16

Introduction - NCTE · Hometown History: The Hickory Flat Oral History Project Peggy Maynard Corbett 67 11. My Classroom Really Is a Zoo (What We Did and What ... former capital of

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Introduction - NCTE · Hometown History: The Hickory Flat Oral History Project Peggy Maynard Corbett 67 11. My Classroom Really Is a Zoo (What We Did and What ... former capital of
Page 2: Introduction - NCTE · Hometown History: The Hickory Flat Oral History Project Peggy Maynard Corbett 67 11. My Classroom Really Is a Zoo (What We Did and What ... former capital of

Introduction ix

Contents

PrefaceKCAC Print Publications Team: Patsy Hamby, Sarah Robbins,Linda Hadley Stewart, Rozlyn T. Truss, Leslie M. Walker, andDave Winter xi

Acknowledgments xiii

Introduction: Building Communities of Learning—An Invitation toTeachers

Sarah Robbins xv

Thematic Strands for Studying CommunityKCAC Project Teachers and Amy Meadows xxi

I. Introductory Activities

1. Sharing Stories to Build CommunityLinda Hadley Stewart 3

2. Making the Classroom Our PlaceLeslie M. Walker 9

II. Single-Class-Period Activities

3. Take Two: Reading Community PhotosMimi Dyer 15

4. Viewfinders: Students Picturing Their CommunitiesGerri Hajduk 21

5. Giving Students a Penny for Their ThoughtsOreather J. Bostick-Morgan 27

6. A Correspondence between Atlanta StudentsDave Winter 34

III. Units/Major Assignments

7. Setting the Stage for Historical FictionBernadette Lambert 45

a59206_fm 12/2/04, 7:39 AM9

Page 3: Introduction - NCTE · Hometown History: The Hickory Flat Oral History Project Peggy Maynard Corbett 67 11. My Classroom Really Is a Zoo (What We Did and What ... former capital of

x Introduction

8. Preserving the CityBonnie G. Webb 51

9. Recovering Displaced Heritages in Multiple ContextsLinda Templeton 59

IV. Extended Research Projects

10. Hometown History: The Hickory Flat Oral History ProjectPeggy Maynard Corbett 67

11. My Classroom Really Is a Zoo (What We Did and WhatI Wish We Had Done)

Dave Winter 76

12. “Writing Suburbia” in Pictures and PrintSarah Robbins 88

Afterword and Action PlanDiana Mitchell 93

BibliographyEdited by Stacie Janecki 99

Editors 105

Contributors 107

x Contents

a59206_fm 12/2/04, 7:40 AM10

Page 4: Introduction - NCTE · Hometown History: The Hickory Flat Oral History Project Peggy Maynard Corbett 67 11. My Classroom Really Is a Zoo (What We Did and What ... former capital of

Introduction xxi

KCAC Project Teachers and Amy Meadows

Thematic Strands forStudying Community

Drawn from the program Web site (http://kcac.kennesaw.edu).

W e and our students have studied ways in which American com-munities are formed in various times and places by drawingon a cluster of themes. These themes originally guided the in-

quiry of teacher participants at summer institutes and in academic-yearinquiry teams. Later, we adapted the themes for teaching in a wide rangeof settings and disciplines. The following list identifies the basic con-tent of each theme, the first two of which focus on community-orientedaction and the next three of which emphasize the power of place:

Reclaiming Displaced Heritages—recovering aspects of historyand local culture that could be undervalued or misunderstoodby future generationsEducating for Citizenship—developing learning approachesthat prepare community members for active engagement inAmerican democracyCultivating Homelands—shaping the natural environment anddrawing on it for support while honoring traditions of rurallifeBuilding Cities—analyzing urban spaces that represent andpromote community values in particular historical periodsShifting Landscapes, Converging Peoples—reconfiguring con-temporary suburban landscapes and social practices to balancea region’s local heritage with newcomers’ cultural contribu-tions

Because we have found these themes to be so productive for stu-dent learning, one of the organizational plans for this book (as seen inthe table of contents on the inside front cover) highlights their role asorganizing tools for teaching. With that in mind, following is an over-view of ways we have used each theme.

