Language of Ratios, Partch

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/25/2019 Language of Ratios, Partch

    1/10

    CHAPTER FOUR

    The Language

    of Ratios

    Frequenciess Ratios

    Or

    rno unNy characteristics of a

    musical

    tone the most important for

    musical

    science s

    the

    number

    of

    pulsations

    it

    creates, n a

    given length

    of

    time, n the air

    in whi ch it is heard.

    We call these

    ulsations

    ibrations,and

    u'hen we use the

    sixtieth part

    of a

    minute

    as our measureof time, it

    is

    now

    customary to call them cycles.

    The

    number of cycles-per second-de-

    termines he

    pitch

    of the tone.r

    A systemof music

    is

    an organization of relationships

    of

    pitches,

    or

    tones,

    to one another,

    and these relationships are inevitably

    the

    relationship

    of

    numbers. Tone is number, and sincea tone in music is always heard in re-

    lation to one or

    several

    other tones-actually heard

    or

    implied-we have

    at

    least o numbers o deal with: the number

    of the tone under considera-

    tion and the number of the tone heard or implied in relation to the first

    tone. Hence, the rat io.2

    It is

    u'ell

    to

    plunge

    at once nto ratio nomenclature

    nd

    to disregard he

    more familiar "A-B-C

    "

    terminologv by

    which

    the ratios in our con-

    ventional

    scales

    re expressed.

    he

    advantages f doing so, n openingnew

    tonal vistas,

    n getting

    to the analyzable root of music

    and

    the core

    of

    the

    universe of tone, are

    inestimable. If

    time is taken out to translate each ratio

    into what is assumed to be a synonymous word

    value, these

    vistas

    are

    dimmed or

    lost

    altogether, and the

    values, u'hich

    are not synonyms, are

    nevertheless convicted

    of

    fraud

    by alleged

    synonyms. After

    hearing a

    "major

    third"

    on-the organ or

    piano

    or

    some

    other instrument

    with

    tem-

    pered intonation,

    this

    interval

    becomes ixed in the mind as a

    pretty poor

    consonance, t

    leastby some

    comparisons, certain modern composer, ne

    Ifhe

    use ofthe

    word cycles

    prevents

    any

    confusion as between

    vibrations

    in whole and

    halves

    of vibrations, thc latter

    being

    the French manncr of

    indicating frcquencies.

    '1In

    Euclid's words,

    "all

    things which consist of

    parts

    numcrical, whcn compared

    togethr,

    arc subject to the

    ratios

    ofnumber; so that music al sounds or notes

    [tones]

    compared

    together,

    must

    consequently be in some numerical ratio

    to

    each othcr."

    Da\\, L.lk$,2t265.

    76

    of

    numerous

    is, of not be

    just

    interval

    If ratios

    language

    so

    of musical s

    results are m

    um

    surround

    ing and ted

    any case.

    Before pr

    instruments

    tones ested

    this

    precise

    facile

    hinki

    and functio

    The han

    an exact ma

    tave") abov

    This additio

    since

    200 cy

    cycles.

    To g

    the 2/1 belo

    constitutea

    with

    the

    sam

    for

    example

    relationship

    This2tol

    why they

    ca

    result,

    ust

    a

    "octave" at

    and

    its

    doub

    same

    quality

    (200

    to 600

    3Hindemith

    4With

    cents

    which

    represcnt

  • 7/25/2019 Language of Ratios, Partch

    2/10

    for

    of

    vibrations,

    an d

    e, it is now

    or tones,

    relationship

    of

    re-

    r considera-

    the

    our con-

    opening

    new

    of

    the

    tio

    ar e

    hearing a

    with tem-

    pretty poor

    one

    in whole and

    together,

    together,

    THE LANGUAGE

    OF

    RATIOS 77

    of numerous

    possible

    examples, convicts

    his

    "thirds" of

    inexactitude-that

    is, of not being

    exact

    widths-for no real reason

    except

    his confounding of

    just

    intervals and

    tempered intervals3

    (see

    page

    i53).

    If ratios seem a

    new language, let it be said that it is in actual fact a

    Ianguage so

    old

    that

    its

    beginnings as an expressionof

    the essentialnature

    of

    musical sound can only

    be conjectured. In learning any new

    language,

    results are more immediate

    if

    a

    total

    plunge

    is made, so that the

    new

    medi-

    um

    surrounds and

    permeates he thinking; and it is no more time-consum-

    ing and tedious

    than translation, which frequently cannot be exact

    in

    any case.

