Upload
faizah-mohd-khalid
View
216
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 1/32
ACCA mAlAysiA
sustAinAbility reporting AWArDs (masrA) 2011
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 2/32
2
2
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 3/32
3
contents
Introduction 4
Theageofintegration:anewdawnforcorporatereporting 6
Panelofjudges 11
Entrants 12
Shortlistedreports 14
ACCAMaSRA2011winners 17
Judges’feedback 25
Supportingorganisations 28
AboutACCA 31
ACKnoWleDgement
ACCAwouldliketothankandacknowledgethecontributionandsupportof
thedistinguishedpanelofjudges,AccountAbility,BursaMalaysiaBerhad,
CorporateRegister.com,TheDepartmentofEnvironment(DOE),TheEdge
BusinessWeekly,TheEdgeFinancialDailyandlastbutnotleastallparticipating
companiesintheAwards.Webelievethattheparticipatingcompanies
deserverecognitionforleadingthewaytoidentifyandcommunicatetheir
environmentalandsocialperformance.Companiessuchasthesearecontributingtowardstheadvancementofsustainabledevelopmentandperformance.
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 4/324
SincethelastACCAMaSRA,the
worldofcorporatesocialresponsibility
andsustainabilityreportinghasbeen
undergoingtremendouschange.Thisis
reflectedinthevariousdevelopmentson
theinternationalandlocalfront.
Nationally,BursaMalaysiaremainsa
keydriverofsustainabilityreporting
forcorporateMalaysia.Followingthe
developmentoftheCSRframework
in2006,BursaMalaysialaunched
thesustainabilityportalandGuide
forDirectorsin2010.Thisinitiative
recognisesthatthesustainabilityagenda
needstobedrivenfromtheboardroomandembeddedwithinacorporate
strategy.TheEnvironment,Socialand
Governance(ESG)Indexscheduledto
belaunchedinlate2012willbeBursa
Malaysia’snextsteptofurtherdrive
sustainabilitystrategiesanddisclosurein
corporateMalaysia.
Aregionalinitiativeaimedatinvestors
–The2010AsianSustainabilityRating–placedMalaysiancompanies
Wc h ACCA r h Jd h
maaa saa r Awad (masrA)
2011. ACCA ad a h
masrA 2011 wd k hak a h ca
ha acad h a.
asoneoftheleadersofsustainability
disclosureintheregion.However,
corporateMalaysiacannotbecomplacent.
Companieswhowerefirstmoversin
sustainabilitydisclosureareblazing
ahead.Thesecompaniesareadopting
managementsystemstoseamlesslytrackandimprovesustainability
performance.Likewise,countriesinthe
regionpreviouslyratedbehindMalaysia
insustainabilitydisclosurearenow
catchingup.Thispastyearsawregional
stockexchangesbeginningtomandate
sustainabilityreportingandthelaunchof
sustainabilityindexes.
Thestandardswhichguidegoodpractice
inreportingarealsoevolving.Earlierthis
year,theGlobalReportingInitiative(GRI),
launchedarevisionoftheirguidelines,
theG3.1.Fiveyearsonfromitslastrevision,
theG3.1isthemostcomprehensiveand
completesustainabilityreportingguidance
todate.Therevisionaimstomakethe
frameworkmorerobustwiththeadditionof
11newindicatorsintheareasofhumanrights,societyandlabourpractices.
4
introduction
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 5/32
5
Attheendof2010,ISO26000onSocial
Responsibilitywaslaunched.ISO26000
givesacomprehensiveandcleardefinition
ofwhatsocialresponsibilitymeans.The
ISO26000representsa‘standardof
standards’,bringingtogetherbestpractices
fromabroadrangeofinitiatives.ISO
26000wasdevelopedoveradecadeof
consultationwithstakeholders,andisnow
recognisedinover90countries.
TheISO26000isanoncertifiablestandard
basedonsevenprinciples:Accountability;
Transparency;Ethicalbehaviour;Respect
forstakeholderinterest;Respectforrules
oflaw;Respectforinternationalnormsof
behaviour;andRespectforhumanrights.
Theseprinciplesareappliedinsevencore
areasoforganisationalgovernance,humanrights,labourpractices,fairoperating
practices,consumerissues,environment
andcommunityinvestment.
Investors,akeystakeholderofcompanies,
arealsoincreasinglydemanding
companiestodisclosesustainability
performance.InSeptemberthisyear,
thePlasticDisclosureProject(PDP)
waslaunchedundertheClintonGlobal
Initiative.Aninvestorsupportedinitiative,
thePDPtracksdisclosurebycompanies
oftheirplasticuseandtheirstrategies
forreducingitsenvironmentalimpact.
ThisfollowsonthesuccessfulCarbon
DisclosureProject(CDP)whichrepresents
551institutionalinvestors,witha
combinedUSD71trillionfundunder
management.TheCDPwaslaunchedtoacceleratesolutionstoclimatechangeand
introduction
watermanagementbyputtingrelevant
informationattheheartofbusiness,
policyandinvestmentdecisions.Over
3,000companiesinsome60countries
aroundtheworldnowmeasureand
disclosetheirgreenhousegasemissions,
watermanagementandclimatechange
strategiesthroughCDP.
Acommonthemerunsacross
thesenewinitiatives:emphasison
accountabilityandtransparency.
Accountabilityisaboutproving
sustainabilityperformancewith
evidencetobackupanyclaimsmade.
Accountabilityalsomeanswelcoming
scrutinyandengagementwith
criticalstakeholders.
Transparencyrequiresacompanyto
providesufficientinformationsothat
stakeholderscan‘seeinto’thecompany.
Thismeansthatwhenastakeholder
looksatdocuments,corporatewebsites
andassociatedreports,enough
informationshouldbeavailabletoallow
themtohaveagoodideaabouthowthe
companyisrun,howwellitismanaged,
howdecisionsaremadeandwhat
thematerialrisksassociatedwiththe
businessare.Arobustsustainabilityreport
canachievethis.
Thisyear,ACCAMaSRAreceivedatotal
of43entries.Thesereportswerescored
andrankedbyashortlistingpanel.The
top20companieswereevaluatedby
theACCAMaSRAjudgingpanel.Oftheshortlistedentries,15werestand-alone
sustainabilityreportandfiveaspartof
theirannualreports.
Inourview,eachcompanythat
participatesinACCAMaSRAisa
winner.Participationdemonstratesa
company’scommitmenttocommunicating
sustainabilityperformance.Participationin
theACCAMaSRAshouldsetabenchmark
forcompaniestoimprovetheirrespective
sustainabilityreporting.TheACCAMaSRA
judgeshaveseengreatimprovementsin
thequalityofsustainabilityreportingin
Malaysia–atestamenttocompanies’
continuouslearningprocesses.
Nextyear,theACCAMaSRAwillcelebrate
itstenthanniversary.Wecontinuetobe
committedtothevaluesofthisworldwideinitiativetoidentifyandrewardinnovative
attemptstocommunicatesustainability
performance.Inthecomingmonths,we
welcomecompaniestoengagewiththe
ACCAtogetabetterunderstandingof
sustainabilitydisclosureinpreparation
forthenextACCAMaSRA.
Welookforwardtoyourparticipationin
theACCAMaSRA2012.
