Upload
david-bailey
View
224
Download
3
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
1/356
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
2/356
JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY, VOLUME :
CRIICAL APPRAISALS OF CRIICAL VIEWS
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
3/356
S S
V H. M,S E
N
JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY, VOLUME :CRIICAL APPRAISALS OF CRIICAL VIEWS
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
4/356
JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY, VOLUME :
CRIICAL APPRAISALS OF CRIICAL VIEWS
E
P N. A,
Fx J, S.J.,
T
BRILLLEIDEN BOSON
007
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
5/356
JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY, VOLUME :CRIICAL APPRAISALS OF CRIICAL VIEWS
C 007 S B L
T S B L K B NV, L, T N.
A . N , , , , x x - 976 C A . Rq R P Of, S BL, 8 H M R, A, GA 09 USA.
L C C--P D
J, J, / P N. A, Fx J, .. . (S B L ; )
C: . . C .I x.ISBN: 978-90-0-7-9 ( : . ). B. N.. JC, , .C. . J C
HC. I. A, P N., 96 II. J, Fx. III. , ,
967. IV. . V. S.BS6..J6 0076.'067 007079
ISSN: 69-67
P T N - .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
6/356
Contents
A ...............................................................................................................
P: C V J, J, H
Pul N. Aerso ....................................................................................................
Part 1: Introductory Matters
I: T J, J, H Pom Ttcher...........................................................................................................9
W T S I N, W I I N NPul N. Aerso ..................................................................................................
Part 2: Reviews o the Literature:How Did John Become the Spiritual Gospel?
T D G JRobert Kysr...........................................................................................................7
T S G: H J T W HMre Meye Tompso................................................................................ 0
T D-J J: T R C S
N-C G SJck Verheye ................................................................................................... 09
T D-J J: T C BMrk All Powell..............................................................................................
T C B J SD. A. Crso .......................................................................................................
Part 3: Disciplinary Approaches to the Issues:
Grinding New Lenses and Gaining New Insights
J: A S J RD. Mooy Smth.................................................................................................. 6
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
7/356
W K T H I : J C
HArew . Lcol .............................................................................................. 79
N H H J J: F FCollee M. Cowy ............................................................................................ 99
J L U P HGlbert V Belle wth Syey Plmer.............................................................. 7
M H K: T M
I H T JJoh Pter........................................................................................................ 9
Part 4: Ways Forward: A Case Study
T H J, S , G JPul Frerkse................................................................................................. 9
O D-B DMrk All Powell.............................................................................................. 77
Part 5: Concluding Matters
G S M: A CPul N. Aerso ............................................................................................... 8
E: W D W G HFelx Just, S.J........................................................................................................ 9
B ............................................................................................................... 9
C ............................................................................................................... 7
Ix A S.......................................................................................... 9
Ix M A A ............................................................
CONENS
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
8/356
Abbreviations
AB A B
ABD Achor Bble Dctory. E D N F. 6 .N Y: D, 99.
ACN A C N AB A
ANRW Austeg u Neergg er rmsche Welt: Geschchte u KulturRoms m Spegel er euere Forschug. P , Prcpt. E H W H. B: G,97.
A.J. F J,Atquttes juce (Jewsh Atqutes)
BEL B Bb BblcBbIt Bblcl IterprettoBIS B I SB.J. F J, Bellum jucum (Jewsh Wr)BNC B N CBRev Bble RevewCBQ Ctholc Bblcl QurterlyCBN C : N SEL Ephemeres theologce loveses
Expm Expostory mesFE F EFG F GFRLAN F R L A N
GBS G B SHer. I L, Cotr hereses (Agst Hereses)Hst. eccl. E C, Hstor ecclesstc (Hstory o the Church)It Iterpretto
JBL Jourl o Bblcl LtertureJSHJ Jourl or the Stuy o the Hstorcl JesusJSN Jourl or the Stuy o the New estmetJSNS J S N S S
--
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
9/356
JSO Jourl or the Stuy o the Ol estmet
JSOS J S O S SJS Jourl o Teologcl StuesNIB Te New Iterpreters Bble: Geerl Artcles Itroucto, Com-
metry, Refectos or Ech Book o the Bble. . N-: A, 9900.
Nov Novum estmetumNS N SNS New estmet StuesQR Quker Relgous ToughtRB Revue bblqueRBL Revew o Bblcl LtertureRGG Relgo Geschchte u Gegewrt. E K G. 7
. . : M S, 976.SBLDS S B L D SSBLSS S B L S SSB S B TSNSMS S N S M SSNSU Stue zum Neue estmet u seer UmweltTeol Teologc
RE Teologsche Relezyklope. E H R B, G- K, G M. 6 . B: G,97700.
Ru Teologsche RuschuS T x SUGAL x U G L-
yBul yle BulletWJ Westmster Teologcl JourlWUN W U N ZNW Zetschr r e eutestmetlche Wssesch u e Kue
er ltere Krche
ABBREVIAIONS
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
10/356
Prologue:Critical Views o John, Jesus, and History
Pul N. Aerso
F B, G J , , . I - G, . O , J , L J. H - -
I , G, J J , - . F , J G ; , J G - q J.
O , G J S
G J G . J G- . J J M G ( M , , M G). F-, J mue q x J . A, J - wht how ,
x , . T J q x, (A 996, 6). G
--
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
11/356
JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
- -
J G, , J . Y S-J G, . S x
I c.e., C Ax - (E, Hst. eccl. 6.): B, , J, x G, , S, G. B C D A C MG890 S W - L C F, - ot C . B , - , - , -. F, C W J SG P . R, J -
J . G, C , wrog C - J (H 00) correct - M L beore M ( ) - M . O , J , J , J , .
F, fwe-:
B J , . I
. T . H , -
.
D , , x .
T S G ot , , -; oly J .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
12/356
ANDERSON: PROLOGUE
W S J, --
J . G .
A J , ; - .
A .
O S J J, J - x .
B M G, .
B J G, .
B M G , J .
N C G - J , ,
J. T, J J .
O , ; . F, , , q . T q, , , , crtcl . I - , J , J -J. T . E , . T , ; . N , . A , , . P ( J J
J ) , J, J, -. T , , , .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
13/356
JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
A x , J, J, H P-
C (0000) S B L A M, . T , -, , - . G (00007), J J ; ; . F (00800), - -J J J , J, J J . P .
W , , - N 00 I , q . A , 80 , q- , . F ,
q . F q- .W x , q .C , - q why .
T q q q:
H F G
H - J
H -
H J S -
q ,
H
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
14/356
ANDERSON: PROLOGUE
(, Q) G ,
H J - - , J
H J-
H J q J
H x , f c shoul ect our questos, ought ot fuece the results
H - , , , , - q
H J S -
W ,
q
H q , G
W J J - C - C
H J J ,
W J -
T q, . P , J, J, H P . P
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
15/356
6 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
--- , .
P J, . P , .P , .
O - , x , J J C . I,J both ses . L, - , , G J q J (A 006, 6,99). H J G , - lck . W , , x .T, , .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
16/356
Part 1:Introductory Matters
I T J, J, HP, P A J J . A - , T x- J J (000; 006), -. I G J (00), T J J . I ,
J J -. - J : J J ( F 00); J (007). I , T x - .
