Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
INDONESIAN JOURNAL FOR ISlAMIC STUDIES Volume 4, Number 4, 1997
ISSN 0215-0492
!SLAM AND MEDICAL SCIENCE: EVIDENCE FROM MALAYSIAN AND INDONESIAN FATAWA
M. B. Hooker
ISLAMIC LEGAL LITERATURE
AND SUBSTANTIVE LAW IN INDONESIA Nur Ahmad Fadhil Lubis
AN EMPIRICAL ASSESSMENT
OF DIVORCE LAW REFORM IN INDONESIA Mark Cammack
INDONESIANS IN SAUDI ARABIA:
WORSHIP AND WORK Laurence Husson
STUD lA ISLAMIKJ\ lndonesran Joumal for Islamic Studies
Volume 4, Number 4, 1997
EDITORIAL BOARD Hamn Nasuliou Mastubu M Quraisb ~brbab A Aziz Dab/an M. Strlria Jijfelldi Vabilah Lubir M. l'tt~l(/11 I usuf Komartuldin Hidaytrl M Dm !!J:ram~uddill Muslim .Vaslllion \fl'flhib Mu'lbi
EDITOR-IN-CIIIEF Az)'ltmardi tb'ra
EDITORS \'ai[rrf ,l1ujalll flrmdro Pras~t) o .ftJban H. Alc!lllrmtm Didltr ~)'afrruldin .'\II Mrmbanif
ASSISTANTS TO THE EDITOR: Arief Subbau 01111111 l-atburrabma11 Nrml NttrOIIf
ENC.LISH LANGUAGF. ADVISOR. Donald Pourr
AI!ABIC l.ANGCAGE ADVISOR N111'$WIIU(/
COVER DESIGNER S. Prinka
~TUUIA ISLAMlKA (ISSN 0215-!H92) is a journal published quarterly by the /nstitut Agama Islam Ni!geri (WN. lhe St:lle Instirute lor lsl:umc SIUdies) Syarif Hida)'lltULIJh,Jakarta (STT DEPPEN No. Jl9i5K/Dl1JEN/PPG/STT/1976) and sponsored by the Deparm1cnt of Reli!lious Affairs of the Republic ollndone~ia . It speclahzes in Indonesian Islamk studies, and is imcndcd ro communicare onginJI researches and current issues on the subjccr !his )ournO!l warmly welcomes contribuuons from scholars of rdatcd discrplines. All articles publrshcd do not neccssanly represent the views of tht: journal. or other institutions to
wh1ch it1s arf1hared Thcrare solclv the: views of the authors. The aruclcsconts~ned in this journal have hct:n refcn:cd by the Board of Editors.
Emzi Netri
AI-T afk!r al-Islam! 'an Ta}:lr1r al-Mar'ah bi Indun!siya
Abstrac: 7he generally weak positton of women in M~JSiim soaety h.ts given lm-cb to ..l mO'Uement and thought among Indonesian Muslims concernmg women's emancipation. Prominent figures have criticizedMtJS!im understandzng of women's position inherited from generation to generation for inferior and subordinate posttion of women m society. According to these figures, !slam is God's mercy for all and, as such, Islam cannot possibly treat men as special whtle regarding women as having a lower stattfS. Although critical of how Islam rmdmtood women's staltfS, d1eir conceptualization and artiotlation of the problem has differed accm·ding to the historical period and comext m question
Women's inferior place irl Muslim society, for example, can be seen in the "kitab kuning-" (or yellow books-Islamic classical texts thac bave become yellow becatJSe of age) 17Je kitab kuning, widely used by muiitional kiyai and 'ulama' (religiolfS scholars/leaders} of the pesantren (Islamic boarding schoolj, haveasu/ftciently clear albeit not absolute point ofview which regard~ women's status as below that of men. An illuscration of this viewpoint is the text Uqud ai-Lujayn f) Bayan f:iuqug al-Jawzayn, by Nawawf al-Bantant, a zext widely read m the pesamren ofjava. In many matters, this text stresses a wife's duty to her btiSband rather than the other war round. The men are positioned as the sub;ect of the text, women as the ob;ect. According to the text, one of the main duttes of women is to serve their husbands in bed RejiJSal of sex wi tb her hus· band represents a woman's great sin. Nawaw£, basing his opmion on the Qur'an and (ladfth, greatly stressed an attitude of a woman's total obedience and enslavement to her husband.
Indonesian responses to an opinion such as that held by Nawawf can be divided mto three phases. The first phase occurred between the end of the 19th amtu?y and tbe beginning of the twentieth. 7he second phase was in the 1960s and 1970s and the third phaseafier the 1980s.
The first phase of Indonesian Muslim disc01me represents that of pioneer thinkers. Attention during this perzod was directed to the improvement ofttr· gent and basic problems that women confronted including m areas of education,freedom from traditional discrimination, and imprO'Uement nfindivid~ial
177 Swdiahlmmkn, \fu/ 1(, Nn. 4, /?17
liS f.m• Sttr:
and socUil stttcus in rruzrriage-especially regarding the issue of polygamy. Although .Mus! im aspirations foy em;1napation were not as strong as those held by secu!a1· women's groups, figttres such as Rohant1 Kudu.s a11d Rahmab elYuni{.St)yab quue clearly demaruled tmprm)emen t of apport unities fm-women. Beginning with "iqra" or the command to read the Qur'Jn, Rohana Ktdus expwined that reading fmd writing was not the specUil right of men, but also a b,wc right that women should recezve. From a youthful age, she was .-tlrearly aaive struggling/or u•omens education. In addzt10n, she diSatssed po!ttzul rights for women ~tsing women's achievements internationally as a model on which lo base her ideas. She was strongly owosed to the practice by tbe Dutch in. tbe Indies of keeping "second wives" and improper treatment ofwomen workers on Deli plantations.
17Je second phase of Mztslim discourse concerned the theme of women and development. 'J7Jis pe1iod was marked by lndoneszan women's efforts to gain what is called "partnel'Ship in development."' One figure representative of this second phase of struggle was Zakiah Darajat. 7Akiah re;ected the opinion that women cannot mvolve themselves m national development and wider socUil acti~1itzes, or that they should be rest?7.Cted from tbe same rights and duties of men to demand knowledge. Rough!)' during this period, !ndonesian intellectu· als began to use the tenn feminism and gender in established scholarship.
17Je third phase possessed its own specific cbamcte1·, as there was greate1· ar· tzad,tllOn of eman.cipatzon by exponents ofMttslim thought. They intensi~1ely sought tn hold Mwslzm dialogue in relation to women's soaal reality. They criticized religious mrerpretaciom responsible for gender injustice. Promznent figHres during this period were Wardah Hafidz, BudJTY Munawar· Rachman and Mamour hqih. They were convinced chat certain religiozts understand· ings 1-epresenced soczal constructions. WardaJJ Hafuiz,for instance, has argued that verses oftbe Qr,w'an or /:Jadd.th that give the impression oflowmng women's stattLS mttsl 'zot be scm solely in normative tetrrl5 bztt shot-tUI also be viewed fivm bistmical/culturallsociallpolitical context. For WarckJJ and like-minded thinkers, there existed an urgent need for reinwpretation of religwus values, coinciding with the need for economic, political, and legal or stmctural transformation that would permit women to become tbe subject of social behavim· and discourse. According to 'XIardah, there was a need to socialize more just religwus understandmgs that cook mto account the tmerests of women's groups.
These three histoncal phases u·ere interrelated, as each phase spawned the next. Mltslim thought regarding emancipation began with a conviction that all tbat i~ at for.tlt concerning male/female relations must be corrected. Yet, in each historical fle'iod there has never been an unsurpassed imerpretation of male female social and tndividual relations.
Emzi Net~-i
Al-Tafk!r al-Islam! 'an Tabr!r al-Mar'ah bi Indun!siya
Abstraksi: Posrsz perempuan yang umumnya lemab dalam masya?·akat telah mendorong !ahtmya pemikzran dan gerakan emanstpasz perempuan da·ri kalangan Muslim Indonesia. Para tokob utamanya menggugat pemahaman Islam tentangperempuan yang diwariskan dari satu generasi ke generasi karena dinilai be?·tanggungjawab atas irzferio?·itas dan pomi subordinatifperempuan di ten.gah·tengab rnasya1·akat. Menurut keyakinan mereka, Islam adalah rahmat bagz semua. Karena iw, Islam tidak mungkin mengisumewakan laki-lakr dan merendahkan pe1·empuan. Semua tokoh ini kritis terhadap pemahamarz Islam dalam lmbungannya derzgan posist pe?·empt~an, sekalipun artikulasi pemikirannya dalam menanggapi penoalan tersebttt berbeda·heda sesuai dengan perbedaan zaman dan konteksnya.
Pe1nahaman Islam yang memberi tempat rendah pad,t perempuan misalnya dapat dtlihat dalam 'kitabkuning': "Kitabkuning"yang meluas dipakai kiyaz dan ulama tradislOnal dengan basis pesantren, memandang bahwa kedudttkan perempuan berada di bawab faki-laki. Penggambt1rarz demikian dapat dilLhat misalnya cU!fam kitab 'Uqud al-Lujayn fl Bayan f-:iuquq al-Jawzayn, karya Nawawt al-Bantani, yang merupakan salah satu kitab yttng banyak dibaca di pesantren-pesanlren dz ]awa. Dalttm banyak hal, kitab t(?Ysebu t banyak menekankan kewajiban isteri atas suam i daripttda sebaliknya. Laki-laki dalam kitab ini diposisikan sebagai subyek, sedangkan perempuan sebagai obyek.
Respons aLas pemahaman semacam iw, di Indonesia, apabila dilibat dari temanya, Japat dibagi kepada tig,t gelombang. Gelombang pertama
179 Studu lsl~m.lt.1. Vol 4. Nu 4, /997
180 £nu f'iet•·•
ter;adt ,1khrr abad ke-19 d4n awal abad 20. Gelombang kedua ialah ksmm 1960-an dan 1970-an dan gelombang ketiga adalah periode pasca tahun 1980-an.
Diskursus Islam gelombang pertama mempakan plktran-prkiran pelopor d,m penggagas. Pada pe1·iode ini perhatian tertuju pada perbaikan persoa/an mendesak dan meruiasar bagi pe·rempuan meliputi pendidtkan, pembebasan dan disk1iminasi tradm dan perbaikan status indwidual dar1 sostal dalam perkawinan seperti kasus poligami. Wal,u~pun aspirasinya tidaksekuat da1't perempuan golongan sekuler, tokoh gerakan gelombang iniseperti Rohana Kudus dan Rahmah el-Yunusiyyah dengan sangat jelas menzmwt perbaikan kesempatan bagi perempuan. Rohana Ku.dtts bertolak dari '~qra" atau perimah membaca dalam af-Qur)an, menegaskan bahwa tulis-baca bt~kanlab bak isttmewa pihak lakz-fakt, akan Letapi juga hak mendasar yang han-ts diterima perempuan.
Diskunus Islam gelombang kedt~a ber-kisar tema perempuan dan pembangunan. Penode ini ditandar oleb waha perempuan Indonesia untuk memperoleh apa yang disebut "micra dalam pembangtman ".Salah seorang tokoh yang dapat disebsa ia!ab Zaktah Daradjat. Tokoh ini menolak anggapan sementara orang yang berpandangan babwa perempuan tidak dapat berkiprah dalam pembangunan nasional atau dalam lapangan so,~ial febib luas. Juga terhadap pandnngan yang membatasi perempuan dan· hak dan kewajiban11ya unwk bersama laki· laki memmtut ilmu. Yang peming dicatat, lebzb kurang pada pe1·iode inilah iklim intefektual Indonesia mulai menggunakan istilah feminisme dan gen.de1· sebagai istilah teknis keilmuan.
Celom bang ketiga memtliki kekhasan karena pada masa ini eksponen pemikiran Islam tentang emansipasi lebih artikufatif. Mereka dengan incens berusaha mendialogkan Islam vis-a-vis realitas sonaf perempuan dan segala sematu yang terkaz t dengannya. Mereka menggugat penafiiranpent:tfiimn keagamaan yang telah bertanggung jawab alas ketidakadi lan gender. Tokoh terkemuka perzode ini di antaranya ialah Wardah HafidzJ Budhy Munt:twar Racbman dan Mansour Faqtb. Mereka umumnya meyakini, pemahaman keagamaan tertentu pada dasa.rnya merupakan kontntksi sosial. Bagi tokoh·tokob gelombang keciga, reimerpretasi nilainilai agama sangat mendesak dilaku.ka.n, namtm pa.da saat yang sama juga hart<S dilakukan transformasi struktur ekonomi) politik dan hukum yang mem ungkinkan perempuan sehagai subyek.
Q i~l _r-~ ti-JL...; ~ _:,i (:\deney) ~.:li JJL..,. ...L..lJ
J~l _r:-1} .J.:! L.. ~_?11..} j:....:i J}i. l : ... ::A,.,.y ..::.;~ )l ~;...L:4
.:r-: ~._.. or-JI ~ J-:....:; ~L:l'; ~.:r-~' J~, J.l'}J _r:.s. C'"'81
\;..;~t.....:.ll ..l......: L.. ~ ..:.; _; 4.!.l\.:ll • J : lj . ... ...:,...L..-.\1 • ...:,...\.:....:.....J\ - • J...> J f"'v -· .J-
~ iii_r-JI ~ ~J...~,;4 .._f)L':J\ ~\ ~)L.. ~J
1-i..A JJL>..: ~.:lT ~ J)'l .:r- w)\k;IJ ~~")\!ll ._:...\.>.-r-11 ..:it j )l>.
oi_r-JI r..~ JJ->' S'")L...':JI .r---<.81 e'; p. ,;._,...ajl ~ Ji ~~
Jy .r---<.i:\1 _:,i ~ ~ J , ~)L...':JI .r<..il1 (:j.).:: _; oiJL-.liJ
-~ ~ ')'--:>-- t::i-)81 :r ._:...~ ~ ..u oiJL-.l'J ;;i~' f..~
- t~ .rJI dJJ .rlSJI c.S ~~ (J,JIJ _;:-_,.II ~ _;J..:>- ..} ._}i~ l J..>:-
) y ~ ~ .h...:J, ~\ ...:,...I.J_r1;JI j--" ~ ~ -.:lb J\S'.)
