Upload
guna-sekaran
View
218
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 1/36
ww w.l awye rsli ne .ne t 2 lawyers line - march - 2013
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 2/36
ww w.l awye rsli ne .ne t 3 lawyers line - march - 2013
Edito & Pblihe :V.gunasEkaran, B.Sc, B.L
Exective Edito :B. Sarkarai Pandian
D.VasudevanNallan Ramasamy
sb Edito :S.Sathyamurthy, M.K.Anand
Edito-i-CheCoimbatore : Na. Thangavelan
Puducherry : S. Rajasekar
advioy Committee :E.EzhilCarolinM.A,B.L. , J. Suresh B.A, B.L.
R.Rajaram B.A, B.L.,
C.Murugan B.A,B.L.,
K.Ethiraj M.A., M.Phill.,B.L.,
G.Nithiyakumar B.A, B.L. ,
T.Gnanabanu B.A,B.L.
Ivetitio Tem :C. Manimaran,G.Prabu,V.PrabuJ. Jenilaya,R. Srinivasan,
A.Ravikumar,P. Kalpana.M. Sakthivel,G. Hariharan,Karu.Marimuthu,
R. Sivaram,
advt. & sb. Meti :
G.Prabhu - 9942317237V.Baskar - 91763 12470G.Himalaya - 99654 40349
Dei & LyotG.Kumaraguru
OnLInE suPPOrT :
www.lwyersline.net
Vetrichelvan,Govindarajan,Babu,VadivelShakthi Online Services
Copyight & Pblicatio Ifo :Copyright Lawyers line. Al l Rights reserved. Re-
production in any manner is prohibited. Published
and owned by V. Sekar and published from No.
15, Velu Natchiyar Street, M.G.R. Nagar, Chennai
600 078, and printed by M.S. Ashok at Kadalosai
Achagam, No. 1/1, Bay Arcot Road, Kodambak-
kam, Chennai - 600 024. Editor : V.SEKAR
all Communictions / Queries /
Feedbcks to be contcted t
LawyErs LInE (Mothl)
72/3, Anand Appartments, Ground Floor,
100 Feet Road, Vadapalani, Chennai -26.
Tel :044- 23650044,9841607006
Email : [email protected]
Web: www.lawyersline.net
All disputes are subject to exclusive jurisdiction of competent courts and forums in
Chennai only
àœ«÷
6 & ªð‡ °ö‰¬îèœ âF˜ªè£œÀ‹ð£Lò™ Hó„¬ùèœ
20 & ñ‚è¬÷ ²ó‡´‹ áìèƒèœ.
22 & Þ‰Fò£  õ£›õèŸø ï£ì£?
25 & °®ñ‚è÷™ô£î Þ‰Fò˜èÀìù£ù
F¼ñí‹
30 & â¡ù õ÷‹ Þ™¬ô Þ‰î F¼ï£†®™?
32 -& ÞNõ£ù ñóí î‡ì¬ù
°ö‰¬îèœ eî£ùð£Lò™ ߘŠ¹
ê‰î£ ªê½ˆ¶«õ£˜ èõùˆFŸ°..ê‰î£ ªî£¬è 裫꣬ôò£è«õ£ Ü™ô¶ ®ñ£¡† ®ó£Š†ì£è«õ£ ñ†´«ñ ãŸÁ‚ ªè£œ÷Šð´‹.臮Šð£è ðíñ£è ªê½ˆî «õí¢ì£‹. ðíñ£è ªê½ˆî G¬ùŠðõ˜èœ W›è‡ì õƒA èí‚A™«ïó®ò£è ªìð£C† ªêŒòô£‹.õƒA èí‚° ⇠: 149202000000797õƒAJ¡ ªðò˜ : Þ‰Fò¡ æõ˜Yv «ðƒ‚ (IOB)
èí‚A¡ ªðò˜ : ô£ò˜v ¬ô¡ðí‹ ªìð£C† ªêŒîõ˜èœ àìù®ò£è 9841607006 â¡ø â‡µì¡ ªî£ì˜¹ ªè£‡´ àÁF ªêŒ¶
ªè£œ÷¾‹. îƒèÀ‚è£ù ê‰î£ Mõóƒè¬÷ Lawyersline.net â¡ø Þ¬íòî÷ˆF™ êK𣘈¶‚ ªè£œ÷¾‹.
Volme : 2, Ie-16, Mch: 2013
F†ìI†ì ªè£¬ô& àò˜cFñ¡ø b˜Š¹
ð¿î£ù 膴ñ£ù‹&ê†ì gFò£ù b˜¾
ªõO´ Mõ£èóˆ¶
16
8
14
28
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 3/36
ww w.l awye rsli ne .ne t 4 lawyers line - march - 2013
ï£ƒèœ â¡ùˆî‚ 臫죋. ÞŠð® ïì‚°‹¡Â ªîKò£«î, àƒè¬÷Š «ð£ô  â¿ˆî£ ð®„C¼‚«è£‹? è 㡠ܬîªò™ô£‹ 𣘈«î£‹.ⶂ«è£ õ˜ó£ƒè¡Â G¬ù„²‚A†®¼‰«î£‹.
Þ¬õ îLˆ ñ‚èO¬ì«ò Gô¾‹ ÜPò£¬ñJ¡ ܃èô£ŒŠ¹èœ. Þ¶ å¼ è£ôˆF™ ªð¼¬ñ‚°Kòî£è¾‹, HøK¡ ðKî£ðˆ¬îŠ ªðŸÁˆ î¼õî£è¾‹ Þ¼‰
F¼‚èô£‹. Ýù£™ Þ¡«ø£ Þ¶«ð£¡ø «ðî¬ñèÀ‚° (Innocence)M¬ì ªè£´ˆ¶ ÜŠ¹‹ è£ô‹õ‰¶M†ì¶. ÜF™ å¡Á  ªð‡ °öîèÀ‚° ãŸð´‹ ð£Lò™ õ¡º¬øèœ, ð£Lò™ªî£™¬ôèœ ð£Lò™ ªè£´¬ñèœ.
1. ªð‡ °ö‰¬îèœ Ü¬ùõ¼‹ ð£Lò™²ó‡ì½‚°, õ¡º¬ø‚° ݆ðì‚îòõ˜èœâ¡ð¬î ºîL™ 輈F™ ªè£œ÷ «õ‡´‹.
2. 嚪õ£¼ ݵ‹ õ£ŒŠ¹‚ A¬ìˆ  ð£Lò™ °Ÿø‹ ªêŒò‚ îòõ˜â¡øâ„êK‚¬èªð‡èÀ‚°ˆ «î¬õ.
3. ÞŠªð‡ °ö‰¬îèÀ‚°Šð£Lò™ ²ó‡ì™ °´‹ð àÁŠHù˜èœ, àøMù˜èœ, ªï¼ƒAò ï‡ð˜èOìI¼‰¶  ÜFè‹ ïìˆîŠð´Aø¶.
4. ð£Lò™ à혫õ£´  ñ Ý‡èœ Üµ°A¡øù˜â¡ð¬îŠ ªð‡ °ö‰¬îèœ àíó«õðô ï£†èœ ÝAø¶.
5 . îñ‚° ïì‚°‹ ð£Lò™ªî£™¬ô¬ò îñ¶ î£Jì‹ Ãì‚ÃÁõŠ ªð‡ °ö‰¬îèœ Ü…²A¡øù˜, îòƒ°A¡øù˜, è£ô‹
ˆ¶A¡øù˜.6 . îñ¶ °ö‰¬îèœ ÃÁ‹
ÜÂðõˆ¬îŠ ªðŸ«ø£˜ ºîL™ ï‹ðñÁ‚A¡øù˜.
7. ªð‡ °ö‰¬îèO¡ õò«î£ Ü™ô¶ ð£Lò™ªî£™¬ô  ÝE¡ õò«î£ å¼ ªð£¼†ì™ô.ÜŠªð‡ °ö‰¬îèœ CPòõ˜è÷£è Þ¼‚èô£‹,êŸÁ õ÷˜‰îõó£è¾‹ Þ¼‚èô£‹. ð£Lò™ªî£™¬ô ¹K«õ£˜ CPò ¬ðòù£è¾‹ Þ¼‚èô£‹.õòî£ù Aöõó£è¾‹ Ãì Þ¼‚èô£‹.
8. ªð‡èÀ‚°‹, ݇èÀ‚°‹, ªð‡èœ eî£ùð£Lò™ õ¡º¬ø ðŸPò MNŠ¹í˜¾ ÜõCò‹.
9. ªð‡ °ö‰¬îèO¡ e¶ Üõ˜è¬÷„ ²ŸPõ¼‹, ªî£†´Š «ð²‹ ݇èO¡ e¶‹ èõù‹
Þ¼ˆî™ ÜõCò‹.10. îò ñ†´‹ ªð‡ °ö‰¬îè¬÷ˆ îQ¬ñJ™
M´õ¬îˆ îM˜Šð¶ ï™ô¶.11. ªð‡èœ Þò‚èƒèœ, ªð‡èœ ܬñŠ¹èœ,
ñQî àK¬ñ ܬñŠ¹èO¡ àîM¬òˆ îòƒè£ñ™ «î´õ¶ Cø‰î¶.
12. ð£Lò™ ¶¡¹Áˆ ° Ý÷£ù ªð‡°ö‰¬îèÀ‚° ÝŸÁŠðE ªêŒõ¶ ÜõCò‹.
13. ªðŸ«ø£«ó ªêŒõ¶è®ù‹. ï™ô ªð‡ ÝŸÁŠðEò£÷K¡ àîM¬ò(Ü™ô¶) ªð‡ õö‚èPë
K¡ àîM¬ò õ¶ ï™ô¶.14. ð£Lò™ ªè£´¬ñ
ò£™ ñùG¬ô ð£F‚èŠð†ìõ˜
èÀ ‚° ï ô ‹ ܬìò ˆ«î¬õŠð´‹ Åö™, è£ô‹
îóŠðì «õ‡´‹.15. ªð‡ °ö‰¬îèÀ‚°‹,
Þ÷‹ ªð‡èÀ‚°‹ îŸè£Š¹è¬ô Þ‚è£ôˆFŸ° I辋«î¬õ.
16. 𣶠ªð‡èO¡e¶ ÔÔÝC†ÕÕ i²‹ ªè£´¬ñ»‹Üî¡ M¬÷õ£è ð£F‚èŠð´‹ªð‡èO¡ õ¡ªè£´¬ñ»‹ñóíº‹ ªð¼°Aø¶. âù«õ,ÜIô 膴Šð£†´‚è£ù ê†ì‹àì «ù G¬ ø «õ Ÿ ø Š ðì«õ‡´‹.
ªð‡µK¬ñ¬ò «ðE裊«ð£‹!
«ðî¬ñ¬ò îM˜Š«ð£‹!
«ðî¬ñ¬ò õNòŠ¹î™
âN™ è«ó£L¡õö‚èPë˜Ü‹«ðˆè˜ ªð‡
õö‚èPë˜ Ã†ì¬ñŠ¹
Þ÷‹ ªð‡èÀ‚° îŸè£Š¹ è¬ô I辋 «î¬õ.
õ£êè˜èœ èõùˆFŸ°...ê†ì‹ ðŸPò àƒèœ «èœMè¬÷ ²¼‚èñ£è¾‹
ñŸÁ‹ ªîOõ£è¾‹ â¿F ÜŠð¾‹.
ÜŠð «õ‡®ò ºèõK:
ô£ò˜v ¬ô¡, àƒèœ õö‚èPë˜ ð°F,72/3, Ýù‰ˆ ܊𣘆ªñ¡†v,
Ëø® «ó£´, õìðöQ, ªê¡¬ù & 26
ªî£¬ô«ðC : 044 & 2365 0044I¡ù…ê™: [email protected]
ªð‡ °ö‰¬îèO¡õò«î£ Ü™ô¶ð£Lò™ ªî£™¬ô
 ÝE¡ õò«î£
å¼ ªð£¼†ì™ô.ÜŠªð‡ °ö‰¬îèœ
CPòõ˜è÷£èÞ¼‚èô£‹, êŸÁõ÷˜‰îõó£è¾‹Þ¼‚èô£‹.
å ¼ ªê£ ™
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 4/36
5 lawyers line - march - 2013 www.l awyersline.net
ªõ.°í«êèó¡ ºî¡¬ñ ÝCKò˜ô£ò˜v ¬ô¡
ÝCKòKìI¼‰¶
ªî£ì˜‰¶ õ¼‹ bMóõ£î °î™èœ Ýó‹ðè£ôƒèO™ º‹¬ð, ªì™Lâ¡Á õì ñ£Gôƒè¬÷ °P¬õˆ¶ ïìˆFò bMóõ£Fèœ îŸ«ð£¶ ªî¡ ñ£Gôƒè¬÷ «ï£‚A ï蘉F¼Šð¬îŠð£˜‚°‹ «ð£¶, Þ‰Fò£M™â‰î ͬô º´‚¬è»‹
âOF™ AMìô£‹ â¡ø G¬ô Þ¼Šð¬î àíó º®Aø¶. ¬ìò ð£¶è£ŠHŸ° ãŸð†ì Þˆî¬èò܄ꈬî G¬ù‚°‹ «ð£¶ªõ†Aˆ î¬ô °Qò «õ‡®»œ÷¶.
݉Fó ñ£Gô‹ ¬ýî ó£ð£ˆF™ êeðˆF™ ïì‰î bMóõ£FèO¡ °îô£™ðô ÜŠð£M àJ˜èœ ðLò£A»œ÷¬î ò£¼‹ ñø‚è º®ò£¶. â‡íŸø ÜŠð£M ñ‚èœ ÞF™ ðLò£ù «ð£¶‹
ÔÔ݇죇´ è£ô‹ Ü¿¶ ¹ó‡ì£½‹ ñ£‡ìõ˜ e‡´ õ¼õ
F™¬ôÕÕ â¡Á Þø‰îõ˜è¬÷ ñø‰¶
Ýè «õ‡®ò è£Kòƒè¬÷ èõQ‚è Þò™¹ õ£›‚¬è‚° F¼‹¹‹ ñ‚èœå¼¹øI¼‚è...
«õ¬ôJ™ô£ñ™ Þ¼‰îõ¡¬èJ™ è‰î™ ¶E¬ò ªè£´ˆ¶AN â¡Á ªê£™õ¶ «ð£ô °‡´¬õŠðõ¬ùŠ ðŸP ÜôC, Ý󣌉¶æŒ‰¶«ð£ù ðˆFK¬èèœ ñŸÁ‹áìèƒèœ Þ¡ªù£¼¹ø‹...
ÝÀ‹ è†C»‹, âF˜‚è†CèÀ‹,ÜóCò™ ï£ìèƒè¬÷ Üóƒ«èŸø,cò£, ï£ù£ «ð£†® ï™ô«õ¬÷!
«è£H Þƒ° Þ™¬ô... ÞF™ «èõôñ£ù, ªõ†Aˆ
î¬ô°Qò «õ‡®ò Mûò‹â¡ùªõ¡ø£™ bMóõ£Fèœ
芫ð£õ¶ º¡Ã†®«ò ñˆFòÜ󲂰 ªîK»ñ£‹. ܬ èœñ£GôˆFŸ° ªîKMˆ¶M†«ì£‹â¡Á ÃP âv«èŠ.... ÞõŸ¬ø
G¬ù‚°‹ «ð£¶ Ü¿õî£ Ü™ô¶CKŠðî£ â¡Á ïñ‚° ¹KòM™¬ô.
å¼ 10 «ð¼ ⡬ù ÜŠð®«ò
É‚A†´ «ð£Œ Þ¬ìªõOJ™ô£ñ™ Ü®„ꣃè, Ü«î£ì M†ì£ƒè÷£? ÜõƒèÀ‚° ¬è õL‚°
¶¡Â ÜŠð®«ò Þ¡ªù£¼ Þ숶‚° É‚A†´ «ð£ù£ƒè܃è 25 «ð¼, ñ£P ñ£P IF„ꣃè,ÜŠð£ì£ Üšõ÷¾  ̈́² Mì G¬ù‚°‹ «ð£¶ â¡ùñ™ô£‚è 膮 å¼ ÍˆFóꉶ‚°Ã†®†´ «ð£ù£ƒè, ܃è å¼50 «ð¼ æõ˜ ¬ì‹ «ð£†´ Ü®„ꣃè.....  å¼ Ü® Ãì F¼ŠH
Ü®‚èô ã¡ù£ ܶô å¼ˆî¡ c ï™ôõ¡Â ªê£™L†ì£¡ â¡ø õ®«õ½M¡ ï¬è„ ²¬õ¬ò G¬ùˆ¶
  ÝÁîô¬ìò «õ‡´‹.ÔÔÞQ ®™ ïì‚芫𣰋
Mðgî M¬÷¾èÀ‚° Þ‰î ê‹ðõ‹ðô õ¬èJ½‹ õNõ°‚°‹. Õ Õ
Þ¶ ÜŠê™ °¼M¡ É‚° î‡ì¬ù G¬ø«õŸøŠð†ì«ð£¶ àñ˜ÜŠ¶™ô£ ªõOJ†ì ÜP‚¬è...
å¼ bMóõ£F¬ò ê†ìŠð®
î‡ì¬ù‚° à†ð´ˆ¶õ¬î å¼ñ£Gô ºî™õ˜ âF˜Šð¶ ÜŠð†ìñ£ù îõÁ. ºî™õ˜ ðîMJ™
Üñó Þõ¼‚° â¡ù «ò£‚Aò¬î Þ¼‚Aø¶. àøƒA‚ Aì‚°‹ bMóõ£Fè¬÷ ಊHM´‹ Ü÷Mô£ù
Þõó¶ «ð„Cù£™ Þõ¼‚°‹, bMóõ£FèÀ‚°‹ â¡ù ªî£ì˜¹â¡Á  «ò£C‚è «î£¡ÁAø¶.
ª õ š « õÁ ñ £ G ô ƒ èÀ ‚A¬ì«ò ðô Hó„C¬ùèœ Þ¼‰
‹, 冴 ªñ£ˆî Þ‰Fò£M¡åŸÁ¬ñ â¡Á õ¼‹ «ð£¶ ñ£Gôƒèœ îƒèœ ªê£‰î ÜóCò™ Hó„C¬ùè¬÷ ͆¬ì‚ 膮 M†´
®¡ Hó„C¬ù‚° º¬ùŠ¹ì¡ ªêò™ðì «õ‡´«ñ îMóܬ ÜóCòô£‚A ²òô£ð‹
ß†ì ºòô‚ Ã죶. ïñ¶ ïô¬ù â‡EŠð£˜‚è£î
ÜóCò™ î¬ôõ˜è¬÷ àìù®ò£èi†´‚° ÜŠ¹õ¶ ðŸP ñ‚èœC‰F‚è «õ‡®ò ªï¼ìô£ùè£ô‚è†ì‹  Þ¶. 𣶠ïì‰î ¬ýîó£ð£ˆ
°‡´ ªõ®Š¬ð  ê£î£óíñ£è â´ˆ¶‚ ªè£œ÷ Ã죶.
Þî¡ H¡ùEJ™ ð£Avù£,Yù£«õ£ Þ¼‚èô£‹. â¶õ£è
Þ¼‰î£½‹ ܶ Þ‰Fò£M¡ ð£¶è£ŠHŸ° MìŠð†ì êõ£ô£è«õªè£œ÷ «õ‡´‹.
êeðˆF™ îIöè àò˜cFñ¡øàˆîó¬õ Ü´ˆ¶ îIöè ªï´…ê£¬ôèO™ ÞòƒA õ¼‹ ²ñ£˜ 560ì£vñ£‚ è¬ìèœ ÍìŠðì àœ÷ùâ¡ø£½‹ Þ‰î àˆîó¾ ÔÔYŠ¬ðåOˆ¶ ¬õˆ¶ M†ì£™ F¼ñí‹
G¡Á M´‹ÕÕ â¡ð¬îŠ «ð£¡«øàœ÷¶.
ªï´…꣬ôèO™ è¬ìèœ
Þ™ô£M†ì£™ ܉î ïèóƒèO¡ Þ¬í„꣬ôèO™, Aó£ñƒèO¡à†¹øƒèO™ ܬñ‰¶œ÷ ñ¶ð£ù‚ è¬ìèO™ 憴ï˜èœñ¶ ܼ‰î ñ£†ì£˜è÷£? ñ¶Ü¼‰FM†´ e‡´‹ Mðˆ¬îãŸð´ˆF àJKöŠ¹è¬÷ ãŸð´ˆîñ£†ì£˜è÷£?
ñ¶ ܼ‰FM†´ õ£èùˆ¬î Þò‚Aù£™, æ†´ï˜ àKñˆ¬îº¿¬ñò£è óˆ¶ ªêŒõ¶ì¡
è´¬ñò£ù °ŸøŠ HKM™ 3݇´èÀ‚° Iè£ñ™ C¬øˆ î‡ì¬ù MFŠðî¡ Íôñ£è¾‹,
ñ‚èœ C‰F‚膴‹...
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 5/36
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 6/36
7 lawyers line - march - 2013 www.l awyersline.net
“Ý´«õ£«ñ ðœÀ 𣴫õ£«ñÝù‰î ²î‰Fó‹ ܬ쉶M†«ì£«ñ”,â¡Á ð£óFò£˜ ð£®M†´ ªê¡ÁM†ì£˜. à‡¬ñJ™ ªð‡èœ ²î‰Fó‹â¡ð¶ «èœM‚°Pò£è«õ àœ÷¶. ï£èKè õ÷˜„C ܬìò ܬìò ñQ
î¬ìò ÜP¾ M¼ˆFò£A¡ø«î åNò, â‡í‹ «ï˜ðìM™¬ô. ªð‡è¬÷ è£ñ‚è‡«í£´ 𣘈î àôè‹ ªð‡°ö‰¬îè¬÷»‹M†´ ¬õ‚èM™¬ô. ÷´èO½‹,ªî£¬ô‚裆CèO½‹ â™ô£ èO½‹ªð‡èÀ‚° âFó£è ïì‚°‹ ð£Lò™°Ÿøƒèœ °Pˆî ªêŒFèœ â¡ð¶è†ì£òñ£AŠ «ð£JŸÁ.
ªð‡ °ö‰¬îèÀ‚° âFó£è ð£Lò™°Ÿøƒèœ ïìŠðîŸè£ù è£óíƒèœ.
1. °ö‰¬îèOì‹ îƒèÀ¬ìò º¿õ‚Aóˆî¡¬ñ¬ò»‹ 裆ìô£‹.
2. °ö‰¬îèœ ÜFè‹ âF˜Š¹ ªîK
M‚èñ£†ì£˜èœ.3. °ö‰¬îèœ ªñ¡¬ñò£ùõ˜è«÷4. °ö‰¬îÀ‚° ïì‰î °ŸøˆF¡ H¡
ùQ¬ò º¿¬ñò£è MõK‚è ªîKò£¶.«ñŸè‡ì è£óíƒèœ  °ö‰¬î
èÀ‚° âFó£è õ¡º¬øèœ ÜFè‹ ï¬ìªðø è£óíñ£J¼‚Aø¶.
°ö‰¬îèÀ‚° âFó£ù ð£Lò™ õ¡º¬ø‚° Íô è£óí«ñ à÷Mò™ gFò£ùHó„C¬ù ñŸÁ‹ å¼õ˜ «ñ™ å¼õ˜ªè£‡ì ð¬è, 裛Š¹í˜„C õ‚Aó‹ ÝAò¬õ»‹ º‚Aò ðƒ° õA‚Aø¶. ÜPMò™
õ÷˜„C ®¡ º¡«ùŸøˆFŸ‚°ðò¡ð´õ¬îMì Y˜«è†®Ÿ° ÜFè‹ðò¡ð´ˆîŠð´Aø¶. ܬô«ðC¬ò»‹,I¡ù…ê¬ô»‹, ªî£¬ôˆªî£ì˜¹‚°ðò¡ð´ˆ¶õ ðFô£è è‡ì è‡ìè£ñ õ‚AóƒèÀ‚° ðò¡ð´ˆ¶A¡øù˜.
Þîù£™ Þî¬ù 𣘊ðõ è̃À‚°‹ ñù‹õ‚AóŠð´Aø¶.
°ö‰¬îèÀ‚° âFó£ù ð£Lò™õ¡º¬ø ò£˜ ò£˜ Íô‹ ïì‚Aø¶ â¡Á𣘈 ªê£™ô ªï…ê‹ ï´ƒ°Aø¶.
î, ê«è£îó¡, ªï¼ƒAò àøMù˜,
ð‚舶 i†®™ °®J¼Šðõ˜èœ, ðœO‚°Ü¬öˆ¶ ªê™½‹ ï숶ù˜ ñŸÁ‹ ðô˜ ä‰îP¾œ÷ I¼ƒèÀ‚°ˆî£¡
 ß¡ø °†®»ì¡ «ê˜‰¶ ÞùŠªð¼‚è‹ ªêŒòô£ñ£ â¡ø à혾 Ãì
Þ™ô£ñ™ °†®«ò£´ ¹í¼‹. Ü«î«ð£ôªê£‰î ñè¬÷«ò ¹í¼A¡ø ÜP¾‚ªè†ì ðô èFó£è õö‚° ïìˆî«õ‡®ò ¶˜ð£‚Aò G¬ô¬ñ‚°Ý÷£A»œ«÷¡. ÜŠ«ð£¶ ãŸð´‹õL¬ò ªê£ôõ õ£˜ˆ¬îèœ Þ™¬ô.
ܼA™  àK¬ñ«ò£´ °ö‰¬îè«÷£´ ðöèM´‹ ïñ¶ àø¾‚è£ó˜,܇¬ì i†ì£˜ ñŸÁ‹ ðôó£™ Þ‰î
ªð‡ °ö‰¬îèœâF˜ªè£œÀ‹ð£Lò™ Hó„¬ùèœ!