P A, - J, J, H P, x : J -
J J. F 00 , F G q J, J - (006, 97). H J C B J , - G , (996). T -x - J . I J J 6 (997), A
- J . H J- M G , - J (00; 00) J (006; 006).
-7-
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
17/356
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
18/356
Introduction: he John, Jesus, and History Project
om htcher
T J, J, H G S B L. T J, J, H G, 0 , -
J ( F G , , J). D x (0000), G - J
J. S, , G F G , - q, q, . A , q - J J.
A q . T ,
J . A , , - , , .
F, - C Ax, llG G, G J. W F E x M, M, L, C J . A , G J x J
x q , q. O , F G J J - C. I , , J
-9-
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
19/356
0 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
G J
S.S, x J C- . A , J C, , x J C . T - J J, ( ) F G J .
T, x x J, J, q J , J. O q, F E J( . J 9:; :). B J q C , , S, S( :; :6; :6). A G , J
x J , F G -J . O q , J - J . S S , q J x . B F G J ,
q x C .
J q J q q x. A J - S . T , -S J J . A J x J , ,
, , S G F S . A , -J , x, F G
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
20/356
HACHER: INRODUCION
S . O
coclue F G, B , J (B- 98, ); , , preclueJ G J ( G T ). J x - , .
I , , ot. F, q , ( ). E, , . S, J, J, H SC (A C, D. M S, M C, J C S,Fx J, P A, ) J . N x J , J , J .
W , , J -, .
T : crtcl, ot - . W J , - . N F G x x (.., E ), .P , - . W , .
W , . I , , q
J , J J , - J J , . W
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
21/356
JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
, q
. T , q , - J, J, .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
22/356
Why his Study Is Needed,and Why It Is Needed Now
Pul N. Aerso
J G , - . F , , J -J J. , , : F G o , J
utte J . T q , . N f , . S
. J, J, H , -
. H , q . P A, Te Fourth Gospel the Quest or Jesus (006) O P PA C A CF R J, J H (. 97). P .
. C F, H, JS (997, 0) G J J . J . J , J S, J
G J. F S J. S J; J S J (R F J S 998) q . Noe J J , J(, ), .
--
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
23/356
JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
, , ,
. T why .O, J F
G J, J E J L S, x, (J :; 9:6, ; :7, 0, ). O PP , I 0, 0 0, J, Z, - (96, ). A J -. T xB R . W q - J, : D hstorcty J B - - , . F,
, q : I J -- crtcl I , . S , . H, , , -. T ow.
B , , x . F, , , J J ; , x, x
. R F (996, 7) : I G J, J -- - . I J, J , , . A J J C, J . F , q J -
G J.. W J A. . R (99) N L F G, J (98) q . A .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
24/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED
x . O S,
L, W, S, R, H, D, B, S,B, L, C, B-M, M, H, J . A R B ,
W S G J . I , - J S G. W
FG. (96, 7)
A , , x J - . A x D S Le o Chrst. I J , :6
F G, W - N Lebe Jesu Chrst, oubtul o my erleroubt G. I I , I o loger cert ots uthetcty. F , x , x G, I , - , . I
.
I, S, F. C. B, . J
. I J (96), B J L S . A, S P C , -
. B J x J (00, 90).6. H D F S (97, )
, B.
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
25/356
6 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
J ,
. F , G J x x J , G T -- J . T q x J . O , q J - J , . S .
1. Planks in Platorm A: he Dehistoricization o John
J . I J - M, M, L, J J E . F, F E J , q- J. A J -, ,
. F , .
1.1. Johns Dierences with the Synoptics
A J very S. R , J L. R , P
J. R J ,J , J C G. R x- G, J J J J . R G , , J J I-A , -. I S J, J J x .F, L S P
E , J P . T S- J.
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
26/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED 7
Strengths. J -
- , J G . T K G B, 80 , S,
, J.7 R, - J , S F S J S, B the true m o scece .8 I, J , J , , x . L, J , S J J J I-A . T q J S.
Weaknesses. I L M M, , J - S -- .C,
beore M ,
- . I M , M L. I J M - the B-Optc Gospels, ,9 J M . F , J J J, J . T , J - M - , J x . I, M J , J
7. K G B (80) q J -: J x -; ; G; . B x J , B x J
, q.8. S (977, ) , , S, x - S J .
9. S A 006, ., x .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
27/356
8 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
(, B )
--- L J.W - P (q E-, Hst. eccl. .9; P the JoheEler !), M P - , thewrogorer I , G (J - 808 c.e., beore G L M) .0 J M, J M . I, M L , M.W , J S -- J . W -
J M, B-O G, C - . T , x N .
1.2. Synoptic Omissions in John
O J S, Z , . F, J, . S, J, P, J, J J G G. T, BD J L S,
T . F, J
0. O J , - B L (98), 80, B D 00 CE. H I B, , J- E, ( L), E betwee . I L
P (J :8), . 6, 7, , B D . C L, L .
. J M B-O G - (A 00, 00, 00, 006).
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
28/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED 9
G
J. F, J x J. T S J J .
Strengths. I, J J , x x - . H Z, , , , , J G, F G T J , . A Z ( ) M :7, (L 9:). T F G , . B , J , G, x f - J , Z. F ,
J .Weaknesses. O , M ,
Z, ts . T Z P, M . F, P P - ther, P ( ) , . N P A J. C Z MJ P J . N Z J M (0:89), P J J (:89). W J J ,hstorcl M -M , P T
. N P, J, prtculr . I, ,
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
29/356
0 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
G ;
, M, S . M . T, x yoe J S J .
A J S J - x. F , F E M, . A J J , x - f G.T M x P -- M . L, J Jue mrcles, J S. T, F E - M, x M . M L upo M; J
rouM.6 T J 6 J J ( 80 8 c.e.) . I J J J M, J M .
A . T - J J M E . I M, M
G P J trjectores (A 996, 60, . 6) - .
. 998 P.D. I D M J 6 M 6 8 ( 00). I J M oepeece solto.
. N E, Hst. eccl. ..7 . C G J E M -
. . A J E J - J, G (, .., P 96).N P - .
6. S A 006, .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
30/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED
E : (
M :); J B. I J, , B (M) E (J :97). H J M -. T B x J, J. N J E ( J , E : ; K: l), x M D8: (J 6:). I x J- J M , 7 J M .J, B, E M J.
A S J, , -. M J S ( f/, , , , .), , . L, S- J,
J . T - S J , J. A , -, J. I, J q S, J , J- J x. A . T bset J, J S . S J , - J . I M T, J, - q . C, , S- J :8
7. S D 8: J F-S (A 999).
8. S x J D 90 B 987.
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
31/356
JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
I . (:)
M I H-S-M-O . (:) D , I
L, I , . (:)
T . F , , I ; , . (:68)
U , ; q . (:)
T ; . (:)
I , , I . I , F . (:6)
T : ; I, I , . (:)
Y . W ; . W , , . (:6)
T J , , x . J J 8, . T ot . T, J S- , J - (, J 0:6; 6:0) . T M - (M :, ). O , J I-A , S , - J . W x J J f x, ll S J . T , M . T x M J
J, Z(M 9:8).9 I ,
9. W - J
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
32/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED
, J -
J , x J J x. B J S , J , x J .
