Upload
mimem
View
219
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
1/29
!"!"!"!"
#!$$%&%$""$!!$" $$ ' !"( $"! "$" $ $ !")*+, +-.-($!" $( !" /!((!"( $!" !$ $&( $ $$($"$"" !" '!'!$/+-01!+021)3$"
!" ' 4"$ $"& $!5$" "( '' $'"'"64"$$( !$")# $ " 6! "' "& !
" "$!78$!"! $"$" 9'6' "$)*:, ' " !"!" "" '"' $ "!
" "! ' " ! "$ ')$($$($'$$!")
Portrait of Japanese Meiji Emperor
in military garb, in the Ottoman
Turkish journalResimli Gazete
circa 1892.
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
2/29
#'$$!$'$""$$!$)*;,"!!"""!"$'$""!!$!!"%"(%!5
Frequently published image of the admired Japanese
Admiral To o, hero of the Russo-Ja anese War.
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
3/29
"'"!9!$"&&'!!64"$$!"!)#$""#$""#$""#$""
'!""$$""!$!"$""$"$$!!")3($$$6$"!$K'!"""
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
4/29
$!''''$"!"$''5''$A!B)!"("$"$!"'"$!D!"5"($""
$"$(5"$$$$("""$""5!$!($($!"!)$"'!$$!"$!$"9/4!")$!$"($D(!"'")
D!""D!"@"44$!"!!'!"
Article on the Japanese Emperor and Russian Czar appearing in JurjZa dns Arabic scientific,literar ""6H""+02?)
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
5/29
!"('!'9'"9""!$(!$5$$""$!'"!"$!'"$
)H'"$')"9""('5!'"$!$("MN($""!"$"""'!("'$/&!+021)*+:,#D!"$"$(/"""
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
6/29
(%$$""95$$($'$$A!)B*:2,
'"$"$$"($"!$!%$!>!!")
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
7/29
>!"'($"$!!(!!"'"$!"$!!"$$$!"$"! =((''")
Q" $"(" )'"")
$)'""!$!!(!!( "!!$""""6 "$("9)*:.,#7#8($$$("$%!"("6!>K"6H""(!"D/)*:E,$"/"6>''""D!+021!6'G$F'
3$6!/"$95/!!$('!"!%!"!"%$$!$!)*:-,#$"O+02-"!
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
8/29
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
9/29
"(>!""' A'""'('!P""'" "PB4!$$"!"6J(9 "!)*;-,
3"6U(A""'B7$"!A=""'"B8'"!'A"B!("!(!$$('$!"5$!"!)/!'$$""'$"$('")"6U'!''"$!!6")*;0,"$"$"$"$
#+02-$!""!!"!$"""$4"$"D!"6/")4(3$"!!$&!"$!"$"!)3"""'!"!$!!"")*;0,4'$!('(">!"!"
$9!)#$'"!$$!""!"'!"$$'"$"$$!"!"$$'4"$6")4=!#!9"!+02-(""6"5!$$$!5$!"$(!""!"")I'$!"!"$"!"$"$'!)*?2,D!9'"+-E.$!
'"'!"$("$"$""$!"$"'$"$%!$'!"!$5$'("$")#!'"""$"'5$$!"'"'!$5"
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
10/29
"$"$"!!$
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
11/29
#$!"!+020!$$'$'$A64"$B$/)/4!"(U"W!$$!)*?.,#"$!6$!!""
!"@"44)!$"""$!$&(/($&"$"!'""!""($$!6H""76/8!)$"'$$$'$+020)*?E,#!"/!>!"!$"$""D!""""$"$""""""$$"7''8'A""B'7#!98"$$!
!"D)*?-,#$"&+020($"!$$"!'A!6(B$!"$"$$""6$")U"W!!"/!!64"$("$$"#!9"!/"$""6#!9(!"!")*?0,I"(H"!"'9=!#!9'5$$"69#!9
/("#!9("(!(($)#6!"""5"($"!"'"964"$$(!!$!"("#!9")*12,#!'$'!/"$($"+0++""$"$""F7H@"N8!"$
''!"$$/")*1+,""!'"$9'>!""$""'"!$!D$""!$"6V""64"&%$$+020$"""6X))#$9"'!'""(!"!$6D
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
12/29
!$")*1:,#!$""6V"$!$$#!9!!'5$""9%!)
96@"9!!!$$9"'"($/)*1;,$/$'"$5$")(5$'($!$!"$"$$"$)D'""$$&$"(!"!$$!!"(/"$!!$$
!$5)#!'!"$$!$%!"')*1?,/"5$$!$>!$)35"(""$"$"(!KU!V"$!'"6!>$"$$&"#!9"!$!"!"+020)*11,/6/+0++'(*1.,''!$"!('!'7!'"68+020$!$)4'$"+0+;!
