journal of business finance & accounting

7/17/2019 journal of business finance & accounting

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/journal-of-business-finance-accounting 1/26

JournaIof

Eusiness Finance

&

Accounting

h,rz

.{*

e t

,-

-.a

\

Market

Underesrimadon

of *re

Implications

of R&D

Increases

for Future

Earnings:

The

US

Evidence

AsheAr,

Musfua

GrcMv]rje

M. O]H\4

,lxhd nn

inq

n<E

lla tutur

.pY9

{b..qumt

.bbs

mNu.

c_r"-8..G,tu-*;__r --*-

b"_s

d,o.ko.F

-h.b,

sk.

d

^sd.b..

.;-".

L.B

oqPnvR& &llllo',,-rqeul|,t6bDo

Ftu6

o

bu.

Fh

(?.nmr

ino

ln4g, ,0o2,

rb.,nan

4 J ,0a4. ud

Lev

eL:1., 20os\

Th.

rron.

Io'

rhn d

Tne nd.

,l,&e.

of f

.Iu

b.n.f

\

rFD..E.\

'lr",,nrFL

^

&.mE;dbyuF

u\

GAAP

rqtEmnr

D

hFn.e

4x

RrD

lcE\h.n

intumd

6

\ ci{Ar.ba.d

rpomns

rh.

drhid. RLD

rn\ E,

o

pffp.,

b4.rel.,

dd n@" e.n

R&D

rt-

oenr

Bb3turi

uqEE

i

saruft,Fa\a\or _rld- îs

-.

ihar,k.r

i ,

an

/dr

(eFd

od

i

j

s

."-

r@-,

.s

eL

qr

tu.

J

*@;, q

-.

ff.f".f-mtx"*_,,,*.,tupeuR*rsMs

nd"",,"

n60eea Ls

ifuj}trhq,stsdo}L&a



or lnc

6m

tud

inE@E

densd

trigi..

rcrlhs

a

.oEF,sdon

rd

bari.g

rhis

rn].

Comon

b

bori p.,5p€crives

n lhe pr6.n.e

or

aF4id€3$d,n6nb. rnR&Dindc*6tud$bequ.nrr.tums.

lbc,nd.

ar.

{2004)

shd l},r 6ms wil]l x*D

infte46

.*itit

sr.aar

tuE.e

op.ndns

p.rfomuc.

dm o'n.,

6lc. rh.y ilgue

drt

lrl

hdkr

nitoy

b r.os,

nia

drc.

b. .68 ud

nena

.d.c.alu$

6ms

"i1h

x&D

inrea.s.

Howsti

&cn

did.n..

d6 nor

nn

ou tn.

p6sibilty

that dre

m,rk

t is

.mcient

r rtcogni;ns

pmp.r,

6.

tuur

b.o.6B

r.oE

F.&n

i r&3.

Tb.

obs.ned dsocirlion

b.s..n

rutur.

ibnm,l Esd

hd

l&D

inq.6.5

Day

be

due

b

.roE in

$en

longlindde

abnomal rEm n6DB, aising Ircn inprc .r

.ontul

Ior n5k

la.bE

r.]*d b

l* ins.aK. Eb.ind.r 1l.

(200r)

cDnEol io

n. 36dJd

nrr

racbB,

Iraely

b.E, nd.r b t@L,

ire,

and momcnM,

Ho**r,

rh6e

fadcE rle utrrik+ b

co,r.r rd

chmg6 in

rill

sdard Iirh

d ino.e. i,

R&D

sp.nd;& This n

d i,npo6r conc.m giv.. i}I lbrlEri .r .I

(2002)

shd

ihl

R&D inccas arc

Elred b sighfid

y hignd

lrr'Bbilit

ln

tusrc ffing'

Fnincmo .,

Al Hotui

d

11.

(20or)

:nd

B..r

d

d.

(20o{)

pdide aid.Dc.

drar

rrlD inr.sm.ns

in and of

nent

qhrh

tho,id

b.

p,i

.d

b se ru , .ps

rila

uooEd

boor

b

nwr.' tud [,r uL

n, L.

-'ur(

d,. .b'

'rd.rr

I

\rmr,

r$ar.h dBtn d6

,or

4ficidy

Irs.

R&D

i,.I.2g

dnibirinsr.rs.

psidrc

ldus

of

d.ir $;oDar

rc6m

ndud

for tuoE

yta.

ou

3d

h.c

n

6

ndr.

f"n

@

tu]I, rcos,ia

tutur

.mings

nDpIcatio..

of

eD bc..6.r

1r'.

follo-

ih. nb.rc.d

d

al.

(200{)

appbacrr

@ id.ndry

fimyean widr

ecc

noEielly

sisnifiani

ind6.s

in R&D

(Ne

d.nne lh;-in

dedil

below). CoNist nr

tu.ure

abnomar

rcumi

w.

tud

r.d

.aming:

amoun.en.nE. Tb; . id.n.e

ruggBb

rha

$.se

abnomal retums

a.. r

r.sr

pMjal_y

aruibubbre 6 nilpricing

inr.

tuy

.JrcrB

lhoutd nor

M h

daE .

Trra

jr,

&laicins mod.l

da

not pEdrct

signmdt

5hfE

in

dp*ad

&bD

oE shod

ri'do*

cBmrd

od Tbl,@,

reas

d rs o: rnd

B.nErd

*

rr.

reez.r

Mond.4 onenhdon

ot

aboomat

Ete,

a

$b$quenr €aminF

snnouncm.nE

cr.c6

ll). .or..rion

or

fi.

4ispncibs

on 6ese

mnoun

.mor

daE

vh.n

disprc?oiio.ab\

Irs.

mounts

of i.romarion

,hout 6m p.iaom,nc.

ud.

&it

some or

ll1.

abnomal

r.Dms

sociar.d

wi$

R&D increrd a auihuEble

b

$e marr.fs

raruE

6 run), recosnize

p*D\

tuEre

impliarioru o.

r dn.,

t€sis.

Lb rr-+ 6i

-id

4E(ds{o..ba.- (ErE,-",i,no(;dJu E.lrue

.@i,6d+Mbqs6,tr.J,@r di4,.ll-fu



To

doe

dn.fl]y

@i,.

yhedrs

.rins,

\. r in. rouorjnp

pro.edure.

$'. nBr

6de. 1,. rrrdon

b.srn

n&D

pr.d ftion

@odd.

R&D.nau"

.n

'}s

oodet

rr.c6

rh.

b.r.66

ofx-&D

in

em

PosrriE,

ugg^M8

Jrn

ruG

.n

'.m3

modd,

u 6Emdr;.,

incra6 ind

futuE minc;

u\.. aa

impri.iti.

h,rd

pd.*.

spe.in.a&

ya

r.sEs

t on'mpoa.ou

, rtuB dgains

rr$.rid ff'os

hh.E

1m

ls\

-iF

.Dbotu

a.

lpdifi.d

in 6la

orprid p.riodt

eami.F and

x&D

i..rs6.

co.6dnE ftom

'nn

ood.l

pDid.

e

BdnaE of l]lc

rotdi

p.n.p

on

d

rur.mmsr rnefiE

orx&D

ind."g.

w.6nd

ihir

,lr.

.hings

p..dicd6

nod.l n lisniicmdy

seE.

ihm rh.

@rBponding

coes.i.m

or

6.

F\eD Ed2br. imrlicd froE

dr.

rctum Dodd.

Thn

K;tr

sss;b

$*

$e

narter

undcBrimt6

ih.

.1L.r

of R&D hd.6s

on

tuor

sminss. Tnis

nnding

abromar

rcoh.

soded liln

R&D

increae;

e con..nhEd

ar eminss rroDn..hmB.

Togerh-,

rb.s. r.suts

suss.*

6athe

rnl ih€n

tutuEl.mrn41

r

o I bb.

Srdl

ne*d

prd.ipmE,

"l o

udd*dnatc

6.

nrtorc

.,,nng:

idptiodo;s

or

p &D

in.r*a rr

nor. rnighrroEd

-

karor 1bla

h dJF

.min8 ,

beu. sllr.

rh.makei\Fm:E

or tuturc.mingi

i4JrL.^m"k,

r,.68. w.hm

t}r udnl

._.6s of r{

'l]-

aF,

r

rr4 d45J

ro .4c,

i-apFBr..fr,n"

d,

ron@jrs

t*D incrcr. r.

4

terr

in

par

du.

b

rn. Darkert

und.Estinarion

or

eami,g:

b.n

6r

orr&D i'd.M.

In

sm, or

.Edy onEibu*

@ th.

h€Bur

by ebi,nos

vhy EIB

ni,n r&D

;n(r er

.x"€na..

p.6dv.

nror.

abnomal

r.rle.

ou rtsuls

e

consnEnr wirh

r]].

Dah.r

sJ6Btudelty

md.Esrinari.g

tutur.

.amins

ben.lis

r, n

dftni

R&D

bb.

'}1.

ol. ron for d.

eoci"don b-M.n

R&Din;.cB4nd

r.rr:bnom,r

Ir.

6r of rhe papd

n o.ganized s

fonox.

$cdon

2

distus.s th.

r.ricd

LrnIE.

Sc.don

qrDre

*le.don

Procedur

s.lrion 4

dtu.nB

ror on'

,h BLiti,h.d

.et,ooo beMen

or

drde 2bnlm,r

dm n emi.g: h.oun.ef.nt.

s.crion 6 p*..b nldE

tub

n ,as

on

Iur,r

.oing\ s.njo, 7 do<ufl

rv ij

,

o

?onr,}l.

rsa.

or R&D

nffit ir

$.;on

s

.,mlrr.-

d.

p.

p".

