Is “the Love of Money” the Root of All Evil? Or Different Strokes for Different Folks: Lessons in 12 Countries Thomas Li-Ping Tang The International Conference

Is “the Love of Money” the Root of All Evil?

Or Different Strokes for Different Folks:

Lessons in 12 Countries

Thomas Li-Ping TangThe International Conference on

Business Ethics in the Knowledge Economy, Hong Kong

April 3, 2002 (Revised 9/16/2002)

Co-Authors

Adebowale Akande, Abdulgawi Salim Alzubaidi, Mark G. Borg, Bor-Shiuan Cheng, Randy K. Chiu, Chin-Kang Jen, Ali Mahdi Kazem, Vivien Kim Geok Lim, Eva Malovics, Johnsto E. Osagie, Raja Pholsward, Elisaveta Sardzoska, Allen F. Stembridge, Toto Sutarso, Theresa Li-Na Tang, Thompson Sian Hin Teo, and Peter Vlerick

Now, Please Pay

Attention to my Outline:*The Meaning of Money*The Love of Money*A Model of Unethical Behavior*Methods*Results: the Whole Sample, Compare 12

Countries Simultaneously*Recommendations

The Color of Money

ColorSizeShapeCross-Cultural Differences: History, Culture, People (Citizen,

President, King, Queen), Architecture, National Pride, World View, Euro-305M 12

The Meaning of Money

Father Joseph P. Breen of St. Edward in Nashville, TN Celebrated 40 Years Priesthood on 2/28/2002. (Story by Fr. Wiatt A. Funk.) Turbulence,

In God we..

Priests: Pray, Ask


$20 vs. $1 in a Money BagShall we create a pay-for-

performance program for priests?The Government has no money until

you pay... The Terrorists


Money is the instrument of commerce and the measure of value (Smith, 1776/1937).

The meaning of money is “in the eye of the beholder” (McClelland, 1967, p. 10).

Money is the Measure of Value

Who has more value?1. An Economist Eugen Bohm Bawerk

2. A Psychologist Sigmund Freud

3. An Artist Moritz M. Daffinger

In Austria

Austrian Schillings (ATS)US$1 = ATS 15.53 (1/1/2002)

An Economist ATS 100A Psychologist ATS 50An Artist ATS 20The Value is on the Face of ATS!?Who has the most money?

In the US

1 Dollar Bill: 5 Dollar Bill:Washington Lincoln10 Dollar: 20 Dollar:Hamilton Jackson50 Dollar: 100 DollarGrant Franklin2 Dollar: 3 Dollar:Jefferson Clinton

White House (For Sale)

The Meaning of Money: Theory

Money is a motivator (Gupta & Shaw, 1998; Lawler,

1981; Locke, Feren, McCaleb, Shaw, & Danny, 1980: 381). Money is a hygiene factor (Herzberg, Mausner &

Snyderman, 1959; Kohn, 1998; Pfeffer, 1998).

People’s attitudes toward money can be perceived as their “frame of reference” in which they examine their everyday lives (Tang, 1992).

Managers

*Attract, Retain, and Motivate employees

*Achieve Company Goals (Chiu, Luk, & Tang, 1998; Milkovich & Newman, 2002; Tang, Kim, & Tang, 2000; Tang, Luk, & Chiu, 2000).

Research: Performance Improvement

4 Methods:

1. Participation

2. Job Design

3. Goal Setting

4. Contingent Payment

The Meaning of Money-Motivator

Performance ImprovementParticipation: 0%Job Design: 9%Goal Setting: 16%Contingent Payment: 30%.Movements vs. Intrinsic Motivation.What gets measured gets done (Inc., 1998, June)

The Meaning of Money-Hygiene

Money is a Hygiene factor (Herzberg, Mausner

& Snyderman, 1959). 0, 0 point escalatesSalary has more potency as a job

dissatisfier than as a job satisfier (82).In the lows salary is found almost three

times as often in the long-range as in the short-range sequences (82).

The Meaning of Money-Hygiene

Cameron & Pierce (1994). Review of Educational Research.

Kohn (1993, September/October). Harvard Business Review.

