Invalid Ecj and Invalid Wa

8/14/2019 Invalid Ecj and Invalid Wa

1/31

1.) G.R. No. 70906 May 30, 1986

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Petitioner, vs. HON. LUIS V. SISON,

Pre!"!#$ %&"$e, Re$!o#a' Tr!a' (o&r o* +#!&e, -ra#/ , a#" %O(ELN 2E

+SIS re4o#"e#.

FACTS

T/e Pro5!#!a' F!a' /ar$e" /e re4o#"e#, !/ &5er!o# *or /a5!#$ eoe a

eer o* /e Ne Peo4'e +ry. Re4o#"e# 4'ea"e" #o $&!'y o /e /ar$e.

Pe!!o#er, !# /! 4e!a' a!o# *or er!orar!, aa!' /e Or"er !&e" y /e

re4o#"e# %&"$e L&! V. S!o#, re:e!#$ /e e;ra:&"!!a' o#*e!o# o* 4r!5ae

re4o#"e# *or /a5!#$ ee# a a!5er o* /er r!$/ o

oe' a a"e !/o& /e a!a#e o* oe', !# /er o#*e!o#, /!/ a

a


2/31

T/e -a$o# !'!#$ arr!5e" a /e 'oa' I#e$rae" Na!o#a' Po'!e a!o# o* o

re4or /e!r ro/er !!#$ D/e "eeae"). T/e a!o# oa#"er 'e" a ear/

4ary o o a# !#&!ry a#" /ea"e" o** o /e!r 4'ae o &e!o# 4o!'e

!#ee /e# &4o# !#&!ry a# #ae" 5o'eer !#*ore" /e /a /e

"eeae" a 'a ee# o$e/er !/ o#e o* /e a&e" /ere!#.

?/e# /ey *o" a&e" a#" ao& o &e!o# /!, /e !''e$a''y ro

T/e /ree ere a'' e#e#e" *or /e r!e o* &r"er. He#e, /e a44ea'.

T/e &r"er o* /e "eeae" a !#ee" y #o o/er 4ero#. T/e 4o'!e /a" &

/e /ree a&e"Aa44e''a# aee# o &44or ! 'a!!#$. T/e *"ae#a'

!&e /e# ! /e/er or #o /ee aee#, a a#y e;ra:&"!!a' o#*e!o#

o#*ro#!#$ &, a# a#" &4 !# o&r.

ISSUE ?/e/er or #o /e /ree a&e"Aa44e''a# e;ra:&"!!a' o#*e!o# are!#a"!!'e a e5!"e#e@

RULING:

L!


3/31

No 4ero# /a'' e o4e''e" o e a !#e a$a!# /!e'*. T/! o#!&!o#a'

4r!5!'e$e /a ee# "e*!#e" a a 4roe!o# a$a!# e!o#!a' o4&'!o#, & /!

/a !#e ee# e;e#"e" o a#y e5!"e#e o!a!5e !# #a&re a&!re" "er

!r&a#e o* "&re. Ee#!a''y, /e r!$/ ! ea# o a5o!" a#" 4ro/!!

4o!!5e'y /e re4e!!o# a#" re&rre#e o* /e era!#'y !#/&a# 4roe"&re o*

o4e!#$ a 4ero#, !# a r!!#a' or a#y o/er ae, o *&r#!/ /e !!#$

e5!"e#e #eeary *or /! o#5!!o#. T/! a /e 'eo# 'ear#e" *ro /e

a#!e# "ay o* /e !#&!!!o# !# /!/ a&a!o# a e&!5a'e# o $&!'. T/&,

a# a, /e/er e!o#!a' or 4a!5e, /a o&'" ao o "!'o&re o*

!#r!!#aory *a ! o5ere" y /e !#/!!!o# o* /e (o#!&!o#.

?HEREFORE, :&"$e# ! /erey re#"ere" o"!*y!#$ /e 2e!!o#. T/e

a&e"Aa44e''a# are +(UITTE2 o# /e $ro" o* reao#a'e "o&.

So&re

/4BB./a#ro'e.oB"e!!o#B:&r!4r&"e#e1987Be41987B$rC7109=C198

7.4/4

3.) G.R. No. L-51770 March 20, 195

T!E "E#"LE #F T!E "!ILI""INES, "$a%&'%((-A*$$**, +.FRANCISC# GALIT, *(*&a&'-A*$$a&'.

FACTS

T/e a&e" a44e''a# a arree" *or

roery. He /a" ee# "ea!#e" a#" !#erro$ae" a'o o#!#&o&'y *or *!5e "ay.