-d

odftfudoiddrfoucloia@p



ffitr""c"8'J*il'ju*#r.,,*3i.f

;;5;;i;1***

z,grcrcrorr'.nrrrrr,turr'

HS,Lrr

tffifH',-,

ff

HHf*"*

#fr

,..Iritrit

**ig#j#l:tn:x+iiT.,L"j=3r$:IJ::,iil,.,":I

mH*tr,+rrruU#i:m^{*r*

"rx;':;;::l;:rl:n

::

:

;;;";:,:,i:;

1;;l*,".-;:

I

fi

*#*;{rq,m+**ffi

#l'':Fffi

m***ts,io*,*#u,n*m

ffi*ffirffi#rffiffiri+iffi

'1ry;,f*gg*+;l+,1""fl;:r,1,':,"ru;;

$1ffi

i"^ffi;,1t*:#,#.*:*.*:E



iEi6 oi

r.pofud

F &?b.IF

Da.t]E,lirich

ds6.lnln

RllD inv.sb.os

g7c 5d dr

l&D

.iF66M

e

Dard

e

.r?.n$

in

ln.

I.ar

jn

yhi.h

dr./

T.

incnRd.r Hotrft4

cbab.

.t ,l

(:0n2)

.mph6iE

thi

on.

@Dor ru].

ou.h.

exld.nci,s

rm in@

du.

b

r&D

+ddbs

ind.&s

m

prcrdy

dj{ou .d

rcr. rhr pn 6

or

fijB

D6r

5Fn.ntrs

3r.i if

(rBe.

ra

n:o de

I .r

rt

,

roo.1,

Tlus

NouDdnE. Errcdd

lad.o

"

neFU\r

FhEon

b.Nr4 R D.no.d6,nd

b.*in

et 31.

(2004)

E

h

$n ri . ou

sd

rrlsc

R&D infrLn nhbit

pc

op.Edng

p.rfomn.B

n

'brq;

p.riodli.

Tnr

con.iudr

Hs.E,

n ir pqdbl.

'l r

Lh.

n

inc@6.

6

r :mPrcFr

lonht

fo

or long *indw

abmmil

r.oru

driv6

fi.ir

r.sdE.

The nodon

of ooiied

or

he,lnt

sr. u

.onp

"

nJG

"b,om?

.e

utu

Th.; MJyir

lonbol.

foi

mr}-,,ob

r.

/e,

nor;n.j

ldhr.d

d.rhi3b'

?.1

'

otdng

6E

d.

u rir.r/

b

,oEPl.Ety

ro

or

brMr

ud

equpmmr

invsh.nL.

ru,6.m6re

Al

Honn.

n c:

-00cr

dd

E

,t

for

tbefnm.r:

.,

find.ls

+r

t.

B.

R3o

n ,."

a ie

pd

be]

,...r;

b,14,

In

su, rh.re

n

bo

co.dE;E

.viden.. in

ri.

licnbr.

thai

ln. obsered

lonB_

ciated vi$

F &D incr.as

r. hl),

abnomar.

r;

otn..

mrdt

n

n

nd

d.a d,4

rhe etr .r

of

.mied

n*

fac6^

.or.laEd

lir]]

ofd

rdDbl.

'ult)

rlr{dju.Dd

tongtu

"bnom,l

rcLm

m.dL,..

oawing

r.[1b1.

'd.'.nf..horLRlDa,pnrgca.,6bsdo4.on3,tur

GIllmL, orp6,ot.

tn

h.

Ndr

v.

dddr

s

rhir pl

obtem

bw

Ens

blE

rhn d;

nor Fh

on tons tu;

rbiomJr

'eEm1

In

on.3d

oI68 w..6in.

"h.ur

ru.D i,rm;.

d..eaEd

@

huro

$onk:ndo,

r.lrm

.rcud

6

oro

o,

o. nlL

kco^ L

'

ntrdy

'ob.d

poblm

aEihon

tu

rm0,

He

dro.;,

eqhr${ tuLE,.

uft

ffi1cd L

rh

i&D

:n.E e

d

.

"-1;1

*'^-'

*P*

'

'

'

,

".J*P,ry-P*

ud

";

,



-

or

r 6iFJ.d

b

rh.

rcn

r

c,."r,

onr.nhoon

or

:,t,[email protected]\o

d,-sBsr,l-,"rrddli)trg.ooL

o:,u

rc,

dim

(fu

/r

rb4

m"

-de

dnprcpoEon".et,

4s.;o.nj

or

Eolaoon :tuu'

m

p.nolrla4

E.\6

'i.

oakd

4

lrl4

rin.

orr

hono

-

c

EB

c-r n.rnodolosr

u,t

roth

rvnhrrn.tosl)

spenr6n).n.*.

r

.rP.crjonr

or@s:

a. hf.n d rrcm

rdt

pr B,

:

i ,lr.n wr h, h

herh.r

dre,e

Dpld

q?..Edoa

p'oFl),in6rp.EE

EptroEon. of

Rrt)

inn-&1

b,

tutu,.

.di-g:

o

,,

6n,l

*t

or

66

.sin.

ih.ur.r

qR

dry arrFL

rnd.rFM

.

,l,e

torcff

13:

opli:d66

ofR&D,n.r.*3.

(ou. uEh.

g.,e

rc B.h.d

n.r

Lshr

.buohinsR3_Din,,r; {<"rr 4LrD-4J,

th.

@r

kis6orR*D

m..a-.

w

oban

drE:rcD

lh.

?0I compu5urrd

clsp

6.e. ou u,ph.onbr

^y(F

ME)(,rd

NBJ:qlw wiLh.oD

.o 2006

'thc

mpt.

p.riod

5@

rrcm t97i

b6rB.

,bEne

Iom

o.bb.,

.r{

rs,tAs No.21

cAAp

rqr6.x}.Bins

or R&D

erp.nd,tuFi

i'-. p."a-.-_

s,006b^"..f,,tT.o-u.."J.:..h.

papfl

he

nfrd

rod+..rdt.M

.

6v.

h,Ion

rc irc.d

nJ

d-noi

tr

"brp,ab.

*r rchkd b-;nB.r",eci. q

diL

1oa

lals

OLr

lrph

ror

rh:.^,.

on,.rs o,

t9. 9i.,m

1a ob ftoot,\,.i

b.-.

p&D/14a

y\rn

L 6 hr

"lqe

or on.

o"

bm

hd

n Mn

inrndD

.r.

h.nb6of p,&DbdeBrdRaDb

dte

"r

-h.

b*rn g

or LhI,

n}D inn.d.

.d

i

olar

r.d

s%i.n

e&.

.6

dn iJ

do..dr

@ p.n&3

rtr r l.r.\%.ddinrIt"g

jr

Eoo

or

R*D

ro

s.E

byrt.e&J5.0

Far

our spl.,

15.52% ot

rh.

obs.mrion

ar.

dsriri.d

a ba,ins rirs.

incr.{e

(pr3r

n

44

mrd.cijonb'mp

up R&D

rr*m.n.

rd 6_r",ib

trr R&D

rncFeB

\n6

hf

+BFj.hrgfindnujR*Dlp.ndinsii

I

I I

cn

-h43.

in R3D

s.ndins in

I,

the

itop.

(o.r5.i.nr

s'1dlLnsLlh.bk

c;m

0,^.ds..;eo"r

L

dzq

tr@,-^,;",d.-,,

-. ..--r, uij

vD,.dM*.",(,'.P'6bs

E$q EeediqoDtsdcfur



0.0505).

Ia2i

n,

lor rb* 618,

'n.

)d

r

rlD

sp.nding i'd6d ft on rv.mg.

lv. E sii.*djuEd

abnom3r

r.omin

sFd6dr}',

a.n fim

in

dre

smple is

aign.d

b

a

coEF,ion

ponfolio ba$d

o i6

d.dl.

m)dns by

sir.

si?. is d.frned

a

ahe

,IT)-i

r .

of

.quiy

ar lh. e

of

Dmmbcr

ol 6.

preious

y:r

Th.

nz ddil.

bEarpoi,B e d.r.min.d

by.rBdfiiry dr. NIEE o6pan6 imo kn

.qu,lsrcuF.

T1'.

boDr}Jy

*r{djuEd atnom

EIIE,.

.h.n

coEpui.d

a

&. diff.r6..

,r

tn€ 6mt no,d)ly r.tun ninu

th. comp2nion p.rdoliot

Bru+

Eighcd

monrh

rM, m. aD

tn.

nondrD abnomzr r.Em

rrom

rour Eod

slte' dr.

.nd or

I

tu.,

)td

m

ronr

no l}4

afEr

tn. .nd

oa dr. next 6*,

16.

If

a

6m

n d.]isEd, re

r.no{

c]un .r al.

(200r)

ed put ddndng

r.llh

for

6. mn6 d]e

5m

n de[sEd

od

r.ru-y.ishrd

Earret r.M ror rh. roll4itrg nonihs.

wlnL

?lior

l.sact

(rsad

sousis,nis,

rse6)

6nd

drar

p*D

r.ads @ subs@dar

roll@ins

rh. R&D itrrE6,

Th.rc

r. Mo EAon for

drt

dly-yed

l(u' fin L4

rd sougimnn,

6

y.u

a

orh.Ei 6nd $ar

t&D emi'3s

iEpacE

3En sborils up

jn

.miry zlhortruD.dl2bt.se.oi,ifR&Diu+acBe{,nrFiDorcpdoddr. drn

inpld

facbE

in6 n

xr

p.riod'r

.imirs

.rT€cadonj

b.aE

.he msr.r

is

r

etv

b

bs"

.