"6X('D!9"6)")*1E,U!V""'$"/"$$G!$!"6!>($'!7$!""/"85$!+0+1O+.""'$!!"$!"+0+E)*1-,$"""$!"'!"$"5$"!$$!!"$!)
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
13/29
"$($D"($$"$""""G($&$"$!!C4"(X!Y!K(6
4"$$"&(4"$"C""'$'!"""$5)"$"$$$"$!$$!"$"!$'"!$!"!(!"!$')4A3!!(B!"KZ"6LF%!""6V4+0+2(!'$"!"'!"!!'"'!$!'!"!
(")*.2,$A(!"!!"$(*,!""""(5$("(!!")B*.+,4"$9'7!P8$!"$!$!$")#!$"( ''$'! !('!!(!'!"
!( ""5(" !!"!")*.:,3'(!'""('!"""'""$$$"&)#!""'"$'$&(""$$$(
"""$'!" $$"!("$ !!"('('" !$$)*.;,#'!"!""'&$!'!!$$!
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
14/29
"!$"$)#!'""'"($"5"!"!$!"")*.?,""!''"$96
!$!"('(A9""($)F("$"($!"$$!)B*.1,$""$!"'"!"$$!!'$!"($("6")#$$!!"""!"!($!$!$"$78"!!$
9$$!('/!"($"A$!B!"&4"$$!"!)$(""!!!)4A#9(B!!"$$""!!")""($!"""$$$("($')*..,D!"!"(!!"!"$$$$"")*.E,
4"$$"'''!!"!!!!$"!"G$'!$!!"'"!$"&)'$!"6!>$!""$'!$$!""!$!"!9'"$"$$&!)*.-,
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
15/29
"$$$)*.0,/"$G$!"$"$!"!)*E2,#!"%$!$'A!!"""!$"'$$$(B!
$$"9)*E+,4"'"(!""!7'8(!$$$"$!$)#!$$''$'"$>!9'"!"$"G'"")$$'%!""6!>(U!V"9'"""$"&'"("!)H"""$"&"
$$"5$$($"&)*E:,#"'$$!"!')#$'!!!$9'"'$$!"!')#!$!6$$"&'$!""$$!"!'$'!"!$""$"&(A)B*E;,#$"&'!"$$$"('"$!"!"!)/$"$$"
"!"'$!")U!V""$"$$!("$'$!"'9)*E?,U!V"$$""$"""'"!$!"!'")*E1,!"$!$)U!V"$"!$$$""!$'!"$$/"$(!
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
16/29
6!""!')4!$$"AI"!$(B5" #>!!$$">! '"))))I"7'J8!$
!$$!$("!( $!(")
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
17/29
$""$#!9#!9$")*-2,4''$!"$#!9$$$)3('"!$!$)4'$(!
5$$!"!(("!(64"$$"&(''($9)IIII#$"'""!"7)8(#4"$"$((
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
18/29
$$$"('!!$$!)4((!$9'"$$"$!""!"$)#!"((VV"9$!"!")#!$$9""
"(($!"$!"!)))V"$!"!")B/%(#I3/""6/""H7$$(+00;8(.)*;,D/"7F"/"(+00-8$""$($"A"$"""'""""""6$$B7-8$!$$A"$""'!""$$!$"$!"'"!"B708)""$>!>!$""!
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
19/29
$""'$"6$!$7$"!"""$(5"8(!"$$!$$!(>!(&("!'$$$"!('
$")*E,D/3(A/35D(B""H)H""F)$'"7)8I"I6I"D#"!(7/"!!D(+0EE8)*-,D"(#"H7I'=95(+0018(:-O.0($"$'$$!)
*0,"(1;)*+2,"6!>K"6H""%!'!!/6'%!">!"!"$""$$!$"!!!6)!"$7"8$"!KYV"6Y!KKUY""6F'Y)*++,F$9$$"!"$!"!!$!
/!(!!"!$'$$)#$!$!($'$!"$"A"B$$!$(9$"'$"')3'"A/$$(+-E.O+0+-B7)))(/$(:22+8($E(A(/!")B*+:,"$D!"@"44
54!"!$F(4)H("3$W&"N9@NWI@M(+02+7!$.+..8GWWDN()I!GDNN()I3$GUR9DN(!)
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
20/29
*+;,
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
21/29
+020D(F("((D$$$($!$D)B#$"HJ&K4YYA#(B'$!"&$!$"'!")*:2,A#*,$"!$$$B''"A$!($(""$($""("
"$$)B
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
22/29
*:-,D!3F!4"(A!(B"6>-():7+1!+0218?0O1E(!3=!Y!U"Y"(A"6HJ'YY"6D"6Y(B"6>-():7+1!+0218E;O-:)*:0,D!3YY"F!Y$9(AI&KVZYK'Y""6=YY(B"6
>E()17+$+02?8+0;O:2?)H$$$A"6($($("&($!"$$$($"'$$79'"8(9B7+0.8)*;2,F!Y$9(:2:)*;+,F!Y$9(:2+)*;:,=!#!95"!'!>!"!