.j~l
..) ;; jUI ,;.\..> ':J I ~ 'Y} :?." ) 1 ~ ~I l...i.A ~ ...:i ~
~~~ J-" ~li:. _.) y:> J ~o i;L-.l~ Lf:i')~ J oi_,..JI y- ;,_;I;JI ~I
Studw ftl.tnlllt•. VoL ~. No . ./, 1997
182 Enz• Netn
-~..}~_;;~;
(Masdar F. t..S.::> .Y'---" . .....; .J...L...a..< ~ G)! \A... t..S-l>-1 ~
..!.1J.; ,;i_,.-JI ~~..WI~~\)\ ~<JI (::' .f t..S...V y Mas'udt)
t~l t...>...U ~ ~) C:"'\) ~ 4---IJ.>..:;......I Rl ~\~I
G.....pl_, 4l.J ~ ..:..,jt) ~l:.JI ~1)1 ~...\.Jl>L.... ._} .:r-:~1 ~4-iiJIJ
~ t..S :> .Y'---" .J..l..aA.I ~ ~ ~ J \.>..)I .:r jii o i __,.JI ~ lS:.. .J i _}
Lt5:... t..S ~ a_;\)t ~~ 0i ~ ~l_,.ll 0'1 .U')\.kl ~ (.,Sf)\ ~IJ~
r._r:-1 ~ Jt>.-)l.:y c!) V.lj j.! ,~ Jt.>.)l d.;W ~_,L...... oi.rJI
c.~ illl opi ~ i~-' t...> .:>~ J..L,a.. '-:?iJ ~ ~ ..}J
~ J...\....:L.o (.,SiJ J~ <lii r '(Martin Van Bruinessen) ~)f. 0\.;.:} .J\....
~ ~ ~ 0i .:.; .J~ .....;L.,;:,i u..r r-!..li:l ;..~ _,~ ..} J·! ,~ c:~
o~ 0 _p..,_ )I ..J.i oi_,.JI .:r ~I_?\~~ wu _,.. Jy- c..S.::> ~ .J..t..,a..
.:.rs- 4---1~ )I ~ _rj\ i~ '11 )~~ i _;; ~ ~~ rY ~ .JJ.ll
Lr-" ~..r- ~ t_':>\1.)1~ i _;.; L.....w:. l:..i~ u Jw ~ _, ~;;i__,.JI ..~....a ~
(:::'" J , I~L; _;S\JI wui.,_.JI .:r 1_,.;)' ~-<.:...., ld _,~ 41.)1 ~I
: ~) ...::..ol.l:i.>. ~ o~ o~l} .:} J\... ~i ...W -:_J.b
J-.5:; a..;1)1 ~..<J1 0~ ~r.J ~ (.5.:> .Y'---" )..L..a.,. ~ ~ d ; )I_,\
1 ...... :all u~ ~ ~ ~ A...,. _;L. ~ 415' u-) a_;~~
l.r" J 'i L..JI <$ i ~I J ;y\.A!ll ...::..> Wh.:.JI J ~ -.::-A.Ji ..:r-JJI 0WI J
Studia lslamika, VoL 4, No. 4, 1997
AI-T~fkir ~l-It/Ami 183
~WI .:_r-1 ~ J t_.yl; J ~ ~ ~1)1 '-:---<11 ~:.A:~ 0\i ~
~~~ ._:..uli'Ji lr-!J U IJ 01_;.11 r-:ltN t$i ~L...'J \ ~')l..'J I
~.-..,; _;Si JL; .u ~1}1 ol::>JI t_} ~ _rjl i~ '11 # oi : 1.:-i~
~~1)1 ~I t_} .::_; )_,- L..... ~ J.T" _?"iy
La l..r.--5 o f_rl~ _ra:. ~~ c.S _;>- \JI ~l_,lliJ ~'J1 0i .:J JV. l5 _r.. ; L:lt.;
-~? ~ r '.rl'J' ~ ~
0i ...;.:- L. ...)~i J JV. .:;i J...l:: ~~ ~L.i;.JI o.i_.,. y _)ijl ....; ..r.:z.:J
.:._~ :t..;l) l ~~ ~ o)L:....ll ., l}.~l oi .J-'l'J c.>~~ J..L,a.... a., Jt;
ljl.S" 4:-J y 0'J ~ j ~ ~\.>.-.J ~ J u...a..:.,. ~ ..::,..;t) ; i_rll
,r.->- ~I ) 1 ~ ":A.::.-~ ~ _,J J .!..l.b ~ d.G \JI .:.r J ~ 'JL:.,. .J
.J~ ~~~ ...)~01~ .)WI c.SJj ~~ ~i c.>.ill yL:S:'JI ~
..u.L-..11 ~ 4-JJIJ,j ~~~~I c.>-L>I ~ t$.ill ~.)_)! J_yA.>
C'""l:JI J ~I ~t ~t; t:-.J\;; e-_r.. c.>.ill yL:S:'JI \.i_.,. J ,o J~ 41)1
-'~ CJ..rJI ..::..s'--:>--1) ~ ~L:-o ~) ~ lS~ c.S~~\ ~
,~ ~ ;;i~l 'O"':}.._p ~ 'CJ..rJI ~ ~ J) ..:..s~ IJJ , 4;,-J )l
.~\JI} ~\JI Jl }iJI :....?J
1 (Budhy Munawar Rachman) 0~ .J ..J.f-" c.SJ y. ~ f' W ~ J
c! f. .:;~ \J I .:.r .ftS' ~ ,;;i_rJI y j.>.-_? ~WI .. I} yl:>JI ~
;;irJI ;~ ,:r ¥ ~ c.> .ill ..:...i _,ll .j ~LUll .J ~J j>--)I .J~ .:./'
. ~.,....WI 4J ~J
Scuditt lslarntktl, Vul. 4, No. 4. 1997
~ ..._..;., .r ~- ~l> ~ <L..o~l ?J ...I....U .:JJL.. L..fJ
4-J-l>- r J 'ji ~WI ~ ~))I .,;.J~ \J ~i ~ "Yv Js- - ... , .. A:SJI
..l.AJ. ~l 4>-Jj y:.) ~ JJI ..jU) .Ji .y ~ '~_r-ll _;, 4->--;)
. }~' :.r ~...~WI ...s ~ LS
......, r .rA: ~ ~i ~ ~~ ~ ._,...\5 _;, ~ r ) )i .Jl
y i:>\5JI ~ ~~ c_;)l ~ ~ ;) ..::...~1; )s- _?-" _rll .:r .uJ y
~:w.. J)l ~ c;..rll ..;...L:>-IJ .:r- ? i ~~'JJ .:.;--:>. ) )1 ..; .ri>
OJJ~ _JL)I t.Sr., ~~~ ~l>; .Ji~l: V"'~\ ) 1 ~L.:.:.....')I~J
, ~~ ~~I ~~1 .U ~~l:-ii l; ~\,; ~_,.A> Lp.-;) ~ J)l t__,..a.>
~ <LiJI ~ j_,...,) J_,i ~ ~~ ..:...:~G- i ~ .)} .,:.tb Js- j.:J..clJ __,
:- L_ • r----
_,:.!• ..:, ':i ;L-..l• .} .h..i.i ~ t""l oi _..j1 <...~ ?" ._}1 .......;1_,...!1 0; .:j .. JI J
y:..<ji _?I __..::Sj1 Jl..,:s.l .} ~j ._r...:; W)of_..jl ~ Y,.. ~ ~lks-! l.,p~ ~~
)~I (..J. _,.... .:.j )L... ....l:i>-'J L... ~ ~.I t.:....L. IJ~J o ~ ..-:.,... ~ j" ,...!
.:r..J• J~ ..:...~;:; ._.i....::) .J\-J ·~ ~ ;" _,..-J• 4J f ._,:!• .__.-<.!
._.] ;1 ....r' J JJ ..~....<~ • ;-'-;! W ..:.U~ ~ j L:.. ~ (Pemkunan J amalllfldin)
~~ -.~\...i.JI r-lWI ( y _..j• .J! J-.J1 jL...>.. ._;.WI <...'MI r-lW• ~\.; .:./' ..;L>..A.,.:.
.~\i 4--' ~: ..:..-.. ~1\; J ~· s _.,.) ''...;_,.4 _.;. .) . .........-..
..J-:!JJI JL..>.- J~ yl:5JI ~\.; ~r I~W _y...; ...l>.- J!. 'Y .d ~J
,;i.r-1 .W~ 'Yl ~ ~~ J.J _rjl r-'1 ~Li>-l.Ji .:JJ~ J:' _?I .J..i9
oG..U'YI \~ ~ J) tj>.- )\ .....AJ\.1;; .:r ~l:JI 0i XWI -.si) (:' ~
..Ja-< !.1~ ;i_r-U ......;w.;'j \ i~ .y ...;trJI •. ·s:Jt ~....~ .b.. ".>WI iW1
Srudw lslamika. Vol. 4, Nn 4, 1997
iil·T4Hral·lslami 185
1.L..:. ~ - J .)L... ~ ...~..>- _?- ~i_rll 1)-...a.::il ;5'\ J~ ~ ~~
'-!\.:5" y) (HukumJima') t_1...>.1.-G.. '-!L:) Jl oJW.)I I .:_r~ ~..L.:J I
~4-UJI...L>-1 '-r"~UI~,\~ j..o~i ~ .y ~y.)l.JI ~~ J~ ~}
.:> J~ ~-~-u~ dWI ~ J.:.- -s..i.JI ~I C L=.;)ll ;; )~ .:_,;, J...-JI
._;-.-.-1~1 ~ J~'YI L.!.~ JLS .J~ ~ -L....>-1 ~~ rJ
.:y J Jj)l ~~ Jt;.,.f .y 0 J? 'JI ~~I 4::}1 Jt..,;:,i _)I ~lyJIJ 1
• Ul....:JI W.. ·1 - - -~ '-!l5 .j ~ ~I .J? '-!l:S" \.pJ~ _)I ..:..~ ~ _,.jl ~J
.Sr. ~..iS" Jljl.J J ~ J)l ..:..w')~ ~ i')L<JI J1 t_ bJI t"'~
t.. l...>.JI ~ yt5 0i ..:-~· \;(11 .f.! J _,..JIJ ,;;i_,JI .y t.;G ~) j.>. )I
.!..LJ~ ~) '~ J)l ,.:..~\)'! )I (.J) ._:.,~ \) vP ~ _?i ~ .)l)
,:,iJ 4....>.-J ..:r->i ~ ~ Jj ~~ j.>. )1 \~ oJJ~ .J; _}\~)I I
)_;.::.....,)II .y J..Jj _r.S"i ~~ ..} ) y.. .:>i J J~ .JiJ ~1_?1 ~
. 4-i~) ~ Jj ..:.>~~~ ..:1.1£ ~)
,_;J~l 4Jo&l\ o~ ~ oiJL....JIJ ;;i~l .r.r J _r>- \')l..S:JI ~ I~ J
v (Baromh Baried) --4.r. c ).r. .Jli ~ Jii J~ J) ~ I ~ _,.JI .y o _,:..ill
J ~I _r>IJI ~ _;L:JI ~ } IJ ~L.JI ~ _rJI J1 )dl ~ <0~
;y')L.. )I I ~--4WI ~ _rJI ).bl.} j:!~l 0 _;ll Y'J'J r- c:---81
~ ~...UI ~--4~1 U _rJI 0~ )Uu o).r. ~) ,~JL.:.!I o~..}
• L........; ..liL w.......JI ;;i (I • •. - )UI \..b I -- -) . ~ .r y (J>" )~
St<~dtfl tslamtka, V~l 4, lvo. •. !997
186 EnuNtm
or--JI ~~~ ~ ol;l-JI; oirJI .r._.rV JJ> I..S'"y._ "Y I ~I .Jl
<o~ ) .S::.;iJ o~IJ ~'Y;~ ~~ ~ .)l,:r~ J}il ~_,....11 .:.r
~ oiJl---JIJ of_rJI ..;-:.~ ~WI ../'}I J~ ~~~ .} ~ jj_,. J
~I _y:. ~ ~\ 0\5' bl d....::>l>- ~L.:.U _r.~l; .r._r--:11 i ~ ~ ;...b
~.r"''Y I o~l ~ JL>.-)4 ~"}...;.; ,;L...:J\ ~\5:.... ~ _; J>.-i if A-~~"YI;
:,5 .r- ;; _,=-.ill o~ ~ .r-<.i:\1 .Jt5" 01 ~ 'Y ~~J .r-<..:6' _r;
~.); ,oi.,-.lJ ~L...~IJ ~JJ~\ ~L.a.i\1 (.~~ > JJ~ I ~~'YI
l JL-.:-)II .:.r" j)U:...... "YI J ~I U _,..81 .y J_r--:11) , ~ _rll ~
4......,.::.\.:.JI y~'YI; ~~_,All J;_;-hll ~ J.J--> ~~I.SJI if j.Ji;
\ -~') - .,:.,\.:.,.;)I ~..w- ~ ~ ~~ ~....Js. __,- c'J)4
~i J-~WI J-j o.J".> W ~ d ~i ~)\... J.J.>...j 1.5jJIJ
0LS .,:., \jJ~ ~ JJ.j~ oi_,..jl .r.~ 0i ' . (H. Zainal Abidin Ahmad)
;;~1 v-i Js- ;;~ 4.>:J..l; ;y. ~J '--!_,ill_; ~ t.;L..i _?i 0~
~JJ.j')l \ ~I ol.:>-~ _} :}y "Yl ~)I ~.)J ,~~'YI
4 i..lij a..l:i>)\... !l~ .!JJ.) ~; ~.~-~'..; olrJI Jt..~ ~t,; .r"'~
")' t_~ _,.JI \~ J.>-> (Howard M. Fiederspiel) ~ J-Y ·i ~ } y
J_j _,.jl .)~ cU j I I?' r." _,4 .:f' ~\.A; ~ ).,Y _}" ~j ' 4-Ub.; J.-.: ~ ~ y ~ ~ f ...U 0LS" ~I .) oirJI JY y- ify._ ')I I
~ L,..lk; 0 J~f.. .:r.jJI 1 "~L...WI l.r--' ~~~I ..L. ui..P ~ _,..JI
...,_;l..f"' u- 1ft) 0 J.r. J-_u, ..:r-:--":J.- 'YI ~J c;i_rlJ 'Jr p i c';)l
~ .wi ~ J-Y .....;wi; 't.rJI ~ )..~..> ~.>..W ..l,j ~WI ~ _rJI
St11d1a /slamilta, Vol. 4, Nt1. 4, 1991
AI· Tajklr ,;/.Jstami l87
.bL.. Ji if r+·.h·. 01.5' ~I .} ;;I_,..JI JJ..ll _:r.-4..;-JI 0i if ~)I
'.JY ;;i_,.JI 1 .. P _y 0i d 0 ~ J.. ~~ if 1..t _; !J~ 0i ~! ~~~
0 ~) ~ u--:l J~~J J-b:._. ~ ~lb c,)\S' J!J IJJ.r. _?i
..:r .• 1 • h .J-:! ....;)l.:>. 'J ._;)L>.. .. ~ ~ ~ 0lS ~ , o...~.> 1 J
\ r .. ,· ·~
~ ~ -!JJ~ d l_,k JY .:r...U\ ..:.;~\ JLS:;i ~ f ~J
-JL..::.iJ '(l<.artini) ~.JIS'J '(Rohana Kudus) U"J.i lil>J.J ~ JI.!:.JI
' (Rasuna Said) ..!..:-- Li J-"I.JJ ' (Nya1 Ahmad Dahla.n) 0')L>.) ~i
(Ahmad.:.;--=- ..L...>iJ '(Rahmah EI-Yunusiyah) ~~~ d.-> J)
. (Munawar Cholil) J:l> .JY J 'Hassan)
1 \ A A f. r.--P r · u-' u..U J ~I U"..l.i l;G. J.J .J~\ ~J
oi_,.JI .f..~ o~I.J (Bukittinggi) ~ ~ y. '(Geda.ng) ~~~ ~~
~ J ~I~ lS..UI 01~~ <l!Ls:J ~I.._;. c} ,..:.;l.J...-JI if
&J~ J ~L-JI Gl>.....JI .)\JJ ~..LV ~ (famar Djaya) ~~ J"'G
L-.,j ;; .r'" J }1 u .J..L.p u-=ll (Sunting Melayu) y.. '}..,. ~ r ~
~L..a..QJ~ ~~)14 ~~I ~I~ Jl c..ilS J i \ ~ \ r _,:l y..
