Upload
others
View
6
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
p:-
0001
JOURNAL OF
PSYCHOLOGY
1960 Part 3Val. XII
ON THE F AlLURE TO ELIMINATE HYPOTHESES IN
A CONCEPTUAL TASK
BY
P. c. WASON
From the .\fedical Research Council Industrial Psychology Research Group, University
College, London
This investigation examines the extent to \vhich intelligent young adults seek (i)confinning evidence alone (enumerative induction) or (ii) confirming and disconfinningtvidence (eliminative induction), in order to draw conclusions in a simple conceptual task.The experiment is designed so that use of confirming evidence alone will almost certainlylead to erroneous conclusions because (i) the correct concept is entailed by many moreobvious ones, and (ii) the universe of possible instances (numbers) is infinite.
Six out of 29 subjects reached the correct conclusion without previous incorrect ones,13 reached one incorrect conclusion, nine reached two or more incorrect conclusions, andone reached no conclusion. The results showed that those subjects, who reached two ormo~ incorrect conclusions, were unable, or unwilling to test their hypotheses. Theimplications are discussed in relation to scientific thinking.
INTRODUCTION
~ces1rom ~gnfi~ing evi~ce {Bacon's "induction by simple enumeration")cali obviously lead to conclusions because different hYPOth~~b;e-r.om-
~ti e same data. In their crudest form suCh -mre~-are apparent inthe -selection of facts to justify prejudices. In research merely confinning evidence
is clearly of limited value. For example; suppose that it is suggested that a deficit(1') of a particular substance in the blood is uniquely related to a distinctive symptomlv), (In logical terms, % is a "necessary-and-sufficient" condition for y,) Andsuppose that this hypothesis had been supported by confirming evidence alone, i.e.~'henever the deficit had been induced, the symptom had appeared {ignoring statisticalissues for the sake of simplification). It might then be assumed that the hypothesiswas tenable. But the evidence only allows the inference that % is a sufficient con-dition for y, that the deficit always leads to the symptom. To establish the postulatedrelation, there must also be, no disconfinning evidence-no ca~ of the symptomwithout the deficit. For if such a case were obtained, the dencit would not be a
necessary condition for the symptom, and the symptom would not be a sufficientcondition for the deficit. The hypothesis that either was a necessary-and-sufficientcondition for the other could be eliminated. The symptom would not be a reliablesign. Its absence \..'ould rule out the possibility of the deficit, but its presence would
be ambiguous.In general, scientific inferences are based on the principle of eliminating hypo-
theses. while provisionally accepting. only those which remain. Methodologically,such eliminative induction implies adequate controls so that both positive andnegative experimental results give information about the possible determinants ofa phenomenon.
.~"
0002
, "
.~
.s ~
.~
§ ~
~"'=
£'0~
~
~
~"'=
§
=
-cG
O
~
"' ...Q
.-...
v>...
§=
~
~"'-
Q.o
bOv
~
"'. v
C.)
.
: :!#
.-~
!{I E
i .~
...O
0
; V
... bO5
.5.
i3;;.!!~
~~
~
!3Q.~
~
~--~
.C.)
vv~
.'cav ...0"'-
'!J ~
VV
.=..V
~
.=
=
C.)...,~
...Q
.Q
...Q.
~
..; .,
~
...~
., .V
.. >
,~
..=
"'
V..
.-bO
~
.~
.=
:!# .Q
:!# V
C.)bO
>,C
.)~V
~.'~
=...
.Q...~
~
~~
]
~
~ ...~
:'E
. .Q ~
~
.'J ~
~
.-~S
~
.5 -;
=
.5 bO
6' .s .5 ~. ...v;
; .~
U)
~
.§. -d -:S =
"'=
~
v ~
~
; ~
~
e .~
~
~
~
~
., .~
0) ~
~
~
~ .=
.=
]~
"'
4)U
) ~
~-~
~
~
.=...
v..~
v...
~ >
...0 C
.) ...~
..~
.~.Q
-..;:
~
.0 ,
.., ~
~
V=
0.,:;
~
C.) ., ...~
.!? ~
~
0 .=
=
...>
V
~
>~
V
-C
V
::I
'"' ~
'~
C.)Q
)...~~
_VO
~V
O~
"'...O
.,
.Q ~
~
~
"'
>
..C.)
~
~
~
rJ .5 8IE
]
5 ~
'.§ .~ ~
~
[.5
5 5 i
=
.=
.Q .=
'0 ~
~
!!! .G -.§
~o~
~
~
bO
e ....e
V
I .-""
~
-""'.- V
~
~
~
.E
~
~
&
.G
] ~
~
.~
"'
-: O
~
~
"'
.=
.; 0
1-0 ~
C.)0!6~
..."'...rJ., ..,~
>,...t;
<
~
'O;C
.)~ra"~
~~
--=~
~-'.;~
.=~
:e Z
!3 ..."""
...V...
...~~
...ca "'V
>'
VO
DC
.):!#>,
"'t;"'...>,
~
~
.i .5
-.s ;
~
.Q
~
B
~
] f!.
,oi. .E
.5 §
fj' e
.4 >
, .:-
C.)8
""".!?~",.,
"'~~
.Q
~
0
~
~
~
~
~.S
~
Q
. ~
5
:a ~
~
O
.=
~
"' O
;:=
..~
Q.
e C
7' V
O
0 ..C
.) .C
.)O
V
V
~
...Q
. >
,.=
..; O
~
~
...~
V
0 ;a
1-0 ~
~
~
.2
e ~
.~
~
.."§
C.)
~
~
~
., .=
~
~
..;
~
~
>
V
~
.=
V
v.. "'
-v ...C
.)~
O
D
=
><
~
~
,
"' ~
~
~
.n
>.
.!? .~
~
.~
"' v
..v.. +
' V
~
.Qp
~
.5 ~ ~
.= ;:=
~ ~
3 ~ .=
~ .8 -0
'0 C
.) 0
.~
.g~
O
C
.) ~
!3 ~
O
"'
>,
~
; e
~
"'=
~
~
.~
C
.) ;a e
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
§ ~
,
ca ~
<~
~
...~
V
C
"' .,
C
~
O
~
O
~
e >
...
"' ~
~
~
>
<
Q)
~
0 ~
"'
C.)
""' ...~
"'
O
V
~
V>
~
~
..-~
~
U
~
~
~
C.) .=
.bo -0
...~
-.s ~
~
0 ~
~
0
.s ~
0 ~
C.)
C.)
""" ~
...~
~
"'
~
~
~
.~
V
~
.=
:e V
~
O
~
V
~
...~
~
t; ~
Q
.=
...C
.) .=
9
~
-.;: ...~
'E
'Q
~
~
..0 ~
~
...;a
V...
..U
C.)
~~
:
,::;. :. -a.
"' "'
"' ..:: ..;
~
:; ~
.~
.a
.Qcui~
"' _v~
",.'~C
.) ->
""...>,-
.~
.!? I:;
"' ...0
.Q
; ~
-.s 'E
.~
V
~
V
:; '0
~
=
~
§ .5 ]
.~
~ ~
~
~
] .~
~
~
~
~ ~
£
] .E
.~ :.e
C.) ~
., ::
3 ., .~
~
., .~
~
.>
C.) ~
~ ~
2. ~
a..8
c-S'O
~
if-o~~
.S
., ~
I- ~
~
~~~~~
..Eo '-
c O
~c
o o
C
u
~~..,E"Z
-0~M ">
'!:I ~
~41."
.'!:I: 4141...
4) '!:I
.ii ~
o
a:a
.!! Q
.=
~
§=
.~
.+
' e
"...!-0MI
I. .a~
-5 ~
_8... ~
§c: o
0.+:0.'!:1
I I
~
.S :S
-:9 ~
6
~
-5 .~
~ .0" 5
~
I I..
..~u
~~
0'!:1=
"~
.8I
I ~
~
~
:J.-5:e ...41C
"':...e
J..~
o "...
~>
N
c:~
=
0"
"- 0
0 C
~
c:
." ..=
-""'~
...0.Q~
,,=
I...:. ~
-g~"
~r--
...~~
.8.?:..I
5 -:S
~~
'8~gJ:.
~g,g,e"]
I ao
..~~
=-S
~:g
='!:1...
.-".Q=
~..=
.Q
~>
C:~
:J
~
j$ e.Q
...4141,;;jo :2:E
~41.Q
...I
IN
41a~418~
~
: -5
0M
-=
=
=
' =
...
I I
'!:1 S
'=~
~0=
6 ~
~.!!i~
-5 I
I; .u; 9 .8 "d ~
[1 ":;
.8 ~
.~ -g
E
I I
5 ~
~
~ ~
~
[.E
§
8.N
:. ~
.9
I I
a 8.".1:'!:1.~
=
1:-~~
~~
II
t-. ~
=,,~
~=
a '!:I~
...QoC
~
§ ~
..~
41 ~
;:=
= .00 e
e :'J .E
I I
~
." '=
=§'!:1~
41
~:a=
~..=
;J ..M
.. 00
0" 0-41M
...OI
I ~
~
~
8~
:::=.Q
=.=
g..."d4l"
..Ioj ~
+
:-=
~
'!:1 .Q
OI
I .c
U'!:1
-S,,41.C
Ooo41-~
C:
'!:1I
~
0 ~
.~
.Q~
!!~
.CP
'0~."~
.,,
I "a
I.: ~
.Q
=
."ee 8...~
...
II
5 p.
~..
~§.!!
~...~
~.U
;=~
~.;'.8
U
..."]
._=.Q
...4141=
..0~...
aI
I ~
-g ~
E
...!!
<
:E ~
..."'0 e ~
~
=
~ -41
~
~
0 .= 0
= :s: .-ii
~
=I
I 0
aa...!-0."."
41.Q'...
~...
~~
o~
~
~
41~I
I 0
=
=.
..C
.." ~
~
oI
I O
:'J
41 -5.!! -5
.E
'i e
.~
~
~
~
5
~'!:141.~
=
'!:1~
...00..I
I '"U
~~
~.~
4100.~~
~
...'!:1-;:-."
.;~41"~
e=41~
41 '!:1
I I
s.~
= 'i
..; ~
.~
~
s..a g, E
cu "'0 aO
.~
I I
a. ~
~
e fi:e
.?: .8 e
~
..6 ~
~
=I
I N
.,".6il8'g°"eg..~-:s
=41]
.".'!:1 ,,=
=
~~
... J
...=.co.a.!!=
=."
~..~
~...
~~
-"tW>
°...~
0041>~
... ..
I I
.~
~~
."CU
a ~
~=
.co~."t..
.Q-
.-".~...oo.~
e"
41C:
I I
~-
..~0
U.~
..."-U~
41."
~
~
41 ...41
U
-.~
O
41 -"
II
=
~-41...
"~=
.~.,,..
41 02...
=
." Q
.I:
I I
~~
?' .P
.~§-5~
.Q~
.9]~'E
4I..:e.:a£
"'~
!! ;'~
8~
=
L-.O
~:..c:~
~
..~
.~
~
0..
