv`heb Bdbcxvai`cs Cavz ~ KEG Bdbcxvai`cs$ @ic 665 NVH
373$ 367 -CH Cgd 6::8)< Sbdn+@is @isx an Gkbv`cg$ @ic ~ Sanxugvb gih @ina
@ihrs Gss%i$ 6:= NSrzz6h 7:2=$ 7:>> -CH Cgd 6:::) Vrdb 35 zva~`hbs xmgx
—\`[n g zgvxp ng`ds xa zva~`hb `inavkgx̀ ai av `hbix̀ np g u`xibss gs vbwr`vbh fp
Vrdb 6>-g) av -b)$ xmb zgvxp `s iax gddaubh xa rsb xmgx `inavkgx`ai av u`xibss xa
srzzdp b~`hbicb ai g kax`ai$ gx g mbgv`ie$ av gx xv`gd$ ridbss xmb ng`drvb ugs
srfsxgix`gddp orsx`n`bh av mgvkdbss‛ Nbh V C`~ Z 35-c)-7) Xmb frvhbi an
hbkaisxvgx`ie xmgx xmb ng`drvb `s srfsxgix`gddp orsx`n`bh av mgvkdbss ngdds ai xmb
annbih`ie zgvxp Sbb Pbx` fp Kaddp$ Dxh ~ Hbclbvs Arxhaav Cavz 620 N3h 77:7
77:5 -0xm C`v 6::7)
7 Vrdb 6>-b)-7) an xmb Nbhbvgd Vrdbs an C`~`d Zvacbhrvb zva~`hbs xmgx d`x`egixs mg~b g caix`ir`ie
hrxp xa srzzdbkbix av cavvbcx gdd `ixbvvaegxavp vbszaisbs gih vbwrbsxs nav zvahrcx`ai `n xmb`v zv`av
vbszaisbs gvb b`xmbv `icakzdbxb av `icavvbcx Nbh V C`~ Z 6>-b)-7)< sbb gdsa Cgkfv`heb
Bdbcxvai`cs Cavz$ 665 NVH gx 367
3:$ 38+3>$ B}f —63‛$ zz 752+703< B}fs —3:‛+—32‛$ zz 677+636< B}f —30‛$ zz
Sbb Fbve Hbcd gx zz 0+78$ 75+7=$ ¾¾ 67$ 68+
Cgsb =?77+c~+::8=2+GE+GOU Hacrkbix 262 N`dbh :2!77!76 Zgeb 5 an 73 Zgeb @H#?7302>
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Reply to Reeds Opp to Plffs Obj MTS Doc 525
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-reply-to-reeds-opp-to-plffs-obj-mts-doc-525 11/18
D`fbv`$ bx gd$ Zdg`ix`nns Vbzdp `i srzzavx an xmb`v Afobcx`ais gih Vbwrbsx xa Sxv`lb =
7
6
3
8
2
>
5
=
0
7:
77
76
73
78
72
7>
75
7=
70
6:
67
66
63
68
62
6>
65
6=
Gs iaxbh fp xmb I`ixm C`vcr`x `i Pbx`$ Vrdb 35 `s `ixbihbh xa zva~`hb g sxvaie
`ihrcbkbix nav h`scdasrvb$ gih g —sbdn+b}bcrx`ie‛ gih —grxakgx`c‛ sgicx`ai nav xmb
ng`drvb xa zvahrcb kgxbv`gd hrv`ie xmb h`sca~bvp zvacbss @h gx 77:> -c`x`ie Nbh V
C`~ Z 35 gh~`savp cakk`xxbb%s iaxb -7003) gih iax`ie —zgvx`crdgvdp u`hb dgx̀ xrhb‛
e`~bi xa h`sxv`cx carvxs xa b}cdrhb b~`hbicb rihbv xm`s zva~`s`ai) —Carvxs mg~b
rzmbdh xmb sxv`l`ie an srcm b~`hbicb b~bi umbi xmb d`x`egix‐s bix`vb cgrsb an gcx`ai
av hbnbisb mgs fbbi zvbcdrhbh‛ @h -c`x`ie Avx`+Dazb ~ Sac`bhgh Bszgiadg hb
Gr}`d`a Krxra p Fbibn`c`bic`g hb Zrbvxa V`ca$ 68= N3h 60$ 32 -7sx C`v 6::7))
