52
INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES SOURCES, PATTERNS, EXPLANATIONS & SOLUTIONS © Dr. Francis Adu-Febiri, 2020 24/02/2020 1

INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES

SOURCES, PATTERNS, EXPLANATIONS & SOLUTIONS

© Dr. Francis Adu-Febiri, 2020

24/02/2020 1

Page 2: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

24/02/2020 2

• MOTIVATE:

– Why we should be interested in the social indicators of indigenous health

Page 3: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

Introduction: The Health Status of Indigenous Peoples in Canada

• The marking of Indigenous peoples as diseased, addicted, and unworthy of care—along with the deaths attached to them—are deeply historical. Kelm (1998) wrote of the discursive construction of Indigenous peoples as sick and vulnerable, arguing that it has worked under Settler colonialism to construct a population of peoples believed incapable of governing themselves ( Cannon and Sunseri, 2018, pp. 205-206).

24/02/2020 3

Page 4: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

24/02/2020 4

INTRODUCTION: Main Theme, Central Question and Main Thesis

• MAIN THEME:

• Indigenous health and well-being in a settler colony

• CENTRAL QUESTION: • What are the sources of the patterns of Indigenous health

conditions/experiences and well-being in Canada, the impacts of these patterns, and strategies to sustainably transform them?

• MAIN THESIS: • The patterns of Indigenous health conditions/experiences and well-being in

Canada are socially constructed. The devastating patterns of settler colonial violence and their consequences will continue until effective sustainable decolonizing and indigenizing strategies are designed and implemented to deconstruct these patterns and socially reconstruct sustainable Indigenous healing and well-being.

Page 5: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

INTRODUCTION: Main Argument

• The imperial violence of settler colonialism embedded in the evolution of the capitalist political economy underlies the patterns and impacts of indigenous health conditions/experiences and well-being in Canada. This pattern would not fundamentally change until the human agency of Indigenous peoples is transformed to use sustainable decolonizing and indigenizing strategies to diminish/eliminate the core of imperial violence such as ideology of scarcity of resources, centered power, oppressions, racisms, cultural hegemony, new poverty, and white patriarchy. Until then, the patterns of deteriorating Indigenous health and well-being will continue with tragic consequences.

24/02/2020 5

Page 6: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

24/02/2020 6

Introduction: The Imperial Root of Indigenous Health

Conditions/Experiences

• http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Iv-dG8XH_8A

Page 7: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

25/02/2020 7

INTRODUCTION: Main Argument Illustrated:The Imperial Root of Indigenous Health

Conditions/Experiences

• Through stories handed down over many generations, it is well known that pre-contact Indigenous peoples had effective infrastructures, upheld traditional values and beliefs, followed customs and traditions, and were in fact very healthy people (Fox and Long 2000: 288)

Page 8: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

25/02/2020 8

INTRODUCTION: Main Argument Illustrated:The Imperial Root of Indigenous Health

Conditions/Experiences

• However, it is false to think that “Aboriginal People had no diseases and health problems prior to contact. Aboriginal people did suffer from disorders such as arthritis and rye problems caused by too much smoke in enclosed spaces, for example. It is just that the big-killer communicable diseases were not a problem.” (Steckley and Cummins 2008, p. 187).

Page 9: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

24/02/2020 9

• EXPLORE:

• To know and understand the major concepts related to Indigenous health and well-being

Page 10: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

Major Concepts• Imperialism

– Settler Colonialism

– Imperial Violence: Aggressive, Peaceful, and Lateral

– Racisms: Individual, Institutional, Systematics, Systemic

– Oppression

• Socially Constructed Indigenous health and well-being

• Political Economy– Capitalist Political Economy

– Ideology of scarcity of resources

– New poverty

• Human Agency• Human Capital

• Human Factor• Hu

• White Patriarchy

• Cultural Hegemony:

– Pathological Indigenous Culture

– Assimilation

– Multiculturalism

• Centered Power

• Decolonization and Indigenization 10

Page 11: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

Major Concepts

• IMPERIALISM:

• Systemic and systematic subordination of the culture, discourse, theories, knowledges, governance system of Indigenous groups by Western capitalist countries for economic purposes. Colonialism is a weapon of this imperialism.