U M, J , . G cotrst to . I N G,J , (J :). A, P , J (8:8), x .I J G : relgous poltcl. D ,, J ( G) J, J J, S A , G
q S-, G -- . I , J , J summrzes . W J, , . J , , J, , .0 O , J S- J, . J Jesus
J - (A 996, 777), I . P J A :90 : P J ( A :9 :7 ; J: J : ). L J J Ix , - .
0. C, , J J : J I(J :9; :), M (6:), - Z 9:9 (J :), q (8:7;9:), J (8:, 9; 9:, , , 9, ).J C .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
33/356
JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
S,
J .W S J,
J . O x . S M , M E J( J B), x ( G ), J J . I S- J , ot ; , . A L P J 7. F, x , , .
1.3. Johannine Omissions in the Synoptics
C J, J
G. T I-A (I , , , , , , , ) J - . F J ( , f , J , , L) S. T , ot G- O J , J
N, S , J ,P, P. F, J J J , S Joly oce . G S-, J other , q x.
Strengths. O, L J , S- . P , L ,
. C. F. E (977), J x Q J .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
34/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED
G B J
F E, J J M, J J .T . L, I-A - J G. I J , S C, J J J B ( J :6) F E-. I , J J E J -. F, - S M , J J x other .
Weaknesses. A , q J . S , . everythgsgct J S, G , .
T J x (:), M G. I M ll P ( M ), . F, J , , , 9, M J , C J , J x M - . I , J M -, J . TE ot ths ( , Y, I M , I I , ), these (
. W - S G M J , x , J L .
. A J. B. H q J : I J F G (960, 68).
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
35/356
6 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
, beyo M
; J 0:0).W J J E, J J. I, M J I-A , J. W cot J I-A , , M, - J M J .
.I M 6:0, ( ; I I!); J 6:0, (I A!) .
A I-A , A, Ex : J J ( M:6, x J 8:8).
I-A M : I C M :6; J B -, I ot C! J :0.
A P q (M :6: A C, S B I !; J 8:7: A , Y I .).
O I-A J - S ( / , -, --- , / , , ), S J. W S J, J C- J . W cot J I-A S, - .
. F M (966) J , .
. S, , J M :66, ,
C, S B, J , I A! A S M . A , . S J : (I I; ! M 6:0), J J 6:0, x .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
36/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED 7
: J bre(M :; L :),
bre(M :; :9; M6:; 8:0; L 9:07). : J lght o the worl(M :6). : T ()gte (M 7:; L :)
le. : T shepher (M 8:0; L
:7) J . : D resurrecto J J
(M :; M :87; L 0:70), J (M 9:86; M :; L 8:06) .
: T wy (M :8) wy (M 7:).
: T G truth J (M :6; M:, ; L 0:).
: T le (M 7:), J (M 9:6, 0; M 0:7, ; L8:8, 0).
E I- J S. I, J S J, . S - x . J C J , J S. I J J M, - G T, q J- .
1.4. he Johannine Jesus Speaks and Acts in the Mode o the Evangelist
O J J J E. T , J B. T J f x . I B , J M. T, J
J :0, L J :6 .
O, E , B
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
37/356
8 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
E A , W L
J C S F , (98; 989). H, E- B J , J x J E J J S J, x f psssm verb J J x. T ( ) J J J x J J J , .
Strengths. F, J x - . S J , , , (J:; :6). L, J , H S,
J (7:79; :7, 90;:; :66:; 6:6). F , J , - . I , mes ow .
A q J J J E. A , J J E, J - P, B, E, J, J . I - J J, --M D 8:. I, F G, E J .T, -
, : () N G , / G F. () J G , G . () T R ;
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
38/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED 9
, . () T G R,
J x . () J f F, . (6) T F A F(D 8:). (7) T ; R .
N J G, E - J B . T q: x J J J E C ( M ): J ; E . I, J ( , G - G, J :) E J. A our J
J 6, J 9.6 I , J J E, J q.
Weaknesses. T , , - . , . E ,
. M , q M J J -. F, G J J . G J
6. N () S-
(ot sme ); () J q M (D 8:); () J G ; () P J -I D ( J 6 A 997).
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
39/356
0 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
J E -
, .F, J , - J J . T ; - - J . F , W F H x J,7 L B -x J.8 A B D- H. G J, x f why J - -- G T G J .9 A x J , x. M , , , - .
A , J , ,
y . H x, . G A() B (J ), C ( ) B. P , J - I ( G ), -. T, , f oly .A : W J -
7. J :; :6, 9; :, 6, 8; :, , , , , , 8; :, 7, 9, , 0, 0, ; 6:7,, , , 6; 7:7, 7, , 7; 8:, 6, , , 6, ; 9:, 9, ; :; :, , 6, , 6, ,7; :, 0, , ; :, , 6, 9, , , 7; 7:; 8:6, 7. H (9, 67) x J D (90, 79). H , M , . x-x. O xx. 9.
8. J :; :9; :, ; :, , 8; :9; 8:, ; 9:; :6; :, 6;
:6, 0; :6; :, 6, 0; 6:0, ; 0:, 7, 9. S A B LMK B 987, 8.9. I, J S J
G ( A 000) - - !
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
40/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED
P . T,
J J .A J J
J.E -, . F M J G J J- , J mess.0I J ( ), M , , , , ( ) E . W M , . F, - J . S, x
J . T, J , x J . I , - J.
W J J E, J B F G. T , -, J . N , x . N J - . W J J, , , J. T , J J . A M ( , M L) J
0. M q, W (966). , J E .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
41/356
JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
, J , J
J .
1.5. he Johannine Material Is Rendered in Response to the History othe Johannine Situation
B J J , - J . I ,
llG ; q , W spect A J , x J. I , P (070 c.e.), . T G S- , J, J- . T
J B M, B J . I , A M I (708 c.e.), J C . T x J J J J M. T - x R D (896 c.e.), q. T , A M II (800 c.e.), J
. T G C- q . T , J. T x C, J . T J - 808 c.e., J E G 00 c.e. ( ). A x
G . W q J- J , M G .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
42/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED
An Outline o the Johannine Situation in Longitudinal Perspective
P : T P , (. 070 c.e.)
C A D / (G/J)
C B R J BTe oral Johannine tradition develops.
P : T A M I, (. 708 c.e.)
C A E J
C B D R Te frst edition o the Johannine Gospel is prepared.
P : T A M II, (. 800c.e.)
C A E G C
C B E C (D )
C C E C J
( )Te Epistles are written by the Johannine Elder, who then
fnalizes and circulates the testimony o the Beloved Disciple
aer his death.
Strengths. S , , . F , - , , . T , - . T , J . W (J 9:; :;6:) .
R , J- J E. W S,
G, (G ), Iouo J, J S , x J -
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
43/356
JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
J . I ,
J (J; 78) x G S - I. W E B J - B (0:0). T J , J B J. I, J J - . T, E B J.
T J E , AM; . F, x J J G . S, A G L H . T, J R C x J . W
70 c.e., J J . A J J D 8: C (J :8), J . T B H J C - x A M , J . E
J (9:; :; 6:), x.I , -, JC J . T . T R , q x q . D(896 c.e.) q R L G, T P J 80. A J R -
, J x . I J J .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
44/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED
T J
(800 c.e.): G- C R, D: -I C . A , J (J 9:) , - J . I, J ( :8; 6; 7; ; BD ). L, x P B D- - . H P B D, J , . T S . T , J J . H , - J .