C.êƒèIˆF¬óõö‚èPë˜
7 lawyers line - march - 2013 www.l awyersline.net
Ý «ô£ ê ¬ù
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 7/36
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 8/36
9 lawyers line - march - 2013 www.l awyersline.net
êeð è£ôñ£è ñ ðîø„ ªêŒ»‹ å¼ ªêŒF
å¡Á à‡ªì¡ø£™ ܶ °ö‰¬îèœ eî£ùð£Lò™ ªè£´¬ñèœ °Pˆî ªêŒFèœ !! Þ¬õ «î£Á‹ â™ô£ ðˆFK¬èèO½‹ îõø£ñ™ Þì‹H®ˆ¶M´Aø¶. Þî¬ù 𮂰‹ ªðŸ«ø£˜èœ ï‹ñ°ö‰¬î‚° Hó„¬ù å¡Á‹ Þ™¬ô, ï¡ø£è 
Þ¼‚Aø£œ(¡) âù êñ£î£ù‹ ªêŒ¶ è쉶 «ð£ŒM´Aø£˜èœ. Ýù£™ Hó„¬ùJ™ bMó‹ Þ¡¬øòªðŸ«ø£˜èœ º¿¬ñò£Œ àíóM™¬ô. ⃫è£
ïì‰î¶ ÷ ï‹ °ö‰¬î‚°‹ ïì‚èô£‹ âùå¼ èí‹ C‰F‚è «õ‡´‹... Üšõ£Á C‰Fˆî£™
Þ‚ªè£´¬ñJ™ Þ¼‰¶ ï‹ °ö‰¬î¬ò âŠð®ð£¶è£‚èô£‹ â¡ø «èœM â¿‹...ðF¬ô «î´
õ£˜èœ...Å›G¬ô¬ò âF˜‚ªè£œ÷, êñ£O‚è îƒèœ °ö‰¬î‚° èŸÁ ªè£´Šð£˜èœ !
ªðŸ«ø£˜è«÷ â„êK‚¬è ! ÷ àƒèœ °ö‰¬î»‹ Þ‚ªè£´¬ñ‚°
Ý÷£èô£‹ ??!!å¼ ð£Lò™ õ‚Aó‹ Üóƒ«èPò¶‹ ܬîŠðŸP
ñ‚èœ è£óê£óñ£è Mõ£FŠð£˜èœ...Üõ¡ å¼I¼è¡... Üõ¬ù àJ«ó£ì Mì‚Ã죶... É‚A™«ð£´ƒèœ â¡Á !! ªð¼‹ð£½‹ Þˆî¬èò°Ÿøõ£OèÀ‚° ꣘ð£è õ£î£ì õ‚W™èÀ‹ º¡õ¼õF™¬ô, eP õ‰î£½‹ Hø õ‚W™èœ ܬîM¼‹¹õF™¬ô, ÜÂñFŠð¶‹ Þ™¬ô. Ýù£™â™ô£‹ Ü‰î ªêŒFJ™ Å´ Þ¼‚°‹ õ¬ó
...H¡ù˜ ñ‚èÀ‚° «õÁ å¼ ¹Fò ªêŒFõ‰¶M´‹. ðô ªè£´¬ñèœ ªîK‰¶‹, ªîKò£ñ™
ªî£ì˜‰¶ ï쉶 ªè£‡®¼‰î£½‹ ï‹ ñ‚èO¡MNŠ¹í˜¾(?) Þ‰î Ü÷M™  Þ¼‚Aø¶.
& å¼ êÍè Üõô‹
Í¡Á õò¶
°ö‰¬î¬ò
ð£Lò™ gFJ™
¶¡¹Áˆî âŠð®ñù‹ õ¼Aø¶...
ÝøP¾ ñQî˜è÷£è
Hø‰î Þõ˜èœ ã¡
ÞŠð® ºó‡ð†´
ïì‚Aø£˜èœ â¡ð¬î
ðŸPò ÝŒ¾è¬÷
𮂰‹ «ð£¶ I辋MòŠð£è Þ¼‚Aø¶.
°ö‰¬îèœ eî£ù ð£Lò™ ߘŠ¹& ªè÷ê™ò£, F¼ªï™«õL
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 9/36
ww w.l awye rsli ne .ne t 10 lawyers line - march - 2013
ñ‚è¬÷ ªð£Áˆîõ¬ó °ö‰¬îèœ eî£ùð£Lò™ ߘŠ¹œ÷ ñQî˜è¬÷„ êºî£òˆF™
ïìñ£ì M´õ¶ Ýðˆ¶ â¡ð«î. 强¬ø Þˆ î¬èò °ŸøƒèO™ ß´ð´ðõ˜èœ e‡´‹ e‡´‹Ü¶«ð£¡ø õ¡º¬øèO™ ß´ð´Aø£˜èœ.CÁ°ö‰¬îè¬÷ ¬õˆF¼‚°‹ ªðŸ«ø£˜èœ Ièèõùñ£è Þ¼‚è«õ‡®ò Å›G¬ô Þ¶.
Í¡Á õò¶ °ö‰¬î¬ò ð£Lò™ gFJ™ ¶¡
¹Áˆî âŠð® ñù‹ õ¼Aø¶... ÝøP¾ ñQî˜è÷£èHø‰î Þõ˜èœ ã¡ ÞŠð® ºó‡ ð†´ ïì‚Aø£˜èœâ¡ð¬î ðŸPò ÝŒ¾è¬÷ 𮂰‹ «ð£¶ I辋MòŠð£è Þ¼‚Aø¶. Þî¡ î¡¬ñ ðŸP ÃÁ‹ à÷Mò™ ÜPë˜èœ Þ¶
‘d«ì£ŠdLò£’ â¡Â‹ å¼ õ¬è à÷Mò™ «ï£Œ â¡A¡øù˜. Üõ˜èO¡ ßÁŠð® Þ‰î â‡íƒèœå¼õ¼‚° Üõ˜ ð¼õ õò¶ õ‰î¾ì«ù õ‰¶ M´Aø¶.ªðKòõ˜èœ êñõòFù¼ì¡ ܈î¬èò ªêò™èO™ß´ðì º®ò£îõ˜èœ Ü™ô¶ ܉î õ£ŒŠ¹A¬ì‚è£îõ˜èœ ÞŠð® °ö‰¬îè¬÷ ðò¡ð´ˆF‚ªè£œAø£˜èœ.
«ñ½‹ Þˆî¬èò ªêò™èO™ ß´ð´ðõ˜èO™å¼Cô˜ îƒè÷¶ CÁõòF™ Þ«î «ð£¡ø å¼ ¶¡¹
Áˆî½‚° Ý÷£A Þ¼‚è‚ô‹ â¡Aø¶ ÝŒ¾.ñóHò™ è£óíƒèÀ‹ Þ¼‚èô£‹! å¼ °´‹
ðˆF™ Þˆî¬èò ñùG¬ô ªè£‡ìõ˜èœ Þ¼‰F¼‚Aø£˜èœ â¡ø£™ Ü´ˆ¶ õ¼‹ õ£K²èOì‹ Þˆ
î¬èò â‡í‹ õ¼õ õ£ŒŠ¹ ÜFè Ü÷M™ Þ¼Šðî£è M…ë£Qèœ è¼ˆ¶‚èœ ªê£™L Þ¼‰î£½‹, ܈î¬èò ñóðµ Þ¡Á õ¬ó 致H®‚èŠðìM™¬ô â¡ð¶ ïñ‚° å¼ ÝÁî™. Þõ˜è¬÷ ªõÁ‹ °Ÿøõ£Oò£è ñ†´‹ 𣘂
è£ñ™ à÷Mò™ °¬ø𣴜÷ «ï£ò£Oè÷£è¾‹ð£˜‚è «õ‡´‹ â¡Aø£˜èœ à÷Mò™ÝŒõ£÷˜èœ.
Ýù£™ òˆî‹ â¡ùªõ¡ø£™, Þˆî¬èòõ˜è¬÷ à÷Mò™ gFò£è¾‹ , ñ¼‰¶ CA„¬êèO¡Íôñ£è¾‹ °íð´ˆîô£‹ â¡ø£½«ñ ÜI°‰î CóñŠðì«õ‡´‹, îMó¾‹ Þˆî¬èò Þ„¬êè¬÷ 膴Šð´ˆî Þõ˜èœ õ£›‚¬è º¿õ¶‹Iè èwìŠð†´ ºòô «õ‡´‹ â¡ð«î...!?
ÝŒ¾èœ â¬î»‹ ªê£™LM†´ «ð£è†´‹,Ýù£™ ªðKòõ˜è÷£Aò  ï‹I¬ì«ò Ièê£î£óíñ£è ïìñ£® ªè£‡®¼‚°‹ Þˆî¬èòÝðˆî£ùõ˜èOì‹ Þ¼‰¶ ï‹ °ö‰¬îè¬÷ âŠð®è£Šð£Ÿø «ð£A«ø£‹ â¡ð«î  àƒèOì‹â¿Š¹‹ å¼ «èœM. Þˆî¬èòõ˜èÀ‚° °ö‰¬îèœ âF˜‚è ñ£†
ì£˜èœ â¡ð«î å¼ º‚Aò è£óí‹. °ö‰¬î蜪ð¼‹ð£½‹ îƒè÷¶ àøMù˜èœ, ð‚舶 i†®ù˜,ðœO‚° ܬöˆ¶ ªê™½‹ ïð˜èœ «ð£¡øõ˜è÷£«ô«ò I°‰î ð£FŠ¹‚° Ý÷£Aø£˜èœ.ªð‡ °ö‰¬îèÀ‚°  Þ‰î ð£FŠ¹ ÜF苫+ â¡ø£½«ñ ݇ °ö‰¬îèÀ‹ Þ‰î ªè£´¬ñ‚° õF™¬ô. èòõ˜èœ Ü‰î «ïóˆF™
ò£¬ó âŠð® «õ‡´ñ£ù£½‹ ðò¡ð´ˆF‚ªè£œõ£˜èœ. Üõ˜è÷¶ «î¬õ îŸè£Lèñ£è îƒ
è÷¶ â‡í‹ ß«ìø «õ‡´‹ Üšõ÷«õ !!ð£F‚èŠð´‹ ܬùˆ¶ °ö‰¬îèÀ«ñ îƒèÀ‚°
ïì‰î ªè£´¬ñ¬ò ªê£™õ£˜èœ â¡Á âF˜ð£˜‚躮ò£¶. ªê£¡ù£™ ªðŸ«ø£˜èœ îƒè¬÷ˆî£¡Ü®Šð£˜èœ Ü™ô¶ F†´õ£˜èœ â¡ø Ü„êˆF¡è£óíñ£è ñ¬øˆ¶ M´Aø£˜èœ.
è†ì£ò àø¾‚° Ý÷£°‹ °ö‰¬îèœ ñùgFò£èàì™ gFò£è I°‰î ð£FŠ¹‚°œ÷£Aø£˜èœ . ð£F‚è
ð†ì °ö‰¬îèœ âF˜è£ôˆF™ °´‹ð õ£›M™ ß´ð´‹ «ð£¶ I°‰î ñù à¬÷„꽂° àœ÷£Aø£˜èœ.ðô Mõ£èóˆ¶ Hó„¬ùèO¡ H¡ùEJ™ Þ‰îHó„ê¬ù º‚Aò è£óíñ£è Þ¼Šð¶ ê‹ð‰îŠð†ì ݇, ªð‡µ‚«è ªîKõF™¬ô â¡ð¶î£¡
ÞF™ ªð¼ˆî «ê£è‹.
Þ è´¬ñò£ù î‡ì¬ùèœ â¡Á Þ¼‰î£™ îõÁ ªêŒò ⇵‹ ïð˜èœ Ü„ê‹ ªè£‡´ Þ‰î ªêò¬ô îM˜Šð£˜è÷£ â¡Á å¼ «èœMâ¿‹¹Aø¶. «ñ«ô£†ìñ£è 𣘂°‹«ð£¶ êKâ¡Á «î£¡Pù£½‹, è´¬ñò£ù î‡ì¬ùèÀ‚°ªðò˜ ªðŸø Ü«óHò ®«ô«ò Þˆî¬èò°Ÿøƒèœ ê£î£óíñ£è ï¬ìªðÁ‹«ð£¶ î‡ì¬ùñ†´«ñ Þ b˜õ£è Þ¼‚è º®ò£¶ â¡«ø«î£¡ÁAø¶. îMó¾‹ ïñ¶ ®™ Þ„ªêò½‚°,
î‡ì¬ù â¡Á 𣘈, ªð‡èœ ð£F‚èŠð†ì£™ ªè£´‚èŠð´‹ Ü«î 7 ݇´ ºî™ 10݇´èœ C¬øõ£ê‹  °ö‰¬îèœ ð£F‚èŠð†ì£½‹ °Ÿøõ£OèÀ‚° ªè£´‚èŠð´Aø¶â¡A¡øù˜...?!
Ýù£™ Þ¬õ ñ†´‹ «ð£î£¶ î‡ì¬ùèœ Þ¡Â‹ è´¬ñò£‚èŠðì «õ‡´‹.
2002 õ¶ ݇®¡ èí‚A¡ð® 89,000 °ö‰¬îèœ ð£F‚èŠð†´œ÷ù˜. ªõOJ™ õ‰î èí‚°
Þ¬õ ñ†´«ñ... õó£î¬õ âˆî¬ù ÝJó«ñ£....??!! Þ¬õ ꣰‹ õ¬ó ÜNò£î õ´‚èœ... ÜPò£î
õò¶ â¡ø£ ½‹, ÜP‰î H¡ ªî£¬ôò£î ªè£´¬ñ!!!?
♫ô£˜ i†®½‹ °ö‰¬îèœ Þ¼‚Aø£˜èœâ¡Aø «ð£¶ Þ¬î 𮂰‹ 嚪õ£¼ˆ
 ÞQ«ñô£õ¶ îƒèœ °ö‰¬îèO¡ ð®ŠHŸ°è£†´‹ Ü‚è¬ø¬ò ªè£…ê‹ àƒèœ °ö‰¬îèO¡ «ñ½‹ 裆´ƒèœ...
°† ì„, «ð† ì„ ðŸP ªê£™L ªè£´ƒèœ.¬è¬ò ªî£´õ¶, °½‚°õ¶ ñ†´‹  °†ì„ âù «ð£F»ƒèœ.
°ö‰¬îèœ ªê£™½‹ â‰îå¼ C¡ù Mêòˆ¬î»‹ 裶
ªè£´ˆ¶ ªð£Á¬ñò£è «èÀƒèœ.
â‰î °¬ø ªê£¡ù£½‹ Ü F†ì£ñ™ àŸê£èð´ˆF º¿¬ñò£è ªê£™ô ¬õ»ƒèœ. º‚Aòñ£è°ö‰¬îèœ ªð£Œ ªê£™ô ñ£† 죘èœ
â¡ð¬î  ñø‚è‚ Ã죶.
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 10/36
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 11/36
ww w.l awye rsli ne .ne t 12 lawyers line - march - 2013
3Þ‰Fò ê†ì ê‚èóõ˜ˆF
Ü‡í™ Ü‹«ðˆè˜
ð°F
& ªï™¬ô ñE
ªè£ô‹Hò£ ð™è¬ô‚ èöè‹ îù¶ ñFŠ¹I°‰î ñ£íõ˜èœ â¡ø ñ°ìˆF¡ ñFŠ¹ I°‰î
óˆFù è™L™ Ü‹«ðˆè¬ó å¼ óˆFùñ£è ðFˆ¶ªè£‡ì¶. ܉î ð™è¬ô‚ èöè‹ Üƒ° Ü‹«ðˆè˜
îƒA ð®‚è M´Fèœ Þ™¬ô. Üîù£™, îQò£˜
M´Fè¬÷ ù£˜. Ýù£™, ܃° Üõ¼‚° ãŸøàí¾ õ¬èèœ Üƒ° A¬ì‚èM™¬ô. ÝF‚èªõPò˜èœ 𣘬õJ™ ˆîŠð†ìõ˜èœ â¡ø£™,Üõ˜èœ â¬î»‹ ꣊H´õ£˜èœ â¡ø â‡í‹
ïñ¶ ´ ï‰î¡ êKˆFóˆF™ «è†ì¬îŠ «ð£™ñ£´ F¡Â‹ ¹™¬ôò£ àù‚° ñ£˜èN
F¼ï£÷£ì£ â¡ð¬îŠ «ð£™ Üõ˜ Ý´, ñ£´ F¡ð£˜ â¡Á G¬ùˆ¶ Mì£b˜èœ. Üõ˜ê£ŠH´õ¶ âOò ¬êõ àí«õ. ܬî Üõ˜Üƒ° «î® «î® ܬô‰î£˜ A¬ì‚èM™¬ô.܃° ð®‚è «ð£°‹ ñ£íõ˜èœ CQñ£ ï£ìè‹«èO‚¬è Üóƒ°èœ, ‚° ¼Cò£ù Ýì‹ðóàí¾ õ¬èèœ â¡Á Þ¼‚°‹ «ð£¶, Ü‹«ðˆè˜à™ô£ê õ£›¬õ ¶ø‰¶ âOò õ£›‚¬è ïìˆFàò˜‰î è™M¬òŠ ªðŸø£˜. ï™ô M´F¬òªðøM™¬ô. ÞÁFò£è LMƒvì¡ ý£™ â¡Â‹
Þ숬î ܬì‰î£˜. ܃«è Ü¡«ð à¼õ£ùð‹ð£J™ Þ¼‰¶ õ‰î ð£˜C ñ£íõ˜ «ïõ™ð«î¡ â¡ðõK¡  A¬ìˆî¶. Þ¼õ¼‹ ܃«è
îƒAù£˜èœ.Ü‹«ðˆè˜ HøŠð£™ ˆîŠð†ìõó£è
Þ¼‰î£½‹, °íˆî£™ àò˜‰¶ Þ¼‚°‹ àò˜‰îð‡¬ð à혉î ð«î¡ ð£ó£†®ù£˜. Üõ¼ì¡
ªï¼ƒA ðöA àò˜‰î ‚° Þô‚èíñ£è F蛉èœ. õ£›M¡ ÞÁFõ¬ó Þ¼õ¼‹
ï£Â‹ ࡬ù «ð£¡ø ñQî¡ î£«ù, ¹¿õ™ô«õ ã¡ Þ‰î ªõP à혾.ܪñK‚è£ ªê¡ø«ð£¶ ܃° Þ‰î ªè£´¬ñ Þ™¬ô«ò. ܃° ê£F «ðî‹
Þ™¬ô«ò, âŠð® ²î‰Fóñ£è ïìñ£®«ù¡. ܃° âŠð® Høó£™ ñF‚èŠð†«ì£‹.
îù¶ ÜP¾‚° âˆî¬èò ñKò£¬î A¬ìˆî¶ â¡Á Üõ˜ è‡èœ °÷ñ£Aù.
C ø Š ¹ ªî£ ì ˜
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 12/36
13 lawyers line - march - 2013 www.l awyersline.net
Þ¬í HKò£î ï‡ð˜è÷£è Þ¼‰ èœ. ð®‚è ï™ô Å›G¬ô¬òà¼õ£‚A‚ ªè£‡ì Ü‹«ðˆè£˜æŒM¡P Fùº‹ 18 ñE «ïó‹ð®ˆî£˜. îù¶ àí¬õ °¬øˆ¶‚ªè£‡´ âOò õ£›¬õ «ñŸªè£‡´ îù¶ àðè£ó ê‹ð÷ˆF™å¼ ð°F¬ò ñ¬ùM‚° ÜŠH
¬õˆî£˜. îù¶ «ñŸð®Šð£ù â‹.ã.ð†ìŠð®ŠHŸ° ÜóCò™ M…ë£ù‹å¿‚è õ‹, ªð£¼÷£î£ó‹, êÍèMò™ ñŸÁ‹ ñQî õ‹ ÝAòð£ìƒè¬÷ â´ˆ¶‚ ªè£í¢ì£˜.
îù¶ è®ù à¬öŠH¡ è£óíñ£è 1915&‹ ݇®™ð‡¬ì è£ô Þ‰Fò õ£Eð‹ â¡ø î¬ôŠH™Ý󣌄C 膴¬ó êñ˜ŠHˆ¶, â‹.ã. ð†ì‹ ªðŸø£˜.ܫ ñ†´ñ™ô£ñ™, Þ‰Fò£M™ ê£FèO¡«î£Ÿøº‹, õ÷˜„C»‹, â¡ø Ý󣌄C 膴¬óâ¿F Üî¬ù 輈îóƒA™ ð®ˆî£˜. ܉îÝ󣌄C 膴¬ó¬ò å¼ ¹ˆîèñ£è ªõOJ†ì£˜.
ܶ Ü‹«ðˆè˜ Ü„C†´ ªõOJ†ì ºî™â¿ˆ¶ õ®õ‹ Ý°‹. ܉î 膴¬óJ™ Þ‰Fò£M™ê£Fèœ Üî¡ õ÷˜„C Üî¡ bò «ð£‚°. ܶñ¬øò£î º‚Aò è£óíƒèœ ÝAòõŸ¬øIè Üöè£è¾‹, ªîOõ£è¾‹ M÷‚A»œ÷£˜.1916&‹ ݇´ Þ‰Fò£M™, «îCò ðƒ° iî‹â¡Â‹ ªð£¼÷£î£ó Ý󣌄C 膴¬ó â¿Fªè£ô‹Hò£ ð™è¬ô èöèˆF™ êñ˜ŠHˆî£˜. ܶõóô£ŸÁ CøŠ¹ I‚è 膴¬ó Ý°‹. ܉î膴¬ó‚° Ü‹«ðˆè¼‚° ì£‚ì˜ ð†ì‹A¬ìˆî¶. ì£‚ì˜ Ü‹«ðˆè˜ â¡ø ªð¼¬ñ¬òŠ
ªðŸø£˜. ܉î CøŠ¹ I°‰î 膴¬ó H‰ï£O™ Þ‰Fò£M™ ݃A«ôò ݆Cò˜ ñ£è£ù ªð£¼÷£î£ó õ÷˜„C â¡ø ¹ˆîèñ£è ªõO õ‰î¶.Üî¬ù îù¶ ï¡P èìù£è îù‚° è™M ÜOˆîð«ó£ì£ ñ¡ù¼‚° è£E‚¬èò£‚Aù£˜.
¹è› ªðŸø ÜPë˜èÀ‹ ªð£¼÷£î£ó MŸð¡ù˜èÀ‹ ªõ°õ£è Þ‰î ˬôŠ ð£ó£†® «ðCù£˜èœ. ñ£íõ˜èÀ‹, ê†ìñ¡ø àÁŠHù˜èœ Þ‰î ˬô «ð£ŸP ðò¡ð´ˆF‚ ªè£‡ìù˜.â‹.ã. ð†ìº‹, ì£‚ì˜ ð†ìº‹ ªðŸÁ‹
Ü‹«ðˆè¼‚° ð®ŠH¡ î£è‹ îEòM™¬ô. Üîù£™ 1916&݋݇´ GÎò £ ˜ ‚A™ Þ¼ ‰¶¹øŠð†´ ô‡ì¡ õ‰¶ «ê˜‰î£˜.ô‡ìQ™ ð® ‚ è ð « ó £ ì £ñ¡ùKì‹ ÜÂñF «è†´ è®î‹â¿Fù£˜. ñ¡ù¼‹ ê‹ñFˆ¶ GF嶂è Fõ£Â‚° àˆîóM†ì£˜.
Ü‹«ðˆè˜ C«ó M´FJ™ îƒAù£˜.𣘠& ܆ô£ ð®‚è ñ ðF¾ªêŒ¶ ªè£‡ì£˜. Ü«î êñò‹ ¹è›ªðŸø ªð£¼÷£î£ó ðœOJ™â‹.âv.C., ªð£¼÷£î£ó‹, ÜóCò™
ð£ìƒèO™ ð†ì‹ ªðø¾‹ ðF¾ ªêŒ¶ ªè£‡ì£˜.ªð¼‰î¡¬ñ à¬ìò ñ¡ù˜ àˆîóM†ì£½‹,ê£F ªõP»‹ °ÁAò ñùŠð£¡¬ñ ªè£‡ì
Fõ£¡, Üî¬ù M¼‹ð£ñ™, Ü‹«ðˆè¼‚° ð®Šð ªêŒî åŠð‰î‹ º®‰¶ M†ì¶. àì«ù
Þ‰Fò£¾‚° Ü‹«ðˆè˜ F¼‹H õó «õ‡´‹ â¡Á Fõ£¡ ðF™ è®î‹ â¿F M†ì£ .̃ ªð¼ˆî ãñ£Ÿø‹
Ü‹«ðˆè¼‚° ãŸð†ì¶. ðí õêF Þ¡P âŠð®ð®‚è º®»‹. ñù‹ ¶õ‡ì£˜. «õÁ õNJ¡P
Þ‰Fò£ F¼‹ð º®¾ ªêŒî£˜. ¹øŠð´õº¡ ô‡ì¡ ð™è¬ôèöè «ðó£CKò˜ 죂ì˜â†M¡ è£ù£¡ â¡ðõKì‹ 1917&Ý‹ ݇´Ü‚«ì£ðKL¼‰¶ ° ݇´èÀ‚°œ F¼‹Hõ‰¶ î¡ ð®Š¬ð ªî£ìó ÜÂñF «è†ì£˜.Üõ¼‹ ð™è¬ô‚ èöèˆF¡ Íô‹ ÜÂñFªðŸÁˆî‰î£˜. ñù‹ ñA›‰¶  ®Ÿ°¹øŠð†ì£˜. ¹øŠð´‹ «ð£¶ îù¶ ÜPõ£Ÿø¬ôàò˜ˆî ༶¬íò£è Þ¼‰î ÜPò Ë™è¬÷
膴 è†ì£è 膮 å¼ èŠðL™ ÜŠHM†´Ü‹«ðˆè˜ «õÁ å¼ èŠðL™ Þ‰Fò£ F¼‹Hù£˜. ÜŠ«ð£¶, Þó‡ì£‹ àôè »ˆî‹ ï쉶ªè£‡®¼‰î¶. Üîù£™, Üõó¶ ¹ˆîèƒèÀ‹,ê£ñ£¡èÀ‹ õ‰î èŠð™ ªü˜ñ£Qò cK™Í›A èŠðô£™ èŠð†´ Í›A «ð£JŸÁ.ÜF˜wìõêñ£è Ü‹«ðˆè˜ õ‰î èŠð½‚° â‰î
bƒ°‹ «ïóM™¬ô. Ýù£½‹, Ü‹«ðˆèK¡ÜPò Ë™èœ èìL™ Í›A «ð£ù, I辋õ¼ˆîŠð†ì£˜. ÜPò Ë™èœ «ð£ù£½‹,ÜPò ªð£‚Aû‹ ïñ‚° A¬ìˆî«î â¡ø
ñA›„C ˆîŠð†ì ñ‚èÀ‚° ܉î àô芫ð£K™ «ïê èÀ‚° HK†ì¡ î¬ô¬ñãŸÁ‹, âF˜ ÜE‚° ªü˜ñQ î¬ô¬ñ ãŸÁ‹«ð£˜ ï쉶 õ‰î¶. ªü˜ñQ ªõŸP ºèñ£è
Þ¼‰î¶. HK†ì¡ «î£™M ñùˆî£™ ¶õ‡´è£íŠð†ì¶ . Þ‰Fò ²ò£†C Þò‚èˆ
Fù˜ «ð£ó£†ì‹ ïìˆFù£̃ . Þ‰Fò ¹ó†C ió˜èœI辋 bMóñ£è ªêò™ð†ìù˜. Üì‚° º¬ø¬ò¬èò£‡´‹ ªó÷ô† ê†ìˆ¬î «ð£†´ ñ‚è¬÷ªè£´¬ñŠð´ˆFò ñ‚è¬÷ êñ£î£ùŠð´ˆî Þ‰Fò¼‚° ²ò£†C Fø¬ù õ÷˜‚è
Þ‰Fò î¬ôõ˜èO¡ 輈¶è¬÷ «è†ìPò Þ‰Fò ®¡ ݃Aô è£KòîKC ô‡ìQ™ Þ¼‰¶ ñ£‡«ì° Hó¹ Þ‰Fò£ õ‰î£˜. ªê‹v
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 13/36
ww w.l awye rsli ne .ne t 14 lawyers line - march - 2013
«ð£˜´ Hó¹ Þ‰Fò£M™ ¬õv ó£ò£è Þ¼‰îõ˜. Þõ˜î£¡H¡ù£O™ ñ£‡«ì° ªê‹v«ð£˜´ Y˜F¼ˆî‹ ªè£‡´õ‰îõ˜. ñ£‡«ì° Hó¹Mì‹ð™«õÁ ÜóCò™ è†CèO¡°¿‚èœ îƒèO¡ °¬øè¬÷â ´ ˆ ¶ ¬ ó ˆ î ù . Þ ‰ F ò
õóô£ŸP™ ºî¡ ºîL™ ˆ îŠð†ì ñ‚èO¡ HóFGFèO¡°¿‚èœ îƒèO¡ °¬øè¬÷ˆªîKM‚è º¡õ‰îù.