".

h.

p"",

F,rm es

i1r

rh.r

i,.

, h.

Dd*

""mng: b.

om,.

rhtuugh

y}nch

mdlei pmdpds E(ha.iaur

in.orp6Ee

.h.

tub.. mins im?rica'ions ol

lh.

rr.D

incEr.. For .ruple, ir a

R&D

ins6.

mnif.* ib.r in

)tr

r

+

r .amis:

by m

doun

(,

rhe.

a siEple

mdof wrr.xp..DrioN &odel

youu

frnry

in.orponE

riis

:lue

inro

expeded

amins

for

year

r+3. co.*qn nL),

od/

ir

rhe R&D dpsdor.

i q.a6

'+3

mings

bI

noE

lnm

r

yould

Llr. m2rrer

d,i

d6

not pmp.dr i..o.ponk

lalgs

ins5

qp.cadons

b. pr.dj(bbly

surp*ed

i.

Far

{rer poiJolo romadon

de

fo'

fims

firh a 1I3. nsa.

in R&D inEshenE

(X&r/nrtdr

=

r)

(x&rlMe

=

0).

I. dr

ytr

or rh. R&D

in.Ese

rhe R&D

iueae

Em

Etums

ir.

iudj:dngunhabk

c

=

r.26)

6om

rhc.

ot

orh..

klD

fim

iDc 6.,

how.4 rh. sbnomar rirms r.5isni6md/

graEr

ro.

fimr

lidr l,{e

not

in rh.

rhird

y.ii

ot ...11, thes. r6u16 r. conGEn

with

drc.

of rb.ftan .t

,1.

/2001,

,nd

i-ccen

'ntr

cmr

i'J

LrB.

Rs

indrds

.rnrn..

FolBr

Lr'.

Don.LonadRdEt(2008)sDgBestharg

qn

jnR&D,[email protected]

indt& i.

R&D,

n nD. Mi:r.d lid tutuc

rEm.

They dai,r rhat

p,ior

$udies

5d

6d rt6

&

qd

br o nrk {jE

:Y},T.Y,T::fl:.::'*.T'*,-1-B

d*.'

@

& hts.-l

beu

dFqd .* 4 ucb



r\nnual ,$nomal

Re6ms

oflims ui.h

6d Hnnour

tnse

In.rse in

R&D

Dr tut- urerr ]itd

&&..o

64dNr44fulolHilfu

wr.

r.*'4.

l ]fuj4db

4didd

4Td.d

rurci

o,

Gr,4;r

oE,

. _

;

d-nuldq-'

oEF

sedeEhrr4(trF.d,,G,i.i.4

\l-&u+I,.,rd,,...

.d. ideEjgl]6q

j

ft14'5tddlo*lftl';x.o..;i

'Ji

64 J

Fi,\i+

Do-TLon

-d

R.orrlrFr

ud

o

iomi-.xy

t,.Ee

inr,.4e"

Don-Lon

rnd Re,urr

do

nor

emoloy

e"h

:n

.oromicaxr

tdse.

tu-,

Enrt

n,an.

".

*e,

h.ch"6

R&D

srcwdr

p.rdotio

in.ude

both

tronom,rtv

nsniji.J

d

tuistufaF.

R&D

lh o.r% R&D

.o

&E kl.

be . on.id.r.d i

}.sh

R gDdr,h

nhro05c

infr .:n

R&D

indt

en.tdD,n,o,o@o

ir+ e

How.i

l}i

srct$

s.td

no.

be dn

.ronomn"xr

,

,sn

6 an,

h r€.

Th.

Do.l5.n

&d

Rlurr roJqs

do$

pornr

ol

id

src4l-

in

bd

e.L

B:n

hptur

rcftt.rd

omiir.d

d.rb@

m.dtrf

orin.fr.

in

R&D.pooing,nd

tur,.

ftf,ru

10 e:min.

.

'

obsmB

6r th.

rLoon

bfs.m

lrrse

R&D

,nd

ed.

rd

futu,

r

abnorual

rermr

b

tn.

indBi@

o,dj.

CEynr

in

bbr

65.s

BaU.,

w.

sdmab

tn.

rollNing

r.srsion

@r1,.=&

r

o,

n&Dr.l]ra,.

+

&AAssET.

+

qRDAS,

,4r SM3,

+4MOMENr,+:-.

(r)

hh4

Â5SeT..

d 6ned

4

F.ft.nLse

chmSe

n

eLl

bt., RD^S,. j

n

o

odB..d

b)

l1.

d.fini on

or

}ish

R&o

:nhnsitr

.n

flc

or

R&D

j

dsB

rd-R&D'-,J..

_,_.

(-I-b.^

dar.

(200?)

dche

a posirir

Eladon

b.ker

R&D

in tuity

and

ruDr.

ntums,

&d

nribuB

6n

ei.don

6

obnEd

rnl

fa.68.

In ord.r

b

.oDEor

id \.

.f.a

of ReD

inbciN

o

Lb(

EL[on b.hM

n&ryrfu,4

ed AR .,

.,

*r re

ruA.-,,

d.turd

a

lh. ndo

of I&D dp@

b roEt

u.E

rt ,ne

b.gjminB

or



,;d'ad.ddaon,onoottr"bt..r,pav.L

je.oeo,6-bool

\,t1.or.qdt)

dr

{j.d

6 o. 6rld ,:rJ.

or €qLiq

"

*.1

,

vOralri

3 b', rd

hold r.lljft in

dr.

nnr

et*n no.rh

or

yed

.

Ttr.

16

so

ldjlhl.s

n

'nd

'dd

b onm.

ror

pebl. lik

prcmrb

omdmnB

h

in.

d.p.ndr

ra r.2GFE6

L\c

r€Esio

Esurts

or

6E. hodels

ba.d ..

equrion

o),

Th.

d.Fnrr.ot

dialrs

fo'

ln.

ihr.

noa.r,2rc

lxEr4"

AraETd'

2nd

axET4 '

,6p.dEly. For

th.

AItET,rr Dadd,

6.

.a6cienr

on

a4ssET, k negariE hd

3ni56l coBnrnr

r'i,ir

the renJBofpnor -dA

s,.

a.

r"trne.d

e. J,zoojl

Th.

((Eio.nr

on

RDAS.

,

:-

por6e

ind

.ignicldr.onri.

of

Cnub.- et ar.

1:002).

Thc

ce6cie, .n our

EiabL or i,Gr.s,

Rr&D.rm64

Itmi6

poddE

a.d

si8niJior

Tr. .e6.i.nr

nlE n

0.0513. which

$ssets rtrar

tn.

onF}tar abnom2l

EtunE

of6drem

ei&

Iris.

xr.D in.r.se r

5.23*

gmDr

r]'r

rrrr of 6mr

6 {bo( b

L7.51{

lk

Trbr.

j).

ror Lhr

î T,-:

mudet $r

rqftcienton

RxlDr@ry

i]lo

'sEi'B

ngtifi@dr poddF

ar a02%,

bDr for

i]e

ArtT,,r

modet, d.

c-tri.1..r

on

l&Dlmq ir iBigDiE. Tn

inwen

r- rrd

'

'

2

rh,n

iny.e r

I

r

Tnr

ErtL:

@,um4r,n-

$. o.comB

.he coftsponrnng

mou6

hs.d

on

,h.

unidde

an:rrsis

Ge.

Tabte I

).

T],ui

in

6e

R*resion

6f

Arnual

R.bms on rh.

Lara. P\&D

Increae rndi.,6r lLriabl.



293

y1*LaD *u

4.

paeo,E

crr(r

rh.66Bos

of 6uE.urE

to.h. incruion

ot

a.{ssm,

md xD^sr,r

E conrol

Enabk

i.

dr. abnomat

r.tuft

nodr.

5, XIjD

INCR lsES,lND

FI'TURI

PAiNINC,S

]N-OiJrA{IIIENT

XITURNS

kb6.

thd

ihe.SDomrt

Eum<,houtd

nor

be

roncnhko

d

Lu

amjnB

dnor6.n6.

T*n

3

r. .tufu

Eamtng.

AnnoDnc.m.n

P.dod

Abnofral

RcNds

or

Eims 1d6 ed fr,h.rl

Lrs. rb.B.

ib

R&D

,:#sIii_l:t'f,ffi

,.#

:1i*i,1.:trw

lî.$i*tcs;lir.j.:}iT;

1:.t1119_..1

j.:pg""

.9-_1,,

l,.ff.

.,q"o',,,

-. ,

-

;i _.rr

4E

I

.'

ido'Lsko'i,k4p&t

Ubdr6iqsgJsl'd,ih



ro.

ihe

F.iforio

or

n@

widr

od

'il]lNr

LIge

ird@.

D

R&r,.F \ve merkc

,

.h"

Pfnod

04

_

b

e,

0.

hnrrc

o4 o

L ,n.

In.

portrolD

rom:er

&r,

se

ap.n Lh.

, nof ,jr.$n6mJ,.tumoJ

he,our

gLrHry

tuins

dn.u .menG

r:[email protected]'n.o

ftnEndEs

rcBNM'

qu

Bnrd

Kohd

tt'rel,

\ho

show

rh,

.5mmdl

?m

dond.ming, enou(m.n,

prdod-r^ oa,EEsc

pc'6r.

rn

6e tuord. imr.

'tr.

akng.

.mins

rnoun.em.nr p_

iod

4Jm

lor rh. lirs.

r ,.4

fimr, hoEr.i

is.m.n.,

I

=

.