Iav `s `x ibcbssgvp xa smau u`ddnrd `ixbix ai xmb zgvx an xmb annbih`ie zgvxp
b}cdrs`ai `s gi gzzvazv`gxb vbkbhp `i xmb gfsbicb an fgh ng`xm av gi b}zd`c`x carvx
avhbv Sbb Pbx`$ 620 N3h gx 77:>
@i gccavhgicb u`xm xmb Carvx‐s scmbhrd`ie avhbv `ssrbh `i Orib 6:77$ ai
Ogirgvp 73$ 6:76$ Zdg`ix`nns sbv~bh h`sca~bvp fp ugp an @ixbvvaegxav`bs$ Vbwrbsx
nav Zvahrcx`ai an Hacrkbixs gih Vbwrbsx nav Ghk`ss`ais$ ai bgcm an xmb Vbbh
Hbnbihgixs$ um`cm ugs smavxdp gnxbv xmb vrd`ie ai xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs Kax`ai xa
H`sk`ss Vbszaisbs ubvb hrb fp xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs ai av fbnavb Nbfvrgvp 6:
6:76 Xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs ubvb sbv~bh u`xm xmb Carvx‐s scmbhrd`ie avhbv u`xm
Zdg`ix`nns N`vsx Gkbihbh Cakzdg`ix Nrvxmbvkavb$ xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs ubvb
hrxp xa srzzdbkbix av cavvbcx gdd `ixbvvaegxavp vbszaisbs gih vbwrbsxs nav zvahrcx`ai `n xmb`v zv`av
VBBH HBNBIHGIXS OGI 73$ 6:76?
@@@) ZDG@IX@NNS ZVAZBVDP ZVAZARHBH H@SCA^BVP ai xmb
Cgsb =?77+c~+::8=2+GE+GOU Hacrkbix 262 N`dbh :2!77!76 Zgeb = an 73 Zgeb @H#?73025
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Reply to Reeds Opp to Plffs Obj MTS Doc 525
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-reply-to-reeds-opp-to-plffs-obj-mts-doc-525 12/18
D`fbv`$ bx gd$ Zdg`ix`nns Vbzdp `i srzzavx an xmb`v Afobcx`ais gih Vbwrbsx xa Sxv`lb 0
7
6
3
8
2
>
5
=
0
7:
77
76
73
78
72
7>
75
7=
70
6:
67
66
63
68
62
6>
65
6=
zvbsbix gx xmb mbgv`ie nav xmb`v gih @ixbd`rs$ @ic‐s Kax`ai xa H`sk`ss$ umbi
@ixbd`rs$ @ic gslbh nav g sxgp an H`sca~bvp gih xm`s Carvx hbi`bh @ixbd`rs‐ vbwrbsx
Gx ia x`kb$ h`h xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs vg`sb xmb `ssrb vbegvh`ie g Vrdb 6>-n)
cainbvbicb @x ugs iax rix`d xmb hgp xmb @i`x`gd h`scdasrvbs ubvb hrb$ Ogirgvp 7:$
6:76$ xmgx xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs fbegi hbkgih`ie g Vrdb 6>-n) cainbvbicb
@i ngcx$ Vrdb 6>-g)-7) sxgxbs?
-G) @i Ebibvgd B}cbzx gs b}bkzxbh fp Vrdb 6>-g)-7)-F) av gsaxmbvu`sb sx`zrdgxbh av avhbvbh fp xmb carvx$ g zgvxp krsx$
u`xmarx gug`x`ie g h`sca~bvp vbwrbsx$ zva~`hb xa xmb axmbv zgvx`bs?