J_,s:_... Lil> JJJ (Amai Setia) ~ <,?L..T L .JJ..o 0i LS" ,~L..JI
oirJI ~; J:.:.- d l;G. )J if l-4--.-! c)'j..;...; t;;\S' (Rohana School)
~i ~I r ul........ ~I o~ ..:....ii.S'J '~.JJ.i if C!)J ~J..yiJ
.~1 .._;. ;;f_,.JI d' ~ .JLS:;i _r.j .;:_; _,jl ~ c.) ~ JJ 4J b\J:;...\
u-=ll ~T_;JI •. ::A~\11 J} if ~ .J~i c.)~ 01 I~ 0\.S' ..lA.l J
~J ,~l.s:JI ~ ~IJ t_J\.b'J'I ;;JJ.? ~ o,;.I.}JI ~~ ~
Smdia /sl.msikto, Vc.L 4, No. 4, 1997
188 £nZJ .Vctn
~t..:SJ I.) o.:. 1_,.-411 o i .r-JI ~ LP>.:> yp:- _} 4J b .r" ..;:...; IS" ~I ..:.> 4 ':J I
~ ;;f_rlJ .__;_;.. J-~ ~ jL...>. )J ljl;::..ol W - LP> )ii .} - ~I
;f~l JUi ~ _,.:! ~ --4 ~ ~ J 4 _r.;-1 ...l.U .!JJ.l!J ,;1_,_11
ui~ ...Lt ~ _r:.s. ~~ _rJI ,y ty ~ L.~ ._i> J •.:.r _r-y ~ ,y J
o~ ..j._.-<:; ~ J ,~\.::5:.!1J o;l_rill ~ 4-:-..} uWI ~b. J.>
4-;l_,.iJI 6.....l..,.:. y_j ..:Jijt ..... 4J i \..::l>.- __,..L:J w_;., j Li; ~I -~I
<.5?~1 \ .... , .. W IJ ~l:S:JIJ o;. l~l ~- (:\gus SnJun) rlL- v-~~
,oi_.,J'---1 L..,.,.WI ~1.:-JI 4~1 ~l ~.i.S""" ~ r1 ~ ;i~~
..:....jlS J ~ y..')L. & .)"'-" ~ .} ~\ 4-i~\..i.. ..} .!Jj~ ...r-~:
o _,...k>..! ..::........~ ..G L>-JJ 4-i _r.&'l u=JI .;~1 c)> ~WI ..:;\5" _rJI
4 i ? "OJ~ ,~}.S:.;~ w,.;,_,_; ~ ...Li ~J...Wl..} w fi"'l ___,; j L>.-) I ~ LS .i..JI iilil .)::-! a..; J I..U.I~ ')\!... o i _rJI ~ L. I~
.:_,-- ;;i~l ~ L... ..:.r.::J ~\J .:_r--~ )...w~ ol:>JI -.?"If~
~\ .:>~~\ .>-"' L>-)J ,~,)\;.A ..;:._j\S" ~\ l_:wa\1 ,y)
..)--::! ..L:J .,.U ~) .r-ll) ..:.> l>.-.) )I o _r~ ,;. __,.;..; _) ~ 0 .lJI o i _r-JI _};:
:r (Deli) .__s-4.:> ,_) ..:;~; )_rjl ..:;')\...WI .J ...::......;:, ~ L. J u~l_,.jl ,y
~ ~ ~..L:J ~\ ~ _r...jl ~ l..i.t. ~ rl.J ~ ~~ _d:- ~~
.~i ~.)~~~ ~~~ ~
J~ ~...~' ~L..JI ~_r-:}1 u .r .:>IJ.> ,y L> _r:-~~ ;;~ 1)1 L.iJ
DQor jJL...,) u _r->:V ~L:. (K.'lrtini) ._r.; JlS ~ 4-Jl o }-;,~ I
Dn.ri 01~ (:\.m.lr Pane) J~ .r---i ~) ~\ DuiJ"Iem£r lot LiciJr
Stud~ !slamt.L, 1/(1/ 4, f\'o. 4, /997
AI·T..flcira/.fslami 189
.}~.J~ ~ j ~ ({)~\ .y ,;_,:.ll tfo) Gelap Terbidah Terang
\':>\WI .:.r Dari Gelap MenUJU Cahaya 01~ (Haryati Sudibyo) .)'::!,;) r
~ ~ ...:...ilS' l ~t w J.» ~\..ill J...\>.JI .y ~ ) 1 J.;-) ~ J_,:JI Jl
.)'J.J u..t> l ~~ :yt5:J1 J~ ~ ':/ i i ~')L..':/ 1 o}i:JI .:.r ~~~ ~,;t5:..ti
J~ ~l_,:jl ._? ~\,; ,;~':/1 I~J ~~J~~ ~WI _r-_r:\1 ~ ~
J )~I ~ ~ w ~ J - (Milnsur Suryanegara) 1
\ l>..;4,;.J-"
:_,i JJL_:..U 45' ~ d ...:...ilS"" ~)IS' 0( .:.r - J~ ~ ~i J J? ~I
':/! ~1.,W1 d ~~ ~ ~ 0b 1 "{>G ':/ I ..; ;1JLJ1 i ~ .:.r- '"'~
~ L:...a..i J IS' ,s;. .J IS' J~ ___; fi 0 .ill (' )L.,., ';/ I J i )! t:"" f.. ~I :_, i
~ j\y->. i..u." ~l(.S .:. i L-,.. 4~~ ~ ~ ~Jj _;S"i .)\.))I
(E. C. J _,..1-41 .J- t?l ~~ ;;JL...... J) ..::Ju LS "Wl .Ji_riJI ~~
4 o )l._:,. .) i _rill ~; .:r~ ~ J ((' \ ~ • '\' ~I \ o 4 :\bendanon)
a....:.,. _;)I J ')1..:.:. :r 0 T _;)I ~~...; ,P J _rdl .:r ._;.;,;IS" , -.,;,.<...; L..~ J
._s...L>-1 l,-" ~ u _r.$- w-- ~)L.,., ';/ \ ~LA:ll .:r ~ ~ ,)i ~\.k::..... l
.w..-i w JL:l I., •• : .. ..i .. ! •. :S"\; "\.:....a.. i " I\.; A II ..__li\1 0 L" I . I•L.,., . - ~r-- .. '+"")
.o) r iJ Ji}JI f lY"'
~~ ~..UI ~ ~ ; i.,.-JI ~ ~,;IS' if J ~ ~ J
4-L I/ j')L.:. .y J u~ ';/I ;.WI J I y i ..u.L.::.; L....\.:.&. 4-i ~ i
J _,..) Ju ~~~J J ,_i..J..:.: iJ (Stella) )\.;:..- JL..;:..I :_r ~.}JI oirJI l:'
':/l U.--4 ~ ~L:$" & ~ ~ t)\..b)\j 4-:>- .)\.)) ' (Ny. Van Kol)
, JL:-<.11 ~.r<j_j1 ;.I) t:" ~L:;.;:; ~I 4-=J.> .J ~ ~ 4J J L:.;
~ __?I ~_rJI l:' u l::.;_;jl ~ L:.l~ 4-> ")\....., 1/ j)\> .y ~w..:; W'"
St~dk! 1;/nmika, Vfll. 4, No.4. 1991
190 Enz.r N•m
~ c_J~ ~I j ) .... JI .y .)~ ~ ~i >'OJ~ ,~_;JI d 4-:
; w.; J ')\J h..h>-J J L.>:.;i d ~l...::o ~ '~ ~ t;;. tS lll _ra-J I JS'~
Jl \}.=:' 4Jr J~ c!.) 0ll1 Y' l.k 0\S"' ~) J ,~I_,.JI 0 ~
-~J..I.j'Y\ ~)\ ~\ 45'? .)\)) -...;~ d ~_)IS'~)
LJ ~L:.... , L... ..t..> u-->1 ..::...;LS ~l.a.i J ~_)IS" J~i ~ J
'~~~ ~ ~ .:>LS" ~_) ~ J_;jiJ ,._,.,...G 1.:..> )_)G.!...:...-.\.;
_rJ ~ §" ._:..WJ J' )-wl ~W-.i!J ~I ~ 1.:..> JJ -.:....;1.5"' ~
- ~J\S' ._::..~ ;;i_,JI f..~J ;;IJLJI c__,...;,~ j..::,; ~) ~}.S::.;~\
~ J ~4 - U.J_rW J oi_r..ll i..>~ ~LZJ'YI o~ y- }iJI _; ~
L+J J~ ~ ._:Lb ~J ,~lkJI (....~ .y ~ .Ji ~i_rlj ._,.,L. ~I
;;i_rS uWI<S_,:-- u-->1 ~ ~ t.>lll ~..-JI)Il-5_,:-...ll y- Jjl.:U
. ...,.,UI ( lr .y 4:.)~
~_r-\1 ~J ~ t....a:i lJ.jl__r.l J~ _)I ~?~I ~IJ
L•.u4 ~ JLS" oL.t.) (....~ Uo.)':>\:..- .JIS' ~~ (Rahmah el-Yunusiyyah)
~ U Jr" -.:....;U J '\ \ '\ .. ~.) '1' • _} -L::~~J L;-:_); ..:.JI.f-
~G....i~ ~b~ o~ ~..J1 -4-JI L....... r 4 ~ J->- 'Y ..::..._;)
._.,...:II ~I o~ J 1
"'' (Perguruan Diniyah Putri Padang Panjang)
L..:>Wl U"JJ..Ul ~ J1 (Rasuna Said) ~ l;J"'""'\J ~ j C:: ~~
..U\J ' (Syekh Abdul Malik .1\mrullah) .u.ll / i ~I ~ ~\ ~
~~ a.....J..WI ~ o~ _}I U"JJ.ill ~t;) i..W '(Hamka) ~
~ ~ J ~~ J~T ._::.. 1 ~ d..)\.:.JI t. i_,...ll oJy.P f.JU ,u, y-i \..bl=..;i
Ji ~ ,~ Ul~ ~~ I~ ~ ~ .r.yAJ ~ J ~ )81
~tud"' !Jiszmrle#, Vol 4, No 4, }9')7
AI-Tafkir"/.1'/ami 191
J WI ~ Js- ..::.s-l.b.:...l ...w ~ Ll> ~ ~ ~ f ~ '-'; .. b.:> Ll> _;l.S:.;i
.....:; r l t.>..i.JI oi_,-JI ~IJ o..u.L;. ~_; a..~ J o ~ JLS:.;~ _;\.; Ji
.r.r G .f-A-.~ o}~l ~ ~ _)I Ll> _;LS:;i .y J ~~Wlw ?"-"
'-~ a..; )IS- l..l>IJ _)I ;;i_,.JI <.5 ~ "I.A.; J 'jl d ;; p1 ~ _) y. ;;i__,.JI
. L*- '-'-j')\JI <.5 _,::.-JI Jl j.p.JI
'-'~ 4ii J...i.....:-: ~;;i_,-JI t_ ~} ~ ~ _; .h1,:,:..; ~ :fJ J
4l J~ L.S' Ll>_;y 0~_;;_, ~~ ~ 0i ~ ;;i_,.JI 0i ;;.r~ .:.r
~~ ?~ d.....>.Jj ~~ ~ ~J Ji 1.5~ '::-~ 'i)L..,)il
oi__,.JI 4--! ~ u=JI ~WI ~}I .Ji ~ ..:...;L$' J. o~)l ) 1 ~ r--L...Uiy !..\L.:.,:. .Ji lS; t./ J '~,)1 t./ u-:~~ ~ J.y ~\y. i _;; .Ji
uJ~S- <>i_,.JI ..::......-bLo ~l c.:..J\.i ~ "·~-~~_,i ~-' ;;i_rll ~ Lr-?
