31
Lecture 2 Foundations of Finance 0 Lecture 2: Equities: Markets I. Reading. II. Primary Equity Markets in the U.S.. III. Terminology. IV. Types of Orders: V. Secondary Equity Markets in the U.S.. VI. Trading on the NYSE. VII. Discussion VIII. Decimalization. Lecture 2-3: Stock Positions and Portfolio Return I. Reading. II. Return Calculation and Dividends. III. Stock Positions. A. Example. B. Long the Stock. C. Buying Stock on Margin. D. Short Selling Stock E. Comparison IV. Portfolio Return Formula

Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2 Foundations of Finance

0

Lecture 2: Equities: Markets

I. Reading.II. Primary Equity Markets in the U.S..III. Terminology.IV. Types of Orders:V. Secondary Equity Markets in the U.S..VI. Trading on the NYSE.VII. DiscussionVIII. Decimalization.

Lecture 2-3: Stock Positions and Portfolio Return

I. Reading.II. Return Calculation and Dividends. III. Stock Positions.

A. Example.B. Long the Stock.C. Buying Stock on Margin.D. Short Selling StockE. Comparison

IV. Portfolio Return Formula

Page 2: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2 Foundations of Finance

1

Lecture 2: Equities: Markets

I. Reading.A. BKM Chapter 2: Sections 2.3-2.4.B. BKM Chapter 3: Sections 3.1-3.5 and 3.8 are the most closely related to the

material covered here.C. Useful websites

1. NYSE: http://www.nyse.com2. NASDAQ: http://www.nasdaq.com

Page 3: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2 Foundations of Finance

2

II. Primary Equity Markets in the U.S..A. Primary market: Shares are issued by a firm that receives the proceeds from the

sale.B. Investment banks are usually used as intermediaries.

1. A firm wishing to sell securities listens to presentations by investmentbanks and then chooses one to be the lead underwriter.

2. The underwriter then contacts potential buyers.C. Underwriting Agreement:

1. Firm-commitment: the investment bank purchases the shares from theissuing company and then resells them. a. The investment bank pays a purchase price lower than the public

offering price: the spread serves as compensation for theunderwriter.

b. The investment bank bears the risk of not being able to resell thestock at the offer price.

2. Best-efforts: the investment bank agrees to help the firm sell the securitiesbut does not actually purchase the securities.a. The investment bank does not bear the risk of being unable to find

buyers for the stock at the offer price.b. Less common than firm-commitment.

D. Two Types of Issues:1. Public offerings: an issue of stock sold to the general investing public that

can then be traded on the secondary market.a. Initial: an issue of stock by a formerly privately-owned company

selling stock to the public for the first time.(1) Underpricing: leads to high returns on the first day of

listing.(2) Long-run under-performance over next 5 years.

b. Seasoned: an issue of stock by a company that has already soldstock to the public.

2. Private placements: an issue of stock sold to a few wealthy or institutionalinvestors.

Page 4: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2 Foundations of Finance

3

Page 5: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2 Foundations of Finance

4

Example: The closing price for IBM on Monday May 15 is 82.89. A. Limit Orders

1. A limit order to buy at 82 says buy at 82 or less.2. A limit order to sell at 83 says sell at 83 or more.

B. Stop-loss Orders1. A stop-loss order to buy at 83 says execute a market buy once the price

goes above 83.2. A stop-loss order to sell at 82 says execute a market sell once the price

goes below 82.

III. Terminology.A. Bid Price:

1. Price at which an intermediary is ready to purchase the security.2. Price received by a seller.

B. Asked Price: 1. Price at which an intermediary is ready to sell the security. 2. Price paid by a buyer.

C. Spread:1. Difference between bid and asked prices.2. Bid price is lower than the asked price.3. Spread is the intermediary’s profit.

Investor Price Intermediary

Buy Asked Sell

Sell Bid Buy

IV. Types of Orders:A. Market Orders: simple buy or sell orders that are to be executed immediately at

current market prices.B. Limit Orders: provide liquidity to the market.