a59206_fm 12/2/04, 7:40 AM21

Page 5: Introduction - NCTE · Hometown History: The Hickory Flat Oral History Project Peggy Maynard Corbett 67 11. My Classroom Really Is a Zoo (What We Did and What ... former capital of

xxii Introduction

Reclaiming Displaced Heritages

Typically, when studying community through this thematic lens, teach-ers and students identify a particular occasion when members of a com-munity have been disenfranchised in ways that may have suppressedor obscured records of their cultural heritage. Students read literatureassociated with such groups’ communal stories, visit public history sites,

xxii Thematic Strands for Studying Community

study changes in the local landscape, and gatheradditional records of cultural experience (such asoral histories, photographs, public documents).

In Georgia, for example, our initial applica-tion of this theme involved reexamining the Chero-kee Removal, including studying the causes lead-ing up to the historical event, its effects on the landand social practices in northwest Georgia, and its

impact on members of the Cherokee Nation, from the 1800s until today.Participants read texts such as Diane Glancy’s Pushing the Bear and Rob-ert Conley’s Mountain Windsong alongside primary historical documentsfrom the era of the Removal. They visited sites such as New Echota (theformer capital of the Cherokee Nation), and they contributed to thewriting of a play about events in Georgia leading up to the Removal.

Given this initial focus for our work with this theme, on our Website and in this book we have used an image of Sequoyah to designatethis body of our work. Sequoyah, who was born to the daughter of aCherokee chief and a Virginia fur trader in the village of Tuskeegee in1776, developed the Cherokee writing system in 1809 after moving toGeorgia to flee the encroachment of white settlers. In 1821 the Chero-kee Nation officially adopted the system, which helped lead to the pub-lication of the first Native American newspaper, The Cherokee Phoenix.

Educating for Citizenship

This theme considers how various groups have tried to use educationas a way of claiming a place in American culture. At the same time, itinvites teachers to educate today’s students for informed, proactive citi-zenship.

For example, while using this theme, teachers in our project groupstudied the early history of Spelman College as an example of collabo-ration between blacks and whites to create an empowering educationalinstitution for African Americans in the decades after the Civil War.Team members collected oral histories and archival materials, includ-ing turn-of-the-century copies of The Spelman Messenger, a bulletin about

Reclaiming DisplacedHeritages

a59206_fm 12/2/04, 7:40 AM22

Page 6: Introduction - NCTE · Hometown History: The Hickory Flat Oral History Project Peggy Maynard Corbett 67 11. My Classroom Really Is a Zoo (What We Did and What ... former capital of

Introduction xxiiiThematic Strands for Studying Community xxiii

college students and graduates. Along the way,team members considered how students’ aware-ness of educational opportunities often taken forgranted today could shape their involvement in citi-zenship issues in the future.

As a logo to mark this theme, we chose animage of the Georgia State Capitol Building, dedi-cated on July 4, 1889. The capitol building is the center of the State Capi-tol Complex in Atlanta.

Cultivating Homelands

This theme delves into rural communities, seeking ways to honor theirtraditions and complexities. Teachers and students research records ofrural life, such as landmarks (cemeteries, barns, churches, historichomes), documents (land grant deeds, archival photographs, familyBibles), and social practices such as regional festivals. While preserva-tionist energies drive much of the work around this theme, participants

also question why some aspects of their communi-ties’ past have received more attention than others,and what familiar narratives of local life need to beexpanded or revised—and how.

Our first application of this theme exploredthe heritage of farm communities in Georgia, espe-cially in the early twentieth century. Reading Ray-mond Andrews’s The Last Radio Baby and former

president Jimmy Carter’s An Hour before Daylight, the group traced simi-larities and differences in these vivid narratives about rural experiences.Our inquiry into the histories of local places often promoted grassrootscollaborations with citizens’ groups, sometimes leading to the renova-tion of neglected sites. These efforts taught us that chronicling parts ofa rural community’s history can help develop communities of criticalthinkers and informed preservationists.

To delineate this theme on our Web site and in this book, we haveused a photograph from Jimmy Carter’s memoir, An Hour before Day-light. A young Carter poses with his mother and sister in rural Plains,Georgia, circa 1933. The son of a farmer who owned land, Carter grewup among tenant sharecroppers, often working alongside them to har-vest the cash crops of peanuts and cotton for his family. His book, likeresearch done through this theme by students and teachers, honors thecontinuing influence of rural heritage on American culture.

