View
749
Download
0
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Citation preview
Nonprofit Organizations in the Digital Commons Environment
Jyh-An LeeWhen Cultures Encounters Internet
Dec. 15, 2010
Introduction• Research Question• Methodology• Contribution to Scholarship• NPOs in the Commons Environment• NPO Theories• Associating NPOs with the Commons
Environment• Conclusion
information economy
2 economies
proprietary economy
financial gain
IP = exclusion
commons economy
permission free
social movements
� free/open source software movement
� free/open source software movement
� open access movement
� free/open source software movement
� open access movement� open educational resources
(OER) movement
� free/open source software movement
� open access movement� open educational resources
(OER) movement� free culture movement
Three Sectors� Government
� Business
� NPO
proprietary economy
commons economy
government PTO, IP rules research, OSS
business proprietary owners Red Hat, IBM
NPOs BMI, ASCAP CC, FSF, PLoS
proprietary economy
commons economy
government PTO, IP rules research, OSS
business proprietary owners Red Hat, IBM
NPOs BMI, ASCAP CC, FSF, PLoS
proprietary economy
commons economy
government PTO, IP rules research, OSS
business proprietary owners Red Hat, IBM
NPOs BMI, ASCAP CC, FSF, PLoS
proprietary economy
commons economy
government PTO, IP rules research, OSS
business proprietary owners Red Hat, IBM
NPOs BMI, ASCAP CC, FSF, PLoS
proprietary economy
commons economy
government PTO, IP rules research, OSS
business proprietary owners Red Hat, IBM
NPOs BMI, ASCAP CC, FSF, PLoS
proprietary economy
commons economy
government PTO, IP rules research, OSS
business proprietary owners Red Hat, IBM
NPOs BMI, ASCAP CC, FSF, PLoS
What is NPO?
non-distribution constraint
“third sector” or “voluntary sector”
• Introduction Research Question• Methodology• Contribution to Scholarship• NPOs in the Commons Environment• NPO Theories• Associating NPOs with the Commons
Environment• Conclusion
Environmental movement
Environmental movementCultural environmentalism
“The public domain should have its
Greenpeace, its Environmental Defense Fund, its Nature Conservancy, its Environmentally Concerned Scientists.”
“The public domain should have its
Greenpeace, its Environmental Defense Fund, its Nature Conservancy, its Environmentally Concerned Scientists.”
How NPOs crafted the intellectual-commons environment
in the digital world?
� What are the NPOs in the commons environment?
� Why they matter?� Can current NPO theories explain
this phenomenon?� Why commons environment is an
ideal milieu for NPOs to flourish?
• Introduction• Research QuestionMethodology• Contribution to Scholarship• NPOs in the Commons Environment• NPO Theories• Associating NPOs with the Commons
Environment• Conclusion
� academic literature� news� NPO website� 26 in-depth interviews (from
19 NPOs and 3 for-profits)
sources
theoretical framework
� commons theories
theoretical framework
� commons theories� NPO theories
theoretical framework
� commons theories� NPO theories� other theories
� theory of collective action� theory of the firm� theory of altruism
• Introduction• Research Question• MethodologyContribution to Scholarship• NPOs in the Commons Environment• NPO Theories• Associating NPOs with the Commons
Environment• Conclusion
� filling the gap in mainstream IP scholarship
� filling the gap in mainstream IP scholarship
� testing NPO theories in a new setting
� filling the gap in mainstream IP scholarship
� testing NPO theories in a new setting
� new lens to understand the intellectual-commons environment
• Introduction• Research Question• Methodology• Contribution to ScholarshipNPOs in the Commons Environment• NPO Theories• Associating NPOs with the Commons
Environment• Conclusion
<1> social norms and licensing terms
<2> organizational support for peer-production projects
F/OSS Foundations
managing property rights transacting with other entities providing collective decision-making
mechanism protecting individuals from liabilities
<3> legal support
<4> political advocacy
<5> information access & repositories
<6> public-interest grant-making
-
-
-
• Introduction• Research Question• Methodology• Contribution to Scholarship• NPOs in the Commons EnvironmentNPO Theories• Associating NPOs with the Commons
Environment• Conclusion
<1> contract failure theory
Henry Hansmann
Henry Hansmann
NPOs function as a trusted channel when donors of specific services or goods and recipients have no connections with each other.