1. A limit buy order says buy at a certain price or lower.2. A limit sell order says sell at a certain price or higher.

C. Stop-loss Orders1. A stop-loss buy order says execute a market buy once the price goes above

a certain price.2. A stop-loss sell order says execute a market sell once the price falls below

a certain price.

Page 6: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2 Foundations of Finance

5

V. Secondary Equity Markets in the U.S..A. Secondary market: already-issued shares are traded.B. Exchanges.

1. National:a. NYSE: largest.b. AMEX.

2. Regional: several.3. Some stocks trade both on the NYSE and on regional exchanges.4. Most exchanges have listing requirements that a stock has to satisfy.5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange.6. Exchange members execute trades for investors and receive commission.

C. Over-the-Counter Market.1. NASDAQ

a. the major over-the-counter market. b. utilizes an automated quotations system which computer-links

dealers (market makers). c. dealers:

(1) maintain an inventory of selected stocks; and,(2) stand ready to buy specified numbers of shares of stock (at

least one round lot, usually 100 shares) at their stated bidprices and ready to sell at their stated asked prices.

(3) required to reveal customer limit orders if better than theirstated bid and ask prices.

(4) compete with public for order flow.d. no centralized trading floor.e. individuals hire brokers to find the dealer offering the best deal.f. SuperMontage:

(1) is NASDAQ’s integrated order display and executionsystem.

(2) aggregates limit orders at all price levels and makesavailable the best 5 prices on both sides of the market.

(3) ideally, would serve as a central order book for allNASDAQ-listed securities, but to fill this role, needsparticipation of all important traders.

D. Third Market: refers to the trading of exchange-listed securities on the over-the-counter market.

Page 7: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2 Foundations of Finance

6

E. Fourth Market. direct trading between investors in exchange-listed or Nasdaq-listed stocks without using a broker.1. Electronic communication networks or ECNs allow members to post buy

or sell orders that are “crossed” with orders of other members.a. ECNs have captured a large fraction of the trading volume of

NASDAQ-listed stocks: around 40%.b. ECNs provide traders with anonymity.c. ECNs must be certified by the SEC and registered with NASDAQ

to partipate in the NASDAQ market.d. Two of the biggest ECNs are Island/Instinet and Archipelago.

F. Intermarket Trading:1. A “Consolidated Tape” reports trades on the NYSE, the AMEX, and the

major regional exchanges as well as on NASDAQ stocks.2. The Intermarket Trading System links several markets by computer

(NYSE, AMEX, Boston, Cincinnati, Midwest, Pacific, Philadelphia, theChicago Board Options Exchange, and the NASD); brokers and marketmakers can thus display quotes on all markets and execute cross-markettrades.

Page 8: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2 Foundations of Finance

7

Page 9: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2 Foundations of Finance

8

VI. Trading on the NYSE.A. Participants: 4 types of members

1. Commission Brokers: execute orders that the public has placed withbrokerage firms.

2. Floor Brokers: assist commission brokers when there are too many ordersflowing into the market.

3. Floor Traders: trade solely for themselves.4. Specialists: maintain a market in one or more listed stocks.

B. Daily Opening:1. Call auction for each listed stock.2. All orders are aggregated into supply and demand schedules.3. Price is set equal to the intersection of the demand and supply schedules

and comes close to approximating the true “equilibrium price” at which allinvestors are satisfied with their positions (i.e., they do not want to tradeagain at that time).

Page 10: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2 Foundations of Finance

9

C. Role of the Specialist:1. maintain a “book” of all unfilled limit orders entered by brokers on behalf

of customers. 2. when the highest outstanding limit buy order exceeds the lowest

outstanding limit sell order: execute or “cross” the trade.3. be willing at any time to buy at her listed bid price and sell at her listed

asked price.4. maintain a “a fair and orderly market” by trading in the stock personally.5. not allowed to take the other side of a trade unless her price is better than

the best outstanding limit order price.D. How does the Specialist Set Prices Throughout the Day?

1. The Specialist is constantly searching for the price that makes the flow ofshares bought and sold in the market the same.

