32
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011 http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 1/32 ACCA mAlAysiA sustAinAbility reporting AWArDs (masrA) 2011

Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 1/32

ACCA mAlAysiA

sustAinAbility reporting AWArDs (masrA) 2011

Page 2: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 2/32

2

2

Page 3: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 3/32

3

contents

Introduction 4

Theageofintegration:anewdawnforcorporatereporting 6

Panelofjudges 11

Entrants 12

Shortlistedreports 14

ACCAMaSRA2011winners 17

Judges’feedback 25

Supportingorganisations 28

AboutACCA 31

ACKnoWleDgement

ACCAwouldliketothankandacknowledgethecontributionandsupportof

thedistinguishedpanelofjudges,AccountAbility,BursaMalaysiaBerhad,

CorporateRegister.com,TheDepartmentofEnvironment(DOE),TheEdge

BusinessWeekly,TheEdgeFinancialDailyandlastbutnotleastallparticipating

companiesintheAwards.Webelievethattheparticipatingcompanies

deserverecognitionforleadingthewaytoidentifyandcommunicatetheir

environmentalandsocialperformance.Companiessuchasthesearecontributingtowardstheadvancementofsustainabledevelopmentandperformance.

Page 4: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 4/324

SincethelastACCAMaSRA,the

worldofcorporatesocialresponsibility

andsustainabilityreportinghasbeen

undergoingtremendouschange.Thisis

reflectedinthevariousdevelopmentson

theinternationalandlocalfront.

Nationally,BursaMalaysiaremainsa

keydriverofsustainabilityreporting

forcorporateMalaysia.Followingthe

developmentoftheCSRframework

in2006,BursaMalaysialaunched

thesustainabilityportalandGuide

forDirectorsin2010.Thisinitiative

recognisesthatthesustainabilityagenda

needstobedrivenfromtheboardroomandembeddedwithinacorporate

strategy.TheEnvironment,Socialand

Governance(ESG)Indexscheduledto

belaunchedinlate2012willbeBursa

Malaysia’snextsteptofurtherdrive

sustainabilitystrategiesanddisclosurein

corporateMalaysia.

Aregionalinitiativeaimedatinvestors

–The2010AsianSustainabilityRating–placedMalaysiancompanies

Wc h ACCA r h Jd h

maaa saa r Awad (masrA)

2011. ACCA ad a h

masrA 2011 wd k hak a h ca

ha acad h a.

asoneoftheleadersofsustainability

disclosureintheregion.However,

corporateMalaysiacannotbecomplacent.

Companieswhowerefirstmoversin

sustainabilitydisclosureareblazing

ahead.Thesecompaniesareadopting

managementsystemstoseamlesslytrackandimprovesustainability

performance.Likewise,countriesinthe

regionpreviouslyratedbehindMalaysia

insustainabilitydisclosurearenow

catchingup.Thispastyearsawregional

stockexchangesbeginningtomandate

sustainabilityreportingandthelaunchof

sustainabilityindexes.

Thestandardswhichguidegoodpractice

inreportingarealsoevolving.Earlierthis

year,theGlobalReportingInitiative(GRI),

launchedarevisionoftheirguidelines,

theG3.1.Fiveyearsonfromitslastrevision,

theG3.1isthemostcomprehensiveand

completesustainabilityreportingguidance

todate.Therevisionaimstomakethe

frameworkmorerobustwiththeadditionof

11newindicatorsintheareasofhumanrights,societyandlabourpractices.

4

introduction

Page 5: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 5/32

5

Attheendof2010,ISO26000onSocial

Responsibilitywaslaunched.ISO26000

givesacomprehensiveandcleardefinition

ofwhatsocialresponsibilitymeans.The

ISO26000representsa‘standardof

standards’,bringingtogetherbestpractices

fromabroadrangeofinitiatives.ISO

26000wasdevelopedoveradecadeof

consultationwithstakeholders,andisnow

recognisedinover90countries.

TheISO26000isanoncertifiablestandard

basedonsevenprinciples:Accountability;

Transparency;Ethicalbehaviour;Respect

forstakeholderinterest;Respectforrules

oflaw;Respectforinternationalnormsof

behaviour;andRespectforhumanrights.

Theseprinciplesareappliedinsevencore

areasoforganisationalgovernance,humanrights,labourpractices,fairoperating

practices,consumerissues,environment

andcommunityinvestment.

Investors,akeystakeholderofcompanies,

arealsoincreasinglydemanding

companiestodisclosesustainability

performance.InSeptemberthisyear,

thePlasticDisclosureProject(PDP)

waslaunchedundertheClintonGlobal

Initiative.Aninvestorsupportedinitiative,

thePDPtracksdisclosurebycompanies

oftheirplasticuseandtheirstrategies

forreducingitsenvironmentalimpact.

ThisfollowsonthesuccessfulCarbon

DisclosureProject(CDP)whichrepresents

551institutionalinvestors,witha

combinedUSD71trillionfundunder

management.TheCDPwaslaunchedtoacceleratesolutionstoclimatechangeand

introduction

watermanagementbyputtingrelevant

informationattheheartofbusiness,

policyandinvestmentdecisions.Over

3,000companiesinsome60countries

aroundtheworldnowmeasureand

disclosetheirgreenhousegasemissions,

watermanagementandclimatechange

strategiesthroughCDP.

Acommonthemerunsacross

thesenewinitiatives:emphasison

accountabilityandtransparency.

Accountabilityisaboutproving

sustainabilityperformancewith

evidencetobackupanyclaimsmade.

Accountabilityalsomeanswelcoming

scrutinyandengagementwith

criticalstakeholders.

Transparencyrequiresacompanyto

providesufficientinformationsothat

stakeholderscan‘seeinto’thecompany.

Thismeansthatwhenastakeholder

looksatdocuments,corporatewebsites

andassociatedreports,enough

informationshouldbeavailabletoallow

themtohaveagoodideaabouthowthe

companyisrun,howwellitismanaged,

howdecisionsaremadeandwhat

thematerialrisksassociatedwiththe

businessare.Arobustsustainabilityreport

canachievethis.

Thisyear,ACCAMaSRAreceivedatotal

of43entries.Thesereportswerescored

andrankedbyashortlistingpanel.The

top20companieswereevaluatedby

theACCAMaSRAjudgingpanel.Oftheshortlistedentries,15werestand-alone

sustainabilityreportandfiveaspartof

theirannualreports.

Inourview,eachcompanythat

participatesinACCAMaSRAisa

winner.Participationdemonstratesa

company’scommitmenttocommunicating

sustainabilityperformance.Participationin

theACCAMaSRAshouldsetabenchmark

forcompaniestoimprovetheirrespective

sustainabilityreporting.TheACCAMaSRA

judgeshaveseengreatimprovementsin

thequalityofsustainabilityreportingin

Malaysia–atestamenttocompanies’

continuouslearningprocesses.

Nextyear,theACCAMaSRAwillcelebrate

itstenthanniversary.Wecontinuetobe

committedtothevaluesofthisworldwideinitiativetoidentifyandrewardinnovative

attemptstocommunicatesustainability

performance.Inthecomingmonths,we

welcomecompaniestoengagewiththe

ACCAtogetabetterunderstandingof

sustainabilitydisclosureinpreparation

forthenextACCAMaSRA.

Welookforwardtoyourparticipationin

theACCAMaSRA2012.