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 6/32
6
Theglobalfinancialcrisishaspersuaded
manyoftheneedforaneweconomic
modelthatcanprotectbusinesses,
investors,employeesandsocietyfrom
acycleofsuccessiveandincreasingly
debilitatingcrises.Atpresent,short-term
financialgainscantakepriorityover
long-termvaluegeneration,encouraginga
gung-hoapproachtorisk-takingthatcan
leadtoalevelofmarketinstability,which
hasthepotentialtodevastateindividualbusinessesandwholeeconomies.The
currentmodelofcorporatereporting,it
isfelt,doesnotdoenoughtodiscourage
suchbehaviourbecauseitdoesn’tpay
enoughattentiontofactorssuchasrisk,
strategy,governanceandthesustainability
ofbusinessmodels.
Theseconcerns,whichhavegrownas
businessleadersandgovernmentshave
agonisedoverthecausesofthefinancial
crisis,havegivenimpetustoexisting
demandsforachangeinemphasisin
corporatereportingonthegroundsthat
itdoesnotcurrentlyadequatelyreflect
materialenvironmental,socialand
governance(ESG)factors.Theseinclude
resourceusage,socialimpacts,human
rightsandhowabusinessmightcontributetoorbeaffectedbyclimatechange.
ACCA’ n s k a wh ad wha
d h a d a ad
awk ad ak c
Manybelievethatover-consumptionof
finitenaturalresourcesandtheriskof
catastrophicclimatechangepresentoneof
theworld’sgreatestchallenges–andisits
biggestbusinessrisk.
Supportersofintegratedreportingargue
thattheinclusionofallthesenon-
financialbutneverthelesscrucialrisk
factorsintocorporatereportingwould
helpsteerbusinessdecision-makinginamoresustainabledirection–inboth
financialandenvironmentalterms.They
arguethatthequalityofreportingwould
improvebecausebusinesseswould
provideamorestrategicpictureofthe
issuesthatarecriticaltotheirlong-term
sustainabilityandsuccess.Inaddition,
thosemanagingcompanieswouldbe
abletomakebetterresourcedecisionsby
includingissuesrelatingtonaturaland
socialcapitalaswellasfinancialcapital.
Theresultwouldbeamoreholistic
pictureofthereportingentitythatcovers
bothrisksandopportunities,andreflects
theinterconnectionsbetweenESGand
financialfactors.
NeilStevensonisACCA’s
executivedirector–brand,
andamemberofthe
InternationalIntegrated
ReportingCommittee
(IIRC)Engagementand
Communicationstaskforce.
HisremitatACCAcovers
marketing,communications,
policy,technicalissuesandpublishing.Thisincludes
promotingaglobalagenda
ofresearchandinsights,
complementinghisinterest
inissuesinvolvingchange
andinnovationintheglobal
professions.
newdawnforreporting
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 7/32
7
newdawnforreporting
integrAteD reporting
Whiletherehavebeensignificant
advancesinsustainabilityreportingover
recentyears,nosinglebodyhassofar
hadtheauthorityoroversighttobringall
thedifferentreportingpillarstogetherin
asingle,mandatory,fullyintegratedand
globallyendorsedframework.
ThisistheambitionoftheInternational
IntegratedReportingCommittee(IIRC),
formedlastyearbyaprogressivesection
ofthebusiness,financialandaccounting
community,bringingtogethermanyleading
accountancyfirms,big-namecompanies,
businessgroupsandprofessional
accountancybodies,includingACCA.The
twokeybodiesinvolvedarethePrinceof
WalesAccountingforSustainabilityProject
(A4S)andtheGlobalReportingInitiative.A
seriesofprofile-raisingeventsareplanned
for2011,kickingoffwitharoundtable
discussioninMumbai,India,chairedby
InternationalOrganizationofSecurities
CommissionschairmanJaneDiplock,as
AccountancyFutureswenttopress.
Thereleaseofadiscussionpaperlooking
atanintegratedreportingframework
isplannedforJune2011.Interested
stakeholdersareinvitedtocomment
beforeitisformalisedandpresentedto
theG20inCannesinNovember2011.
G20approvalwilladdcredibilityand
injectvigourintothemovetowardsglobal
standardisation.TheIIRC’saimisthatthe
frameworkwillbeconstructedinaway
thatallowscompaniestoreportinaclear,
concise,consistentandcomparableway.
sustAinAbility CHAllenge
Theaccountingelementofthemassive
changerequiredwashighlightedbythe
creationofA4Sin2004,whichreiterated
theneedfornewapproachestoaccounting
andreportingtoreflectthebroaderand
longer-termconsequencesofcorporate
decisions.Withoutmorecompleteand
comprehensiveinformation,management,
investorsandotherscannotmakethefully
informeddecisionsneededtoprosperin
thefaceofsustainabilitychallenges.
A4Sfeltthattheprofession’sbest
contributiontosustainabilitywouldbeto
establishaglobalframeworkofmandatory
‘connectedreporting’requirements
forlistedcompaniesandforaglobal
committeeofkeystakeholdergroupsto
pushforglobaladoption.
TheGRI,alongwithotherbodiessuch
astheCarbonDisclosureProject,
havemadesignificantstepsforward
informalisingreportingguidelinesfor
companies’materialenvironmental,
socialandeconomicimpacts.Yetdespite
thecorporateuptakeandintegrationof
more-than-financialimpactassessments,
thereisstilllittleevidencethatcollective
corporateeffortshavesignificantlyhalted
activitiesthatpollute,depleteresourcesanddestroynon-financialvalue.
M a n a
g e m e n t
c o m m
e n t a r y
G o v e r n a n c e a n d
r e m u n e r a t i o
nE n
v i r o n m e n t a n d s o c i a l
F i n
a n c i a l
Integrated
reporting
framework
S o u r c e : I I R
C
integrAteD reporting:
foCusing on tHe top sliCe
Integratedreportingprovides
thetoplevelstructureforthe
wholereportingpyramid
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 8/32
8
newdawnforreporting
Thevoluntarynatureofsuchreporting
initiativesmeansthattake-upcanbe
fragmented,allowingcompanieswith
largeimpactsontheenvironment
andsocietytoavoidfulland
transparentdisclosure.
WHAt Will it looK liKe?
Consideringthatintegratedreportingisstill
inanembryonicphase,itshouldcome
asnosurprisethataclearformulation
ofwhatexactlyitconstitutesisstill
beingdebated.Definitionsrangefrom
themaintenanceofcurrentfinancial
reportingandaccountingpracticesbased
onInternationalFinancialReporting
Standards(IFRS)withanESGsection
boltedon,rightuptoacompletechange
inthefundamentalsofaccountingandreportingformats.
Thereis,however,agreementonthe
needforaconciseandcomprehensive
integratedreportingframeworkwhich
isstructuredaroundanorganisation’s
strategicobjectives,itsgovernanceand
businessmodel,andintegratingmaterial
financialandnon-financialinformation.
Thekeyconsiderationisthestrategic
ingraininganddisclosureofallESG
factorsaffectingthefuturefinancial
performanceandassociatedriskratingof
acompany’sactivities.Thecentraltenet
ofintegratedreportinghasbeenpartof
thesustainabilityandCSRreportingspace
foranumberofyears,butitisIIRC’s
ambitiontobringtogetherfinancialand
non-financialriskdisclosureinaglobal,
mandatoryframeworkwhichsetsitapart
frompastinitiatives,andwhichengages
andrelatestoinvestors.
