JW[f:WY[`` VWd9dTW[fWdTWiWYg`Y]s_bXW` V[W9dTW[fWd[` VWdYS`lW`NW^fg`fWdVWdDaeg`Y ha` ESdj g`V =`YW^e4!Hda^WfSd[WdS^^WdDs`VWd%hWdW[`[YfWgUZ !<[WeWlu`VW`VWDaeg`Y VduU]fVSe`Sfud^[UZWJfdWTWVWd9dTW[fWdSge%YWYWVW YW_W[`eS_W>W[`V%VSe[`fWd`Sf[a`S^hWdTg`VW`WCSb[fS^%[`fWd`Sf[a`S^WJa^[VSd[fsflg uTW`g`V V[W9]f[a`eW[`ZW[flg eUZSX'XW`(9gUZ V[WAA(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^WZSffWS`XS`Yeh[W VSlg TW[YWfdSYW`%V[W9dTW[fWdS^^WdDs`VWd[_ ?W[efWVWebda^WfSd[eUZW`A`fWd`Sf[a`S^[e_gelgWdl[WZW`(

9`YWe[UZfeVWdTWeUZ^Wg`[YfW`Cd[WYehadTWdW[fg`YW`VWdA_bWd[S^[efW`XSrfWV[WAA(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^WSgXVW`A`fWd`Sf[a`S^WJal[S^[efW`]a`YdWeeW`[` JfgffYSdf+3*1%CabW`ZSYW+3+*g`V :SeW^+3+, _SrYWTW`VW:WeUZ^ueeW%V[WS^^WHSdfW[W`lg W[`W_W`feUZ[WVW`W`CS_bX YWYWVW`E[^[fSd[e_geg`V V[W[_bWd[S^[ef[eUZWCd[WYeYWXSZdhWdbX^[UZfWfW`(9gX VW_A`fWd`Sf[a'`S^W` Jal[S^[efW`'Ca`YdWr[` JfgffYSdf +3*1 efW^^fWDW`[` YW_W[`eS__[fIaeS DgjW_TgdYPgeSflS`fdsYW%V[WVWdha` :WTWW[`YWTdSUZfW`IWea^gf[a`dWha^gf[a`sdWA`ZS^fhWd^[WZW`(<S`SUZea^^fWV[W9dTW[fWd]^SeeWg`V TWea`'VWdeV[W9dTW[fWd\gYW`V![_ ?W[efWVWdMt^]WdhWdTduVWdg`Yg`V VWeJal[S'^[e_ge WdlaYWg`V ekefW_Sf[eUZ_[f C^SeeW`TWigrfeW[WdXu^^f!iWdVW`%eaVSr V[W]d[WYeiuf[YWA_bWd[S^[efW`e[W[UZfXud[ZdWPiWU]W_[rTdSgUZW`]a``fW`( <Wdha` DW`[` g`V IaeS DgjW_TgdY hadYWeUZ^SYW`Wg`V ha_Ca`YdWr S`YW`a__W`W JUZ^grSTeUZ`[ffVWdIWea^gf[a` ZSffWXa^YW`VW`Nadf^Sgf4

!<daZf VWd9geTdgUZW[`WeCd[WYWe%ea e[`V [` VW`TWfW[^[YfW`Ds`VWd`V[W9dTW[fWdg`V [ZdWbSd^S_W`fSd[eUZWMWdfdWfWdhWdbX^[UZfWf%S^^WeSgXlg'T[WfW`%g_ VW9geTdgUZVWeCd[WYWeVgdUZ9`iW`Vg`Y W`febdWUZW`VWdE[f'fWlg hWdZ[`VWd`%V[We[UZ\W`SUZVWdMWdeUZsdXg`YVWeC^SeeW`]S_bXWeg`VVWdS^^YW_W[`W`ba^[f[eUZW`J[fgSf[a` `SfgdYW_sr s`VWd`g`V efW[YWd`(>S^^eVWdCd[WYVW``aUZ(SgeTdWUZW`ea^^fW%e[`V e[WhWdbX^[UZfWf%XudVWeeW`dSeUZW:WW`V[Yg`YW[`lgfdWfWg`V _[f S"^^WCdsXfW VSZ[` lg efdWTW`%g_ V[W

VLK;ZVW Cd[WYZWdTW[YWXuZdfWi[dfeV[SXf^[UZWg`V ba^[f[eUZWCd[eWlgd ba^['f[eUZW9gXd[[ffW^g`YVWdMa^]eeUZ[UZfW`g`V lgd :WeUZ^Wg`[Yg`YVWeJfgdlWeVWd]Sb[fS^[ef[eUZWC^SeeW`ZWddeV[SXfSgelg`uflW`( !+

<[WeWdKW[VWdJfgffYSdfWdIWea^gf[a` igdVW[` VW9`f[]d[WYeTWeUZ^ueeW`VWdA`fWd`Sf[a`S^WJal[S^[efW`]a`YdWeeW[` CabW`ZSYW +3+* g`V :SeW^+3+, itdf^[UZ i[WVWdZa^fg`V Wd`WgfTWefsf[Yf(NW[fWdTWeUZ^arVWdCa`YdWr[` CabW`ZSYW`%VSr S^^WHSdfW[WVWd++(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^W!S` VWdi[WVWdZa^fSgeYWebdaUZW`W`MWdbX^[UZfg`YVWdeal[S^[ef[eUZWMWdfdWfWd[` VW`HSd^S'_W`fW`%V[WIuefg`YW` _[f S^^WCdsXfWlg TW]s_bXWg`V V[WE[ffW Z[Wd'Xudlg hWdiW[YWd`"f'%XWeflgZS^fW`ZSTW`(

<[WHSdfW[WVWd++(A`fW_S[[[a`S(AW(VSeZW[rfV[WESeeW`VWdE[fY^[WV(Wd(^WZ`fWV[WMWdegUZWVWdGbbadfg`[efW`%VW ESdj[e_ge lg'dWh[V[WdW`g`V[Z` eW[`WedWha^gf[a`sdWA`ZS^felg TWdSgTW`%_WZdXSUZST(<[WEWZdZW[f[`VW`>uZdg`YW`VWd_W[efW`HSdfW[WVg^VWfW\WVaUZVW`Gbbadfg`[e_ge%luUZfWfW[Z` VgdUZbd[`l[b[W`^aeWPgYWefs`V`[eeWZaUZ(<[W >uZdg`YW`W[`[YWdHSdfW[W`iSdW` ha_ Gbbadfg`[e_ge TWZWddeUZf(E[f VWd=`fi[U]^g`YVWeA_bWd[S^[e_geTW_sUZf[YfW`e[UZSUZ VW_KaVW>d[WVd[UZ=`YW^e"nV[WGbbadfg`[efW` lg`WZ_W`VVWdHSdfW[hadefs`VW(VWdEWZdlSZ VWd9TYWadV'`WfW`_S`VSfWg`V VWdW[fW`VW`>g`]f[a`W` [` VWdA`fWd`Sf[a`S^W%M[%WmWd[UZf[YW:WeUZ^ueeWVWdA`fWd`Sf[a`S^WigdVW` [` VWdbdS]f[eUZW9dTW[fVgdUZV[WGbbadfg`[efW` hWdXs^eUZfaVWd[UZfVgdUZYWXuZdf(

9^e V[WA_bWd[S^[efWVW`WdefWNW^f]d[WYTWYS``W`%TWi[^^[YfWV[WHSd^S_W`feXdS]f[a`WVWdYdtrfW`g`V W[`X^grdW[UZefW`HSdfW[WVWd@(A`fWd'`Sf[a`S^W [ZdW` dsgTWd[eUZW`[_bWd[S^[ef[eUZW`IWY[Wdg`YWV[WCd[WYe']dWV[fW(<[WHSdfW[XuZdg`YW`eWflfWV[WCdSXfVWd9dTW[fWdTWiWYg`Y[ZdWdDs`VWdVSXudW[`%VW [_bWd[S^[ef[eUZW`Cd[WYlg g`fWdefuflW`(J[WhWdd[WfW`V[W9dTW[fWd]^SeeW[ZdWeW[YW`W`DS`VWe%V[WA`fWd`Sf[a`S^Wg`V VW Jal[S'^[e_ge( AZ`W S^^WY[`Y V[WIW[UZefSYeXdS]f[aVWdVWgfeUZW`Jal[S^VW_a']dSf[WSgXVW_NWYWVWeeUZsd[V^[UZefW`MWddSfeS_ bda^WfSd[eUZW`A`fWd'`Sf[a`S^[e_ge hadS`( <[WAA(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^WTdSUZeUZ_sZ^[UZlgeS__W`%VWdGbbadfgd[[e_geZSffWe[WlgYdg`VWYWd[UZfWf(

Fgd V[WTa^eUZWi[ef[eUZWHSdfW[[` Igr^S`V g`fWd VWd>uZdg`Y DW`[`eXuZdfWeaXadfg`V aZ`WJUZiS`]W` V[W:WeUZ^ueeWVWdA`fWd`Sf[a`S^WVgdUZ%[`VW_ e[W_[f S^^WE[ffW^` YWYWVW [_bWd[S^[ef[eUZW`Cd[WY]s_bXfW(J[WWd_gf[YfWV[W:WefW VWd[`fWd`Sf[a`S^W9dTW[fWd]^SeeW%V[Wlad`WdXu^^fhadVW Kdu__Wd` VWdA`fWd`Sf[a`S^WefS`VW`(

FWTW VW :a^eUZWi[][ `SZ_W` 'U iW`` SgUZVgdUZJUZiS`]g`YW` g`V

! !A`fWd`Sf[a`S^WdJal[S^[efW`'Ca`YdWr JfgffYSdf +3*1!%:Wd^[` +3*1%J( +*,(" !A`fWd`Sf[a`S^WdJal[S^[efW`'Ca`YdWr[` CabW`ZSYW`!%:Wd^[` +3+*%J( -/(

L`]^SdZW[fW` YWZW__f' V[WeWdT[eUZW`Jal[S^[efW`%V[WTg^YSd[eUZWHSdfW[VWd=`YZWdl[YW`%V[WJal[S^VW_a]dSf[WVWeCt`[YdW[UZeHa^W`g`V D[fSgW`e%V[WZa^^s`V[eUZWKd[Tg`[efW` g`V E[`VWdZW[fW[` S`VWdW HSdfW[WVW`CS_bX YWYWVW [_bWd[S^[ef[eUZWCd[WYSgX(

9gUZ [` <WgfeUZ^S`VSZ_ V[W?dgbbW VWdD[`]W` [``WdZS^TVWdJal[S^'VW_a]dSf[Wg`fWdVWd>uZdg`Y ha` CSd^D[WT]`WUZf%IaeS DgjW_TgdY%;^SdSP(Wf][`%>dS`lEWTd[`Y% N\^ZW^_ H[WU]g`V S`VWdWg`hWdluY^[UZYWYWVW`[_bWd[S^[ef[eUZWCd[WYJfW^^g`Y( J[W ZSffW eW[f^S`YW_ [ZdW` @SgbfefarYWYWV[WCd[WYehadTWdW[fg`YW`VWeVWgfeUZWA_bWd[S^[e_geYWd[UZfWf%VW`ha^]eXW[`V^[UZW`;ZSdS]fWd VWeA_bWd[S^[e_geg`V E[^[fSd[e_ge W`f^Sdhfg`VS^eW[`l[YWVW`A`fWd`Sf[a`S^[e_ge hWdfW[V[Yf(AZdCS_bX W`febdSUZha^^ g`VYS`l VW` Sf[a`S^W` A`fWdWeeW`VWeVWgfeUZWMa^]We(

<[WVWgfeUZW`D[`]W` fdSfW`SgUZefs`V[Y YWYWVW`Gbbadfg`[e_ge [` VWd9dTW[fWdTWiWYg`YSgX(A_ ?WYW`eSfllg VW`dWha^gf[a`sdW`:WefdWTg`YW`VWdD[`]W` XtdVWdfWV[W>uZdg`Y VWdVWgfeUZW`Jal[S^VW_a]dSf[WV[WdWXad'_[ef[eUZWMWdeg_bXg`Y[` VWdHSdfW[g`V VW`?WiWd]eUZSXfW`(<[W abbad'fg`[ef[eUZW=`fSdfg`Y VWdVWgfeUZW`Jal[S^VW_a]dSf[WiSd _[f VW_J[WYVWeGbbadfg`[e_ge [` VWd++(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^WW`Y hWdTg`VW`%YS^f VaUZ V[WVWgfeUZWJal[S^VW_a]dSf[W[` VWdA`fWd`Sf[a`S^WS^eV[WfZWadWf[eUZWg`V ba^['f[eUZW>uZdWd[`( <[W Gbbadfg`[efW` bdabSY[WdfW`[UZf VW` C^SeeW`]S_bXVWeHda^WfSd[SfeYWYWV[W:agdYWa[e[W%ea`VWd` V[W9dTW[feYW_W[`eUZSXf_[fVW_ CSb[fS^%efSff dWha^gf[a`sdWESeeW`S]f[a`W` lg adYS`[e[WdW`%W`fi[]']W^fWe[We[UZlg ]^W[`TudYWd^[UZW`HSd^S_W`fSd[Wd`(J[W^WZ`fW V[Weal[S'A[ef[eUZWIWha^gf[a` ST g`V ia^^fW` V[WJal[S^VW_a]dSf[W lg W[`WdTudYWd'^[UZWIWXad_bSdfW[_SUZW`(

?mYW`VSeCdWTeYWeUZiudVWeGbbadfg`[e_ge [` VWd[`fWd`Sf[a`S^W` 9d'TW[fWdTWiWYg`YXuZdfWDW`[` W[`W g`WdT[ff^[UZWCS_bX( Pg Cd[WYeTWY[``ZSffWV[WtefWddW[UZ[eUZW:agdYWa[e[WDW`[` [` W[`W_YS^[l[eUZW?WXs`Y`[eW[`YW]Wd]Wdf(JaXadf `SUZeW[`Wd=`f^Seeg`Y hWdtXXW`f^[UZfWWdV[WKZWeWo<[W9gXYSTW`VWddWha^gf[a`sdW`Jal[S^VW_a]dSf[W[_ Wgdabs[eUZWCd[WYW!(A`([Z`W`TWYdu`VWfWDW`[` eW[`W>adVWdg`Y%W[`WWgWA`fWd`Sf[a`S^Wlg(eUZSX'XW`%VWdW9gXYSTWWeeW[` _ueeW%V[WTudYWd^[UZWI[UZfg`Y [``WdZS^T VWdeal[S^[ef[eUZW:WiWYg`Y W`feUZ[WVW`g`V g`i[VWddgX^[UZlg TWeW[f[YW`(

E[f ha^^W_ MWdfdSgW[` V[WCdSXf VWd9dTW[fWd]^SeeWWd]^sdfWDW`[`iW`[Y ebsfWdVW`9dTW[fWd S^^WdDs`VWd4o<[Wbda^WfSd[eUZWA`fWd`Sf[a`S^W[ef `[UZf g`fWdYWYS`YW`%g`V e[Wi[dV `[UZf g`fWdYWZW`(<[W9dTW[fWd_SeeW`iWdVW`umWdS^^W@[`VWd`[eeWZ[`iWY V[W`WgWA`fWd`Sf[a`S^WeUZSXXW`%!

