_ _

II ~

r I I ~eP ~J-3 ~ E CEI VED

I E A Jf (IW ~JlmiddotI3~1

-___ __ _____ ~~_QTc Jff1-~ ~J~-I ~Dl~_~ __ _ __ __ __ __ __ I c~middot W~6trl_lKfUflrTDNCD ~_W~ t5lY t-d_ __

-- - ~_ JfIcK-~qAJ JF ~~UIX- J~~7-tCgt middotmc-()l~-2]-tf7kJ 1 i _ __UJJD ~r~ _CJF- _((~lb_~ _ ~ LO~~) = __ _ (Q_ i Q _(OJLjJ~_ _ _

__ fI-Q~S_ tPmiddot_iAlt_IMID -t fI~4-D()t)euE~~tpound- 11 __ __ InOT7DN foIt-~A~~~-AUD=P~v~r atJJIJFfJDAI------- --- ------- -- - - rl ----- -- --- - -~- - - -- ----shy

91JJezgt)J yene-tjB_(J() P~a()~7F(l~fI--ro~t-fJQ __~1JDl1 ~euro

~t1-~_~~~ltf ~13 eVrY-fljfr-poundlJeVec-mflb=j~

712~l~lFt~~~~-~Z~J-~~= ~Id JI-I~~1yen~a--=-gDI11i-~ 1JgrlLDtgtcn irt3JVWdF0()D~ )jS_JLpoundd(~~ s-~~c-~~D~J fI1JQ far7+-PIf-kJ+ -C171t~ l- ____ IH2Jl~olt-_O~e~ft)~m ro)jlT~l _ f)_~_7Jf15 ~L~~

~~rzi2Sn~~~~i~~5I~ -- -------- -- --- - --- --------- _LitLtf~_6~____ --- ------dJ --- -----shyC7gtD N ~~j~kft~ ilfJJf1 ~~oi2l1l271oJJjfI] lJI~c yenJo3 J157cv

i~7=l~fiEP=~~OP~~i- Ie Diz~IJzexcgtphLI(je~ om7J1-IJR~~~e__h~~

--- ______ _ _ _ _ _ __ u _ - - - - ----- _ -- - -- - - ----~--- - __ ____= __ _ ___ ______ ~- ___ - _ __ n_ - _ - - bull bull --- - 4

~ ~oiJ4 ~nJJ~~~(tff)LlJq jJ(nIS-rrJttEf)f-rJit _aflt ______ _iJ __ ~(ftJDl)~__c2r_C~ IJ~ fZgtLff itdfI~+~(~I~