– “Imperialism is the highest state of capitalism” (V.I. Lenin)

24/02/2020 11

Page 12: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

Major Concepts

24/02/2020 12

• INSTITUTIONAL RACISM

• Policies, procedures, and practices– in institutions and organizations that consciously or

unwittingly promote, sustain, or entrench differential advantage or privilege for the dominant group at disadvantage/disprivilege to racialized groups:

• e.g. word -of-mouth recruitment, discriminatory hiring based upon employer’s bias, union policy of internal job posting, lack of recognition of foreign credentials and Indigenous knowledges.

Page 13: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

Major Concepts

24/02/2020 13

• SYSTEMIC/SYSTEMATIC RACISM • Laws, rules, and other norms woven into the social system

– that result in an unequal distribution of economic, political, and social resources and rewards among various racial groups (Henry et al, 2000: 56).

• E.g. Denial of access, participation and equity to racial minorities for services such as education, housing, employment

• E.G. Negative representation of people of color, the erasure of their voices and experiences, and the repetition of racist images in the media.

• When these allocation of resources are backed up by legislation, they constitute SYSTEMATIC RACISM.

Page 14: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

Major Concepts

•VIOLENCE

24/02/2020 14

Page 15: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

PATTERNS OF INDIGENOUS HEALTH:AGGRESSIVE VIOLENCE

• Aggressive violence, the “guns, germs and steel invasion” ( Jared Diamond, 1998) that accompanied the European imperial domination of the Turtle Island

24/02/2020 15

Page 16: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

PATTERNS OF INDIGENOUS HEALTH:PEACEFUL VIOLENCE

• Haunani Kay-Trask (2000) invokes Frantz Fanon’s notion of a “peaceful violence” to emphasize that not only is imperial violence carried out through aggressive invasions and occupations or physical warfare, but that it also consists of the “ordered realities of confinement, degradation, ill-health and early death” (p. 118).

24/02/2020 16

Page 17: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

PATTERNS OF INDIGENOUS HEALTH:VERTICAL VIOLENCE

• Indigenous Infants/Children:• Infant mortality rate, especially for reserve

Indians, is considerably higher than for the general population.

• The chance of an Aboriginal child developing pneumonia is about 17 times that of other Canadian Children.

• Indigenous children have more ear infections, meningitis, and hepatitis

• Indigenous experience the highest incidence of fetal alcoholic syndrome. – Sources: Absolon 2011, Ahenakew 2012, Daschuk 2013, Frideres, James and Rene R. Gadacz.

2001:Chapter 3; Wotherspoon, Terry and Vic Satzewic. 2000: Chapter 6; Bolaria, Singh B. and Rosemary Bolaria (ed.). 1994: Chapters 13-16.

24/02/2020 17

Page 18: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

PATTERNS OF INDIGENOUS HEALTH:LATERAL VIOLENCE

• Indigenous Adults:• Life expectancy rates remain an average of 10 years behind the rates of

the general population.• The incidence of diabetes is 10 times the general Canadian rate; cervical

cancer 6 times higher.• Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer

than the general population. • Suicide and self-inflicted injuries are three times higher (six times higher

for the 15-24 age group).• Homicide rates are 2 times as high, congenital anomalies are 1.5 times

higher, tuberculosis is over 9 times higher, and pneumonia over 3 times higher.

• The overall rate of violent deaths is between 3-4 times the general Canadian rate.

• The death rate for the Aboriginal population ages 15-44 is more than three times of the general Canadian population. – Sources: Greenwood et al (2015), Absolon 2011, Ahenakew 2012,

Daschuk 2013, Frideres, James and Rene R. Gadacz. 2001:Chapter 3; Wotherspoon, Terry and Vic Satzewic. 2000: Chapter 6; Bolaria, Singh B. and Rosemary Bolaria (ed.). 1994: Chapters 13-16, Assembly of First Nations 2007, Mensah and Williams 2017, p. 3. 24/02/2020 18

Page 19: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

PATTERNS OF INDIGENOUS HEALTH:VERTICAL & LATERAL VIOLENCE

• "One-third of HIV-positive Canadians are Aboriginal."

XVI International AIDS Conference in TorontoTo Address HIV Among Aboriginals

August 13-18, 2006

• “With the highest HIV rates in Canada, Saskatchewan’s epidemic is uniquely Indigenized”(Dr. Pamela Downe, Associate Professor, College of Arts and Science, University of Saskatchewan).

