Upload
hakhue
View
218
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1
The Craft of Scientific WritingScientific Writing
Nach Michael Alley's Buch "The Craft of Scientific Writing",
"Writing by Similarity"
Springer, 1996.
Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch bestimmt.
Karl C Posch März 2004
Kompliziert? Ja.Kunst? Nein.Handwerk? Ja.
WissenschaftlicheSprache ist komplex
Wissenschaftliches Thema ist komplex
Wie geht man an ein technisches Problem heran?- definiere die Randbedingungen!
Wie schreibt man einen Text dazu?- Outline zuerst?
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 2
- Einleitung zuerst?- Bilder, Mindmap zuerst?
→ definiere die Randbedingungen zuerst!
2
InhaltTypologieyp gRandbedingungenStil
Struktur: Anfang – Mitte – Ende Übergänge, Tiefe, BetonungSprache
l h ff h
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 3
• Präzision – Klarheit – Offenheit –Einfachheit – Prägnanz - Flüssigkeit
IllustrationenPsychologie des Schreibens
1 TypologieExtended AbstractConference PaperJournal PaperThesisCorrespondenceProposalsInstructionsPresentations
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 4
Report (technical, management)Web presentationTutorialTextbook...
3
2 Die Randbedingungen
Innenwelt Außenwelt
Thema Adressaten Format
TITLE
Abstract
Innenwelt Außenwelt
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 5
Zweck Mechanik Politik
2.1 Der Zweck
InformationInformationMathematik, Netzwerke, Security, HW, SW, ...Das Ziel ist EffizienzSchlussfolgerungen zuerst
Überzeugung
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 6
ÜberzeugungLogische Argumente in überzeugender Reihenfolge
4
2.2 Die AdressatenWer liest?
Manager, Wissenschaftler, IngenieureMehrere Gruppen?
Welches Vorwissen?Welche Hintergrundinformation ist notwendig?
Warum wird gelesen?
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 7
Hat Auswirkung auf HervorhebungenWie wird gelesen?
Alles oder nur Teile, Browsing, SprintLesen
2.3 Das FormatFonts
TITLE
Abstract
SeitennummerierungRänderAbständeFormat für LiteraturangabenLänge des Dokuments
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 8
Länge des Dokuments
Normalerweise keine Freiheitsgrade für Autoren
5
2.4 Die MechanikGrammatikGrammatik
Eher kurze Sätze machenZeichensetzung
Unterschiede zwischen Deutsch, Englisch und Amerikanisch
Harte Regeln und weiche Regeln
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 9
Harte Regeln und weiche RegelnNeue zusammengesetzte HauptwörterMischung von Englisch und Deutsch
2.5 Die Politik
Triviale Welt: "bleib ehrlich"Triviale Welt: bleib ehrlichReale Welt
Rechtliche SituationNicht alles darf/soll gesagt werden"Beschönigung" von Resultaten
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 10
6
Analogie "SW-Entwicklung"
Funktion ist vorgegebenFunktion ist vorgegebenLook-and-Feel muss passenEinfachheitKlare Strukturierung Coding styles
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 11
Coding stylesSyntax
und wo bleibt
3
... und wo bleibt die Freiheit?
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 12
... es ist eine Frage des Stils.
7
StilwerkzeugeWas ist Stil
HervorhebungenSatzlängeWie detailliert...
El t d Stil
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 13
Elemente des StilsStrukturSpracheIllustrationen
3.1 StrukturWichtigstes Stilwerkzeugg gStrategie des AufsatzesOrganisation von Details
Tiefe der DetailsÜbergang zwischen DetailsHervorhebung von Details
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 14
Wenn die Struktur nicht stimmt, verliert man den LeserIst wichtiger als Sprache und Illustration
8
3.2 SpracheBenutzung von Wörterng
Wahl von WörternReihenfolge von Wörtern
PhrasenSätze(Absätze)Zahlen
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 15
ZahlenFormelnAbkürzungenBeispiele und Analogien
Attribute von Sprache
GenauigkeitGenauigkeitsage was du meinst
Klarheitlasse Überflüssiges weg
verwendeeinegewohnteSprache
gerade heraus
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 16
gerade herauskeine Mätzchen
Knappheitjedes Wort soll zählen
formuliereflüssig
9
3.3 Illustrationen
AbbildungenAbbildungenTabellenUnd verweise im Text auf diese!
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 17
So weit, so gut
Randbedingungen StilRandbedingungen
AdressatenFormatMechanikPolitik
Stil
StrukturSpracheIllustrationen
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 18
(keine Freiheiten) ("volle" Freiheit)
10
... and after is it mostly also still English ...
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 19
... und dann ist es meistens auch noch Englisch ...
4 Structure:Organizing Your Document
BeginningTitleSummary (abstract)Introduction
MiddlesSections and subsections
EndingsConclusions
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 20
ConclusionsBack Matter
• Appendix• Glossary• References
11
Beginning, Middle, EndingBeginning prepares for the middle What
Define the workShow why the work was doneGive background informationReveal how the work will be presented
MiddleWhat happened in the workHow did it happenPresent results and show
WhyBackgroundMapping
WhatHow
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 21
Present results and show where they came fromExplain the meaning of the result
EndingFurther analysisOverall perspective of workFuture perspective
ResultsRelevance
What not yetWrappingFuture
4.1 Beginning
Prepare readers to understand Prepare readers to understand middleIt determines whether audience will continue readingMake-or-break situation
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 22
12
Creating Titles (1/5)
Reducing the Hazards of Operations
1. Identify field of study
Nuclear power plant? AIDS?