    Before proceeding

    to a study of the Monophonic intervals, experimental

    instruments

    will

    be

    described on which each ratio can be computed and

    its

    tones

    tested. For the

    present, what is required is a facility in thinking

    with

    this

    precise

    article-this

    sine

    qua

    non of musical

    structure-and for such

    facile

    thinking it is necessary o have a

    thorough

    understanding

    of its nature

    and functions.

    The handling and

    consideration of tones s, by virtue of their

    vibrations,

    an

    exact mathematical

    process. f

    a

    tone

    makes

    200 cycles, he 2/l

    ("oc-

    tave")

    above

    t makes

    400

    cycles,a

    doubling of 200, or 200 more cycles.

    This additional

    200 cycles s not, however, constant for the

    2/1

    measurer

    since 200 cycles added to 400 do not give the 2/1 ("octave") above 400

    cycles. To get the 2/l above

    400 we multiply

    by

    2 and,,conversely, to

    get

    the 2/1 below

    400 we

    divide by

    2. The cycles, or frequencies,of two tones

    constitute

    a ratio, and

    it has long been established hat two

    pairs

    of tones

    with the same

    ratio-200

    cycles

    o 400 cycles and 400 cycles o 800 cycles,

    for example, both

    2/1's-are accepted by the ear as identical musical

    relationships.

    This 2

    to

    1 relationship is a constant one. Musicians

    frequently wonder

    rvhy

    they cannot

    add the ratio of one interval to another to

    get

    the correct

    result,

    just

    as they add a

    "perfect

    fifth" and a

    "perfect

    fourth" to

    get

    an

    "octave"

    at the

    piano. But the fact is that Nature does not offer one tone

    and

    its

    doubling

    (200

    to 400) as a

    given quality

    of relationship, and

    the

    same quality of relationship in two tones which are not a ratio of doubling

    (200

    to 600, for example ).4

    sHindemith,

    CtuJt

    oJ Mudeal

    Conposition,

    1t78,

    rwith

    cents,etplained

    at

    thc

    end ofthis chap ter, t is possible

    o

    add and subtract

    quantities

    which

    represcnt atios.

  • 7/25/2019 Language of Ratios, Partch

    3/10

    GENESIS

    OF

    A

    MUSIC

    The2tolrelat ionship,basedonthefactorof2'appl iesonlytopro-

    gr*ri""

    L'pi,.tt

    by

    2/1's.^ihere

    is

    of

    course

    much

    more

    to

    the

    calculation

    of

    musical

    intervals

    than

    successive

    /1's'

    But

    if

    the

    factor

    of

    2 applies

    to

    the

    2/1.

    then

    certain

    decrements

    of

    the

    factor

    of

    2 must

    apply

    to

    intervals

    ;;.;;;;;;";u.J

    fro*

    u 2/1,

    or-increments

    of

    the

    factor

    of

    2

    starting

    ;;i.

    i; a;ust Intonation the comPutations are v^ery imple' sinceeach

    ,*ff-nrr-U.i

    ratio

    is itself

    a

    patticular

    measure

    of

    the

    factor

    of

    2'

    The

    i"[*"i]oolzoo,

    or 312

    fit'si

    "perfect

    fifth")'

    for

    examPle'

    an

    interval

    ,ru..o*e.

    than

    a

    2/1,

    represents

    a certain

    measure

    of

    the

    factor

    of

    2'

    and

    the

    ,"i

    ZSo

    zOo,

    or

    5/4-(just

    "major

    third'')'

    an

    even

    smaller

    measure'

    Ob.riorrrly,

    then,

    if

    it

    is

    impossible

    to add

    fre

    quencies

    by

    some

    constant-

    ZOO

    "u.t..,

    fo,

    .*ample'

    which

    was

    suggested

    bove-to

    get a

    series

    of

    2/1's'

    t;;ilil;..tbi.

    to

    ^aa

    f'equencies

    by

    constants

    ogtt

    any

    series

    of

    in-

    i.*Jt

    .t

    ri-

    than

    2/1.

    Positively,

    if a

    sequence

    of

    2/1's

    is

    de

    ermined

    by

    ii.

    i"",-

    .f

    2, by

    multiplication,

    then

    any

    sequence

    of

    intervals

    narrower

    ir,""i/r

    i.

    a.t".-ined

    by

    their

    respective

    proPortions

    of

    the

    factor

    of

    2-by

    -,-ri,lii"u,io.t.

