Department<of JJ.ls.tic,e In~pectPr Gener~1 Qu~s,ti,onnair~ R~9.ar.din:g ~etain~~s

D,OJ.-01G INVESTIGATIVE QUESTIONNAIREFOR: R:EV1E'WAND USE ONLY B'(INDIVIDUAL FBI ~ESPONDENTS

,.... . . O'P NQT FOItWARD' OR DJs.SEMI~ATE .

qU,ESTION N'AIRE 10: test-O,O.O,OO,542

1-' '.' :.

,,'

.AS,ot ~IJ.~ I~sttime .this qu~~ronn~ire.w~s ~a\!~Jfr'~Qme re-quire.d iielqs; hav~.nc;>t. "een C9IT1ple!~d.PI.eas~\r.e.'vie.wyour resliohses.

~'j]&.:~,:.'::~.

,Gr~Qn~1:Inf~'rn~at~~~: ' ,Please providEHhe fo1I6wih~' information:1. first 1iqm¢ 6&:7CPERA~REElinfENT

'2. Midl1le Inltil:ll: Ii & 'rC,PERAGREEMENT3'; Last name:' 6& l.CPERlJ,GREEMENT

4., El1t~r:ed bJ1 Duty Date ,(EOD): .~ &, 7C5:, Ci:m:eht DLyisi9n}Held bffic~: ~ a,7¢,6). Cqrrent Jp[) title: $peGlal Ag.ent.1: Dire~t~ial office.tel,ephone"number: '6 &7C.PER,AGREEITI1ENT

8. FBI t:~11 phone: riumoer: ~ &;'l¢ PER./.tG;REE/YlENT

,9: Ff3.I pager ,nutnb.er~ 6*,70 PE,RAGREJ=-MENTW. Best: cQn'tact number foryol!~, '611 rePER,AGREEMENT.

J.1; ,At any time all€fSe/itemo.er He 20.01J did 'You sef've.;3s,a member oHlie U. S. Military I Of as an,employee ,or contractor or the, FBI,or any other :government agency, at Guantanamo Bayr. O.lbaj Iraq;Afghi;lnlstC1n; 'or in areqS con!roll~ ~Y' the l):~~ Militq,ry or,a U.S. in~~I.lig~n~~ s~r~i.ce in 'Conn~di.qn wit~ ~he:g 19bal Wi3r 00' ,tenor?

12,., !=n~er the Dumber of til:ne.s~Ydu,weteJj~piQYedO'... :~sSlgnetl. to each oUheJoifowing IO:catio!is.:(GiJantanamo BaYiCuba;, Iratr}.Afgh,fnistani ,6'rin''aoyi areas controlled by the US. MHitaryora U.S~

intelljge.nce s~rVj~~) ;}, ' , . .

For.each deployment or as'signmeilt complete the following section.Location (select om'!) . Dep'loym~nt 9r lis.sigli~erit'l~egiln ,o1',pr Dep)0.vri:iMt or il,sSign.ment~n.de~on,

.. .. abp,ll.t or about,

)du'a'~,t~n~itf£'!f~Y O,8/12J200~. 09/2.5/2.0,03,

1~a. What wa$ tl1e :geti:e~al riat~re ang p,utp'6~~ q"fY9ur assigti!'rt~rjtanQ ;a!:tivjties?FBI interViews and inite-stigatiQris12.b. Please provide, the· names of the,.specific,camps, bases;- or facilities where you worked.GJMO m~in'qlmp only' . .12t: NQrn,: If lnfp'rmafion: cHioLi!:, a~pedf'ic canip~" ba~~;_ or 'facilitY i$ c1a'$~ifjed :ab'pye SE~RET,

please th:e.tk. h~r~ Dr 'include in YO\.l[ :answer tliat you' hav,e· "ad.dI~.f9!ial 'information da$sIfied 'above'SECREf,'~' and; if yoU know, id.entify'the.c1assification level, ticket, ;compaltment, program/,ar',otherdesignation tha~.applies.~9' t~e i.nformat'lon. po not, include the ,adq Itlo,ndl C1assffled fn(ormatiqn !r! your

OIGQ-005213

"

questionnaire response!:l. DIG pers(jf1rlel with the, necessary clearance WiIl.contact you to rec~ive it.

INam: L. ' ' , ~~~~~~: '_ __ ' ' ' _:12~. Old 'YQ,I,J jOintly' iD~~ryieW gr iQt!,;!rn,)gate any det,airi~ewi,ttl tlQn-f~t p¢r~onqel? :':' 0 Yes e NQ ::i2f~ 'DJd-Yo~jOii;tly. p]qit~ari,ytle£ain~ irit~riJiew~,or-lhterr6~;tiort ~str;tegy: 6bj~iVei br tidies-.with non--::::FBI personnel? ':', mm b~

, ..:'W~h ,whit kirtti;6fP'~~:f~i p'~rsOrirtel ~,id 'y~u ~b;i jblnt\y? '. --:- .- - -. - -- - ._... - .. --- - ~ -- ~ -::.: 0.CITF': 0" 'ather u.s; Military,: D u.s. intelligence agenGY,; 0 J=;qre;igl') rnili~ry or il)telligen~ C19.eIlGy:: 0 Q~h€!.r

,.... -.... ~ ~ -.. . , ~ - - --- - -- _ ~ '" .. ~ ~ - ~ ,~ - .. - - - - ~ - - ---'''' _.~ . - -',- -

2- -'--- - - - -:- - - -- ~ -_.- -- - --'- -:"""'; "::'- -- - ...-- -.;"'"- - - ....-.:.-----:-.- -------,,- - --;:- ..."":"-'---:: - -~.-"--- - - ---~-12g. Were.'Vou eVer bl.herwise )nv'01V'e~ in ;detainee' interviews. ori,literrQgation~,With ncin-FBI per.s6nri~I?: '

, . 0 Yes :0 NQ

:PJ.~qs.¢ '~~$ri~:~': Q.b!>erYi3·t)gn '9J int~rv.i.~W~ by l) ,.S,•.Mi1ft<)t'Y; p~rsqnnel---~----'---"---------'-----------'------'_._----'-"-------~--~-----_._--------

b6b7C

~ " • ~ ~ • ". ". I~

A,. Trc,ining Pripr, tp Cv,ers:ea.s, P.epJQymenJ 'or A~s.ignment---:.--=:-- ~----------J

,13. Did:-you receive any tr-aining,.'instnictiOn,or'gLiidance sp-ecifieally ih'preparation f.o'r atly."of'yo'Ur 'Q,'le.r.~~s ,9.epl0.'iIT).~,nts ~r ~ssi9':l!T1en~s? ' , . '.:

OYes .01'lo

Ul'. In preparatlen for' any of You'r ,ove'rse-as: dep16ylri'ents,or- assignmentsl,d IA. Y-QU' receiVe,any trallilng,,'instruction,. OF guidance concerning tne,;standi:lrds~0f:conduct applicable'to .'the treatment~,

il)t!3rviewr1?r' jl:irerrQ9?tiQIJ: oT'4et~inee~ QY f.B~. pers'on,t:te,l?

OYe.s

15. In preparation for' any 6fyo.ur overseas d.eployments;6r assIgnments, dId you receive~any traIning, ,instru~ion, or gl\ic.la!1ce concernJ,ng tb~',9tc\!l9ard's Qf conduct apfllkab.le>~o the.'tr~tll)ent, ;l!1t.!3rvl~Wi qr IliterJq9?tIQn,qf getail1~esby no~';.FBI pers~)I~n,er?

