Jose Eustate, A047 128 564 (BIA Dec. 20, 2013)

8/13/2019 Jose Eustate, A047 128 564 (BIA Dec. 20, 2013)

1/7

Stepe A. agana, sq.aw Oces o Steen A. agaa145 ssex St.arece,

Name:USTAT,JOS

ic

Executive Oce r Immgraon Revew

B mm O h

5 I 07 Leesburg Pik, Suit 2000Fals Chuc Vgin 20530

HS/IC Oice o Chie Counsel - BOSP Box 72Bosto, A 214

A 4712564

Date o tis notice:2/2/213

Enclosed s a copy of he Boad's ecison and orde n the above-eenced case.

Encosre

Pe Meme:Ga dwad

Sncerely,

D cDonna Car

Chef Cerk

eem

For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished

Cite as: Jose Eustate, A047 128 564 (BIA Dec. 20, 2013)


2/7

EUSTAE, JOSEA047-128564LASALE PARISH DEENTION CTR830 PNEH ROADJENA, LA 132

Name:EUSAEJOSE

ic

xecive Oce r igraion Reve

B mm O h

5107 eesurg Pe Su 200Fals Churc Vrgina 20530

HS/CE Oice of Chie Counsel BOP Box 8728Boston, MA 02114

A 128564

Dte o ths notice:2221

ncosed is a cp o e oas decson n e aberereced case Ts cp s eingprovded o o as a coues Yo aoe o repesenaive as been seed i idecson psan o 8 CFR. 1292(a) e aace decsin es a ou bereved o e Unied aes o ams an igaon Jdges decisn derng a obe reoved, an peion eve o e aaced decsin s be ed i and recevedb e apppiae ct appeas iin 0 as f e ae o e ecsion.

ncsue

e Meme:Ga dwad

ncee

D cna CaCie Ce

k



3/7

of JExecutive Ofce Imgraton Revew

Deso o the Boad of ato Appeals

Fas Chuh, Vga 5

Fie: A047 128 56 - Boston MA

In re JOSE EUSTATE

IN RMOVL PROCEEDNGS

APPEA ND MOION

Date

ON BEHA SPODEN Stephen A agana Esquire

APPLICAION eoeng; remand

C 0

The responent has appeaed om the Imiation Judge's decision ated Juy 16 03.he Imigration Juge dee the resondent's motion to reopen proceeings in whic he wasordered removed in absentia. n ctober 28, 203, the resondent ed a motion o remadThe responent's motion to reman il be ante

The oar revies an Immigration Judge's nings of ct incluing ndings as to hecredibiliy of testimony under the "clearly erroneous standard 8 C..R 1003(d)(3)(i) TheBod reiews estions of aw discretion, judgment ad all oter issues in apeals omdecisions ofmiation Judges e novo 8 C 1003(d)3)(ii)

In suppor of is motion to reman he resonent ha presented eience that his 20 5conviction r he oense of awl Distribution of a Controle Substance in violation ofMas Gen aws ch 94C 32A(a) was vacated and a "guityed jugment as enteredner hese circusances e nd i approriae o read the record o he migaion Jdger consideration of e respondent's evience relating to the vacation of his coniction an thelega eec of that action S Pckg 23 I&N Dec 61 (IA 2003 ; RdgzRz 22 I&N Dec 1378 (BIA 200) nding siict the istinction eweenconvictions acated on the basis of a proceura or substantive ect in the underlyingproceeings and conictions acaed because of ostconiction events such as rehabiiation oriiation arships) Accordingy the lowing orer wil be entere.

ORDE he motion o reand is te and roceedings are remae to he ImigrationJudge r er roceeings consistent the regoing ecision



4/7

UNITED STATE DPARTMNT OF JSCXCUTVE OFC FOR MMGRATON REVEW

UITD SAT MMRATON CORBOSON, MACHUSE

N HE MATTR F: ))))

EUSTAE JoseA 4-564

podent

PPLICAON

In Removal ProceedingsDEED

H h nd vn d w t nl f vn nr tmp v n w gn

S r ut g d A ..

: ln \ p tr tn dnd b h t Gnr

Mtn Rn

ON BALF OF SPONDENT

Sphn Lgn Eq

ON BEHALF OF HS

nt Cf CnO f Chf CunLw O Stpn Lg

45 Ex Srrn Mut 84

FK Fdr Buldg Rm 425Bn h 22

O RESPONDNT'S OTO TO REOPEN

. Poceura istoy

On u 7 27 th Dpmn mld S DHS) rd th Rpndn Eutt wh t ppr T) wh gd h I n tzn r

ntn Und St 2 nv nd zn h Dmnn Rpubl 3) wgratd w pmnt rdn h Utd St n n 4 999 4) w nvd nr 9 00 f t ns f nll srbut ntrll ubstn lss n nvln M n w 94C 2 5 pd r mn h ntd S ll prn rn n My 2 7 u M Marn Inn n Sua Pur R 6 w pard mp h nd S t Btn Mhu n M 227 r dd np 7f dd n ppr r dd and rqurd frrdnptn n un 2 27; 8 ad n prn n h nd S wthu dmn r