1.d5,

ur.n,h.

drf

nc-

rlr-m

in .dnlBs

amonncd.r

EEms

b.s.e

nm

Yiin

hq. in .r.

in R&D

and

rr,w

qJ,uL'

4 us.lia

y)o:iLqrorG..hof

,hr

rh,r.

qE

n .r o- p{

o.o

romaoon

d:c. r1l.

dfi.mer

tor

\.r

',2

"nd

s

oe o. irs;. 0 orL,

";d

o

ohp,

Th. oIGponrlns

d 't rncer ror

,1.

Iull

yir

(."mrne

fl

oLn-.m.nr

jd

nonlmoln(.m.nL

p.dod

omb,n.dt,

s pod,n

."bt:

t,,E

Oo7j.

0oot3

rd

0m96. ro'

raB l, ? ,rd

3.

,e p(iPt,

Thd,.de6n.,.n.h,1

.

gt

an.olnc.menr

Fiod

abnom.l r.ruru

beE..6n

6]c

$dr

ad

\idrour

l}g. ;.

.r.&

in R&D a

13.2{96

(=0_0r37l0,0r51)

md

26.e2%

(=0.ol6r/o.o6rt

;r

de

rcftspondrns

'fluB

fo,

'}l.

luu

r.rr

p.nod

ror

44

I

dd

z

$.

Lo,

o,

ioqd.r

u-

'r.

rong\

lds,-tn

d.0s.n.. ror

r.r

i5

norsub

d 41l

tign

itu.

Gee

r.bte I.. L',.n

61 l?n,n*

",

no

1.-.

p.nod

roi

oruJ3on\

5%orth.

bd d

a;-.-.,

*-.","." .

4nn8

r

r,.

€n iir dnof(m.nL

dh.n

:gn6j,

r.om,uon

"bod

0n,

,

"dcrJ

d 6

00i*ri6 0;r,^

rr. r

'qurc i

.41.d6Lr.

,

.4omr*rB+;4_m.;4..'

-itu.

,F

s

.o6cpo{htu

ero,\,6

-Fcu;dhsi{;d

ed.F

"-

n-d.i..-

r5.

o.

s;.;-"

,r

.,-, -.;rb:_:F

u:,(F< pra.u1s1,,

_

.-dsfu$Prud.iG,PdmL E@ fl@dor'd.boi.lE@,hdd4u



Po.l B

of Tablc 3

pr.sen6 rM.r.c.s

in

o.a

reM:

b€$een rh.

nrc

yiln

,dr

rou la'gt R&D

in

ra.

t/

diE

..nt

i'dury

gturp5

ConsnrenL$Gllv}d

Sou8imnj

(1996)

we

oNider

6 . x&D incsnr

indEr/

s,olps

br.d o.

tdiqii

el(cnic, [email protected]

no

b.longi,s

io dr.s. indrriB m .Lsi6.d

a

0l}l..

indsui6.

Th.

resds

ror06 r

indEEiB

-e

consisr.nr

virb

rho*

rpotud

fo rh. .nrir.

sMFl. ror

the five

R&D

inh'iv.

irduEl.s,

dr.

r6rJ6

r.

gen.nny

kaL.

rhan that ro. oLhn

i.dusri.s,

.Jgg.\,jng,n:,,nhbnd.F.k,..4tuingu".11, em.ns.imptiadon,

or Rao

dd hr...R&r,inff.;

rc

Lu d

To

cri..r

ih.

6b866

0t dr. uniB

wrrnh

ndlr b

.qudon

(1),

.k.pr

tnfl

tn.

d.pe'd.ot

ldabr.

i5

ArixT,,",

*hich

n

rh. r'n or

d,.

6R

d,y

(-2,

u)

min& anouc.menr

3brcm3t

retums

of rh. fonr qui,@

ofy.ar ,+ 4

ta-.AlJr1-.

4+dRllDr@u.

4r6NLT..4RDA5

,

qr.gNB

"

,

AVOMLN'T +I,

Thc

r.srdion

r.sdE

of.qudo,

(2)

ar

repolEd in

T$1.

{. Ttre

.orfiicj.nt

on

n&DI@q

n

posilr€

d

signiE.mt fo

r*

i+I

ud /+2

(0.0067,

r

=

.20

tud

0.0056,

'

=

r.93, bod' dcnfioDr

rt b.rk than

,to

le et), bui

n

n6 5isli6caDr

ror

Hr r+1Tnhr,6L.Bsugg..r

I}r r.Fn.{.

for

or I

ituir

pri...onrrlo,

aeiacd

viih

incrs.

in R&D rp.nding

in

).r

/

hapFN

dun;g dr. .amirss

.

poiong

.o-r.iq.nB

on

FU^

.le, (o.

rh.

ru

Ea. e Fpotud

rn

T1bt. 2, * 0.05

12rg

inruin R&D

aE

15%

(=0.0067/0.0129

md

u%

(=0.0056/0.04{2)

or$e

con

sponding

rrms

ror lh. .ux y.ar

p.ridd

for

ytau

,+l ?nd

r+2.

civ.o, ln.

aming. ,nnounc.r.nl

period .onsrituE

only 5%

or tod

hding

d:F, our r.sut6

.ao(g:

anounc-.n6.

n6

r.umr tirh rh.,.rJn

durinc

ln.

10F

annoucdcrr

p.no4

unEbul2ad

ilulB

sb*

6ar

dr.

Es'jtins

.o.ticienG

o.

n&D.Im@

hay. Iry.r

liCdiEdnc.

LEh

(r

=

1.76, and

r.2, ro;

y.aB

+ I

jd

i+2, raF iv.l/)

rhu

i.

the

ce

or.,minss

mrcuncco..r

frndoi

Etums

0

=

??Oadr.93rorFnr+I,rd,+2,rsp..dv€ty).T6ese .sul6rui}..u

.6core

or

d.

stni6@r

r.LidoBhip b.M..n r%:rim64

&a ruturt

p.nod.; tong dndow

6.TH'MARIET.SFSIMATIoF,I

FOX

nmrRE

L{RNh-CS MIr}IODOLOC.T

or

Esu.la i, Tam6 3

d { susse* rh2t

ruure

abnoftrl

rebms

N(iar€d

li,}x*Din.e6ein

p61dne

b ln.hdrt.ls

und*6dmrion

orfu

reiinLicatjons

or R&D io6la5.

To emidc vhether

it is $.

future ffins5

benefiE or r- D

in

r6.s

b vti.h

dre

mdler

udeFraciing,

E us rh. rouoljns

p,ocedure.



Tz[le]1

Regr6ion

ofI@ing

Announc€n.n

Pedod

Alnonnal

R tums on &e LJBe

R&D h6@

Irdiabrvdiath

ll:.:.d.ii|'.q:$E-'.-]rb ,I-

di6d

r

Md

'..q

nt4(;

d- ktu4 tud;

(nojhM, qddM

tu

j.Fddo;rud

a&J6Fenscq,.dfuJ|'I6rlMo[/N,

Fn

rc

cdec $. 2ltriarion

t

M*,

t&D in@er

dd

tuor.

.min8 .

N.i1

E

6drac

ih.

ed:tion

b.laEn

p &D

in@es

md

futu

BmhS.

i6llicit itr

rcr .tu'. ljdl,

rc c.onpr

6.

adbacd

cc6d.nB

F.n

nr id

;o

lrps

to

.ondud. *h.lh.r

dr nfr.i

utrd.'8d,Da6

$.

.[d

oaR&D

incr.,s

on

tu.;

w.

u. rh.

folleing

equ6o,

b dd@E

thc

rchdon

h.M€n

R&D in6.e

md

"tr.r.

E

u

oP.ndng

in, oo.

bd-o

dnded

by rh. rd

r.r

lzrur

o,.qu,,

",

;. b.s,^,,n

s

d

y.",

,

b. d*--

d

q

"o

dEnL

Hi'i'

'i':'

oI

Lv

rd s.L

i:,

d

:pprcpEr

D5

.

or

R&D

3

b.n. B.

'itro

.

on;@.ene

d

nxn

,B

6reo

s

.

urg.x

xtu

Lr€d

o

Do@EEtug

ilm.

u h

s inrr.q

.qBe

D.pr.idrion is

*trud,

d

6o- opmring 6rcm.

s-.

n

,.p

*""d

b*

-;.0..r_dbt.

-d

nhgibr.

a*

x&D

dpas

re ddnd.d

b€aE.

re h inEre,Gd

in .mini.s



302

tb.

r.a.6E

or R&D. d

loEd.r R&D in@

3:

epmb

.rFGndbr/ \"nlbt.

ir i3

d indied wi2u.

tn

618

ln.

utu. of on.

if dr. 6m

hB

2n RsD ;ft.ndN

i

'

.

.

6.

EdG

or R&D

b cgE

ud

R&D

b st6)

6I a leqr

5{6, mfts in

dolhr

R&D

oId

rdr

t*,

&d r.:te

in 6.

E@ oI R&D

b3sBord

r€r

r%.

w.6d@

rh. El:rio.

b.t@ R&D bl@

arrftu.

..min8

rh.r

i

iBpli.it

in ma'r.t

Prio

b, leB

r.l,c

,o0wids

6@l:

IArirT,,,

=

4+

quq.,

+.,-,

(1)

wh.E,

rillET,.

i si,MdjBrd

,6nomat

rclMr

sDi.d

over

rhe

fof .minsr

annou..ndl

p.ri.d

h

y.u

+

r,

uE

+r

i

undp.cEd

.ftjns5

ud G d.6ned 6:

u[i+]

-

14,

-

ErpdriondrorE ,.

combi,ins.qudons

(3),

({)

dd

(5),

,i.L&

drc

fonoNins

ftoder:

rA-r1xEr,,

=

4+a,

(E,+,

-

(r;

+

bi,

+

b;,*Dttut)J

+

.,

-\

(6)

'b.e

,i d

4

in

.qudon

(6)

Gned

rr. so.irdo.

or

4

3nd n&Drtui

$dmadon pc.ourcs

on p@led

d"a

.o

Fb.E

rbr

oionq

.q.-bo

i.