ªê¡¬ù ñ£è£ù ð…êñ˜è™M ÜHM¼ˆF êƒ è‹ ,ªê¡¬ù ÝF Fó£Mì˜ ñè£üùêƒè‹ ªó†ìñ¬ô YQõ£ê¡â‹.C.ó£üõƒè£÷ ˆîŠð†ì ܬñŠ¹ å´‚èŠð†ìõ˜èO¡ ܬñŠ¹èœ ÝAò¬õ
Ü‹«ðˆè˜ ªêòô£Ÿø á‚èñOˆîù. ÜŠð®Šð†ì °¿‚èO™ Ü‹«ðˆè¼‹ Þ¼‰î£˜.
ÜóCòL™ Üõ˜ îù¶ Þùˆ FŸè£è è£ô® â´ˆ¶ ¬õˆîºî™ G蛄Cò£°‹. ð«ó£ì£ñ¡ù˜ ªêŒ¶ ªè£í¢ì åŠð‰
îˆF¡ð® 10 ݇´èœ ðEò£Ÿø Ü‹«ðˆè˜ ð«ó£ì£ªê¡ø£˜. Üõ¬ó ¹¬èõ‡®
G¬ôòˆF™ Þ¼‰¶ ܬöˆ¶õó ñ¡ù˜ ݬíJ†®¼‰î£˜.
Ýù£™ ܃° ò£¼‹ õóM™¬ô.âŠð® õ¼õ£˜èœ. Þõ˜ ˆ
îŠð†ìõ˜, âšõ÷¾ 𮈶 Þ¼‰î£½‹, âšõ÷¾ àòó‹á˜‚°¼M ðø‰î£½‹ ܶ ð¼‰
ñ£ â¡ø «è†°‹ ê£FªõP H®ˆîõ˜èœ Þõ¬ù ñFŠðî£ â¡ø Ýíõ‹. Ýè«õò£¼‹ óJ™ G¬ôò‹ õóM™¬ô.ñ¡ù˜ Ü‹«ðˆè¼‚° GFܬñ„ê˜ ðîM ªè£´‚è
Þ¼‰î£˜. ܉î ê£F Þ‰¶‚èœãŸÁ‚ ªè£œõ£˜è÷£? Þ‰îªêŒF 裆´ˆ bò£è ðóMò¶.܉î êñvî£ùˆF™ ðEò£Ÿ
Á‹ è¬ì G¬ô áNò¡ ÃìñF‚èM™¬ô. ã÷ùñ£è 𣘈¶âœO ï¬èò£®, Þ蛄Cò£è «ðC
b˜ˆî£˜èœ.Ü‹«ðˆè¼‚° Üõñ£ù‹
î£ƒè º®òM™¬ô. ܽõôèˆF™ °®c˜ Ãì îó ñÁˆ
èœ. ‹ M´FèO™ Hø
ÞìƒèO™ i´ «î® ܬöˆ¶‹êñvî£ù àˆFó„¬ê ̬ù
èœ Þõ¡ W› ê£F‚è£ó¡ i´ªè£´‚è£b˜èœ â¡Á Hó„ê£ó‹ªêŒî£˜èœ. å¼ï£œ º¿‚èܬô‰¶ H¡ù˜ ð£˜Cè£ó˜èÀ‚° ªê£‰îñ£ù å¼ êˆFóˆ
F™ ªðò˜ ñ£ŸP ÃP  å¼ ð£̃ Câ¡Á ªê£™L îƒAù£ .̃ F¯ªó¡Áå¼ ï£œ ãªö†´ ð£KCè£ó˜èœ
F´ F´ªõù Þõ˜ èî¬õ ò£˜ c âŠð® ªð£Œ ªê™L
Þƒ° îƒèô£‹. àì«ù êˆF óˆ¬î è£L ªêŒò£M†ì£™à¡¬ù è£L ªêŒ«õ£‹ â¡ÁÝ»îƒè÷£™ Ió†® M†´«ð£ù£˜èœ. Üõ˜èœ «ð£ù Hø°êˆFóˆ¬î è£L ªêŒ¶ M†´ªîK‰îõ˜èOì‹ i´ «è†´ð£˜ˆî£™ ò£¼‹ îó M™¬ô. îù¶ Üõô G¬ô¬ò M÷‚A
ñ¡ù¼‚° è®î‹ â¿F Üó‡ñ¬ùJ«ô«ò îƒè ãŸð£´
ªêŒ»ñ£Á «è†´ ð‹ð£Œ ¹øŠð†ì£˜. ñ¡ù¼‹ Fõ£Â‚°àì«ù îƒè ãŸð£´ ªêŒòªê£¡ù£˜. ê£F ªõPŠH®ˆî
Fõ£¡ Üî¬ù„ ªêŒò ñù‹ Þ™¬ô. ñù «õî¬ù»‹ Ü‹«ðˆè˜ ïì‰î¶ îù¶ ÝCKò˜A¼wí£T ªè™ÖvèKì‹ÃP ܿ. A¼wí£T Ü‹«ðˆè¬ó «îŸP îù¶ ï‡ð˜å¼õ˜ ð«ó£ì£M™ «ðó£CKò
ó£è Þ¼‚Aø£˜. Üõ¼‚° è®î‹â¿¶A«ø¡. Üõ˜ âŠð®»‹
Þì‹ î¼õ£˜ â¡Á è®î‹ â¿
Fù£̃ . Üõ¼‹ ð°ˆîP¾ C‰î¬ùà¬ìòõ˜. Üîù£™ Ü‹«ðˆè˜ îù¶ Þ™ôˆF™ îƒè ê‹ñFˆ¶ è®î‹ â¿Fù£˜. Ü‹«ðˆè£˜ ñù‹ ñA›„Cò¬ì‰¶ ÞQHó„C¬ùJ™¬ô âù ð«ó£ì£¹øŠð†´„ ªê¡ø£˜. óJ™ G¬ôòˆF™ ù
õó«õŸè «ðó£CKò˜ ݆è¬÷ÜŠH Þ¼Šð£˜ â¡Á 𣘈
. Ü‰î «ðó£CKò˜ å¼õ¬óÜŠH Þ¼‰î£˜. ܬöˆ¶ªê™ô Ü™ô âƒèœ i†®Ÿ°õó«õ‡ì£‹ â¡Á ªê£™ô.Üõ¼‚°‹ Üõ˜ ñ¬ùM‚°‹ªðKò ꇬìò£‹. W› ê£Fè£ó¬ó i†®™ ÜÂñFˆî£™
 â¡ Ü‹ñ£i†®Ÿ° «ð£ŒM´«õ¡ â¡Á ªê£¡ù£ó£‹.
«ðó£CKòK¡ ñ¬ùM ªõŸP ªðŸø£˜.e‡´‹ ñù‹ õ¼‰F ð‹ð£Œ
ªê¡ø£˜. ð«ó£ì£ ÜÂðõ‹ Ü‹«ðˆè¼‚° I°‰î ñù«õî¬ù¬ò
î‰î¶. °®‚è î‡a˜ Ãìªè£´‚è ñQî£Hñ£ù‹ ñÁ‚èŠð´Aø¶. ܬî î´‚°‹ õ™ô¬ñê£F ªõP‚° ãŸð†´ Þ¼‚Aø¶.
ê£F ªõP ªè£¬ôªõP«ð£¡øî£? ï£Â‹ ࡬ù «ð£¡øñQî¡ î£«ù, ¹¿õ™ô«õ ã¡
Þ‰î ªõP à혾. ܪñK‚裪ê¡ø«ð£¶ ܃° Þ‰î ªè£´¬ñ
Þ™¬ô«ò. ܃° ê£F «ðî‹ Þ™¬ô«ò, âŠð® ²î‰Fóñ£è ïìñ£®«ù¡. ܃° âŠð®Høó£™ ñF‚èŠð†«ì£‹. îù¶ÜP¾‚° âˆî¬èò ñKò£¬îA¬ìˆî¶ â¡Á Üõ˜ è‡èœ°÷ñ£Aù. Þ‰î ®¡ Üõô‹ Üõ˜
àœ÷ˆ¬î èê‚A HN‰î¶.
è‡a˜ M†´ b˜‚è «õ‡®òHó„C¬ùò£ Þ¶. APvîõ˜èÀ‹,ºvL‹èÀ‹ ê£F «õÁð£´ð£ó£†ì M™¬ô«ò, Þ‰¶‚èœñ†´‹ ã¡ ê£F º¬ø ð£ó£†ì«õ‡´‹. ï£Â‹ Þ‰¶ ù.⡬ù ñ†´‹ ã¡. ¹ø‚èE‚A¡ø£˜èœ ⡬ù ñ†´‹ ã¡å¶‚A îœÀAø£˜èœ. Þ‰î
G¬ôJ™  ã¡ Þ‰¶õ£è Þ¼‚è «õ‡´‹. ÞŠð® å¼
«èœM àîòñ£ù¶ Ü‹«ðˆè˜ñùF™.
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 14/36
15 lawyers line - march - 2013 www.l awyersline.net
ñ£Gô Ü󲂰 âFó£ùõKî£ «ê£QJ¡ õö‚°:¹¶F™LJ™ àœ÷ ªì™L
àò˜cFñ¡øˆF™º¬øf†´ â‡: 928/2011
«îF : 2/1/2013º®M¡  : 15/1/2013
õKî£ «ê£Q.....
º¬øf†ì£÷˜ñ£Gô Üó² ......... HóFõ£F.º¡Q¬ô:
ñFŠHŸ°KòcFðF F¼.ê…Yš è‡í£
ñFŠHŸ°KòcFðF F¼.Cˆî£˜ˆ I¼¶¡
b˜Š¹ :cFðF F¼.ê…Yš è‡í£ Þ¶ Þ.H.«è£. 302 Ý‹ HKM¡
W› âŠ.ä.ݘ. ðF¾ ªêŒòŠð†´, îù¶ èíõK¡ ͈î î£óˆF¡
ñè÷£ù 31/1/2007&¡ ð® 9/10õò¬î»¬ìò õ‰îù£ «ê£Q¬òªè£¡øî£ù õö‚A™ 21/5/2011 Ü¡Á îù‚° âFó£è õöƒèŠð†ì
b˜ŠH¬ù âF˜ˆ¶ õKî£ «ê£Q,ðF¾ ªêŒî «ñ™ º¬øf†´ñÂõ£°‹. ÞF™ Þõ¼‚° 10݇´èœ è´ƒè£õ™ î‡ì¬ù»ìù£ù Ý»œ î‡ì¬ù MF‚èŠð†´, C¬øJ™ 20 ݇´èœ
̘ˆF ªêŒî H¡ù«ó M´M‚èŠðì «õ‡´‹ âù b˜Š¹ ÜO‚èŠ
ð†ì¶.31/1/2007 Ü¡Á ï¬ìªðŸø
õ‰îù£ «ê£QJ¡ ªè£¬ô ꉫîèˆFŸAìI¡P GÏH‚èŠð†´œ÷¶. õ‰îù£ «ê£Q b¡
îò£œ àð£ˆò£Œ ñ¼ˆ¶õñ¬ùJ™, Üõêó CA„¬ê HKM™«ê˜‚èŠð†´œ÷£˜. ÜŠ«ð£¶Üõ˜ ²òG¬ùM¡P Þ¼‰¶œ÷£ .̃Üõ¼ì¡ Üõó¶ 𣆮»‹ Þ¼‰
¶œ÷£˜. ªõOŠ¹ø è£òƒèÀ‹,ªõ†´‚ è£òƒèÀ‹ Þ¼‰îî£è
ðF¾èœ ªîKM‚A¡øù. «ñ½‹Üõó¶ H«óî ðK«ê£î¬ùÜP‚¬èJ™,
õJŸP™ ð™«õÁ Ü÷¾œ÷Ýöñ£ù ªõ†´‚ è£òƒèœ.
W› àî´ è£òŠð†´ Þ¼‰î¶.õô¶ è‡E¡ «ñ™ 7 ªê.e.
Ü÷¾œ÷ è£ò‹ð™«õÁ Ü÷¾œ÷ Ýöñ£ù
ªõ†´‚ è£òƒèœ, 迈¶ Üî¡H¡ð°F âùŠ ð™«õÁ ÞìƒèO™ Þ¼‰îù.
ªõ†´‚ è£òƒèœ º¶°, Þì¶ñE‚膴, õô¶ ñE‚膴
ÝAò ÞìƒèO™ Þ¼‰îù.«ñ½‹ î¬ôJ™ ðôˆî Ü®J
ù£™ ͬ÷ à†ðì ð™«õÁ ÞìƒèO™ óˆî‹ 膮J¼‰î¶. âù‚ÃøŠð†´œ÷¶. Þîù£™ ñóíˆFŸè£ù è£ó
í‹ Í¬÷ ñŸÁ‹ î¬ôJ™ãŸð†ì ÜFèñ£ù óˆî‚ èC¾ 
â¡Á ªîOõ£è‚ ÃøŠð†´œ÷¶.«ñ½‹ ͬ÷ ñŸÁ‹ î¬ôŠð°Fè£òƒèœ å¼ èùñ£ù Ý»îˆFù£™, ãŸð†´œ÷¶. Cô Ýöñ£ùè£òƒèœ جñò£ù Ý»îˆFù£™ ãŸð†´œ÷¶ âùˆ ªîOõ£è‚ ÃøŠð†´œ÷¶. «ñ½‹ °Ÿ
ø‹ ªêŒò àð«ò£èŠð´ˆîŠð†ìÝ»îñ£ù èˆF»‹, ꣆C»ñ£èåŠð¬ì‚èŠð†´œ÷¶. ÞF™ ºî¡¬ñò£ù è£Kò‹
â¡ùªõQ™, ñÂî£ó˜ 
Þ‚è£òƒè¬÷ ãŸð´ˆF»œ÷£ó£â¡ð«î. ñÂî£óK¡ õö‚èPë˜,
Þø‰îõK¡ î£ˆî£ 31/1/2007 Ü¡Á²ñ£˜ 4.41&4.42 ñEò÷M™ îù¶¬èŠ«ðCJ™ Þ¼‰¶ è£õ™
G¬ôòˆFŸ° ܬöˆ¶ îù¶ñè¬÷ å¼õ¡ èˆFò£™°ˆFM†´ ªê¡ÁM†ì£¡. âù‚ÃPòî£è ðF¾ ªêŒòŠð†ì¶.âù«õ, «õªø£¼õ˜ Þ‚ªè£
¬ô¬ò ªêŒ¶œ÷£˜ â¡Aø«è£íˆ¬î»‹  ñø‰¶Mì‚Ã죶, â¡Á ÃPù£˜. «ñ½‹
Þø‰¶Š «ð£ù õ‰îù£ «ê£Q ê‹ðõ‹ ïìˆî «ïóˆF¡ «ð£¶, 𣆮裊𣈶ƒè, 𣆮 裊𣈶ƒèâ¡Á‹ «ñ½‹, ÔÜ‹ñ£ ⡬ùÜ®„«ê ªè£¡Â´õ£ƒèÕ â¡
Á‹ èˆFòî£è, ܇¬ì i†´ ꣆Cèœ ÃÁA¡øù. Þø‰îõK¡
îèŠðù£˜ F¼.ó«ñw «ê£QJ¡ê«è£îó˜ F¼.²«ów «ê£Q,
Þõ¼‹ Þõó¶ ñ¬ùM»‹ Þ«îi†®™ îƒA»œ÷ù˜. Üõ˜
F†ì
à ò ˜ c F ñ ¡ ø b ˜ Š ¹
b˜Š¹
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 15/36
ww w.l awye rsli ne .ne t 16 lawyers line - march - 2013
ÃÁ‹«ð£¶, Þø‰îõK¡ ‹, îù¶ ê«è£îóQ¡ºî™ ñ¬ùMò£Aò F¼ñF.ê£îù£ «ê£Q, 31/5/2004Ü¡Á è£ôñ£ù£˜. Üî¡ Hø° Þ‹ñÂî£óó£ùõKî£ «ê£Q¬ò, ó«ñw «ê£Q F¼ñ틪ꌶœ÷£˜. Þõ˜èœ Þ¼õ¼‹ Ü«î i†®¡ºî™ ñ£®J™ °®»œ÷ù˜. Þø‰¶Š «ð£ùõ‰îù£ «ê£Q Üõó¶ î£ˆî£ ñŸÁ‹ 𣆮»ì¡ W›î÷ˆF™ °®J¼‰î£˜. 31/1/2007 Ü¡Áñ£¬ô ²ñ£˜ 4.00 ñEò÷M™, ñÂî£ó˜ õ‰îù£«ê£Q¬ò, îù¶ è™ò£í Ý™ðˆ¬î 裆´õî£è‚ÃP è¬ìC î÷ˆFŸ° Æ®„ ªê¡Áœ÷£˜.
Þõó¶ ñ¬ùMò£ù ñ£¡ú£ «ê£Q Üõ˜èÀì¡
Þ¼‰¶M†´ CP¶ «ïóˆF™ W«ö ÞøƒA õ‰¶
M†ì£˜. ²ñ£˜ 4.30 ñEò÷M™ õ‰îù£ «ê£Q,º¡ °PŠH†´œ÷¬îŠ «ð£ô èˆF»œ÷£˜. Þõ˜èœ «õèñ£è 殄 ªê¡Á 𣘂°‹ «ð£¶,ñ£®‚è£ù èî¾ Ü‰îŠ ð‚è‹ î£NìŠð†®¼‰î¶.âù«õ, ð‚舶 i†´ ñ£®J™ Þ¼‰¶ Þ‰îi†®¡ ñ£®‚° ªê¡Á 𣘈îF™ õKî£ «ê£Qå¼ æóˆF™ à†è£˜‰F¼‰î¬î»‹, õ‰îù£ «ê£Qðô ªõ†´‚ è£òˆ¶ì¡ °Oòô¬øJ™ G¬ùM¡P
Þ¼‰îî£è¾‹ ÃPù£˜. ÜŠ«ð£¶ õKî£ «ê£Qò£«ó£ å¼õ˜, ð‚舶 i†´ ñ£®J™ Þ¼‰¶ õ‰¶
Þšõ£Á ªè£¬ô ªêŒ¶M†´„ ªê¡øî£è‚ ÃPù£˜.«ñ½‹ °´‹ðˆFù¬ó Mê£KˆîF™ ðô îèõ™è¬÷
ªðø º®‰î¶. õKî£ «ê£Q ÜŠ«ð£¶ 蘊𠺟P¼‰î£˜.
Ýù£™, ܬîMì õ‰îù£«ê£QJ¡ e¶ Üõó¶ èíõ˜ÜFè Ü¡¹ ªê½ˆFò¬î Üõ󣙪ð£Á‚è º®òM™¬ô. «ñ½‹
Þø‰î îù¶ ñèÀì¡ ñÂî£ó˜ ï™ô àø¾ ¬õ‚èM™¬ô âù܈îèŠð«ù 効‚ ªè£í¢ì£˜.
ܬùˆ¶ ꣆Còƒè¬÷»‹¬õˆ¶Š 𣘂¬èJ™, ܬùõ¼‹
õ‰îù£M¡ Ü¿°ó™ «è†´,æ®õ‰¶ èî¬õ ò H¡Â‹,õKî£ ²ñ£˜ 8&10 GIìƒèÀ‚°èî¬õ Fø‚èM™¬ô. «ñ½‹ ÜŠð®ò£ó£õ¶ å¼õ˜ õ‰¶ 9 õò¶¬ìòõ‰îù£¬õ AM†´, ܬîŠð£˜ˆ¶‚ ªè£‡®¼‰î õKõå¡Á‹ ªêŒò£ñ™ ªê¡ø¶ ã¡?«ñ½‹ Þõ˜èœ i´ ªïKê™ I°‰îå¼ ð°FJ™ Þ¼Šð, ò£«ó£å¼õ¡ i†´‚°œ ¹°‰¶ Þšõ£Á
°‹ «ð£¶, õKî£ Ã‚°ó™ Þ†´ Þ¼‰î£™ G„êò‹ «è†´, ܬùõ¼«ñ àîM‚° õ‰F¼Šð£˜èœ.Ýù£™, Üõ˜ Üšõ£Á ªêŒîî£èâ‰îªõ£¼ ꣆Còº‹ Þ™¬ô.
âù«õ ꣆Còƒèœ ñŸÁ‹ ê‰ î Š̃ð Å›G¬ôè¬÷ ¬õˆ¶ ð£̃ ‚°‹«ð£¶, Þõ«ó °Ÿøõ£O âù ꉫîèˆFŸAìI¡P GÏH‚èŠð†´,
Þõ¼‚° 㟪èù«õ ÜO‚èŠð†´œ÷ î‡ì¬ù Gò£òñ£ù¶ â¡
Á‹ ªîKAø¶. âù«õ Þ‹«ñ™ º¬øf†´ ñ îœÀð® ªêŒòŠð†ì¶âù b˜ŠðO‚èŠð†ì¶.
†ì ªè£¬ô!
õ‰îù£ «ê£QJ¡ e¶ Üõó¶ èíõ˜ ÜFèÜ¡¹ ªê½ˆFò¬î Üõó£™ ªð£Á‚è º®òM™¬ô.«ñ½‹ Þø‰î îù¶ ñèÀì¡ ñÂî£ó˜ ï™ô àø¾¬õ‚èM™¬ô âù ܈îèŠð«ù 効‚ ªè£í¢ì£˜.
ÁF ªêŒî¶ àò˜cFñ¡ø‹...
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 16/36
17 lawyers line - march - 2013 www.l awyersline.net
24.6.1999 Ü¡Á ï¬ìªðŸø F¼ñí‹, Iè‚ °ÁAò è£ôˆF™,ñÂî£óó£ù èíõó£™, ꣡®ò£«è£ ñ£è£íŠ HKM™ èLç«ð£˜Qò àò˜cFñ¡øˆF™ ðF¾ªêŒòŠð†ì õö‚A¡ è£óíñ£è,17.4.2000 Ü¡Á õöƒèŠð†ì
b˜ŠH¡ Íô‹ óˆ¶ ªêŒòŠð†ì¶.èLç«ð£˜Qò cFñ¡øˆFù£™õöƒèŠð†ì b˜ŠH¬ù âF˜ˆ¶,ñ¬ùM, ªê¡¬ù ºî¡¬ñ ô´‹ð cFñ¡øˆF™ õö‚A¬ùˆªî£ì˜‰î£˜. ÞF™, ܉Gò ´cFñ¡øˆF¡ b˜Š¹ ªê™ô£î¶
Üò™ï£†´ Mõ£èóˆ¶
à ò ˜ c F ñ ¡ ø b ˜ Š ¹
b˜Š¹
17 lawyers line - march - 2013 www.l awyersline.net
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 17/36
ww w.l awye rsli ne .ne t 18 lawyers line - march - 2013
âù‚ «è£K ñ¬ùM ªê¡¬ù àò˜ cFñ¡øˆF™,õö‚A¬ù ªî£ì˜‰î£˜. ÞF™ ñFŠHŸ°Kò cFðF F¼ñF ݘ.ð£ÂñF
ñŸÁ‹ ñFŠHŸ°Kò cFðF F¼ñF âv.Mñô£ÜOˆî b˜Š¹:
Iè‚ °ÁAò è£ô«ñ Þ¼‰î F¼ñí ð‰î‹èíõ¡ èLç«ð£˜Qò cFñ¡øˆF™ ðF¾ ªêŒîõö‚A¡ Íô‹, óˆ¶ ªêŒòŠð†ì¶. Þî¬ù âF˜ˆ¶,
ñ¬ùM ªê¡¬ù °´‹ð cFñ¡øˆF™ ªî£ì˜‰îõö‚° ÞŠ«ð£¶ Mê£ó¬í‚° õ‰¶œ÷¶.24.6.1999 Ü¡Á Þ‰¶ º¬øŠð® ñÂî£ó¼‚°‹
HóFõ£F‚°‹ «õÖ˜, «ê£Lƒè¹óˆF™ F¼ñí‹ ïì‰î¶. èíõ¡ ñ¬ùMò£è , ªê¡¬ùM¼è‹ð£‚èˆF™ Üõ˜èœ õ£öˆ ªî£ìƒAù£˜èœ.HóFõ£F 12.7.1999 Ü¡Á, ñÂî£ó¬ó G„êò‹ F¼‹ðõ‰¶ ܬöˆ¶ ªê™õî£è‚ ÃP, ܪñK‚è£MŸ°ªê¡ø£˜. ܃° ªê¡ø Hø°, èíõ¡ â‰îõ¬èJ½‹ ñ¬ùMJì‹ ªî£ì˜¹‚ ªè£œ÷£î,
Þõ˜èO¬ì«ò Þ¼‰î ܬùˆ¶ ªî£ì˜¹‹ ¶‡®‚èŠð†ì¶.