+ N( A(DW`[`%9geYWisZ^fWNWd]W[` liW[ :s`VW`% :V( A%<[Wfl MWd^SY%:Wd^[` +3//%J(1..(

PgeS__W`YWTdaUZW`iSd V[Wha` VW`Gbbadfg`[efW` lWdeftdfWAA(A`fWd`S'f[a`S^W%STWdVWd?W[ef VWebda^WfSd[eUZW`A`fWd`Sf[a`S^[e_ge WTfW[` VW`9dTW[fWd_SeeW`(=e iSd `afiW`V[Y%[Z`W` VW`Gbbadfg`[e_ge S^eLdeSUZWVWe]SfSefdabZS^WPgeS__W`TdgUZWeVWdAA(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^Wlg lW[YW`%g_V[WMadSgeeWflg`Ylgd =dd[UZfg`YW[`WdWgW`%XWefW`eal[S^[ef[eUZWA`fWd'`Sf[a`S^Wlg eUZSXXW`(!L`eWdW9gXYSTWZW[rf\Wflf4g`TWV[`YfWd%aXXW`WdCS_bX YWYWVW`[`fWd`Sf[a`S^W Gbbadfg`[e_ge g`V YWYWV[W%V[W[Z`VWU]W`((( ES` VSdXhad V[WeWd9gXYSTW[UZflgduU]fdWfW`(!+ Ja ]^Sd g`V]a`eWcgW`fXad_g^[WdfWDW`[` V[W9gXYSTWVWdPW[f(

$)=d d[WXVW 9dTW[fWd`lg4 !<[W(AA(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^W[ef faf%ha_ Gbbadfg`[e'

_ge TWe[WYf(F[WVWd_[f VW_Gbbadfg`[e_ge% We WTWV[W((( ha_ Gbbad'fg`[e_ge YWesgTWdfWAAA(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^W !,

<gdUZV[W9gX`SZ_W ha` MWdT[`Vg`YW`lg ^[`]W` ?dgbbW` [` hWdeUZ[W'VW`WDs`VWd`TWdW[fWfW`V[W:a^eUZWi[][VW PgeS__W`eUZ^gr VWdA`fWd'`Sf[a`S^Whad( A` V[WeWdI[UZfg`Y SdTW[fWfWDW`[` SgUZSgXVWdA`fWd`Sf[a'`S^W` Jal[S^[ef[eUZWCa`XWdW`l[` P[__WdiS^V ha_ /( T[e 2( JWbfW_TWd+3+/( DW`[`^WYfW[_ 9gXfdSYVWePW`fdS^]a_[fWWeVWdJal[S^VW_a]dSf[eUZW`9dTW[fWdbSdfW[Igr^S`Ve #:a^eUZWi[][$V[WIWea^gf[a` !<WdNW^f]d[WYg`VV[W9gXYSTWVWdJal[S^VW_a]dSf[W!eai[W W[`!ES`[XWef!had( <[W<a]g'_W`fWXadVWdfW`V[WMWdiW[YWdg`YVWdCd[WYe]dWV[fWVgdUZV[Weal[S^[ef[eUZW`HSd^S_W`feXdS]f[a`W`(VW`IuU]fd[ff VWdeal[S^[ef[eUZWE[`[efWd Sge VW`IWY[Wdg`YW>dS`]dW[UZe%:W^Y[W`eg`V =`Y^S`Ve%V[W:W]s_bXg`Y VWeJal[S^UZSgh[`[e_geg`V V[WMWdgdfW[^g`YVWee[UZabbae[f[a`W^ YWTsdVW`VW`PW`fdg_e g_ CSgfe]k%VW` WYS^W`g`V [^^WYS^W`CS_bX YWYWVW [_bW'd[S^[ef[eUZW`Cd[WY%V[WGdYS`[e[Wdg`Yha` ESeeW`S]f[a`W`%i[W MWdTduVW'dg`YW`S` VW >da`fW`%t]a`a_[eUZW g`V ba^[f[eUZWJfdW[]e%JfdSrW`VW_a`'efdSf[a`W`g`V V[WL_iS`V^g`Y VWe[_bWd[S^[ef[eUZW`Cd[WYWe[` VW :ud'YWd]d[WYlg_ Jfgdl VWeA_bWd[S^[e_ge[` \WVW_DS`VW(

<[W:a^eUZWi[][ia^^fW` V[WJal[S^[efW` Sge VW_JUZiS`]W` g`V 9TiSd'fW` lg_ g`hWd_W[V^[UZW`:dgUZ _[f VW_Gbbadfg`[e_ge g`V PW`fd[e_geXuZdW`(<[WCa`XWdW`lWZ`fWV[WIWea^gf[a` DW`[`e_[f +3 YWYW+, Jf[_'_W` ST(E[f VWdEWZdZW[fef[__fW` SgUZV[WTW[VWMWdfdWfWdVWd!?dgbbWA`fWd`Sf[a`S^W!%VWdWMWdZS^fW`IaeS DgjW_TgdY[` W[`W_:d[WXSge VW_?WXs`Y`[ehWdgdfW[^fW(

<Se ha` VWdCa`XWdW`lTWeUZ^aeeW`WES`[XWefWd]^sdfW%VSr VWdCd[WYW[`[_bWd[S^[ef[eUZWdeW[%WeTWlW[UZ`WfWV[Weal[S^UZSgh[`[ef[eUZWDaeg`Y ha` VWd!MSfWd^S`VehWdfW[V[Yg`Y!S^eDuYW%g`V hWdgdfW[^fWeaiaZ^ V[W:Wi[^^[Yg`Y

+ N( A(DW`[`%Js_f^[UZWNWd]W%:V( OMAAA%N[W`':Wd^[` +3,3%J( 1-(, =TW`VS%J( 3+Q(

VWdCd[WYe]dWV[fWVgdUZV[Weal[S^[ef[eUZWHSd^S_W`feXdS]f[a`WS^eSgUZV[W:gdYXd[WVW`eba^[f[](<Se ES`[XWefhWd_[WV\WVaUZ%V[WJal[S^UZSgh[`[efW`g`V V[W]Sb[fg^S`fW`ZSXfWPW`fd[efWlg hWdgdfW[^W`5Wei[We ]W[`W`dWha'^gf[a`sdW`9geiWY Sge VW_Cd[WYWg`V d[WXVSeHda^WfSd[Sf`[UZflg ESeeW`'S]f[a`W` SgX%WeXadVWdfW`aUZ`[UZfW[`_S^W[`VWgf[YV[WJf[__STYSTWYWYW`

(V[WCd[WYe]dWV[fW(Kdafl V[WeWdJUZisUZW ef[__fW` SgUZV[W:a^eUZWi[][ VW_ES`[XWeflg%

iW[^ WeVW Cd[WYd[UZf[YUZSdS]fWd[e[WdfWg`V W[`WdefWdJUZd[ff[` VWdI[UZ'fg`Y W[`We[`fWd`Sf[a`S^W CS_bXWeYWYWVW [_bWd[S^[ef[eUZW`Cd[WY%W[`WdefWdJUZd[fflg_ :dgUZ_[f VW_aXXW`W`Jal[S^UZSgh[`[e_ge g`V hWdefWU]fW`Gbbadfg`[e_ge iSd( <Se TWVWgfW`VefW=dYWT`[eVWdCa`XWdW`liSd VWdPg'eS__W`eUZ^gr VWdW`feUZ[WVW`W`A`fWd`Sf[a`S^[efWlg W[`WdYWeUZ^aeeW`W`?dgbbW%V[We[UZ!P[__WdiS^VW D[`]W! `S``fW( J[WigdVW VWdCW[_ VWdebsfWdW+++(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^W(

<[WP[__WdiS^VWdCa`XWdW`lTWeUZ^Wg`[YfWVW`C^sdg`YebdalWr [` VW`eal[S^VW_a]dSf[eUZWHSdfW[W`5uTWdS^T[^VWfWe[UZ[`fWd`Sf[a`S^[ef[eUZW?dgbbW`( A`Xa^YWVWdhWdZWWdW`VW`9gei[d]g`YW` VWeCd[WYWe%VWdg`eSY'TSdWDW[VWVWdMt^]Wdg`V VWd9Y[fSf[a` VWdA`fWd`Sf[a`S^[efW`igUZeW`VWdCS_bXYW[efg`V V[WdWha^gf[a`sdW9]f[h[fsf VWdESeeW`(

9^e V[WA`fWd`Sf[a`S^WJal[S^[ef[eUZWCa`XWdW`l[` C[W`fZS[ha_ ,.( T[e-*( 9bd([++3+0fSYfW%XadVWdfW`V[WMWdfdWfWdVWdP[__WdiS^VWdD[`]W` _[fVW`:a^eUZWi[][ S` VWdJb[flW Wd`Wgf%V[WJal[S^[efW` lg hWdbX^[UZfW`%V[WJal[S^UZSgh[`[efWg`V PW`fd[efWlg W`f^SdhWg`V W`feUZ[WVW`lg TW]s_b'XW`!SgX V[WF[WVWd^SYWVWdW[YW`W`:agdYWa[e[WZ[`lgSdTW[fWg`V VW`[_bWd[S^[ef[eUZW`Cd[WY[` VW:udYWd]d[WYYWYWVW W[Y(W`W`A_bWd[S^[e_geg_lgiS`VW^`( J[WeUZ^gYWW[`WIW[ZWVW_a]dSf[eUZWd>adVWdg`YWhad%g`fWd[Z`W` V[W=dd[UZfg`YVWdVW_a]dSf[eUZW`IWbgT^[] S^e qTWdYS`Ylg_CS_bX g_ V[Wba^[f[eUZWESUZf VWeHda^WfSd[Sfe%XudVW`Jal[S^[e_ge( <[W=`feUZ^[Wrg`YhWdgdfW[^fWSTWdV[Wha` VW`PW`fd[efWbdabSY[WdfW[ddWXuZ'dW`VWDaeg`Y W[`We!VW_a]dSf[eUZW>d[WVW`e"("%iW[^ W[` ea^UZWdg`fWdVW`VS_S^[YW:WV[`Yg`YWg`_tY^[UZ iSd(

9TWdSgUZV[WeWCa`XWdW`lW`feUZ[WVe[UZ[UZfXudW[`WW`feUZ^aeeW`WdWha'^gf[a`sdWD[`[W%ea`VWd`XudW[`WlW`fd[ef[eUZWHae[f[a` SgXVW_:aVW` W[`Wdeal[S^bSl[X[ef[eUZW`>d[WVW`e^aeg`Y(

<WdMWdfdWfWdVWd"4:dW_WdD[`]edSV[]S^W`ZSffWe[UZVWdP[__WdiS^VWdD[`]W` S`YWeUZ^aeeW`%VSYWYW`ef[__fW` V[WTW[VWMWdfdWfWdVWdo?dgbbWA`fWd`Sf[a`S^W!SgUZ[` C[W`fZS[ [UZfXudV[WMadeUZ^sYWVWdD[`]W`(

<[WeW[`]a`eWcgW`fW@S^fg`Y efS`V [_ N[VWdebdgUZlg VW_ _gf[YW`dWha^gf[a`sdW CS_bX VWdD[`]W` [` <WgfeUZ^S`V(CSd^ D[WT]`WUZf(VWd