24/02/2020 19

Page 20: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

IMPACT OF MARGINAL INDIGENOUS HEALTH

• Reinforcement of:

–Low economic status

–Low educational achievement/attainment

–Negative racial stereotypes

24/02/2020 20

Page 21: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

EXPLANATIONS FOR AND SOLUTIONS TO THE INDIGENOUS HEALTH CRISIS

• The disparity between the health status of Indigenous people in pre-contact and the post-contact periods renders the biomedical theory and genetic deficiencies less convincing in explaining the contemporary marginal health and wellness status of Indigenous people. The Biomedical Model is therefore unable to resolve the Indigenous health crisis on its own. This is because the biomedical health care system of Canada “does not, has not, and cannot meet their needs [health and wellness needs of Indigenous peoples of Canada]” (Loppie-Reading et al 2009, HFNC 2011).

• What then explains and can resolve the Indigenous health crisis?

24/02/2020 21

Page 22: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

Sociological Perspectives of the Indigenous Health Crisis

• Major Concept: Social Construction: Health is socially constructed.

• That is, it is, “ a product of social circumstances” (Wotherspoon and Satzewich 2000: 176).

• Health is dependent very much on “socially determined ways of life” beyond the individual’s control (Bolaria 1988: 135) that prevent Indigenous people to eat well, rest well, exercise well, and connect well with community/society.

• “Of course, the causes of such socioeconomic and health disparities are never easy to pin down. Yet, the salience of racism in all this cannot be easily discounted (McGibbon and Etowa 2009,; Raphael 2009)” (Mensah and Williams 2017, p. 3).

• Solutions to the Indigenous health challenge therefore lie more in change of social conditions than in utilization of Western biomedical health care services. Increase in the human factor competency (HFC) of Indigenous communities could facilitate this transformation of the Indigenous social conditions. High HFC could transform Indigenous communities/peoples to transform their access to valued resources (Adu-Febiri 2017) that would make them “eat well, rest well, exercise well, and connect well with community/society” (Bolaria 1988, p. 135)24/02/2020 22

Page 23: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

Sociological Perspectives of the Indigenous Health Crisis

• Major Concept: Oppression—Restrictions on Indigenous lives: Fragile freedoms; lack of real choices

• Oppression is a Social Determinant of health(Greenwood et al 2015, Elizabeth McGibbon, 2012).

• Oppression and health are intricately connected. A recent emphasis on the social determinants of health has focused attention on the “causes of the causes” of ill health, including systemic forces such as capitalism, globalization, imperialism, medicalization, neo-colonialism and neoliberalism. If we are to change the oppressive practices that cause ill health our analysis must consistently and explicitly integrate these systemic forces and thus reframe growing health inequities within the scope of moral responsibility and social justice (McGibbon, 2012)

24/02/2020 23

Page 24: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

24/02/2020 24

Sociological Perspectives of the Indigenous Health Crisis

• “The Story of Minnie Sutherland:Death By Stereotype?”

• http://afternoonsncoffeespoons.wordpress.com/2011/04/28/aboriginal-canada-the-story-of-minnie-sutherland/

Page 25: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

Indigenous Perspectives of the Indigenous Health Crisis

• “…colonialism is indeed the broadest and most fundamental determinant of Indigenous health and well-being in countries where settler-colonial power continues to dominate” (De Leeuw et al, 2015, p. xii).– Existing literature focused on determinants of health has

been primarily concerned with how the “social” determines human (ill) health or lack of well-being, often to the exclusion of other forces that may not be considered strictly “social” in nature, including colonialism—historical and contemporary colonialisms—that continue to bear down on all aspects of Indigenous peoples’ lives (ibid.)24/02/2020 --25

Page 26: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

24/02/2020 26

• CREATE:

• Be a Changemaker; be a Gamechanger

Page 27: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

CREATIVITY & INNOVATION EXERCISE

• Critically review the explanations and suggested solution strategies in the rest of the slides.

– a) If you agree that any of the strategies are sustainable, provide an innovative design (provide a brief description and also a clear diagram connecting processes/steps, tasks, people, and resources) to successfully implement it/them.

– b) If you question the sustainability of the suggested strategies, provide creative ideas that could inform sustainable strategies and innovative designs to implement them.