'aY-es

16. In preparation 'for any.of your :o~erseas: deployments 'or assig.nment,s,dfd you receiv.e any .training,instruction,. or g!JTd.ance 'Conceming what yoU were'~suppo~d to 90 if you 9bse:;rve.d 'or' heard about

OIGQ-005214

the treatm,ent, interview" or interrogation of detainees by Fa.I persoJ:lnel" Whic~h you believed tob.~ inappropriate:, '(Jnpr;ofe!!SiOnal~ c<:5erclveJ ,abusive, or unlClwful?

:ayes

1'l, In preparation for any of your overseas deployments or assignments; did you recelve,any tralning r '

instru~lon, or gqidanc:e q:m~emlng Wh<;l,t yOU were suppose,cj t.Q. do 'if yO!J 'Qbs~rved 'or heaxdabbQt .the treatiil.eJit, in,teMew,. or liitertogat'i9.n of detarne'es by n'pn-FIU pi3r~onriel, which ,yOl( JjeJieved,to be inappropriate, unptc)fessiQnal~cOercive) .abusive, or unlawful? . '.

Oyes '0No. ODb .Ndt'Recall

B. Tr~ioing Dl,.Iring Qv~~s~,a~ Dep.Ioyments 'or Assignments

18. During 'any oJ YOllr over.Seas:deployments at assigrfthents, did you receive an'ttrairiing, jnstruction,:or,9 tildance conGefnirig the',sta'ndards of'cend'uct ,apj:Hicabl~ to. the'treatment, IntervieW~.orinterrogation ,of detainees by FBI personnel?

:Gyes ,ONol~a: W,,~,Q:...L1rmdlli~~Lti35Wll.lliJ, 'instryct.iQni- or ,gU!9anc~7

S.lsB. Btil-,"'y""''''',""',es...· c-r....i ...·.e"-·t...-e-s....·u-.-.s~ta:nce of>the train ing:" ihstruttibn,. 'Of' gtlidancf:j. ptovld,l=d to: you.

Inf.cmucllgwI,dC;ftic;e r.~g9J9,il1g possible 'i.ssu~s i.\g~h~ hi,ay, elJ~9!ln~¢r' in .th~ <;:ar.np•.l.~~. WCls'al1Y ;oft~e t.rai,hing:, instriJd.iPn( w ·94id.ar1c~ proyigeq Tn yrrJtJ,hgJ '

QYes' 0Ne· ,(} 00 Not Retaff

19:. $U/ill,g ·any 'Of'YQur overseas,q~ploY'11el)t.s'or as~ignrneii~~; d'j~ yqu re~ivE; C!n;f't,r:a'fni.hg" lnStru.ctif)I'),. Qr 'g t1 idance t9'lCernin'g ·the':s_tan<;!.ard·s Q(condu.et "a'ppli¢abfe: t~ the,:~teatrrYeri~J 'mt~l\Ij~w, or .

ihterr09.atibh of detainee~:by rion-F,BI, personnel?

'0y.eS 'ONo QoO' Not R~l;:an

19a ' ing,. insti't.)ctionr or Quida'nce?

L..",...,.....,,.......,,...-....,.,.......,,.,,...-~ -JAG .1.9,b.J~riefly descr,ibe t ~ !iu~stance.of the t~ajniDQ, i!1~trYoGtiQllrqr'g,4igcwc::e' provjd,~ ~o you,.

In weekly staff 'rrieeti'r'ig-,gu idahce reg,am ing, bouri(hlries~for ihterrogations conductedbY,u..s,; Military personneL tn~lvj(:Iually-""limlta~ions;on constitutional rights fordeta'lnees. ' " . .', , ' , . "

19c. Was any 'of the:training r 'instruction, .or gUidance provided in'writing?

t!>Yes ONq· 0: D9 'N.at Ret:a:fi

2cl'. p'u~irm any of'yoW 0versea~,.deploYll.lentsor a~signments,l:Hd 'yoU re~v~'anY'1raJl,1ing" 'in~n,lcti9n, ,o~ ~uid(nlc,e ,concetning What you w!=r~ Sl:tpr:;O$'~ t~ 90 if yoy 9,bserY~9 Qr b~~d 'a~pyi: ~h'~ ,-treatment iritervleV{, or ihterr0,Qation"oHtetainees by FBI· persp:nnel, which you b'elieved to befnajJ,pt:opriate!, u~nprofessioriall. :coei'ciVel. aous1Ve, of uhlaWful?-

b6b7C

b6b7C

'0Yes ONo~2aa. WHo' pr:0vided this training, instruction, 'or guidance?

·boo Not Recall

OIGQ-005215

2:0b, ~~eflY describe the sUbs!anc~of the ~r~iningJ in~ructionr.or guic;la,nce provided t<;r y0U,, Individual ,guidance to' rhanage potentially' prilblematic·situations:wherein individuals

from other agencies may be usi.ng. tech.niq!-!es not'approved by the. FBI..20c. Was any of the.hc!ining, .instruction, or ~liidance prOVided In writing,?

OYes ~~p 0 Bo. Not RetaH

:ll. DlJring any 'of yoiJr overseas,deployments at asslg nments, did you reGelve any tic! inlng, instruction,or gUidance'conee.rning wbCj.tyouwere suppos~ tO'do jf you obs~rved or he<,lJd about the~j-ea'trrtentrihrervi§W~pi" Int~rrQgati.Qn: df'detqine:es by n~ti-FBIp~r'~onn~I,Which :yo~ Qelie:ve~r to.Be inappropriate, unprofessional,. coerCivet.:ahusive( ,Qr unlawful?

b6b7C

OY~. 0Nb :00,0 Not Recan

I...C_"_A_d_e....;<J;...u_a_t.;.;;.y_o_f_T_ra_i_n_in.....;·9 1·.. , ..

:i't.In your opinion, dId' you rec~l\(e adequate, tralnlnQ, Instruction,. ?fJluldance relating to.standards,,of conduct qy -FBI ·anc!· non-FBI personnel r~!ating. to treatment, interview;, dr interro'gatio.n 'of.det~fineesprior ~o~'i'our··d~p:loymentor:assignment7

l2a. prease desGribe the·.ways:in which you oelieve the training,. instruGtion,ol' guidance wasinapequate:,'Nitti i:l').~" h~n.ent gf2~f~O QiJJ~~rg hti g:r~a..t.er;, fQrm~J :g u.!(fan:ce rega.rdi'ng,tb~ F~rs' responp.i bJltty· tp

d pbflc~" bth~r·ag~ncl~~ bY, ft:P.ortllJg miscphtluct a.s,well as· cot'le;;r~te gl,lldal1ce r.egardlng tectml.qu~$. that.constitufed misconduct iN.ould· have' been helpflil. " .

. ...... - ....... - .. - .. -_. _....'" ,... "( - - ~ . _... ... -' -~ - - .. - .... - --- ". -. / ... _. ". --.... - ." ...... -. --- - .... - _. . - .... - .

;2q.In Y1:iur:Q'pihio!i, di~' Y9lJ i.ec~iYe(a.t1eq!""ate training,. iilstrudi6.n,..oi\gUidance reia:tirig to'stal'ldc\rM.of condUct by FBI and noh-FBI l>ersonheLrelaun~'td,·t'teatmeflt'!inferVieW{ or rnterr6!l.~ti6n.Qf

detainees during: your qeployment or Clssig nment? .

Q'Yes 0 No

. :23~.~ PJei~~~. ci¢;cri'b~,tlie- ~riY;:i~ Which'Yd~ 1>:~li~v'~ tb~ tt~ihhtg,~ r~~ti~ttjdh:o.t .~,~id~~c~':~a;·· .,. - .. - ~ ;fnaaeqiJate: ' " ,. . .At thetime,. the 'guidance, provided se~ed ·adequate. However'" with the benefibof:20j29: hindsight, .