2. The Specialist’s inventory plays a key role:a. If inventory increases, it means that there are more sell orders than

buy orders, and the Specialist lowers the price.b. If inventory decreases, it means that there are more buy orders than

sell orders, and the Specialist raises the price.3. In general, NYSE specialists do not take a view of where a stock is going

over time. They are not in the business of long-term investing but rather ofmaking money from buying and selling while maintaining as littleinventory as possible.

4. The Specialist can make profits from her knowledge of the limit orderbook which is more detailed than that of any other market participant.

Page 11: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2 Foundations of Finance

10

E. Effective Price1. bid price: the higher of the specialist’s bid price and the highest unfilled

limit buy order.2. asked price: the lower of the specialist’s asked price and the lowest

unfilled limit sell order. F. Example.

1. The specialist’s book for a stock looks as follows:

Price Limit Sell Limit Buy Specialist

90.8 100 sh

90.7

90.6 100 sh asked

90.5 100 sh 100 sh bid

90.4 100 sh

90.3 100 shWill any trades take place, given this book. Answer: Yes. The limit sellfor 100 shares at 90.5 will cross with the limit buy for 100 shares at 90.5.

2. The book now looks as follows:

Price Limit Sell Limit Buy Specialist

90.8 100 sh

90.7

90.6 100sh asked

90.5 bid

90.4 100 sh

90.3 100 sh

a. If a market sell order for 100 shares comes in, at what price will itexecute? Answer: The higher of the highest limit buy (90.4) andthe specialist’s bid price (90.5). So 90.5 and the specialist takesthe other side.

b. If a market buy order for 100 shares comes in, at what price will itexecute? Answer: The lower of the lowest limit sell (90.6) and thespecialist’s asked price (90.6). So 90.6 and the limit sell takes theother side..

Page 12: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2 Foundations of Finance

11

G. How the specialist determines her asked and bid prices: 2 examples.1. Example: The specialist’s obligation to maintain an orderly market.

a. The specialist’s book for a stock looks as follows:

Price Limit Sell Limit Buy Specialist

90.8 100 sh

90.7 100 sh

90.6 100 sh asked

90.5 100 sh bid

90.4

90.3 100 sh

90.2 100 shSuppose a market sell for 100 shares arrives. It will get executedat 90.5.

b. The book now looks as follows:

Price Limit Sell Limit Buy Specialist

90.8 100 sh

90.7 100 sh

90.6 100 sh

90.5

90.4 bid

90.3 100 sh

90.2 100 shSuppose another market sell for 200 shares arrives.

c. If the specialist does not offer a better bid, 100 shares of the sellorder will get executed at 90.3 and the other 100 at 90.2. Although the specialist may be concerned about the possibility ofbad news, her responsibility to maintain an orderly market mayobligate her to post a bid of 90.4 and take the other side of thetrade.

Page 13: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2 Foundations of Finance

12

2. Example: The specialist’s ability to profit from observing the order flow. a. The specialist’s book for a stock looks as follows:

Price Limit Sell Limit Buy Specialist

90.8 100 sh

90.7 100 sh, 200 sh, 200sh

90.6 100 sh,100 sh, 200 sh asked

90.5 100 sh, 200 sh, 200sh bid

90.4 100 sh, 200 sh, 200sh

90.3 200 sh

90.2Suppose limit sell orders for 300 shares at 90.6 and 400 shares at90.7 are withdrawn. The implication is possible good news aboutthe stock.

b. The book now looks as follows:

Price Limit Sell Limit Buy Specialist

90.8 100 sh

90.7 100 sh

90.6 100 sh bid

90.5 100 sh, 200 sh, 200sh

90.4 100 sh, 200 sh, 200sh

90.3 200 sh

90.2Suppose a market sell for 100 shares arrives.

c. If the specialist does not offer a better bid, the sell order will getexecuted at 90.5

d. However, based on the order flow the specialist may prefer to bid90.6 and take the other side of the trade. She may think it is agood bet given the large quantity of limit buy orders at 90.5 and90.4 (limited downside) and the evaporation of limit sell orders at90.7 and 90.6 (potential for upside gain).