• Submit your designs and ideas for 2 bonus marks.24/02/2020 27

Page 28: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

24/02/2020 28

• APPLICATION OF SOCIOLOGICAL PARADIGMS

Page 29: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

THE FUNCTIONALIST PERSPECTIVE OF THE INDIGENOUS HEALTH CRISIS

• Explanation: “PATHOLOGICAL” INDIGENOUS CULTURE

• Indigenous traditional medicine is disappearing but Indigenous Canadians are unable to adequately access/utilize advanced medicine (the biomedical health care services) because of their traditional cultures, according to Brant (1990: Clare Brant. “Native Ethics and Rules of Behaviour.” Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 35: 534-539).

24/02/2020 29

Page 30: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

THE FUNCTIONALIST PERSPECTIVE OF THE INDIGENOUS HEALTH CRISIS

• 1. Indigenous people prefer intimate contacts with physicians, as they do with traditional healers, and therefore find de-personalized biomedical services unacceptable.

• 2. Indigenous people are more likely to utilize hospital emergency departments for non-emergency treatment, because they culturally blind to the purpose of emergency departments.

• 3. Indigenous people are less likely to make appointments, and to show up for appointments, because they are past- and present-oriented, and not future oriented.– Clare Brant. “Native Ethics and Rules of Behaviour.” Canadian Journal

of Psychiatry, 35: 534-539).

• Stereotypes?

24/02/2020 30

Page 31: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

THE FUNCTIONALIST PERSPECTIVE OF THE INDIGENOUS HEALTH CRISIS

• Major Concept: Assimilation

• Solution: ASSIMILATION:– Must abandon Indigenous cultures and immerse in the

mainstream Canadian culture so as to properly utilize the biomedical Canadian health care services

• Critique:• “Few Aboriginals are unicultural (many have already lost

their traditional cultures and are assimilated into Euro-Canadian culture) and most Aboriginals are bicultural, able to live adequately in both Aboriginal and Euro-Canadian cultural milieux” (Waldram 1994: 326).

24/02/2020 31

Page 32: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

SOCIAL CONFLICT PERSPECTIVE OF INDIGENOUS HEALTH CRISIS

• Explanation: POVERTY:• Major Concepts: Political Economy: The intersection of power and wealth

driven by the ideology of scarcity of resources.

• New Poverty: New poverty is extreme poverty resulting from the introduction of the

cash economy (through macroglobalization processes) to Indigenous people without providing them with access to Welfare State services and without empowering them to access the formal economic sector. These conditions make new poverty an issue more prevalent in underdeveloped countries and communities (Adu-Febiri 2016, p. 30).

• Capitalist Political Economy: Colonization and Social Class:

– Indigenous Poverty Produced by Capitalist Exploitation through colonization:

• New Poverty leads to very high rates of suicide and violent death, alcohol abuse, and domestic violence, areas in which biomedical health care services have had little effect (Waldram 1994: 328).

24/02/2020 32

Page 33: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

SOCIAL CONFLICT PERSPECTIVE OF INDIGENOUS HEALTH CRISIS

• 1. Poor housing conditions result in high incidences of infectious diseases, such as scabies and tuberculosis (Ibid.).

• 2. Low incomes also affect diet: Indigenous peoples have in recent years developed very high rates of nutritional disorders, such as diabetes, lung cancer, and cardiovascular disease (Feather 1991)

• 3. Poverty and low level of education reduce health care utilization of lower/under class people, Aboriginals not excepted (Waldram 1994: 329-21).

24/02/2020 33

Page 34: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

SOCIAL CONFLICT PERSPECTIVE OF INDIGENOUS HEALTH CRISIS

• Solution: Establish Self-government and Eliminate Poverty:

• “…effective changes in health status require major transformations in the organization of social life that go beyond what native peoples can achieve on their own” (Wotherspoon and Satzewich 2000: 176).

• 1.Create Indigenous self-government• 2. Eliminate Poverty by

• Destroying capitalism and introducing socialism/communism.

• Critique:• Complete Indigenous independent state is not feasible in a settler colony

where the indigenous population is small.

• The project of replacing capitalism with socialism/communism is overwhelming, and so far has not worked anywhere.