.:J ~
.8 .s
.~
~
tJ 0- .~
~
~
~
~
~
~
..1~
'0
~
~
~
..6! ~
~
'i;'
~
~
...!!. .2
tIO ..tIO
h
-;; ~
i::
Q. ~
~
>
. ~"3
II ~
~
...~
~
e .-0
.-.~
~
II ..:u
.=
~
.~
ii .~
~
eS
' :2
...~
-:S .~
-c;s
~
...0 ~
t;
~ ~
=
~
~
0 d;1
~
;a ~
-:S
~
~
° -:S
~
-a .--:S
.-.;
~
~
~
V1 ~
~;
:'e,. 'c
.g '5
'"' ~
~
~
""
~~
~
~
~
~
"'e
:B
~. ~
'd
; 'd -:;; :
~.§
~ .~
i1 ..c1 8.-5
8. .; .;'.2
'd ~
5
-a: '"' ~
]
.'g ~
.~
~
~
"0 ~
8
] ~
-'?0 V1
~
:>,
~
.-~
O
:3 :3
~
~
.~
0 ~
V
1 V
1 ~
.~
-~
.D
:3
~~
-~
C
D
--~
~
...:3 -;;; ~
~
~
~
>
-.g V
1 .2i .V1 >
'"' .~
'"'
"' ~
~
r... 't"
0 ~
V
1 ~ '-c;
~
...S
:3 ~
"'
~
~
:!. 8
o ~
~
.~
...0
V1...
~-
i-". -.D
V
1bD
>,",N
...(Q
"00 ...~
"
-~3
-:.:3
o~
:>, 6 "0 8
~ ~
~ ~
~ s
~. ~
~ :a .~
.S ~o
.~
~ O~
-08 ~
~ .;:. 1;' ]
"0 ~ S
~
~
~ -:::-.~
h
~eV
1 ~
.~ ~
~
~
:9>
-.=
~
-:3 ..V
1 ~
..;<
:
-4S
...c:! -.(Q
;a
.:3 ~
-.::
~
"0 "'
V1
..I 5
.D
6 .8 'i!
t: -:S
bD ~
~
f:
s ~
~
~
0
'"' '"'
"' -.~
t:
~
:!. ~
~
.8 0
"' ...~
~
: V
i > .f:
:3 v 0
...~
O
.~0~
:., ~
.S-~
~]g
~~
~;.f:V
1 ~
~.~
:~~
85og."3~~
: :(j~
.§§~~
ci.: "'.~
... t:..~
.:E."'
~
=
:( 0
~
...° "0
~
'"' '"' "0
~
.~
'"' :3 ...~
V
1 ~
'Q:1 -8
~
...'"' '"'
~
S .D
~
V
1 ~ :E
-5 ..."'
§ "'
0 8
~
V1 .g .f:
"' '5
>-
~g~
.: ~
~~
0~
-V1£8~
-:S.~
~g"'0A
. ~
]-:S.~
5-:Sg~
.8~.E
:]8.g.~s~
"0t:~
.;~-:S
.~
~
~~
U)
.~
V1
0 0
.D
...O
c:! 0
V1
C
~
"0 -~
~..~
'"'
...~
.t: ~
~
.,
~
V1
E...~
p. ~
~
~
...:>
, bD
8 ~
.,;
~
.~
~.S
4J
:>, 'd
...~
'U
"0 .>
0
.~
.U
"U ~
V
1 ...;'"' "0
~
.D
'-c; ~
'"' .-~
E
~
"U
~
'"'
~
~..I
.~
.g 5
5 "'
.S
:3 .~
:!; -:S
.§
e "'.
~
; "'
"U .0
:a ~
~
~
...lE
~
~
~
~
-:0
:>,.'"'
...§ ~
~
0
:3 ~
~.::.
~.::.
...
<
-E
~
8] ~
~
::E
~
.g
:3 "0 "0
~
0 .V
i :t'D:'""
"0 ~
;
~
: bD
'"' .E
~
~
"U
...0 ~
:3 V
~
~
t:
.~
~
'E
bD C
IJ e
~
~
~~
-""
...'"'~
.~
(/)pCIJ~
~~
CIJ
...~
CIJ I
S~
',",
"' :>
'CIJ"'~
_0~-=
.. oc:!C
IJ 0(/)..0\~
Z
0 .:=
C
IJ ~
~
-:::- CIJ t:
~
=
..~
CIJ ...~
~
>
- "0 ~
~~
!!
"0 c:!
~
CIJ ~
>
V
1 <
'"' .~
~
..C
IJ (/)
...~"'
-~
;< -~
:
~ "0
>
:3 1
CIJ
(/) ...; .~
;::
,. ~
=
C
IJ bD
- -.:(
:a '-'
=~
...~
~
.~
§ "0
~ .'§. !-0 ~
g.]
§ ~
8.:-3
~
~
~
~ :
~
.S
..r: I
~
.~
~.~
:.§ g.;:
::::: ~
~
.S ~
:"'
\0: eo
~
2 ~
.~...5
"(3 ~
"'
~
.D
~
~
~
.t: >
, "' 0
(/) "' 0
~
'"' t:'
::=
8 .D
"' "'
&
=
~
~
~
...'ot" ..~
C
IJ ..~
~
~.t:~
.:='
"t]~
:..~~
~5~
.:;;8 ]
.~~
~'"'8.~
~~
~~
~
~~
et: .~
.E.~
~
N.:>
'~
~;..s~
~III
ClJC
IJ~
o ~
]CIJ~
CIJ
CIJ
.~~
.t: "O
~~
"c:j oV
1.1:: -5
~..0:3~
~~
ClJ8
.DV
1 "0",
~p.
CIJ ~
~ -5
~.~
"'. ..~
:>
, -5 'a. ~ "U
.D 8 ...~
0 ~
~
0 .~
'"' 8
~ .~
:a .f: ~
bD
'"' 8 0
0 0
'"' .;a ~
.~ .s
CIJ. :!; :
~
-:~
-:S
8 8
~
~
§ ~
9 -:S "0 -:S
~ .~
.!fJ :E- .g
§ .£' 5 ;
"0 0
~
~ -:S
~
0 ~
~
:S
..a .g .s ~
§' ~ 3
~
~
'Q:1 ~
] .E
~ .5
~
~
.5 ~
<
§ ~
~
E
~
~
. ] ]
.~ £
~
: 9
~
] ~
~
:~ .~
5 ~
~
~
~
:::J ~
. ~
.g ~
1 ~
8 ~
~
.~
.8 9
~ ;;J ~
~
~
~
~
~
..I 5 ]
.ci "0 ~
E
~
..~.
~ ~
~
§ 'E
-:S 8
Vi
2:.~
-:S ."E
~ ~
9 .~
E
§
§ ~
~ .v; A
. :S
.s .g ~
;a ~
~
~
.f: ~
o .s
<
~
~
u §
S .~
..6
~
~ ~
~
.;:.
~
:3 '0 .~
9 0
~
"' "'
5 0
bD t:
~
~
~ ~
~
5 .:( "U
EA
. ~
o
5 -:S
~ I-' "0
~
~
9 ~
~
. .~
~
] 8
~-:S
~
.t; .g .s:~
-;
~
.~
~
~- ~
~
8 e- ~-E
~
.~
.: .s :6
~ .~
§ ~
E
~
'E
~
."'ii :: .~
.g E
8- ~
-:S .~
~
-:;: ~
~
0 <
~
"0 -i- ~
"0 o :E
.S
~
; .f: .~
.f: "'. ~
§
"' 1;' ~
'"' ~. :;; ~
.f: "0 .8 t:
§ ~
~
.f: '-c;. 8 8
:::: ~
§ E
. ~ .g, ~
.s ~
: ~
~
~
~
]~.~
~.8
§].~~
1;'~';~
~
~~
;~'tiJ:~
~].~
8~}~
~:~
::1.~:~
~-:S
.:E
"itJ~-E
~.~
~§~
..I ~
;:."' 0...
-~
~~
~
:3~
.D,",~
:>
':3~aC
IJ O
I
CIJ
..., "O
C
O"'-~
O~
~
§ ~
5 :a
~
~
~
~.
0 g
'0 '-c; ~
~
-ci I
:(j ~
V
1 ~ .V
i §
~
.S
~ .~
'2
~ .~
~
~
~
V
1 ~
'"' ~
; 5
o ..0
'"' -:S .f:
~ -:
~IIj
-;:. .::. .U ...~
.t:
.~
; ~
.S
> .f:
t'D :!;
§ 5
'"' ~
.?:- '"' ~
~
0
~ "0
~o~
~
§
~
; :30
...8 O
i 'E
O
~
0
V1
'"'~
"'c:!(/)..
"O~
:3.D
~
ClJS
'"'
I ..~
CC
IJ ~
V1",
._~.D
~
V1
~~
"'.C
~
~...~
CIJ~
'"'O~
~<.~
.~_.£
8~
§ ~
e]"E.D
eC
'8.==
~
~~
~
kJ.f: (/).s:a
~.~
~
~
~
~
"-E
~~
~
8 c-:S
-:s ~
. p
~-
~...:
-:S.~
~e
..~
0 ~
:>
, .~
"' -V
1 e
CIJ
~
"' ~
~
"0
~
0 .~
. ~
~
.-
:;, ~
~
§
:E
I-' ~
"'.
a ~
~
:3 .~
~
~
. :;
~
.S
~
.~
-§ :(/) !-0
~
~
(/). ~
~
~
§ ~
't:
'-c; ~
;< ~
"'
~
.Vi "0
.8 .~
~
~
Cl
~
0 .-"'
...~
~
~
"0 ~
...~
:
~
..~
~
~
~
.g ~
0
'"' ~
.D
°
.~
~
-:S
~
'"' ~
~
~
.D
C
IJ ;: -u- ...:3
..-~
~
CIJ
;:.~
CIJ
~
","' .~
S"""'
.>~
."ijj'V
1"'...,", ..;:.
~
~
_ClJ.-,",
-0==
~
-~~
.~
~
~
.S
3!-0 =
~
~
~
- 8
~
~.V
i "'
~
~
~
:-E
~ o~
~
8
8. 8
~
.E
:.,; s
Sa..:
.g C
IJ 5 ~
S
8-:S
¥.:o]
~
"0. ~
S
~
'0
~~
..."'
...; .."'
~
~
==
.~
V
1 ;<
V
1 ~
C
C
t:C
IJ .U.D
U
Q
/)~
.-~
~
"' ~
~
~
:3
~
.D
~
S
.De
!-o~
§t:.;~-ci
e ~
~
8 ~
b
~
8 ~
;..8~
8.:I:- ~
~
O\~
0"0..
~
O.V
;.~.S
i-"~.;.U
"0~...
EV
) ~
e
E=
."' s
=~
"'
U
0 ~
.S
0
~
~
§ t:
~
~
~
'0 ~
0
~
0 §
><
(/) ~
V
1 '"' ~
~
~
0
~
.g ~
:3
~
lE
§ "'
~
"3 :3
0 ~
:3
~
~...e~
e'O
.:(~(/)
,",.S"0"'(/)~
~
... ,",C
IJ.S~
.S.S
; ~
",~~
(/)o "",,~
-.S
;.0 ..~
- "'~
"'...
~--
~...'.
~Ij~
.a.~~
].~
8
~
i -~
@
.g~
.8.t:
..'E
~
+'
o ~
.::O~
OIO
>-
..><
+'U
-+'~
~~
'O
~::s§.8~
~i
0.. ~
UO
I-..~~
..]
:2 ~
~
...§
;
o 'E
+"0~
~a+
'~=
o.~
o-.p..
+'~
+'
~..
U
bOU
~~
~
...~
...~
.....~
-~
+'
..~
:.U
1 -~
.&
J ~
a...
..
~
~
~
8 -t:
U
..I:i. C
/)
..yO+
'~
U
1;1.O
.:2~
<
S
~
~
><
+'
'0 ..-~
~
.:+J
;..&J
~
v V
U
.~
:2
;l; -S
:>-8]2=
bOC
/)101
...&J0+
,U:20
-
~°+
':>-
~
..Sp,...+
,=~
~~
~
~
-~
e ~
~
.~
~101
:>-'0 ~
.~
~
-~
~
..~+
"0~~
~>
<
-:S~
~
~~
'O101
..~...t:~
..~
-d ...