«ñ½‹ ñ¬ùM, îù¶ ê†ì àK¬ñè¬÷‚ «è£KñÂ î£‚è™ ªêŒî£˜. Üî¡ «ðK™ èLç«ð£˜QòcFñ¡øˆF™ Þ¼‰¶ 1.10.1999 Ü¡Á Üõ¼‚°ê‹ñ¡ ÜŠðŠð†ì¶. Þîù£™, ñ¬ùM Üõ˜
îóŠ¹ õ£îƒè¬÷ ⿈F¡ Íô‹ ÜŠð¾‹,è†ì투î óˆ¶ ªêŒò¾‹ «õ‡®ù£˜. Þî¡Hø°, 17.4.2000 Ü¡Á b˜Š¹ õöƒèŠð†ì¶. Þî¬ù ªê™½ð®ò£è£¶ âù¾‹, Üò™ï£†´
cFñ¡øˆF¡ b˜Š¹ Þ‰Fò£M™ H¡ðŸøŠðìô£è£¶âù¾‹ ÃP ñ¬ùM õö‚° ªî£ì˜‰¶œ÷£˜.
èíõ˜, W›‚è‡ì è£óíƒèÀ‚è£è °´‹ð
cFñ¡øˆF™ î¡ ê£˜¹ Mõ£îƒè¬÷ ¬õˆî£˜.èLç«ð£KQò àò˜cFñ¡øˆF¡ ê‹ñ¡è¬÷ ñFˆ«îñ¬ùM îù¶ îóŠ¹ õ£îƒè¬÷ ⿈F¡ Íô‹ªîKMˆî£˜. Üî¡ Hø«è b˜Š¹ õöƒèŠð†ì¶.
ÞŠ«ð£¶ Ü«î b˜ŠH¡ Gò£òƒè¬÷ ꉫîAŠð¶º¬øòŸø¶. «ñ½‹ Þšõö‚A¬ù Mê£K‚è °´‹ðcFñ¡øˆFŸ° â‰îMîˆF½‹ ê†ì ÜFè£ó‹
Þ™¬ô âù¾‹ ÃPù£˜.4. âù«õ, Þî¡ Ü®Šð¬ìJ™, Cô «èœMèœ
â¿‹¹A¡øù.(I) °´‹ð cFñ¡øˆF™ ñ¬ùMJù£™ ªî£ìóŠ
ð†ì õö‚° ïìˆîŠð´ñ£?(II) °´‹ð cFñ¡øˆFŸ° Þšõö‚A¬ù Mê£K‚è
ê†ì ÜFè£ó‹ à‡ì£?(III) ºîL™ ñ¬ùM èLç«ð£˜Qò cFñ¡øˆF¡
ê‹ñ¡èÀ‚° ðF™ ÜOˆ¶M†´ Hø° ã¡ Üî¡ b˜ŠH¬ù âF˜ˆ¶ º¬øJ†ì£˜?
Þ¬õò¬ùˆF¡ Ü®Šð¬ìJ½‹ ñ¬ùMJ¡ îóŠH™ õ£î‹ ªêŒòŠð†ì¶.
Ýù£™, Þ¬õò¬ùˆFŸ°‹ ðFô£è, à„êcFñ¡øˆFù£™ «õªø£¼ õö‚A™ ªè£´‚èŠð†ì
b˜ŠH¡ å¼ ð°Fò£õ¶, Üò™ï£†´ cFñ¡øƒè÷£™õöƒèŠð´‹ b˜Š¹èÀ‹, ê†ìƒèÀ‹ ïñ¶
®™ Mõ£îˆFŸ°Kòî£è«õ àœ÷ù. âù«õ, މ®¡ cFñ¡øƒèœ ÜõŸP¡ ï‹ðèˆ î¡¬ñ¬ò Mê£K‚è «õ‡®ò ÜFè£óˆ¬î‚
ªè£‡´œ÷ù. å¼ Üò™ï£†´ cFñ¡ø‹ b˜Š¹‚ÃPM†ìð®ò£™, Üî¡ Ü‹êƒè÷£™ ïñ¶ ®¡Hó¬üèÀ‚° ð£îè‹ ãŸð´‹ â¡ø£™, Üî¬ù Mê£Kˆ¶, ñÁ b˜Š¹ õöƒèô£‹ âù‚ ÃøŠð†´œ÷¶.
Þî¬ù Ü®Šð¬ìò£è‚ ªè£‡«ì ñ¬ùM îóŠ¹õö‚èPëó£™, Þ‰¶ F¼ñí„ ê†ìˆF¡ Ü®Šð¬ìJ™ ï¬ìªðŸø F¼ñíˆF¡ e¶ Üò™ï£†´cFñ¡øƒèœ ê†ìƒèœ ªê™½ð®ò£è£¶ â¡Â‹
õ£îˆ¬î º¡ ¬õˆî£˜. Þ ðô õö‚°èO¡ b˜Š¹èœ â´ˆ¶‚裆ì£èº¡ ¬õ‚èŠð†ì¶. ÜõŸP¡ Ü®Šð¬ìJ™,èíõ˜, Þ‰Fò£M™ F¼ñí‹ ªêŒ¶‚ ªè£‡ì,Üõó¶ ܬùˆ¶ ªêò™ð£´èÀ‹ Þ‰¶ F¼ñí„ê†ìˆFù£«ô«ò èõQ‚èŠðì «õ‡´‹. «ñ½‹
Þ„ê†ìˆF¡ð® F¼ñí Hó„C¬ùèœ Þ¼õ󶺡Q¬ôJ½‹ °´‹ð cFñ¡øˆFù£™ Mê£K‚èŠðì «õ‡´‹. ܬî M´ˆ¶ Üõ˜,
îQò£è ñ¬ùM Þ‰Fò£M™ Þ¼‚°‹ «ð£¶ ñ†´‹ èLç«ð£˜Qò cFñ¡øˆF™ õö‚A¬ùŠðF¾ ªêŒ¶ b˜ŠH¬ù ªðŸÁ ñ¬ùM¬ò ܈b˜Š
HŸ° 膴Šðì„ ªêŒõ¶ Þ„ê†ìˆ¬î ÜõñFŠð
‹ âù‚ ÃøŠð†ì¶. âù«õ, èLç«ð£˜Qò
cFñ¡øˆFù£™ õöƒèŠð†ì b˜ŠHŸ° ñ¬ùM膴Šðìˆ «î¬õJ™¬ô âù °´‹ð cFñ¡ø‹ÃÁõ¶ à‡¬ñò£°‹.
«ñ½‹ Þ¼õ¼«ñ Þ‰î ñîˆF¬ù «ê˜‰îõ˜èœ. îI›ï£†®™ Hø‰îõ˜èœ, îI›ï£†®™ Þ‰¶ ñîˆ F¼ñí„ ê†ìˆF¡ W› ñíñ¬ì‰îõ˜è÷£î, Þ¼õ¼«ñ ÞˆF¼ñí ê†ìˆFŸ° à†ð†´œ÷ù˜. Þ‰¶ F¼ñí„ ê†ìˆF¡ð®, F¼ñíñ£ù å¼ õ¼ìˆ FŸ°œ Mõ£èóˆ¶ ªêŒò Þ¼õ¼‚°«ñ ÜFè£óI™¬ô. Ýù£™, èíõ˜ Þî¬ù eP å¼ õ¼ìˆFŸ°œ, Mõ£èóˆ¬îŠ ªðŸÁœ÷£˜. ܶ¾‹, èLç«ð£˜
Qò cFñ¡øˆF™ õö‚裮, Þ¶ Gò£òñŸø‹.«ñ½‹ ò£¼«ñ ÜŸø G¬ôJ™ ÜŠªð‡ îù¶Ü®Šð¬ì «î¬õèÀ‚«è îù¶ àŸø£¬ó ï‹H àœ÷£ .̃
Þõ¬ó îQò£è M†´„ ªê¡ø¶I¡P, Üõó£™¹K‰¶‚ªè£œ÷ º®ò£î Üò™ï£†´ ê†ìˆ¬îàð«ò£Aˆ¶ ÜõKì‹ Þ¼‰¶ Mõ£èóˆ¬îŠ ªðŸø¶ð£õ‹ ñ†´ñ¡P ãñ£ŸÁõ êññ£°‹.
âù«õ, Üò™ï£†´ cFñ¡øˆF¡ b˜Š¬ð âF˜ˆ¶,ñ¬ùM ªî£ì˜‰¶ õö‚° ªê™½ð®ò£°‹. âù«õ,ñÂî£óó£ù èíõ˜ ªê¡¬ù °´‹ð cFñ¡øˆF™ªî£ì˜‰î âF˜ õö‚° ܬùˆ¶ˆ îóŠH½‹
îœÀð® ªêŒòŠð´õ¶ì¡, Þšõö‚A™ °´‹ðcFñ¡øˆF™ õöƒèŠð´‹ b˜Š«ð ÞÁFò£ù‹.
å¼ Üò™ï£†´ cFñ¡ø‹ b˜Š¹‚ÃPM†ìð®ò£™, Üî¡ Ü‹êƒè÷£™ ïñ¶ ®¡ Hó¬üèÀ‚° ð£îè‹ãŸð´‹ â¡ø£™, Üî¬ù Mê£Kˆ¶,
ñÁ b˜Š¹ õöƒèô£‹ âù‚ ÃøŠð†´œ÷¶.
ww w.l awye rsli ne .ne t 18 lawyers line - march - 2013
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 18/36
19 lawyers line - march - 2013 www.l awyersline.net
«èœM :
äò£,  è˜ï£ìè ñ£Gôˆ¬î„ «ê˜‰îõœ. âù¶èùõ˜ â¡ ñèÀ‚° 11 õò¶ Þ¼‚°‹ «ð£«î Þø‰¶M†ì£˜. êeðˆF™ ï£Â‹ âù¶ å«ó ñèÀ‹ H¬öŠ¹‚è£èªê¡¬ù‚° õ‰«î£‹. Þƒ° Cô è£ôƒèÀ‚° º¡¹å¼õ˜ â¡ ñè¬÷ CQñ£M™ ﮂè õ£ŒŠ¹ ãŸð´ˆFî¼A«ø¡ â¡Á ÃP ݬê õ£˜ˆ¬î 裆® ð£¶å¼ Cô ðìƒèO™ ﮈ¶‹ õ¼Aø£œ. Ýù£™ Cô
Þò‚-°ï˜èœ °´‹ð ð£ƒè£ù èðˆFóˆF™ ﮂè¬õ‚A«ø¡ â¡Á ªê£™L ÜõÀ‚«è ªîKò£ñ™ Côܬø °¬øò£ù à¬ì»ì¡ ﮂ°‹ð®ò£ù 裆Cè¬÷â´ˆ¶M†ìù˜. ܬî âƒèOì‹ «ð£†´ 裆®ò¾ì¡I辋 ÜF˜Cò¬ì‰«î£‹. Ýù£™ Üõ˜èœ ܬîê£î£óíñ£è â´ˆ¶‚ªè£œAø£˜èœ, ðì‹ ªõO«òõ‰î¾ì¡ 𣼠àƒè ªð£‡Â‚° ªðKò âF˜è£ô‹ Þ¼‚°‹Â è†ì£òŠð´ˆ¶ø£ƒè. âƒèÀ‚° ðòñ£èàœ÷¶. îò¾ ªê£Œ¶ äò£ Üõ˜èœ Þ‰î G¬ôJ™ ï£ƒèœ ê†ìð®ò£è â´‚è «õ‡®ò ïìõ®‚¬è¬òðŸP ªîKM‚°ñ£Á «è†´‚ªè£œA«ø¡.
& ªðò˜ ªõOJìM¼‹ð£î õ£êA
ðF™:
ªð£¶õ£è«õ å¼ ªð‡¬í Üï£èKèñ£èCˆîKˆî™ â¡ð¶ î‡ì¬ù‚°Kò °Ÿøñ£°‹.ªð‡è¬÷ Üï£èKèñ£è CˆîKˆî™ (î¬ìªêŒ»‹) ê†ì‹ 1986 (Idecet repeettio of ome (Po-
hibitio) act 1986) HK¾ 6 ñŸÁ‹ 7 ÝAòõŸP™å¼ ªð‡¬ù ñ£ùðƒèŠð´ˆ¶‹ õ¬èJ™ àì™gFò£è«õ£, è‡Eò‚°¬øõ£è«õ£ CˆîK‚°‹
裆Cèœ «ð£¡ø â¬î»‹ ê‹ñ‰îŠð†ì ªð‡¬ùCÁ¬ñŠð´ˆ¶‹ «ï£‚A™ ªõOJ´«õ£¼‚°,ê‹ñ‰îŠð†ìõ˜ Þ‰î °Ÿøˆ¬î ºî™ îì¬õªêŒ»‹ ð†êˆF™ Þó‡´ Ý‡´èÀ‹, e‡´‹ Ü«î°Ÿøˆ¬î ªî£ì˜‰¶ ªêŒ»‹ ð†êˆF™ ä‰î£‡´èœC¬ø î‡ì¬ù»‹, ñŸÁ‹ Þó‡ì£Jó‹ ºî™ å¼ô†ê‹ õ¬ó Üðó£îº‹ MF‚èŠð´õ˜.
Ýîô£™ àƒèÀ¬ìò MûòˆF™ cƒèœ ܼA½œ÷ è£õ™ G¬ôòˆ¬î ÜÂA ¹è£˜ ÜOŠðô«ñ Þ‰î Hó„ê¬ù àƒèÀ‚° º®¾‚° õó£ô£‹.ÜŠð®»‹ àƒèÀ‚° b˜¾ A¬ì‚èM™¬ôªòQ™cƒèœ õö‚èPëK¡ àîM»ì¡ àKò cFñ¡øˆ¬îÜ°õî¡ ºô‹ ÞŠHó„ê¬ù‚° Gó‰îó b˜¾è£íô£‹.
àƒèœ õö‚èPë˜õ£êè˜ «èœMèÀ‚° õö‚èPëK¡ ðF™èœ
Q:
Iam married in year 1982 and i have 1 sister and 3 brothers
and my father has land of 800 cents and 3 houses who died
in the year 1998. can i claim share of 1/5
- Ranjani Rao, Trivandrum
Ans:Only legal heirs can claim share in your father’s property.
If your mother is alive, she will also be added as a party to the
suit for partition. If your father’s mother is alive, she will also
be added as a party to the suit for partition. If your father has
another wife and children, they will also be added as a party
to the suit for partition.
You can claim 1/5th of share in your father’s property
provided that your mother was died, your grand mother (fa-
ther’s mother) was died and your father did not have another wife. In your case, you should rst le a ‘suit for partition’
or ‘suit for succession of property’ before the Court of Law.
«èœM:
꣘ âù¶ èíõ˜ å¼ ªðKò °®è£ó˜.  i†´«õ¬ô‚°„ ªê¡Á  â¡ °´‹ðˆ¬î 裊ð£ŸP
õ¼A«ø¡. Üõ˜ ê‹ð£F‚°‹ ðíˆF™ Fùº‹ °®ˆ¶M†´ âƒè£õ¶ «ó£†®™ M¿‰¶ M´õ£˜. Fùº‹ ºè‹ªîKò£îõ˜èœ Cô˜,  à¡ èíõ¼‚° ðˆî£Jó‹¼ð£Œ î¡, ä‰î£Jó‹ ¼ð£Œ î‰«î¡ Ü¬î c  ªè£´‚è «õ‡´‹ â¡Á ⡬ù ªî£‰îó¾ªêŒAø£˜èœ.  «ð£hv ú«ìêQ™ Üõ˜èœ e¶ ¹è£˜ÜOˆîî¡ «ðK™ «ð£h²‹ Üõ˜è¬÷ ܬöˆ¶ Üõ˜õ£ƒ°‹ èì‚° ܉î Ü‹ñ£ â¡ù ªêŒ»‹, cƒèœÜ‰î Ü‹ñ£Mì‹ ªê¡Á ðí‹ «è†´ ªî£‰îó¾ªêŒò‚Ã죶 â¡Á Ió†® â¿F»‹ õ£ƒAM†ì£˜èœ.
â¡ èíõ«ó ÝJ‹ Þõ˜ õ£ƒ°‹ èì¡èÀ‚°  Ü™ô¶ ï£ƒèœ ªð£ÁŠð£O Ü™ô â¡ø àˆFóõ£îˆ¬î  ªðøº®»ñ£ ?
îŸêñò‹ Üõ˜ àJ¼ì¡î£¡ Þ¼‚Aø£˜ â¡ø£½‹Üõ˜ è£ôˆ¶‚°Š H¡Â‹ èì¡ b˜‚°‹ Hó„¬ù Þ™ô£ñ™ Þ¼‚è õN à‡ì£?
& Þ.ªðKòï£òA, «è£¬õ
ðF™:àƒèœ Hó„ê¬ù Iè C‚èô£ù¶ .cƒèœ °PŠH†ì¶ «ð£ô “è£õ™ G¬ôòˆF™
â¿F õ£ƒèŠð´‹ ú«ì†ªñ¡† ñ†´«ñ àƒèœ
èíõ˜ õ£ƒ°‹ èì¡èÀ‚° cƒèœ ªð£ÁŠ«ðŸèº®ò£¶ â¡Á ܘˆîñ£è£¶”. Þ‰Fò ê†ìŠð® å¼õ˜ ñóí‹ Ü¬ì‰î H¡
ªõ.°í«êèó¡ õö‚èPë˜, ªê¡¬ù àò˜cFñ¡ø‹
19 lawyers line - march - 2013 www.l awyersline.net
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 19/36
ww w.l awye rsli ne .ne t 20 lawyers line - march - 2013
Üõó¶ ªê£ˆ¶‚èœ âŠð® Üõ˜ õ£g²èÀ‚°õ¼Aø«î£, Ü«î «ð£™ Üõó¶ èì¡èÀ‹ Üõó¶õ£g²èÀ‚°ˆ  õ¼‹.
å¼ «õ¬÷ Üõó¶ ñ¬ø¾‚° H¡ èì¡ ªè£´ˆîõ˜èœ cF ñ¡øˆ¬î ù£™ Üõó¶ èì¡èÀ‚°,Üõ˜ °´‹ðˆFù˜  ªð£ÁŠ¹ âù ªê£™ôô‹.
ÞŠ«ð£¬î‚° “ò£Kì‹ èì¡ õ£ƒAù£«ó£
ÜõKì«ñ âù‚°‹ Ü‹ ê‹ð‰î‹ Þ™¬ô” âùªê£™ôô£‹. Ü™ô¶ èíõ¬ó ðŸP è£õ™ ¶¬øJ™¹è£˜ ÜOˆ¶, è£õ™ ¶¬øJù¬ó M†´ “ÞŠð®°®‚è£b˜èœ, èì¡ õ£ƒè£b˜èœ” âù ªê£™ôªê£™ôô£‹. Þ¬õ  âù‚° ªîK‰î õ¬ó àœ÷
ÞŠ«ð£¬î‚è£ù b˜¾èœ. ܶ¾‹ êKð†´õóM™¬ôªò¡ø£™ è¬ìC ÜvFõ£ó‹ ÜõKìI¼‰¶
Gó‰îóñ£è HKõ¶ .
Q:My dad died without writing any will. My step mother
does not open her mouth about the will or the huge property
details. My only sister denies me from going to court.
- Susan Rayer, Bangalore
Ans:
Wow! If ur dad has not written any will, you are lucky.
obviously everything should be equally divided between you
and your step mother and step sister.That is law.Property that
comes down should go to all three equally
«èœM:
äò£, õí‚è‹, â¡ ªðò˜ êóõí¡, â¡Â¬ìò ̘iè ªê£ˆF™ àœ÷ i†¬ì Þ¼ ðƒ°è÷£è ‹Üõ¼¬ìò ܇í‹ HKˆ¶‚ ªè£‡ì£˜èœ.ÜŠ«ð£¶ â¡Â¬ìò î£M¡ i†®Ÿ°„ ªê™ô 弪𣶊 ð£¬î ܬñˆ¶‚ ªè£‡ì£˜èœ. î£M¡Ü‡í¡ ÜŠð£¬î¬ò (ªðKò î£) ðˆFóˆF™°PŠH†´ HKM™ô£î ð£F ð£ˆFò‹ â¡Á â¿F Þó‡´
ðˆFóƒè÷£è ðF¾ ªêŒîù˜. ÞŠ«ð£¶ â¡Â¬ìòî£M¡ Ü‡í¡ (ªðKòî£) ñèœ Üõ˜èÀ¬ìò ð£è i†¬ì «õÁ å¼ ï𼂰 MŸÁM†ì£˜.ÜŠð® MŸ°‹ «ð£¶ âƒèOì‹ «è†èM™¬ô. ÞŠ«ð£¶Ü‰î i†¬ì õ£ƒAòõ˜ Ü‰îŠ ð£¬î¬ò H¡ù£™ Þ¼‚°‹ âƒèœ i†®¡ õ£ê™ º®¾ õ¬ó àK¬ñ «è£óº®»ñ£? Ü™ô¶ Üõ˜ õ£ƒAò i†®¡ Ü÷¾ õ¬óð£¬î¬ò àK¬ñ «è£ó º®»ñ£? ãªùQ™ Üõ¼‚°«ó£†®¡ e¶ õ£ê™ àœ÷¶ Ýù£™ âƒèÀ‚°ÜŠð£¬î å«ó õNò£è àœ÷¶. ÞŠ«ð£¶ ܉îi†¬ì õ£ƒAòõ˜ ÜŠð£¬î¬ò â¶õ¬ó àK¬ñ «è£ó
º®»‹? Ü™ô¶ ð£F Ü÷¾ ñ¬ø‚è àK¬ñ àœ÷î£?ê†ì‹ Ü â¡ù ªê£™½Aø¶.
ðF™:
àƒèœ i†ì¼A™ º¡«ù àœ÷ Þ숬î õ£ƒAò ïð˜ cƒèœ ªê™ô º®ò£î ð® º¿¶‹ ñ¬øˆ¶è†®ì‹ è†ì º®ò£¶. Þó‡´ i†´‚°‹ ªð£¶õ£ù ï¬ìð£¬î e¶ Þ¼õ¼‹ ªê™ô àK¬ñà‡´. Þ ªðò˜ ßv†ªñ¡† àK¬ñ. Þî¡ð®
ï쉶 ªê™ô Þ¼‚°‹ õN¬ò ñPˆ¶ å¼õ˜ îù‚è£ù i´ 膮‚ ªè£œ÷ º®ò£¶.
«ñ½‹ ºîL™ Þ¼ iì£è HKˆî ð£èŠHKM¬ùðˆFóˆ¬î â´ˆ¶ 𮈶Š 𣼃èœ. ÜF™ Þ‰î
ï¬ìð£¬î Þ¼õ¼‚°‹ ªð£¶õ£ù¶ â¡Á°PŠHìŠð†´œ÷î£ âùŠ ð£˜‚è «õ‡´‹.ÜŠð® °PŠH†®¼‰î£™, º¡ù˜ i´ ¬õˆF¼‚°‹
ï𼂰 îù¶ i†´‚° º¡ àœ÷ Þ숶‚° º¿àK¬ñ A¬ìò£¶. °PŠð£Œ ܃° H™®ƒ è†ìàK¬ñ õó£¶. Þ¶ ðŸPò «ñ½‹ MðóƒèÀ‚° àƒèÀ‚°
å¼ ï™ô CM™ õö‚èPë¬ó Þ¶ ê‹ð‰îñ£ù죂°ªñ‡´èÀì¡ Üµ°ƒèœ àKò b˜¾
A¬ì‚°‹.
Q:
My sister, has left her huband’s house 3 years back for
dowry harrasement has led case for maintenance. Her
husband got married to another lady what action she should
take now?
- Sanjeevi Sharma, Trichy Ans:
If your sister has come to know the fact that her husbandmarried another girl fraudulently, she should have immediate-
ly lodged a criminal complaint with the police station against
her husband by lodging FIR under section 494 & 498A of the
IPC & section 4 of dowry prohibition act. If one year lapsed
after her knowledge about her husband’s second marriage,
it is difcult for her to get punishment to her husband from
the Court. Documents (or at least witnesses) are necessary to
prove the second marriage of your sister’s husband. He will
be punished up to 7 years under Section 494 and 496 of IPC.
In case your sister’s husband married without disclosing his
rst marriage to his second spouse, he may be punished up
to 10 years under Section 495 of IPC.
She can concurrently le a case for maintenance under
section 125 Cr.P.C.
she can claim share in his husband’s property by ling a
case under protection from domestic violence act.
she can also ask for a separate residence under the afore-
said act or she can get his house partitioned.
All the above said remedies are simultaneously available
to your sister provided you should be prompt in approaching
the court and the police. better you can consult a lawyer who
is specialised for family casses at the time of ling the casefor maintenance because pleading is of much importance.
ww w.l awye rsli ne .ne t 20 lawyers line - march - 2013
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 20/36
21 lawyers line - march - 2013 www.l awyersline.net
ªêŒF «êù™èÀ‹, ªð£¿¶«ð£‚° «êù™èÀ‹ ñ‚èÀ¬ìòHó„C¬ùè¬÷»‹, ¶¡ðƒè¬÷»‹
b˜ˆ¶ ¬õŠð¶ î£ƒèœ î£¡ â¡Áâ‡E‚ ªè£í¢®¼‚Aø£˜èœ.