_lJJlf10 ( DC-~~ffJM~___oJ _____ __ __ __ _________ ___ _ _ - __

~~~~~~~~~~euro~~v~~ - ii)filli ~ f=tlltD to~-i -5ffs-~~-t-iY--cf-fl fbmiN tcyC~

--951Vsa~ -

[1 i -shy

-~71J

21-L 5(1-(~ 11 7JOfU shy

~OLDElOlt ~I J 02tdJ-f ~LL sggtV ~2 11$7 sHLL aoF)4gz I 5ryOtt-~d (I Upcfl El~Q-L elL 5~K(VgtaXBILLflti1 lf7l~cI -10 ~rtsrcl -PCC(7

------fu--tl ~-srrOL-1Sl(7(p 31=tJ71d~71gttJ CJi1f I -pO (7 _

~PO-Vaz -tiP 50 ~~qL 7jHs~(7_ 5~-ut1r shy ----~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~---H-~~~j9-~~~~gt~CHriJ 0-fI(YJ shy

--~-p~rJ5r1~~QL~JOOIVa~ (f SHpoundi-_

7t1rntQJrt]IIJoTA]tnIlttUBJ-S-+I ~f)-DN Ciiql -bf-(lf -Q --rtlj--shy

L~1UipC to -fCl (Y~LEI~2--PfiLnf(amp -ClI

btJ-M-cte-YO -rW ~ OY ~W~c --rm -10 -~C-JtJ-I(7J 1pound

I) ~~)~((r=-ft 5-IIm Ii1-L12cJ S-rfJ-LflUlJI-OifJ FJmiddotJi3Id Orfl ~(LLU2-~W QL vavrlCt)sJcY ~5(f(JO5 ~110(1 ft 3-tLL LLLa(

I~VU~(1) (Y~ -I -~-gtWC O~ aJ-lt--7-OIl~ II ~r((lCL (l~uaC P C2L 3S(YCYSa()ttl p-jr~YfIJ--0ST-~bT-~7I ~ ortf

-C~~h-C1 JI oh (HIi1-L _lt=W$~C()oe P7op 39 CI7()O JrtHLLorY

j~~dC5~ 11 a-~tYt)q)_~OIV2~(-eJZ9) ffcfth ~ttd OL 7Jry~cy---rq)tfft7J~tJc ~Q(~~Jdeg7 fVO~Ll -EJ7LL OJ 3$(Ycysay ~I ~91tIJ)-~~ ~ 5Cn0(77 LL 3LLQTY

~1IJ---L2- 31LJ-(ntI7JCHW(YJ Jat-LzHd Qaaa~I rttI Onj ) cr-u-( -t7 -

~JiLLezfVo~~rt rvod(J filUJrvLJaS ~-fI-I-70 (09 Ii -Jl(fild

---~W() ~(l1cY 7J0I fVoJLJ2--J aL2 Cl-Lshy

-fjj)IiL gt-~ s(WC2 98 QL 2IOIWfiWLL 1atJ17 (-tld(2 ~-~ Aw ltJL35ry~JI V (1(OQ~II3 ~1I(fIfI-OQ-fjjfCf

~J~d-VLn JV-fLL CJ1-Cf)bl ~-e17J7O ~r7dH1 ~=u-=tt-~ -WS (jIm -Of70 lh1njO B7~5IWr~LLQffI 3KitW -vY i+L ____ __---=-__ I CT

middot-e-~I 01 (IOLL-1j CJ1() ~w OL-~r-COcJsal ~$ 1- 07cn-shy- ---p-p(l -=---a- -pt-o -rw oN I tUpj ~r(7 ~JI (r7 tiT b-----Cre~ ~u ~

pfiL tt-f m pound--IOC lcH YO 7--tI()~ Crt-I JUaCLII~-r(rJ[F Of EFiJ2L-to (yoLW7QIl sHii-NOLII iiCJ 3ItL QL P5HlI91(J ~(fS~

1i-1_ QrOOFiaKc(Hleff~Y~rYOO~-1J1Y 7deg~jtt~Le pound1 o-e eel art(pound e-~7 7-~1 orr SrtDJ YI~-

--951Vsa~ -

[1 i -shy

-~71J

21-L 5(1-(~ 11 7JOfU shy

~OLDElOlt ~I J 02tdJ-f ~LL sggtV ~2 11$7 sHLL aoF)4gz I 5ryOtt-~d (I Upcfl El~Q-L elL 5~K(VgtaXBILLflti1 lf7l~cI -10 ~rtsrcl -PCC(7

------fu--tl ~-srrOL-1Sl(7(p 31=tJ71d~71gttJ CJi1f I -pO (7 _

~PO-Vaz -tiP 50 ~~qL 7jHs~(7_ 5~-ut1r shy ----~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~---H-~~~j9-~~~~gt~CHriJ 0-fI(YJ shy

--~-p~rJ5r1~~QL~JOOIVa~ (f SHpoundi-_

7t1rntQJrt]IIJoTA]tnIlttUBJ-S-+I ~f)-DN Ciiql -bf-(lf -Q --rtlj--shy

L~1UipC to -fCl (Y~LEI~2--PfiLnf(amp -ClI

btJ-M-cte-YO -rW ~ OY ~W~c --rm -10 -~C-JtJ-I(7J 1pound

I) ~~)~((r=-ft 5-IIm Ii1-L12cJ S-rfJ-LflUlJI-OifJ FJmiddotJi3Id Orfl ~(LLU2-~W QL vavrlCt)sJcY ~5(f(JO5 ~110(1 ft 3-tLL LLLa(

