15
Snapshot of a Successful Life Company Does Size Matter? Industrial Alliance Insurance and Financial Services CIBC World Markets Frontenac Institutional Investor Conference Quebec City, September 18, 2003 1 Snapshot of a Successful Life Company Does Size Matter? CIBC World Markets Frontenac Institutional Investor Conference Quebec City, September 18, 2003 2 Key Success Factors of a Life Company Sound business strategy Good financial strength Strong operational efficiency Which lead to strong growth and high and consistent profits

Key Success Factors Insurance Industry

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Key Success Factors Insurance Industry

Citation preview

Page 1: Key Success Factors Insurance Industry

Snapshot of a Successful Life CompanyDoes Size Matter?Industrial Alliance Insurance and Financial ServicesCIBC World Markets Frontenac Institutional Investor ConferenceQuebec City, September 18, 2003

1

Snapshot of a Successful Life CompanyDoes Size Matter?

CIBC World MarketsFrontenac Institutional Investor Conference

Quebec City, September 18, 2003

2

Key Success Factors of a Life Company

� Sound business strategy� Good financial strength� Strong operational efficiency

Which lead to strong growth andhigh and consistent profits

Page 2: Key Success Factors Insurance Industry

Snapshot of a Successful Life CompanyDoes Size Matter?Industrial Alliance Insurance and Financial ServicesCIBC World Markets Frontenac Institutional Investor ConferenceQuebec City, September 18, 2003

3

Excel in one functional skill

Build dominant positions in chosen marketsStake out position less vulnerable tohead-to-head competitionExploit industry changes

Develop permanent competitive advantages

Sound Business Strategy

Impact of size

-

-

4

Good Financial Strength

Strong asset quality

Adequate actuarial reserves

Proven risk management

Capacity to raise long-term capital

High ratings

Impact of size

---

Page 3: Key Success Factors Insurance Industry

Snapshot of a Successful Life CompanyDoes Size Matter?Industrial Alliance Insurance and Financial ServicesCIBC World Markets Frontenac Institutional Investor ConferenceQuebec City, September 18, 2003

5

Strong Operational Efficiency

Cost-efficient

Competitive and up-to-date technology

Performance-driven environment

Well-developed people system

Impact of size

--

6

Industry Characteristics

� Products No differentiation� Growth potential Moderate for insurance products

High for wealth management� Distribution Distributors have significant power in

consumer purchasing decisions� Fixed costs Represent a small proportion of the

cost structure (beyond a certain criticalmass, relatively few economies of scale)

Conclusion: Distribution is the key

Page 4: Key Success Factors Insurance Industry

Snapshot of a Successful Life CompanyDoes Size Matter?Industrial Alliance Insurance and Financial ServicesCIBC World Markets Frontenac Institutional Investor ConferenceQuebec City, September 18, 2003

7

Industry Characteristics

Claims53%

Compensation19%

Expenses14%

Profit and taxes (incl. IIT)

14%

Distribution of the Price of an Individual Insurance Policy

Example of a UL level cost of insurance policy

Expenses are not a key differentiating factor

8

Sound Business Strategy

Page 5: Key Success Factors Insurance Industry

Snapshot of a Successful Life CompanyDoes Size Matter?Industrial Alliance Insurance and Financial ServicesCIBC World Markets Frontenac Institutional Investor ConferenceQuebec City, September 18, 2003

9

Sound Business StrategyKey Elements of IAG’s Business Strategy

1. Excel in one functional skill: Distribution (underpins strategy)

2. Build dominant positions in chosen markets3. Stake out a position that is less vulnerable to head-to-head

attacks from competitors4. Exploit industry changes (forward-looking management)5. Develop permanent competitive advantages

10

1. Excel in One Functional Skill: Distribution

� The key paradigm of the life insurance industry: lifeinsurance is a product that is “sold to” consumers,not a product that is “bought by” consumers

� Success is therefore achieved through distribution

IAG’s strategyServe all the needs of a segment of distributors, captive or

independent, where our “global offering” can make a difference

Page 6: Key Success Factors Insurance Industry

Snapshot of a Successful Life CompanyDoes Size Matter?Industrial Alliance Insurance and Financial ServicesCIBC World Markets Frontenac Institutional Investor ConferenceQuebec City, September 18, 2003