Page 14: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2 Foundations of Finance

13

H. Block Trades1. Definition: If an investor wishes to trade more than 10000 shares of a

NYSE stock, it is known as a block trade.2. As of 2001, block trades constitute about 50% of trading volume on the

NYSE.3. Block houses have evolved to help in the placement of block trades.

I. The SuperDOT System1. SuperDOT enables exchange members to send orders directly to the

specialist over computer lines.2. Most trades are executed and reported back to the originating member

within 2 minutes. 3. Most orders handled are small; so although a large fraction of all orders

are handled by SuperDOT, these only account for a small fraction oftrading volume.

Page 15: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2 Foundations of Finance

14

VII. DiscussionA. Market Order versus Limit Order

1. Trade-off between immediacy and pricea. Market order gets executed immediately but usually buys are at the

asked and sells are at the bidb. Limit orders don’t get executed immediately but the price is

usually better than that obtained by a market order.B. Determinants of the Bid-ask Spread

1. Volume of trade: higher volume means lower spreads since risk associatedwith holding inventory is lower.

2. Volatility of equilibrium price: higher volatility means higher spreadssince risk associated with holding inventory is higher.

3. Competition between market markers: greater competition means lowerspreadsa. NASDAQ trading reforms of 1997 designed to improve

competition between dealers.C. Trading Costs

1. Commission:a. Fee paid to the broker for making the transaction.

2. Bid-Ask Spread:a. Cost of immediacy.b. Incurred when using a market order.

3. Market Impact: For large orders.D. Motivations for Trading.

1. Information: You believe that you have information about the asset that isnot reflected in price.

2. Liquidity: You have surplus cash to invest (and you will buy securities) oryou need to raise cash (and you will sell securities).

3. Rebalancing: The composition of your investment portfolio has changeddue to differences in the performance of the assets currently in theportfolio. You want to readjust the composition to reflect your riskpreferences.

Page 16: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2 Foundations of Finance

15

E. NYSE vs OTC market1. NYSE has higher fixed costs (due to the need for a central physical

location), lower per-trade costs ( since more likely to be trading withanother investor and not a market maker) and greater structure (rules andregimentation).

2. The higher fixed costs for the NYSE means that a stock must have anactive market to cover these costs; this is why the NYSE has stringentlisting requirements.

3. The distinction is becoming blurrier:a. NASDAQ has listing requirements like an exchange.b. NASDAQ order handling rules since 1997 force dealers to display

customer limit orders allowing one customer to trade with anothercustomer.

Page 17: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2 Foundations of Finance

16

VIII. Decimalization.A. Two issues:

1. Quoting prices in decimals.2. Minimum tick size becomes 1 cent rather than 1/8 or 1/16.

B. Dates:1. Island: July 2000.2. NYSE: all stocks 29 Jan 2001.3. NASDAQ: all stocks 9 Apr 2001.

C. Effects:1. Spreads narrower particularly for active stocks.

a. Impatient market orders benefit.b. Limit order traders are disadvantaged.c. NASDAQ dealers are harmed.d. Institutional investors are harmed.

2. Specialist will trade more often and more profitably: easier to “stepahead” of limit orders to exploit her information about order flow.

Page 18: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2-3 Foundations of Finance

17

Lecture 2-3: Stock Positions and Portfolio Return

I. Reading.A. BKM Chapter 3: Sections 3.6-3.7.B. BKM, Chapter 5: read Section 5.2.

II. Return Calculation and Dividends. A. Return Calculation

1. Return over a Period: Percentage change in the value of the investmentover that period.

2. Formula to calculate Return: For an arbitrary asset i:

R i(t,t%1) 'p i(t%1) % c i(t%1) & p i(t)

p i(t)

'p i(t%1) % c i(t%1)

p i(t)& 1

where pi(t+1) is the market price of asset i at time t+1; ci(t+1) is the cash flow from the asset at time t+1; pi(t) is the market price of asset i at time t; and, Ri(t+1) is the return on asset i over the period from t to t+1.