I~VU~(1) (Y~ -I -~-gtWC O~ aJ-lt--7-OIl~ II ~r((lCL (l~uaC P C2L 3S(YCYSa()ttl p-jr~YfIJ--0ST-~bT-~7I ~ ortf

-C~~h-C1 JI oh (HIi1-L _lt=W$~C()oe P7op 39 CI7()O JrtHLLorY

j~~dC5~ 11 a-~tYt)q)_~OIV2~(-eJZ9) ffcfth ~ttd OL 7Jry~cy---rq)tfft7J~tJc ~Q(~~Jdeg7 fVO~Ll -EJ7LL OJ 3$(Ycysay ~I ~91tIJ)-~~ ~ 5Cn0(77 LL 3LLQTY

~1IJ---L2- 31LJ-(ntI7JCHW(YJ Jat-LzHd Qaaa~I rttI Onj ) cr-u-( -t7 -

~JiLLezfVo~~rt rvod(J filUJrvLJaS ~-fI-I-70 (09 Ii -Jl(fild

---~W() ~(l1cY 7J0I fVoJLJ2--J aL2 Cl-Lshy

-fjj)IiL gt-~ s(WC2 98 QL 2IOIWfiWLL 1atJ17 (-tld(2 ~-~ Aw ltJL35ry~JI V (1(OQ~II3 ~1I(fIfI-OQ-fjjfCf

~J~d-VLn JV-fLL CJ1-Cf)bl ~-e17J7O ~r7dH1 ~=u-=tt-~ -WS (jIm -Of70 lh1njO B7~5IWr~LLQffI 3KitW -vY i+L ____ __---=-__ I CT

middot-e-~I 01 (IOLL-1j CJ1() ~w OL-~r-COcJsal ~$ 1- 07cn-shy- ---p-p(l -=---a- -pt-o -rw oN I tUpj ~r(7 ~JI (r7 tiT b-----Cre~ ~u ~

pfiL tt-f m pound--IOC lcH YO 7--tI()~ Crt-I JUaCLII~-r(rJ[F Of EFiJ2L-to (yoLW7QIl sHii-NOLII iiCJ 3ItL QL P5HlI91(J ~(fS~

1i-1_ QrOOFiaKc(Hleff~Y~rYOO~-1J1Y 7deg~jtt~Le pound1 o-e eel art(pound e-~7 7-~1 orr SrtDJ YI~-

~--------=--~~-----)S-_~-3~r-_3 J15

-Y+-----

~

XJJ~

--------=---H----~~----=-lt

o oIJseL

~--=-----=-c~r__=_~~J--

_

()

~---=----~-----=R=--_ampI7+ 77Jlt3

_J~~-=--+l-J

~ [JJJe_jL ~(=i--ti J7~~ sgISrE Dec t- O IJ ~tiL2) ~ti

3~0on1 t-erI-rTm~ -- oe 1tfIDl)U~ 7)oe TO ___~otJH MlsfePf~eOTflriolJ t3v JS m~otJI)~_ _ _

Il-~ 1 (ilk)middot~ ______ 70 ~1 D~cJ ~~~ oltgtlFrr= yCgt()Z-_ _ _

Z-)JDer r bCIlrS hJD (2~r7f7tirJ IJJD~ DI- fH~rnilJ fecofLIJ To7--

-iE2C-JJC1 U)~HmJ Genc=tlt- db 7DDCJ I~~O ~ rut ~ __ o~ HUtJC~ Ifss~JJej) amp-JD HJD (7t-Igt(JU(lmiddotmiddotr8-GY

)-- --- -- - ----shyampt-o=--=-_Ite_ -~ ilf6 r1HJ (i ~3 ~ TO _

IoDalamp-~~ t9t-lgt71 e7H3 bull J ~

h-----=--e7-0--zJ=7J~r)~~f )IOmilJ p~MJ 7D IIJCUJ~~~ ___

--rJHL THJT ~71 ~ W3()uj- SO ~D~ _

1~C) OP71t- IJ7LE11tr J1-J Ilt- ltJIB) of- L~reT3 Bdo(-3r

_-raquo- DU wIJUt-O H-I+Ut ]2oJ-je- 71HS ~(j774_aJj)U) ~

KPtJuJP MOl( J1Ll1FemflmiioN Jc JJo 3--~tu= [i~ -JI1 J tgt13 WII1~)tUI~~ 0 urr fert-m~6Y (JJe I2t+

C-~ 2 ~ ltjD --rtt rll s amp-ltjLue=ci) ~7Je-U)UIYI TO fO 711-G

- __f+--~)M70~ J-JJIJ tfet~5()HJ~ HJJ)olC _

efmI viJ-rloJ of- urC feltn rr ND JfC- ~Z2 - trampO 9 I J) ~CUDeT)1) 711-e fl2)1v 5~UE tfeC6j()~_

Otfl~LampL~ I~ -Cgt13 tf~()~ MJ) T7~ 2gt3 hYgtZLJry)m 7tJS~O~l - 70 11euro amp- SusJ4-Ai

U(i P~IG- TlIJt4 I+YD~ 7 7~t tH-i e~(JOlJse- r~()rn m+etG JJo~RECslQllJ5llL

7 _gt c~fZ- lu-f ~amplJr1-1)lA-w1l-C cshy

)fil3I4JPOM T6 7~gPfZ f OI3 UIJ~7fpound cove f7rk~r ~l21) fZJV~I Jf~u~nJJ( i ~77FteV ~JJOet tgt ~ ~ eJJT1~el-1~mlJJ 1~-r~tJ6 ercgtKi) IJtgtlopee( (014 -yr Y Lj-o ~~tL~e-Q(Jesr(s)erflt cv~ o6t-~)~Y f~

I ~

~~---IIc=~o 70 77kf w~ ~e7

==--=--=-=H~- c- 1)10 hVD mye 0

T7D J S