Donors Recipients
contract failure
Donors RecipientsNPOs
contract failure
applications
applications
typical application: donation to commons community
applications
typical application: donation to commons community
new application: donors = contributors of intellectual resources
<1> access failure
<1> access failure
<1> access failure
publishing
copyright
<1> access failure
<1> access failure
<1> access failure
<1> access failure
content
$$$
<1> access failure
In the past ten years 220%~752%
<1> access failure
<1> access failure
<2> collaborative failure
problem of collective action
<2> collaborative failure
<2> collaborative failure
less likely to impair diverse interests
<2> collaborative failure
less likely to impair diverse interests
only in large projects complexity / scale enough resources
<3> licensing failure
<3> licensing failure
potential users potential copyright infringement concerns high transaction costs
<3> licensing failure
potential users potential copyright infringement concerns high transaction costs
creators high legal fees
theory implications (1)
trust hypothesis / trust theory
theory implications (1)
trust hypothesis / trust theory from the interviews
trust credibility independence neutrality
theory implications (2)
convention wisdom:
The Internet eliminates middlemen and organizations
F/OSS is a production process without organization
“OSS is not sustainable because it has no formal governance mechanism.”
Richard A. Epstein
limit of contract failure theory
assumption: consumers distrust for-profit hard to explain the existence of NPOs
involved in promoting social norms, lobbying activities
<2> government and market failure theory
Burton A. Weisbrod
NPOs, emerge to meet an unsatisfied demand for public goods due to both market failure and government failure.
government and market failure theory
assumptions:
because government can only satisfy majority interest
for the minority interests that cannot be satisfied by the government and the market, people turn to NPOs for certain public goods.
applications
current IP laws legislative process contract failure under-provision over-exclusion
theory implications (1)
social experimentation
government: not allowed to conduct policy experiment
theory implications (1)
social experimentation
government: not allowed to conduct policy experiment
NPO can help to fulfill the role of experimenter for future policymaking
theory implications (1)
social experimentation
examples: Hewlett Foundation Creative Commons
theory implications (2)
the neglected interests of individuals
Peter Frumkin: “ “[n]onprofit and voluntary action expresses a
complex desire to defend the pursuit of private individual aspirations.”
theory implications (2)
the neglected interests of individuals the history of copyright laws
theory implications (2)
the neglected interests of individuals the history of copyright laws NPOs in the commons environment
representing individual interest emphasizing on individual values
limits of government and market failure theory
government failure Weisbrod:
government satisfies majority interests but fails to responds to minority interests
commons NPO & IP scholars: government is captured by the copyright industry
and fails to protect the majority
limits of government and market failure theory
Larry Lessig:“around 85 percent of the citizens is
inappropriately ignored in the copyright legislation”
limits of government and market failure theory
market failure the role of proprietary companies
limits of government and market failure theory
NPOs serve as vehicles for for-profits to provide public goods to access the voluntary contributions
• Introduction• Research Question• Methodology• Contribution to Scholarship• NPOs in the Commons Environment• NPO TheoriesAssociating NPOs with the Commons
Environment• Conclusion
<1> gift economy
<2> information community
<3> demand revelation
• Introduction• Research Question• Methodology• Contribution to Scholarship• NPOs in the Commons Environment• NPO Theories• Associating NPOs with the Commons
EnvironmentConclusion
NPOs provide indispensable social infrastructure for commons production
current NPO theories help us to understand NPOs’ role in the commons environment, but these theories have their own limit
compared to the nature of for-profits and government, the nature of NPOs is more consistent with commons-environment culture
Thank you!! 1/2 Commons and Suggestions 2