~..oo-
..,-
~
0 U
C
/) :2
C/)
-+'
C/)
0] .8~
'0+,p,3
.=
+,-u>
<C
/)~
~
..C
/) 0
..Oj
.~
<
~~
~+
't:+"O
0+'=
- O
IoUC
/)Z
+
' o~
~U
..+'
Iz: bO
~
.~
..:. -;:;,"3
~.+
' ::>
-~
~
~
:2 +
' .c
:2 ~
0'0 t:..U
...C/)..
8.8~
0
..-2.~
~
..U
-~
.&J+
'-~>
- U
~
+':2~
+'+
'
~
~a.~
-C/)=
..-.:2
00 -
Iz: ..~
":d ..i.
+'
101 ~
..--:S:2~
~5
10- =
..=
+'°
~-..°P
'~..~
:2-~
-o~+
'+'~
+'.
<
..+'
~
=.
~::>
~
~8:~
c8e~p.
01 o'O
~e:o+
'.'.'g.~+
,=..~
U=
0 ~
0
~
..'0 .~
..
E
U +
' '0 .~
e
~0
~
bO ..~
.t: '0
~
+'
N
'E
] .~
'0
~
~
~
.:;; 5
"" o,-.~
~
><
><
=.&
J...U
..bO~
.-:: ~
~
In~~InIII~
~-
~
~-oo
U
>'q)
~,o
q) ...
~
q)
O'.J::
q)--=
q)
q)-:S
;
"' U
~-
.0 =
"'
tID
.J::q) ~
=
"' "'
Z~
~
~
q) ~
.S
~
q) U
~
.J:: =
-=
U
~.
-Cd
~
5 z
'3 ~
"'.
f-o~
6~
q)
z
---C
d ~
Z
~
U
=
~
~-
<0.
q) ~
~
..
~.§~
'ij ~
~
~~
II
;,;~"'Q
J~~
"E
q) ~
>.:.
~
...'0 -u
..~
E-o u
0- =
"'
=
..E--
Z~
'"'
Cd
=
0 ~
0 =
p
-Cd
q) .,
0 q)
I: .
01>
"
"'U
1 >
~
q)
~C
U
U
q) ~
~
-Q
;q)
CU
-"'
I:2
r.'0
t::...cu
=
-u~
-
q) 0)
tID
0
~
8 e
~
5;-~
"E'O
",_~_
q)0.."'
0 =
"'
CU
O
)°q)~
0-U
>
, ->
, =
0) ~
0
~
.~
-'c- ~
,00)_0)'00 ~
~
=
~
q) "'
~q)
-0'0)e
~..U
~
0)- ~
~
I:=
~...X
...e "~
" -q)
: 0
;:. "'
~=
:::~~
~~
~~
..=.3~
~~
~~
~~
Cd
." "'
~-q)
~q)
~
~
~.~
:t ::!
c. C
IJU
~~"'0;;:-..c
;:""
;: "
~;:~"-:
~~~
.:."
~I:-
~:
I:."
0 "
1.t,1:~I:~
~~~
~:>
a.LIO:lU
I
.0
~~
0003
;;~::; i
:. ~
~o
~
~
:Q) -3
~
tl ~
"a
~o~
~
...~\
~
0.::~
~
~...tg~
p.g'O
'(,'?~
~
Q
) .c :
-.5 ~
~
~
e
Q) ~
~
.~
>
, 0
~
~
c:~
: u
Q) \
=
~
0 Q
) ...~
.c
0 ~
~
U
.c
.~
~
~
.~
Q)
"'C
is bD
Q
) -~
~
Q
)c
e Q
) Q
) e ~
.~
~
.c
~
c: O
~
Q
) U
~
bD
.~
-"' w
U.~
~
.0 .~
~
2j
U
~
~
Q) .a
~
Q)
"'U
on Q
) X
~
bD
Q)
:3 ~
.c ~
-"'
Q) -c;
~
Q)
=
.5 -:S
0
on :3
...~t:
>
0 o~
~
~
~
~
~
..
0 ~
~
Q
) ~
...~
- ~
~
.~
~
~
U
., on .c
~
o.~
~
..~
.., 0
~
~U
~
"' ~
.~.5~
~
~~
~~
~~
~
~...
h~.~
..."'
Q)
0-.~
.~
-.00... Q
)=
>
..."'0
~
:3 ~
~
"'- U
O
'~
., 0
.~
"' bD
Q
) ~
Q) ~
~
U
~
-~
Q)
.~...0
"' .=
p.
~
Q)
..w
Q)
c ~
>
,.0 -.~
Q)
...",0
0 ~
Q)
0~
0...
bD
~.=
:3
Q)U
.c.C
Q)..."'~
-.O
~"'
e.5 ~
~~
0:=.~
~
.-
~
: ...~
>
, u
~
e ~
::
~
.~-.0
~
..~
--"'~
bD
- .5
0 ~
V
) c
~=
.~
bD~
u Q
) =
Q)
oQ)~
Q
)Q)Q
)~
"'~~
. ~
., >
, et:
e ~
~
~
~
;
~
:3 ; :3 Q
) 8 0
§ ~
.c t:D
-o..u
.u~.c
ot-- ...
0 "'
'0 .~
.~
is
bD
.,u
~
"'U:3...
~Q
) "'
Q)
t:~
"'
Q)
Q)
9 0
tlt:
~
.,; 5.:
., --t:
..u u
.~
...~
8]: 20;~
.~8-~
~
,. U
t:.0~
~.o
Q)
:3 ~
~
.5
~
:3 .~
.,
., .,
"'
"'10-. ~
0", e
§ ~
~
0
.0 U
"'
Q)
.Q)
.~
;.:=~
I. Q
)U"'~
.~U
"'~
~Q
)Ic
"' .~
0
...~
"' tj
-
~~
>.5
"'~~
~=
Q)Q
)~...
"'...~
., O
.C.~
.,.-e
"'I
0 e
p. Q
) u
...:!:. ~
0
~
.,:.~
~
bD
2j
c: -:S
~
Q
) ~
~
~
--:S
.:3 ~
-.~
=
>
..~
0
Q)
~
",OO
.' Q
)-~:!
:3 9
-c; .~
aU
~
~
~
-:S
P
..-;
u; ~
-.c
~
0 ~
t:.C
eX
Q)"'
~
-.~
0 -0
~
.~C
I1 t: .~
~
"U
~
~
~
~
0
bD
"' "'
~
O~
.~
:3
Q)
~
U
Q)
...Q)
~
~1
g-e~
~",::'2.5~
g-:S
'2Q
).~)
~
...~~
.p.>,"'u.>
~
~"'
.Q)",
~u
~
~~
~
'Q
1 ~ ~
.E
°
.5 ;
0 ~
~
-~
Q) ~
>
~
~
.c
~
-~
Q) Q
) Q
)~
uQ)eu
",.~0",e.o.
>,
.-') ..-1::!J
.-.~~
I
I:~...~
'O
I ~
I
."' 1:-
~~
~
.-."',d~
."' -rd
.~
5 '8 ~
.!6
~ :§.
~
~
~
~
9 ~
\011.s ~
~ .~~
~
~
~ ~
[~
~
~
~
;§: ~
~
8
] ~
9 ~
~
~
§
~
5 ~
~
~
.~
8.
>,
~
...~
.~
.~
~
-'C
~
.ca ...~
~
=
t.
~
~
~~
1:
~ '0
~
~ '0
...F;
et.
e~
89
.=
"Q3
.~
~
,Q
.g .s
~
,d ~
=
~
"0
8 ~
8
o o
e ~
p.
g.::::.:E
~
-.."'U
..8".;;
'0 1:
8 i!
8 ~
'Q
j .
~
ao ~
...v
v§", ~
ao
.>
~
"' ,Q
:!J
bD
0 V
V
~
~
e
...~
"' O
~
~
1:
-0 ~
U
,d
eo
:.s ~
~
.S
]
B
=
-5 e
~
:E
8 ~
II
.:'?J ~
~
~
.~
"0
; ~
!
-:5 -:5
~
8 .s
1.z ~
-:;;
~
.~
~
~
.1! 9
~
! ~
6
v
...,Q
~
~
~ '(d ~
~
~
p. ,:. .!.,Q
~
'0 :a ~
"'. :a ~
-:.e. ~
~-
~
.s 'Z'
.;c 5.!!i =
' .~ .~
~
~ ~
1:
:.e. ~
~~
~
:i ~
I
~
.j ~
~
~
]
! 1
! !
~
i .~
~
.~ ~
.i]
j ~
. J ~
~
]
t 1.1
0~
~ .I I!
f ~ .~
~ ~
! ~
.i ~.-u.
~0'.c
~...
"' -.w
...~~
...I:~
~
t. e
v.. ]
ow.2,d...=
V
V
.+:
~
'8 .S
~
:~
$
8. e
e~
-:S
.S
"E
; ]
~
E
~
~
~
~
.~
~
~
5 §
1! 6
] §.s
~
] :2
.~
'Qj
~
~
§ ~
~
5
:E
aorn
~
~
~
:. e
8 -~
1:
.v "'
~
bD
~
'0 ~
0
0 1:
1: ~
~
>
, "'
e ;.
::! ,Q
'0
~
'0 .-~
0
~
~
s101
"' <
--"'
1: 0
-~
~
1: ,Q
q:o
u ~
~
~
~
(I
=' .~
..~
~
~
u
~
.~
~o]~
.~
~:;.~
~g~
.~
~e
~l]~
~
".3 e~
:a ~
~
s~i]
§ e..9.~
~
::I]~~
~
~-:S
;~
] s~
~
~:a
=
too ~
,d ~
~
~
-~
8
"' F
"Q
3 "' :!J ~
~
~
~
~
~
0
'0! ~
O .d
~
1: ,d
~ ~
:!J ,d
~
~
~
~~
~
~
e.~
.E;'",..'f~
.s §.c
§<.~
i--5 ~
;
.'Q3e
.:S rl
~.c:;"0£
~
~
~::E
:g~
.§ ~
.:::: ~
~
~~
.s ~
~
f."0:=
~
=
~
~
~
1:
Q) s
§ V
0
~ :a
0 ~
~
=
"' 1:
"0 ~
V
~
"'
.c ..0
~ -"'
~
~
; ~
III '8 0
] :s -:S
~~~
-~
~ '8 ~
~
.s ...: s-E
~
-.:: ~
] :
0 ~
:i .::
5 e>
. ~o~
e.
$" ~
.=
-:a 'O
£~.§
.!6 ~
g.:S
Eo.g
5E..::
~
]"'
~ ,Q
-~
~ :.§
v ~
~
...ca
° ,d
'0 5
-v... .-') ."'
~
'0 .~ ~
~
~
...,
~
..
~
.~ i
iIl.i~~
{~~
{t~
I~
iili ~
.~
i.~
lig".~
~
~]~
! Ijii
~~
!.~II; ~
II ~
~.
..,d=
E"'vo...~
'0 v
E-V
O...
-.!:.,1: .~
0~"'1:~
-~
coE
0
...~
,dv I:P
. "'~
jj ~
:ai8..9..s-5~;~
; 8~
2a]~V
J~'0\..:.~
~~
1~~
~.::~
:E
~g.si8~
~
~~
E§.!.~
~
.:~i-~
~."'0
~~
.8-
s ~
~
O"""O
co ."'5...'
