21
#A46 INTEGERS 18 (2018) JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND CONGRUENCES FOR BINOMIAL COEFFICIENTS Maxie D. Schmidt School of Mathematics, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, Georgia [email protected] ; [email protected] Received: 2/11/17, Revised: 2/20/18, Accepted: 5/12/18, Published: 5/18/18 Abstract We prove two new forms of Jacobi-type J-fraction expansions generating the bino- mial coecients, ( x+n n ) and ( x n ) , over all n 0. Within the article we establish new forms of integer congruences for these binomial coecient variations modulo any (prime or composite) h 2 and compare our results with known identities for the binomial coecients modulo primes p and prime powers p k . We also prove new exact formulas for these binomial coecient cases from the expansions of the h th convergent functions to the infinite J-fraction series generating these coecients for all n. 1. Introduction 1.1. Congruences for Binomial Coecients Modulo Primes and Prime Powers There are many well-known results providing congruences for the binomial coe- cients modulo primes and prime powers. For example, we can state Lucas’s theorem in the following form for p prime and n, m 2 N where n = n 0 + n 1 p + ··· + n d p d and m = m 0 + m 1 p + ··· + m d p d for 0 n i ,m i <p [3]: n m n 0 m 0 ◆✓ n 1 m 1 ··· n d m d (mod p). (Lucas’ Theorem) We also have known results providing decompositions, or reductions of order, of the next binomial coecients modulo the prime powers, p k [5]: np k + n 0 mp k + m 0 np mp ◆✓ n 0 m 0 (mod p k ). Similarly, we can decompose linear and quadratic (and more general) polynomial inputs to the lower binomial coecient indices as the congruence factors given by

JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND ...math.colgate.edu/~integers/s46/s46.pdf#A46 INTEGERS 18 (2018) JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND CONGRUENCES FOR BINOMIAL COEFFICIENTS Maxie

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND ...math.colgate.edu/~integers/s46/s46.pdf#A46 INTEGERS 18 (2018) JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND CONGRUENCES FOR BINOMIAL COEFFICIENTS Maxie

#A46 INTEGERS 18 (2018)

JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND CONGRUENCESFOR BINOMIAL COEFFICIENTS

Maxie D. SchmidtSchool of Mathematics, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, Georgia

[email protected] ; [email protected]

Received: 2/11/17, Revised: 2/20/18, Accepted: 5/12/18, Published: 5/18/18

AbstractWe prove two new forms of Jacobi-type J-fraction expansions generating the bino-mial coe�cients,

�x+nn

�and

�xn

�, over all n � 0. Within the article we establish

new forms of integer congruences for these binomial coe�cient variations moduloany (prime or composite) h � 2 and compare our results with known identities forthe binomial coe�cients modulo primes p and prime powers pk. We also prove newexact formulas for these binomial coe�cient cases from the expansions of the hth

convergent functions to the infinite J-fraction series generating these coe�cients forall n.

1. Introduction

1.1. Congruences for Binomial Coe�cients Modulo Primes and PrimePowers

There are many well-known results providing congruences for the binomial coe�-cients modulo primes and prime powers. For example, we can state Lucas’s theoremin the following form for p prime and n,m 2 N where n = n0 + n1p + · · · + ndpd

and m = m0 + m1p + · · · + mdpd for 0 ni,mi < p [3]:✓

n

m

◆⌘✓

n0

m0

◆✓n1

m1

◆· · ·✓

nd

md

◆(mod p). (Lucas’ Theorem)

We also have known results providing decompositions, or reductions of order, of thenext binomial coe�cients modulo the prime powers, pk [5]:

✓npk + n0

mpk + m0

◆⌘✓

np

mp

◆✓n0

m0

◆(mod pk).

Similarly, we can decompose linear and quadratic (and more general) polynomialinputs to the lower binomial coe�cient indices as the congruence factors given by

Page 2: JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND ...math.colgate.edu/~integers/s46/s46.pdf#A46 INTEGERS 18 (2018) JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND CONGRUENCES FOR BINOMIAL COEFFICIENTS Maxie

INTEGERS: 18 (2018) 2

[5, §3.2]:✓

np

rp + s

◆⌘ (r + 1)

✓n

r + 1

◆✓p

s

◆(mod p2),

✓np

mp2 + rp + s

◆⌘ (m + 1)

✓n

m + 1

◆✓p2

rp + s

◆(mod p3).

Within the context of this article, we are motivated to establish meaningful, non-trivial integer congruences for the two indeterminate binomial coe�cient sequencevariants,

�x+nn

�and

�xn

�, modulo both prime and composite bases h � 2 by using

new expansions of the Jacobi-type continued fractions generating these binomialcoe�cient variants that we prove in Section 2 and in Section 3. The next subsectionestablishes related known continued fractions and integer congruence properties forthe general forms of Jacobi-type J-fractions of which our new results are specialcases.

1.2. Jacobi-Type Continued Fraction Expansions

1.2.1. Continued Fractions Generating the Binomial Coe�cients

In this article, we study new properties and congruence relations satisfied by theinteger-order binomial coe�cients through two specific, and apparently new, Jacobi-type continued fraction expansions of a formal power series in z. The expansions ofthese J-fractions are similar in form to a known Stieltjes-type continued fraction,or S-fraction, expansion given in Wall’s book as [10, p. 343]

(1 + z)k =1

1�kz

1 +1·(1+k)

1·2 z

1 +1·(1�k)

2·3 z

1 +2(2+k)

3·4 z

1 + · · · .

(Binomial Series S-Fraction)

1.2.2. Jacobi-Type J-Fractions for Generalized Factorial Functions

The loosely-termed “non-exponential” forms of a generalized class of binomial-coe�cient-related generalized factorial functions, pn(↵, R), defined as,

pn(↵, R) := R(R + ↵)(R + 2↵) · · · (R + (n� 1)↵),

where the special cases of n! = pn(�1, n),�xn

�⌘ (�1)n(�x)n/n!, and pn(↵, R)/n! ⌘

(�↵)n ·��R/↵

n

�when (x)n = x(x+1) · · · (x+n�1) denotes the Pochhammer symbol,

are studied in [9]. Exponential generating functions for the generalized symbolic

Page 3: JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND ...math.colgate.edu/~integers/s46/s46.pdf#A46 INTEGERS 18 (2018) JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND CONGRUENCES FOR BINOMIAL COEFFICIENTS Maxie

INTEGERS: 18 (2018) 3

product functions, pn(↵, R), with respect to n, are known and given in closed-formby

Xn�0

pn(↵, R + 1)zn

n!= (1� ↵z)�(R+1)/↵ ,

where the corresponding generalized forms of the Stirling numbers of the first kind,or ↵-factorial coe�cients, are defined by the generating functions [8, cf. §2-3]

Xn�0

[Rm]pn(↵, R + 1)zn

n!=

(�1)m↵�m

m!⇥ (1� ↵z)

1↵ ⇥ Log(1� ↵z)m, for m 2 Z+.

The power series expansions of the ordinary generating functions for these factorialfunctions, which typically converge only for z = 0 when the parameter R is afunction of n, are defined formally in [9] by infinite J-fractions of the form

Conv1 (↵, R; z) =1

1�R · z �↵R · z2

1� (R + 2↵) · z �2↵(R + ↵) · z2

1� (R + 4↵) · z �3↵(R + 2↵) · z2

· · · .

