Lecture 19 Mundell OCA

7/25/2019 Lecture 19 Mundell OCA

1/40

!"#$ '( )#*+*+,

-+ *. & )"#+' $/ .0' 1234"4 )"##'567 '(8

9'6."#' :;

? @?:A

"


2/40

#$%&'()#*) +,-

#$%& .%(+

/


3/40

#$%&'( 0(1&%( +,- +2(% "343

5


4/40

6&7'&89:&, &1 #$%&'(

European Countries

EU Countries

(27 countries)

!"#$B$5'

;"< =&$,:%(8>

?(@A9$7) B%+,=() C(%7+,D) E(FG(%@+,-8)H$I(70&$%A) -.(C7D -#'C(5ED F#''6'D G$#."H(CD

I2(*5D.$8F%9+) B9,@+,-) 6D'%$8) #8F&,9+) J@&K+L9+)J@&K(,9+) M+@F+N

* P) Q(,7+%L) JR(-(,)6S(=G T('$0@9=)U$,A+%D) H+FK9+)

H9FG$+,9+) V&@+,-)?$@A+%9+) T&7+,9+

Non-EU Countries

G$.'53(C !K)(5E*E(.'+

)#$(3(D L(6'E$5*(D-6'C(5ED L$5.'5'H#$D

I'#M*(D N"#O'7


5/40

Z':7$7

6$%%(,=D

.%(+[

. Q98=$889&,

\


6/40

T&0(%F M$,-(@@]8 6&,F%90$:&,

^. _G(&%D &1 Z':7$7 6$%%(,=D .%(+8`) T&0(%F.N M$,-(@@N!"#$%&'( *&+(+"%& ,#-%#./ X&@N \")E&N Y ;J('N) "3a">) ''N a\


7/40

!"#$%&&

)*%+,-.# /-0#0*,- 1%2,%3 45647+0* !"#$$ '#($# ) *+# ,-#"./#$ &.0$1(20 34(20 56 ,7#8#29

!".:# .2 ;


8/40

What does Mundells Article say?

!"#$%&&N8 .+:,-&% L+,%D9 *%#:,0#8 :>% .$2.#:.?%8 0C . -0**0#-"++%#-9; 8"-> .8 &03%+ :+.#8.-:,0# -08:8 ,# :+.$% .#$ &%88"#-%+:.,#:9 .L0": +%&.:,2% @+,-%8B

F>% $,8.$2.#:.?%8 .+% $%8-+,L%$ ,# ?+%.:%+ $%:.,&B F>% *.O0+

$+.3L.-P ,8 :>% $,Q-"&:9 0C *.,#:.,#,#? %*@&09*%#: 3>%#->.#?%8 ,# $%*.#$ 0+ 0:>%+ H.89**%:+,- 8>0-P8H +%G",+% .+%$"-:,0# ,# +%.& 3.?%8 ,# . @.+:,-"&.+ +%?,0#B !"#$%&& %*@>.8,R%$:>% ,*@0+:.#-% 0C >,?> &.L0+ *0L,&,:9 ,# 0+$%+ :0 0S8%: 8"->$,8:"+L.#-%8B

T% ->.+.-:%+,R%$ .# 0@:,*"* -"++%#-9 .+%. .8 . 8%: 0C +%?,0#8

.*0#? 3>,-> :>% @+0@%#8,:9 :0 *,?+.:% ,8 >,?> %#0"?> :0 %#8"+%C"&& %*@&09*%#: 3>%# 0#% 0C :>% +%?,0#8 C.-%8 .# .89**%:+,-

8>0-PB U:>%+ +%8%.+->%+8 %=:%#$%$ :>% :>%0+9 .#$ ,$%#:,


9/40

'#-(2B28#'' C58(?

!"#$%&&N8 -0#8,$%+.:,0#8; 8%2%+.& $%-.$%8 .?0; 8%%* >,?>&9 +%&%2.#:

:0$.9B V"% :0 ,#-+%.8,#?&9 >,?>%+ -.@,:.& *0L,&,:9 ,# :>% 30+&$%-0#0*9; +%?,*%8 3,:> . :%*@0+.+,&9 .#?%+.:% >.2% L%-0*% *0+% C+.?,&%W 8"-> +%?,*%8 .+% .&80 L%,#? -.&&%$,#:0 G"%8:,0#B !.#9 0L8%+2%+8 2,%3 . -"++%#-9 "#,0# 0+ . D0.:,#?