Page 6: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 6/32

6

Theglobalfinancialcrisishaspersuaded

manyoftheneedforaneweconomic

modelthatcanprotectbusinesses,

investors,employeesandsocietyfrom

acycleofsuccessiveandincreasingly

debilitatingcrises.Atpresent,short-term

financialgainscantakepriorityover

long-termvaluegeneration,encouraginga

gung-hoapproachtorisk-takingthatcan

leadtoalevelofmarketinstability,which

hasthepotentialtodevastateindividualbusinessesandwholeeconomies.The

currentmodelofcorporatereporting,it

isfelt,doesnotdoenoughtodiscourage

suchbehaviourbecauseitdoesn’tpay

enoughattentiontofactorssuchasrisk,

strategy,governanceandthesustainability

ofbusinessmodels.

Theseconcerns,whichhavegrownas

businessleadersandgovernmentshave

agonisedoverthecausesofthefinancial

crisis,havegivenimpetustoexisting

demandsforachangeinemphasisin

corporatereportingonthegroundsthat

itdoesnotcurrentlyadequatelyreflect

materialenvironmental,socialand

governance(ESG)factors.Theseinclude

resourceusage,socialimpacts,human

rightsandhowabusinessmightcontributetoorbeaffectedbyclimatechange.

ACCA’ n s k a wh ad wha

d h a d a ad

awk ad ak c

Manybelievethatover-consumptionof

finitenaturalresourcesandtheriskof

catastrophicclimatechangepresentoneof

theworld’sgreatestchallenges–andisits

biggestbusinessrisk.

Supportersofintegratedreportingargue

thattheinclusionofallthesenon-

financialbutneverthelesscrucialrisk

factorsintocorporatereportingwould

helpsteerbusinessdecision-makinginamoresustainabledirection–inboth

financialandenvironmentalterms.They

arguethatthequalityofreportingwould

improvebecausebusinesseswould

provideamorestrategicpictureofthe

issuesthatarecriticaltotheirlong-term

sustainabilityandsuccess.Inaddition,

thosemanagingcompanieswouldbe

abletomakebetterresourcedecisionsby

includingissuesrelatingtonaturaland

socialcapitalaswellasfinancialcapital.

Theresultwouldbeamoreholistic

pictureofthereportingentitythatcovers

bothrisksandopportunities,andreflects

theinterconnectionsbetweenESGand

financialfactors.

NeilStevensonisACCA’s

executivedirector–brand,

andamemberofthe

InternationalIntegrated

ReportingCommittee

(IIRC)Engagementand

Communicationstaskforce.

HisremitatACCAcovers

marketing,communications,

policy,technicalissuesandpublishing.Thisincludes

promotingaglobalagenda

ofresearchandinsights,

complementinghisinterest

inissuesinvolvingchange

andinnovationintheglobal

professions.

newdawnforreporting

Page 7: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 7/32

7

newdawnforreporting

integrAteD reporting

Whiletherehavebeensignificant

advancesinsustainabilityreportingover

recentyears,nosinglebodyhassofar

hadtheauthorityoroversighttobringall

thedifferentreportingpillarstogetherin

asingle,mandatory,fullyintegratedand

globallyendorsedframework.

ThisistheambitionoftheInternational

IntegratedReportingCommittee(IIRC),

formedlastyearbyaprogressivesection

ofthebusiness,financialandaccounting

community,bringingtogethermanyleading

accountancyfirms,big-namecompanies,

businessgroupsandprofessional

accountancybodies,includingACCA.The

twokeybodiesinvolvedarethePrinceof

WalesAccountingforSustainabilityProject

(A4S)andtheGlobalReportingInitiative.A

seriesofprofile-raisingeventsareplanned

for2011,kickingoffwitharoundtable

discussioninMumbai,India,chairedby

InternationalOrganizationofSecurities

CommissionschairmanJaneDiplock,as

AccountancyFutureswenttopress.

Thereleaseofadiscussionpaperlooking

atanintegratedreportingframework

isplannedforJune2011.Interested

stakeholdersareinvitedtocomment

beforeitisformalisedandpresentedto

theG20inCannesinNovember2011.

G20approvalwilladdcredibilityand

injectvigourintothemovetowardsglobal

standardisation.TheIIRC’saimisthatthe

frameworkwillbeconstructedinaway

thatallowscompaniestoreportinaclear,

concise,consistentandcomparableway.

sustAinAbility CHAllenge

Theaccountingelementofthemassive

changerequiredwashighlightedbythe

creationofA4Sin2004,whichreiterated

theneedfornewapproachestoaccounting

andreportingtoreflectthebroaderand

longer-termconsequencesofcorporate

decisions.Withoutmorecompleteand

comprehensiveinformation,management,

investorsandotherscannotmakethefully

informeddecisionsneededtoprosperin

thefaceofsustainabilitychallenges.

A4Sfeltthattheprofession’sbest

contributiontosustainabilitywouldbeto

establishaglobalframeworkofmandatory

‘connectedreporting’requirements

forlistedcompaniesandforaglobal

committeeofkeystakeholdergroupsto

pushforglobaladoption.

TheGRI,alongwithotherbodiessuch

astheCarbonDisclosureProject,

havemadesignificantstepsforward

informalisingreportingguidelinesfor

companies’materialenvironmental,

socialandeconomicimpacts.Yetdespite

thecorporateuptakeandintegrationof

more-than-financialimpactassessments,

thereisstilllittleevidencethatcollective

corporateeffortshavesignificantlyhalted

activitiesthatpollute,depleteresourcesanddestroynon-financialvalue.

   M  a   n  a

  g   e   m  e   n   t

  c  o   m   m

  e   n   t  a   r   y 

     G    o    v    e    r    n    a    n    c    e    a    n     d

    r    e    m    u    n    e    r    a     t     i    o

    nE     n    

v    i     r    o    n    m    e    n    t     a    n    d     s    o    c    i     a    l     

F     i     n    

a    n    c    i     a    l     

Integrated

reporting

framework

S    o   u   r   c   e   :  I    I    R    

C    

integrAteD reporting:

foCusing on tHe top sliCe

Integratedreportingprovides

thetoplevelstructureforthe

wholereportingpyramid

Page 8: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 8/32

8

newdawnforreporting

Thevoluntarynatureofsuchreporting

initiativesmeansthattake-upcanbe

fragmented,allowingcompanieswith

largeimpactsontheenvironment

andsocietytoavoidfulland

transparentdisclosure.

WHAt Will it looK liKe?

Consideringthatintegratedreportingisstill

inanembryonicphase,itshouldcome

asnosurprisethataclearformulation

ofwhatexactlyitconstitutesisstill

beingdebated.Definitionsrangefrom

themaintenanceofcurrentfinancial

reportingandaccountingpracticesbased

onInternationalFinancialReporting

Standards(IFRS)withanESGsection

boltedon,rightuptoacompletechange

inthefundamentalsofaccountingandreportingformats.

Thereis,however,agreementonthe

needforaconciseandcomprehensive

integratedreportingframeworkwhich

isstructuredaroundanorganisation’s

strategicobjectives,itsgovernanceand

businessmodel,andintegratingmaterial

financialandnon-financialinformation.