Ýù£™, à‡¬ñ ܶõ¡Á. ñ‚èOì‹ ÞŠð®Šð†ì Hó„C¬ùè¬÷»‹, ¶¡ðƒè¬÷»‹ ãŸð´ˆ¶õ«î
Þõ˜èœ . àî£óíñ£è Côñ£îƒèÀ‚° º¡¹ M¿Š¹óˆ¬î„«ê˜‰î î‹ðFèO¡ °´‹ð Hó„C¬ù (Üî£õ¶ èíõ¡ ñ¬ùMHó„C¬ù)
ªî£ì˜ «ïó¬ô ªêŒF GÁõùƒèœ õ‰î Hø° àôA™ â‰î ͬôJ™â¶ ïì‰î£½‹, ܉î G蛾è¬÷àì‚°ì¡  ܬùõ¼‹
ªîK‰¶ ªè£œ÷ º®‰î Ü«î «õ¬÷J™ ÞòŸ¬è YŸøƒèœ Gè¿‹«ð£¶àî£óíñ£è Cô ñ£îƒèÀ‚°º¡ð£è Ôcô‹Õ ¹ò™ è¬ó¬ò èì‰îÜ¡Á‹, Ü º‰¬îò ï£À‹
Þõ˜èœ ð´ˆFò𣴠޼‚Aø«îÜ¬î ªê£™L ñ£÷£¶. ¹ò™ è¬ó¬òèì‚è Þ¼Šð, èìŸè¬óJ™ò£¼‹ Þ¼‚è‚ Ã죶 â¡Á è£õ™
¶¬ø»‹, Üó² ¶¬ø ÜFè£KèÀ‹ñ‚è¬÷ ܃A¼‰¶ ÜŠ¹øŠ
𴈶Aø£˜èœ. Ýù£™, ªî£¬ô‚裆C GÁõùƒè«÷£ îƒèÀ¬ìòªî£¬ô‚裆C ªêŒF «êèKŠð£
÷˜è¬÷ â™ô£ èìŸè¬óèÀ‚°‹ÜŠH ܃A¼‰¶ ªêŒFè¬÷àì‚°ì¡ ªêŒFè¬÷ õöƒAªè£‡®¼‰îù. ÜŠªð£¿¶ ܉îªêŒF «êèKŠð£÷˜èÀ‚° ãî£õ¶«ï˜‰F¼‰î£™ (ï™ô «õ¬÷ò£è
ò£¼‚°‹ ⶾ‹ «ïóM™¬ô) àì«ù Üóê£ƒèŠ ð£¶è£Š¹
°¬ø𣴠ñŸÁ‹ º¡ªù„êK‚¬è°¬øM¡¬ñ â¡Á ÃP ðN¬òܬùˆ¶‹ ÜóꣃèˆF¡ e«î²ñˆFJ¼Šð£˜èœ. îƒèÀ‚°‹Ü‰î G蛄C‚°‹ ê‹ð‰î‹ Þ™ô£
î¶ «ð£ô«õ 裆®J¼Šð£˜èœ.à‡¬ñJ«ô«ò õ£Q¬ô ÝŒ¾
G¬ôò‹ Íôñ£è¾‹, è£õ™¶¬ø,Üó² ¶¬øèœ Íôñ£è¾‹ ÞòŸ¬è
YŸø G蛾è¬÷ ªõOJ†ì£«ô«ð£¶ñ£ù¶. Ýù£™, Üî¬ùñø‰¶, ñ‚èÀ‚° º¡ªù„êK‚¬èªêŒA«ø£‹ â¡ø ªðòK™ðòºÁˆF àƒèÀ¬ìò (TrP)¬òÜFèŠð´ˆF º¡QÁˆî «õ‡´‹â¡ðîŸè£è«õ Þ¶ «ð£¡ø ªêŒFè¬÷ àì‚°ì¡ â¡ø «ðK™ º¿õ¶‹, åLðóŠH‚ ªè£‡®¼‚Aø£˜èœ. Þõ˜è÷¶ ªêŒFè¬÷Cô «ïóƒèO™ êKò£è¾‹, Cô «ïóƒ
èO™ I¬èŠð´ˆF»‹, Cô «ïóƒèO™ îõø£è¾‹ Üõ˜èœ ꣘‰îÜóCò™ è†CèÀ‚° ãŸø£Ÿ«ð£™
ñ‚è¬÷ ²ó‡´‹
áìèƒèœ
G.«ñ£èùA¼wí¡î¬ôõ˜, ªê¡¬ù àò˜cFñ¡ø
õö‚èPë˜ êƒè‹.
21 lawyers line - march - 2013 www.l awyersline.net
è õ ˜ v «ì£ K
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 21/36
ww w.l awye rsli ne .ne t 22 lawyers line - march - 2013
ªõOJ´Aø£˜èœ. Þ¬îò£õ¶ ñ‚è÷£Aò  êAˆ¶‚ªè£œ÷ô£‹. Ýù£™, Þ‰î ªð£¿¶«ð£‚° G蛄Cè¬÷ õöƒ°‹ ªî£¬ô‚裆Cèœ ªêŒA¡ø «ñ£ê®èœ Þ¼‚«è I辋 ªè£Çóñ£ù¶.
àî£óíˆFŸ° ªî£¬ô‚裆CèO™ Cô «èœM蜫è†ð£˜èœ. ÜKò ðF¬ô ñ ܬô«ðCJ™
Þ¼‰¶ °Á…ªêŒFò£è ÜÂŠð„ ªê£™õ£˜èœ. Ü Üõ˜èœ õÅL‚°‹ è†ìí‹ Ïð£Œ
3 L¼‰¶ 5 õ¬ó. õ£®‚¬èò£÷˜èœ àð«ò£èŠð´ˆ ¶‹ ܬô«ðC GÁõùƒè¬÷ ªð£Áˆ¶ õÅL‚èŠð´Aø¶. Þˆî¬èò ªî£¬ô‚裆C GÁõùƒèœ«ñŸ°PŠH†ì G蛄CèÀ‚° ªêô¾ ªêŒõ«î£Cô ÝJóˆFL¼‰¶ Cô ô†êƒèœ õ¬ó.Ýù£™, ܉G蛄CèÀ‚° °Á…ªêŒF Íôñ£è
Þõ˜èœ ªðÁ‹ ðíñ£ù¶ Cô ðô «è£®èœ,«ñ½‹ M÷‹ðó GÁõùƒèœ Íôº‹ Cô ðô«è£®è¬÷Š ªðÁAø£˜èœ. Þ¬îò£˜ î´ˆ¶
GÁˆ¶õ¶? ã¡ ÞŠð® ñ‚èOìI¼‰¶ ðí‹ ªðÁAø£˜èœ â¡Á «è†ì£™, ñ‚è¬÷ °Á…ªêŒFè†ì£òñ£è ÜŠð «õ‡´‹ â¡Á ÃøM™¬ô«ò
âù ðF™ ÜOˆî£½‹ ÜOŠð£˜èœ. G蛄CJ™«è†°‹ «èœMè¬÷‚ «è†ì£™ ïñ‚° «õî¬ùèô‰î CKŠ¹î£¡ ãŸð´Aø¶. ↴‚裙 Ì„C‚°âˆî¬ù‚裙? ° ê‚èó õ£èùˆF™ âˆî¬ùê‚èó‹ Þ¼‚°‹? ÞŠð®ˆî£¡ Þõ˜èœ «èœM蜪ð¼‹ð£½‹ Þ¼‚Aø¶. Þõ˜èœ  îƒèÀ‚°ñ‚èœe¶ I°‰î êÍè Ü‚è¬ø Þ¼Šðî£è‚ 裆®‚ªè£œA¡øù. ñ‚èœ Hó„¬ù ê‹ð‰îñ£è Cô Mõ£îƒ
è¬÷ ïìˆFM†´, ñŸø ðô «ïóƒèO™ èô£„ê£óYóN¬õ ãŸð´ˆî‚îò ªï´‰ªî£ì˜è¬÷»‹, °Á…ªêŒFè¬÷ ÜŠð ¬õˆ¶ Üî¡ Íô‹ ñ‚èOìI¼‰¶ ðíƒè¬÷ ªðÁõ¬î»«ñ °P‚«è£÷£è‚ªè£‡´œ÷ù. Þ «ð˜î£¡ Þõ˜èœ â¡ùæ†ìˆF™ êÍè Ü‚è¬ó«ò£ â¡ù«õ? èì¾À‚°ˆ
 ªõO„ê‹!Cô M÷‹ðóƒèœ â™ô£ˆ ªî£¬ô‚裆CèO½‹
åOðóŠð£Aø¶. ܉î M÷‹ðóƒèO™ 裆ìŠð´‹è£†Cèœ ï¬ìº¬ø‚° 别î õó£¶. Cô
M÷‹ðóƒèœ ޡ‹ å¼ð® «ñ«ô «ð£Œ cƒèœâƒèœ ªð£¼¬÷ àð«ò£èŠð´ˆFù£™ º® àFó£¶.
Þ‰î «ï£Œèœ °í£°‹. ÞõŸPL¼‰¶ îŠH‚èô£‹â¡ªø™ô£‹ åOðóŠðŠð´A¡øù. Þ¶ ê‹ð‰îñ£è M÷‹ðó‹ åOðóŠðŠð†ì ªî£¬ô‚裆C«êù™è¬÷ ܵA «è†ì£™ ܉î M÷‹ðóˆFŸ°‹,
îƒèÀ‚° ê‹ð‰îI™¬ô â¡Á‹ Ü ܉îM÷‹ðóî£ó˜ ñ†´«ñ ªð£ÁŠ¹ â¡Á ÃPù£½‹ÃÁõ£˜èœ. à‡¬ñJ™ M÷‹ðóî£ó˜ ñ†´«ñªð£ÁŠ¹ A¬ìò£¶. Üî¬ù åOðóŠHò èÀ‹
 Ü ªð£ÁŠ¹ â¡Á ã¡ ãŸÁ ªè£œ÷ñ£†«ì¡ â¡Aø£˜èœ â¡Á ªîKòM™¬ô. å¼õ˜ªê£™L å¼õ˜ ªè£¬ô„ ªêŒî£™ Ü‚ªè£¬ô‚ °Ÿøˆ
FŸ° Þ¼õ¼‹  ªð£ÁŠ¹. êÍè Ü‚è¬óê‹ð‰îñ£è å¼ îQïð˜ (Ü) îQò£˜ GÁõù‹ å¼ G蛄C¬ò îò£K‚°‹ ªð£¿¶ ܬî åOðóŠHÜîù£™ ªðøŠð´‹ ¹è¿‚° ñ†´‹ èÀ‹ å¼ è£óí‹ â¡Á ÃÁ‹ ªî£¬ô‚裆C GÁõùƒèœ,M÷‹ðóƒèœ ê‹ð‰îñ£è Hó„¬ù õ¼‹ «ð£¶ ñ†´‹
îù‚°‹ ܉î M÷‹ðóˆFŸ°‹ ê‹ð‰î‹ Þ™ô£ñ™è£†®‚ ªè£œõ¶ âšMîˆF™ Gò£ò‹? å¼ GÁõù‹
ï숶õ ªð£¼÷£î£ó àîM º‚Aò‹ â¡ð¶ Gò£ò‹ ? ÜîŸè£è àƒèœ ªè£œ¬èè¬÷ M´ˆ¶Cô îõø£ù M÷‹ðóƒè¬÷»‹, G蛄Cè¬÷»‹åOðóŠ¹õ¶ ã«ù£? êÍè Ü‚è¬ø«ò£´‹,
ñ‚èÀ‚° ï™ô MûòƒèO™ º¡Âî£óíñ£è Fèö «õ‡®ò cƒè«÷ õNñ£P ªê™õ¶ ã«ù£?Cô Üê‹ð£Mî ê‹ðõƒèœ ®¡ Cô º‚Aò
ïèóƒèO™ ïì‚°‹«ð£¶ ñ†´‹ ܶ ê‹ð‰îñ£èMõ£îƒè¬÷»‹, G蛄Cè¬÷»‹ åOð󊹋
ïñ‚° ®¡ CÁ ïèóƒèO«ô£, Aó£ñƒèO«ô£ Fù‰«î£Á‹ ܶ «ð£¡ø Ü™ô¶ ܬîMì «ñô£ùÜê‹ð£Mîƒè¬÷ 致‹ è£ù£îî£è åOð󊹪êŒõ¶ Gò£ò‹ ù£?
ÜóCò™õ£Fèœ î£¡ ñ‚èO¡ õ£›‚¬èJ½‹,«î¬õèO½‹ ÜóCò™ ªêŒAø£˜èœ â¡ø£™,
cƒèÀ‹ Üê‹ð£Mî G蛄Cè¬÷ F¼‹ð F¼‹ðåOðóŠH ñ‚èOì‹ «è£ðˆîù¬ô ãŸð´ˆFÜóCò™ ªêŒòˆî£¡ 𣘂Al˜èœ.
ªð£¿¶«ð£‚° G蛄Cè¬÷õöƒ°‹ ªî£¬ô‚裆C蜪êŒA¡ø «ñ£ê®èœ Þ¼‚«è
I辋 ªè£Çóñ£ù¶.
ww w.l awye rsli ne .ne t 22 lawyers line - march - 2013
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 22/36
23 lawyers line - march - 2013 www.l awyersline.net
Þ‰Fò£ï£‹ õ£›õèŸø ï£ì£?
& ï™ô£¡ Þó£ñê£I
ï‹ «îêˆF™ õ£¿‹ 120 «è£® ñ‚èO™ ñ ÝÀ‹ ªõÁ‹ Í¡Á M¿‚è£́ ñQî˜èœ îMó 97 M¿‚裴 ñ‚èO¡ ñùˆF™ â¿A¡ø ¶ò˜I° «èœM«ò ޶. 膴‚èìƒè£î èì¡ ²¬ñ. IîI…Cò áö™, «ñ£êñ£ù ðíi‚è‹, áî£Kˆîùñ£ù Ýì‹ðó„ªêô¾èœ, ªð£¼÷£î£ó„ Y˜F¼ˆî‹ â¡Aø ªðòK™ Þ‰Fò£¬õ ܉Gò ´‚°Üì° ¬õ‚°‹ «ð£‚°. ñ‚èœ Hó„C¬ùè¬÷Mõ£F‚è£ñ™ ï£ì£Àñ¡øƒè¬÷ ºì‚AM†´ ܬùˆ¶ ÜóCò™ è†CèÀ‹ «ðó‹«ðC ïìˆF õ¼‹ ÜóCò™ Hˆîô£†ìƒèœ
àœO†ì Gè›¾èœ åšªõ£¼ ð£óî‚°®ñèQ¡ àœ÷ˆF½‹ Þ‚«èœM¬òâö„ªêŒ¶œ÷¶. Þ‰Fò£  õ£›õèŸø ï£ì£?è£K¼À‹ ê£M¼†´‹ êÍèˆ¬î‚ è™M‚
ªè£‡´œ÷ù. ð²¬ñ YóN‰î ªõÁ‹ GôˆF™ªõŠð‹ ñ†´«ñ Gó‰îó‹. î‡a¼‚è£ù ꇬì¬ò cFñ¡øƒè÷£™ Ãìˆ b˜‚躮òM™¬ô. ¬õè¬øJ¡ è‡ MNŠ¬ð‚裇ðœ ñQî °ôˆF¡ põ¡ «ð£ŒM´Aø¶. ªð‡èœ, °ö‰¬îèœ, ªðK«ò£˜èœ
àœO†ì ܬùõ¼«ñ õ£›M¡ î¼íƒè¬÷Üõv¬îè÷£™ Þ†´ GóŠð «õ‡®ò è†ì£òˆF™ àœ÷ù˜. Üóê£ƒè‹ â¡ð¶ ñ‚
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 23/36
ww w.l awye rsli ne .ne t 24 lawyers line - march - 2013
è¬÷ˆ ‚°‹ vî£ðùñ£èñ£PJ¼‚Aø¶ ÜóC¡ ªè£œ¬èèœ Þ‰îˆ «îꈶ ñ‚è¬÷ àJ«ó£´ ¹¬î°N‚° ÜŠH‚ ªè£‡´œ÷¶. îŠH‚è ⇵A¡ø ñ‚èœ
 îƒèœ ñùˆF™ Þˆî¬èò«èœMè¬÷ â¿ŠHò õ‡í‹àœ÷ù˜.
²ò ªî£N™ º¡«ùŸø‹àŸðˆF ꣘‰î ºîh´, CÁõEèõ÷˜„C ÝAòõŸ¬ø Þ‰Fòˆ
F¼ï£†®™ Ü®«ò£´ Þ™ô£ñ™ªêŒî£AM†ì¶. Þ‰Fò£M™¹öƒè «õ‡®ò ðí‹ Ü‰Gò˜õê‹ °M‰¶ ªè£‡®¼‚Aø¶.
Þ¬õ «ð£î£ªî¡Á ÞŠ«ð£¶C™ô¬ø õ˜ˆîèˆF™ 51 êîMAî܉Gò «ïó® ºîh†¬ì ÜÂñFŠðªî¡Á ñˆFò Üó² º®¾ªêŒ¶œ÷¶. Þ cFñ¡øº‹
î¬ìMF‚è ñÁˆ¶M†ì¶. C™ô¬ø õ˜ˆîèˆF™ «ïó® ܉Gòºîh†¬ì ÜÂñFŠð¶ â‹ ñ¡«ñ£è¡ Cƒ ÜóC¡ º®¾‚°Šð™«õÁ ñ£Gô Üó²èœ âF˜Š¹‚裆®»‹ ⶾ‹ ï쉶MìM™¬ô.
ñˆFò ܬñ„êó¬õJ™ Þ싪ðŸP¼‰î î¡ è†C¬ò„ «ê˜‰î6 ܬñ„ê˜è¬÷ ó£Tù£ñ£ ªêŒò¬õˆî«î£´ 裃Aóv Ü󲂰ˆ
 ÜOˆ¶ õ‰î Ýîó¬õ»‹,
Mô‚A‚ ªè£‡ì£˜ «ñŸ°õƒèºîô¬ñ„ê˜ ñ‹î£ ð£ù˜T. ܶñ†´ñ¡P ªõOìõ˜ ò£¼‹«ñŸ° õƒèˆF™ è¬ì Fø‚è º®ò£îõ£Á Ü‹ñ£Gô„ ê†ìñ¡øˆ
F™ b˜ñ£ùº‹ ªè£‡´õóŠð†´œ÷¶. îIöè ºîô¬ñ„ê˜ ªüò
ôLî£ C™ô¬ø õ˜ˆîèˆF™Ü‰Gò ºîh†´‚°ˆ îI›ï£†®™ ÞìI™¬ô â¡Á èø£ó£èÜPMŠ¹ ªõOJ†ì£˜. ܬî
»‹ eP õ£™ñ£˜† GÁõù‹ ªê¡¬ùJ™ è¬ìMK‚è ºò¡Áõ¼Aø¶.
Mõ£îƒèO¡ Íô‹ ñ‚èœ Hó„¬ùèÀ‚°ˆ b˜¾è£µ‹ ñóHL¼‰¶ ï¿M‚ «èõôñ£ù ÜóCò™ ïìõ®‚¬èèO™ âF˜‚è†CJù˜ß´ð´A¡øù˜. M¬ôõ£C àò˜¾,ªð†«ó£™ M¬ô °¬øŠ¹, ïFc˜ Mõè£ó‹, ªð‡èœ Þì 嶂W†´ñ«ê£î£, èÁŠ¹Š ðí Mõè£ó‹,2T áö™, Gô‚èK„ ²óƒè嶂W†´ áö™ àœO†ì º‚AòMõè£óƒèO™ âF˜‚è†Cèœ
â¡ùªõ™ô£«ñ£ ªêŒ¶ð£˜ˆ¶‹è£ƒAóv Ü󲂰 âFó£è å¼
¶¼‹¬ð‚Ãì â´ˆ¶Š«ð£´‹ Fó£EòŸøõ˜è÷£è«õ Üõ˜èœ Þ¼‰¶ õ¼õ¶ è£ô‚ªè£´¬ñ.
ÜóCò™ è†CèO¡ ïìõ®‚¬èèœ ñ‚è¬÷ ªõ†Aˆ î¬ô°Qò¬õˆ¶œ÷ù. ñ‚èœ ªè£‡
´œ÷ ܬñF»‹ ï™Lí‚躋݆Cò£÷˜è¬÷„ ê˜õ£Fè£K蜫𣙠º®ªõ´‚èˆ É‡´A¡øù.Üõ˜è¬÷ «ñ½‹ «ñ½‹ îõÁªêŒò õNõ°‚A¡øù. ñÝœõ„ CP¶‹ î°FòŸøõ˜èÀ‚°  C‹ñ£êù‹ õöƒA»œ«÷£‹. ñ‡E™ ªïO»‹ ¹¿‚èÀ‚° «ñ¡¬ñ îƒAò â¡A¡øð†ìˆ¬î„ ņ´õ¶«ð£™ñ£†C¬ñ ªð£¼‰Fòõ˜è÷£è
Üõ˜è¬÷ ïìˆF‚ ªè£‡®¼‚A«ø£‹. ï‹e¶ Ü‚è¬øJ™ô£î, ïñ‚° ܉Gòñ£AŠ «ð£ŒM†ìõ˜è¬÷ ÌTˆîð® ̬ùŠð¬ìèœ ¬õˆ¶‚ è£õ™ ªêŒA
«ø£‹ ⡪ø™ô£‹ ñùˆF™«èœMªò¿ŠH‚ °ºÁ‹ Þ‰FòQ¡ Ü„ê‹ Þ¶î£¡. Þ‰Fò£
 õ£›õèŸø  î£ù£?C™ô¬ø õ˜ˆîèˆF™ ܉Gò
ºîh†¬ì ÜÂñFˆî£™ ® ½œ÷ ðôËÁ «è£® ã¬ö ñŸÁ‹ ï ˆ́îó ñ‚èœ «õ¬ô Þö‚°‹ Üð£òºœ÷¶. ÞŠ«ð£¶œ÷ M¬ôõ£Càò˜¾ «ð£î£î£? âF˜è£ôˆF™àŠ¹, ¹O Ãì õ£ƒè º®ò£«î âù
ñ‚èœ èîPˆ ¶®‚è, ºè‹ º¿‚è„C¬î‰¶ õ£Œ«è£EŠ«ð£ùáö™èO¡ ªî£°Šð£èˆ Fè¿‹
î¬ôõ˜ å¼õ˜ ªê£¡ù£˜ ÔÔÜ󲺮ªõ´ˆî£™ â´ˆî¶î£¡,Üó² î¡ º®¾è¬÷ ñ£ŸP‚ªè£‡®¼‚裶ÕÕ.
ªì™L¬ò ÝÀ‹ «ñ†´‚°®Šªð‡ñE î¡ ÜÂðõˆFŸ°‹ õò
FŸ°‹ Þ¿‚°ˆ «î®‚ªè£œÀ‹õ¬èJ™ ªê£¡ù ªê£™ Þ¶
ÔÔC‚èùñ£è õ£ö‚ èŸÁ‚ ªè£œÀƒèœ ñ‚è«÷.ÕÕ ÞõŸÁ‚ªè™ô£‹ å¼ð® «ñ«ô
ªê¡ø ï‹ñ ᘂ èí‚°Š¹LÔÔñQî˜èœ ꣊H´õ¬î‚ °¬øˆ¶‚ªè£œ÷ «õ‡´‹ÕÕ â¡Á ܆¬õvªêŒî£˜. ðîMJ¡ º‚Aòˆ¶õ‹
Þõ˜èO¡ ÜP¬õ‚ «è£íô£‚AJ¼‚Aø¶. Þõ˜è¬÷„ ²ŸP»œ÷ ÆìˆFŸ°‹, ªõOJ™ àœ÷ñ‚èÀ‚°‹ Þ¬ìJ™ àœ÷ MˆF
ò£ê‹ ªîKò£ñ™ «ðC‚ ªè£‡´œ÷ù˜. ®™ â¿A¡øHó„¬ùèÀ‚ªè™ô£‹ è£óí‹,
Þõ˜è¬÷Š «ð£¡øõ˜èœî£«ù îMó, «õÁ âõ¼I™¬ô.
Þ‰Fò£ õÁ¬ñ‚«è£†´‚°‚W› õ£›A¡ø ñ‚è¬÷‚ ªè£‡´œ÷ èO™ àôA«ô«ò Í¡ø£õ¶ Þìˆ¬îŠ H®ˆ¶œ÷¶.àôè õƒAJ¡ 2005 Ý‹ ݇´ÜP‚¬èJ¡ð® Þ‰Fò£M™ 42M¿‚裴 ñ‚èœ õÁ¬ñ‚«è£†´‚°‚ W› õ£›Aø£˜èœ. 75 M¿‚裴 Þ‰Fò˜èO¡ å¼ ï£œ õ¼ñ£ù‹ 2 Ï𣌂°‹ °¬øõ£ù¶.è™M, àì™ ïô‹, õ£›‚¬èˆîó‹â¡ø Í¡P¡ Ü®Šð¬ìJ™ Þ‰Fò£M™ Þ¼‚°‹ 8 ñ£GôƒèO™ 421 I™Lò¡ ñ‚èO¡ õ£›‚¬è
â‡íˆF¡ °ó™ & 1
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 24/36
25 lawyers line - march - 2013 www.l awyersline.net
ÝŠHK‚è èO™ Gô¾‹ õÁ¬ñ¬òMì‚ ªè£´¬ñ G¬ø‰îî£èàœ÷¶. Ýù£™ ðóñ ã¬öèœ
G¬ø‰î ï‹ ï£†®™î£¡ ÝCò£M¡I芪ðKò ðí‚è£ó˜èœ õ£›‰¶ªè£‡®¼‚Aø£˜èœ. îƒèœ 弫õ¬÷ àí¾‚è£è¾‹, îñ¶ ªê™ôŠHó£EJ¡ ªï£Á‚°ˆ bQ‚è£è¾‹
ÝJó‚ èí‚A™ ªêôõNŠðõ˜èœ Þõ˜èœ.嚪õ£¼ º¬ø»‹ îñ¶ Üó² î´
ñ£Á‹ «ð£ªî™ô£‹ îœ÷£†ìˆ¬î«ï˜ªêŒõîŸè£è âF˜‚è†CèÀ‚°M¼‰¶ ¬õŠð¶ Hóîñ˜ ñ¡«ñ£è¡Cƒ°‚°‚ ¬è õ‰î è¬ô. ä‚Aò ºŸ«ð£‚°‚ ÆìE Üó² Þó‡ì£
õ¶ º¬øò£èŠ ðîM«òŸÁ Í¡ø£‡´èœ G¬ø¾ªêŒî¬îªò£†®ˆ îù¶ Þ™ôˆF™ ªê™õ‰î˜èÀ‚°‹ âF˜‚è†Cˆ î¬ôõ˜èÀ‚°‹ M¼‰¶‚°ãŸð£´ ªêŒAø£˜ ïñ¶ Hóîñ˜. 603 «ð¼‚°Ü¬öŠ¹ M´ˆîF™ 375 «ð˜ èô‰¶ ªè£œAø£˜èœ.܉î M¼‰¶‚è£ù ªñ£ˆî„ªêô¾ 35 Þô†ê Ïð£Œ.èí«ïó G蛄C‚è£ù ð‰î™ ªêô¾ ñ†´‹ 15 ô†ê‹Ïð£Œ. ܉î M¼‰F™ å¼õK¡ 弫ïó„ ꣊𣆴‚è£ù ªêô¾ 775 Ïð£Œ. Þ¶  ã¬öèœÜóC¡ C‚èù ïìõ®‚¬è.
ñ¡«ñ£è¡Cƒè£™ ÝC˜õF‚èŠð†ì F†ì‚°¿ˆ ¶¬íˆî¬ôõ˜ ñ£‡«ì‚ Cƒ ܽõ£Lò£ îù¶Ü½õôèˆF™ èNŠð¬ø 塬ø Yó¬ñ‚è 37 Þô†êÏ𣌠ªêôõN‚Aø£˜. ã¬öŠ ðƒè£÷˜èO¡C‚èù ïìõ®‚¬è Þ¶. iìŸøõ˜èO¡ «îêˆF™
®™ ºî™ °®ñè÷£èˆ F蛉î å¼ ñ£îóC,ðîM 挾‚°Š Hø° ñ£O¬è ܬñˆ¶‚ªè£œ÷ 75 ã‚è˜ Gô‹ «è†ì¶‹, ðîM‚è£ôˆF™ ªðŸø ðK²Šªð£¼†è¬÷ â™ô£‹ ÜœO‚ ªè£‡´ ªê¡ø¶ñ£ù Üõô‹ Þƒ°î£¡ ïì‰î¶. ÞŠ«ð˜ð†ì
üùï£òè ®™  õ£öô£ñ£? â¡ð¶î£¡ñ‚èO¡ «èœM.