Scepticsoftheintegratedreporting
initiativepointtowardsaraftofissues.Thefirstisthesheerambitionofthechange
thatisbeingputforward,involvingthe
hugechallengeofgainingglobalconsensus
toamandatorychange,especiallygiven
thatithassofartakenmorethan30years
toagreetheglobalapplicationofIFRS.
Othercriticismsincludefearsthatitwill
Theresultwouldbeamoreholisticpictureof
thereportingentitythatcoversbothrisksand
opportunities,andreflectstheinterconnections
betweenESGandfinancialfactors
leadtoincreasedcomplexityinreporting
andgreaterresourcingrequirements,anda
tick-boxapproach.
Butgiventhepowerfulbackersandthe
fundamentalfinancialandenvironmental
issuesinvolved,thelaunchoftheIIRC
maywellturnouttobeaturningpointin
thedevelopmentofcorporatereporting.
However,alongsidethisdevelopment,itis
clearthatwewillalsoneedtoencourage
agreaterproportionofshareholdersto
becomemoreinterestedinthegovernance
andsustainabilityoftheorganisations
theyinvestin.Thiswillbethebestwayof
ensuringintegratedreportingisembedded
inbusinessinpractice.Muchattentionhas
beenpaid,rightly,tothemodelsaroundauditingandassuranceandcorporate
reporting.Perhapsweneedtodevelop
moreurgencyaroundthisthirddimension:
governanceandstewardship.Thiscould
leadtothefulfilmentoftheambitionsof
thosewhoadvocatethe‘triplebottomline’:
asustainableapproachtosustainability.
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 9/32
9
newdawnforreporting
b : Caca wha
a dd, ACCA’ rach
Jack a ad ca
ha h c ca ac
Theideaofintegratedreportinghas
beenincreasinglyunderdiscussionby
stakeholdersintheworldofbusiness
accountingandsustainabilityreporting.
Thedefinitionofwhatintegratedreporting
actuallycoversiscurrentlyarangeof
blurrygreysratherthanacrispandclear
blackandwhite.However,lookedatin
broadterms,integratedreportingissimply
theendresult(thereporting)ofacomplex
butinclusiveprocessthatintegrates
thebusinessstrategywithmaterial
sustainabilityissues.
Someoptimisticobserversseean
integratedstrategyasboosting
transparencyandofferingaclearer
explanationoftherelationship
betweencompanies’financialand
non-financialperformance.Other,
morecautiousprofessionalshighlight
possiblechallengessuchasgreater
reportingcomplexity,comparabilityand
assuranceacrosssectorsandcountries,
anddiscordintimescalesbetween
compilationoftheintegratedreporting
frameworkandcontinuingphysical
impactsofclimatechange.
Thereisnodoubtthatawell-developed
integratedreportingmethodologycould
focuscorporateeffortstointegratematerial
sustainabilityissuesandimpactsarising
frombusinessactivitiesmoredeeplyin
strategicdecision-makingprocesses.
Deployinganintegratedstrategyasa
riskscreentoassessoperationsfortheir
mediumtolong-termsustainabilityand
financialimplicationscouldstrengthen
governanceprotocols,createlessdisparate
businessesandchangefinancialmarket
investmentbehaviour.
Fewcompaniescurrentlytakean
integratedreportingapproach.Thisblankcanvasofferstherelevantprofessions
anopportunitytoshapetheframework.
ACCAispleasedtobepartoftheIIRC,
whichhasambitiousplanstodojustthis.
Weshallcontinuetoparticipateactively,
takingpartinthedebatesthatarise,
addressingquestionsaroundtherelevance
ofintegratedreporting,findingwaysto
stimulateinvestorandregulatordemand
forintegratedreporting,anddeveloping
usefulreportingmetrics.
RachelJacksonisACCA’s
headofsustainability.She
championsACCA’sglobal
sustainabilityagendaon
reportinganddisclosure
withspecificreferenceto
environmental,economic
andsocialissues.
RachelrepresentsACCA
onvarioustechnicalcommitteesandworking
groupsincludingFEEand
theEPCClimateChange
AdaptationTaskForce.
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 10/32
10
newdawnforreporting
RogerAdamsFCCAis
ACCA’sdirector–special
assignments.Hepreviously
managedACCA’sglobal
policypositionson
professionalissues,suchas
sustainabilityandcorporate
responsibility.
J h d: f h a
h k dac ad
a d wdad ak-,
a ACCA’ r Ada
Oneofthemainproposalsmadeby
theInternationalIntegratedReporting
Committee(IIRC)istheneedfornew
approachestoaccountingandreportingto
reflectthebroaderlong-termconsequences
ofcorporateactivities.Byprovidingrobust
andcomparablereportingguidanceon
howtolinkcorporatestrategytofinancial
andnon-financialperformance,theIIRC
canconvincebusinessesandinvestors
thatfinancialvaluecanbederivedfrom
integratedreporting.
Integratedreportsshouldclearlyidentifyandexplainthelinkbetween
anorganisation’sstrategicgoalsand
theresultingimpactonparameters
suchasthewiderbusinesscontext,key
relationships,resourcedependenciesand
governancestructures,andhelpestablish
amoreholisticcorporateriskprofile.
Toensurewidespreadbusiness
acceptance,theIIRCmustconnectthe
dotsbetweenitselfandotherkeyreporting
guidance.ACCAcontinuestosupport
theGRIanditssustainabilityreporting
framework,andtheClimateDisclosure
StandardsBoard(CDSB)anditsclimate
changereportingframework.Aswell
asidentifyingtheinformationneeds
ofinvestors,theIIRCneedstoprovide
solutionstoanyperceivedbarrierstothe
take-upofintegratedreporting.Theto-do
listincludesaddressingtherequirements
ofmultiplestakeholders,determiningthe
materialityofissues,givinganoptionof
differentreportinglevels,assessingknock-
onimpactstoauditingstandardsand
internalcontrolchecks,andovercoming
corporateconfidentialityissues.
Opportunitiesandbenefitsarisingfrom
amovetowardsintegratedreportingwillhavetobeclearlydemonstratedwithinan
urgentcontextrequiringthemomentum
towardsasustainable,low-carbonglobal
economytogatherpace.Ultimately
theestablishmentofaninternational
frameworkthatnotonlymergesfinancial
andsustainabilityoutcomesbutalso
supportstheachievementofasustainable
economywillrequiresupportfrom
governments,thefinanceandaccounting
communityandwiderstakeholdergroups.