~~~~~

-OS (3- 13-)- -[i) IJ~ (2 a-o~3--S_

0 f - I ------=-~-=++~ll5~e-verftY1 rr (L)JJDIT7DIJS- () Allgtid- IC Pdmrr (lQIo 1J ~-_~_

~~D~U7~ ~ ~~poundC __~__ dMP~ ~D 13-~

----==~_=____++_=_=_IteUJ J1 i~ 1J-Ld~tSrf) fb)iJe-Nf)() m_~nD~_ Dr YI1~~--42C2DT7Ji~ J9I1(JU~ IfULL-S IHJTJ 1J05j

~ ~ J1~~ lt) P~(ji- amp ML hrCf lM)cpound

------~~=t+- fHJ I] 2013_~e1duI ~IJ Y1 etJIKePc4- N (JtZ sTf--rff)CI17L) _ t )-rff-J-7 h ~ tAtn()iL Yf7)et IuDtJ)fl) rJfe ~fJfZ-trJ (~ Or=shy

_tiD b-MJ (lluX of- h4G -rul-t)cAUI D5 QJJ 7gt1 ~ ampJOJJT7LLJotff LK--r 0 rnmett kgtL bullbullbull ~ tvwU 11 IClr(campttJ frDo middot o ~)

_ r rO TJI-e ~JJ~PecmK- a~~~-ro D()etr7olJ11-U-To I

-+rk-

M2If Re-77HS UGl~

I rf- 1lIpound~~ 0e-el715 TlHS

~ MLlT~I~ ~D-ua~()tJf(l~s JJ TJfe-tJDJtv~ -n-vP lIJOCt- J 177pound ~ - er-k t

Sgt e t7

~ ) ar6 hit ~H7~~1 ~ gJ-C--(c- Tb Cil hJO (l) _ euro7J-t3Jamp1EJrJ6r hJO VPoiffrz 7lt= KGGDIQJ ~