T/ere a #o e5!"e#e o '!#< /! o /e r!e. T/e !#5e!$a!#$ o**!er e$a# o

a&' /! a#" o or&re /! 4/y!a''y o &eeJe" o#*e!o#. + *!r /e


4/31

a&e"Aa44e''a# !#!e" /! !##oe#e. So /ey o#!#&e" o a'rea a#" ea

/! !' /e 4r!o#er o&'" #o a


5/31

Se&r!y G&ar" o* /e R+PS+ Se&r!y +$e#y a!$#e" a#" o# "&y !# a V!''a$e

ere a'ere" y a re4or re$ar"!#$ /e "ea/ o* a oa# #eary /ey /&rr!e" o /e

e#e o* /e r!e /ere /ey a /e '!*e'e o"y o* a oa# 'y!#$ o# /e

$ro". T/ey !e"!ae'y o#"&e" a ear/ o* /e !e"!ae &rro"!#$

/o4!#$ o *!#" /e 4ero# re4o#!'e *or /e

e5!"e#e@

RULING E5!"e#e /o /a a!" oe' a 4ree# o#'y "&r!#$ /e !$#!#$o* /e e;ra:&"!!a' o#*e!o# a#" #o "&r!#$ /e a&a' !#5e!$a!o#. T/e reor"

! ere* o* a#y !#"!a!o# /a a!" oe' e;4'a!#e" a#y/!#$ o or a"5!e" /e

a44e''a# o* /e o#e&e#e o* /! o#*e!o#. Mere &4!!o# a#" 4e&'a!o#

a# #e5er e /e ae o* a o#5!!o# !# a r!!#a' ae. T/e o&r /o&'""eer!#e /e/er /e 4roe&!o# /a &!e" &**!!e# 'e$a''y a"!!'e

e5!"e#e /o!#$ eyo#" reao#a'e "o& /a a r!e /a o!e" y /e

a&e".

So&re

h'':66.$ah%$.&*'688r%68r%19976a19976r1103971997.h'$

5.) G.R. No. L-;// A' 11, 19

"E#"LE #F T!E "!ILI""INES, Plaintiff-Appellee, 5. EUAR#ELEGIN# < S#RR#NT# *' a$, a&e"A a44e''a#.

FACTS:

T/e a&e" a /ar$e" *or /a5!#$ o!e" /e r!e o* Roery !/

Ho!!"e.


6/31

T/e +&e" a /e# arree". Pr!or o /e!r &o"!a' !#5e!$a!o# /e a&e"

ere a44r!e" o* /e!r o#!&!o#a' r!$/ o rea!# !'e# D/!/ /ey a!5e" !#

r!!#$) a#" o e a!e" y oe'. (oe'e 'ayer a re&ee" y /e 4o'!e

o a! /e "&r!#$ /e !#5e!$a!o# a#" !$#e" a !#e o /e!r o#*e!o#.

T/e r!a' o&r a"!e" /e e;ra:&"!!a' o#*e!o# o* /e a&e" a'/o&$/ !# /ea44ea' /ey "!o#e" /e!r o# /e $ro" /a /e!r aee# ere $!5e# "er

4re&re a#" /ro&$/ /e &e o* *ore a#" 5!o'e#e &4o# /e!r 4ero# or !# o/er

or" /ey "eroo< a# !#erro$a!o#. T/e a

/! o#!&!o#a' r!$/ o rea!# !'e# a#" o oe' a#" o e !#*ore" o* &/

r!$/, a#" /! r!$/ o /a5e #o *ore, 5!o'e#e, /rea, !#!!"a!o#, or a#y o/er

ea# e4'oye" &4o# /! /!/ 5!!ae /! *ree !''. He a''e$e" /a /eo#*e!o# a 4re4are" y /e 4o'!e /a /e a eae# !/ a raa# !

/! a"5!e a#" oe' "&r!#$ /e !#5e!$a!o#. +# !#"!5!"&a' /a a r!$/ o re&e

*or a 'ayer, /! *a!'&re o a< *or a 'ayer "oe #o o#!&e a a!5er. No

e**e!5e a!5er o* /e r!$/ o oe' "&r!#$ !#erro$a!o# a# e reo$#!Je"

'e 4e!*!a''y a"e a*er /e ar#!#$ /ere "e'!#eae /a5e ee# $!5e#.