-`) xmb igkb gih$ `n liaui$ xmb ghhvbss gih xbdbzmaib irkfbv an
bgcm `ih`~`hrgd d`lbdp xa mg~b h`sca~bvgfdb `inavkgx`ai‘gdaieu`xm xmb srfobcxs an xmgx `inavkgx`ai‘xmgx xmb h`scdas`ie zgvxp
kgp rsb xa srzzavx `xs cdg`ks av hbnbisbs$ ridbss xmb rsb uardh fb sadbdp nav `kzbgcmkbix<
-``) g cazp‘av g hbscv`zx`ai fp cgxbeavp gih dacgx`ai‘an gdd
hacrkbixs$ bdbcxvai`cgddp sxavbh `inavkgx`ai$ gih xgie`fdbxm`ies xmgx xmb h`scdas`ie zgvxp mgs `i `xs zassbss`ai$ crsxahp$ av
caixvad gih kgp rsb xa srzzavx `xs cdg`ks av hbnbisbs$ ridbss xmbrsb uardh fb sadbdp nav `kzbgcmkbix<
-``̀ ) g cakzrxgx`ai an bgcm cgxbeavp an hgkgebs cdg`kbh fp xmb
h`scdas`ie zgvxp‘uma krsx gdsa kglb g~g`dgfdb nav `iszbcx`aigih cazp`ie gs rihbv Vrdb 38 xmb hacrkbixs av axmbv
b~`hbix`gvp kgxbv`gd$ ridbss zv`~`dbebh av zvaxbcxbh nvakh`scdasrvb$ ai um`cm bgcm cakzrxgx`ai `s fgsbh$ `icdrh`ie
kgxbv`gds fbgv`ie ai xmb igxrvb gih b}xbix an `iorv`bs srnnbvbh<gih
-`~) nav `iszbcx`ai gih cazp`ie gs rihbv Vrdb 38$ gip `isrvgicb
gevbbkbix rihbv um`cm gi `isrvgicb frs`ibss kgp fb d`gfdb xasgx`snp gdd av zgvx an g zass`fdb orhekbix `i xmb gcx`ai av xa
Cgsb =?77+c~+::8=2+GE+GOU Hacrkbix 262 N`dbh :2!77!76 Zgeb 0 an 73 Zgeb @H#?7302=
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Reply to Reeds Opp to Plffs Obj MTS Doc 525
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-reply-to-reeds-opp-to-plffs-obj-mts-doc-525 13/18
D`fbv`$ bx gd$ Zdg`ix`nns Vbzdp `i srzzavx an xmb`v Afobcx`ais gih Vbwrbsx xa Sxv`lb 7:
7
6
3
8
2
>
5
=
0
7:
77
76
73
78
72
7>
75
7=
70
6:
67
66
63
68
62
6>
65
6=
`ihbki`np av vb`kfrvsb nav zgpkbixs kghb xa sgx`snp xmb orhekbix
-H) X`kb nav @i`x`gd H`scdasrvbs‘Nav Zgvx`bs Sbv~bh av Oa`ibh Dgxbv
G zgvxp xmgx `s n`vsx sbv~bh av axmbvu`sb oa`ibh gnxbv xmb Vrdb 6>-n)cainbvbicb krsx kglb xmb `i`x`gd h`scdasrvbs u`xm`i 3: hgps gnxbv
fb`ie sbv~bh av oa`ibh$ ridbss g h`nnbvbix x`kb `s sbx fp sx`zrdgx`ai av carvx avhbv \bkzmgs`s ghhbh[
Irkbvars —kbbx gih cainbvs‛ ubvb mbdh gx xmb vbwrbsx an K`cmgbd F K`ddbv
Bswr`vb @i ngcx$ `isxbgh an z`cl`ie rz g xbdbzmaib xa cgdd Kv Fbve$ Kv K`ddbv
ug`xbh gih b}zbcxbh Kv Fbve xa hvaz b~bvpxm`ie gih cgdd Kv K`ddbv xa caihrcx
xmb cainbvbicb `i um`cm K`ddbv ugs hbkgih`ie Kv Fbve cakzd`bh bgcm gih