Thekeyconsiderationisthestrategic

ingraininganddisclosureofallESG

factorsaffectingthefuturefinancial

performanceandassociatedriskratingof

acompany’sactivities.Thecentraltenet

ofintegratedreportinghasbeenpartof

thesustainabilityandCSRreportingspace

foranumberofyears,butitisIIRC’s

ambitiontobringtogetherfinancialand

non-financialriskdisclosureinaglobal,

mandatoryframeworkwhichsetsitapart

frompastinitiatives,andwhichengages

andrelatestoinvestors.

Scepticsoftheintegratedreporting

initiativepointtowardsaraftofissues.Thefirstisthesheerambitionofthechange

thatisbeingputforward,involvingthe

hugechallengeofgainingglobalconsensus

toamandatorychange,especiallygiven

thatithassofartakenmorethan30years

toagreetheglobalapplicationofIFRS.

Othercriticismsincludefearsthatitwill

Theresultwouldbeamoreholisticpictureof

thereportingentitythatcoversbothrisksand

opportunities,andreflectstheinterconnections

betweenESGandfinancialfactors

leadtoincreasedcomplexityinreporting

andgreaterresourcingrequirements,anda

tick-boxapproach.

Butgiventhepowerfulbackersandthe

fundamentalfinancialandenvironmental

issuesinvolved,thelaunchoftheIIRC

maywellturnouttobeaturningpointin

thedevelopmentofcorporatereporting.

However,alongsidethisdevelopment,itis

clearthatwewillalsoneedtoencourage

agreaterproportionofshareholdersto

becomemoreinterestedinthegovernance

andsustainabilityoftheorganisations

theyinvestin.Thiswillbethebestwayof

ensuringintegratedreportingisembedded

inbusinessinpractice.Muchattentionhas

beenpaid,rightly,tothemodelsaroundauditingandassuranceandcorporate

reporting.Perhapsweneedtodevelop

moreurgencyaroundthisthirddimension:

governanceandstewardship.Thiscould

leadtothefulfilmentoftheambitionsof

thosewhoadvocatethe‘triplebottomline’:

asustainableapproachtosustainability.

Page 9: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 9/32

9

newdawnforreporting

b : Caca wha

a dd, ACCA’ rach

 Jack a ad ca

ha h c ca ac

Theideaofintegratedreportinghas

beenincreasinglyunderdiscussionby

stakeholdersintheworldofbusiness

accountingandsustainabilityreporting.

Thedefinitionofwhatintegratedreporting

actuallycoversiscurrentlyarangeof

blurrygreysratherthanacrispandclear

blackandwhite.However,lookedatin

broadterms,integratedreportingissimply

theendresult(thereporting)ofacomplex

butinclusiveprocessthatintegrates

thebusinessstrategywithmaterial

sustainabilityissues.

Someoptimisticobserversseean

integratedstrategyasboosting

transparencyandofferingaclearer

explanationoftherelationship

betweencompanies’financialand

non-financialperformance.Other,

morecautiousprofessionalshighlight

possiblechallengessuchasgreater

reportingcomplexity,comparabilityand

assuranceacrosssectorsandcountries,

anddiscordintimescalesbetween

compilationoftheintegratedreporting

frameworkandcontinuingphysical

impactsofclimatechange.

Thereisnodoubtthatawell-developed

integratedreportingmethodologycould

focuscorporateeffortstointegratematerial

sustainabilityissuesandimpactsarising

frombusinessactivitiesmoredeeplyin

strategicdecision-makingprocesses.

Deployinganintegratedstrategyasa

riskscreentoassessoperationsfortheir

mediumtolong-termsustainabilityand

financialimplicationscouldstrengthen

governanceprotocols,createlessdisparate

businessesandchangefinancialmarket

investmentbehaviour.

Fewcompaniescurrentlytakean

integratedreportingapproach.Thisblankcanvasofferstherelevantprofessions

anopportunitytoshapetheframework.

ACCAispleasedtobepartoftheIIRC,

whichhasambitiousplanstodojustthis.

Weshallcontinuetoparticipateactively,

takingpartinthedebatesthatarise,

addressingquestionsaroundtherelevance

ofintegratedreporting,findingwaysto

stimulateinvestorandregulatordemand

forintegratedreporting,anddeveloping

usefulreportingmetrics.

RachelJacksonisACCA’s

headofsustainability.She

championsACCA’sglobal

sustainabilityagendaon

reportinganddisclosure

withspecificreferenceto

environmental,economic

andsocialissues.

RachelrepresentsACCA

onvarioustechnicalcommitteesandworking

groupsincludingFEEand

theEPCClimateChange

AdaptationTaskForce.

Page 10: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 10/32

10

newdawnforreporting

RogerAdamsFCCAis

ACCA’sdirector–special

assignments.Hepreviously

managedACCA’sglobal

policypositionson

professionalissues,suchas

sustainabilityandcorporate

responsibility.

 J h d: f h a

h k dac ad

a d wdad ak-,

a ACCA’ r Ada

Oneofthemainproposalsmadeby

theInternationalIntegratedReporting

Committee(IIRC)istheneedfornew

approachestoaccountingandreportingto

reflectthebroaderlong-termconsequences

ofcorporateactivities.Byprovidingrobust

andcomparablereportingguidanceon

howtolinkcorporatestrategytofinancial

andnon-financialperformance,theIIRC

canconvincebusinessesandinvestors

thatfinancialvaluecanbederivedfrom

integratedreporting.

Integratedreportsshouldclearlyidentifyandexplainthelinkbetween

anorganisation’sstrategicgoalsand

theresultingimpactonparameters

suchasthewiderbusinesscontext,key

relationships,resourcedependenciesand

governancestructures,andhelpestablish

amoreholisticcorporateriskprofile.

Toensurewidespreadbusiness

acceptance,theIIRCmustconnectthe

dotsbetweenitselfandotherkeyreporting

guidance.ACCAcontinuestosupport

theGRIanditssustainabilityreporting

framework,andtheClimateDisclosure

StandardsBoard(CDSB)anditsclimate

changereportingframework.Aswell

asidentifyingtheinformationneeds

ofinvestors,theIIRCneedstoprovide

solutionstoanyperceivedbarrierstothe

take-upofintegratedreporting.Theto-do

listincludesaddressingtherequirements

ofmultiplestakeholders,determiningthe

materialityofissues,givinganoptionof

differentreportinglevels,assessingknock-

onimpactstoauditingstandardsand

internalcontrolchecks,andovercoming

corporateconfidentialityissues.

Opportunitiesandbenefitsarisingfrom

amovetowardsintegratedreportingwillhavetobeclearlydemonstratedwithinan

urgentcontextrequiringthemomentum

towardsasustainable,low-carbonglobal

economytogatherpace.Ultimately

theestablishmentofaninternational

frameworkthatnotonlymergesfinancial

andsustainabilityoutcomesbutalso

supportstheachievementofasustainable

economywillrequiresupportfrom

governments,thefinanceandaccounting

communityandwiderstakeholdergroups.

