Inventing Disorders Hebrew

8/8/2019 Inventing Disorders Hebrew

1/32

-

1969-


2/32

, . " "

:

" " .1 :

:

,

,

. . .

" " , .

. .2 " " , .

. " "

,

. , , , '

"

, .( )

."

, " ,

"

,

."

.3

." "

,

, "

" " ,

.

.

" :

, .

."

.4 " " . )

(

, .

, , .

": ,Blaming the Brain

."

.5 .

,

" .

, "

, ,

.

. ,

.


3/32

:2 ...... " "

:5 ..........................

:11 ..

:

15 .........................

:

19 ........................

23 ..................................

24 .....

-


4/32

, :

,

, ,

, ,

" "

"

"?

374

Diagnostic

and Statistical Manual for

Mental Disorder DSM-IV"

(APA)

-

of) International Classification

Diseases (ICD

.,ICD- DSM

,

, " "

,

,

, . ,

.ICD DSM -

,.

" :

,

- DSM-IV- ,

, " ICD

,APA-1.

- " "

,

.DSM-

.DSM- ,"

-

- .

- .

, .

2."

" ,1987" -

.

,

,

," "

.

" "

,

3. DSM-IV-

,

,DSM-

,

" : ,

] ,

, [

, ' , ' '

, ' , .'4

"?' ', "

:

Whores of the Court

The: Fraud of Psychiatric and the Rape of Americn

Justice

:DSM-5."

, . ' '

" " : ,Making Us Crazy

, "

,

,

.

,."

, , ' .2004 , ,


5/32

DSM- " " ."6.

'

"

,

, .

.

?

, ' , . .

, ' ,

DSM-

,(ADD)

, ,(PTSD)

,(OCD)

.(APD)

...

,

, ...

,

7."

, ' ,2004

" , ,

' ' ' '

.

.' ' .

, .' '

. ,

. ,

,' '

886 DSM- .' '

...

,

,

,8."

DSM

.

. DSM-

.

.DSM- ,

'

,


6/32

1

2

34

5

' ' ,

,

150

.

DSM-

.

"

, " "

, .

.

" "

.

,

.

(DSM-IV)

"

."

- ,, DSM-IV 2001 .(DSM)

," ,

."


7/32

5

,

,

.

.

Ph.D ,

"

,

- " "

-

...

-

-

-

.

-

."

- '

," " , .

- ,DSM- " :

-

- , ,

- , DSM

9."

.

DSM -

.

-

DSM

: " : APA

...

...

)

(APA -:

..."

-

-

10."

' '

.

. " "

,DSM-III -

,

." ,

"

, .

."

, "

.1994 ,


8/32

DSM-III-

...

. ( ) DSM III-

...

."

DSM-IV

"

."

' , ' .'

" ,DSM-IV

-

." DSM-IV

, APA- 1973- .

3,810 5,584

,

.APA -

,

" : ,

,

11."

, ,1994

,(1999 1996)

" ,

, .12."

,1995-

( 4.9)

, ,

) :WPA-

,DSM-

1990 ," " 1963

, (NIMH)

.

1000

800

600

400

200

1949(NIMH)

1952

. 112 DSMI .

1963

DSMIII 1980. 224

DSMIIIR 1987

. 253

MIMH1990

." "

DSMIV 1994. 374

2004

1949

1952

1963

1968

1980

1987

1990

1994

2004

DSMII 1968163

NimH


9/32

' ' .(

."' , "

, " :

,' '

,

, ,

. -13."

*DSM ,*

' , 2001-

'

150 ,

,

.DSM

DSM-IV - " ,14." DSM ,

: DSM- " "

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

." "

, "

,

.

.

,(DSM-IV)

.


10/32

, ,

, ,

, .

. ,

" , "

."

. "

' :

, '

'

, .'

"?

, .

,

.

,

,

.

" , .

.

.

,

"

" '

."

" ,2002

' ,

: ,

"

,

.

.

)

' '


11/32

.

, ,

,

."

2004 ,

The Mercury News

, ,

2,500 , .19."

.

) " :

.(20." (SPECT)

. "

. " ,"21.

