-
8/20/2019 Kienitz v. Sconnie Nation, 7thCir
1/7
In the
United States Court of AppealsFor the Seventh Circuit
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
#$% &'('))*
+ ,-./01 2 ,0#,34 5!"#$%&$''()**+""#%& 5
,-
6-7##,0 # /3,7# 11- 89: ; #=7;#< ? =,#3,#> (@,6-7#6,# 5
1%1%-%5
.+'+%/#%&0()**+""++0%
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
/AAB8C DE$F GHB ;9IGB: 6G8GBJ
-
8/20/2019 Kienitz v. Sconnie Nation, 7thCir
2/7
M #$% &'('))*
Y89GJ G$ JHLG :$Y9 GHB 899L8C BNB9G% _$E GHB M)&M
SC$KX?8EGU5 6K$99IB #8GI$9 F8:B J$FB G(JHIEGJ 89: G89X G$AJ
:IJ(AC8UI9W 89 IF8WB $D 6$WCI9`J D8KB 89: GHB AHE8JB \6$EEU
D$E?8EGUI9W%] 3HB T* J8CBJ5 $9 YHIKH 6K$99IB #8GI$9 KCB8EB: 8JF8CC
AE$DIG5 CB: G$ GHIJ JLIG5 I9 YHIKH AH$G$WE8AHBE +IKH8BC2IB9IGa
8KKLJBJ 6K$99IB #8GI$9 89: IGJ NB9:$E $D K$AUEIWHGI9DEI9WBFB9G%
6K$99IB #8GI$9 K$9KB:BJ JG8EGI9W YIGH 8 AH$G$WE8AH GH8G2IB9IGa
G$$X 8G 6$WCI9`J I98LWLE8GI$9 I9 M)&&% 6$WCI9
ZYIGH2IB9IGa`J ABEFIJJI$9[ H8: A$JGB: IG $9 GHB -IGU`J YB^JIGB5DE$F
YHIKH 6K$99IB #8GI$9 :$Y9C$8:B: 8 K$AU% 3HB AH$G$(WE8AH Y8J
A$JGBEIaB:5 GHB ^8KXWE$L9: Y8J EBF$NB:5 89:6$WCI9`J D8KB Y8J GLE9B:
CIFB WEBB9 89: JLEE$L9:B: ^U FLC(GI(K$C$EB: YEIGI9W% .BEB 8EB GHB
$EIWI98C 89: GHB EBNIJI$9b
-
8/20/2019 Kienitz v. Sconnie Nation, 7thCir
3/7
#$% &'('))* '
/ F8WIJGE8GB cL:WB5 JBENI9W ^U K$9JB9G L9:BE Md ;%6%-%eO'OZK[5
WE89GB: JLFF8EU cL:WFB9G D$E GHB :BDB9:89GJ5H$C:I9W GH8G 6K$99IB
#8GI$9 H8: F8:B D8IE LJB $D GHB AH$G$%VOT _% 6LAA% M: &)*M
Z@%
-
8/20/2019 Kienitz v. Sconnie Nation, 7thCir
4/7
* #$% &'('))*
>%8%5 T&) ;%6% TOV5 TgV Z&VV*[% 3HB 6BK$9: -IEKLIG
H8J EL9YIGH GHB JLWWBJGI$9 89: K$9KCL:B: GH8G \GE89JD$EF8GINBLJB]
IJ B9$LWH G$ ^EI9W 8 F$:IDIB: K$AU YIGHI9 GHB JK$AB $De&)g%
6BB5 B%W%5 7#4$
-
8/20/2019 Kienitz v. Sconnie Nation, 7thCir
5/7
#$% &'('))* T
.BEB IJ GHB CIJG I9 e&)gb
,9 :BGBEFI9I9W YHBGHBE GHB LJB F8:B $D 8 Y$EX I9 89U
A8EGIKLC8EK8JB IJ 8 D8IE LJB GHB D8KG$EJ G$ ^B K$9JI:BEB: JH8CC
I9KCL:BP
Z&[ GHB ALEA$JB 89: KH8E8KGBE $D GHB LJB5 I9KCL:I9W
YHBGHBEJLKH LJB IJ $D 8 K$FFBEKI8C 98GLEB $E IJ D$E 9$9AE$DIG
B:LK8(GI$98C ALEA$JBJh
ZM[ GHB 98GLEB $D GHB K$AUEIWHGB: Y$EXh
Z'[ GHB 8F$L9G 89: JL^JG89GI8CIGU $D GHB A$EGI$9 LJB: I9