j\...>....JI ~ Ji ~ ~jj) IV,~ J 4-'-~} 0k3 ~I ~
J-.-> .:>~ ~~~ Y ~\j; d .ri .r-' ,JG,. )I .r W' ~ t.?<J ;;i_,.....u
.,;~_,.... J>--)1_, ;;i_r-JI Lr-? ~~
~I iLkJ~ ~ j ~ J ~ ~ ;;i_,.JI ~ ~ ·~ J
~L.... ~ )I ci__,J~ 4...pWI ~L.a.ill y \~ !..1\.:.Jb 0~ ~I
if\_;,:. ~ ~L;..;l ~~I ...0J~ J>.i .:r J 'iUaJI I~~ i)\5JI _,1
(.S..i.JI )._p-JI ~ ~I ;. L.:;.:.'j (.j _,_iJI 4>-.r-1 ~) \A'...:;~
~) ~ \ '\ Y A J-{.r.l \ \ o_;~L..a.ll (Femina) ~ ~ .G~ J)\
u;L> ...:-..Jf" :4J Ju ~ ~_JI \.fo~':J JJJ1 CJ?.j ?,'~ 1 ~
~ J.)WI ~ ..6L:-JI .....:, _r)l ~ J .:./' .!.L.;:,_;~ 0\ ;WI .:r
~J ~l_,i 0i ....UI ;;._ =: ~~ ~~ dl": ~ c.:..J\..0 ~~JWI oh
Studitt l>bumk.•, Vol. 4, No.4, 1997
192 Em<Ntm
L..~ ~ ~ J-+>. ~ J-4 ~ .,t.:-.:; ...:-;LS" L. 4J ~ ..,Lj)
r J ,~l...-i4 ~bl...: ~~ ..:..>l:..:li ~..\JI ~I ~ 0i ~\.LI
~..:.>WI~ -0~ 0i ~J ~ ..:.;~\) W"'- ....;~ ~
~J ~J ~fo u4--'i ~ ~~"YI ~I .:_,-- U'L..r
. JlA;-' ol.i~ .til o.>~ j1 _,!I (J.Z J ~I ~\,;) ol.>...j 4 r-..54 ,· !;. ';. ~\ JL5:;~\ 0~ ~ ~1_,..:..-- 1 ~ L... J-J J
..y '~J\;1 L>-_,.JI Jyk ~ oi_,.JI .:1-rJ o\JL.....ll Jy-v~l
d.......:>\.> ~I o~ ,:r jt.>.. )I .....»yo ~ I~~ ~ 0i :> y 4.:>t.)l 0i
.oi_rJI .:1-rJ oi1L..JI J~ ¥ 1JJI Jl5:'.;~1 ..:..>~ I L.~
jr.i ((\AAV ~ JJJ) Jl-..> ...L..>-i JLS" Lil..l:i>)l. :>)~ dJ
:-.:..>L/~ 1 i~ ,:r ~I .J..U ,~\..:....JI J~ ~ ~ L5...L..a,; ,:r
~ J_,_.. )I~ oi_rJI 4,j~ .f..:.;~ J_,jl oJr' ,:r i \ --r t
u..L.II J->. )I \,0. JlS (Fidecspicl) ~ J~ ~ J 'r-L J ~ill\
~J .• .a.!l ~) (Moenawar Cholil) j-J.>- J.rJ C::" _,h;L:.i ot..,;l J~
"Y o,_j~ C~ ,~1 ~ oi_rJI JJ:> J.r-- (Hasbt :\ sh-Shidd1eqy)
..L.>i 0i o~ ~ ~~ ~ "YJ ,;~1 .; ~w'J Jt.>..)l .b)l:>. l j~
~')L..I ~u.~ ~ ,oi.il::. .:r ~~ yi? ~ ~ .:r J.ii d..>. J:> ,} ~~
..t-.>i 0i J~J , l ·lJ. J,.t; .:.r" ~ _,u ...::..,._; _,11 ~ ..; 6J J~,;...,... 1 ;fr-D
~ ~ r-t.;l ~ t>.r- L. ~ :>..wa.\1 I~~ ~iJ cf-::. 0l5' 0~
"l'l ~ .:r cr 0i ;ir-D jy:c.!. 'i ~ r-L J ~ wl J.-.o J_,..... )I
5tudra /s/a,uk.r, Vol. 4, No 4, /9?7
AI-Tajl.,.rai·Mimi 193
-.b~} ,r\ ~) s-b~J ~J_,_JI Jt ~.i; 0\s' ~t..>~ o.J;_,..al
LS.UI LS_,:.ill ~.J~ ,_}J ~JL>.)I C: :J_f.:: 0i ~ ~-' .:..l:->-IJ
([Mas)'umi]if _,...:;.L.) .,:r.A I ..II .S.JY.. ~ ;.WJI ~ o.J~i
~ jl~ 0 r=JI ~ y J~ ~i J.,~ 'i' ~o·, r}y.. ._}
·i ~ J Y -'~' c)> Jl ;;i_,.JI
..,J:ijl ~J ~ ~ .Gf ~;, ~ oJ~ 0~ ~i L>.r..J
.Ji jl.r""' i~ Jl 4.tL..<o)l4 .~Lo.>.JI o)l..:. i y 0i oirlJ j~ )I ~...U1
o.)~ ~? Jf; ,;.WI J~ 0f 4J jy--: )I w · ,;; i_,..JI ,y ~~ J~
Jr-~ Ji ~ -oi~1_, J-.>:-)1 .f.:!~~ .} ..jJb:-1 !l~ ;,l , ~~ ~
..:.Uil J ~ ~ e:--L.ill ~u ~; .}.-_,u w ~ 4-J~ oirlJ
<L)! ..L:;.......,\ t>iJI vL... ~I y l..i.P. jJ J ~ U. .JY oi_rll J ~ J j>--fo
~?J ~ :io..L . li if.r-.Jt ~ ~~ ~ 0~ ...L....>-i
oi_,...ll ~ d..:>- l.r"' ~ i-y._ )II 0~Pmmpual1 Lrlam dt Dcnun dan Podium
~ 4_:~ ~ Ji ;;i_,-JI ~ Jl:>-~ JL:l4; ,~4J J L>. )4
JL.:.:-)4 ~ ~ 0~ .t...>-i ol_r- ~.)" rJ- )\.!:.. ~u.J ~
.~ u_y<...JI ~)I J~ _w
cWI ~\ rJt> ill..i) ojlr.! .J~ LSill <.S__,>-~1 ~IJ
oi_rJI ~ .)\~ ot..J ....A-J y J)l>. :/ (( \ 1\ A\-\ 1\ • A) jJ.> .J.f-"
;; i~l L>.-.J~ .J~\ Jl ~ j ~i.J _} .Ji ,y ~)I _}.....; '(Nilai lf-'amta)
J->-)I ~ U')WIJ o i _r-li j->:-)I ;; )i; y l.:S:JI ~ ' j>--)I .y Ji I
o~ ~ ,~ J.Ji .sill rJI Jl W4 t.....l.ii _;)i A ;;i_,.JIJ
"~\ .Ji ._A.l _;.jl ~ .i; 'i \ 1\ o \ L Jlr .u.!i Gill yl.:S:JI 1-4)
5rurlr.t l!l.tmik~. Vol. 41 No. 4. /997
194 EnzrNI!ln
0'1 ~8 .J:' A Ji ~ JlS' J ,~, d ;;i_rll ~~ 0~ Y' <~.;...
. o J _rll ;~T ..:J.:,...;I L..~ L..~ ~l>- (._,..P _rJI _} J..WI
~\Qohan Meuleman) ~y Juy ol_ri LS.iJI ~ ¥..>
._s--:;)':1\J ~_r':J\ ~\ ~ ~ _r ._} ~ L).iJI .._,..\.::SJI I~ 0~
a:......J\J -:>T~I ~ oi_rJI JY J ol_,l-..JI ~ ~L.... __,.; ~
__,.; ;;i_rll ~\5:... J~ .dJ~ ..}J ~o~ ~J L>))l ~I ~J
~ ~ {_rJI a.....;l5:_. .:_r>- I~ ~...l>J4 ~\..:) J.:.l>- J _,:...-~ (;}.._':}I
. ...,_.;~\ ~_, 04.))'\
~ ;;i_,..JI Jl JJ rJI ~ ~ J'JIJ
¥ ~~ .__~ J.:.l>- .;y \..y~ JlS' _}I ~l.i..JI .:>i J~
~ u~l JL>. )I ~ ~WI Jb.:,.; ~ ,~ ..:Jij L.. ;;i~l
'~)a J~ ~ JU4_, '~~ ~L.a.> J J.WI ~~.; ~ .y
ok ,JL,..j':J\ .y tf ~ ;y ~ ~ ;;i~u ~~ ...0.h ..j .JJ J
, n JL>. )1 y- y J j 0..l.-.>JI o j~ ~J ,~ ~ _,L. J ,~)
.. ;->=-~ _, JG,. )J L>. Jj c:r-JLJI ...,.. J ~ ;;i~l .:>! :>'Ju ~..>
0 J...l..! ~ ':} j->.-)I o~ J~ ill.lJ J ,.JJ\ .)\) 0.lJI iljdl ~
~ oi.rJIJ j->-)1 0i J-.=.6:- )~ 0i; ~ .y) 'Tr ._,.s:.J4) ;;i_r)l
~~_,._ JJJ ~L-....>.- o~ ~J ,~'11 01-..~J _,>'il w..L>i
~\ __,; ;;\_,_..JI JY .y L.i_, .t;~l ~I ¥ I~ J ,;; ~
;;i~IJ j>-)llfl J} ':} ~i ,J:i..a.:.dl .y ~ C: ,J.).> JY 0i; ..LQ.;
~J ,r~~l::-JIJ y~':Jiv'iL.....JI ~ v~I)IJ J_,.c.JI _}
e:JLAI ~.> ibL. J:,U,j t,?~ i.,..Z Ji ;;i__,.-JI ~ rc-> ~~ ~
Studia lrlamika, Vnl. 4, Nn 4, H97
AI-Tafleir nl-bl.imi 195
~) L:.JJ.? ~ .JY LAIJ- .1> J.? ~t.;..,. -!.1!~ (:: J ,\..i:.-~I
.k;G..; .:>iJ ,~ _rll i~ ~I 4-bW d o \~1 ~ )li 4-:-- ~~\$- If
~J..L:>J\ li~\fJ ,~l_;y ~ Y,...l_rll l.r-J ,~L-JI ~ ._?
. ~ y.jl ~~IJ Jw1 i.J.s. J ,.k)b:. )IL; ~WI
~ii114~1 ~ ~ y. o_r-.J..>. ~~T 4i i..U ~I ._:...\k.')W\ 0f J~
~ ~4l!ll 6..>.-_,....ll .:/' o_?i)l oh..} ~\ .:f ~~ ~) )~)' \
J:u; o _r-All o~ ..} d ._5-!.~ i .b.') ~~ J \.... i J J-..LII ._,.., l:S:J 4-o..Ai
Jy'' ~.:~T .,~i L.. ~ J_r=-JJ ~ b fl->. J.W .:>i ;;i_rll ~
~I r .:>1.5' ~.:~ T ~)I \.... 0i f>tk.ll .:/' J {,~"~I -.) ~.r=JI
Jl!.. 0t5' J o_?i)l o..L:. d ol_rll .r-r) 4\JI.......J\ .:f i')\.5JI ;.\.JJ i:..<LS:J\
.~i i~)l l
~ ~ ~.:~1 o_?'~ ~ _;>-i _,.-i ~~ -!.1!~ J1 d.;L..;:.)'~)
~L.,a; ~ i')\.5JI J1 J~ .:.>i ~ if')L)II ~\ .)\5" bLJ Jl_j-JI
o _,:-..cill ill;~ ;;i_r-JI_; j-->- )' .:.J--;:! u">\JIJ Ci\JL-JI) ;;fr-JI _r-~
ill~~ j_r;-S __,:)1 ~WI Cif>tk.ll ..::...;15" ~\.)\ I-4J ~ J ~vl..iJL;
~I..LII Y'-. ~I -!.1!~ jJ J ~;WI s..l! ...5 J)\ ../_,II ;.~ ../' _r:aJI
~l \')L)II )i:: ~ 0.?- t of~~ Jl y \J .JtS:;i JP ~~~
~ ~ ~ ~ ;;i_r-JI 0i ~1}1 ~ d ~ 01.5' LJ ,;;i_rll
Stud'" lslamikA, Vol. 4, No. 4, 1997
196 Enu .\'tm
~ r---'l: A- =:.JI <Llll ri ~~ ~\ ~ c_WIJ
~ .Jw 'jl .J~ ~I ~~\ ~I r (( \ ~A\- \ I\ • A) (Hamka)
J.jj , ~ l!.\1 d.->. _,.JI .:.r" ;; _,:..-JI o..i.J. ~ ~I ,y- ~..J..>...:; ~ J 41
.. .:.>\5'\_,L.... ~L: ~ ~ ~JY ...::.. ~ ~I "-.i~\.A.. ii.LL -.:..,.j\5"
iC-JI 4.;15:.,. .)1~ y\5 ._} ~ _r>.<--" ...::.> r ~ t(Panjt M:tsyarakclt}
L..\-i J .r(:, Ji ~ (K,dudukull Peremp11a11 DtJiam l.dum) (){....; Yl ~
.y VY-V\ ~i_,A11 ...::..4~ 1 (~ .y L;~L; ~oi.r-JI J~l} jl/'j
'i')L..'YI ~ ;;i_,-JI ;w\.S:.. J.r> ,;L;..;L;,.. ~~;.WI o.Jr
y\5:... ;;i_r-U ~ C7-r J ~~J J-.~ 1-y..,_ 'il .:>i ~~ ~..i.t
J .;--WI i)\__, 'YI ~ ~i ~l_r}IJ c_Y.:::. _,JI ~J ,~\)J ~ ) 1
.:Gi .:.r" ~~ ~.> L. j.J J ~JL>.-)l ~ W'" L.W ,._l-:l.l ...::..~ I)IJ
._:U:, .r .__,-<.JI ~ ~ ,:i__,-}1 .J ~U:.; J ~ ?- .:>i .:.ut j>--_)j v-)
0\...J 1J~\ ~ '~ -.L:.)} I' g a•! dL>.-)\ ~ yu Jl oi.r-JI ~
~ .:t_j i ......c-SIJ 0-'c(j '~ .r .!..LJ.) ~ ..L> i ~ ~ ..:.....:>- '1--4.1.>.
n."':!f) ~ _?i j~ ._?A
~U; J .!lb Ji .)l ~I ~LJI I~ ~~ ~.l.b .y ~i;
....; J.rJL: r~' ~ ,~, ~ ~ ~w'J JL>.-) 1 .:r-: o-_,:.-::..... ~} Ji ~~ ~ ..L.i J ,.!..LJ:, ~I L.. J Q\5" ) lJ , ~~ ,y- ~\J
Ji ~ ~r l/' ~ y ~ ;WI ~ L.:. j l.)i ~1}1 ;;l) )I
u'YuJI ~l ~ ~ .:>15' ~ JJJ ~~ ~~.> J t_ri ~ 0§.;
\'oi.rJtJ j>--)I .p:
~tudia !slamtka. Vol. 4. No. 4. 1997
AI-Tnfkirt~l-ls/Jml 197
;;ir-tJ (>~ ;J1 ..r::~ .:;--- ~)I ~ G i ~ 0\.S' ~i J~
~ J ~l> \.Jy y_:... ..1..>-IJ ?J 0~ 'J>.-)J \.AJ.,t; \... ~ ~~
j->--)1 yW ~ ~ o_,Ji; ~ c>?l ~I 0~ ~~J ,~
o__r"" 'YI ~ \...6-__;1 ;;~\ Lr" ~ ~I ~~ ..:.it ,;;i~l J~IJ
.:.r ~ ~ ~i.J ~ ~ ~ c>jjl ...,..~...,., ~ ~ .r l.iA 01S" J ~~~J
oJ_,.- .:;---it ·;, ... / ,JI ot..Jt 0JL;i LS ._L....;.)\ '-~ 0,vl_,j J~.>.-)10i
u .:r"J ~~L>.-Jj ~ I~ .:>i Jl.>.-)1 ~ ~ ,_0.LiJJ ,;U I
i.J...J- 0 f.. if ..:...:..WI ~I ..} ..~.>.-y. 0i ~ ~ J ~I ,y ~
Ji \~1 ~ .:.r- 0i LS' ,J.>.-)J ;;i~l ~~~ o.JJA Jy411 .SJ->-=
Ji J~ .J..l-aJI l.iA ._} J !of__,.jl o~y ob ...::~ ~ ~ j>. )I J-.'>~
w~ r \-;~ ,;;~1 ~ ~ ~ ...L:.Y ;;~~\ i~
•<' I ~ (\ . .C.J~
Jl.b)'l l.i....lt> ._} 4JI} ,Y ~.WI ~ ~I u~l .f J
ol)l-..JI ~ .:;--- 4-Uiy yJ JLS' ...1...0 ( 0\.:.:. .J~ ~j ;;h.S ..JI _,r
0.J y ~ ~IJ t./' LS ,~ i ~.;;; 0i ;;i__,.JI _p. ~ 1.5jjl .JJ..J\J
~) 4(lfltJtll dan Perana/1 [V'anita) i{rJI ..)).)) r'L,... Yl Jl~ 4l ...----1..: ..::,;~ ~\ c~ll ~~ a..Lill Lr" yl:SJI l.iA 01.5' t v~ _r-J
. ~ J..l.il ._} ;;i__,.JI J- ;;i_,.JI
l..i..J. ~ ~ ) 1 .J~\ J-~ c>.iJ\ l>'"'\....., ~~ t_~ _,...JIJ
~ 4-A>- JUI..:J ,~..JIJ ~IJ o_r:.YI ..} ;;i~l .JY r yl:SJI
..;.;~ ~ ~-J\ w~...... ~ ~ r c>jj\ ~~) ,J>.-)J ~ ~~
JJL>.:.; :Ji ~ )\,; ,~1 ~ ..} ~ .:.,~ ~ 4J ._.;,:. ~ u=l'
Swdta lrlnrmb. Vol. ~.No. 4, 19'17
~ ;:
"'i
f ;;:. ?
