1
Component Amount Function Tau (383) 16 μM Protein Antibody 5-150 nM Experimental Variable Thioflavin T 5 μM Fluorescence EDTA 10 mM Chelation of trace metals NaCl 100 mM Maintenance of ionic strength Hepes, pH 7.5 10 mM pH Buffer Heparin Sulfate 5 μM Facilitate Aggregation Human microtubule associated protein Tau (MAPT) is an important factor in the pathophysiology of Alzheimer’s Disease. Dissociation of MAPT from neuronal microtubules culminates in the formation of intracellular filamentous inclusions known as neurofibrillary tangles, a common feature in a class of neurodegenerative diseases collectively known as Tauopathies. The fluorescence of the fibril-binding benziothiazole dye thioflavin T was used to measure Tau aggregation in a 96-well plate in an Infinite M200 Pro microplate reader. Varying nanomolar concentrations of antibody were mixed with an aggregation master mix . The samples were loaded in triplicates of 100 μl. Fluorescence intensity was measured every 4 minutes with continuous shaking at 280 rpm using 444 nm excitation and 485 nm emission filters. Methods Background Data was fitted using Sigma Plot statistical software. Sigmoidal curves were estimated with four parameters obtained from raw, in-vitro Tau aggregation data as variables in the 4 parameter sigmoid curve formula: Aggregation Master Mix Data Fitting Results Elongation Rate Constant Time (Hours) Nucleation Rate Constant Concentration of Antibody (nM) Concentration of Antibody (nM) Fluorescence Kinetics of Tau Aggregation in the Presence of Antibody 396 Among three experimental antibodies A10, 181 and 396, only antibody 396 produced a dramatic increase in the nucleation rate constant, corresponding to a shortened lag phase across all concentrations of antibody. While addition of 396 significantly altered the nucleation rate constant, increases in concentration of the antibody showed no discernible influence. Among three experimental antibodies A10, 181 and 396, only antibody 396 produced a dramatic increase in the elongation rate constant, corresponding to an increase in the rate of fibril formation across all concentrations of antibody. While addition of the 396 antibody significantly altered the elongation rate constant, increases in concentration of the antibody showed no discernible influence. Antibody Mediated Therapy Elements of active and passive immunization have been the subject of experimentation against Tau aggregation, with varying degrees of success . Passive immunization with engineered antibodies directed at peptide sequences on dissociated Tau has been shown to be efficacious in mitigating the onset of neurocognitive deficits associated with tauopathies and mitigating the cell to cell transmission of protein aggregates, also known as interneuronal seeding. The most eminent challenge to antibody therapy is the existence of a physiological blood-brain barrier which safeguards against the passage of macromolecules from the bloodstream into the extracellular fluid of the brain by tightly regulating vascular permeability. Engineering blood-brain barrier permeable antibodies and direct intrathecal injectons have enhance the likelihood of antibody penetration, nevertheless, cerebrospinal fluid concentration. Objectives The mechanism of antibody-mediated Tau therapy remains elusive. In-vitro kinetic aggregation assays containing very low concentrations of antibodies may help facilitate the understanding of antibody-Tau interactions at physiological levels. We aim to examine the kinetic effect of three antibodies (A10, 181, and 396) on the formation of Tau fibrils. Antibody Binding Sites on Tau Kinetic curves exhibiting antibody 396-mediated Tau aggregation reflect decrease in the lag phase, corresponding to an increase in the nucleation rate constant. The addition of antibody also produced an increase in the elongation rate constant, resulting in a hastened rate of fibril formation per unit of time. Dissociated Tau monomers are thermodynamically unstable and form oligomeric complexes with other Tau monomers to lower their free energy. These complexes recruit nearby oligomers in a process known as nucleation. When a critical threshold of nucleation is reached, the oligomers begin to actively form fibrils in a process known as elongation. The final outcome of this process is the formation of neurofibrillary tangles. Nucleation Dimer Protofibrils Mature Fibrils Monomer Oligomer Four Parameter Sigmoid Curve Time (Hours) Fluorescence Xo Yo a The kinetics of tau fibril formation can be illustrated through a four parameter sigmoid curve, whereby four variables contribute to the understanding of common attributes found in tau aggregation. In this case Yo represents the thioflavin T fluorescence (as a measure of aggregation) values at time = 0, Xo reflects the time at which fluorescence (as a measure of aggregation) is at half of its peak value a. The lag phase (Xo-2b) describes the period of time prior to the onset of fibrillation when nucleation occurs. The reciprocal of the lag phase (1/[Xo-2b]) denotes the nucleation rate constant, or the rate at which nucleation occurs per unit of time. The elongation constant (1/b) describes the rate at which fibril formation occurs during active aggregation. Electron Microscopy Samples treated with antibody 396 retained some oligomeric character compared to their untreated counterparts. Fibril formations in treated groups were visibly less dense and more diffuse compared to control groups. Conclusions We observed that addition of the antibody 396 to the microtubule associated protein Tau in the process of its aggregation resulted in an increase in the rate of lag phase nucleation paralleled by an increase in the rate of active elongation/fibrillation. Although aggregation rates had undergone a sizable increase, electron microscopy revealed retention of oligomers and a reduction in the density of end product fibrils. Perhaps these states represent a less toxic form of Tau inclusions that form in the presence of the antibody. Control Control Control 35 nM, Ab 396 65 nM, Ab 396 110 nM, Ab 396 Targeting Alzheimer’s Disease: Insights on Immunotherapy Against Tauopathies in Neurodegenerative Disorders Konstantin M. Ravvin a* , Leonid Breydo a, b , Vladimir N. Uversky a, b a Department of Molecular Medicine and b Byrd Alzheimer's Research Institute, Morsani College of Medicine, University of South Florida, Tampa, FL Elongation/Fibrillation