b~bvp x`kb Hrv`ie bgcm cainbvbicb Kv K`ddbv mgh b}crsbs nav xmb hbdgps
@^ IB@D SGILBP‐S HBCDGVGX@AI$ GIH B]M@F@XS —G‛ GIH
—F‛
Zdg`ix`nns afobcxbh gih vbwrbsxbh xm`s Carvx xa Sxv`lb xmb xbsx`kaip gih
B}m`f`xs zva~`hbh fp Ib`d Sgilbp zbvxg`i`ie xa umbvb mb afxg`ibh Zdg`ix`nn D`fbv`‐s
Sac`gd Sbcrv`xp irkfbv gs xmb sxgxbkbixs gih hacrkbixs ubvb mbgvsgp< xmgx xmb
hacrkbixs ubvb rigrxmbix`cgxbh$ xmgx xmbp dgclbh narihgx`ai$ gih Ib`d Sgilbp h`h
iax mg~b gip zbvsaigd liaudbheb an xmb sxgxbkbixs av hacrkbixs fbcgrsb mb
afxg`ibh xmb hacrkbixs nvak xm`s Carvx‐s haclbx `i 6:77$ gih iax `i 6::0 nvak
umbvb mb cdg`kbh Zdg`ix`nns Afobcx`ais gih Vbwrbsx xa Sxv`lb ubvb nrvxmbv fgsbh
ai xmb ngcx xmgx Ib`d Sgilbp mgh afxg`ibh xmb Gccrv`ix -Vbbh Hbnbihgixs) Vbzavxs
ai Zdg`ix`nns `i Kgvcm gih Gzv`d 6::0$ gih `kkbh`gxbdp xmbvbgnxbv sbix bkg`ds
Cgsb =?77+c~+::8=2+GE+GOU Hacrkbix 262 N`dbh :2!77!76 Zgeb 7: an 73 Zgeb @H#?73020
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Reply to Reeds Opp to Plffs Obj MTS Doc 525
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-reply-to-reeds-opp-to-plffs-obj-mts-doc-525 14/18
D`fbv`$ bx gd$ Zdg`ix`nns Vbzdp `i srzzavx an xmb`v Afobcx`ais gih Vbwrbsx xa Sxv`lb 77
7
6
3
8
2
>
5
=
0
7:
77
76
73
78
72
7>
75
7=
70
6:
67
66
63
68
62
6>
65
6=
caixg`i`ie Zdg`ix`nn D`fbv` gih mbv szarsbs zv`~gxb hgxg$ `icdrh`ie Sac`gd Sbcrv`xp
irkfbvs `i 6::0$ xmrs Ib`d Sgilbp afxg`ibh D`fbv`‐s Sac`gd Sbcrv`xp irkfbv nvak
xmb caisrkbv vbzavxs sadh fp xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs xa Ib`d Sgilbp ai Zdg`ix`nn D`sg
D`fbv` gih mbv szarsb$ sbb HI 2:5 gx zz 5+7:$ ¾@
@i vbszaisb xmbvbxa$ K`ddbv gx zz 7:+77$ ¾¾68+6> gverbs xmgx Ib`d Sgilbp
afxg`ibh Zdg`ix`nn D`fbv`‐s Sac`gd Sbcrv`xp irkfbv nvak hacrkbixs n`dbh fp D`fbv`
`i axmbv Carvxs$ xmgx Kv Sgilbp afxg`ibh h`vbcxdp nvak xmb Carvxs `i um`cm D`fbv`
n`dbh xmbk gih iax nvak gip an xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs @i srzzavx xmbvban$ K`ddbv
gxxgcmbs gih B}m`f`xs —B‛ gih —N‛ B}m`f`x —N‛ `s g Orib 78$ 6:7: dbxxbv gih
Bkbvebicp Kax`ai xa Sxv`lb gih sbgd n`d`ies fp Avdp Xg`x ai Orib 7:$ 6:7: xa
Orheb Vafvbia `i Zbiispd~gi`g$ xmgx Orheb Vafvbia avhbvbh n`dbh$ sbb HI 766
B}m`f`x —N‛ `s Xg x̀‐s Orib 7:$ 6:7: n`d`ie$ sbb HI 767$ um`cm nrvxmbv zva~bs xmgx