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 11/32
11
tHe ACCA masrA 2011 JuDges
m gh Ch y*
Executivedirector,strategyanddevelopment,SecuritiesCommission
y bh Da’ Hajah ra iaah
Directorgeneral,DepartmentofEnvironment,Malaysia
m saa raah
Chiefregulatoryofficer,BursaMalaysiaBerhad
m Dh th
Groupeditor-in-chief,TheEdgeCommunicationsSdnBhd
p sah Haa
Independentconsultant(corporategovernanceandcorporatereporting)
m mhad raa Ad raha
Managingpartner,KPMG
Aca p D fazah Da**
HeadAsia-Pacificcentreforsustainability(APCeS),AccountingResearchInstitute,
FacultyofAccountancy,UniversitiTeknologiMARA(UiTM)
D H J A**
Seniorlecturer,FacultyofEconomicsandManagement,UniversitiPutraMalaysia
m rkk n**
Executivedirector,CSRAsia
*Chairmanofjudgingpanel**Shortlistjudge
panelofjudges
11
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 12/32
12
Astro maaa Hd sd bhd
InspiringSustainability2010Report
bh Aca tacc (maaa) bhad
AnnualReport2010:Passion
Dg tcca sd bhd
SustainabilityReport2010
Drb Hi-Com bhad
SustainabilityReport2010:OurPast,Present&Priorities
fa g bhad
AnnualReport2010:EnrichingLives
g Ach bhad
CorporateResponsibilityReport2010:ProgressingSustainably
iJm Ca bhad
AnnualReport2010:TurningtheTide
iJm lad bhad
AnnualReport2010:EnablingSuccess,EnrichingLives
iJm paa bhad
AnnualReport2010:NurturingSustainability
idah Wa K sd bhd
SustainabilityReport2010
Kaa l C C
CorporateSocialResponsibilityReport2010
K (maaa) bhad
AnnualReport2010:TomorrowStartsHere
laa maaa C bhad
AnnualReport2010:CementMadeForLife
l’oa maaa sd bhd
MorethanEver,anEssentialCommitment:HonoringExceptional
WomeninScience
mah s g bhad
AnnualReport2010:ExpandingOurReelofCaptivating&PrestigiousSpaces
maaa rc Ca bhad
CorporateSocialResponsibilityReport2010
maaa rc Ca bhad
AnnualReport2010:WeareFocusedonGrowth
max bhadCorporateResponsibilityStatement
maak
SustainabilityReport2010
mda pa bhad
SustainabilityReport2010:Care>Commitment>Community
merCy maaaAnnualReport2010
maa bhad
AnnualReport2010:SustainingOurMission:SeedingGrowth
maa bhad
CorporateResponsibilityReport2010
entrants2011
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 13/32
13
entrants2011
na Hd bhad
AnnualReport2011
né (maaa) bhad
CorporateReport2010:RisingAbove
né (maaa) bhad
CreatingSharedValue2010
pa naa bhad
SustainabilityReport2010
phaaaa bhad
AnnualReport2010:PursuingOpportunities
plus exwa bhad
CorporateSocialResponsibilityReport2009
pc bak bhad
AnnualReport2010:SurpassingExpectations
pcak naa Hd bhad
AnnualReport2010:SustainableGrowth
pajaa pdaa bhad
AnnualReport2010
swa C bhad
AnnualReport2010:RewardingMemories,RisingHigh
swa Hd bhad
AnnualReport2010:Strengthen,Strategise,Synergise
tk maaa bhad
SustainabilityReport2010:StartToday,SaveTomorrow
tx Cc sd bhd
SustainabilityReport2010
tx Cc sd bhd
AnnualReport
tha ecc maaa sd bhd
CorporateSocialResponsibilityReport2009/2010
tadwd paa bhad
AnnualReport2010
uem e sd bhd
SustainabilityReport2010:PartneringwithOurCommunity
uem lad Hd bhad
CorporateResponsibilityReport2010
ytl Ca bhad
SustainabilityReport2010:TheJourneyContinues
y K gaa id bhad
AnnualReport2010
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 14/32
14
stAnD Alone CAtegory
1 Astro maaa Hd sd bhd
InspiringSustainabilityReport2010
2 Dg tcca sd bhd
SustainabilityReport2010
3 Drb-HiCom bhad SustainabilityReport2010:OurPast,Present
&Priorities
4 g Ach bhad
CorporateResponsibilityReport2010:
ProgressingSustainably
5 idah Wa K sd bhd
SustainabilityReport2010
6 Kaa l C C
CorporateSocialResponsibilityReport2010
7 maaa rc Ca bhad
CorporateSocialResponsibilityReport2010
8 maak
SustainabilityReport2010
1 2 3
5 6
7 8
4
Progressing SustainablyCorporate Responsibility Report 2010
short-listedreports
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 15/32
15
short-listedreports
9 mda pa bhad
SustainabilityReport2010:Care>
Commitment>Community
10 né (maaa) bhad
CreatingSharedValue2010
11 pa naa bhad
SustainabilityReport2010
12 tk maaa bhad
SustainabilityReport2010:StartToday,Save
Tomorrow
13 tx Cc sd bhd
SustainabilityReport2010
14 uem e sd bhd SustainabilityReport:PartneringwithOur
Community
15 uem lad Hd bhad
CorporateResponsibilityReport2010
9 10 11
S U S TAI NABI L I TYR E P O R T2010
Gr u C r r t C unic ti n sTE L EK AL AYS I AE H A (128740-)Level 8(South ing), enaraTJalan antai aharu, 50672KualaLumpur
alaysia
C ONNEC T C OMMU NIC AT E C OL L AB ORAT E
Thissustainability reportisprintedon recycledandenvironmentfriendly material.
12 13 14
15
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 16/32
16
AnnuAl report CAtegory
1 bh Aca tacc (maaa) bhad
AnnualReport2010:Passion
2 iJm Ca bhad
AnnualReport2010:TurningtheTide
3 K (maaa) bhad AnnualReport2010:TomorrowStartsHere
4 pcak naa Hd bhad
AnnualReport2010:SustainableGrowth
5 swa Hd bhad
AnnualReport2010:Strengthen,Strategise,
Synergise
1 2
l .c .follow puspelon
u nc i H l i n rh 416087 U
i m li, , r i r n u n , y n 1 ,
1 h h Al m, l n r r ul Eh n , l y iT+ 9
F+ 9
E c r c m u nc n i . c m. my
. u n c n i . c m. my i nv t r . ht ml
Sustainable Growth
AnnualReport2010
u
c a
i a a
l i
r a
u
l
r t
4 5
3
short-listedreports
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 17/32
17
oa W – b saa r
Nestlé(Malaysia)Berhad
W – r ea pac
UEMEnvironmentSdnBhd
W – r sca pac
TelekomMalaysiaBerhad
W – r A Aa r
BritishAmericanTobacco(Malaysia)Berhad
W – b f t r
Maybank
Cda – sa ad gacMaybank
Cda – sakhd ea ad ic
Nestlé(Malaysia)Berhad
Cda – Aac
UEMEnvironmentSdnBhd
Cda – iad r
PuncakNiagaHoldingsBerhad
ACCAMaSRA2011winners
17
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 18/32
18
overAll Winner – best sustAinAbility report
ACCAMaSRA2011winners
né (maaa) bhad
Demonstratesimprovementwithasustainabilityreportthisyearthatisindexedusingthe
GlobalReportingInitiative(GRI)G3IndexandassuranceaccordingtotheISAE3000.
JointwelcomemessagefromtheChairmanandManagingDirectorsetsthetoneand
demonstratesmanagementsupportforsustainabilityinitiatives.
Nestle’sbusinessethosof‘CreatingSharedValue’wasclearlycommunicatedandclearly
linkstoNestle’sapproachtosustainabilityandNestle’sCorporateBusinessPrinciples.
Agoodunderstandingofrelevanceandchallengesofmaterialissues,suchasnutrition
needsoflowincomeconsumers,theglobalwatercrisis,reductioninpackagingmaterial,
andsourcingofsustainablepalmoil.