3.29 I™Lò¡ ê¶ó‚ A«ô£ e†ì˜ ðóŠð÷M™ ðó‰¶ MK‰¶ ÝCò£M«ô«ò Þó‡ì£õ¶ªðKò ï£ì£è£è¾‹, àôè Ü÷M™ ãö£õ¶ªðKò ï£ì£è¾‹ Fè¿‹ Þ‰Fò£M™ ÞòŸ¬è
õ÷ƒèÀ‚°‚ °¬øM™¬ô. ð£óî «îêˆF¡I芪ðKò ðôƒèO™ å¡Á ÞòŸ¬è õ÷‹.à¬øò ¬õ‚°‹ è´ƒ°OK™ àôA™ Þó‡ì£õ¶
Þì‹ õA‚°‹ «ñŸ° ô죂 ð°F¬ò»‹, 55 ®AKªê™Còv è´¬ñò£ù ªõŠðˆ¬î ªõO‚ 裆´‹åKê£ àœO†ì ñ£Gôƒè¬÷»‹ 弃«è ªðŸøÜŸ¹îˆ «îê‹.
ð-öƒ°® ñ‚èO¡ õ£›õ£î£óñ£èˆ F蛉îè£´èœ ÜN‚èŠð†´, ÞòŸ¬è õ÷ƒèœªè£œ¬÷ò®‚èŠð†´  èìˆîŠð†ìù.ñ¬ôèœ è£í£ñ™ «ð£Jù. ÝÁèœ ð£›ªõOèœ ÝJù. Gô‚èK ºîô£ù ÜŸ¹î„ ªê™õƒ èœÜKî£AM†ìù. Ü̘õ àJKùƒèœ, ÍL¬èèœÜN‚èŠð†´ õ¼A¡øù. 裴èÀ‹ èìŸðóŠ¹èÀ‹
ªè£œ¬÷ò˜èO¡ H®J™ C‚°‡´Aì‚A¡øù. Þˆî¬èò Üð£òè óñ £ù
Å›G¬ôJ™î£¡ ã¬ö ï´ˆîóñ‚èO¡ õ£›õ£î£óˆ¬î„ C¬îˆ¶Üõ˜è¬÷ àJ«ó£´ ¹¬î°N‚°ÜŠð„ C™ô¬ø õ˜ˆîèˆF™Ü‰Gò ºîh†¬ì ÜÂñFˆ¶ 冴
ªñ£ˆî Þ‰Fò ñ‚èO¡ âF˜Š¬ð»‹ê‹ð£Fˆ¶‚ ªè£‡®¼‚Aø¶ñˆFò Üó². ÜóC¡ Þ‰î º®¾å¼ï£œ Ü™ô¶ æ󣇴 å¼ê裊 º®‰¶«ð£õF™¬ô.å¼ «îêˆF¡ ñ‚è¬÷, Üõ˜èO¡ ê‰îF¬ò Ü®¬ñŠð´ˆ¶‹
ºòŸC.2009 Ý‹ ݇´ ªêŠì‹ðK™ àôè õƒAJì‹
Þ¼‰¶ 4.345 H™Lò¡ ܪñK‚è ì£ô˜è¬÷‚èìù£èŠ ªðŸÁœ÷¶ Þ‰Fò£. Þ¶ îQŠð†ì
죡Á‚° àôè õƒA õöƒA»œ÷ Þó‡ì£õ¶I芪ðKò ªî£¬è. 2010 Ý‹ ݇®½‹ ܪñK‚è£MìI¼‰¶ 126.6 I™Lò¡ ì£ô˜ èì¡ ªðøŠð†ì¶.
Þ¬õ îMó Þ‰Fò£M™ àœ÷ 嚪õ£¼ ñ£Gôº‹ªõOèOì‹ Þ¼‰¶ èì¡ õ£ƒA‚ ªè£í¢́ 
Þ¼‚A¡øù. ñ‚èO¡ ªðòK™ õ£ƒèŠð´‹ èì¡,ñ‚èœ ïô‚è£è„ ªêôõN‚èŠðì£ñ™ ªõŸÁ Ýì‹ðó‹, «èO‚¬èèœ, áö™è÷£™ ií®‚èŠð´A¡øù. Þ‰Fò£ â‹ I芪ðKò üùï£òè ®™
ã¬öèÀ‚ªè¡Á Þƒ° ⶾ«ñ ªê£‰îI™¬ô.Üõ˜èœ ñ‡E™ ïìŠð‚ Ãì àK¬ñ
ñÁ‚èŠð´‹  ªõ° ªî£¬ôM™ Þ™¬ô. ²î‰Fó‹ªðŸÁ 65 ݇´èœ Ýù Hø°‹ Üõ˜èOì‹ Þ¼‰¶åšªõ£¡ø£è àK¬ñèœ î£¡ ðP‚èŠð´A¡øù«õ
îMóŠ ¹Fò àK¬ñè¬÷ ò£¼‹ ãŸð´ˆFˆ î¼õF™¬ô.
嚪õ£¼ «î˜îL¡«ð£¶‹ 5 ݇´èO™â™«ô£¼‚°‹ i´ â¡ð£˜èœ. ®™ àœ÷嚪õ£¼ îQñQî‚°‹ îóñ£ù ñ¼ˆ¶õ õêFA¬ì‚èŠ ð£´ð´«õ£‹ â¡Á ºöƒ°õ£˜èœ. 10
ï£O™ M¬ôõ£C¬ò‚ °¬øŠ«ð£‹ âù„ êˆFò‹ªêŒõ£˜èœ. ꣬ô õêF, °®c˜ õêF, è™M
«ñ‹ð£´, ªî£N™¶¬ø «ñ‹ð£´ â™ô£õŸP½‹ê£î¬ù ð¬ìŠ«ð£‹ â¡Á ðꊹ õ£˜ˆ¬î蜫ð²õ£˜èœ.
â¡ù ïì‰F¼‚Aø¶? ê£ñ£Qò˜èO¡ «èœM‚° ÝÀƒè†C»‹, âF˜‚è†CèÀ‹ â¡ù ðF™ªê£™ôŠ«ð£A¡øù?
âF˜‚è†CèÀ‚°‹ ªî£NôFð˜èÀ‚°‹ M¼‰¶ãŸð£´ ªêŒõ º¡ 裃Aóv Üóꣃ躋,Üó²  M¼‰F™ èô‰¶ ªè£œõ º¡ùî£èâF˜‚è†Cˆ î¬ôõ˜èÀ‹ ñ‚èœ HóFGFèÀ‹
ê£ñ£QòQ¡ «èœM °Pˆ¶Š ðF™è¬÷ˆ «î´õ¶ ï™ô¶.
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 25/36
ww w.l awye rsli ne .ne t 26 lawyers line - march - 2013
ªõO´ èù¾èœ, ðô«ïóƒèO™, Þ‰î NRI-‚èÀì¡ F¼
ñíñ£ùõ˜ ªõOèÀ‚°ªê™õF™ àœ÷¶. Cô «ïó‹ Ü‚èù¾èœ ªõO®Ÿ° ªê™õº¡«ð è¬ô‰¶ M´A¡ø¶.
ðô Þ‰Fò êÍèˆFùK¬ì«ò,ª õ O ï £ † ® ™ õ £ ¿ ‹
Þ‰Fò˜èÀ‚° îƒèœ ñè¬ù«ò£ Ü™ô¶ñè¬÷«ò£ F¼ñí‹ ªêŒ¶ ¬õŠð¶ å¼ Ü‰îvˆ
F¡ ܬì ò£÷ñ£èŠ ð£̃ ‚èŠð´A¡ø¶. ãªùQ™ Þîù£™ ªõO´‚° ªê™ô å¼ ï™ô ê‰î˜Šðñ£è𣘂èŠð´A¡ø¶. I¡Âõªî™ô£‹ ªð£¡ù™ô â¡
ð¬îŠ «ð£ô, ²è õ£›¾‚°‹, ªê£°² õ£›‚¬è°‹Ý¬êŠð†´, ªðŸ«ø£˜ º¡H¡ ÜPò£î å¼õ¬óº¿õ¶‹ õ«î Þ è£óíñ£°‹. Þîù£™ò£¼¬ìò õ£›¾ ðLò£A¡ø¶.
ªð£¶õ£è NRI F¼ñíƒèœ â¡ø£™, Þ‰Fò£M™õ£¿‹ å¼ ªð‡µ‚°‹, ªõO®™ õ£¿‹
Þ‰Fòó£ù å¼ Ýµ‚°‹ Þ¬ì«ò ï¬ìªðÁ‹ F¼ñíˆ¬î °P‚A¡øù. «ñ½‹ ÞˆF¼ñíƒèœ Íô‹ãñ£Ÿø ñ¬ì»‹ ªð‡èœ cFˆ ¶¬øJ¡ Íô‹ Gò£ò‹«è†ð¶ I辋 è®ùñ£ù º¬øò£°‹. ãªùQ™ÜŠªð‡ îù¶ ªê£‰î ñ‡E™ Þ¼‰¶‹, ªê£‰îƒèœÜ¬ùõK캋 Þ¼‰¶ HK‚èŠð†´, ªñ£N, Mõó‹,
ê†ì‹ âù ܬùˆ¶ MîƒèO½‹ îQ¬ñŠð´ˆîŠð´A¡øù .̃ Þ‰î Mîñ£ù F¼ñíƒèœ ðôMî Hó„¬ùèO¡ Ü®Šð¬ìJ™ ãŸð´A¡øù.õóî†ê¬í, ªð‡ªè£´¬ñèœ, 㟪èù«õ F¼ñíñ£ù ñ¬ùM¬òÜò™ï£†®™ ñ¬øˆ¶ ªê£ˆ¶‚è£è Þ‰Fòªð‡è¬÷ F¼ñí‹ ªêŒõ¶ «ð£¡ø¬õò£°‹.
W›õ¼ð¬õ NRI F¼ñíƒèO™ ãŸðì‚îòHó„C¬ùè÷£°‹.
1. NRI‚° ñíº®‚èŠð†ì ªð‡ Üò™ ´‚°èíõ¼ì¡ ªê™õ º¡«ð Þ‰Fò£M™¬èMìŠð´õ¶.
2. ªð‡ I辋 ªè£Çóñ£è Ü®‚èŠð†´,è£òŠð´ˆîŠð†´, êKò£è àíõO‚èŠðì£ñ™,ܬùˆ¶ MîˆF½‹ ªè£´¬ñ‚°†ð´ˆîŠð†´,
®Ÿ° F¼‹HŠ «ð£è ªêŒî™ Ü™ô¶ Mó†´î™.3. «õèñ£ù G„êòˆîˆ¬î ªî£ì˜‰¶,
ªðKò è™ò£í‹, ÜFèñ£ù õóî†ê¬í ñŸÁ‹«î¡Gô¾, Þî¬ùˆ ªî£ì˜‰¶ NRI èíõ¡ ªõO
´‚° ªê¡ÁMì Þ‰Fò£M«ô«ò ñ¬ùMMê£MŸ° 裈¶‚ ªè£‡®¼Šð£˜.
4. F¼ñíñ£ù ñ¬ùM, ªõO®™ îƒèœèíõ¼ì¡ õ£ö ªê¡Á ªõ° «ïó‹ Mñ£ù G¬ôòˆ
F«ô«ò 裈F¼‰¶, èíõ¡ õó£ñ™ «ð£õ¶.
5. NRI èíõ¡ 㟪èù«õ, Üò™ï£†®™,«õªø£¼ ñ¬ùM¬ò F¼ñí‹ ªêŒõ¶.
6. ªð‡¬í ãñ£ŸP F¼ñí‹ ªêŒò î¡ Â¬ìò ܬùˆ¶ Mõóƒè¬÷»‹ °Pˆ¶ ªð£Œò£ù îèõ™ ÜOŠð¶.
7. Þ‰Fò£M«ô£ Ü™ô¶ ªõO®«ô£, îù¶ F¼ñí Hó„C¬ùèÀ‚è£è «ð£ó£´‹ ªð‡èœ ªî£ì˜‰¶ ðô ªî£N™¸†ð Þ¡ù™è¬÷ ê†ìˆ
¶¬øJ™ ê‰FŠð¶. Þ¶ «ð£ô õ£›M¬ù ðL ªè£´ˆî ªð‡èœ
ïô‚è£è W›‚è‡ì õNº¬øèœ ªêŒòŠðì«õ‡´‹.
1. õNè¬÷ ²ôðñ£‚A Þ‰Fò£M™ àœ÷Üò™ï£†´ Éîóèƒèœ M¬óõ£è Mê£ ÜOŠð¶.
2. NRI/RIO èíõ¡ îù¶ ñ¬ùMJ¡ ꣘¹¬ì¬ñ¬ò óˆ¶ ªêŒò£ñ™, Þ¼‚è ªêŒõ¶. Þî¡
Íô‹ ð£F‚èŠð†ì ªð‡ ܃A¼‰¶ «ð£ó£ìõêFò£è Þ¼‚°‹.
3. Þ‰Fò£M™ ªêŒòŠð†ì F¼ñí ð‰î‹Üò™ï£†´ cFñ¡øƒè÷£™ óˆ¶ ªêŒòŠðì‚Ã죶.
4. F¼ñí º¬ø«è´èO™ ß´ð´‹ NRI èíõK¡àKñ‹ óˆ¶ ªêŒî™.
5. Üò™ï£†®™ Þ¶ «ð£¡ø ð£F‚èŠð†ìªð‡èÀ‚° ôîô£ù Ýîó¾ ÜOˆî™.
NRI Hó„C¬ùè¬÷ ¬èò£÷ CøŠ¹ ¶¬øèœ ñŸÁ‹Ü½õô˜è¬÷ õ®õ¬ñˆî™. «ñ½‹ Þ¶ «ð£¡øHó„¬ùèÀ‚è£ù FIR ðF¾è¬÷ èõQŠðF™ è£õô˜
ñŸÁ‹ ÜFè£Kè¬÷ º¬ùŠ¹ì¡ ªêò™ð´ˆ¶î™.ªð‡èœ ñŸÁ‹ °ö‰¬îèœ «ñ‹ð£†´ ¶¬ø, NRI-
‚è£ù F¼ñí‹ ªêŒ»‹ ªð‡èÀ‚° Þó‡ì£‹ð£v«ð£˜†¬ì õöƒ°ñ£Á «è£¼A¡ø¶. å¼ «õ¬÷ºî™ ð£v «ð£˜† èíõó£™ H´ƒèŠðì£ñ™, Þó‡ì£‹ ð£v«ð£˜† Üõó¶ ªðŸ«ø£Kì‹ Þ¼‰î£™, ÜŠªð‡¬í ðˆFóñ£è ®Ÿ° ªè£‡´õóªðK¶‹ à. Þ‰î Þó‡ì£‹ ð£v«ð£˜†®¡
ïèL™ ÜŠªð‡ ñŸÁ‹ Üõó¶ NRI èíõK¡ Mõóƒèœ Þ¼‰î£™ ܶ Üõ˜èO¡ F¼ñí ꣡ø£è¾‹ªêò™ð´‹. Þ¶ ÜŠªð‡
õ£öŠ «ð£°‹ Üò™ï£†®¡ Þ‰Fò ÉóèˆF™ ðˆFóŠð´ˆîŠð´‹. Þ¶ ªðK¶‹à. ÞŠHó„C¬ùèœ ãŸð´‹
ªð‡èÀ‚°, ܉î‰î èO™ àœ÷ ÉîóèƒèO™ àîMèœ ÜO‚èŠð´‹ â¡Â‹MNŠ¹í˜¾ Þ¼ŠðF™¬ô.âù«õ, Þ¶ °Pˆ¶ ªð‡èO¬ì«ò MNŠ¹í˜¾ãŸð´ˆ¶õ¶ I辋 ÜõCò
ñ£ù å¡ø£°‹.
°®ñ‚è÷™ô£î Þ‰Fò˜èÀìù£ùF¼ñí‹ (nrI Mige)
& å¼ ê†ìŠ 𣘬õ
ê Í è ‹
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 26/36
27 lawyers line - march - 2013 www.l awyersline.net
The Dawn of the 20th Century sawthe production of great man from the
madras Christian college. The first
was Shri G A Natesan, a journalist of
reputation and with whom Mahathma
Gandhi stayed at his residence in My-
lapore during 1929-30 and it is said that
it was Natesan who asked Gandhiji to
attend the second round table confer-
ence in 1930. R.V.Krishna Ayyar,
who is the one of the founding of our
parlimentary system and democracy.
Then came S.Radhakrishnan, who roseup to become the president of India
Lakshmanaswamy mudaliar and Ram-
aswamy mudaliar came next and then
Sir Mohamed Usman who was an active
governor of Madras Province and the
veteran parlimentarian S.Sathyamurthy
also came. Sathyamurthy, Usman,
Radhakrishnan and Mudaliar brothers
became close friend of R.V.Krishna
Ayyar and the friendship lasted till their
last days.R.V.Krishna Ayyar was born poor
at Rasipuram in Salem district.He then
went to Salem Municipal high school,
then Salem College. At Salem College
during the years 1897-99 he became
a student of Rt.Hon.Srinivasa sastriar
who was a lecturer there. Srinivasa
Sastri wanted R V Krishna Ayyar to join
the servants of india society and wrote
to the president of the society Gopala
Krishna Gokale that he is persuading anexcellent student R.V.Krishnan to join
the society. But R V Krishnan preferred
the path of Bal Gangadara Tilakar. From
Salem College R.V.Krishna joined the
Madras Christian College for his B.A.
It should be said that R.V.Krishnan
took the rst rank in every examina-
tion from infant class till M.L. And he
studied on scholarship and won about
all the medals all the classes,This is the
record. The professors were so much
impressed by the intellectual eminenceof krishnan that during the various
functions krishnan was asked to sit in
rst row along with professor a rare
achievement.From there Krishnan went
to Law College and became a student of
DR.S.Swaminathan, father of Govinda
swaminathan. Swaminathan was a
professor was a professor the Madras
Law College. He was impressed by the
intellectual document R.V.Krishnan
and He asked Krishnan to prepare thenotes for him to conduct the lecture
for the law classes. Thus it was a rare
case of a student preparing subject and
notes for his professor, rare case student
became a teacher for his own teacher.
He was enrolled in 1904 and served as
a junior to Swaminathan. But Krishnan
went to Salem 1905 to practice Law. It
was here he became into contact with
Rajagopalachari who was practicing as
an advocate there. Rajagopalachari real-ised the intellectual potency of Krishnan
and they became a great friends. This
friendship lasted for nearly 67years till
they died. But in 1910 the Government
appointed him a District Munsiff and his
posting was at Erode. It was at Erode
he made a great name for himself and
people used to say, If you want justice,
then go to Krishnan court. It was at
Erode E.V.Ramaswamy Naicker and
Krishnan became good friends. No
one knows how they respected eachother till their last. From Erode he was
shifted to Eluru now in Andhra pradesh.
Here T.Prakasam used to appear be-
fore Krishnan and they became great
friends. From Eluru he was shifted to
Chengalpet and here he decided the
famous Prasadam case. There was dis-
pute between Vadakalai Ayyangar and
Thenkalai Ayyangars over the right to
get the rst prasadam. The judgement
was hailed as the best and the Privycouncil to which the case went on ap-
peal accepted the ndings of krishnan
and reported that this was one of the best
judgements they had come across. From
Chengalpet he was shifted to Kulithalai
and from there he was shifted to Naga-
pattinam. It was when he was serving
as District Munsiff at Nagapattinam, his
career changed. During 1918 the Gov-
ernment of India act introduced Dyachy
The ParlimenT leGend
r V KriShna aYYar
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 27/36
ww w.l awye rsli ne .ne t 28 lawyers line - march - 2013
in the provinces and Legislative council was formed in British
Provinces. The Government then shifted Krishnan to the Law
Department of the Madras Government as a special ofcer
cum Assistant Secretary for the implementation of the 1918
act. Krishnan drafted the modalitities and other constitutional
features of 1918 Government of India Act and when the rst
Legislative council was formed in 1921 he was appointed as
assistant secretary of the Legislative council. The rst chair -
man of Madras legislative council was sir S.P.Rajagopalachariand in 1923 he was posted as an advisor to the secretary of
state for india in London he vacated the ofce as president
of the Legislative council. To this vacancy the rst secretary
of the Legislative council Shri L.D.Samikannu pillai was ap-
pointed president as of legistrative council and the Governor
appointed R.V.Krishnan as the secretary of the Legislative
council in 1924. It was at the Table of the House Krishnan
made a huge name and a time came during 1930, every one
considered him as an authority in Parlimentary Law, They
stopped consulting Sir Erskin may because there was R V
Krishnan to be consulted and he became the efford Erskin
may of India. During the period when he was at the table of the house, Madras Province produced great parliamentarians
like S.Sathyamurthy, C.P.Ramaswamy ayyar, M.C.Rajah,
R.K.Shanmugam chetty, Sir A.Ramaswamy mudaliar,
Sir Mohamed usman, T.Prakasam, P.Ramamurthy,
M.Kalyanasundaram, C. Rajagopalchari etc. He sent a
note to the British Government in London 1930 Krishna
Ayyar report on the parlimentary system at the time
of the round table conference and this was hailed by
Macdonauld who was Prime minister of England then
and the Macdonauld award issued after the failure of
the second round table conference granting provincialautonomy and Constitution Custom Procedure formed
the basis for they 1935 government of India act. Every
one in India accepted R.V.Krishna ayyar as one of the
great authority in constitutional law and law and prac-
tice Parlimentary of bodies. He vacated ofce in 1942.
The congress lost havily in the rst elections in
1952 to the Madras Legislative Assembly, the Congress
secured only 144seats in a house of 395, Rajagopala-
chari was requested to form a ministry. Rajaji wanted
a strong person to be in charge Legislature and to train
new members under the Indian constitution. He cannot
think of anyone else than his old friend R.V.Krishnanand made a personal request to him to accept the posi-
tion of the secretary of the Legislature. Krishnan Ayyar rst
declined the offer but Rajaji persuaded him to become the
secretary and so he joined the Legislature. R.V.Krishnan
was the only person to conduct the legislature at every stage
of the Indian constitutional. Development as the secretary,
First during the 1919 Government of India Act, then under
the 1935 Government of India act and then again under the
present Indian constitution in 1952.
No Law no enactment passed during the period when he
was the secretary of the legislature was questioned in anycourt at any time.
He was an ofcial member of the central Legislative
assembly and S.Sathyamurthy and M.Ananthasayanam Ayy-
angar who late a became speaker of India 1957 they were
together Simla were living during the period 1932 onwards.
The rst company Act of 1934 was his draft. He relinquished
ofce in 1955 after Kamarajar became the Chief Minister
of Madras. The was an unprecedent public reception given
to Krishnan ayyar when he laid down his ofce. This was
the only occasion a secretary was given such a reception on
laying down ofce in the whole of India. If Sathyamurthyhad been alive he would not have allowed Krishnan Ayyar
to vacate ofce and would have allowed him to continue in
ofce as long as desired. A person claiming as the deciple of
Sathayamurthy, Kamarajar knows well the relations between
Sathyamurthy and Krishna Ayyar and how Sathyamurthy
respected him. Thus Kamaraja Nadar should have continued
R V Krishna ayyar in ofce so long he was available. It is a
great mistake of on the Kamarajar to have allowed Krishna
ayyar to vacate ofce. It only Krishna ayyar had continued
in ofce he would have given a Parlimentary Practices.
There are no monuments of memorials for Krishna ayyar
but look around the Parlimentary system in his memorial.This legendary personality will be remembers so long as
the Government of the people and for the people by people
survives in humanity.
The well known lm and TV Artist Kavithalaya Krishnan
considered as a ‘Chella Pillai’ as lm Director Balachandar,
and Electrical Engineer graduate Kavithalaya Krishnan is a
grand son of R.V.Krishna Ayyar.
As a Secretary of the Legislature, Krishna Ayyar will not
made any difference between the Ruling Party and Opposi-
tion. He will treat both alike as the production of the opposi-
tion and minority he is fundamental Law of the Parlimentary
Constitution. -DR.R.K.BALASUBRAMANIAN
l
e t t e f o m F o m e S u p e m e C o u t
J u d g e V . r . K i s h n a y y
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 28/36
29 lawyers line - march - 2013 www.l awyersline.net
ÞŠ¹è£˜, «ð£˜«õ£KI™ àœ÷ õì «è£õ£M¡ ñ£õ†ì ¸è˜«õ£˜ ¹è£˜ ¬ñòˆF™, ð¿î£ù 膴ñ£ùˆ¬î‚ °Pˆ¶
ÜO‚èŠð†ì‹. ÜF™, Þ¶ àƒèÀì¡ «ñŸÃøŠ ð†ìÜ´‚°ñ£® i†¬ì ðK«ê£F‚è ï£ƒèœ ªê¡øî¡ ²¼‚èñ£°‹.11/10/2003 Ü¡Á Þ «ñ™ àœ÷ i†®¡ èNõ¬øJ¡
î÷ˆF™ ãŸð†ì ßó„ ²õ´è¬÷ ðK«ê£F‚è ªê¡«ø£‹.«ñ½‹ ܉î èNŠð¬øJ™ î÷ˆF½‹ Þ¡ªù£¼ èNŠð¬øJ¡ ²õŸP½‹ ðô ßó„ ²õ´èœ Þ¼‰îù. ÜõŸP™ðô ÝŒMŸ° º¡«ð ꣌‰¶ Þ¼‰î¶. ñŸø î÷ˆF½‹ c˜ˆ«î‚èˆF¡ è£óíñ£è Ì…¬ê H®ˆ¶ Þ¼‰î¶. Cô ñ£îƒèÀ‚°º¡¹ Þ‹ñ£FK, W›Šð°F èNõ¬øèO™ c˜‚èC¬õ î´ŠðîŸè£è Cªñ‡† Ì„²èœ «ð£ìŠð†´œ÷î£èˆ ªîKMˆî£˜èœ.«ñ½‹ 𴂬èò¬ó ñŸÁ‹ ý£™ ð°FJ™ àœ÷ c˜‚èC¾
è¬÷»‹ èõQˆ«î£‹. Þ¬õ ã.C. è¼MJù£™ à‡ì£ù‹. ÞõŸÁ‚°‹ «ñ™ i†®¡ èNõ¬ø‚°‹ â‰î ê‹ð‰îº‹ Þ™¬ô. Þ¶ °Pˆ¶ 弫õ¬÷ àƒèÀ‚° ꉫîè‹ ãŸð†ì£™,âƒè¬÷ ܵ辋 âù ÜŠ¹è£¼‚° ðF™ ÜO‚èŠð†ì¶.