Y^uZW`VWIWha^gf[a`sd% W`fXS^fWfWT[e lg eW[`WdMWdZSXfg`YW[`WdWYWKsf[Y']W[flgd JS__^g`Y VWddWha^gf[a`sdW`CdsXfW(=d Wd]^sdfWTWdW[fe+3+.%VSr\WVWeal[S^[ef[eUZW'HSdfW[[ZdW`>W[`V%VW`>W[`VVWe[`fWd`Sf[a`S^W` Hda^W'fSd[Sfe(h[d`4W[YW`WDS`VWTW]s_bXW`_ueeW( <WdCd[WYlW[YWVWgf^[UZ%VSrVSeNaZ^WdYWZWS^^WdMt^]Wdg`fdW``TSd hWd]`ubXfeW[%VWeZS^T]t``W VWdC^SeeW`]S_bX `gd [`fWd`Sf[a`S^ YWXuZdfiWdVW`(=d XadVWdfWg`WdT[ff^[UZW`C^SeeW`]S_bX YWYWVW`[_bWd[S^[ef[eUZWCd[WY(F[UZf :gdYXd[WVW`%:gdY']d[WYeW[afiW`V[Y( !<Wd@SgbfXW[`VVWeVWgfeUZWMa^]WeefWZf[` <WgfeUZ'^S`V! %ea d[WXWdVW_VWgfeUZWMa^]Wlg( <S_[f `sZWdfW e[UZV[WVWgfeUZW`D[`]W` eWZdefSd] VW`Daeg`YW` VWdTa^eUZWi[ef[eUZWHSdfW[(GbXWd_gf[YXuZdfWe[WVW`CS_bX YWYWV[WW[YW`W[_bWd[S^[ef[eUZW:agdYWa[e[W(

! W[`W_:d[WXS` V[WP[__WdiS^VWd Ca`XWdW`lXadVWdfWCSd D[WT]`WUZfV[WeWSgX%VSr e[WW[` ]uZ`We :W]W``f`[e lg_ C^SeeW`]S_bX ST^WYW_tYW(F[UZf C^SeeW`ZSd_a`[W%ea`VWd` C^SeeW`]S_bX XudVW`>d[WVWg`V XudV[Weal[S^[ef[eUZWIWha^gf[a` ea^^fWe[Wbda]^S_[WdW`(=d WdiSdfWfW%VSr V[WCa`'XWdW`lV[WJUZiS`]W`VW` g`V PtYWd`VW`hadisdfebW[feUZW%g`hWdetZ`^[UZ?Wd[UZfuTWdV[WXS^eUZW`Jal[S^[efW` ZS^fWg`V e[UZha` VWdhWdZs`Y`[eha^^W`Ha^[f[] VWd!HSdfW[W[g_uf[Y]W[f! aeeSYW(!9gUZ IaeS DgjW_TgdY ZSffWTWdW[fe+3+/ _[f YdarWd:[ffWd]W[f[` W[`W_9df[]W^ VW`eUZs`V^[UZWMWddSfVWdIWXad_[efW` g`V VWeCSgfe]keUZW` PW`fd[e_ge YWYW[rW^f(<Wd9df[]W^igdVW [` VWdWdefWFg__Wd VWd+3+/ ZWdSgeYWYWTW`W`[^^WYS^W`PW[feUZd[XfVWdD[`]W` !<[W A`fWd`Sf[a`S^W!S^eDW[fSdf[]WhWdtXXW`f^[UZf(IaeS DgjW_'TgdYTdS`V_Sd]fW CSgfe]k%VWd%VW`MWddSfVWdIWXad_[efW`W`feUZg^V[YW`V%YWeUZd[WTW`ZSffW%V[WA`fWd`Sf[a`S^WeW[ ![_ iWeW`f^[UZWW[` >d[WVW`e'_efdg_Waf!% STWd!]W[` i[d]eS_We NWd]lWgY[_ Cd[WYW!(!BWVaUZeUZsflfW`V[WD[`]W` LdeSUZW`%Ia^^Wg`V DWTW`eVSgWdVWeGbbadfg`[e_ge XS^eUZW[` 'g`V WdiSdfWfWlg V[WeWdPW[f`aUZ !V[WdWffW`VWKSf lgd N[WVWdZWdefW^^g`YVWe>d[WVW`ei[W VWdA`fWd`Sf[a`S^W!. ha` VW`eal[S^VW_a]dSf[eUZWHSd'fW[W`%V[W[` VWdKSf lg NWd]lWgYW VWdIWXad_[efW`YWiadVW iSdW`( 9gUZVSeNWeW`VWePW`fd[e_ge S^eW[`Wd>ad_ VWeGbbadfg`[e_ge igdVW ha` VW`D[`]W` lg`sUZef `[UZf]^Sd Wd]S``f( J[WY[`YW _[fVW` PW`fd[efW lgeS__W`%iW[^ e[WZaXXfW`%i[W >dS`l EWZd[`Y [_ 9bd[^ +3+0 e'UZd[WT%VSr !V[WHSdfW[ha` VWdeUZiWdWCd[e[e%[` V[We[WVgdUZVW`.( 9gYgef YWefudlfiadVW` eW[%YW`WeW`]t``fW% _ueeW g`V iWdVW"!%g`V liSd VgdUZV[WhWdW[`[YfWGbba'

! !<a]g_W`fW g`V ESfWd[S^[W`lgd ?WeUZ[UZfWVWdVWgfeUZW`9dTW[fWdTWiWYg`Y!%IW[ZW@%:V( +%<[Wfl MWd^SY%:Wd^[` +3/2%J( +0/(

, J[WZWWTW`VS%J( ,--),-.(- =TW`VS%J( +.^[(. =TW`VS%J( +.0(/ =TW`VS%J( --3(

e[f[a` ![``WdZS^TVWdHSdfW[g`V SgXVW_:aVW` VWdHSdfW["f'(<[WVWgfeUZW`D[`]W` Wd]S``fW`WdefebsfWdV[WFafiW`V[Y]W[f%e[UZeaiaZ^ ha` VWaXXW`W`i[W hWdefWU]fW`Gbbadfg`[efW` ha^^efs`V[Ylg fdW``W`(J[WWddW[UZfW``[UZfV[Wbd[`l[b[W^^WC^SdZW[fg`V CdSXfVWdTa^eUZWi[ef[eUZW`HSdfW[%V[WTWdW[fe[_ Esdl +3+/ [` VW ha` DW`[` SgeYWSdTW[fWfW`KZWeWXudV[WCa`XWdW`lVWd9ge^S`Ve'JW]f[a`W` VWdJ<9HI #:$ ]^Sd SgeYWebdaUZW`ZSffW4!=e isdWW[`WeUZsV^[UZWA^^ge[a`%SgXVW N[WVWdSgXTSgW[`Wdi[d]^[UZeal[S^[ef[eUZW`A`fWd`Sf[a`S^WaZ`WhadZWdYWZW`VWha^^efs`V[YWadYS`[eSfad[eUZWJUZW[Vg`Yha` VW Gbbadfg`[efW`eW[`W@aXX`g`Ylg eWflW`(!"

<[W MWdeUZsdXg`YVWd9geW[`S`VWdeWflg`YW`_[f VW`PW`fd[efW`g`VDW`[`e@[^XW[WrWIaeS DgjW_TgdYWd]W``W`%VSr V[WA`fWd`Sf[a`S^WaZ`Wg`V YWYW`S^^Wabbadfg`[ef[eUZWI[UZfg`YW ha` VW dWha^gf[a`sdW9dTW['fWd YWeUZSXXW`iWdVW_grfW( A_ ?WXs`Y`[eW`fiSdXIaeS DgjW_TgdYV[W!DW[fesflWuTWdV[W9gXYSTWVWd[`+Wd`Sf[a`S^WJal[S^VW_a]dSf[W"h%V[WSgXVWdIW[UZe]a`XWdW`lVWdD[`]W` S_ +( BS`gSd +3+0 TWdSfWg`V S`YW'`a__W` igdVW`(=[`Wea^UZWH^SffXad_S^e?dg`V^SYWXudV[Wba^[f[eUZWg`VadYS`[eSfad[eUZW9dTW[fVWdD[`]W` [` <WgfeUZ^S`ViSd Vd[`YW`VafiW`V[YYWiadVW`(=`fYWYWVWd:gdYXd[WVW`eba^[f[]VWdIWXad_[efW`YST IaeSDgjW_TgdYVW 9dTW[fWdVW dWha^gf[a`sdWDW[feSfl4<WdCS_bX g_ VWmJal[S^[e_ge !i[dV ha` VW_[`fWd`Sf[a`S^W`Hda^WfSd[Sfgd hWdi[d]^[UZf%[`VW_ WeYWYWVW`A_bWd[S^[e_geSgXVWdYS`lW` D[`[W>da`f _SUZf g`VV[WDaeg`Y %Cd[WYVW_Cd[WYW"g`fWd9gXT[Wfg`YVWdha^^WCdSXfg`V sgrWd'efW`GbXWd_gfWelgd I[UZfeUZ`gdeW[`WdbdS]f[eUZWHa^[f[] WdZWTf!(<[WDW[f'esflWVduU]fWV[WJWZ`egUZfS^^WdVWgfeUZW`9dTW[fWdSge%[`VW_e[WXadVWd'fW`%!W[`WWgW9dTW[fWd'A`fWd`Sf[a`S^Wlg eUZSXXW`%iW^UZWV[WDW[fg`Yg`VPgeS__W`XSeeg`Y VWedWha^gf[a`sdWC^SeeW`]S_bXWeYWYWVW`A_bWd[S'^[e_ge [` S^^WDs`VWd`uTWd`[__f!(

JbsfWdefW^^fWV[WD[`]W` [ZdW JbSdfS]geTd[WXW`g`V >^gYT^sffWdefWfeliW[ JsflW Sge V[WeWdH^SffXad_MGKS`%VgdUZV[We[W[__Wd i[WVWd[ZdWKdWgWlgd A`fWd`Sf[a`S^WTW]g`VWfW`g`V [` VW`VWgfeUZW`9dTW[fWdVW`?WVS`]W`VWeA`fWd`Sf[a`S^[e_geefsd]fW`( !A` VWdA`fWd`Sf[a`S^W[WYfVWdJUZiWdbg`]f VWdC^SeeW`adYS`[eSf[a VWeHda^WfSd[Sfe(((<[W"HX^[UZflgd9geXuZdg`YVWd:WeUZ^ueeWVWdA`fWd`Sf[a`S^WYWZfS^^WS`VWdWGdYS`[eS'f[a`ebX^[UZfW`hadS`(!

DW`[` _RSrVW VWgfeUZW`D[`]W` W[`WYdarW:WVWgfg`YTW[(<WeZS^TZS^XWd[Z`W`%TWea`VWdeisZdW`V VWeCd[WYWe%Es`YW^ g`V%fZWadWf[eUZW>WZ^Wd

+ =TW`VS%J( --2(, N( ( DW`[`%Js_f^[UZWNWd]W%:V( OMAAA%J( +0-(e (<a]g_W`fW g`V ESfWd[S^[W((( !%IW[ZWAA%:V( A%J(,13',2,(

lg uTWdi[`VW`(Pg VWdZWdhaddSYW`VW`JUZd[XfIaeS DgjW_TgdYe%VWd!Bg'(`[geTdaeUZudW!%eUZd[WTDW`[` W[`W]d[f[eUZW:WfdSUZfg`Yg`V _W[`fW%V[We_ueeW Wd!lgd S^^eW[f[YW`uTWdbduXg`YVWd9`eUZSgg`YW` fg`%V[WS^e[VWa'^aY[eUZW?dg`V^SYW VWdA@(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^WV[W`W ea^^W`!+( DW`[` _W[`fW%VSr e[UZ[` VW DW[fesflW V[WeW^TW`fZWadWf[eUZW`Es`YW^ i[W [` VWdBg`[ge'TdaeUZudWi[VWdeb[WYW^`%VWeZS^TiudVW` V[WeW]d[f[eUZW:W_Wd]g`YW` SgUZSgXV[W!DW[fesflW!lgfdWXXW`%V[WDW`[` \WVaUZZaUZeUZsflfW(

<[W VWgfeUZWD[`]W` Wdi[WeWe[UZfdafl [ZdWdAddfu_WdS^e iSZdZSXfWA`fWd`Sf[a`S^[efW`(J[Wefsd]fW` SgXe WgWVW ?W[ef VWebda^WfSd[eUZW`A`fWd'`Sf[a`S^[e_ge [` VW`ESeeW` VWeVWgfeUZWHda^WfSd[Sfeg`V eUZgXWVS_[fV[W?dg`V^SYW"Xud V[WWZdW`ha^^WJfW^^g`Y%V[WV[WCH< ebsfWd [` VWdA@(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^WW[``SZ_(

A_ BSZdW+3+1 eUZd[WTDW`[`%VSr `gd ea^UZWHSdfW[Wg`V EW`eUZW`i[W VWd[_ PgUZfZSge e[flW`VWCSd^ D[WT]`WUZf%V[WduU]e[UZfe^aeYWYW`V[WW[YW`WIWY[Wdg`Y%V[WW[YW`W:agdYWa[e[W%V[WW[YW`W`IWXad_[efW`g`VPW`fd[efW` ]s_bXfW`% TWdgXWe[`V%V[W`WgWA`fWd`Sf[a`S^Wlg Ydu`VW`(mW`[` ]S_ WehadWdef [UZf SgXV[W?dtrW g`V :dW[fW%ea`VWd` SgXV[Wba^\'( [eVi 5C^SdZW[fVWdWgW`A`fWd`Sf[a`S^WS`( =d ]s_bXfW lsZ g`V SgeVSgWd`Vg_ V[WeWC^sdg`Y [` S^^W eal[S^[ef[eUZWHSdfW[Wg`V ?dgbbW` g`V eUZgXS^e MadSgeeWflg`Y Z[WdlgTWVWgfW`VWfZWadWf[eUZW9dTW[fW`(=d eUZd[WT[_Bg^[ +3+/ V[W:daeUZudW!<Wd PgeS__W`TdgUZ VWd@( A`fWd`Sf[a`S^W!%[_BS`gSd +3+0 WdeUZ[W`!<Wd Gbbadfg`[e_ge g`V VWdPgeS__W`TdgUZ VWd@( A`fWd`Sf[a`S^W!g`V eUZ^[Wr^[UZ[_ @WdTef+3+0 V[Wi[UZf[YW9dTW[f !<WdA_bWd[S^[e_geg`V V[WJbS^fg`Y VWeJal[S^[e_ge!( DW`[` i[We g`i[VWd^WY'TSd `SUZ%VSr VWdGbbadfg`[e_ge V[WA`fWd`Sf[a`S^Wg`V VW` Jal[S^[e_gehWddSfWg`V V[W9dTW[fWdTWiWYg`YYWebS^fWZSTW(<[WLdeSUZW VWdJbS^'fg`Y eSZ Wd[_( VW_ qTWdYS`YW[`WeKW[^eVWdeal[S^VW_a]dSf[eUZW>uZdWd(g`V VWd9dTW[fWdSd[efa]dSf[W[` VSeDSYWdVWeA_bWd[S^[e_ge(