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 23
2. Separate document from other documents3. Think of computer searching through list of titles
Creating Titles (2/5)Effects of Humidity on the Growth of ects o u d ty o t e G o t oAvalanches
Snow? Or electron avalanches?
Effects of Humidity on the Growth of
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 24
yElectron Avalanches in Electrical Gas Discharges
But why is this paper special?
13
Creating Titles (3/5)Studies on the Electrodeposition of Lead on Copper
Distinguish from other work:Effects of Rhodamine-B on theElectrodeposition of Lead on Copper
But only three or four details:
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 25
Effects of Rhodamine-B and Saccarinon the Electric Double Layer DuringNickel Electrodeposition on PlatinumStudied by AC-Cyclic Voltammetry
Creating Titles (4/5)Effects of Rhodamine-B and SaccarinEffects of Rhodamine B and Saccarinon the Electric Double Layer DuringNickel Electrodeposition on PlatinumStudied by AC-Cyclic Voltammetry
Use of AC-Cyclic Voltammetry
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 26
Use of AC Cyclic Voltammetry to Study Organic Agents in the Electrodeposition of Nickel and Platinum
14
Creating Titles (5/5)Do not forget small words:g
10 MW Solar Thermal Electric CentralReceiver Barstow Power Pilot Plant Transfer Fluid Conversation Study
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 27
Proposal to Use a New Heat TransferFluid in the Solar One Power Plant
Writing Summaries (1/2)
Winston Churchill: Winston Churchill:
"Please be good enough to put your conclusions and recommendations on one sheet of paper at the very beginning of your report so that I
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 28
beginning of your report, so that I can even consider reading it."
15
Writing Summaries (2/2)Scientific writing is not mystery writingStrategy
State what happened upfrontUse rest of paper to explain how it happened
Two typesDescriptive summary (descriptive abstract)
• "table of contents" in paragraph form• Can be done at the beginning of writing
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 29
• Can be done at the beginning of writingInformative summary ("extendend abstract")
• Synopsis of work• Actual results are presented• Major conclusions and recommendations of work• Independent of the paper itself
Descriptive Summary (1/2)
A N Ch i l P f Eli i ti
Can be done at before the actual paper writing
This paper introduces a new chemical process for eliminating nitrogen oxides from the exhausts ofdiesel engines. The process uses isocyanic acid,
h l d l l
A New Chemical Process for EliminatingNitrogen Oxides From Diesel Engine Exhausts
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 30
a nontoxic chemical used to clean swimming pools.In this paper, we show how well the process reducedemissions of nitrogen oxides from a laboratory dieselengine. To explain how the process works, we presenta scheme of chemical reactions.
16
Descriptive Summary (2/2)
A N Ch i l P f Eli i ti
This paper describes a new inertial navigation system for mapping oil and gas wells. In this paper the mapping accuracy and speed of this
d h
A New Chemical Process for EliminatingNitrogen Oxides From Diesel Engine Exhausts
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 31
new system are compared against the mappingaccuracies and the speeds of conventional systems.
Informative Summary (1/2)
Repetition or condensation of main Repetition or condensation of main textTypically 5-10% of text lengthAlso mixtures between descriptive and informative summaries possible
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 32
p
17
Informative Summary (2/2)This paper describes a new inertial navigation system that will
increase the mapping accuracy of oil wells by a factor of ten. The new system uses three-axis navigation that protects the sensors from high spin rates. The system also processes its information byKalman filtering (a statistical sampling technique) in an on-site computer. Test results show that the three-dimensional location accuracy is ±0.1 meters of well depth, an accuracy ten times greater than conventional system.
Besides mapping accuracy the inertial navigation system has
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 33
Besides mapping accuracy, the inertial navigation system has three other advantages over conventional systems. First, its three-axis navigator requires no cable measurements. Second, probe alignment in the borehole no longer causes an error in displacement. Third, the navigation process is five times fasterbecause the gyroscopes and accelerometers are protected.
4.2 Writing Introductions
What exactly is the work?
WhatWhyBackgroundMapping
Scope and limitationsWhy is the work important?
Readers need incentives to readWhat made you curious about the work?Length depends on intended audience
Background: What is needed to understand the work?Strongly depends on the intended audienceBe selective!
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 34
Be selective!Use also middle of document for further clarificationOr use separate section
Mapping: How will the work be presented?Is expected!Nice transition to middle
18
Introduction: Scope
WhatWhyBackgroundMapping
This paper presents a model to describe the electrical breakdown of a gas. We call this model the two-group model because of the similarity between the problem of gas breakdown and the problem of neutron transport in nuclear reactor physics. The two-group model is based on electron kinetics and applies to a broad range of conditions (breakdown in pure gases, for example). The model also provides a continuous picture of the initial phase of breakdown above the Townsend regime both in
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 35
initial phase of breakdown above the Townsend regime, both in structure of the breakdown and the physics of the processes. [Kundhardt and Byszewski, 1980].
Introduction: Limitations
What notWhyBackgroundMapping
In this paper, we have compared the life expectancies of threedifferent groups of people: heavy alcohol drinkers, moderatealcohol drinkers, and people who do not drink alcohol. We havenot, however, studied the social, medical, or economic makeup of these groups—three elements that could affect life expectancies much more than alcohol intake.
