Upload
phamdung
View
216
Download
3
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Who Pays for What ?
Goods move across international borders because there has been a sale involving:
• Seller • Buyer Contract of sale should define the responsibilities of both parties
relating to:
• The physical nature of the goods • Movement of the consignment Buyers and sellers have various options relating to the movement
of the goods regarding:
• The division of costs • Defining each parties responsibility and the transfer of risk
2
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
What is an Incoterm ?
Sales term incorporated within the contract of sale
It impacts the contract of carriage
Incoterms identify the obligations placed on the parties to the contracts in terms of
• Responsibilities relating the costs and their division when
shipping the goods
• Distribution of risks associated with the movement of the
goods
• Where these risks transfer to another party
Freight forwarders need to understand these terms to:-
• Ensure that consignments are processed in line with the
appropriate Incoterm
• Assist in handling claims should they arise
3
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
What are Incoterms ?
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
4
Definition
A series of International rules for defining specified terms of Trade in foreign trade
What are Incoterms ?
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
5
Task
Regulating basic purchaser and seller obligations
• Who must bear the transport costs and from when
• Risk transfer specially for international business
What are Incoterms ?
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
6
Goals
An international, standardized interpretation of specific obligations of
purchasers and sellers for contract partners
• Misunderstandings & legal disputes can be avoided
Incoterms 2010
Published by the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) to be used in international transactions
First published in 1936
Reviewed every 10 years to ensure that they are kept up to date with current trade practices
Incoterms 2010 have been effective from 1st January 2011
7
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Summary of main changes
Post 1st January 2011 the number of categories has been reduced from four to two
These categories cover
• Terms for any Mode or Modes of Transport, or • Terms for Sea and Inland Waterway Transport
The aim is to assist Incoterm users to identify the correct terms for their particular requirements
8
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
9
Incoterms Do
Complete a sale of goods
Indicate each contracting party’s costs, risks and obligations with regard to delivery of goods:
When is delivery completed ?
Mode & terms of carriage
Delivery terms & requirement for proof of delivery
Risk of loss transferred from the seller to the buyer
Incoterms
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
10
Incoterms Do
Indicate each contracting party’s costs, risks and obligations with regard to delivery of goods:
Transport cost division between the parties
Notices parties required to give to each other regarding transport & transfer of goods
Delivery terms & requirement for proof of delivery
Incoterms
Do Not Regulate
When & where the ownership of the goods is transferred from the seller to the purchaser
The contract of sale
The condition of the goods
The warranty of the goods
The payment or non-payment of the goods
Place of jurisdiction
11
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
12
Incoterms Do Not
Do not apply to contracts for services
Cover the goods before or after delivery
Define the remedies for breach of contract
Determine how title to the goods will be transferred
Define contractual rights and obligations other than for delivery
Protect a party from his/her own risk of loss
Incoterms
Do Not Regulate
13
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms are used in contract of sale and not in a contract of carriage
Reduction in the number of Incoterms
Previously there were 13 incoterms which have been reduced to 11
The following Incoterms have been removed
• DAF
• DES
• DEQ
• DDU
The following new Incoterms have been introduced:-
• DAT
• DAP
14
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Important Terms Defined
Delivery
It is the point where “the risk or loss of damage passes from the
seller to the buyer.” This is often the “named port or place” but not necessarily the buyer’s place of business
Carrier
Any person or firm who by contract “undertakes to perform or procure” services for transportation of goods. In some cases the buyer nominates the “carrier” and the seller accepts the nomination
for the term to work
15
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Important Terms Defined
Pre-carriage
The initial transport of goods from the seller’s premises to the main
port or place where main carriage begins. Usually by truck, rail or
inland waterway
Main carriage
The primary transport of goods, generally for the longest part of the
journey and generally from one country to another. Usually by sea
vessel or airplane, but also by truck, rail or inland waterway
16
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Important Terms Defined
Onward carriage
Transport from the port, terminal or place of arrival in the country of
destination to the buyer’s premises. Usually by truck, rail or inland waterway
Multimodal
Use of more than one mode of transport (road, rail, sea, air) to
transport goods from origin to final destination
17
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
INCOTERMS
EXW Ex Works (named place of
delivery)
FCA Free Carrier (named place of
delivery)
FAS Free Alongside Ship (named
port of shipment)
FOB Free On Board (named port of
shipment)