Addressesenvironmentalchallengesincludingwatermanagement,climatechange,
energyusage,andpackaging.Clearpresentationofperformancedataandstrategiesforfurtherimprovement.
Showsinitiativeandquickresponseinaddressingmaterialissuesandcostsavingssuch
astheroll-outofthePackagingImpactQuickEvaluationTool.
Performancetableforeachofthefourpillars,whicharecomplimentedbyatableon‘whatwesetouttoachieve’,‘whatweachieved
todate,and‘ourwayforward’.
TheNestleSupplierCodewhichspecifiesandsupportstheimplementationofnon-negotiableminimumstandardsforsuppliers,their
employees,agentsandsubcontractors.
Engagesemployeesthrough‘employeeinsighttaskforce’whichfocusesonqualityoflifeandemployeeopinionsurveyparticipation.
Transparentdisclosureonhumanrightsandlabourstandardswhicharesupportedbythenumberoffactories/sitesaudited.
Sectionsarewellpresented.Visionandpoliciesareintroduced,followedbytheidentificationoftheissuesandpriorityareas.The
variousmanagementapproachesandstrategiesarethenexplainedcomplimentedbyusefulcasestudies.
Clear,relevantandwelldistributedgraphicalanddiagrammaticpresentationsacrossallsections.Tabulatedkeyinformationinclear,easy-to-readdatapageswithyearonyearcomparisons.
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 19/32
19
Winner – reporting on environmentAl performAnCe
uem e sd bhd
Demonstratesincrementalimprovementsandprogressionhavingmovedthisyearfrom
thequantificationoftheirGreenhouseGas(GHG)emissionsinthepastfouryearsto
implementingacompany-wideprojecttomanageandreduceGHGemissions.
Onlycompanytoreportonitscarbonfootprintandvoluntaryreductionofcarbon
emissions,accordingtotheGHGprotocolclassificationofdirectandindirectemissions.
Providescomprehensivegraphicalanddiagrammaticpresentationofcomparativedata
forannualcarbonemissionsfromactivitiesmaterialtooperations.
Transparentobjectives,targetsandexplainsreasonstargetswerenotmet.
Comprehensiveandtransparentdisclosureonmonitoringofenvironmentaland
consumptionindicatorssuchasresourceuse(waterandairquality)andnoise
monitoring.
Comprehensivedisclosurestrategytowardsthepreservationofbiodiversityincludes
bio-aquaticmonitoring,bioassaytesting,andchlorellavulgarisgrowthrate.
Detaileddescriptionofcontinuousimprovementprogramme.
FloraandfaunasurveyofsitestoidentifythetypeandtotalnumberofspeciesalignedtotheInternationalUnionforConservationof
NatureRedListofThreatenedSpeciesandthoselistedundertheMalaysianWildlifeProtectionActof1972.
ACCAMaSRA2011winners
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 20/32
20
tk maaa bhad
ProvidesaclearpictureofTM’ssustainabilitypracticesagainsttheCSRframework.
Humanrightstrainingforpersonnelinensuringthatemployees’rightsareprotected
andrespectedaspartofitscommitmenttotheUNGlobalCompact.
Incentivestiedtosustainabilityperformance,suchasanAccidents-FreeAwardtostriveforayear-roundaccident-freeenvironment.
Explainsitssupplierengagementprocess,implementationofitsCodeofBusiness
Ethics,andresultsofitssuppliersatisfactionsurvey.
Detailsitssignificantsupport,investmentandimpactineducationinitiativesthrough
scholarshipsandTheMultimediaUniversity.
Disclosesequalopportunitypracticesthattakeintoaccountemploymentopportunitiesforpeoplewithdisability,equalpayformenandwomen,andethnicity.
Clear,transparentpresentationanddisclosureonfiveyeartrendsofaccidentrates,
injuryfrequencyrate,lostworkdayrates.
Detailedactiveemployeeengagementandtransparentdisclosureon‘Collectivebargainingagreements’andtherelevantpolicies.
ACCAMaSRA2011winners
Winner – reporting on soCiAl performAnCe
S U S T A I N A B I L I T YR E P O R T2010
TELEK L I E H ( 12 4 -
L l ( uth in , n r TJ l n nt i h r u, K u l L um u r
l si
CO NN E CT COMMUN I CA TE CO LLA BO R A TE
Th is sus t in i li t r r ti s r in t n r c c l n n vi r nm n t fr i n l m t r i l .
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 21/32
21
ACCAMaSRA2011winners
Winner – reporting in An AnnuAl report
bh Aca tacc (maaa) bhad
TheonlyannualreportwithaGRIG3index.
DetailedexplanationofperformanceagainsteachGRIindicator,supportedwith
relevantdata.
ExplainstheCSRgovernancestructurewhichplacesitsmembersandthemanagingdirectorasthehighestdecision-makingbodyforsustainabilityinitiatives.
BATMalaysia’sCSRframeworkprovidesaclearunderstandingandlinkbetween
BATMalaysia’sstatementofbusinessprinciples,CSRcommitteeandtheirrelevance
andrelationtogovernance,reportingandverification.
Stronggovernancesectionwhichhighlightsresponsibilitiesoftheboard,committee
setup,internalauditprocesses,managementapproaches,whistleblowingpolicies,
corporateriskmanagementmeasuresandidentification.
Welllaidoutandoveralldisclosureinallfouraspectsofenvironment,marketplace,
workplaceandcommunity.
Usefulinclusionofhighlightswithinspecificsectionsofthereport,whichprovidessummariesandkeystandoutperformancepoints.
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 22/32
22
ACCAMaSRA2011winners
Winner – best first time reporter
maak
Providesclearunderstandingofreportingscope,reportingperiod,reportingcycle
andreportingframework.
Welloverallstructureandlaidoutdisclosureacrossenvironment,workplace,
marketplaceandcommunity.
ProvidesaclearoverviewofMaybank’scommitmentsrelevanttoeachsection.
AstrongstatementfromthePresidentandCEOshowingunderstandingofthe
linkagesbetweensustainabilityandthebusiness.
Detailsoncustomerengagementandfeedbackmechanismssupportedbytrends
ofthenumberofcomplaintsandengagementindexscore.
ExplainsenergyefficiencyandGHGemissionreductioncommitmentsincludingtargetsettingsandinitiativestaken.
DisclosescommitmentbetweenmanagementandemployeesthroughanEmployee
EngagementIndexandthemonitoringofoutcomes.
Clearcommitmentstomaterialissuesinthemarketplacesuchasthegreentechnologyfinancingscheme,cleanenergyfund,supply
chainprocurementpolicy,ethicalsupplychainmanagement,andpreventionofcorruption.
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 23/32
23
ACCAMaSRA2011winners
CommenDAtion – strAtegy AnD governAnCe
maak
DisclosureofMaybank’sstrategicfocusthroughitsvision,fiveyearaspirationsandintegrationofCSR
aspartofMaybank’sbusiness.
InclusionofMaybank’sGroupSustainableCorporateResponsibilityPolicyStatementcomplemented
withadiagramofMaybankGroupSustainableCorporateResponsibilityFramework.
Clearmaterialitymatrixidentifyingissuesthataremostmaterialtothebusinessandstakeholders.