Kohn (1998, March/April). Compensation and Benefits Review.

Pearce (1987). New perspectives on compensation.

Pfeffer (1998, May/June). Six dangerous myths about pay. Harvard Business Review.


Money always represents or signifies something other than itself (Crump, 1981).

One is not interested in money, but in what money will buy (Crump, 1981).

Time is Money

Time

$

Time is Money

My account is worth every penny he charges because of the time he saves me.

This year, for example, he probably saved me five to ten years in prison.

The ABCs of Money Attitudes

Affective: Do you “love or hate” money?

Behavioral: What do you “do” with your money?

Cognitive: What does money “mean” to you?

Measures of Money Attitudes-1

Burgoyne (1990). Money in marriage.

Janda (1998). Love & Sex Tests. Holbrook, MA: Adams Media Corp.

MES


Bailey & Gustafson (1986, 1991). Money beliefs and behaviour scale. Handbook of Behavioral Economics.

Bailey & Lown (1993). Journal of Consumer Studies and Home Economics.

Bailey, Johnson, Adams, Lawson, Williams, & Lown (1994). Consumer Interests Annual.

Doyle (1992). American Behavioral Scientist. Fank (1994). Money handling inventory, PAID.


Furnham (1984). Many sides of the coin: PAID.

Furnham & Argyle (1998). The psychology of money.

Goldberg & Lewis (1979). Money madness: The psychology of saving, spending, loving, and hating money.

Gresham & Footenot (1989). The Money Attitude Scale. Advances in marketing.

Hanley & Wihelm (1992). Money Beliefs and

Behaviour Scale. JEP.


Haraoka (1990). Money & value orientation, PJSSP.

Lim & Teo (1997). Sex, money and financial hardship, JEP

Luna-Arocas, Quintanilla, & Diaz (1995). EAD-6, IAREP.

Luna-Arocas (1998). Dinero, Trabajo y Consumo. PROMOLIBRO

Lynn (1991). The secret of the miracle economy.


McClure (1984). Money attitudes and overall pathology, PAQJHB.

Mitchell & Mickel (1999)**. The meaning of money: Money Importance Scale, AMR.

Opsahl & Dunnette (1966). The role of financial compensation in industrial motivation, PB


Quintanilla (1997). Psicologia Economica. McGraw Hill.

Richins & Rudmin (1994). Materialism, JEP.

Rubenstein (1981). Money & self-esteem, relationships, secrecy, envy, satisfaction, PT.

Tang (1992). The Money Ethic Scale, JOB.

Tang (1995, PAID; 1999, PPM; in press, PR; Tang et al.,

2002), 5 Versions


Thierry (2000). The meaning of pay, in Erez & Thierry (Eds.) Work motivation.

Wernimont & Fitzpatrick (1972). The meaning of money, JAP.

Yamauchi & Templer (1982). Money attitude scale, JPA.

Zelizer (1989). The social meaning of money: Special monies, AJS.

Zuckerman (1983). Sensation seeking.

Mitchell & Mickel (1999)

The well-developed measures are those that have been developed more carefully and used more systematically. There are three of these: (1) the money ethics scale (Tang, 1992, 1993, 1995), (2) the money belief and behavior scale (Furnham, 1984; Furnham, Kirkcaldy, & Lynn, 1994), and (3) the money importance scale (Mitchell, Dakin, Mickel, & Gray, 1998) (AMR: 571).

Why Do We Study Money Attitude?

The Importance of Money (Mitchell & Mickel, 1999)

The Meaning of Money (Individual Difference)

Money Materialism

Other Attitudes--Pay Satisfaction

Why Do We Study Money Attitude?

Pay Dissatisfaction has numerous undesirable consequences (Heneman & Judge, 2000)

Commitment, Turnover, Counter-Productive Behavior, and Unethical Behavior (Cohen-Charash & Spector, 2001; Hom & Griffeth, 1995; Tang, Kim, & Tang, 2000)

The Money Ethic Scale

1. Measures the Meaning of Money2. Follows the ABC Model3. Has Multi-Dimensional Constructs (5

versions)4. Is Well Developed and

Systematically Used (17 papers)5. Reflects Individual Differences

The Money Ethic Scale

Has been used in many samples,

in many countries, and

in many languages (published articles): Chinese, English, French, Italian, Spanish, Russian, etc.