"

" :

.22."

' ,

. , ..." :

." , ,

,(

."

The Complete Guide to)

,2000 ,Psychiatric Drugs)

,M.D ,

" : ,

...

...

'

...'15." ' '

Ph.D, ,

(Rebellion Commonsense)

, " :

, , ,(ADD)

, , ,

,16."

,Ph.D ,

(Blaming the Brain)

" :17."

..." :

... /

' '

... ,18."

"

...

...

...' '

'

." '

,.M.D,

,'


12/32

1

23

4

17

.DSM- " "

.

- ADHD-

.

ADHD-

.

.

2004 2003

- ,

" , ,

,

SSRI

18

.

,

," "

. " "

,

.

5


13/32

11

17 . -

.

-

,(LD)

(ADD)

-

-

.(ADHD)

DSM-IV

:ADHD

;-

;

-

- ;

,

;

- ;

- ; , ;

.( , )

,

ADHD- " "

,

... :The Hyperactivity Hoax

,DSM - ,

-

...

, ,

,

, . DSM

DSM

,

."

-

-

. ;

.

The Physicians Desk

Reference Guide

- ,

" "

ADHD-

23 . ,

- 24.

, (DEA) "

. ,

: " , .

"

. ( )

.

)

(

."

, , . Rape of the Soul: How the Chemical ImbalanceModel of Modern Psychiatry has Failed its

Patients


14/32

Rape of the Soul: How) "

the Chemical Imbalance Model of Modern

,(Psychiatry has Failed its Patients

" :

,( )

( ) .25."

,

,2003 .(SSRIs)

SSRI

. ,18

,

, (FDA)

FDA - ,2004 .

,SSRI -

.

, .

" " .

, 10 .

SSRI

) ,26. (FDA-

ADHD-, ,2004

" : ,

,

(ADHD) .

ADHD ." "

,

." "27." ,

: , , "

, .( ) ADHD"

.

"ADHD . ,

,( )." "

, ADHD." "

,."

,

.2004 ,

:ADHD

,

."

, ' , " -

.

,DSM -

, ...

,,

. DSM DSM ,

.

, " "The Hyperactivity Hoax

- ] ADHD". [

ADHD ..

. [ ] .. ..[ ]

.ADHD- , " "


15/32

13

,28." , ,

, ' . "

,

29 . ,

ADHD

. " "

ADHD , "

" ,(No More ADHD)

.

ADHD" : ."

.

ADHD .

.

,."

"

,ADHD

" , "

ADHD

...

,

ADHD

"?

" "

," "

." - "

,2002

The Culture)

, ,of Fear

DSM- ,

.

, :

, ,

, , ,

,

30.

: "

"

,

,

,

,

31."

... " :

(juvenile delinquency)

.

."

DSM

, :

,,

, ,," "

,.

, .


16/32

1

2

3

4

,

-

.' ,

" ,DSM

,

" "...

,

."

The Psychiatric ,2003

Times

" DSM-

."

.

" , ,

"

. -


17/32

15

" " ,DSM

.

,

." " 1952 DSM

,

.

- .

-

- .

- 1962

Northwestern Law

,Review

,

-

- ,

- ,

.

." "

, .

-

- , .

,

.

, ,

' "

'

."

- ,1994 -

- ,

-

.( 3.2) ,

- ,

.

"

learned) "

h e l p l e s s n e s s )

- .

-

"

."

-

.

, " , DSM -

DSM-IV-

,

."

' "

' ' ' ' ,' ' ,'

. , "

? "

?

,

."33%

1997 ,Ph.D "


18/32

, '

,

" 1988

."

.

' ," "

"

, ,DSM

."

"

:' ' ,

?

?

,

...33%-

. ,

32 "...

, 100 - ,1884-

"

"

" ,33."

" " ,

" .

, ,

- ,

- .

- ,

.34." - :

,

.

.

,

" - "

DSM -

,

.

.

,1998-

"

,"

.

.

,

.


19/32

,

,

, ,

DSM- ,

.

,1998

(WHO)

"

"

" "

, 35.