?HEREFORE, /e "e!!o# o* /e r!a' o&r *!#"!#$ /e a44e''a# $&!'y o* /e

r!e o* roery !/ /o!!"e ! re5ere" a#" e a!"e. T/e a!" a&e" !

a&!e" o* /e r!e /ar$e".

So&re

/4BB.'a4/!'.#eB:&":&r!B:&r!1988Ba&$1988B$rC'C688C1988./'

1.) G.R.No.136066A67 Fer&ary , =003

"E#"LE #F T!E "!ILI""INES 54INA S C!UA,

FACTS:

+!#$ o# /e re4or o* a# !#*ora#, 4o'!e o4era!5e *ore" a ea a#" a


7/31

a#" !#ro"&e" /ee'5e a 4o'!e a&/or!!e. T/e# a#" /ere /e a &:ee"

o a o"y ear/ a#" a *o" o e !# 4oe!o# o* 4ro/!!e" "r&$ a#" a /or

*!rear. T/erea*er, /e a ro&$/ o /e Po'!e Sa!o# a#" !# /e 4ree#e o*

re4orer, a 'a e#*orer o4e#e" /e o; a#" a&e"Aa44e''a# a a"e o /o'"

/e o; /!'e 4!&re ere e!#$ a


8/31

2.) G.R. No. 10927 Ar%$ 1, 199;

"E#"LE #F T!E "!ILI""INES,Plaintiff-Appellee, v. ANT#LIN CUI=#N O**!e DP+O) a e#$a$e" y /e 4o'!e o a!

/e a44e''a# "&r!#$ /e !#5e!$a!o#.

+44e''a# "e#!e" "&r!#$ /e r!a' /a /e

e5!"e#e, /oe5er, *a!' o &44or /e a''e$a!o# o* /e a44e''a# /a /e a

a'reae" y /e ara#$ay o**!!a' !# /e /o&e o* -ara#$ay

H! are a''e$a!o# o* /rea *ro /e ara#$ay a4a!# ! era!#'y #o o#5!#!#$

!# 5!e o* /e o5er/e'!#$ e5!"e#e o /e o#rary. -ara#$ay (a4a!# a#" /e

/!e* o* /e ara#$ay a#o" ere'y ao4a#!e" /e a44e''a# o /e 4o'!e

/ea"&arer !# 5!e o* /e 'aer> 4re5!o& a"!!o# o /e


18/31

"eeae". He a !e"!ae'y &r#e" o5er o /e 4o'!e a#" !#*ore" /e /a

/e a44e''a# a#e" o &rre#"er *or

So&re/4BB./a#ro'e.oB"e!!o#B:&r!4r&"e#e=000Bar=000B13=7

K.4/4

5.) G.R. No. L-/3/ S*'*B*r 1/, 197


19/31

T!E "E#"LE #F T!E "!ILI""INES,Plaintiff, v.A4ELAR# MARUE= MARTINE=, "e*e#"a#.

FACTS T/e a&e" a *a/er a


20/31

So&re/4BB./a#ro'e.oB"e!!o#B:&r!4r&"e#e1987Be41987B$rC'C

883C1987.4/4

1.) G.R. No. 99. Mar/ 1K, 1996


21/31

"E#"LE #F T!E "!ILI""INES,Plaintiff-Appellee, v. I#NISI# LA"URAy CA>AN,Accused-Appellant

FACTS:

T/e a&e" a44e''a# a o#5!e" o* &r"er. Rea''!#$ /e !r&a#e, /e

a44e''a# a arree" y 4o'!e o**!er a /e eoe a &4e !# a

/e aro$ra4/! o* /e

!#5!e" o /e 4o'!e a!o# a#" /e eye!#e o#'&"e" !"e#!*!e" /! !# 4o'!e

'!#eA&4.

ISSUE:

?/e/er or #o /e arra#'e arre a 5a'!"@

RULING:

-y /! a44'!a!o# *or a!', a#" y e#er!#$ a 4'ea o* #o $&!'y a#" /e# &!!#$

o /e 4roee"!#$ a44e''a# & e "eee" o /a5e *or$o#e /! r!$/ o

4re'!!#ary !#5e!$a!o# a#" o &e!o# a#y !rre$&'ar!y /a !$/ /a5e ae#"e"

&/ !#5e!$a!o#.

SOUR(E

/4BB./a#ro'e.oB"e!!o#B:&r!4r&"e#e1996Bar1996B99.4/4

2.) G.R. No. 12372. >a&ar< 30, 199
http://www.chanrobles.com/scdecisions/jurisprudence1996/mar1996/94494.phphttp://www.chanrobles.com/scdecisions/jurisprudence1996/mar1996/94494.php


22/31

"E#"LE #F T!E "!ILI""INES,Plaintiff-Appellee v.RU4EN M#NTILLA< GATULA,Accused-Appellant.