Research Question:

Does money (income) have a direct and/or indirect impact on unethical behavior?

Does money attitude (the love of money, the MES) have a direct and/or indirect impact on unethical behavior?

MES in This Study

1. Money is a Motivator2. Money is a sign of my Success3. Money is Important4. I want to be Rich

58 items, EFA—US Sample, 14 factors,

Select 4 factors (17 items), EFA, CFA--Whole Sample, 12 Countries

The Love of Money

1. Motivator

2. Success

3. Important

4. Rich

Motivator

No other incentive or motivational technique comes even close to money (Locke, Feren, McCaleb, Shaw, & Danny, 1980: 381).

Money is a motivator (Gupta & Shaw, 1998; Lawler, 1981).

Ex. I am motivated to work hard for money. Money is a motivator.

Success

In America, money is how we keep score (Rubenstein, 1981).

Some people are obsessed with “money as a sign of success” (Furnham & Argyle, 1998: 148)

Ex. Money represents my achievement. Money is a symbol of my success.

Importance

The one consistent thread in this body of work is “the emphasis on its importance” (Mitchell & Mickel, 1999: 569)

Ex. Money is important. Money is an important factor in the lives of all of us.

Rich

Would you like to be Rich or Poor?Most people: RichBeing Rich will make you feel Good,

Happy, Powerful, Beautiful, Healthy, etc.

Many CEOs are tested G-r-e-e-d positive (Crystal, 1990, Fortune).

Ex. Having a lot of money (being rich) is good. I want to be rich.

Other Variables

IncomePay SatisfactionOrganizational CommitmentUnethical BehaviorEthical Corporate CultureSex, Job Changes

Pay Satisfaction

18-Item Pay Satisfaction Questionnaire:

Pay Level

Benefits

Raises

Pay AdministrationHeneman & Schwab (1985)

Organizational Commitment

15-Item Organizational Commitment Questionnaire.

Two Indicators:

Commitment, Not to Leave (- items)Mowday, Steers, and Porter (1979)

Ethical Culture

5-Item Corporate Ethical Culture

Two Indicators:Ethical Policy (3 items), Act

Ethically (2 items) (Hunt, Wood, & Chonko (1989).

Unethical Behavior

15-Scenario Unethical Behavior Tendency

Abuse Position (theft, 5 items) +Ex. Take merchandise and/or cash.

Abuse Power (corruption, 5 items)Ex. Accept money, gifts, and kickback from others.

Abuse Resources (office supply, 3 items)Ex. Waste company time. Use office supplies.

Take No Action for Unethical Behavior (look the other way, 2 items)

Ex. Take no action for shoplifting/stealing cash/merchandise.

In This Study

Motivator, Success, Importance, & Rich

“The Love of Money” Abuse Position, Power, Resources,

& Take No Action “Evil”

In This Study

Is “money” the root of evil?

Is “the love of money” the root of evil?

The love of money is the root of all evils (Bible: Timothy, 6:10).

Cross-Cultural Study

Australia*, Austria, Belgium, Brazil*, Bulgaria*, Canada, Chile, China, Congo (Zaire), Cuba, Czechoslovakia, Egypt, France, Germany, Hong Kong, Hungary, India, Ireland, Italy*, Macau, Macedonia, Malaysia, Malta, Mexico*, Nigeria*, Oman, Panama (?), Peru, Philippines, Poland, Portugal*, Puerto Rico, Romania*, Russia, Saudi Arabia, Singapore, Slovenia*, South Korea, South Africa, Spain*, Taiwan, Thailand, Turkey, Ukraine, the UK, the USA, and Venezuela.

Need Your Help

To expand this project:

Need People in different parts of the world

If you or your colleagues in your country or other countries are interested, please let me know. Thank YOU.