Page 19: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2-3 Foundations of Finance

18

3. Example: The following price data is available for IBM:

What is the 1-day return on IBM stock for 11/5/04? Answer:

Date Dividend: IBM Closing Price:IBM

11/4/04 0 92.38

11/5/04 0 93.28

So,

R IBM(11/5/04) 'p IBM(11/5/04) & p IBM(11/4/04)

p IBM(11/4/04)

'93.28 & 92.38

92.38' 0.9742%

Page 20: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2-3 Foundations of Finance

19

B. Return Calculation with Dividend.1. Important Dates associated with a Dividend

a. Declared Date: when the board formally approves the dividend.b. Ex-date: when the stock trades without its dividend.

2. Example (cont): The following price information is available for IBM:

What is the 1-day return on IBM stock for 11/8/04? Answer: Know11/8/04 is the ex-date for IBM’s dividend.

Date Dividend: IBM Closing Price:IBM

11/5/04 0 93.28

11/8/04 0.18 93.37Thus,

R IBM(11/8/04) 'p IBM(11/8/04) % DivIBM(11/8/04) & p IBM(11/5/04)

p IBM(11/5/04)

'93.37 % 0.18 & 93.28

93.28' 0.2895%

Page 21: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2-3 Foundations of Finance

20

III. Stock Positions.A. Example.

1. XYZ has the following price series

Date Dividend: XYZ Closing Price:XYZ

end 1/06 0 8

end 2/06 0 10

end 3/06 0 72. Suppose you have $8000 cash at the end of 1/06. Your balance sheet at

the end of 1/06 looks like:

Assets Liabilities

Cash 8000 Net Worth 8000

Total Asset 8000 Total Liab & Net W. 80003. Assume your broker requires interest of 1% per month on any funds

borrowed from her. Any funds placed with your broker earns 1% also. This rate (EAR=12.68%) can be thought of as the riskless rate.

Page 22: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2-3 Foundations of Finance

21

B. Long the Stock.1. Definition: Buying the stock with your own funds.2. Example (cont):

a. At the end of 1/06, you invest $6000 in XYZ shares at the closingprice; so buy 750 shares and the remaining $2000 you invest withyour broker at 1% .

Assets Liabilities

750 XYZ sh @ $8 6000

Cash 2000 Net Worth 8000

Total Asset 8000 Total Liab & Net W. 8000b. By the end of 2/06, XYZ’s price has gone up.

Assets Liabilities

750 XYZ sh @ $10 7500

Cash (2000 @ 1%) 2020 Net Worth 9520

Total Asset 9520 Total Liab & Net W. 9520c. By the end of 3/06, XYZ’s price has plunged.

Assets Liabilities

750 XYZ sh @ $7 5250

Cash (2020 @ 1%) 2040.20 Net Worth 7290.20

Total Asset 7290.20 Total Liab & Net W. 7290.20

Page 23: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2-3 Foundations of Finance

22

C. Buying Stock on Margin.1. Definition: Buying stock using funds borrowed from a broker; the client is

charged the call money rate on the borrowed funds (plus a fee).2. Percentage margin: refers to net worth (value of the stock less amount

borrowed) as a percentage of the value of the stock:

Margin 'Net Worth

Value of Stock

a. In the U.S.,the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve Systemhas set the minimum initial margin at 50%; so the borrowedamount must be less than 50% of the value of the stock purchased.

b. As the value of the stock decreases so does the percentage margin. c. If the percentage margin falls below the maintenance margin set by

the broker, the customer has to put up enough collateral satisfy themaintenance margin.

Page 24: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2-3 Foundations of Finance

23

3. Example (cont):a. At the end of 1/06, you want to buy 1400 shares in XYZ; and so

need to borrow 1400x$8 - $8000 = $3200 from your broker. Percent Margin = 8000/11200 = 71.43%>50%.

Assets Liabilities

1400 XYZ sh @ $8 11200 Loan 3200

Net Worth 8000

Total Asset 11200 Total Liab & Net W. 11200b. By the end of 2/06, XYZ’s price has gone up.