~ ;;<-.
~ ~
~ "
'l ~- ~ t :r I r t 't t ~:. ~ r ~[· .f' ~- t r f ~:. l.. r - G. ti. ~ ~ -· y- > ~ -· r ~ ~ ~ ~ < ~ r: ~ ~~ ~ -~ r J· \. ~ t .E. 1: ~ f. ) . \J - '--- E T. - E ! f c: ':l (· \ - ~ v ~ 0 V ~ -• - .1::- - ' '-.. -~ I ~ 11 ' 1!:::.:
\ .. Ot , ,__ ,... • • \. t ~ -
1c ~ " 1 -- T "'- ~ 1. ·. -t: \i. 1 ~ .. [ {. t -.L r F:" _ c l <> ~ r. -· u:. " ~ . . r ~ c ~. ~ \o· .c ~ -'-· ~~ ~b ~ r};.. ~ ~ r ~ \:" I f1 . t. [ ·~ f. :.k r c ~ '-.. .t- c · !:::.: ~ - [ ~1 <;\. ("r.· '£ 01 ..
:r~ . ); \- [ t·· (~ ~· ~ ·:, l- t· ·. - ~- t . {. \1 ~- ~ l ru_ 1
'-.. • ( '[ X \ .. c· \. rr .e <..· "'- •• ·t::. (" _ (..· 1.,. I I (; e.:_ ""\ • l - • 't__ c-: c;._
· •t' ._, ,t ,... '-' · ~ 'f -; o• '" .. · ~. ~ • ~-. .e• -
\. [ 1: ~ ~- ~ ~ \<. ~\ \; 't ( ~- r.-· ~ .~ ~. 1 ~ )· - ~ \ l ~ \o. ~ r. <;.. 0 . . f. [. 1}:- ~ ~' t ' l· ex- t. '--1 r t· ~ { ~·. t" ~ : . _.. f ~ v· '-.. -
€ C\ r r'>t ~ •· •(. ~. ~ • L 1 ' !:::. f • '-J. ~· -· l ' 1..1 ,c -\) L r.:. '- "\ .l? !l • . - \.._ ' L t' - • ~\ • -
{ ~ ~ ~:_ ( 't, : [. ~ E ~ ~' ~ t t;. l ~ t s. ~ ·• 1;. ~. 1.. "". ~ e:. t '-- r 'f.· ~ f ~ G: , ~ ~ -· ~ 1 ~ v.- ·r f ~. 0: ~ ~. .~[ ~ v_ C· F. f""· ·~· L~. ~ ~· '" S:::- ..
~ ~ 1.... (..· '-• C" r ~. ~ (,· ,. ~! ' ' - - · (;": ' . If ' ' ' -~ f. r· 1 C;:- 1~ ~ '-- '-- [ ·~ f. f - t ·t. ~- .t .. . !L cf. . 1..... L ~ b. - . .2. . ~ (.·. 5 ~ f:. - - · c- - "' ~ .c- '--- . - ~ - .c- "t - . '-t. . \....
:0 .. !!! i1 ~ ... :!
AI-T.jkiral-11/.imi 199
~ ~')\..., "YI Wt-..11 .:>t l.:Jj 1~1 ~l_rdl ~\.;.:..j 'i .!.1\~1
~ ..:..jl.S t..;J~L..!l l op ~~~I.:> ,;;i_rJI f..~) oiJL.-JI
L...) ~L...J\ u _rJJ ~ ')U\ .r"'~\ t::; .......;~ .) fo>. J )15:;4
Ji Ji~ l J.s- ,~ Ji ~~ ~ .5> ,t_p~ J ...,.-i .:.r ~
~ .> ~\ JtS' ~ .>...I.....JI I~ t_} J ~Jt...a;'} l .:.r -4~ 4-:J~ ~
.J-.A ~ \j;. ~ r" i !J u , '--' L..a.i '}I .:_r -4 ~ a;L....JI ~ _rJI Jl _,kjl
,} a;L....JI ;o-_rc.ll Ji rJ ,~ ..t?81J ~ -.~1-.lA.I ! fo ~\11
,~1)1 ~)I ~J.ra-: ..:..jJ$'- ~U:-.> ~ ~ JtS' LS- ~J..tj\
~u ..rJI Jl_,..:..-~ ~ ~ 'i J , ......; _;-k:ll ~ ~ ~ ~ J
~ ~ T ' .) )')y l5 )...!..! T ~~ )\..::, i W') ~ y ;JI d ij )a.:....~ I ~WI
~.) ~ .._A....b:..j ~ )..tj')l\ a;L....J\ <6' _rc.ll 4~ ~.) \.... Ji ,j\.:..J\
~ j..! , ~~ ..b.__.. J \II J _rjl u-') y __,iJI .} ~WI ._:.,1$' _rc.ll ~1
~ ;s--r ~)L\ ~ J.;- J~' e.? i~'il:? f..~ .h.... )
·')~)
4.:JWI ~~ ~ .:r-~ J..tj~ if ';Y.-)II ~I J_,_k; ~ .r'\.WI .:.r
~\...a.>. d..!JGI 'L>.-_,.JI .J-.A ;; _;-.ill o-4J J f , c;i __,.JI f....rU J ol JL.-JI
~ L... o_r-t ~ L:....PIJ ~ JLS L.. ~L> ,;;~1 ~1_;...-IJ
:../' t.Yli> J.s- ~ t_l} y i :.·1 'i \')\) I~ J t ...:.>Y:-iW.h
Swdia /$/am .Ita, Vol. J, M>. 4, 1997
200 £ PIZJ Nttrr
r._r; J ;;1JL-.J1 ~ y .f~ ':JI r-<:.i:lt .:>l.S" bl ~i 4J}
~10i t.>~ L.:;~ ,~ ~ ~I ... :Jt..il.JI .y ~ ,oi_,..jl
~:dl!ll ~ yJI .y ~ .,..JI oh,} d.L.l::... ~i ...ti
,;.\_,->. '; U J~ ~ _n-J:; :J ~ ~ o .r-JI o..G. 0i ~~ J
.:.;-- <Ll L. C: ~ Wl L?~ ';J I til _,ll J \ ')L ';J I .J::! <L>.- _,l 4->:-J ) _r-JI
o_rkj ~:J J~\ o_r.Q.ll oh.} t.>_r ...W ~ .YJ '"'-! 6..ili..:.JI J.Y'~\
~L..J\ w')~ J oi_rll r-~ J o\JL....JI ~ y w r J J..£ \')\....."YI
t. ~ .r-: u..a:.. ;; _;-.iJI o~ t_} ~ .r<.ill Wt........ll ..::-; lS" ~~
,~ 1.5jjl _ra...D ~~ ~ .J~ l <:S"i;; _,...,L-..11 .:.....15" b!J ~;;....r""t.-..11
;; ;;_;:J ~JJ y ~L: ~ ~ ~L>- ,~4 ~i WL-..11 .!.U:.I.:>~
.~1..} _;WI ~I~ 0~ .Ji ~ W
,;.\J ~ I ~ J ~L-.JI ~L.. ~...b..j ._i }iJI o:J~l J! ~ly..l.ll .Jl
c:Lkll ~ ...:...;LS ,d_J~ ~J a::~ o...L..Il o~ J5' ~ ~I ~...UI
oiJL-.Jt ~ ~~"YI WL-..11 y ...::...:--~>--.\\ .:r o_,:AJI o~..; iw' tr-~ ';JL..a.;l j.......a;; WI.A.JI ~ ..:;_;L) ~I.UL: 4J J ,;(_,..JI J-~ J
IJ~\ 0-:!..UI ..;::~1 .:J..:l Jl .)l ~ ')\; ~ .y J ,~~I J~~l:
(Amina W~dud) :J ):> J 4 1 Ju_.i .y ,,;.WI ~L..J ..;::.U\..>...... J pL.
.J-.oiJ t(t-.fernissi) ~ .r. J '(Muzhar ul-Haq Khan) .:>l> ~I fo)
L~l .) ~ t(Riffat Hasan) .:_r-->-~ JJ (Asghar Ali) ~
J\5:.; 'Jt ..::-;l.S" I~W ~ ~~ ,} :.J ~ ..U J 'JL-a.....ll 1h .} o _r....:..JI
iL:AJI :J~ y:-J ~ J...li4 u--')L "Y I _?:..ill ~ y ...) !.\ JL.;.; ~ JWI
Stud~a /slamw. VoL 4. No.4, /997
~ .,:r.~L-.11 ...s--~IJ ~\ i ~\ ~..u; ~i .y .) _,.p.JI J~
,~ 1./'LJ; JL>.-)I~~~ -JU 0-:!.ill JG ~~ L-S:J~ ,~1
Y'"J~\J ily J~ L...S' ~~ .Y'J ~~-/~I o~l ~ Jl~
~ L...S') ~,... JG,. _)j ~\ tll1 .:/' ~ JljL. (Dawarn Raharjo)
0i ..,r' ~\.; ..T'"" ~I .:r~ 4 .,_;i (Marwah Daud) n.) Jb :; )/' ~
~ t<.SJ~I ~J ~~1_,......., ..G-~ ,-L...J\) JL>.-)I.:_r ")\....)
·ili i\..,.........j~ \~ Ji ~ .,:r..ill ~~J V'~ ;J \ lS ~
L...iL::.:..,. ..:; \~1 ..:...;LS Jly-~~ o~ 0i J~J
.r-.ill ~} o J~ 0i ...L.:..r. 01.5'" L.).ill <.> y<..ill U'L.. ~ I l/' -~ p)
oi_;L...JIJ ;;i~1 _r..~ ~ J..r> )_pJIJ ..:;L:.iWI ~.-~ 0 )> 1 _p..
~ LS~I ob;:JI ~<.>.ill ~)I 1y-J1 ..,!' ..:..j\.5'") H::--~J~~
~ ~ jl_r.l 0i ~ .,:r..ill ~L........ ~ \ .y) ~~8\ 6.>.-_,.JI .y orJI o~
.y .JWI JWI JU:.i ~ ~(\Vardah Hadfidz) .h.;t.> o.) JJ .)...L.a.!\ I~
u ~ ~~.&--lll ~ ~...,.:. ..r- ;;~..UI _?i ..:...;IS" ;;1J\......J'J .r.~' ~i
r-~ ~ c_l.:.WI ~~~~WI ~ _rJI J~ '~J..li~ ~WI
~ -.:..s-\.k.::.....l _)1- o.) JJ ..:_jl)" ...l.i J ,;;\Jl-JI y i .y J W IJ ;;i_rJI
~L....J I ~ _r.ll 0i <.>j -~ J..lil Jl ~ ..:....Ai;. t)\; Ji ~~ jJ
~ J~ i _,_z Ji e:k· : ~ ,.)L.,a..J\ ~I 1y ~ 0i .:r~
jl.....aJI 0 ~~WI a) _rJ~ , n~ )~) ~\ d ~81 _t)\..i:}l
.)~'i uJ~ U.~ ~ ..:_jU ._?1- ol_;l-JIJ .r..r=JI ~i .y
y- ..:;IJL:=> ;JI .)~ 0i ~ _,.-JI 4J ~ ~ o~l ..._,.-. ~ J l-.4
S111d1rt IJI.umlta, Vol. 4, No. 4, 1997
202 £nz1Nrm
..::...;u <.5.?-r o}-~· .. u ,~~ yull ~~ ~ .:>i .:.l-:JJ .:>l}il
.)i ~ )l_; ~ .:/) ,;;i~l ~ 6..\lj ! .)~ .:/ 0.)~ ~i ~.JI.Aj
Jl J~ .r ~G .:.>lS 1 ~1 ~\/' JT_,ill iP .,.;..,.;..; 4J ) .»-..) J~
~ 0U I~W y <~...! i _,.....z ~ J Ji 0~ , 1£ 0 _f.; 0i oi_,.JI ~
'"~. "1£ 0 .f.; .)( ;f_,..Jl
~ ~ jiA ~ ~~ .,~ 4-:--..!.i ~~ o _r-..-JI o .r<..ill 01
.,;..L.:-!) r"\L..:.,.,. J ~~ ;f_,.JIJ J>-)0=! ;;1JLJ1 ;;_?-; ,J>--J ~~J
~ _,;:.'Y ~ ~ ~~ ~')Lp'il dS' _rJI ~ I~ )l:i .!..U~ ~ ~i
y...UI ~Li.JIJ 1.5..LiJI ~WI i.J....J:> .....;~ ~\) ,~.p ).J) _r._r-JI
~\ .J]-P if 0 )~ j) 6..\ljl ~..iS" .....;~) ,~L:.,. )I ~\ ..::,..\~
I~) ~ol.;.>JI ~ j...>--)I C'" <.5 )L.....:; 0f ;;f_,.JI ~ ~ jL>. Jj
L5jl ~~ . \_..., - JL:.,. I I ~I 0 C- --II - ')UI J ..: · - lw .) ,_,r . ~ - . J-""" f..~ ..5 Y' .) .r-- .
