International and national rankings. Myth & reality. What is first?

Olga MorozovaHead of FAD, NUST “MISIS”

Main International rankings

SCI ENG

LIFE MED

SOC

E&T Arts&Hum

Med Life

Ph Sc SCI

E&T LIFE&MED

NAT Sci Arts&Hum

ARWU (SHANGHAI)

TIMES HIGHER EDUCATION• Citation index (Web of Sci) (worth 30 per cent of the overall ranking score)• Survey of quality of research ( 18%)• Survey of quality of education (15%)• Ratio PhD to academic staff (6%)• Ratio of publication to academic & research staff (6%)• Research income (6%)• Ratio undergrad stud to acad staff (4,5%)• Industry Income from applied research (2,5%)• Ratio of foreign acad. staff (2,5%)• Ratio of foreign students (2,5%)• Ratio of public with foreign researchers cooperation (2,5%)• Ration of PhD/Bach degree awarded (2,25%)• University budget to FTE academic staff (2,25%)

QS WORLD UNIVERSITY RANKING

• Academic reputation (40%)• Employer reputation (10%)• Faculty/student ratio (20%)• Citations per faculty (20%)• International faculty ratio (5%) • International student ratio (5%)

RESULTS 2012 ARWU (SHANGHAI)

TOP 500USA 150 GB 38GER 37 China 28FR 28 Spain 11Fin 5Pol 2RF 2Cz 1

Barriers for Universities

Unives couldn’t influence onto criteria with high weight)

Alumni - Nobel Prize winners (NPW)NPW awarded have been worked for the UnivSurveys of experts

Quality evaluation – high standarts! Nature&Science – low possibility to publish

paper of applied science, engineering“Club member” do not decree their activity

Structure of the Russian national ranking

4 Международная деятельность

•Оценка академической мобильности студентов, преподавателей, учёных.

•Оценка международности образовательных программ.

•Оценка влияния на международные рынки образования, исследований.

•Оценка объема привлеченных средств от международной деятельности.

•Показатели сотрудничества с зарубежными вузами и исследовательскими организациями в научно-исследовательской деятельности .

Thank you for attention