A` eW[`WdSgrWdadVW`f^[UZTWVWgfg`Yeha^^W`9dTW[f!<WdA_bWd[S^[e_geS^eZtUZefWeJfSV[g_ VWeCSb[fS^[e_ge! S`S^ke[WdfWDW`[`Ydu`V^[UZVW` A_'bWd[S^[e_geg`V V[WVSVgdUZWgYWeUZSXXW`W`:WV[`Yg`YW`XudVW C^SeeW`']S_bX VWeHda^WfSd[Sfe(L_ V[WdWh[e[a`[ef[eV[Wg`V CSgfe]keUZW`=`fefW^'^g`YW`VWd_Sdj[ef[eUZW`JfSSfefZWad[Wlg lWdeUZ^SYW`%eUZd[WTWdmJfSSf g`VIWha^gf[a`!( (

<gdUZ DW`[`e K[fS`W`SdTW[figdVW V[WKZWad[WVWeESdj[e_ge' DW`[`[e'_ge TWdW[UZWdfg`V lg_ XWefW>g`VS_W`f VWdCa__g`[ef[eUZW` A`fWd'`Sf[a`S^W(

mQN(+(DW`[`%qTWd <WgfeUZ^S`Vg`V V[WVWgfeUZW9dTW[fWdTWiWYg`Y%<[Wfl MWd^SY%:Wd^[` +3/2%J( -/^(

A_ =dYWT`[eVWd?darW` Jal[S^[ef[eUZWG]faTWddWha^gf[aZSffWV[W<[]'fSfgd VWeHda^WfSd[SfeSgXW[`W_JWUZefW^VWd=dVWYWe[WYf(EWZdVW`` \Wd[UZfWfW``g` V[W:agdYWa[e[Wg`V V[WIWh[e[a`[efW [ZdW9`Yd[XXWYWYWV[WDWZdWha` VWd<[]fSfgd VWeHda^WfSd[Sfe%YWYWVW`CWd`VWeESdj[e_ge'DW`[`[e_ge(

<[WiWd]fsf[YW ESeeW` [` VWdYS`lW`NW^fTWYS``We[UZ\WVaUZg_ VSe^WgUZfW`VW:S``Wd VWeJal[S^[e_ge lg eUZSdW`(<Se DWTWZSffWV[Wlg W[`W_<aY_S YWiadVW`WKZWeWlWdeftdf%SUZVWdV[W9dTW[fWd]^SeeW[` S^^WaVWdVW_W[efWXadfYWeUZd[ffW`W`Ds`VWd`Y^W[UZlW[f[YV[WESUZfWdaTWd`iudVW(<[Wg`Y^W[UZ_sr[YWt]a`a_[eUZW g`V ba^[f[eUZW=`fi[U]^g`Y VWdW[`lW^`W`

' Ds`VWd[_ A_bWd[S^[e_ge_SUZfV[Wbda^WfSd[eUZWIWha^gf[a` SgUZ[` W[`W_W[`lW^`WDS`VW_tY^[UZg`V `afiW`V[Y%g`V liSd Vadf%ia e[UZV[WN[VWd'ebduUZWVWe[_bWd[S^[ef[eUZW`JkefW_elgeS__W`TS^^Wg`V W[`WdWha^gf[a`sdWDteg`Y XadVWd`(A`Xa^YWVWd]SfSefdabZS^W9gei[d]g`YW` VWeCd[WYWeg`VVWe:W[eb[W^eVWd?darW` Jal[S^[ef[eUZWG]faTWddWha^gf[adW[XfW[` VW`]d[WYXuZdW`VW`Ds`VWd`W[`WdWha^gf[a`sdWCd[eWZWdS`(

N[W [` Igr^S`V% ea _grfW SgUZV[W9dTW[fWd]^SeeWS`VWdWdDs`VWd9gX'YSTWg`V P[W VWdZWdS``SZW`VW`IWha^gf[a` TWef[__W`(Fgd g`fWdVWd>uZdg`Y dWha^gf[a`sdWdHSdfW[W`iSd V[W9dTW[fWd]^SeeWXsZ[Y%VW`Cd[WYSgXdWha^gf[a`sdWNW[eWlg TWW`VW`g`V V[WIWha^gf[a` uTWdVW Jfgdl VWeA_bWd[S^[e_geg`V E[^[fSd[e_ge T[e lgd bda^WfSd[eUZW`IWha^gf[a` g`V VW_J[WYVWd<[]fSfgd VWeHda^WfSd[SfeiW[fWdlgfdW[TW`(<[W?du`Vg`Y g`V V[W[`fWd`Sf[a`S^WMWdW[`[Yg`YdWha^gf[a`sdWdHSdfW[W`iSd lg W[`WdYWeUZ[UZf'^[UZWFafiW`V[Y]W[fYWiadVW`(

A_ Esdl +3+2 `SZ_ V[WJal[S^VW_a]dSf[eUZW9dTW[fWdbSdfW[Igr^S`Ve#:a^eUZWi[][$VWFS_W` Ca__g`[ef[eUZWHSdfW[Igr^S`Ve #:a^eUZWi[][$S`(A_ 9gYgef +3+2 Ydu`VWfWdWha^gf[a`sdW9dTW[fWd[>[``^S`V%[_ FahW_'TWd+3+2 [` L`YSd` g`V GefWddW[Vd%[_ <WlW_TWd+3+2 [` Ha^W`g`V<WgfeUZ^S`V]a__g`[ef[eUZW HSdfW[W`(A` V[WeWDs`VWd` ha^^laYW`V[WdWha^gf[a`sdWCdsXfWVW :dgUZ _[f VW_Gbbadfg`[e_ge g`V eUZgXWHSd'fW[W_[f _Sdj[ef[eUZW_HdaYdS__%V[W[ZdWJa^[VSd[fsfg`V MWdTg`VW`ZW[f_[f VWdCHI#:$ g`V VWd9dTW[fWd]^SeeWJai\Wfdgr^S`Ve TW]g`VWfW`(DW`[`iudV[YfWTWea`VWdeV[W?du`Vg`Y VWdCH< S^e W[`W`feUZW[VW`VWe[`fWd'`Sf[a`S[^We=dW[Y`[e4

o9^e VWdVWgfeUZW%JbSdfS]geTg`V"_[f ea^UZW[` VWdYS`lW` NW^f TW']S``fW` g`V [` VWdYS`lW`NW^fTWduZ_fW>uZdWd`%_[f ea^UZW`fdWgW?W'XsZdfWVWd9dTW[fWd]^SeeWi[W D[WT]`WUZf%IaeS DgjW_TgdY%65^SdSPWf][`%>dS`l EWZd[`Y W`VYu^f[YeW[`WMWdT[`Vg`Y_[f Jal[S^[efW` ha_ JUZ^SYWJUZW[VW_S``eg`V JuVW]g_e lWdd[r%( (( S^e VWd(JbSdfS]geTg`V" VW`

F S_W` (Ca__g`[ef[eV[WHSdfW[<WgfeUZ^S`Ve"S``SZ_% VSiSd V[W"270(50+VWdi[d]^[UZbda^WfSd[eUZW`%i[d]^[UZ[`fWd`Sf[a`S^W`%i[d]^[UZdWha^gf[a`sdW`A@(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^W%VWd$1//50-34-3',)0 #04)20&4-10&.)!65 W[`Wd%&43&',)YWiadVW`(<Wd>ad_ `SUZ[ef V[WeW?du`Vg`Y `aUZ`[UZfha^^laYW`%STWd[`VWdKSf TWefWZfV[WA@(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^WTWdW[fe(!+

Cgdl `SUZVWd=dd[UZfg`YVWdJai\Wf_SUZf%[_ BS`gSd +3+2%TWd[WfVSePW`fdS^]a_[fWWVWdTa^eUZWi[ef[eUZW`HSdfW[[` HWfdaYdSV_[f MWdfdWfWd`eal[S^[ef[eUZWdHSdfW[W`S`VWdWdDs`VWdV[WMadTWdW[fg`Ylgd ?du`Vg`Y VWdA`fWd`Sf[a`S^W(<[WeWKSYg`YisZ^fWW[`[`fWd`Sf[a`S^We:uda(

<Se PW`fdS^]a_[fWWhWdi[d]^[UZfWVS_[f VW :WeUZ^grVWd9^^dgee[eUZW`9bd[^]a`XWdW`lVWdJ<9HI ha_ ,.( T[e,3( 9bd[^ +3+1%!eaXadfJUZd[ffWlgd?du`Vg`Y VWdA@(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^Wlg g`fWd`WZ_W`!(Pgd :WYdu`Vg`YigdVWYWeSYf4!=e [ef V[W9gXYSTWg`eWdWdHSdfW[%V[W[` W[`W_DS`VWi[d]f% [`VW_ V[WIWha^gf[a` XduZWdS^e [` S`VWdWDs`VWd` TWYa``W`ZSf%V[WA`[f[Sf[hWlg WdYdW[XW`lgd ?du`Vg`Y VWdA@(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^W%V[W_[f VW`(GTada`lW`"6W`VYu^f[YTd[UZfg`V SgUZYWYWV[WPi[ffWdba^[f[] VWe%PW`'fdg_e" W[`WW`feUZ[WVW`W`CS_bX XuZdf(!-

L`fWd VW_=[`X^gr VWdTa^eUZWi[ef[eUZW`HSdfW[g`V VWe[`fWd`Sf[a`S^W`:udae W`fefS`VW[` Igr^S`V Sge^s`V[eUZW?dgbbW` ha` Cd[WYeYWXS`YW`W`%V[We[UZlg W[`Wd[`fWd`Sf[a`S^W`>tVWdSf[a` lgeS__W`eUZ^aeeW`(M[W^WCd[WYeYWXS`YW`WigdVW` SgXdWUZfWIWha^gf[a`sdW%V[WebsfWd[` VW IWha'^gf[a`e]s_bXW` [ZdWdDs`VWdg`V [` VWd9dTW[fVWd]a__g`[ef[eUZW` HSd'fW[WW[`WZWdhaddSYW`VWIa^^Web[W^fW`(

JUZ^[Wr^[UZXS`Vg`fWdVW_Made[fl DW`[`e 9`XS`Y +3+3 W[`W:WdSfg`YSge^s`V[eUZWd?dgbbW` efSff%V[W[` W[`W_JUZdW[TW`S` -3 ]a__g`[ef[eUZWg`V ^[`]eeal[S^[ef[eUZWHSdfW[W`%?dgbbW` g`V GdYS`[eSf[a`W`lg_ ?du`'Vg`Ye]a`YdWrVWdCa__g`[ef[eUZW` A`fWd`Sf[a`S^WSgXd[WX(A_ =[`^SVg`Ye'eUZdW[TW`Wd]^sdfWe[WV[WFafiW`V[Y]W[f%V[WA`fWd`Sf[a`S^Wlg Yd[[`VW`((g`V W`fi[;]W^fWVWdW@SgbfSgXYSTW`(

<Se ]Sb[fS^[ef[eUZWJkefW_ TWXS`Ve[UZS_ =`VWVWeCd[WYWe[` ht^^[YWdPWdduffg`Y(<WgfeUZ^S`V%GefWddW[UZ%L`YSd`%Ha^W`%AfS^[Wg`V VWd:S^']S` igdVW` ha` VWddWha^gf[a`sdWNaYW uTWdX^gfWf(<[W dWha^gf[a`sdW`CdsXfW]s_bXfW` XudV[WIsfW_SUZf(JW^Tef[` VW J[WYWd^s`VWd`^WTfWV[W:agdYWa[e[W[` 9`Yef had VWddWha^gf[a`sdW?sdg`Y g`fWdVW NWd]fsf[YW`[ZdWdDs`VWd(JaiaZ^ VgdUZVSeMadT[^VVWddgee[eUZW`IWha^gf[a` S^eSgUZ

!# N( A(DW`[`%qTWm<WgfeUZ^S`Vg`V V[WVWgfeUZW9dTW[fWdTWiWYg`Y%J(.2*).2+(, Igee[eUZWv"hSfWd^S`VehWdfW[V[YWd!(- (IWea^gf[a`W` VWd9^^dgee[eUZW9bd[^]a`XWdW`lVWdJ<9HI!5 N( A(DW`[`%Js_f^[UZW