A Model of Unethical Behavior Model

Z Income

Money Ethic

Culture

Commitment

Unethical Behavior

PaySatisfaction

Jobs

Sex

Income Money EthicInverted U: + , 0, --Unsatisfied needs are important,

satisfied needs are not (Alderfer, 1971; Maslow,

1970)

Financial Hardship Obsessed with Money (Dittmar, Tang, & Tillery, 2001; Lim & Teo, 1997; Lynn, 1991; Tang et al., 2001) (+ path)

Income Money EthicHigher Incomes Lower Marginal

Utility of Money (Brandstatter & Brandstatter, 1996) (-- path)

Fairly Paid Income MES: Non-significant (Tang, Luna-Arocas et al, 2001)

Compare Income with (1) GDP per Capita or (2) Bill Gates (52.8B)

Income Money Ethic

Among nations: As nations get richer, increases in wealth are associated with diminishing increases in well-being (Ahuvia & Friedman, 1998; Schyns, 1998)

Objective Wealth vs. Subjective Appraisals (Ahuvia & Friedman, 1998)

Objective Money (Income)

Within nations: Increased income is associated with well-being for the poor; once the poverty threshold is crossed, increased income matters little for happiness (Czikszentmihali, 1999;Diener,

2000; Myers 2000; Oishi, Diener, Lucas, & Such, 1999; Oropesa, 1995, Richins & Rudmin, 1994; Schyns, 2000; Tatzel, 2002)

Objective Money (Income)

If we are so rich, why aren’t we happy?

Csikszentmihalyi, M. (1999). American Psychologist, 54, 821-827.

Subjective Money (Compare)

Subjective well-being increases as income increases from below average to above average within one’s home community (Hagerty, 2000)

East Asia

The major global market for luxury goods (Wong & Ahuvia, 1998)

Thailand: very Materialistic, regarding possessions as a measure of Success, valuing possessions for their public visibility (face) over private, personal meaning (Webster & Batty, 1997; Wong & Ahuvia, 1998).

Hong Kong

Cash Mentality (Chiu, Luk, & Tang, 2001)

The Most Popular Car in Hong Kong…Public Visibility--Face

MES Pay Satisfaction

Equity Theory (Adams, 1965)

Discrepancy Model (Lawler, 1971)

Expectation vs. Reality

“The Love of Money” as the Frame of Reference, i.e., expectation, standards

High MES High Pay Dissatisfaction

Pay Satisfaction Commitment

Job Satisfaction Commitment (Williams & Hazer, 1986, SEM)

There is reciprocal and synchronous causality between commitment and satisfaction, with satisfaction influencing commitment more than vice versa (Home & Griffeth, 1995: 98).

Pay Satisfaction Commitment

Perceived unfair procedural and distributive justice negative attitudes toward the organization (e.g., lower trust and commitment) (Cohen-Charash & Spector, 2001: 288)

Commitment Unethical Behavior

From a procedural justice perspective, perceived injustice will lead to negative perceptions of the organization and, hence to counterproductive behaviors that will hurt the organization (Cohen-

Charash & Spector, 2001: 287).

Business Ethics

Taxonomy and Concepts (Forsyth, 1980; Michalos, 1995)

Culture (Hofstede, 2001; Trompenaars, 1994)

Social Institutions (Parsons, 1990)

Personal Values (England, 1975)

Cross-cultural (Wines & Napier, 1992)

Ethical Culture Commitment

Top-level Manager can reduce unethical behavior (Finn, Chonko, & Hunt, 1988)

Attraction-Selection-Attrition (Chatman, 1989; Douglas & Schwartz, 1999; Ponemon & Glazer, 1990; Tang & Frost, 1999)

Differences in ethical culture across firms and across offices within the same firm (Jeffrey & Weatherholt, 1996)

Ethical Culture Commitment

Ethical Culture Ethical Behavior (Hunt & Vitell, 1986; Trevino, 1986) *“Directly”

Ethical Culture Individual Values (i.e., idealism) Ethical Judgments (Douglas, Davison, & Schwartz, 2001) *“Indirectly”

Ethical Culture Commitment Unethical Behavior *Indirectly

Sex MES

Men prefer equity, women prefer equality (Tang, 1996; Tang, Furnham, & Davis, 2000)

Men consider money more important than women (Lawler, 1971)