Page 11: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 11/32

11

tHe ACCA masrA 2011 JuDges

m gh Ch y*

Executivedirector,strategyanddevelopment,SecuritiesCommission

y bh Da’ Hajah ra iaah

Directorgeneral,DepartmentofEnvironment,Malaysia

m saa raah

Chiefregulatoryofficer,BursaMalaysiaBerhad

m Dh th

Groupeditor-in-chief,TheEdgeCommunicationsSdnBhd

p sah Haa

Independentconsultant(corporategovernanceandcorporatereporting)

m mhad raa Ad raha

Managingpartner,KPMG

Aca p D fazah Da**

HeadAsia-Pacificcentreforsustainability(APCeS),AccountingResearchInstitute,

FacultyofAccountancy,UniversitiTeknologiMARA(UiTM)

D H J A**

Seniorlecturer,FacultyofEconomicsandManagement,UniversitiPutraMalaysia

m rkk n**

Executivedirector,CSRAsia

*Chairmanofjudgingpanel**Shortlistjudge

panelofjudges

11

Page 12: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 12/32

12

Astro maaa Hd sd bhd

InspiringSustainability2010Report

bh Aca tacc (maaa) bhad

AnnualReport2010:Passion

Dg tcca sd bhd

SustainabilityReport2010

Drb Hi-Com bhad

SustainabilityReport2010:OurPast,Present&Priorities

fa g bhad

AnnualReport2010:EnrichingLives

g Ach bhad

CorporateResponsibilityReport2010:ProgressingSustainably

iJm Ca bhad

AnnualReport2010:TurningtheTide

iJm lad bhad

AnnualReport2010:EnablingSuccess,EnrichingLives

iJm paa bhad

AnnualReport2010:NurturingSustainability

idah Wa K sd bhd

SustainabilityReport2010

Kaa l C C

CorporateSocialResponsibilityReport2010

K (maaa) bhad

AnnualReport2010:TomorrowStartsHere

laa maaa C bhad

AnnualReport2010:CementMadeForLife

l’oa maaa sd bhd

MorethanEver,anEssentialCommitment:HonoringExceptional

WomeninScience

mah s g bhad

AnnualReport2010:ExpandingOurReelofCaptivating&PrestigiousSpaces

maaa rc Ca bhad

CorporateSocialResponsibilityReport2010

maaa rc Ca bhad

AnnualReport2010:WeareFocusedonGrowth

max bhadCorporateResponsibilityStatement

maak

SustainabilityReport2010

mda pa bhad

SustainabilityReport2010:Care>Commitment>Community

merCy maaaAnnualReport2010

maa bhad

AnnualReport2010:SustainingOurMission:SeedingGrowth

maa bhad

CorporateResponsibilityReport2010

entrants2011

Page 13: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 13/32

13

entrants2011

na Hd bhad

AnnualReport2011

né (maaa) bhad

CorporateReport2010:RisingAbove

né (maaa) bhad

CreatingSharedValue2010

pa naa bhad

SustainabilityReport2010

phaaaa bhad

AnnualReport2010:PursuingOpportunities

plus exwa bhad

CorporateSocialResponsibilityReport2009

pc bak bhad

AnnualReport2010:SurpassingExpectations

pcak naa Hd bhad

AnnualReport2010:SustainableGrowth

pajaa pdaa bhad

AnnualReport2010

swa C bhad

AnnualReport2010:RewardingMemories,RisingHigh

swa Hd bhad

AnnualReport2010:Strengthen,Strategise,Synergise

tk maaa bhad

SustainabilityReport2010:StartToday,SaveTomorrow

tx Cc sd bhd

SustainabilityReport2010

tx Cc sd bhd

AnnualReport

tha ecc maaa sd bhd

CorporateSocialResponsibilityReport2009/2010

tadwd paa bhad

AnnualReport2010

uem e sd bhd

SustainabilityReport2010:PartneringwithOurCommunity

uem lad Hd bhad

CorporateResponsibilityReport2010

ytl Ca bhad

SustainabilityReport2010:TheJourneyContinues

y K gaa id bhad

AnnualReport2010

Page 14: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 14/32

14

stAnD Alone CAtegory

1 Astro maaa Hd sd bhd

InspiringSustainabilityReport2010

2 Dg tcca sd bhd

SustainabilityReport2010

3 Drb-HiCom bhad SustainabilityReport2010:OurPast,Present

&Priorities

4 g Ach bhad

CorporateResponsibilityReport2010:

ProgressingSustainably

5 idah Wa K sd bhd

SustainabilityReport2010

6 Kaa l C C

CorporateSocialResponsibilityReport2010

7 maaa rc Ca bhad

CorporateSocialResponsibilityReport2010

8 maak

SustainabilityReport2010

1 2 3

5 6

7 8

4

Progressing SustainablyCorporate Responsibility Report 2010

short-listedreports

Page 15: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 15/32

15

short-listedreports

9 mda pa bhad

SustainabilityReport2010:Care>

Commitment>Community

10 né (maaa) bhad

CreatingSharedValue2010

11 pa naa bhad

SustainabilityReport2010

12 tk maaa bhad

SustainabilityReport2010:StartToday,Save

Tomorrow

13 tx Cc sd bhd

SustainabilityReport2010

14 uem e sd bhd SustainabilityReport:PartneringwithOur

Community

15 uem lad Hd bhad

CorporateResponsibilityReport2010

9 10 11

S U S TAI NABI L I TYR E P O R T2010

Gr u C r r t C unic ti n sTE L EK AL AYS I AE H A (128740-)Level 8(South ing), enaraTJalan antai aharu, 50672KualaLumpur

alaysia

C ONNEC T   C OMMU NIC AT E  C OL L AB ORAT E

Thissustainability reportisprintedon recycledandenvironmentfriendly material.

12 13 14

15

Page 16: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 16/32

16

AnnuAl report CAtegory

1 bh Aca tacc (maaa) bhad

AnnualReport2010:Passion

2 iJm Ca bhad

AnnualReport2010:TurningtheTide

3 K (maaa) bhad AnnualReport2010:TomorrowStartsHere

4 pcak naa Hd bhad

AnnualReport2010:SustainableGrowth

5 swa Hd bhad

AnnualReport2010:Strengthen,Strategise,

Synergise

1 2

  l .c .follow puspelon

u nc i H l i n rh  416087 U

i m li, , r i r n u n , y n 1 ,

1 h h Al m, l n r r ul Eh n , l y iT+ 9

F+ 9

E c r c m u nc n i . c m. my

. u n c n i . c m. my i nv t r . ht ml

Sustainable Growth

 AnnualReport2010

 u

 c a 

i   a a

l  i  

 

r  a

 

 u

 l  

 r  t 

4 5

3

short-listedreports

Page 17: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 17/32

17

oa W – b saa r

Nestlé(Malaysia)Berhad

W – r ea pac

UEMEnvironmentSdnBhd

W – r sca pac

TelekomMalaysiaBerhad

W – r A Aa r

BritishAmericanTobacco(Malaysia)Berhad

W – b f t r

Maybank

Cda – sa ad gacMaybank

Cda – sakhd ea ad ic

Nestlé(Malaysia)Berhad

Cda – Aac

UEMEnvironmentSdnBhd

Cda – iad r

PuncakNiagaHoldingsBerhad

ACCAMaSRA2011winners

17

Page 18: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 18/32

18

overAll Winner – best sustAinAbility report

ACCAMaSRA2011winners

né (maaa) bhad

Demonstratesimprovementwithasustainabilityreportthisyearthatisindexedusingthe

GlobalReportingInitiative(GRI)G3IndexandassuranceaccordingtotheISAE3000.

JointwelcomemessagefromtheChairmanandManagingDirectorsetsthetoneand

demonstratesmanagementsupportforsustainabilityinitiatives.

Nestle’sbusinessethosof‘CreatingSharedValue’wasclearlycommunicatedandclearly

linkstoNestle’sapproachtosustainabilityandNestle’sCorporateBusinessPrinciples.