    Therefore,

    when

    any

    two

    ratios-two

    intervals-are

    to

    be

    addei,

    muttiPlY

    heir

    ratios'

    --

    frc

    ttt"afi"g

    of

    small-number

    ratios,

    representing

    the

    intervals

    to

    *frl.tr

    it.

    ea,

    i, irost

    responsive,

    nvolves

    nothing

    more

    than

    simple

    multi-

    ol icationanddivis ionofimProPerfractions.onlywhentheexpedientof

    H;ia.'i;

    ;i.,trod.,..d

    ao

    tt't

    computations

    hcome

    at all

    complicated'

    *i.'"

    i.g"ti,ttt".

    are

    employed

    to

    produce.

    deliberately

    chosen

    irrational

    oercentJees

    of

    the

    factor

    of

    2

    (seepage 101)'

    *^;;;:i;.

    ;i;

    ,.1*r,..

    of

    d"e

    intJrvals,

    somewhat

    at

    random

    in

    pitch'

    rr".,ine

    a

    lo*et

    consiant

    of

    1200

    cycles,

    the

    five

    ratios

    being:

    2400/1200'

    iaoiiii

    zoo,

    ooo/1200,

    500/1200

    2000

    1200'

    n their

    owest

    erms

    hese

    ;:;;:;:;.:;i-,

    ili,

    +it, stq,

    s/:'

    tris

    same

    eries.or

    erationships

    ourd

    i".il *.rr b.'.o.t.id"..d *ith u" ttpptt

    t9"t 1nt

    9l'^YI'^2400

    vcles;

    he

    i.",i*

    *."rt

    th.r'

    u.

    24oo

    rzoo,

    i+oo

    1tooo,

    2400/1800'240011920'

    i-+oO7f

    oO,

    -rti"h,

    reduced

    o the

    owest

    ossible

    erms

    re'.again:

    /1'3/2'

    +tii'it+,

    i/1.

    rtt,r.

    a

    musical

    atio

    rePresents

    he

    relationship

    etween

    ..r.i.r,

    ,id,r..d

    to

    its

    owest

    errns

    t

    is n

    abstract

    uantity

    applicable

    o

    ^ir,,l*..ioi,.h

    in

    the

    otal

    musical

    cale,

    nd

    n

    this

    orm

    ts

    primacy-

    il i;.ii;frJ;;nk

    in

    the

    significant

    esources

    f

    music-is

    he

    more

    mani-

    fest,

    as

    will

    be

    shown

    in

    the

    next

    chapter'

    i i ,s in . . , in theconceptof theinterva l2/ | (the. .octave ', ) , the lower

    number

    is

    e

    numbcr

    is

    e

    than

    a

    2/1;

    such

    as

    3/2,

    sequentlY,

    w

    halved or th

    16/5

    is brou

    nithin

    a

    21

    expressed

    n

    A

    syste

    cated

    n ev

    s,vmbols-r

    211,

    and

    th

    Nlusicians

    given

    "A"

    i

    any

    given

    9

    cians

    will

    fi

    should be e

    But

    such

    a

    seven

    2/1's

    its

    own,

    an

    the

    numbe

    two

    or

    mo

    up

    and

    do

    2,i

    1,"

    "Hig

    It

    is co

    built

    up*'a

    and

    this

    P

    is

    specifica

    ities,and i

    cation

    is

    s

    reverse

    wi

    Itonocho

    SupPo

    a

    mark

    on

    rhat

    ndic

  • 7/25/2019 Language of Ratios, Partch

    4/10

    only to pro-

    calculation

    to the

    to intervals

    of 2 starting

    since

    each

    of 2. The

    an

    interval

    of 2,

    and the

    measure.

    constant-

    series

    f 2/1's,

    of in-

    determined

    by

    narrower

    of

    2-by

    to be

    to

    multi-

    of

    complicated,

    in pitch,

    2400 1200,

    terms

    these

    could

    cycles; the

    2400

    1920,

    2/1,3/2,

    between

    to

    its primacy-

    more mani-

    the lower

    THE

    LANGUAGE

    OF RATIOS

    ; )

    number

    is exactly half the upper

    number,

    any ratio in

    which the lower

    number s ess han

    half the

    upper,

    such

    as 5/2, represents

    n

    interval

    wider

    than a 217; and

    one

    in which

    the

    lou,er

    number

    exceedshalf the

    upper,

    such

    as

    3/2,

    represents n interval smaller,

    or

    narrower,

    han

    a 2/1. Con-

    sequently, when an

    interval is wider than

    a

    2f 1,

    the upper

    number may

    be

    halved or the

    lower number doubled to bring i t within

    a

    2/7.