NWd]W%:V( OO%,( @S^TTS`V%N[W`':Wd^[` +3,2%J( ,3.(

[`Xa^YWVWdN[d]g`YW` VWddWha^gf[a`sdWFSUZ]d[WYe]d[eWigUZe g`fWdVW`W`Y^[eUZW`%XdS`lte[eUZWg`V S_Wd[]S`[eUZW9dTW[fWdVWdN[^^Wlg_ 9`'Yd[XXSgXV[WA_bWd[S^[efW`%VWd[` [__Wd `WgW YdarW`ESeeW`efdW[]elg_9geVdgU]]S_(

<[WaT\W]f[hWMadSgeeWflg`YWXudVWJ[WYVWdeal[S^[ef[eUZW`IWha^gf[a`iSdW` [` h[W^WDs`VWd`hadZS`VW`%V[WegT\W]f[hWdW[XfW`ZWdS`(<[W9dTW['fWd]^SeeW[` V[WeWDs`VWd eSZe[UZhad V[W9gXYSTWYWefW^^f%VW J[WY[` VWdIWha^gf[a` lg Wd]s_bXW`(<[W\g`YW`]a__g`[ef[eUZW` HSdfW[W`g`V dWha^g'f[a`sdW` ?dgbbW` ZSffW e[UZ\WVaUZ_W[efhWdebsfWfha` VW abbadfg`[ef['eUZWeal[S^VW_a]dSf[eUZW`HSdfW[WYW^tef%e[WW`fefS`VWg`V WdefSd]fW`[_>WgWdVWdIWha^gf[a` g`V eS__W^fW%[ZdW=dXSZdg`YWg`fWdYdarW GbXWd`(

<WeZS^Td[UZfWfW`V[W9dTW[fWdVWdYS`lW`NW^f[ZdW9gYW` SgXJai\Wf'dgr^S`V%SgXV[WHSdfW[DWg[`e(Ma` VWde[WYdW[UZW`dWha^gf[a`sdWHSdfW[VWedgee[eUZWHda^WfSd[SfeWdiSdfWfW`e[W[VWa^aY[eUZW@[^XWg`V V[WqTWd'_[ff^g`Y VWd=dXSZdg`YWVWdW`[`[ef[eUZW`JfdSfWY[Wg`V KS]f[](

<[W]^SeeW`TWigrfW9dTW[fWd[` S^^WDs`VWd`Wd]S``fW`%VSr VWdGb'badfg`[e_ge V[WF[WVWd^SYW%DW`[`e AVWWVW J[WYTWVWgfW`(<[WeWAVWW`ZSffW%[Zd(We[WYZSXfWCdSXf[` Igr^S`V TWi[WeW`(<[WpdS VWdbda^WfSd[eUZW`IWha^gf[a` WdXadVWdfWW[`WWgWA`fWd`Sf[a`S^W%V[W[_efS`VW iSd% V[Wabbadfg`[ef[eUZW>si+`[e dWef^aelg uTWdi[`VW`(<WdiW^fZ[efad[eUZWCS_bXVWd9dTW[fWdXudVW J[WYVWdeal[S^[ef[eUZW`IWha^gf[a` XadVWdfWYWT[WfWd[eUZV[W?du`Vg`Y VWdCa__g`[ef[eUZW` A`fWd`Sf[a`S^W(

<[WlWdd[eeW`W`[`fWd`Sf[a`S^W MWdT[`Vg`YW_grfW` i[WVWdZWdYWefW^^fiWdVW`(<[WAVWWVWebda^WfSd[eUZW`A`fWd`Sf[a`S^[e_ge%VWdYWYW`eW[f[YW`@[^XW[_ dWha^gf[a`sdWCS_bX%iSdW` eW[fDW`[`e >g`]ebdgUZ !9` S^^W!^WTW`V[YWdVW``\W(<[W9dTW[fWdS^^WdDs`VWd%VSdg`fWdSgUZV[WVWgfeUZW`%ia^^fW`VWd9dTW[fWd'g`V':SgW_'ESUZfJai\Wfdar^S`Ve [` [ZdW_ZWda[eUZW`CS_bX YWYWV[WA`fWdhW`fW`ZW^XW`%i[W VZdWdeW[feV[We[WYdW[UZWJai\Wf'd`SUZfVWd[`fWd`Sf[a`S^W9dTW[fWdTWiWYg`YefWfeYWZa^XW`ZSffW(

9`VWdWdeW[fehWdegUZfW`V[WA_bWd[S^[efW`%[` ?(WefSd^fVWeMt^]WdTg`VWe%W[`:u`V`[e VWd]Sb[fS^[ef[eUZW`JfSSfW`YWYWV[W_fW_Sf[a`S^W IWha^g'f[a` g`V had S^^W_YWYW`Jai\Wfdgr^S`V (lg eUZSXXW`(<[WdWUZfW`eal[S^'VW_a]dSf[eUZW`>uZdWdW[efWfW`[Z`W` VSTW[@[^XeV[W`efW(<Se =[`^SVg`Ye'eUZdW[TW`lg_ A(Ca`YdWrVWdAL(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^WiW[ef VSdSgXZ[`%VSr V[Weal[S^VW_a]dSf[eUZWHSdfW[W`%V[WeW^TW`%V[WisZdW`V VWeCd[WYWe[ZdW:agdYWa[e[WT[e lg^Wflfg`fWdefuflf g`V e[UZYWYW`eW[f[YTW]s_bXf ZSffW`%TWSTe[UZf[YfW`%e[UZWd`Wgflg W[`Wd!A`fWd`Sf[a`S^W!lgeS__W`lgeUZ^[WrW`%`SUZVW_e[WW[`S`VWd!9_`Wef[W! WdfW[^fZSffW`(

<[WeWCa`XWdW`lXS`V[_ >WTdgSd+3+3 [` IW_ efSff(J[WiSd W[`MWdegUZ%

V[WESeeW` lg TWfduYW`%[` VW`WV[WJWZ`egUZf SUZ W[`WdWgW i[d]^[UZW`A`fWd`Sf[a`S^WVWd9dTW[fWdWTW`V[YiSd( A` VWdEWZdlSZ^iSdW` MWdfdWfWdeal[S^UZSgh[`[ef[eUZWdg`V lW`fd[ef[eV[WdHSdfW[WS`iWeW`Veai[W W[`W]^W[`W?dgbbW A`fWd`Sf[a`S^[efW`(V[WeaXadf_[f VWdCa`XWdW`l_WZdZW[f[` Ca`X^[]fYWd[Wf(9gX VWdCa`XWdW`leb[W^fWV[WHSdfW[WVWe:^aU]e VWdJ[WYWd^s`VWdV[WXuZdW`VWIa^^W%V[WV[WHae[f[a` [ZdWd[_bWd[S^[ef[eUZW`IWY[Wdg`YWSgXVWdHSd[eWd>d[WVW`e]a`XWdW`lg`fWdefuflfW`( Kdafl S^^WdUZSgh[`[ef[eUZW`Ca`X^[]fW%V[Wli[eUZW` VW` !Jal[S^[efW`! VWdWZW_S^[YWTW[VW[_bWd[S'^[ef[eUZWESUZfT^tU]WSgXfdSfW`%iSdW` e[We[UZ[` VWd9T^WZ`g`Y VWd<[]'fSfgd VWeHda^WfSd[Sfeg`V [_ ZSrWdXu^^fWCS_bX YWYWV[WJai\Wfd`SUZfW[`[Y(<Se iSd V[WlW`fdS^W>dSYWSgXV[WeWdCa`XWdW`lg`V UZSdS]fWd[ef[eUZXudVW`S`f[eai\Wf[eUZW`CS_bX VWdHSdfW[WVWd++(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^W(A` V[W'"e(W_?W[efWigdVW V[W++(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^WXad_S^ i[WVWdZWdYWefW^^f(<[W PW`' %4fd[efW`TW_uZfW e[UZliSd TWea`VWdeS]f[h STWdhWdYWT^[UZ%V[Weal[S^UZSgh[')`[ef[eV[W` >uZdWd%V[WMWddSfS_ bda^WfSd[eUZWA`fWd`Sf[a`S^[e_ge uTfW`%dW[`lgiSeUZW`( (

=e YS^f%VW`TWfduYWd[eUZW`ES`thWd` VWdA_bWd[S^[efWg`V [ZdWddWUZfW`eal[S^VW_a]dSf[eUZW@W^XWdVgdUZV[WdWha^gf[a`sdW[`fWd`Sf[a`S^WGdYS`['eSf[a` g`V 9]f[a` lg TWYWY`W`(E[f IWUZfZW[rfWe[_ =[`^SVg`YeeUZdW[TW`%VSr V[WisZdW`V VWeCd[WYWe%TWea`VWdeSUZ VWd?darW` Jal[S^[ef[eUZW`(G]faTWddWha^gf[a`%!TWdW[feWdiamTW`WSgrWdadVW`f^[UZdW[UZWdWha^gf[a`sdW=dXSZdg`Yg`V V[WA`fWd`Sf[a`S^[e[Wdg`YVWdYS`lW` IWha^gf[a`eTWiWYg`Y!V[W?du`Vg`Y VWdA@(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^Wli[`YW`V `afiW`V[Y _SUZfW(

<WdA(Ca`YdWr VWdCa__g`[ef[eUZW` A`fWd`Sf[a`S^WiSd ha` /+ <W^WY[Wd'fW` Sge -* Ds`VWd` TWegUZf(PSZ^dW[UZW<W^WY[WdfW]a``fW` [`Xa^YWVWd:^aU]SVWJai\Wfdgr^S`Ve `[UZf `SUZ Eae]Sg YW^S`YW`(<Wd Ca`YdWr fSYfW[` W[`W_]^W[`W`JSS^WVWeCdW_^(<[W :agdYWa[e[W%VWdV[W9`Yef had VWdIWha^gf[a` [_ FSU]W` eSr%hWdegUZfWW[` YWcgs^fWe@aZ`YW^sUZfWduTWdV[W!@S`Vha^^ =jfdW_[efW`! S`lgef[__W`( <aUZ V[WMWdfdWfWdVWd[`fWd`Sf[a`S^W`dWha^gf[a`sdW`9dTW[fWdTWiWYg`YeUZgXW`l[W^TWigrf V[W?dg`V^SYWXudV[WYWiS^f[YefWiW^fg_ebS``W`VW GdYS`[eSf[a` VWeHda^WfSd[Sfe%V[WWe\WYST(

A` eW[`Wd:WYdurg`YedWVWWZdfWDW`[` CSd^ D[WT]`WUZfg`V IaeS DgjW_'TgdYS^eV[WTWefWMWdfdWfWdVWd+++(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^W(=d efW^^fW'XWef%VSr W[`WIW[ZWha` Ds`VWd` ha_ :udYWd]d[WYWdXSrfeW[%g`V lW[YfW%VSr VSe Hda^W'fSd[Sf V[W>ad_ X[`VW_ueeW%g_ eW[`W@WddeUZSXf' VSe Jai\WfekefW_ ' lghWdi[d]^[UZW`(

L`fWd VW ebWl[X[eUZW`:WV[`Yg`YW`VWdPW[f%S^eVSedgee[eUZWHda^WfSd[Sf%g_YWTW`ha` >W[`VW`%[_ WdefWDS`VWVWdNW^f eW[`WESUZf Wdd[UZfWfW%T[^VWfWWeV[WSge VW_dWha^gf[a`sdW`CS_bXWeW^TefWdiSUZeW`WIsfW VWd

9dTW[fWd'%Ja^VSfW`'g`V :SgWd`VWbgf[WdfW`(9^e V[W9dTW[fWd%Ja^VSfWg`V:SgWd` [` S`VWdWDs`VW_ e[V[+3+2WdZaTW`%isZ^fW` SgV[e[We[UZIsfW S^eCS_bXadYS`W(

IaeS DgjW_TgdYWd]^sdfW([` [ZdWdbdaYdS__Sf[eUZWIWVWSgXVW_?du`'Vg`YebSdfW[fSYVWdCH<%VSr `SUZVW_;ZSae%[` iW^UZWeVWdg`fWdYWZW`VWA_bWd[S^[e_geVSeVWgfeUZWMa^] YWefudlfZSffW%oVSedWffW`VWHd[`l[b! V[WDaeg`Y VWd9dTW[fWd'g`V Ja^VSfW`dsfWeW[%g`V V[WeWeZsffW`V[WVWgfeUZW`Hda^WfSd[Wdha` VWdgee[eUZWYW^Wd`f(

<[W i[UZf[YefW ba^[f[eUZW<a]g_W`fW VWeA(Ca`YdWeeWee[`V4 DW`[`eKZWeWuTWdTudYWd^[UZW<W_a]dSf[Wg`V <[]fSfgd VWeHda^WfSd[Sfe%V[WI[UZf'^[`[W`VWdCa__g`[ef[eUZW` A`fWd`Sf[a`S^Wg`V VSeES`[XWefVWdCa__g'`[ef[eUZWA`fWd`Sf[a`S^WS` VSeHda^WfSd[SfVWdYS`lW`NW^f(

<Se =dYWT`[eVWeCa`YdWeeWeiSd V[W?du`Vg`Y VWdCa__g`[ef[eUZW`%VWdAAA(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^W(

<[W `WgWA`fWd`Sf[a`S^WigdVW ha` VW`dWha^gf[a`sdW 9dTW[fWd[`<WgfeUZ^S`VW[`ZW^^[Yg`V TWYW[efWdfTWYdurf(AZdA`ZS^fg`V 9gXTSg W`f'ebdSUZha^^g`V YS`l [ZdWMadefW^^g`YW`g`V VW_:WeUZ^grVWe?du`Vg`Ye'

