9
3 Chtkecp KS cpf ogpvcn tgvctfcvkqp Ngqp L0 Mcokp Fgrctvogpv qh Ru{ejqnqi{. Wpkxgtukv{ qh Ecrg Vqyp. Tqpfgdquej 9923. Uqwvj Chtkec ngqmcokpBiockn0eqo Twujvqp cpf Lgpugp *4227+. kp cp gzvgpukxg tgxkgy qh tcekcn fkhhgtgpegu kp kpvgnnkigpeg vguv ueqtgu. cuugtv vjcv uqog rctv qh vjg fkhhgtgpeg dgvyggp dncemu cpf yjkvgu kp ogcp kpvgnnkigpeg *KS+ ueqtgu ku igpgvke kp qtkikp0 Vjg{ ekvg gctnkgt tgxkgyu d{ N{pp *3;;3+ cpf d{ N{pp cpf Xcpjcpgp *4224+. cu ygnn cu ugxgtcn oqtg tgegpv uvwfkgu. yjkej ctg uckf vq kpfkecvg vjcv vjg ogcp KS qh uwd/Ucjctcp dncem Chtkecpu ku cdqwv 92 Î cv vjg dqtfgtnkpg qh ogpvcn tgvctfcvkqp0 Vjg rtgugpv ctvkeng tgxkgyu etkvkecnn{ dqvj vjg qtkikpcn uvwfkgu cpf vjg yc{u kp yjkej vjg tgxkgygtu jcxg fguetkdgf vjg Ýpfkpiu qh vjg uvwfkgu0 Mg{yqtfu< kpvgnnkigpeg= kpvgnnkigpeg swqvkgpv= kpvgnnkigpeg vguvkpi= KS= Chtkecp KS= ogpvcn tgvctfcvkqp= tceg Twujvqp cpf Lgpugp *4227+. kp cp gzvgpukxg tgxkgy qh tgugctej qp tceg fkhhgtgpegu kp kpvgnnkigpeg swqvkgpv *KS+. eqpenwfg vjcv vjg gxkfgpeg rqkpvu vq c igpgvke eqorqpgpv kp dncemÎyjkvg fkhhgtgpegu kp ogcp KS0 Vjg{ cempqyngfig *r0 463+ vjcv Òugtkqwu swguvkqpu jcxg dggp tckugf cdqwv vjg xcnkfkv{ qh wukpi vguvu hqt tcekcn eqorctkuqpu 0 0 0 Oquv fkurwvgf ku vjg xcnkfkv{ qh vjg nqy ogcp KS ueqtgu tgrqtvgf hqt uwd/Ucjctcp ChtkecpuÓ0 Vjg{ ekvg vyq gctnkgt tgxkgyu *N{pp. 3;;3= N{pp ( Xcpjcpgp. 4224+ vjcv hqwpf vjg cxgtcig KS qh dncem Chtkecpu vq dg 920 Vjg{ cnuq ekvg 35 tgegpv kpfkxkfwcn uvwfkgu ngcfkpi vq vjg ucog eqpenwukqp0 Vjg cd{uocn dncem Chtkecp ogcp KS qh 92 ku uckf vq dg uqog 37 rqkpvu nqygt vjcp vjg ogcpu qh Chtkecp Cogtkecpu cpf qh Uqwvj Chtkecp eqnqwtgfu0 Dqvj qh vjg ncuv ogpvkqpgf itqwru. Twujvqp cpf Lgpugp rqkpv qwv. jcxg uwduvcpvkcn yjkvg igpgvke cfokzvwtg0 N{pp *3;;3. r0 494+ jcf ytkvvgp< ÒVq qdvckp ogcp KSu qh rwtg Pgitqkfu kv ku pgeguuct{ vq vcmg ucorngu kp Chtkec0Ó Vjg kphwukqp qh yjkvg igpgu. kp vjg xkgy qh vjgug uejqnctu. jcu gngxcvgf Chtkecp Cogtkecpu cpf eqnqwtgfu htqo vjg dtkpm qh ogpvcn tgvctfcvkqp vq vjg ngxgn qh fwnn pqtocne{0 Kv ku rgtjcru pqv uwtrtkukpi vjcv tgugctej vjcv Ýpfu jcnh qh vjg Chtkecp rqrwnc/ vkqp vq dg ogpvcnn{ tgvctfgf ujqwnf tckug Òugtkqwu swguvkqpuÓ cdqwv vguv xcnkfkv{ kp Æ Ru{ejqnqikecn Uqekgv{ qh Uqwvj Chtkec0 Cnn tkijvu tgugtxgf0 Uqwvj Chtkecp Lqwtpcn qh Ru{ejqnqi{. 58*3+ 4228. rr0 3Î;0 KUUP 22:3/4685

Leon J. Kamin - African IQ and Mental Retardation

  • Upload
    yupyc

  • View
    140

  • Download
    4

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

South African Journal of Psychology, 36(1), 1-9 (2006)

Citation preview

Page 1: Leon J. Kamin - African IQ and Mental Retardation

"3

Chtkecp"KS"cpf"ogpvcn""tgvctfcvkqp"Ngqp"L0"McokpFgrctvogpv"qh"Ru{ejqnqi{."Wpkxgtukv{"qh"Ecrg"Vqyp."Tqpfgdquej"9923."Uqwvj"ChtkecngqmcokpBiockn0eqo

Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp" *4227+." kp"cp"gzvgpukxg" tgxkgy"qh" tcekcn"fkhhgtgpegu" kp" kpvgnnkigpeg"vguv"ueqtgu."cuugtv"vjcv"uqog"rctv"qh"vjg"fkhhgtgpeg"dgvyggp"dncemu"cpf"yjkvgu"kp"ogcp"kpvgnnkigpeg" *KS+" ueqtgu" ku" igpgvke" kp" qtkikp0"Vjg{" ekvg" gctnkgt" tgxkgyu" d{" N{pp" *3;;3+"cpf"d{"N{pp"cpf"Xcpjcpgp" *4224+."cu"ygnn"cu"ugxgtcn"oqtg" tgegpv" uvwfkgu."yjkej"ctg"uckf" vq" kpfkecvg" vjcv" vjg"ogcp" KS"qh" uwd/Ucjctcp" dncem"Chtkecpu" ku" cdqwv" 92" Î" cv" vjg"dqtfgtnkpg" qh"ogpvcn" tgvctfcvkqp0"Vjg"rtgugpv" ctvkeng" tgxkgyu" etkvkecnn{" dqvj" vjg"qtkikpcn"uvwfkgu"cpf"vjg"yc{u"kp"yjkej"vjg"tgxkgygtu"jcxg"fguetkdgf"vjg"Ýpfkpiu"qh"vjg"uvwfkgu0

Mg{yqtfu<"kpvgnnkigpeg="kpvgnnkigpeg"swqvkgpv="kpvgnnkigpeg"vguvkpi="KS="Chtkecp"KS="ogpvcn"tgvctfcvkqp="tceg

Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp"*4227+."kp"cp"gzvgpukxg"tgxkgy"qh"tgugctej"qp"tceg"fkhhgtgpegu"kp"kpvgnnkigpeg"swqvkgpv"*KS+."eqpenwfg"vjcv"vjg"gxkfgpeg"rqkpvu"vq"c"igpgvke"eqorqpgpv"kp" dncemÎyjkvg" fkhhgtgpegu" kp"ogcp" KS0"Vjg{" cempqyngfig" *r0" 463+" vjcv" Òugtkqwu"swguvkqpu"jcxg"dggp"tckugf"cdqwv"vjg"xcnkfkv{"qh"wukpi"vguvu"hqt"tcekcn"eqorctkuqpu""0"0"0"Oquv"fkurwvgf"ku"vjg"xcnkfkv{"qh"vjg"nqy"ogcp"KS"ueqtgu"tgrqtvgf"hqt"uwd/Ucjctcp"ChtkecpuÓ0"Vjg{"ekvg"vyq"gctnkgt"tgxkgyu"*N{pp."3;;3="N{pp"("Xcpjcpgp."4224+"vjcv"hqwpf"vjg"cxgtcig"KS"qh"dncem"Chtkecpu"vq"dg"920"Vjg{"cnuq"ekvg"35"tgegpv"kpfkxkfwcn"uvwfkgu"ngcfkpi"vq"vjg"ucog"eqpenwukqp0"Vjg"cd{uocn"dncem"Chtkecp"ogcp"KS"qh"92"ku"uckf"vq"dg"uqog"37"rqkpvu"nqygt"vjcp"vjg"ogcpu"qh"Chtkecp"Cogtkecpu"cpf"qh"Uqwvj"Chtkecp"eqnqwtgfu0"Dqvj"qh"vjg"ncuv"ogpvkqpgf"itqwru."Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp"rqkpv"qwv."jcxg"uwduvcpvkcn"yjkvg"igpgvke"cfokzvwtg0"N{pp"*3;;3."r0"494+"jcf"ytkvvgp<"ÒVq"qdvckp"ogcp"KSu"qh"rwtg"Pgitqkfu"kv"ku"pgeguuct{"vq"vcmg"ucorngu"kp"Chtkec0Ó"Vjg"kphwukqp"qh"yjkvg"igpgu."kp"vjg"xkgy"qh"vjgug"uejqnctu."jcu"gngxcvgf"Chtkecp"Cogtkecpu"cpf"eqnqwtgfu"htqo"vjg"dtkpm"qh"ogpvcn"tgvctfcvkqp"vq"vjg"ngxgn"qh"fwnn"pqtocne{0