Educating for Citizenship

Cultivating Homelands

a59206_fm 12/2/04, 7:40 AM23

Page 7: Introduction - NCTE · Hometown History: The Hickory Flat Oral History Project Peggy Maynard Corbett 67 11. My Classroom Really Is a Zoo (What We Did and What ... former capital of

xxiv Introduction

Building Cities

To study community through this thematic lens, teachers and studentsfocus on a particular period when the identity of a city in their regionwas being constructed to reflect a vision of that community as distinc-tively American. Learners using this theme typically visit urban build-ings and neighborhoods, interview longtime residents, retrace key de-velopments in architecture and urban planning, and identify ways inwhich political, social, and economic forces converged to affect a city’sway of life.

The Georgia team initially explored this theme by reimaginingAtlanta as a cultural, corporate center, with emphasis on ways that

xxiv Thematic Strands for Studying Community

1970s–1990s civic leaders tried to move the cityfrom being a regional center to having a nationaland international presence. Teachers read FrederickAllen’s Atlanta Rising: The Invention of an Interna-tional City, 1946–1996, took an architectural walk-ing tour of downtown, visited urban museums, andbegan to gather family stories about life in the cityof Atlanta. Studying Dolores Hayden’s The Power

of Place and Paul Fleischman’s Seedfolks helped teachers consider howthey and their students might contribute to the culture of the city throughwriting and new kinds of landmark making.

As a logo for this theme, we selected images of several Atlantalandmarks that would resonate outside our own region. Pictured clock-wise from the top in the logo are John Portman’s Westin Peachtree PlazaHotel, at one time the tallest hotel in the western hemisphere and hometo the three-story revolving Sun Dial Restaurant; the former WinecoffHotel, site of a 1946 fire that killed a record 119 people, spurring hotelfire safety measures nationwide; and the Carnegie Building, completedin 1925 as the Wynne-Claughton Building and hailed then for its land-mark exterior design.

Shifting Landscapes, Converging Peoples

The Shifting Landscapes, Converging Peoples theme explores how therapidly changing landscapes of contemporary suburbia can bereconfigured to achieve a productive balance between the native andthe newcomers’ cultural contributions. Teachers and students activelyinterpret changing social spaces, such as restaurants, public buildings,and shopping centers; cultural events, such as fairs, homecomings, andethnic celebrations; public policies, including planning and zoning or-

Building Cities

a59206_fm 12/2/04, 7:40 AM24

Page 8: Introduction - NCTE · Hometown History: The Hickory Flat Oral History Project Peggy Maynard Corbett 67 11. My Classroom Really Is a Zoo (What We Did and What ... former capital of

Introduction xxv

dinances; and oral histories that both keep the old way of life and helpcreate the new.

To begin their study of suburbia, the Georgia KCAC team stud-ied Kenneth T. Jackson’s Crabgrass Frontier: The Suburbanization of the

Thematic Strands for Studying Community xxv

United States and listened to the National PublicRadio oral memoirs of Carmen Agra Deedy onGrowing Up Cuban in Decatur, Georgia. They also be-came avid readers of their local newspapers, track-ing recurring stories about immigrants’ experiences,innovations in suburban lifestyle, and issues asso-ciated with sprawl (e.g., traffic, endangered natu-ral resources). They took walking tours of Atlantasuburbs. Students interviewed contractors about how subdivisions aredesigned and built, used digital cameras to record the rapid changes inthe suburban landscape, and talked with both longtime residents andnewcomers about their views on life in the outskirts of Atlanta.

The logo for this theme records a scene familiar to suburban lifeall over the United States today. Two soccer players reflect the growingdiversity in suburban public schools like Wheeler High in Cobb County,Georgia, where this photo was taken.