<[W ?du`Vg`Y VWdCa__g`[ef[eUZW` A`fWd`Sf[a`S^WiSd VWdN[^^WVWdVWgfeUZW`g`V [`fWd`Sf[a`S^W dWha^gf[a`sdW9dTW[fWdTWiWYg`Yg`V Wd'Xa^YfW[_ =dYWT`[eVWd?darW` Jal[S^[ef[eUZWG]faTWddWha^gf[a`(DW`[`Xad_g^[WdfWV[W=`fiudXW VWdi[UZf[YefW <a]g_W`fW `SUZ Ydu`V^[UZefW`9`S^keW` VWe[_bWd[S^[ef[eUZW`JfSV[g_e VWeCSb[fS^[e_ge%iaTW[ WdV[W_Sdj[ef[eUZWKZWad[WSgXV[WWgWJ[fgSf[a` S`iS`VfW g`V V[W=dXSZdg`YW`VWde[WYdW[UZW`?darW` Jal[S^[ef[eUZWG]faTWddWha^gf[ahWdS^^YW_W[`WdfW(

<[WCa__g`[ef[eUZWA`fWd`Sf[a`S^WigdVWSgXVWdXWefW`?dg`V^SYWVWeESdj[e_ge'DW`[`[e_ge YWeUZSXXW`(<WdCWd`V[WeWdDWZdW%V[W>dSYWVWd<[]fSfgd VWeHda^WfSd[Sfe%efS`V VWeZS^T[_ E[ffW^bg`]f VWd:WdSfg`YWVWeA(Ca`YdWeeWe(

:udYWd^[UZW<W_a]dSf[WaVWd<[]fSfgd VWeHda^WfSd[Sfe8:udYWd^[UZWIWbg'T^[] aVWdIsfW_SUZf8 Ja efS`V V[WYWeUZ[UZf^[UZW=`feUZW[Vg`Yhad VW`Mt^]Wd`(

A` Igr^S`V ZSffW`V[W9dTW[fWd[_ :u`V`[e _[f VW iWd]fsf[YW :SgWd`V[W[_ CS_bXWW`fefS`VW`W`IsfW lgd JfSSfe_SUZfVWeMa^]Weg`fWdVWd>uZ'dg`Y VWd9dTW[fWd]^SeeWWdZaTW`(=e iSd V[WeV[WVW_a]dSf[eUZefWJfSSfe'_SUZfXudV[WNWd]fsf[YW`%V[WWeT[e VSZ[` [` VWdNW^fYWYWTW`ZSffW(<[WS^fW[_bWd[S^[ef[eUZWJfSSfe_SUZfiSd lWdeUZ^SYW`iadVW`%W[``WgWdKkbgeW[`WdMa^]e_SUZfiSd W`fefS`VW`%[` VWdV[W9dTW[fWd]^SeeWV[WJfSSfeYWiS^fYWYWV[W9geTWgfWd]^SeeWS`iS`VfW( J[WiSd V[W@WddeUZSXfVWduTWdis^f['YW`VWEWZdZW[fVWeMa^]WeuTWd"W[`W]^W[`WE[`VWdZW[fha` 9geTWgfWd`(

DW`[` eUZd[WT4!<[W `WgWESUZf%S^e <[]fSfgd VWdYWiS^f[YWEWZdZW[f%]a``fW e[UZW[`l[Yg`V S^^W[ZS^fWg`V Z[W^fe[UZ%iW[^ e[WVSeMWdfdSgW`VWdTdW[fWefW`ESeeW` YW`ar%W[`l[Yg`V S^^W[VSVgdUZ%VSr e[WV[WYS`lWESeeWSgXeXdW[WefW%g_XSeeW`VefWg`V efsd]efWlgd KW[+`SZ_WS VWdESUZfZWdS`laY(! Fgd W[`Wea^UZWESUZf ]a``fW VW_Ma^]WS^^WIW[UZfu_WdVWd?WeW^^eUZSXfS` HdaVg]f[a`e_[ffW^` g`V i[U]^[V[W>dW[ZW[fYWTW`%V[W9ge'TWgfWdg`fWdVduU]Wg`V VW`Jal[S^[e_ge WdTSgW`(<[W Ma^]e_SeeW` VWd]Sb[fS^[ef[eUZWDs`VWdiS`VfW` e[UZ([`ef[`]f[h VW IsfW` lg%VaUZV[W:agd'YWa[e[Wg`V V[WdWUZfW`>uZdWdVWdeal[S^VW_a]dSf[eUZW`HSdfW[W`hWdegUZfW`%e[WVgdUZV[WDaeg`Y VWdTudYWd^[UZ'bSd^S_W`fSd[eUZW`<W_a]dSf[Wha_dWha^gf[a`sdWCS_bX g_ VW J[WYVWdJai\Wf_SUZf STlgZS^fW`(

<[Wha` VWddWUZfW`Jal[S^VW_a]dSf[WhWdTdW[fWfW`dWXad_[ef[eUZW`A^^ge[a'`W` eai[W VWdJUZi[`VW VWdPW`fd[efW`(V[WV[WIsfW _[f VW_TudYWd^[UZW`JfSSfeSbbSdSf hWd]abbW^ia^^fW`%igdVW` W[` Wd`efWe@[`VWd`[eXudV[WdWha^gf[a`sdW=`fi[U]^g`Y( DW`[`e !KZWeWuTWdTudYWd^[UZW<W_a]dSf[Wg`V <[]fSfgd VWeHda^WfSd[Sfe!W`f^SdhfWS^^WV[WeWhWdi[ddW`VWDuYW`%J[WlW[YfWV[W!dW[`W<W_a]dSf[W! g`V V[W!uT_' VW`C^SeeW efWZW`VW<W_a]dSf[W!S^eV[WhWdZu^^fW<[]fSfgd VWd:agdYWa[e[W(<Wdi[d]^[UZWC^Se'eW`[`ZS^fVWdTudYWd^[UZ'VW_a]dSf[eUZW`IWbgT^[][ef V[W<[]fSfgd VWd:agd'YWa[e[W%V[W\WVWe_SaXXW`lgfSYWfd[ff%iW`` V[WESUZf VWd9geTWgfWd[`eNS`]W` YWdsf(DW`[` lWdeUZ^gYV[WHdabSYS`VS^uYWVWd:agdYWa[e[Wg`V[ZdWdDS]S[W`%V[WTudYWd^[UZW<W_a]dSf[WeW[W[`WdWS^W<W_a]dSf[W%WdefW^^fW[Zd V[Wi[d]^[UZW<W_a]dSf[WYWYW`uTWd%V[Wha` VW Ma^]e_SeeW`[`VWd>ad_ VWdIsfW_SUZfYWeUZSXXW`iSd(

<[W!KZWeWuTWdTudYWd^[UZW<W_a]dSf[Wg`V <[]fSfgd VWeHda^WfSd[Sfe!e[`V [` S^^WYdg`Vesfl^[UZWKW[^WZWgfWaUZ YW`SgeaYu^f[Yg`V S]fgWqi[W &%( PW[f[ZdWdF[WVWdeUZd[Xf(J[WigdVW` W[`Wi[d]eS_W NSXXWVWd]a_'_g`[ef[eUZW`HSdfW[W`[_ CS_bXWYWYWV[WbSd^S_W`fSd[eUZW`A@ge[a`W`eai[W YWYWV[WL`fWdeUZsflg`YVWddWha^gf[a`sdW9ge`gflg`Y VWeTudYWd'^[UZWHSd^S_W`fe(

<[W]a__g`[ef[eUZW` g`V 9dTW[fWdbSdfW[W`WddW[UZfW`VgdUZ[ZdW9dTW[f%VSr eWZdh[W^WNWd]fsf[YW[` VW ]Sb[fS^[ef[eUZWDs`VWd`TWdW[feVW g`'VW_a]dSf[eUZW`%ha^]eXW[`V^[UZW`;ZSdS]fWdVWeTudYWd^[UZW`JfSSfWeWd]W`'`W` ]a``fW`%VWdW[`ESUZf[`efdg_W`fiW`[YWdEa`aba^]Sb[fS^[efW` lgd =d'ZS^fg`YVWd9geTWgfg`YVWdMa^]ed`SeeW([ef(

9gX V[WKZWeWYWefuflf%]a``fW` V[WCa__g`[efW` [` VW`ESeeW` VSeMWdefs`V`[eWdiWU]WXudV[W9gXYSTWVWd<[]fSfgd VWeHda^WfSd[SfeisZ'

+ N( A(DW`[`%M[Wd9dTW[fWlg >dSYW VWdIWha^gf[a`%VWe:udYWd]d[WYe%VWd<[]fSfgdg`V lg JUZiS`]g`YW` VWd]^W[`TudYWd^[UZW`<W_a]dSfW`%<[Wfl MWd^SY%:Wd^[` +3/1%J( .-(

dW`VVWdHWd[aVWVWdeal[S^[ef[eUZWL_YWefS^fg`Y%[`eTWea`VWdWXudVSeNWeW VWdJai\Wfd`SUZf[` Igr^S`V S^eW[`Wd@WddeUZSXfeXad_VWd9dTW[fWd']^SeeW(<[WeW=d]W``f`[e efsd]fWVW bda^WfSd[eUZW`A`fWd`Sf[a`S^[e_ge(

<[WKZWeWYSTWVW]a__g`[ef[eUZW` g`V 9dTW[fWdbSdfW[W`h[W^Wi[UZ'f[YW9`dWYg`YW`TW[VWd=`fi[U]^g`Y g`V >Wef[Yg`YVWdha^]eVW_a]dSf[eUZW`JfSSfeadYS`W[` VWdPW[f`SUZ +3..% V[We[UZlg GdYS`W`VWd<[]fSfgd VWeHda^WfSd[SfeW`fi[U]W^fW`(

DW`[`e ;ZSdS]fWd[e[Wdg`YVWdTudYWd^[UZW`<W_a]dSf[W efWZf [UZf [_N[VWdebdgUZ%ea`VWd`[_ ha^^W =[`]^S`Y _[f VW_WdT[ffWdfW`CS_bX VWd9dTW[fWd]^SeeW[_ CSb[fS^[e_geg_ V[Wha^^W=`fXS^fg`YVWd<W_a]dSf[W(<[W9dTW[fWd]^SeeW]s_bXfW efWfeg_ V[W=dZS^fg`Yg`V VW 9geTSg VWdVW_a']dSf[eUZWIWUZfWg`V >dW[ZW[fW`' iW`` e[WSgUZgd Xad_S^iSdW` ' g`VhWdfW[V[YfWe[WYWYWV[W9`Yd[XXWVWdIWS]f[a`(

<[W?WeUZ[UZfWTWiW[efT[e SgXVW ZWgf[YWKSY%VSr V[WA_bWd[S^[efW`[ZdW_W`eUZZW[feXW[`V^[UZW`Cd[WYeb^s`WVgdUZlgeWflW`hWdegUZW`%[`VW_ e[WhadZWdSV^WTudYWd^[UZ'VW_a]dSf[eUZW`>dW[ZW[fW`TWeW[f[YW`%V[WiWd]fsf[YW`ESeeW`ht^"^[YW`fdWV[fW`g`V S^^WbSd^S_W`fSd[eUZ'VW_a]dSf[eUZW`KSd`g`'YW[ZdWd<[]fSfgd XS^^W`^SeeW`(<[W9dTW[fWd]^SeeW\WVWeDS`VWehWdfW[V[Yf_[fVW VW_a]dSf[eUZW`IWUZfW`lgY^W[UZV[WEtY^[UZ]W[f%V[WCdsXfWVWeYS`lW`Ma^]Welg_ CS_bX XudVW`>d[WVW`%XudV[WSf[a`SB^Wg`V eal[S^W`A`fWd'

(WeeWVWeMa^]Weg`V VW`Jfgdl VWdESUZf VWdEa`aba^ZWddW lg adYS`['e[WdW`(

A` VW BSZdlWZ`fWeW[fVWd?du`Vg`Y VWdCa__g`[ef[eUZW` A`fWd`Sf[a'`S^WZSf e[UZVSe CdsXfWhWdZs^f`[e[` VWdNW^f Ydu`V^[UZhWds`VWdf(<W`]d[WYe^uefWd`W`A_bWd[S^[efWefWZWVSe XWefYWXuYfWeal[S^[ef[eUZWNW^f'ekefW__[f VWdJai\Wfg`[a` S` VWdJb[flW%V[WPa`W VWdXd[WV^[WTW`VW`S`f[']a^a`[S^W`Mt^]Wd%V[WW[`X^grdW[UZW`]a__g`[ef[eUZW` g`V 9dTW[fWdbSdfW[W`VWd]Sb[fS^[ef[eUZWDs`VWd%V[WNW^fXd[WVW`eTWiWYg`Y%V[W`Sf[a`S^W`%S`f[]a^a`[S^W` :WXdW[g`YeTWiWYg`YW`g`V V[WWgfdS^WJfSSfW`YWYW`uTWd(<[WEWZdZW[fVWdEW`eUZZW[fZSf e[UZTWdW[feVWd@WddeUZSXfVWdA_bWd[S'^[efW W`flaYW`(<[WeWeWgWCdsXfWhWdZsDf`[e[` VWdNW^fZSf V[WEtY^[UZ']W[f"YWeUZSXXW`%W[`W[_bWd[S^[ef[eUZW`NW^f]d[WYlg hWdZ[`VWd`%g`V V[WeWEtY^[UZ]W[figdVWTWdW[fei[WVWdZa^flgd N[d]^[UZ]W[f(<[WKZWeWha` VWdL`hWd_W[VTSd]W[f%[_bWd[S^[ef[eUZWdCd[WYW%V[W[` VW`<a]g_W`fW` hWd'eUZ[WVW`f^[UZSgeYWVduU]fi[dV%[ef VgdUZV[WMWds`VWdg`YVWeCdsXfWhWd'Zs^f`[eeWe[` VWdNW^fuTWdZa^f%\WVaUZhWdeUZi[`VWfV[WCd[WYeYWXSZdW`V'Yu^f[YWdef_[f VWdMWd`[UZfg`YVWeA_bWd[S^[e_ge(