These typically divergent ordinary generating functions are usually only expanded aspower series in z by “regularized” Borel sums involving reciprocal powers of z (and↵z) such as those given as examples in the introduction to [9]. This reference provesnew identities for the generalized factorial functions pn(↵, R) by considering thecoe�cients of the rational hth convergents to the divergent power series defined onlyformally by the previous equation which are 2h–order accurate in approximatingthese generating functions. We employ a similar approach to enumerating newexact identities and congruence properties of the binomial coe�cients in this articlebased on a formal treatment of the rational convergents to the generating functionsdefined by two special cases of the infinite Jacobi-type J-fractions defined in thenext subsection.

1.2.3. Properties of the Expansions of General J-Fraction Series

More generally, Jacobi-type J-fractions correspond to power series defined by infi-nite continued fraction expansions of the form

J [1](z) =1

1� c1z �ab1 z2

1� c2z �ab2 z2

· · · ,

(J-Fraction Expansions)

for some sequences {ci}i�1 and {abi}i�1, and some (typically formal) series variablez 2 C [6, cf. §3.10] [10, 1, 2]. The formal series enumerated by special cases of the

Page 4: JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND ...math.colgate.edu/~integers/s46/s46.pdf#A46 INTEGERS 18 (2018) JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND CONGRUENCES FOR BINOMIAL COEFFICIENTS Maxie

INTEGERS: 18 (2018) 4

truncated and infinite continued fraction series of this form include ordinary (asopposed to typically closed-form exponential) generating functions for many oneand two-index combinatorial sequences including the generalized factorial functionsstudied in [1, 2, 4, 9].

The hth convergents, Convh(z), to the J-fraction expansions of the form in theprevious equation have several useful characteristic properties:

(A) The hth convergent functions exactly enumerate the coe�cients of the infinitecontinued fraction series as [zn]J [1](z) = [zn] Convh(z) for all 0 n < 2h.

(B) The convergent function component numerator and denominator sequencesare each easily defined recursively by the same second-order recurrence inh with di↵ering initial conditions. The hth convergent functions are alwaysrational in z which implies an “eventually periodic” nature to their coe�cients,as well as h-order finite di↵erence equations satisfied by the coe�cients of thesetruncated series approximations.

(C) If Mh := ab1 · · · abh denotes the hth modulus of the generalized J-fractionexpansion defined above, the sequence of coe�cients enumerated by the hth

convergent function is eventually periodic modulo Mh and satisfies a finitedi↵erence equation of order at most h [2, Thm. 1]. Moreover, if Mm is integer-valued and h � 2 divides Mm for some m � h, then [zn]J [1] ⌘ [zn] Convm(z)(mod h) [4, §5.7].

Typically we are only interested in the congruences formed by the hth convergentfunctions for the coe�cients of zn the infinite series, J [1](z) in z for 0 n h, which are in fact exactly enumerated by these convergent functions. Otherproperties of the convergent functions, such as finite di↵erence equations satisfiedby their coe�cients, suggest other non-obvious and non-trivial properties of theresulting congruences guaranteed by the convergent functions.

1.3. Organization of the Article

We provide two new forms of infinite J-fractions generating the binomial coe�cients,�x+nn

�and

�xn

�, for n � 0 and any non-zero indeterminate x in the next sections of the

article. These new continued fraction results lead to new exact formulas and finitedi↵erence equations for these binomial coe�cient variants, and new congruences forthe binomial coe�cients modulo any (prime or composite) integers h � 2 whenever

12h

✓x + h� 1

h� 1

◆✓x

h� 1

◆/

✓2h� 3h� 2

◆2

2 Z.

Addition formulas for these J-fractions imply new identities for reductions of orderof the upper index, x, comparable to the statements of Lucas’ theorem and theother results modulo primes p and prime powers pk given in Section 1.1.

Page 5: JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND ...math.colgate.edu/~integers/s46/s46.pdf#A46 INTEGERS 18 (2018) JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND CONGRUENCES FOR BINOMIAL COEFFICIENTS Maxie

INTEGERS: 18 (2018) 5

The proofs of these new continued fraction expansions mostly follow by inductivearguments applied to known recurrence relations for the hth numerator and denom-inator convergent function sequences. The proofs that these infinite J-fraction ex-pansions exactly enumerate our binomial coe�cient variants of interest follow fromthe rationality of the hth convergent functions in z for all h � 1. Consequences ofthe proofs of our main theorems include new exact formulas for the binomial coe�-cients,

�x+nn

�and

�xn

�, and new congruence properties for these binomial coe�cient

variants. Since the proofs of the corresponding results in each case given in Section2 and Section 3, respectively, are so similar, we give careful proofs of the results forthe case of the J-fractions generating

�x+nn

�in the first section, and choose to only

state the analogous results for the case of�xn

�in the second section below for clarity

of exposition.

h P1,h(x, z)

0 0

1 1

2 1 + 1�x3 z

3 1� 25 (x� 2)z + 1

20 (x� 2)(x� 1)z2

4 1� 37 (x� 3)z + 1

14 (x� 3)(x� 2)z2 � 1210 (x� 3)(x� 2)(x� 1)z3

5 1� 49 (x� 4)z + 1

12 (x� 4)(x� 3)z2 � 1126 (x� 4)(x� 3)(x� 2)z3 + (x�4)(x�3)(x�2)(x�1)

3024 z4

6 1� 511 (x� 5)z + 1

11 (x� 5)(x� 4)z2 � 199 (x� 5)(x� 4)(x� 3)z3 + (x�5)(x�4)(x�3)(x�2)

1584 z4

� (x�5)(x�4)(x�3)(x�2)(x�1)55440 z5

h (2h� 1)! · P1,h(x, z)

0 0

1 1

2 6� 2(x� 1)z

3 120� 48(x� 2)z2 + 6(x� 2)(x� 1)z2

4 5040� 2160(x� 3)z + 360(x� 3)(x� 2)z2 � 24(x� 3)(x� 2)(x� 1)z3

5 362880� 161280(x� 4)z + 30240(x� 4)(x� 3)z2 � 2880(x� 4)(x� 3)(x� 2)z3

+ 120(x� 4)(x� 3)(x� 2)(x� 1)z4

6 39916800� 18144000(x� 5)z + 3628800(x� 5)(x� 4)z2 � 403200(x� 5)(x� 4)(x� 3)z3

+ 25200(x� 5)(x� 4)(x� 3)(x� 2)z4 � 720(x� 5)(x� 4)(x� 3)(x� 2)(x� 1)z5

Table 1: The Numerator Convergent Functions, P1,h(x, z), Generating the BinomialCoe�cients,

�x+nn

Page 6: JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND ...math.colgate.edu/~integers/s46/s46.pdf#A46 INTEGERS 18 (2018) JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND CONGRUENCES FOR BINOMIAL COEFFICIENTS Maxie

INTEGERS: 18 (2018) 6

h Q1,h(x, z)