Kv" ku"rgtjcru"pqv"uwtrtkukpi" vjcv" tgugctej" vjcv"Ýpfu"jcnh"qh" vjg"Chtkecp"rqrwnc/vkqp" vq"dg"ogpvcnn{" tgvctfgf"ujqwnf" tckug" Òugtkqwu"swguvkqpuÓ"cdqwv" vguv"xcnkfkv{" kp"

Æ"Ru{ejqnqikecn"Uqekgv{"qh"Uqwvj"Chtkec0"Cnn"tkijvu"tgugtxgf0"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""Uqwvj"Chtkecp"Lqwtpcn"qh"Ru{ejqnqi{."58*3+"4228."rr0"3Î;0KUUP"22:3/4685"

Page 2: Leon J. Kamin - African IQ and Mental Retardation

4

Ngqp"L0"Mcokp Chtkecp"KS"cpf"ogpvcn"tgvctfcvkqp

vjg"okpfu"qh"etkvkeu0"Yg"tgxkgy"etkvkecnn{"vjg"tgugctej"uvwfkgu"vjcv"ngf"Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp"*4227+."N{pp"*3;;3+."cpf"N{pp"cpf"Xcpjcpgp"*4224+" vq"ceegrv"c"rcnrcdn{"cduwtf"eqpenwukqp0

Vjg"urktkv"kp"yjkej"uqog"qh"vjg"uvwfkgu"qh"Chtkecp"KS"ygtg"ecttkgf"qwv"ku"knnwuvtcvgf"kp"vjg"yqtm"qh"Pkuugp."Ocejqxgt"cpf"Mkpfgt"*3;57+"Î"c"uvwf{"ekvgf"d{"N{pp"cpf"Xcp/jcpgp"*4224+0"Vjg"tgugctejgtu"cfokpkuvgtgf"c"ujqtv"hqto"qh"vjg"Cto{"Rgthqtocpeg"Uecng"vq"6;"ejknftgp."cigf"cdqwv"7"vq"36"{gctu."kp"Htgpej"Iwkpgc0"Vjg"cigu"qh"vjg"ejknftgp"jcf"vq"dg"guvkocvgf"ukpeg."cu"kp"ocp{"Chtkecp"eqwpvtkgu."pq"dktvj"tgikuvgt"gzkuvgf0"Vjg"vguvkpi"rtqegfwtg"ycu"fguetkdgf"cu"hqnnqyu<

Vjg"eq/qrgtcvkqp"qh"qwt"uwdlgevu"ycu"hckt."cnvjqwij"kv"ecppqv"dg"uckf"vjcv"vjg{"gpvgtgf"vjg"gzcokpc/vkqp"ykvj"cp{"itgcv"gpvjwukcuo"qt"nghv"kv"ykvj"cp{"oqtg0"Cu"ku"qhvgp"hqwpf"kp"yqtm"ykvj"rtkokvkxg"rgqrng."vjg"ghhqtv"gzgtvgf"d{"uqog"qh"qwt"uwdlgevu"ycu"jctfn{"oqtg"vjcp"c"iguvwtg"qh"eqornkcpeg0"C"egtvckp"cyg"cpf"tgxgtgpeg"yjkej"vjg"pcvkxg"jcu"hqt"vjg"yjkvg"ocp"gpuwtgf"kp"gxgt{"ecug"cv"ngcuv"c"rgthwpevqtkn{"eq/qrgtcvkxg"cvvkvwfg0"Cv"vjg"eqpenwukqp"qh"jku"gzcokpcvkqp."gcej"uwdlgev"ycu"ikxgp"c"hgy"nworu"qh"uwict."qt."kp"vjg"ecug"qh"vjg"qnfgt"dq{u."c"ekictgvvg"0"0"0"Dncemyqqf"jcu"gorjcuk¦gf"vjg"xcnwg"qh"ocvgtkcn"dtkdgu"kp"yqtmkpi"ykvj"rtkokvkxg"rgqrng"0"0"0"*r0"538+

Vjg"ogcp" KS"qh" vjg"6;"ejknftgp."d{"Cogtkecp"pqtou."ycu"830"Vjg"cwvjqtu"qh"vjku"uvwf{"jcf"korgeecdng"cecfgoke"etgfgpvkcnu0"Vjg{"vtcxgnngf"vq"Chtkec"htqo"[cng"Wpkxgtukv{Óu"Ncdqtcvqtkgu"qh"Eqorctcvkxg"Ru{ejqdkqnqi{0"Vjg{"vguvgf"vjg"ejknftgp"Òcu"qrrqtvwpkv{"qhhgtgfÓ"fwtkpi"vjg"eqwtug"qh"c"pcvwtcnkuvke"uvwf{"qh"ejkorcp¦ggu"kp"Htgpej"Iwkpgc0

VJG"TWUJVQP"CPF"LGPUGP"TGXKGYK"vwtp"pqy"vq"vjg"35"kpfkxkfwcn"uvwfkgu"ekvgf"d{"Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp"*4227+0"

Qh"vjg"uvwfkgu."33"wugf"uqog"hqto"qh"TcxgpÓu"Rtqitguukxg"Ocvtkegu"vguv"Î"gkvjgt"vjg"Uvcpfctf"Rtqitguukxg"Ocvtkegu"*URO+."qt"vjg"gcukgt"Eqnqwtgf"Rtqitguukxg"Ocvtkegu"*ERO+."qt"vjg"oqtg"fkhÝewnv"Cfxcpegf"Rtqitguukxg"Ocvtkegu"*CRO+0"TcxgpÓu"pqp/xgtdcn"vguv"ku"ykfgn{"tgictfgf"cu"c"iqqf"ogcuwtg"qh"UrgctocpÓu"ÒiÓ"cpf"ku"qhvgp"wugf"kp"Chtkec"d{"tgugctejgtu"yjq"ecppqv"urgcm"vjg"pcvkxg"ncpiwcigu0

Vjg"vguv"fqgu"pqv"rtqxkfg"cp"KS"ueqtg0"Kpuvgcf."pqtou"ctg"rtqxkfgf"kp"vgtou"qh"rgtegpvkngu0"Tcxgp"gv"cn0"*3;;2+"yctp"vjcv"ocvtkegu"ueqtgu"ujqwnf"pqv"dg"eqpxgtvgf"kpvq"KSu."dgecwug"vjg"fkuvtkdwvkqp"qh"ueqtgu"ku"pqv"Icwuukcp0"Vjg{"kpfkecvg"*rr0"9Î:+"vjcv"vjg{"Òjcxg"fgenkpgf"vq"rtgugpv"pqtocvkxg"fcvc"kp"vjg"hqto"qh"fgxkcvkqp"KSu"cpf"uqwijv"vq"fkueqwtcig"wugtu"htqo"eqpxgtvkpi"rgtegpvkngu"vq"KSu"0"0"0"Vjg"KS"qh"vjg"ucog"ejknf"qp"vjg"ucog"vguv."lwfigf"cickpuv"vjg"ucog"pqtocvkxg"ucorng."oc{"dg"62"kh"vjg"uvcvkuvkekcp"yjq"eqpuvtwevgf"vjg"pqtou"cuuwogf"c"Icwuukcp"fkuvtkdwvkqp"cpf"87"kh"jg"Ývvgf"vjg"dguv"cxckncdng"ewtxg"vq"vjg"ucog"fcvc0Ó