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 36
19
Introduction: Justification (1/2)
Bad example:
WhatWhyBackgroundMapping
This paper presents the effects of laser field statistics on coherent anti-Stokes Raman spectroscopy intensities. The importance of coherent anti-Stokes Raman spectroscopy instudying combustion flames is widely known.
Bad example:
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 37
Introduction: Justification (2/2)
Good example (bold face only on slide!):
WhatWhyBackgroundMapping
This paper presents a design for a platinum catalytic igniterin lean hydrogen-air mixtures. This igniter has application inlight-water nuclear reactors. For example, one danger at sucha reactor is a loss-of-coolant accident, in which large quantitiesof hydrogen gas can be produced when hot water and steamreact with zirconium fuel-rod cladding and steel. In a serious
id t th l ti f h d b id th t it
Good example (bold face only on slide!):
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 38
accident, the evolution of hydrogen may be so rapid that itproduces an explosive hydrogen-air mixture in the reactorcontainment walls, allowing radiation to escape. To eliminatethis danger, one proposed method is to ignite intentionally the hydrogen-air mixture at concentrations below those for which any serious damage might result.
20
Introduction: Mapping
Thi t di th ff t f k th th‘
WhatWhyBackgroundMapping
This report discusses the effects of smoke on the earth‘s climate following a large-scale nuclear war. In the first section of the report, we present a war scenario in which 10,000 megatons of high-yield weapons detonate. The secondsection of the report then introduces assumptions for the amount of smoke produced from the resulting fires, the chemical characteristics of the smoke, and the altitudes at which the smoke initially enters the atmosphere. In the third
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 39
y psection, we present computer models that show how the smoke distributes itself in the weeks and months following the war. Finally, in the fourth section, we discuss how the earth‘s climate changes as a result of that smoke distribution.
4.3 Writing Middles
Simply presents the workSimply presents the workStrategies:
ChronologicalSpatialFlow
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 40
Cause-effect
21
4.4 Writing Conclusion Sections
Expectations of readerExpectations of readerAnalysis of key results from middleFuture perspective or recommendationsTreat the results as a wholeDon't introduce new material
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 41
"Complete the circle"
Example for Conclusion Section
Th t t h d th t d i it f l These tests showed that a non-powered igniter for lean hydrogen-air mixtures is feasible, and that such an igniter could contribute to the safety of light water nuclear reactorsby igniting safe concentrations of hydrogen during aloss-of-coolant accident.
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 42
22
5 Structure:Transition, Depth, Emphasis
Transition between detailsTransition between detailsDepth of detailsEmphasis of details
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 43
5.1Transitions Between Details
Between sentences paragraphs Between sentences, paragraphs, and sectionsWhite space makes reader stopGlues togetherMapping sections
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 44
Mapping sections
23
Mapping Sections
R ti l b di b th d i t d thRecreational scuba divers breathe compressed air at depthsdown to 190 feet. Breathing compressed air at these greatdepths and even at more moderate depths poses manydangers for scuba divers. These dangers are nitrogen narcosis, decompression sickness, and arterial gas embolism....
The reader is prepared for three subsections to
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 45
The reader is prepared for three subsections to follow.
Avoid Beginnings Like ...Empty beginningEmpty beginning
In medias res
Genesis
The behavior of materials in combustion systemshas considerable technological significance.
Item 12 on Drawing 5 shows the tolerance of the safe adapter.
Man has since the beginning of time attempted to acquire a greater
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 46
Man has since the beginning of time attempted to acquire a greaterand greater control over his environment. Gaining control over a situation serves not only a survival-related need, but also a psycho-logical need. Man‘s need for better control of his environment has increased greatly during and following any time of major conflict, such as World War II. This need and desire for control is evident in all technological settings, including the welding field.
24
How to Begin ...
Introduce the subject of the sectionIntroduce the subject of the sectionRepeat headingOr begin with background information in order to introduce unfamiliar term of heading
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 47
g
Check out text on pages 57-59 of book
5.2 Depth of Details
Depends on lengthDepends on lengthThink of audienceThink of purpose of document
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 48
25
5.3 Emphasis of DetailsReader must understand relative importance of detailsStrategy
RepetitionWordingIllustrationPlacement
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 49
Placement• Text that borders white space• Short sentence after long one• Short paragraph after long one• Don't bury important details in middle of paragraphs
Emphasizing with WordingOne of the panels on the north side of the solar receiver willp
be repainted with Solarcept during the February plant outage.
Because the February plant outage gave us time to repair thenorth side of the solar receiver, we repainted the panels withSolarcept, a new paint developed to increase absorbtivity.
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 50
Dependent clauses: because, since, as, although, when
Infinitive clauses (starts with "to"): to repair, to increase
26
Emphasizing with Placement (1/2)This report uses data from both the test and evaluation andp
power production phases to evaluate the performance of theSolar One receiver. Receiver performance includes such receivercharacteristics as point-in-time steady state efficiency, averageefficiency, start-up time, operation time, operations during cloudtransients, panel mechanical supports, and tube leaks. Each ofthese characteristics will be covered in some detail in this report.
This report uses data from both the test and production
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 51
This report uses data from both the test and production phases to evaluate the performance of the Solar One receiver. In this report, we will evaluate performance by studying the receivers‘s efficiency, operation cycle, and mechanical wear.