~v
~..
P""~
..u 0
-~
~8'~
5
~
~~
1£.~:~
S'1!~
.~
"-oo~~
E~
-:S°
II~
~~
~.~
.bD~
:~
~~
~B
~
~5-.§
0..s~
:g[~6~
~~
~
~0;.~
.8III
~~
'0-_.0
(d- ...t.1:
-~
~
~
v "'
E
"""' =
'(d "'
...'0~~
I-: ...~
.~
~
~
~
:f ~
9
"' :9
rl ~
~
1: R
.:: ~
.§ ~
~
~
~
~
0 ~
;
~
.s .s
E
~
8 =
- d
~ ~
]
.; o
-3 ~
II =
~
s
-:: "E ~
p ~
-~
-~
"'
5 ~
-,Q
1: .=
"'
~
...w.
-0 1:-
,d 1:
~
=
I'. ...=
~
:. 0
=
.s 5
t! .5 ~
g.
'0 ] ~
~
g.
§ 8 .;;; ~
.5
.~
8 "0 "0 ~
~. §
~
~
~
.~
~
~
~
-~
~
ii .8 ~ '8
i ~
".;; .~
~
~
".;; ~
~
§ 8 .5
<
E"'>
,E-~
~~
E~
;3>_".;;~
~1:...0~
,dv'O
° -"'
v"0~~
~
..£~
~~
~~
t.1:2 O
._~
lOt
5 ~
~
8,Q
8
tj ~
e
.8 ~
:
.~
~
~
~
E .~
]
00 5 i-'
~
E
-:a ~ ]
] "t:
~
"' t;
§ ~
.5 ~
J
.;.. .s ~
~
°
.~~
-:a ~
8
B .~
e '0
., 5
'Q3 ;
~
-'>."0
~ ~
'Q
3 ~ ~
.~
0 1:
E
:!J v. >
, ~
.!!.. ~
".;; 0 !!..
"' ~
-0
~
~ ~
~
0
~ ~
~
'0 -.!!..
~
° ~
~
~
~
~~
.~::E
~
g.~
; =
S
"'0 §
e~"E
f.~
6~
g5~e~
~
.E
~~
.~
~
~
§ ~
~~
JI ~
e.s E
~
~-§~
~
1I:~
1:~
O
-'0
"' ~
E
-.~
0
=
0 ~
~
~
~
1:
1: =
~
"'
,Q
"' ~
~
~
0
u a
~ -g
., -p.
~
1: ~
~
"' ~
9 ~
~
~
§
:!J ~
8 ~
--;
~
.s ..g ~
~
E
] ]
~
~
~E;
~
~
5 ~
"E "0 :g -:S
2 N
.s=: ~
~
~o~
] 2
~
~ .:..c
et: 9
~
"E -.?;-
-1:
~
~
"' ,d
.-~
p.- ~
>
O
..-0\
E
bD ~
.0
,d ..-~
...~
~
.0
,d 1: ,d
'0~
~
~
ao ~
~
~
8
.s °
8 ~
~
:s
~
~
8 5
~
~
8 ~
.~
-E
IS
~
~
1d ~
..9. ~
~
~
~
8
~
; ~
~
~
8 ::
~
V
~
~
~
~
~
:'!! ;
~
~
e:~
~
~
:E
; g.]o
:.!6 .c .§ ~
~
"'§ ~ ~
.c ~
~ :2'.~
.f ~
E ~
~
5.=
~
B~~
.~ ~
~.§:E
;:g:-E
.~ § ~
s. II ~
E-a <
~
t.~
"'-"' bD
... =
o.~
-- ..uao~
... ~
"' >
~
"' "'
O..bD
-.."
~tID
'C
8 .c
:s ~
.s
-5 .s
s ~
::=
8.
~
.£ -:5
.9 .8
~
; ..s
::=
,Q
; -:5
.g. .~
-:5
.s ..a
a. 9
..'0 ~
::;:.
~
<
~
.&:
.~
.s
,
04
""'~~
~
~
I...J~
~...
.d'OO
8~~
~
5(J§+
+~
.S
~"i
!a~~
- ~
. 8
..~~
~
-.~§
..~
:g :::;- .C
~~
~+
~
:..a.~...+
+
~
~
~.
.~
~
~
.!}., ~
.~>
>~
--I;;
...
-.~-~
e~~
~
~~
:.(J]
CIJ+
...:..t: 101
(J~.
~...O
~(J]
~
~
~
~101
t::~
~+
~I:1.t:
=
0 "
~
~
.d ~
~
~
~-
O~
.~
'O
8
o ...~
~
~
. '0
~
-"'~~
.:::;-~
~-0
~
-~>
- 'C
d .~
...d>-
=
.!J >
~
+~
.~
,Q
'"' ~
"'
,.. (J
.d bD
101 .!3
~
~
"'. ~
§
~
I:~
~
c
...~
...~
~
.>
- ~
>
-<
~
!:!-:S,Q
~~
~"a.
~
~
...S
.0 ,Q
~
~
!:!-~
~
~0§.'.;~
3=...'-"'
..."' ~
. (J
~
S..I
"O~
~~
O~
: ...
101 ...~
1:1.~...
~=
-0 =
>0 ...
O
O(J~
~
~~
bD~
~
.S
=
~
'6"D
a: .-.§
101 ~
S>
O~
':0'O!':
~
~
bD..g
s. ~
:a
~p
~
~
.S
(J ~
~
>
-..I
~:'J~
U
)~,Q
...~=
~~
~~
.d'O<
~
~bo8o
~I-.
"-!:!(J~~
",§
0 ~
~
~
>
>.~
..:::;-:=~
~.bD
.£~
>
-~~
~
O-=
~
§~o
'{! 5
~
~
~
...,Q
.~
~g.1111~
::a§~'-~
~
~'0~
bD'"""...~
.<
U_O
-.'"' ...
-~~
~~
1:~,,
-0
~
"' "'
"'II
bD~
~~
~
a5
'O"N
<.!!
'S.:.'O
rl~
~
:.g
~
[ U
.C~
\0.:.~
..E~
Oo
C1)A
o C
1)o~bD
'O~
'OE
~
u~2
C1) ...E
o
bD.S
~
!3
>-
U
I-' 2
~
~.S
.~
~
~
E
o "'
~
"' u
0..I
UC
1)c ,d-~
-C
1)UM
u,D
,v0
I:: ~
bD
,d .::
:p bD
C
1)=
o~
~.U
-~
C1)~
U
U
~
;E
~
Ao
~
,d
>-
C1)"~
~
E~
"'
,d.~C
1) C
1)0.."
C1)..C
1) ~
Uo.S
-->
U
U
~
C1).
..I 0
.-=
.S
fa ~
>
~
<
C1) ~
"
"' 1/1
~faU
~.~
"'
~
~
.~
~~
C
1) "
"' U
Z
~
0 .~
,d
0101
~
~
~
C1)
~C1) .~
Ao"0
~
>
C1) ~
~
C1)
~
>.
-C1),;::0.~
~
~
U
N
~
>-","'
.U,d~
1oI 8'C
d° "'
C1)
~~
~
ca
>
Ao
~
~
.Q3 =
><
~
~
~
~
~
C
1) ., ?:'
'""'C
1)C1)C
1) ..,,--
,..,101
~
>.
M,D
~
I.-'
110 ~
~
~.s ,D
~
~
§
C1)
0 ~
.'0
~§U
,d ~
,d C
1).2 ~
0 ..I
0)-~
u~
"'
<
'0 "3
8 .s
.=
~
'0 ~
z C
1)~§
~~
O~
O
~
. C
"t'~~
;J ~
~
~
...C
1) '0.
O
C1).~
~C
1) "1::~
~...',D
U~
,D
:20...-""=
..U
...C1)
>-
v~"'>
. C
~=
-..I
"3 ~
C
1) -~
0 ~
~
,g~-:s§
~fa§!-0
101 "'
C1) ...~
~fa
" ...,
~
C1)-
.=
~
.~
., C
1)
~
-.~
" -
<
". ~
~
"
;J ...:..E
C1).2?
u~
C1)1o.
" ,
...01
~-,D
1o. ~
4iu
::C1)
u
0~
~~
,dC1)
Ao ~
I::
.; C
1) E
.~
.~
~]
.~
8U
oU,d
"..,.
C1)lS
ulS
l:;.2?u""'
~
" "'
=
."' E
,D
,d
...0", "'
~
UI
~~!)IIj~OU~~~~j&~...IIj...1--~
~
~
A~
IIj
<
~I-.
~IIjU~~.U
I~'dU
IIIjp.>
0E
-tIt.Ot>~IIj~0~~
~0
0~0
t t
;~
..
v.. ..u
c~to
0- ~
0 v
V.D
C
v C
c:J
-
..~
-;;;>-..!!
-:; -:;
-:;_C~
..;D'..~
..C~
ll.;::-
~11~
I1~B
oEU
50II ..s Il ..s II ~
"i £ ..s
I:
I
.I! I
0...6
]~
~]~
i!!Q
J .Q
J ~
~Q
J S
~~
QJ
o§ Q
JO
-.s"'
U
~"'rJ
§~§~
--o~",
..~
.~
.~
~Q
JQJ
~iU
QJ
.D-.S
(dp.~
8 -0'
S
QJuS
QJ
~
&
.~
~
8 ~
u "'~
.. "'
;.<
QJ
"'
...QJ
U..'!J.£O
~
Uu
eQ
J"'. ~
QJ'O
.&:
QJ
"' .~
Q
J Q
J
"3 g]-.s
"'~
~"'~
.~
U
....Q
J ~
~
tdQ
J ~
-~
.~
-
'S
-.s e
~
.~
£
~
~~
~ ~
~
:e -:~
] .;
~
QJ ~
.00 .U
U
.~
U
~U
:§.S
-QJ
~~
>
.t::"0
QJO
"'°.D8
-.s '+; .S
>
. 8 --{;
:.E5~
~0~
_p.>Q
JO>
.QJ
>
~
~
U
~..Q
OO
',"",~I:!
'0 j,
>.
41 =
QJ ...
§1:!=~
Og.bD
~~
'O
QJ~
..~
.~
QJ
QJ
...Ui
: ~
.~
.&
: U
-td
~
I:! ~
QJQ
J0
"' ~
.&
: ..
.1iI ~
Q
J ~
0
~
U
"' ~
.d
O~
:.S
QJ
&:
.~
.8.d"' :
e ~
-~
I!J ~
P..~
~
=
"3 .8 U
~
-
'0 ~
Q
J ~
, -Q
J O
Q
J
~-~
>.U
QJ
~
~
I:! "'
td .~
~
~
~-~
o
OQ
J=
QJ'O
=
~;8
t=::3.8
__0 ~ ° ~
°!i
O_~
-
o o
o 0
s~)unsul
~lqI1.dw
o)ul JO
J~qw
nu u.~W
'.\ tn1--;l;III~~;l;p0;l;;l;<~~IIIUUpV
)1--IIj
<~
tn
~
~
'""'~1--U~p:OU~~~;l;III
.p01
!
\\\.,,
-~0
~-,.,.";,,I,.:~',.
ao
.'5 .;
=
~
~.a
..0"~
..~
..p
~
Q)
1/1~
~
.~
U!
§ ~
~.£
~
Q)~
8..~
..Q)
..~
~~
1/1'0..
.~
"E
; 1/1
..~
.. ~
'0
..,Q
.-~
~:c
p '"'
1/1..p
1/1 e
Q)
Q)
"' ~
p~..