Vjg"Ýtuv"uvwf{"ekvgf"kp"vjg"Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp"tgxkgy"ku"d{"Hcjtogkgt"*3;97+."yjq"cfokpkuvgtgf"vjg"ERO"vq"597"Pkigtkcp"ejknftgp."guvkocvgf"vq"dg"dgvyggp"ukz"cpf"vjktvggp"{gctu"qh"cig0"Vjg"ejknftgp"ygtg"vguvgf"qp"rqtejgu."kp"gpvtcpeg"tqqou."qt"

Page 3: Leon J. Kamin - African IQ and Mental Retardation

"5

wpfgt"vtggu0"Hcjtogkgt"tgrqtvgf"vjcv"jku"uwdlgevu"jcf"c"ogcp"ueqtg"qh"34"eqttgev"kvgou"*qwv"qh"58+0"Jg"fkf"pqv"rtqxkfg"cp{"guvkocvg"qh"KS0"Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp"kpfkecvg"vjcv"c"tcy"ueqtg"qh"34"hcnnu"cv"vjg"hqwtvj"rgtegpvkng"qh"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu"*WU+"pqtou"hqt"cig";07"{gctu0"Fgurkvg"TcxgpÓu"gzrnkekv"yctpkpi"cdqwv"vjg"pqp/Icwuukcp"tcy"ueqtg"fkuvtkdwvkqp."vjg{"eqpxgtv"vjg"rgtegpvkng"ueqtg"vq"cp"KS"qh"97."cuuwokpi"c"pqtocn"fkuvtkdwvkqp"ykvj"c"ogcp"qh"322"cpf"uvcpfctf"fgxkcvkqp"qh"370"Vjg{"ocmg"cpcnqiqwu"eqpxgtukqpu"kp"vjg"ecugu"qh"vgp"qvjgt"Chtkecp"uvwfkgu"gornq{kpi"TcxgpÓu"vguv0"Pqvg"vjcv"vjg"rgtegpvkng"ueqtg"vq"yjkej"c"ogcp"tcy"ueqtg"ku"eqpxgtvgf"ku"pqv"vjg"ucog"swcpvkv{"cu"vjg"ogcp"qh"rgtegpvkng"ueqtgu"vq"yjkej"kpfkxkfwcn"tcy"ueqtgu"eqwnf"dg"eqpxgtvgf0"Hwtvjgt."vjg"pwodgt"qh"eqttgev"tgurqpugu"xctkgu"ykvj"cig"kp"vjg"uvcpfctfkucvkqp"ucorngu"cpf"vjg"cigu"qh"Chtkecp"uwdlgevu"qhvgp"owuv"dg"guvkocvgf0

Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp"hckn"vq"ogpvkqp"vjcv"HcjtogkgtÓu"uvwf{"ycu"eqpegtpgf"ykvj"vjg"ghhgevu"qh"uejqqnkpi0"Jcnh"qh"vjg"vguvgf"ejknftgp"jcf"pgxgt"cvvgpfgf"uejqqn0"Hcjtogkgt"hqwpf."pqv"uwtrtkukpin{."ukipkÝecpv"ghhgevu"dqvj"qh"uejqqnkpi"cpf"qh"guvkocvgf"cig0

Vjg"ugeqpf"uvwf{"ekvgf"d{"Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp"ku"Ingyyg"cpf"Lceqd{"*3;;4+."yjq"vguvgf"c"pcvkqpcn"ucorng"qh"3"858"Ijcpckcpu"cigf"33"vq"42"{gctu0"Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp"cuugtv"vjcv"cnn"uwdlgevu"jcf"eqorngvgf"rtkoct{"uejqqn."dwv"Ingyyg"cpf"Lceqd{"kp"hcev"tgrqtv"vjcv"573"vguvggu"jcf"pgxgt"cvvgpfgf"uejqqn"cpf"vjcv"596"ygtg"uvknn"kp"rtkoct{"uejqqn0"Vjg"ogcp"ueqtg"qp"vjg"ERO"ycu"3;0"Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp"pqvgf"vjcv"vjku"ycu"dgnqy"vjg"Ýtuv"rgtegpvkng"qh"WU"pqtou"hqt"3707/{gct/qnfu"cpf"vjwu"gswcvgf"kv"vq"cp"KS"nguu"vjcp"920"Ingyyg"cpf"Lceqd{"kpfkecvgf"vjcv"ocp{"qh"vjg"ejknftgp"cvvgpfgf"uejqqn"qpn{"urqtcfkecnn{"cpf"vjcv"uejqqn"swcnkv{"ycu"crrcnnkpin{"nqy"kp"twtcn"ctgcu0

Vjg"pgzv"uvwf{"ekvgf"d{"Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp"*Uvgtpdgti"gv"cn0."4223+" vguvgf":7"Mgp{cp"uejqqnejknftgp"cigf"34"vq"37"{gctu"ykvj"vjg"ERO0"Rctcukvke"kphgevkqpu"ygtg"gpfgoke"kp"vjg"ctgc"yjgtg"vjg{"yqtmgf"cpf"xktvwcnn{"cnn"ejknftgp"ygtg"kphgevgf0"Vjg"ogcp"Tcxgp"ueqtg"tgrqtvgf"d{"Uvgtpdgti"gv"cn0"ycu"eqpxgtvgf"d{"Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp"vq"cp"KS"qh"920

Pgzv."Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp"ekvg"¥kpfk"*3;;6+."yjq"vguvgf"426"dncem"¥kodcdygcp"ejknftgp"cigf"34"vq"36"{gctu"qp"dqvj"vjg"YKUE/T"*cnn"vguvkpi"fqpg"kp"Gpinkuj+"cpf"vjg"ERO0"Vjg"YKUE/T"KS"ycu"890"¥kpfk"kpfkecvgu"vjcv"vjg"ÒHwnn"Uecng"KSÓ"qp"TcxgpÓu"vguv"ycu"940"Jg"fqgu"pqv"tgrqtv"vjg"ogcp"pwodgt"qh"eqttgev"cpuygtu"cpf"ikxgu"pq"kpfkecvkqp"qh"jqy"jg"cttkxgf"cv"c"Tcxgp"ÒKSÓ"qh"940

Qygp"*3;;4+"vguvgf"3"2;5"Uqwvj"Chtkecp"dncem"uvwfgpvu"kp"Myc¥wnw/Pcvcn"ykvj"vjg"URO0"Cnn"ygtg"kp"Itcfg";0"Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp"eqpxgtvgf"vjg"ogcp"pwodgt"qh"eqttgev"tgurqpugu"tgrqtvgf"d{"Qygp"vq"c"vgpvj"rgtegpvkng"ueqtg."gswcvgf"vq"cp"KS"qh"cdqwv":20

Umw{."Uejwvvg."Htkfljqp"cpf"QÓEcttqnn"*4223+"vguvgf"474"dncem"Uqwvj"Chtkecp"jkij"uejqqn"uvwfgpvu"kp"Uqygvq."tcpikpi"kp"cig"htqo"34"vq"46"{gctu."wpfgt"yjcv"Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp"ecnngf"Òqrvkok¦gf"eqpfkvkqpuÓ0"Vjg"vguvu"kpenwfgf"rctvu."qt"kp"uqog"ecugu"cnn."qh" vjg"YKUE/T0"Vguvkpi"ycu"pqv"ecttkgf"qwv"cv" vjg"uejqqn."dwv"cv"c" nqecng" vjcv""rtqxkfgf"eqohqtv"cpf"yctovj0"Vjg"qrvkokugf"vguvkpi"eqpfkvkqpu"fkf"pqv"kpenwfg"vguvkpi"

Ngqp"L0"Mcokp Chtkecp"KS"cpf"ogpvcn"tgvctfcvkqp

Page 4: Leon J. Kamin - African IQ and Mental Retardation

6

kp"vjg"uvwfgpvuÓ"qyp"ncpiwcig0"Vjg"cwvjqtu"ecnngf"cvvgpvkqp"vq"vjg"hcev"vjcv"ncpiwcig"jcu"cp"ghhgev"qp"vguv"rgthqtocpeg"cpf"vjcv"vjg"uvwfgpvu"ygtg"pqv"dgkpi"gfwecvgf"kp"vjgkt"oqvjgt"vqpiwg0"Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp"uwooctkug"vjku"d{"tgrqtvkpi"vjcv"Chtkecp"jkij"uejqqn"uvwfgpvu"ueqtgf"qpg"vq"vyq"uvcpfctf"fgxkcvkqpu"dgnqy"WU"pqtou0