Agoodunderstandingofrelevanceandchallengesofmaterialissues,suchasnutrition

needsoflowincomeconsumers,theglobalwatercrisis,reductioninpackagingmaterial,

andsourcingofsustainablepalmoil.

Addressesenvironmentalchallengesincludingwatermanagement,climatechange,

energyusage,andpackaging.Clearpresentationofperformancedataandstrategiesforfurtherimprovement.

Showsinitiativeandquickresponseinaddressingmaterialissuesandcostsavingssuch

astheroll-outofthePackagingImpactQuickEvaluationTool.

Performancetableforeachofthefourpillars,whicharecomplimentedbyatableon‘whatwesetouttoachieve’,‘whatweachieved

todate,and‘ourwayforward’.

TheNestleSupplierCodewhichspecifiesandsupportstheimplementationofnon-negotiableminimumstandardsforsuppliers,their

employees,agentsandsubcontractors.

Engagesemployeesthrough‘employeeinsighttaskforce’whichfocusesonqualityoflifeandemployeeopinionsurveyparticipation.

Transparentdisclosureonhumanrightsandlabourstandardswhicharesupportedbythenumberoffactories/sitesaudited.

Sectionsarewellpresented.Visionandpoliciesareintroduced,followedbytheidentificationoftheissuesandpriorityareas.The

variousmanagementapproachesandstrategiesarethenexplainedcomplimentedbyusefulcasestudies.

Clear,relevantandwelldistributedgraphicalanddiagrammaticpresentationsacrossallsections.Tabulatedkeyinformationinclear,easy-to-readdatapageswithyearonyearcomparisons.

Page 19: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 19/32

19

Winner – reporting on environmentAl performAnCe

uem e sd bhd

Demonstratesincrementalimprovementsandprogressionhavingmovedthisyearfrom

thequantificationoftheirGreenhouseGas(GHG)emissionsinthepastfouryearsto

implementingacompany-wideprojecttomanageandreduceGHGemissions.

Onlycompanytoreportonitscarbonfootprintandvoluntaryreductionofcarbon

emissions,accordingtotheGHGprotocolclassificationofdirectandindirectemissions.

Providescomprehensivegraphicalanddiagrammaticpresentationofcomparativedata

forannualcarbonemissionsfromactivitiesmaterialtooperations.

Transparentobjectives,targetsandexplainsreasonstargetswerenotmet.

Comprehensiveandtransparentdisclosureonmonitoringofenvironmentaland

consumptionindicatorssuchasresourceuse(waterandairquality)andnoise

monitoring.

Comprehensivedisclosurestrategytowardsthepreservationofbiodiversityincludes

bio-aquaticmonitoring,bioassaytesting,andchlorellavulgarisgrowthrate.

Detaileddescriptionofcontinuousimprovementprogramme.

FloraandfaunasurveyofsitestoidentifythetypeandtotalnumberofspeciesalignedtotheInternationalUnionforConservationof

NatureRedListofThreatenedSpeciesandthoselistedundertheMalaysianWildlifeProtectionActof1972.

ACCAMaSRA2011winners

Page 20: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 20/32

20

tk maaa bhad

ProvidesaclearpictureofTM’ssustainabilitypracticesagainsttheCSRframework.

Humanrightstrainingforpersonnelinensuringthatemployees’rightsareprotected

andrespectedaspartofitscommitmenttotheUNGlobalCompact.

Incentivestiedtosustainabilityperformance,suchasanAccidents-FreeAwardtostriveforayear-roundaccident-freeenvironment.

Explainsitssupplierengagementprocess,implementationofitsCodeofBusiness

Ethics,andresultsofitssuppliersatisfactionsurvey.

Detailsitssignificantsupport,investmentandimpactineducationinitiativesthrough

scholarshipsandTheMultimediaUniversity.

Disclosesequalopportunitypracticesthattakeintoaccountemploymentopportunitiesforpeoplewithdisability,equalpayformenandwomen,andethnicity.

Clear,transparentpresentationanddisclosureonfiveyeartrendsofaccidentrates,

injuryfrequencyrate,lostworkdayrates.

Detailedactiveemployeeengagementandtransparentdisclosureon‘Collectivebargainingagreements’andtherelevantpolicies.

ACCAMaSRA2011winners

Winner – reporting on soCiAl performAnCe

S U S T A I N A B I L I T YR E P O R T2010

 TELEK L I E H ( 12 4 -

L l ( uth in , n r TJ l n nt i h r u, K u l L um u r

l si

CO NN E CT  COMMUN I CA TE  CO LLA BO R A TE

Th is sus t in i li t r r ti s r in t n r c c l n n vi r nm n t fr i n l m t r i l .

Page 21: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 21/32

21

ACCAMaSRA2011winners

Winner – reporting in An AnnuAl report

bh Aca tacc (maaa) bhad

TheonlyannualreportwithaGRIG3index.

DetailedexplanationofperformanceagainsteachGRIindicator,supportedwith

relevantdata.

ExplainstheCSRgovernancestructurewhichplacesitsmembersandthemanagingdirectorasthehighestdecision-makingbodyforsustainabilityinitiatives.

BATMalaysia’sCSRframeworkprovidesaclearunderstandingandlinkbetween

BATMalaysia’sstatementofbusinessprinciples,CSRcommitteeandtheirrelevance

andrelationtogovernance,reportingandverification.

Stronggovernancesectionwhichhighlightsresponsibilitiesoftheboard,committee

setup,internalauditprocesses,managementapproaches,whistleblowingpolicies,

corporateriskmanagementmeasuresandidentification.

Welllaidoutandoveralldisclosureinallfouraspectsofenvironment,marketplace,

workplaceandcommunity.

Usefulinclusionofhighlightswithinspecificsectionsofthereport,whichprovidessummariesandkeystandoutperformancepoints.

Page 22: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 22/32

22

ACCAMaSRA2011winners

Winner – best first time reporter

maak

Providesclearunderstandingofreportingscope,reportingperiod,reportingcycle

andreportingframework.

Welloverallstructureandlaidoutdisclosureacrossenvironment,workplace,

marketplaceandcommunity.

ProvidesaclearoverviewofMaybank’scommitmentsrelevanttoeachsection.

AstrongstatementfromthePresidentandCEOshowingunderstandingofthe

linkagesbetweensustainabilityandthebusiness.

Detailsoncustomerengagementandfeedbackmechanismssupportedbytrends

ofthenumberofcomplaintsandengagementindexscore.

ExplainsenergyefficiencyandGHGemissionreductioncommitmentsincludingtargetsettingsandinitiativestaken.

DisclosescommitmentbetweenmanagementandemployeesthroughanEmployee

EngagementIndexandthemonitoringofoutcomes.

Clearcommitmentstomaterialissuesinthemarketplacesuchasthegreentechnologyfinancingscheme,cleanenergyfund,supply

chainprocurementpolicy,ethicalsupplychainmanagement,andpreventionofcorruption.

Page 23: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 23/32

23

ACCAMaSRA2011winners

CommenDAtion – strAtegy AnD governAnCe

maak

DisclosureofMaybank’sstrategicfocusthroughitsvision,fiveyearaspirationsandintegrationofCSR

aspartofMaybank’sbusiness.

InclusionofMaybank’sGroupSustainableCorporateResponsibilityPolicyStatementcomplemented

withadiagramofMaybankGroupSustainableCorporateResponsibilityFramework.