Emphasizing with Placement (2/2)
Vertical lists emphasizeVertical lists emphasizeVertical lists disrupt readingToo many vertical lists make document appear like an outline(Long) lists tend to bury information
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 52
(Long) lists tend to bury information
27
6 Language
PreciseThe right word Precise
Clear Familiar
Level of detail
Avoid needless complexityAvoid ambiguity
ToneStrong nouns and verbs
Define unfamiliar terms, use examples, analogies
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 53
Fluid
Forthright
Conciseprägnant, präzise, kurz und klar
Sentence rhythm, transitions
6.1 Being Precise (1/2)Choosing the right wordg g
weight vs. mass
Don't use synonyms
The problem centers around the drying and aging of the bloodstain.
The problem revolves around the drying andaging of the bloodstain.
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 54
Don t use synonymsDon't rely on thesaurusBe aware of connotations ("adequate", "cheap")Go in fear of absolutes ("always", "never")
28
Being Precise (2/2)
Choosing the right level of detailChoosing the right level of detailStrong writing requires both general statements and specific statementsBy themselves, generalities are soon forgottenSometimes specific statements confuse
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 55
Sometimes specific statements confuse
6.2 Being ClearAvoiding needless complexityAvoiding needless complexity
Complex wordsComplex phrasesComplex sentences
Avoiding ambiguityWord choice
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 56
Word choiceSyntaxPronounsPunctuation
29
Needless ComplexityKeep things simple!Keep things simple!Watch out for words with "ize" at the end and try to find simple substitutes
utilization usehas the functionability can function
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 57
finalize endfirstly firsttherewith withhitherto until nowindividualized individual
Needlessly Complex WordsThe objective of this study is to develop an effectivej y p
commercialization strategy for solar energy system by analyzing the factors that are impeding early commercial projects and by prioritizing the potential government and industry actions that can facilitate the viability of the projects.
This study will consider why current solar energy systems have not yet reached the commercial stage and will evaluate the
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 58
have not yet reached the commercial stage and will evaluate the steps that industry and government can take to make these systems commercial.
Use simple words. Keep inherent complexity in your ideas only.
30
Needlessly Complex PhrasesWatch out for stringing modifiers in front of nouns
Solar One is a 10 megawatt solar thermal electric central receiver Barstow power pilot plant.
Solar One is a solar-powered pilot plant located near Barstow, California. Solar One produces 10 megawatts of electric power by capturing solar energy in a central receiver design.
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 59
The decision will be based on economical fluid replenishment cost performance.
We will base the decision on the cost of replacing the thermal oil.
Needlessly Complex Sentences (1/4)
In scientific documents, the average , glength is often more than 30 words.In most newspapers it is less than 20 words.But, short sentences are not always the cure. You need longer sentences for variety
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 60
variety.Not long sentences, but complex sentences confuse readers.
31
Needlessly Complex Sentences (2/4)
The object of the work was to confirm the nature of electrical breakdown of nitrogen in uniform fields at relatively high pressures and interelectrode gaps that approach those obtained in engineering practice, prior to the determination of the processes that set the criterion for breakdown in the above-mentioned gases and mixtures in uniform and non-uniform fields of engineering significance.
At relatively high pressures (760 torr) and typical electrode
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 61
At relatively high pressures (760 torr) and typical electrode gap distances (1 mm), the electrical breakdown of nitrogen was studied in uniform fields. ...
Needlessly Complex Sentences (3/4)
One sentence should have one main idea.One sentence should have one main idea.Sentence should not wander.In a well-written long sentence you don‘t notice that it is long.Write your paper as if you were talking to your most important reader
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 62
your most important reader.But, this does not mean that your writing should be informal.
32
Needlessly Complex Sentences (4/4)
In that the “Big Bang,” currently the most credible theory about how the universe was created, explains only the creation of hydrogen and helium, we are left to theorize as to how all the other elements came into being. Having studied the nuclear reactions that constitute the life and death cycles of stars, many scientists believe therein lies the key.
The “Big Bang” is the most credible theory for the creation of
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 63
the universe. Nevertheless, the “Big Bang” explains the creation of only helium and hydrogen. What about the other elements? Many scientists believe that they arose from nuclear reactions that occur in the life and death cycles of stars.
Avoiding AmbiguityRadiometer System. Two general requirements to be met
are (1) to survive and accurately measure the radiation incident on the receiver and (2) to present the data in a form that can be used to verify computer code predictions.
Radiometer System The radiometer system for the solar
Bad transition, sentence has gaps (who or what must survive?),and, instead of 2 there are actually 3 requirements.
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 64
Radiometer System. The radiometer system for the solar receiver must meet three requirements: (1) it must accurately measure to within 5 percent the solar radiation on the receiver; (2) its electronics must survive in solar radiation as intense as 300 kilowatts per square meter; and (3) its output must be able to verify computer codes.
33
Ambiguities in SyntaxIn low water temperatures and high toxicity In low water temperatures and high toxicity
levels of oil, we tested how well the microorganisms survived.
We tested how well the microorganisms survived in low water temperatures and
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 65
survived in low water temperatures and high toxicity levels of oil.
Ambiguities in PronounsBecause the receiver presented the radiometer with a high flux
What is mounted in the container?The receiver?The radiometer?The environment?
Watch out for "it" and "this"
environment, it was mounted in a silver-plated stainless steel container.
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 66
There are no peaks in the olefinic region. Therefore, no significant concentration of olefinic hydrocarbons exist in fresh oil. This places an upper limit on the concentration of olefins, no more than 0.01 percent.
this: oil? concentration? idea of previous senctence? lack of peaks?