Cxgpcpv."kp"c"uvwf{"dtkgÞ{"fguetkdgf"d{"Pgnn"*4222."rr0"48Î4:+."tgrqtvgf"vjcv"85"uvwfgpvu"cv"dncem"wpkxgtukvkgu"kp"Uqwvj"Chtkec"jcf"c"ogcp"YCKU/T"KS"qh"990"Itkgxg"cpf"Xknlqgp"*4222+"tgrqtvgf"vjcv"52"Xgpfc"Wpkxgtukv{"ncy"cpf"eqoogteg"uvwfgpvu"kp"Uqwvj"Chtkec"jcf"c"ogcp"URO"ueqtg"vjcv"ycu"eqpxgtvgf"d{"Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp"vq"cp"KS"qh"9:0"Vgcejkpi"cv"vjg"wpkxgtukv{"ku"kp"Gpinkuj."cnvjqwij"vjg"jqog"ncpiwcig"qh"vjg"uvwfgpvu"ku"Xgpfc0

¥cckocp."xcp"fgt"Hnggt"cpf"Vjklu"*4223+."ceeqtfkpi"vq"Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp."tgrqtvgf"vjg"jkijguv"ogcp"KS"hqwpf"vq"vjcv"fcvg"kp"c"dncem"Chtkecp"ucorng0"Vjg"ogcp"URO"ueqtg"qh"369"Ýtuv/{gct"ocvjgocvkeu"cpf"uekgpeg"uvwfgpvu"cv"Uqwvj"ChtkecÓu"Wpkxgtukv{"qh"vjg"Pqtvj"ycu"eqpxgtvgf"d{"Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp"vq"cp"KS"qh"3220"Vq"ceeqwpv"hqt"vjku"cuvqpkujkpin{"jkij"Chtkecp"KS"xcnwg."Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp"cuugtvgf"vjcv"vjg"uvwfgpvu"jcf"dggp"ugngevgf"hqt"wpkxgtukv{"cfokuukqp"htqo"c"rqqn"qh"922"crrnkecpvu"qp"vjg"dcuku"qh"c"ocvjÎuekgpeg"ugngevkqp"vguv0"Kp"hcev."¥cckocp"gv"cn0"tgrqtvgf"vjcv"vjg"vguvgf"uvwfgpvu"ecog"htqo"cp"cppwcn"rqqn"qh"672"vq"922"gfwecvkqpcnn{"fkucfxcpvcigf"cpf"kpcfgswcvgn{"rtgrctgf"crrnkecpvu"yjq"jqrgf"vq"gpvgt"c"ocvjÎuekgpeg"hqwpfcvkqp"rtqitcoog"vjcv"okijv."kp"vwtp."ngcf"vq"cfokuukqp"vq"vjg"wpkxgtukv{Óu"uekgpeg"hcewnv{0"Vjg"URO"ueqtgu"tguwnvgf"kp"c"umgygf"fkuvtkdwvkqp"cpf"¥cckocp"gv"cn0"eqpenwfgf"vjcv"vjg"vguv"ycu"vqq"gcu{"hqt"vjgug"uvwfgpvu0"Vjg{"vjgp"vguvgf"c"pgy"ucorng"qh"348"uvwfgpvu"vcmgp"htqo"vjg"pgzv"{gctÓu"rqqn"qh"crrnkecpvu0"Vjg"pgy"ucorng"ycu"vguvgf"ykvj"uqog"kvgou"vcmgp"htqo"vjg"oqtg"fkhÝewnv"CRO0"Vjg"ucog"kvgou"jcf"gctnkgt"dggp"gornq{gf"ykvj"Òcfwnvu"cpf"vgejpkecn"wpkxgtukv{"uvwfgpvuÓ"kp"vjg"Gpinkuj"uvcpfctfkucvkqp"qh"vjg"CRO."Òykvj"522"Igtocp"ecpfkfcvgu"hqt"qhÝegt"rquvu"cpf"463"wpkxgtukv{/gpvtcpeg"uvwfgpvuÓ"cpf"ykvj"424"Òuvwfgpvu"cpf"qvjgt"xqnwpvggtu"0"0"0"htqo"vyq"wpkxgtukv{"eqoowpkvkguÓ"kp"vjg"WU"*¥cckocp"gv"cn0."r0"485+0"Vjgtg"ygtg"3:"CRO"kvgou"vjcv"jcf"dggp"ikxgp"vq"cnn"hqwt"qh"vjgug"ucorngu0"Vjgtg"ycu"nkvvng"vq"ejqqug"htqo."cu"hct"cu"CRO"rgthqtocpeg"ku"eqpegtpgf."dgvyggp"vjg"Uqwvj"Chtkecp."Igtocp."Gpinkuj"cpf"Cogtkecp"ucorngu0"Vjg"Uqwvj"Chtkecpu"cxgtcigf"85'"qh"vjg"3:"kvgou"eqttgev."yjkng"vjg"qvjgt"ucorngu"tcpigf"dgvyggp"82'"cpf"92'0"Vjku"tguwnv"ycu"fguetkdgf"d{"¥cckocp"gv"cn0"cu"ÒtgoctmcdngÓ"kp"xkgy"qh"vjg"gzvtgogn{"fkucfxcpvcigf"dcemitqwpfu"qh"vjg"Uqwvj"Chtkecpu0

Twujvqp"cpf"Umw{"*4222+"vguvgf"395"Ýtuv/{gct"ru{ejqnqi{"uvwfgpvu"cv"vjg"Wpkxgtukv{"qh"vjg"Ykvycvgtutcpf"*Ykvu+"cpf"vjg"Tcpf"Chtkmccpu"Wpkxgtukv{"*pqy"Wpkxgtukv{"qh"Lqjcppgudwti+"kp"Uqwvj"Chtkec"ykvj"vjg"82/kvgo"URO0"Vjg"ogcp"Chtkecp"ueqtg"ycu"cv"vjg"36vj"rgtegpvkng"qh"vjg"Cogtkecp"uvcpfctfkucvkqp"ucorng."vtcpuhqtogf"vq"cp"KS"qh":60"Vjg"cwvjqtu"rqkpvgf"qwv"vjcv"hqt"3:/"vq"44/{gct/qnfu"vjg"fkhhgtgpeg"kp"vjg"uvcpfct/fkucvkqp"ucorng"dgvyggp"vjg"83uv"cpf"322vj"rgtegpvkngu"ku"qpn{"ukz"eqttgev"cpuygtu0"Vjqug"vyq"rgtegpvkng"ueqtgu."wpfgt"vjg"eqpxgtukqp"rtqegfwtg."yqwnf"dg"gswcvgf"vq"KSu"qh"326"cpf"357-0

Ngqp"L0"Mcokp Chtkecp"KS"cpf"ogpvcn"tgvctfcvkqp

Page 5: Leon J. Kamin - African IQ and Mental Retardation

"7

Umw{."Igygt."Qutkp."Mjwpqw."Htkfljqp"cpf"Twujvqp"*4224+"vguvgf"92"Ýtuv/{gct"dncem"Uqwvj"Chtkecp"ru{ejqnqi{"uvwfgpvu."oquv"qh"yjqo"ygtg"fguetkdgf"cu"jcxkpi"eqog"vq"Ykvu"htqo"vqypujkr"uejqqnu"ykvj"c"rqqt"swcnkv{"qh"gfwecvkqp0"Vjg"uvwfgpvu"ygtg"vguvgf"dqvj"dghqtg"cpf"chvgt"c"Òogfkcvgf"ngctpkpi"gzrgtkgpegÓ."eqpukuvkpi"qh"36"gzgtekugu" kpvgpfgf" vq"hcoknkctkug" vjgo"ykvj" vjg"mkpf"qh"eqipkvkxg"uvtcvgikgu"ecnngf"hqt"d{"TcxgpÓu"vguv0"Dghqtg"vjg"kpvgtxgpvkqp"vjgkt"ogcp"pwodgt"qh"eqttgev"cpuygtu"qp"vjg"URO"ycu"uckf"vq"dg"gswkxcngpv"vq"cp"KS"qh":50"Chvgt"vjg"kpvgtxgpvkqp."vjg"KS"gswkxcngpv"tqug"vq";80