CFR Cost & Freight (named port of
destination)
CIF Cost, Insurance & Freight
(named port of destination)
CPT Carriage Paid To (named place
of destination)
CIP Carriage & Insurance Paid To
(named place of destination)
DAT Delivered At Terminal (named
terminal at port or place of destination)
DAP Delivered At Place (named
place of destination)
DDP Delivered Duty Paid (named
place of destination)
Each Incoterm® requires that the Seller and Buyer agree upon a named port, or place, at either origin or destination to make the chosen term valid
11 Official ICC Incoterms® as of 1/1/11
18
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
INCOTERMS
Group E [Departure]
The costs & risk are transferred
to the importer when the goods
leave the exporter’s premises i.e. the seller only provides the
buyer with goods on his
own premises
Group F [Main Carriage Unpaid]
The costs & risk are transferred to
the importer at the delivery location
in the country of export i.e. the
seller transfers the goods to one of
the carriers specified by the buyer
Group C [Main Carriage Paid]
The costs & risk are transferred
separately. The exporter bears the costs
up to a particular destination in the
country of import, and takes out a
minimum insurance policy. The risk is
transferred to the importer when the
goods are transferred to the carrier at
the delivery location
Group D [Arrival]
The costs & risk are transferred to
the importer at the specified
destination
The 4 Incoterm Groups
19
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Any Mode of Transport
These consist of the following seven terms
EXW - Ex Works (named place of delivery)
FCA - Free Carrier (named place of delivery)
CPT - Carriage paid to (named place of destination)
CIP - Carriage and insurance paid to (named place of destination)
DAT - Delivered at terminal (named terminal at port or place of
destination)
DAP - Delivered at place (named place of destination)
DDP - Delivery duty paid (named place of destination)
All of these terms need to specify the port or destination
20
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – For Sea and Inland Waterways
These consist of the following four terms
FAS – Free alongside ship (named port of shipment)
FOB – Free on Board (named port of shipment)
CFR - Cost and Freight to (named port of destination)
CIF - Cost, Insurance and Freight to (named port of destination)
21
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
EXW – Ex Works : Named Place of Delivery
Ex Works (EXW): Named Place of Delivery
Minimum risk to the Seller
Delivery occurs when goods are made available at the Seller’s facility in origin
Seller is not responsible for export customs clearance or loading of collecting vehicle
All transportation & customs related costs are for account of the Buyer
Maximum responsibility for risk of loss or damage to the Buyer
Can be used with any mode or transport, or combination thereof
22
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
EXW – Ex Works : Named Place of Delivery
Critical Points
Buyer to carry out all export formalities
Carriage to be arranged by the buyer
Risk transfers from seller to buyer when goods are made ready for disposal to the buyer
Cost transfers from seller to buyer when goods are made ready for disposal to the buyer
Insurance on buyer’s account
Used for any mode of transport
23
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
FCA – Free Carrier : Named Place of Delivery
There can be more than one delivery point at origin (Seller’s facility, forwarder’s facility, port or airport)
Delivery occurs when goods are presented to the carrier nominated by the Buyer at the named place or port, cleared for export
If delivery is at Seller’s facility, the Seller must load the collecting vehicle
If delivery is not at the Seller’s facility, Buyer is responsible for loading
All costs and risks beyond delivery point are for Buyer’s account
Can use any mode of transport
26
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
FCA – Free Carrier : Named Place of Delivery
Critical Points
Seller to carry out all export formalities and deliver goods custom cleared for export to carrier
Carriage to be arranged by the buyer or by the seller on buyer’s behalf
Risk transfers from seller to buyer when goods have been delivered to the carrier at the named place
Cost transfers from seller to buyer when goods have been delivered to the carrier at the named place
Insurance on buyer’s account
27
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
FCA – Free Carrier : Named Place of Delivery
Critical Points
Seller is responsible for loading goods on to the buyer’s collecting vehicle
Buyer’s obligation to receive the Seller’s arriving vehicle and unload it
Used for any mode of transport
28
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
FCA – Free Carrier
Incoterms® 2010: Scenario � Under the FCA term, who is the carrier? Under Incoterms 2010, the “carrier is the party with whom carriage is contracted” The carrier can be the trucker picking up the cargo at the Seller’s facility, a freight forwarder or an airline/steamship line
29
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
FAS - Free Alongside Ship : Named Port of Shipment
Delivery occurs in the port of shipment alongside the vessel, prior to loading Export clearance and inland freight charges up to the delivery point are for the Seller’s account All charges beyond delivery point (including loading onboard the vessel at origin) are for the Buyer FAS is normally used for over sized or out of gauge shipments with special handling requirements Intended for ocean or inland waterway transportation only
31
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
FAS – Specific Uses
Often used for the ocean borne shipment of what is know as