1 1 + (x + 1)z

2 1 + 23 (x + 2)z + 1

6 (x + 1)(x + 2)z2

3 1 + 35 (x + 3)z + 3

20 (x + 2)(x + 3)z2 + 160 (x + 1)(x + 2)(x + 3)z3

4 1 + 47 (x + 4)z + 1

7 (x + 3)(x + 4)z2 + 2105 (x + 2)(x + 3)(x + 4)z3

+ 1840 (x + 1)(x + 2)(x + 3)(x + 4)z4

5 1 + 59 (x + 5)z + 5

36 (x + 4)(x + 5)z2 + 5252 (x + 3)(x + 4)(x + 5)z3 + 5(x+2)(x+3)(x+4)(x+5)

3024 z4

+ (x+1)(x+2)(x+3)(x+4)(x+5)15120 z5

6 1 + 611 (x + 6)z + 3

22 (x + 5)(x + 6)z2 + 299 (x + 4)(x + 5)(x + 6)z3

+ 1528 (x + 3)(x + 4)(x + 5)(x + 6)z4 + (x+2)(x+3)(x+4)(x+5)(x+6)

9240 z5

+ (x+1)(x+2)(x+3)(x+4)(x+5)(x+6)332640 z6

h (2h� 1)! · Q1,h(x, z)

1 1 + (x + 1)z

2 6 + 4(x + 2)z + (x + 1)(x + 2)z2

3 120 + 72(x + 3)z + 18(x + 2)(x + 3)z2 + 2(x + 1)(x + 2)(x + 3)z3

4 5040 + 2880(x + 4)z + 720(x + 3)(x + 4)z2 + 96(x + 2)(x + 3)(x + 4)z3

+ 6(x + 1)(x + 2)(x + 3)(x + 4)z4

5 362880 + 201600(x + 5)z + 50400(x + 4)(x + 5)z2 + 7200(x + 3)(x + 4)(x + 5)z3

+ 600(x + 2)(x + 3)(x + 4)(x + 5)z4 + 24(x + 1)(x + 2)(x + 3)(x + 4)(x + 5)z5

6 39916800 + 21772800(x + 6)z + 5443200(x + 5)(x + 6)z2 + 806400(x + 4)(x + 5)(x + 6)z3

+ 75600(x + 3)(x + 4)(x + 5)(x + 6)z4 + 4320(x + 2)(x + 3)(x + 4)(x + 5)(x + 6)z5

+ 120(x + 1)(x + 2)(x + 3)(x + 4)(x + 5)(x + 6)z6

Table 2: The Denominator Convergent Functions, Q1,h(x, z), Generating the Bino-mial Coe�cients,

�x+nn

2. J-Fraction Expansions for the Binomial Coe�cients,�x+n

n

Definition 1 (Component Sequences and Convergent Functions for�x+n

n

�).

For a non-zero indeterminate x, let the sequences, c(1)x,i and ab(1)

x,i , be defined overi � 1 as follows:

c(1)x,i := � 1

(2i� 1)(2i� 3)(1 + 2(i� 2)i� x) ,

ab(1)x,i :=

8><>:� 1

4(2i�3)2 (x� i + 2)(x + i� 1) if i � 3�1

2x(x + 1) if i = 20 otherwise.

Page 7: JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND ...math.colgate.edu/~integers/s46/s46.pdf#A46 INTEGERS 18 (2018) JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND CONGRUENCES FOR BINOMIAL COEFFICIENTS Maxie

INTEGERS: 18 (2018) 7

We then define the hth convergent functions, Conv1,h(x, z) := P1,h(x, z)/Q1,h(x, z),through the component numerator and denominator functions given recursively by

P1,h(x, z) = (1� c(1)x,hz) P1,h�1(x, z)� ab(1)

x,h z2 P1,h�1(x, z) + [h = 1]� (1)

Q1,h(x, z) = (1� c(1)x,hz)Q1,h�1(x, z)� ab(1)

x,h z2 Q1,h�1(x, z)

+ (1� c(1)x,1z) [h = 1]� + [h = 0]� .

Listings of the first several cases of the numerator and denominator convergentfunctions, P1,h(x, z) and Q1,h(x, z), are given in Table 1 and Table 2, respectively.

Proposition 1 (Formulas for the Numerator Convergent Functions). Forall h � 1 and indeterminate x, the numerator convergent functions, P1,h(x, z), havethe following formulas:

Ph(x, z) =h�1Xn=0

✓x + n� h

n

◆(h� 1)!

(h� 1� n)!· (2h� 1� n)!

(2h� 1)!· (�z)n

=h�1Xn=0

✓x + n� h

n

◆✓h� 1

n

◆✓2h� 1

n

◆�1

· (�z)n.

Proof. The proof follows from (1) of Definition 1 by induction on h. The claimedformula holds for h = 0, 1, 2 by the computations given in Table 1. Suppose thath � 3 and that the two equivalent formulas stated in the proposition for P1,k(x, z)are correct for all k < h. In particular, the stated formula holds when k = h�1, h�2.Then by expanding (1) using our hypothesis, we have that

P1,k(x, z) =✓

1 +(1 + 2h(h� 2)� x)z

(2h� 1)(2h� 3)

◆⇥

h�2Xn=0

✓x + n + 1� h

n

◆✓h� 2

n

◆✓2h� 3

n

◆�1

(�z)n

+(x + 2� h)(x + h� 1)z2

4(2h� 3)2⇥

h�3Xn=0

✓x + n + 2� h

n

◆✓h� 3

n

◆✓2h� 5

n

◆�1

(�z)n,

which then implies the following expansions:

Page 8: JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND ...math.colgate.edu/~integers/s46/s46.pdf#A46 INTEGERS 18 (2018) JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND CONGRUENCES FOR BINOMIAL COEFFICIENTS Maxie

INTEGERS: 18 (2018) 8

P1,k(x, z) =h�1Xn=0

✓x + n + 1

n

◆✓h� 2

n

◆✓2h� 3

n

◆�1

(�z)n

� (1 + 2h(h� 2)� x)(2h� 1)(2h� 3)

h�1Xn=1

✓x + n� h

n� 1

◆✓h� 2n� 1

◆✓2h� 3n� 1

◆�1

(�z)n

+(x + 2� h)(x + h� 1)

4(2h� 3)2

h�1Xn=2

✓x + n� h

n� 2

◆✓h� 3n� 2

◆✓2h� 5n� 2

◆�1

(�z)n

= 1 +

✓x + 2� h

1

◆✓h� 2

1

◆✓2h� 3

1

◆�1

� (1 + 2h(h� 2)� x)(2h� 1)(2h� 3)

!(�z)

+

(x + 2� h)(x + h� 1)

4(2h� 3)2

✓x� 1h� 3

◆✓h� 3h� 3

◆✓2h� 5h� 3

◆�1

�✓

x� 1h� 2

◆✓h� 2h� 2

◆✓2h� 3h� 2

◆�1!

(�z)h�1

+h�2Xi=2

✓x + n� h

n

◆✓h� 1

n

◆✓2h� 1

n

◆�1

2(2h� 1)(h� n� 1)(x + n + 1� h)(2h� 2� n)(2h� 1� n)(x + 1� h)

� 2n(1 + 2h(h� 2)� x)(2h� 3)(2h� 1� n)(x + 1� h)

+n(n� 1)(2h� 1)(x + 2� h)(x� 1 + h)

(2h� 3)(2h� 2� n)(2h� 1� n)(x + 2� h)(x + 1� h)

!(�z)n.