«îCò ¸è˜«õ£˜ °¬øˆb˜Šð£¬íò‹, ¹¶ªì™L ñÁÝŒ¾ ñ â‡. 2012&¡ 2359.
(«ñŸÃøŠð†ì, ðù£TJ¡, «è£õ£ ñ£Gô ¸è˜«õ£˜°¬øˆb˜Šð£¬íòˆF¡ ݬí¬ò âF˜ˆ¶ õö‚°)
º¡Q¬ô:ñFŠHŸ°Kò cFðF F¼. ªü.â‹.ñ£L‚.ñFŠHŸ°Kò cFðF F¼. MùŒ°ñ£˜ñÂî£ó¼‚è£è : F¼.ªè÷vîŠ C¡ý£
HóFõ£F‚è£è: c«ñ£«îF : 1/11/2012
b˜Š¹ :cFðF : «ü.â‹.ñ£L‚1. ñÁ£Œ¾ ñ I™«ó£‚ ªìõªôŠªñ‡† ꣘ð£è ðF¾
ªêŒòŠð†´œ÷¶. ¹è£óOˆîõó£è F¼ñF Ü¡«ì£Œªù†ì£KªðK«ò£ ®«ê£ê£. «ñŸªê£¡ù Ü´‚°ñ£® °®J¼Š¬ðâF˜ˆîóŠHùKìI¼‰¶ 8.7.1998 Ü¡Á õ£ƒA»œ÷£˜.ÜîŸè£ù åŠð‰îº‹, MŸð¬ù ðˆFóº‹ 29.3.2006 Ü¡Á
Þ¼ˆîóŠHù󣽋 ðF¾ ªêŒòŠð†ì¶.2. ¹è£óOˆîõ˜ îù¶ ¹è£K™, MŸð¬ù M÷‹ðóˆF™
Þ‚°®J¼Š¹èœ ²ñ£˜ 350 i´è¬÷»‹, è¬ìè¬÷»‹ A÷Š¹è¬÷»‹ ªè£‡ì¶ âù‚ ÃøŠð†ì¶. «ñ½‹ ¹øº‹ñF™ ²õ¼ì¡, ªðKò ̧ ¬ö¾ õ£J½‹, ÜF™ ð£¶è£ŠHŸè£è
ð¿î£ù
膴ñ£ù‹?& ê†ìgFò£ù b˜¾ !
²õŸP™ àœ÷ èKò GøªîKM‚A¡øù. Þîù£
è‹HèÀ‹ ÜKˆ¶œ÷ù. «ÃøŠð†ì Ý›¶¬÷ AíÁ
ÝAò¬õ õö
29 lawyers line - march - 2013 www.l awyersline.net
¸ è ˜ «õ£ ˜ ð ‚ è ‹
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 29/36
ww w.l awye rsli ne .ne t 30 lawyers line - march - 2013
è£õô£O»‹ Üñ˜ˆîŠð´õ£˜ âù¾‹ ÃøŠð†ì¶. «ñ½‹ÜF™ ñÁð®»‹ è¬ìèÀì¡, õƒA, ñO¬è‚ è¬ìèœ, Üö°
G¬ôò‹, àíõèƒèÀ‹ Þ¼‚°‹ âù¾‹ ÃøŠð†´ àœ÷¶.âù«õ, ¹è£óOˆîõ˜ Ï.9,47,500/& å«ó îó ðó£ñKŠ¹ ªêô¾‚è£èÏ.39,813/&»‹ è†ìíñ£è„ ªê½ˆF Üši†¬ì ðF¾ªêŒî£˜. âQ‹ MŸð¬ù åŠð‰îˆF™ «ñŸ°PŠHìŠð†ìå¼ õêF»‹ Þ싪ðøM™¬ô. «ñ½‹ 膴ñ£ù‹ I辋«ñ£êñ£ùî£è Þ¼‰î¶ì¡, ²õ˜èO™ ðô ÞìƒèO™ MKê™
ãŸð†ì¶ì¡, c˜‚èCMù£™ ðô ÞìƒèO™ Ì…¬êèœ ãŸð† ,́ Þîù£™, ðô Mî Ì„CèÀ‹ ̧ ‡A¼IèÀ‹ õ‰î, Þ¶ ¹è£˜ÜOˆîõ¬ó»‹, Üõó¶ èíõ¬ó»‹ ðôMî «î£™ ê‹ð‰îñ£ùMò£FèÀ‚° à†ð´ˆF àœ÷ù. ÞîŸè£è Üõ˜èœ ñ¼ˆ¶õCA„¬êè¬÷»‹ «ñŸªè£‡´œ÷ù˜. «ñ½‹ ê¬ñòô¬øJ¡Aó£¬ù† î¬óèœ êKò£è ܬñ‚èŠðìM™¬ô. I辋èõùñ£è ܈î¬óJ™ Þ¼‰î 憬ìèœ Ü«î Gø Cªñ‡†
Ì„Cù£™ ÌêŠð†´œ÷¶. ܶ õ£ƒ°‹ «ð£¶ Üõ¼‚°ªîKòM™¬ô. Ýù£™, CP¶ «ïóˆF™ ÜŠÌ„² HK‰¶ Üî¡ñ†ìñ£ù ñ ªîKò õ‰¶œ÷¶.
3. ªð£Pò£÷˜, F¼.âv.â¡.«ð£«ð Üõ˜è÷¶ Þ™ôˆ¬î3.10.2003 Ü¡Á «ê£î¬ùJ†´, Üõó¶ ÜPM‚¬è¬ò
ÜOˆî£˜. Üõ˜, ²õŸP™ àœ÷ èKò Gø„²õ´èœ ÜFèc˜‚èC¬õ ªîKM‚A¡øù. Þîù£™ àœ«÷ Þ¼‚°‹ v¯™è‹HèÀ‹ ÜKˆ¶œ÷ù. «ñ½‹ MŸð¬ù åŠð‰îˆ¶ì¡ÃøŠð†ì Ý›¶¬÷ ê‹Š, I¡ê£ó ð‹Š ñŸÁ‹ «ðƒ‚ ÝAò¬õõöƒèŠðìM™¬ô. Ýù£™, ôîô£è, î‡a˜ õöƒè ªðKò죃¬è 膮»œ÷ù˜. Ýù£™, Þî¡ î‡a˜ ªð£¶«õ¬ôˆ¶¬øJ¡ î‡a¼ì¡ èô‰îF™, ¹è£˜ ÜOˆîõK¡i´ à†ðì ò£¼‚°«ñ ï™ô î‡a˜ A¬ì‚èM™¬ô. âù«õ,«ñŸÃPò ܬùˆ¶ 膴ñ£ùŠ Hó„C¬ùè¬÷»‹ b˜Šð
¶ì¡, ïwì ßì£è ¹è£˜ ÜOˆîõ¼‚° Ï.1 ô†ê‹ õöƒèŠðì«õ‡´‹ âùˆ b˜ŠðO‚èŠð†ì¶.
4. Þî¬ù âF˜ˆ¶ âF˜ˆîóŠHù˜ õö‚A¬ù ªî£ì˜‰îù˜.⿈F¡ Íô‹ ÜOˆî õ£‚°ÍôˆF™, ¹è£˜ ÜOˆîõ˜èœõ£®‚¬èò£÷˜ Ü™ô âù‚ ÃPù˜. Üõ˜èœ ꣘¹ °ŸøƒèœÃøŠðìM™¬ô. âù«õ, ⶾ‹ ªêŒò Þòô£¶ âù‚ ÃPù˜.
5. ñ£õ†ì ݬíò‹ ÞŠ¹è£¬ó ãŸÁ‚ ªè£‡ì¶. «ñ½‹Ü¶ «ñŸÃPò c˜‚èC¾ ñŸÁ‹ MKê™è¬÷ êK ªêŒõ¶ì¡,Ï.50,000/& ïwì ßì£è õöƒèŠðì «õ‡´‹ âùˆ
b˜ŠðO‚èŠð†ì¶.6. âF˜ˆîóŠHùó£™ ðF¾ ªêŒòŠð†ì ¹è£˜ ñ£Gô
ݬíòˆFù£™ îœÀð® ªêŒòŠð†ì¶.7. Þî¬ù âF˜ˆ¶ ñÁ ÝŒ¾ ñ ðF¾ ªêŒòŠð†ì¶.
âF˜ˆîóŠ¹ õö‚èPëó£™ Þšõö‚° õ£î£ìŠð†ì¶.
8. ÜF™, åŠð‰îˆF™ àœ÷, 7&Ý‹ MFJ¡ è¬ìCŠ ð°F«ñŸ«è£œ 裆ìŠð†ì¶. ÜF™, ÔÔMŸð¬ù‚° Hø°, °®«òPò¾ì¡ â‰î å¼ MKê™ ßó„ ²õ´èœ 膴ñ£ùŠ ð¿î£è‚è¼îŠðìô£è£¶ÕÕ ÜõŸ¬ø «ê£î¬ùJ†´ MŸð¬ùò£÷K¡ªð£Pò£÷˜ ÃPù£™ ñ†´«ñ êK ªêŒòŠð´‹.
9. Þîù£™, F¼.ªüò‰F. M. 𣌠ªõ˜ùè™ â¡Â‹ G¹í ó£™, «ê£î¬ùJìŠð†´, º¡¹ °PŠHìŠð†ì ÜP‚¬èÜO‚èŠð†ì¶.
10. ÞšõP‚¬èJ¡ Íô‹, ã.C. è¼MJù£™ ²õ˜ ð£FŠð¬ìAø¶ â¡ø£™, Üî¡ «ñ£êñ£ù 膴ñ£ùŠ ðE ªîOõ£èˆ ªîKA¡ø¶. âù«õ ¹è£˜ ÜOˆîõK¡ °Ÿø„꣆´
G¼H‚èŠð´A¡ø¶.11. âù«õ ñÁ ÝŒ¾ ñ Gó£èèK‚èŠð†ì¶.
õ´èœ ÜFè c˜‚èC¬õàœ«÷ Þ¼‚°‹ v¯™‹ MŸð¬ù åŠð‰îˆ¶ì¡¡ê£ó ð‹Š ñŸÁ‹ «ðƒ‚
ŠðìM™¬ô.
ww w.l awye rsli ne .ne t 30 lawyers line - march - 2013
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 30/36
31 lawyers line - march - 2013 www.l awyersline.net
üù£FðF, Hóîñ˜ àœO†ìM.M.ä.H‚èœ ðòí‹ ªêŒõîŸè£è
Þˆî£L¬ò„ «ê˜‰î Üèv죪õv†«ô‡† GÁõùˆFì‹ Þ¼‰¶12 ÜFïiù ªýL裊ì˜è¬÷ Ï.3600«è£®J™ õ£ƒè ñˆFò Üó² åŠð‰
î‹ ªêŒî¶. ÞF™ Þ‰Fò£¬õ„ «ê˜‰îõ˜èÀ‚° ¬èΆ´, ªè£´‚èŠð†ì
î£è êeðˆF™ ¹è£˜ ⿉¶œ÷¶.
Þˆî£L¬ò„ «ê˜‰î H¡ªñ‚è£Q‚è£â¡ø GÁõù‹ ó£µõ î÷õ£ìƒèœñŸÁ‹ Mñ£ùƒè¬÷ îò£K‚°‹ I芪ðKò GÁõùñ£°‹. Þî¡ ¶¬í
GÁõùñ£ù Üèvì£ ªõv†«ô‡† GÁõù‹ 2010-™ ñˆFò ÜóCì‹åŠð‰î‹ «ð£†´œ÷¶.
H¡ªñ‚è£Q‚è£ GÁõù‹ Þˆî£L¬ò «ê˜‰îî£è Þ¼‰î£ ½‹, ÞƒAô£‰F™ Þòƒ°‹ ܉î GÁõùˆF¡ ¶¬í GÁõù‹ ªýL裊ì˜è¬÷ ꊬ÷ ªêŒ¶œ
÷¶. ÞƒAô£‰F™î£¡ Ü‰î ªýL裊ì˜èœ îò£K‚èŠð´A¡øù.ªî£N™ ªî£ìƒè¾‹, àŸðˆF ªêŒîªð£¼†è¬÷ MŸè¾‹ àôè Ü÷M™«ð£†®è¬÷ êñ£O‚è, Ý˜ì˜ ªðø,ÜóC¡ ÜÂñF¬òŠ ªðø Þ¬ìˆîóè˜èÀ‚° èIû¡ îóŠð´‹ àˆF¬òCô GÁõùƒèœ è¬ìŠH®‚A¡øùâ¡ð¶ ñÁŠðîŸA™¬ô. Þ¶õ¬ó 3 ªýL裊ì˜èœ 
ꊬ÷ ªêŒ¶œ÷¶. 9 ªýL裊ì˜èœ ޡ‹ ꊬ÷ ªêŒòŠðìM™¬ô. áö™ àÁF ªêŒòŠð†ì£™,åŠð‰î‹ óˆ¶ ªêŒòŠð쾋 õ£ŒŠ
¹œ÷¶. Þ‰Fò Mñ£ùŠð¬ì 18ÝJó‹ Ü® àòóˆF™ ðø‚è‚îò M.ä.H. ªýL裊ì˜è¬÷õ£ƒè ºîL™ F†ìI†®¼‰î¶.Hó£¡v ®¡ Ϋó£è£Šì˜ ñ†´«ñ 18 ÝJó‹ Ü® àòóˆF™ ðø‚è‚îò¬õ. ñŸø GÁõùƒèO¡ªýL裊ì˜èœ 15 ÝJó‹ Ü® àòó‹õ¬ó ñ†´«ñ ðø‚°‹. Þîù£™ Þ‰
Fò ªì‡ìK™ ñŸø GÁõùƒèœ èô‰¶‚ ªè£‡´ ªì‡ì˜ ªðøº®ò£î G¬ô Þ¼‰î¶. Þ‰Fò ݘì¬ó ªðÁõ, Þˆî£L ®¡ Üèvì£ ªõv†«ô‡† GÁõù‹ bMóñ£è ºòŸCˆî¶. Þ‰GÁõù‹ Þ¬ìˆîóè˜è¬÷ ܵA 10 êîiî‹ õ¬ó èIû¡ «ðC, ðí‹ ¬èñ£
Pò¶‹ Mñ£ùŠð¬ìJ™ Gð‰î¬ù î÷˜ˆîŠð†´, Üèvì£ ªõv†«ô‡† GÁõù‹ ݘì¬ó H®ˆ¶œ÷¶ âù °Ÿø‹ ꣆ìŠð†´œ÷¶.
GF ܬñ„êèˆF¡ ݆«êðˆ¬îeP, ð£¶è£Š¹ˆ¶¬ø ܬñ„êó¬õ°¿ Þˆî£L GÁõùˆFŸ° ݘì¬ó ÞÁF ªêŒîî£è‚ ÃøŠð´Aø¶. ê£ñ£¡ò ñ‚èœ i†®™ê¬ñ‚è º®ò£î Å›G¬ôJ™ Þó¾«ïóƒèO™ àíõèƒèO™ ð£˜ê™õ£ƒ°‹ «ð£¶ «èK «ð‚°‚° Ï.2/
îQò£è îó «õ‡ ‹́ âù «ð£˜́ ¬õˆ ¶œ÷£˜èœ. «èK «ð‚¬è Þôõêñ£è î‰î£™ 膴Šð®ò£èM™¬ô â¡Aø£˜èœ. ï¡ø£è C‰F‚è «õ‡´‹.
ËÁ Ï𣌂° ð£˜ê™ õ£ƒ°ðõ˜èÀ‚° æ¼ «èK «ð‚¬è ªè£´‚è îòƒ°Aø£˜èœ ï‹ ï£†®™. ÞŠ
â¡ù õ÷‹ Þ™¬ô
Þ‰î F¼ï£†®™?áö™º¬ø«è†®Ÿ°
º®¾¬ó â¿îŠðì«õ‡´‹.“Ìxò áö™”(Zero Corruption) â¡ø G¬ô¬ò ªè£‡´õ¼õ¬î«ò݆C‚° õ¼ðõ˜èœ
ºî™ êõ£ô£èâ´ˆ¶‚ ªè£œ÷«õ‡´‹.àôA«ô«ò Iè‚è´¬ñò£ù áö™ î´Š¹ ê†ìˆ¬îÜñ™ð´ˆ¶‹ ï£ì£è,Þ‰Fò£ ñ£ø
«õ‡´‹.
T.²õ£Iï£î¡ M.A., B.Ed.,
ï£ñ‚è™
C ‰ î ¬ù
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 31/36
ww w.l awye rsli ne .ne t 32 lawyers line - march - 2013
ð®Šð†ì G¬ôJ™ ªõO ´ GÁõù‹ «è£®‚èí‚A™ èIû¡ î¼Aø£˜èœ â¡ø£™,âšõ÷¾ ô£ð‹ Þ¼‰î£™ ,(膴Šð®ò£ù£™) î¼õ£˜èœ?
 Cóñ‹ 𣘂è£ñ™ i†®«ô«òê¬ñˆî£™, ªêô¾ I„ê‹î£«ù.ܶ «ð£ô  ªê£‰îñ£è ó£µõ
î÷õ£ìƒèœ îò£K‚è ã¡ ºòŸC‚è‚ Ã죶? âšõ÷¾ ªî£¬èI„ê‹? ° «ð˜ ªè£‡ì å¼°´‹ð‹ ܬêõ àí¾ ê£ŠHì«ý£†ì½‚°„ ªê™õî£è¬õˆ¶‚ ªè£œ«õ£‹ . 弫õ¬÷ àí¾‚° ñ†´‹ Ï. 400/&ªêôõ£°‹. ܬî«ò i†®™Ü¬êõ àí¾ ê¬ñ‚èŠð†ì£™,ñFò‹, Þó¾ âù Þ¼ «õ¬ôèÀ‚° «ð£¶ñ£ù àí¾ õ¬èè¬÷ °¬ø‰î ªêôM™, ôîô£è¾‹, î£ó£÷ñ£è¾‹ ê¬ñˆ¶ê£ŠHìô£‹. ªñ£ˆî ªêô«õ£,ð£F‚°‹ °¬øõ£è«õ Þ¼‚°‹.
ï‹Iì‹ ñQî õ÷‹, ÞòŸ¬èõ÷‹ î£ó£÷ñ£è àœ÷¶.  㡲Mì¡, Þˆî£L «ð£¡ø CPò
èOì‹ «ð£Œ GŸè «õ‡´‹?ð®ˆî Fø¬ñ õ£Œ‰î ð†ìî£Kèœ
ï‹ ï£†®™ Þ™¬ôò£? ºîh´èœî£¡ Þ™¬ôò£?  ªê£‰îñ£è îò£Kˆî£™ 1800 «è£®ªêôM«ô«ò 12 ªýL裊ì˜èœ
G„êòñ£è îò£K‚è º®»‹.ªõO èOì‹ Ý˜ì˜ ªðŸÁMŸø£™ ïñ‚° ô£ðº‹ Ü¡Qòªêôõ£Q»‹ A¬ì‚°‹. Þ¡¬ø‚° ÌI‚è®J™ ²óƒ
èƒèO™ «î£‡® â´‚èŠð´‹ Gô‚èK, Aó£¬ù† ºî™ õ£ùˆF™ðø‚A¡ø ªýLè£Šì˜ õ¬óáö™ Mõè£ó‹ «ðêŠð´õ¶
ï‹ ï£†®Ÿ° ªðKò Üõñ£ù‹.ªõ†è‚«èì£ù Mûò‹. ÞîŸè£èõ£ ²î‰Fó‹ ªðŸ«ø£‹? àôA«ô«ò áöôŸø ï£ì£è, ï‹«îꈬê ñ£Ÿø bMó ïìõ®‚¬èâ´‚è «õ‡®ò î¼í‹, è£ô‹èQ‰¶ õ¼Aø¶. ܇¬ñJ™ªê¡¬ù ñ£ïèó£†CJ™ àœ÷辡Cô ˜ è¬÷ ܬö ˆ¶(ªì‡ì˜ àœO†ì Mõè£óƒèO™) «ï˜¬ñ»ì¡ ªêò™ðì«õ‡´‹. âù îIöè Üó² ÜP¾ÁˆFò¶, I辋 ð£ó£†´
°Kò¶. áö™, Mê£ó¬í‚èIû¡, «è£˜†, «èv Þ¬õèÀ‚ªè™ô£‹ ºŸÁŠ¹œO ¬õ‚èŠðì «õ‡´‹.
ºîô£‹ ð£QŠð† «ð£K™
ð£ðK¡ ð¬ì ¶Šð£‚A¬òŠðò¡ð´ˆF»œ÷¶. ªû˜û£è£ôˆF™ dóƒAèœ ðò¡ð´ˆîŠð†´ Þ¼‚A¡øù. FŠ¹ ²™î£¡è£ôˆF™ 󣂪膴è¬÷ ðò¡ð´ˆF ݃A«ôò˜èO¡ Ý»îA샰è¬÷ °PŠð£˜ˆ¶ ÜNˆîió õóô£Á ï‹ õóô£Á. ïiùè£ôˆF™ Þó£µõ î÷õ£ìƒèœñŸÁ‹ ªýL裊ì˜è¬÷ 㡠ªõO®™ Þø‚°ñFªêŒò «õ‡´‹?  ªê£‰îñ£èàŸðˆF ªêŒî£™ ªõOèÀ‚°ãŸÁñF ªêŒò º®»‹ Ü™ôõ£?«ó£¬ñ î¬ôïèó£è‚ ªè£‡ìCPò ï£ì£ù Þˆî£L 1861™ 
îQ ï£ì£Aò¶. 1920™ º«ê£LQJ¡ ê˜õ£Fè£ó ݆CJ™
¶õƒAò¶. 1946 -™ üùï£òèð£¬î‚° F¼‹Hò¶. åJ¡àŸðˆFJ™ º¡ùE õA‚°‹
. ªõÁ‹ 6 «è£®‚°‹ °¬øõ£ù ñ‚èœ ªî£¬è»‹, 3,01,278ê¶ó A«ô£ e†ì˜ ðóŠð÷¾ñ†´«ñ ªè£‡ì CPò .Üõ˜è÷£™ º®‰î¶ ã¡
Þ‰Fò£õ£™ º®òM™¬ô? Fø¬ñ»œ÷ Þ‰Fò˜èœ ,
ܪñK‚è£M¡ ï£ê£ GÁõùˆF™ðE¹KAø£ ˜ èœ . Ü¡Qò
®Ÿ° º¶ªè½‹ð£è Fè›A ø£˜èœ. ï‹ ï£†¬ì ã¡ àò˜ˆî‚Ã죶? ñˆFò ð†ªü† 2012&13&™ñ†´‹ ð£¶è£Š¹ «ê¬õèÀ‚°1,92,407 «è£®‚° GF 嶂èŠð†´œ÷¶. Þ‰Fò Mñ£ùŠð¬ìàôA¡ è£õ¶ IèŠ ªðKòMñ£ùŠð¬ì Ý°‹. ð£¬îò
Þî¡ ðô‹ 1,20,000 «ð˜.“«îüv” â¡ø «ð£˜ Mñ£ù‹
Þ‰Fò£M«ô«ò º¿¬ñò£è îò£K‚èŠð†ì¶. “ˆ¼š” â¡ð¶ Þ‰Fò£ ù ªê£‰îñ£è à¼õ£‚Aò ܆õ£¡v´ ¬ô†ªýLè£Šì˜ Ý°‹. ãŸèù«õ
 «ð£˜ Mñ£ù‹ ñŸÁ‹ ªýLè£Šì˜ îò£K‚°‹ «ð£¶ 㡪õOèO™ õ£ƒè «õ‡´‹?
Þ¼Šð¬î MK¾Šð´ˆFù£«ô«ð£¶ñ£ù¶. Þ¶«ð£ô, ñ îò£Kˆî£™,
àôè èÀ‚° MŸø£™Ü¡Qò ªêôõ£Q»‹, ô£ðº‹A¬ì‚°‹. ªêô¾‹ °¬ø»‹.áö™ - ðôè£ôñ£è ï‹ ï£†®™ðóMJ¼‚°‹ êÍè ¹ŸÁ «ï£Œ.
Þ‰Fò£M™ êeð è£ôƒèO™ÜFèñ£èŠ «ðêŠð´õ¶ áö™.
ªð¼‹ ªî£N™ ÜFð˜èœ ô£ð‹
ܬ컋 Mîñ£è ªè£œ¬èèœñ£ŸP ܬñ‚èŠð´õî£è °Ÿø„꣆´ â¿A¡ø¶. ðöƒè£ôƒèO™áö™ °Ÿø„꣆´èO™ ß´ð†ìõ˜èœ «êó, «ê£ö, 𣇮ò˜è£ôƒèO™ «î˜îL™ «ð£†®J´‹õ£ŒŠ¬ð Þö‰îù˜. ªð¼A õ¼‹áö¬ô °N«î£‡® ¹¬î‚è«õ‡´‹. Þ‰Fò ó£µõˆFŸ°155 mm field hoitze â¡ø õ¬èÝÎîƒè¬÷ îò£KŠðîŸè£ùãôˆ¬îŠ ªðø 1989&-90&-èO™«ð£ð˜v â‹ ²iì¡ GÁõù‹º‚Aò ¹œOèÀ‚° ¬èΆ´ªè£´ˆîî£è ðóðóŠð£è «ðêŠð†ì¶. ܉î õö‚° Þ¡ùº‹º®¾‚° õ‰îî£è ªîKòM™¬ô.
áö™ õö‚° Mê£ó¬íò£÷˜èÀ ‚ ° º¿ „ ² î ‰ F ó ‹ªè£´‚èŠðì «õ‡´‹. ÜŠð®
ïìõ®‚¬è â´‚è ÜóCò™ ꣘H™ô£î ²î‰Fóñ£ù ÜFè£ó‹ ªðŸøáö™ âF˜Š¹ GÁõùƒèœà¼õ£‚èŠð†´ ªêò™ð´ˆîŠðì«õ‡´‹. õÁ¬ñ‚ «è£†´‚°W«ö õ£¿‹ Þ‰Fò˜èO¡õ£›‚¬èˆîó‹ àòó áöôŸø
Þ‰Fò£î£¡ Þ‰Fò˜èO¡ ð£îò «î¬õ.