I , J , q : Whch A J ; q J, J , J , J . T - J J q J , J J - J .
Weaknesses. A, , , J J -. . F, J G J J . M , P, P, . O M J
. F - J , A 006, 99.. K Q (989),
J .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
45/356
6 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
: ; -
C; ; x J . L, M J M C, J J M, L J - R J . I S J , J .
A , J , J . T - . P, .I, J , ot - . T J J q S , .
F, J J G, J J , . S, J G J , , S-. W Abb-F M J J F-S , - J . T, J S J S, . F, J G, J S . J q , , , , ( J R), x J, , ot . R y
. T , , . A x- J S ,
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
46/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED 7
B J.
T J x q . F , J - J , J , J C.
1.. he Johannine Evangelist Spiritualizes and heologizes accordingto His Purposes
T C, S J , J G, J . B , - J S S J . W J, J J ( ) . W J , ,
J J. A, J, L S, E J . S x J S ; J - theologcl hstorcl. T q .
Strengths. I, F E - G ,
c.e. . I J, J I-A S F C . A , - E. L, J E . E x- J E, (C F, J F ),
. F , A 996, 6.
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
47/356
8 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
. O x J , -
E L S T, - . T -- J/S , J . I J - , G . T J - , C .
Weaknesses. W J J, C J .T ( , S J) , J J. I , C J S.C . H , G , , . T, C J
. I , -- J M . I - J/M , J .
A x J - E L S T F. T E . I, J B , B L G, ! (J :9, 6), L G G. T J A C L, J A G , . J x B -, E. I C J R
. S - A 00; 996, 66, A, E, F 00.
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
48/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED 9
J (:7),
. O J,J G S, S, . T C S J J L, . F, J , - ( P) . IP S F E .
A J L S. I, , , - - J . R , - . F, (J :) . T : ( ) , - , ( [ C]
, :). T x , , -: (A P J ) , P- . T , P () (:). W E , , - . T .
A . F, J ( C, :) J,
:. W J, J . A J , , N
. q P ; P J :, q. S B L, . I -
, x P J 6:, x . C :0 R , J P ( A 996, 77).
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
49/356
0 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
J , ( :)
. T , , , J J ( S), J x J J . A J :8 J- - J, J , x x. T J J 7, f erly - J. A, J ; - J /q .
A f M J . F ,M J J , . J J M -
. M J J, , , . F, M P, J , J . T , J - . A M J
J. F , M :7 (. J :7), J M :7 (. J :8). S J : J (M :8); (M :0). I, J , portrye J:9. B J : , - M ,
x M x J.
A M J J
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
50/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED
. F,
-x 7 c.e., J , H 9 b.c.e.6 F, - J :0, J , x ; - - . S, , (:), q .A, J , S/J . A : P M P wrog orer E (Hst.eccl. .9.). W J E, - M I , J hstorcl M . F , -- J M M J. A , J somtc, O (Commetry o Joh .9).
B L S I M P J T A , M :6 L S , D P-, P . S, J D P (J 9:, , ) E M. .F, P S, J x S, M , . J beore S . A M M , S ( J), J (M 6:, 9). G M , , J q. Y M : J D P, M . L J
- , J
6. S H 960, 6, J,A.J. ...
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
51/356
JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
M; M M. T , P-
S , . A P - ; - . T J 9: S , P S .
A P - J x C . J J (:) E J x . I, J gst C , M - . F , x x S/J - .
T E x x J ( A 006). R
, . T x.F, J , x M (M :) FE J.7S, J M, M M. T, P M J , - . F, J , - J . I vor oJ , , , .
A : . I, - q ,
7. B, B L G, ! (J :9, 6), I :7, I S S Y , .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
52/356
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
53/356
JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
, P. G-S, R E.
B, D. M S, C. K. B, F N, T B J M.8 T J, J, , J - M, J. O , J x M J. O , M J M - . W , J M f M , , .
Strengths. T J M , J. T M J. B ( J P) G J B, ,, , . S, - . B J, L S, , ( J R), x , , , ,
. T, , , , P. F, ( M J) x ( ; ; H O G ; I 6:90 x G- ). T . F, J M. T N- B M ,9 G- (J :; :) J (0:0). F , J M .
8. W G-S 98, B 00, S 00
B978, N 977, B 99, M- .9. R B J R M (997, 77)
I M (00) . J-M , , .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
54/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED
Weaknesses. T , ,
, . M ; J . W H O G J G, M (M :), J P (J 6:69). I, - J 6 M 6 8, oe .0 F, J J M. A x J S, M, MS f P G-S 98: F E M S- x, . C , J M M G.A J J, M J -. F , J M , M . T, J M , , .
2.2. Johns Composition: Diachronic or Synchronic?
J J x (pors). F, x P (:8) J . T P - ( ), J . A x - q : 7 J, 6 G; J :,
(8:); J 0: , ; M - J, ; J I 6:, T :; , : 7:8: G - J, x . T x
0. F , 0 A 996, 8790. S x .. A , D. M S (00) G-
S, R B (00) - J , .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
55/356
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
56/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED 7
J 6:6 (W W )
. H J; 6; ; 7 J 6 G. T, J E. I , terl E x. W B , - . W E, J, x J .
A , J - , J 808 c.e. 00 c.e. B D ( J :8). M P, 6, 7, , B D -. Wth B , q J, J- E J G. T x
- ( J :, .). I - , J G beore er E ( 8 9 c.e.). W -- , , J JM , J, W.
2.3. he Lateness o John and Historical Validity
A -J J J G. I, J J G, J 00 c.e. W
. B L 97, 6; , JA I ( A 99,0), B, I. S x .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
57/356
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
58/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED 9
P J , -
H .() J x J G . S J:6, ; :9; :; 6:; 7:; :; 9:, 0, P J -J . I J , x.
() J x G. P - x, J (B J, :8;7 A S, :; J, :6; 0:0) J ( J, G, :; :; 6:; 7:, 9;C G, :; :6; C, :; :6; 6:7, , 9; J, :,7, ; 7:, ; :7; S, :, , 7, 9; S , 6:, ; :; B,:, 8; E J , :).
() P : P, A, P B (J :; :0); J, N-, N, I, (:8); J S K J ( J ; . J 8:; A :; J 6:7; :; :; J , J:); J , H C G (
C B, D , J 7:); B M, M, L (:, 80; :); J N (8:7); M M , M (9:6; 0:;8); J A q J (9:8); N C G (:).
() Ex C 0 st (, ; J6:79); J B, st J(:8); 00 (, ) , J (:89). L, (, ) J ( J,:; :; 7:8, 0; :; :0; , 7:; , :); (, C, :; :7, 9;
7. I B Bethbr Bethrb . , B
J E x , ( P 9). L J x J R ( J), J J .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
59/356
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
60/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED
x , - (:6). T
J , f (:). T x x, (9:). L, (8:6; 9:;:9, ; :7; 9:) ( , 6:9, 0, , ; :;:8) J, . I , (:), (:9; 0:9), x : (:); J () (:90); J S (:0, ) B (:6); L (:7); J x P (:); J (0:6). T - C (:9, ; 8:), ( -x , :0; - , :; J , 8:7), F D (0:). A, (8:8; 0:;:), (6:6; 0:9).
