44
INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE POLYURETHANE FOAM SPECIMENS Experimental and numerical analysis Fabien PLASSARD, Pierre-Louis HEREIL, Jérôme MESPOULET, Patrick THIOT Thiot Ingenierie, PUYBRUN - 46130, France, www.thiot-ingenierie.com InnoTesting Conference WILDAU February 19-20, 2015

INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF

LARGE POLYURETHANE FOAM SPECIMENS

Experimental and numerical analysis

Fabien PLASSARD, Pierre-Louis HEREIL,

Jérôme MESPOULET, Patrick THIOT

Thiot Ingenierie, PUYBRUN - 46130, France,

www.thiot-ingenierie.com

InnoTesting Conference – WILDAU February 19-20, 2015

Page 2: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

Introduction

2

PU foam

Page 3: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

3

Introduction

Rigid polyurethane foam

ρ = 0.1 g/cm3 ρ = 0.3 g/cm3 ρ = 0.5 g/cm3 ρ = 0.75 g/cm3

Goals:

• Compaction behavior with dynamic loads study

• Strain rate effect study

• Test on large samples

• Numerical models improvement

• Energy absorption capacity analysis for dynamic loads

Page 4: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

4

Laboratory

R&D, numerical simulations, Engineering dep.

TITAN &

HERMES

VULCAIN &

JUPITER

Page 5: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

5

Laboratory

Strain gauges

Force sensors

High speed cameras

Interferometers

Ultra fast cameras

Flash Xrays

Displacement sensors

Page 6: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

6

Laboratory

Hermes

Vulcain

Page 7: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

7

Laboratory

Titan

Hopkinson bars

Page 8: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

8

Samples dimensions

Ø20 mm – L 30 mm

250 mm

250 mm

Ø80 mm – L 50 mm

150 mm

Page 9: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

9

Jupiter Dynamic Press

Page 10: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

10

Jupiter Dynamic Press

Page 11: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

11

Jupiter Dynamic Press

Page 12: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

12

Jupiter Dynamic Press

Concrete compression

Page 13: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

13

Jupiter Dynamic Press

Concrete compression

Page 14: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

14

Jupiter Dynamic Press

Concrete compression

Page 15: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

15

Jupiter Dynamic Press

Granit Compression Crashbox compression

Page 16: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

16

Jupiter Dynamic Press

Granit Compression Crashbox compression

Page 17: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

17

Jupiter Dynamic Press

Granit Compression Crashbox compression

Page 18: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

18

Jupiter Dynamic Press

Tensile/shear tests

Page 19: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

19

Jupiter Dynamic Press

Tensile/shear tests

Page 20: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

20

Simple compaction configuration on Jupiter

Sample

Piston

Load sensor

500T

Displacement

sensor

Page 21: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

21

Simple compaction configuration on Jupiter

Sample

Piston

Load sensor

500T

Displacement

sensor

Page 22: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

22

Studied PU foam : ρ = 0.1 g/cm3

Before

After

300x300x100 mm

Page 23: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

23

Studied PU foam : ρ = 0.1 g/cm3

Before

After

300x300x100 mm

Page 24: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

24

Studied PU foam : ρ = 0.1 g/cm3

Before

After

300x300x100 mm

Page 25: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

25

Studied PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3

Before

After

300x300x100 mm

Page 26: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

26

Studied PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3

Before

After

300x300x100 mm

Page 27: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

27

Studied PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3

Before

After

300x300x100 mm

Page 28: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

28

Studied PU foam : ρ = 0.5 g/cm3

Before

After

150x150x100 mm

Page 29: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

29

Studied PU foam : ρ = 0.5 g/cm3

Before

After

150x150x100 mm

Page 30: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

30

Studied PU foam : ρ = 0.5 g/cm3

Before

After

150x150x100 mm

Page 31: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

31

Studied PU foam : ρ = 0.75 g/cm3

Before

After

150x150x100 mm

Page 32: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

32

Studied PU foam : ρ = 0.75 g/cm3

Before

After

150x150x100 mm

Page 33: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

33

Studied PU foam : ρ = 0.75 g/cm3

Before

After

150x150x100 mm

Page 34: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

34

Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3

Page 35: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

35

Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3

Page 36: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

36

Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3

Page 37: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

37

Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

échantillon

20mmh30mmf

pistonh80mm

cellule oedométrique

80mmh80mmf

Ø20 mm

300 mm

Static Dynamic

Page 38: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

38

Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

échantillon

20mmh30mmf

pistonh80mm

cellule oedométrique

80mmh80mmf

Ø20 mm

300 mm

Static Dynamic

Page 39: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

Str

ess (

ba

r)

Str

ain

ra

te (

s-1

)

Specific volume (cm3/g)

Static oedo test

Numeric oedo Jupiter

Strain rate

39

Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3

Stress increase :

Purely geometric effect?

Dynamic effect due to strain rate ?

Dynamic effect due to compaction level value?

Scale effect?

Page 40: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

40

Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3 static/dynamic analysis

Oedometric compression with Gas gun at 40 m/s

Page 41: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

Summary and outlook

41

ρ = 0.3 g/cm3

Simple

Simple/Oedo

Oedo Oedo

Page 42: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

Summary and outlook

42

Simple/Oedo

Simple/Oedo Simple/Oedo Simple/Oedo Simple/Oedo

Simple/Oedo

10-3 s-1 10 s-1 200 s-1 1000 s-1 4000 s-1

Simple/Oedo

Page 43: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

Summary and outlook

43

Experimental:

• Compaction tests at lower strain rates between 1 and 10 s-1

• Compaction tests at higher strain rates between 200 and 4000 s-1 (Titan gas gun and Hopkinson bar)

• Design of an œdometric setup on Jupiter

Numeric:

• Development of a numerical model reliable on full range of load

• Strain rate/compaction level dependency

Industrial challenge:

• Energy absorption control against dynamic loads

• Shock absorber design

• Anti-blast structure design

Page 44: INVESTIGATION ON STRAIN RATE SENSITIVITY OF LARGE ... · cellule oedométrique 80mm h80mm I Ø20 mm 300 mm Static Dynamic . 38 Results : PU foam : ρ = 0.3 g/cm3: static/dynamic analysis

44

Thanks for your attention !