,ICD-10- DSM-IV-

.

,

,

." "

. " "

80% ,

.

' , "

, ,' ,

DSM- " :2003

)Diagnosis of Simple Minds ,(

' '

, .

. ,

.

.36."

:

,Psychiatric Times ,2003

' ,DSM- "

"

."

' . '

Out of , .

..." : Its Mind, Psychiatry in Crisis, A Call For Reform

DSM-IV

37."

," ' ' "

' '

,DSM -

.' ' .

'38".'

,DSM-

.

DSM " "

. "

.

,

."

' , .1993 ,


20/32

1

2

3

4

,

,

.

.

.- ,UCLA-

-

-.

, "

"

,

."

40% ,. 5

;

.


21/32

,

- .

-

' .

- , , .

:Medicine on Trial

-

- -

...

,

-

-

,

,

39 "...

,

' .M.D , .

, '

"

."

"

."

,

:

' , . .

14 ,

,

, 10

,

,

40."

.

20 -

" "

(LD)

90% ,

41."

,

, , .

- , , ,

19

,

,

...

( ) ,

."...

.1991 ,


22/32

, , , ,

, ,

,

.

" ,(ADD)The , ,

.Hyperactivity Hoax

,Ph.D. , '

12- ,

, 803 -

,

47 .

8,076 " - "

, .

16 - 1.142. 40 -

" "

83 ,

42 .

, , " "

48 .

,

76 .

43.

. " .

: , 21 .

." "

"

" ,

44."

.

Medical Evaluation Field ,

, ,Manual (1991)

,

...

( )


23/32

DSM-

,

.,18 "

.' '- ,

10

, ,

.

" "

.

!

."

,

.

,

.

"

" "" ."

,"

.

.

,

.

." "

., , "

, .

,

.

...

.

. :

,

...

,

."

- " ' "

10

, ,

,

.

: " : " "

, ' ."

,

,

, " ,

, ,

'

. " ," "

, " :

." ,

" ' "

.

," "

.

." ,

,

."


24/32

45."...

Health & " , ' "

" : Healing

. , ( )

, ,

. ' '

, ,

- ,

. ,

."

" "

,

.

,

.

.

,[ ] "

.

, ,

."

Health & Healing , ' "


25/32

1

2

3

4

5

23

.

.

,

.

, ,

.

,

,( )

. , ,

.

, , ,

, DSM - .DSM -

.


26/32

24

1969

.

. 31- 130 CCHR

, Commisioners, ,

, , ,

.

, CCHR

.

- " "

.

,

, -

,

.

,

: ,

, :3

.

:5

.

:7

.

,

,

" " ,

.

CCHR

,

.


27/32

.

,

.

.

:Citizens Commission on Human Rights International

6616 Sunset Blvd.

Los Angeles, California 90028

Phone: 800-869-2247 323-467-4242 Fax: 323-467-3720

http://www.cchr.org E-mail: [email protected]

.M.D ' "

, ,

:Health & Healing "

,

.

, , ,

,

."

,.M.D , ' ' "

:

"

."

,

: ,

"

,

."


28/32

CCHR

CCHR

.

'

Citizens Commission on Human RightsInternational

'

Citizens Commission on Human Rights"

United States

CCHR ' .

, , ". ,

' '

'

'

'

'

'

,

, . '

'

' ' "" ,

..Ph.D , "

" , ".

) M.D. ,

( CHHR'

- " ,

M.D. , 'M.D. ,M.D. ,

.Ph.D , "

M.D. , 'M.D. ,

.Ph.D ,

'

26


29/32

CCHR

CCHR AustraliaCitizens Commission on HumanRights AustraliaP.O. Box 562Broadway, New South Wales 2007AustraliaPhone: 612-9211-4787

Fax: 612-9211-5543E-mail: [email protected] .au

CCHR AustriaCitizens Commission on HumanRights Austria(Brgerkommission frMenschenrechte Oesterreich)Postfach 130A-1072 WienAustriaPhone: 43-1-877-02-23Fax: 43-1-662-80-72E-mail: [email protected]