EBC8(GI$9 G$ GHB K$AUEIWHGB: Y$EX 8J 8 YH$CBh 89:
Z*[ GHB BDDBKG $D GHB LJB LA$9 GHB A$GB9GI8C F8EXBG D$E $E
N8C(LB $D GHB K$AUEIWHGB: Y$EX%
7GHBE GH89 D8KG$E Z*[5 YHIKH YB H8NB :IJKLJJB: 8CEB8:U5
$9CUZ'[PGHB 8F$L9G G8XB9 I9 EBC8GI$9 G$ GHB K$AUEIWHGB: Y$EX 8J8
YH$CBPH8J FLKH ^IGB I9 GHIJ CIGIW8GI$9%
-
8/20/2019 Kienitz v. Sconnie Nation, 7thCir
6/7
O #$% &'('))*
WLB GH8G :BDB9:89GJ` 8KGJ H8NB EB:LKB: GHB N8CLB $D GHIJ
AH$(G$WE8AH5 YHIKH HB CIKB9JB: G$ 6$WCI9 8G 9$ E$U8CGU 89: YHIKHIJ
A$JGB: $9 8 AL^CIK YB^JIGB D$E NIBYI9W 89: :$Y9C$8:I9WYIGH$LG
K$JG%
3Y$ GHI9WJ K89 ^B J8I: D$E 2IB9IGa% _IEJG5 :BDB9:89GJ :I:9$G
9BB: G$ LJB GHB K$AUEIWHGB: Y$EX% 3HBU Y89GB: G$ F$KXGHB +8U$E5 9$G
G$ K$FFB9G $9 2IB9IGa`J JXICCJ 8J 8 AH$G$WE8(AHBE $E HIJ 8EGIJGEU
I9 AE$:LKI9W GHIJ A8EGIKLC8E AH$G$WE8AH%3HBEB`J 9$ W$$: EB8J$9 YHU
:BDB9:89GJ JH$LC: ^B 8CC$YB:G$ 8AAE$AEI8GB J$FB$9B BCJB`J
K$AUEIWHGB: BDD$EGJ 8J GHBJG8EGI9W A$I9G I9 GHBIE C8FA$$95 YHB9 J$
F89U 9$9(K$AUEIWHGB: 8CGBE98GINBJ ZI9KCL:I9W J98AJH$GJ GHBU
K$LC:H8NB G8XB9 GHBFJBCNBJ[ YBEB 8N8IC8^CB% 3HB D8IE(LJB
AEINICBWBL9:BE e&)g IJ 9$G :BJIW9B: G$ AE$GBKG C8aU
8AAE$AEI8G$EJ% ,GJW$8C I9JGB8: IJ G$ D8KICIG8GB 8 KC8JJ $D LJBJ
GH8G Y$LC: 9$G ^BA$JJI^CB ID LJBEJ 8CY8UJ H8: G$ 9BW$GI8GB YIGH
K$AUEIWHGAE$AEIBG$EJ% Z+89U K$AUEIWHG $Y9BEJ Y$LC: ^C$KX 8CC
A8E$(:IBJ5 D$E Bf8FACB5 89: GHB 8:FI9IJGE8GINB K$JGJ $D DI9:I9W89:
$^G8I9I9W K$9JB9G DE$F K$AUEIWHG H$C:BEJ Y$LC: DELJ(
GE8GB F89U 8K8:BFIK LJBJ%[6BK$9:5 GHIJ LJB F8U I9cLEB 2IB9IGa`J
C$9W(E89WB K$F(
FBEKI8C $AA$EGL9IGIBJ5 BNB9 GH$LWH IG :$BJ 9$G EB:LKB GHBN8CLB
HB :BEINBJ DE$F GHIJ A8EGIKLC8E AIKGLEB% .B AE$FIJBJHIJ JL^cBKGJ
GH8G GHB AH$G$J YICC ^B CIKB9JB: $9CU D$E :IW9I(DIB: LJBJ% _BYBE
AB$ACB YICC HIEB $E K$$ABE8GB YIGH 2IB9IGa IDGHBU GHI9X GH8G GHB
HIWH iL8CIGU $D HIJ Y$EX YICC F8XB GHBAH$G$J F$EB BDDBKGINB YHB9
LJB: 8W8I9JG GHBFj SLG 2IB9IGa:$BJ 9$G AEBJB9G 89 8EWLFB9G 8C$9W
GHBJB CI9BJ5 89: GHB K$9(
JI:BE8GI$9 I9 GHB AEBKB:I9W A8E8WE8AH IJ 9$G B9$LWH G$ $DDJBGGHB
D8KG GH8G5 ^U GHB GIFB :BDB9:89GJ YBEB :$9B5 8CF$JG 9$9B
-
8/20/2019 Kienitz v. Sconnie Nation, 7thCir
7/7
#$% &'('))* g
$D GHB K$AUEIWHGB: Y$EX EBF8I9B:% 3HB :IJGEIKG K$LEG GHLJEB8KHB:
GHB EIWHG K$9KCLJI$9%
/ __,=+0<