"$$$$D!"!$$$!")D)@9@H"!#=!#!97I'=95(+0018"!7I'=95(:22+8)3"'6!%$((AVD$9!VI(B:2EO;2)*;;,4!F'!((A$!4)B*;?,D5""!!KKYF!K"6"!YKYA"6HJ""Y>"6#YB*#/5
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
23/29
*;1,#'#!9'H"W$'"$'"#A4+021("""$!"'"9('$(HH9!""#("(
'!)B""(H"W(H"7I'=9(+0E:8(:+0)*;.,3
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
24/29
*;0,">Z"6HJ787/K"69Y(+02.8(.-)("!"YKY4"'"6Y)
*;0,#""'$"'$$!""6$$'$!'7))5(95('8)#5$""$"''"!$!"$!)4!""!%$("!!$"(""$!("!$$)*?2,HU"W(=!#!9((4"(+02-O+0+-7!"#!9G!+-0.96@"9$$"'!"$"$)H"$"$"($"!qimakmI&+020("$"+0++)D9">!!AD$Q$"I'"3"DF$!"(B")!)"7)8(D!4"$D$
/!"
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
25/29
'!"(!($$$$"$"!D$)B*??,DKayal,;0O1+($$=!#!9)
*?1,Kayal(1.O1E)*?.,Kayal(E0)*?E,Kayal(E.)*?-,DD9"(-?O-1(5""$'$)
*?0,#""!"!!'$/'#!9#!9"")!$$!!!/$"&"$$$!$"$"(6$""A#!9$B"$)Kayal7-:O0.8$"!!$!5"$!"#!9"!$!"""+-E./!"!"#!9$""!>!!!""($"'$'!"!+02-G#!9'!"'$!"!%$
"$"'!"$"!!$$!$+02-G+020'!"$"!""$!("$"$"$!"!!"70+O0:8)4+0+;/""'#!9!$"$!(>!$"$9'$('$$$"$($$$"("$"!7
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
26/29
!5""$"$+020+0++)D$!"0.O++1)*1:,(B4""$!"F(+-02O+0;0()')
7
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
27/29
*.2,!KV"Y(A!>""6D>(B"6V4Y(1$+0+2(?2:(:("6V4Y(;I+0+2(?.EO.-)*.+,V"(A!>""6D>(B?.-)
*.:,V"(A!>""6D>(B:(?E2)*.;,DYVYY(A#Y!""6=YYY"6Y(B*""!"A#F!B,"6V4Y(;2+0++(?;;)*.?,DYVYY(A#Y!""6=YYY"6YY(B?;;):$"("6V4Y(+;!+0++(?.+O.?($"$D(/!$(
A"!)B*.1,DYVYY(A#Y!""6=YYY"6Y(B"6V4Y(+;!+0++(?.?)*..,!Y=>!Y(AYY9YV"6YY(B"6!>7"68(:E$+020A!""('"''!!9$$)#5"(''$"&5
"$'")!"""'(!'9!!!9$('$$')#!5")""'(''$9!$"&'!"'!'")))'!"&'!"!$!)))!"'$9''!''')#9!$!$"&''"$!!"$!$$)#'
$($(!"'$('(53'$!")'9*,P('''$!!$!!""!!!$!"!)#!'G9'5$"'$$!7
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
28/29
$8)#'"9$($!"(*,$'&9'!!)B
*.E,!$"$)DA"6YY(B"6!>7"68($:0(+020)D"LY9Y!Y(AD!!Y'D!%!Y(B"6!>(!++(+0+2GA"6YY"6=YY(B"6V4Y(:0$+0+;(?0O1+)*.-,D!KU!V"Y(A"6#"Y"6YY"6=YY(B%"""6!>0().7+0++8101O0.)H'"'+-024"$!$"!$"""$"""'(!"("!A!'$"
$!"$)))!9$!""$$$)B710.8)H$A!(!$"""$)4$"!"$'$'"!"!%$B710E8)*.0,4)(10.)*E2,A#$!"""")#9!"G*",$("
"$!)#9"")#5$$(9""$!$!)#'65$!!9)4'"$>!("!"$!!$'!%!$>!)B74)(10E)8#
8/14/2019 Japans Progress Reified: Modernity and Arab Dissent in the Ottoman Empire, by Rene Worringer
29/29
*E?,!KU!V"Y(A"6=YY"6HJY(B%"""6!>;().7+0++8::.)*E1,H$$"""$!"'$"($"!%!"D$9!(
#!9(U!('')D!U!"("U""#7()/)/!$"$FD$(+01?8(+.(12(02O0;($!$#!9%!"/"N"IMS