    The ratio

    16/5 is brought

    within a 2/1by

    rvriting

    t

    8.,/5, nd the ratio

    5,/2

    s

    brought

    lithin a 2/1 by

    rvriting it 514. Nearly

    all

    ratios

    in this

    exposition

    ar e

    cxpressedn the less han 2/l form.

    A s)stemof music

    s determined or

    one

    2/1;

    the system s

    then dupli-

    cated n everyother

    2/1, aboveor below, hat is

    cmploycd.

    Consequently,

    svmbols-ratios in this exposition-are

    used o denote the

    degrees

    f

    one

    2 1,

    and

    the

    symbols

    are

    repeated in

    every 2/1

    of

    the

    musical gamut.

    \lusicians are accustomed

    o this

    idea;

    the

    "octave"

    above

    or below

    a

    given

    "A"

    is sti l l

    "A."

    The situationhere

    s dentical;

    a

    2/1

    above

    or below

    any

    given 9/8 is still 9/8. Onl y the

    physicists

    who

    are not pract ising

    musi-

    cians will find

    this

    objectionable,

    since,acoustically,

    a 2/1

    below a given

    9

    8

    should be expressed9/16, and,a

    2fl

    above 9/8 should

    be expressed

    9/4.

    But such a

    procedure would mean

    that every one

    of the approximately

    seven

    2/1's of the

    common musical gamut would

    have

    a

    set

    of symbols

    of

    its own, and when forty-three degrees-ratios-in a single 2/1 are involved

    the number of total

    symbols would

    be unwieldy. The

    relative positions

    of

    tuo or more 2/1's,

    when tables

    or diagrams or examples nvolve

    ratios

    both

    up and down from

    a given 1/1,

    are

    indicated

    n this

    exposition

    by

    "Lower

    2,'1,"

    "Higher

    2/1,"

    "Third

    2/1," and.

    Fourth

    2/1,"

    etc.

    It is

    common

    practice

    musically to

    consider ratios

    (intervals)

    as being

    built upwards

    (with

    the larger

    numbers above)

    from a lower

    constant,

    and this

    practice is followed

    throughout this

    book except when

    the reverse

    is specifically ndicated.

    Such ratio symbolism sjust

    one

    of

    several possibil-

    ities,

    and

    is a matter of arbitrary choice;

    the

    reverse

    orm in practical

    appli-

    cation is synonymous, and in

    order

    that

    this fact may not

    be obscured

    the

    reversewill

    be

    indicated rom

    time to time.

    Monochord rocedures

    Suppose

    we have

    a metal

    string

    stretched

    across wo

    bridges, and make

    a mark

    on

    the wood beneath

    that divides the string in

    half, then

    a mark

    rhat

    indicates

    a third ofthe string, and finally

    a mark that

    divides the

    third

  • 7/25/2019 Language of Ratios, Partch

    5/10

    80 GENESISOF A

    MUSIC

    in half, or

    into sixths of the whole string, as shown

    in

    Diagram

    1. Suppose

    the whole

    string makes 100 cycles when in vibration;

    if

    a

    third

    bridge

    is

    placed at the halfway mark, either half of the

    string would then give tones

    of200 cycles,and

    ifthe bridge is

    placed

    at the one-third mark and only one-

    third of

    the string

    set n

    vibration the

    resulting

    tone

    would make 300 cycles.

    Thus the relationship of the half to the whole is 200 to 100,or 2/1 ; and the

    Drlcnlu

    1.-Trre RuauoNsmp or Cvcr-rs o Pasrs or StnNc

    relationship

    of the third

    part to

    the

    half is

    300

    to 200,

    or

    3/2. Each of these

    ratios representsboth

    a given tone and an interval between two tones.

    The

    rario 3f2, via

    the

    agent

    3, represents the higher tone of that

    relation-

    ship; at

    the same ime

    it represerits he interval from 3 to 2, or 3

    2.

    For lack

    ofa

    better

    term this concept

    might

    be called

    "upward

    ratio thinking" from

    a

    lower cotslant,

    the number 2,

    it

    3/2

    (200

    cycles),

    representing the

    con-

    stant.

    Now,

    without

    regard to

    cycles,

    et us think in terms of

    parts

    of a

    string

    length,

    the ancient monochord

    proceduie.

    If one-half the string represents

    three equal parts (each a sixth of the whole string) one-third of the string

    represents

    wo equal

    parts.