CCHR BelgiumCitizens Commission on HumanRights

Postbus 552800 Mechelen 2BelgiumPhone: 324-777-12494

CCHR CanadaCitizens Commission on HumanRights Toronto27 Carlton St., Suite 304Toronto, OntarioM5B 1L2 CanadaPhone: 1 416-971-8555E-mail: [email protected]

CCHR Czech RepublicObcansk komise za lidsk prvaVclavsk nmest 17110 00 Praha 1Phone/Fax : 224-009-156E-mail: [email protected]

CCHR DenmarkCitizens Commission on HumanRights Denmark(Medborgernes Menneskerettighedskommission - MMK )Faksingevej 9A2700 BroenshoejDenmarkPhone: 45-39-62-90-39E-mail: [email protected]

CCHR FinlandCitizens Commission on HumanRights FinlandPost Box 14500511 Helsinki

FinlandPhone: 358-9-8594-869

CCHR FranceCitizens Commission on HumanRights France(Commission des Citoyens pour lesroits de LHomme - CCDH)BP 7675561 Paris Cedex 12

FrancePhone: 331-4001-0970Fax: 331-4001-0520E-mail: ccdh@wanadoo .fr

CCHR GermanyCitizens Commission on HumanRights Germany National Office(Kommission fr Verste derPsychiatrie gegen Menschenrechtee.V. - KVPM)Amalienstrasse 49a80799 MnchenGermanyPhone: 49-89-273-03-54Calling from within Europe dial: 0049-89-273-03-54

Calling from within Germany dial:

089-273-03-54Fax: 49-89-28-98-67-04E-mail: kvpm@gmx .de

CCHR GreeceCitizens Commission on HumanRights65, Panepistimiou Str.105 64 AthensGreece

CCHR HollandCitizens Commission on HumanRights HollandPostbus 360001020 MA , AmsterdamHollandPhone/Fax : 3120-4942510

CCHR HungaryCitizens Commission on HumanRights HungaryPf. 1821461 Budapest HungaryPhone: 36-1342-6355Fax: 36-1344-4724E-mail: [email protected]

CCHR Israel

37020 . .61369

972-3-5660699 :

972-3-5663750 :[email protected] : -

CCHR ItalyCitizens Commission on HumanRights Italy(Comitato dei Cittadini per i DirittidellUomo - CCDU)Viale Monza 120125 Milano - ItaliaE-mail: [email protected]

CCHR JapanCitizens Commission on HumanRights Japan2-11-7-7F KitaotsukaToshima-ku Tokyo"170-0004, JapanPhone: 81-3-3576-8110

Fax: 81-3-3576-1741

CCHR Lausanne, SwitzerlandCitizens Commission onHuman Rights Lausanne(Commission des Citoyens pourles roits de LHomme - CCDH)Case postale 5773

1002 LausanneSwitzerlandPhone: 41-21-646-6226E-mail: [email protected]

CCHR MexicoCitizens Commission on HumanRightsMexico(Comision de Ciudadanos por los

Derechos Humanos CCDH)Tuxpan 68, Colonia RomaCP 06700, Mexico DFE-mail: [email protected]

CCHR Monterrey, MexicoCitizens Commission on HumanRights Monterrey, Mexico(Comision de Ciudadanos por losDerechos Humanos CCDH)Avda. Madero 1955 Poniente Esq.Venustiano Carranzaedif. Santos Oficina 735Monterrey, NL MxicoPhone: 83-480329Fax: 86-758689E-mail: [email protected]

CCHR NepalP.O. Box 1679Baneshwor Kathmandu,NepalE-mail: [email protected]

CCHR New ZealandCitizens Commission on HumanRights New ZealandP.O. Box 5257Wellesley StreetAuckland 1New ZealandPhone/Fax: 649-580-0060E-mail: [email protected]

CCHR NorwayCitizens Commission on Human

Rights NorwayMedborgernes menneskerettighets-kommisjon, MMKPostboks 8902 Youngstorget0028 Oslo, Norway "E-mail: mmkcchr@online .no

CCHR RussiaCitizens Commission on HumanRights Commonwealth ofIndependent StatesP.O. Box 35117588 MoscowRussia, CIS