(9) G - J -. I, , . S J: J C (J :0) (:);N (:8); x (:6); J (:);N J (:); J (:6); 00 (6:7); (6:0); (6:9), ( , 6:9, ; :9,0, ); J (8:9); (9:6); L (:9);L (:); - (:); 00 (:); (:); J (:);J (:0); (8:);
rght ( M) (P, 8:0); , (8:8); P (8:7); J
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
61/356
JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
(9:, ); P H, L,
G (9:0); J (9:); J , , (9:); J, (9:90); J ( , 9:); ( 00 x , 9:9); M (0:); P , (0:7); (0:9, 6); T J (0:7); (:6); P ( ) (:7); (:9); (:).
(0) J .A (J :0, ; 6:8; :) P ; T (:6;:; 0:, 6, 7, 8, 9; :) Dymos (:6;0:; :); Z (:), Cephs
A S P (:), P (:0, ; 6:8, 68; :6, 9,, 6, 7; 8:0, , , 6, 7, 8, , 6, 7; 0:, , , 6; :, , 7, , , 7,0, ) J (:; :, 6, 7); J (6:7; :; :, 6, 9; 8:, , ), J ( I, 6:7; :; :, 6; :) (:);N I (:,6, 7, 8, 9; :); P J G (:, , , 6, 8; 6:, 7; :, ; :8, 9); (:, 7; :), (, ) (8:, 6; 0:, , 8); B D J (:; 9:6, 7; 0:; :). B , .
I J , A(J 8:, ) -- C (:9; 8:, , , 8); J A (9:8) - ; B (8:0); J J (:; 6:); J
, (:; 9:); L J (:, , , , , ; :, , 9, 0, 7), M (:, , 9, 0, 8, , , ; :) M (:, , 9, 0, , ,0, 9; :); M M L (9:; 0:, 8)
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
62/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED
; M
(8:0); N J (:, , 9;7:0; 9:9); S (:7, 9, , , 7, 9, , , 7, 8, 9, ); P (8:9, , , , 7, 8; 9:, ,6, 8, 0, , , , 9, , , , 8). I , . S J S .8
O, , .9 I, , . I , , JS G reverse - . M J M- L, M L M , . IJ , S, , -
M. I , x J M , terfuetl. B x , -. T L M M : - . L J J , rght
8. A -- , C(J 8:), J , J C (8:8) ( - ) J S (F JS 998, 9, ).
9. E A (9) - . R L. S (980) J, W D -
.W , x E (). A, : ll J , oe J . .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
63/356
JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
St eterg Jus. O ,
, J . T J J . S .
2.4. Criteria or Determining Historicity
T J . T - . T J. T J . T , . O , G , - J .0
Strengths. I, J J. Ex S M M L J . I, J J H- -- J , J J . T
G . T -G J B, , J 6 ( , , - , P), J, , . T , , J q G,
0. I , J P. M (99, 67
9), , A, P , , S , . S- E. P (000) G A G J, G x, G x , .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
64/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED
q x J. T
J , , , , x - J. T J G , x . C-- , J J . T, C J , J J , .
Weaknesses. P , - . T ssmlrty, , , J othg . I J , , . W C, -
. S, , .
T , multple ttestto, J , . W , , - . I G . T G J, , G , J B, , , , , x . I, J S- . W , , . I , f, , .F , J M, E
. A, B (00); .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
65/356
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
66/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED 7
(:89; :8; 6:6, 80; 0:9),
(:). I J J lso M. L, J (:) J (:; :; 7:), J M: er - (M 9:9), . T, M J, M . A M J: . I, J J , JJ (J :6), (:6:), B L (6:70) J . J , , . T , J , J
J M, J J
. I J.
T , turlsm, q J . J J . T J P J x , q J . J , (J :8; :; :, 69; :6, ; 6:, 6) (7:0; 8:9; 0:9). H G (:89; 6:; 8:89, ), x - (:9; :; :0; 6:, 66; 7:, 89; 8:,8; 0:, 8; :, ; :, ; :, 8; :, 80, ; :; 6:6,0, 8, ; 8:9, ), . J , ,
. S J . F 97 .. S J 6 A 996, 80. P -
J
M 0:, J 6:8 / J , why - . J; (996,06, 070).
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
67/356
8 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
x , -
-J q x J, . C J J J J M, . T J J J . O (9:); T J (0:7); --(6:8), . J (:); (:; :7; :); (:, 8); (9:8); (:, , 6; :, , ; :; :9, 0,; 9:6; 0:; :7, 0) pthos, J.6I, J J C , C, J J.7 J J , , J. H J
, - J F G , . I J q , J J . S x .
P J J J .J x , J x. W - , J
. S U S 99 M M 988.6. F , A 000.
7. J J , : C D8; E; J ; E - J. S A 996, 6; 997.
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
68/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED 9
. W J
S, x; , - -J ( M M); , . T, J J q , .
I J , , . () Ex- J S . T J B, , J6 (, , , P ), J, , , . () C M L ( M) J.U , M : - , . A M J,
M J . () M J S . C x, x
. () A J - S . P M , - J . PL Q J . P M J C . T xG x . () R J J - J. D , C . M x , J . T x J wth Joh the mx.
2.5. he History o Religions Background o John
I J J, x ; -
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
69/356
60 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
E . G
- A - J S M A, J - . L, H S J, H , F E.8 B , , theos r( - -) J , E , x. L, J J J . I J , J- J H .
Strengths. S - -M .9 T J x G;60 P A
x A D ;6 R G , H D ,
;6 A ;6 ;6 S V
8. S M E J- J.
9. Hellestc Commetry to the New estmet(B, B, C 99) H G J. M , J H F E .
60. B, B, C 99,8. S J :, P :9; 8:0; B- (97, ).
6. B, B, C 99, 9. S J : P, Le o Apol-
lous o y 6.0.6. B, B, C 99,66. S J :6 . B.6. B, B, C 99, 66.S J : A A, R
W A, Speech 9..6. B, B, C 99,7. S J 6: B 8:.
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
70/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED 6
;6 H
, O Z.66 I J J- .
Weaknesses. W J H G J , J -. T J J . A . A -J - B J .67 T , J . A H J J J q . A , J J J M E x
J S. E L C P G , D S S , B . F- J H, J J JM J H .68 A - , , J S J, J . T , - J M G x .69 H
6. B, B, C 99,88. S J 9:6, S, Lves o the Cesrs7; , Hstores .89.
66. B, B, C 99,9. S J :9 H, Oyssey 0.970.67. R K (999, 0)
J , I .
68. M C99. S, , J P K-J K 99, 69.69. B S-J ( A
006, 6), J . A - J 8 c.e.,
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
71/356
6 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
J , f
, , J .
2.. Emerging Portraits o Jesus
O J J, - . M B J (99).B J J . F, J - J , -. S, J - Q , G. T, J - C - J R , S - . F, J x-
. A , B , J .70 E - J .