“oversized”, “out of gauge” or “project cargo.” This includes large structures for the oil and gas industries, etc The use of FAS for these types of shipments makes a lot of sense because the nature of the cargo calls for a great deal of crating, handling and manipulation while in transit Under this term the Seller is responsible for the inland freight up to the named port of export and export clearance, but once the goods are placed alongside the vessel, the Seller’s delivery obligations have been completed
32
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
FAS - Free Alongside Ship : Named Port of Shipment
Critical Points
Export clearance to be arranged by the seller
Carriage to be arranged by the buyer
Risk transfers from seller to buyer when goods have been placed alongside the ship
Cost transfers from seller to buyer when goods have been placed alongside the ship
Insurance on buyer’s account once placed alongside the ship
Intended for ocean or inland waterway transportation only
33
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
FAS - Free Alongside Ship : Named Port of Shipment
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
35
FOB - Free On Board : Named Port of Shipment
Delivery occurs in the port of shipment when goods are loaded on board the vessel Export clearance and inland freight charges up to the delivery point are for the Seller’s account All costs and risk beyond the delivery point are for the Buyer FOB is better suited for bulk cargo Not suitable for containerized cargo (use FCA in this case) Intended for ocean or inland waterway transportation only
36
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
FOB - Free On Board : Example
� Can the FOB term be used for shipments where delivery occurs at a destination port?
The Seller’s obligations states that delivery obligation ends when goods are loaded on board the vessel at origin FOB is intended for bulk goods
37
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
FOB - Free On Board : Named Port of Shipment
Critical Points
Export clearance to be arranged by the seller
Carriage to be arranged by the buyer
Risk transfers from seller to buyer when goods pass the ship’s rail
Cost transfers from seller to buyer when goods pass the ship’s rail
Insurance on buyer’s account once goods pass the ship’s rail
Intended for ocean or inland waterway transportation only
38
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
CFR – Cost & Freight : Named Port of Destination
Delivery occurs in the port of shipment when goods are loaded on board the vessel As a result, risk shifts to the Buyer at the port of shipment Seller is responsible for all transportation costs up to the port of arrival Better suited for bulk cargo Not meant for containerized cargo (consider CPT as an alternative) Intended for ocean or inland waterway transport only
40
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Import Example Using the “CFR” Incoterm®
Without naming a port at destination you are blind to what your
cumulative lead times will be.
41
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
CFR – Cost & Freight : Named Port of Destination
Critical Points
Export clearance to be arranged by the seller
Carriage to be arranged by the seller
Risk transfers from seller to buyer when goods pass the ship’s rail
Cost transfers from seller to buyer at port of destination
Insurance on buyer’s account once goods loaded on board the vessel
Intended for ocean or inland waterway transportation only
43
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
CIF - Cost, Insurance & Freight : Named Port of Destination
Delivery occurs in the port of shipment when goods are loaded
on board the vessel Risk shifts to the Buyer at the port of shipment Seller is responsible for all transportation costs up to the port of arrival Seller must secure minimum cover insurance on behalf of Buyer Better suited for bulk cargo Not intended for containerized cargo (consider CIP as an alternative) Intended for ocean or inland waterway transport only
45
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
CIF - Cost, Insurance & Freight : Named Port of Destination
Critical Points
Export clearance to be arranged by the seller
Carriage to be arranged by the seller
Risk transfers from seller to buyer when goods pass the ship’s rail
Cost transfers from seller to buyer at port of destination
Insurance on seller’s account
Intended for ocean or inland waterway transportation only
46
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
CIF - Cost, Insurance & Freight : Named Port of Destination
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
47
CPT - Carriage Paid To : Named Place of Destination
Risk shifts with the first carrier at origin (normally the collecting vehicle at the Seller’s facility)
Can be used for any mode of transportation or combination thereof
Seller is responsible for all transportation costs up to the named place at destination
Very important to name the place at destination (port, airport or inland location)
48
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
CPT - Carriage Paid To : Named Place of Destination
Critical Points
Export clearance to be arranged by the seller
Carriage to be arranged by the seller
Risk transfers from seller to buyer when goods have been delivered to the carrier
Cost transfers from seller to buyer at named place of destination
Seller not obliged to cover for insurance
Intended for any mode of transport
49
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
CPT - Carriage Paid To : Named Place of Destination
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
50
CIP - Carriage & Insurance Paid To : Named Place of Destination
Seller is responsible for all transportation costs up to the named place at destination
Very important to name the place at destination (port, airport or inland location)