Finally, we can simplify the last equation into the form of

P1,k(x, z) = 1 +✓

x + 1� h

1

◆✓h� 1

1

◆✓2h� 1

1

◆�1

(�z) +✓

x� 1h� 1

◆✓h� 1h� 1

◆✓2h� 1h� 1

◆�1

(�z)h�1

+h�2Xn=2

✓x + n� h

n

◆✓h� 1

n

◆✓2h� 1

n

◆�1

(�z)n.

The next identity is used to prove Theorem 2 below. In particular, the coe�cientsof the powers of zn on the right-hand-sides of the stated formulas satisfy

(�1)n

✓x + n� h

n

◆✓h� 1

n

◆✓2h� 1

n

◆�1

(2)

=nX

i=0

✓x + n� i

n� i

◆✓x + h

i

◆h!

(h� i)!(2h� 1� i)!

(2h� 1)!(�1)n�i,

which is proved directly by summing the corresponding hypergeometric terms ex-actly with Mathematica.

Proposition 2 (Formulas for the Denominator Convergent Functions).For all h � 0 and fixed indeterminates x, we have that the denominator convergent

Page 9: JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND ...math.colgate.edu/~integers/s46/s46.pdf#A46 INTEGERS 18 (2018) JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND CONGRUENCES FOR BINOMIAL COEFFICIENTS Maxie

INTEGERS: 18 (2018) 9

functions, Q1,h(x, z), satisfy the following formula:

Qh(x, z) =hX

i=0

✓x + h

i

◆· h!(h� i)!

· (2h� 1� i)!(2h� 1)!

· zi.

Proof. The proof again follows from (1) of Definition 1 by induction on h. Theclaimed formula holds when h = 0, 1, 2 by the computations given in Table 2. Next,we suppose that h � 3 and that the formula stated in the proposition for Q1,k(x, z)is correct for all k < h. In particular, the stated formulas hold when k = h�1, h�2.Then by expanding (1) using our inductive hypothesis, we have that

Q1,h(x, z) =h�1Xi=0

x + h� 1

i

!(h� 1)!

(h� 1� i)!(2h� 3� i)!

(2h� 3)!zi

+(1 + 2h(h� 2)� x)(2h� 1)(2h� 3)

hXi=1

x + h� 1

i� 1

!(h� 1)!(h� i)!

(2h� 2� i)!(2h� 3)!

zi

+(x + 1� h)(x + h� 1)

4(2h� 3)2

hXi=2

x + h� 2

i� 2

!(h� 2)!(h� i)!

(2h� 3� i)!(2h� 5)!

zi

= 1 +

x + h

1

!hz

(2h� 1)+

x + h

h

!h!(h� 1)!zh

(2h� 1)!

+h�1Xi=2

x + h

i

!h!

(h� i)!(2h� 1� i)!

(2h� 1)!zi

2(h� 1)(2h� 1)(h� i)(x + h� i)h(2h� 2� i)(2h� 1� i)(h + x)

+2(h� 1)i(1 + 2h(h� 2)� x)h(2h� 3)(2h� 1� i)(h + x)

+(h� 2)(2h� 1)(i(i� 1)(x + 2� h)

h(2h� 3)(2h� 2� i)(2h� 1� i)(h + x)

!

=hX

i=0

x + h

i

!h!

(h� i)!(2h� 1� i)!

(2h� 1)!zi.

The expansions of the J-fractions and, more generally, for any continued fractionwhose convergents are defined by the ratio of terms defined recursively as in (1),provide additional recurrence relations and exact finite sums for the hth convergentfunctions, Conv1,h(x, z), given by [6, §1.12]:

Conv1,h(x, z) = Conv1,h�1(x, z) +(�1)h�1 abx,2 abx,3 · · · abx,h z2h�2

Q1,h(x, z)Q1,h�1(x, z)

=1

1 + (x + 1)z+

hXi=2

(�1)i�1�x+i�1

i�1

�� xi�1

��2i�3i�2

��2z2i�2

2 · Q1,i(x, z)Q1,i�1(x, z).

Page 10: JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND ...math.colgate.edu/~integers/s46/s46.pdf#A46 INTEGERS 18 (2018) JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND CONGRUENCES FOR BINOMIAL COEFFICIENTS Maxie

INTEGERS: 18 (2018) 10

Theorem 2 (Main Theorem I). For integers h � 2, we have that the hth conver-gent functions, Conv1,h(x, z), exactly generate the binomial coe�cients

�x+nn

�for

all 0 n h as

[zn] Conv1,h(x,�z) =✓

x + n

n

◆.

Proof. Since Conv1,h(x, z) is rational in z for all h � 2, Proposition 1 and Propo-sition 2 imply the following finite di↵erence equations for the coe�cients of theconvergent functions, Conv1,h(x, z), when n � 0 [4, §2.3]:

[zn] Conv1,h(x,�z) = �min(n,h)X

i=1

x + h

i

![zn�i] Conv1,h(x, z)⇥ h!

(h� i)!(2h� 1� i)!

(2h� 1)!(�1)i

(3)

+ [zn] P1,h(x,�z) [0 n < h]� .

We must show that [zn] Conv1,h(x,�z) =�x+n

n

�in the separate cases where 0

n < h and when n = h. For the first case, we use induction on n to show ourresult. Since [z0]F (z)/G(z) = F (0)/G(0) for any functions, F (z) and G(z), with apower series expansion in z about zero, we have by the two propositions above that[z0] Conv1,h(x, z) =

�x+00

�⌘ 1 for all h � 2.

Next, we suppose that for h > n � 1 and all k < n, [zk] Conv1,h(x,�z) =�x+k

k

�.

Since 0 n � i < n for all i in the right-hand-side sum of (3), we can applythe inductive hypothesis, combined with the observation in (2) from the proof ofProposition 1, to the recurrence relation in the previous equation to obtain thatwhen n < h we have

[zn] Conv1,h(x,�z) = �nX

i=1

✓x + h

i

◆✓x + n� i

n� i

◆h!

(h� i)!(2h� 1� i)!

(2h� 1)!(�1)i

+nX

i=0

✓x + h

i

◆✓x + n� i

n� i

◆h!

(h� i)!(2h� 1� i)!

(2h� 1)!(�1)i

=✓

x + n

n

◆.

To prove the claim in the first special case of (3) where [zn] P1,h(x,�z) ⌘ 0, i.e.,precisely when n = h, we use an alternate approach to evaluating these sums byexactly summing with Mathematica as

[zn] Conv1,h(x,�z) = �nX

i=1

✓x + h

i

◆✓x + n� i

n� i

◆h!

(h� i)!(2h� 1� i)!

(2h� 1)!(�1)i

=✓

x + n

n

◆(1�3 F2(�h,�n,�(x + h); 1� 2h,�(x + n); 1), )

where pFq(a1, . . . , ap; b1, . . . , bq; z) denotes the generalized hypergeometric functionwhose coe�cients when expanded in powers of z are given by the next Pochhammer

Page 11: JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND ...math.colgate.edu/~integers/s46/s46.pdf#A46 INTEGERS 18 (2018) JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND CONGRUENCES FOR BINOMIAL COEFFICIENTS Maxie

INTEGERS: 18 (2018) 11

symbol products [6, §16]:

pFq(a1, . . . , ap; b1, . . . , bq; z) =Xk�0

(a1)k · · · (ap)k

k! · (b1)k · · · (bq)k

zk.