Strengths. B J, J .T J J F, ,
- . T ,
00 c.e.; E E, G B D. J-M , - J M. L Q J , J Q, , L M
J. A M J , J , x P BD J.
70. S B D. E 999 x .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
72/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED 6
J
J F G J .Weaknesses. H, J x - . D J S , J J, more clerly th S G. C, , - J J .T J J --M D 8: ( A999). R , F-S J J F, F (D 8:). T, G (8:8), G J G (8:9), (8:). T J- J M ,7 J M J -- S --D . T J J F, -
F , D 8:.I S- .
J J - . I F G, J ; s W W G (P 8:0) . J W C , . J ; s L (J :, , 8, 9; :9; 8:; 9:; :6). T F G (6:0; . I :; D 8:),7 J (J 7:). EG J (:0). T W J Q, J M
7. J-A B 977; . F. G 96; A R 989
J.7. R E. B 00, 96, W M. I B W J J G. F J, ME. W 99; S H. R 999; B W III 99.
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
73/356
6 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
L Q J
.7
T J J S .
J J - C, J , S, J , R G . TJ J , ; R G , , . O x B D- P J - , J - . A J M 6:79, . D , C 7I, J G J - N .
L, J , J. W x, J J - . L N S , J x G J, f J - . J G, x .U J, x G. I, J G gorss ( )7 , .T , . H x , J G J J, J -, - . I
7. C J Q J (A 00, 80).
7. S 0 A 996, 0; , A 997, 07.7. S R. A C 998, 78.
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
74/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED 6
, J J
J. T J .A J J: , J J G .76 A G (J :). T , , S (:), (6:9, 0, , ). T J S M , x x J G. T J (:), - S M, D (D7:; J :; 6:6). I , J , , J . W - J J . I J, .
A J J
, - J J, J, J J . O more clerly J G-, J J . T , , ot , x . O J - A P, A- J, D S, G , G J G T J J . H , , S- J J
76. J Wr Scroll Q. J , J / G - J. S B 00, 9; A 99, 07.
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
75/356
66 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
F G77 O J -
, J , . A -J- J, J J x .
I , -J J , . H, , x-
. W J M, J . I , - J M - J.D J, - .J , J . C , S , J J . A J J S J , . F, J S f J , J J . D J J , - , , . L J, -J J q
.
Findings
N J -J J , - G J . I,
77. C, , M H (98) J - J, S- J G B (987) . I J , J J .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
76/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED 67
,
. F , . D J S , , , q . I , - , q .
S, qI J -J J -- , - ( J ), . J J , J - q. U, , , . I , ; .78
78. A , x . I (A 006,77), J - .Ax A 006, 6.
W R K q , Te Fourth Gospel the Quest or Jesus (A006, xxx) 00 H (. 909): I A - , - J. H S J,
(P III). W G J . I , I , J q J (K A 006, xx)
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
77/356
68 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
Appendi 1
A Charting o Johannine-Synoptic Interluential Relations
EM
090
Q
08
P-M
070
EL
08
EJ
08
M
70 c.e.
L
8 c.e.
F E J
808 c.e.
Final Edition J
00 c.e.
J8 c.e.
J
90 c.e.
J
9 c.e.
M
90 c.e.
C
P
O
W
M J
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
78/356
ANDERSON: WHY HIS SUDY IS NEEDED 69
Appendi 2
Jesus in Bi-Optic Perspective: A Nuanced Proposal
I J x , - S x (A 006, 9). A q, , G - q J J x. I G,J J , -, , R J. O , J S .
A. D A: J S. J J B
. J . A . J ; S. J F
6. J 7. T J : , ,
J8. A J -
D J , S J , . I , J J , x , , .J S G . E S , , / - E .
B. S C Q J H. J G
,
. T . J x . J . J
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
79/356
70 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
6. J
G7. J : G 8. J
D S , J J . I , J M G (D 8:8:) F , J G. J B J , J J . J J , - P .
C. J C Q J H. J J B
. J
. J J . E J. F G S, ,
G6. J J 7. T L S 8. J S
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
80/356
Part 2:Reviews o the Literature: How Did John
Become the Spiritual Gospel?
I x J G, --- . B K, J , - J G .K J ,
(97; 98; 006). I J J (00; 986; 986),K J G - J : , , (99). I (006), K - J J . I , .
K M M T, J J (996). C K J J G
, T (988) humty J J . H F-S G F G (00) E, - J C x x J. T T S F F G. O K T q: W hstory T -
- , , -- J E.H J P , J E. T
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
81/356
J, -
, .T x -
-J J, E G , -- A . J V - G , S -- G - (S 97).V, A , , . H E, B, S, B why , ws s .
M A P - . P M B J , H J S SBL A M x . A,
, . I ,
, . V P .
O P - J . T ; . W B, - J - J x. DC J (99), J - C. H. D (98; 98). E , J x J , . A F G ,
. I B QR J q (A 000), M B P Jesus s Fgure Hstory (998) - J (B 00, 7).
7 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
82/356
C (98; 987; 00)
.T x , . T J J , . E , . W , . A , . F . T , , , . T -, , .
PAR 7
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
83/356
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
84/356
he Dehistoricizing o the Gospel o John
Robert Kysr
W Websters Dctory , , . . W , - , I q . F , I , - ( ). T , , , /
.T q , , F G J J . I q: W, , F G S G
A E, C Ax, M, P , G R q . Eq C , B , J, x
G, , S, sprtul Gospel. J , . R, F G x G . S S J , C
J.
H, C . D. A. C (99, 9), , E ,
. Q E, Hst.eccl. 6..7, .. S, .., E. P. S 99, 7.
-7-
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
85/356
76 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
, [] ;
-. H, C G - . N . C
M, -C G, x G, J C, H ( O ). I , , , FE J . T Gospel o ruth - G J. I J , G J .
T , , F G .6 R,
J . I
, , C ( ) F G , , G . I , , , x . F , F G - G, whch hstory . S G J x C G . I , , - , , G J C . S J t the tme o the compo-sto o the Gospel. I, G
. S J,
. F x, L. W C99 D R. D 00.. S R B 9, :; B 97, 67.. R S (9688, :9) .6. F , K 999, 6099.
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
86/356
KYSAR: HE DEHISORICIZING OF HE GOSPEL OF JOHN 77
x J
( , ).7
O , J , x. S V P q G J q J, I F G q; , - .
T I - J : () J;() S G J; () G FG; () J; () J / -; (6) q J; (7) .
1. he Authorship o John
T F G J , , q J J, S Z, BD; E J . T J q .8 I , q - G ; q, .9 H, F E J .0
7. J A. . R [ J ] o sequtur G J J (98, 90).
8. O G
H. P. V. N 9.9. I (K 99, 6).0. J A J B
(99, 7). H , , G q ().
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
87/356
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
88/356
KYSAR: HE DEHISORICIZING OF HE GOSPEL OF JOHN 79
S B D
H .7
I , , .8
I J, .9 BL , . T BD . F L , F G - .0 G R. B-M . B , F G.
U , , G .D. M S, , , G , . J ,
G (999, 7).I , J -
. F J. M -, , , [] G G G S, J C. W x, M .