%=->.#?% +.:% X :>% :30 -.8%8 !"#$%&&N8 .+:,-&% $%.&: 3,:> X .8 :>%*08: +%&%2.#: .&:%+#.:,2%8B

Y%%$&%88 :0 8.9; !"#$%&&N8 .#.&98,8 >.8 .&80 .Z+.-:%$ .Z%#:,0# ,#

-0##%-:,0# 3,:> :>% -0**0# /"+0@%.# -"++%#-9B 1%8%.+->%+8 3>0>.2% %=.*,#%$ :>% %-0#0*,- .$2.#:.?%8 .#$ $,8.$2.#:.?%8 0C /![>.2% .$0@:%$ :>% ,$%. 0C .# 0@:,*"* -"++%#-9 .+%. .8 .# 0L2,0"8

8:.+:,#? @0,#:B \#$%%$; 0#% 0C :>% P%9 ,88"%8 ,# :>,8 -0#:%=: ,8 &.L0+*0L,&,:9 ,# +%8@0#8% :0 .89**%:+,- 8>0-P8B

3


10/40

)$+.+ T Q'5'U.+ $/ (5 1)&

"O


11/40

,5B"


12/40

^%88 :+.#8.-:,0#8 -08:8

/&,*,#.:,0# 0C %=->.#?% *.+P%:83,:>,# "#,0# %&,*,#.:%8 -08: 0C

%=->.#?,#? 0#% -"++%#-9 ,#:0 .#0:>%+ `08: +%$"-:,0#8 .*0"#:8 :0 ABab :0

ABbc 0C dV_ I.--0+$,#? :0 /"+0@%.#

`0**,88,0#J 7"&&8 -08: +%$"-:,0# 0#&9 .->,%2%$

3>%# @.9*%#:8 898:%*8 .+% C"&&9

,#:%?+.:%$ "/


13/40

_+,-% :+.#8@.+%#-9

U#% -0**0# "#,: 0C .--0"#: C.-,&,:.:%8@+,-% -0*@.+,80#8

`0#8"*%+ e8>0@ .+0"#$f *0+%

`0*@%:,:,0# ,#-+%.8%8

_+,-%8 $%-&,#% .#$ -0#8"*%+8 ?.,#

"5


14/40

/=->.#?% +.:% "#-%+:.,#:9 .#$ :>% @+,-%*%->.#,8*

^.+?% %=->.#?% 2.+,.L,&,:9 +%$"-%8 :>% G".&,:9

0C @+,-% 8,?#.&8 ,# .&&0-.:,#? +%80"+-%8

/=.*@&%K &.+?% 02%+2.&".:,0# 0C $0&&.+ ,# 45gA8

&%$ :0 $%-&,#% 0C %=@0+: 8%-:0+W . $%-&,#% :>.:

:"+#%$ 0": :0 L% "##%-%88.+9 0#-% :>% $0&&.+$%-&,#%$ .?.,#B

F>%8% &.+?% +%.& %=->.#?% +.:% -9-&%8 &%.$ :0

&.+?% .$O"8:*%#: -08:8

^%88 %=->.#?% +,8P]/"+0 %&,*,#.:%8 %=->.#?% +,8PB

"Y


15/40

E%#%% $0&&.+ -+%.:%88%,?#,0+.?% ?.,#8 C0+ :>% [h

h,*,&.+&9; ,C %"+0 L%-0*%8 .#

,#:%+#.:,0#.& -"++%#-9; 8%,?#,0+.?%?.,#8 3,&& C0&&03 C0+ /"+0&.#$

F>%8% ?.,#8; >03%2%+; +%*.,#

+%&.:,2%&9 8*.&&W ,# :>% -.8% 0C :>% [hK&%88 :>.# ABbc 0C dV_ @%+ 9%.+

"\


16/40

E%#%


17/40

h

#=&,&79= i,F(A%+:&, +,- FG( ?(,(eF8 &1 +B9I(- #I=G+,A( T+F( .%(+[ 00J=G(-$@(

g L$5'.(#7 'R6*'567 H(*5

h

_G( W&9,(%]8 8+K9,A 1%&7 +K&9-9,A FG( $,=(%F+9,FD) =&,1$89&,) +,- =+@=$@+:&,+,- F%+,8+=:&, =&8F8 FG+F +%98( RG(, (I=G+,A( %+F(8 j&+FN