11

1. Excel in One Functional Skill: Distribution

Insurance brokers

64%

Securities brokers

9%Other

2%

Exclusive agents

25%

Insurance brokers

59%

Exclusive agents

41%

Exclusive Insurance Securities Mutual fundsagents brokers dealers planners1,280 Over 12,000 Over 300 Over 1,000 (new)

IAG’s Key Strength: Manage Large and Multi-Channel Networks

Individual InsuranceH1 2003 sales: $61.3 million

Individual AnnuitiesH1 2003 sales: $365.1 million

12

2. Build Dominant Positions in Chosen Markets

Individual Insurance Segregated FundsTop 52002 Sales Premiums Net sales Assets

1 Sun/Clarica Sun/Clarica Great-West Great-West2 IAG Great-West Sun/Clarica Manulife3 Manulife Manulife IAG Maritime4 Great-West IAG TD Bank Sun/Clarica5 Transamerica Maritime Manulife IAG

IAG marketshare1 12.9% 6.9% 14.4% 7.3%

Among the top 5 providers in each line of businessin which we choose to operate

IAG: Key Player in the Retail Insurance and Annuity Markets

1 2002 figures, except for seg fund assets (June 30, 2003)Sources: CLHIA, LIMRA, IFIC, Investor Economics and Beyond 20/20

Page 7: Key Success Factors Insurance Industry

Snapshot of a Successful Life CompanyDoes Size Matter?Industrial Alliance Insurance and Financial ServicesCIBC World Markets Frontenac Institutional Investor ConferenceQuebec City, September 18, 2003

13

Current Price Pressures

2. Build Dominant Positions in Chosen Markets

� Not a new element� Usually only lasts for a very short period� If pressure is maintained for a longer period, there are only

two possible outcomes for each company:� Move back towards more disciplined pricing� Lose margins

14

3. Stake Out a Position That is Less Vulnerableto Head-to-Head Attacks From Competitors

IAG Avoids Competing on Price Only� Develop a smart product mix

� IAG is not a “single” product company

� Rely on a loyal sales force� Exclusive career agents and dedicated brokers

� More concentrated in the family market (less crowded),while pursuing development in the high-income market

� Stand out with:� New complementary products: RESPs, hedge funds� Original sales concepts: new insured annuities� Innovative features: critical illness refund

Page 8: Key Success Factors Insurance Industry

Snapshot of a Successful Life CompanyDoes Size Matter?Industrial Alliance Insurance and Financial ServicesCIBC World Markets Frontenac Institutional Investor ConferenceQuebec City, September 18, 2003

15

Take Advantage of Convergence in Distribution

� Stock brokers 74% have a life license� Mutual fund agents 60% have a life license� Life agents 65% have a mutual funds license

4. Exploit Industry Changes

And many agents have more than two licenses

16

Year Company Sector

2001 Concorde Mutual fund dealer2002 ISL-Lafferty Securities broker2002 BNP (Canada) Securities broker2002/03 FundEX (75%) Mutual fund dealer2002 Leduc Securities broker2003 Global Allocation Mutual fund dealer2003 Co-operators MF Mutual fund manufacturer

IAG’s Wealth Management Strategy: Recent AcquisitionsAimed at Enhancing Distribution

4. Exploit Industry Changes

Total purchase price: less than $14 million1,000 new brokers and some $4.5 billion in AUA

Page 9: Key Success Factors Insurance Industry

Snapshot of a Successful Life CompanyDoes Size Matter?Industrial Alliance Insurance and Financial ServicesCIBC World Markets Frontenac Institutional Investor ConferenceQuebec City, September 18, 2003

17

5. Develop Permanent Competitive Advantages

� We help our distributors grow their business,attract new agents and improve their head office

� No key decision is made without their input� We focus on distributors for which our support

can make a difference

IAG Focuses on Distribution

18

Good Financial Strength

Page 10: Key Success Factors Insurance Industry

Snapshot of a Successful Life CompanyDoes Size Matter?Industrial Alliance Insurance and Financial ServicesCIBC World Markets Frontenac Institutional Investor ConferenceQuebec City, September 18, 2003

19

Good Financial Strength

Strong asset quality

Adequate actuarial reserves

Proven risk management

Capacity to raise long-term capital

High ratings

Impact of size

---

20

Prudent Long-Term Management Approach

� Strong asset quality� Everyone agrees that IAG has a high, above-average

quality of assets

� Adequate actuarial reserves� Compares favorably to peers on any criteria (PADs, EmV)� Conservative seg fund reserving: highest standard at CTE 80