Shifting Landscapes,Converging Peoples

a59206_fm 12/2/04, 7:40 AM25

Page 9: Introduction - NCTE · Hometown History: The Hickory Flat Oral History Project Peggy Maynard Corbett 67 11. My Classroom Really Is a Zoo (What We Did and What ... former capital of

Sharing Stories to Build Community 1

I Introductory Activities

b59206_ch1 12/2/04, 8:12 AM1

Page 10: Introduction - NCTE · Hometown History: The Hickory Flat Oral History Project Peggy Maynard Corbett 67 11. My Classroom Really Is a Zoo (What We Did and What ... former capital of

Sharing Stories to Build Community 3

1 Sharing Stories to BuildCommunityLinda Hadley StewartKennesaw State University, Kennesaw, Georgia

Overview

Seeking a warm-up activity that reflected the KCAC emphasis onstorytelling as a way of understanding and composing history, I askedmy students to write about a memorable tree-climbing experience (orrelated activity, such as building a tree house or creating a backyard“club”). Brannen’s paper is the result of a writing activity I assigned the

The English composition course isthe second in a sequence ofrequired general educationcourses at Kennesaw StateUniversity in Kennesaw, Georgia.Once a small, rural community,Kennesaw is now considered asuburb of metro Atlanta. Theuniversity is primarily a com-muter campus serving nearly18,000 students. This course,limited to 25 students, focuses onwriting and research. Many of thestudents are from rural andsuburban northwest Georgia; asignificant number, however, areinternational students fromcountries such as Nigeria, Guate-mala, Bulgaria, or Brazil. Studentages range widely because manyare returning to Kennesaw tocomplete or begin their collegecareers as adults.

first day of our English composi-tion class to be read aloud to theentire class at the following meet-ing. This type of writing activitywould, I hoped, reveal and vali-date the different ways we tell sto-ries, begin to create communitythrough describing a shared expe-rience, and prepare the studentsfor reading Raymond Andrews’smemoir The Last Radio Baby, aKCAC Summer Institute selec-tion.

This brief assignment was atrial balloon that yielded somesignificant results. Brannen’s pa-per is a paradigm for the manypapers that emerged from this as-signment. I chose his paper to in-clude because his essay uncannilyevoked several KCAC themes.When he speaks of white flight, hetouches on our theme of ShiftingLandscapes, Converging Peoples. His description of the removal of thelandmark jet evokes the Building Cities thematic content. I realized that

b59206_ch1 12/2/04, 8:12 AM3

Page 11: Introduction - NCTE · Hometown History: The Hickory Flat Oral History Project Peggy Maynard Corbett 67 11. My Classroom Really Is a Zoo (What We Did and What ... former capital of

4 Introductory Activities

the assignment had elicited concepts and ideas thatKCAC recognizes and explicitly names. These prin-ciples, fused with teaching practices (e.g., valuingstorytelling), have galvanized my students’ writingand thinking.

Brannen’s paper meanders through the sub-urban streets on Brannen’s return home from mili-tary duty as he describes the streets both past and

Shifting Landscapes, Con-verging Peoples

present. His paper is laden with historical observations and personalmemories. In so many ways, Brannen’s writing evokes the work andthe value of community-based inquiry. His narrative artfully fuses homeand place, memory and history, the personal and the public. His paperbegs the question, “What was there before?” His former address, “Six-One-Nine Camelia Circle,” becomes present as he describes the rottingremains of the tree his father removed “to make room for his old Volvo.”

His writing, like that of many of his classmates who shared theirbrief memoirs, reveals the twine of personal memory with cultural his-tory, much as Raymond Andrews’s memoir reveals the history of ruralGeorgia in the early 1900s. This initial writing assignment was a wedgeinto our later exploration of and writing about the communities aroundus. Through this initial assignment, students began to validate story-telling, recognizing how culture and history are at work in their per-sonal lives.

Instructional Sequence

For this course-opening activity, students arrive in class ready to readtheir journal entries to the class. The assignment is given as homeworkthe previous class, and students are aware that they will be reading theirwriting aloud to the entire class. The writing prompt invites them totell a story about the first time they climbed a tree or to adapt the topicto a similar outdoor experience. When asked to volunteer, students haveshown a willingness to read, which is surprising since this must be asomewhat high-anxiety task so early in the semester.

I ask everyone to have journals out and note details, passages,ways of telling stories, subject matter, or other observations. They areencouraged to listen carefully and write down their observations be-cause they will be posting them in response to a prompt on an electronicdiscussion board.