Insights on Immunotherapy Against Tauopathies in Neurodegenerative Disorders

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

USF Health Research Day 2015

Citation preview

  • Component Amount Function

    Tau (383) 16 M Protein

    Antibody 5-150 nM Experimental Variable

    Thioflavin T 5 M Fluorescence

    EDTA 10 mM Chelation of trace metals

    NaCl 100 mM Maintenance of ionic strength

    Hepes, pH 7.5 10 mM pH Buffer

    Heparin Sulfate 5 M Facilitate Aggregation

    Human microtubule associated protein Tau (MAPT) is an

    important factor in the pathophysiology of Alzheimers Disease.

    Dissociation of MAPT from neuronal microtubules culminates in

    the formation of intracellular filamentous inclusions known as

    neurofibrillary tangles, a common feature in a class of

    neurodegenerative diseases collectively known as Tauopathies.

    The fluorescence of the fibril-binding benziothiazole dyethioflavin T was used to measure Tau aggregation in a 96-wellplate in an Infinite M200 Pro microplate reader. Varyingnanomolar concentrations of antibody were mixed with anaggregation master mix . The samples were loaded in triplicatesof 100 l. Fluorescence intensity was measured every 4minutes with continuous shaking at 280 rpm using 444 nmexcitation and 485 nm emission filters.

    MethodsBackground

    Data was fitted using Sigma Plot statistical software. Sigmoidal

    curves were estimated with four parameters obtained from raw,

    in-vitro Tau aggregation data as variables in the 4 parameter

    sigmoid curve formula:

    Aggregation Master Mix

    Data Fitting

    Results

    Elongation Rate Constant

    Time (Hours)

    Nucleation Rate Constant

    Concentration of Antibody (nM)

    Concentration of Antibody (nM)

    Flu

    ore

    sce

    nc

    e

    Kinetics of Tau Aggregation in the Presence of Antibody 396

    Among three experimental antibodies A10, 181 and 396, only antibody396 produced a dramatic increase in the nucleation rate constant,corresponding to a shortened lag phase across all concentrations ofantibody. While addition of 396 significantly altered the nucleation rateconstant, increases in concentration of the antibody showed nodiscernible influence.

    Among three experimental antibodies A10, 181 and 396, onlyantibody 396 produced a dramatic increase in the elongationrate constant, corresponding to an increase in the rate of fibrilformation across all concentrations of antibody. While additionof the 396 antibody significantly altered the elongation rateconstant, increases in concentration of the antibody showed nodiscernible influence.