Women are more subjectively satisfied with their pay than men, the contented female worker (Crosby, 1982; Major & Konar, 1984; Sauser & York, 1978; Smith, Kendall, & Hulin, 1969)

Job Changes Unethical Behavior

Reason for Voluntary Turnover: higher wages/career opportunities (Campion, 1991)

Leavers have lower pay satisfaction and receive 20% pay increase on their new jobs

The number of job changes is a predictor of management professors’ pay (Gomez-Mejia & Balkin, 1992) Self-Interest vs. Organization

Sample

2,338 Full-Time White-Collar Employees from 12 Countries:

The US, Belgium, Hong Kong, Hungary, Macedonia, Malta, Oman, Philippines, Singapore, South Africa, Taiwan, and Thailand.

HK is a part of China. We use the term “country” or “culture” for each sample.

Additional Data

US: income = $34,661, *GDP per Capita = $31,500, *ratio = 1.10*CPI 2001 (1) Rank = 16, (2) Score = 7.6

Hi income: HK (1.89); Thailand (3.41), Macedonia (2.07)

Lo income: HungaryHi Corruption CPI: Score < 5: South Africa,

Thailand, Philippines Low Corruption > 9

Data Analysis

Convert income to Z Income

1. Perform CFA for all measures

The Whole Sample

Cross-Cultural Equivalence:

(1) Factor Structure, (2) Factor Loadings

2. Test the SEM Model: The Whole Sample

3. Compare the Model Across 12 Countries

A Model of Unethical Behavior

Whole

Z Income

Money Ethic

Culture

Commitment

Unethical Behavior

PaySatisfaction

Jobs

Sex

.17*-.13*

.55*

-.28*

.68*

.14*

-.06

.01

.12*

Main Results

The Money Ethic is directly and indirectly related to Unethical Behavior, whereas Income is not.

The “Love of Money” is the root of all Evil.

Money is not the root of all evil.


The US

Z Income

Money Ethic

Culture

Commitment

Unethical Behavior

PaySatisfaction

Jobs

Sex

.88*.03

.60*

-.26*

.62*

.00

.04

.01

-.04


Belgium

Z Income

Money Ethic

Culture

Commitment

Unethical Behavior

PaySatisfaction

Jobs

Sex

.87*.09

.22*

-.22*

.81*

.15

-.09

-.07

.01


Hong Kong

Z Income

Money Ethic

Culture

Commitment

Unethical Behavior

PaySatisfaction

Jobs

Sex

.50*-.30*

.68*

-.04

.38

.28*

-.28*

-.14

.02


Hungary

Z Income

Money Ethic

Culture

Commitment

Unethical Behavior

PaySatisfaction

Jobs

Sex

.45*.09

.56*

-.23*

.64*

.02

-.33*

.66*

-.12


Macedonia

Z Income

Money Ethic

Culture

Commitment

Unethical Behavior

PaySatisfaction

Jobs

Sex

-.26*.00

.35*

-.12

-

.04

-.13

.17

.08


Malta

Z Income

Money Ethic

Culture

Commitment

Unethical Behavior

PaySatisfaction

Jobs

Sex

.11-.25*

.70*

-.34*

-

.38*

-.03

-.13

.04


Oman

Z Income

Money Ethic

Culture

Commitment

Unethical Behavior

PaySatisfaction

Jobs

Sex

.96*-.35*

.50*

-.18

.52

.33*

-.22*

-.14

.25*


Philippines

Z Income

Money Ethic

Culture

Commitment

Unethical Behavior

PaySatisfaction

Jobs

Sex

.04.13

.74*

-.33*

.92

.01

.17

.07

-.13


Singapore

Z Income

Money Ethic

Culture

Commitment

Unethical Behavior

PaySatisfaction

Jobs

Sex

.22*-.21*

.56*

-.19*

.58

.29*

-.04

-.20

.04


South Africa

Z Income

Money Ethic

Culture

Commitment

Unethical Behavior

PaySatisfaction

Jobs

Sex

.25*.55*

-

-

-

.15*

-.02

-.31*

-.05


Taiwan

Z Income

Money Ethic

Culture

Commitment

Unethical Behavior

PaySatisfaction

Jobs

Sex

.14*-.13

.69*

-.22*

.51*

.14

-.09

-.12

.01


Thailand

Z Income

Money Ethic

Culture

Commitment

Unethical Behavior

PaySatisfaction

Jobs

Sex

-.20*-.20*

.60*

-.12

-

.06

.22*

.15

.13

Summary: 12 Countries

12 Countries

Z Income

Money Ethic

Culture

Commitment

Unethical Behavior

PaySatisfaction

Jobs

Sex

+:5; (-:2)-: 5; (+: 1)