-------H---~--=---=L 5~TD Poat1l ft1turc-i-l )_amp6e7fr W~_ ~C) 6~ SrrcI1kzIJ m eYSDo2ft ~recbC-ixJIJSe-C

UtAJ ) ~ LV ~ Jt 7D YlH~ It- 1II71IkJtC-IJq7cB-~ ePttlK IfuD U~Z-)J~ Re [7feClDIJI-shy

-~~~~~I~~~-~~)~poundn~3 mo-rro~2p~ 7(shy~ lt bull

-

e--zJJd~

prJ-tJ-ttJ$r

lD~ )Smlpound5Ivc J-nnt)~62L 1fev~ rK moor _ -shy ~ honciJs ~~ ~tgtrnftHmTO ruel ~611-cl-~L

~ 77ffl-7 fIfJIL Cshy 13 rtk~ D)f~~ or t1ff- I[ Q3 )_ I ===shy WI

Reinoue) m T7HE ~ fjuzsshyIJ-P

~L

T7D J S

~~~~~

-OS (3- 13-)- -[i) IJ~ (2 a-o~3--S_

0 f - I ------=-~-=++~ll5~e-verftY1 rr (L)JJDIT7DIJS- () Allgtid- IC Pdmrr (lQIo 1J ~-_~_

~~D~U7~ ~ ~~poundC __~__ dMP~ ~D 13-~

----==~_=____++_=_=_IteUJ J1 i~ 1J-Ld~tSrf) fb)iJe-Nf)() m_~nD~_ Dr YI1~~--42C2DT7Ji~ J9I1(JU~ IfULL-S IHJTJ 1J05j

~ ~ J1~~ lt) P~(ji- amp ML hrCf lM)cpound

------~~=t+- fHJ I] 2013_~e1duI ~IJ Y1 etJIKePc4- N (JtZ sTf--rff)CI17L) _ t )-rff-J-7 h ~ tAtn()iL Yf7)et IuDtJ)fl) rJfe ~fJfZ-trJ (~ Or=shy

_tiD b-MJ (lluX of- h4G -rul-t)cAUI D5 QJJ 7gt1 ~ ampJOJJT7LLJotff LK--r 0 rnmett kgtL bullbullbull ~ tvwU 11 IClr(campttJ frDo middot o ~)

_ r rO TJI-e ~JJ~PecmK- a~~~-ro D()etr7olJ11-U-To I

-+rk-

M2If Re-77HS UGl~

I rf- 1lIpound~~ 0e-el715 TlHS

~ MLlT~I~ ~D-ua~()tJf(l~s JJ TJfe-tJDJtv~ -n-vP lIJOCt- J 177pound ~ - er-k t

Sgt e t7

~ ) ar6 hit ~H7~~1 ~ gJ-C--(c- Tb Cil hJO (l) _ euro7J-t3Jamp1EJrJ6r hJO VPoiffrz 7lt= KGGDIQJ ~

-------H---~--=---=L 5~TD Poat1l ft1turc-i-l )_amp6e7fr W~_ ~C) 6~ SrrcI1kzIJ m eYSDo2ft ~recbC-ixJIJSe-C

UtAJ ) ~ LV ~ Jt 7D YlH~ It- 1II71IkJtC-IJq7cB-~ ePttlK IfuD U~Z-)J~ Re [7feClDIJI-shy

-~~~~~I~~~-~~)~poundn~3 mo-rro~2p~ 7(shy~ lt bull

-

e--zJJd~

prJ-tJ-ttJ$r

lD~ )Smlpound5Ivc J-nnt)~62L 1fev~ rK moor _ -shy ~ honciJs ~~ ~tgtrnftHmTO ruel ~611-cl-~L

~ 77ffl-7 fIfJIL Cshy 13 rtk~ D)f~~ or t1ff- I[ Q3 )_ I ===shy WI

Reinoue) m T7HE ~ fjuzsshyIJ-P

~L

UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY WASHINGTON DC 20460

OFFICE OF THE INSPECTOR GENERAL

May 14 13

Drive Brooklyn MI 49230

RE Hotline Number 201amp3-1

Ms Yerman

Thank you for your April Agency of

OIG Hotline Number 201 to document of your information COllcermlllg the West Bay Exploration Co Permit No MI-075-2D-0009 Information

~Hb to your concerns has been forwarded to the US Chicago Folloving this a determination will as to

appropriate course action

your interest in human health and the environment you have please do not hesitate to me at (202) address the Hotline is 1200 Pennsylvania Avenue NW MC 1 Washington 20460

UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY

REGION 5

77 WEST JACKSON BOULEVARD

CHICAGO IL 60604-3590

REPL Y TO THE ATTENTION OF MAILCODE

WU-16JJAN 1 4 2013

RE EPA Undergro~nd Injection Control Permit MI-07S-2D-0009 West Bay 22 Jackson County Michigan