Percent Margin = 10768/14000 = 76.91%.

Assets Liabilities

1400 XYZ sh @ $10 14000 Loan ($3200@1%) 3232

Net Worth 10768

Total Asset 14000 Total Liab & Net W. 14000c. By the end of 3/06, XYZ’s price has plunged.

Percent Margin = 6536/9800 = 66.69%.

Assets Liabilities

1400 XYZ sh @ $7 9800 Loan ($3232@1%) 3264

Net Worth 6536

Total Asset 9800 Total Liab & Net W. 9800

Page 25: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2-3 Foundations of Finance

24

D. Short Selling Stock1. Definition: Borrowing the stock and selling it.2. Proceeds from the sale must remain with the broker.3. Percentage margin: refers to net worth as a percentage of the value of the

stock borrowed:

Margin 'Net Worth

Value of Stock

a. As the value of the stock increases, the percentage margindecreases.

b. In the U.S., the minimum initial margin is set at 50%.c. If the percentage margin falls below the maintenance margin set by

the broker, the customer has to put up enough collateral to satisfythe maintenance margin.

4. Example (cont):a. At the end of 1/06, you have $8000 in cash with your broker.

(1) You borrow 1400 shares of XYZ. The loan is denominatedin shares of XYZ not in dollars.

Assets Liabilities

1400 XYZ sh @ $8 11200 Loan (1400 sh @ $8) 11200

Cash 8000 Net Worth 8000

Total Asset 19200 Total Liab & Net W. 19200(2) You sell the borrowed shares at the closing price at the end

of 1/06.Margin=8000/11200=71.43%

Assets Liabilities

Cash 19200 Loan (1400 sh @ $8) 11200

Net Worth 8000

Total Asset 19200 Total Liab & Net W. 19200

Page 26: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2-3 Foundations of Finance

25

b. By the end of 2/06, XYZ’s price has gone up.Margin=5392/14000=38.51%

Assets Liabilities

Cash ($19200@1%) 19392 Loan (1400 sh@$10) 14000

Net Worth 5392

Total Asset 19392 Total Liab & Net W. 19392c. By the end of 3/06, XYZ’s price has plummeted.

Margin=9786/9800=99.86%

Assets Liabilities

Cash ($19392@1%) 19586 Loan (1400 sh@$7) 9800

Net Worth 9786

Total Asset 19586 Total Liab & Net W. 19586d. To close out the position at the end of 3/06, take the following

steps:(1) purchase 1400 shares of stock.

Assets Liabilities

Cash 9786 Loan (1400 sh@$7) 9800

1400 sh XYZ @$7 9800 Net Worth 9786

Total Asset 19586 Total Liab & Net W. 19586 (2) repay the stock loan.

Assets Liabilities

Cash 9786 Net Worth 9786

Total Asset 9786 Total Liab & Net W. 9786

Page 27: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2-3 Foundations of Finance

26

5. Short Interesta. At the end of each month, all brokers report their customer’s short

positions in all stocks.b. Short interest ratio:

(1) Short Interest/Av Daily Trading Volume.(2) measures the number of days to close out the outstanding

short position given the average daily trading volume forthe stock.

Page 28: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2-3 Foundations of Finance

27

c. Interpretations of a high short interest ratio:(1) indicates that informed investors believe that stocks are

overvalued(2) indicates that short-sellers need to buy a lot of stock to

close out their positions relative to daily volume which willexert upward pressure on prices.

d. Performance of firms with high short interest empirically:(1) see Asquith, P., Pathak, P. and Ritter, J., 2004, Short

Interest and Stock Returns. NBER Working Paper 10434. (2) consider period from 1976-2002 and risk-adjusted

performance.(3) value-weighted portfolios underperform in the subsequent

month by as much as 0.5% per month while equal weightedportfolios fail to under or overperform.

(4) could still be due to inadequate risk-adjustment.

Page 29: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2-3 Foundations of Finance

28

E. Comparison1. What is the monthly return each month for the three investments?

a. Recall that in the absence of any dividend payment:Return = [Price (end) / Price (start)] - 1.

b. So Portfolio Return = [Portfolio Value(end) / Portfolio Value(start)] -1

c. Note that Portfolio Value is given by Net Worth.