Fgd VWdJal[S^[e_ge e[UZWdfVWdEW`eUZZW[fVW`>d[WVW`(<[W@WddeUZSXfVWd9dTW[fWd]^SeeWTWVWgfWf`[UZf gd VWJfgdl VWd9geTWgfWdg`V V[WL`fWd'

VduU]g`Y[ZdWdIWefSgdSf[a`ehWdegUZW%ea`VWd` [ef !Xud V[WYS`lWESeeW VWdNWd]fsf[YW`S^eW[`l[YWdJUZgfl YWYWV[W<[]fSfgd VWd:agdYWa[e[W%V[Wlg_Cd[WYYWXuZdfZSf g`V `WgWCd[WYWhadTWdW[fWf"K%S`lgeWZW`%efW^^fDW`[` [`VW`KZWeWXWef(

<[W]a__g`[ef[eUZW` g`V 9dTW[fWdbSdfW[W`%g`fWd [Z`W` V[WJal[S^[ef[eUZW=[`ZW[febSdfW[<WgfeUZ^S`Ve%WdefdWTW`had S^^W_[` VWd>dSYWVWd=dZS^fg`YVWe>d[WVW`eV[WPgeS__W`SdTW[f _[f VW`eal[S^[ef[eUZWHSdfW[Wg`V S^^W`CdsXfW`%V[WS_ >d[WVW[`fWdWee[Wdfe[`V( J[WTW_uZW e[UZ%S^^W:WduZdg`Ye'bg`]fW g`V 9``sZWdg`Ye_tY^[UZ]W[fW` li[eUZW` VW`9dTW[fWdbSdfW[W`g`V'adYS`[eSf[a`W` [` V[WeWdDWTW`eXdSYWVWdEW`eUZZW[flg `gflW`( =[`W YdarWN[^B!]g`Y SgX V[WNWd]fsf[YW` [` S^^W`]Sb[fS^[ef[eUZW Ds`VWd` uTf V[Wefud_[eUZW=`fi[U]^g`Y VWeeal[S^[ef[eUZWDSYWdeSge%V[WT[e +33/ W[`WW`f'eUZW[VW`VWNW`VWlgYg`efW` VWeJal[S^[e_ge ZWdTW[XuZdW`i[dV( !?WefuflfSgXV[WESUZf VWeeal[S^[ef[eUZWDSYWde%iWdVW`V[WXd[WV^[WTW`VW`Mt^]WdVS`` V[W]d[WYe^uefWd`WCdW[eWVWeA_bWd[S^[e_geli[`YW` ]t``W`% SgXV[WH^s`WW[`WeWgW`NW^f]d[WYWelg hWdl[UZfW`(!,

A__Wd _WZdWdtXX`WfVSe hWds`VWdfWCdsXfWhWdZs^f`[eV[WEtY^[UZ]W[f%[`W[`lW^`W Ds`VWd` VgdUZ]dSXfha^^WMa^]eTWiWYg`YWg`fWd >uZdg`Y VWd9dTW[fWd]^SeeWV[W@WddeUZSXfVWd9dTW[fWd]^SeeWaZ`W :udYWd]d[WY%g`fWd9ge`gflg`Y g`V L_iS`V^g`Y VWeHSd^S_W`fe%lg Wdd[UZfW`(<aUZ _gr VgdUZW[`Wea^UZW:WiWYg`Y fdafl [ZdWedW^Sf[hXd[WV^[UZW`;ZSdS]fWde W[`WdWha'^gf[a`sdW L_iS`V^g`Y ha^^laYW`iWdVW`%[` VWdV[W]Sb[fS^[ef[eUZWJfSSfe'_SUZf lWdeUZ^SYW`i[dV g`V e[UZdWha^gf[a`sdWJfSSfeadYS`Wg`V eal[S^[ef[eUZWHdaVg]f[a`ehWdZs^f`[eeWZWdSgeT[^VW`(A` V[WeWdHWd[aVWVWdL_is^lg`Y_gr V[WJfSSfe_SUZf [_ A`fWdWeeWTdW[fWefWdMa^]eeUZ[UZfWV[WdWha^gf[a`sdW<[]fSfgd VWeHda^WfSd[SfeeW[`(<[WEtY^[UZ]W[fW[`WdXd[WV^[UZW`=`fi[U]^g`Y

%VWddWha^gf[a`sdW`L_is^lg`Y Zs`Yf ha` VWdK[WXWVWdba^[f[eUZWg`V t]a'`a_[eUZW` Cd[eWVWeCSb[fS^[e_ge ST%ha_ ]a`]dWfW` MWdZs^f`[eVWdC^SeeW`']dsXfW%ha_ ?dSV VWdGdYS`[e[WdfZW[fg`V VWe:WigrfeW[`e VWd9dTW[fWd']^SeeW%[`eTWea`VWdWha` VWdIW[XWVWd_Sdj[ef[eUZ'^W`[`[ef[eUZWHSdfW[%V[WWehWdefWZW`_gr% W[`Wd[UZf[YWHa^[f[] VWe:u`V`[eeWe VWd9dTW[fWd]^SeeW_[fVW` iWd]fsf[YW` :SgWd` g`V S`VWdW iWd]fsf[YW` JUZ[UZfWeai[W S^^W`bSfd[af[eUZWCdsXfW`VgdUZlgXuZdWg`V S^^WSf[a`S^W` :Wea`VWdZW[fWVWeCS_bXWe lg TWduU]e[UZf[YW`(<[W _Sdj[ef[eUZ'^W`[`[ef[eUZWHSdfW[VWd9d'TW[fWd]^SeeW[ef [` S^^WDs`VWd` g`fWd VW`ZWgf[YW:WV[`Yg`YW` VWeC^Se'eW`]S_bXWeafiW`V[YWdVW`` \W(

' J[WZWJ( /3 VWehad^[WYW`VW`:S`VWe(, F( J( ;ZdgeVdfeV[ai% !uTWd V[WCa`fda^^l[XXWd XudV[W=`fi[U]^g`Y VWdMa^]ei[dfeUZSXf

VWdLVJJI [` VW`BSZdW`+3/3 T[e +30/!% <[Wfl MWd^SY%:Wd^[` +3/3%J( 20(

:WdW[feESdj g`V =`YW^eWd]S``fW` V[WEtY^[UZ]W[f%g`fWd TWef[__fW`:WV[`Yg`YW`%iW`` W[`W_SUZfha^^WdWha^gf[a`sdW HSdfW[Wj[ef[Wdf%VSeNSZ^dWUZfg`V VSe TudYWd^[UZWHSd^S_W`f !Sge W[`W_E[ffW^ VWdHdW^^WdW[%iSe WeT[eZWdiSd% [` W[`NWd]lWgYVWd:WXdW[g`Y! lg hWdiS`VW^`(DW`[`TWfa`fWi[WVWdZa^f4!<[W 9dTW[fWd]^SeeWiudVW We Sfud^[UZhadl[WZW`%V[WESUZf *2-)(.-', lg uTWd`WZ_W`(!, <aUZ laY WdY^W[UZlW[f[YSge VWd?WeUZ[UZfWV[WJUZ^grXa^YWdg`Y%VSr We![_ ZtUZefW?dSVWiSZdeUZW[`^[UZ!eW[%!VSr V[W:agdYWa[e[WVW_Hda^WfSd[Sf]W[`WXd[WV^[UZWCa`lWee[a` _SUZW`%ea`VWd` [_W`feUZW[VW`VW`9gYW`T^[U][ZdWHd[h[^WY[W`_[f ?WiS^f hWdfW[V[YW`i[dV!-(

NW[^ V[WZWddeUZW`VW`C^SeeW`lgf[WXefha^]eXW[`V^[UZ%W`fSdfWfg`V ha_Ma^]WYWZSrfiSdW`%iW[^ e[Wht^^[Y :S`]daff YW_SUZfZSffW`%VWeZS^ThWd'^[WXWV[WIWha^gf[a`W` [` Igr^S`V +3+1%eai[W S`VWdWIWha^gf[a`W` [` hWd'eUZ[WVW`W`Ds`VWd` =gdabSe% dW^Sf[hg`T^gf[Y( =def V[WCa`fWddWha^gf[a`g`V V[W[_bWd[S^[ef[eUZWA`fWdhW`f[a`e]d[WYWeWflfW`VW`:udYWd]d[WYSgXV[WKSYWeadV`g`Y(?WYW`isdf[Y _Srf e[UZVWdA_bWd[S^[e_geVWdLJ9 V[WIa^^WVWeNW^fYW`VSd_WS` g`V hWdegUZf5V[WS`f[[_bWd[S^[ef[eUZW:WiW'Yg`YW`eW^Tef[` eaghWds`W`Ds`VWd` [_ :^gfW lg Wdef[U]W`(<aUZ ZWgfWi[dV\WVWeg_ eW[`W>dW[ZW[fd[`YW`VWMa^] ha_ NW^fekefW_ VWeJal[S^[e_geg`fWdefuflf g`V YWefsd]f(

<[W 9dTW[fWd]^SeeW[` VW`_W[efW`Ds`VWd` _gr SgUZiW[fWdZ[`_[f VW_YWiS^feS_W` N[VWdefS`V"VWeZWddeUZW`VW`Ea`aba^]Sb[fS^e% eW[`WddWS]'f[a`sdW` Ha^[lW[%9d_WWg`V eW[`W_:WS_fW`SbbSdSf dWUZ`W`%V[WVW`Xd[WV'^[UZWNWY lg_ Jal[S^[e_ge lg Z[`VWd`hWdegUZW`(L_ [ZdW@WddeUZSXfSgX'dWUZflgWdZS^fW`%XuZdW V[WEa`aba^]Sb[fS^[efW` g`V [ZdW<[W`Wd%V[WdWUZ'fW` >uZdWdVWdJal[S^VW_a]dSf[W%hWd^aYW`W[VWa^aY[eUZ'ba^[f[eUZW9dYg'_W`fWlgd MWdfW[V[Yg`YVWdTdgUZ[YW@WddeUZSXfVWd>[`S`la^[YSdUZ[W[`e> W^V(AZdW9dYg_W`fW e[`V [_ iWeWaf^[V[W`[UZf `Wg( J[WW`fefS__W` VW_S^fW`%hWdTdSgUZfW`9deW`S^ VWd!MWdfW[V[YWdVWe9TW`V^S`VWe!%_[f VW`W`DW`[` Ydu`V^[UZSTdWUZ`WfW(

DW`[` TWfdSUZfWfWV[WJai\Wf_SUZf `gd S^e W[`WVWd_tY^[UZW`>ad_W` VWd<[]fSfgd VWeHda^WfSd[Sfe(KSfesUZ^[UZW`fi[U]W^fW e[UZ[` VW` Ds`VWd`E[ffW^' g`V NWefWgdabSe[` VWddWha^gf[a`sdW`Cd[eWSUZVW_WdefWNW^f']d[WYhWdeUZ[WVW`Sdf[YWCW[_WVWd WgW` JfSSfe_SUZf VWd9dTW[fWd]^SeeW(<[WeWg`V V[WebsfWdW`fi[U]W^fW>ad_W` VWdha^]eVW_a]dSf[eUZW JfSSfe'_SUZf WdigUZeWSge VW_ dWha^gf[a`sdW`CS_bX VWdMa^]e_SeeW` g`V Wd'

+ CSd ESdj g`V >d[WVd[UZ=`YW^e%9geYWisZ^fW JUZd[XfW[` liW[ :s`VW`% :V( A%<[WflMWd^SY%:Wd^[` +3/2%J( ++. ((

, N( A(DW`[`%NWd]W%:V( .% J( ,1*(- =TW`VS%J( ,1+(

_tY^[UZfWWTW`eai[W V[WJai\Wfe%VW N[^^W`VWeMa^]WeSgelgXuZdWg`Vg`fWdVWd>uZdg`Y VWd9dTW[fWd]^SeeWV[WTdW[fWefW`Ma^]e_SeeW`lg adYS`['e[WdW`%VWdWCdsXfWlg W`fXS^fW`%g`V V[W9geTWgfg`Ylg TWeW[f[YW`(