24/02/2020 34

Page 35: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

INTERACTIONIST PERSPECTIVE OF INDIGENOUS HEALTH CRISIS

• Explanation: DEFINITION OF HEALTH & HEALTH CARE

• Major Concept: Human Agency: Peoples’ capability/ability to define situations and make choices with their human capital and human factorthrough the looking-glass self process

• Human Agency: Definition of Clinical Reality:

• 1. Define health or healing as total well being and to include whole communities or families.

• 2. Perceptions of racism in the biomedically-based health services delivered by EuroCanadians, especially in the absence of formal means to discuss them with the others involved (medical employees and employers), condition the negative response of Indigenous people to the Canadian health care system (Waldram 1994: 333, Alan and Smylie 2018, pp. 214-223).

24/02/2020 35

Page 36: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

INTERACTIONIST PERSPECTIVE OF INDIGENOUS HEALTH CRISIS

• Solution: RE-DEFINITION OF HEALTH AND HEALTH CARE– Change in the perception that the EuroCanadian biomedically-

based health care service is racist would influence Indigenous people to access and utilize the biomedical services to heal their diseases.

• Critique:

• Given that many Indigenous people define health or healing as total well-being (World Health Organization’s definition) and to include whole communities or families, increased utilization of the EuroCanadian biomeddically-based health care system won’t resolve the health crisis. 24/02/2020 36

Page 37: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

FEMINIST PERSPECTIVE OF INDIGENOUS HEALTH CRISIS

• Major Concept: White Patriarchy: European sexist ideology and structures of male dominance

• Explanation: White Patriarchal Health Care System.• Lack of consultation and participation of Indigenous women

in the major decisions affecting Indigenous health in post-contact Canada is a major factor in Indigenous health crisis.

• Women are the main care givers in Indigenous communities but unlike in the pre-contact period, they don’t participate in health policy making.

• Solution:

• Make Indigenous women major participants in health policy and decision making processes of Indigenous health care system.

24/02/2020 37

Page 38: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

FEMINIST PERSPECTIVE OF INDIGENOUS HEALTH CRISIS

• Critique:

– Indigenous women’s participation in the major decision-making processes in a colonial biomedical health care system is not likely to totally resolve the Indigenous health crisis because gender is only one dimension of the Indigenous health crisis.

24/02/2020 38

Page 39: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

POSTMODERN PERSPECTIVES OF INDIGENOUS HEALTH CRISIS

• Major Concept: Politics of culture creates a Cultural Hegemony—a vertical cultural mosaic with one culture as the most dominant.

• Explanation: Cultural Hegemony

• Mono-cultural (Eurocentric) Health Care System:

• Culturally insensitive and inappropriate health care services (Waldram 1994, Allan and Smylie 2018).

• Language barriers

• Disrespect for Indigenous health values and beliefs.

• Lack of consideration of the unique life circumstances and living conditions of Indigenous peoples.

• Lack of Indigenous care services provided in Indigenous cultural context by

Indigenous health care deliverers.24/02/2020 39

Page 40: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

POSTMODERN PERSPECTIVES OF INDIGENOUS HEALTH CRISIS

• Major Concept: Multiculturalism—horizontal cultural mosaic or cultural equality

• Solution: Multiculturalize the Health Care system• Provision of health services in Indigenous languages or language

interpretation services in situations where clients are not fluent in EuroCanadian language.

• Sensitivity to Indigenous health beliefs and values.

• Health care services provided in proper Indigenous cultural contexts by Indigenous health care providers.

• Critique:– Culturally sensitive and appropriate health care services in

Contemporary Canada would not necessarily eliminate the fundamental structural inequalities of racism, sexism, and classism from the health care system.24/02/2020 40

Page 41: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

POSTSTRUCTURALIST PERSPECTIVE OF INDIGENOUS HEALTH CRISIS

• Major Concept: Centered Power—concentration of decision-making resources in the hands of a selected few

• Explanation: Centralized Power Structures– Racism, sexism, and classism, as intersected centralized

power structure, disempower Indigenous people and thus unable them to control Indigenous health care services.

– Thus lower class Indigenous women experience the blunt of Indigenous health crisis.

• Solution: De-centralized Power• Indigenous health crisis will be resolved only when

Indigenous Canadians have equal access to and participation in a decentralized power.