    When

    sounded, one-third represents

    2 parts

    and

    one-half

    represents3

    parts,

    or

    the ratio 2/3. The ratio 2/3, via the agent 3,

    represents

    he

    lower tone, while at the same time

    it

    represents

    he interval

    from

    2 to 3, or 2/1, exactly

    the same nterval as 3

    2-

    lr{e

    thus

    see

    hat the

    numbers

    of vibration are

    inversely proportional to the string

    lengths

    (see

    page 99 for

    reservations regarding this

    generalization). And the mental

    processof considering

    ratios as

    parts

    of a

    sounding

    body,

    rather

    than as

    vi-

    brations, or

    cycles, as

    here presented, s essentially

    "

    downuard atio think-

    inq" lrom

    rrnc of

    thc

    These

    s

    ncl ing

    o

    i.

    arb i t rar

    : r r rar s thc

    r

    -1.

    2. 8

    .r ci 5

    -l

    rc

    r , ,

    11).4

    rn l ( Ival

    to

    i r l icc l

    ntcr

    rnr l

    an

    im

    Exprcs

    l -nqths,

    th

    : i r lc the o

    r :Lro-rvou

    icnc. but

    rr 1 1. Be

    The sc

    rhe upper

    asccnds n

    rhe

    same

    r

    aiucs, h

    "Tttinkin

    Upon

    rts

    comPr

    numbers

    In the

    ar rhc

    up

    l:cnce

    he

    :ntcrval

    f

    * i th in

    th

    51

    44

    54

  • 7/25/2019 Language of Ratios, Partch

    6/10

    L Suppose

    bridge is

    then give

    tones

    and only

    one-

    300

    cycles.

    or 2/1

    ;

    and

    the

    of

    these

    two tones.The

    relation-

    3

    2.

    For lack

    thinking"

    from

    the

    con-

    of a string

    represents

    of

    the string

    2 parts

    and

    via

    the agent

    3,

    he interval

    see hat

    the

    lengths

    (see

    the

    mental

    than

    as vi-

    ratio

    think-

    TIl

    E LANGUAGE OF RAT]OS

    BI

    ing"

    from an upperconstant, the number ? in

    2 3-representing

    the upper

    tone

    of the

    re ationship-being

    the constant.

    These

    very elementary examples

    are essential to

    a thorough under-

    standing

    of the

    Monophonic

    procedure,

    where he

    under number

    of a

    ratio

    is arbitrarily

    chosen o represent1/1, unity,

    or the Prime

    Unity, and

    is

    aluar

    s

    the ower of thc t\,\ 'o atio

    tones,heard

    or impli cd. In the ratios

    5/4,

    1.

    3, 3

    2,

    8/5 the under numbers4,

    3, 2, and

    5

    represent

    he constant1

    1,

    and

    5/4

    rcpresents single one

    upuard from 1/1

    (and,

    n

    implied

    interval

    ro lil),4/3 represents single tone uprvard from 1/1 (and an implied

    inlcrval

    to 1/1),3/2 represents single

    one upward

    from 1/1

    (and

    an im-

    plicd interval

    to 1/1), and 8/5 rcpresents

    single one

    upward from 1/l

    tand

    an implied nterval o 1/ l) .

    Expressed n the

    "dounuard thinking" manner,

    as

    parts

    of

    string

    lcngths,

    hesc atios .r 'ould e 4/5,3/4,2i3,

    5 i8t and 4,3,2,

    and 5-this

    time the

    over numbers and the higJher ones,

    heard

    or

    implicd,

    of each

    ratio-would

    again reprcsent1

    11

    And

    each ratio rvould represcnt

    a single

    tone,

    but dou nuard nstead

    of upward from 111,

    and an implied interval

    to 1/1. Below s

    a

    schema

    of theseexamples:

    ]

    8

    (higher

    ones

    f

    intervals

    pward rom 1/l)

    ? 2: t

    t t '

    the Prirne

    UnitY

    3 8 (lower ones f intervals ownward rom 1/1)

    The scale

    of four

    tones s

    designed

    o be identical in the two

    processes;

    rhe

    upper

    scale

    ascends rom 5 to

    8

    (from

    left

    to right); the lower scale

    ascends

    nly

    ifread in reverse,

    rom 8 to

    5

    (right

    to left). To

    achieve exactly

    the same

    pilches

    n

    both

    scales,

    without regard

    to synonymous

    interval

    values,

    he lower

    scale

    u'ould be written:

    5/8,

    2/3,3/4, 4/5.

    "Thinking" in Ratios

    Upon

    further investigation

    of the nature

    of ratios we find that each has

    its

    complement within

    the

    2/1,

    and if

    the ratio is composed

    of

    small

    numbers its

    complementary ratio is

    also composed

    of

    small numbers.