When h = n, the terms contributed by the generalized hypergeometric functionin the previous equation are zero-valued1. Therefore when n = h, we have that[zn] Conv1,h(x, z) =

�x+nn

�.

We can actually prove a stronger statement of Theorem 2 which provides that[zn] Conv1,h(x, z) =

�x+nn

�for all 0 n < 2h, though for the purposes of showing

that our J-fraction expansions defined by Definition 1 are correct, the proof of thetheorem given above su�ces to show the result. One consequence of the theorem isthat we have the following finite sums exactly generating,

�x+nn

�, for any x and all

n � 0, i.e., in the case of (3) where h = n:✓

x + n

n

◆=

nXi=1

✓x + n

i

◆✓x + n� i

n� i

◆✓n

i

◆✓2n� 1

i

◆�1

(�1)i+1 + [n = 0]� .

Corollary 1 (Congruences for�x+n

n

�Modulo Integers h � 2). For h � 2,

let �h(x) :=Qh

i=2 abx,i, or equivalently, let �h(x) ⌘ (�1)h�1

2

�x+h�1h�1

�� xh�1

�/�2h�3

h�2

�2.

For all h � 2, m � h, 0 x h, and n � 0, whenever �m(x) 2 Z and h | �m(x),we have the following congruences congruences for the binomial coe�cients moduloh:✓

x + n

n

◆⌘

nXi=1

✓x + m

i

◆✓x + n� i

n� i

◆· m!(m� i)!

· (2m� 1� i)!(2m� 1)!

(�1)i+1

+✓

x + n�m

n

◆✓m� 1

n

◆✓2m� 1

n

◆�1

[0 n < m]� (mod h).

Proof. The result is an immediate corollary of (3) from the proof of Theorem 2 andthe J-fraction coe�cient congruence properties cited in property (C) of Section 1.2in the introduction [2] [4, cf. §5.7].

Remark 3 (Exact Congruences for the Binomial Coe�cients). We conjec-ture that in fact for all h � 2, h > n � 0, and x < h, which typically correspondsto the cases of the binomial coe�cients that we actually wish to evaluate modulo

1i.e., since (�n)n+1+k = 0 for all k � 0 and where for all integers n � 1 the next hypergeometricsum is evaluated exactly with Mathematica as

nXk=0

⇣n

k

⌘2⇥ (�1)kk! · (2n� 1� k)!

(2n� 1)!= 0.

Page 12: JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND ...math.colgate.edu/~integers/s46/s46.pdf#A46 INTEGERS 18 (2018) JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND CONGRUENCES FOR BINOMIAL COEFFICIENTS Maxie

INTEGERS: 18 (2018) 12

h, that

✓x + n

n

◆⌘

hXi=1

✓x + h

i

◆✓x + n� i

n� i

◆· h!(h� i)!

· (2h� 1� i)!(2h� 1)!

(�1)i+1 (mod h),

(4)

at a minimum for any x such that h evenly divides �h(x) as an integer factor,though other choices of the indeterminate x may correctly yield congruence moduloh. Given this restriction on the x modulo each h, we then define the correspondingindex sets

Mh :=

(x 2 Z :

12h

✓x + h� 1

h� 1

◆✓x

h� 1

◆✓2h� 3h� 2

◆�2

2 Z)

.

The first few particular special cases of these restricted index sets include

M2 =⇢

x :x(x + 1)

42 Z

�= {x : x ⌘ 0, 3 mod 4}

M3 =⇢

x :(x� 1)x(x + 1)(x + 2)

2162 Z

= {x : x ⌘ 0, 1, 7, 10, 16, 19, 25, 26 mod 27}

M4 =⇢

x :(x� 1)(x� 1)x(x + 1)(x + 2)(x + 3)

288002 Z

= {x : x ⌘ 0, 1, 2, 7, 12, 17, 22, 23, 24 mod 25}\ {x : x ⌘ 0, 1, 2, 13, 14, 17, 18, 29, 30, 31 mod 32}

M5 =⇢

x :(x� 2)(x� 1)(x� 1)x(x + 1)(x + 2)(x + 3)(x + 4)

70560002 Z

= {x : x ⌘ 0, 1, 2, 3, 21, 22, 23, 24 mod 25}\ {x : x ⌘ 0, 1, 2, 3, 10, 17, 24, 31, 38, 45, 46, 47, 48 mod 49} .

Now using these results, we can expand these special case congruences for�x+n

n

�modulo 2, 3, 4, and 5 as follows:✓

x + n

n

◆⌘ 2(x + 2)

3

✓x + n� 1

n� 1

◆� (x + 1)(x + 2)

6

✓x + n� 2

n� 2

◆(mod 2),

for all x 2M2

✓x + n

n

◆⌘ 3(x + 3)

5

✓x + n� 1

n� 1

◆� 3(x + 2)(x + 3)

20

✓x + n� 2

n� 2

+(x + 1)(x + 2)(x + 3)

60

✓x + n� 3

n� 3

◆(mod 3),

for all x 2M3

Page 13: JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND ...math.colgate.edu/~integers/s46/s46.pdf#A46 INTEGERS 18 (2018) JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND CONGRUENCES FOR BINOMIAL COEFFICIENTS Maxie

INTEGERS: 18 (2018) 13

✓x + n

n

◆⌘ 4(x + 4)

7

✓x + n� 1

n� 1

◆� (x + 3)(x + 4)

7

✓x + n� 2

n� 2

+2(x + 2)(x + 3)(x + 4)

105

✓x + n� 3

n� 3

� (x + 1)(x + 2)(x + 3)(x + 4)840

✓x + n� 4

n� 4

◆(mod 4),

for all x 2M4✓x + n

n

◆⌘ 5(x + 5)

9

✓x + n� 1

n� 1

◆� 5(x + 4)(x + 5)

56

✓x + n� 2

n� 2

+5(x + 3)(x + 4)(x + 5)

252

✓x + n� 3

n� 3

� 5(x + 2)(x + 3)(x + 4)(x + 5)3024

✓x + n� 4

n� 4

+(x + 1)(x + 2)(x + 3)(x + 4)(x + 5)

15120

✓x + n� 5

n� 5

◆(mod 5),

for all x 2M5.

We also notice that once we know the restricted sets Mh for any h � 2, thecongruences expanded above provide us with new information about the centralbinomial coe�cients,

�2nn

�for n 2Mh \N, modulo prime and composite choices of

h.

Example 4 (Divisors of the Central Binomial Coe�cients). One famousexample of a problem we can approach using the new machinery proved in thisarticle is stated in [7, §4]. The problem (and its prize) due to Ron Graham is todetermine whether there are infinitely many n such that

�2nn

�is relatively prime

to 105, or equivalently, to find the sequence of n such that none of the individualprime factors divide the nth central binomial coe�cient: 3, 5, 7 -

�2nn

�. Two of the

congruences explicitly expanded in the previous equations imply new generatingfunctions for two of the three cases we need to consider in Graham’s problem. Forany integer modulus h � 2, we set

Bcent,h(z) :=X

n2Mp\N

⇢✓2nn

◆(mod p)

�zn.