5/7

p

aoe aer ispecio d athorizaio by imaio cer Based o ese cua alegaios DHS charged the esponet as removae ursuant to A 2 2(a)2)(A)i)(I),

a cotred sustce oese, and A 2 2a)(6)(A)(), as a alen preset i e itetates whout amisson or arle

On Noveber 7 2007 a ntce as ae to he Resodent avsig hm aear atthe Bs Immration Cor C) r hearig schedue r Deceber 4 2007, a 9:30a. Becase he esden e to apear r the Deceber 4, 2007, herig, te Coreeed t s case in senti OH e -213 s evidece the esndet'sremvaby, d te Cr sust ined bt harges n he NA As the Reset e abls g ce i er w1 e a o d O e U D 7 d

. p oo o Rop

On J 1 201 e end e o o e i rar t ede ned D A 6 22 7 Lv _ { j ' U sscet evence ssta e e cae ta r Id. ccrdgy teResodet requests tat s case be reoeed and ermated ith rejdice

Stanars of Law

Te Imgraon Jdge ay n s r er on otn at ay tie, or o oion byD or te esde reoe case wc e or se has ade a decs, essrisdico s vested with he Bard o Igratin Appeas IA or Bor) 8 CF 1003.23(b)() 203). A moio to reoe sha sae te ew cts that i be prove at ahearg to e held if e oto s granted ad sha be suored by adavits ad oherevdetiay aterial 8 C.R. 03.23(b)3)

Subect o liied excepios a paty may le oy oe otio o reope ihi ieydas o te te f etry of a na amisative order o reova. oever, a order oremoval etered n beni may be rescnde pon a mto to reope ed n 80 dasaer the date of te order remova e aie demonsates tha te re to ape reslted

o eceptoa crcmstaces as dee secto 240e)() o he Ac. A 2)(5))2013); 8 C 100323)()(i) Ateatvey, a orde o eova etered n benti ayas be rescide a y e te ae esrates ta e r se d t receve ce o ehearg d

We e Cur may epe a case er is ne ower, suc aor s sedspargy as a geera re t s no eant be a "geera reedy r ay rss created yerceet o the te and uer is te oos regatios, ut raher an


6/7

extaorday emedy esere y ecepionl saos" Mater of G-D, 22 I&N Dec

132, 3 BIA 999); see l Me ofJen 23 & ec 373 380 n9 (G 200.

V. Fnng o Fat a Coclusn of Law

As a geer er, motos to reope ae dsvoe s cona to the copelgubc eress i n e eedous processig of proceeings Rz Glz,484 F3d 25 2 s Cir. 200 quotg bes . onles 22 3d 3 35 1st Cr 2005Accod ee ae poceda ad sbsave bars to eoe eoa roceedgs SeeS He 62 F.3 27 3 s C 010

Puy p .sui nx CFR 3 23(b}1 4) T t o Je 14 2013-nearly x e e w odered mv we eo 80-adeae eced n e eaios S 8 C 103(b Te eoe o

aee a e e litao e iaie o ack o oice o to caned coy e o o withodg f mv Cone e Couf 8 02

" s s s h b ap : ' \J ll, S 3 cg A F ( coteds a hs poceens sol e eoeed an eaed because ee as isuceneviece to nd removabe usa to secio 22a)) o he ct See Res't oo eope eo. s an niia ate he d o ovie ada or y oe eviece tocooorae hs asserton. See upie Ahc 36 3d 87 49 s Cir 2005 (Conses

cu asseros n peans o eg memoa ae no edence a o ot estabsh atercs Coty o he espoden's cms he record evidece suppos the cage ofreovabiy The -23 ncaes ha o M 22 2007 e s paoed no he Uied Saesni he dae o s ee nspecto o e 2I, 200 he Responen never appeae s eed nspeco and hs stas as automacly eated o a dae See 8 CF.R 22Se o wen otce tenang hs roe sats as eired I

Te Cor s no bss o cocde th he chae ne 2 12)6(A(i aseroneosly sustaied Moreover in ts t decson the ou aso un he Respoeteovabe s o A 22aAiI Tus even i one of e reov cesshod ot ave een sustaed e esoe reed reoabe o oe gros

ccodny, the Cu ns a e espoe as no esishe at hs proceedigs souldbe eoened termae

De to te esoets lac o dgee le o deoste m e cser y eef o emoa, e Co aso ds tat eopeg is eova proceedns usone is ot ated See e Bec/od, 22 Dec 2 BIA 2000 Me 2 I& ec. 9 IA 997 Wen te Respone as poe no e nied Saes he hotce o s deed seto e bu led to pea. He ofred o exaon sabsece o s lre o escedue s specton. Nor dd e povide reasos e ed o

3


7/7

,

atend his removal eng . Fuer, e Resnent did not reqest y vable of liom remal n adai or appcatos wr smed ad hre s n dence hat he s y 1if. B exr\n auhoty, he Cu ms be ersuade he Rspndn's siuan is "y exepon" Mater of G-D, 2 I&N Dec. a 113Bease te es as sshd s a suo n hs ase s moton epen s

deied and te in rdr sa e enrd:

R

7 1C(13D

4

Documents

Jose Eustate, A047 128 564 (BIA Dec. 20, 2013)