    In

    the

    ratio

    3/2, 2 represents /1,

    the lower limit

    of the

    2/1. The

    tone

    at tlre

    upper

    limit

    of the 2/1 may

    be

    represented

    y

    4

    (a

    doubling of

    2) ;

    hcnce

    he

    interval

    from the

    3 of 3/2 to this

    upper

    limit

    of the 2/1

    is

    th e

    interval

    from

    3 to

    4,

    or

    4/3,

    which is

    therefore he

    complement of 3/2

    *itlrin

    the 2/1i the two intervals

    might

    be expressedhus: 2:3:4. In the

    54

    43

    54

  • 7/25/2019 Language of Ratios, Partch

    7/10

    GENESIS OF A MUSIC

    ratio

    5/4,4

    represents 1/l; the 2/1 above

    4

    is 8; the complement of 5/4,

    therefore,

    s the

    interval

    from 5 to 8, or 8/5, and the two

    intervals might be

    expressed,

    :5:8. In

    the

    ratio

    6/5, 5

    represents /1; the 2/l above

    5

    is 10,

    and the complement of 6/5

    is

    therefore the

    interval

    from

    6 to 10,

    or

    70/6,

    or, in

    its lowest

    terms, 5/3; the two

    intervals might

    be

    shown in this form,

    5:6:10.

    To find the sum of two

    intervals

    multiply the two

    ratios. The sum

    of

    5/4

    and 6/5, f or example, 5/4x6/5:30/20 ,

    which, reduced o its lowest

    terms, is 3/2

    (a

    "major

    third" and a

    "minor

    third" make a

    "perfect

    fifth").

    To

    find

    the interval

    between

    t\ /o tones invert the smaller or narrower

    ratio and

    multiply. For example, to find

    the

    interval

    between

    3/2 and

    4/3

    invert

    the

    smaller,4/3,

    and use

    t

    as a

    multiplier:

    3/2X3/4:9/8,which

    is therefore the

    interval representing

    he tonal distance between

    the 4 of

    4

    3

    and the of 3

    2.

    (The

    difference between a

    "perfect

    fourth" and a

    "perfect

    .fifth"

    is a

    "major

    second.")

    To find a

    given interval

    above a

    given

    tone is of course

    simply

    a matter

    of

    multiplying the two ratios involved; to frnd the same

    interval

    distance

    downward from the same tone, the procedure is inversion and multiplica-

    tion. Forexample,a6f5 above3/2

    is

    arrived at r}Lvs3/2X6

    /5:9/5;

    and

    a

    6/5 below 3/2 t hrs: 3/2X5/6:5/4.

    Were

    Do RatiosFall

    on

    hePiano?

    It is inadvisable to think

    of

    these ratios in terms

    of

    piano

    keys except

    with the most

    precise eservations.To

    do so without reservations

    s

    a triple

    abuse-of

    the ratios, of the

    piano,

    and

    of oneself.One

    can

    go

    crazy trying

    to

    reconcile

    irreconcilables,

    but

    given

    an appreciation of the essentiality of

    ratios in understanding musical resourcessome knowledge of the

    piano's

    discrepancies

    may

    prove

    enlightening.

    If in the teaching of simple arithme tic the number 1 was called Sun, 2

    called Moon, 3

    called

    Jupiter,

    and

    4

    called Venus, and

    if this procedure

    were carried to the

    point where

    the teachers hemselves o

    longer knew that

    Sun:1, Moon:2,

    Jupiter:3,

    and Venus:4, and

    forced upon students

    the euphemistic

    proposition

    that Moon*Moon: Venus, because hey

    had

    learned

    it

    that

    way, we would

    have in simple

    arithmetic

    a

    fairly

    exact

    parallel to the

    "Tonic-Supertonic-Mediant"

    or the

    "C-D-E"

    nomencla-

    ture

    in the teaching

    of

    the science

    of musical vibrations.

    And the idea that

    Moon*Moon

    :

    Venus could accurately represent2*2:4

    \s

    no more awk-

    ward,

    to

    p

    vals

    "C-F*

    In

    res

    adopt

    the

    would

    say

    tone flat i

    think

    of th

    and

    the m

    tion

    and

    i

    rtould

    sa

    equal

    sem

    the pursu

    recommc

    crepanci

    Ellis'

    Me

    One

    m

    presente

    principle

    ander

    J.

    E

    tions J

    T

    scmitone

    ables

    he

    magnitud

    sches.

    Th

    lish his

    n

    number

    1

    subscque

    l-'oundar

    If

    "G"

    cents

    as

    s

    rains

    400

    ccnts.