Risk shifts with the first carrier at origin (normally the collecting vehicle at the Seller’s facility)
Seller must secure minimum cover insurance on behalf of the Buyer
Can be used for any mode of transportation or combination thereof
51
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
CIP - Carriage & Insurance Paid To : Named Place of Destination
Critical Points
Export clearance to be arranged by the seller
Carriage to be arranged by the seller
Risk transfers from seller to buyer when goods have been delivered to the carrier
Cost transfers from seller to buyer at named place of destination. Seller pays additional costs of carriage up to named place of destination
Insurance to be arranged by the seller
Intended for any mode of transport
52
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
CIP - Carriage & Insurance Paid To : Named Place of Destination
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
54
DAT - Delivered at Terminal : Named Terminal at Port or Place of Destination
Can be used for any mode of transport
Delivery is complete when the goods are placed at the disposal of the Buyer at a named terminal at the named port or place of destination, off-loaded
“Terminal” includes quays, warehouses, container yard or road, rail or air terminal
Buyer is responsible for customs clearance, duties & taxes
If the Seller wishes to extend his responsibility beyond the terminal DAP or DDP can be used
55
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
DAT – Example
� Who is responsible for a damaged shipment under the “DAT Moscow Airport” Incoterm®?
First, the arbitrator must determine that the sales contract stipulates the above Incoterm®, and that the contract references Incoterms 2010® Next, it is up to the arbitrator to use the documentation trail to determine where in the supply chain the damage occurred The arbitrator can see from DAT rules that delivery is complete when goods arrive at the terminal of the air carrier at Moscow airport, off-loaded
56
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
DAT - Delivered at Terminal : Named Terminal at Port or Place of Destination
Critical Points
Export clearance to be arranged by the seller
Seller should ensure that their forwarding contract mirrors the contract of sale
Seller is responsible for the costs and risks to bring the goods to the point specified in the contract. Only term where seller is responsible for unloading at destination
Importer is responsible to arrange import customs formalities and pay import duty
Seller not obliged to cover for insurance
Intended for any mode of transport
57
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
DAT - Delivered at Terminal : Named Terminal at Port or Place of Destination
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
58
DAP - Delivered at Place : Named Place of Destination
Seller delivers when goods are made available to the Buyer at the named place in destination, prior to customs clearance and not unloaded from the delivering vehicle
Multiple options for named place at destination (ocean/air port, warehouse or Buyer’s facility)
Seller is responsible for all transportation costs up to named place at destination
Risk of loss or damage passes to Buyer at named place in destination
Buyer is responsible for customs taxes, duties, VAT or cost of clearance
formalities
Can be used for any mode of transport, or combination thereof
59
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
DAP– Example
� Who is responsible for inland freight at destination using the term DAP, customer’s facility, Stuttgart, Germany?
The Seller is responsible for the inland freight charges in Germany because under DAP that is what he committed to
60
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
DAP - Delivered at Place : Named Place of Destination
Critical Points
Export clearance to be arranged by the seller
Seller should ensure to obtain contract of carriage that match the contract of sale
Seller bears responsibility and risks to deliver the goods to the named place
Importer is responsible to arrange import customs formalities and pay import duty
Seller not obliged to cover for insurance
Intended for any mode of transport
61
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
DAP - Delivered at Place : Named Place of Destination
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
62
DDP - Delivered Duty Paid : Named Place of Destination
Seller delivers when goods are made available to the Buyer at the named placed at destination, cleared for import but not unloaded from the delivering vehicle
Multiple options for named place at destination (ocean/air port, warehouse or Buyer’s facility)
Seller is responsible for all transportation costs up to named place at destination
Risk of loss or damage passes to Buyer at named place at destination
Seller is responsible for all customs taxes, duties, VAT and cost of clearance formalities
Can be used for any mode of transport, or combination thereof
63
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Sample Export Quote: DDP, Buyer’s Facility, All In Price
64
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Caveats of Using DDP
When you quote DDP named place at destination, the first step is to agree with the Buyer where at destination your delivery responsibilities end You must have a comprehensive understanding of all the costs associated with shipping your goods to each of the countries you do business in In addition to transportation costs, you as the exporter are responsible for customs clearance and the payment of all duties or taxes at destination
65
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
DDP – Example
� When using the DDP term is the Seller responsible for securing insurance on behalf of the Buyer?