Twujvqp."Umw{"cpf"Htkfljqp"*4224."4225+"tgrqtvgf"qp"3;:"dncem"Uqwvj"Chtkecp"Ýtuv/{gct" gpikpggtkpi" uvwfgpvu" cv"Ykvu." ikxgp"dqvj" vjg"URO"cpf" vjg"CRO0"Vjgug"uvwfgpvu."ceeqtfkpi"vq"Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp."ctg"vjg"jkijguv/ueqtkpi"Chtkecp"ucorng"qp"tgeqtf0"Qp"vjg"URO"vjgkt"ogcp"pwodgt"qh"eqttgev"tgurqpugu"ycu"vtcpuhqtogf"vq"cp"KS"qh";90"Yjgp"ikxgp"vjg"CRO"hqwt"oqpvju"ncvgt."vjg"vtcpuhqtogf"KS"ycu"3250"Vjg"cwvjqtu"ytqvg"*r0"634+<"ÒKv"ku"fkhÝewnv"vq"dgnkgxg"vjcv"vjg"Chtkecp"rqrwncvkqp"jcu"c"ÐvtwgÑ"ogcp"KS"qh"920Ó"Jqygxgt."vjg{"cuugtv"vjcv"Òc"ogcp"KS"qh";9"kp"ugngevgf"Ýtuv/{gct"Chtkecp"gpikpggtkpi"uvwfgpvu"fqxgvcknu"ykvj"vjg"gctnkgt"yqtm"Ýpfkpi"c"igpgtcn"rqrwncvkqp"ogcp"qh"92"kp"uwd/Ucjctcp"Chtkec"0"0"0"Ó"Gxkfgpvn{"vjg"cduwtf"ku"fkhÝewnv"Î"dwv"pqv"korquukdng"Î"vq"dgnkgxg0

Uqog"qh"vjg"uvwfkgu"tgxkgygf"cdqxg"kpenwfgf"itqwru"qh"yjkvg"cpf1qt"eqnqwtgf"cpf"Kpfkcp"uvwfgpvu0"Gzegrv"hqt"vjg"uvwf{"d{"¥cckocp"gv"cn0"*4223+."vjg"eqooqp"Ýpfkpi"ycu"hqt"ueqtgu"qh"dncem"Chtkecpu"vq"dg"nqygt"vjcp"vjqug"qh"qvjgt"vguvgf"itqwru0"Yjgp"dncem"wpkxgtukv{"uvwfgpvu"ueqtg"KSu"kp"vjg":2u"qt";2u."vjg"kpxguvkicvqtu"kphgt"vjcv"vjg"cxgtcig"dncem"Chtkecp"KS"owuv"dg"qpg"qt"vyq"uvcpfctf"fgxkcvkqpu"nqygt0

VJG"UWTXG[U"D["N[PP"CPF"D["N[PP"CPF"XCPJCPGPVjku"ugevkqp"fgcnu"ykvj"vjg"vyq"gctnkgt"uwtxg{u"ekvgf"d{"Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp0"N{pp"*3;;3+"tgrqtvu"qp"33"Chtkecp"ucorngu."cnn"dwv"vyq"qh"yjkej"ctg"kpenwfgf"kp"vjg"4224"uwtxg{"d{"N{pp"cpf"Xcpjcpgp0"N{pp"cpf"Xcpjcpgp." kp" vwtp."tgrqtv"qp"44"Chtkecp"ucorngu."qpn{"qpg"qh"yjkej"ycu"ekvgf"d{"Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp0"Vjg"44"uvwfkgu."cv"ngcuv"36"qh"yjkej"wugf"Rtqitguukxg"Ocvtkegu."ygtg"rwdnkujgf"dgvyggp"3;4;" cpf"42220"Vjg{"cff"nkvvng"vq"vjg"Ýpfkpiu"cntgcf{"fkuewuugf."dwv"c"hgy"qh"vjgo."qh"kpvgtguv"hqt"qpg"tgcuqp"qt"cpqvjgt."yknn"dg"fguetkdgf"dtkgÞ{0"Hktuv."jqygxgt."yg"pqvg"c"uvtkmkpi"qokuukqp"htqo"N{ppÓu"3;;3"uwtxg{0

Kp"c" vcdwnct" uwooct{"qh" ÒOgcp" KSu"qh"xctkqwu"Pgitqkf"rqrwncvkqpuÓ" *r0"489+."N{pp"kpfkecvgu"vjcv"3"233"¥codkcp"cfwnvu."vguvgf"ykvj"vjg"Rtqitguukxg"Ocvtkegu."jcf"c"ogcp"KS"qh"970"Vjg"ekvgf"uqwteg"ku"vyq/hqnf<"ÒRqpu."3;96="Etcyhqtf"Pwvv."3;980Ó"Vjg"tghgtgpeg"ugevkqp"qh"N{ppÓu"tgxkgy"fqgu"ekvg"cp"wprwdnkujgf"rcrgt"rtgugpvgf"d{"Rqpu"vq"vjg"3;96"Eqpitguu"qh"vjg"Uqwvj"Chtkecp"Ru{ejqnqikecn"Cuuqekcvkqp"Î"dwv"fqgu"pqv"ekvg"cp{"yqtm"d{"c"Etcyhqtf"Pwvv0"Kp"hcev."kp"3;98"Etcyhqtf/Pwvv"fkf"tgrqtv"c"uvwf{"ecttkgf"qwv"kp"Uqwvj"Chtkec0"Kp"vjcv"rwdnkujgf"rcrgt"Etcyhqtf/Pwvv"kpenwfgf"c"vcdng"htqo"RqpuÓu"3;96"rtgugpvcvkqp"vq"vjg"eqpitguu0"Rqpu"jcf"fgoqpuvtcvgf"vjcv"

Ngqp"L0"Mcokp Chtkecp"KS"cpf"ogpvcn"tgvctfcvkqp

Page 6: Leon J. Kamin - African IQ and Mental Retardation

8

Ngqp"L0"Mcokp Chtkecp"KS"cpf"ogpvcn"tgvctfcvkqp

c"oqfkÝgf"ogvjqf"qh" rtgugpvcvkqp" qh" vjg"URO."jgnrkpi" vjg" vguvgg" vq" wpfgtuvcpf"yjcv"yqwnf"dg"tgswktgf"kp"vjg"vguv."rtqfwegf"jkijgt"ueqtgu"coqpi"¥codkcp"eqrrgt""okpgtu0"Ykvj"uvcpfctf"kpuvtwevkqpu."vjg"ogcp"pwodgt"qh"eqttgev"tgurqpugu"ycu"450"Ykvj"c"pgy"ucorng"qh"3"233"okpgtu."vjg"oqfkÝgf"rtgugpvcvkqp"rtqfwegf"c"ogcp"qh"56""eqttgev"tgurqpugu0"N{pp."vcmkpi"vjg"Rqpu"fcvc"htqo"Etcyhqtf/PwvvÓu"rcrgt."eqpxgtvgf"56"eqttgev"tgurqpugu"vq"cp"KS"qh"970

N{pp"eqorngvgn{"kipqtgf"vjg"qtkikpcn"tgugctej"tgrqtvgf"kp"Etcyhqtf/PwvvÓu"rcrgt0"Etcyhqtf/Pwvv."wukpi"vjg"ucog"rtgugpvcvkqp"ogvjqf"cu"Rqpu."vguvgf"44:"Uqygvq"jkij"uejqqn"uvwfgpvu"ykvj"vjg"URO0"Vjgkt"ogcp"pwodgt"qh"eqttgev"tgurqpugu"ycu"67."yjkej"Etcyhqtf/Pwvv"eqorctgf"vq"vjg"ogcp"qh"66"qdvckpgf"d{"vjg"ucog"cig"itqwr"kp"vjg"yjkvg"uvcpfctfkucvkqp"ucorng0"Jg"ytqvg"*r0"426+<"Òvjg"htgswgpvn{"tgrqtvgf"fkhhgtgpeg"dgvyggp"dncemu"cpf"yjkvgu"vguvgf"qp"vjku"vguv"fkf"pqv"qeewtÓ0"N{pp."tgcfkpi"Etcyhqtf/PwvvÓu"rcrgt."ejqug"vq"tgrqtv"vjg"Rqpu"wprwdnkujgf"Ýpfkpi"*KS"97"coqpi"¥codkcp"okpgtu+"cpf"vq"kipqtg"Etcyhqtf/PwvvÓu"rwdnkujgf"Ýpfkpi"*322"coqpi"Uqygvq"uvwfgpvu+0"Jg"vjgp"pgingevgf"vq"kpenwfg"Etcyhqtf/PwvvÓu"rcrgt"kp"jku"tghgtgpeg"nkuv0