ñ‚èœ àí˜¾èœ à¬ôJ™ÜKC ªè£FŠð¶ «ð£™ ªè£F‚A¡ø¶. à¬ôŠð£¬ùJ™ ÍìŠð†ì î†ì£ù¶ ÝM Ü¿ˆî‹,
è£ñ™ îœOMìŠð´õ¶«ð£ô, ñ‚èœ ñùF™ ¹¬è‰¶ªè £‡®¼‚°‹ áö½‚°âFó£ù àí˜¾èœ «î˜î™êñòˆF™ ªõ®ˆ¶ CîÁAø¶.
ËÁ, ÝJó‹, ô†ê‹, «è£® â¡ø G¬ô ñ£P Þ¡¬ø‚° áö™ô†ê‹ «è£®èO™ «ðêŠð´õ¶I辋 Üð£òèóñ£ù¶. áö¬ôåNŠð¶ Þòô£î è£Kò‹ â¡ø
G¬ô ñ£ŸøŠðì«õ‡´‹. ܬó ËŸø£‡ì£è ªî£ì¼‹ áö™º¬ø«è†®Ÿ° º®¾¬ó â¿îŠðì«õ‡´‹. “Ìxò áö™” (Zeo Co-
uptio) â¡ø G¬ô¬ò ªè£‡´õ¼õ¬î«ò ݆C‚° õ¼ðõ˜èœºî™ êõ£ô£è â´ˆ¶‚ ªè£œ÷«õ‡´‹. àôA«ô«ò Iè‚ è´¬ñò£ù áö™ î´Š¹ ê†ìˆ¬î Üñ™ð´ˆ¶‹ ï£ì£è, Þ‰Fò£ ñ£ø«õ‡´‹. áö™ ⃰ ⊫ð£¶
ïì‰î£½‹ ܬî Ü®«ò£´åN‚è Þ‰Fò£ ð£´ðì«õ‡´‹.
Þî¬ù G¬ø«õŸø ÜóCò™ î¬ôfìŸø ²î‰Fó ܬñŠ¹èœõ½Šð´ˆîŠðì «õ‡´‹.
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 32/36
33 lawyers line - march - 2013 www.l awyersline.net
å¼õ¬ó ðô õ¼ìƒè÷£èè£õL™ ¬õˆî Hø° É‚AL´õ¶ ñQîˆ î¡¬ñòŸø ªêò™ â¡øà„ê cFñ¡ø‹ ñŸÁ‹ àôªèƒA½‹ àœ÷ cFñ¡øƒèO¡ 𣘬õ¬ò ÜŠê™ °¼M¡ ñóí î‡ì¬ù¬ò G¬ø«õŸPòF™, Üó²«õ‡´ªñ¡«ø Üô†Cò‹ ªêŒ
¶œ÷¶.2013 HŠóõK 9‹  ïì‰î
ÜŠê™ °¼M¡ É‚° î‡ì¬ù G¬ø «õŸø‹ Þ‰Fò ÜóC¡ ñQî
ñòŸø ïìõ®‚¬è. 2005 Ýèv† 4&‹ , à„ê cFñ¡ø‹ÜŠê™ °¼MŸ° ñóí î‡ì¬ù
b˜ŠHìŠð†´ 㿠݇´èœèNˆ¶‹, 2006 ïõ‹ð˜ 8&‹ Üõó¶ 輬í ñ °®òó²
î¬ôõ¼‚° ÜŠðŠð†´ ÝÁ݇´èœ èNˆ¶‹ Üõ˜ É‚ALìŠð†ì£˜. Þ¬ìŠð†ì è£ôˆ
F™ Üõ¼‹ Üõó¶ °´‹ðˆFù¼‹
Üõó¶ MF â¡ùõ£è ܬñ»‹â¡Á â‡E ÜÂFùº‹ I°‰îñù«õî¬ù°œ÷£ù˜. Þ‰î
G¬ôò£ù¶ à„ê cFñ¡øˆî£½‹, ï£ègèñ¬ì‰î è÷£½‹è‡®‚èŠð´Aø¶. è£ôƒè쉶ñóí î‡ì¬ù G¬ø«õŸÁî™°Pˆ¶ cFñ¡øˆF™ Þîóõö‚°èO™ «ï˜‰¶œ÷¶ «ð£™,
Þšõö‚°‹ cFˆ¶¬ø ðKYô¬ù‚° «ð£Œ Mì‚Ã죶 â¡ðîŸè£è, ÝÁ ݇´èœ èNˆ¶ 2013HŠóõK 3‹  ÜŠê™ °¼M¡
輬í ñ °®òó² î¬ôõó£™ Gó£èK‚èŠð†ì¶, «õ‡´ªñ¡«ø Üõó¶ °´‹ðˆFù¼‚°
I辋 ÞNõ£ù«î£˜ñóí î‡ì¬ù ªêòô£‚è‹
®. ݘ. ܉Fò¼Tù£
à„ê cFñ¡ø ͈î õö‚èPë˜ Þ‰Fò£M¡ º¡ù£œ ªê£LC†ì˜ ªüùó™
M ¼ ‰ F ù ˜ ð ‚ è ‹
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 33/36
ww w.l awye rsli ne .ne t 34 lawyers line - march - 2013
ªîKM‚è£ñ™ MìŠð†ì¶. 輬í ñ Gó£èK‚èŠð†ì æK¼ èO™ Üõó¶ °´‹ðˆFù¼‚°‚Ãì ÜPM‚è£ñ™ ÞóèCòñ£è 2013 HŠóõK 9‹
 ñóí î‡ì¬ù G¬ø«õŸøŠð†ì¶ì¡,Ü«î Ü÷¾ ÞóèCòˆ¶ì¡ Üõó¶ àì™ ¹¶
F™L, F裘 C¬øJ™ ¹¬î‚èŠð†ì¶.ÝÁ ݇´èœ îù‚° õöƒèŠð†ì
î‡ì¬ù¬ò ñ¡Q‚è«õ£, îŸè£Lèñ£è
GÁˆF ¬õ‚è«õ£ °®òó² î¬ôõ¼‚°ñ ªêŒõ¶, Þ‰Fò ÜóCòô¬ñŠ¹ê£êùˆF¡ êóˆ¶ 72¡ ð®, å¼ î‡ì¬ù¬èFJ¡ àK¬ñò£°‹. «ñ½‹ ܉î ñÂõ£ù¶ Gó£èK‚èŠðì£î õ¬ó Üõ¼‚°
î‡ì¬ù¬ò G¬ø«õŸø º®ò£¶. Þ‰Fò ÜóCòô¬ñŠ¹ ê£êùˆF¡ êóˆ¶72&¡ Wö£ù ñ¬õ ÜóC¡ àîMÜ™ô¶ ÜP¾¬ó ã¶I¡P °®òó²
î¬ôõ˜ îù¶ ²ò M¼Š¹K¬ñJ¡Ü®Šð¬ìJ™ º®¾‚° ªè£‡´
õó º®ò£¶ â¡Á 1989&‹ ݇®™ªèý˜ Cƒ õö‚A™ à„ê cFñ¡ø‹
b˜ŠH†´œ÷¶. Þƒ° º‚Aòñ£ù«èœM â¡ùªõ¡ø£™ °®òó²
î¬ôõ¼‚° ÜŠê™ °¼ ñ ªêŒ¶ÝÁ ݇´èœ è쉶 «ð£ùÅöL™, è£ôƒè쉶 î£ñîñ£è ñóí
î‡ì¬ù G¬ø«õŸøŠðìô£ñ£â¡ð¶ .
ÜŠê™ °¼MŸ° ñóí î‡ì¬ù G¬ø«õŸø «õ‡´‹ â¡ø «è£K‚
¬è¬ò â¿ŠHò ð£óbò üùî£ è†C,âF˜õ¼‹ «î˜îL¡«ð£¶ ÞŠHó„¬ù¬ò e‡´‹ â¿Š¹‹ â¡ðî£™ÜŠê™ °¼M¡ 輬í ñ ÜóCò™ Hó„ê¬ù Ýù¶. °®òó²
î¬ôõKì‹ àœ÷ ñ¬õ, Ü󲺮¾‚° ªè£‡´õó£î¶ îù¶ªê£‰î ÜóCò™ «ï£‚èˆFŸè£è«õÝ°‹. âˆîˆF™ èì‰î 2006 ºî™ 2008 õ¬óJô£ù è£ôè†ìˆ
F™ ªì™L ÜóꣃèˆFŸ° ÜŠðŠ
ð†ì ÜŠê™ °¼ ªî£ì˜ð£ù «è£Š¹è¬÷ «õ‡´ªñ¡«ø î£ñîŠð´ˆîÜŠ«ð£¬îò àœ¶¬ø ܬñ„ê˜ÜP¾ÁˆFù£˜. 2008&‹ ݇ ,́ ÜŠê™ °¼ Üõó¶ñù õ¼ˆîˆF¡ è£óíñ£è, å¼ «ï˜è£íL¡«ð£¶, “Þ‰Fò£M¡ Ü´ˆî Hóîñó£è â™.«è.܈õ£Q õó «õ‡´‹ â¡Á  ªñŒò£è«õ M¼‹¹A«ø¡ ãªùQ™ Üõ˜ å¼õó£™ ñ†´«ñ ⡬ù
É‚A™ «ð£ì º®ªõ´‚è º®»‹. °¬ø‰îð†ê‹âù¶ õL»‹, ÜÂFù «õî¬ùèÀ‹ ÜŠð®ò£õ¶º®¾‚° õó†´‹” â¡Á ÃPù£˜.
à„ê cFñ¡ø b˜Š¬ðˆ ªî£ì˜‰¶ 2012 ïõ‹ð˜21‹  bMóõ£F Üxñ™ è꣹‚° ñóí î‡ì¬ù
G¬ø«õŸøŠð†ì¾ì«ù, ÜŠê™ °¼¬õ É‚A™
«ð£ì «õ‡´‹ â¡ø îƒè÷¶ «è£K‚¬è¬ò âF˜è†CJù˜ e‡´‹ â¿Šð Ýó‹Hˆî£˜èœ.âF˜‚è†Cèœ Þ„Åö¬ô îƒèœ ïô‚è£èðò¡ð´ˆ¶õ¬î îM˜‚°‹ Mîñ£è Üó²
ïìõ®‚¬èè¬÷ â´‚è Ýó‹Hˆî¶. è꣊ óèCòñ£è É‚ALìŠð†ì¬î º¡ñ£FKò£èªè£‡´ Ü«î «ð£ô óèCòñ£è ÜŠê™ °¼MŸ°‹
É‚° î‡ì¬ù G¬ø«õŸøŠð†ì¶. 2012 ïõ‹ð˜
15 Ü¡Á °®òó² î¬ôõ˜ Hóí£Š ºè˜T,ÜŠê™ °¼M¡ 輬í ñ¬õ e‡´‹ðKYô¬ù ªêŒò Üõó¶ «è£Š¹è¬÷ àœ¶¬øܬñ„êóèˆFŸ° F¼‹ð ÜŠHù£˜.܉î ñ¬õ 2013 üùõK 23 Ü¡Áàœ¶¬ø ܬñ„êè‹ îœÀð® ªêŒòðK‰¶¬óˆî¬î ªî£ì˜‰¶ 2013 HŠóõK
3&‹  Ü¡Á °®òó² î¬ôõ˜ ܉îñ¬õ Gó£èKˆî£˜. ܉î Gó£èKŠH¬ù ªî£ì˜‰¶ àœ¶¬ø ܬñ„ê˜2013 HŠóõK 4&‹  î‡ì¬ù¬ò
Üñ™ð´ˆF, 䉶 èÀ‚° Hø°,2013 HŠóõK 9&‹  ÜF裬ôJ™ÜŠê™ °¼ É‚ALìŠð†ì£˜.
ÜŠê™ °¼M¡ ñóí î‡ì¬ù G¬ø«õŸø‹ è£ôƒè쉶 «ð£ù Üõ¼‹Üõó¶ °´‹ðˆFù¼‹ â¡ù ïì‚°«ñ£ â¡ø Ü„êˆFŸ°‹ ñù «õî¬ù‚°‹ àœ÷£ù£˜èœ. à„ê cFñ¡ø‹ ð™«õÁ õö‚°èO™ àˆîóõ£îŠð´ˆF»œ÷ ê†ìˆ¬î Þî¡ Íô‹ Üó²eP»œ÷¶. 1974&‹ ݇®™ ⮂ñ£
Üùñ£ âF˜ ݉Fó Hó«îê Üó² â‹õö‚A¡ b˜ŠH™, cFòóê˜ A¼wíŒò˜ “C¬øJ½œ÷ î‡ì¬ù ¬èFè¬÷݇´‚èí‚è£è Å›‰¶ ªè£œÀ‹ ðòˆ¬î»‹ dF¬ò»‹” ðŸP °PŠH´Aø£˜.®.M.¬õbvõó¡ âF˜ îI›ï£´ Üó²â‹ õö‚A™ 1983&‹ ݇´ cFòóê˜C¡ùŠð ªó†®, è£ôƒè쉶 ñóí
î‡ì¬ù G¬ø«õŸÁõ¶ ñQîˆî¡¬ñòŸø M¬÷¬õ ªè£‡ì¶ ñŸÁ‹å¼õó¶ àJ¬ó Gò£òñŸø, º¬øòŸø,
ÜGò£òñ£ù º¬øJ™ ðPŠð,ÜóCòô¬ñŠ¹ ê£êù‹, êóˆ¶ 21&¡W› àˆîóõ£îŠð´ˆF»œ÷ Ü®Šð¬ì
àK¬ñ‚° °‰îè‹ M¬÷M‚Aø¶ â¡Á ÃP»œ÷£˜.«ñ½‹ Üõ˜ è£ôƒèì‰î î‡ì¬ù G¬ø«õŸø‹°Pˆ¶ HKM 辡C™ õöƒA»œ÷ b˜ŠH™, “ñ£Pñ£P õ¼‹ ï‹H‚¬è ñŸÁ‹ ãñ£ŸøˆF¡ ¶òó‹,
G¬ôJ¡¬ñJ¡ «õî¬ù ñŸÁ‹ Þ¬õ å¼ ïðK¡àì™, ñù¶ ñŸÁ‹ à혾èO¡ e¶ ªê½ˆ¶‹
î£‚è‹ ÝAòõŸ¬ø èí‚A™ ªè£œ÷ «õ‡´‹”â¡Á ÃÁAø£˜.
°Ÿøõ£OèÀ‚°‹, Üõó¶ °´‹ðˆFù¼‚°‹ ñù«õî¬ù 1983&Ý‹ ݇®™, «û˜ Cƒ âF˜ ð…꣊ñ£Gô Üó² â‹ õö‚A™, cFñ¡ø‹ «ñŸè‡ì
ªð¼‹ð£ô£ù
èO™, î‡ì¬ù¬èF¬ò, É‚°
G¬ø«õŸøˆFŸ°º¡ð£è Üõó¶àøMù˜è¬÷ê‰FŠð
ÜÂñFŠð«î£´,Üõ˜èÀ‚°
É‚° «îF¬òÜPMŠð¶ì¡, î‡ì¬ù
G¬ø«õŸøˆFŸ°ŠHø° Þø‰î
àì¬ô Üõ˜èOì‹åŠð¬ìŠð¶‹ªð£¶õ£ù
õö‚èñ£°‹”
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 34/36
35 lawyers line - march - 2013 www.l awyersline.net
Ü«î «ñŸ«è£œè¬÷ e‡´‹ àÁF ªêŒî¶.«ñ½‹ 1989&‹ ݇®™ FK«õE «ð¡ âF˜°üó£ˆ ñ£Gô Üó² â‹ õö‚A™ à„ê cFñ¡
øˆF¡ ÜóCò™ ê£êù ªð…„, î£ñîñ£è G¬ø«õŸøŠð´‹ ñóí î‡ì¬ùò£ù¶,ÜcFò£ù¶‹, Gò£òñŸø¶‹, º¬øòŸø
¶ñ£°‹ â¡ð¬î e‡´‹ õL»ÁˆFò¶.輬í ñÂ‚èœ îœÀð® ªêŒòŠð´‹
ªð£¿¶ î‡ì¬ùò£O àì™ gFò£ù ð£FŠ¹èÀ‚° àœ÷£‚èŠðì£M†ì£½‹ I°‰îñùgFò£ù CˆFóõ¬îèÀ‚° àœ÷£Aø£˜â¡ð¶ àôè÷£Mò Ü÷M™ ܃WèK‚èŠð†ì å¡ø£°‹. î‡ì¬ù G¬ø«õŸø c‡ìè£ô î£ñîñ£°‹ ÅöL™ î‡ì¬ù ¬èFcFñ¡øˆ¬î ܵA, îù‚° õöƒèŠð†ì
î‡ì¬ùò£ù¶ Gò£òñ£ù¶ î£ù£,êKò£ù¶ î£ù£ â¡ð¬î «è£ó º®»‹ â¡ÁcFñ¡ø‹ b˜ŠH†´œ÷¶. Ýè«õ, 輬íñ îœÀð® ªêŒòŠð†ì¶ °Pˆî Mðóƒèœ
è†ì£òñ£è ªõOŠð´ˆFJ¼‚è«õ‡´‹.2012&‹ ݇®™ ü‚bw âF˜ ñˆFò Hó«îêñ£Gô‹ â¡ø õö‚A™ î‡ì¬ù G¬ø«õŸøÜFè è£ô‹ è숶õ¶ î‡ì¬ùò£O‚°ñ†´ñ¡P Üõó¶ ªï¼ƒAò àøMù˜èÀ‚°‹ñù«õî¬ù¬ò»‹, ¶òóˆ¬î»‹ à‡´ð‡
µ‹ â¡ð¬î à„ê cFñ¡ø‹ ðF¾ ªêŒ ¶œ÷¶.
1994&‹ ݇®™, Þ‰Fò à„ê cFñ¡øˆ F¡ «ñŸ«è£¬÷ ãŸÁ‚ªè£‡ì HKM辡C™, îù¶ b˜ŠH™, “ñóí î‡ì¬ù b˜Š
H†´ ðô õ¼ìƒèÀ‚° Hø°, å¼ ïð¬ó É‚AL´‹ ꣈Fò‚ÃÁ‚° âFó£è Þò™ð£ùªî£¼ ªõÁŠ¹ â¿Aø¶. ã¡ Þ‰î ÞòŸ¬èò£ù ªõÁŠ¹ â¿Aø¶? ‘ïñ¶ ñQî«ïò‹’â¡ð¶ ñ†´«ñ Ü ðFô£è Þ¼‚躮»‹. ñóí î‡ì¬ù G¬ø«õŸøˆ¬î âF˜«ï£‚A c‡ì è£ôñ£è å¼õ¬ó ñù«õî¬ù»ì¡ 裈F¼‚è ¬õŠð¬î ñQîˆî¡¬ñòŸø ªêòô£è  輶A«ø£‹... c‡ìªï´‹ è£ôñ£è è£õL™ ¬õˆ¶, H¡ ñóí
î‡ì¬ù G¬ø«õŸÁõ¶ â¡ð¶ ñQî ñ
òŸø‹” â¡Á °PŠHìŠð†´œ÷¶. 1989&‹Ý‡®™ ñQî àK¬ñèÀ‚è£ù ä«ó£ŠHòcFñ¡øº‹, èùì£ à„ê cFñ¡øº‹ Þ«î輈¬î º¡¬õˆ¶œ÷ù. ÜŠê™ °¼MŸ°ñóí î‡ì¬ù G¬ø«õŸPòF™, ïñ¶ à„êcFñ¡ø‹, ñŸÁ‹ Þîó ÜFè£ó õó‹¹è¬÷‚ªè£‡ì cFñ¡øƒèO¡ 輈¶è¬÷ Üó²«õ‡´ªñ¡«ø Üô†Còð´ˆF»œ÷¶.
ñóí î‡ì¬ù G¬ø«õŸøˆF™ ãŸð´‹ î£ñîñ£ù¶, î‡ì¬ù ¬èF ñ†´ñ™ô£¶ Üõ˜ e¶ Ü¡¹‹, «ï꺋 ªè£‡ìõ˜èÀ‚°‹ ñù«õî¬ù¬ò»‹, ªð¼‰¶òóˆ¬î»‹ ãŸð´ˆ¶‹ â¡ð¶ àôè÷£MòÜ÷M™ ܃WèK‚èŠð†ì 輈¶ .
ñóí î‡ì¬ù °Pˆî Hóðôñ£ù ð£ì¹ˆîè‹å¡P™ , “ î‡ì¬ù G¬ø«õŸøˆFŸè£ù ªï¼ƒ°‹ «ð£¶, °PŠð£è ¬èFJ¡ àøMù˜èœªð¼‰¶ò󈶂° àœ÷£‚èŠð´Aø£˜èœ. Þî¬ù ܃WèK‚°‹ Mîñ£è, ñóí î‡ì¬ù Þ¡ø÷¾‹ õö‚èˆF™àœ÷ ªð¼‹ð£ô£ù èO™, î‡ì¬ù ¬èF¬ò,
É‚° G¬ø«õŸøˆFŸ° º¡ð£è Üõó¶ àøMù˜è¬÷ê‰FŠð ÜÂñFŠð«î£´, Üõ˜èÀ‚° É‚° «îF¬ò
ÜPMŠð¶ì¡, î‡ì¬ù G¬ø«õŸøˆFŸ°Š Hø° Þø‰îàì¬ô Üõ˜èOì‹ åŠð¬ìŠð¶‹ ªð£¶õ£ù õö‚èñ£°‹” â¡Á °PŠHìŠð†´œ÷¶.
ÜŠê™ °¼ õö‚A™ î‡ì¬ù G¬ø«õŸø‹ °Pˆ¶,Üõó¶ °´‹ðˆFù¼‚° ÜPMŠ¹ ªè£´‚èŠðì£î¶ì¡,
î‡ì¬ù G¬ø«õŸøFŸ° º¡ð£è ÜŠê™ °¼¬õÜõ˜è÷£™ ÞÁFò£è 强¬ø ê‰F‚辋 º®òM™¬ô.2013 HŠóõK 8&‹  M¬ó¾ îð£L™ ÜPMŠ¹ ÜŠðŠð†ì¶ âù Üóê£ƒè‹ ÜPMˆF¼Šð¶ ܘˆîñŸø¶.܉î è®îñ£ù¶ è£weK½œ÷ Üõó¶ °´‹ðˆFù¼‚°,
î‡ì¬ù G¬ø«õŸøŠð†´ Þó‡´ ï£œ èNˆ¶î£¡
«ê˜‚èŠð†´œ÷¶!!2012 ñ£˜„ - ãŠóL™ à„ê cFñ¡øñ£ù¶, «î«õ‰î˜
𣙠Cƒ ¹™ô˜ ñŸÁ‹ ï«ó‰î˜  î£v ÝAò Þó‡´ñóí î‡ì¬ù ¬èFèO¡ 輬í ñÂ‚èœ ðKYL‚èŠð† ,́ 8 ºî™ 11 ݇´èœ î£ñî‹ ªêŒî H¡ù˜ î‡ì¬ù
G¬ø«õŸø‹ ªêŒò º¬ù‰î¶ ªî£ì˜ð£ù õö‚°è¬÷ Mê£Kˆî¶. cFñ¡øñ£ù¶, ÞõŸÁì¡, 輬í ñ‚èœ
Gó£èK‚èŠð†´ c‡ì è£ôñ£è î‡ì¬ù G¬ø«õŸø£ñ™¬õ‚èŠð†®¼‚°‹ Þîó î‡ì¬ù ¬èFèO¡õö‚°è¬÷»‹ 輈F™ ªè£‡´, Ü‚¬èFèœ ªî£ì˜ð£ùMðóƒè¬÷»‹ «è£Š¹è¬÷»‹ êñ˜H‚è Þ‰Fò Ü󲂰,
àˆîóM†ì¶. Üî¬ùˆ ªî£ì˜‰¶, Þ‰Fò °®òó²ˆ î¬ôõKì‹ G½¬õJ½œ÷ 輬í ñÂ‚èœ ªî£ì˜ð£ùMðóƒè¬÷ Üóê£ƒè‹ ÜOˆî¶.
c‡ì î£ñîˆF¡ ê†ì î°F G½õJL¼‰î õö‚°O™ å¡Á ÜŠê™ °¼M¡ õö‚°.
Ièc‡ì î£ñîˆFŸ° H¡ î‡ì¬ù ¬èFè¬÷ É‚AL´õ¶ °Pˆ¶ ðKYô¬ù ªêŒò «õ‡® cFñ¡ø‹ ⡬ùcFñ¡ø ï‡ðù£è (ÜIAv °«ó) GòIˆî¶. âù¶ îóŠ¹õ£îˆF™  °PŠð£è ÜŠê™ °¼ õö‚A¡ ªð£¼‡¬ñè¬÷«ñŸ«è£œ 裆®«ù¡. 2012 ãŠó™ 19‹  õö‚° Mê£ó¬íº®‰¶ b˜Š¹‚è£è åˆF¬õ‚èŠð†ì¶. É‚° î‡ì¬ù
¬èFèO¡ î‡ì¬ù G¬ø«õŸøˆF™ ãŸð´‹ c®ˆî î£ñîˆF¡ ê†ìˆî°F ªî£ì˜ð£ù Mê£ó¬í ï쉶ªè£‡®¼Šð¶ °Pˆ¶ ÜóꣃèˆFŸ° º¿¬ñò£ùªîK¾ Þ¼‰î¶. Þ¼‰¶‹, Þ‰î õö‚° ªî£ì˜ð£ù à„êcFñ¡øˆF¡ ÜÁFò£ù b˜Š¹ õ¼‹ õ¬óJ½‹ 裈F¼‚è«õ‡®ò Üóꣃèñ£ù¶, Üšõ£Á ªêŒò£ñ™, 2013HŠóõK 9‹  ÜŠê™ °¼¬õ É‚AL†ì¶.
ªñ£ˆîˆF™, Þ‰Fò Üó꣙ G¬ø«õŸøŠð†ì I辋 Þø‚èñŸø ñóí î‡ì¬ùò£è ÜŠê™ °¼M¡ É‚°êKˆFóˆF™ Þ싪ðÁ‹.
(HŠóõK 19, 2013 Ü¡¬øò F U‰¶ ï£OîN™
ªõOò£ù 膴¬óJ¡ ªñ£Nò£‚è‹) Þ. Þ. Þó£ð˜† ê‰Fó°ñ£˜, ê£. êHî£.
7/28/2019 Lawyers Line March 2013 Edition
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lawyers-line-march-2013-edition 35/36
ww w.l awye rsli ne .ne t 36 lawyers line - march - 2013