34
Ambiguities in PunctuationAfter cooling the exhaust gases continue to expand until the
density reaches that of freestream.
When feeding a shark often mistakes undesirable food items for something it really desires.
The three elements were hydrogen, oxygen, and nitrogen.
The three elements were hydrogen oxygen and nitrogen
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 67
In our study, we examined neat methanol, neat ethanol, methanol and 10 percent water and ethanol and 10 percent water.
The three elements were hydrogen, oxygen and nitrogen.
how many fuels?
6.3 Being Forthright
Controlling tone
offen, ehrlich,gerade heraus
Controlling toneAvoiding pretentious wordsAvoiding arrogant phrasesAvoiding silliness
Choosing strong nouns and verbs
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 68
35
Avoiding Pretentious WordsPseudo-intellectualityWrong use of "interface"(e.g. people or groups don't interface :-)Wrong use of "implement"(put into effect, carry out)"manufacturability" (can manufacture)"utilize", "utilization" (use)
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 69
The elevated temperatures of the liquid propellant fuel facilitated an unscheduled irrevocable disassembly.
The higher temperatures caused the liquid propellant to explode.
Avoiding Arrogant Phrases"as is well known, .…" "unambiguous"
"of course …""clearly demonstrate"
As is well known, the use of gaseous insulation is becoming increasingly more widespread, with gases such as air and sulphur hexafluoride featuring prominently. There has been some discussion of using gas mixtures like nitrogen and sulphur
"it is obvious"
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 70
hexafluoride, and of course nitrogen is the major constituent of air.
The results clearly demonstrate the ability of Raman spectroscopy to provide unambiguous chemical compound identifications from oxides as they grow on a metal surface.
36
Avoiding Silliness
Avoid clichésAvoid clichés"come up to speed""touch base with you""knock heads together""!"
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 71
"greatest thing since sliced bread"
I am in search of a meaningful growth position, and your company is a gateway to the highest professional levels and beyond ...
Strong Nouns and Verbs
Most important wordsMost important wordsNouns: stepping stonesVerbs: provide momentum
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 72
37
Strong NounsThe existing nature of Mount St. Helens' volcanic ash spewage
nature ?spewage (no noun at all, comes from "spew")usecapabilities
g p gwas handled through the applied use of computer modeling capabilities.
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 73
Crisp, more direct.Nouns provide images to the reader.
With Cray computers, we modeled how much ash spewed from Mount St. Helens.
Concrete Nouns and Abstract Nouns
Concrete nouns provide images to the Concrete nouns provide images to the readerReducing amount of abstract nouns strengthens your writingTypical weak nouns:
bilit i t
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 74
ability environmentapproach factorcapability natureconcept parameter
38
Abstract NounsMake abstract nouns concreteMake abstract nouns concrete
"method""criteria"
This study considered three methods for detecting plastic explosives in airline baggage: ion mobility spectrometry, x-ray backscatter, and thermal neutron activation. To evaluate these
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 75
three methods, we used four criteria: cost of the method, effectiveness of the method at identifying a plastic explosive, speed of the method at processing baggage, and ease of use for the method.
Strong Verbsmade the arrangement for arranged
d th d i i d id dmade the decision decidedmade the measurement of measuredperformed the development of developed
The human immune system is responsible not only for the identification of foreign molecules, but also for actions leading to th i i bili ti t li ti d d t ti
Sentence sits:
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 76
their immobilization, neutralization, and destruction.
The human immune system not only identifies foreign molecules, but also immobilizes, neutralizes, and destroys those molecules.
Sentence moves:
39
Buried Verbs Slow Downis beginning beginsi f ll i f llis following followsis shadowing shadowsis used to detect detects
The distance between the electrodes is dependent on the pressure environment and the result of metal corrosion.
The distance between the electrodes depends on the gas d th l t d ´ i
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 77
pressure and the electrodes corrosion.
Use of "is" as equal sign only:A positron is a positively charged electron produced in the
beta decay of neutron-deficient nuclides.
Wrong Use of Passive VoiceSlows downReduces efficiencyLifeless, dead words
The feedthrough was composed of a sapphire optical fiber, which was pressed against the pyrotechnic that was used to confine the charge.
The feedthrough contained a sapphire optical fiber, which d i t th t h i th t t i d th h
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 78
pressed against the pyrotechnic that contained the charge.
On the second day of our wildebeest study, one of the calves wandered just a few yards from the herd and was attacked by wild dogs.
But: (calve is focus of paragraph)
40
Wrong Use of Passive VoiceA new process for eliminating nitrogen oxides from diesel p g g
exhaust engines is presented. Flow tube experiments to test this process are discussed. A chemical reaction scheme to account for this process is proposed.
This paper presents a new process for eliminating nitrogen oxides form the exhaust of diesel engines. To test this process, we performed experiments in flow tubes. To explain this process,
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 79
we developed a scheme of chemical reactions.
But Be Careful
The voltage was given on the oscilloscopeThe voltage was given on the oscilloscope.
The oscilloscope displayed the voltage. (comfortable)
The oscilloscope measured the voltage. (marginal)
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 80
p g ( g )
The oscilloscope calculated the voltage. (uncomfortable)
41
Use of "I" and "We" (1/2)
As long as emphasis stays on the As long as emphasis stays on the work, it is OKDon't use too oftenUnnatural phrases:
It was determined that...