24/02/2020 41

Page 42: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

POSTSTRUCTURALIST PERSPECTIVE OF INDIGENOUS HEALTH CRISIS

• Critique:– Indigenous local control of Indigenous health care seems to be

working for Aboriginals in The William Charles Band located in the Montreal Lake in Saskatchewan (Waldram 1994). This is in spite of the fact that Canadian State is still a centralized structure of racism, classism and sexism.

• When the band gained control of health care delivery in 1988, there was a dramatic change in attitude.

• Immunization rates increased.

• Home management improved.

• Elders began to see the nurses on a regular basis.

• After-hours visits to the nursing stations decreased.

• Health care services was accompanied by new educational and outreach initiatives.

24/02/2020 42

Page 43: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

POST-COLONIAL PERSPECTIVE OF INDIGENOUS HEALTH CRISIS

• Explanation: Imperialism• Imperialist interaction and social practices in the

health care institution systematically excludes Indigenous peoples from equal participation and treatment (Reid 1994).

• Indigenous perception that the predominantly EuroCanadian health care staff are imperialistic: treating the EuroCanadian patients better than the Indigenous peoples (Waldram 1994).

• Health care deliverers tend to hold imperialistic stereotypes of Indigenous peoples as inferior: drunks, incompetent parents, etc. (Sherley-Spiers 1989, Alan and Smylie 2018).

24/02/2020 43

Page 44: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

POST-COLONIAL PERSPECTIVE OF INDIGENOUS HEALTH CRISIS

• Major Concept: Decolonization—returning economic and political power to dominated people

• Solution: Indigenous Control; Decolonization

• Indigenous Control of Indigenous Health Care system:

– Indigenous health care personnel delivering health care to Indigenous patients in Indigenous cultural context.

• Structural change [Indigenous Self-government] is required to reduce the pervading impact of systemic, systematic and institutional racism on the health of Indigenous people in Canada (Allan and Smylie 2018)

24/02/2020

Page 45: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

POST-COLONIAL PERSPECTIVE OF INDIGENOUS HEALTH CRISIS

• Critique:– 1. This perspective doesn’t discuss how such a structural

change would come about in a White settler colonial state like Canada.

– 2. Indigenous control may mean Indigenous elite control of Indigenous health care that marginally benefits or even works against lower class Indigenous people, particularly poor Indigenous women.

24/02/2020 45

Page 46: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

INDIGENOUS PERSPECTIVE OF INDIGENOUS HEALTH CRISIS

• Explanation #2: Systemic, Systematic and Institutional Racisms emerging from settler-colonialism

• Racist social structure [of the White settler colonial state] rather than cultures of Aboriginal society generates sickness and premature death in Aboriginal society (Fox and Long 2000: 298, Allan and Smylie 2018). 24/02/2020 46

Explanation #1: Dominance of the

Western Biomedical System that

disregards Indigenous Medicine Wheel

Page 47: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

INDIGENOUS PERSPECTIVE OF INDIGENOUS HEALTH CRISIS

• Major Concept: Indigenization—making Indigenous philosophies, knowledges, cultures, and imaginations the base for constructing a sustainable health and well-being of Indigenous peoples.

• SOLUTION: “…any solution will have to be based on cultural and spiritual revival in the native community” (Greenwood et al 2015, Fox and Long 2000: 290).– Any solutions will have to reflect the holistic health and wellness system informed by

the Indigenous medicine wheel.

• Critique:

– Fails to articulate that effective and sustainable revival should be based on total empowerment of Indigenous people. That is, not only the revival of cultural and spiritual capital, but also human capital, social capital, emotional capital, moral capital, and aesthetic capital (Adjibolosoo 1995, Adu-Febiri 2016). In other words, high human factor competency (HFC) in Indigenous communities could lower the health risks and increase the well-being in Indigenous communities.24/02/2020 47

Page 48: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

CONCLUSION

• The Indigenous health conditions and experiences, are intricately connected to social, cultural, spiritual, political, and economic marginalization that present a formidable challenge to Indigenous communities rather than biological and cultural deficiencies.

• Three general trends are required if the health care situation of Indigenous people is to improve sustainably (Waldram 1994: 336-7):

– 1) A greater cultural sensitivity in the health care system on the part of non-Indigenous biomedical practitioners.

– 2) A continuing process of acquisition of Indigenous control of health at the community level.