Phone: 7095-518-11-00

CCHR South AfricaCitizens Commission on HumanRights South AfricaP.O. Box 710Johannesburg 2000Republic of South AfricaPhone: 011-27-11-615-8658Fax : 011-27-11-615-5845

CCHR SpainCitizens Commission on HumanRights Spain(Comisin de Ciudadanos por losDerechos Humanos, CCDH)Apdo. de Correos 18054

28080 Madrid, SpainPhone: 34-635-330-714Fax : 34-915-217-405E-mail: [email protected]

CCHR SwedenCitizens Commission on HumanRights Sweden(Kommittn fr MnskligaRttigheter - KMR)Box 2124 21 Bandhagen+46-(0)8-83 85 18

E-mail:[email protected]

CCHR TaiwanTaichung P.O. Box 36-127Taiwan, R.O.C.

E-mail: [email protected]

CCHR Ticino, SwitzerlandCitizens Commission on HumanRightsTicino(Comitato dei cittadini per I dirittidelluomo)Casella postale 6136512 Giubiasco, SwitzerlandE-mail:[email protected]

CCHR United KingdomCitizens Commission on HumanRights United KingdomP.O. Box 188East GrinsteadWest Sussex "

RH19 4 RBUnited KingdomPhone: 44-(0)1342-313926Fax : 44-(0)1342-325559E-mail:[email protected]

CCHR Zurich, SwitzerlandCitizens Commission on HumanRights SwitzerlandSektion ZurichPostfach 12078026 ZurichSwitzerlandPhone: 411-242-7790E-mail: [email protected]
mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]


30/32

1. Dr. Tana Dineen, Ph.D.,Manufacturing Victims, ThirdEdition (Robert Davies Multimedia Publishing, Montreal,2001), p. 86.

2. Paula J. Caplan, Ph.D., They Say Youre Crazy (NewYork: Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, 1995), p.90.

3. Dr. Sydney Walker III, M.D., A Dose of Sanity (JohnWiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1995), p. 19.

4. Op. cit., Paula J. Caplan, They Say Youre Crazy, p. 91

5. Margaret Hagen, Ph.D., Whores of the Court, The Fraudof Psychiatric Testimony and the Rape of American Justice

(Harper Collins Publishers, Inc., New York, 1997), p. 77.

6. Herb Kutchins and Stuart A. Kirk,Making Us Crazy:The Psychiatric Bible and the Creation of Mental Disorders (The Free Press, New York, 1997), pp. 260, 263.

7. Paul R. McHugh, How Psychiatry Lost Its Way,American Jewish Committee Commentary, 1 Dec. 1999.

8. John Read, Feeling Sad? It Doesnt Mean Youre Sick,New Zealand Herald, 23 June 2004.

9. Op. cit., Kutchins and Kirk,Making Us Crazy, pp. 260,263.

10. Op. cit., Paula J. Caplan, Ph.D., They Say Youre Crazy,pp. 221222.

11. Lawrence Stevens, J.D., Does Mental Illness Exist?,undated article, Internet address:http://www.mentalhealthfacts.com/antipsychiatry/exist.htm, accessed: 9 Jan. 2001.

12. Lars Boegeskov, Mentally Ill Have to Have HelpNot to be Cured, Politiken 19 Sept. 1994.

13. Introducing Thomas Dorman, M.D., Internetaddress: http://www.libertyconferences.com/dorman.htm.

14. Ten Things That Drive Psychiatrists to Distraction,The Independent, United Kingdom, 19 Mar. 2001.

15. Edward Drummond, M.D., The Complete Guide toPsychiatric Drugs (John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York,2000), pp. 1516.

16. Bruce D. Levine, Ph.D., Common Sense Rebellion:Debunking Psychiatry, Confronting Society (Continuum,New York, 2001), p. 277.

17. Elliot S. Valenstein, Ph.D., Blaming the Brain (The Free

Press, New York, 1998), p. 4.18. David Kaiser, M.D., Commentary: Against BiologicPsychiatry, Psychiatric Times, Dec. 1996.