We can easily compute (i.e., using Mathematica) that the non-identically-zero co-e�cients of the next generating functions, denoted by eBcent,h(z), are congruent tothe respective coe�cients of Bcent,h(z) defined in the last equation. For h 2 {2, 3},particular concrete examples of these generating functions are expanded as

eBcent,2(z) =12� 5

32B(z)+

1732

B(z) +532

B(z)3 � 132

B(z)5

eBcent,3(z) =5� z

10� 63

256B(z)+

4364

B(z) +63640

B(z)3 � 9320

B(z)5 +1

256B(z)7,

Page 14: JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND ...math.colgate.edu/~integers/s46/s46.pdf#A46 INTEGERS 18 (2018) JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND CONGRUENCES FOR BINOMIAL COEFFICIENTS Maxie

INTEGERS: 18 (2018) 14

in powers of the ordinary generating function for the central binomial coe�cientsdefined by

B(z) :=Xn�0

✓2nn

◆zn =

1p1� 4z

.

It is easy to see by induction from (4) that for higher-order h > 5, a general formulafor the expansions of the generating functions eBcent,h(z) can be expressed as a sumof a rational function of z of small degree less than h plus a finite sum of odd powersof B(z)m for m 2 [�1, 2h + 1] \ Z \ 2Z. We can then obtain formulas for “most”of the

�2nn

�mod h when n 2Mh by Faa di Bruno’s formula or directly by taking

the Cauchy products corresponding to multiple convolutions of the central binomialgenerating function defined above.

Corollary 2 (Reduction of Order of the Binomial Coe�cients). For integersr, p such that p � r � 0, let the sequences, kr,p(x), be defined as

kr,p(x) = (�1)p�r

✓x + p

p� r

◆✓2rr

◆✓p + r

r

◆�1

.

For all integers p, q � 0, we have an addition theorem for the binomial coe�cientsgiven by

(�1)p+q

✓x + p + q

p + q

◆= k0,p(x)k0,q(x) +

min(p,q)Xi=1

�i+1(x)ki,p(x)ki,q(x),

where �h(x) is defined as in Corollary 1.

Proof. We can prove the result using the matrix method from [1, §1, p. 133] and[10, §11]. In particular, for integers p � r � 0, let the functions, ekr,p(x), denote thesolutions to the matrix equation266664

ek0,1(x) ek1,1(x) 0 0 · · ·ek0,2(x) ek1,2(x) ek2,2(x) 0 · · ·ek0,3(x) ek1,3(x) ek2,3(x) ek3,3(x) · · ·· · ·

377775

=

266664

ek0,0(x) 0 0 0 · · ·ek0,1(x) ek1,1(x) 0 0 · · ·ek0,1(x) ek1,1(x) ek2,2(x) 0 · · ·· · ·

377775

266664

cx,1 1 0 0 · · ·abx,2 cx,2 1 0 · · ·

0 abx,3 cx,3 1 · · ·· · ·

377775 ,

(5)where here we define ek0,p(x) :=

�x+pp

�for all p � 0. We claim that for all integers

p, r � 0 with p � r � 0, the two functions, kr,p(x) and ekr,p(x), are equal. To prove

Page 15: JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND ...math.colgate.edu/~integers/s46/s46.pdf#A46 INTEGERS 18 (2018) JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND CONGRUENCES FOR BINOMIAL COEFFICIENTS Maxie

INTEGERS: 18 (2018) 15

the claim, we notice that for fixed p, equation (5) implies recurrence relations overr given by

ek1,p(x) =1

abx,2

⇣ek0,p+1(x)� cx,1 · ek0,p(x)⌘

, p � 1

ekr+1,p(x) =1

abx,r+2

⇣ekr,p+1(x)� ekr�1,p(x)� cx,r+1 · ekr,p(x)⌘

, p > r � 1.

The first recurrence relation provides that for p � 1

ek1,p = � 2x(x + 1)

✓(�1)p+1

✓x + p + 1

p + 1

◆+ (�1)p(x + 1)

✓x + p

p

◆◆

=2(�1)p�1(p + x)!

(p + 1)(x + 1)!(p� 1)!

✓(x + 1)(p + 1)

px� (x + p + 1)

px

=2(�1)p�1

(p + 1)

✓x + p

p� 1

◆,

which is the same as the formula for k1,p(x) stated above. We can then use thesecond recurrence relation to complete the proof of the claim by induction on r.When r = 0, 1, we have that the two formulas for kr,p(x) and ekr,p(x) coincide. Wesuppose that the claim is true for some r � 1, which by the previous recurrencerelation in turn implies that

ekr+1,p(x)

=�4 · (2r + 1)2

(x� r)(x + r + 1)

(�1)p�1�r

x + p + 1p + 1� r

! 2p + 2p + 1

! r + p + 1

p + 1

!�1

� (�1)r�1�p

x + p

p + 1� r

! 2r � 2r � 1

! p + r � 1

r � 1

!�1

+(�1)p�1�r(1 + 2(r � 1)(r + 1)� x)

(2r + 1)(2r � 1)

x + pp� r

! 2pp

! r + p

p

!�1!

= (�1)p�r�1

x + p

p� 1� r

! 2r + 2r + 1

! p + r + 1

r + 1

!�1

⇥ 4(2r + 1)2

(r � x)(x + r + 1)⇥

(p + 1)(p + 1 + x)(r + 1 + x)2(p� r)(p + 1� r)(2r � 1)(2r + 1)

� (p + r)(p + 1 + r)(r + x)(r + 1 + x)4(p� r)(p + 1� r)(2r � 1)(2r + 1)

� (1 + 2(r � 1)(r + 1)� x)(p + 1 + r)(r + 1 + x)2(p� r)(2r � 1)(2r + 1)2

!

= (�1)p�r�1

x + p

p� 1� r

! 2r + 2r + 1

! p + r + 1

r + 1

!�1

.

Since the two formulas are equivalent, we obtain the next form of the additionformula, or alternately, a formula providing a “reduction” of the order of the upper

Page 16: JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND ...math.colgate.edu/~integers/s46/s46.pdf#A46 INTEGERS 18 (2018) JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND CONGRUENCES FOR BINOMIAL COEFFICIENTS Maxie

INTEGERS: 18 (2018) 16

and lower indices to the binomial coe�cients,�x+n

n

�, given by the expansion in the

references in the following forms for all integers p, q � 0:

(�1)p+q

x + p + q

p + q

!= k0,pk0,q + abx,2 ·k1,pk1,q + abx,2 abx,3 ·k2,pk2,q + · · ·

= (�1)p+q

x + p

p

! x + q

q

!

+min(p,q)X

i=1

(�1)p+q�i+1(x)

x + pp� i

! x + qq � i

! 2ii

!2 p + i

i

!�1 q + i

i

!�1

.

Example 5. We notice that this result provides exact finite sum expansions of thebinomial coe�cients,

�x+nn

�, for any x and n � 0 which hold modulo any integers

h � 2 (prime or composite), and compare the reduction in the upper and lowercoe�cient indices to the congruence result provided by Lucas’ theorem and itsrelated variants stated in the introduction. For a concrete example, let p = q = 2in Corollary 2. Then we obtain that

✓x + 4

4

◆=

(x + 1)2(x + 2)2

4� 2

9(x + 2)2(x + 1)x +

(x + 2)(x + 1)x(x� 1)72

=(x + 4)(x + 3)(x + 2)(x + 1)

24.