DDP term states that the Seller is not required to secure insurance cover on behalf of the Buyer
66
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
DDP - Delivered Duty Paid : Named Place of Destination
Critical Points
Export clearance to be arranged by the seller
Carriage to be arranged by the seller
Risk transfer from the seller to the buyer when the goods are placed at the disposal of the buyer
Cost transfer from the seller to the buyer when the goods are placed at the disposal of the buyer
Seller arranges for clearance of goods at destination country & pays for all customs formalities, duties, taxes, VAT etc
67
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
DDP - Delivered Duty Paid : Named Place of Destination
Critical Points
Seller not obliged to cover for insurance
Intended for any mode of transport
68
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
DDP - Delivered Duty Paid : Named Place of Destination
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
69
Incoterms – Passing of Risks & Costs
In E, F and D terms, both risks & costs pass from seller to buyer at
Named Place
Named Port or
Named Terminal
In C terms : Transfer of risk occurs at a different point than the
transfer of costs
70
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms - Variants
Incoterms® 2010: Scenario � Is “EXW loaded” recognized as a legitimate Incoterm®? Incoterms® 2010 does not prohibit variants on Incoterms® If Sellers and Buyers do use variants on Incoterms®, the meaning must be well explained in the sales contract
72
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms - Variants
� Is “CIF & c & i” recognized as a legitimate Incoterm®?
Yes
C & I stands for commission and interest.
It clarifies to the buyer that above two components are payable by
him
If buyer pays the bill prior maturity, he is allowed a rebate
Such terms used when export effected to distant places where
settlement of bill of exchange drawn on importer takes some time
73
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms - Variants
� Are “CIF & C” and “FOB & C” recognized as legitimate Incoterms®?
Yes
C stands for exchange rate fluctuation
Quoted when exporter assumes risk of exchange rate fluctuations
that may occur between date of contract acceptance and payment
74
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms - Variants
� Is “CIF ex” recognized as a legitimate Incoterm®?
Yes
Refers to cost, insurance, freight and exchange
Exchange – ambiguous term – refers to banker’s commission & exchange fluctuation
Exchange fluctuation – purchase price not affected by subsequent
rise or fall of agreed currency of payment between exporter &
importer
75
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms - Variants
� Is “DDP VAT unpaid” recognized as a legitimate Incoterm®?
Yes
Seller is responsible for paying import duty, but not for paying VAT
76
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms - Variants
� Is “FOB Stowed” recognized as a legitimate Incoterm®?
Yes
For some types of cargo, costs arise from stowing the cargo on the
Vessel
Incoterms rule "FOB stowed" makes it clear that the seller is
responsible not only for loading the cargo on board, but also for
stowing it
77
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Tips for Using Incoterms
Incoterms® are NOT your primary contract of sale
Is the chosen Incoterm® allowed in the countries where we’re operating?
Consider terms appropriate to the goods being shipped
Consult the “Guidance Notes” in Incoterms® 2010
Consider terms fitting to the necessary transport
Incorporate the appropriate rule into the contract of sale
Decide who will organize the transport
Pinpoint the point, place and port of delivery as precisely as possible
Decide who will organize the insurance, if required
Incorporate Incoterms® 2010 into your contract of sale
78
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Usage
“EXW” , “Ex Works” , “Ex Factory”
Can they be used interchangeably
79
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Usage
“C&F”
Is it a correct to use this Incoterm instead of CFR
80
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Usage
Why is it important to suffix the year after Incoterm ?
81
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Usage
Are Incoterms legally binding ?
82
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Usage
Are Incoterms legally binding ?
No!
• Incoterms have no legal force; they only become legally binding once they have been validly agreed by the purchaser and seller
• Their use is not compulsory
• They only recommend a minimum standard; individual modification is possible
Clear regulations should be applied to modifications to avoid misunderstandings
83
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterm Usage
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
84
Which Incoterm is used for supply contracts with
external suppliers ?
Incoterm Usage
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
85
Incoterm usage - supply contracts with external suppliers ?