h iF 98 G9AG(%) FG( G9AG(% FG( -(A%(( &1 (=&,&79= 9,F(A%+:&, 0(FR((, FG(W&9,9,A =&$,F%D +,- FG( eI(- (I=G+,A( %+F( +%(+N

g 008=G(-$@(

h

iF 8G&R8 G&R FG( '&F(,:+@ A+9, &1 + =&$,F%D 1%&7 W&9,9,A FG( ($%& S&,(-('(,-8 &, 9F8 F%+-9,A @9,L R9FG FG+F %(A9&,N

h iF 8@&'(8 $'R+%-N

_G( _G(&%D &1

Z':7$7 6$%%(,=D .%(+8

"% F>%0+9 0CU@:,*"* `"++%#-9 )+%.8

"4


19/40

h

#=&,&79= i,F(A%+:&, +,- FG( 6&8F8 &1 + B9I(-#I=G+,A( T+F( .%(+[ _G( 11J=G(-$@(

g !6$5$4*6 +.(M*C*.7 C$++

h

_G( (=&,&79= 8F+09@9FD @&88 FG+F +%98(8 0(=+$8( + =&$,F%D FG+F W&9,8 +, (I=G+,A( %+F(+%(+ A9K(8 $' 9F8 +09@9FD F& $8( FG( (I=G+,A( %+F( +,- 7&,(F+%D '&@9=D 1&% FG('$%'&8( &1 8F+09@9S9,A &$F'$F +,- (7'@&D7(,FN

h iF 98 @&R(%) FG( G9AG(% FG( -(A%(( &1 (=&,&79= 9,F(A%+:&, 0(FR((, + =&$,F%D +,-FG( eI(- (I=G+,A( %+F( +%(+ FG+F 9F W&9,8N

g 11 8=G(-$@(h

iF 8G&R8 FG( %(@+:&,8G9' &1 FG( =&$,F%D]8 (=&,&79= 8F+09@9FD @&88 1%&7 W&9,9,AN

h iF 8@&'(8 -&R,R+%-N

_G( _G(&%D &1 Z6.[ 6&8F8

"3


20/40

F>% F>%0+9 0CU@:,*"* `"++%#-9 )+%.8

/O

_G _G 1


21/40

h _G( Q(=989&, F& k&9, + 6$%%(,=D .%(+[ V$l,A

FG( 00+,- 11J=G(-$@(8 _&A(FG(%

g _G( 9,F(%8(=:&, &1 00+,- 11h

Q(F(%79,(8 + =%9:=+@ @(K(@ &1 (=&,&79= 9,F(A%+:&, 0(FR((, + eI(-

(I=G+,A( %+F( +%(+ +,- + =&$,F%D

h JG&R8 G&R + =&$,F%D 8G&$@- -(=9-( RG(FG(% F& eI 9F8 =$%%(,=D]8 (I=G+,A(

%+F( +A+9,8F FG( ($%&

_G( _G(&%D &1

Z':7$7 6$%%(,=D .%(+8

/"

_G _G 1


22/40

h mG+F i8 +, Z':7$7 6$%%(,=D .%(+n

g iF 98 + %(A9&, RG(%( 9F 98 0(8F ;&':7+@> F& G+K( +

89,A@( =$%%(,=DN

g

Z':7+@9FD -('(,-8 &, -(A%(( &1 (=&,&79=

9,F(A%+:&,[h _%+-( 9, A&&-8 +,- 8(%K9=(8

h B+=F&% 7&09@9FD

g

. eI(- (I=G+,A( %+F( +%(+ R9@@ 0(8F 8(%K( FG(

(=&,&79= 9,F(%(8F8 &1 (+=G &1 9F8 7(70(%8 91 FG(

-(A%(( &1 &$F'$F +,- 1+=F&% F%+-( +7&,A FG(7 98

G9AGN

_G( _G(&%D &1

Z':7$7 6$%%(,=D .%(+8

//


23/40

F>% F>%0+9 0CU@:,*"* `"++%#-9 )+%.8

/5


24/40

mG(, -& FR& =&$,F%9(8 1&%7 +, Z6.n

/Y


25/40

Z':7$7 6$%%(,=D .%(+8 ;Z6.>

Q(e,9:&,[ ^., +%(+ =G+%+=F(%9S(- 0D ,$7(%&$8 (I=G+,A(8 0(FR((,

'(&'@() RG+F(K(% FG( =$%%(,=D) @(+-9,A F& + 8979@+% (=&,&79==D=@() 9-(,:=+@ A%&RFG %+F() +,- R9FG 1(R 8F%$=F$%+@-9f(%(,=(8) 98 +, &':7$7 =$%%(,=D +%(+N`

Z%9A9,+@ =&,F%90$:&, &1 T&0(%F M$,-(@@ ;"3a">

.88$7( FR& =&$,F%9(8) B%+,=( +,- C(%7+,D

.8D77(F%9= 8G&=L 9, -(7+,-

Q(=@9,( 9, +AA%(A+F( -(7+,- 9, B%+,=(

i,=%(+8( 9, +AA%(A+F( -(7+,- 9, C(%7+,D

_G98 @(+- F& +--9:&,+@ $,(7'@&D7(,F 9, B%+,=( +,- +-(=@9,( &1 $,(7'@&D7(,F 9, C(%7+,DN

/\


26/40

M$,-(@@]8 "3a" M&-(@

#f(=F8 &, FG( =$%%(,F +==&$,F[

6. o -&7(8:= &$F'$F g -&7(8:= 8'(,-9,A

i, B%+,=() FG( K+@$( &1 -&7(8:= &$F'$F G+8 -(=@9,(- +8 + %(8$@F &1 FG(

8G92 9, +AA%(A+F( -(7+,-N i1 8'(,-9,A 0D B%(,=G %(89-(,F8 -&(8 ,&F-(=@9,( 0D FG( 8+7( +7&$,F) B%+,=( R9@@ G+K( + =$%%(,F +==&$,F -(e=9FN.,- FG( =&,K(%8( 9, C(%7+,D