The‘Maybank’sCorporateGovernanceModel’providesdetailsofboardremunerationandperformance
evaluation,boardsatisfactionindex,andinternalcontrol.Thesectionincludesexplanationofarisk
governancestructurecoveringareassuch‘BaselIIapproach’and‘whistle-blowerpolicy’.
StatementofcomplianceprovidesunderstandingofMaybank’smonitoringofcorporateriskonnon-complianceofstatutoryand
regulatoryrequirements.
CommenDAtion – stAKeHolDer engAgement
né (maaa) bhad
Clearidentificationofstakeholdersandengagement.
TwoannualstakeholderengagementsessionsattendedbyexpertsrelevanttothethreesharedvalueofNestle–nutrition,waterandruraldevelopment.
Resultsofstakeholderengagementbrokendownintotopicsidentified,issueshighlighted,stakeholder
recommendationandNestleactionplans.
Activeconsumerengagementthroughroadshowstounderstandanddevelopproductsthatmeettheir
expectationsandnutritionalneeds.
EngagementwithlocalfarmersinKelantantoproduceandsupplychilliesforMAGGIChilliSauce,helpingtocreatenewandsustainableincomeopportunities.
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 24/32
24
ACCAMaSRA2011winners
CommenDAtion – AssurAnCe
uem e sd bhd
Demonstratesincrementalimprovementwithinclusionofathirdpartyassurancestatementinthisyear’s
sustainabilityreport.
Establishesscopeofassurance,independenceandimpartiality.
Providesalistofinternalandexternaldocumentationinvestigatedandreviewed.
Explainsshortcomingsandprovidesrecommendations.
CommenDAtion – integrAteD reporting
pcak naa Hd bhad
Withthemovetowardsintegratedreporting,companiesareincreasinglydemonstratingthis
seamlessconnectionbetweennonfinancialandfinancialreporting.PuncakNiagaHoldingsBerhad’s
attemptsonintegratingconventionalinformationwithinanannualreportandsustainabilityreporting
ishighlycommendable.
l .c .follow puspelon
unc i H l in rh 416087 U
ismaoz al i , o4, ers iaran ukan, eksyen 13,
40100 hah lam, elangor arul Ehsan, alays iaT+603 5522 8589
F+603 5522 8598Ecorcom uncakniaga. com. my
. u n c n i . c m . my i n v t r . h tm l
Sustainable Growth
AnnualReport 2010
u
c a
i a
a
l i
r a
u
l
r t
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 25/32
25
Asinpreviousyears,thejudgesofthe
ACCAMaSRA2011providefeedback
onthestateofreporting,basedonthe
reportssubmitted.Companiesinvestalot
oftimeintheirsustainabilityreportand
thefeedbackandreflectionprovidedhere
ismeanttoraisethebaronsustainability
reportinginMalaysia.
ThroughthenineyearsoftheACCAMaSRA,theoverallqualityofsustainability
reporthasimprovedyearonyear.
Amongtheleadersinsustainability
reporting,therecontinuestobesignificant
improvementsbuttherestofthefield
arecatchingup,andnewleadersare
emerging.Thejudgeshavenotedasmall
increaseinstand-alonesustainability
reports,andasignificantjumpinthenumberofreportsthatarebeingassured,
lendingmorecredibilitytothesereports.
MovingontothenextdecadeoftheACCA
MaSRA,thejudgesnotethefollowing
areasforfutureimprovementstofurther
drivecredibleandrobustsustainability
reportsinMalaysia:
foCus on reporting prinCiplesMorecompaniesareadoptingtheGRI
framework.However,manycompanies
appeartobelievethatanA+reportis
thebenchmarkofgoodreporting.This
encouragestheuseofGRIappearstobe
usedasatick-box,focusingonreporting
onthemaximumnumberofindicators,
ratherthanaddressingtheGRIPrinciples
thatshouldguidesustainabilityreporting.Itisworthnotingthatthewinnersof
theMaSRAoverthepastthreeyears
havebeenGRIreporters,butnoneof
thesereportswereA+reports,but
reportswhichclearlyaddressedthe
principlesofMateriality,Inclusiveness
andCompleteness.
mAteriAlity AnD bAlAnCe
Materialityisacoreprinciplefor
definingreportcontent.Materialityistheprioritisationoftopicsorindicators
sufficientlyimportanttobeaddressed
inthereport.Readersofsustainability
reportswanttoknowwhatinternaland
externalmethodologieswereusedto
determinewhetheranissueismaterial.
Companiesthatunderstandmateriality
areabletoprovideacomprehensiveandconcisepictureofitssignificanteconomic,
environmentandsocialimpacts.The
judgesnotedthatthelackoffocuson
materialityledtodiscrepanciesbetween
peers.Forexample,thetwotelecoms
companies,TMandDiGi,appearedto
placeconflictingemphasisonclimate
change:WhereasTMreportedthisasa
lowpriority,DiGireportedthisasafocus
areaandakeymaterialissue.Thelackofdetailedexplanationonthemateriality
identificationprocessmakesitdifficultfor
readersandstakeholderstoassessthe
accuracyoftheprioritisation.
Asustainabilityreportshouldreflect
positiveandnegativeaspectsofa
company’sperformancetoprovidefora
reasonableandbalancedassessmentof
overallperformance.Thejudgesnotedthat
sustainabilityreportstendtobeskewed
towardspeople-centricimpacts,and
towardspositivestories.Therewaslittle
discussionoffailuresandchallenges.In
onecase,anotherwisecomprehensive
reportmadenomentionofasignificant
governanceissue,whichhasbeen
widelyreportedinthemedia.Thisleaves
stakeholderswiththeimpressionof‘cherry
picking’,andcastsdoubtonthecredibilityofthereport.
Completeness AnD bounDAries
ManyMalaysiancompanieshave
growninsizetobecomeinternational
businesses.Theirgeographicalspread
iswide,employingthousandsofpeople
acrossdiversifiedbusinesses.Malaysian
companieshaveoperationsindeveloping
countrieswheretherearerisksof
humanrightsviolation,securityrisksto
employees,aswellasdevelopmental
opportunitieslinkedtotheiroperations.
ThisgrowthofMalaysiancompaniesis
notreflectedinsustainabilityreportsas
mostcompanieschoosetoconfinetheir
reportingtolimitedpartsoftheiractivities
orgeographicaloperations,withnotime
boundplanorcommitmenttoexpandtheirreportingboundaries.
Inparticular,environmentalreportingis
oftenlimitedtoheadquarterimpacts,
ignoringimpactsfromlogistics,retailor
fieldoperations.Companiesalsotendto
excludebranchesoroperationsabroad,
whichcombinedmayconstitutealarger
footprintthantheheadquartersalone.
Equallytroublingistheopacityofthe
judges’feedback
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 26/32
26
reports.Inmanycasesitisnotclearwhat
aspectsthereportcoversandwhatis
excluded,leavingstakeholderswithouta
clearpictureofimpactsandeffectiveness
ofactivities.
inClusiveness AnD stAKeHolDer
engAgement
Stakeholderengagementiscoreto
developingandembeddingarobustsustainabilitystrategy.Overtheyears,this
aspecthasbeenstrengthenedinMalaysian
sustainabilityreportsthroughcasestudies
andinterviews.