Clearmaterialitymatrixidentifyingissuesthataremostmaterialtothebusinessandstakeholders.

The‘Maybank’sCorporateGovernanceModel’providesdetailsofboardremunerationandperformance

evaluation,boardsatisfactionindex,andinternalcontrol.Thesectionincludesexplanationofarisk

governancestructurecoveringareassuch‘BaselIIapproach’and‘whistle-blowerpolicy’.

StatementofcomplianceprovidesunderstandingofMaybank’smonitoringofcorporateriskonnon-complianceofstatutoryand

regulatoryrequirements.

CommenDAtion – stAKeHolDer engAgement

né (maaa) bhad

Clearidentificationofstakeholdersandengagement.

TwoannualstakeholderengagementsessionsattendedbyexpertsrelevanttothethreesharedvalueofNestle–nutrition,waterandruraldevelopment.

Resultsofstakeholderengagementbrokendownintotopicsidentified,issueshighlighted,stakeholder

recommendationandNestleactionplans.

Activeconsumerengagementthroughroadshowstounderstandanddevelopproductsthatmeettheir

expectationsandnutritionalneeds.

EngagementwithlocalfarmersinKelantantoproduceandsupplychilliesforMAGGIChilliSauce,helpingtocreatenewandsustainableincomeopportunities.

Page 24: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 24/32

24

ACCAMaSRA2011winners

CommenDAtion – AssurAnCe

uem e sd bhd

Demonstratesincrementalimprovementwithinclusionofathirdpartyassurancestatementinthisyear’s

sustainabilityreport.

Establishesscopeofassurance,independenceandimpartiality.

Providesalistofinternalandexternaldocumentationinvestigatedandreviewed.

Explainsshortcomingsandprovidesrecommendations.

CommenDAtion – integrAteD reporting

pcak naa Hd bhad

Withthemovetowardsintegratedreporting,companiesareincreasinglydemonstratingthis

seamlessconnectionbetweennonfinancialandfinancialreporting.PuncakNiagaHoldingsBerhad’s

attemptsonintegratingconventionalinformationwithinanannualreportandsustainabilityreporting

ishighlycommendable.

  l .c .follow puspelon

unc i H l in rh  416087 U

ismaoz al i , o4, ers iaran ukan, eksyen 13,

40100 hah lam, elangor arul Ehsan, alays iaT+603 5522 8589

F+603 5522 8598Ecorcom uncakniaga. com. my

. u n c n i . c m . my i n v t r . h tm l

Sustainable Growth

 AnnualReport 2010

 u

 c a

 

i   a

 a

l  i  

 

r  a

 

 u

 l  

 r  t 

Page 25: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 25/32

25

Asinpreviousyears,thejudgesofthe

ACCAMaSRA2011providefeedback

onthestateofreporting,basedonthe

reportssubmitted.Companiesinvestalot

oftimeintheirsustainabilityreportand

thefeedbackandreflectionprovidedhere

ismeanttoraisethebaronsustainability

reportinginMalaysia.

ThroughthenineyearsoftheACCAMaSRA,theoverallqualityofsustainability

reporthasimprovedyearonyear.

Amongtheleadersinsustainability

reporting,therecontinuestobesignificant

improvementsbuttherestofthefield

arecatchingup,andnewleadersare

emerging.Thejudgeshavenotedasmall

increaseinstand-alonesustainability

reports,andasignificantjumpinthenumberofreportsthatarebeingassured,

lendingmorecredibilitytothesereports.

MovingontothenextdecadeoftheACCA

MaSRA,thejudgesnotethefollowing

areasforfutureimprovementstofurther

drivecredibleandrobustsustainability

reportsinMalaysia:

foCus on reporting prinCiplesMorecompaniesareadoptingtheGRI

framework.However,manycompanies

appeartobelievethatanA+reportis

thebenchmarkofgoodreporting.This

encouragestheuseofGRIappearstobe

usedasatick-box,focusingonreporting

onthemaximumnumberofindicators,

ratherthanaddressingtheGRIPrinciples

thatshouldguidesustainabilityreporting.Itisworthnotingthatthewinnersof

theMaSRAoverthepastthreeyears

havebeenGRIreporters,butnoneof

thesereportswereA+reports,but

reportswhichclearlyaddressedthe

principlesofMateriality,Inclusiveness

andCompleteness.

mAteriAlity AnD bAlAnCe

Materialityisacoreprinciplefor

definingreportcontent.Materialityistheprioritisationoftopicsorindicators

sufficientlyimportanttobeaddressed

inthereport.Readersofsustainability

reportswanttoknowwhatinternaland

externalmethodologieswereusedto

determinewhetheranissueismaterial.

Companiesthatunderstandmateriality

areabletoprovideacomprehensiveandconcisepictureofitssignificanteconomic,

environmentandsocialimpacts.The

judgesnotedthatthelackoffocuson

materialityledtodiscrepanciesbetween

peers.Forexample,thetwotelecoms

companies,TMandDiGi,appearedto

placeconflictingemphasisonclimate

change:WhereasTMreportedthisasa

lowpriority,DiGireportedthisasafocus

areaandakeymaterialissue.Thelackofdetailedexplanationonthemateriality

identificationprocessmakesitdifficultfor

readersandstakeholderstoassessthe

accuracyoftheprioritisation.

Asustainabilityreportshouldreflect

positiveandnegativeaspectsofa

company’sperformancetoprovidefora

reasonableandbalancedassessmentof

overallperformance.Thejudgesnotedthat

sustainabilityreportstendtobeskewed

towardspeople-centricimpacts,and

towardspositivestories.Therewaslittle

discussionoffailuresandchallenges.In

onecase,anotherwisecomprehensive

reportmadenomentionofasignificant

governanceissue,whichhasbeen

widelyreportedinthemedia.Thisleaves

stakeholderswiththeimpressionof‘cherry

picking’,andcastsdoubtonthecredibilityofthereport.

Completeness AnD bounDAries

ManyMalaysiancompanieshave

growninsizetobecomeinternational

businesses.Theirgeographicalspread

iswide,employingthousandsofpeople

acrossdiversifiedbusinesses.Malaysian

companieshaveoperationsindeveloping

countrieswheretherearerisksof

humanrightsviolation,securityrisksto

employees,aswellasdevelopmental

opportunitieslinkedtotheiroperations.

ThisgrowthofMalaysiancompaniesis

notreflectedinsustainabilityreportsas

mostcompanieschoosetoconfinetheir

reportingtolimitedpartsoftheiractivities

orgeographicaloperations,withnotime

boundplanorcommitmenttoexpandtheirreportingboundaries.

Inparticular,environmentalreportingis

oftenlimitedtoheadquarterimpacts,

ignoringimpactsfromlogistics,retailor

fieldoperations.Companiesalsotendto

excludebranchesoroperationsabroad,

whichcombinedmayconstitutealarger

footprintthantheheadquartersalone.

Equallytroublingistheopacityofthe

judges’feedback

Page 26: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 26/32

26

reports.Inmanycasesitisnotclearwhat

aspectsthereportcoversandwhatis

excluded,leavingstakeholderswithouta

clearpictureofimpactsandeffectiveness

ofactivities.

inClusiveness AnD stAKeHolDer

engAgement

Stakeholderengagementiscoreto

developingandembeddingarobustsustainabilitystrategy.Overtheyears,this

aspecthasbeenstrengthenedinMalaysian

sustainabilityreportsthroughcasestudies

andinterviews.