.{.. e

s

sllf

1996: md

yr{td.l,2007,.

Hoh$.,.

v.

6wk ,1

.:o.:o"bC trd tu_

.crionir

.qBdon

6

ob6i.

6d, a6 of ri and

,i:

'ih^j

b;= \,/o,

na b:,

=

-

i,/d,.

Tbe e.dnr6

an

cdorared

annuny ad

rhe

m.a raru.

of th.

diihaG

aDd

h.

rsbrisrid

of

th. m.an

a,e

obbin.d

from

d,.

di5Eibudo.

of th.

mnu"l

6tim&.,

.onnsGnr

wirb ih.

rma-r{a.B.th

apptuich.

oB.

i

iE

Briturion

fq

:,e

tremlv.pE.dLE

hhi-h

o b.

l]4L,bk.

In6

,t5o

no,

lnd

n ii dim.urr

i;on

d ol .or wctionn

,lmboo

in

d.

(s:Bion

6idu" whrneMddnsanon

[n.d

eoudoon,,].ug\

rfirtumdi

ud Popr

\201t,

troHprwd.1olJuo;@

u Dmbhm

If

rh.

D ,r.r

rppbprnEry

inrcrpodB

r_&D

rn.1e6

;n.o

iG .r:p..Ebon:

or

tutur.

lihil3l

rli.o

4

Lould

.qIJ

4

"tl h

L

obuin?d

Irco

sdmaiing

rs)

h

'}.

nJI

md.6@18

r,b.

frilm

eming

imp[cloB

or R&o ,n

.cg, d.n

6t 6dd

b. s:n.

rhi

4

s,in:t r,,

a .omptur

ol

Di

dd

4

houtd

ndr.1r

ir

'}l.

T".t.t

prcp.rly

6m"6 d.

rct.

oon b.tu.

(r]ft;Lud

rud pi6Dbtllry.

d

lill

h. a

E

tul

b€ncnEal

fo.

inErpEd'g

.ry di6. m.c

*e obs6.

b.M&o ,r

oum.dodotogynsio_t

b

ur4in

r.ri

&sD6' of

L\.

rn:l

mrrLboo

,n

tunalrt/

dj4n .d

,tl-n.,\

tu

js

.hn&

rd.orulud.

mb

6r

'}..rJnt

b

thib

6.

makt Lnd.,6drt:b rhe

(ri..l

(orudon

so{

(19961

2rs

d.

Erlt.L

i)ltEdl@

6c

dIFr

of

&mfk

o

tum

.,hrF

Hovmr,

untn.



a;i ud B4oy

0996),

n.

l]g

bl, retums d.r

bo$ rhe

.hinss

annouDc.nenl

x:i .oftuou..ncm

p..iods

rnd

atb uc: non.liner

6dDado.

me$od

rrirh

r. por.d

@don2l

ad

dns.ri6

d2E,

6 sssst d

by

Milhrin

(r9a3

rir:rr.

ar

(9007)

d ffi leril

pDbhD,

B&iied

,jrr

Ej,s drd

Mnhlir

c*

rd

on. or $s

ror(m.

+plv

'o

'}.

Bil .od

B,tu

cpp,od.h d

v.n.

B.roq

f.E6dirg ud

pri.;s.gurim

Da),

l.ia

b

incoftct

conclNioG

about

e E.ien

pn.i.g

of ecorndng

riabl6, ir

th.

orned

Eliau.s

d. .o.

Bdondly pri..d. To

h. r+.".

our

"nd@,

irrfl

nttldiB ,

",

Drc.ir

s

-nd

pnang.qdddonl:n

d..onm:

a

"o,.i

6a

pno, ,

-.*,s

^"-h

.

ic

"

'

b&

@ be

coEdmd

h'rh

lutu

.onr6l

Eibl3

rha

xr:Jt.r

ar.

(2o0?)

co,sid.i

onr

2ppG.n

n dniinsujshabL

rroD

yfati

et at.

(2007)

in

dra

ye,

rile B3ll and

. I n.

sr@

rooo/

md xr:r,

.r Jt.

e00?)

e r(Dm.

r5on #ndo{

fum. E

dur

omBion

ofin.

tur rrro;,n

u. pn,ing.su:ijo,

mlilcry

E

h;6

,r. ccrnii.nb on

E

incrld.dhda6t.s

by tu.n,

beBE;xP.d.d

E,

n

=

6

+

h

E,

+

\R&Drnddti

+

r ,{,

+ r1sA]-r,

+ r.asAllsi

+

r.cAlE&

+

6?ac,\PEx,

+

rNoa&

+

r,^NoAR,

+

r.r,

,

+

rnll&Drfu.,-,

+

tDAisslTi

+

rnRD,{s,

,+r,IoCB}l + ,TMOMENT,

(3)

En

{xET,,,

=

ro

+

r,rir,

+

r) r

+

rr,{&DJd 4.i

+

i,,1

+

rrc{_E

+

rr^s{rEg

+ ricl?Ex,

+

rrAo{rlx,

+ ,rNoAR,

+

l,aNoAxi

+

rtrri_,

+

rLi,{&rrfua.,

L

+

r ÂssETi

+

rlRnASi

,r,ibgBM,

+

I$MOMI

ITi

+

.$t.

(9)

kh.G,

a

n L€g.d

onu2l rtuh,

s,&, md

asar-r

re

.n.

ldel

d .hang.

in

erc d.triEd

ty roEl

&s, c{rEx,

tud

acApEx

m

$c tnd

md

.hri6 i.

BpiEr

.xp.ndllG

sat.d

br bul

a.B. Md

NoA{

,

n., op.dd,

s

6.6 ? o

dngm'ion.add

a o4R:

rh.

rhr

s.

in NoAp,

lrr.u

Biibl4

e defin-d

r:nxratir

J.

i200.,.tr.,1.o

nlh,l- r"8grdwJ-

o

-eddLss.dElD6orR&Di.cm.,.hd}n&Dr@@,.Thsc4;.drdables

rlni.r.ontul

lo'

uy.md.ko

oniird

q

'"bts

.r..L (rrlh,lin

l,)Bo;dd

xd,

^nsSET,,

den..d

a

pne,Ese

chang.

in

rod s.E,

RD

g

.xp.q

oq

ro'.r

,MB.

Lq8M.

rhe

t%of

rle

bml.'Gmd,fl

6rio

r

ri,.,,

n

d

MOMINT..bdJ,sdhotdrffi ind.66...e\?n

mon,rBof

\eu,

lin"ta,

f,nlt

.r

J

.200r,

,Jggd,

BdtuMg

ontr.quio,

rh. cmd.nr 6n

R&r/@, if

{grJ6ouy

p.sirr..

"o

Jd

ssgr..

rh",

,}. md rer



und.rElu6 ih.

f @

impuado'

olR&D.

HoEds,

r.

cbnoL

inr.r

E6m thk rBltr

\t'.rrr lhft L

a

nl:d.n 6.&E, IL&D dd tuM. minSs ad ior inpo@dt

fierher

dr. ,rEr.r

ud.Ednab

dr. tuE

ming. b.n.Er

ot x&D

in(]a.s.

sp.d5 rny,

b

6d@rus

bol}l.qrdo

($Md

(9'

rpanr.V +

-'n

b..blr

b

.ldDu

h.

d,.

&N:l

rcradon

b.ko

x&D

mcffi,nd

rL ue 4mrn$.

d

ri,

fd

futu'. aming,

inpticir in

mtrr.r

pn.e. Th.

6dr.2E of6 ad

{

n

$ft

dabL E b

inf.r

Nh.lher

the

nTret und.rBdnaG

th.

tuore

ming

h-Teis

of

R&D-

(a)

On6Y.Tin.ad

&nnn33

and

i.bms Mod.ls

rabr. 5 pc.n6 d'nE rr@

Bdn

ins

.9x2'io,.

(3)

ald

(e).

ror breviry,

y.

do noi

.p.n

tne

.o.f6ci.nr

6dEaG of

dr. conhl wiabl6. Th. rsulc

or rhe eamings

pr.dicrion

nod.)

s

gg6b d,ar

4,

,rf

srope

.einci.Dr

en

4,

k

posiriv.,

0.6a07

{/.

'Ed5dc

-

23,05)

md

4,

r]'. :lop. cemci.nr

on

,R&D.IIroi,

ir

al5o

posittu, 0.0r0t

(ae nd.

=

2..{2).

Th.

Brnb of u5. rcsm mod.r, whi.h rer..E

'}.

ma.Ieas

pft.piio.,

33.*

triat ili th. slop.

cclnci.nt

or

4,

$

nsni6Bndr

p6idvr. 0.67?3

t

tr'isdc

=

21.52),

-d

4,

ir.

nop. co.m.icnt

on

n&[email protected], n

issisnirianq

0 0r75

('.Edsric

=

-r.10).

n

n.more,

rr. dop..ocm.nnr

on

4

rEn,he.im,

ing

pr.dictioo Dod.r

atrd

dr Eoos

Bodd,

nm.r}l

6

fd

,j,

trK no 3isni6endy

di6.r.nt

alsEiisric

=

-0.35),

snggesdnE

dra *,. nnl4

dos

nor

5..m ro b. bi6.d

Eor

"ah;s5

tor

futun

.iminF Ho,o.i

&,

ihe

n

'n..hiDs5

pr.di.do.

dodet

k3isriticandy

gi6krJr,i,6. loP..El d.n

(r.6d5dc

=

2.r3).