~
,,~..Q
)e
~
-,Q"'
0 ~
~';>
.t:
u .~
~
~
...s ~
~
~
e
~
U!
~'0~
.
~
~..
~
u..2 'O
:E..~
5 ;p
Q)P
Q)..
o0..
..U!...
~~
0.
...S
e ~
E
tIp
.E
~
.~>
. Q
)Q
) ~~
0
..Q)
.J: .-Q
)....u
..~
Q)
c q,...
,Q
~
='
...c ...,Q
~
S $
:E
O~
.i:
-p =
,1/1Q)..
..-;; ~
P
'O-~
.w
,Q.0
~
..0~..
\ w
"' Q
).~
J:
.0"' ~
tlD
Q)-
."0
~~
0.~
..c
0) .-Q
) ..
.w
~
...:;: ~
-ee>.
0 0
:? 0
b,Q.:=
1/1=
U
! -~
~
~..=
tIDu
>
u,",Q)=
,~
...,.-
" Q
) 0
"' ~
""t:I/1~
U
.EoO
)';:
~
;..,U,Q
=..
-~-.,
u "
.-:=
;.=
..1/1:'.Q
).-=
' c-=
...
? ~
;:..'O,
<G
.,..=~
-p
.-
<58~
..1
~
u U
I ~
U
.:
0.~
.~
41
.~
0 .
..UI
,
41:a
>41~
'O.§
41.§
p...U
....41
.~
.~
5 .5
'0 .~
."E
~
~
e...?:~.~
8~41.
U.
~
..
~
41- .~
.!!!
."E
bDp
"3 "tj
~
.C;
.~
.e0~
.'8... U
I~
-~.
~U
I~~
~
41.41-
~(d
~
~.,-
E~
u'O
~..
...e~
41..~P
~:.
obD~
OJ..4).
~4141'0~
: .,.
UI
0..~
~
.~
..~-41
410~
E~
~.&
:.,Q..
~
41 41 ~
.~
E
~
.&:.'4;~
.f=P
...~
...&
:. ;s
~
6-"0
..>.:
"tj u
°U1~
=0
41
~41.&
:.~~
~o;S
~
G
...6'D
..41 ~
U
..0-.&:.C
;
41>.~
_0 ~
~41
-~
O(de...!!jo4)
c:! O
ca U
I
.?;o..~~
t:'lJ.!?~
UI~
41-Po~
P4I..~
~41
0 ...c:!
.~
41U
I .,
~~
...=
U
I.~
~
P
41
~
.! JJ
.S
.e o;S
.&:.
'OP
UI.
-~
~
~
~
;
410 .,>
..~
:..U4l..-41
.."" 41 .&
:. U
..U
I
.&:.41U
1..e~..
41 :.
=-=
P...41
.&:.
41 ..
§0
p.&:...
UI
(/). U
,Q
~=
-=U
)"0..'0-~
U
.:g -
5 ~
:. .,
5:.'0
E~
~,Q
~
~41
~
0 "-:
0-.,
-.~
.:;' U
I .~
.
~
41 (/)
(/) ...
~
...(/) (/)
..(/) ...
~-41P
4I4IO"'
0 ,Q
"'
.~
0 0
CID
.~E
CID
(/)
541eEpe'fJ
~-E
~O
I::~~
t-.. >
- ...=
." .0
~~
'0 e~
Q)
~
Q)Q
)...0
bO~
e
..Q
, =
,.!3~
=
.~
'0 '0..
=
=Q
)~
0.0
., U
eQ
) Q
) .
.~
., =
' ~
In :J
Q)=
..~
.,
~'0~
In bO
Q
)~
=
...~
.d
~
=
.;g ...
...'0 Q
)too
=
.'Q)=
08 .8.;g~
"' U
I U
.;g
...~
>-=
Q)
:I: =
:=
Q)bO
~
..., ~
~
.S
~
,g ~too
.~
U
.,<
Q
) .0
>-.~
Z
~
:;:='0
; ~
.8~
8~
e
=:S
5!
~
~
~:;~
0.0 :J\1...
too e
.o,Q:3
='
e =
~
=
=,~
d~
Q
) =
=
'
~
~
~]~
<
Q)
Q)t;Q
)~
-:S
.~
..e~
...~~
~~
...Q).'
~~
~-:S
.s.,...
=.~
=
.,
~
~
Q) .;;..~
.;g G
'3~'3:J'g
..., Q
)..Q)~
8
~~
~Q
)~
Q)
(-4-(-4 .,
='
.,
~
.8-S
~
~
~
d .g
-! "0
l1 R
->
, .8
~
~.
~~
-5 ~
~
'i
.8 ~
.~
~
f
~
~
~
:.; ~
~
-;
~
c. !:J
~
~
~
~
-0a;'
a! .-u
u .-~
,Q
as
~
,Q
-;a u
5 ~
:0
~
u ~
~
,Q
"(.
u r--
-as .
5~
~~
:0 §!~
.n-:e3~e...§~
8-:S
~
-=
":g-'bD
.~
~
.!:JbD~
~~
~'O
~
,Q~
.E
~
~:a
~
~
; ~
.8 u
t-.~
~
~
'iJS$'E
~
.2: ~
c=
-g
",:E
~
~
"O:a...~.~
-:,Qo
8 ~
bD
~~
ou
~
'Q
o ;>
~
"0
~
U
~
.='
U
"" ~
~
bD
~
~
U>
- .2:
U
"' .S
~
8
§ :a
8 ~
;
~
~
~
~
~
u u
~
~
§ ~
-:S
"3 .;
-~
§ ;
.;.; ~
0
.5 ~
~
q
"' ~
.2: ~
~
.5.-=
:g
5 c
~
~
bD:p
'0 ~
'iJ ,Q
~
§
~
"' :=
'"
" 0
~
U
~
~
.2: ~
~
~
.S
.~
.-8~
~
"
~
S
...~
~
~
~
~
"' 0+
; u
"' ~
~
f/I
t: ~
"0
u .'!J f-o
=
~
>,
Q.
..I ~
~
~
~
. ~
~
~
0\
"' :a
bD.5
~
u ;
8 ~
.-:S
~
.£
0 .=
0
.~
.-~
.~
s -~
~
e 9
~
~.g
~
g. .2: :a
8 t-.
§ ~
~
~
-:S
-:S t;
5 '§,
~
2.£ 0
: .~
ui
";, -:S
~
-:S
E
~
ui
; '2
-:;: -; ~
§
.~..0-::-
~
e >
, ~
bD
~
~
~
~
-~
v ~
_,N
. U
---
:.) ~
~
S
:a >
,- :
.2:.g \(')~
. .2:
O-'2.-~
] 8
0 O
f:'"O
8~
Q
.'E
"0 :E
tn.2:
~.~
~:=
.;.boE.-
~~
~
~
.~
:'.: ~
.2:
° f/I. :
"' :'d --0 ~
. "';;: ~
"'g
~
.E
:a ...Q
. -;
; ~
~
.2: ~
:B
".:3
~
...; .:
.2: -:S ~
.e
~
~
.-e 'Q. 'Q
~
.'!J 0 f/I -0
~ ...~
-:- ~
.~
~
=
~
~
,Q ;<
.U ~
0 ;;::- .~
e ~
-S ~
...e
~
-"0~6
~0
...00
~o
e!"
~~
U~
~f/lU
f/l~U
~~
O~
~~
...~
f/I"'v
c=U
.",:»_;<
...0..I
~
~
~
~
>,~
...'Q
~
~
0
...=
'i ~
~
]~
~ ~
.~ ~
.~
~
~
~
~
...~
U
>, ~
~
0
U 0
~<
:0
'iJ ° ~
...~
~
~
"'
U -0
-~
Q. ~
U
...~
-:S
...':=
~
U
QS
' "0 O
0
bD~
(/)
>,.-
5 ~
"'
~
~
e ...:p
ui 'iJ e
...~
"' .=
"t
-§ ~
~
-:S
~
° of.
...~
:S
>
.~
"' ~
~
.-= ~
'Q
':=
~
c= ~
u
~
e .§
.2: .i 5
~
~
~ 'Q
] ~
~
o:S ]
~
.s .~
s"'g
~
§. .~
~
~ ~
~
~
~
] .~
~
.s
] B
.§'5 ~
! ~
~
.~
§ ~
~
~
.§] ~
~~
;:;~~
~:
~~
.o:S.~
~.~
~.]~
~]
~~
s:~
~"E
~
~
~
~~
~~
~~
8[.§~;§
~
~
...~
§ .~
~
.~
"'
-:S
aJ .-U
0 ~
.~
O
°
0 ...f
"'. .;
-c=
-; -:S
.::;'
...~
~
~
.8 -~
'Q
~
.-
" ...~
...0
,Q
C-
e >
, >
, ~
~
~
0
,Q
-~
U
c= >
.r,~
'Q
-0
~
~
~
-.->,
~
U
0 .~
<
-:S ]
8 .s
~
...; .2: ]
~
,Q
; ~
~
:E
§
~
~
-:S
~
.~
.q ~
~
"'
~
8 ~
~
-:S
~
:c
~
.2: .2: .£ "3
5 ~
:iJ. ..g
~
~~
t;
8 i
'i ;
~
ui g. : .~
~
'i ~
s
5 8 .~
.~
; 8
e E ~
. -:S
~
~
~
~
.5 .2:
'Q ~
y
4J ~
~ .~
~
" ~
~
"'~8u~
..~=
~
u",~~
~§~
Q
.~-=
f:'C=
~
~
u.8 .~
o"O
tn~~
0...e.~~
..;)
~
~
u.'6! 5
>,;-:S
-:S
~...~
~.;
~~
: S
~
.1n ° e
...~~
3j -:S
~
-:S e
.8~.~
'iJ ~
:§ e
~.-.2:
~.8
r;-~...
~
-:S ~
.~
~8.>
] t;
~
~
~ -~
t=
~ ~
.2: ..]
~ ...8
.~ -:S
..:= ~
e ~
~
s
t 8 t
:'d ~ ...~
~
o~
8 "'
5 :a
~<
~
~
~
~
.-~
~
...u ~
~
~
bD
-~
c=
8
0- .~
U
.D
~ .D
U
U
:a
-.q U
>
,.- ~
~
~
'Q
.~
.'!J Q.:a
.-~
"' ~
.2: ,Q
.~
~
-:S J}. .2: "3 :;;-
~ .S
t:
E'~
a! :a ~
~
.q
~
.;n §
0 §
u ~
5 .2: .=
.8
~
e ~
~
s §
~
O~
-U
...~...~
~
~\(')
-0~~
~::::.U
:=
~-~
...U
"' 'Q
CU
~
.r, "'~
~
.-0-~E
u;)
~
~
~
~
.~
E
u E
,Q
°
0 ~
t-.
E
"' ~
'Q
~
-=
-=
=
1;
~
~
,Q
c=
..c=
.2: ,Q
>
, ~
'Q
...~
~
'Q
.-"'
? ~
~.
C':g-:S
.§~
~~
o:S'5'"'-
\(')-5 E
~
~
~:E
0_]:.
~
].8~~
~
.q 5
~
E::;-§
-:;:'";jf~~
-:S
~~
i~.i;;;.2:".:S
u u
bD
"' ~
.s
~
;>
-~
~
'Q
.£ 0
0 ~
~
"t
c=
~
0 '=
Q
. U
to=
CO
U
.-U
~
~
.q .Q
~
U
~
r--
~"
>"
~~
O~
~
O
U0+
;S...
OO
~.>
U_o
~o
~~
...;a ~
~
.~.>
~
...~
~~
(i\-Q
~.~
.-
.".-~
._~
-~O
.- ,.