._ j~':"l!l1j'lg_~e:.~~.r.ib:e.ifJ~.!P..'(r~~~9JJIi~'!9~~~{~:.:Y.te.ulet-~.~v-'eJ~~p.~z.E:rHj3_r,:~! f1lY31J~i.y~131 £3J1119:. __ ~ ,

24. In ·your 'opinion, did' you recei"e adequate training! instruction,or.guidance concerning what youweresu.ppqs-eg tp <;1o. ifyot.J ob~erve{i .OT ht;?!rd' -a~~untJe treatm~nt:r 'iritervij:!w,'O[ int~rfpgation of~.¢t?li.h~~s., bY.F.B~Wnt?h~FBI persqnnel,. tlia:t yO!) 'believed ·W~·s.lh~ppr:oRtia.te)'. ynpr:ofe,~~li:mai;:coercive, ~bUsi\ie! or unlawful? . .

o Yes $ No. ·2.4a:PI~~S~~d~~itr~t~; w~ys~I~'VihiGhY0u ·bcll;y~ ihe tr.~·I~I-l1g:ln~irQctlp~ ..O~,'g~ld.~n:~~wa·$- - -. - ~.

inape:q,U'i=1te:_T~~~r)9.!~J~~~~ ~~t!:lB!:!ld~~~eJ~g~(~!.tJ9.!~i§.~a~~e~. -: :

OIGQ-005216

25.. (ORtionai) In what ways· can th~ FBI improVe trainihg on this subject for f.uture, deployments.,or-assig,nments? '

I believe:the:'role·of the FBI and Agents in sue:h -situations must be,dearly,defined. ACthe time';of mydep,loyment 1:9 GTM9,r t!1e ~nQersta,nd ing c()nveyed to m~ 't-Jas., t~i3t thC? ~:q;. Milit9ry wC!~ tile ,lead 9gency)

they had th~ir'o\Ni1 rule~tha;t ~hey Were.bp~rating Wider, and our role; was t,o c.dn~uct FBI ,busin:es,s by.:coordinating with Milita-ry- trersonnel without 'int~rfering in th~ir acce'pted ·practic~5-. We 'w¢r'~ p'r6vid~9

witha,c6py of approved interro~.atiori techniqiIes to give wine·C1arification as t6 their accepted.practices. !:;hould the FBr be.taking on the role.of '''poli'cing". other agenoies~. that role should be clearly

e:Qml:m-!!1IC?t~ tq. Ag~n~s 'prlpr to:~nd'~urJ!1g thlFlr deploym~l'!t.

': 26. Please proVide any atiditiO.rial informatlo'n,d:>.ncernin9 tr-aining' for (lverSeaS,deployments.orassig nments cif FBI pers0nnel you believe is -relevant.' .

S.ee above.,

~_'{~~~'@1~.·~i~_.. "Q]~I~\~~~(§);:~~. '.:":',"

,Introduction to 'PartIII: In- this ·section,;:we 'are seeking. infol1T1atio~ regarding, a wid'e range. of­I~,t~(-Vie~. 9r lI1terrog~tid.n ~~c~niq(Je?: pnp 'q~l1.er typ~S:.9f c!e!~i11,~, trea~r:n~J1.1; :A1I~gl~~, t;Q h.~ve OC\:,u n:~q:"t:,OlJ §,hQ.l!I.cJ :riq):'.a~s~1I11eT jl):st Ji~UAs.e w~.~'r.:e:~l'~Kilig. :aijPJ.1't a pa[ii.cula.r j:~clin'iq\tepr p.r:adi!=~, ~h~t We: n~ve,concludea that iti.ii: fact-b~tu.rred. We recog'hize that"some-ofthe'se techJiicjlleS:br practices' mi3y-~t timesbe, riecessci'ry fOr',sCifety and, seCurity rn a .d.eferition settiFig. I'n ai:lditien, ,w.e .recognize that-,some.oHhese'~~d~n!q!:le~f()rprC!9ti~~1Tli!l.Y- ,helve be'E¥i 9ut~9rized fpr,use'!?v mln~a,ry <?rottrer g~<?ve~nJl)~,nt .p¢r~9l)n,~J.·

With re$jJ~tt to:eq:ch itf¢htifiM t~chili,que, prci'tj:i<;e,..o.'rtyp~ of c~ofld,liGt:des,c;tjp.ed pe!QW" W.e :ck¢ se~l{ing,irifomiatlQh'about It~9Gcurrelic~.during .or-in c.onnectl6n wlth'toe interview or Interrogation' Qfa·detainee"or during, the detention :ofcr detainee' beyond what is needed 'for safety ,and security,.ID'~fiat·r;SliiteJ:CJi we Will C\sk, YQIJ ~Q ~ell ~s w~~~he( 'qfl!= -9f more of-thE;. foll\?wfng ;stafernen~~ ar~ t~,e:

L I pe'r$Qh.~i1y·o~ser-ve'd tlil~ cpndllGt.2\ I',observed :detaiJiee.(s) in 1:1 :conditiob that led. me td .believe that this,coriduct had .occurred,'3. Detarneefs] told me-that this:.conduct had occurred.4.- 9.ttTer~~ho 9b~rv~d th1~' CC?!ld,!-lr;r9~~~rrb~-q'i~, t~' me:,~.- I have"rele:v2i'nt fnf,br(natiQn <;:Ia~~ifled appve·II,SECREP,.-'6. r never Qbs:-¢rY..ed this ,conducttlOr h,ear~ 1:lbolJt it from some:qOe,WhQ.d id..

"27.., D'epriving a detainee onood ,or water

a':· 0 r PJ~r$,Qnally Qbserved thiS con!JuGt,

b;. D r- Cib$'eJV~d -oetarne'ets) in ,<:I c?5nd ition ~bat led 'l11e to belr~yethat tlii~ tcin'd,l,l~,had Q'c<urr~d.

c. 0 D~,talnee'(s) toid Ill¢ that ~nis. concj\,lct had pccllrred.

d. 0 c:>thers: wh'o obser:Ved this tond,uct desWbed it to. I1ie.",

e. 0 r. have relevant information .tIassified ab.ove "SECRET"..- ..

OIGQ-005217

f. l~r I never observed this conduct nor heard about It from 'someone who did.•

'.28..Depriving '~ detainee~ifcla.thing

a. 0 I p~ndlly observei:l this .conduct.

p. 0 [o.bserY_ed:,detainee(s). in'a condition th~t led me: to beJie,ve that this- c;on.dl,l~ h~ oc~urted.

c. 0 Detainee(s) t'old 'me that tliis c:;:ohCIuct nad .o.ceut'r"ed.

d. 0 Others who Dbseiiled thls cb"nd utt deScribed It.to me.

e. 0 I have relevant information classified aboVe l'SECRET".

1. 0 I. never observed' thls:canduct nor heardaboutlt ·from.someone. who did.

.,'29. Deprivlng,a detainee:of'sleep; or interrupting sleep' by frequent cell,reloca.tions;or other methods

a: 0 I' ~ersonail'{.(j.b~rv.e.d this.:cqn~:h..l~t.

b. 0 I'ohserv,ed.a.etaine-e:<s) iii ~'cohditibn thl!lt led me: to believe thaUhis c.6nduct·had .QceurreB.6. 0 Oetaine.e(s) told me that thi~,tor1duj::thad ,occurrea.

d. 0 Oth.ers· !Nbo 'obserVed this CondUct descr.lbed It 10 r.ne;e. 0 haye 'relevant itlrorma"ti6il classified aboye "SEeREP'.

f. 0 I never-obServed.this;ooliduet Ii.br""heard about-it from someone who,clio.

"9.- P!~~.s~ RroYI~e.t~~ approxllJla~e irme 'fiame,~uringwhich t~ls,CQnd·uctoccurred.