?&FG =&$,F%9(8 R9@@ G+K( +, +-W$8F7(,F '%&0@(7[ B%+,=( 98 '@+A$(- R9FG

$,(7'@&D7(,F +,- + =$%%(,F +==&$,F -(e=9FN C(%7+,D (I'(%9(,=(8 +0&&7 +,- + =$%%(,F +==&$,F 8$%'@$8N

i8 FG(%( + 7(=G+,987 FG+F @(+-8 F& +$F&7+:= (p$9@90%+:&,) R9FG&$F FG(

=&$,F%9(8 G+K9,A F& %(8&%F F& -(K+@$+:&,8 +,- %(K+@$+:&,8n

_G( 1&$,-9,A '+'(% &1 FG( Z6. _G(&%D '%&'&8(8 ;M$,-(@@) "3a">[

m+A( B@(I909@9FD

H+0&$% M&09@9FD

/a


27/40

mG(, 8G&$@- FR& =&$,F%9(8 1&%7 +,

Z6.n

M$,-(@@q8 +,+@D898 FG(%(1&%( 8$AA(8F(- FG+F[

91 FG( 97'+=F &1 8G&=L8 &, '+%:=$@+% +%(+8 R+8

8979@+% ;9N(N 8D77(F%9=>) eI(- (I=G+,A( %+F(8) &% +

7&,(F+%D $,9&,) R+8 +''%&'%9+F(r

91 FG( 97'+=F &1 8G&=L8 R+8 +8D77(F%9=) G&R(K(%)

2%32 4'5+$ "+5%4%67+,-s&% .'3# 8#9%5%4%67;7&%(

'+%:=$@+%@D 9, + -&R,R+%- -9%(=:&,> R(%( FG(

7+9, '%(%(p$989F(8N

/%,+ 0":@": :0 0:>%+ /[ -0"#:+,%8B

/[X[BhB :+.$% ,8 0#&9 ac 0C [BhB dY_B

^.L0+ ,8 *"-> *0+% *0L,&% 3,:>,# :>% [BhB:>.# 3,:>,# /"+0@%B

7%$%+.& :+.#8C%+8 .#$ ->.#?%8 ,# C%$%+.& :.=

@.9*%#:8 @+02,$% . *"-> L,??%+ -"8>,0#C0+ +%?,0#X8@%-,0-P8 ,# :>% [BhB :>.#$0 /[ +%2%#"%8 .#$ %=@%#$,:"+%8B

5Y


35/40

Another answer: Europe is an OCA

\#:+. /[ :+.$% ,8 :>% L,? @.+: 0C,#:%+#.:,0#.& :+.$%B

T,?> -0++%&.:,0#8 L%:3%%# dV_ 0C /[%-0#0*,%8

5\


36/40

U&R -9- #$%&

.%(+

8F%9K( F& +=G9(K(

=&,-9:&,8 &1Z6.n

5a

L . * 0. N . ;"33"> . i F F


37/40

J(F &$F + 0@$('%9,F 1&% FG( F%+,89:&, '%&=(88 1%&7 FG(

#MJ eI(- (I=G+,A( %+F( 8D8F(7 F& #M*N

_G( M++8F%9=GF 6&,K(%A(,=( 6%9F(%9+ +,- FG( JF+09@9FD

+,- C%&RFG V+=F V%9=( 8F+09@9FD 8'(=9e(-[

L(V*4"4 *5W(3$5 #(.'

!V60(5H' #(.' +.(M*C*.7

Q"EH'. E*+6*2C*5'

.I.(M*C*.7 (5E F#$S.0 G(6. XIFGY 9, "33< 8(F8 $'[

_G( 7(-9$7bF(%7 0$-A(F+%D &0W(=:K( &1 '&89:&,8=@&8( F& 0+@+,=( &% 9, 8$%'@$8

. :7(F+0@( 1&% FG( 97'&89:&, &1 e,+,=9+@ '(,+@:(8&, =&$,:(8 FG+F 1+9@ F& =&%%(=F 89F$+:&,8 &1^(I=(889K(` -(e=9F8 +,- -(0F '%&7'F@D (,&$AG

5

Documents

Lecture 19 Mundell OCA