– 3) An overall general improvement in the socio-economic status of Indigenous Canadians.

24/02/2020 48

Page 49: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

CONCLUSION• In effect, the focus of resolving health and well-being issues in Indigenous

communities should not be on just culture. The insight of Allan and Smylie(2018) is worth taking seriously. We should be:

– “…concerned with culturalist solutions to problems involving racism and colonialism in the context of health care services delivery. It is important to draw a distinction between culturalist and anti-colonial approaches to health care delivery…cultural sensitivity training actively prevents health care practitioners from dealing effectively with issues of racism, and from producing scholarly epidemiological research illuminating the social determinants of health…Indigenous peoples are impacted by poverty, poor water quality, stress, and identity-related issues, and that this impacts health and health outcomes…the focus of research…ought to be on health outcomes and on remedying disparate and negative health indicators (Cannon and Sunseri 2018, p. 206)

Under the constraints of internal or settler colonialism, the health and well-being outcomes and indicators about Indigenous peoples would be changed mainly through changed Indigenous peoples, that is, human factor competent Indigenous leadership at all levels. 49

Page 50: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

CONCLUSION

• Conventional efforts at resolving the health crisis will make little headway. The point is that it will take decolonization and indigenization of health and well-being to overcome the Indigenous health crisis. Increases in the human factor competency (HFC) of Indigenous communities could provide the “quiet revolution” or the effective lever or the tipping point to facilitate these processes.

24/02/2020 50

Page 51: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

REFERENCES• Adjibolosoo, Senyo B-S. K. 1995. The Human Factor in Developing Africa,

Westport, Conn.: Praeger.

• Adu-Febiri, Francis. 2016. “Microglobalization Pardox: Encounters of Indigenous Poor Micro-entrepreneurs with Microfinance”. Review of Human Factor Studies, Volume 22, Number 1, pp. 27-63.

• Allan, Billie and Symilie, Janet. 2018. “The Role of Racism in the Health and Well-being of Indigenous Peoples in Canada”. In Martin J. Cannon and Linda Sunseri (Eds.). 2018, Racism, Colonialism, and Indigeneity in Canada: A Reader. Second Edition. Don Mills: Oxford University Press.

• Anderson, Alan A. 1994. “The Health of Aboriginal People in Saskatchewan: Resent Trends and Policy Implications.” In B. Singh Bolaria and Rosemary Bolaria (eds.). Racial Minorities, Medicine and Health. Halifax: Fernwood Publishing.

• Brant, Clare .1990. “Native Ethics and Rules of Behaviour.” Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 35: 534-539.

• Cannon. Martin J. and Sunseri, Linda (Eds.). 2018, Racism, Colonialism, and Indigeneity in Canada: A Reader. Second Edition. Don Mills: Oxford University Press.

51

Page 52: INDIGENOUS HEALTH CONDITIONS AND EXPERIENCES · cancer 6 times higher. • Indigenous adults in Canada have a 20.8 percent higher rate of cancer than the general population. • Suicide

REFERENCES• Greenwood, Margo, Sarah de Leeuw, Nicole Marie Lindsay and Charlotte

Reading (ed.). 2015. Determinants of Indigenous Peoples’ Health in Canada: Beyond the Social. Toronto: Canadian Scholars’ Press

• McGibbon, Elizaberth (ed.). 2012. Oppression: A Social Determinant of Health. Halifax: Fernwood Publishing

• Mensah, Joseph and Williams, Christopher J. 2017. Boomerang Ethics: How Racism Affects Us All. Halifax and Winnipeg: Fernwood Publishing.

• Reid, Carol. 1994. “Sick to Death: The Health of Aboriginal People in Australia and Canada.” In B. Singh Bolaria and Rosemary Bolaria (eds.).

• Sherley-Spiers, S.K. 1989. “Dakota Perceptions of Clinical Encounters with Western Health Care Providers.” Native Studies Review, 5(1):41-51.

• Waldram, James B. 1994. “Cultural and Socio-Economic Factors in the Delivery of Health Care Services to Aboriginal People.” In B. Singh Bolaria and Rosemary Bolaria (eds.).

• Wotherspoon, Terry and Vic Satzewich. 2000. First Nations: Race, Class and Gender Relations. Regina: Canadian Plains Research Center.

24/02/2020 52