From- .0."9/2Q03 ~o· 99/.:29'0;3 000 'Nct( Re~1I

OIGQ-005218

h. The,detaihee(s) treated in this way were. located at the time in::l. 0 Guaritana~d2 [j'Iraq3 tJ Afghanistan

4 d Q~tyer l.,ofatjon

S0 D9,NQt,~~1I

Ij Plffise jdentify·the detajnee(s) I~~t~~~e~i~~~~~e~~be~ ~(jaL690P ,

'j. 'Please identify the 1Jersoil(s) who ,treated the 'detain'ee($J hi this marme(, including theirname(s) and government,agency(.l~}: ' .

,tc;!t;l nqt kOQVV W119 ,~pe<)ificaJly'did th[s•. The:d,etain~~ wa~rol) ~he j!freg!Je.nt'fry~r program" Whichfn\l.o'ly¢.dnUtrleroU'$ cell change,S, fit p '24 hour pe.rIpc;ll'to inciUdi: Ce!J{:h:qn~e:s ttifQugtioutj:h~

, rii9'tlttime. hoaTs, '

~. Please ideri,tifY',~M'Qtl'ier FBl pers~nrr~1 qr nQn~FeI p'er'~9riliel WhQ Qb,~rved d~t~h,~e(~) treated

IiO this' m@het in~lsUp'd,ecin,gl'a'~hA.egir na'm.e(s) 'and iq,gency(ies) ~

. _ II, el)ti,. was al§o a\'Var~ ~f th:i's techniqge

,I~ This,condtH;:to<::~urre~, i'1 '~9nlJe¢.ti9!1 Wltt1:,i '0 ,One. detainee

i:o ~e~er~i ~~~~in~ees (~-4);3 0 Mariy:Cletaihe'es (rhbre:iIi~!J ~J-4 d DQ Not Recall

'The>numb,er of d~~C)ih~~$- i$'lm~n,ownjo ,me}' but 'it j'$ my l,In~~rstqng ihg tha:Ohts t¢ern:ii.Q l!'e' was'()~ed Mrith rlumerou5:,i:i,etainees.

'a. 0 II.< persdnall}(.obsei'\l,ed. thls~<;:ohdu(;;t.---------------------------1b, 0 I .observed :aetainee(s) in :a',E:ond ition that led 'me.to belieVe thanhis c6.ndLiCt,,hadocc'urrea.,

c. 0, Uetai'nee(s)-t6Id me that this cotiduet h'ad ,oetLirfed.

d, 0 pthers who observed this conduct d'escribed It to me.

e. d.lL have re/avant information classified above ','SECRET".f. 0' If n~\ltrQb?erv~d'thiS ,condu~t !lor hea~dab_ol)t, itffQOJ'sorne9n~ wh9 Qid,.

.31; Using' wa~er,t9 pre.yen~' ~reat,hir:Jg by 'a .qetalm~e, dr t9: CfE$t,e :the sen,satlcm' or.-·drowning

b2 per DODb6b7C

b6b7C

OIGQ-005219

.. , ..

a; D I personally observed thls.conduct.

b. D II observed detainee(s) in a'conditioll that led me to believe that this conduct had occurred.

c. D Dt?tainee(~) told me that ~hi~ condlJd ~ad 'oq:urre~t

.~. 0 Otbe~ whp 'observ~q this l;:ond1!.ctQes~Jlbed ~t .to .me:

e.· 0 I have reievant information c!assifiep pbove "SJ;C.RETJ\ •

:- ,.... .._------------. --f. I~r r never observed. this ,t9n9lJ~t nor heprd 'about it (rom.:SQn1eonewho did.

'32. U$lflg, hands, rope, Qr:·anythlng else to chok~ or strcmgje ad~ainee.

"a~ d ~,personally.observed this·conduct.

b. D 'I observed'f!etainee(s) In'a condition that led meto belle.ve that this Goniluct nad .occurred.

~! 0 Detai.nee(s) ~qld rn~ thqt this ~onduc;thpd 'occurJ~:

<L 0 9t\Jel? wl19 opsecye,d t.hls <;:Orfd,U9t d~~eril:!ed jt tQ ftIe;"

e... 0 I. hj'ilVe.re.I~v.arit l.iJfqrm~:tIQn' flcfssJfl.ed <,!~ove "~'ECREf'!;

f. 0 I never Qb?t;lnL~.q t~j.s·1C;QnquGt .noY ti~rd 'aQQ.lJt it fr9rrr,some~l1e'Whodjd.

a'. D I pe'tSGnaHy observed this eondud.

b. [j I·observed detainee(s) in'a condition'that led me.to believ.e that this conduct had ·occurred.

c- D petainee(s) told me that this conduct had .occurr.ed.

d, D !btners' who ob~er:v~d tnis. condu.ct·~·escribed it to J11~;

e; o II have relevant !nforrn~ti?n dC!ssifi~d above "·SECR:ET"·.

f. o I. n!=V.erobs.erv~:~ t~iscon~~!3t lrqr,heArfl·.qbqut. it Jrorn',~qm!=Qne w11lJ. qid.

,~~ OJh~r treatment qr p.g:iQn G3l)sfng s!g.r'tlfi~cmt 'physical p'ain pr injury, pr Ga),fsilig di,sf[guremen.t or;death" . '

~'. D I- person.~IIy o:bserv~d thi~ <;onduct.

b: 0 I;oQ,seryed .detqlne~(s) In 'acondlti<mthcit led me to' believe.thaNhis conduct had :occurred..' ~.. '. " . .' . ~ .. _. .. .... -. .~. o IDe~ine~(~Ho.ld rn~·t/1qt thIs conduc,t bad 9ccurr:eq.

d., 0 O~.her?· Who ob~rv~q 'this to·n~~(;:t·d.est.ribeQ i(to m~·........... . -~ .. " ... - . ••••••vv .... v .. ..... ..._-- ... .. .. .. •• v • ............. . _-- ...- ....- .. ..... .. . ..

OIGQ-005220

, .

,

e. D I have relevant Information classified above '~S.ECRET".

t: 0' I never observed this ,conduct nor heard about it from'someone who'did.

.3'S•. Plac:;ing a d'et~Jnee ph a hot SUrface qr burning .a d~ti3inE;:e

.a. D I p~rsonally obs~rv.ed this:conCluct.

b. 0 I.boser'ied de'tainee(s). ina·condition that leo ~me .to. believe that'this conauer. had dc.cdr-r;ed.

t. D Detainee(s) told .me that this:cond'uct had occurred.

:d.. D' Others· who observed this conduct d.escribed it tame.

e. q L have relevant Information classified above' "'SEGRET".

f. 0 I never.observed thls.:conduet nor'heard 'about It 'from-someone,who did.

':3(j,.~sing sh~ckl,es or .o,th~r r:E;lshgints in ,a prQ[0oged 'IT!ann~r

.a. D r p~rson~lIy'observed this conductt.

lb, D I"observed det.ainee(s) In a,epndition that led me to believe that this conduct hcid·,o,Gcurrea.:

c; 0 Detaln~(s) told me that rhl's !=ond'uct ha,d .occurred.

,d, 0 others' who ·6l:iseroed this conduct described it to me·,e. 0 r have -relevant ioformation (}Iassified "'lbove I~SECRET'!~

f. [~f r: never observed this..c:onduct nor heard ab()ut it ,from 'someone who did.

'-37. ~e'qUirlng <a,detaine~<to m,afl)t~'in; or res'trairjing a .detafnee:ini a 'stres,s[uj or painful positio[l

;3. 0 I, pe.rsonaHy o'bserved this conduct.

b. D Iohserv.ed detaihee(s) ib.a cbnditibn that led me to believe ,that this: Gbnduct had ot.turted.