10

7

4

5

+: 1, 0: 8-: 3

+:1; -:1

1

A Simplified Model

12 Countries

Money Ethic

Commitment

Unethical Behavior

PaySatisfaction

-.13*

.61*

-.24*

Discussion

Employee theft is a $200 million-dollar a year problem in the US

Some managers condone theft by looking the other way

Treat that as “an invisible wage structure” to compensate for their lower than average wages

Discussion

Financial loss is attributed to

Employee Theft--38.4%

Shoplifting—35.6%

Administrative Error –19.4%

Vender Theft—6.4%

Discussion

Average Loss Shoplifting—$142.49 per incidentEmployee Theft–$737.31Armed Robbery–$2,410Culture of corruption Business

failuresDiscourage and Prevent

How Do Managers Discourage and Prevent Unethical Behavior?Create Pay FairnessInternal Equity (Vertical Pay

Differential) External Competitiveness (Market)

and Individual Equity (Merit, Seniority)

Discourage and Prevent

Procedural Justice (rules of the game, How the decision was made, the means)

Distributive Justice (results of the game, What was decided, the ends)

Discourage and Prevent

Set Role Models

Create Ethical Corporate Culture

Use Reward and Punishment

Establish Ethics Hot Line

Develop Profiles of Dishonest Employees

Select Good Employees HRM

Install Surveillance Systems

Provide Training to Employees

Organizational CultureTop management: Decoration or Dedication?

One company has built their organization around these four values*:– Communication, Respect, Integrity, Excellence

Can you name this company?

Culture can only be strong when the commitment to norms and values is strong.

*Taken from Year 2000 Annual Report

CEOs’ Pay

Corporate CorruptionsEnron Chairman Kenneth Lay and his

wife own over 30 million dollars worth of real estates and stocks

Employees lost their jobs and 1 billion deferred compensation and pension plan

CEOs’ Pay

Michael Eisner, CEO of Walt Disney made US$575,592,000 in 1998

The average worker made $30,000 in 1998

Pay Differential = 19,320 to 1

Money Profiles

Evil, Budget, Charity, Importance, Motivator, Success, Cluster Analysis

Conscientious Steward

Frugal Budgeter

Money Worshiper

Careless Handler

Good Money Profiles

Conscientious Steward (H-C; L-IMS) H satisfaction, L jobs, all Unethical Behavior

Frugal Budgeter (H-B; L-E) H Satisfaction

Evil, Budget, Charity, Importance, Motivator, Success

Bad Money Profiles

Money Worshiper (H-EIMS)- Abuse Power, Take No Action

Careless Handler (L-BC) Abuse Position, Resources

Evil, Budget, Charity, Importance, Motivator, Success

Conclusion

The love of money is the root of evil. (Tim, 6:10)

Additional Thoughts

It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle, than for a rich man to enter into the kingdom of God.

Judas, who betrayed Jesus for a sum of money (30 pieces of silver), was the treasurer of the disciples. John, 12: 6; 13: 29

For when he dieth he shall carry nothing away: his glory shall not descent after him. Psa, 49: 17

Beloved, follow not that which is evil, but that which is good. He that doeth good is of God: but he that doeth evil hath not seen God. John, 11

Professional Wrestlers as Ushers: Increased Collection Plate

Donations by 72%

Thank YouDanke

Dankeshen

Grazie

Merci

Muchas Gracias

Documents

Is “the Love of Money” the Root of All Evil? Or Different Strokes for Different Folks: Lessons in 12 Countries Thomas Li-Ping Tang The International Conference