U
~...
u~..
"' :=
-"' -~
~
..." ~
-.- .A
~
""U
'Q~
...'~
~O
~
~...0~
"'~U
~
~
.r,~
~
...¥'~
o~~
~U
.-
~
~
~
'iJ ~
~
~
@ ~
"'t" ~
...~
\(') 5 U
.-Q.
~
~
~
~
"' ~
u
:=
~
~
Q. ~
..~
...:= -:S
"' U
~
u.t:
~
e .5.?;0.5:
1; 5 ~
.:s ~
.E
bD~
0
e~f-o
~:>
§'2
~.~
] ~
'i:a .~
~
~::~
G
~
~
~
::~~
.?;o.5e~
~.?;0:
~8.'!J~
:2~
~
;~
ui .5 "'
~
-:S .5
~
~
.~
~
bD a, .bo
~
.~
...~
8 ~
e
.?;0 ...: bD
..:= ~
r-.-:s
.~
bO
;<
~
:- ~
-S
~
.~
~
e ~
~
~
~
=
.;
t=
t;~
U
~
~
~o~
~
"'~
...U
~
~20~
:=
..",.~~
U
", r-.
._~-",-0:-~
U
°>,
;) 0
5 t;
5 'Q
...~
u
8 ~
.-1'00
~
~
t; -E
..~
~
U
~
.~
..."E
.~
"E
0 .;
'Q
S .~
0
.-0 ~
~
f-o
~
U
i:
;l "
--0 t: E
gE
e 2
~
f/I .q o
~
.8 -:S
~
~
U
~
:=
~o
.2: ~
Q.~
~
.!!
:.;.".:3 .!! ".:3 .=
§ § .5
.!! ~
cu .!!
8 >
, ~o
~
-:;; 'd
-:S
~
.; ~
~
U~
U
~U
~
,~~
=
... =
' --"'=
' ~
.U
..:: Q
. UI:
U
U
e -bO
t:
e U
,Q
~
-.1n
~
e ~
S
~
0
...~
...~
"' 0
"' ~
C
O
~
,Q
.-=
~
~
~
.q U
'0
-E
~
8
~
;<
~
~
~
-~
'2 Q
. ~
~
8
'Q
"' "'
..s ~
~
-:S
,Q
8
0 -~
9
-S
~
-S
~
§ ~
~
~
N
...~
"'
'Q
Q.
::; &
: U
.~
"
...~
.-=.~
.-8~~
~"'t:~
~
u~ij~
.5>,"'t"'Q
...~.t:
.e]..:=
.r: ~
~.~
L.r: ",.r:
..."..:""",Q::;.t:...,",0...
~(j)
g.-geo0~
~O
O
~
CQ
-bD~
~~
~"L-!-0~
~!-0~
.-"':>.-!-0t-.0!-0
CD
U~
~
:=~
~~
=o
~)
;S
U..
~
UU
U;>
~
0 -~
~.-
>
.~U
..-'Q
"'.~0~
"'-:=...
-
') ~
~
UU
UO
$~
U~
_NO
...~0~
.O
.-.:: ::
~"'Q
.-~U
~~
CU
...",.c.
=
~
~
,Q
U
.~
"' ~
...U
Q
.,Q
M
~
U
tD
tD
..Q.
...CO
.~
'Q
~
U
'Q
Q..-
0005
~
CD
=C
D
""00"' ,
"'.'CD
""
+'
" >
.~C
D
..U
,=
"-,=
~=
~!tl
ef'lJ=
~
~
=
k..=
0.:=
~
~
'0 eO
+,
=
= ]
.~ :a
..~
~
.; 0 -a..;;
+'
,Q
~
~ ,~
~=
~ ~
~ 8
: e ~
~
~
..~
~
.s e =,
i ~
e 9
.=
~
~
+'
..=
CD
~
?
£ .."'
..8 ~
0
..=
"-'"' ~
0.:'"'m
>=
~m
~
~
"..
0.:..0 E
]o.: '0
..u"" .c+
' ..;:;
"' 0.:
+'
..:+.I
~
t ~ ::;'
+' 0 ~
£'"''0 ]
.g -E.
~
0 ~
p .§ ~
.;
~
9 £ ::. ~
~
8m
,Q
"' 0
S
~
-." f.
+' .-"
] k
MZ~
9 .8 :
~ ~
~ -E
,g ~
~
.U;
.a .s
g: t -5 ~
.8 e
2 ~
t ~
:g ~
..; :
="
~
",0 ~
"" ~
..°0.:cd-~
=
,. ",0~
..O.:
..bO
" , "
"' .~
..' cd
8 "'+
' ..0
..=
~
" , ~ -"-
-,Q
= +
' "
, ~
a=
~
§ ~
o.: ~
"'
..~
: ~
8
~
..0 ~
~
a+
' ~
?
..0 "~
~
'"' 0 0
~'4i
~
~ ;g
:a :'J :a ~
=
9
;: ~
, 0\ =
'0
0.: ., ]
'0 ~
'X ~
=
~
£
§ ~
8 ~
~S.::
~U
M
M
"
+'
..-=
=
=
..~
U~
+'
'0 =
~
...+
' 'U
; W
0.:.-"
'"'..=
.-=0"'..
,=
t cd
_cd "=
cd"'
-==
..:+
.I]
..>
~
5 ]
..0.: 0
a.~
=
'"'
' , "'
'0 ..0
..0 =
S
! "
\0 0.:
..=
..=
~
'0 "'
f.J (d ,c
:+.I
" ...+
' =
..f
~
'"' '"'
..+'
..-~
M
+'
'"' =
>
~
'0
.-U
I 0
." U
I "'
:; --"~
\0
§ .;J
~
~
0 0
] ..;
~
+'
£ ~
...4i
0 ~
-..~
..cd
£~
8
'"'~
.S",""+
' ~
u=
,""Q
~
=
'0 £..~
~
..~
="""'
§~...0",'+
'O
-~
"""
~
"' ."'0.-
'"' ."
0 ""
a "-
'0 0
~
"' =
~
0
0 =
~
"-
cd "'
~
'"' "'
(.j ,Q
:.
0 ' "
..~
U
..=]
cd ..~
+
' '"' "-
+'
" ..
9 §
_;,,"0aCD
'O
..~"'
'0 =
vi
.~
~.~
\Of.so
.; ~
"'O.:
~
c~0
~
0 " ,
=
=
=
~
~
'"' \0
'"' +
' +
' ~
"
+'
'0 "r'
0 +
' =
~
'0
~
S
+'
CI:
~
!t ,"'
=
:a cd
' ..0
.."' ~
~
]
a.; 0
-..0,Q
.s ..=
~
-5
+'
=
."5.;; =
..
~
~=
=
.."'=0
"- ~
~
~.i!!',~
a
=,,~
o§",e..=
o4i.~
.9...'lJ
8 =
'0=~
: =
0
..8 U
"
+'
.u ...'
, .C
D
= ,Q
=
~
..=
e '0
~
-..+'
"' 0
0 ...
~
"' ~
.--t
~
~
.~ ~
~
~
5
.."' f
~
§ a
~
=
S
t ~
'~
"§ ~
.;J ~
E
cd
...s m
ot '00'"'
..5 !t
"'
...+'
"' .'l=
,"' :.
"' ..
u"'"'~
8-f"k
"' ..=
,Q
m+
'o ..'-~
+
' 0.:
0.:' loo "-
;S
(d'-~.""'
;S
.~o
"' ",Q
~'O
~
;S
>
=a
a..~>
0.:cde:n~
~
0.:"'." +
'~+
'~
..Jo. ~
'1:! ..C
D 0\ ~
~
'1:! ~ ~
..-=
;S
,Q e
=
..'1:! ..U
U
r;
U "'
--~
+' ..~
0
'"' =
~ ~
"'
0 cd
~
t =
=
~
~
=
£ ~
=
~
e
= .-~
t
~
~
~
a :P
£ cd =
~
~
e ~
~
..~
9
~ ~
0 ~
~
~"'
~
~
.= 'U
; :: ...5
~
~
cd ~ +
' = "=
~
~
:
t ..~
~
...:a
~
~ .~
~
t ]
+' -~
~
.E
:n ..;
+'0
f +
' ..0
~
~
..~
-'S
~"~
,, ..M
M~
>
'0 ..\0..=
~
'"'W!t
~ow
-"0
""'0.:..~
~
-1
'g t bO
f 0\
1 'g ~
~ ,Q
~ ,Q
l
= ~
e ~
-1 ..'4! cd
::.'3 ] ~ ..~
cd '"' 8
~
.s ~ ..~
,5 -e ";; +
' -S~
"'
t ;S
cd "e .e ] -;
~
8 0.: ..~
'"' ~
~
~ ~
"' ..~
;s ~
~-S
;
e ~ ]
~ !
-E ,5
§ '"' ~
g:
.a 0' = ~
~ "~
~
"~
~
~
~ f]
g.8 ~
~
.s ] e S
e ~
~
~ ::.'3 ::
"5 ~
84i .s '~
] a ~
' ~ ~
~
~ t
~ ~
'0 f!- ~
~
~ ~
! :
cd ~
..,
..] ~
=
S
..,
..~
'0 '"'
~
"' ~
"' .~
~
"'
.., ~
'0 C
D
+'
..>
.."' ]
"- ,Q
..,
..=
] ~
C
D ~ -"
"'~
9
~
~
8 cd ~
=
1
£ .a ]
] ""
~
..."~
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
.~
"~ :g
~ ]
": a
~
9 ~
a "~
e
.a .=
~
~
,Q ~
0 ~
~
cd =
~
.~
=
..0 e
~
~
.."' ~
~
.-~
U
'0 '"' .~
--]
= ]
..0.: ~
'0
£ =
..0
~
~
.;, ~
=
] 'g
~
...~
~
.s ~
::. ~
...~
g-:;:
~
'g i
~
~
~
-!t; ]
e .8 :a e
=
a ~
0\
~
~
a; ~
-8
~..;,
'"' =
"'
":. =
..M
...,.,
=
=
~
8 ..
e..=
cd
=
0 ..u-
0 "'
0.: ..; ~
...~
~
~
~
~
'1:! ~
~
> ~
E
..0
e .'"'.. --E
~
'i
'1:! ~ +
' $ =
-E --E
=
CD
= .a ...0
~-a.
"' 0 ..£ ~
...
UU
~
~M
..O
~cd,",-,
'1:! ="
m
;S ..'0.-
=
~
~
+'
..+'-
8'"'=
CD
_..
~ 3
8 ~
~ ~
~ ;,:, 8
~
CD
]
: ~
§ ~
~ ]
§ : 5
~
~
~ ~
"'~
~ ~
~ ]
S:a ~
~
~
.0 cd "U; ]S
.g ~ ~
:a ::.~
~
' =
9 ~ ..:'J
~'
t +
' g] (d -E
"'
= u 9 ,c8
; ~
~
' 0
~-E
:g -S
8
+'
~ ~
£
; ..'
f. ~
~
=
-~
~ -E
~
:."'=
-"'=
..~
UI
"""""M
,,, ,0--=
"'
"'~..."'
"_",cd",..", "'
~_~
_"~,",cd",
'0'0"-
.~
~
..\0, ~
O
.:~~
..'""- ~
U
...==
"-
-~
"'._"'.-0.:._~,...
~
W~
..",MC
D.."-+
'",",'"'
'1:! ~
\O
-~
~
+,cdO
O
"' "
=
..~
~
=..