7. S 9688, :0. U S (99) - J. M H E J E. N, E G (989, 0).
8. K G (990, 76).
9. ,
( P), x (00, 96).0. B L 97, ; . L, E, C 000, .. G R. B-M 987, xxxx. S G OD 99, 9800.. S R K 98, 69; K 99, 990.. F J. M 998, 69 , q 89. S M 99, 79.
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
89/356
80 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
A
(S 99, ).O , F G, , NA J ( ) , G
.
2. John and the Synoptic Gospels
J S , , , , F E G . B q .
Recto crtcsm J S , . I S J G, G. I , ehstorcze the Syoptcs,
J C . A , f, . W ,J S. -, G . 6 T , , J; - ( ).
Johs epeece rom the Syoptcs . O, q J S ( ), D. M
. A x W W (97), M - J .
. F x, J x -
G J J, .6. B J S
J , S (96; 96, 9).
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
90/356
KYSAR: HE DEHISORICIZING OF HE GOSPEL OF JOHN 8
S .7 H, G-S
(98) - J SG, J.8 I J er S, G .F, S - J (.., J S), F G .9J. N. S B. A. M (968, 7) : FG , . N C S J ; J er S!
F J S , J G . F J, , C C-.0 W C
, J C C
x . S, - , J H-, , / M, J FG ( Q
7. D. M S 00. A L. B -
J S J C ( B 99, ).8. M J S -
, I D (99) S F G.
9. S B 96; 96, 909. M M , J S G (996, 6).
0. I F C B (86) . F , P B 998.
. C. F. D. M C J -
, . (977, ). A. K. M. A W W N - (99, 77).
. F x, R B 997, . .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
91/356
8 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
), J C
.
T, J ( ) G c.e. . T J . A -, . I -. I J , G J C
R , J S . E Sx, x, J S F G S . M, J mke preset to thechurch J . H J J :
, G J G J; , -
J .
A 99, J A. . R T NL F G. H FG , , J J S G.6 I Te Prorty o Joh (98),R J
. S B 96; 96, 88. A. J. B. H (96, 8) J S M P J - . M M (996, 7) G : D S S, P G, J S.
. S, x, D. M S 99, 6.. E Sx 980, 78. I
G, Sx (979, 9) ,
J, , , J (.., J J ,J :).
6. J A. . R 99; 96, 00. I R , A. J. B. H 960.
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
92/356
KYSAR: HE DEHISORICIZING OF HE GOSPEL OF JOHN 8
G J,
.7
W R x , - J, . I, J some o the Syoptc Gospels my hve use Joh s sourcerther th the other wy rou.8 W .
D. M S, , . C. K. B- F E G M, S,
, ( q ) J .9 I Joh mog the Gospels, S B. H , x F G S-, M (S 00, 9). H, , S Joh my be hstorclly relble t those
pots where the Fourth Gospel ers rom Mrk the other Syoptcs. P- J , (S 00, ).
I , S - J J S, x J (.., J ). H, G. F J - M , S x . E J - , x F E . F x,
J A, S , , (C) M - . (S 00, 0)
, N A S J S . N ,
7. R 98, . R - J (98, 0).
8. F x, M A. M 00; 00; P N. A 00.9. C. K. B 978, ; 6.
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
93/356
8 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
, , . N-
, q J, f -. F , S . H , , ,, q [ ] ; , C , I f J C (:) M : (S 00, , 6, 0, , ). I S , f .
T S f . M , , , T -. S , , se qu o (S 00, ). S, M q . O
q , .
C J S - M C . C - J G. H , , J J J G J. T, J - f N , J .B J G , , C J .0 A ,C J S.
0. M C 99, 0; q . M S J. P (998) J J J.
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
94/356
KYSAR: HE DEHISORICIZING OF HE GOSPEL OF JOHN 8
N C ,
J S F G .
3. he Gospel Genre
E M G () . T : G q - ( ) O G . T C G , . T, q.
A ( ) J x - F G J . E C H F G -
. A H (97, 6), J . , C q G , J, [] .T F G G . T, G , .
H , G . W H S (97). H - () F E - P. C. K. B, , F E f
. F x, 988.
. J A 99, , .. A 896 M K J , Te hstor-cl Jesus o moer uthors cocels rom us the lvg Chrst(96, , ). I , B K (8).
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
95/356
86 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
G . J , J
.
TF G C: J J. J (B 98, ).
F M (96, ) J , , , J N, x C .T . T J G (K 97,798). D. M S (999, 7) F G J J, . T EF J ; wth J. - wthout (F 96, 90).
M M T M S Festschr
F G C J. S J , T . S - S J, T . S J C . I J J G S- J x M, J J - [ F E] (T 996, 0). A F G J x S-, J. Cq, J E, J - S. T ,
. B 978, . B F G (96; 96, 99).
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
96/356
KYSAR: HE DEHISORICIZING OF HE GOSPEL OF JOHN 87
F G
S ( x ). S . T q, , .
T J C J. S q- (T 996, , 7 . ), . S - J C . W - H, T . O , , or whom W - S, T , , the questo o wht s hstory.
T q F G the role o postvstc hstory s the ctul proclmto o the Gospelmessge.6 T , , - ( )
( , ) . T . S G , O, J G C , - I J . W - q .
G B , .B G L 9. I , ,
. 996, . H q
J F G ( 988).6. q P - J. W L (989, 900) F E C J .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
97/356
88 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
, , . W
, , [] -. [] . S , B , - x .7 O, , J , - (B 9, :9). H - - .
H x -, G , . I F G, f J C . T G , , . H A (00), E G.T , G, , , ( )
. O , F G W -- (9:7). O , J J (.., :; 6:9, 6). J F G x , , G .8P J , , B , .
H G J. T B x .T q , .
7. RB 97, 9, . S B (B H 96). Y V A.H (966, 7)
oe .8. I . , I oot me -. , , .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
98/356
KYSAR: HE DEHISORICIZING OF HE GOSPEL OF JOHN 89
4. Early Oral radition in John
I , C. H. D - J C J. I , - , Te Iterpretto o the Fourth Gospel(9), , Hstorcl rto the Fourth Gospel(96). , S J . A , , D both the Sy-optcs Joh. A , Hstorcl rto,D C (96, ). D F G - J C (96, ). H F G A, J-C J . H J S (.., S P) F E
. H S J -S J . H, D - J J.9
D q J, , x J S. H : J q J J (K 97, 66). U, J F G, D .
T , , J. B L D
9. D 96, ; 9, .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
99/356
90 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
S . M ,
J .0
R B (96670, :x). H G -. H, , , J . T J , x (B 96670, :xxx, :8).
I , F G J / P C ; - J. T S (.., ) ( ) J, D . I J, F G. T - , ,
F G ( M 000, 9).I D -
J S, P N. A, x J S G Q. H - . I A, - . T J (. 808 c.e.) J E (.00 c.e.). S, J G , A (-J). H J
0. L 97, 6. S L 97; B 96670, :780; B96.
. S J D 99, 9. S A C W00. O J
(000). L J .
. A 00, 9. H L J (00, 8) - -
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
100/356
KYSAR: HE DEHISORICIZING OF HE GOSPEL OF JOHN 9
S,
G .
B , , , , A M . T J.
A , , J S- ; J S . W M, J - kowg tetolty. M, J M , M J J .A , , W J G , , J .T G .6
T A .