.C: o ~Detajil~e.(s) told :frie that this cond lid had :o.tturr.€d .

o IOthers' whO observed this C9nduct described it to. me."

d.

~ 0 II ~~~.~ rele~~ht inf~~mation claS~ifjed above. ':S~~REfIl.. <' ." '< .~lr never observed thls'condUct nor heard ,ab0ut It rrom"some.one who dId.

OIGQ-005221

from 09/2.003. to' 09/2003'

h. T~e ~etaiOEi!e(~) treated i.n this w.a.y were 19;cat~ at th~ ~jm~li! 'In:1 gI ~uan~<:!n~niO .

20 Iraq3. 0 ,Afghanistan

,If 0 ·Other Location

5000 Not Recall

Dna Nor Recall

i. Please'identify the detainee(s) by name ,and' number:I 1rnternmel)~ Serial ~um~tL-__ 101l9.?~9I?P b2 perb6

·j,PI!=!.asl:!. lo!=!n!ify- the person(s) who lre.ate"d. the detalnee(s) hi th~ rnanh'err intludirtg their b7Cnarriets) and g6v¢rnment·agency(les): ' .I cal"!' not recall his,true. name. Marine CaptaIn" ~ryt 'by the niCknam~ Irequested the stress~itio.n. Other guard.s:at"the.c.amfj :assist~ Witl) this;

k. Please Idenilfy-·any·other Fat personnel or non-fBI 'personnel who, observed detainee'(s) treated'in this manner!' Including tttli!ir name(s} a'nd agenCY(.ies):S~ I·.. . ..I. This·col'ldUet .oCCLlIted. in connection-with:'1 '.0 One deta"ine¢:2:@ gev~ral detain'ees (2-.4.1

3:0 Ma!1Y {letglin~r~s "lmt;>re than 4)'4 0 Do ~.o.t R=I!

m. (Opiional) Please describe. the relevant·cir.cumstances in more-d.etail:

I 'had heard.of thlS.let::hrilC\lle. being uSed with.other detainees" but onIV",QtiseNed' It ,b'n one"occasfgn with the getainee·<:!.bo~.

'3'8. forcing a·,detainee fo perf.oITrl"demahdhlg physical exer.Cise

a'. 0 pel";sO~~Ily'observ~~~hls '!=Om;luG.l.

b: 0 [Q~se.r:ved detainee(s). in :;;t,C9nPi1=lo./lthat I~ m~, to- b,eliev~· that this conpl,lC!;- h~ oCtiurred.

q. 0 be~ain'ea(sltol~ tn"e ~ha~ this- "C~ndlJ~t f@p Qc~urr~.

d, 0 Qthe$ WhO tlp.S¢"rv~ ,thiS, aql1.dl:lc.t d'es.Cr.lbed I~ ~o. me!.

e. 0 "': nave re~va[lt fnrormiltloJ)" cfa~ifi~d i!1Q<jve. ;iSECR'ET·~

f. 1<1 r never oBserved this:c9nciu<;:t ~Qr hear.d .abbut It frpm Sofr)eon¢,who ".did.

.39. Using" ,eltktfital sno'r!:k·on a delafriee

DoD

b6b7C

OIGQ-005222

"

d~ 0 I personally observed thls"conduct.

b. 0 [,observed detainee(s) in a 'cone! itiorl' that led me to believe thatthis conduct had 'occurred.

c~ 0 De~ainee(s) tol,d me that this conql,let ~ac! 'o'cclJ[.red.

9. 0 Oth~~ who 'ob$eryed thl~ c:ond.L!ct:d'es~ribed It; tp me.

¢. D r have refevant inrormatiolJ c1assi(ie~ above. "$.J;CREr>I,.- - --- --f: 0 r never o,bserved this cgn.cfu"et nor heard 'i:} b,out it from ~me~>ne who 9id. ,

'40. Threqtehlng to.use electrical ,sh6clcon a detainee

a. p 1. personally observed this conduct.

b. 0. l~observed, detainee(s) In ·acGl/Jdltlon that led me to believe that this conduct nacJoccurred.

€. D Det~i.pee(sj tqld me that t/lis conduct hpd '(jccurreif~

C!~ o (oWer.s whp 'o_b$e!Y~eJ :tl)is cQnd,u~t de~cribed It to, IT,le..:

e. 0 r h9ven~l~va'rit 11)(~rma~lo,n fl,rs,s)fi~ Clb9V~ "~'EC'RET"!.

't 0, II o~ver QP~r\(~Qtbjslc;ondlJet nor hc::,ara:~gh9,llt it from: -?ome~me~Wh() qid.

a'. D r persori'any ,observed this conduct. '

b. 0 I<observed detainee(s) in 'a condition that led me to believe thatthis Gonduct had 'Occurred.

'c, o lDetainee(s) told me that this: conduct had ,occurred.I

Q. D !Others who observ.ed t.his condu,ctdescribed it to fTlt):

'8'; o It h~ve ,rel~valJ~ jnTOrfTl?t~qn ~Ia!>sified 'above, "SE:C~cr'(.

t 0' ~,nr=yer;OpS!2rvf;:dthis 'cpnpllPt 'J1,Qr,hearp 'a Qc;1Ut. it /rprrr.sqmeone. whp' d.id.

a. 0 I personally observed this cOIidlkt.

)3: 0 roBser.Ved de'taineets} iri ,a~tona itloh 'that led me to, believe thatthis condiJtt' had ocdirred..

.c; D Detainee(s:) told me that this conduct had occurred . I

'Q: D. Others whD :obser:ved~tlis cond,w;r de~cribed !t tp me..~. 0 r ~av:e retevant Irlformation c;las!:?ified C!~ov~ '!SECRET"'.

;

OIGQ-005223

[] I.~f II ne\ler'ob~erve~ this conduct nor heard about It from 'someone who d'id.

:2j.j. Subjeq:ing a.detainee to ,extremely cnld or hot ro.om tempen'l~tures for extend,ed periods

a. 0 I per.sonally observea this ,conduct.

p. 0 'I bpselYed cdetainee(s) In a cond'itRm th\:'lt led m¢' to b~li~ve that this, cort.clu~t M,d occurred.

c; 0 Detai!ie~(s),toldme ~tiat this conduct had ,od:urred.

,d. 0 Others who Qbseiired thIs ccJnd udt described it to me,

e. 0 r have relevant. rnformation classified abol/e, "-SECREf'~.

f: It1 ~,never observed this:conduct nor 'heard aboutit from someone who did.

a: 0 t p:ersoil~II}':O:bse-rv~tj this.:cqn,c1u~t."

b. 0 I'-obServ.ed detaln~.e(s)' jn:a ',cbtiditibr'i that led me. to 6eUeve that.this condact had ,occurred.,

c. o p'etain~(s) told me that this con<fuc,t had ,ocC'iJrred.

d. 0 Otb,ers' Whoobser:ved thiS t,onduct described It to in'e. I.e. 0 I have 'relevant iOfertnation classified .-abmJe '~S-ECREJ"',

f. 0' I never- observ.ed, this,'coiiduct:nor' heard :ab-out it .from'someonewho, did.