However,manyengagementsappeared

tobetestimonials,ratherthan

genuineengagements.Thejudges

encouragecompaniestobemore

engagedwithcriticalstakeholders,

astheseengagementscanhaveits

benefits.Opennesstoconcernscan

leadtoproductivecooperationoverkey

challengesthatimpactsonacompany

anditsindustry.

Stakeholderengagementneedstogo

beyondmerelyreportingmeetingswith

stakeholders,butalsodemonstrateresponsivenessandawillingnesstolisten

toconcerns.Inonereport,thecompany

dismissedthecommunity’sconcernsas

‘unfortunatelymis-constructed’ratherthan

addressingwhatthecompanywished

todoaboutsuchmisunderstandings.

Ascompaniesembedsustainability,a

morestructuredstakeholderengagement

processwillbeneededtodemonstrate

responsiveness.Thisinvolvesidentifying,

defining,anddisclosingwhothekey

stakeholdersare,demonstratingthat

concernshavebeentakenonboard,and

involvingstakeholdersinimprovements.

embeDDing of sustAinAbility

Sustainabilitystrategyshouldbe

integratedintocorporatestrategy.

Thisisreflectedwhenthehighest

decisionmakingbodyofacompanydrivessustainability.Thedomino

effectofintegratingsustainabilityatan

organisation’shighestlevelchangesthe

wayanorganisationoperates,itspriorities,

performance,employeemoraleandtime

spentonengagementwithstakeholders.

Thejudgeswouldliketoseemore

disclosureonwhoisultimatelyresponsible

forsustainabilitywithinacompany,

howsustainabilitystrategyisdeveloped,

implementedandsubsequentlydriven

acrossthecompany,andhowKPIs

andemployeerewardsarelinkedto

sustainabilityperformance.

tHe vAlue of AssurAnCe

Itisapositivedevelopmentthatmore

companiesseekthird-partyassurance,asthisprovidesforgreatercredibilityand

robustnessofthereportingprocess.

However,thejudgesnotedthatmany

assurancestatementsdidnotseem

toaddvaluetothereports,andthat

assurancestatementsappearedrepetitive,

ratherthanspecificallyaddressingthe

individualcompany.Severalassurance

statementscontainederrors,incorrect

referencing,identicalexclusionsand

recommendationsacrossdifferentreports,

andlimitedscopeofassurance.

Third-partyassurancebringsadditional

costtothereportingprocess,and

companiesshouldthereforeensurethat

theyunderstandtheobjectivesandgetfull

valuefromtheprocessofassurance.

Companiesneedtoaskseveralquestions:

Whatisthereasonforanassurance?

Whichstakeholdersneedtobeassured?

DostakeholdersunderstandanISAE3000

assurance?Doeshavinganassurance

withexclusionsorlimitedscopeaddvalue

tothesustainabilityreport?Doesthe

assurancedefinewhere,whatandwhy

areaswereexcluded?Istherevalueto

assurancestatementswhereinternational

standardsarenotedbutnotfollowed?

Isthereaconflictofinterestbetween

assuranceproviderandtheauthor/ 

consultantofthereport?

Thoughanassuranceistypically

providedbyprofessionalfirms,there

areotherwaystoassurestakeholdersa

sustainabilityreportisrobustandcredible.Companiescanengageasubjectmatter

expert,acriticalstakeholder,orapanel

ofstakeholderstoprovideareviewof

sustainabilitydisclosuretoensurethe

reportisbalance,completeandaddresses

allmaterialissues.

proACtive DisClosure

Thejudgesnotedthatmorecompanies

reportonresourceuseandreductions

judges’feedback

Page 27: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 27/32

27

achieved.Thisformofreport,though

insightful,isretrospectiveinnature.

Movingforward,companiescantake

amoreproactiveandforwardlooking

disclosurethrough:

setting long term tArgets

LongtermtargetsandKPIssendastrong

messagetostakeholdersonthecompany’s

goalsandcommitmentstoaddressingmaterialissues.Italsodemonstratesthat

sustainabilityisembeddedinoperations

bydisclosingthemanagementapproach

andinitiativesundertakentoachieve

suchtargets.

benCHmArKs

Benchmarkprovidescontextastohow

thecompanyisperforminginrelation

toitsindustrypeers.Whatarethe

industrybenchmarksforsustainability?

Arethereindustrycertificationschemes?

Isacompany’scommitmentrealistic

andonparwithintheindustryandcan

thecompanydemonstrateleadershipin

theindustry?

voluntAry Commitments

Theinternationalcorporatecommunityhasgalvanisedasacoalitiononarange

ofsustainabilityagendasthroughthe

developmentofvoluntarycommitments.

Somevoluntarycommitmentsare

universal,suchastheUnitedNations

GlobalCompactandtheCarbonDisclosure

Project,andsomewhichareindustry

specific,suchastheEquatorPrinciple,the

GreenBuildingIndexandtheRoundtable

onSustainablePalmOil.Beyondjust

signinguptothesecommitments,

companiesneedtoreportonprogrammes

andactivitiestodemonstratecompliance

andactivecommitment.

invest AnD involve Communities

Malaysiancompaniesareverygenerous

tothecommunitiestheyoperatein.This

isreflectedintheirdisclosureofcorporate

givingprogrammes,theamountoftimespentandfinancialresourcesdonated.

Thereisaroleforbusinessestocontribute

tothedevelopmentagendainMalaysia

thatgoesbeyondmerelyhelping

studentsattainhigherpassingrates.

Companiesfailedtorecognisetheimpact

suchinvolvementhavebroughttothe

community,aswellasforthecompany

staff.Emphasisonlocalemployment

opportunitiesandskillsdevelopmentto

buildwealthinlocalcommunitiesand

adoptionofappropriatetechnologiesare

alsocommunityinvolvementandimpact

thatcanbemeasuredanddisclosed.

Communityinvolvementandengagement

isapartofstakeholderengagement.

Emphasisofsuchlinkswiththecommunityensuresthattheyare

involvedindecisionsthatimpactthem.

Suchengagementandinvolvement

withcommunitiescanhavepositive

reputationalimpactsaswellas

maintainingalicencetooperate.

judges’feedback

Page 28: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 28/32

28

supportingorganisations

AccA

AccountAbilityisaleadingglobalorganisationprovidinginnovativesolutionstothemostcritical

challengesincorporateresponsibilityandsustainabledevelopment.Since1995wehavebeen

helpingcorporations,non-profitsandgovernmentsembedethical,environmental,social,and

governanceaccountabilityintotheirorganisationalDNA.Ouruniquevaluepropositionbrings

togetherleading-edgeresearch,widely-recognisedstandardsandstrategicadvisoryservicesto

deliverpracticalsolutionsforourclients.

AccountAbilityworksto:

• Helpitsclientsandmembersimprovebusinessperformanceandbuildsustainablecompetitive

advantage

• Enableopen,fairandeffectiveapproachestostakeholderengagement;

• Developandrecogniseresponsiblecompetitivenessincompanies,sectors,countriesandregions;

• Createeffectivecollaborativegovernancestrategiesforpartnershipsandmultilateralorganisations

thataredeliveringinnovationandvalue,andsetandinfluencesustainabilitystandards.

• Helpcorporations,non-profitsandgovernmentsembedethical,environmental,socialand

governanceaccountabilityintotheirorganisationalDNA.

