View
220
Download
2
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Introduction to Antitrust Law
Always two questions in any antitrust case:– What is prohibited according to the
antitrust statutes?– Will the actions the firm is taking/has taken
result in these prohibited things? Legal side of antitrust is answering the
first question.
Economic Side of Antitrust
Determine whether a firm’s actions will have specific effects that have been determined to be illegal.– For the most part, a postitive question -- a
question of fact.– But ultimately the courts will decide
because inevitably different economists will have different opinions.
Sherman Act - 1890 Earliest antitrust act by any country. Outlaws "every contract, combination . . . or
conspiracy, in restraint of trade,”– Supreme Court decided it only prohibits contracts that
restrain trade unreasonably. What is unreasonable is up to the courts.
Makes it unlawful to monopolize, or attempt to monopolize a market. – As interpreted by the courts, the law is violated only if
the company tries to maintain or acquire a monopoly position through unreasonable methods. Courts decide what is unreasonable.
Clayton Act - 1914 Prohibits mergers and acquisitions where the
effect "may be substantially to lessen competition, or to tend to create a monopoly." – Determining whether a merger will have such an
effect requires a thorough economic evaluation or market study.
Also interpreted as limiting the use of tying and exclusive contracts.
Passed partly in response to perceived shortcomings in the Sherman Act as interpreted by the courts.
Federal Trade Commission Act -1914 Outlaws "unfair methods of competition.”
– Does not define unfair. The courts must decide.
– The Supreme Court has ruled that violations of the Sherman Act also are violations of FTC Act, but the FTC Act covers some practices that are beyond the scope of the Sherman Act.
Robinson-Patman Act - 1936
Price discrimination that lessens competition is illegal.– In general, price discrimination is lawful. Must hurt
competition to be illegal.
“Chicago School”
A group of academics, primarily at the University of Chicago.
Belief that markets will eventually erode most monopolies quickly and more effectively than governments.
Post-Chicago School
Revival of interest in antitrust law and economics.– Development of new theories that show
persistent existence of market power. Additional increase in interest due to
increase in merger activity.
History of Industrial Organization
Structure-Conduct-Performance Paradigm– First formal theory of industrial organization– Developed in the 1940’s by Mason and
Bain– Assumes a causal relationship:
Structure Conduct Performance
S-C-P
Structure: characteristics of the market.– number of firms, distribution of market share,
degree of product differentiation, entry conditions, Conduct: choices of firms.
– price, quantity, investments, service, quality. Performance: how firms do.
– price, consumer surplus, product variety, technological progress.
New Industrial Organization
Focuses on models of firm behavior. Uses game theory as a basic tool.
– Explicitly incorporates strategic interaction among firms
New Empirical Industrial Organization (NEIO)– Based on theoretical models.– Econometric analysis, not case studies.