~ JL:l'-!.,; , w..,... l__,.....i - y...UI ~_,...d) ~~ .:. r y- d.....>.-81
~ ~ ~_r.JI ...:..:.)'--> \11.,; ~I ).II 04'11 if ~b. 0\S' I ~!J
~ ~ '~ ~.J~ o,;--k.i 4)1 fo ')\.;,.:.WI J..lt .y J.:U:ll
I.J"'i ~ 1/' }I 01- o.).JJ J~ w- <.5..J..:.Aj" ,l...a.!i ~1_;11 JL.~.b;l l
n. "JI_,ill J~\ ~ cY. ..k..U ~? 4 ~
~;;.) .JJ ..l..:$o ol _,L..JI L-~ ~ -4 p J
;;\~ w~l )S~\ ~...UI ~Li.JI &-'; ~ ~~ 01
\....:l.a.i 0~ U. )i.i ~ r-+" _,.-i _,;:. J ,.:.UI cJb ~ .J~I ~ ~ J
r-Li.JI t::--' _; J ')\..>. l.r" ..::...; U o...L.JI o~ J')l.:. 0 l:..; t.?l o i _rll
Studt4 11/amilta, VoL 4, Na. 4, /997
AI·7:.Jkirai·Mimi 203
r"> o.) .JJ ~ r.u.JI ..!J.J; .:_r J ~~..lll ~I ~~ ..} ~ d.!kWI
Ji1 ,~L..JI ~ j~'Y \ ~-~ uJ 1y~l \L.j ~L. j.>:-)1 -:>4 J_,Ajl
y ~L.....ill ~ J ,jL>. )I ~ ?..::- _y> ~! a..WI o~l ..} _;~I
r"~ ~ c~i ..5> J~.>.-)I c..>..ll ~; r-' tS..u1 .r lh J ~~ J li>.
, rvL:l>l..lll ~~ if;.~ .:_+iij ,JG,. )1 !.\')l.l if ~ r ;.LJI Jis')
.r"" j->.-)I o4-J ~\..lll ~G.JI ~ oi.rJI t:P J :t:P )I lh ji.S:;
j)l)! J,_..., .:y< o1~ ~ ..0, ... b J'l 'J..Y ~ o-:~1) 4=--PJ~ <.SjJI
.oi.rJI
l_;l.,Q.; ~ J o_;J? o.=~JJ <.>~ u-L:--JI ~I ~..,;!~
lh J ,jt......;)l\ J _,A> ~ J c..J:.I} r:!..lll ~L.. _;! ~ .:_r ;. y:S oi.rJI
u-'i ~,.-~) oiJL-.11 J~ \~1 J _,hi bl o.,j'1 , '-:-"'WI t:P )1 r
~I ~ i'j.S rl ,a]\~ pi~ ~ of.rJIJ j>:-)I t.ft <U")\JI
<.5 _,_..)!\ <.5 _,.:--.}1 ~ "',..... .)\)'11 t.ft all..u:. pi d;~ .)~1 J! ~ ..L.U ~ b! ~\) ..r"'!..lll ~\j 0---" l;!. )i.i ..} lh J ,~~)II ii
~ j.:~~ <U')I.P _y> .s..UI LS"'"L.. ~\J J J ~I l;!.~ c..J:.I) y--;..lll ~
·\\?"-)IIJ ..r.!...l..i:JIJ V'l......> 'll
~~)~ L;,;\1 .* ~~ o1W.~I J~ tS..iJI _r:-'11 r-')11 L.iJ
U _rll if lr.5' l;!. 1 \.S:;i ~ o.=~ J) .,:...;I.) \)!) '(Ratna Mcgawangi)
-4..b-..:J~J , rAU rJ-1 .:~l.a..JI }:.JI Jl WJ l;.;\1 .Ji _r-lWlt ,;yLJI
~L..JI U _r]l ~t ..Li:.ll .:_r \~ <L>. y.. t.>..UI ,)\...4.J\ ~\ [)J
u ).S:,;f J~ i~")U v"'_r:ll Jl ~ ~i L. lr.5' t.>..UI /~1 ,~..WI
Studra 1!/amilut. Vol. 4, No. if, 1997
;.~ ~)~ ~I..UI ~.iJI _} .. ...a..;i .:.;-- ~) ,~L..JI a) _rJI ..t.,;, ._;(;
..:-JI ~u JJ~ t.S~ y ...:.>~~ ~
t.>JJ\ y a,;L....:JI as'~;;~~~ Jt.S:;~~ ~ )G -:>IS'~) J
~L.._. ._?'dl) }' JJ1 .p J) ~ y-) _} ~LJI ..::--.:J a..i~ J~ ~
- 4 \J ~ _, ~Lo -L> _}~ t.S~ y:- J) .r w~ ,~ ~~~ ~\;,
..;.;I~L: (L::AJI ~~ t_? _}I ~L..JI a) _rJI jlp ,P. ~\ j _,~
~j ~L..JI U _rJJ ~~~\ ~ _,)1 ..:..,.jlS- [.}>J\ ,y ~J..W\
~ ~~1 ~~ ~~ ~LZJ'Y I_, ~J) ~_,.II ~l f5't .JL.i)ll
r• I • .JL<" ~ ~ ')L;.t; Li;_,k ~?I ~\ ...::;1~1 $ ~ ~ J ,J-a-31
~ -JL.i'YI t.5i _p ~~f-1~ l.:f" } I L-~ r ~~I J>-I..UI ~
~I~ j$" f-1~ ill.lS'_, ,~~I ~WI .PJ ~J ,~
.Ji Li\J 1.5 _r; J ,~.:> y. _,.jl j _,_,_.JI ;r ~)I tP 65" _,:.WI ~/' ... ~1
.J~ ~l t.S.:>i t.>.i.JI y .,J )~ ,Y L. y Jl ~WI 65" _rJI (?'
.)l_.j)ll ~~~i .p j\...a..4j)ll ,~ ,y-~ ~l:-!. 'YI ._} JWU,;I t_?
~I·· ·~· . -· ._r:.._~ r ~ .....
.u: a,;i -.? <G')~ J .J)l l )~ Jl 4...W:. ~ JL...i'il .)\ -.W~
o.....-A.i '-:--:! i.aJ ~l J l-.i )l I 4....>.c..11 ..L.U JL:.I ~ J , tfi I U. )' 1__,..) J , }' ~
Wt.uJ'-' ~~ ~ .Jl5 , .? JJI ,u-y, ~ L. ~'i t.:.>U-.a.:
~~ ~J ,~ o.A---JI ~\5:...~ y ~~J ~~'il-' o) .. .i.JI-'
~~ )11 ~)IS' ...:;u..... .:.r" ~'i' u'l' l ~ Lo ~~ .!..l.b .:r
• ...:;\...i..p ,y ~~ L. J ~_,...81-' ~~J -l> _r!IJ
~rud~or hlarnika, Vul 4, No, ~. 1997
AI·Tajkir a/.Jslti.mi lOS
..0.-t 0i u-"1?1 ~ ~Lt G l_) uwi LS ~~~ ~..0-J
:.; .r<; ...L>JI IL ~b ,)L...:.i JL...;I J.S s..U c ~ p 41) ..:.;l.i...dl
__,.; ~ ~ Ji.S ~~ 4-:?L..:.i \... 1.)1 ;;__. yl.. ~ ~) ,;;.;~ ~
_;s J ~~ ~(;J .. ~.?.J IJ ,;;~\J ~~ J~ t.JJ ;;J§" ill ..::..>lA...::>
<GL::. .:.;' ~ y j) ~l>.;IJ ~~\) ~~ J~ t.JJ ~ j":J\ -.:.;LA...::,
d.,:_,;..l.ll JY ~4 d-....:.)IJ c;\W4 .b~ J ':}\ y. J JL..;':J\ .J~ if ~ -:_,i
~ . . <v y.WI vl.i....a.l4 ...jl...,a.;":JIJ j.p.JI \)li; d t_; ) IJ
~l U.~ ~ .f Jl G IJ ~tk.:..,... \ ..h_U 1.5 _,:..--.)1 \.i..l. _} J
~ J ~\ ._A..jl_,.jl .)L;..:.;":J d..;4JI d .._;o ~ ~\ ~WI ~ _rJI
~ Ji J JG...; ~WI d.) _rJI 0i <..5,) J ,~1 ~ f~l vl.i....a.l ~}
0i ~ J ~ JG-....JI o..0. ~) ~JL>.-)\ '-).>:. 0 ~) ,:.L..l\ ~\
L. ..)! ..b.__i9 ,_p y ~.l.b if V"""'<.JI ~ j, ,~i L.lh; ;;t.y..ll ~
. J~)L. ~L. WI ...:- i . . . _)
Ji - (Murata) L;\JY <$i.J .;..U~ ~ ~L;- <.5; ~ \.:..2. if J
d.:.r.JI ~.:~1>- f..JIJ ~T_;jl t.f ya.JI ~._}vi~\~ <.>ill~~
? ~ ":Ji , ~i_r-JI J..G .:.r' ~\ ~ L,b /tk ~~I ~_,..:j l
! 1
• ~JlJIJ d..:.kl;JI ~~I J~ ~~ ~ J , 4J J _rJI ~I
0 ).)-'""' .:.;' 1 t ~~I ~ ~il \..tZ 0i ~ ~~ a.h..~ l if)
~ .. L..JI .:.r- ~i u. );\ J-..>:-) 1 J ~ lf' ~ /11; ~_)I< t) ~wl
.!JJ.) ~ ~! .JW-\1 J>. )I .:.>IS' ~WI J! WU; J ~~ L. 1~1-.:r<lJ
.:.;' .u ;\~ a...; _,-jl _)y-:..; .. ~1 (Sill ~ )) \l...i.JI Jl ..; ; <..Sill
. ...1.-.:>J\J ~I ? I <G y
Stmlt.drlmnik,,, Vnl. 4, Nn. 4. /997
20& EllZI Nem
L.. -IL, • W I \.,L.a,; WLA... j ;-C: -II \.;.;I .._;u - -I l,;)\>. -·r' . ... - 1.> ~ ...5"' J r-' )
(Budhy Munawar .JL--J JY c..5..)-1 ~i: l~WI ~..;; J ~ ))\
.wf ~1 - \..;;IJ ~ c...OIJ ._?1 \.j\J.Y' ~ J>~ vl_r>-1 C: - Rahman)
L>.J~4 ,..U:.S"\IL: oiJL-.JIJ ;i_r-JI j.S"L...J J-.> .:l~l ~ ';/ ~ ..:.J..i; J wl J.Y' <b-_,b ~ .JI ~ JY c..5 .:l y. c..5 .T- w-J ~ ~ J)
.,..k.JI ~ J .:r .wi \II ,~WI ~ J)4 ~; 4.:-il... JJ ;; )::2; L:;\J
_)_,...~'--! ~ ~~~ .. w, j~ L...l:J:. 4-LC!...JI w ~~
j..>-)I e:\L.,.:. ,_} , o ~I J o y.ll C: o")\>. ,_} r 'i I C7'"" i) ¥ k::>.- ';/I
"-.:U£ .r-ey, olS'" I ~!J , ;;i_rJI .:.r i _;"i L..U.. J J;:-i d..>. J.:l ~ ~
..r' ..::....JI I.Sy~l ;.~\II ;;_?-:, ;.\.J) ~~I~~\ lJ JL:; L.. l .l~
~ljP. i ~ L:.J ~ ')\; ,;;i.rll (\5")\.... \II) .u..ill <l&-~) c..5ll\ i ~I
~I ~ ~~ ~~ ,._L..j\ ~ w ~~I L,.,.\..>JI ..;:...L.i.a.\1
..} .s_,=;~l -.l:->JI ~L.a.>- .y 4J L.. ~ ~~ ~) ~ ~ J~l
:r_;;irU ;;_;_,...JI -!1t I~ 0i JL>.-)1 J;:- .y Jofi c..Sill..;....;)l
~ ;;i_rJI w ~) ~\ o.J_,....JI o.k d ~ 0~1 :ULJ~..;
~~ ~ ;.~ ,._:_JI ~ I;~ ~).:/'JY .J~ 0ts"' ,._L.JI
l+i~ J ;;i _,..}I J...LQ; ..} ._;\..aj\11 i~ .:r c..A.i\1 d ~ )La.; , ~ _,:; ~ 1
oiJ...L>.-J 4W c.,?y!j'iiJ ~k::>.-')11 ~I~ b.J ,;;~IJ o_,A-}4
~ o..u.L;.; W' L.W ,.;>-T 0W~ J..-y ,..lj ~~,..WI¥ j d
~)I )..L.J\ d j>--)I e::_:.a; ~I ;:.I.J ~~ o.k , ~ r ~.l.ill ~I ;:.I; 'YI
C'" <...P J-! .J....:s. ..}> JLA.:; -~)\>. ,r ol_r11 ~l J..->.-)1 ~ ~ -
~vi~\ ;;J_,_ 0-" 'i ~)II ~ ~~\ 0T~1 \.J} ~~ oiJL....JI
Stududslnmrlw, Vol. 4, No. 4, /997
AI-Tafoiralls/Jmi 207
, ~.;J.r" 1_,...-i y..J\ v" _,....aJI ~ ~ ~\ tY-..w JIS' JL::.I~_,
~ j e:--' a....p..ly ~ ;;_;L.....JI a.5 _,..JI ~~ (. L..:.U i-·~.i ~J
;; i _r-11 a_j\5:... ~ ~~ ~..y.i::ll ~ 1.J ~ 1 .:rs- 0 _,__.,.;u-:! ..:r-.i.ll ~~~
i..f~ 1\....bij ~~~ ;; .JJ? ..!D~ _)~ u~ '¥~ t.>~ y. t.S r-J
~ _,-hJI o~U:.l Jl ~WI v--i~ - J~ ~- 81 ,;;i_,..JI I~
~ o )6 ,:>'}\ c.5> ~ ~I ~I.J ~I ..!.it ,;;i_,J4 ~I ~..JI ~~J \JI
(.5--L>-1 ,_} .JY t..P J-! 4)l ~ y _)I ~LJ\ (..r" ~ ..:JJ.j) t t ,JL:.,. )I
L....S'- y..JI ;I.J \JI ~ )dl id~~ ~I _,ij ~~ 4-JI ~_L,. J ~~~i
.J~ J-: ,~ 4 .. 1 J 1 ;;f.r--11 _r:.~ .._j~ 'Y -t.> ~ >--! t.SJ..