,45. 'Subjectlng ~ d~t~jne~ t9l?rlg?.:.h;;.:;"t..;;t!~~....~h:.:.:,i;.:.ng",....;.;II""g':.L~t;;;;:~...;'o:.::.l...:'d:.::a.:..:rk:.::·lJ:;.:e;;:;.ss:i,.? _

a. 0 I p~r:s6tialiy opserve.t;l' this ¢Q!i'duct.

b.. 0 I ob'selVe,d d.~talrl'~,e(i) In 'a cDiid itlon that led me- to. beUeV~ tha:t,thIs t.oncluct' had :occurre,d.

t: o \Detainee(s) told me that this- conduct had 'o,ccutr:~.

d. 0 Others: Who observed this coridud deScribed it to' me.e. 0 I haVe .relevant Informatlo.h classified aboVe, ':.SECRET".

fl0' I neVer observed thistcoriduct nor heard -aboUt-it from someone'\lvh6 did .... ,,' .........., ........-.- ............., ..._ ...,........ , ..... • _........- _____~·· ... n.' ,,_ o~_~~.•_ ..... ,.." . ..;"''''' ... _~ _ ... _.... " ............ . ., ......... ........--,-.'

46. Isolating a, detafneefoJ an?~xtended period

OIGQ-005224

, ,.

a. D I personally observed thls,conduct.

b. D I observed detainee(s) in a'condition that led me to' believe that this conduct had occurred.

c. 0 Detainee(s) told me that ~his condyd: had ·occurred.

d. D bthen; wl10 'olJserved this t;bnd.l.!ct,<;I:es~JlbedIt to me:

e. 0 I hav,e relevant information c1assifi~f1.ab'ove."SECRETJ~.

f: I~r rn~\,Ier a.bserved thiscQnJ!4¢t ndr near9'about it from;~rrieone··w.h9pid.

47. Uslng"duct tape to r~straln, gag, 'or punish: a detalne,e,

a; D Lp.ersonally ebserved this <::onduct.

b. D, I'observed'detalnee(s)'lna'Gondltion that led meta beJieYe that this aonduct had occurred.

<=;; D Det~i.l)ee(s) tqld me thq~ this: cond 1,J(;:t h?ld 'Qccurred..

g:- D otl}er:?' lAIhi', o!J~e,ry~q ~hfs ~(;mtl.u~.t d.~sc;r,ib~ jt t9' me.;e., 0 I hi?ve 'r~l~v,a'rit J,I)f~rma~l(m c1a~s,s.JfI.e~ ?lbQve "·~'EtRET.I!.:

f. 0' II n~ver"o~$erV,¢,q this;<;Olidl:!~t norh~rd 'about, it from'som~pi1~'whodid,

a', D II persenafly',Q,bsenied this,coilduct.

b. D !I,observed detainee(s) in a'cond itionthat led me to believ.e that-this cenduet had 'ocGurred.,c. o jOefuinee(s}told me that this conduct had ,occurred, I-

D!O~her.s 'N,he obse0'e.d this con.du,ct descr!~ed it to me;:d,

e'. D iI ~?lye rel~yant ini'orm~~i91",c;Ia.ssifleq ,'a bove ">SECREf";~

t o II, n!=yer·o,~$~r.v~:9, thi,s 'q?npJ.1~,t T!qr "h~r:.d ';::lpqut. it ,from ,sQm~orr~ WJ10 did..

49. ,0:~ing 'a military: wQrkirig 'dqQ Q'tl ;d.r n~ar a' det,ci'jn~: b~h~r than 'dLJrlrtg d~,taineetrahsp,9rtCltibh

a, 0 I pers6ri'ally, obserued this:condt.i'd.

Jf, D r,obserVM de'tainee{s) in ;a'.tOhditlon'that led ine to. belieVe thaUliis conduct fiad 0c'dirred.,

c; 0 Detainee(s) told me thafthfs conduct had occurred.

Q,. 0 Others whQ :obser,v,~d. t,~is l;8!1q u<;t de~cr'iqeil it to me.,

~'. D I ~a\fe ,retevant [l)f~rlTfati9n classified C!bov~ "SECRIT',.- ,

OIGQ-005225

[[gOtnever observed this condu~t nor ~eard about it from so~eoneWh'o did.

50. Threatening to lise mliitary working dogs on or near a detainee

a. o II per.sonaily observed this condtJct.

b. 0 I QbseJV.~d detain"¢e(s). in a cond'iti<m thj3t led me' to b~lie.ve thflt this con~uct hadoctunetl.

c;. 0 D¢taine~.(s)told me that ttiJs'conduct had ;octu'rred.

.d. 0 Ottiet5! WilD n.bseroed Uris conduddestribed it 10 me.

e. 0 I have relevant information classified above "SECRET'!.

f. 0 I. nev.er observed'thls~c0nduct nor heard about it Trom someone. who did.

si. .Usjng spiders, :scqrpionsi snakes, or'other an\m~ls:on 'or neqr a,de~ajl')ee'

;:;1'. 0 r p:erSQtt'allY',(),b!>e-rv.~q thiS::c,Qn~\1c.l.

b. 0 Iobsery,ed. detain¢,e.(:s) in.a ',condition that led me to believe that tbrs c.6nduct had :octurteCl.c. 0 Detainee(s) told me that this.conduG.t had ,ckcurred.

d. 0 Others Wh.a obseriie'd tbls p,o.nduct described It to. me.

e: 0, ~r have relevant information classified abeye "SECRET""

f. 0' ~ nev:er' observed. this:concfuct nor'heard :about.it from:someo'ne:wh6 did;

52:,. Threatening to u,se spider~, 'scorpjO!l~t ,snakes,. or()th~( 'anlma!!; Qn a. 9etaioee

.a. 0 t p~r.s6haliy 6..Qser-vep thisc,()Jid.u.ct.b:. D !t obser\(e.d,d.~talnee(~)' In~ ·.condltlon that led me to b~Ueve that. this: tohduet· hail.occurred.

t. 0 D'etaihee(s) told me .th~t thi$conduct had :occurtf!(f.

d. 0 QthetS: whl:>ol).sehted -this corid UCt'de'scri5ea it 'to' rnae. 0 I ha\.ie releva'rit Information classified 'aboye. '~SECRR"·. i

if, 0' 'I' never observed' ttiisi.condlict"nor heard aboilt.it from someone'who did. ..~,,__,~...J, _J... _.. " ......... ' .. _ " .••" _. __." ....... , ..,_ .. ",......._"•. " _ ....... _ ........_...... _ ..~~___ ...

·5-3. JJisr.es~ectful statements; handling! 'or actrons' involving t.h~ Kor.an

OIGQ-005226

- ,. , . ,

a; 0 I personally'observed thls.conduct.

b. 0 r observed detainee(s} in a 'cond itioll that led me to believe that this ~onduct had occurred ..

c. 0 De~ainee(s) t01d me t!laqhi? €onc!yd had 'occyrre4.

d. 0 Others 1IVho 'ol1sery~d thfs condUct d,~~qlbed It to me'.

e. 0 I have relevant information classified above "SEtRET"'.,..:.- I- -'.::.-------..:.--------~-...:-~,----'-.-----~---------. -----

f: 0' ~. n~ver9bs'er'{ed this .cqn.dll.ct n'ar heard >about it from :someone "who di9:.

54. Shavlh:g a. detaln~'~ facIal or other halrt.d enjbarrass: or humllla.te: a .detainee

a. q ~,personally 0bserved this conduct.

b. 0, I ·observeddetalnee(s) Ina'Gond Itlon t~at led me to believe that· this conduct had .o·ccurred.

G: 0 Del:~i~ee(s') told tTl€; th~t th!s ~ondu~t hpd 'Qc<;u~rt;eL

d. 0 O\~'er§ wh.9 'O_q~ery~.d tris c0nd~~t"d~'~crI~ed jt t9 me..·.e., 0 I have relevant Information da-ssJfied above ",SECREf't.