“FCA – designated delivery location” [i.e. warehouse or service location of supplier]
Which circumstances can prevent the use of FCA here?
• No transport contracts with service providers for this region
• Special transport is necessary [e.g. silo, valuables]
• Supplier has special supply chains, adapted to the product
[e.g. electronic components]
Which Incoterm must be used then?
Incoterm Usage
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
86
Incoterm usage - supply contracts with external suppliers ?
• FOB [Free on Board]
• DAP [Delivered at Place]
Incoterm Usage
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
87
Which Incoterm is used for contracts with
OEM customers ?
Incoterm Usage
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
88
Incoterm usage - Contracts with OEM customers ?
• Preferably Incoterm “FCA-designated delivery location” should be used, so that customer picks up goods from company’s warehouse or production location
• If customer is not arranging for the transport, then FCA cannot be used
• If above is the case, use Incoterm DAP [Delivered at Place]
Incoterm Usage
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
89
Is CFR Bangkok Port a correct Incoterm ?
No
Bangkok has two terminals : Bangkok Port & Laem Chabang
Port
Similarly Dubai has two ports : Sharjah & Jebel Ali
Nhava Sheva has three terminals : JNPT, NSICT, GTIL
Incoterms – Scenario 1
The client shipped 10x20’ containers of Gypsum board to India under CFR Mumbai. Unfortunately the vessel could not call on the port
because of a strike. After some weeks delay the goods arrived at an
alternate port as the containers were offloaded at Dubai (due to
strike) and thereafter shipped to the alternate port as the strike in
Mumbai Port continued. This has caused delay and additional charges.
Who [Buyer or Seller] is to bear the extra cost / charges ??
90
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Solution Scenario 1
CFR – Seller must pay carriage costs
Buyer not responsible for any carriage costs or extra charges for delay
Buyer can also claim penalty as the delay disrupts the supply chain
Strike is not a part of civil unrest and therefore not a “Force Majeure” condition. Strike is normally a peaceful form of agitation
As per the agreement with the carrier, the carrier should pay for:
Extra costs / charges
Pay for penalties if the buyer raises a claim
The seller sought a claim and got compensated by the carrier for the delay. Additionally, the seller ensured that such unexpected delays are covered under insurance in future
91
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Scenario 2
Seller:
As America’s premier supplier of cuddly fluffy white rabbits and other soft toys, we deal with customers all over the world. We market by
internet, and our added value selling point is we arrange all the
shipment details for our clients, right up to their point of sale, office or
storage facility. They don’t worry as we do everything for them. Buyer:
I have never imported anything from overseas-and as a small
company, I don’t have the time or staff to arrange this – and what if
something went wrong? I just need this consignment here in time for
the Easter sales, and I know we can double the price we paid, if not
triple it. Give me a delivery date that is guaranteed, and I’ll be happy. Which is the best Incoterm in this scenario?
92
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Solution Scenario 2
Which is the best Incoterm in this scenario?
DDP [Delivery Duty Paid]
US Factory to Delivery Point U.K.
Great for those buyer’s with little knowledge / expertise in International movement of goods
93
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Scenario 3
A London based seller in the U.K. supplies to an India buyer (Nahar
Textiles) under the term DAP Himachal Pradesh. Nahar Textiles
billed the seller for internal transportation to his factory on the outskirts
Of Himachal Pradesh (Tikri Khas) which because of hilly terrain and local
union rates cost the UK exporter dearly (INR 60,000 higher @ INR
20,000 per truck)
94
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Solution Scenario 3
The exporter in U.K. had assumed that the importer (Nahar Textiles)
would take delivery at his factory in Paonta Sahib, but Nahar Textiles
preferred to take delivery at their other factory located at Tikri Khas.
Tikri Khas was located at the other extreme of the same state and the
terrain was hilly. Moreover, trucks were not easy to get to this location
and all movements to this area were governed by the local truck union
(irrespective of whether the truck belonged to the state or came from
any other state).
Despite protestations it was held that DAP Himachal Pradesh was not
specific enough for the UK exporter to reject the charges, as Himachal
Pradesh was a state and in absence of a named destination in H.P. the
exporter was obliged to deliver at any location in the state of H.P.