At the end of class, after listening to their comments and insights,I summarize particular rhetorical strategies, note different motivations

b59206_ch1 12/2/04, 8:12 AM4

Page 12: Introduction - NCTE · Hometown History: The Hickory Flat Oral History Project Peggy Maynard Corbett 67 11. My Classroom Really Is a Zoo (What We Did and What ... former capital of

Sharing Stories to Build Community 5

for tree climbing, underscore the cultural aspects of their personal sto-ries, and emphasize much of what the students have already shared.

To extend this brief assignment, I have students post online ob-servations about the class discussion. We brainstorm possible researchor writing activities that could emerge from the various narratives andthen compile a class list of these activities. Most important, we have builta sound foundation for the semester by sharing and validating manyways of telling stories.

Student ArtifactJournal Entry—Tree Climbing

I make the left turn from Green Street onto Pleasant Hill Road aftera night of delayed and finally diminished anticipation. I had hopedmy first night back home would culminate elsewhere, but the onlyguest that accompanies me is the slight fragrance of alcohol andcigarette smoke. I follow Pleasant Hill about three quarters of amile, making a sharp right turn past Sewell Circle Park. A staticmodel of an old Air Force jet once decorated the edge of the park,but the “powers that be” dismantled and relocated it to a differentside of town. This is the “old neighborhood.”

When I was younger most of the inhabitants of this area werewhite. As I aged, they changed and the neighborhood darkened. Iwitnessed “white flight” before I ever knew there was a term todescribe it. Families began moving southward to the country,where newer homes, schools, and less diversity existed. About thesame time that whites in the neighborhood began flying south, thejet at Sewell Circle Park took off and landed in another park. Thejet was a tribute to Robbins Air Force Base, which supplies 20,000civilian jobs to central Georgia. My father was one of thoseemployees. Apparently, the new inhabitants of our old neighbor-hood were unworthy of having the jet in their neighborhood. Ipassed the park and made a left onto Camelia Circle. I drove pastthe home of my old friend Charles Ranger.

When we were five, Charlie’s mom heard me call Charlie afew select names during a fight the two of us were having. Charlieand I were no longer allowed to play together. She didn’t know Ilearned the words from her son. I was disappointed about losingmy friend, but the incident only supported my belief that his momwas crazy. She looked like a homely, red-haired Cher. Charlieonce told me his mom and dad showered together to save water. Itwas 1983, Reagan was president; the only thing America caredabout conserving was nuclear weaponry. To hell with water!

Four or five houses down from Charlie’s house is Six-One-Nine Camelia Circle. The first address I ever learned. It is my old

b59206_ch1 12/2/04, 8:12 AM5

Page 13: Introduction - NCTE · Hometown History: The Hickory Flat Oral History Project Peggy Maynard Corbett 67 11. My Classroom Really Is a Zoo (What We Did and What ... former capital of

6 Introductory Activities

house. We moved in 1985, but my father still owns it. It no longerlooks like it did when I lived there. The red brick was replaced withsome type of plastic or poly-whatever-you-have-it siding yearsago. A large evergreen once flanked the right side. It bombardedthe front yard with blue-green meteors. In the hands of my oldersisters they became flying projectiles, bullets, or missiles, just aeuphemism for one more item to throw at Brannen and make hislife miserable.

But if the tree created a source of misery, it also provided ameans of escape. The trunk opened up like a stairwell so that asmall child, like myself, could easily climb the branches. Thesetrees tend to grow out rather than up, so my fear of heights wasnever able to take advantage of my fear of sisters. It was easy tofind a place to lie for hours, surrounded by the tree’s fruit. Carpen-ter ants tickled the little white hairs on my arms. They were the“good” ants because they never bit. It is difficult to remember thetexture of the limbs or the trunk. I mostly remember the berries.

The tree no longer stands by the right side of my old home. Myfather felled it before we moved. He needed to make room for hisold Volvo. The tree blocked a potential parking spot on the side ofthe house. It became a victim of its own random, stubborn nature.It grew in the wrong place, and would be moved only by force.The only remains are rotting if they haven’t already. Gone likechildhood, unearthed only by returning children who are curiousabout their memories.