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 81
It was decided that...It was attributed to...
Use of "I" and "We" (2/2)In that an effort to identify a specific control circuit y p
responsible for the failure of the gear box was unsuccessful, it was determined appropriate to resurvey the collector field for torque tube damage.
Because we could not locate the control circuit responsible for the gear box failure, we surveyed the collector field again for damage to the torque tubes.
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 82
Reserve for situations where your role is importantAvoid putting "I" at the beginning of a sentenceSome editors don't like "I" and "we"!
42
6.4 Being Familiar
Avoiding unfamiliar termsAvoiding unfamiliar termsDefining unfamiliar termsIncorporating examples and analogies
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 83
Avoiding Unfamiliar Terms
Simplest: avoid themSimplest: avoid themPossibly avoid abbreviations, slang, jargon
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 84
43
Defining Unfamiliar TermsIntroduce abbreviations only if used oftenIntroduce abbreviations only if used oftenDefine abbreviation
at first appearance of term,or maybe later, when term is used frequently only later in the paper
AIDS, DNA ?
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 85
S,May be used in titles, summariesBut still should be defined for completeness sake somewhere in the document
Use Examples and Analogies (1/2)
Two of the best tools for explaining unfamiliar conceptsAnchor general statements with examples
Since the design of the Solar One Power Plant, significant advances have occurred in solar energy technology.
Since the design of the Solar One Power Plant, significant advances have occurred in solar energy technology. For
l i t l t t h h th t i lt lt
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 86
Examples are what people remember
example, experimental tests have shown that using molten salt, rather than water, as the heat transfer fluid could increase overall system efficiency from 17 percent to 25 percent.
44
Use Examples and Analogies (2/2)
Cited from Feynman:
If you were standing at arms´s length from someone and you had one percent more electrons than protons, the repelling force would be incredible. How great? Enough to lift the Empire State Building? No. To loft Mount Everest? No. The repulsion would be enough to lift a weight equal to that of the entire earth.
Cited from Feynman:
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 87
... see also other examples by Einstein (train and dropping a stone), and Freud (ego and id: rider and horse).
6.5 Being Concise
Follows from being clear and being
prägnant,präzise,kurz und klar
Follows from being clear and being forthrightHow to "cut fat:"
Eliminating redundanciesEliminating writing zeroes
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 88
Reducing sentences to simplest formsEliminating bureaucratic waste
45
Eliminating Redundancies(already) existing introduced (a new)( lt ti ) h i i (t th )(alternative) choices mix (together)at (the) present (time) never (before)(basic) fundamentals none (at all)(completely) eliminate now (at this time)(continue) to remain period (of time)(currently) being (private) industry(currently) underway (separate) entities(empty) space start (out)
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 89
Catch while revisingRead with policy "no additions allowed"
(e pty) space sta t (out)had done (previously) (still) persists
Eliminating Writing ZeroesIt is interesting to note that over 90 incidents of satellite g
fragmentations have produced over 36,000 kilograms of space debris.
The requirements to be met for the detection system of plastic explosives include a detection rate of at least 95 percent and a false alarm rate of less than 5 percent.
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 90
If not interesting, then leave detail away; if interesting, then omit phraseAre there requirements not to be met?
46
Other Typical ZeroesAs a matter of factAs a matter of factI might add thatIt is noteworthy thatIt is significant thatIt should be pointed out that
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 91
The course ofThe fact thatThe presence of
Example33 words:
Vibration measurements made in the course of the missile´s flight test program were complicated by the presence ofintense high-frequency excitation of the vehicle shell structureduring the re-entry phase of the flight.
19 words:
Vibration measurements made during the missile´s flight
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 92
g gwere complicated by intense high-frequency excitation of the vehicle shell during re-entry.
47
Reducing Sentences to Simplest Forms
Fat phrase Reductionp
at this point in time nowat that point in time thenhas the ability to canhas the potential to canin the light of the fact that because
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 93
in the event that ifin the vicinity of nearowing to the fact that becausethe question as to whether whetherthere is no doubt but that no doubt
Cutting Needless Adjectives
37 words:
The objective of our work is to obtain data that can be used in conjunction with a comprehensive chemical kinetics modeling study to generate a detailed understanding of the fundamental chemical processes that lead to engine knock.
37 words:
26 words:
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 94
Our goal is to obtain experimental data that can be used with a chemical kinetics model to explain the chemical processes that lead to engine knock.
48
Cutting Needless Adverbs
(somewhat) unique(somewhat) unique(somewhat) perfect(very) importantDepends (very heavily)( th d t il d) d t di
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 95
(rather detailed) understanding
Example
31 words:
The achievement of success in these advanced technologies depends very heavily on a rather detailed understanding of the complex processes that govern the velocities in the unburned gases prior to combustion.
31 words:
18 words:
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 96
The success of these advanced technologies depends on understanding the velocities in the unburned gases prior to combustion.
49
Nouns Containing VerbsDon‘t attract needless adjectives and adverbsj
The establishment of a well proven, well documented, rational methodology for making precise velocity measurements in the unburned gas has been realized and is being used extensively to aid in the development of numerical models, which in turn are used in the design of advanced piston engines.
45 words:
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 97
27 words:
We have found a method to measure velocity in the unburned gas, and with this method, we are developing numerical models that will help design advanced piston engines.