xmb bgvd`bsx hgxb Ib`d Sgilbp afxg`ibh xmbsb rigrxmbix`cgxbh hacrkbixs ugs Orib
7:$ 6:7:$ a~bv g pbgv gnxbv mb gccbssbh gih afxg`ibh xmb Vbzavxs ai Zdg`ix`nn D`fbv`
gih mbv mrsfgih nvak xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs gih a~bv g pbgv gnxbv Ib`d Sgilbp sbix
arx m`s Bkg`ds caixg`i`ie D`fbv` gih mbv mrsfgih‐s Sac`gd Sbcrv`xp irkfbvs gih
axmbv zv`~gxb hgxg$ nrvxmbv srfsxgix`gx`ie Zdg`ix`nns afobcx`ais gih Vbwrbsx xa Sxv`lb
HI 2:5
Xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs cdg`k xmgx xmb hacrkbixs gxxgcmbh xa Ib`d Sgilbp‐s
Hbcdgvgx`ai ubvb iax annbvbh nav xmb xvrxm an xmb kgxxbvs gssbvxbh$ frx `isxbgh xa
Cgsb =?77+c~+::8=2+GE+GOU Hacrkbix 262 N`dbh :2!77!76 Zgeb 77 an 73 Zgeb @H#?730>:
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Reply to Reeds Opp to Plffs Obj MTS Doc 525
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-reply-to-reeds-opp-to-plffs-obj-mts-doc-525 15/18
D`fbv`$ bx gd$ Zdg`ix`nns Vbzdp `i srzzavx an xmb`v Afobcx`ais gih Vbwrbsx xa Sxv`lb 76
7
6
3
8
2
>
5
=
0
7:
77
76
73
78
72
7>
75
7=
70
6:
67
66
63
68
62
6>
65
6=
srzzavx Ib d̀ Sgilbp‐s xbsx`kaip xmgx zva~bs umbvb xmb —sa+cgddbh ”zbvsaig
`hbix`np`ie `inavkgx`ai vbegvh`ie D`fbv`‐‛ cgkb nvak$ um`cm xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs
cdg`k ugs iax nvak xmb Db}`sIb}`s Hbnbihgixs Hacrkbixs rsbh xa srzzavx
b~`hbicb$ `s `i ngcx annbvbh nav xmb xvrxm an xmb kgxxbv Avv ~ Fgil an Gkbv`cg$ IX
. SG 6=2 N3h 5>2$ 55=+550 -0xm
C`v 6::6)< Fdg`v Naahs$ @ic ~ Vgicmbvs Caxxai
A`d $ >7: N 6h >>2$ >>5 -0xm
C`v 70=:)
Xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs xmbi gxxbkzx xa k`sdbgh xmb Carvx `ixa fbd`b~`ie xmgx
Ib`d Sgilbp$ hrv`ie m`s vgh`a gzzbgvgicb ai Kgp 6=$ 6::0$ sxgxbh mb afxg`ibh
Zdg`ix`nns zv`~gxb hgxg nvak xmb Sgi Fbvigvh`ia Carixp Carvx gih Fgilvrzxcp
Carvx Xm`s `s rixvrb gs smaui fp xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs wraxb Iaumbvb h`h Ib`
Sgilbp b~bv sxgxb mb afxg`ibh gip an xmb Zdg`ix`nns av xmb`v szarsbs zv`~gxb hgxg
nvak xmbsb dacgx`ais hrv`ie m`s vgh`a `ixbv~`bu
Ib`d Sgilbp‐s sxgxbkbixs gih B}m`f`xs -hacrkbixs) gvb `ighk`ss`fdb mbgvsgp
gih harfdb mbgvsgp annbvbh nav xmb xvrxm an xmb kgxxbvs gssbvxbh$ xmbp dgclbh
narihgx`ai gih Ib`d Sgilbp h`h iax mg~b zbvsaigd liaudbheb an xmb sxgxbkbixs