" ., • h • .~ _ ' ~'. ..... •• ,. _. ".... ~ ~

f. 0 I ne\1.er'o,.b,serve,~ t1:iis~c;onduCt n~r h~rd ,abo!J~ it from sOIT].~9n<?'wh() d'id.

a'. D I personarry obserVed thiseonduet.

b. 0 I ·observed detainee(s) in a'<::ond irion that led me to believe that thrs Gonduct had ·occurred.

c; D lDetainee(s) told me that thiS c<:>nduct had ,occurr.ed.

d, o IOthers Wh0 obser;v~d tnis conduc.t described it to me(:

e'. .0 !~ have,relevant jnfOfl1l?ti9n c1ass~ff~d 'above '!·~.ECRET'~: .

f. 6ZJ' It,. n~ven~tis,er~€!~ .thls 'cqnpupt-r!o,r ,h~r.d -abq.u~, !t .fro!1r.sqm~Q~~ w~p d.ld..

5.Q. ::rouching:a detalne¢ Qr actifl'g ~oward adela(nee 'iil ~ S'E:x·l,J.al·manner

.a. 0 I personally oDsehled this. conduct.

b'. 0 r ·obSer:,Ved detalnee(s} In ,a .tona ifroh that led me' tio belieYe ,thafthls condudt tiad ~6tdjr.red.,

c; 0, Det'ainee(s.) told me that this conduct had occurred.

~: D others who observed this,G!,mductdescrlbeCI it to me.• 'I •• • ~ I" ". ,,' \ ,..' •

~. D t' ~ave ,re!evaTlt l!1f9fm9,tion c1a'ssifi~ a~o.v~ '!S.ECRB",.

OIGQ-005227

[!J IiI' II never observed this conduct nor heard aboutlt from someone who did.

57:. H<;>lding ~~t~in~(sl whq wt=r~ not 9fftC;i.allY'~<;KI)OWledged Qr regi~ter~q ?is $u.l=h J;>y the.agE!ncy~etainlng th~ persqrl.

a. 0 I perSonally 6bserVt=d this c-onduct.

b, D I observed defalneeIs} In 'a,co.hd Itlon that led me to believe thaNhls- conduct had .occurred.

c. 0 Detainee(s) told me that til is conduct had ~occurred.

d, 0 Others who obsel1fed this cond uct d.escribed it to me.!--e, 0 I h.ave r~levant: [nformatib!l sl?l.ssi.fieg B!?9ve uSEC·RET'''.

t 0 1,118v.erobst;lrved this conduct 119r h~rd :abol,l.t it from someo!1e; whq dJd.

S8; Sending·a: qeta"itl'~ tp am)tl:t~r'(.';oontryfor more;.pgjl'-r_es....;s...;.:ly....;e_·i....;rit_e....;r....;fo-"g'-a....;ti~on-". _

.·a. D I personal[y.observ:ed this ,condu~t.

b. D i1 observed'detainee(s) in·a.coflditioiT·thatleCl·me to believe thatthis conduct had .occur-retl.

c, d Detaihee(s) told nie that this cond.oCt had .occurred.

-d. 0 Others who 'observed ·this conduct descrfbed it' to' me.

'e. D' II. have relevant information classified -a'hove '.'SECRET'''.

f. o I never observed this'COl,lduct nor' heard about It from someone who did., , . , " '... .. '. ,". , ,'.. '., .

59'. Threatelii09 t9 ;send a deta'fnee to another'couotrY for detenti.Qrl pr more aQg rl,5sjve' ilit~rrQgalion

a. D L persOnally' observed this .conduct.

b. D ir ·observed 'de~airie~(sJ in'a cond itioh tnat led me' to believe Hi~t tl:1is conduct had ·.occu'fred.

c. LI Detalnee{sJ told me that this cohducl: had .occiJrfecJ.d. 0 OtherS who .obserVed this cOndiIct deScribed it to maoe. D. I. nave relevant information dassified above II·SECRET'\:.

f. 0 I'l)evero,b5~rved. this·<:qnqu<;~ nQr h..~r.d ·~.b~4t: it 'frorn~m~~I)~"Yh~9!9,

'{;·o. Threatening to tak~'acbonag,ains"t-a .det~inee's·family

OIGQ-005228

a 0 ~ perponal'Y'ob~rved t.hiS·coJl~uct...b. 0 i:"().bserved:detain~S) tn.a cpnd.ition thi:!t Jed :rre ~o'~I~eve th~t tJ:1is cond!Jct ha.d o·cl;l,lrred..

j:;. 0 D~taln~e(s}tol~ m~ tl)at .t.his: ~~.uct had oCCl,l~red.

d. 0 Pthers'whp "Observed thi~ ¢.Qr1Pl.Jct aescl"i.1;Ied it "tQ m~

e. 0 t h;3V.~ l'eJeV9"nt 1.Ii~rmatioh·tra"Ssifi~ ~i?6vj!' "SECRET~.

t: Itl : n:ever 9b~rv,eQ ~hls aml;luct n9r"h!=£lrc! '<;lb9u,t It "from'sQnr~~mewh9" Ol.d.

.61. Jxttier tre"alment or action al)Jsing severe emotional Of PSychpJoQical trauma to a detainee.

a. 0 I. p!'!r$OnalJy opserve:t tJ;lis colJduct

b 0 I o.l1serve(.rc.tetainee:(~). in;rrq>nPiUon" that 1e9 me ~9 .Qf;nev~ thi;INhls. cqndJJeJ:· had QC!4Jrr~ ..-,"<;,. 0 D~.taine¢(SJ tolp .me t!l~t tllis:@l)due.th!ldoccl,lrred.

d. 0 pthers' w.hp .qb:sery¥ tlli~ ~npuct des_(:r'ib~ it t<;1 me','

e: 0 t have rele.V?int lofQriTi.ation .c1as,~ifled ab,ove: "S,ECRET'''.t: Itl I. rieVer'6b:ser\led tbis'cQnduC;'t n"or h~rd :abQut it frQm:so:m:e9newhQ die.

:62. ,o.ther l'eligiOtis or .sexual harassment at hurriillaH6rtjj.fajl.etalnee

<:I: o. {:personanY'q~s~r:ved ~hr~ GQnq,uct,_

b. 0 tobserved·detainee.(s) fll;a:t~mdij:i9.rJtnat Jed me. to: Qelieve th?lt this'condu:et b~ OC41fl"eP.

~; 0 [;re.~)n~(?) ~Q19 r:n~ t!lii!t t~i~<;:.o~dl,(q 11~:d-~fI)rr:e9:

<I. o 9the~ wbo '9b~rv'¢"9 ·t.hls !:t!nd.u~.de~~lbed I~ to m~:

~;" 0 t have,rt;:levant Irlforrtia}iOD'r;;la·s:slfie;l.abov~ "$~REr';

t Itl t n¢\(¢r 6.bserv.ed' thfS-:q;lliquct npl"!l.ea.r.d pbcLut ,t frQIT1'SQme"Qne, wOO, !:lid.

",6-3. 'OtMr"treatment ofa d~talnf*! tbat .In YOiJr,bplhl6n was'unpI'6fesslon-al f .un'tlUIY H:arsh.on3,ggresslvel

coercive, abusive, -or 'unlawful . . .

a. 0 [ persQJla)ly-ob~rveP this ·cplldl,l,ct.

b. 0 (·9b;::Jery.eO deti'jln:e~t~) In,~ e.onditiQIl that. led me to ~elieye .t.h~tthj5 ,¢Qnif,uq: ha.d ocdJrred'.

c, 0 O~.talne·ets) t9:l~ m~ tt)~t this s:.on9 !J~t had ,o'9C!lrr~.

<I. .0 lOthl'!rs wh'6 pbserve:d thi$ cqnduc.t desc:.tftie:d it lq me.