—Brannen

Teacher Reflection

Let me offer some background about why I chose this particular assign-ment. It was the result of a class conversation the previous semesterwhen one of my students mentioned climbing a magnolia tree and herclassmates showed great interest in her story. Realizing this was an ac-tivity they all shared, I asked them to tell me their tree stories, and I leftthe class mulling over the various kinds of trees they so clearly describedand the different motivations for climbing trees—for sanctuary, for com-petition, for solace, for companionship, for a better view, and simplybecause “everyone else was climbing it.” The following semester I de-cided to start with this activity, explaining to my class why I had cho-sen it: because their predecessors had shown me that it was a sharedactivity, one that a student called “a national pastime.”

My students’ tree stories surprise me with their range and unso-licited vivid description. Students describe mango trees and magnoliatrees; reveal their competitive and ambitious response to a challenge;

b59206_ch1 12/2/04, 8:13 AM6

Page 14: Introduction - NCTE · Hometown History: The Hickory Flat Oral History Project Peggy Maynard Corbett 67 11. My Classroom Really Is a Zoo (What We Did and What ... former capital of

Sharing Stories to Build Community 7

discover a fear of heights; narrate a formula plot; call on metaphor; re-member family relationships; celebrate imagination; and delve into theirpersonal histories. Students repeatedly express surprise at how a simi-lar, shared experience can produce such an array of writing styles andsubject matter. And they begin to connect their personal histories withcultural practices, examining their stories in a fuller context within theirnew classroom community.

Trees are deeply personal, but they are political, environmental,cultural, poetic, literary, and historical as well. Think clear-cutting, theSurvivor Tree at the Oklahoma City National Memorial, trees as sign-posts for Cherokee along the Trail of Tears, to name a few. This brieftree-climbing warm-up assignment is a good springboard for writingand research activities such as reading newspaper articles; connectingto poetry; completing a scientific observation; interviewing a tree farmeror a land developer; or visiting trees that function as icons. This assign-ment works as an introductory or journal response to any novel or lit-erary work with a tree as a central or minor trope (e.g., A Separate Peace,Beloved, Their Eyes Were Watching God). Or, to encourage us to think ascitizens, as a prelude to planting a tree for conservation or memoriali-zation. I’ve learned much from listening to my students’ tree stories, andthey provide our classroom community with rich material to begin asemester of writing and research.

Community ✜ Crossings

Suggestions on how you might adapt this lesson for a different classroom setting

This activity could be used with any shared cultural experience, such aspublic transportation stories in an urban setting, vacation stories, bicyclestories, etc. Using a common writing prompt reveals the different waysstories are told even as it creates community within the class. Thisactivity could be extended by having students identify similar stories inthe media (e.g., cartoons, films, television shows, news) and analyze thevarious ways of sharing these stories.Younger students could illustrate their stories and then tell them to theclass. Another option would be for students to create an illustratedstoryboard of their narratives, either independently or collaboratively.Such storyboards could include captions.Another way to build community early in the course is to have studentsconstruct a “life map.” Students choose five to seven defining momentsor life stories to represent graphically, such as a poster, a computer-generated representation, or other format. Each student presents his or

b59206_ch1 12/2/04, 8:13 AM7

Page 15: Introduction - NCTE · Hometown History: The Hickory Flat Oral History Project Peggy Maynard Corbett 67 11. My Classroom Really Is a Zoo (What We Did and What ... former capital of

8 Introductory Activities

her life map to the class, explaining the significance of each event. Sharingthese life maps helps students recognize how much they have in commonwith others who might, on the surface, seem very different. The activityalso helps to foster a safe and supportive learning environment forclassrooms of all levels. For other variations of this lesson, see DeborahMitchell and Traci Blanchard’s “Critical Reading, Imaginative Writing andthe Me Montage” in the Extended Lesson Treatments section of ClassroomResources on the KCAC Web site (http://kcac.kennesaw.edu/).

b59206_ch1 12/2/04, 8:13 AM8

Page 16: Introduction - NCTE · Hometown History: The Hickory Flat Oral History Project Peggy Maynard Corbett 67 11. My Classroom Really Is a Zoo (What We Did and What ... former capital of