Ourvisionisofaworldwherepeoplehaveasayinthedecisionsthathaveanimpactonthem,and

whereorganisationsactonandaretransparentabouttheissuesthatmatter.

AtthecoreofourworkistheAA1000SeriesofStandardsbasedontheprinciplesof:

• Inclusivity–peopleshouldhaveasayinthedecisionsthatimpactonthem

• Materiality–decisionmakersshouldidentifyandbeclearabouttheissuesthatmatter

• Responsiveness–organisationsshouldbetransparentabouttheiractions.

enDorser

ba maaa bhad

BursaMalaysiaisanapprovedexchangeholdingcompanyunderSection15oftheCapitalMarkets

andServicesAct2007.ApubliccompanylimitedbysharesundertheCompaniesAct1965,Bursa

Malaysiaoperatesafully-integratedexchange,offeringequities,derivatives,offshore,bondsaswell

asIslamicproducts,andprovidesadiverserangeofinvestmentchoicesglobally.BursaMalaysia

SecuritiesregulatesandoperatesthesecuritiestradingactivitiesinMalaysia,astockmarketwith

about1,000companiesacross50economicactivities.Companiesfromanyeconomicsectorsare

listedeitherontheMainMarketforlarge-capestablishedcompanies,orontheACEMarketfor

emergingcompaniesofallsizes.TheExchangeadoptstheFTSEBursaMalaysiaKLCIvaluesasits

mainindex.

enDorser

Page 29: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 29/32

29

supportingorganisations

supporter

Car.c

CorporateRegister.comistheglobalcorporateresponsibility(CR)resourceswebsite.Ithoststhe

world’smostcomprehensivedirectoryofCRandsustainabilityreports,profilingover35,000reports

worldwidefromover8,000companies.Withanarchivestretchingbackto1990itisindispensable

foranyoneworkinginthefieldofCRandsustainabilityreporting.

Therearenownearly6,000newreportseveryyear,andthissiteistheonlyplacetofindthemall.

Thesitealsofeaturesafullsearchabledirectoryofover7,000organisationsinvolvedinCRreporting.

CorporateRegister.com’sannualCRreportingawards,theCRRA,arenowintheirfifthyear–see

www.-awad.c

www.corporateregister.com

[email protected]

+442070143366

Da e (Doe)

TheDepartmentofEnvironment(DOE),establishedin1975,ismandatedundertheEnvironmental

QualityAct(EQA),1974toprevent,controlandabatepollution.Itisalsoempoweredtoenforce

SectionIVoftheExclusiveEconomicZoneAct,1984.

m

DOE’smissionistoensuresustainabledevelopmentintheprocessofnationbuilding.

sa a aa•PollutionControlandPrevention

•SustainableDevelopmentthroughConservationofResources

•IntegrationofEnvironmentalFactorsinDevelopmentPlanning

•EnvironmentalEducationandAwareness

•PublicParticipation

•Inter-AgencyandFederal-StateCooperation

•Bilaterally,RegionallyandInternationalCooperation.

enDorser

Page 30: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 30/32

30

supportingorganisations

meDiA pArtners

th ed b Wk

TheEdgeBusinessWeeklyisanaward-winningandbestsellingbusinessandinvestmentweekly

newspaperinMalaysia.Itprovidesreaderswithauthoritative,analyticalcontentonthecorporate,

investment,realestate,technology,management,mediaandlifestylesectors.Sinceitslaunchin1994,

ithasbecometheweeklystapleforcorporateexecutivestokeepabreastofbusinessandinvestment

developmentsinthecountry.Itisdistributednationwidevianewsstandsandbypaidsubscription.

TheEdgeBusinessWeeklyispublishedbyTheEdgeCommunicationsSdnBhd.

th ed faca Da

LaunchedonMay22,2007,TheEdgeFinancialDailyisthelatesttitlefromthepublishersofTheEdge.

Itactsasastandalonedailybusinesspaperwhichcomplementsitsweeklysisterpublication.Published

MondaystoFridays,TheEdgeFinancialDailyprovidesbusinessnewsreportingandarticleswithlocal

insightsandglobalerspectives.ItisdistributedmainlyintheKlangValleyaswellasotherkeymarket

centres.Itisavailableatnewsstandsandbypaidsubscription.

Page 31: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 31/32

31

ACCA(theAssociationofChartered

CertifiedAccountants)istheglobalbody

forprofessionalaccountants.Weaim

toofferbusiness-relevant,first-choice

qualificationstopeopleofapplication,

abilityandambitionaroundtheworldwho

seekarewardingcareerinaccountancy,

financeandmanagement.

Foundedin1904,ACCAhasconsistentlyhelduniquecorevalues:opportunity,

diversity,innovation,integrityand

accountability.Webelievethat

accountantsbringvaluetoeconomies

inallstagesofdevelopment.Weaimto

developcapacityintheprofessionand

encouragetheadoptionofconsistent

globalstandards.Ourvaluesarealignedto

theneedsofemployersinallsectorsand

weensurethat,throughourqualifications,

weprepareaccountantsforbusiness.

Weworktoopenuptheprofessionto

peopleofallbackgroundsandremove

artificialbarrierstoentry,ensuringthatour

qualificationsandtheirdeliverymeetthe

diverseneedsoftraineeprofessionalsand

theiremployers.

Wesupportour147,000membersand

424,000studentsin170countries,

helpingthemtodevelopsuccessful

careersinaccountingandbusiness,and

equippingthemwiththeskillsrequiredby

employers.Weworkthroughanetwork

of83officesandcentresandmorethan

8,500ApprovedEmployersworldwide,

whoprovidehighstandardsofemployee

learninganddevelopment.Throughourpublicinterestremit,wepromotethe

appropriateregulationofaccounting.We

alsoconductrelevantresearchtoensure

thatthereputationandinfluenceofthe

accountancyprofessioncontinuestogrow,

provingitspublicvalueinsociety.

ACCAhasbeenactivelyinvolvedinthe

unfoldingdebateofCSRandsustainability

reportingformorethan15years.ACCA

promotestransparencyandaimstohelp

businessesandorganisationsrealisethe

growingimportanceofsustainability.ACCA

promotesCSRandsustainabilityglobally

andinMalaysiathroughrecognition

ofbestpractices,capacitybuilding,

education/informationandresearch.

31

aboutACCA

Page 32: Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 32/32

ACCA maaa sd bhd(473007P)

27thFloorSunwayTower Kch bach

No86JalanAmpang Unit#8.01

50450KualaLumpur 8thFloorGatewayBuilding

tel:+60327135051fax:+60327135052 No9JalanBukitMataemail:[email protected] 93100KuchingSarawak

www.accaglobal.com tel:+6082425051fax:+6082426061

ACCAMalaysiaSustainabilityReportingAwards(MaSRA)2012

An invitAtion to pArtiCipAte

Ifyoudiscloseenvironmental,socialorfullsustainabilityinformationaboutyourorganisation,weinviteyou

toparticipateinACCAMalaysiaSustainabilityReportingAwards2012.

TheACCAMalaysiaSustainabilityReportingAwards2012timetableis:

mach 2012 Announcementofthe2012Awards

30 J 2012 Entrydeadline

A 2012 Judges’meetings

oc 2012 Awardspresentationceremony

IfyouhaveanyquestionsabouttheAwardsscheme,pleasecontact

m vah gaah

tel:+(603)27135051ext15fax:+(603)27135052

email:[email protected]