N{pp"cpf"Xcpjcpgp"*4224+"ekvg"c"uvwf{"d{"Hgtpcpfg¦/Dcnnguvgtqu."fg"Lwcp/Gurkpquc."Eqnqo"cpf"Ecngtq"*3;;9+"cu"fgoqpuvtcvkpi"vjcv"vjg"Òpcvkqpcn"KSÓ"qh"Gswcvqtkcn"Iwkpgc"ku"7;0"N{pp"cpf"Xcpjcpgp"ytkvg"*r0"425+<"ÒCtqwpf"3;:6."fcvc"hqt"6:"32/"vq"36/{gct/qnfu"ygtg"eqnngevgf"qp"vjg"YKUE/T"0"0"0"Vjgkt"KS"ycu"850"Dgecwug"qh"vjg"34/{gct"kpvgtxcn"dgvyggp"vjg"vyq"fcvc"eqnngevkqpu."vjku"pggfu"vq"dg"tgfwegf"vq"7;0Ó"N{pp"cpf"Xcpjcpgp"gpvgt"7;"cu"vjg"xcnwg"hqt"Gswcvqtkcn"Iwkpgc"kp"c"vcdng"*r0"359+"tgncvkpi"ÒPcvkqpcn"KSu"cpf"Geqpqoke"Fgxgnqrogpv" kp"3:7"EqwpvtkguÓ0"Gswcvqtkcn"IwkpgcÓu"cduwtfn{" nqy"pcvkqpcn"KS"ku"ocvejgf"d{"c"eqttgurqpfkpin{"xgt{"nqy"rgt"ecrkvc"kpeqog0

Kp"hcev."Hgtpcpfg¦/Dcnnguvgtqu"gv"cn0"*3;;9+."cvvgorvkpi"vq"ugg"yjgvjgt"c"eqipkvkxg"vtckpkpi"rtqitcoog"eqwnf"kpetgcug"URO"ueqtgu"*kv"fkf+."fguetkdgf"vyq"gzrgtkogpvu0"KSu"kp"gcej"ygtg"cuuguugf"d{"vjg"YKUE0"Vjg{"fguetkdg"*r0"475+"c"Òugeqpf"gzrgtkogpv"ykvj" hqtv{/gkijv"uwdlgevu."32/" vq"36/{gct"qnfu."cvvgpfkpi"c"uejqqn" hqt"jcpfkecrrgf"ejknftgp"*850247"KS"Ogcp+Ó0"Jcnh"qh"vjg"6:"uwdlgevu"jcf"dggp"enkpkecnn{"fkcipqugf"cu"Òqticpkecnn{"korcktgfÓ="vjg"qvjgt"jcnh"ygtg"fguetkdgf"cu"Òewnvwtcnn{"fgrtkxgfÓ0"N{pp"cpf"Xcpjcpgp"vqqm"vjg"ogcp"KS"cv"c"uejqqn"hqt"vjg"jcpfkecrrgf"cpf"dtckp"fcocigf"cu"c"ogcuwtg"qh"cp"Chtkecp"eqwpvt{Óu"pcvkqpcn"KS#"Vjg{"okijv"lwuv"cu"ygnn"jcxg"guvk/ocvgf"Gswcvqtkcn"IwkpgcÓu"pcvkqpcn"KS"htqo"vjg"nctigt"Ýtuv"gzrgtkogpv"qh"Hgtpcpfg¦/"Dcnnguvgtqu"gv"cn0"*3;;9+."fguetkdgf"kp"vjg"ucog"rctcitcrj"cu"vjg"ugeqpf0"Vjg"Ýtuv"gzrgtkogpv"kpxqnxgf";2"ejknftgp"htqo"Ògfwecvkqpcn"egpvtgu"hqt"ewnvwtcnn{"fgrtkxgf"ejknftgpÓ0"Vjktv{"uwdlgevu"jcf"KSu"dgvyggp"337"cpf";2."vjktv{"jcf"KSu"dgvyggp":;"cpf":2"cpf"vjktv{"jcf"KSu"dgvyggp"9;"cpf"92"Î"c"ucorng"ogfkcp"qh"cdqwv":70

Vjg"qnfguv"uvwf{"ekvgf"kp"vjg"tgxkgyu"ycu"d{"Hkem"*3;4;+"kp"Uqwvj"Chtkec0"N{pp"*3;;3."r0"494+"fguetkdgf"HkemÓu"yqtm"cu"Òvjg"Ýtuv"iqqf"uvwf{"qh"vjg"kpvgnnkigpeg"qh"rwtg"Chtkecp"PgitqkfuÓ0"¥wnw"ejknftgp"cigf"cdqwv"32"vq"36"{gctu."vguvgf"qp"vjg"Cogtkecp"Cto{"Dgvc"Vguv."jcf"cp"KS"qh"87."ceeqtfkpi"vq"Cogtkecp"pqtou0"Vjg"pqp/xgtdcn"Dgvc"vguv"cumu"vguvggu."coqpi"qvjgt"kvgou."vq"pqvg"vjg"cdugpeg"kp"c"ftcykpi"qh"c"pgv"dgvyggp"

Page 7: Leon J. Kamin - African IQ and Mental Retardation

"9

vyq"kpfkxkfwcnu"rnc{kpi"vgppku0"Kp"cpqvjgt"ftcykpi"vjg"vguvggg"owuv"pqvg"vjg"cdugpeg"qh"c"dcnn"kp"vjg"jcpf"qh"c"ocp"uvcpfkpi"cv"vjg"jgcf"qh"c"dqynkpi"cnng{0"Kp"uvknn"cpqvjgt"kvgo."ftcykpiu"fgrkevkpi"ugswgpvkcn"cevkqpu"kp"c"icog"qh"dcugdcnn"owuv"dg"cttcpigf"kp"vjg"eqttgev"qtfgt0"Hkem"pqvgf"vjcv"uqog"kvgou"Òctg"pqv"swkvg"hckt"vq"vjg"pcvkxg"ejknfÓ."dwv"vjku"fkf"pqv"rtgxgpv"jko"htqo"ecnewncvkpi"¥wnw"KSu"kp"vjku"ÒÝtuv"iqqf"uvwf{Ó"qh"Chtkecp"KS0

Hcjo{"*3;86+."kp"Uwfcp."cnuq"hqwpf"nqy"vguv"rgthqtocpeg"d{"uejqqnejknftgp0"Jg"fguetkdgf"qpg/tqqogf"uejqqnu"ykvj"pq"dqqmu."fgumu."qt"gswkrogpv0"Ejknftgp"ucv"qp"vjg"itqwpf."nkuvgpkpi"vq"wpkpvgtguvgf"cpf"kpcfgswcvgn{"vtckpgf"vgcejgtu0"Jcxg"ru{ejqnq/ikuvu"yjq"tgictf"vjg"tguwnvu"qh"KS"vguvkpi"wpfgt"uwej"eqpfkvkqpu"cu"c"ogcuwtg"qh"vjg"kpvgnngevwcn"ecrcekv{"qh"c"tceg"qh"jwocpmkpf"vcmgp"ngcxg"qh"vjgkt"ugpuguA

Vjg"uvwfkgu"tgxkgygf"cdqxg"jcxg"c"engct"qwveqog0"Yjgp"ru{ejqnqikuvu"uwdlgev"dncem"Chtkecpu"vq"uvcpfctf"KS"vguvkpi."vjg"Chtkecpu."eqorctgf"ykvj"vjg"Yguvgtp"rqrw/ncvkqpu"qp"yjkej"vjg"vguvu"jcxg"dggp"uvcpfctfkugf."fq"pqv"cpuygt"cu"ocp{"swguvkqpu"eqttgevn{0"Itcpvgf"vjg"gpxktqpogpvcn"eqpfkvkqpu"vq"yjkej"Yguvgtpgtu"cpf"Chtkecpu"jcxg"dggp"gzrqugf"cpf"vjg"fkhhgtgpegu"dgvyggp"vjgkt"ewnvwtgu."uwej"cp"qwveqog"ku"uectegn{"uwtrtkukpi0"Jqy"ocp{"Chtkecp"uwdlgevu."hcknkpi"vq"igv"vjg"jcpi"qh"vjg"wphcoknkct"vguv/kpi"ocvgtkcnu."ocmg"qpn{"Òc"iguvwtg"qh"eqornkcpegÓA"Vjg"ueqtg"fkhhgtgpeg"ecppqv"dg"cvvtkdwvgf"vq"c"igpgvke"ghhgev0"Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp."jqygxgt."pqv"qpn{"kpxqmg"igpgvke"ecwucvkqp0"Hwnn{"cyctg"vjcv"vjgkt"encko"yknn"ecwug"etkvkeu"vq"fkurwvg"vjg"xcnkfkv{"qh"vjg"vguvu."vjg{"cuugtv"vjcv"vjg"cxgtcig"KS"qh"dncem"Chtkecpu"ku"920