J~l ~ 'Y s.lJI ,~_.i> a·J\ ~ tfi..JI Jj _,.JI l.r" ~i JL>. )I
. ..:r-..UI) 0 _,;Lih.) ~\ _)i; .} ;;i_,JIJ j>-)I ..p1 a;\.S:..J\ ~I JL-.1
~ )~ ~ ..!.LJ..i) G. ).r.l )~ ~\ ..::...~\ (..r")
y..JI ;\.J ~I ,)i -LS~ .)-1 ~~ ~.> ~- <.5 f.. t.>ll\ (Mansour .Faqih)
;;i.r--11 ? ~~ ~ ~ 4\1 , ;;.1..:-L>.- ..:..~.W 1 ~~ J:'?
~~ ~ ~\ o_L,. WI.-~ ~ .:}J.) ~4-J'Y.>lJ
~ ~L... i (::>--.rS ,) 1_;-All Ji 0~ D..:.:>:Jt.-~ <l,j~
~ oi...-JIJ j.>--)1 ~,;.WI oJr .y JJ\!1 ~)U ~ J if)l._,'il
L;~ J~ (>L ... 'Yl; ~\J~U. ~J ..L>- IJ JL.5:... ~;I_,_... ..L>
~ o~i ~ JU ~ 4ey t4A1 y.. ~ ~t.s::_. ;; \_r11 4.J~ J
~__,..>-'JI ~ ~~~ J~ 'Y ~ (o.h-IJ ~ l.r") a.;.:.JI ~~
o~l J. .JL<:.;\JIJ ..lJLi:liJ ~..JI ;: I.; ';I o~ J...W .:..r<....: ~ _;:J J
Studirt !slamika, Vol. 4, No. 4, 1997
f ~ l! ; ~ ,_
-· ~ .• -'C
:e
'[ ~ ~ ~. l ~ r. ~; (' ~- c: l· ~ ~ t v ct. r ,. ~- f.- t t -~- ~ ~ ~ r ·~ t r. \:. ) - C "· r r e: r " r:: ·t' 1: r ~. - t c.· -.. t c ·I... c.·. \::-( '"*· \ <: ~·· ~ 1~ 'e: f. T ~ - ~l. .c ~ t~ ~ ~ -~ ~ \... 0 f t I ( · ,.. \- \... t -· T c. 0. c. ~- -r ~ ~ (__ r: ~ ~ ~ 'f. '";. 1_ ~ ~~ "-· t;:_ ~ t } b l_ ~ ~ ~-~ ~· 1. .(' (. y [ ~ c c -~ 1. r 1. ·=· \,_ .r ·~ [ { ~ ~ tt· - \ -· .:- \ 1,: f. ·[ ~ · L 1. -r ) '7 ~ e... 1-~ h- ~ r ~ r~ c ·~ ~ :: :: (.. .t. t ~ ~ t \- £ £ -~ L t t ~ '1 't r-~ V\ t "--· '~~ ·L '--- ':t c, ,_ <.. . . ~ '~ (· ' ' --- ~, c.: \). ~ ~-:· :~ . 'c.· . f. - . · l: ~ ·- T ~ n [ - ~ - · f ~. ~- [ ~. z =· c- ~. .t E~ 'it ';t. ~ f: ~ .c- r.- ~~ r t ~ 'L c.. · r -. !- c:: r ~ . 'f. .b '--- • - .l 1 ~ • -
- - \• ~ 'r1 .~ u ...z..• ...z.. - I..L [ · - r r ...Z.. r _ • (;": 1 - \..•"\-
\1:- ~ - . r <;... \ .1:- - 0 · ~ h: 0 t- ·- -~ ~ ('I ~ t ·-t r.IJ· (· ~ r ...z.. c r. t. ~ ~c: ...:. ~-:- '"\ t. r ~ t e: · ~: - "'" r "' ·e ·- 'h. L ~ - ~ e ~ - c . . t. ~: .r ·r- \ \...: r ,;. i. f. r- J- :f \~. t r· E l ~f ~ ~ ~ [ ,. r~, --;· 1 - '-t ~ c '-· .t~ I ~ ,. - ~ ~ 1 _ "- ; · ~ ~I r· c.· lb. ~ ~ ~. EIJ ~- ~ 1 c f.\, Cr.; [
1· ~ I
V \.,. C7 - 't.. - 1.,_ -~ t.l r- [ I • -~ r [ · ~ (_ c. c~ c. L ~. . .r· G-. _: ~· . · ~
t ...z.. ~ [ r ·L .E <;... .t_. ~ ~ ~ c· ~ l.· ~ - . · ·~- [ -- - .._ ~ T l . l,\ . .._ o.L - c. - ·- L
1 - - ' - ' ' - 'f' - • o• - "1. ·
- 1 \..,. {;• ·( ~ ,... ' lr C.• (._ c- r. o.L ~ 0 0 I
\.._ I I 0 ~ \_ \ Q 0 ~ ~ [ •L- ,_ f;· b. t _ 1 t 1:. t [;' t ~· ~Z ·c ~ 't r.- c: ):- c ~ c
2
g. ~
?r :!
AI-Taj/tir~I-Mimi 209
LS.iJI ~~ ~ o-4-!' c>iJI 1iliu ,o\.il.;. .:r JJ.i:ll .:r~ 'i L.
C;:-'YJ ..::;L....IJJJI op ~lS"J ,c}5:;i~J) ~..i.JI \~ .v~
c_L.....JJ d .1u.:...:.ll I~~ ,..:..JI J! oi_rJI o->~~ j~ ~\ _;l5:.;fy1
.:r J-5' ~ t>lll JJ..U\ --4~ ~J~ J ,oirJIJ j.>-)1 0:"! ..k')\.::.:.'YJ
~')L.... ')I ~WI .:_;-A o J~l L. ? ~l..:.: , ..\....: ...1.>.- if oirJIJ j.>-)I
. ~_;J ~..WI 1~ ->r-:J ~ o->L..o ~->i ~ ~~ y ,~,
.WI~ ~L5 ~<.}->)}I LS~I _;\.1.)'1 0 ~ .)i ~J
(Tragtrli Kartini, Selmah Pertanmgan ~ ..}fi.J..:I [. ~ '~.Jl.) ~
\' ii.r---JI ~_ri ..;r--:f ~ y ~ J ~ _rO .Y' e:J~ c>.lJIJ ldeohgt)
I~ J+.--.-~ t L;1; LJ L..;..,_.piJ 'JL..;... ' (EmolliipfJJ"i Mall Kema11a)
:Ji ~\5:.)1 C~ t'(Asma K.1.rirnah) ~~ rs-'T cili LSlll ~l=SJt
\_s-1,}:11 lSJ~\ o~'i~ i y.. ~Loy..~ .>b j oirJI f.-~ AS"?
J' .Y'uJ1 ~ -> r J .J ~ ~tS:J1 LS; L...:S ;;irJI .r-r ~ 01 ~
. .) y.pl 'ilJ 0 r-:}JI 'i l v~ ')\; 'LS"')L.. ')I
~ ~..? 4)~ ~.) ~\ J\.5:.;~\ ~ ~\J_,ll Jl b>..J I ~IJ
L:.AL... i <..5 ..UI .)l-.>- -lA...> i 4--e..ti W ~~ o i_,JI J j.>-)I J)~ j . ·!
.r j5J 0f if ~l ~ii l....:S j\.!..JI ~ ~ ~IJ \~ J ~~ J _,.ill
0lJ ,J->WI ~ ~ )1.; ,\.A.b:..... l_;y Jl.:d~1 ¥, oirJIJ J.>-) 1
...r--"''i iJ ~')\..-') \ ~I \..u ~ \Lk.:JI IL \J.;J a.J1L-.. ~I
.~k:>.-'J\
.)\ J ~ 4........ <" ~ ...LO ')' oi . I\ ...u ~~ - -- w L.i • ..,~ . .r . ~ r-' JJ . ~ • J
~ ~LS~I ~\ ;;4>- .,J')l>. .:_r-o ~ t>.lJI ~\ .../' ;;irJI
StHdra {ILrm.lta, Vol. 4, No.4, 1991
~
~. ~!:- ~ t .t rt ~. 1 'c f ~. l "' \ c· r \)- r .t 0
'l 't - 1 "" 'L 0 'c · ·'1, ..<" f. \ f. '· ~ '1 ..< ? l / T f "'· ,_ 1 t ·::: t . '; ~ 1 ·~ c; \ ~ t ~ ~
~: l [· - !;: J ) . ~ 1 [· 1 t-· ~ t 'y :: t t ·f. s
{ \ ~ -t t ~~ \ }\ \ "I ·t: t t 1: ~ f " ~ . . 1 . F f ! t t-· c . ·~ o -~ E - . . G ,. . ·~ V .b ~ " f. \. 1,_ 't r ·r c.. t; f c .b 1. ~. 0" 1· '1. ~· ~· ~· ~ <i:;- t . r . t ..c_· ~ '-s · - ~. . ~ . T (.· ~ ~ l . ~ - -:- ~.. " 1;- ~ \ ·~ s. 'L ... [ .,__ "' . . r t . ..-. t ~ l.. ~ 'Z" . -. .. .c- ,,.. • • . "-- c . ./_ . I_. ,,.. ' ' 1.. r )_ c; r ~ E t - .. < ·t~ [ c- 't ~ .c- c- ~. _r:. t -. f. C.:. \r, [ '\,.. t !... t;: .:-- c t ~ ~ ~.. : r ~· ~ .:. f 't t ~ ·_ ~ .~. t r ·'' . (. .. \ -· - - e; t - t 1 . '-
· ,c- .,. ~... T- _ · <f. e· t ·_ · ~ ·. ·: 0 ~ 1: j. ~ { ~ \ 1· J f i{ 'b { t . -~ [ ~. ~ f ~· ~ ;:;- (:· t ~ "'· f. f: 'it ~ t ~ '>=-. [ £; .r.: ·~ ~ '[ t '1 ;;-3 ~· ); t' ~ ~ rf (: .f ' 'L { i { ·t~ [ t t [ : .,_: ~ :> ~ ·· · 1 ~ ~... . r ~ - [ . - · . ~"' ~... • • • 01 I • ('" (. I G . I C.· . - O l '""" ~ ./_ &! · 'L" ~ 1_ . .,:. L 1= t ..:- ~ f. ·- . -· & _.c.
~ ~_. e · ~ '- ~ '-t-- - c: c_ \ 1-'-..... [ ~ 1.. .1:- - [ ~ ·- - ltl ~ \ - f - t ~ ~ ~ 1.: 't t ~r ~ ~ f {. 1: l; E L t ~·. ~ <£ ~ . ...
.AI·T..Jitir tCJ./tJ.imi 211
..!.-..-!-L,.,;,)i ~ L. ~ cs-' oi.rJI ~ ;; •(Fr:mce.s S. Adeney) ._r.::..· .,_.. ...r--' ,;~ . I
(A!,omo ...,......_!.)\ J t.....l ; ,:r-..1.!1 : ~ (SprlllJal.itas Perempuan Pnd9 Era Po~t Modem)
.A Y . .,.r (I'\ q, i .Dian lJllcrfidei :~; j"t..). .Y-) .dan Aspmm &kyul)
<.....;t;JI , ___ :S:.h • ..: ...... ~ t.r"' oi_,..Jt .(Masdar F. Mas'udi) ..5-' ~ , ..J )~ y
. ..:.A- ;..U ,.r i.......-...\1 ;· ,.....!' : ..; .(Pcrempuan eli antara Lembarw Klmb Kuruog)
:~ ;..U~) ' (Kitob l<Juunc ..;I;JI ~I (Martin V:ln Brumessert) ~),j. J \i..; }~ . r
. I V c ·../ ( \ '\ ~ "' ,lvfizan
~:f _,.Jt :/ :yWt 'iS' ,rJI; ('i--~~ :(Budhy Mumw:u: Raclunan) .)~;;f--....;.>~>!