OIGQ-005229

"

e. D I have relevant InformatIon' classified above '!SECRET",

,f. [~l I never observed this,conduct nor' heard about it from someone· who did..

m:W4~~@;~~ ij64; Did yqu9Q~rveal1Y impersonptlon of FBI per~o.nnel bY'~nyone dlJring an int,erview,or int.errqgCltio.n of:a' d~tainee?

'0 Y~$ (V'No

"65.. Pid, ~ny detainee or 9th~r ~r*->nJell YQ.l! ~hat he pr ~h~ h?39 Wit[lF!ss'ed t.h"~ inip~r:s(:madonof fBi.per.s6nnel.in cQl'1ned,iQi'r w.ith 'a· oe,tain~ interVi~w or iriterrogatio'tl?, :0' y,e$. ,0 No9-~ i>!ea~~ provi~e.the·apprqxfma.te·tirn.e frame during 'which thi,s conduct oq:urre,~.

/From (MjbjyyYy fpm'i'cjt or M]yYYy) ,tq :<.M/.D/yYY'i fo~m.~t Of MJYyyY)' l~lDo Not. Recall

i?~: 1!l~ d~~~in.e:~~$l tr~?!t€=q in tNs:~ay w~:m:~.iq~;:lted ~t;lt ·t,h§l t.lrp~, in;1 !i1,G,~t;lntaD~m9

,;z Olre,rq,'3, 0 Afg.hanistan:4, 0 :CJ.tller location,$ 0 Do Not Recall

9. p($is~ iden~i1y the p¢tQilieeC~) by hci'm'e,ah,d numb,e! ,to, the Pes.t :Qf YOll( r:~cpllect[6n:can ,hot recall

',~. p.1~a~Jden~l.fy,th~ p~r.son(~j who ~r~t~ th~·ge~aln~e(~l fn ~~f~:mi!J:1nert Inc;:luq.ln9, if yqur~~qll, th~ir' rj9m~(s'J ,ana, g9ver.nm~n.t':agentytie'~):: .unknown" ' ,

"e. the. il9m¢,~ of allY 'otner FBi p.ersQlJnel, ,arid ,theilame:s' and 9Qyemment agency' .of rlpri-:FBIpersO'nilel, Whom I believe sa'vi'the,.detaihee(s) treated in this: manner are:' '

.',f.. This·conduct.0ccufr'ed in connection ,with:·10~One detainee"2- .0' :SeveraIdeta inees (2'-4):~3- Q Mc;mY'4,~:ta'il)ees (lTlQre-, tll'!=lI1A)'4- -9 Do Np! Re~1I

,'g. (9p~i9n91) PI~s.e'describe the .releyant 'c!rclJm.st<;l,nc~?·(rr ij'lore det{lil;.',S,ey,eral,Qn.h~ 'pe~aJnees ~ ,tCjIIs~d. to rep'Qfj:~ they'-hap, 5ilJql$~n. t9 p'~~P'le 1f!ho had )den~jfied ,.tl1emselves'i:is. FBI AgentS, but diq oqt:app:ear'to b;e: identificibl¢ 'With' artY'kh!:iwn' FBI petsdi'l'riel,a'sSi{jned, to GTMQ. Jt.w'a$,Qjfficjjlt for me to discern iftlTeir reports were true 'or if the ,detaineeswere fa'bricating in 'order to manipulate interviewers.56. Are you aware of any "sham!' or'''siaged'''detainee:intefYiews or interrqgmoDB,:conducted:fOr·Members-of1h~:Y:$·. ~fl~ess ortb:eir'staff.?, '" .. ... ,. . _,........, ,_ .. ,_ ,

OIGQ-005230

a Yes (;) No

67. To, your knowledge, did any military or intelligence personnel ever deny or delay FBI access to a '',detaine~ t,he Ff3I ~anted .to q!.!estion pecauselhe-:detaillee t:rC!d susta,inf?d. injuri~s C!fter he ~,s capt!Jr.ed?

O'(e~ <!>NI:?'

D1--

68'. Did you ,ever erid your participa':tion ill or' dbseniC:ltlbn of a.detainee IntetV,ieW' or interrogafionbecause :6f the. interview' or interrogation methods. being usedt '

Q' Y.es: ~ N.o,69.. Wef~ YO.l! ev.er t91~thar<:lno~her.FEn:~mp'ioYf?e'enp~, \1}s:QT ,h~.r P9r~lclp.~t!on In·gr, 0R.~~rva~!Qn 9f~"9

·d.¢tgllJ~ i.llte(Yi~w..9r il1l~ITQ9p·ttQn \J¢ca'u~~ .qfthe in.tervtew Qrjnt~rr..Qg.gti~11 Tn~thQ~.$' D.eing!1~ed?

DY:e~ '~Np

o Y.es' 0 Non; Haye you ·¢1:<p'¢'rJe.nGeo ,any. .actua[ Qi' tbr~are[l~, ret;'Uiati.on for r~PQrting 'QQservationS'Qt';~il¢gati9r1s

of detainee.treatment Dr In.tervieW or interrogation actions or practices]' 'dYes~"No

0: Ye-s,(£) N~

71. Duriri.9, a~y of.y(jur,?verse~s aeploYf!1enls o'r-}lsSig nmenls, did you rep~'rt alJ'y'eonlZer~s, regardjngany 'Q'e~¥!I'1ee,JOt~mqe\\l0rlJ1t.efrpga~I~1lp.raqlGes '~r ~t~f?:r.ty.Res 'of-qe.ta,In,~ treatlT1ert yo!.!

,qlJ.serve9, Qr h~rd i;l:tjP.U,t:, Jo '~r nQ.n';'F~I-~Q~rvi~o.ror' Qther' n.on-F~.I·p:ecs,~'nnel?,.Q ye.?- '0 N.o

7~. Hav.e yo.u 'elJeroeen: or.dered br:dir:ec.te'(l not~to repdrt,or,discourag¢d,in. any way'from r:epoH:ir:ig'robservations or allegations: related to detainee treatment or ihterView or interrogation aGtions orpr~ctices? '

'70\ Durlng ?l,,!y,:o(-¥ou.r 0ver~a,? qeproyftJ,en~~ 9r a,sslg nrneritsj qld you report- aIrY,' :G9ncer(l~· reg,ard !ng~.n:'l qet~:rn~~ jI')Jerv!e.w 'or t!1t~rr9g?ti9n praq:i~~.sr or: ptner types oJ delair:t~ j:reC1trne!1~r' t9 pn FBI

, ,_~~p.¢rvl~Qr'?'

74, GOptiQ'oal) PI~~·s.e pr(Md~ .any addttio)1a! i;:,drfllft~nt.s r'e~~.fdihg th~ r~p.or.til19, of I;;do~eni$,r~tat~ tointerv.ieW, or interJogation lechniqu·esr. detention:pradices, ,or,other detainee treatment.It was.mYunderstanding fhat teGhni'ques.utilized' by U:S~. 'Military personnel which would have beenlJ,llR~cept~~,I.~ fQr FBI, R~JS~:;IJI)~! ,to !:J~~ W!=fe.: lJorj:-repo.!'table :in thp,t Milit?lry persofl,nel w~re ?IJj:ingWit!lin .ac,cept~(Ls,t9npS)r<;f?;'Q't ,b,ehaYIQr'fqr tt):elf ~'ger)(::i~s.

,_'~"~~'~' ..0"175: We(e '(OU debriefedl.other tha'n the'standard ciebrief in fD-g72~.c.6hcernj~9 y,our ,overseas.assigrimenf(s),or deploymerit(s) after'you c;ohipleted the .depIQyrrieht(~) or assignrherit(s')J

,OVes· e No

OIGQ-005231

76. Additional q:>mments,..a.mt ReComm~nd.ations.:

Thank yqu for your '~o.op.er.atjDrr in compjetin~ this, qu.estio.nnair~

OIGQ-005232