Furthermore, if we let n 2 Z+ and specialize x = p = q := n in the corollary above,we are able to obtain the new sum✓

3n2n

◆=✓

2nn

◆2

+ 2⇥nX

i=1

(�1)i

✓n

i

◆✓n + i

i

◆�1✓ 2nn� i

◆2

=✓

2nn

◆2

� 2n(n + 1) ·✓

2nn� 1

◆2

� 2✓

6n + 2

� 2n + 1

� 1◆✓

2nn� 2

◆2

� · · · .

Related identities and congruences are formulated similarly by taking each of x, p, qto be integer multiples of the positive integer n � 1 specified in the previous exam-ple.

3. J-Fraction Expansions for the Binomial Coe�cients,�xn

�We can construct (and formally prove) similar convergent-based J-fraction construc-tions enumerating the binomial coe�cients,

�xn

�, for an indeterminate x and n � 0.

Since the proofs for the propositions, theorem, and corollaries in this section arealmost identical to those given in the case of the binomial coe�cient variants,

�x+nn

�,

in Section 2, we omit the proofs of the next results stated below. We begin with

Page 17: JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND ...math.colgate.edu/~integers/s46/s46.pdf#A46 INTEGERS 18 (2018) JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND CONGRUENCES FOR BINOMIAL COEFFICIENTS Maxie

INTEGERS: 18 (2018) 17

the definition of the component sequences and convergent functions correspondingto the J-fractions generating the binomial coe�cients,

�xn

�, in this case.

Definition 6 (Component Sequences and Convergent Functions for�xn

�).

For a fixed non-zero indeterminate x and i � 1, we define the component sequences,c(2)x,i and ab(2)

x,i , as follows:

c(2)x,i := � 1

(2i� 1)(2i� 3)�x + 2(i� 1)2

ab(2)x,i :=

8><>:� 1

4(2i�3)2 (x� i + 2)(x + i� 1) if i � 3�1

2x(x + 1) if i = 20 otherwise.

For h � 0, we define the hth convergent functions, Conv2,h(x, z) := P2,h(x, z)/Q2,h(x, z),recursively through the component functions in the forms of

P2,h(x, z) = (1� c(2)x,hz) P2,h�1(x, z)� ab(2)

x,h z2 P2,h�1(x, z) + [h = 1]� (6)

Q2,h(x, z) = (1� c(2)x,hz)Q2,h�1(x, z)� ab(2)

x,h z2 Q2,h�1(x, z)

+ (1� c(2)x,1z) [h = 1]� + [h = 0]� .

Listings of the first several cases of the numerator and denominator convergentfunctions, P2,h(x, z) and Q2,h(x, z), are given in Table 3 and Table 4, respectively.

h P2,h(x, z)0 01 12 1 + x+2

3 z

3 1 + 25 (x + 3)z + 1

20 (x + 2)(x + 3)z2

4 1 + 37 (x + 4)z + 1

14 (x + 3)(x + 4)z2 + 1210(x + 2)(x + 3)(x + 4)z3

5 1 + 49 (x + 5)z + 1

12 (x + 4)(x + 5)z2 + 1126(x + 3)(x + 4)(x + 5)z3

+ (x+2)(x+3)(x+4)(x+5)3024 z4

6 1 + 511 (x + 6)z + 1

11 (x + 5)(x + 6)z2 + 199 (x + 4)(x + 5)(x + 6)z3

+ (x+3)(x+4)(x+5)(x+6)1584 z4 + (x+2)(x+3)(x+4)(x+5)(x+6)

55440 z5

Table 3: The Numerator Convergent Functions, P2,h(x, z), Generating the BinomialCoe�cients,

�xn

Page 18: JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND ...math.colgate.edu/~integers/s46/s46.pdf#A46 INTEGERS 18 (2018) JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND CONGRUENCES FOR BINOMIAL COEFFICIENTS Maxie

INTEGERS: 18 (2018) 18

h Q2,h(x, z)

1 1� xz

2 1� 23 (x� 1)z + 1

6 (x� 1)xz2

3 1� 35 (x� 2)z + 3

20 (x� 2)(x� 1)z2 � 160 (x� 2)(x� 1)xz3

4 1� 47 (x� 3)z + 1

7 (x� 3)(x� 2)z2 � 2105 (x� 3)(x� 2)(x� 1)z3

+ 1840 (x� 3)(x� 2)(x� 1)xz4

5 1� 59 (x� 4)z + 5

36 (x� 4)(x� 3)z2 � 5252 (x� 4)(x� 3)(x� 2)z3

+ 5(x�4)(x�3)(x�2)(x�1)3024 z4 � (x�4)(x�3)(x�2)(x�1)x

15120 z5

6 1� 611 (x� 5)z + 3

22 (x� 5)(x� 4)z2 � 299 (x� 5)(x� 4)(x� 3)z3

+ 1528 (x� 5)(x� 4)(x� 3)(x� 2)z4 � (x�5)(x�4)(x�3)(x�2)(x�1)

9240 z5

+ (x�5)(x�4)(x�3)(x�2)(x�1)x332640 z6

Table 4: The Denominator Convergent Functions, Q2,h(x, z), Generating the Bino-mial Coe�cients,

�xn

Proposition 3 (Convergent Function Formulas). For all h � 2 and a fixedindeterminate x, the numerator and denominator convergent functions, P2,h(x, z)and Q2,h(x, z), each satisfy the following respective formulas:

P2,h(x, z) =h�1Xn=0

✓x + h

n

◆(h� 1)!

(h� 1� n)!(2h� 1� n)!

(2h� 1)!zn

=h�1Xn=0

✓x + h

n

◆✓h� 1

n

◆✓2h� 1

n

◆�1

zn

Q2,h(x, z) =hX

i=0

✓x� h + i

i

◆h!

(h� i)!(2h� 1� i)!

(2h� 1)!(�z)i.

Theorem 7 (Main Theorem II). For all integers h � 2 and 0 n h, wehave that the hth convergent functions, Conv2,h(x, z), exactly generate the binomialcoe�cients

�xn

�as [zn] Conv2,h(x, z) =

�xn

�.

As in Section 2, we remark that one consequence of the second main theoremresulting from the proposition above is that we have a new proof of the next exactformula generating the binomial coe�cients,

�xn

�, for any x and all n � 0:

✓x

n

◆=

nXi=1

✓x� n + i

i

◆✓x

n� i

◆✓n

i

◆✓2n� 1

i

◆�1

(�1)i+1 + [n = 0]� .

Corollary 3 (Congruences for�xn

�Modulo Integers h � 2). Let the hth mod-

ulus, �h(x), of the J-fraction defined by Definition 6 correspond to the definitions

Page 19: JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND ...math.colgate.edu/~integers/s46/s46.pdf#A46 INTEGERS 18 (2018) JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND CONGRUENCES FOR BINOMIAL COEFFICIENTS Maxie

INTEGERS: 18 (2018) 19

given in Corollary 1. For all h � 2, m � h, 0 x h, and n � 0, whenever�m(x) 2 Z and h | �m(x), we have the following congruences congruences for thebinomial coe�cients,

�xn

�, modulo h:

✓x

n

◆⌘

nXi=1

✓x�m + i

i

◆✓x

n� i

◆· m!(m� i)!

