1
PROPOSAL AFL AFL PLAYERS UNCHANGED 3/1 – 3 ON BENCH 1 SUB • Trends in first two seasons encouraging • Congestion still an issue • Pressure on doctors when team has two game ending injuries • Interchange rates will continue to increase SUPPORTED • This is the players’ strong preference if the AFL is not prepared to revert to 4 interchange players and 1 substitute. 2/2 – 2 ON BENCH 2 SUB • Rest time decrease of 5mins per players (17.1 to 12.0 mins) • Likely reduction in player speed and intensity • 2012 NAB Cup trial: stoppages down 19%, tackles down 10% and clearance rates up 4% compared with H&A • Game may open up earlier • Reduced adverse impact of 2 game ending injuries • Number of interchanges will still increase over time NOT SUPPORTED • Players strongly oppose this rule change • Any move to limit players’ rest time during a game will increase fatigue, potentially resulting in more injuries rather than less • We understand there is no support for this proposal from the AFL Coaches Association, the AFL Sports Science Group, the AFL Medical Officers Association or AFL Physios 3/1 WITH A CAP OF 80 – 3 ON BENCH 1 SUB • Increased work-rest period from 16.6/2.8 mins to 24.0/4.0 mins (based on current avg of 130 interchanges) • Similar ratio of work-rest as current 3/1 system • Likely reduction in player speed & intensity • Game may open up earlier • Team which loses player to injury not disadvantaged due to limit on interchanges • Refer 2008 NAB Cup trial of 16 interchanges per quarter NOT SUPPORTED • Players strongly oppose this rule change • We understand there is no support for this proposal from the AFL Coaches Association, the AFL Sports Science Group, the AFL Medical Officers Association or AFL Physios DELIBERATE RUSHED BEHINDS Make deliberate rushed behinds interpretation consistent with deliberate OOB (remove benefit of doubt to the defender) NOT SUPPORTED • Would put an unfair amount of pressure on defenders • Current rule strikes the right balance REDUCE TIME ALLOWED FOR KICK-INS Reduce time allowed for kick-ins to 5-6 seconds to be consistent with kicks around the ground NOT SUPPORTED • Could have a negative impact on congestion by putting kick-out players under further pressure, leading to increased amount of long kicks to packs, rather than allowing more time to hit a target, which keeps ball flowing QUARTER START TIMES Heavier sanctions for clubs not complying with quarter start times SUPPORTED • Supported if rule operated in reasonable way TRAINERS Trainers only permitted on ground following goals NOT SUPPORTED • We do not see how this will contribute significantly to reducing congestion • There are ramifications from a health and safety/ performance perspective due to the importance of hydration in our game • Not all players rotate heavily and there are long periods of time between goals in some games FREE KICK ON 50M PENALTY Free kick on 50m penalty for opposition runner interfering with play (if team in possession) SUPPORTED • Supported if rule operated in reasonable way (i.e. penalty only given for blatant breaches or following warning) PROTECTED AREA AROUND PLAYER WITH BALL Stricter enforcement of protected area around the player with the ball a) If in protected area, must remain passive, free kick if involved in play b) Can only enter if accompanying opponent, not if within 5m c) Increasing protected area? NOT SUPPORTED • Players consider the current approach strikes the right balance between fairness to player seeking not to infringe, and protection for player in possession QUICKER THROW INS, BALL UPS & RESTARTS FOLLOWING GOALS Continue with quicker throw ins, ball ups and restarts following goals SUPPORTED PROTECTED AREA AROUND PLAYER WITH BALL Continued strict enforcement of rules designed to allow the team who has earned the ball to move it on quickly (protected area, cribbing, throwing ball back, holding after mark or free) SUPPORTED LAWS OF THE GAME SUBMISSION SUMMARY 2012

Laws of the game

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Laws of the game summary

Citation preview

PROPOSAL AFL AFL PLAYERS

UNCHANGED 3/1 – 3 ON BENCH 1 SUB

• Trendsinfirsttwoseasonsencouraging

• Congestionstillanissue• Pressureondoctors

whenteamhastwogameendinginjuries

• Interchangerateswillcontinuetoincrease

SUPPORTED• Thisistheplayers’strong

preferenceiftheAFLisnotpreparedtorevertto4interchangeplayersand1substitute.