Thd.

Es,rc augger Inr rne harre.

und.r.srin

es

rhe.rectof

.oc6ci.ot

otr

4ar

in r]). ro'ns mod.l

equaL 0.3005.

mis

.cmd.nL

m.rurcs the

inouc.E.rr p.nod

.mins .esponse ce$ci.nt ild

leans

&r. a

$r

Dovemelt

in

rnnouncem€m

p.riod

.ming3

p.r shft.

n, on 2€ngl, Isochied irh a

90.30

r in

*ck

pr,c.. Tni

rdd lnite consnknr

id)

oln.r

a.a}*

(..g.,

Ftu.n

.t

al

,

?002,

repo

awDs. Bndon

wal* ERc

of

0.:r5

N..\prh.iion. fo,

s-lr w.ir. mdr. dusmdud.

tre&nenmr

rd,.l r eduns

oa.kd emings cxp.cciions, non{r..p.nd.n(.

besan aminss

shocrs

and

ah

n@

lndk

(ie.,

Epoed .mi.g

so&.hov

n nor ral)i

a.d

8en.Bl

incmcienr

pndng of

emings shEk.

rr

n ,ot cr.a,

},ow*.i

lnar

th.r

.xptdarions have

_r,

.

ruMc eaEins:

inptiBrio's orsuch intrea.s.

(b)

r\*Y.ern.d llmins:

r,d

R.tums

Moders

The

ffiurB in

Tade 5 nG EtAxEl

orya /+

1, a th. dep.ndenr wiabl. in dr. r.Ems

aod.l

(.q rdon

(e)).

sin..

6

Dr

rPtsir l r4

,q,

dus

6r

.4be

hpriadoE d M64)

61

6'h rd6 5 d 6It

dd

d

;ecDC ov GrcFd

E6d

h



Ta}]e

5

Acdal

veBE

the M-keas

A$smenr

of ,r

Aso.iarion

b.Meq,

in ll&D

ud

oneytu-Ah.:d

E:h,a€

timings

Pndi(oon

Moddl

h,t

=

.n-b

1-

02Id<DtnF?a

+,,

&

IrsiLEs,.4asAt_rsi

6C_A?EX,+EAC,A?EX.+ANOA&- A

aNOIX

-r,,

E-,

-

h

R&Dtwu.

r

_dr.

aassrT.

_

r. ru;As

r.4,LosBv

+,I: MOMENT,

+6,.,

Retums

Mod€t

(a)

rA-aR.E',r,lr

=

|

4-r-

n-

rr

I.+r"

a&Dhd,a4

.

^

r

.

r

sAl_Lc

+\

ds^r_fl.

.$G.Ptr,.

'

Ô{.ri.

r:s\oM.

+re

^NoAI

_.,^

F.

rt,,,?r'n/i?r.;,

+.lf

aASSET,+

lr

P.DAS,

r.rrrogBM +TTMOMENTi

T,br.

r

5h(M

rh.,L{^xr

f

.

, ,.o

lignjfddy

ao..#d

l.:l;,1,""."1s.*,i

1"".

J-',ep

i..ng,r.

;.p.^d.

.,,"""brc

.A

Axr

r.

;"j."?ii:

*" ;

lli":.I

:i;i::jHfl

.T:11il:-

"

.:il

;,t,:

:

tiDl...o-

lh:

':r8..

o1,:.r

qLh

'1.G.

[email protected]

frb:

5

<p..rn4.r.

:*"]:;tril:'.1"",ff

.i.T#*.iffi"_i,i.i

:l*:.il

#"1; *:

gtuad)

ditr

frr(riDEe=

or{,.$s8BMg$

,h"

04Lr

oo"5norxemto



Trn'

5

Actu,

'.sE

th.

Mi.t t's

[email protected]

of

rh.

Asuizrion

b.Meen l:rye

IncEde

in l&D dd

TvGYa-Ahead E3mings

Flhings

Predi.doa

Mod.t

Etnl+"

=

6+

6

Et+

b

R&DI\@ +r,

&+6r

SALE5,+

E

^5ArES,

+4

CApE&

+

t

^CA?EX,

+

hNoA&+6

^NOA&

+

rD

E/-r

+

,n

X&DIM64

,

+

,r

AASSiT

+

,,,

RDAS,-r

+ ,h

lrABM,

+

ri5

MOMENT,+q+r,/-t

(3)

rA-Ax[T +

].,+r

=

&

+

ar

4+r. +,

+

),t

4

+

12

ELDI"

Ba+ )\. Rl

+)q

sALEq +&

AS,Ar- q

+

&

CqP X,+

r7

AC,AIE]{

+

16

Noa&

+

re aNoA& +

^m

ri-1

+rI

i&Dlada

r

+

rD

AASSET+

rs

RDAs,

-

l

rb IoglM,+IE MOMENTT+. +r.r+,

(9j

$F $Fr

5q

N4iq

r;

id-.d ii tu'.ôdosr

qrr

,fi'dt&d y6<Nd'd,d.qii,JdlEeil43{6rrd

,J,rd''&oju'dr

r*q6ss,nd4.nJs6{(ddb,ld&E

Nui oDddatstrdilE'dabyl

<hu3 hbd&uhF,lfr.E,dl-l6nd '@d

ucshF{l-l'L4Buiid lqdd.bd\dud.q$qdniddt,slnIklE {.qtJ

;@i

E

,-.bLrridEe6vd

LF

6. hi: .d iD ..rimadng

6.

inpli.adon or

cuftnr emi.gs

ror

lutrtr

sEing:

Table

rod.r,

n

rig,i6edy

poiidE

(t*Eristi. =

2.,14),

sugC.srj.C

rhar

R&D

jn.ra.s

l.ad

6

higher

tutuE

..mings. Hovdq ,i, rh. dope coeEcienr on

P&rha64

imPri.d

rron the r.tums Eod.l,

is

insignm.oc

-0

0?O'{

{ s6dsd.

:

r

sr. Morcd.i n.

w slop.

codlci.nB

r. signinardy difercn

(BEdsdc

=

2.{3).

'nres.

rsd6

on..



,{2jr

$$Bi

dBr l}. bzt

r unn.crimB

rtr.

.s6

of xlLD intu

od tuuc

w. 3ubj6

ou ,6utB ir

s.aaoE r

4o 5 6

+.

totei,

s

kNmn o.ds bd

j.

nJ6oB

FFq

{ Frli@k

th.

r.Lff hdd

r.qLbon

'9)

ir

T.nE

t ed

6,

"nfi

rpLon8

ln.

dep.nd.,,

?robr. l'aningt

'}

4oq

jbnom.l

E,un , {hrch

il

tn.

h;I

E@

oB

borh

ih.

aliDss

rD

eofrongtudeEo

rrh.d.p.ndmthbl.i Lr.ryb,.dur.ndLFnrnr

.ft

in

th. o9l:

brr

l"sbl , ln

nor

zr

inroruoo .boI

.di.sr i ,;.iEd

o);.

---,

-

,r,..*g'

onou.mord:h

udns lonsffds

Eoh

s:r .

rf\

r.nu..,n. co,

\.7

ab.r

lb.

Ert L dricipihs

bed n* b.Io.

l}.

.2rfu4 mro

u eE.n.

&r

t ee.mb$Mrcu.d

E

q$

bed trtu

hd

b

F d-et"rd

,(.

r6m6k

4

Th.

ib)E frm

*i

adFn

Lad

b

di.

gD.

ondEiod

;

beroc.

Fffn, v.

rpat ou

mirEn

lkr.xJdins

d.

hr.fr

d

:1.

\2007)

.msEd

ionuo'

6

ib

er

in

-qidoE

,3'

dnd

(o..

rhe

rclurb

i

an

rhe a6

rcn;;.o,$..d

H.jr

-\c.

Fpotud

in Tabl4

5

-d

6.

w. n@E

B,&D

inc,4

bud on

R*n

:o

is.r

Rrio ro

b.

.6n l

hr li6

lh.fid.i

al.

(20M).

W. elb.h.ck

robEb.s

or.ur

trutE vhen

{. ne&e

lala€

r.&D iftr&.

bE.d on 5% inc,ee

i

ruLD

6

5,ts

Edo

$,e

find

l0c6 irocad

of h'n

h6G& ln

RAD

w.

6nd c4

th.,.su,B

r. q

-bh\.ry

lmit

b

ih@

r.pfud in T"bla

5 and 6.

(c)

Anoucoot

.ri.d

Ri5r

a *.,

aF..r

oa ou matlsir

n

rh

sroosl,

in uoom.6e psiods

rer.d .

b

non.amourc.n.nt

*dd5 Bdr and

Iiodr4i

\r99r',luw.i

6nd

d..

ronoLrme

p.n d

Ftum.

iE.

q

"temg.

@rL H.n(,

dR&D n

EUEo

b rh(

domdrion

rnl

of

€m

e\d,tru

ruimens

th.n

$ch

ii.t

&

a

posibt

sue of th. R&D

rctiEd

dnouncoent

p.riod

Etum

ir

-

lbpLEibl.

dpLn&on

br

l}.

6ndrns

.

;p.n

-rnr"

B-n

rd

166r

09011

6nd

r

&nsc amomlment

p.nod

rtunnlr pFam

o

o r4%.

ln

rcnhl

6. ffig ,bnom:t

-moLn em.n,

p.nod

fM

ror r"E. n&D

i

i,4e

d

062%

_0

024a.

f,om

l.bh

1 a_a.a

u,

l,

p.