9gUZV[W!I[UZf^[`[W`VWdCa__g`[ef[eUZW` A`fWd`Sf[a`S^W!ZSffW XudV[W9dTW[fWdTWiWYg`YW[`WYdarW:WVWgfg`Y(L`fWd VWd@WddeUZSXfVWeIWXad'_[e_ge ^[`VPW`fd[e_ge YSTWe[` VWXuZdW`VWHSdfW[WVWdAA(A`fWd`Sf[a'`S^W]W[` ]a`]dWfWeHdaYdS__ XudV[W9gXYSTW VWd9dTW[fWd]^SeeWlg_dWha^gf[a`sdWJfgdl VWd:agdYWa[e[Wg`V VW 9gXTSg VWeJal[S^[e_ge( E[fVW`!I[UZf^[`[W`! WdZ[W^fV[W[`fWd`Sf[a`S^W9dTW[fWd]^SeeWW[`ea^UZWeHda'YdS__( <adf ZW[rfWe4!<[W`WgW=baUZW[ef YWTadW` ((( <[W=baUZWVWd]a_'_g`[eX[eUZWIWha^gf[a` VWeHda^WfSd[Sfe(!! A` S^^W Ds`VWd` isUZef V[WdWha^gf[a`sdW:WiWYg`YS`( Hda^WfSd[eUZWg`V ]a^a`[S^WIWha^gf[a`W`eai[W`Sf[a`S^W:WXdW[g`YeTWiWYg`YW`WdeUZuffWd`VW`A_bWd[S^[e_ge%VWd[UZf_WZd S`YW[_efS`VW[ef%eW[`Wg`ZW[^ha^^W=[`X^gr [` VWdNW^fSgelguTW`(<[WCdSXf%V[WV[WEW`eUZZW[fS`e VW_]Sb[fS^[ef[eUZW`;ZSae ZWdSgeXuZdW`]S``% [ef VSeHda^WfSd[Sf(<WdNWYYWZfuTWdV[W=dd[UZfg`YVWdba^[f[eUZW`ESUZfVWd9dTW[fWd]^SeeW%V[W=`fW[Y`g`Y VWd?darTagdYWa[e[Wg`V V[WJa'l[S^[e[Wdg`Y[ZdWdL`fWd`WZ_g`YW`(L_ e[WYW`lg ]t``W`% _gr VSedWha^g'f[a`sdWHda^WfSd[Sfe[UZha` VW Gbbadfg`[efW` fdW``Wg`V _[f S^^WlgeS_'_W`YWZW`%V[WXudVW`J[WYVWd<[]fSfgd VWeHda^WfSd[SfeW[`fdWfW`(9^^WCS_bX_WfZaVW' SgUZV[WbSd^S_W`fSd[eUZW`' _ueeW` VWd=`fXS^fg`YVWdESeeW`S]f[a`W` VWdNWd]fsf[YW g`fWdYWadV`WfiWdVW`(

A_ !ES`[XWefVWe+(Ca`YdWeeWe!TW]S``fWe[UZV[WAAA(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^Wlg_!ES`[XWefVWdCa__g`[ef[eUZW` HSdfW[!ha` ESdj g`V =`YW^e(<[WCa_'_g`[ef[eUZWA`fWd`Sf[a`S^WTWfdSUZfWfWe[UZS^eFSUZXa^YWdg`V Ma^^Td[`YWdVWdJSUZWVWd:WYdu`VWdVWei[eeW`eUZSXf^[UZW`Jal[S^[e_ge( @WgfW%.* BSZdWebsfWd%Y[^f aUZ_WZdS^e+3+3 V[W>WefefW^^g`Y[_ ES`[XWefVWeWdefWCa`'YdWeeWe4!A_ ?dg`VWY[`YV[W=`fi[U]^g`Y VaUZVW`NWY%VWd[Zd[_ ES`['XWefVWdCa__g`[ef[eUZW` HSdfW[hadYWlW[YfiSd(! , 9_ JUZ^gr VWe<a]g'_W`fWed[WXV[WCa__g`[ef[eUZWA`fWd`Sf[a`S^WV[WHda^WfSd[WdS^^WdDs`VWdSgX%e[UZg`fWdVW_:S``Wd VWeCS_bXWeXudV[WIsfW%XudV[W=dd[UZfg`YVWdESUZfVWd9dTW[fWd]^SeeWlg hWdW[`[YW`(

<[W:WeUZ^ueeWVWe+(Ca`YdWeeWeigdVW` aZ`WWd`efWEW[`g`YehWdeUZ[W'VW`ZW[fW`S`YW`a__W`( =e Wdi[Wee[UZ%VSr DW`[` ht^^[YdWUZfZSffW%S^eWdTWdW[fe[_ 9bd[^ +3+1 eUZd[WT%V[W 0)5)! dWha^gf[a`sdW%bda^WfSd[eUZWA`fWd'`Sf[a`S^W! TWefWZWXS]f[eUZeUZa`%e[Wi[d]W VgdUZ9]f[a`W` g`V VgdUZ!VW`

+ J[WZWJ( 1. VWehad^[WYW`VW`:S`VWe(, J[WZWJ( 2, VWehad^[WYW`VW`:S`VWe(

d[UZf[YW9geVdgU] VWdAVWW`g`V VWdHa^[f[] VWei[d]^[UZ dWha^gf[a`sdW`Hda^WfSd[Sfe!7S^^WdDs`VWd(<[WdWha^gf[a`sdWD[`]W` [` VW HSdfW[WVWdWZW_S^[YW`AA(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^WiSdW` TWdW[fe`[UZf_WZd`gd W[`WJfdt_g`Y[` VWd[`fWd`Sf[a`S^W9dTW[fWdTWiWYg`Y%ea`VWd`ZSffW`e[UZ[` VW i[UZ'f[YefW Ds`VWd` lg HSdfW[WW`fi[U]W^f%V[WVW`N[^^W` ZSffW`%e[UZVW`ESdj[e_ge'DW`[`[e_ge S`lgW[Y`W`(<WdCa`YdWrlW[YfW%VSr SgUZV[WiWd]'fsf[YW`ESeeW` VWd]a^a`[S^W` g`V ZS^T]a^a`[S^W Ds`VWde[UZg_ V[WeWe:S``Wd lg eS__W[` TWYS``W`(9gX VW_Ca`YdWriSdW` MWdfdWfWdSge;Z[`S%CadWSg`V HWde[WS`iWeW`V(Pg_ WdefW`_SW`fefS`VW[`WV[WYS`lWNW^fg_ebS``W`VWA`fWd`Sf[a`S^W(

<[W FSUZd[UZfha` VWd?du`Vg`Y VWdAAA(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^W[`_[ffW` VWddWha^gf[a`sdWCd[eWVWe]Sb[fS^[ef[eUZW`JkefW_eefsd]fWVWCS_bXWei[^^W`VWd]^SeeW`TWigrfW9dTW[fWd(<[WIafW 9d_WWTWe[WYfW[ZdW>W[`VWg`VhWdfd[WTe[Wha_ Jai\WffWdd[fad[g_(<[W9dTW[fWd]^SeeW[` L`YSd`%VWdJ^a'iS]W[ g`V :SkW_ bda]^S_[WdfWIsfWdWbgT^[]W`(9gX Ea4e]Sg%VSe@WdlVWeWdefW9dTW[fWd'g`V':SgWd`'JfSSfWe%VW`J[fl VWdA`fWd`Sf[a`S^W%d[UZfWfW`e[UZZaXX`g`Yeha^V[W9gYW`S^^Wd9geYWTWgfWfW`(DW`[`igdVW[__Wd _WZdS^eVWdTWVWgfW`VefW9dTW[fWdXuZdWdS`Wd]S``f(

<[W]a__g`[ef[eUZW` HSdfW[W`igUZeW`%g`fWd[Z`W` SgUZV[WCa__g`['ef[eUZWHSdfW[<WgfeUZ^S`Ve%aTiaZ^ e[W[` VWdIWha^gf[a` YdarWGbXWdYW'TdSUZfZSffWg`V g`fWdeUZiWdWMWdXa^Yg`YW`]s_bXW` _grfW( A` VW lW`'fd[ef[eUZWHSdfW[W`hWdefsd]fWV[WdWha^gf[a`sdW9dTW[fWd[ZdWGbbae[f[a`g`V TWYS``W`%e[UZVWdAAA(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^Wlg `sZWd`(=[`W9`lSZ^ HSdfW[W`Wd]^sdfW[ZdW`:W[fd[ff lgd AAA(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^W%VSdg`fWdV[Weal[S^[ef[eUZW`HSdfW[WTWl[WZg`YeiW[eWVWdW`[`]W?dgbbW`%[` >dS`]dW[UZ%AfS^[W`%:g^'YSd[W`%FadiWYW`%JUZiWVW`%@a^^S`V%VWdJUZiW[l%VWLJ9% [` ?darZd[fS`'`[W`g`V JbS`[W`( <[W]a__g`[ef[eUZW:WiWYg`YWdYd[XXSgUZV[WSe[Sf[eUZW`Ds`VWd;Z[`S%CadWS%@a^^s`V[eUZ'A`V[W`%A`V[W`%HWde[W`g`V V[WKud]W[(

=[`[YWlW`fd([ef[eUZWHSdfW[W`fdSfW g`fWdVW_<dgU] VWd]^SeeW`TWigrfW`9dTW[fWdSge VWd@(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^WSge g`V TWS`fdSYfW`[ZdW9gX`SZ_W [`V[WA@(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^WaVWdTWYS``W`%uTWd[ZdW:W[fd[fflg hWdZS`VW^`(9^ee[UZV[WESeeW` `SUZ^[`]e iS`VfW`%ebS^fWfWV[Wabbadfg`[ef[eUZW>uZdWdd[YadaeW[`[YWHSdfW[W`(A` S`VWdWHSdfW[WY[`YW`lW`fd[ef[eUZW>uZdWdeUZW[`TSdTWdW[fi[^^[Ye`[fVWdWha^gf[a`sdW9dTW[fWd_SeeW`%`gd g_ S` VWdJb[flWlg T^W[TW`g`V TdW_eWlg ]t``W`( =e W`fefS`VV[W?WXSZdW[`WePg'efda_e lW`fd[ef[eUZWd=^W_W`fWlgd Ca__g`[ef[eUZW` A`fWd`Sf[a`S^W(=[`uTWdZS`V`WZ_Wea^UZWd=^W_W`fWZsffWS`YWe[UZfeVWdabbadfg`[ef[eUZW`

! N( +(DW`[`%9geYWisZ^fWNWd]W[` liW[ :s`VW`% :V( AA%<[Wfl MWd^SY%:Wd^[` +3//%J(.*(

@S^TZW[fW`g`V [VWa^aY[eUZW`JUZisUZW VWdPW`fd[efWV[WWgWA`fWd`Sf[a'`S^W^sZ_W`%lWdeWflWg`V ]S_bXg`XsZ[Y _SUZW`_ueeW`( <[W Ca__g'`[ef[eUZWA`fWd`Sf[a`S^WZSffWV[W9gXYSTWlg ^teW`%VW PW`fd[efWVW Pg'fd[ff [` V[WCa__g`[ef[eUZW A`fWd`Sf[a`S^Wlg hWdebWddW`%STWdY^W[UZlW[f[YV[WaUZ _[f [Z`W` hWdTg`VW`W9dTW[fWdlg YWi[``W`( <Wd AA(Ca`YdWr_grfW V[WMWdbX^[UZfg`YW`XWef^WYW`%V[WV[WeWHSdfW[Wg`V >uZdWd_[f[ZdW_=[`fd[ff [` V[WAAA(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^Wlg uTWd`WZ_WZSffW`(

A`<WgfeUZ^S`VXadVWdfW`V[W9dTW[fWd[` VWdL`STZs`Y[YW` Jal[S^VW_a']dSf[eUZWHSdfW[%V[WW[`W9dTW[fWdbSdfW[_[f W[`WdlW`fd[ef[eUZW>uZdg`YiSdf%ha` [ZdW >uZdWd`WZd^[UZW=d]^sdg`YW` uTWdVW hadTWZS^f^aeW`9`'eUZ^grVWdLJH< S` V[WCa__g`[ef[eUZW A`fWd`Sf[a`S^W(L`fWd V[WeW_ESeeW`VdgU]Wd]^sdfWe[UZSgUZea^UZWlW`fd[ef[eUZW>uZdWdi[W <[ff_S``g`V ;d[eb[W` _[f VW_9`eUZ^gr W[`hWdefS`VW`%STWde[Wia^^fW` e[UZXud[ZdW`Gbbadfg`[e_ge [` VWdbdS]f[eUZWHa^[f[] ha^^W>dW[ZW[fTWiSZdW`(<WdDW[b'l[YWdHSdfW[fSY[_ FahW_TWd+3+3TWeUZ^arVW 9gefd[ff VWdLJH< Sge VWdAA(A`fWd`Sf[a`S^Wg`V TWSgXfdSYfWV[WHSdfW[XuZdg`Y%_[f VWdAAA(A`fWd'`Sf[a`S^WuTWdVW :W[fd[ffVWdLJH< lg hWdZS`VW^`(

9`VWdWdeW[feuTWdeb[flfW_S`UZW?dgbbW` dWha^gf[a`sdWd9dTW[fWd[`hWdeUZ[WVW`W`Ds`VWd` [ZdW`HdafWefYWYWVW`MWddSfVWdGbbadfg`[efW`g`V iS`VfW` e[UZg^fdSdSV[]S^Wg`V ek`V[]S^[ef[eUZW9gXXSeeg`YW lg(=e ZS`VW^fWe[UZ_W[efg_ WZd^[UZWdWha^gf[a`sdW9dTW[fWd%VW`WV[WCa_'_g`[efW` liSd ]W[`Wbd[`l[b[W^^WCa`lWee[a`W` _SUZW`VgdXfW`%VW`We[WSTWdVgdUZ]S_WdSVeUZSXf^[UZWCd[f[] ZW^XW`]a``fW`( AZ`W _grfW VSeMWd'efs`V`[e XudV[WIa^^WVWd]a__g`[ef[eUZW` HSdfW[WdeUZ^aeeW`iWdVW`%W[`WdHSdfW[_[f ]^SdW_ dWha^gf[a`sdW_HdaYdS__%dWha^gf[a`sdWdKS]f[] g`VW[eWd`Wd<[el[b^[`(