However,manyengagementsappeared
tobetestimonials,ratherthan
genuineengagements.Thejudges
encouragecompaniestobemore
engagedwithcriticalstakeholders,
astheseengagementscanhaveits
benefits.Opennesstoconcernscan
leadtoproductivecooperationoverkey
challengesthatimpactsonacompany
anditsindustry.
Stakeholderengagementneedstogo
beyondmerelyreportingmeetingswith
stakeholders,butalsodemonstrateresponsivenessandawillingnesstolisten
toconcerns.Inonereport,thecompany
dismissedthecommunity’sconcernsas
‘unfortunatelymis-constructed’ratherthan
addressingwhatthecompanywished
todoaboutsuchmisunderstandings.
Ascompaniesembedsustainability,a
morestructuredstakeholderengagement
processwillbeneededtodemonstrate
responsiveness.Thisinvolvesidentifying,
defining,anddisclosingwhothekey
stakeholdersare,demonstratingthat
concernshavebeentakenonboard,and
involvingstakeholdersinimprovements.
embeDDing of sustAinAbility
Sustainabilitystrategyshouldbe
integratedintocorporatestrategy.
Thisisreflectedwhenthehighest
decisionmakingbodyofacompanydrivessustainability.Thedomino
effectofintegratingsustainabilityatan
organisation’shighestlevelchangesthe
wayanorganisationoperates,itspriorities,
performance,employeemoraleandtime
spentonengagementwithstakeholders.
Thejudgeswouldliketoseemore
disclosureonwhoisultimatelyresponsible
forsustainabilitywithinacompany,
howsustainabilitystrategyisdeveloped,
implementedandsubsequentlydriven
acrossthecompany,andhowKPIs
andemployeerewardsarelinkedto
sustainabilityperformance.
tHe vAlue of AssurAnCe
Itisapositivedevelopmentthatmore
companiesseekthird-partyassurance,asthisprovidesforgreatercredibilityand
robustnessofthereportingprocess.
However,thejudgesnotedthatmany
assurancestatementsdidnotseem
toaddvaluetothereports,andthat
assurancestatementsappearedrepetitive,
ratherthanspecificallyaddressingthe
individualcompany.Severalassurance
statementscontainederrors,incorrect
referencing,identicalexclusionsand
recommendationsacrossdifferentreports,
andlimitedscopeofassurance.
Third-partyassurancebringsadditional
costtothereportingprocess,and
companiesshouldthereforeensurethat
theyunderstandtheobjectivesandgetfull
valuefromtheprocessofassurance.
Companiesneedtoaskseveralquestions:
Whatisthereasonforanassurance?
Whichstakeholdersneedtobeassured?
DostakeholdersunderstandanISAE3000
assurance?Doeshavinganassurance
withexclusionsorlimitedscopeaddvalue
tothesustainabilityreport?Doesthe
assurancedefinewhere,whatandwhy
areaswereexcluded?Istherevalueto
assurancestatementswhereinternational
standardsarenotedbutnotfollowed?
Isthereaconflictofinterestbetween
assuranceproviderandtheauthor/
consultantofthereport?
Thoughanassuranceistypically
providedbyprofessionalfirms,there
areotherwaystoassurestakeholdersa
sustainabilityreportisrobustandcredible.Companiescanengageasubjectmatter
expert,acriticalstakeholder,orapanel
ofstakeholderstoprovideareviewof
sustainabilitydisclosuretoensurethe
reportisbalance,completeandaddresses
allmaterialissues.
proACtive DisClosure
Thejudgesnotedthatmorecompanies
reportonresourceuseandreductions
judges’feedback
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 27/32
27
achieved.Thisformofreport,though
insightful,isretrospectiveinnature.
Movingforward,companiescantake
amoreproactiveandforwardlooking
disclosurethrough:
setting long term tArgets
LongtermtargetsandKPIssendastrong
messagetostakeholdersonthecompany’s
goalsandcommitmentstoaddressingmaterialissues.Italsodemonstratesthat
sustainabilityisembeddedinoperations
bydisclosingthemanagementapproach
andinitiativesundertakentoachieve
suchtargets.
benCHmArKs
Benchmarkprovidescontextastohow
thecompanyisperforminginrelation
toitsindustrypeers.Whatarethe
industrybenchmarksforsustainability?
Arethereindustrycertificationschemes?
Isacompany’scommitmentrealistic
andonparwithintheindustryandcan
thecompanydemonstrateleadershipin
theindustry?
voluntAry Commitments
Theinternationalcorporatecommunityhasgalvanisedasacoalitiononarange
ofsustainabilityagendasthroughthe
developmentofvoluntarycommitments.
Somevoluntarycommitmentsare
universal,suchastheUnitedNations
GlobalCompactandtheCarbonDisclosure
Project,andsomewhichareindustry
specific,suchastheEquatorPrinciple,the
GreenBuildingIndexandtheRoundtable
onSustainablePalmOil.Beyondjust
signinguptothesecommitments,
companiesneedtoreportonprogrammes
andactivitiestodemonstratecompliance
andactivecommitment.
invest AnD involve Communities
Malaysiancompaniesareverygenerous
tothecommunitiestheyoperatein.This
isreflectedintheirdisclosureofcorporate
givingprogrammes,theamountoftimespentandfinancialresourcesdonated.
Thereisaroleforbusinessestocontribute
tothedevelopmentagendainMalaysia
thatgoesbeyondmerelyhelping
studentsattainhigherpassingrates.
Companiesfailedtorecognisetheimpact
suchinvolvementhavebroughttothe
community,aswellasforthecompany
staff.Emphasisonlocalemployment
opportunitiesandskillsdevelopmentto
buildwealthinlocalcommunitiesand
adoptionofappropriatetechnologiesare
alsocommunityinvolvementandimpact
thatcanbemeasuredanddisclosed.
Communityinvolvementandengagement
isapartofstakeholderengagement.
Emphasisofsuchlinkswiththecommunityensuresthattheyare
involvedindecisionsthatimpactthem.
Suchengagementandinvolvement
withcommunitiescanhavepositive
reputationalimpactsaswellas
maintainingalicencetooperate.
judges’feedback
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 28/32
28
supportingorganisations
AccA
AccountAbilityisaleadingglobalorganisationprovidinginnovativesolutionstothemostcritical
challengesincorporateresponsibilityandsustainabledevelopment.Since1995wehavebeen
helpingcorporations,non-profitsandgovernmentsembedethical,environmental,social,and
governanceaccountabilityintotheirorganisationalDNA.Ouruniquevaluepropositionbrings
togetherleading-edgeresearch,widely-recognisedstandardsandstrategicadvisoryservicesto
deliverpracticalsolutionsforourclients.
AccountAbilityworksto:
• Helpitsclientsandmembersimprovebusinessperformanceandbuildsustainablecompetitive
advantage
• Enableopen,fairandeffectiveapproachestostakeholderengagement;
• Developandrecogniseresponsiblecompetitivenessincompanies,sectors,countriesandregions;
• Createeffectivecollaborativegovernancestrategiesforpartnershipsandmultilateralorganisations
thataredeliveringinnovationandvalue,andsetandinfluencesustainabilitystandards.
• Helpcorporations,non-profitsandgovernmentsembedethical,environmental,socialand
governanceaccountabilityintotheirorganisationalDNA.
Ourvisionisofaworldwherepeoplehaveasayinthedecisionsthathaveanimpactonthem,and
whereorganisationsactonandaretransparentabouttheissuesthatmatter.