H J -
. A J M B-O G S F G (00; 00).H J L, M, Q (00, 7). H J L Q, M M .
. I
J S ;, I , I (K 99, ).
. A 00, 6, 8. M L M. L A q J L x: J-L - - . F ,A L J E her M M M M, L (H 00, 8).
. A 00, , .
6. A 00, 7. A J C B H, J (00, 0). M , , x . S R K 98; S .K 98; P W. H 99; A R 00, 8.
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
101/356
9 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
J. I , FG . A -, A . H, , , ( ) . H - C A 7 I 8 H I , -. H , A , . S, S J , J S , !9
5. he Value o Written Sources
U , F G , , E . O , J R B . A - F G, B J J . H J(B 98, 8), J J! I,B -C -J F G.
F B , , (K 97, 7).I,
7. S A 996 ,Te Chrstology o the Fourth Gospel, Revew o Bblcl Lterture:K 999 A 999.
8. I x - , .
9. F x F G S-, M 00, L J.
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
102/356
KYSAR: HE DEHISORICIZING OF HE GOSPEL OF JOHN 9
F E J (S 999, 8). F
, (K 97), , , . S, J ( S) G.
L E , G. B 60 E. - , , U W (989) R F (970; 988). B - G. V W x , , F . M 97 F G x -x f, (K97, 7). S , , . T x
J .
S , , C G, - / . H, . C G, . F , F x S G , . 6 , , . , F x . H , [] 0
60. B 97; 9, :89. S D. M S 96.6. O , I , -
S G, S C. W 00.
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
103/356
9 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
0 Q.6 S,
, W (989, 77) x, G. T F W, f , . T, - G J .6
W , , - J C . O , I q . W S ,6 .S E. P (000) - q J q
. H, P , q. 6E , L J (996) q J, C .
T -
, I , . S G, .
. he New Criticisms
A N ,J , , - . J H. E - x
6. F 988, 6. F : S G M M . M, S G C J . A S G , ; F 970, .
6. F (00, 00) x J
S G ; F 970, 7.6. N x J P.M 99, :678.
6. S P N. A 000, - - J.
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
104/356
KYSAR: HE DEHISORICIZING OF HE GOSPEL OF JOHN 9
x
x , , , (99, 7). F , J , - .
B M (98) - J J G, - .66 T , M-B x .67T , , . A D R , G J, - J (988, ).
A q - J, x C . T - x , ( ) . F , J,
M R q C (:) x N P J M (:6) q x .68W x, C J. W x M- , x.S- - J.
T lterry crtcsm J - B O (97) R. A C(98). T q J .69
66. F M D, J H. N 988.
67. M , D R 988, .68. B J. M R L. R 998, 70 .69. E.., D W. W 970. S , R K 977, 66. E
G OD F G (986) P D. D 98, G.
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
105/356
96 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
S J-
.70
W q F F G . S, . I , ( q) F G J C- .
T . ( ) , x x - ; , , x x. , E - x ( ) x x. I , . T x
mes , -, . M x, x - x .
H, , ( ) . S - . B , FG , J C . S, , J , . O .
O x - J . T P G (:; 6:; :) f - E J (M 99, :06). I , q
70. C, , Iterpretto FG: . (977) 9 (99); x- J .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
106/356
KYSAR: HE DEHISORICIZING OF HE GOSPEL OF JOHN 97
rrtve tme, (.., C-
98, 70).D x x , x.7
A ,7 . U , , J. I J , , , .7
. What Is History?
, J - - F G. I , G J C . H, .7 U ( !),
q J.7 F, , I J q , . O , . O . O , -, . W
7. S E V. MK 988, B C C,MK 99.
7. E.., C 998 OD 99.7. Wht Is Joh? F S
(996, 0; 998, 76) J . S - Seme (99), C S.
7. C L. B (00, 79) .
7. (00, 6)
: FE J,J , P, . I , q - J J J , , J .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
107/356
98 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
H, q: W S ,
, . S , , . A. K. M. A .76 A A , .77 G P , - - . W , , x q x .78
F F B -. H , , . I x bout :
[H] - x . H x - . tertextulty , .
W , ll o whchre ctol rrtves sturte wth the eologcl stces o the uthors.79 E- B : . F, - rrtve truth, .80
S , - - , , (A 99, 6). I , , ,
x , -. T x
76. A Mkg Sese o New estmet Teology(99). S q ; H 966, 0.
77. S D. M (989, 0)
, .78. G A. P (990, 8, ) x .
79. S F W. B 000, 06; q, 07.80. B 990, 6 ( ).
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
108/356
KYSAR: HE DEHISORICIZING OF HE GOSPEL OF JOHN 99
. T ,
(G H-P 000, 666). Cq, , .
T .H . I - x x merge the pst the
preset. (I B ) H, F G G . I x , (H-P 00).
I q , , , J I -
J. , F G ( , ) . C J C J C I 8
J L. S J Jesus Johe rto (00). W G , , S , . N G , -
8. I, , B F W (908, x)
, , x, ; q , . R , .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
109/356
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
110/356
KYSAR: HE DEHISORICIZING OF HE GOSPEL OF JOHN 0
I
, x I , .
CONCLUSION
N f .H, F G, ( M, M, L, J) x . I, . J, J, H . F , .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
111/356
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
112/356
he Spiritual Gospel: How Johnthe heologian Writes History
Mre Meye hompso
O B K , - q, W J J, J B q : B J G S G; , J , , -. I ,
, - , , . T J J J , J J , ,- (H998, 7). I - q .
I , B J . A , G ,
J G. - S G ; J , S ; J . B C - J G, , , . f G k wy . T , G , . C J u J ; ,
. A M W , [ F G] - (960, ).
-0-
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
113/356
0 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
J, G J,
. B - . q, , . H , , Jwe er egetlch gewese st, , E H ,J J C, (97, ).
P , J - . W , J. , : J , q. T , ot . T - , , , x, , - , . A x J . B , , ,
, , . H N , . A -, .
M , , q J J , J og -. T , G , x J . W x J J, J, J J . O q- J - ,
. M J B. G, :M C 988; P V 98; H W 987 ( 999); BS 990; A C 988; D L 98. E B 99.
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
114/356
HOMPSON: HE SPIRIUAL GOSPEL 0
. I , I
- . T J , , J J . I x ; I q .
F, J . W J, - , , x G.I q, J , J . A - D, B, , G x. I , J , , , , , , J , q J G . I
J ,
J - J.
S, J x , I G - . I x J- q J J. F, J, . M, : J, J S M , M, x S, I , (J :6). T M , S. S, 0, M, . A S, , A M- I J , , F G. I J M , , . T J . A J A. . R , M -
[J] C G (970, 98).B J .
7/31/2019 John, Jesus, And History. Volume 1, Critical Appraisals of Critical Views
115/356
06 JOHN, JESUS, AND HISORY
O . C J
, J . A , E. P. S (98, 7, 87) J x x x - I D . J ; . M, J ( , N, S ). T J , . R, J theologcl x . T - J , J q.
S, J ; , . H J J ,
I J , I - . I , , J J - , J I, G . J J , J , , , .
A q , , J J . I J J , , , . T J q J J . B J , J J . A , J , W her , see . A J, G,q I 6:90 , -
, q ,