    Th

    Thcrefor

    irc cxpre

    lonc.

    sPage

  • 7/25/2019 Language of Ratios, Partch

    8/10

    of 5/4,

    might

    be

    above

    5

    is 10,

    or 70/6,

    in

    this form,

    The

    sum

    of

    to its

    lowest

    "perfect

    fifth").

    or narrower

    3f 2

    and 4f 3

    /4:9

    /8,

    which

    he 4

    of 4/3

    a

    "perfect

    a matte

    distance

    and multiplica-

    /5

    :9

    /5;

    and

    keys

    except

    s

    a triple

    crazy

    trying

    to

    essentiality

    of

    of the piano's

    called

    Sun, 2

    knew

    that

    had

    a fairly

    exact

    the idea

    that

    no

    more

    awk-

    THE

    LANGUAGE OF RATIOS

    *'ard, to

    put

    it charitably,

    than the idea that the ascending

    musical inter-

    vals

    "C-F *F-C

    :

    C-C" can accurately epresent 3

    X3

    /

    Z 2 1,

    In resorting to the

    piano two

    procedures

    are

    possible. First, one can

    adopt the negative

    procedure

    of regarding

    ratios as altered

    piano tones.

    One

    would say that 16

    9,

    for example, is

    "F"

    one tu'enty-fifth

    of an equal

    semi-

    tone flat

    in

    the

    "key

    of G." On the

    other hand, it

    is quite

    as

    possible

    o

    think of the

    piano tonesas altered

    atios.This is the constructive pproach,

    and the more fruitful

    one,

    since t predicatesan understanding of the

    func-

    tion and indispensability f ratios. In accordance 'ith this procedureone

    rlould say

    that "F"

    in the

    "key

    of

    G" is 1679

    plus

    one t$'enty-fift h

    of an

    equal semitone. f translation

    nto conventional

    valuesseems esirable n

    the pursuit

    of

    the Monophonic theory,

    the second

    s

    certainly

    the

    procedure

    recommended.

    Follorting

    the explanation

    of cents a

    table

    of

    piano

    dis-

    crepancieswith the

    nearest

    mall-number ati os will be

    given.

    Ellis' Measure

    f

    Cents

    One mori

    step n the simple

    mechanics f dealing

    with ratios must be

    prcsented

    n preparation or the exposition f

    the Monophonic

    concepts

    nd

    principles, namely,

    the measure of

    musical intervals established

    by Alex-

    anderJ. Ellis

    n an appendix

    o hi s translationof Helmholtz's

    On theSensa-

    tians J Tone.6 his measure s the cent, the hundredth part of an equal

    semitone-1200 to rhe

    2/1. Cents

    provide a logarith mic device

    which en-

    ables he theorist

    o add and

    subtract numbers epresenting

    he respective

    magnitudes f the

    various atios,

    which he

    cannot

    do

    with

    the

    ratios hem-

    selves. he y give the adventurerhis

    longitudeand

    latitude and thus estab-

    lish

    his

    u'hereaboutsn that

    vast.

    barely

    explored

    sea which

    lies

    from the

    number 1 to the araway

    shores f the

    number 2. The

    ratios

    on

    previous

    nd

    subscquent

    ages,

    hen, are

    the familiar or exotic

    slands hat

    lie within the

    boundariesof this

    little-knoransea.

    If

    "G"

    is the starting

    point,

    the

    intcrvalsof the

    piano keyboardcontain

    centsas

    shown n Diagram 2.

    The tempered

    major

    third,"

    "G

    to

    B,"

    con-

    rains400 cents.

    The true

    "major

    third," 57'4, ontains

    only a

    tr iflc

    over 386

    cents.The diference, nearly 14 cents, sapproximatelyone-seventh f 100.

    Thcrefore

    B"

    in the

    "key

    of G,"

    which is 14 cents

    harPer han

    5/4.

    may

    be cxpressed s 5/4

    plus 14 cents,or approximately

    one-seventh

    f a semi-

    tone.

    sPaces

    446-451.

  • 7/25/2019 Language of Ratios, Partch

    9/10

    B4

    GENESIS

    OF

    A MUSIC

    The tempered

    minor

    third,"

    "G

    to

    Bl,"

    contains300 cents,whereas

    the true

    "minor

    third," 6/5, has nearly

    316.

    The

    difference, a trifle

    less

    than 16 cents, s approximately

    one-sixth

    f 100.Therefore

    Bb"

    in the

    "key

    of G," which is 16 cents latter than 6/5, may be stated as 6/5 minus 16

    cents, or approximately

    one-sixth of a

    semitone.