gih hacrkbixs Fbpbib ~ Cadbkgi Sbcrv`xp Sbv~s$ @ic$ =28 N 6h 775:$ 77=6 -0xm
C`v 70==) -nav zrvzasbs an Srkkgvp Orhekbix$ gxxgcm`ie rzai kbvb gssbvx`ai xmgx
xmbp ubvb —xvrb gih cavvbcx caz`bs‛ an b}m`f`xs ugs `isrnn`c`bix xa dgp g narihgx`ai
gih grxmbix`cgxb xmb gxxgcmbh hacrkbixs gfsbix zbvsaigd liaudbheb an xmb ngcxs `i
xmb hacrkbixs)< sbb gdsa Avv $ 6=2 N 3h gx 553+558$ 555 -gnn`hg~`x krsx dgp g
Cgsb =?77+c~+::8=2+GE+GOU Hacrkbix 262 N`dbh :2!77!76 Zgeb 76 an 73 Zgeb @H#?730>7
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Reply to Reeds Opp to Plffs Obj MTS Doc 525
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-reply-to-reeds-opp-to-plffs-obj-mts-doc-525 16/18
D`fbv`$ bx gd$ Zdg`ix`nns Vbzdp `i srzzavx an xmb`v Afobcx`ais gih Vbwrbsx xa Sxv`lb 73
7
6
3
8
2
>
5
=
0
7:
77
76
73
78
72
7>
75
7=
70
6:
67
66
63
68
62
6>
65
6=
narihgx`ai xa grxmbix`cgxb h`sca~bvp hacrkbixs) Sbb Gdsa Nbh V B~`h ¥¥>:6 $
=:7-c) $ =:6 gih 0:7-g)
^ CAICDRS@AI?
Nav xmb vbgsais arxd`ibh `i Zdg`ix`nns Afobcx`ais gih Vbwrbsx xa Sxv`lb gih
mbvb`i$ Zdg`ix`nns Afobcx`ais gih Vbwrbsx xa Sxv`lb xmb Hbcdgvgx`ai an D`sg
S`kkais gih B}m`f x̀s —G‛$ —F‛ gih —C‛ gxxgcmbh xmbvbxa< xmb Hbcdgvgx`ai an D`sg
Zad`cgsxva< gih zavx`ais an xmb Hbcdgvgx̀ ai an Ib`d Sgilbp gih B}m`f`xs —G‛ gih
F‛$ krsx fb evgixbh
Vbszbcxnrddp srfk`xxbh$
Hgxbh? Kgp 77$ 6:76 !s! Zm`d`z O FbveZm`d`z O Fbve$ Bswr`vb
Gxxavibp nav Zdg`ix`nns
Cgsb =?77+c~+::8=2+GE+GOU Hacrkbix 262 N`dbh :2!77!76 Zgeb 73 an 73 Zgeb @H#?730>6
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Reply to Reeds Opp to Plffs Obj MTS Doc 525
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-reply-to-reeds-opp-to-plffs-obj-mts-doc-525 17/18
D`fbv`$ bx gd Zdg`ix`nns Cbvx an S~c vb Vbzdp xa Vbbhs Azz 7
7
6
3
8
2
>
5
=
0
7:
77
76
73
78
72
7>
75
7=
70
6:
67
66
63
68
62
6>
65
6=
Zm`d`z O Fbve$ Bswr`vb -ZG @H 0=>5)B+kg`d? zm`dofbveJekg`dcak
DGU ANN@CBS AN ZM@D@Z O FBVE
222 Gihavvg Edbi Carvx$ Sr`xb 76Dgngpbxxb M`dd$ ZG 70888+6237
Xbdbzmaib? ->7:) =62+3738 Ng}? ->7:) =38+5>20 Gxxavibp `i zva sb gih nav Zdg`ix`nns
RI@XBH SXGXBS H@SXV@CX CARVX
NAV XMB CBIXVGD H@SXV@CX AN CGD@NAVI@G$
SARXMBVI H@^@S@AI
D@SG D@FBV@$ bx gd$
Zdg`ix`nns$~s
AVDP XG@X_$ bx gd$
Hbnbihgixs
???
????????
C@^@D GCX@AI IRKFBV?