· (2m� 1� i)!(2m� 1)!

(�1)i+1

+✓

x + m

n

◆✓m� 1

n

◆✓2m� 1

n

◆�1

[0 n < m]� (mod h).

Remark 8 (Exact Congruences for Special Cases). We again conjecture thatfor all h � 2 and all x, n � 0, we have congruences for the binomial coe�cients,�xn

�, of the form✓

x

n

◆⌘

hXi=1

✓x� h + i

i

◆✓x

n� i

◆✓h

i

◆✓2h� 1

i

◆�1

(�1)i+1

+✓

x + h

n

◆✓h� 1

n

◆✓2h� 1

n

◆�1

(mod h),

for all x 2Mh,

where the sets Mh are defined as in Remark 3 of the previous section. We canthen expand the first several special cases of these congruences using this result asfollows:✓

x

n

◆⌘ 2(x� 1)

3

✓x

n� 1

◆� x(x� 1)

6

✓x

n� 2

◆+

(n� 2)(n� 3)6

✓x + 2

n

◆[n 1]� (mod 2), for all x 2M2✓

x

n

◆⌘ 3(x� 2)

5

✓x

n� 1

◆� 3(x� 1)(x� 2)

20

✓x

n� 2

◆+

x(x� 1)(x� 2)60

✓x

n� 3

� (n� 3)(n� 4)(n� 5)60

✓x + 3

n

◆[n 2]� (mod 3), for all x 2M3✓

x

n

◆⌘ 4(x� 3)

7

✓x

n� 1

◆� (x� 2)(x� 3)

7

✓x

n� 2

◆+

2(x� 1)(x� 2)(x� 3)105

✓x

n� 3

� x(x� 1)(x� 2)(x� 3)840

✓x

n� 4

+(n� 4)(n� 5)(n� 6)(n� 7)

840

✓x + 4

n

◆[n 3]� (mod 4), for all x 2M4✓

x

n

◆⌘ 5(x� 4)

9

✓x

n� 1

◆� 5(x� 3)(x� 4)

36

✓x

n� 2

◆+

5(x� 2)(x� 3)(x� 4)252

✓x

n� 3

� 5(x� 1)(x� 2)(x� 3)(x� 4)3024

✓x

n� 4

� x(x� 1)(x� 2)(x� 3)(x� 4)15120

✓x

n� 5

� (n� 5)(n� 6)(n� 7)(n� 8)(n� 9)15120

✓x + 5

n

◆[n 4]� (mod 5), for all x 2M5.

Corollary 4 (Reduction Formulas for�xn

�). Let the functions, kr,s(x) be defined

for all s � r � 0 as

kr,s(x) =✓

x� r

s� r

◆✓2rr

◆✓r + s

r

◆�1

.

Page 20: JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND ...math.colgate.edu/~integers/s46/s46.pdf#A46 INTEGERS 18 (2018) JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND CONGRUENCES FOR BINOMIAL COEFFICIENTS Maxie

INTEGERS: 18 (2018) 20

We have a corresponding addition, or lower index reduction, formula for the bino-mial coe�cients,

� xp+q

�, given by the following equations for integers p, q � 0:

✓x

p + q

◆= k0,p(x)k0,q(x) +

min(p,q)Xi=1

�i+1(x)ki,p(x)ki,q(x)

=✓

x

p

◆✓x

q

◆+

min(p,q)Xi=1

(�1)i�x�i

p�i

��x�iq�i

��x+ii

��xi

��2ii

�22 ·�p+i

i

��q+ii

��2i�1i�1

�2 .

We can again compare the statements of the two summation formulas in thecorollary to the binomial coe�cient expansions in the statement of Lucas’ theoremfrom the introduction modulo any prime p.

4. Conclusions

We have established the forms of two new Jacobi-type J-fraction expansions pro-viding ordinary generating functions for the binomial coe�cients,

�x+nn

�and

�xn

�,

for any x and all n � 0. The key ingredients to the proofs of these series expan-sions are the rationality of the hth convergents, Convi,h(x, z), for all h � 1 andclosed-form formulas for the corresponding numerator and denominator functionsequences, which are finite-degree polynomials in z with degz{Pi,h(x, z)} = h � 1and degz{Qi,h(x, z)} = h for all h � 1 when i = 1, 2. The finite di↵erence equationsimplied by the rationality of the hth convergent functions at each h lead to newexact formulas for, and new congruences satisfied by, the two binomial coe�cientvariants studied within the article. We note that unlike the J-fraction expansionsenumerating the generalized factorial functions studied in [9], the hth modulus,�h(x), of these J-fractions defined in Corollary 1 is not strictly integer-valued forall x and h, which complicates the formulations of the new congruence propertiesfor the binomial coe�cient variants considered in the article.

We also compare the two forms of the addition, or reduction of index, formulasfor these coe�cients stated in Corollary 2 and in Corollary 4 to the forms of Lu-cas’s theorem and to the prime power congruences cited in the introduction, whichsimilarly reduce the upper and lower indices to these sequences with respect topowers of prime moduli. New research directions based on the results in this ar-ticle include further study of the binomial coe�cient congruences given in Section2 and Section 3 modulo composite integers h � 4. In particular, one direction forfuture research based on these topics is to find exact formulas for doubly-indexed se-quences of multipliers, emi,h,n, such that

�x+nn

�⌘ em1,h,n[zn] Conv1,h(x, z) (mod h)

and�xn

�⌘ em2,h,n[zn] Conv2,h(x, z) (mod h) for all integers x, n � 0. This applica-

tion is surely a non-trivial task worthy of further study and consideration based onthe results we prove here.

Page 21: JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND ...math.colgate.edu/~integers/s46/s46.pdf#A46 INTEGERS 18 (2018) JACOBI-TYPE CONTINUED FRACTIONS AND CONGRUENCES FOR BINOMIAL COEFFICIENTS Maxie

INTEGERS: 18 (2018) 21

References

[1] P. Flajolet, Combinatorial aspects of continued fractions, Discrete Math. 32 (1980), 125–161.

[2] P. Flajolet, On congruences and continued fractions for some classical combinatorial quantities,Discrete Math. 41 (1982), 145–153.

[3] A. Granville, Binomial coe�cients modulo prime powers,http://www.dms.umontreal.ca/⇠andrew/Binomial/ (1996).

[4] S. K. Lando, Lectures on Generating Functions, American Mathematical Society, USA, 2002.

[5] R. Mestrovic, Lucas’ theorem: Its generalizations, extensions and applications (1878–2014),https://arxiv.org/abs/1409.3820 (2014).

[6] F. W. J. Olver, D. W. Lozier, R. F. Boisvert, and C. W. Clark, NIST Handbook of Mathe-matical Functions, Cambridge University Press, 2010.

[7] C. Pomerance, Divisors of the middle binomial coe�cient, Amer. Math. Monthly 121 (2014).

[8] M. D. Schmidt, Generalized j–factorial functions, polynomials, and applications, J. IntegerSeq. 13 (2010).

[9] M. D. Schmidt, Jacobi-type continued fractions for the ordinary generating functions of gen-eralized factorial functions, J. Integer Seq. 20 (2017).

[10] H. S. Wall, Analytic Theory of Continued Fractions, Chelsea Publishing Company, 1948.