19. Lisa M. Krieger, Some Question Value of Brain Scan;Untested Tool Belongs in Lab Only, Experts Say, The

Mercury News, 4 May 2004.

20. Ibid.

21. Ibid.

22. Ibid.

23. Physicians Desk Reference1998 (Medical EconomicsCo., New Jersey, 1998), pp. 18961897.

24. DSM-III-R (American Psychiatric Association,Washington, D.C., 1987), p. 136.

25. Ty C. Colbert, Ph.D., Rape of the Soul: How the ChemicalImbalance Model of Modern Psychiatry Has Failed Its Patients

(Kevco Publishing, California, 2001), p. 78.

26. Ibid., p. 117.

27. Kelly Patricia OMeara, New Research IndictsRitalin, Insight Magazine, 7 Sept. 2001.

28. Louria Shulamit, M.D., Family Practitioner, Israel,2002quote provided to CCHR International, 22 June2002.

29. Dr. Fred Baughman Jr. M.D., http://www.adhdfraud.com.

30. Paul Campos, Beware Timeless Malady; WitchHunt, Deseret News (Utah), 6 July 2003.

31. Thomas Szasz, M.D., Cruel Compassion (John Wiley &

Sons, Inc., New York, 1994), p. 67.32. Op. cit., Margaret Hagen, Whores of the Court, p. 165.

33. Op. cit., Dr. Tana Dineen,Manufacturing Victims, p.155.

34. Ibid., p. 155156.

35. Ibid., Foreword.

36. Anjana Ahuja, Its Time to Stop Taking the TabletsYoure Not Ill, Youre Just Alive, The Times (UnitedKingdom),19 Feb. 2003.

37. J. Allan Hobson and Jonathan A. Leonard, Out ofIts Mind, Psychiatry in Crisis, A Call for Reform (PerseusPublishing, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 2001), p. 125.

38. Jrg Blech, Die Abschaffung der Gesundheit, DerSpiegel (Germany), 11 Aug. 2003, p. 122.

39. Op. cit., Dr. Sydney Walker III, M.D., p.14.

40. Dr. Melvyn R. Werbach, M.D., Nutritional Influenceson Mental Illness, A Sourcebook of Clinical Research, SecondEdition (Third Line Press, Inc., California, 1999), p. 85.

41. Ibid., p. 83.

42. Dr. Mary Ann Block, No More ADHD (BlockBooks, Texas, 2001), p. 84; Stephen Schoenthaler,Ph.D., Institutional Nutritional Policies and CriminalBehavior, Nutrition Today, May/June, 1985

43. Dr. David E. Sternberg, M.D., Testing for PhysicalIllness in Psychiatric Patients,Journal of ClinicalPsychiatry, Vol.47, No. 1, Jan. 1986, Supplement, p. 5; Dr.Richard C. Hall, M.D. et al., Physical Illness Presentingas Psychiatric Disease, (Archives of General Psychiatry,Vol.35, Nov. 1978),pp. 131516.

44. Patrick Holford and Hyla Cass, M.D., Natural Highs(Penguin Putnam Inc., New York, 2002), pp. 125126.

45. Lorrin M. Koran,Medical Evaluation Field Manual,Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences,Stanford University Medical Center, California, 1991, p. 4.


31/32

.

.

' ' - - CCHR. (c) (3) 501 , (Internal Revenue Service)

.

. CCHR

, CCHR

, , ,

.

, 15- ,CCHR

, , , ,

, , ,

: .

' " , . " , ' " : " , '

:

' '

' '

:

CCHR ,CITIZENS COMMISSION ON HUMAN RIGHTS ,CCHR. .CCHR2004 Hebrew-18905-01. " .Citizens Commission on Human Rights

;David Buffington/Getty:20 ;LA Daily News/Corbis :14 ;Tom & Dee Ann McCarthy/Corbis :9 :.Tom & Dee Ann McCarthy/Corbis :22 ;Jim Cummins/Getty:21


32/32

,

,' '

-

,

,

,

, , .

."

, " . '

Documents

Inventing Disorders Hebrew