AtthecoreofourworkistheAA1000SeriesofStandardsbasedontheprinciplesof:
• Inclusivity–peopleshouldhaveasayinthedecisionsthatimpactonthem
• Materiality–decisionmakersshouldidentifyandbeclearabouttheissuesthatmatter
• Responsiveness–organisationsshouldbetransparentabouttheiractions.
enDorser
ba maaa bhad
BursaMalaysiaisanapprovedexchangeholdingcompanyunderSection15oftheCapitalMarkets
andServicesAct2007.ApubliccompanylimitedbysharesundertheCompaniesAct1965,Bursa
Malaysiaoperatesafully-integratedexchange,offeringequities,derivatives,offshore,bondsaswell
asIslamicproducts,andprovidesadiverserangeofinvestmentchoicesglobally.BursaMalaysia
SecuritiesregulatesandoperatesthesecuritiestradingactivitiesinMalaysia,astockmarketwith
about1,000companiesacross50economicactivities.Companiesfromanyeconomicsectorsare
listedeitherontheMainMarketforlarge-capestablishedcompanies,orontheACEMarketfor
emergingcompaniesofallsizes.TheExchangeadoptstheFTSEBursaMalaysiaKLCIvaluesasits
mainindex.
enDorser
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 29/32
29
supportingorganisations
supporter
Car.c
CorporateRegister.comistheglobalcorporateresponsibility(CR)resourceswebsite.Ithoststhe
world’smostcomprehensivedirectoryofCRandsustainabilityreports,profilingover35,000reports
worldwidefromover8,000companies.Withanarchivestretchingbackto1990itisindispensable
foranyoneworkinginthefieldofCRandsustainabilityreporting.
Therearenownearly6,000newreportseveryyear,andthissiteistheonlyplacetofindthemall.
Thesitealsofeaturesafullsearchabledirectoryofover7,000organisationsinvolvedinCRreporting.
CorporateRegister.com’sannualCRreportingawards,theCRRA,arenowintheirfifthyear–see
www.-awad.c
www.corporateregister.com
+442070143366
Da e (Doe)
TheDepartmentofEnvironment(DOE),establishedin1975,ismandatedundertheEnvironmental
QualityAct(EQA),1974toprevent,controlandabatepollution.Itisalsoempoweredtoenforce
SectionIVoftheExclusiveEconomicZoneAct,1984.
m
DOE’smissionistoensuresustainabledevelopmentintheprocessofnationbuilding.
sa a aa•PollutionControlandPrevention
•SustainableDevelopmentthroughConservationofResources
•IntegrationofEnvironmentalFactorsinDevelopmentPlanning
•EnvironmentalEducationandAwareness
•PublicParticipation
•Inter-AgencyandFederal-StateCooperation
•Bilaterally,RegionallyandInternationalCooperation.
enDorser
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 30/32
30
supportingorganisations
meDiA pArtners
th ed b Wk
TheEdgeBusinessWeeklyisanaward-winningandbestsellingbusinessandinvestmentweekly
newspaperinMalaysia.Itprovidesreaderswithauthoritative,analyticalcontentonthecorporate,
investment,realestate,technology,management,mediaandlifestylesectors.Sinceitslaunchin1994,
ithasbecometheweeklystapleforcorporateexecutivestokeepabreastofbusinessandinvestment
developmentsinthecountry.Itisdistributednationwidevianewsstandsandbypaidsubscription.
TheEdgeBusinessWeeklyispublishedbyTheEdgeCommunicationsSdnBhd.
th ed faca Da
LaunchedonMay22,2007,TheEdgeFinancialDailyisthelatesttitlefromthepublishersofTheEdge.
Itactsasastandalonedailybusinesspaperwhichcomplementsitsweeklysisterpublication.Published
MondaystoFridays,TheEdgeFinancialDailyprovidesbusinessnewsreportingandarticleswithlocal
insightsandglobalerspectives.ItisdistributedmainlyintheKlangValleyaswellasotherkeymarket
centres.Itisavailableatnewsstandsandbypaidsubscription.
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 31/32
31
ACCA(theAssociationofChartered
CertifiedAccountants)istheglobalbody
forprofessionalaccountants.Weaim
toofferbusiness-relevant,first-choice
qualificationstopeopleofapplication,
abilityandambitionaroundtheworldwho
seekarewardingcareerinaccountancy,
financeandmanagement.
Foundedin1904,ACCAhasconsistentlyhelduniquecorevalues:opportunity,
diversity,innovation,integrityand
accountability.Webelievethat
accountantsbringvaluetoeconomies
inallstagesofdevelopment.Weaimto
developcapacityintheprofessionand
encouragetheadoptionofconsistent
globalstandards.Ourvaluesarealignedto
theneedsofemployersinallsectorsand
weensurethat,throughourqualifications,
weprepareaccountantsforbusiness.
Weworktoopenuptheprofessionto
peopleofallbackgroundsandremove
artificialbarrierstoentry,ensuringthatour
qualificationsandtheirdeliverymeetthe
diverseneedsoftraineeprofessionalsand
theiremployers.
Wesupportour147,000membersand
424,000studentsin170countries,
helpingthemtodevelopsuccessful
careersinaccountingandbusiness,and
equippingthemwiththeskillsrequiredby
employers.Weworkthroughanetwork
of83officesandcentresandmorethan
8,500ApprovedEmployersworldwide,
whoprovidehighstandardsofemployee
learninganddevelopment.Throughourpublicinterestremit,wepromotethe
appropriateregulationofaccounting.We
alsoconductrelevantresearchtoensure
thatthereputationandinfluenceofthe
accountancyprofessioncontinuestogrow,
provingitspublicvalueinsociety.
ACCAhasbeenactivelyinvolvedinthe
unfoldingdebateofCSRandsustainability
reportingformorethan15years.ACCA
promotestransparencyandaimstohelp
businessesandorganisationsrealisethe
growingimportanceofsustainability.ACCA
promotesCSRandsustainabilityglobally
andinMalaysiathroughrecognition
ofbestpractices,capacitybuilding,
education/informationandresearch.
31
aboutACCA
8/2/2019 Judges Report ACCA-MaSRA2011
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/judges-report-acca-masra2011 32/32
ACCA maaa sd bhd(473007P)
27thFloorSunwayTower Kch bach
No86JalanAmpang Unit#8.01
50450KualaLumpur 8thFloorGatewayBuilding
tel:+60327135051fax:+60327135052 No9JalanBukitMataemail:[email protected] 93100KuchingSarawak
www.accaglobal.com tel:+6082425051fax:+6082426061
ACCAMalaysiaSustainabilityReportingAwards(MaSRA)2012
An invitAtion to pArtiCipAte
Ifyoudiscloseenvironmental,socialorfullsustainabilityinformationaboutyourorganisation,weinviteyou
toparticipateinACCAMalaysiaSustainabilityReportingAwards2012.
TheACCAMalaysiaSustainabilityReportingAwards2012timetableis:
mach 2012 Announcementofthe2012Awards
30 J 2012 Entrydeadline
A 2012 Judges’meetings
oc 2012 Awardspresentationceremony
IfyouhaveanyquestionsabouttheAwardsscheme,pleasecontact
m vah gaah
tel:+(603)27135051ext15fax:+(603)27135052
email:[email protected]