Long 6000 XYZ sh Buy 1400 XYZ sh onMargin

Short Sell 1400 XYZ sh

Date Net Worth Return Net Worth Return Net Worth Return

1/06 8000 8000 8000

2/06 9520 19% 10768 34.6% 5392 -32.6 %

3/06 7290.20 -23.4% 6536 -39.3% 9786 81.5%

2. Buying on Margin vs Going Longa. Instead of using starting net worth to buy a firm’s stock, the

investor uses it to buy a larger number of the firm’s shares onmargin.(1) A given price decline causes a larger reduction in net

worth.(2) A given price increase causes a larger increase in net

worth.(3) So the investor’s net worth is more sensitive to changes in

the stock price.3. Short-selling vs Buying the Stock

a. Short-selling causes net worth to have a negative sensitivity tochanges in the stock price.(1) A price decline causes an increase in net worth. (2) A price increase causes a decrease in net worth.

Page 30: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2-3 Foundations of Finance

29

IV. Portfolio Return FormulaA. The following formula can be used to calculate the return on a portfolio given the

returns on the assets that comprise the portfolio:Rp(t) = ω1,p R1(t) + ω2,p R2(t) + ... + ωN,p RN(t)

whereN is the number of assets in the portfolio;Ri(t) is the return on asset i in period t;ωi,p is the weight of asset i in portfolio p;Rp(t) is the return on portfolio p in period t.

B. Portfolio weights must sum to 1.C. Example (cont):

1. Suppose I have $8000 to invest at the end of January 2006.2. I decide to invest $6000 in XYZ and $2000 in the Riskless Asset.3. I have invested:

a. $6000/$8000=0.75 or 75% of my money in XYZ.b. $2000/$8000=0.25 or 25% in the riskless asset.

4. Your portfolio’s return in February 2006 can be calculated using thisformula:

Rp(2/06) = ωXYZ,p RXYZ(2/06) + ωf,p Rf(2/06)= 0.75 x 25% + 0.25 x 1%= 19%.

which matches the return calculated earlier.

Page 31: Lecture 2: Equities: Marketspages.stern.nyu.edu/~alynch/courses/B01.231160/ff06S02.pdf · 5. Only members of an exchange can trade on the exchange. 6. Exchange members execute trades

Lecture 2-3 Foundations of Finance

30

D. Interpretation of the Portfolio Weighting ω1. Buying a Stock on Margin: ωStock>1 and ωRiskfree<0

a. Example (cont): When 1400 shares of XYZ were bought onmargin at the end of January 2006, the weight on XYZ in theportfolio was >1.(1) The value of the portfolio at the end of January 2006 was

$8000, of which 1400x$8=$11200 was invested in XYZand -$3200 was invested in the riskless asset.

(2) So,ωXYZ,p = $11200/$8000 = 1.4ωf,p = -$3200/$8000 = -0.4

(3) Note the weights sum to 1.(4) Then can calculate the portfolio return for February 2006:

Rp(2/06) = ωXYZ,p RXYZ(2/06) + ωf Rf(2/06)= 1.4 x 25% + -0.4 x 1%= 34.6%

which agrees with the return calculated earlier.

2. Short selling: ωStock<0a. Example (cont): When 1400 shares of XYZ were short sold at the

end of January 2006, the weight on XYZ in the portfolio was <0.(1) The value of the portfolio at the end of January 2006 was

$8000, of which -1400x$8=-$11200 was invested in XYZand $8000+$11200=$19200 was invested in the risklessasset.

(2) So,ωXYZ,p = -$11200/$8000 = -1.4ωf,p = $19200/$8000 = 2.4

(3) Note the weights sum to 1.(4) Then can calculate the portfolio return for February 2006:

Rp(2/06) = ωXYZ,p RXYZ(2/06) + ωf Rf(2/06)= -1.4 x 25% + 2.4 x 1%= -32.6%

which agrees with the return calculated earlier.