Needless Passive Verbs
It was then concluded that a second complete solar mirror field corrosion survey should be conducted in July to determine whether the tenfold annual corrosion rate projection was valid and to allow determination as to whether subsequent corrective measures would be effective in retarding corrosion propagation
85 syllables:
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 98
61 syllables:
To see whether the corrosion rate would increase tenfold as projected and to see whether stowing the mirrors in a vertical position would slow the rate, we decided to survey the solar mirror field a second time in July.
50
Eliminating Bureaucratic Waste
Look at paragraphs and sectionsLook at paragraphs and sectionsWasteful management writingNouns like
"target""parameter"
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 99
p"development"
6.6 Being FluidVarying sentence rhythmsVarying sentence rhythms
Varying sentence openersVarying sentence lengthsVarying sentence structureVarying paragraph lengths
Eliminating discontinuities
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 100
at g d sco t u t esMaking transitions between ideasEliminating needless complex typographyIncorporating equations
51
Varying Rhythm
Mount St Helens erupted on May 18 1980 A cloud of hot Mount St. Helens erupted on May 18, 1980. A cloud of hot rock and gas surged northward from its collapsing slope. The cloud devastated more than 500 square kilometers of forests and lakes. The effects of Mount St. Helens were well documented with geophysical instruments. The origin of the eruption is not well understood. Volcanic explosions are driven by a rapid expansion of steam. Some scientists believe the steam comes from groundwater heated by magma. Other
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 101
scientists believe the steam comes from water originally dissolved in the magma. We have to understand the source of steam in volcanic eruptions. We have to determine how much water the magma contains.
Varying Sentence OpenersSubject-Verb Mount St. Helens erupted on May 18, 1980.
Prepositional Phrase Within minutes, the cloud devastated morethan 500 square kilometers of forests and lakes.
Transition Words Recently, debate has arisen over the sourceof the steam.
Introductory Clause Although the effects of the eruption werewell documented, the origin is not well understood.
Infinitive Phrase T d t d th f t i
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 102
Infinitive Phrase To understand the source of steam in volcanic eruptions, we have to determine howmuch water the magma contains.
Participial Phrase Its slope collapsing, the mountain emitteda cloud of hot rock and gas.
Verb (Question) Is it groundwater heated by magma or wateroriginally dissolved in the magma itself?
52
Example
Mount St Helens erupted on May 18 1980 Its slope Mount St. Helens erupted on May 18, 1980. Its slope collapsing, the mountain emitted a cloud of hot rock and gas. Within minutes, the cloud devastated more than 500 square kilometers of forests and lakes. Although the effects of the eruption were well documented, the origin is not well understood. Volcanic explosions are driven by a rapid expansion of steam. Recently, debate has arisen over the source for the steam. Is it groundwater heated by the magma or water
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 103
originally dissolved in the magma itself? To understand the source of steam in volcanic explosions, we have to determine how much water the magma contains. [Eichelberger, 1983]
Varying Sentence Lengths
On the morning of May 18 a strong earthquake shook Mount On the morning of May 18, a strong earthquake shook Mount St. Helens, causing the volcano´s cracked and steepened north side to slide away. Photographs taken during these early seconds, together with other information, showed that the blast originated 500 meters beneath a bulge on the north face. Photographs and time of destruction of a seismic station established the velocity of the blast to be about 175 meters per second. Of significance, the volume of new magmatic material
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 104
Average should be below 20 words.
ejected in the blast (about 0.1 km3) equals the volume of the bulge.
Monotonous lengths: 24 – 25 – 22 - 22
53
Sentence Lengths (1/2)
Try to keep your average length in Try to keep your average length in the teensChange your sentence length often, at least every two or three sentences
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 105
Occasionally use a short or long sentence
Sentence Lengths (2/2)
On the morning of May 18 a strong earthquake shook Mount On the morning of May 18, a strong earthquake shook Mount St. Helens, causing the volcano's cracked and steepened north side to slide away. Photographs showed that the blast began beneath a bulge on the north face. These photographs, when coupled with other information, established the depth of the blast´s origin to be 500 meters and the velocity of the blast to be 175 meters per second. The measured volume of the ejected magmatic material was about 0.1 km3. This volume equals the
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 106
volume of the bulge.
Lengths: 24 – 13 – 31 – 11 - 8
54
Varying Sentence Structure
Simple sentencesp
Compound sentences
Lava from a nonexplosive eruption ordinarily contains only 0.2 percent water.
Precursor activity to the eruption began on March 20, 1980, andmany times during the next two months the mountain shook for minutes.
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 107
Complex sentencesAlthough the amount of devastation caused by the May 18 blast was a surprise, the eruption itself had been expected for weeks.
Varying Paragraph LengthsGroup of connected sentences that conveys a group of connected ideasEnd of sentence: "stop sign"End of paragraph: "traffic light red"Length is measured in number of linesShort paragraphs: 1-7 linesLong paragraphs: more than 14
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 108
g p g pUse 7-14 with occasional short or long paragraphBut length also depends on format
55
Eliminating Discontinuities
Smooth transition between Smooth transition between sentences and paragraphsDiscontinuities arise from
Poor transitions between ideasNeedlessly complex typography
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 109
Poor transitions between text and equations
Transitions Between IdeasThe Cascade Range, with its prominent chain of towering cones, i t th l th t i l i i i th t U it d is not the only threatening volcanic region in the western United States. Many people who live in the eastern Sierra Nevada community of Mammoth Lakes, California, may have been unaware until recently that their scattered hills and ridges have a remarkably recent volcanic origin as well.