,75%

{=0.029r,

Bob

Tabk

x

djfd.d

i

1)

;d

Dnohcem.nr

in

,u

r ,

+ 2.

LG napsds

& Dbtudrly

ou.

or

[n. ]iri,

c.

ens.d,ouc6r

p{iod

.nr p'*i-,

s..ond,

cohcn

{;,

(rAr,2007)

"ueg.*har a.oc

p.rEining

b

rlimi&tbli9,

liqujdjtl

dd

hnsclioc .o.r d.E;ine

Ji.rl..aln\ubFlllodb'ric.srnral

hdoRe

b) d.6n:don no,

rbihsrb;,rr

6ndrs

R.;, :k,.

"i,ij

$i.

pr.NL

pminjns

EoE

b mispr'ons

uu D .

-,,16:bti

k.t-,

r.rlnd.

ou

sa 8

inrxd.

b8s.d

R&D

<dl.d

by

dE

ro.o

.b

r

b,

tae,

or

R&rr

r

a

Ilr

fz.,or

&rlludl

FiDil,'

h.

d**en, disip,b

mcio.mb)

drr .lc

Rond

rld,opdg,rcm

0.ord

:n

E'

r+2

b 0.0063

u

16,

r

s

"

r.r,r.

s

-d.-;s,L*r.".t

ig"i6*

.,



::::E4.-

d

rlgdtunu

duiro.&rho,ldmil:,j

p.ruL

o.;

,

@

@ sFiso.E(

ria 6.64t

eb

, r

ln.lutu.

a;4g3.trnr;tume

ET:F*

'=

F".

*s

-.r-EoB

"h."h

4 parE"rJy

d.;mn.d

o,

;;

i41,.-1j1.

-*.6.

bl1

'

rrFcdd

of

d,nrs

ror

p.rN

,r

s

d

Effi eeq\Ed, r

miFitus

rh.

dIT(

re

lhoutd

.4fl

b

.e Jr.

.g..t

ft]8n

E,

n.

B ilM.n4h

buo{ng

rh.

n-&D

ina@

r

h4

l.h.

.h

as .fn.

.

ri. rrsPn.rns

oKp.H

hn

.arn;

b

*o

P@.

hr

Pmr P.dod

tuing,

rc"jradon,

'.

TNAI\STS'ESTIMAT

OT

THr

IMPUAIIONS

OP I&D

INCRIISr5

ON

FIJTUR

E{RI.NCA

II]I ::

---"

,1l1.,I*ry

J4t,:8,

rh*

h]E'e

.fus:

Bdoakl

p

ffirJ}

o@br.

(udjr.

mt} L.rycEdoB

ot ehre .

hlnch

hiE

E b. ihr.

n.d

urls

u5.

th.

di8..rnc.

i

tur

Pr,.od6insrblJ_r.n6F

b.M.n rmr

I}c.$t}lR&'Dlna€.i.ouldb.Posltl*,

tu

rcrg

A

gnpt.

ol

19,405

obfmdotr

Drs

rr. d:u

EqJ,o.nB

ror

;r

uald w.

d.ne

(ord'

.mr

r..

--r."^.e"

p*,1*

o.

ru

r.*,

r r

IT*

T" *l

-.y"q"r,..a

__i"s.

.",.6r

-ir,; F,

d*

h.&dra

md-d:nd.dby"r_.

6*.,r,.."a.rn*1*.,

n.-$J

:".I"3,j1:,"1.*:*t-.s*:.-.a,",,..,1*'t"..*"c..mrs-...,y

.

cruq

o

orrcbt.

?

Epom

L\. mtu,"lud

ort,s&r

eno^

d

on.

rx,h..d

Eet-mr .n.sadfbolnfo'6mswi']rrnd

I--11-'-,lcj-ITIti

y?:

fti.

-.

,r, n

..tui,c

;l]r

,h"

s.n.mr

opMbd.

b,-

irpoIa,1r.

andtbu,onut

rofteG

or6mr

wic

bI[.

h@

in

R*D

.rhbiL

k$

n.sadE

r;lu;.n

on

d.

d:rorhm.q,ho,r

n(.

s

0.0042

I

-

l

or,.

ThB

rrdi

sugg.ls

}a,

DE

.d:ng

of l

B vi'}

Lrye

in.E&

[

R&D

_"yl::lt-

y9

,,,..b"T

=,r,

"

r,-,n..oo*n*

ro;-,

-._,-.4b.

tuuai.d

F/ 3d.

bEaE

ofr

4.

h.

@ffi.

orin

otueo

on

F,&D if

ua6

rc'

Fnod

i

TrrE,

ir i3

losbk

rh

d._rrFu-

yho

har. ,or

B

oi-r

,htr

ro,.dB'tjol

h., R&D

inr;6$

woLtd

read b

bghf

."ning)

but lnar

bejd.

rr

no.,.0qhd

o rn.

lonyi.E

roFdr

:"*:*r T.

"F.

Ti,."

i

on

roo*n._roFdr

neAue

compurd

6tn

blnhMbE

6.

d

of

']'.

rcd

\a

ror

\lu

.h ,n.

,or G,

is

dad

-

$;

r .,

ou

llnlDMd,

y,:rbr-,rr

:l+Eh,]ld

no,

\tr

updiL{,rrn,

ro,f6E.o

ren-n

6ruhE2

md

s d r,rl.7

rpon,]l-

otu;uB

d,],.

btr6r

ema

d

6e

on,n

and

01-

.on,},

EpR@]1.

tu

exp.Go

rrd/,aqrr

ro,.%,

ho;a

uw,

ri,,so.

nGcof6ms*[email protected]{Lb



r:h$

Er .

t@ tr.n

of

tims

Hirn

and

*idour

LAe tn.r& i.

]Ifiel}.o9fu4d.Ed4

4*u fu6El.hi.hi\.iiIi]dJ^ '

olYsdl?4rebrqd

&db)ruP i..i

6.;;dra

ifu4

L6 dd .,Iq.d

d

t&

@m,3b.

Jry

re^ n.g,DE

,016r .rcE

,,llm

sar

or nms

suon

..,a.

m.

.&-

,n ro

D.

t\r

rlfi.m"B

m

0.0032

(,

=

.r3,

,nd 0.00,

.,

-

r.3o

,

,;,q

bt-

)

ThB.

r, I

.

luin4

3ussBL

rjl

n

trru'

ror

.

--;p

.r,,-,

"r,t

hbo

dc

ofrbkd

qi'}]

si}}lL

ro,.i ai

.r^

,co,.

4

:r.

,mb,

o,rri \Fnr

midrc

16

i

ir

Table 7 bay

.ot b.

r.liabr..

w.

Be

: nqsnon nro.dnrr ,6

addK'luse'ddm:qng

Ft,n

=

4

+ d\R?<Dhw,+

darol}rl+

4losillvi+

4AAssLri

+4P\DAsi,+&11

drro8

or.t,.

beL :tr

or.qr)

Ged.d

by,]rn.

ddrJ.q;q.rtun;,imd

r-g w,

I

,l.

l% of rh.

nalct Hl

.

o,.q;n

a,if

.

I

a baor.,,

"oo

a.ssL.r,

ud

RDAS,

I

a

:ndjdondl

. Tb

nro4

qn.5k1

b

-aDtu,.

de

en^ \ uf gmnJ n

-

TheF 2-M..8.6;sr.sio

Esd6 ofequ2co

Oo)

ft. ipoGd

in rlblc s.,,

For

roEca6

lidr

s.n

no'6 hodzo.,

rhe .oerrci.nr

o, n&rrsm6.,

is

pdirirc

Dd

signiiqr

0.0042

(aEdsdc

=

2.??).

Thir r6ux

suss.sb

drar

a. for.6

FoE or

f grrl ror

6m lifi

l.

t

onped

b rhr

to'

6mt

i'r oL L' .mo^d.

i, R3D.

tn;-.

srcs,

drB,^r,

imM

i

R&D.

Th.

.elllo.na

or

r,sBlt,

uo

r.gs r:

iS.,,c.a,

-lr ti.

nsrrcnsLhtii}l

Ltr,' obuil.d

b,

pnorrtrdK,c.;.,

it,0,;,

ud"o n,}.

l?l@b,Jalfu6ddt*oDotrfunDrlryc&ni tlEtsndhs ,{,tsi&



R.gr6io.s of An

4*'

Io@r fftE

on the lirge

R&L

Ind.*

lndi.a6r

D.p.ndem

ri2rne FoEd m.

(El*,

oE 6r d.

piqd

FE

o

rod ft rrtud. dt dood

titt,

oiddd ldB b, qr dni&d

h

$,.

F<

n 6c

.4d d k

FE

. ,vrrF

6Ed

-.

uDhry .id

dd

{d .bbs n

{&

tun rD6 su'iry

oEst'tr&iedakD@3*lodeDodi|iI|6'

nq,iJ,qn ,'odb.n,,\

a -IELd ,bdE4hEgll$gdifucl4rL

Nrh.,

_

od

" doot5ttr ,& r000.6

Md00r

ceffici.nE

^-aSS Tr

n

siSamddy

n.8ari8

nlgsedns

rljar aml_sB ottrstinar

ftlm aming: or fim

irh

asr

sred.

TabL s als

shos

l]lr

rb.

lsurb

rd

roffi6 rid rourronih and onioon& horizors arc maist

nt

Nilh thos.

tor

rore.aE

lith s.v.n-moDtn

holn

soPi .

r.nm,c.

p2ni.ip 6,

also

ud.cdn2r. d,e tuuc ffiing: iipliadon

of

large iocrEe u

r.6]nBins.dioN'Id6,yhic]rsusgatrhalthe

mrte. a a

IIDI.

uDd.r6dna6

rhe fuue emins: iEFli.arioDr oaR&D

in.re66.