KFGQNQI["CPF"CHTKECP"KSTcxgpÓu" vguv" ku"qhvgp" tgictfgf"cu"cp"gzegnngpv"ogcuwtg"qh" vjg"igpgtcn" kpvgnnkigpeg"hcevqt."i0"Vjwu"N{pp"ytkvgu"*3;;3."r0"47;+<"ÒIgpgtcn"kpvgnnkigpeg"ku"eqpegrvwcnkugf"cu"UrgctocpÓu"i."vjg"igpgtcn"hcevqt"kp"cnn"eqipkvkxg"vcumu"cpf"oquv"ghhgevkxgn{"ogcuwtgf"d{"vguvu"qh"tgcuqpkpi"cdknkv{"uwej"cu"TcxgpÓu"Rtqitguukxg"Ocvtkegu"0"0"0Ó

Vjg"tgugctej"ekvgf"d{"N{pp."cpf"d{"Twujvqp"cpf"Lgpugp"ku"vjwu"vcmgp"d{"vjqug"cwvjqtu"vq"fgoqpuvtcvg"vjcv"Chtkecpu"ctg"ugxgtgn{"fgÝekgpv"kp"kpvgnnkigpeg"cpf"tgcuqp/kpi"cdknkv{0"Dwv"kv"ku"qh"kpvgtguv"vq"pqvg"jqy"N{pp"*3;:9+"jcf"tgurqpfgf"vq"Hn{ppÓu"*3;:9+"fgoqpuvtcvkqp"qh"ocuukxg"ickpu"kp"URO"ueqtgu"ocfg"d{"uweeguukxg"eqjqtvu"qh""3:/{gct/qnfu"kp"Gwtqrgcp"eqwpvtkgu."oquv"pqvcdn{"kp"Jqnncpf0"N{pp"*3;:9+"ytqvg<

Vjgug"tgswktgogpvu"hqt"c"ewnvwtg/hckt"vguv"ctg"hct"htqo"dgkpi"ogv"d{"vjg"Rtqitguukxg"Ocvtkegu"0"0"0"Vjg"vguvgg"jcu"vq"fgekrjgt"vjg"eqfg"cpf"vjgp"uqnxg"vjg"rtqitguukqp"rtqdngo0"Vjgug"nctign{"ctkvjogvkecn"umknnu"ctg"qh"eqwtug"vcwijv"kp"uejqqnu0"Fwvej"cfqnguegpvu"kp"vjg"3;:2u"jcxg"gplq{gf"ukipkÝecpvn{"oqtg"uejqqnkpi"vjcp"vjgkt"eqwpvgtrctvu"kp"vjg"ncvg"3;62u"cpf"pq"fqwdv"vjg{"jcxg"rkemgf"wr"c"hgy"oqtg"ctkvjogvkecn"umknnu"kpenwfkpi"vjqug"tgswktgf"hqt"uqnxkpi"rtqitguukqp"rtqdngou"0"0"0"Vjg"qpn{"rquukdng"rtqegfwtg"ku"vq"wug"c"igpwkpg"ewnvwtg/hckt"vguv"cpf"pqv"vguvu"nkmg"Tcxgpu"cpf"Ygejungt"eqpvcokpcvgf"ykvj"gfwecvkqpcn"umknnu0"*r0"688+""""

Hqwt"{gctu"chvgt"ocmkpi"vjgug"eqigpv"qdugtxcvkqpu."N{pp"fkf"pqv"vjkpm"vq"eqorctg"Chtkecp"cpf"Fwvej"uejqqnkpi"yjgp"eqpenwfkpi"vjcv"nqy"Chtkecp"KS."cu"cuuguugf"d{"vjg"Tcxgp"cpf"Ygejungt"vguvu."jcf"c"igpgvke"dcuku0

Ngqp"L0"Mcokp Chtkecp"KS"cpf"ogpvcn"tgvctfcvkqp

Page 8: Leon J. Kamin - African IQ and Mental Retardation

:

Ngqp"L0"Mcokp Chtkecp"KS"cpf"ogpvcn"tgvctfcvkqp

Vjg"kfgqnqikecn"wug"vq"yjkej"vjg"cduwtf"encko"qh"Chtkecp"ogpvcn"tgvctfcvkqp"ngpfu"kvugnh"ku"knnwuvtcvgf"kp"vjg"N{pp"cpf"Xcpjcpgp"tgxkgy"*4224+0"Vjg{"ytkvg<

Jkvjgtvq"vjgqtkgu"qh"geqpqoke"fgxgnqrogpv"jcxg"dggp"dcugf"qp"vjg"rtguworvkqp"vjcv"vjg"rtgu/gpv"icru"dgvyggp"tkej"cpf"rqqt"eqwpvtkgu"ctg"qpn{"vgorqtct{"cpf"vjcv"vjg{"ctg"fwg"vq"xctkqwu"gpxktqpogpvcn"eqpfkvkqpu"0"0" 0"Kv"jcu"cnuq"dggp"cuuwogf"vjcv"cnn"jwocp"rqrwncvkqpu"jcxg"gswcn"ogpvcn"cdknkvkgu"0" 0" 0"Vjku"rtguworvkqp"ku"hwpfcogpvcnn{"okuvcmgp0"Dgecwug"qh"vjg"gxkfgpeg"yg"jcxg"cuugodngf"hqt"c"ecwucn"tgncvkqpujkr"dgvyggp"pcvkqpcn"KSÓu"cpf"geqpqoke"fkurctkvkgu."kv"jcu"vq" dg" ceegrvgf" vjcv" vjgtg"yknn" kpgxkvcdn{" dg" c" eqpvkpwcvkqp"qh" geqpqoke" kpgswcnkvkgu" dgvyggp" "pcvkqpu0" Kpvgnnkigpeg"fkhhgtgpegu"dgvyggp"pcvkqpu"yknn"dg" korquukdng" vq"gtcfkecvg"dgecwug" vjg{"jcxg"c"igpgvke"dcuku"0"0"0"*r0"3;7+

Chtkecpu"ygtg"cv"ngpivj"cdng"vq"ujcmg"qhh"Yguvgtp"eqnqpkcnkuvu0"Rgtjcru"vjg"fc{"yknnuqqp"eqog"yjgp"vjg{"ujcmg"qhh"uwej"Yguvgtp"KS"vguvgtu0

CEMPQYNGFIGOGPVK"ykuj"vq"vjcpm"Rtqhguuqt"Ctvjwt"U0"Iqnfdgtigt"hqt"jku"ocp{"jgnrhwn"uwiiguvkqpu0

TGHGTGPEGUEtcyhqtf/Pwvv."F0J0"*3;98+0"Ctg"dncem"ueqtgu"qp"TcxgpÓu"Uvcpfctf"Rtqitguukxg"Ocvtkegu"cp"

ctvghcev"qh"ogvjqf"qh"vguv"rtgugpvcvkqpA"Ru{ejqnqikc"Chtkecpc."38."423Î4280Hcjo{."O0"*3;86+0"Kpkvkcn"gzrnqtkpi"qh"vjg"kpvgnnkigpeg"qh"Ujknnwm"ejknftgp0"Xkvc"Jwocpc."9."