E C I S I # N

F+(TS

+44e''a# a a&$/ ra#4or!#$ =8 ar!:&a#a r!

o#e# o* /e ra5e'!#$ a$, /!/ a44e''a# 5o'ar!'y a#" rea"!'y "!". U4o#

&rory !#4e!o# /e a$ y!e'"e" /e 4ro/!!e" "r&$, o, !/o& o/er!#$ o

*&r/er ear/ /e o;, /ey ro&$/ a44e''a# a#" /! '&$$a$e o /e!r /ea"&arer

*or &e!o#!#$.He a /e# /ar$e *or 5!o'a!#$ Se. +r. II o* 2a#$ero& 2r&$ + o* 197= a

ae#"e" a#" a 4ro#oe" $&!'y eyo#" reao#a'e "o&.

I# /e a44ea', /e a44e''a# "!4&e /e r!a' o&r *!#"!#$ /a /e a 'e$a''y

a&$/ !#flagrante. He aa!'e" /a /ere a #o 4roa'e a&e *or /e a&/or!!e

o /!#< /a /e a o!!#$ a r!e /e# /ey arree" /!. +44e''a# !#!

/a /e ere *a o* ee!#$ a 4ero# arry!#$ a ra5e'!#$ a$ a#" a aro# o;

/o&'" #o e'!! /e '!$/e &4!!o# o* /e o!!o# o* a#y r!e !#e /a

! #ora'. He a'' /e ae#!o# o* /e (o&r o /e *a /a a ear'y a =00 P.M. o*

/e 4ree"!#$ "ay, /e 4o'!e a&/or!!e /a" a'rea"y ee# a44r!e" y /e!r oA

a''e" !#*orer o* a44e''a# !4e#"!#$ arr!5a' /e#e /oe 'a e#*orer /a" /e

o44or!y o 4ro&re /e re&!!e arra#. T/e!r !*eaa#e /o&'" /ere*ore

!#5a'!"ae /e arre o* a44e''a# o# /e *o''o!#$ "a#.

ISSUE

IS THE ?+RR+NTLESS +RREST OF THE +PPEL+NT LEGITIM+TE ?HEN

L+? ENFOR(ES H+2 THE OPPORTUNIT TO PRO(URE THE REUSITE

TO +V+IL ?+RR+NT ?HEN THE ?ERE +PPRISE2 -EFOREH+N2 THE

F+(TS - THE INFORMER@

RULING


23/31

O# &/ are !#*ora!o#, /e 4o'!e a&/or!!e o&'" #o /a5e 4ro4er'y a44'!e"

*or a arra#, a&!#$ /a /ey o&'" rea"!'y /a5e ae o a :&"$e or a o&r

/a a !'' o4e# y /e !e /ey o&'" a


24/31

"*o$* +. a&%$o >a'a&

FACTS

Po'!e +&/or!!e o#"&e" o#eAee< &r5e!''a#e !# re'a!o# o /e !#e''!$e#e

!#*ora!o# /a /e a&e" ! "ea'!#$ !# 4ro/!!e" "r&$. T/e &r5e!''a#e

/oe" a 4o!!5e re&' a#" /e ea 4o'!e ea o#"&e" a &yA& o4era!o#.

O#e o* /e o4era!5e 4oe" a /e 4oe&rA&yer /!'e a#o/er 4oe" a "!**ere#

area o* /e 4'ae.

T/e o5er &4 ory *or &y!#$ Q"r&$ eae &e*&' /e# /e a&e" e

/e Q4oe&rA&yer a#" /e !#*ora# a /e or#er o* a# a''ey, aro" e# eer

aay *ro /e a&e" /o&e. T/e Q4oe&rA&yer $a5e /! a PK00A!'' ar


25/31

PEPLE F T!E P!ILIPPINES "S A#RA!A$ $ICLAT

FACTS:

T/ro&$/ ree!4 o* a# INFOREP eo *ro (a4 (rae re'a!5e o /e !''!! a#"

"o#Ar!$/ "r&$ ra"!#$ a!5!!e e!#$ "era


26/31

5.) G.R. N#. 171729: >$< 2, 200"E#"LE #F T!E "!ILI""INES,Appellee, v.RICAR# 4#!#L

Documents

Invalid Ecj and Invalid Wa