    Antibody Mediated Therapy

    Elements of active and passive immunization have been the

    subject of experimentation against Tau aggregation, with varying

    degrees of success . Passive immunization with engineered

    antibodies directed at peptide sequences on dissociated Tau has

    been shown to be efficacious in mitigating the onset of

    neurocognitive deficits associated with tauopathies and

    mitigating the cell to cell transmission of protein aggregates, also

    known as interneuronal seeding.

    The most eminent challenge to antibody therapy is the existence

    of a physiological blood-brain barrier which safeguards against

    the passage of macromolecules from the bloodstream into the

    extracellular fluid of the brain by tightly regulating vascular

    permeability. Engineering blood-brain barrier permeable

    antibodies and direct intrathecal injectons have enhance the

    likelihood of antibody penetration, nevertheless, cerebrospinal

    fluid concentration.

    Objectives

    The mechanism of antibody-mediated Tau therapy remains

    elusive. In-vitro kinetic aggregation assays containing very low

    concentrations of antibodies may help facilitate the

    understanding of antibody-Tau interactions at physiological

    levels. We aim to examine the kinetic effect of three antibodies

    (A10, 181, and 396) on the formation of Tau fibrils.

    Antibody Binding Sites on Tau

    Kinetic curves exhibiting antibody 396-mediated Tau aggregationreflect decrease in the lag phase, corresponding to an increasein the nucleation rate constant.

    The addition of antibody also produced an increase in theelongation rate constant, resulting in a hastened rate of fibrilformation per unit of time.

    Dissociated Tau monomers are thermodynamically unstable and

    form oligomeric complexes with other Tau monomers to lower

    their free energy. These complexes recruit nearby oligomers in a

    process known as nucleation.

    When a critical threshold of nucleation is reached, the oligomers

    begin to actively form fibrils in a process known as elongation.

    The final outcome of this process is the formation of

    neurofibrillary tangles.

    Nucleation

    Dimer

    Protofibrils

    Mature Fibrils

    Monomer

    Oligomer

    Four Parameter Sigmoid Curve

    Time (Hours)

    Flu

    ore

    sce

    nc

    e

    Xo

    Yo

    a

    The kinetics of tau fibril formation can be illustrated through a

    four parameter sigmoid curve, whereby four variables contribute

    to the understanding of common attributes found in tau

    aggregation. In this case Yo represents the thioflavin T

    fluorescence (as a measure of aggregation) values at time = 0,

    Xo reflects the time at which fluorescence (as a measure of

    aggregation) is at half of its peak value a.

    The lag phase (Xo-2b) describes the period of time prior to the

    onset of fibrillation when nucleation occurs. The reciprocal of the

    lag phase (1/[Xo-2b]) denotes the nucleation rate constant, or

    the rate at which nucleation occurs per unit of time.

    The elongation constant (1/b) describes the rate at which fibril

    formation occurs during active aggregation.

    Electron Microscopy

    Samples treated with antibody 396 retained some oligomeric

    character compared to their untreated counterparts. Fibril

    formations in treated groups were visibly less dense and more

    diffuse compared to control groups.

    Conclusions

    We observed that addition of the antibody 396 to the microtubule

    associated protein Tau in the process of its aggregation resulted

    in an increase in the rate of lag phase nucleation paralleled by

    an increase in the rate of active elongation/fibrillation.

    Although aggregation rates had undergone a sizable increase,

    electron microscopy revealed retention of oligomers and a

    reduction in the density of end product fibrils. Perhaps these

    states represent a less toxic form of Tau inclusions that form in

    the presence of the antibody.

    Control Control Control

    35 nM,

    Ab 39665 nM,

    Ab 396

    110 nM,

    Ab 396

    Targeting Alzheimers Disease: Insights on Immunotherapy

    Against Tauopathies in Neurodegenerative Disorders Konstantin M. Ravvina*, Leonid Breydoa, b, Vladimir N. Uverskya, b

    a Department of Molecular Medicine and bByrd Alzheimer's Research Institute, Morsani College of Medicine, University of South Florida, Tampa, FL

    Elongation/Fibrillation