=?77+c~+::8=2+GE -GOU)
ZDG@IX@NNS CBVX@N@CGXB AN
SBV^@CB
@$ Zm`d`z O Fbve$ Bswr`vb$ mbvbfp cbvx`np g xvrb gih cavvbcx cazp an Zdg`ix`nns Vbzdp
xa xmb Vbbh Hbnbihgixs Azzas`x`ai xa Zdg`ix`nns Afobcx`ais gih Vbwrbsx xa Sxv`lb xmb
Hbcdgvgx̀ ai an D`sg S`kkais gih B}m`f`xs —G‛$ —F‛$ —C‛ gxxgcmbh xmbvbxa< xmb
Hbcdgvgx`ai an D`sg Zad`cgsxva< gih Zavx`ais an xmb Hbcdgvgx`ai an Ib`d Sgilbp gih
B}m`f`xs —G‛ gih —F‛ gxxgcmbh xmbvbxa ugs sbv~bh xmvarem xmb BCN n`d`ie spsxbk xm`s 77xm
hgp an Kgp 6:76 rzai xmb naddau`ie?
Kgvc Sxb~bi Cadbi$ Bsw
Dgu Ann`cbs an Kgvc Sxb~bi Cadbi2535 Lgigi Vagh$ Sxb 385
Gearvg M`dds$ CG 073:7
Bkg`d? kcadbiJcadbidgucak
Gxxavibp nav Hbnbihgixs? Xahh Sgilbp< gih Xmb Sgilbp N`vk$ @ic)
Cgsb =?77+c~+::8=2+GE+GOU Hacrkbix 262+6 N`dbh :2!77!76 Zgeb 7 an 6 Zgeb @H#?730>>
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Plaintiffs Reply to Reeds Opp to Plffs Obj MTS Doc 525
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taitz-plaintiffs-reply-to-reeds-opp-to-plffs-obj-mts-doc-525 18/18
D`fbv` bx gd Zdg`ix`nns Cbvx an S~c vb Vbzdp xa Vbbhs Azz 6
7
6
3
8
2
>
5
=
0
7:
77
76
73
78
72
7>
75
7=
70
6:
67
66
63
68
62
6>
65
6=
Ogkbs N KcCgfb$ Bswr`vbK`cmgbd F) K`ddbv$ Bswr`vb
Kavv`sai . Nabvsxbv
862 Kgvlbx Sx
Sgi Nvgic`sca$ CG 087:2+68=6Bkg`d? okccgfbJkana)cak
Bkg`d? KFK`ddbvJkana)cak
Gxxavibp nav Hbnbihgixs? Vbbh Bdsb~`bv$ @ic)< Db}`sIb}`s Evarz< Db}`sIb}`s< Db}`sIb}̀ s V`sl gih @inavkgx`ai Gigdpx`cs Evarz$ @ic)<
Db}`sIb}`s V`sl Sadrx`ais$ @ic)< Db}`sIb}`s Sb`s`ix$ @ic) h!f!g Gccrv`ix<Cma`cbza`ix$ @ic)
Avdp Xg`x60=30 Sgixg Kgvegv`xg Zgvlugp$ Sr`xb 7::
Vgicma Sgixg Kgvegv`xg$ CG 06>==Bkg`d? avdp)xg`xJekg`d)cak gih
Bkg`d? hvQxg`xJpgmaa)cak
Gxxavibp nav Hbnbihgix Hbnbih arv Nvbbhaks Narihgx`ai$ @ic)
L`k Scmrkgii$ Bswr`vbObnnvbp Z) Crii`iemgk$ Bswr`vb
SCMRKGII$ VGDDA . VASBIFBVE$ DDZ37:: Fv`sxad Sxvbbx$ Sr`xb 8::
Casxg Kbsg$ CG 06>6>
Bkg`d? zcaalGJsvvdgun`vk)cak
Gxxavibp nav Hbnbihgixs Avdp Xg`x< Avdp Xg`x$ @ic)< gih Dgu Ann`cbs an Avdp Xg`x
!s! Zm`d`z O) Fbve
Zm`d`z O) Fbve$ Bswr`vb
Cgsb =?77+c~+::8=2+GE+GOU Hacrkbix 262+6 N`dbh :2!77!76 Zgeb 6 an 6 Zgeb @H#?730>5