96
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Scenario 4
You are a manager in an export firm namely R R Exports. You receive an inquiry from a
buyer in USA namely Home Art Inc. who are located in Harrisburg in the state of
Pennsylvania. The port of entry of goods in USA would be New York from where the goods
would be transported to Harrisburg. You quote to the prospective client for artistic lamps &
shades at USD 600 a dozen basis CIP Nhava Sheva, but the client reverts that the quote is
rather high.
97
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Solution Scenario 4
On CIP terms, the seller pays for ocean freight and insurance till the
goods reach the destination. The terms should be followed by the port at
destination i.e New York
CIP Nhava Sheva – Incorrect
CIP New York – Correct
98
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Scenario 5
You are the head of exports in Shahi Exports and are exporting
garments worldwide. You have executed an order recently to Marseilles,
France and confirm to the buyer as follows;
We confirm having shipped out to you 3,700 pairs of ladies tops & skirts
at Euro 60 per pair basis FOB Marseilles.
99
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Solution Scenario 5
On FOB terms, the seller’s responsibilities end when he delivers the goods at the port of shipment (port of loading), i.e. port of loading in
India. The term should be followed by the port at origin i.e Nhava Sheva
or Mundra, as the case may be.
FOB Marseilles – Incorrect
FOB Nhava Sheva or FOB Mundra – Correct
100
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Scenario 6
You are the Director in a company by the name of Arts & Crafts Pvt Ltd.
You have been requested by your client located at Corso Sardegna,
Genoa, Italy to quote for tables with marble tops. Total order quantity is
40 tables. You quote to the client “40 Tables with Marble Tops – DDP
Nhava Sheva.”
101
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Solution Scenario 6
On DDP terms, the seller must physically deliver the goods to the buyer
at a named place in the import country, i.e. named place of destination
should be added to DDP terms. The term DDP should be followed by
Corso Sardegna (place of delivery), Genoa (city), Italy to avoid any
ambiguities.
DDP Nhava Sheva – Incorrect
DDP Corso Sardegna, Genoa, Italy – Correct
102
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Scenario 7
Seller Says:
This suits us; our main business is manufacturing car parts. We are
always happy, to help our customers, but would outsource all the
transport arrangements to a third party.
Buyer Says:
I am the shipping manager for a large multinational company. Our
centralized buying department has arranged this shipment as the first of
a twice monthly shipment from Pittsburgh to Dagenham. We buy parts
on Just-in-time basis from 136 suppliers all over the globe. I always get
a quote because I can do a great deal with the main shippers – they are
pleased to offer volume discounts to our organization.
Which is the most suitable term which could be used in such a
scenario?
103
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Solution Scenario 7
EXW [Ex-works]
US Factory to Delivery point UK
The most cost effective way for the buyer
104
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Scenario 8
Seller Says:
I’ve been caught out like this before – the company at the other end, do not plan
for the payment to the customs, and the consignment gets impounded – then
there is a huge row over who pays what. But using XXX, we both know
exactly who pays what?
Buyer Says:
I really do not know anything about importing goods from the USA. I however
know and am confident that we will make a good profit on the American Sports
Gear. My supplier is adamant that I pay the EU duty and arrange for the customs
formalities at my end. They can put me in touch with their usual UK agent, and
they will do this for us for a small fee.
Which is the most suitable term which could be used in such a scenario?
105
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Solution Scenario 8
DDU [Delivery Duty Unpaid]
US Factory to Delivery point UK
Advantageous for the seller – seller is not responsible for customs duties, VAT or demurrage while payment of duties are made to the customs.
106
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Scenario 9
Buyer Says:
We hope to get more business from this company. Quoting XXX means we
really can make a great return on this shipment of books, and both parties
are happy. In the best American tradition, we want to meet all our customer’s
needs, but really with a one-off shipment, managing the transport to the UK
port is easy to fit in with our regular clients.
Seller Says:
This is my first really big shipment from the US book supplier, but I cannot
afford for them to do all the work… I can deal with the UK side, and by contracting to the Institute of Freight Forwarders, I can get hold of a
reputable company, who can sort out everything in the UK – but will only
insure from the UK quayside. They can even arrange delivery direct to the
conference centre on the day we are setting up, so I don’t have to any storage
charges.
Identify the most suitable Incoterm that can be applied in this case.
107
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management
Incoterms – Solution Scenario 9
CIF [Cost Insurance Freight]
USA Port to Delivery point UK ?? [ or delivery port UK]
Seller buys marine insurance – but only has to cover legal minimum
108
Ashok Advani - Jaipuria Institute of Management