(hlam dnn Fem.inisme· Oa,i yL-Jt ..S>J' Jy ~..u..J, :~ .>';1....-...l' ..,JJ
!Usalah ~'·!) ,_..... ) .SeutralJsme kepadot Kesetaraan, dal.lill MtmbillrOtlf, 1-imimsmt)
.1 /\.:> . ._r(\"1~'\ .Gmll
-sl...::~ ( ~~ jL:.-h J=-~ fA' ' t_:..;;, _..J, \.J.,<. j ~ ~I .:,r ..;.,_/' ._}s. ..J ~.; ,.U .>
_ i...,.; (M. Ali Hasan U mnr) , .-.$- .:_r- .)s-~ : ..; ··~ ;; .)s- c_;} J ,;...J
.» V- n ·V' •( I"'\ Y .Toha Purra :~1;1-·) .~1 .> ~
. 1 v o., ...r ,_y,Ut c:>" _,.Jt : .:.hL. . -,
. r I r 1' ...r • lslam ... i )I._ )I I , Barorob Baned .J..t,;. • J' .1 . V
.;-.Jt ....r \.J.;JJ:,;J ~J..J.j)l >'_,.Jt ..Jy1.i ~\S:.. ,f.D. Holleman JW.Y' .:.. . ..J .)::;.' .A
;\,; }"~.>-) .(Ktdrulrdeon Huk11111 fl"anita Nil Ptrkembangonfl)a di Hmdiu &lunda) ~..W J~1
. r A-rv ·../ •( \ '\ V \ , Bbarllt:t
(So/uiVb ~ ;~~~ >i.rJt .J~ ~ (::-) . .,; •(Kowmo) _;t.f" : j\4J1 ~ ..;s- P ' . ~ :~i P 'J \'I' ·..T ( \ 0.. v" .Bal:\J Pus taka :I; j"k) .Sttt~~gab~batl rwanitu [Jl{/ollma)
(Sq'amb Perg~rakan II' anita yL......:.ll ... :..t. .. S _,..!1 (::-}_.,; , (Pringgono) _,.:.~f. .~ . ~
. l'V'I' . ._,:>.(\"'.A\ .Dian Rakyat :t; j"k) •fndonw'a)
~ ~ t Li.l.lt; ~'L-\'I i...o!;.l' r.# (Zamal Abidi.u _'\.hmgd) .4> . .. ~~w· ..;.J . 1 •
• (Mmptrk.:mbat'!, dan MemptrtabankPn Pmdidik.an Ts/an; di Tn&wsw) ~ ;..ul
. 'I'VY .._,:;(\~VA.BuhnBintang ·l.;j"k)
Studra illtumka, Vot. 4, N(/. 4, /997
112 Enzt Netrt
;,_,;1) ..,._:SJi ..:...~ ~;·_......II (llowt~rd M. Fiederspiel) ~ ;--:i .~ J ;l_rA. \ \
..;.....__ ;.J• ~ "'--...l ;>_....J : ._sJ (Perempuan w amar.1 Lembaran Ntab ~uillllg)
(IT"'amlo iJlom di lmlnnma th/am KP_;Ja/1 Tdestuol dan Kont~k.stiful '-!rJIJ ;.,...:, _,...dl
.\~~ -~~(1'\0.r .!~IS :t_$''~>
_,...k:JI ._; ~\ •• ..! ••• 11 J ,..;.!1 ..;~ 'j ~ (Bahdur Djohan) ...>'-" Y"' J-A4 ,_/; .:.; ~ oi J~ . I r
J;\ __,.....;rJ _,,......:.-; <.,..-~-w ...J ""~ ..} , ;'Y1 ...:J..: ....>~ ..... ~.: .:'rJ· fir J. WlA.. 01 .J...W' 1-4-J u.1) ·..,-=' ;J..~I ~I ...; ;\_,Ji -:u~ ._.? ......-: .)..lj~\ ... ,..A, .. :.JJ
.~.>':....ciY; ~.,.....! jL..'; .,:_ ..... ?~'J .... ~ ~·4Jt..,......,.;...o..} :;'_,..!· 4~
.(Di r,u:gan \'\'o111.ira) ; I _......I• ._;~· ._r (Bahdt:r Joban) ,,.1u y- ;....,..._. : _ru ~ ~
• 'I' I" . ._r ( \ •. VV ,Ida)'U Pres~ .\:i .P=}
~ :.;-=!J ~J ·~l:-- J;--- ...r-'J ~ -· --=' ~......:J· .J'.>\>J ..s' .:.U~ .. ~; . ' r . \ •, ~ . J" •d.L ... h ~ J...JI :J<-o-J-¥ .>;I)~ : _..::.;i ; ~~I
• (\lenemukan Sej:~c:ili) (:!Jl:J ..JL.!..:S" (Mans\lr Sur:y:megara) ; '->..;-<; .>- J~ \ ~
.Ai \VV · ..rtli'\~ .1\iizau :~;...04)
...,~ .). ~ ;_r-J ~\ cJ • ....J '-+'. ~ ~_.,.;......:> ... _$ .s=l' ~J~ .:>. I~
.._. J~ w.'yr ._;..l;:.; ~ J ,_~i }JI ..:...4· ,:r '-<; ...r" y L.>.ll.:...i JL; ..:...;IS ...if .~
?"' ;.' ..r ~ ..;..., 5'
~I ~ I..> i.i .. ~ _.; .:r J /11 r/') ..:..L..-JI ..:..t.:.,l.J .....,~ ~ ; ..V ~· IJ..,. ..?-! . ' .. ,
..:J~· ..:...L$ ;.L.!.j~ f)"i (y! ~,;.,..,_,.... ~~ /'J'J ...... ..,. .... ~) -~'" ... - )' -4.$
,....Lt::i 0~ ;; .....ll JG:...Ji J> /~/I ,..,__a,. .:>-,...------- ., J .J ..._ - ~
..,;~') .._r;.l.!· ._-(;) ..,___. _r-ll ~ J • (.-\.o.uuuddin Ra<yad) .>L...!. 1 ...r-! .. tli ...r:". _....::u • IV
P<>ugunss Perguruan :Li }'\.;.,.) (Rahm:ili. cl· Yunusiyah dan Zainuddin LJb2y)
i ~ ._..: •( \'\~I . Duuyah Putri Padaog Pau1:mg Perw:Uu.bn J3karta
(Tim .....JI "-:!U . .A --'-!_r. 4--~~ .... )L..)'I -.....l-IJ '"""t:>J•, <....:J : j l:.....)l J,:- JS )i: I 1\
(Emlk.lopdi ~ ;-"~' ~')L_ ') <s. , ........ rl' , Pen.ubs lAIN Sy.u:if Hid.1ptullah)
A · ~ . ...;P •( \ '\ •, T 'Djumbaw.n : u _i"L.,.) • Islam Indooesi~)
Studu lsf:tm:Ju, Vol. I, .Vo. 4. 1'1~7
AI·Tajkit ,,/./sl~mi Zl3
J-!,r.l \ \ , \ 'r \ .).J...¥ (Fem.ina) L.:.,....,; <.....>..... .(Ralunuh el· Yunus1yllh) ~ J..,)\ '--; . I ~
• 'I' ~ • .._..P • ._>!\...JI ~ _...JI ; ~ _r-ll ...._,..) ...,; ... .d'J '\ ~ v A
. \ '\ . . .,r •,j!UI ~ J..Jt :j.:L ;.,Y ;._$- ':NJ . "I' •
·~ ~\ .:-...s- ..:.>~ ._.::!1 _.:5jl J_,.- .. : .. ?'j._,p.U -Oohan Meul=en) ~ Y- JU. )"'". r \
(Analisis TeUiang Bul..-u-Bulo:u Tcntang Wanita Islam Yang 1.:--,i ;.J.iw o...L.-..li
(rt'.anita Islam '-:~1; ~I .• : . ..1. . .-I;J.ll ,_) <...-.11 oi_rJI : ..j Bcredar di Indonesia)
. 1 '\ r · .... -" ( \ •, '\ r .IN IS ;Is .f'=-) .Dalam Kqjian Tekst11al dan Kontde.<t11al)
:} J-") ·.......;~\ ;IJ.......:>\11 (Nilai IFamto) ;~_r-JJ L..,J . (l\loenliW:H Cholil) ~ Jr'. 'I' r
. \ \ . ._r ·( \ ". ". t .Ramadh:wl
. \ \ ·<f' 'v~'~'l ~ _..Jt ; p . '\' 1"
. \ n- . ...r . .j.!L.ll ~ _,.jl 'I' ~
. A t . ._.p ,.j.!LJI 0::: _,.Jt : <fl::- , ~ ,
. (Ketludukon Pmmpuan Do/am islam) ()L...-YI ~ ;(_-JJ :wtS:. ,(1:-[aruka) L(_ . ~I
.A . ._r .( \ ~ '\ i -Pustaka Panjimas :G .f'=-)
• \A • • _r .(/lnalisis) .;.,)'..,l:...:ll • ~.:·.:, Y- .:;u. y. : ):i.> . r V
. "t • , . ._r .. ._'-!'--11 ~ _,.J• . ~ A
~ ~~ ;L<.;i ~~)\....')I I ~...__:.It <5' _rll J# •(.'\.ncL:ee Feillard) .) ;'j..; ...;;..v- , 'I'~
(Tb~ EmeJ8,mni llj a Muslim Feminist MoH!nmlf in tli~ lnullll'l11al Elitf til ~ ;.J...I
~ _,.....i ~~ :('-<;;..UI •U) ~)\... 4.)? ,_) ')L.\5',? r- I'\' •J" ,Jmlonesio)
~i r; ~ ;.J.il ..) ~')I....~~ ~WI <S" _rJJ ..l.,l>.W ~8i ._,..; .)11 ~l)l I~ • • F~ W
_ _... ~ ~ -.:J•j\.. if).~ 0-.>-) L>;~ ~;~ ~ .;_,'jl.:,.. ~L.......i l..-::i -.:Jtjl ..
; ~ ; ............; ~WI <S" - l L....;;.J.i")' i ,... ~WI ,... 0 1 ::;')W k-')\..,; : --';.J.i• ,... .; .,..,1 ; J ~ - ;-- - - \.::.. v . ~ '-;' ... \..:....- .J
.,_rS- :.F! ~ ~ u=JI (oi _rJI) wanita :<....lS" J~ (<-\......;.)1) peremp11an :~ (.._,.;.;_ I
. ~I JL.,.:,..)Ij \$. J'-" .J·" •._.;, p
(Perempu:ur dalam(<.f'Llf) o..!...:!~\....;.. 1 ,__r ~L..:.ll .(Dawrun Rnh~rjo) ~ / -"''J ( I;=>. r ·
. \ .. 'l, t .I ...u.,.... (U/unlfll Qllr'an) j~l! r~../$o .}pembicaraan)
Jw..:...ll ?-;JI; of_r-ll r.r J (-y.5:jl ~ -(Marwah D:tud Thruhim) r-""'..r. ~ ;b 0 JJ' . i I
4J -~'J \I r ~ . ._.p ( \ '\ o. ~ .Miztul :~ ;..l.i4) .(T(o/ogi, Ematuiposi dan TrawendtnSt)
. (Perefnpu:Ul lnd011esia: ~~I ._,j ~ j u _,.5-: '1 1:,W :~ J.J.i'YI ;; _,.Jt :4 i
SuuiM rsl.mllka, Vol. 4, No. 4, 1997
214 £11l1 Ntm
il_.,-)1 (l\1ely G T:u1) Jl; .t__ ..r-- : ...1 Pem.impin Masa Dep3n? Mengnpa Tidak?}
(Pmmpmm lndon<sio Pemimpi11 ;\{aso Dpa11 ~ l'._t,.i:-..../1 Y j .;~~ Y ,.J.J : '- _ ',:....i Y1
I r . ..r •< 1 '\ '. \ , Sinar H .uapan ::.; _,5'1.>-) • )
Fem.irusme Scb~gru ,L.:;.,. .?-.£ ~L....) ~ ,rl J ')--"' ji.:...Jt fr.-- .,F- 4-:l'...i.. _P. . rr
, i ~ -"' .>..u..ll) U/JIIIliiL Qut'a11 J i_.-AJ• ( ;)s-~ c'-.::J' ..s-' .Coun!er-Culrure
.r . .._,;(\",1 ~
(Organisasi wo .1-.-J::.; '-+>-',.,;' , "'=--')\......'i t ..:-L..,Jdl : 4=JU.. _} ..!.J.}.) .:.!' ~ L.S . n
. \~I · ~"" .(lf'imita) i'rJ ..s' .tslaru, \u.h dan Pcngembang:umy:~)
(Femimsme: Agenda Baru ~"j,__.'JI ~ ;~.:,J, ..._ )~c.; :<.,;•- ·1 :S .rJ r-:.
. \ , 0. . ._r •( \ 0, 1"' , i ..U..,.,. , r .>..WI) 0 -_;jl ( jlS- : ,.) .Pen:ukiran hhun)
~WI ..6L.......lt ;l;:JI J ~ L.-1.&. .r' ,_,..UI p 4"! Jt..<; ,t....;'il l..u> ._? ;.\._, ~; ;"-:-! . r"'
rtt\' • ..u ->' l,......,. ;....i4
\ I 1" , .._..:> • (IF' auvllc.Jm) • _..-.1 . r i
. I I \ ·J' :.,Y.LJI ::--~ . r'V
'-:5L-.:.ll w _rJI j')L,:. ..r-" ,L-..:JI ~ : .) ,~ y.:.IU.. j l!.JI J~ _,k-~~. T' A
. " - ~ . ._r •( I'\ 0, i )'t Y- ·, • Komp:ls) . (Nbangk.itan P<'!'tmfJIIOIIIII .. lolHiflnmwllt<')
~~ .._:,"j..s.) ..Wt; uJI ,<.,;1 ....... :.!1 <$"' rJ1 ;,J,.; .(Ratna \legawangi) ~· ;1>....:- \..,; J '!"'\
(Perkembangan Fenunisme ~iasa Ki.IU dtm Mendat:mg Scrta K.ai1annya ..s"'')L..)
..r" >t;L-....11 ~ ,;,;,_·1• ...S rJI ..s' ~,1.>,1 :.j .Dengm1 Pernikiran Keisl:umm)
. (lvl•mbintong Fti!IIIIIJ/1/e, Disk!tr.rttS C&ndtr Prr.rpektif Tswm) I.S'')L. \II J_,...kJI
. ~ 1 v ... ,; ( 1 '\ '\ i .!us:tl:lh Gus1i :~I.J J.'·")
r r 1 ·..? • ._:'!L ..... h :.::;-~..J : ..?'-' ·;~ ~ J. ~.
(Suchiko L.;1J Y ~L- yL...:...<J or-=' ;X.'i• ;l..t.....:>')\] u~ ~ ~~J~ L:.; _, ~ 1
. I · ·...?(I '\'\"1 .Mtzan :<;:';..t.A~) .Tile TaoJJjlslam ..,_.'j...,.'1\ 4.J.J\; :.JI-',:.-A.dvluratn)
4....;,:.f _,.....11 .,r .i.,;l. ...... .:.\1 <$"' _.,.JI; (')L..\}1 .(Budlty Munawar Rnlunan) \.:..-; )_.-..:,.. ...;~ y. t ~
: ...,..; (Islam dan Feminisme: D~ri Sentralisme kcpada Keseta(a:m) ;';---" .).
~y ;,u,! Cl'.fA! J <!U.. _}i.;l;. A- 1 W .._,; • ._~L- .:::" r .~L..J· 45" ,rJ1 .$ ..:_,,~.>,·
(Releonstmk.si ;~_.)1 <...ii <L...,. .i.JLJ:J: ...,..; (Rekonsrmksi Fiqh Perempuan) <i_rll U.
. i • . .._..:> ( \ '\ '\ • .Ababil ·\,; ,S'I..j-J<!.) .Fiqh Pmmpuou)
Vwdra fllamrka, Vol. -1, No. 4, 19'J7
AI· Tajltir a/.fs/ami 21;
. ' - r . . ._r .J.!L-.!• ,:::-..,.J ,.Jl...>-; ; y ~;:; y.. ~ r
. .,. . ., . ._-" ·.Y.'- c:" r ·'-:'WI 'iS' _,.J1 ~.>~i : ,j . ..)1....>- ; ; y ._>;:; y. . ~ ~
; ;,S ..iJ1 ~ .:.r-" ~ o )i; :().... '}1..} >i..,.JI <Jt5:.. . (?viansOtlr Faqih) y.t ;~ . ~.,
: u-i .(Posisi Perempt1an dahm Islam: Tinjauan dari Analisis Gender) ;.; .. l~ IJ
. o , ·v" •.Y.'- c:" r ,'-:'WI OS" _,.,.JI ~.>1.>-;
(Traguli KPrtim; ...r-..J f-~1 ~ 1,- •.r-i/ If <--../.. '(Asma Karimah) ~,? -.r-- . ~ 1
. .:- ·J> ( \ ". ". ~ ,Hnnifah :t; .f'k-) . s~buah Putann'!.a" ld~olot,l}
tL.f ~ _rWI ~)L. Yt :t-W/ f::.WJ vi....- f_;...UJ d i.:)i.J? 1..5 _,:.;, t..5 ~~
· 4..:1~' ~~ r 'E'.)i.: (Imam Botyol) Jr ..J:'
Stud•a lslarruka, Vol. 4, No. 4, 1997