386Î3990Hcjtogkgt."G0F0"*3;97+0"Vjg"ghhgev"qh"uejqqn"cvvgpfcpeg"qp"kpvgnngevwcn"fgxgnqrogpv"kp"pqtvjgtp"

Pkigtkc0"Ejknf"Fgxgnqrogpv."68."4:3Î4:70Hgtpcpfg¦/Dcnnguvgtqu." T0." fg" Lwcp/Gurkpquc."O0." Eqnqo."T0."("Ecngtq."O0F0" *3;;9+0"

Eqpvgzvwcn"cpf"rgtuqpcn"uqwtegu"qh"kpfkxkfwcn"fkhhgtgpegu"kp"kpvgnnkigpeg<"gorktkecn"tguwnvu0"Kp"L0U0"Ectnuqp."L0"Mkpioc."("Y0"Vqoke"*Gfu0+."Cfxcpegu"kp"eqipkvkqp"cpf"gfwecvkqpcn"rtcevkeg"*Xqn0"6+"*rr0"443Î496+0"Itggpykej."EV<"LCK"Rtguu0

Hkem."O0N0"*3;4;+0"Kpvgnnkigpeg"vguv"tguwnvu"qh"rqqt"yjkvg."pcvkxg"*¥wnw+."eqnqwtgf"cpf"Kpfkcp"uejqqn" ejknftgp" cpf" vjg" uqekcn" cpf" gfwecvkqpcn" kornkecvkqpu0"Uqwvj"Chtkecp" Lqwtpcn" qh"Uekgpeg."48.";26Î;420

Hn{pp."L0T0"*3;:9+0"Ocuukxg"KS"ickpu"kp"36"pcvkqpu<"Yjcv"KS"vguvu"tgcnn{"ogcuwtg0"Ru{ejqnqikecn"Dwnngvkp."323."393Î3;30

Ingyyg."R0."("Lceqd{."J0"*3;;4+0"Guvkocvkpi"vjg"fgvgtokpcpvu"qh"eqipkvkxg"cejkgxgogpv"kp"nqy"kpeqog"eqwpvtkgu0"Ycujkpivqp<"Yqtnf"Dcpm0

Itkgxg."M0Y0."("Xknlqgp."U0"*4222+0"Cp"gzrnqtcvqt{"uvwf{"qh"vjg"wug"qh"vjg"Cwuvkp"Oc¦g"kp"Uqwvj"Chtkec0"Uqwvj"Chtkecp"Lqwtpcn"qh"Ru{ejqnqi{."52."36Î3:0

N{pp."T0" *3;:9+0" Lcrcp<"Ncpf" qh" vjg" tkukpi" KS0"C" tgrn{" vq"Hn{pp0"Dwnngvkp" qh" vjg"Dtkvkuj"Ru{ejqnqikecn"Uqekgv{."62."686Î68:0

Ï0"*3;;3+0"Tceg"fkhhgtgpegu" kp" kpvgnnkigpeg<"c"inqdcn"rgturgevkxg0"Ocpmkpf"Swctvgtn{."53."477Î4;80

N{pp."T0."("Xcpjcpgp."V0"*4224+0"KS"cpf"vjg"ygcnvj"qh"pcvkqpu0"Yguvrqtv."EV<"Rtcgigt0Pgnn."X0"*4222+0"Etquu/ewnvwtcn"pgwtqru{ejqnqikecn"cuuguuogpv<"Vjgqt{"cpf"rtcevkeg0"Ocjycj<"

Gtndcwo0

Page 9: Leon J. Kamin - African IQ and Mental Retardation

";

Pkuugp."J0Y0."Ocejqxgt."U0."("Mkpfgt."G0H0"*3;57+0"C"uvwf{"qh"rgthqtocpeg"vguvu"ikxgp"vq"c"itqwr"qh"pcvkxg"Chtkecp"Pgitq"ejknftgp0"Dtkvkuj"Lqwtpcn"qh"Ru{ejqnqi{."47."52:Î5570

Qygp."M0"*3;;4+0"Vjg"uwkvcdknkv{"qh"TcxgpÓu"Rtqitguukxg"Ocvtkegu"hqt"xctkqwu"itqwru"kp"Uqwvj"Chtkec0"Rgtuqpcnkv{"cpf"Kpfkxkfwcn"Fkhhgtgpegu."35."36;Î37;0

Tcxgp."L0."Uwoogtu."D0."DktejÝgnf."O0."Dtqukgt."I0."Dwtekcic."N0."D{mtkv."D0."gv"cn0"*3;;2+0"Ocpwcn"hqt"TcxgpÓu"Rtqitguukxg"Ocvtkegu"cpf"Xqecdwnct{"Uecngu"Î"Tgugctej"uwrrngogpv<"Pq0"50"Cogtkecp"cpf"kpvgtpcvkqpcn"pqtou"*4pf"gf0+0"Qzhqtf."Gpincpf<"Qzhqtf"Ru{ejqnqikuvu"Rtguu0

Twujvqp."L0R0."("Lgpugp."C0T0"*4227+0"Vjktv{"{gctu"qh"tgugctej"qp"tceg"fkhhgtgpegu"kp"eqipkvkxg"cdknkv{0"Ru{ejqnqi{."Rwdnke"Rqnke{"cpf"Ncy."33."457Î4;60

Twujvqp."L0R0."("Umw{."O0"*4222+0"Rgthqtocpeg"qp"TcxgpÓu"Ocvtkegu"d{"Chtkecp"cpf"Yjkvg"wpkxgtukv{"uvwfgpvu"kp"Uqwvj"Chtkec0"Kpvgnnkigpeg."4:."473Î4870

Twujvqp."L0R0."Umw{."O0."("Htkfljqp."R0" *4224+0"Lgpugp"Ghhgevu"coqpi"Chtkecp." Kpfkcp"cpf"Yjkvg"gpikpggtkpi"uvwfgpvu"kp"Uqwvj"Chtkec"qp"TcxgpÓu"Uvcpfctf"Rtqitguukxg"Ocvtkegu0"Kpvgnnkigpeg."52."62;Î6450

Ï0"*4225+0"Rgthqtocpeg"qp"TcxgpÓu"Cfxcpegf"Rtqitguukxg"Ocvtkegu"d{"Chtkecp."Gcuv"Kpfkcp"cpf"Yjkvg"gpikpggtkpi"uvwfgpvu"kp"Uqwvj"Chtkec0"Kpvgnnkigpeg."53."345Î3590

Umw{."O0."Igygt."C0."Qutkp."[0."Mjwpqw."F0."Htkfljqp."R0."("Twujvqp."L0R0" *4224+0"Ghhgevu"qh"ogfkcvgf"ngctpkpi"gzrgtkgpeg"qp"TcxgpÓu"ocvtkegu"ueqtgu"qh"Chtkecp"cpf"pqp/Chtkecp"wpkxgtukv{"uvwfgpvu"kp"Uqwvj"Chtkec0"Kpvgnnkigpeg."52."443Î4540

Umw{."O0." Uejwvvg." G0." Htkfljqp." R0."("QÓEcttqnn." U0" *4223+0" Uwkvcdknkv{" qh" rwdnkujgf"pgwtqru{ejqnqikecn"vguv"pqtou"hqt"wtdcp"Chtkecp"ugeqpfct{"uejqqn"uvwfgpvu"kp"Uqwvj"Chtkec0"Rgtuqpcnkv{"cpf"Kpfkxkfwcn"Fkhhgtgpegu."52."3635Î36470

Uvgtpdgti."T0L0."Pqmgu."E0."Igkuungt."R0Y0."Rtkpeg."T0."Qmcvejc."H0."Dwpf{."F0C0."("Itkiqtgpmq."G0N0"*4223+0"Vjg"tgncvkqpujkr"dgvyggp"cecfgoke"cpf"rtcevkecn"kpvgnnkigpeg<"c"ecug"uvwf{"kp"Mgp{c0"Kpvgnnkigpeg."4;."623Î63:0

¥cckocp."J0."xcp"fgt"Hnkgt."J0."("Vjklu."I0F0"*4223+0"F{pcoke"vguvkpi"kp"ugngevkqp"hqt"cp"gfwecvkqpcn" rtqitco<"Cuuguukpi"Uqwvj"Chtkecp"rgthqtocpeg"qp" vjg"Tcxgp"Rtqitguukxg"Ocvtkegu0"Kpvgtpcvkqpcn"Lqwtpcn"qh"Ugngevkqp"cpf"Cuuguuogpv.";."47:Î48;.

¥kpfk."H0"*3;;6+0"Fkhhgtgpegu"kp"ru{ejqogvtke"rgthqtocpeg0"Vjg"Ru{ejqnqikuv."9."76;Î7740

Ngqp"L0"Mcokp Chtkecp"KS"cpf"ogpvcn"tgvctfcvkqp