Ms Yennan

We received your about the above) You may appeal the West ~H~~ltgtVH date in this case is Januar

mail on 9

pennit y 9 2013 13

22 irtiection well pennit date of the

it is the date at the top the document we senUo

You submitted comments on which is also notification

22 pennit You have now been sent a to decision to issue The notification we sent

you was dated and to you As described in 40 CFR Part 12419 The period which a person may request review under with the service of notice of the

action unless a later date is specified in that notice In your case EPA contends notice was 92013

For further information on how to appeal and to 40 sect 124 19(a) only to the service of notice date for you and does not create a IS any other commenter

answers any about the a permit If you have call me at (312) 886-7060 or contact me via email to miUerannaepagov or fax

to (312) 697-2049

Anna Miller

Branch

UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY

REGION 5

77 WEST JACKSON BOULEVARD

CHICAGO IL 60604-3590

REPL Y TO THE ATTENTION OF MAILCODE

WU-16JJAN 1 4 2013

RE EPA Undergro~nd Injection Control Permit MI-07S-2D-0009 West Bay 22 Jackson County Michigan

Ms Yennan

We received your about the above) You may appeal the West ~H~~ltgtVH date in this case is Januar

mail on 9

pennit y 9 2013 13

22 irtiection well pennit date of the

it is the date at the top the document we senUo

You submitted comments on which is also notification

22 pennit You have now been sent a to decision to issue The notification we sent

you was dated and to you As described in 40 CFR Part 12419 The period which a person may request review under with the service of notice of the

action unless a later date is specified in that notice In your case EPA contends notice was 92013

For further information on how to appeal and to 40 sect 124 19(a) only to the service of notice date for you and does not create a IS any other commenter

answers any about the a permit If you have call me at (312) 886-7060 or contact me via email to miUerannaepagov or fax

to (312) 697-2049

Anna Miller

Branch

bull ---J

adT7h~ of- ~tct= ~y cdq (1Hf=1C0f16 tJh1ft fD~u~--

poundv -r1~c~tl~17~ (3-~~~ t ~p - ~(J~MmDIJ~w~~ ~ P--

middot w4~~ ~ ~WJJpoundffiirt~rtif(Klt mAIL

f~JCi7 7fd~-rON S-fk+g IJI ~ n~ UsIf R~DJj ~

~ 11 oJ ~(fq-~()AJ W() fraquo~ I1j exPutM-tO-J~D ~ _ G(Hu1-M rL (P()~6cf

Ir~~w~6RY ~fO~D~ vitelamp cJf-71~ tfolh4)

1tW~G c-ITY JrC11~f4 _ U~eP(J- - G1f--6

~t~~(~~~~ilplusmn~~~i= bull~~ r=trful)(c-f~~

CiH ~JZL (0 (pO t l - -

SiJ~ IW II-eDMJ jfeampvLIIG ~m I J 97CIfrbrL-

middot1tt)tktiert0) bull bull r~ 2 )03

c-1ft 1- __ r~ t 0 ~ C-cf - -shy --I _ - - --

I

SlHJfJUJ- Pr-o~ElL