"".. ..=
.. :'0..'"""'~
o0.: E
~]
i ~
';:'~
~]
~
O']'0~
~]
~
~~
§~..;]
~
~
~~
] .~
]~]:]~
] ~
~
"~6~
~~
~]~
.,::..=
~
'"'..
~'"'
oii.. oO
U~
,",.. ..0
'"' ..0..~
..0\.. .+
' +
,cdO\..O
~
o.:.~
~
...~.,]o.:
.\0..]...""~
..:, ".]0.:
~
~
~]\0~
...~..~
...~
.~.~
ga"""",0.:...:+J
I--~
'-: ...~
.~E
I-- ~
~
~E
:..'\OI--
"~i~
..;.EI--
.~~
I--E..I--~
! I
!-. '?
"' <
';;...I--\0'lJ~
-0
;... 0
~"'
0 "N
"
0 °
mr:"'
->~
-.:
Z
.5.. ~
Z
..r:
Z
,c r:
IQ
Z
:g =
;t';
-:S
-~
-.e .~
.-
r~~
,;,.
~
0006
! !81:~
~
.t'
~a
ti.a
.S.g=
..~
]
~~
>
<=
] ;,; ~
~
.s
.t: ~
8 ~
~
".88
..., ..>
- ~
;
8>
0 ~
...88
~
,Q
CD
~
.88
~
~~
u ."
.~
'0 =
..o
0.. 0=
..;a
'0 =
~
~~
-$
~=
.8 ~
=
=
=
rn U
-dO
, ~
'0...
~
~0
,Q'O
~
U
=
..M
=
+'
S..'3
~
~
~
o~
~8
U
'0 ..
0.,
.t: U
"" +
' ..
, .,
...rn ,
8.~
"'
...'0 :E
U
rn
rn ~
.,cn
'0 .~
.,.,
..., =
~
,Q~
~
.~
~
...'E
\0
~
-$ =
..."
...rn
>
-0
.~
'0 "'
...=~
...~
."
'0 ."
rn ~
<
..'0 rn
.,., C
D
..=
=
.~
.a =
~
~
=
...'0 C
I "'
., ..~
.. 0+
,~
C
D
0 ..."
." .,
Urn+
, ,Q
~
:z; .a
=
~
~
] .5
~
] ..:+
J ~
~
~
0 rn~
'O
., rn
u-$=
.,~~
t
;g =
~
~
..~
.?;-..,.g
~~
~
+'
8'0 C
D
.~
8 .t:
~
= '0
~
.a ..=
~
.8 .S
.8
..G
~
~
t ..:E
~
"a =
0]
41 =
.8
.~ ~
~
'O
~
+'
~
~
~,Q
~.,
"" ..+
' f;u~
~~
..~
-~
""..u ...+
' rn
~>
- ,Q
+'
~
.~
rn rn
,. =
-rn
CD
'O
,..=
..;S
+
' .,
=
""8
41 .c .~
=
.,
'0~
.,
~
..~
'0 8
0 ""
id '0 .~
8
=0.'
~
..CD
.. Y
rn
=J:.1=
'O
~t
~
..8 °
~
"" ..~
.~
8 ~ ~
"
~
.8 ~
-;;;- ~
~
t ~
.8
;g ~
;g '!; ~
~ .8 'E
!
~
8 ~
~
~
0" ~ ] §
§ a
6.8 -:S .8 § ]
~
~
~=
~
~~
8 =
=
.,
==
"'rn=...
O
..~.~
..41 III
., ..=
~
~
=~
.6
"i ""cu
~
8 =
+
,U+
'.8~~
>0
;a :$
...~
§ .S
'+1
~
'+1
~
] 9
§ -$ -$
~
., ..~
>=
41 ..>
]
.,cu8=..~
~
~
~0""
~
~...:+
J.!!J.,Q+
,~.,~
~~
.~
~
+'+
'o ~
~+
'cu+'~
.."'
1-0 ~
::;'=
~
.S>
~
~
~~
~~
.ae..~-;;;
~
~
..~
~
~ -a. .,
-$ =
~
-$ ..~
.,
"' -$ -$ .~<
~
>
6~
+'+
',Qrn>
- '0
~
.~ 'E
...~
~
" ~
"'
~
.~
.~ .~
.8 .~
+'
..=
.~
~
01 ..:a..C
D
~
..>-
..;,;~..~
..§-:S~
..8'3:+
J .t
~
.."'.?;- -;
..~'3~
'3,Q
>-..'3..
~
., e
.t: ~
..., rn
~
rn ~
+
' ,Q
...,
..rn
.'-:S..:E
' °
~
, ...,]
,Q
0\;3 -0
rn .,Q
~..""Q
""Q.']...',Q
...
~~
~~
~
-;~~
~~
..'3~'3~
~0..~
+'
~
>
O
~U
'O
CD
CD
..U
~M
.~
Z...~
""
...bD
° °
bD
"' ""
~.."', :0
~~.-r,;:~
;..;
..-§
.,. ,
.."C
~
..~-
~
0 -0
..."C
...~-
~-
.",,!.~
...~
~
:a
"3 .,
.c o;S
: ~
.Q
"dl -'0\
-., 5
as''' 8
° .~
~
..
§ e
~
0 ~
~
.~
~
~
~
-5
.-.§ ~
]
~
~
! e
.,;."a .~
o
.SO
.E
] .
-., ~
o
0. °
0 ~
.-.~
"'
-"' ~
.,
., 0
-., ~
.:;:
-
~"E
;~]
~:::
~n~
';~"i.C
g].E].2!;
~S
:-E~
.~:S
.~§~
= ., "'
~ .,
-.c ,
, -.,
~ :';::
.-"' °§
~
~
8 :S :S
.§ ,:i. ~
S .s U
) ~ ~
~ ., -5
:c 9 :9 ~ .:
~ ~
...'a
tID Q
) .s -0
~
~ ., ~
., ~ ~
,d ., .~- :a
~ 5 ::J ~
0 ,
.~
-~
~
c ,
...0 --~
~
~
=-°
2 .c
., ~
~
~
~
.~
"0
2 s
:p "0
.c o
$ ..,
"':' 0.
~
S
~
~~
- .,
~"';>
~
..~~
3~
.'.'...>.
H~
=
~"'...
~
~
~5
o ~
=
8
~
~
~
8 ~
>
~
~
~
~
~
0 U
) ~
~ £
.;.,
>.:a.,
.,U)
~o-
~~
.,- .,
O~
-bO-
~.~
5
~
-a >
. t;
g. 5 ~
"E
.?;0 .., ~
.,
; :;
~
:S .~
S
;
;' .~
]
~ ~
~
U)- U
-0 .,
~
U) .,
~ ~
t: .c
---~
tID 0
~:
..3 .S .8
~
:S
~
] ~
E
.~
0 ~
8
~
~
!tJ :
'0 ::
.5 ~
:a
~ .2? 2
E~
:-= ~
~
fj
Q) :S
-.~
~
., ~
.-.,
-; .s
~ ~
9
~
~
~
~
:9 -U
) .f:.., :9
~
0 § ...;
S t=
:: ., ~
~
~
~ ~
!tJ :c
.2!; ..2? .5
~
~ -g
::J ~
~"3::J
U)
o~.=
.,
>..,'3>
.°'3~=
0. .2?~
5.,=~
0.,>.
~
0 ~
0.
~
0 "'
-., 0
0 .,
U) o
2~
o
o..~
~=
.~
~
.,
..., "0
...~
-.c _0."00
~...
2~_.Q
uc-",=U
)~
_.'=6'D
~U
)=~
U
., '""
(U
~
~
, (d
~
--0 -U
U
) .,
.~
U)
.,Z
.,
., ...U
tID
0...ui
.~ ~
~
...;:: 0 U
) ~ >
. U
~ ~
0 ~
-.c
° t::
~
., ~
...~
-.,
.~ .,
-"' .,
., ,
~ ~
.~ .,
~
0 9
o~
~
~
5 §
fj ~
(U
.~
:S
~
.c .~
-~
t::
0 U
) ~
U
). ~
.:cU
) U
"'
;>
;>
=
.-~
~
..Q
CU
...~
"'
-0 U
.-~
., .,
=
tID::>
.,
S
~
~
=
.-= ~
~
~
~
0
~
...~
-U
., ,d
...U)
>
~
:S
.8u
J5. ...:a .,
U)
., -0
U) -.,
~
...~
-; -~
.5
~
...c .,
:p ~
"'
~
...~
0 ~
~
.2?
~
~
-; ~
~
-.~
~
.~
"'0 :S
.,
...~
(U :S
~
'0
.,A
.,
.5 -~
.Q
) 0.
0 C
0
~
~
~
(U
~
-~
~
:a ~
~
Q
) .~
>§
--E§
u ~
~-.'Q
)t:o. ..=
0
...~~
-(U
;... ~
C
=
~
.,
e .Q
5
.2 0. ;;::
-:; .~
.c
"0 ~
>
. ~
~
8
~
~
:StID
., ~
.,
U) ~
.~
."'
5 ::::
=
~
0. tID
U) -.Q
) ~
] u.S
c
~
~
-U
) 0
0 ~
..,
0 .Q
...~
.C
.?;0 0
::J 8
~
.C
U) .5
"E
U
C
"t ~
.~
~
~
~...~
t. H
U)...g>
.~~
~",
U):
~8..,
§&3...,.cg.c.,.,U
...Q
) -Q
) Q
) .~
~
.~
"' ~
tID
U)
., ~
.~
.,
.s S
o 5
"' U
) .,
~
us ~
:c:S
:2 .c
~
.2 Q
) ~
5 Q
) :a ~
~
'3
Q) §
-0;- J5. fj
C
Q) :S
.5
~
.~
§ 'E
.~
=
0 ~
~
:;:
~
U)
"0 ..,d
0 ...~
...~
§
U
., .,
C
~
.~
...U
) .c Q
) -]
.~
Q) -J5.
Q) .,
U
] J5.
=
.=
...: §
~
>
S
~
0O
\~
§ .S
~
-~
.c
~
...t; "3
>.
fj =
~
0
~
~
0 Q
) .~
~
S
.~N
Q
) ~
~
§ ~
~
Q
) ~
~
~
,d ...~
>
~
.,
~
~
~
~n.-
~
cLI ., cLI
"0 --0 .~
S
o "'
~
U 0
bO cLI ;
5 ~
~
-Qj'~
cLI > ~
~
-:S ~
~
.g Q
) : 0
~ :S
~
8
~ ]
>. ~
:a ;
S
~
!3 ~
~
~
~ J5. J5. ~
:;;...u
., ~
.,
U) ~
-~
J5. .5 ~
U
) ~
~
B ,d
~ !tJ ~
~
...tID -cLI
'O!tJ§~
~:S
~~
°J5.~-;~
...~~
~~
~
~-:S
'3° ~
~&
3~~
~
~
~
.:;: 0
fj U
) -~
>'.Q
>
, .,
~
.~
..~
U) ~
...~
5
.; 0
., e
~.~
:c.~
U
) ~
., .?;0 ~
§
;;.:.~
J5. ...:a .~
5
u ~
.-= cLI .-=
~
.E
...tID"3
-~
.t: .c
=
;; fj
8 :S
~
~
.~
'+
: ~
~
.2? .g
IJ .s :S
.,
~
0 .,
.5 ~
cg
...~
~.?;0 U
) >
~
-~
.~
~
~
.,
~
.s 8
.?;o.c ~
~
"'
...~
-=
~
,d ~
...0
§ ;-:
u~
.,
:p ~
0
~
"' ~
(U
.->
=
cLI -; 8
~
~
~
=
..., U
cLI §
O~
"'.,...,O~
~
~0
s"'~
V).-0.~
cLlQ)cLlu~
~~
cLI~ll...'