    Below are translations

    of all so-called diatonic intervals to the nearest

    small-number

    ratios,

    the discrepanciesbeing expressedn approximate

    plus

    or minus number of cents:

    scale

    and

    placcs.

    or

    suflicient.

    lrc-.ides,r

    rable of

    A

    ( nlv to tha

    r oncl he

    r

    pl:rce

    oga

    r

    i Llclrnh

    l l l is cxpla

    .nrPlc.

    an

    r ' i rh thc

    t

    '

    rnrrncnts

    r : rusical

    c

    For

    pu

    i , ,nat ion

    th

    :1. i .

    r rork

    :( lP{ ramc

    (

    : l . l l ) l ish in

    INTERVAL

    RATIO

    "G"

    1/1

    (the

    unison)

    "G

    to Ab" 16/15 minus 12

    cents

    9/8 minus 4

    cents,ot

    10/9

    plus

    18

    cents

    , ,G

    to

    Bb',

    6/5 minus 16 cents,or

    7 6 plus 33 cents

    5/4

    plus

    14

    cents

    4/3

    plus

    2 cents

    RATIO

    7/5

    plus

    17.5 cents,or

    10/7 minus 17.5

    cents

    3/2

    minus

    2 cents

    8/5 minus 14 cents

    5/3

    plus

    16 cents,or

    12/7 minus 33 cents

    16/9

    plus 4

    cents,

    or

    9/5 minus 18 cents

    15/8 plus 12 cents

    INTERVAL

    "G

    to C*"

    "G

    to Eb"

    "G

    to

    F* "

    This

    table represents,

    of course, the falsities

    that are

    found not

    only

    in

    the

    "key

    of G" but in any

    "key"

    of Equal Temperament. If the

    "key

    of

    C"

    is

    chosen,

    C

    to Dt"-the

    smallest nterval-is

    16/15 minus 12 cents,etc.

    For finding

    the number of cents n

    a

    given

    ratio Ellis

    provides

    a simple

    arithmetical

    method-not

    adequate for investigation

    of a

    many-toned

    Drncnalr

    2.-Celrrs oN THE PreNo KeysoaRD

  • 7/25/2019 Language of Ratios, Partch

    10/10

    cents,

    whereas

    a

    trifle less

    Bb"

    in

    the

    "key

    minus

    16

    to

    the

    nearest

    plus

    RATIO

    I / .)

    cents,

    ot

    mrnus

    I

    /.)

    cents

    14 ccnts

    16

    cents,

    or

    minus

    33 cents

    4

    cents,

    o/

    18

    cent s

    plus

    12

    cents

    not

    only in

    the

    "key

    of C"

    12

    cents,

    etc.

    a simple

    a many-toned

    THE LANGUAGE

    OF RATIOS

    scale-and alsomethods

    by

    logarithms

    hat give

    results

    up

    to

    threedecimal

    placcs.For presentpurposes omputations

    o a tenth of a ccnt

    are

    generally

    sufficient.All

    the

    Monophonic ratios n

    this exposition,and manv

    others

    besidcs, re givcn n cent s o one dccimal point, either n

    the text or in

    th e

    table

    of

    Appendix I. Knowledgc as to com putation

    of ccnts s important

    only to that adventurous

    oul rlho rvishes

    o organize

    a

    scale

    or

    systcm

    bc -

    vond

    the

    ratios

    expounded

    n

    this volumc. For t his purposc

    a tablc of five-

    place ogarithms,

    obtainableat almost an; bookstore, nd the ibrary loan

    of Hclmholtz's On heSensationsJZonrarc the esscntials. n pagcs448-449

    Ellis cxplainshis procedure or

    obtaininq rcsults o a tenth of

    a cent, by ex-

    ample,

    ancl

    on pages450-451hc supplit's

    ablcs o be uscd n conjunct ion

    uith

    the

    tablc

    of

    {ivc-place ogarithms. Ratios

    and ccn ts are thc nvo in-

    s(rumcnts

    bl

    rrhich thc investi {ator xaurines

    nd organizcs is t}rcorctical

    musical csourccs.

    For

    purposcs

    of an

    immediatc papcr

    ccrnparisonof ratios n

    Just

    In -

    tonation the logarithm

    is

    no bcttcr th an rhe ratio,

    and

    is therefore

    uscd n

    this rvork onlf in computing ccnts and in examination

    of the numcrous

    tempcraments.

    or exactitude

    uc havc

    thc ratio itsclf:lbr the purpose

    of

    cstablishing hcreaboutsby-

    prina

    Jacit

    comparison \'c

    havc cents,