Th C d R ith it i t h i f t i
Needs a better tie between the two sentences:
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 110
The Cascade Range, with its prominent chain of towering cones, is not the only threatening volcanic region in the western United States. The Mammoth Lakes area of the Sierra Nevada also has a recent volcanic origin.
56
Transitional Words
Continuation Pause ReversalContinuation Pause Reversal
also for instance howevermoreover for example on the other handfirst...second...third in other words conversely
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 111
Logical Gaps
The Cascade Range with its prominent chain of towering cones The Cascade Range, with its prominent chain of towering cones, is not the only threatening volcanic region in the western United States. The Mammoth Lakes area of the Sierra Nevada also has a recent volcanic origin.
Where is Sierra Nevada?Where is the Cascade Range?
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 112
The Cascade Range, with its prominent chain of towering cones, is not the only threatening volcanic region in the western United States. Farther south, the Mammoth Lakes area of the Sierra Nevada also has a recent volcanic origin.
57
Needless Complex Typography
e.g. for examplee.g. for examplefig. figureFORTRAN Fortran19 nineteen$13,000,000 $13 million
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 113
etc.et al.i.e.
7 Illustration: Making the Right Choices
Choosing tablesChoosing tablesChoosing figures
GraphsPhotographsDrawings
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 114
58
Illustration: Creating the Best Designs
Being preciseBeing preciseBeing clearBeing fluidBeing familiar
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 115
8 Actually Sitting Down to Write
Getting in the moodGetting in the moodWriting first draftsRevising, revising, revisingFinishing
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 116
59
Writing Is Hard Work
ConcentrationConcentrationPatienceInexact solutionsMany revisions neededOften lonely work
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 117
Often lonely workDemands energy
Strong Scientific Writing
demands imaginationdemands imaginationThink as "audience"Become critic of your own work
F i B
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 118
Francis Bacon: "Reading maketh you a full man,conference a ready man, and writing an exact man."
60
8.1 Start Me Up
What to write aboutWhat to write aboutIdea for a proposalResults from your work
Understand your constraintsIdea about format, e.g. length
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 119
, g gPressure from supervisor And all those many distractions
Getting Into the Mood
Requires preparationRequires preparationDisciplined schedule (?)Clear your mind
Put aside personal problemsHemmingway started to write in the
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 120
g yearly morning after eight hours of sleepMotion: walking, running, mowing lawn
61
Getting Into the Mood (cont'd)
Block of free timeBlock of free timeOne to four hoursShut door, unplug the phone, ..."white noise" is OKDeposit computer games in the trash
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 121
Prepare mentally for task ahead
8.2 Writing First Drafts (1/3)
Beginning IS difficultBeginning _IS_ difficultPencil or computer
How to get words onto paper
Outline?Mix of structure and also parts of sentences, maybe also transitional phrases
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 122
maybe also transitional phrasesClean up outline for supervisor
Try to get a "strong outline"
62
Writing First Drafts (2/3)Rabbit's approachRabbit s approach
Hate first draftsWrite down everything and anythingFinish as quickly as possibleRotten text, but they at least got something
Turtle's approach
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 123
u t e s app oacTurtles are patientProceed methodicallyMake only "perfect" sentences
Writing First Drafts (3/3)
Where to start?Where to start?Be a rabbit on first draft of introductionThen write discussion and conclusion at normal pace
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 124
pThen rewrite introduction
63
How to Keep MomentumSet realistic goalsSet realistic goals
Rabbit: 5 pagesTurtle: 1 page
End sitting by writing into next sectionWatch what you eatStore draft under a separate file name
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 125
Store draft under a separate file nameDon't cut time while writing first draft
Writer's BlockCan't think of the right word
Write down the name of someone and keep going
Can't find sentences to express an ideaHave you completely understood the idea?Skip two lines and keep writing, it'll pop up
You hear voices, critical voicesDrown the voices with music
S i tifi iti i h i l th
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 126
Scientific writing is more mechanical than inspirationalThere is no such thing as writer's blockThere are only blocks in science and engineering
64
8.3 Revising, Revising, Revising
Key to strong scientific writingKey to strong scientific writingFirst: obtain some distance from draftChange your personality
Chisel and polish
Become a good readerListen to other good readers
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 127
Listen to other good readersWork hard on your critics of other people's documentsBe specific with strengths and weaknesses
Revising, Revising, RevisingChange the look of your documentg yTry to work through large chunks in each sitting
For smoothnessGet some distance between each revisionRead your text aloud
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 128
Solicit criticism of your writingNot too many readers, though.
Stop. There is no perfection in writing. Only success.
65
8.4 Finishing
Thankless workThankless workTypos, missing words, misspelled words, ...
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 129
9 Help from ...
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 130
66
10 Some links to start withhttp://writing.eng.vt.edu/workbooks/intro.html#audiencehttp://pubs.acs.org/subscribe/journals/ci/31/special/02sb_inet.htmlhttp://www.library.adelaide.edu.au/guide/sci/Generalsci/sciwrit.htmlhttp://owl.english.purdue.eduhttp://www.monroecc.edu/depts/library/cover.htmhttp://www.wisc.edu/writing/Handbook/index.htmlhttp://stipo.larc.nasa.gov/sp7084/index.html
Karl C Posch Nur für den internen IAIK-Gebrauch 131