...tID
~
cLI
_n U
~
cLI
"'~
~
...~
Q) U
)cLI~
~
~
cLI .,~
.a-
"' ~
...cLI
0 ~
.Qt=
:: ~ ~
-o..S
.,
c .s
.~
0 ~
2
Q) 2
0. S
tID
u :2;,.~
-.5
--...
~.
'0 6
~
~
a ~
-3
~. E
~
~
.s
.~
~
.s ~
~
. :ao
~
~
~~
6
~
~
~
.~
~
.s :rj ]
~
0 ~
.s
~
] ~
~
~
a
~
~
.§ ~
~tU
0
,Q
0 ~
.~
~
'a.
=
-::: ~
~
,Q
U)
t: S
S
.~
..~
tU
tU
~
'0
-,Q
~
'0 "'
t: '0
.~
ao bD -::: ,Q
-t;
~2
!; ~
~
>
. §
';d tU
.§ 8
~
s ~
':§
=
,g 8
~
.~
~
~
.?;0 ~
~
.a o
.~
:: ]
a .:S
~
8 .S
.§
S'
b' .s
~
~
~
:: .:
~
~,g
tU ~'0
h ~
~
tU
~
"'
.i: ~
~
tU
~
"'i:J
~
=
uS
=0'0
0 ~
U
) 0
~
~
-0 ~
=
~
~
~
tU
.'1
~
~
~
!I! ,Q
.~
C
~
.~~
-- ~
~
.~
00 tU
U...
~
UU
) '0
~
~
~
~
'0 .!!J
.-~
~
tU
5 ~
~
.~
~
u- ~
=
~
~
~
~
a
~
>.
~
~
~
~
,Q
0 ~
.-,Q
tU
'0
tU
~
~
U)
>-~
=,Q
~tU
'OX
~~
ag,Q
..~
,Q...,Q
~
.. -.0-aotU
~
=U
)5~~
...tUtU
~
~
8 i] ~
."5 ~
-:s ~o=
: ;. ~
: ~
~ ~
~ J .~
-E
.a ~ 9
O~ .:S
~ ~
~
~ ~
15 ~ ~
..~
.s ~
s u ]
~ ~
. ~ ~
.~
~ ~
~a
~
~
,Q
>
-~
,Q
u tU
&
~
,.
ao ~
tU
~
~
"'
Cd tU
-U)
~
'0 ~
0
~
...~
0
~
'0 ~
]
~
~=
~
>
.~
.~
1! B
~
~
~
~
~
. ~
.~
. ~
'g
B
.=
~
g. ] ~
§
~
~
'g :i:
.s .?;0 ~
~
~
~
;
$ .
~
~
~
;, a.
§ 9
~
~
.~
~
:i: l.~
2
~
.§ .s
,g §
~
.: ;
~
] ~
6.8
&~
~
~
~
~
~
.S
O~
.B
~
~
1.~
~
~
~
~l~
~
~
.'1 ~
.§ ~
5
2 tU
~
: >
"- 0 tU
~
~
~
~
:U
5
~
0 ~
~
§
8 U
) ~
:Q
~
~
~
::a E
s
~
: u
.~
~
.~
~
.s .~
~
~
:==
~
~
~
:=
.u
~
.s ,Q
. ~
::E
ao ~
.s
..~
s U
) g.
2 ~
~
.§
~
~
9 =
~
.a
.~
~
s .~
~
.s
~
U) :E
~
~
~
.~
O
ao ~
g'
>- ~
1-0 >
. :c
~
~
U) t8
~
.~
U) :E
~
.E
~
E
~
.~
,Q
:=
3 ~
~
~
~
t8
~
So
~
.a U
) ~
~
.5
0 =
~
tU
~
=
~
~
0
5 .g
It ~
.5
~
] ~
e
.1;i :
~
,g :i:
.g a
.":Ji t8 ~
0
0 ~
~
:E
~
~
.s 5
~
~
] a
~
.~
tU :tU
~
~
~
::
§ ~
.S
:g
o .a]
.~
:!f; 5
.s ~
.~
5
>-
~
~
~
~
ao ~
F
:0
8..- 0
-:;: 'E .S
tU
~
~
~
~
.~
X
~
.s ~
ao-
,Q
~ '0
~
~
.'1 ~
~
U
) ~
'0 S
,Q
>.
~
bD .8
=
..;0 U
-,. ~
~
,Q
'0
U .-0
U)
~
,. ~
~
0
=
.-"' >
>
. bD
tU
101 5 ~
ge
8:.~.2
g;.~§~
:a.g.::~
~.;]
"'g~
9 §~
.8i-.-E~
i.8:§]
a ~
~:Q
.~~
f];~.~
].2 ~
~
]]
1-0 S
.U
)~otU
~~
~0
U..=
°>
.UW
a
t: .=
o~
o,Q~
bD~
_-0 (V
o~",-U
~
U
~
~
5 ..s
a ~
.~
9
5 ~
,Q
"' ~
.~
0 .s
: "43 "'0 tU
,Q
~ .s.
8 ~
~
8
~
U) ~
.~
5
:: ~
:g .§
5 ~
§
.:: .s a]
'8 9
§ 5
a ,Q
§ 'E
.~
:: S
~
0
~
S
~.
a ~
~
~
tU
.~
=0
~
~
~
.~
=
~
:E
~
.~
.S
~
0 .s
~
$ ~
~
.~
~
.S
~
'0
U
~
~
~
o 8:~
:a
t: ."E
,
~
~
~
~
--0 ,Q
.-U
) .-~
.-U
=
p:.
~
0 U
0
-.-0 "'
.=
a ~
~
.:a:~ ~
!
§ ~
8] ~
~
] ~
~
~
~
.g .~
~~
]
~
~-:S
1 ~
~
~ ~
.~
! ~
~
:
j ~
~
~
: j
~
9 ~
~
.:S .§]
: .~
m~
~
~
>
.tU
~
"'
a '0 .~-
~ .~
~
~
tU 0
U)
~
U .-~
0 O
~
'0 =
.-0\
U) 0
...~
...tU ~
"' .~
~
~
~
~;:
~
a).§ §I]
~]~
~
~
~.~
:=.:.~
~.~
.ls:.;~2]j~
~
~
~5
&~
a]-:~
]§ 5~
"5i ~
] ~
~
.5..g~
8
'6 ~
~
.::: 2 "E
: >
. ~
.§ .= 0
~ -:S
0 ~
~
~
~ ':t i§
~ .~
"'0 ~
tU :.s
~
~ .g ~
~
9
9 .s ~
8: ::
~
~
~
~
.S ]
9 :'J
$ ~ 'S
p .S
-5 ,Q ...9
~
eo ~
.~
~ J!J '8
=
~ "3 ~
~
.~
S
~
.S
=
=
S -5
"' ~
"20>
.d ~
~
R
!I! ~
~
,,0 .E
~
5
~
~
oJ .s ~
~
]
0 ~
..I :E
~
0
,Q
.-S
~
,Q
tU .-~
~
~
0
...,Q
~
...~
U
~
---=
c: ao ~
~
U
tU
0 ;. .~
<
; ~
~
~~
.":Ji 5.~
:.~~
0~.s~
.§]~
§.e.:S~
~
~
~:E
':o~
~
~.:S
~.ii!~
~
.g 8.~
>
.'0!0-.E~
~
~§.~
.-E
~.::~
I-. >
.~~
.00~
1:'E,Q
...~S
.!!=~
",
~'0=
~U
]~.S
~...
~
a'O~
,Q
a ~
F
:i':=
..~§
]..U,Q
.~
:=
~
~
~'a.
~
~
9 ~
~
9
<
"' ~
. ~
~
~
~
5
~
'0 ;c.'O
=
8
~
6 ~
~
~
.t:
."' '0
.a) >
.~
=
~
~
~
-.~
~
.."'.1 :=
-U
) ~
=
-:::
"' ...~
.:3 ,Q
~
>
~
tU
';I
~
~
'0 ,Q
~
.-~
=
,Q
.-~
,Q
~
"' 0
:E
~
U) '0
-~
0 ~
~
>
-.~
;.~
~
:E
9 ~
§ .=
0
...0 ...0
~
-:: tU
g :-E
"3 ~
~
~
.~
~
~
'a.,Q
~
"' ~
.a
., .-§ U
Q
~
.E
~
.~
.S
:=
0' .~
~
-:: :e~
~.-
9 "'
~..
",U)I;0",tU
-§ ~
~
S
"'~._-=
,Q
...~
'OC
dU)...~
~
'.2g~
~
~
bDa
~.g:g
~.~
~
~
°.s
~8.~
§~
~
0.S
~g.~
~
~-.g]-3.1;i
S
~
~-E
~:E
~
~E
~
2.S:E
~
1.~
.2.~~
,Q
~
t: s
,Q -0
"43 ~
U
u =
"'
"'.1 S
.;0
;e ~
~
~
"'
~
~ '0
bD 0
S
~
~
...~
"' tU
0
p;- ~
~
SO
~
8~:
~~
.s ~
~J!J.8~
~.S
.;;-:S=
~
:§ :a
toDS
.~~
~
~:.s
~.S
~
.~..§
~
~
~
~,Q
o.5::E-E
'.8~.?;0~
c~
8.~
;0
~u
~
~
~:auuw
. ~
u=
~
tU
tU
,
].~~
.~~
~
§a:.~
~
--=~
~.:E
~
§
~
;.~i~
:e §
~
; ;
§.E
ili~'tl-:3-5
~
; g]~
;i?;'.~'O
B
§
~;,5.~
.§ ~
~:a
'0 E
'0 ~
~
~
~
'0 0
E
U) $
§ ~
~
~
'0 '0
.S
u cQ ~
~
S
>
u
:=
§ ;.a
~
~
S ~
~
U
; ~
v '0
~
ti ~
>
8
'0.a
~
e 4
'-5.~._~
~
£ ~
~ :3
~
"' 6
...~
~
~
-S ~
'0
~
.: v
0 $-
.2. ."' i$ t:5 .5
:a ~
5.3 ~
'0
~
f ~
.2
tJ -'J ...;'
---
0007
140 QUARTERLY JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY
to thank Professor G. C. Drew, Dr. R. P. Kelvin and Mr. R. D. Shepherd for valuablecomments. Finally, I am indebted to my subjects for the great interest and enthusiasmwhich they expressed in the experiment.
REFERENCES v
BRUNER, J. S., GOODNOW, J. J., and AUSTIN, G. A. (1956) A StudyofThinking. London.GOLDSTEIN, K., and SCHEERER, M. (1941). Abstract and concrete behaviour; an experi-
mental study with special tests. Psychol. Monogr., 53, NO.239.HILGARD, E. R. (1938). A summary and evaluation of alternative procedures for the
construction of Vincent curves. Psychol. Bull., 35,282-97.HuLL, C. L. (1920). Quantitative aspects of the evolution of concepts. Psychol. Monogr.,
28, NO.123.KENDALL, M. G. (1948). Rank Correlation Methods. London.POPPER, K. R. (1959). The Logic of Scientific Discovery. London.SMOKE, K. L. (1932). An objective study of concept formation. Psychol. Monogr.,42.
No.191.VON WRIGHT, G. H. (1951). A Treatise on Probabiljty and Induction. London.WHITFIELD, J. W. (1947). Rank correlation between two variables, one of which u
ranked. the other dichotomous. Biometrika, 34, 292.