� Proven risk management� Conservatively-designed seg fund guarantee� Optimal/limited use of reinsurance: not used to front-end profits

Good Financial Strength

Page 11: Key Success Factors Insurance Industry

Snapshot of a Successful Life CompanyDoes Size Matter?Industrial Alliance Insurance and Financial ServicesCIBC World Markets Frontenac Institutional Investor ConferenceQuebec City, September 18, 2003

21

Capacity to Raise Long-Term CapitalSuccessful Issue of Innovative Tier 1 (IATS)on July 4, 2003� Issue of $150 million

� Permanent capital now accounts for 87% of total capital

� Securities carry an annual yield of 5.714%� Represents a spread of 120 basis points over 10-year

Canada bonds� IATS spread is only 15 basis points higher than Sun Life,

Manulife and Great-West

22

High Ratings

Rating agency Rating Level Trend First rating

Standard & Poor’s A+ 4/21 Stable 19951

DBRS IC-2 2/5 Stable 2000A.M. Best A (Excellent) 3/16 Stable 1995

1 Originally from CBRS

� A+ rating from S&P, similar to that of 3 out of the 5 largestCanadian banks

� Rating influence on ability to attract new business� Very low for retail and group insurance businesses� Somewhat important for large Group Pensions accounts

Page 12: Key Success Factors Insurance Industry

Snapshot of a Successful Life CompanyDoes Size Matter?Industrial Alliance Insurance and Financial ServicesCIBC World Markets Frontenac Institutional Investor ConferenceQuebec City, September 18, 2003

23

Strong Operational Efficiency

24

Strong Operational Efficiency

Cost-efficient

Competitive and up-to-date technology

Performance-driven environment

Well-developed people system

Impact of size

--

Page 13: Key Success Factors Insurance Industry

Snapshot of a Successful Life CompanyDoes Size Matter?Industrial Alliance Insurance and Financial ServicesCIBC World Markets Frontenac Institutional Investor ConferenceQuebec City, September 18, 2003

25

IAG is a Low-Cost Producer

� Our strategy favours policy count over size� IAG sells over 100,000 individual life insurance policies a year

(17% market share in 2002)

� Top management’s ability to penetrate to businessmicrolevels

� Culture: one sponsor for every dollar of expenses� Quebec City is a cost-efficient location to operate

Cost-Efficient

We improve what we measure

26

Competitive and Up-To-Date Technology

� Invest in technology if strategic, important and profitable� Close follower, except where we can make a difference

� Software at points-of-sale� Customer relationship management (CRM) for agents

� Technology decision-making process is geared to meetreal needs and deliver benefits

� Job rotation for information system users and professionals� Investments chosen by head of business unit (not head of IS)

Page 14: Key Success Factors Insurance Industry

Snapshot of a Successful Life CompanyDoes Size Matter?Industrial Alliance Insurance and Financial ServicesCIBC World Markets Frontenac Institutional Investor ConferenceQuebec City, September 18, 2003

27

Focus on Achieving Long-Term Goals

� Performance-driven environment� Managers responsible for both the top and the bottom line� Demanding work place� Systematically learn from mistakes

� Well-developed people system� Focus on performance and motivation� Low turnover rate: 5%� Average length of service with the Company: 18 years� Training programs: 3% of payroll

Strong Operational Efficiency

28

And the Future...

Page 15: Key Success Factors Insurance Industry

Snapshot of a Successful Life CompanyDoes Size Matter?Industrial Alliance Insurance and Financial ServicesCIBC World Markets Frontenac Institutional Investor ConferenceQuebec City, September 18, 2003

29

And the Future...

� Beyond a certain critical mass, that IAG easily satisfies,size is not a key success factor

� Sound business strategy matters more than size� Excel in one functional skill: Distribution

� IAG’s distribution strategy is what distinguishes it fromits competitors

Well-Nurtured Success Factors Leadto Successful Results

IAG can be as successful in the futureas it has in the past

30

Snapshot of a Successful Life CompanyDoes Size Matter?

CIBC World MarketsFrontenac Institutional Investor Conference

Quebec City, September 18, 2003