Se..rat

Eccn

sEdi6

dlll:mmt a p6itile asilioD

b. cm

indeB in

R&D

sp€diryed

tuoE

abnomal

..Irlft. Thn

r6uli nay

b. dt.

6

a m.aurencnt eror



in

rbnomal

relrns

du.

@ o B&D .or.laEd omtucd r;r

tubr od/ o, n E1y

refre(

or',tud\ p6ndR4denc

thrrh.

md

4rrinu(rrL

vFoCr'rtu' r.rn'1Br

.4t

p€r

r cpoE'b.

16' u.

po.riE arocildon

b.s..n r&D

i,@

{d

fuor.

Sp.dndry, wc

dmm.

ftar

nnur abnomat

rEms ds

gi

announc.n

n6.

Ttris result

su*ests

drat

th

ese

tb.om.l

EM

zb

u .ry io b. du.

6

ooi&d

n.k trc6.

aron. ud

64

lome

of rhe tuule

abnomal Erums

aeiEd

vnn

R&D inftG.s

e

bk

b,

6

b.

due

6

rh.

@r. s

und.Bddidon

of &e

iDplic.io.s

ofR&D

in.rese.

6iv.n $2r ? large

mon.i

olinfomation about lim s

pdrommc

rarb.s

rh.

srrrer

du.nrg

.oirss

anou.me pedod

coftdion

016. h,r.tt

oispricing

is .on.enmrd muid

'n.q

:ntroLn<.hhb.

tLnh.mo

w. rhoy

$ar

rh.

mrk.r

lisni66dy

urdcGdruEs

dr. fuor. .hin33

b.n.66 6r

R*D iicrcag. Fs,ry,

*.

show

riDsturlr

forccar

of .fihs5 sd aurFc,3r$

nndcBdEaE

th.

tuEE

.din3r

Th. r6ulE

of rhi

nudy ha . th. p.cnd.l

b

conribuE

b rh. lonF6ndjns

c.r

in

'lr

t

s c{^.f

@

.rp..

.

dn P&D

-\P,

i.

lh3sle

lid)

app.oprhal,

a.sinE

rhe

tutur.

profiabi[9

ard

rcrum

iEpfterioDs

orR*D.x?. dioE und.r

6e

c

ar. lophisdekd inEnon, ..eh

to b.

n cd

by $e cxp.Ebs

or

eD

c6ts

aod

6

'

.od*qu.oc. lnd

up b.ins

prcdt.Ebty

$rP;sed

by

his}ld

ituo e

Ertiadons

p.nding

since

r

pdmar,

objEdE

or

i..odndns

Poricy

ir b .onY.y u.ful

PEdicdY

sgs6B

cEenr

x*D rcpordng

3uid.id5

"rc

no..trcdirc.i^

ft. u.aer6ij4ldon

fims may .nd uP und.n.Y6rin3

i

b $.

$en.being

of lne

lim,

bN

b

$. econony

s

{.n.

k n

nor

ct.r

rhough

thr,ll@ing 6B:

to epiEfir

R*D

cxpenditurs

k

l suF.nor

opdon, b.euse

n

.orrd

inhdlc.

too

Buch

snbjecriviq on

ri. r.pon.d

nub.B.L, conduciins

an

amrris

sibirr.

b

t})2r

or

drn

sody

Bpiblizdon

oI R&D ap.ndituE

.u h.]p sled .oDe

tishr oi $. r.tidr. ndE or

..ounr

ad.

R&D.

1{r t.av.

su.h

udFis

tor ruture



AIPENDD'

Alhr€viard

Yd

ry

Y.r

R6ulE

Rllard

o Tabl6 5, 6,

ad

3

@

@Dtwwh

q

q,irDl@e

4-E tza dJoq w)

&Fdd R.Dis

in

'n.

roikd Kosdon

,

htar4n

ffnqr. Id',\a 7,

w

27-16

h , L,

Y Glu .id

c.

bnc

(roa,

.}e

kch.m

d

eD

hd

capiBi Bpudaes

Ball, f,

{d x. B{b

Oee6),

'Eor

N

h@d

aJa@nligdn

E ddn6.\at.21,

ee.3t* 7.



,i&

o/F

d<ral s d4 vol

r7. oo. r_$.

&ld.v

qd

t.rhoma

sr,.psiird.F&m-eD_,

Dd"

D.b.d

h,. bp"u

ot

kn

M@, td

q

^tuez

r@.,l,vol

?r,

m.

,.ffi

-.^

gst.

EndEe

l}z,

sGr

L,6

Do

N;r

rE

,

Jq@t

ot a@-\e

dt bo@;B \d

,

}od.tlne4d

faE

&d''

o,h?'a,,*.a

/l 'a vd

la

ep

Bis,

.

tuh.R,D,Rt@rogr4dRB

ft-F"

[

{mj.:E*" tu--

uj

s@hE-].

6d,1,'

Lirlisolsd c$ut fu

rsr).Th.sd*-u,H-uoodL-d4d

lHor4eFdr6,/dora@

rN ertrE'oD&i''

@@&dn.oNr

ryo

.&

cb4,D.,

d

D.r.r

Lrhds

sunft

(1007,.

3m.ry

turcu

.orr

prcmu

&d

u(hu

bk6wt,tdaJtuatwdrtutu

.oE,l

E, w

r

cu4

ud r

o R-ua r2M"

,DoB

wai'(4s84

(

uu

qd

s

(r

t@dottuM,vd

6t,eo

6M7

mt,,vdlPhFrLefuodcdkc.

cr,lrl@A3B6tI'/o.d93u

Mblu

od

i

R siddqu

r@r,

.s

E; *ua

;, b,s ftm

enomJ sgr fu[ru:dc

oFEdDg F

omd

l

rcJ@,,s

M |..rys

j-.

otrw_

tot

5e

pp_6*tt

r.6dd, e M.,J. s

nhknd

od

r

L

yobn

(Mr,

kru.d

€miisr

rd

ctu$dl

rM{er4dJ vr8.u

'Eu

i

tur

etu od

Eqrioiun.

u

o n J thG

. /@rur

o/

PMfu\'lolsl'ao,67- 6

c.h

D

s.

dm*.'hsFo. srLdorrrD

riquE

tu

b

p,rij.ir$sauon

,/4ryr

otMhws l@en.\a

_29

oo 451_17

m7..

tEo tu.ah.o

d d o

@doalry

rnBm.trL.

hdutoJtu@

Frue c \@na(, vor

s4,D

u+s.

c(..,J P,a1r

s@r

4d HV

b4\JdDftiP.Lry'dU

G@.

P -l

.

B. r.a 5d c aL

cG,. f

,.h. us hy

R&D

,lnd,/3lfu

rav

6r'

ta4rr.

vd

r .;.5, u.

HoD&

H

adl k.o

(rs.,

^

uo6d

rh<oq du,

d;q uol.

vL6.dL4

r dis.4d

G.lreo

f &'M{r.B,l6d

urs4tlte,

L hs

4d

r Le4ro

-@.

sqr v4k.quuon,

prcbJbr,r

rd

$ r.lorcqlBk4hrurcsh



8dnd,

s.

E

1r00r),

.cPid

I6a

r @.h ia

^Krnifq

,

totu

E

f,Ms

qr')

,

r.

e 14 d.

odJ.

a Lo.

(?.o1),

clriEriadoD

y<I$

E+.ds:

EidcD.. d

6c,}jErElp.ddu6EIsrud[+,,& a

o/rq4/is ur6,

vor.

7.

pF

3tF31

Hq

a, aJ.

L6n.

dd

c

E varq

(r0on,

R4r6siod f,scd

16r

d

6.

Muh

hdns

or

red o'dto,yL2r.sqBc"J@ndorr@

B

ra,

B.

ud

T

$ushDt

os6),

"Ihc

c:riElr€doi,

hotudo

ed

vdDc&tcEe

d

Rte .ttu ltaqldsek4et4

vo'l r,

ep

0?

3

_

_

oee$.

?.nMdo3 dr

hrrrfurdBd

B.r.Th. *D Brd-,_trrdol

BMFNUcA@ryi4'yd-2t\po-119.49-

[email protected]''6b

,qaA@ia'ad'ad-2'pP-97J)@€

^Lhrdr

r

(1e33I,

MEd4btu

4r@n

b

qtuN

rdq

PoLo

WM

ddr4rhfisr^

Md

\64q\:

]lniEnry

ol cbiry Pra).

o$ild.

D.

n-

(?003I

"Ihe

Dd.@b

6r

E5.d

qd

kloP@ht

Etp.idjiuc'

u

't.

ui:kd x,$dom',

_rMd

4tuEr

F@o^@d4'\o1. 5'P|.1.2|

P.uu,

s. ud

E. ).

zhus

(?0m),

'&6cnriry

caenrdLn,

'rr.

q,lriry

o.

hinBi rd

shlEturu,

rnsdiBtu,vor.7,Pp.2 7-54.

6. hmr.uud Iiddrr'../o@t

o./

io5

n

c

(

tse6),'b

sd hr6 rd

fuU fu3,',,@d}gfu,vol,l'pp,2s1l5

Do 41.

{d Eels

(s),

or,rauoi ohhr.dEb rdomruoo

tunr',1olLrur

aJ^@

iq

t

N,a,,.tal

46,pd9llM.

Documents

journal of business finance & accounting