2/2 – 2 ON BENCH 2 SUB

• Resttimedecreaseof5minsperplayers(17.1to12.0mins)

• Likelyreductioninplayerspeedandintensity

• 2012NABCuptrial:stoppagesdown19%,tacklesdown10%andclearanceratesup4%comparedwithH&A

•Gamemayopenupearlier• Reducedadverseimpact

of2gameendinginjuries• Numberofinterchanges

willstillincreaseovertime

NOT SUPPORTED• Playersstronglyoppose

thisrulechange• Anymovetolimitplayers’

resttimeduringagamewillincreasefatigue,potentiallyresultinginmoreinjuriesratherthanless

•WeunderstandthereisnosupportforthisproposalfromtheAFLCoachesAssociation,theAFLSportsScienceGroup,theAFLMedicalOfficersAssociationorAFLPhysios

3/1 WITH A CAP OF 80 – 3 ON BENCH 1 SUB

• Increasedwork-restperiodfrom16.6/2.8minsto24.0/4.0mins(basedoncurrentavgof130interchanges)

• Similarratioofwork-restascurrent3/1system

• Likelyreductioninplayerspeed&intensity

• Gamemayopenupearlier• Teamwhichlosesplayer

toinjurynotdisadvantagedduetolimitoninterchanges

• Refer2008NABCuptrialof16interchangesperquarter

NOT SUPPORTED• Playersstronglyoppose

thisrulechange•Weunderstandthere

isnosupportforthisproposalfromtheAFLCoachesAssociation,theAFLSportsScienceGroup,theAFLMedicalOfficersAssociationorAFLPhysios

DELIBERATE RUSHED BEHINDS

MakedeliberaterushedbehindsinterpretationconsistentwithdeliberateOOB(removebenefitofdoubttothedefender)

NOT SUPPORTED•Wouldputanunfair

amountofpressureondefenders

• Currentrulestrikestherightbalance

REDUCE TIME ALLOWED FOR KICK-INS

Reducetimeallowedforkick-insto5-6secondstobeconsistentwithkicksaroundtheground

NOT SUPPORTED• Couldhaveanegative

impactoncongestionbyputtingkick-outplayersunderfurtherpressure,leadingtoincreasedamountoflongkickstopacks,ratherthanallowingmoretimetohitatarget,whichkeepsballflowing

QUARTER START TIMES

Heaviersanctionsforclubsnotcomplyingwithquarterstarttimes

SUPPORTED• Supportedifruleoperated

inreasonableway

TRAINERS Trainersonlypermittedongroundfollowinggoals

NOT SUPPORTED•Wedonotseehow

thiswillcontributesignificantlytoreducingcongestion

• Thereareramificationsfromahealthandsafety/performanceperspectiveduetotheimportanceofhydrationinourgame

• Notallplayersrotateheavilyandtherearelongperiodsoftimebetweengoalsinsomegames

FREE KICK ON 50M PENALTY

Freekickon50mpenaltyforoppositionrunnerinterferingwithplay(ifteaminpossession)

SUPPORTED• Supportedifrule

operatedinreasonableway(i.e.penaltyonlygivenforblatantbreachesorfollowingwarning)

PROTECTED AREA AROUND PLAYER WITH BALL

Stricterenforcementofprotectedareaaroundtheplayerwiththeballa)Ifinprotectedarea,must

remainpassive,freekickifinvolvedinplay

b)Canonlyenterifaccompanyingopponent,notifwithin5m

c)Increasingprotectedarea?

NOT SUPPORTED• Playersconsiderthe

currentapproachstrikestherightbalancebetweenfairnesstoplayerseekingnottoinfringe,andprotectionforplayerinpossession

QUICKER THROW INS, BALL UPS & RESTARTS FOLLOWING GOALS

Continuewithquickerthrowins,ballupsandrestartsfollowinggoals

SUPPORTED

PROTECTED AREA AROUND PLAYER WITH BALL

Continuedstrictenforcementofrulesdesignedtoallowtheteamwhohasearnedtheballtomoveitonquickly(protectedarea,cribbing,throwingballback,holdingaftermarkorfree)

SUPPORTED

LAWS OF THE GAME SUBMISSION SUMMARY 2012